Resolution No. 9—General (resumed).
Contributions 1–132 of 252. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
Last evening, the Minister for Supplies and the Minister for Industry and Commerce raged at members of this House for opposing this Budget. They told us that we lacked moral courage and a proper sense of responsibility in dealing with a crisis with which the country is faced. I wish to say that the statements of the Ministers displayed almost everything except a proper appreciation of the sacrifices the masses of the people have made and are making to enable the Government to solve the problem that confronts us. We were lectured also as to our obligations to those who sent us here and, I should say, lectured in an insulting manner. I want to say that it is because I feel I have an obligation to those who sent me here I am making this statement this morning. In the whole of the statements made by the Ministers, including the Minister for Finance, not a solitary reference was made to the position of the unemployed with families of five or more children who are compelled to accept 23/- a week in our cities and 14/- a week in our country towns. Yet, those are the people who are told that if they make any demand for an increase because of an increase in prices, the Government will set their faces against them.
Knowing the privations of those sections of the community who are denied the right to a means of livelihood by the laws made in this House, and knowing, as I do, that there are in this State at the present time 2,500 persons in receipt of a net annual income of over £8,500,000 between them, I could not conscientiously vote for the Budget as submitted. I say, Sir, that democracy is on trial to-day throughout the world and I know of no country and of no Government that has had, and still has, a better opportunity of proving to the world what a democratically elected Government can do for its people. I say very definitely that no member of this House, that no Government, has a right to say to citizens just as worthy as any of us: "We ourselves can exist on £480 a year allowance but you must live on a miserable pittance of 23/- a week." Until such time as the Government of the day are prepared to govern in the interest of the community as a whole, they must not expect us on these benches to support the Budget that they have introduced in this House.
We were told by the Minister for Industry and Commerce last evening that one of the justifications for mobilising the forces of the Army was to prevent murderous attacks and menaces that were made to the citizens of the State. I challenge the Minister to state any murderous attacks or attempted attacks on any member of the State since the General Election of 1938. I feel that we have a grave responsibility on this occasion and in the days ahead of us, but I must certainly say that the Government have not displayed much sense of responsibility to the ordinary people of this country in submitting a Budget with such taxes in it for us to support. I think it is unfair that we should be accused of any lack of responsibility or any lack of co-operation with the Government in meeting the position that confronts us to-day. I do not think we should have had such speeches as we have had in the course of the last few days. As one who has some appreciation of the difficulty with which the people are confronted, I wish to say very definitely that I will not, in any circumstances, support the Government in the Budget which they have introduced until such times as they first deal fairly and squarely with the masses of the people.
What right have we, as members of this House, to expect the masses of the people to respect any kind of legislation while we have such a submerged mass of people living below the poverty line? I submit that the taxes which are imposed in that Budget are going to hit the very poorest of our people rather than the people mentioned as having grown rich with industrial development; and until such time as these people are dealt with and are made to contribute and to make sacrifices, I, for one, will not support the Budget as submitted.
Comment on this
At the outset, I must deplore the attitude taken up by the Government spokesmen towards Deputies outside the ranks of Fianna Fáil in this House who have tried to express the seething discontent of the community at large against the crushing burden of taxation in this emergency Budget. The new cry is not very far removed from that old cry of "traitor" levied in the not very distant past against anybody who dared to criticise the foolhardy and extravagant administration of the Government.
In my capacity as the only Independent Deputy in this House of the largest constituency in Ireland—South Dublin—one of the industrialised areas in which the economic casualties of this war are painfully evident in the upward curve in the unemployment charts, I take this opportunity to register a most emphatic protest against the increased taxation on such widely used commodities as sugar, beer and tobacco. To use any such word as "unjustifiable" in the case of the sugar tax would be a gross understatement. By this increase in the tax on sugar the Government has, with amazing cynicism, out-profiteered the profiteer. By this tax on sugar we are treated to the first example of organised Government profiteering on a national scale.
The Minister for Supplies gave very definite assurances to this House on the 22nd September and on the 18th October respectively, that he did not anticipate any difficulties with regard to supplies of sugar nor did he anticipate any difficulties in relation to price. By the assurances given by the Minister on those occasions, one is forcibly reminded of the assurance given by another statesman somewhere in Europe that "he had no further territorial ambitions in Europe"—and we all know what happened then. Can the Government therefore, blame the people if they have now come to regard assurances given by the Government as nothing more than an attempt on the part of the Government to lure them into a sense of false security as a prelude to another successful "smash and grab" like the sugar raid?
Everybody is aware of the fact that sugar is a vitally essential food commodity; it is, in fact, the principal constituent in the diet of newly-born babies, infants and children generally. The Minister for Finance indicated that there would be no increase in wages, no increase in unemployment assistance and no increase in unemployment benefit so as to offset the increase in prices entailed by this increased taxation. Therefore, the increase in the taxation of sugar must inevitably mean a curtailment in the supply of sugar to newly-born infants and children generally. Anybody who cares to refer to the public health report of this city will see that already there is an alarming number of cases of malnutrition in the City of Dublin, and this increase in the price of sugar is going to add immeasurably to that very undesirable position.
Most thinking people even as far back as September, 1938, knew that this war was coming. Even I predicted several months ago, Cassandralike, in this House that Great Britain, a nation of 46,000,000 souls, was on the verge of what might prove for her a life and death struggle, that her navy, fine though it is, would find it increasingly difficult to keep her long sea trade routes open and that, as a result, there would be difficulties with regard to the importation of food and the supply of raw materials. Why, then, did the Government, with all its channels of information, not follow the example of other countries six, nine or 12 months ago and restock the national larder and provide the raw materials necessary for our industries to carry on? Had these steps been taken, we would not find ourselves in the dilemma in which we now are. I hoped when I came in here this morning that there might be some of the Government Deputies for Dublin South City in the House. I am sorry to observe they are absent, because there was one Deputy in particular—he is not here and I suppose, in fairness to him, I had better not name him—who absented himself from the House for months, who refrained from voting with his Party because of a personal grievance, and who has not, I suppose, a single word of protest to utter on behalf of his friends in the Coombe, in York Street or Townsend Street against this taxation on sugar and tobacco. I gather from the expressions of some of the Deputies opposite that they have a pain in their faces from listening to all this talk about sugar, but I can assure them that they will never have pains in their bellies from want of it, like many of the people whom they represent here to-day.
Comment on this
I am afraid I cannot congratulate the Minister, either upon his maiden Budget statement, or on his maiden Budget. Both are bad. His statement was imprudent and unwise. In the first place, he has attempted to make Party capital out of the fact that the Government has adopted a policy of neutrality. That was unwise and imprudent, and it enabled a member of the Opposition to make an equally unwise and imprudent comment upon it. Again, we have the fact that the Minister has flung down a challenge to all sections of the community who feel that they have a grievance as a result of the increased cost of living. He has declared that the Government will set its face sternly against any attempt by those people to improve their conditions, but I can assure the Minister that so far as the farming community is concerned, they will not be intimidated by such remarks. If they are to be compelled to pay ever-increasing prices for their requirements, they will insist upon securing fair and remunerative prices for the produce of their labour.
I have said that this Budget is bad, but I think it is even worse than that. It is a callous and mean attack upon the poorer section of the community. In the first place, there should be no excuse whatever for increased taxation. There should have been sufficient economies brought about to have relieved the Exchequer, and even if there were any excuse for increased taxation or new taxes, surely the poorer section should have been passed over? Yet, in the taxation on tobacco and sugar, the poorer section, the manual worker, with his wife and children, are singled out for attack. Can any Minister visualise the position of the agricultural labourer or working farmer in regard to tobacco? Surely that commodity is the only small luxury which such people enjoy, and when we consider how many other luxuries there are available to the wealthier sections, we are forced to ask ourselves why should the miserable little luxury of the working man be singled out for increased taxation? If the Minister knew what it was to work in an unsheltered position, to work on the land, if he knew what it was to work, for example, at pulling beet on a cold winter day under frost, hail, rain or snow; and if he knew the comfort which the working man derives from an occasional smoke, he would surely reconsider imposing increased taxation on tobacco.
What is the excuse offered for this increased taxation? We are told that it is more convenient to collect than other taxes. It is more convenient, perhaps, for the officials of the Revenue authorities to collect this tax, but surely the convenience of high officials should not be placed before the rights and interests of the plain working people? Surely the comfort and convenience of the people who are carrying this nation on their shoulders, the people who are producing the nation's food, the people who are engaged in hard manual labour, should have been the Government's first consideration? Yet, the small luxury of those people, if, indeed, it can be called a luxury, has been taxed to the utmost extent, while other luxuries, the luxuries of the wealthier classes, have been passed over. We find no attempt has been made to increase taxation upon other sections.
If we travel through this city, we find various places of amusement open until very late hours at night. We find picture houses, theatres and other places of amusement crowded with people. We find the various race meetings very well attended; if we go to the greyhound racing at night, we find it crowded to the utmost; and we have been told that there will not be even standing room at a little entertainment down the city between two foreigners, for which the tickets are very highly priced. It appears that there is a certain amount of money inside the nation amongst certain sections of the community and, if new taxation was necessary, surely those are the people who first of all should be called upon to bear it. Yet, it is the overworked section of the community who have been singled out. It is the poor struggling working man in the field and in the factory and the struggling working farmer who are victimised by the tax on tobacco. The increased tax on sugar is even worse. Sugar is a necessary food for all classes of the people, but particularly for the young. Why should a necessary food for children be taxed to such an extent as to be made almost prohibitive and taxed simply because the Minister or his advisers and officials consider it is an easy tax to collect? It may be an easy tax to collect, but it is a very hard tax to pay, and it is the poorest section of the community who will be called upon to pay it. In these circumstances, there is no justification whatever for the increased taxation of either sugar or tobacco.
With regard to income tax, it may be said that the principle of levying taxation on income is fair and just but there is a limit to the extent to which incomes of citizens can be or should be taxed. When taxation passes beyond one-fourth of the actual income, it is becoming excessive to the extent of acting as a deterrent to individual enterprise and industry. It must also be remembered that it is unjust for this Parliament to tax incomes so long as the incomes of members of this Parliament, or at least the Parliamentary allowances of members of this House, are exempt from taxation. Surely that is a matter that should be rectified before there is any further increase in income tax. I have said that these taxes are not justifiable as long as there are other alternative means of securing revenue but, above all, the first duty of the Government should be to reduce expenditure to such an extent as to make it unnecessary to impose increased taxation of any kind. Taxation has passed beyond the limit which is justifiable, beyond the limit which the community of this country can bear.
It is very easy for Ministers to fling down challenges to members of this House and ask them how they propose to reduce expenditure. During the past year a resolution was passed through the House which had the effect of increasing expenditure. It was opposed by members on the Independent and Opposition Benches and they were derided for opposing that increased expenditure. The Government apparently at that time lightly assumed that there was absolutely no limit to the taxpayers' resources. When we had the Presidential establishment set up and when it was opposed on this side of the House, we were told that the dignity of the nation demanded such an establishment but the dignity of the nation now demands that the poor farmer's wife and the labourer's wife must cut down the family allowances of necessary food supplies in order to maintain such an establishment. When it was decided by the Government to increase the salaries of Ministers and members of this House we said that we believed that the country at the present time could not afford such extravagance. We were taunted and ridiculed by Ministers and their supporters. Yet, facts have proved that these increases in expenditure were absolutely unjustified and that they have necessitated the imposition of an intolerable burden on the poorer sections of the community.
It may be said that the two matters which I have mentioned would not amount to a very large part of our national expenditure, but they are just examples of recent legislation which has had the effect of increasing expenditure and thereby increasing taxation. They are simply typical of the policy which has been pursued by the Government for the past six or seven years, a policy of steadily piling on the burden on the unfortunate people in order to provide privileges and abundance for the few. The time has now come, I think, for the Government and every member of the House to take a very serious view of the situation. The people at the present time are not in a mood to bear the ever-increasing burden without complaint. The limit of their patience has been reached, and if this Parliament is to justify itself, if democratic institutions in this country are to be preserved, it will be the duty of every member of the House, and of every member of the Government, to think very seriously upon the present economic and financial position of the country and to take immediate steps to see that, first of all, taxation is reduced and that, secondly, the income-earning power of the people of the country is increased. There is no source from which the Government of this country can derive revenue except from the work, the industry and the savings of the plain people and while industry and enterprise are being stifled by restrictions, by increased taxation, by every action of the Government, there is absolutely nothing facing this country but complete ruin. The plain people must be given some encouragement, some incentive to go on working, to go on producing, to increase production. It is no encouragement to them to find that their daily outlay is increasing and that the purchasing power of their small earnings is every day being reduced by the heavy burdens imposed upon them. Therefore, I appeal to the Government before it is too late to take drastic action to reorganise the Government machinery. It is their duty to recast their entire economic financial policy in order to bring the cost of Government down to a level which the plain people can bear.
It may be necessary, in order to do that, to upset seriously the views and the ideas of high officials in this State, It may also be necessary to upset the ideas of orthodox finance in this country in order to adopt an entirely new financial and economic policy, but the Government must realise that the needs of our people and the urgent necessity of preserving the economic life of the nation, are more important than the long-held views of aged or ageing officials or bankers. The Government must realise that until the plain working people, who cannot find work but are anxious to work, are given a full and adequate opportunity of getting work and increasing the output of the country; that until they are given the opportunity to develop its undeveloped economic resources, that absolutely nothing is being done to achieve the economic salvation of the country. Therefore, I ask the Government to sit down and carefully plan a new war, a war upon poverty and destitution. Let them forget for the moment about the war which is going on in Europe, and think seriously of the war which the plain working man, the unemployed man and the working farmer have got to wage every other day against hunger and destitution. If it be necessary to borrow money in order to develop our economic resources, then I think the Government should have no hesitation in doing so, but they should see that the money so borrowed is not burdened down with a crushing load of interest which the taxpayers and, eventually, the humblest sections of the community, will be called upon to bear.
With regard to the development of the resources of the country, I think the Government should give serious consideration to the suggestions offered on that matter by a member of their own Party who was a member of the Banking Commission and issued a Minority Report. In my opinion, if his advice was carefully considered it would not be necessary for the Government to impose the increased taxation included in this Budget. As far as the farmers are concerned they have suffered very severely during the past six or seven years. They have been forced to carry on their industry at uneconomic prices. During the worst years of depression farmers were selling their live stock at prices which were absolutely ruinous. During those years they were told to turn to beet and wheat, and to beet in particular. When they asked to be given at least an economic price for that product the miserable offer of 30/- per ton was made to them, and when, as a last resort, they asked that, in order that they should get a fair price for the beet, the Government should raise the price of sugar, their demand was turned down. They were told that the Government could not increase the price of a foodstuff, yet to-day, in order to finance extravagant Government schemes, we have the Minister lightly imposing a tax of ¾d. a lb. on sugar. If the price of sugar had been raised by ¾d. a lb. during the economic war, it would have given the farmers an economic price for their beet, or at least a price which would have enabled them to struggle through that depressed period without sinking into bankruptcy. Yet, to-day, that increase is being lightly imposed and no excuse has been offered for it except that it is convenient to the officials of the State to collect that tax.
Surely, there ought to be some sense of justice and fair play in the minds of Ministers, and they ought not allow themselves to be governed by the convenience of their officials or their Departments. They ought, first of all, to consider that they have a Christian duty to distribute equitably, over all sections of the community, the burden of sacrifice and taxation. That should be the first consideration of a Christian Government, and because they have not apparently taken that matter into their consideration I have no hesitation in saying that this is a callous and unChristian Budget.
Comment on this
I have listened very attentively to almost every word that has been spoken in criticism of this Budget. I was not absent from the debate for, I think, more than a few minutes, but the tiresome iteration is getting on my nerves a bit now, and I am afraid I can hardly apply such a respectable word as argument to a lot of what has been said during the greater part of the debate.
Naturally, a Budget imposing additional taxation and the Minister who brings in such a Budget are good cock-shots for criticism. That is natural. Everybody expects it. In bringing in an ordinary Budget imposing any kind of taxation, a Minister in any part of the world puts himself up for attack and accepts attack as gracefully as he can. He will take as gracefully as he can all the hard knocks he may get from all sides of the House. But when one comes along, as I have been obliged to do, in the middle of a financial year with a Supplementary Budget imposing heavy taxation on people already fairly well taxed, well, one wants to be a pretty hefty fellow to take all the blows. But though I am not a very hefty fellow and I am not a very big fellow and would not be able to take an awful lot of punishment, I have not heard anything of a very effective nature from any side of the House or from any Deputy that makes me think I have done anything wrong towards the people of this country in imposing additional taxation or in asking the House to pass this additional taxation that was set forth in the various Resolutions put before the House.
Only a short couple of months ago we came here to this House, suddenly summoned immediately after the declaration of war in Europe. Many Deputies came in here looking solemn and serious and with long faces, some wondering what was going to happen in Europe and particularly what was going to happen here. We all felt serious about the problem, and some took it more seriously than others. We all realised that the war in Europe in which our closest neighbours were engaged, in which were engaged nations with whom we had close, intimate, economic, financial and business associations, was something in which we ourselves were going to be very deeply concerned from the purely financial and economic points of view, and from other points of view as well. We knew that whether we liked it or not we were going to be involved in that war no matter what precautions we took to avoid it. I think everybody with any sort of responsibility, as I said in the Budget statement, knew that war might have very serious political and financial consequences for this country. I think everybody realised that to some extent; some of us realised it to the full extent. The war has now been on for two months but, thanks be to God, it has not developed in the savage, brutal, bloodthirsty way in which the last war had at a very early stage developed. Some of us remember that war. We remember the awful holocausts that took place in the early years of that war. So far nothing like those have taken place this time—
Comment on this
But we did not know and nobody in England, France or Germany knew what was going to happen immediately after the outbreak of the present war. But the same things might have happened as in 1914, and it was thought in England—judging by the preparations that were made there and about which you have all read—that the same terrible loss of life might have taken place this time. We all know that in England thousands and even millions of people were evacuated from the great centres into the country. I take it the same thing has happened in France and Germany. Great preparations were made to meet the awful things that were expected to happen in these countries. But, thanks be to God, so far they have not happened. Everybody can join in the prayer, and the hope, that those terrible things will not happen this time. I hope they will be avoided this time in England, France and Germany just as they have been up to the present; I hope more strongly that we will not see such misfortunes in this country either.
But two months ago we did not know what was likely to happen. We were serious and we took precautions. Every Deputy here was satisfied to give the Government whatever powers the Government thought necessary to meet the terrible situation that was facing us—the terrible situation with which Europe was being menaced, all of us fully realising that some terrible things were likely to happen. They have not happened to the extent it was thought probable at that time. We all feel that a great responsibility, for the time being at any rate, has been lifted off our shoulders. The same feeling has taken place in England. Many of the people there who were evacuated are now taking a chance on the possibility that the things they thought were going to happen are at least postponed and may never happen. The people there are coming back again to their homes. I think the same mentality pervades the members of this House and probably the people in the country. The feeling seems to be that we took the thing too seriously at the beginning and that we ought to forget about it now. That seems to be the attitude of most members of the Opposition who have spoken on this debate. It is not the attitude of all of them. We have not been bombed and there is very little sign here of a striking kind that there is a war going on in Europe. We have not had a visitation from a bomber from any side good or bad and I hope we never will. But we have been seriously affected economically and financially. That is likely to continue.
I have been asked a dozen times from the Opposition side "why did you bring in a Supplementary Budget?" The Leader of the Opposition, Deputy Cosgrave, said he was astonished that a Supplementary Budget should have been thought of. Perhaps it is not a nice thing to say but I think I can say that I do not believe the Deputy was serious in making that statement. He knew as well as I did that it was most likely that a Supplementary Budget would be found necessary. I will give the House my reason for stating why I do not think he was serious on Wednesday last in making the statement that he was surprised at the introduction of a Supplementary Budget. When I made a brief statement here in the middle of October on the financial situation, as I saw it then, one of the last words addressed to me by Deputy Cosgrave was "remember an increase in taxation would mean increased unemployment". How did that come into his mind except that he realised then, as a man having some experience of affairs, that we would not be able to get through this financial year on the Budget brought in last May. He knew we could not. Everyone who gave any thought to a consideration of the situation in which we found ourselves at the outbreak of the war, and especially a man like Deputy Cosgrave, must have known that we would not be able to get through this emergency without serious results for the taxpayers. At all events, at that time Deputy Cosgrave made that statement. In a way I do not blame him. When a Budget has been introduced and a statement on that Budget made by the Minister for Finance, the Leader of the Opposition is not in a very enviable position in being expected to get up there and then and make a statement criticising it.
All I can say is that I heard the same speech from him many times before. He hardly changed a word. We heard about squandermania, extravagance, and all the rest of it. I invite Deputies opposite, if they have a little time to spare, to read the speech made on the last Budget on May 10th by Deputy Cosgrave, and to read the one made on Wednesday last by Deputy Cosgrave. I think they will not find many words changed.
Comment on this
Then on the following day, having had 24 hours to consider what he would say and to select his lines of attack, Deputy O'Sullivan came along with the solemn professorial air which he sometimes adopts, looking solemn, trying to look wise, and trying to be humorous in parts. I can understand a man of his profession trying to look wise. It is part of the make-up. He acts the part pretty well at times. He talked about playacting, in the course of his speech. Well, he is not a bad hand at it himself. But, when he is trying to be humorous, I cannot get any fun out of it, and I do not know whether anybody else in this House can do so either. I should dislike seeing an elephant trying to dance a hornpipe——
Comment on this
——and I think the efforts of Deputy O'Sullivan at nimbleness of wit are about equal to that performance. I sat here for 24 hours——
Comment on this
No Deputy is compelled to sit in the House if he does not want to listen, but while he remains in the House he will have to behave himself.
Comment on this
I am not going to leave the House until I am compelled to leave it, no matter who is speaking.
Comment on this
Why does not the Minister practise what he preaches? He forgets all the promises that were made before the 1932 election, when we were told they would reduce taxation and turn this country into a paradise.
Comment on this
Exhibitions of humour such as we had here on Thursday afternoon from Deputy O'Sullivan do not impress me. As I say, the speeches have not been varied very much, and I suppose in a way nobody is to be blamed for that. Most of the arguments which have been put forward have dealt with three or four items in the Budget. Some of those have been effectively dealt with in reply by two of my colleagues, the Minister for Supplies and the Minister for Industry and Commerce. I suppose I will be expected to go over them again, as the author of this Supplementary Budget, and I do not mind doing so. Even if I cannot make any impression on the members of this House I may make some on the public outside, and after all those are the people who count. There is one thing which has been talked about by every Deputy, and has been hammered home as a shocking thing, and that is the tax on sugar. Everybody who has spoken has mentioned that. It has been referred to by Deputy O'Sullivan and by Deputy Dillon. I think the most extreme statements that were made by anybody in speaking on the Budget were made last night by Deputy McGilligan. He was horrified at the idea that anybody, any member of the Government in this country, should dream of putting on a tax which hits the poor so hard as a tax on sugar. Of course a tax on any kind of foodstuffs hits the poor, but nobody has dared to state that we have not hit everybody. Nobody will deny that we have hit everybody in this Budget. We have hit the poor and hit everybody else as well. Deputy the Lord Mayor of Cork thought that the tax is hitting the lowest ranks of the people.
Comment on this
There are people with large incomes—unfortunately we have not a great many of them; I wish we had a great many more—who, by the time their taxes have been paid into our Exchequer have not 5/- nor 4/- in the £ left for themselves. That is pretty stiff taxation.
Comment on this
I believe I think as much about their position and have as much knowledge of it as anybody else in this House. If taxation has to be got, it will have to be got from every class of the community.
Comment on this
Including the means test—including all those things. If the Deputy were Minister for Finance here at this very time he would not be able to carry on unless he taxed every class of the community.
Comment on this
I am quite satisfied that there should not be any hungry person in this country. Because I believe that, I am saying so.
Comment on this
I am afraid the Deputy will never arrive at the position of having the responsibility for taxing anybody here, and therefore he and his colleagues in the Labour Party can well afford to make statements of this sort. They know they will never be asked to bear the responsibility.
Comment on this
No. What can we go on but experience? I will go away from my line of argument for the moment.
Comment on this
I will digress for a moment. It will interest the Deputy, who was formerly in the Labour Party and was kicked out of the Labour Party.
Comment on this
I would not advise the Minister to develop that. Do not forget that the Public Safety Act is in force to-day.
Comment on this
I am very humble; I am prepared to learn even from the Minister.
Comment on this
We heard yesterday from the leader of the Labour Party a good deal of talk about the organised workers, and what their reactions would be to this Budget and to the statements made by the Minister in the Budget. He spoke for the organised workers of Ireland. The Labour Party spoke for them. They said they would tell this Government what the organised workers thought of them as a government and they would tell them what they thought of their taxes and their statements about salaries and wages. I represent more organised workers I think; or at any rate the Minister for Supplies and I represent more organised workers in the City of Dublin than all the Labour Party put together represent in Ireland.
Comment on this
How is that for you? I say that we represent more organised workers than the whole lot of you put together. They will not vote for you.
Comment on this
We made those promises at different election times; we made them over and over again, and on every occasion you and the members of your Party had a chance to criticise our promises, and where did the representatives of the Labour Party get in my constituency and in Deputy Lemass' constituency in the City of Dublin? For God's sake, will Deputy Norton and the rest of you give up this talking? So far as Dublin is concerned, the organised workers there do not trust you.
Comment on this
Listen to the kind of codology that even a sensible man like the Lord Mayor of Cork talks. We are told "Do not tax the worker".
Comment on this
The leader of the Labour Party, Deputy Norton, dwelt at great length on this subject.
Comment on this
I think the Tánaiste has effectively answered that and he should now get back to the Budget.
Comment on this
I am dealing with the questions raised about the taxation of the workers and the statement in the Budget about wages, salaries, and profits. As regards the workers, every time that I have gone before them, and every time that Deputy Lemass has gone before them in Dublin, they voted for us. The people who voted for me, in the main, were organised workers, trade unionists. The same applies to Deputy Lemass, and I can say that we have been very effective and faithful guardians of their interests.
Comment on this
If we had not been faithful guardians we would not have been, in Dublin City, where the vast majority of them are our friends, put at the top of the poll.
Comment on this
Take your medicine now, and you will get a good dose of it from me any time you talk in that strain. There is nobody who has been more closely associated with the organised workers in Dublin than I have.
Comment on this
They will not be allowed to increase their incomes to meet the rising prices you cannot control.
Comment on this
I am very grateful for these interruptions, because they give me an opportunity of reminding these gentlemen of something they might have forgotten if I did not touch them up a bit.
Comment on this
Deputy McGilligan spoke at length on this subject, and I noted the extremes to which he went. This is one thing which is reported in the Irish Times this morning, and I think it is correct:—
"Sugar was to bear an additional tax of ¾d. a lb. If these were the costs of neutrality, he did not know that he would not prefer war."
That is one statement, and another statement was:—
"Until all their resources had been exhausted, he would object to the tax on sugar. As long as any other range of commodities was open to taxation, he would, with the exception of bread, choose them for taxation before he would touch sugar."
We have these statements from a man who taxed sugar every year he was in office, and for three years in succession he put a higher tax on it than we have.
Comment on this
What years were these? Will the Minister name the years?
Comment on this
I will. Where is the honesty in statements of that kind? Such hypocrisy, such dishonesty, such flapdoodle to expect the country to swallow nonsense of that kind and to believe that he is a serious statesman. The people in the country are not such goms as he thinks they are, nor are their memories so short. Every year that he was a Minister there was a tax on sugar. Is that right?
Comment on this
It was reduced on several occasions. Will you name the years?
Comment on this
I will mention them in time and I will suit myself, not the Deputy. Deputy McGilligan said:
"Until all their resources had been exhausted, he would object to the tax on sugar."
Where is the honest statesman? That is the statement of Deputy McGilligan, one of the leaders of that Party. Where is there any honesty in a statement of that kind, when he taxed sugar every time there was a Budget brought in by the Opposition when they were in office?
Comment on this
It is a completely dishonest statement, coming from the Minister.
Comment on this
That was Deputy McGilligan's statement yesterday:—
"Until all their resources had been exhausted, he would object to the tax on sugar. As long as any other range of commodities was open to taxation, he would, with the exception of bread, choose them for taxation before he would touch sugar".
In 1924 there was 2¾d. on sugar; in 1925 there was 2¾d.
Comment on this
In 1926, there was 2¾d.; in 1927, 1d.; in 1928, 1d.; in 1929, 1d.; in 1930, 1¼d.; in 1931, 1¼d.; in 1932, 1½d.; and in 1933, 1¾d.
Comment on this
Every year that Government was in office, and every year the Deputy who spoke those words last night was a member of that Government, there was a tax on sugar. He was not a member of the Government during the whole ten years, but every year he was there, he taxed sugar. Then last night he held out his hands in holy horror at the idea of this Government daring to put ¾d. on sugar. Every year. And three years in succession he put on a great deal more. Where were the Labour Party in those years howling about how the poor people were being starved to death by an extra tax on sugar?
Comment on this
Where was the Minister in 1924, 1925 and 1926 when they were putting on these taxes?
Comment on this
The public are going to read that statement of the Minister's, and I wonder if they will be gullible enough to fall for it.
Comment on this
The Minister's statement is lying propaganda and he knows it.
Comment on this
I want to get this clarified. I will tell you exactly the figure. Most certainly. I do not want to mislead anybody and, if you ask me quietly the question so that I can hear you, without shouting at me, I will give you the figure. There is no attempt to camouflage or hide the price of sugar or the tax on it. I am talking of the tax on sugar now.
Comment on this
I do not want it to be obscure and I will be glad if anybody, Deputy Morrissey or anybody else, will tell me if I made a false statement. If I did so, I will correct it.
Comment on this
The Minister was caught out. It did not go as well as he thought. It was a boomerang.
Comment on this
I was not caught out, not at all. My statement is that sugar was taxed every year that Government was in office—every year.
Comment on this
It was taxed every year. That is true. We carried the tax over from the British and taxed sugar every year but, in addition to that, for three years that Government put on more additional tax on sugar than we have dreamt of doing.
Comment on this
I will give you the figures. I will give you all the figures of the full tax on sugar from 1924 so that nobody can say I am wanting to misrepresent the position. In 1924 the full tax on sugar was 2¾d. per pound. In 1925 it was the same; 1926 the same; 1927, 1d.; 1928, 1d.; 1929, 1d.; 1930, 1¼d.; 1931, 1¼d.; 1932, 1¼d.; 1933, 1¾d.; 1934, 1¾d.; 1935, 1¾d.; 1936, 2d.; 1937, 2¼d.; 1938, 2d.; 1939, 1¾d.; and now, with the additional tax, 2½d.
Comment on this
Those are the full figures. I think that was what Deputy Keyes wanted, but, with the shouting, I did not catch the question he was asking. If there is any other figure required I will give it. I will give all the figures. I want to hide nothing.
Comment on this
As I say, the tax on sugar was there all the time Deputy McGilligan was a member of the Government and his soul was in a state of ferment last night about the awful crime of putting a tax on sugar. Every other source, he said, should be sought. Were they sought by the last Government when every year they were in office they put a tax on sugar and, in addition, in the years when the tax on sugar was at its highest during the regime of the last Government there was also 6? pence on tea in 1923 and 4? pence on tea in 1924.
Comment on this
God knows I have good reason to remember them—more than the Deputy—very good reason. Do not drag me into that or you will hear more than you bargained for. I may remind you of the Black-and-Tan times too. Do not drag these things in now or it will be worse for you. Your history may be raked up. It is best forgotten.