We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Private Deputies' Business. - Farming Dispute: Motion to Revoke Orders.

Contributions 155–328 of 328. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Might I appeal to the Deputies opposite that if there are going to be any more of these dramatic leavings of the House, they ought to take place at the same time, so that we can get on with the work? I want to impress on the Deputies opposite that we look on this matter as very serious from the point of view of the small farmer who lives in the Wicklow hills, or in any other hills, or even on the plains of Kildare or Meath, who was prevented from going into the fair to sell his few cattle or pigs and, very often, I repeat, by men who the previous day sent their cattle to be shipped. That is the issue we are up against.

Comment on this

Can the Minister give an instance of that?

Comment on this

Yes, dozens.

Comment on this

There are any amount that can be got.

Comment on this

I met them to-day on the Dublin road.

Comment on this

Deputy Costello spoke about the right of the producer to dispose of the produce of his toil and of his soil as he thought fit. That is what we stand for. We stand for the principle in this order—and I will come to the justification of this order soon—that the small producer has as good a right to market his few cattle and pigs in the fair as the bigger farmer. This big farmer has, in some cases, sent his cattle off to be shipped and, in other cases, worse still, when the fair was coming to a close, and when the smallholders wanted their money for their few cattle badly these leaders of the pickets tried to buy these cattle at small prices.

Comment on this

That is a lie.

Comment on this

It is the truth.

Comment on this

It is the truth, and can be proved.

Comment on this

I can prove it, and I am a farmer.

Comment on this

The Minister will settle it by that kind of language.

Comment on this

There is no settlement of this strike. Does the Deputy think that we are going to meet those people——

Comment on this

It is no wonder there is a strike.

Comment on this

——who went on strike and used violence and intimidation to get derating and moratoriums? There is no settling of that strike, and the Party opposite should stand with us in that.

Comment on this

Who raised derating first? Look to your right.

Comment on this

The motion.

Comment on this

Look to your right— Mr. de Valera, in the town of Athy.

Comment on this

We will come to that, too.

Comment on this

And you carried an election on it.

Comment on this

I want to make myself perfectly clear. The Minister, for Justice said that I would be very glad to see the end of this milk strike. I would.

Comment on this

By surrender?

Comment on this

Not necessarily by surrender. I sent word to these people who had not come near me, in September. They got a message through Senator Byrne that I was prepared to consider the price for 1940 in the month of December.

Comment on this

But that you would not sanction any increase.

Comment on this

I did not say that. I said that I would not sanction it at that time, because the cost of production had not increased at that time. Every Deputy knows that men who had their cows on grass in September, and who were paying the same wages, the same rent and rates, had no case whatever for an increase in the price in September.

Comment on this

A higher price for cows to replenish the stock.

Comment on this

They were getting a higher price for cows and for calves, but I said to them at that time that if a case could be made in December for the 1940 price, that case would be considered. The next thing I got was an ultimatum.

Comment on this

We are very near a settlement now after that statement.

Comment on this

In issuing this order, we did not create any new offence. We merely said, in issuing the order, that the Government were satisfied that the ordinary courts were inadequate to deal with offences of this kind that might be committed. We were perfectly justified in making that statement, and in making that order. As Deputy Costello stated, you had offences such as unlawful assembly which were tried by the ordinary courts. You had other matters such as offences under Section 7 of the Conspiracy and Protection of Property Act, 1875, which were always tried by the ordinary courts.

Comment on this

What about the lastmentioned one?

Comment on this

With regard to the requisitioning of food?

Comment on this

An offence under Section 5 of the Emergency Powers Act.

Comment on this

That was never tried before an ordinary court.

Comment on this

It is a new offence.

Comment on this

I maintain—and I think Deputies opposite if they were on these benches would make the same case—that it is not likely that justice could be done in the ordinary courts in cases of this kind. Does not every Deputy know that if a case of this kind came to be tried before a district justice there would be a demonstration outside the courthouse?

Comment on this

Are they not being tried by them now?

Comment on this

They are not being tried.

Comment on this

They are being remanded; and is there a solitary instance where intimidation has been used?

Comment on this

Everybody in this country knows—although Deputies may try to make light of the situation, they, too, know it very well—that if one of these cases were to be tried before a district justice in any of the towns round Dublin where the strike is taking place, there would be a demonstration outside the court.

Comment on this

It has not happened yet.

Comment on this

It is hardly fair to expect these district justices to try these cases, even though they may be very serious. Some of these cases may go for trial before a jury. Is any Deputy going to tell me that you can get a fair trial by jury for these farmers in any one of these counties? Do we not know well that there are some men in these counties would be inclined to hang them for these offences, while there are others who would be inclined to let them off? Surely you are not going to get a fair trial where they would be biassed one way or another?

Comment on this

Will the jury be all big farmers?

Comment on this

I say that they would be biassed one way or the other.

Comment on this

I thought that all the small farmers were all against this business?

Comment on this

No, some of them would be against it and some of them for it. I say that we were perfectly entitled, as a Government, to say that we were satisfied that the ordinary courts were not adequate to deal with these alleged offences. We were satisfied of that because these men who were capable of coming together in eight motor cars to spill the contents of a lorry of potatoes around the road, were equally capable of coming to demonstrate outside a courthouse where a district justice might be trying one of these cases. Deputy Costello said that we could deal with these offences by having the defendants bound over for 12 months by a district justice. Deputy Costello should have a fair idea of how a district justice would be inclined to deal with cases of this kind at the present time, and of the intimidation that is likely to take place. Does Deputy Costello think that binding them over for 12 months is going to have the slightest effect? Many of them may be honourable men and probably would keep their bonds but there would be others to take their place. There would be several ready to take their place if they thought that the maximum penalty for going into the fight on behalf of the Federation was that they might be brought before a district justice and bound over for 12 months. That is not going to be a deterrent.

The special court to which these cases can be sent under this order is not subject to intimidation. It is not subject in any way to any influence of that kind and the Leaders opposite have said on many occasions—and we have said so, too—that those who go before that court will get a fair trial. What more do they want? They get a fair trial. I do not see that we have done anything that should be condemned in this House, when we make sure, as far as we can, that people whom we accuse—I put it that way to please Deputy O'Higgins—of committing certain crimes will be brought before a court where they are sure to get justice. That is all we have done.

Comment on this

Is it a crime to refuse to send milk to Dublin, if they are requested to do so by you?

Comment on this

It is a crime.

Comment on this

That is a new offence.

Comment on this

Yes, under the Emergency Powers Act. Deputy O'Donovan said that the producers of milk had a case. I do not know whether they have or not but if they have, they have the most perfect form of arbitration machinery under the Act passed by this House setting up the Dublin and District Milk Board. The board which was set up was composed of representatives of the producers, the wholesalers and the retailers with a chairman. They were to discuss amongst themselves the price to be paid to producers. If they could agree, that could be looked upon as an arbitration. If they did not agree, the chairman sent me a report together with a statement of the views of the different sections of the board and his own views. It is not correct to say that I determined the price to be paid to the producers.

Comment on this

Did you not get that report and did you not reply to the milk producers that you would not consider any alteration in price?

Comment on this

I shall tell you that in a moment. On the 14th April of this year —this is the last letter I got from the milk producers—I received a communication from them saying that a price had been fixed by the board for May, June and July. They were willing to agree to the May and June price but they thought that the July price should be revised. They have said that I refused to see them. Here is the letter which my secretary wrote to them in reply to their letter. He said:

"With further reference to your letter, dated 14th instant, I am directed by the Minister for Agriculture to state that as pointed out in my letter to you of 14th March, 1938, alteration in milk prices can only be effected through the medium of a determination by the Dublin District Milk Board submitted for the Minister's consideration. The Minister will, of course, be prepared to consider any such determination referred to him by the board. In the circumstances, it is considered that the reception of the proposed deputation would serve no useful purpose."

Comment on this

What is the date of that letter?

Comment on this

The 22nd April. Since that I have got no request to receive them.

Comment on this

No letter passed one way or another since?

Comment on this

No. I have said in that letter that there was no use in receiving them unless the board first made a recommendation. Any Minister would have done the same thing. The next letter I got from the association was on the 3rd November, saying that unless I gave my sanction to 1/10 a gallon they would take other action. That is all.

Comment on this

What was the reaction to that demand?

Comment on this
Mr. Brennan

Was that letter the result of the findings of the board?

Comment on this

No. The board, I think, considered the matter. I am not clear on the point. It is not that I want to evade it. I shall answer any questions I am asked about it. The board considered the matter in or about September and refused to agree—that is, all the members refused to agree—to an increased price.

Comment on this

Did the chairman communicate with the Minister in the ordinary course?

Comment on this

I do not think so. However, I am not sure of that.

Comment on this

But was it not his duty to do so under the constitution of the board?

Comment on this

If there was a formal consideration of prices, certainly, but I do not think there was such a thing.

Comment on this

I have official information from the producers that there was a consideration.

Comment on this

Well, I can deal with the facts if I am asked a question, but, as far as I am concerned, the last letter that I got from the association after the 14th April was this letter of the 3rd November, that unless they got 1/10 they would take action.

Comment on this

I want to assure the Minister that my questions are intended to elicit information and not to interrupt.

Comment on this
Michael Brennan Mr. M. Brennan Fine Gael

That is what I am looking for, too.

Comment on this

I say that I regret this milk strike for this reason: that it was necessary to see that milk was supplied to Dublin. It was necessary to get certain creameries to supply that milk, and it will be necessary to allow those creameries to continue to supply milk to Dublin if they so think fit. Therefore, when this strike ends——

Comment on this

Milk not fit for human consumption?

Comment on this

I can deal with that later. When this strike ends, producers in the five counties will not all be able to supply milk to Dublin again. That will be the position. I am not saying it in any bitter way. I regret it.

Comment on this

Are the creameries that refused to supply milk to Dublin going to be penalised by you and by the Government if they refuse to supply?

Comment on this

Yes. These creameries are sending good milk to Dublin.

Comment on this

Why was the Milk and Dairies Act of 1935 passed if the creameries are sending good milk to Dublin?

Comment on this

That Act permitted certain creameries to send milk to Dublin. I come now to another matter. It may be thought that those people have a good case. Deputy O'Donovan, and other Deputies opposite, take it for granted that they have a good case. They say they believe they have a good case. I have not been in a position to get costings for the production of milk for this area. They are very difficult things to get. I have here a report made by a professor or a lecturer, I am not sure which, in Oxford University. He took quite a long time in trying to get the costings of milk production and distribution. He did not produce anything very definite in the end and admitted that he could not.

The only thing, therefore, that I can do is to look around and see what are the prices paid elsewhere. I quoted here before—many Deputies know them—the prices paid to creameries down the country. They are not more than half what are being paid here in Dublin. It is true to say that the members of the Milk Producers' Association who live in these counties surrounding Dublin have greater expenses to meet than the creamery supplier, but what that figure would amount to I do not know. If we take the case of the supplier in Northern Ireland and Great Britain who is supplying liquid milk under the same conditions as the producers here, what is the position? In England, the October price was 1/1½, less the cost of collection. For November and December the supplier is getting ½d. more. Our price here is 1/4 less cost of collection.

Comment on this

What is the cost of feeding stuffs? I am surprised that the Minister should make such a comparison.

Comment on this

I will come to that later. In the North of Ireland last winter, at this time, the price paid was 1/3. I believe they have said that they are going to pay 3d. more this winter. That will bring the price to 1/6, less 1¾d. levy made by the Northern Government which leaves the price 1/4¼, less cost of collection. That is definitely higher than it is here.

Comment on this

What was the price paid here last year?

Comment on this

1/4¼.

Comment on this

And it is a ¼d. less this year?

Comment on this

Yes, at this particular time. That may be some consolation to the Deputy.

Comment on this

No, it is not. It is information we want.

Comment on this

These are the only comparisons that I could get as to what producers are getting in Great Britain, in Northern Ireland or our own creamery producers. Compared with any of these, the producers here are not being badly treated. Deputy Belton asked what about the cost of feeding stuffs. I would like to tell him that the plea made by those men to me, when I first brought in the Act, was that they were men who deserved support because they were self-sufficient farmers: that they produced their own milk, their own grass and their own crops and that they were self-sufficient in every way.

I say, whether that is true or not, that the man, whether he is in these five counties, or in some other county outside the five counties, who is prepared to produce milk on a mixed farm: the man who produces his own hay, roots and grain, is a greater asset to this country than the man who fills his houses with cows and buys all his feeding-stuffs.

Comment on this

Would the Minister tell us why milk must be cheaper now than it was last year, when they were getting 1/4½?

Comment on this

All I can say to the Deputy is that it may have been too dear last year. I want to say this: that I was asked the day the milk strike started if I would have arbitration on the question as to how much more it cost to produce milk this year than it did at this time last year. I said: "No. I will have arbitration on the point: how much does it cost to produce milk this year." I do not know, but I may have sanctioned too much last year. I am prepared at any time to have the cost of the production of milk coming in here, allowing a reasonable profit, examined. In that case the producers would, in my opinion, run the risk of having their prices come down. That would be just as likely as that they would go up.

Comment on this

Would the Minister give us the wholesalers' prices in England, Belfast and here, as well as the prices paid by the consumers?

Comment on this

I have some tables here. Let us take the winter period from October to April. Milk is 1/4 a gallon delivered to the wholesaler in Dublin. Milk delivered to consumers' houses is 2/4 a gallon. For milk taken at the shops they get 2½d. on 3d. a pint, mostly 3d. That is 2/-.

Comment on this

I am talking about the Belfast price and the English price.

Comment on this

These are the retail prices in Dublin. The retail prices in England are as follows:—In London, all the year round, milk is 2/4 a gallon. In other centres, with a population of over 25,000, the price is also 2/4 a gallon all the year round except in May and June.

Comment on this

But it is 2/4 for the rest of the year?

Comment on this

In London it is 2/4 the whole year round, and, in certain of the larger towns in England, it is also 2/4 throughout the year except during the months of May and June. Now you go down until you reach 2/- in the smaller villages. As I have already said that milk is sold by the producer at an average of 1/0½d. per gallon for the year. The distribution costs in London are very large.

Comment on this

What is the Belfast price?

Comment on this

I am afraid I have not got the cost of distribution there.

Comment on this

That would be somewhat comparable with Dublin.

Comment on this

Is the distributor in England getting 1/3?

Comment on this

There are certain levies and so on. I think they would amount to 3d. These are levies for the pool so as to bring up the price at other times.

Comment on this

So they have about 1/- a gallon?

Comment on this

Yes, about the same as here. Before I sit down I want to refer to two or three other points. A question was raised about derating. Evidently we have to repeat our facts on this issue every time the matter is raised here, before Deputies will see that we more than carried out our guarantees with regard to derating. It is true that when in Opposition we were in favour of derating. And the Government who sat on these benches was then against it. But when we came into power we felt that halving the annuities was a better proposition for the farmers than giving them derating. The rates are levied on the poor law valuation according to the value of the land rated.

Comment on this

The Minister offered them both.

Comment on this

No, I did not.

Comment on this

I have it here. I have the Minister's speech on that matter offering both.

Comment on this

No, we did not. On the other hand, we have the position that some people pay a very high rent for their land and others pay a low rent. By giving half the annuities we were conferring more benefit on the men who were paying a high rent than if we gave them derating. Let us take the figure for the rates which, as the Opposition tell us, have gone up so much. The rates on land have increased by £724,000 but against that we have given the farmers half the annuities which amount to £2,200,000, so that the advantage there is very considerable. There is one other set of figures which I would like to give and that is the Agricultural Prices Index figure. Statements have been made here by the Opposition on this aspect of the question. I have been asked what was the price of cattle, sheep and so on for the year 1931. In 1931 the Agricultural Prices Index was 111. In the year 1938 that had risen to 118 and the figure this year is 126.

Comment on this

The 1931 prices were gold prices.

Comment on this

What difference does that make to us? What difference does it make when we did not get gold?

Comment on this

That is an intelligent remark from the Minister.

Comment on this

I want to go back to where I started, and to impress on Deputies opposite—though there is no use at this stage in asking them not to proceed with this motion—the danger of the course on which they are embarking. The Opposition are doing a dangerous thing in giving the support of so many Deputies here to those outside who have adopted the weapon of violence or intimidation in order to get support for derating or anything else of that sort. In that action they are doing a great disservice to this country. They ought to realise the evil of that course before they proceed with this motion. The people behind this strike are war-minded. They have issued their war bulletins. They have adopted war methods, the methods of violence and intimidation. I would regret exceedingly if any considerable number of Deputies on the Opposition side of the House or anywhere else go into the Opposition Lobbies in support of this sort of thing.

Comment on this

I regret I had not the honour of listening to the Minister for Justice when he spoke this evening here. It strikes me that he could have improved upon the speech to which we have just listened. That speech is characteristic of the policy under which the country has groaned for the past eight years. Let us take the last statement as an example of it. It is quite clear from what he has said that the Minister wants the country to understand that the Government in this case is acting as administrator and not as a partisan, whereas there has been running through his speech, from one end to the other, the most partisan and incompetent series of statements that could be given utterance to by any Minister in any Government. He says the Agricultural Prices Index figure for the year 1931 was 111, that the figure for 1938 was 118, and that it is now 126. Did he really mean to mislead the House and the people when he made that statement? Could he not have said that any person who sold agricultural goods up to a certain date which included 1938, got 118 as against 111 for 1931, and that he is now going to get 126? Let us examine this a step further. It is clear that 126 is in respect of all items. But every farmer is not in all items. Some are purchasing some of their items at 126; they sold at 118. If there is one thing that is fallacious and that has been since the Party opposite cursed this country by coming into public life, it is their treatment of figures.

Comment on this

They never reversed them any way.

Comment on this

The Minister for Industry and Commerce did worse. He put plus where there should be minus. Practically the whole speech of the Minister for Agriculture was in connection with the merits of this dispute. We are not dealing with them. We are dealing with one thing alone and that is good order and good government in this country. We had given an example of administration in that respect which this Government would be glad to have to their credit. This motion runs:—

"That the Dáil disapproves of the action of the Government in making an order under Section 36 of the Offences Against the State Act, 1939."

Comment on this

That is not the whole of the motion. Read on.

Comment on this

The Minister can go home and read it.

Comment on this

Deputy Cosgrave is now acting the heavy father.

Comment on this

If the Minister for Industry and Commerce got proper treatment by a heavy father he would not in his old age be as bad as he is now.

Comment on this

Is it from that Deputy McGilligan is suffering now?

Comment on this

The Minister for Agriculture made a statement that the leaders of the Opposition had laughed at several crimes, and he said:—

"The Government were perfectly satisfied that the ordinary courts were inadequate to deal with offences of this kind..."

There you have the Minister's contribution to this debate. Is that his idea of evidence? Where is his evidence? Where is the evidence for the statement that justice could not be done in the ordinary courts in cases of this kind? He says everybody knows it. That is his evidence and it is the evidence on which the Government acts. In what court would that be accepted?

Comment on this

I think Deputy Cosgrave will find that I spent a quarter of an hour on that point.

Comment on this

That is the sum and substance of the Minister's case.

Comment on this

I dealt with it before the Deputy came into the House.

Comment on this

Has anybody told the Minister that jurymen will not act impartially in these cases in any rural district?

Comment on this

Oh, I said that all right.

Comment on this

What does the Minister mean by that?

Comment on this

That jurors would not be impartial.

Comment on this

In other words that a juryman will go into the box and take an oath to return a true verdict and that in a matter of this sort, which is not really a national question but a social question, he will refuse to do his duty? Would it not be only fair, before one would make a pronouncement like that, that at least one jury should get an opportunity of showing it was not going to do its duty in one particular case? One case would not be convincing to me, but at any rate the House would have been entitled to a single case of that sort. The Minister will recollect that I produced a case here where jurymen were shot at, one being killed and one wounded, and the Minister at that time would not take the suggestion we made for dealing with that particular form of intimidation.

Comment on this

Irish jurymen were only once called perjurers in the British Parliament. We have an Irish Minister charging them with it to-night.

Comment on this

You have not.

Comment on this

We have.

Comment on this

That they would not do their duty.

Comment on this

You have not.

Comment on this

When they go into a jury box, and they know that certain people are charged with certain offences, does the Minister really mean to tell us here that they will not try them fairly? The Minister went on to say that the district justice would be intimidated. We have no case of that sort—none whatever.

Comment on this

And never had.

Comment on this

The Minister said the special court would not be subject to intimidation. I know that quite well, but is there not one thing obvious to any person who has had experience of this sort of internal disturbance in a country, in this country and over in England, that the courts in considering those cases endeavour to make the situation easier between the parties; that there are cases in which, if there is a serious internal situation of that kind, the judge will postpone sentence with a view to seeing whether or not it is possible to compose the differences that there are between the people? This special court is set up to deal with this, directed I have no doubt in some form or other by some intimation that the Government wishes to put it down. Who is to administer justice in this country? Is it the Government or is it the courts? If it be the courts, it is not enough to tell us that they are inadequate to deal with that situation, or that the district justice is fearsome of doing his duty, or that there are so many cases in which he cannot do it.

I am not satisfied that this special court which the Government has set up, and which is the one we set up when we were in office, is the appropriate court to deal with a matter of this sort at all. People who are accustomed to courtsmartial are not the people who are the best adapted to deal with an internal situation of this character. It is not a conspiracy that is going to affect the existence of the State or the security of the State. The Minister went at great length into the merits of this case. He presumably is the judge, and he proceeds to pronounce his opinions, even at a time when one would expect that he would be impartial in his views. I am not concerned with the merits of this case at all in connection with this motion. I am concerned entirely with the question of law and order, and respect for law and order in this State. Those farmers have not been taught that respect for law and order by the very Government that is now speaking of it.

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

When did the Deputy become respectable? Let us be on the level. There is only a question of a year in the difference. Go back to 1921, when we were all the same. We became estranged in 1922.

Comment on this

We took part in a revolution——

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

So did we

Comment on this

——and having taken part in it we put to the people certain things and we got their decision.

Comment on this

In a very shady way.

Comment on this

We were their instruments in carrying out their decision. You proceeded to do much worse than this, and you complained and you whinged when you met with stronger force than you were able to exercise. We taught you law and order.

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

With the British Army at your back.

Comment on this

There was not a single British soldier at our back, and you had more guns from the British than we had.

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

We can all speak of 1922 if the Deputy wishes. We will not run away from it.

Comment on this
Fionán Lynch An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

We will come down to 1939.

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

Keep the Deputy to it.

Comment on this

There is one thing certain, we did not run, but the gentlemen opposite showed great form at that particular kind of activity.

Comment on this

We saw your heels.

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

You never saw our heels.

Comment on this
Fionán Lynch An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

We are dealing with this motion.

Comment on this

I think in fairness to the people and to the country we should deal with the matter before us.

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

Exactly. Keep the Deputy to it.

Comment on this

The Minister himself first talked of 1921 to-night. I think he is sorry for it now.

Comment on this
Fionán Lynch An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Let us confine ourselves to 1939, and to the motion before the House.

Comment on this

We have said and we repeat that we stand for ordered conditions in this State, and have done so for a long time; it is not only to-day or yesterday. We say that it is an abuse of the power of Government to introduce this particular method of dealing with a matter of this kind. It is not an offence against the State. It is a mere internal disturbance. The most that can be said in respect of it is that there is a scattering of property, a destruction of milk. I deprecate the destruction of milk or of any property. I deprecate the burning of boots and of other things of that sort. I deprecate a Minister who will not give a man authority to sell a pig in this country for the highest price he can get for it.

Comment on this

The Oireachtas will not let me.

Comment on this

Do you not move the Oireachtas? Is it not your own law?

Comment on this

I do not always move the Deputy.

Comment on this

He is ashamed of it now.

Comment on this

When we were speaking of getting the best value for the people of this country, the Minister put himself up as the judge. But the people do not regard you as a judge; they regard you as a mere politician, and your Government as a mere collection of politicians who have given no evidence of statesmanship, and that is what has landed us into this position. In connection with this resolution we gave you a further opportunity of resolving this question, taking no hand, act or part in favour of any person engaged in it, by saying that there should be set up——

Comment on this

Arbitration?

Comment on this

——independent arbitration or conciliation machinery.

Comment on this

For what?

Comment on this

With a view to adjusting, in a manner just and equitable in the interests of the farmers, the consumers and the taxpayers, the matters giving rise to such action.

Comment on this

What are the matters?

Comment on this

The matters in dispute.

Comment on this

The censor will not let the public know.

Comment on this

What are they? There are handbills here.

Comment on this

The Minister has the advantage of me if he has handbills. He objects, if I understand it correctly, to this farmers' body, or whatever it is called, putting down as one of its conditions a condition to which he subscribed at a certain time. I sat over there listening to Deputy Ryan, as he then was, telling us of the difficulties of the farmers throughout the country, and how they were unable to pay their way. He had the right to do that here when he was in Opposition, but when he is in the Government he denies the right to some person who puts up that as a proposal.

Comment on this

I do not deny the right to any Deputy to speak. That is all the right I got.

Comment on this

I heard him here like a cry-baby making a case for the farmers. They were never as well off since as they were at that time. The Minister's own statement to-night is an indication of it. He told us that the index figure was 111 in 1931. What was it since? He did not tell us when it was 90 or when it was 85 or when it was 82.

Comment on this

The farmers told you what it was in 1933, and 1937 and 1938.

Comment on this

They made a mistake and they realise it. They found the Minister out. That is the position. The Government has made a mess of this whole business. They have put the farmers in the position in which they are at the present moment. We are offering them the first lesson in how to administer the laws in the courts of this country. We are offering them, secondly, an opportunity to get out of this difficulty that they have got into. I advise them to accept it.

Comment on this

As a mere politician, following so seasoned a statesman as Deputy Cosgrave——

Comment on this

I understood there was a time-table decided upon.

Comment on this

I merely wanted to draw the attention of the House to this fact, that the issues raised by the farmers in this leaflet have been three times referred to the electors of this country. They are the arbitration tribunal, and the only tribunal which can settle these issues. They have given their decision and, if there is to be any appeal from that decision, they are the only tribunal to which that appeal can be carried. We have no right to overthrow the Constitution by asking, as this motion now asks us to do, to set up a tribunal which is going to reverse, if necessary to override, at any rate, a decision which was given by the people of this country on this question of derating, on the question of the land purchase policy of these people and on the question of a moratorium. The people on three occasions have turned these things down and this House is not entitled to reject the verdict of the people on that matter.

Comment on this

I do not know sufficient about deep-sea fishing to know whether herrings are described as moving in a swarm or a flock, but I never witnessed so many red herrings in a pack as have been deliberately introduced across the trail of this motion by Ministers who were afraid to stand up against the motion. We have them in yellow, in green, in white and in red, white and blue—documents transmitted secretly from the Censor's Office to the political Front Bench; documents that were suppressed from the ordinary Deputy of Dáil Eireann and from the ordinary member of the public.

Comment on this

Given to the Government?

Comment on this

We have newspapers in this State controlled, bossed and suppressed for the last 14 days at the beck of the Censor, in the interests of the Government, who are in strife with the most responsible and most important members of the community, and then you come in, having suppressed one side of the case, and jeer at Deputies on this side because they do not know all the little details of the petty squabble. Your actions for the past fortnight are typical of your recklessness in big and little things for the past seven years. You have deliberately provoked a tragic and deplorable state of affairs in this country. It is a tragedy when the peasant farmers of Ireland are in revolt against any Irish Government. It is not a situation in which either the Government or the Opposition can feel comfortable. It is not a situation about which any of us can feel proud.

There was no speech made from the Government Front Bench this evening that was not calculated to make a bad situation worse. We had jeers and jibes of a snivelling, political kind against the audacity of the Irish farmer to demand the derating of his land. Who were the people who first raised that standard in the country, and on what issue did that Government first get into power? It was on the issue that is a despicable issue to-day. Remember, it is the farmers who are in revolt, and if they are engaging in what the Minister for Agriculture presumes to call crimes, it is because they, like many others, are rapidly losing faith and confidence in the democratic institutions of this State. You cannot roll together a mass of support with responsible men, or men holding responsible positions, deluding the public with false promises and then, when they have succeeded, repudiating those promises. We warned you down through the years that the seed that was being sown then would be reaped in turmoil and trouble when you disillusioned those people. If the farmers are inclined to take the unconstitutional path, who blazed the trail, who undermined their confidence, who sapped their faith in Parliamentary institutions?

We had a Minister getting up on one occasion, a colleague of the leader, telling us in this House that when one of our institutions, such as the Military Tribunal, had to be used, it was time for the Government to quit; it was time to quit when any Government had to rely on such instruments. Remember, that was at a time when the Government, having gone through months of armed conspiracy, and having marched behind the coffins of many young and old Irish people, finally came to the House for special powers. But, even in those circumstances, the powers were branded as unjustifiable, undemocratic, and the Government that asked for those powers were told they were a Government of failures. We have these same successful politicians, but broken statesmen, coming in here this evening to apply such drastic powers against a group of poor Irish farmers who presumed to revolt, or presumed to defy, in an economic way, the all-mighty Government of politicians who got in here by scrambling on their shoulders.

We are told that all the courts of Ireland have failed, that the Government are forced to the conclusion that the courts of an Irish State are inadequate to deal with ordinary Irish offences. We are told by the same Minister in the same breath that they came to that conclusion after nine days of agrarian activity; that they came to that appallingly grave decision before they had found even one man guilty before any court. And, in the determined desire not to mend the situation, but to wound their opponents; in the vindictive desire to do untold damage provided they wounded an Irish farmer, we have an Irish Minister in an Irish Parliament getting up to level a charge at our brothers and cousins in this country that even die-hard Unionists revolted at in an English Parliament, when one indiscreet person charged Irish people with being perjurers. Decent Englishmen, decent Scotsmen and decent Welshmen repudiated the person who hurled that charge. And now, because there is a bit of trouble over disillusioned, down-trodden depressed Irish farmers because they presumed to challenge the judicial knowledge of a politician opposite, we are told that Irish jurymen are only a pack of perjurers. The Government have asked powers of this kind to deal with the present situation and surely such a Government should quit office when they show such irresponsibility as has been shown over there to-night?

The situation is bad and the longer it lasts the worse it will get. I said at the beginning that I would not presume to go into the merits of this dispute. Sufficiently bad is it that there is a dispute. If you let this strike go on for one week and two weeks, armed with all the powers you got under false pretences to deal either with a foreign enemy or with armed insurrection, undoubtedly you will beat the Irish farmers to their knees; you will roll them in the dirt; you will bend the strongest and break the weakest. Is that a national victory? Is that any "crow" for this Parliament? Is that anything to make this State prouder—that a Government, armed with war powers, beat the peasant population of the country to their knees? If that does not happen, if this struggle goes the other way, if by more intense organisation the people of the City of Dublin are starved and the farmers are victorious over Government, is that a comforting thought? Is it a thing that any of us could be proud of? It would be a tremendous national humiliation. But you will carry on, armed with the baton, until one or other result is achieved and we are political tricksters to ask you to stay your hand, to stop and think, in the interests of all. Cannot you withdraw this provocative measure and give one hour's talk to the people on the other side and give one minute's consideration to the people who have still some national pride and sympathy in their hearts?

This is too grave a matter for anybody on this side to take sides. There was nothing in the motion to indicate that we were taking sides. It was merely a distortion of the motion and a twisting of our statements to even imply that we had indicated sympathy one way or the other. We said: "If the Government is not conscious of its responsibilities let us in Opposition be conscious of ours. Let us ignore—let us despise—the tempting political bait of taking sides and embarrassing a Government." The Minister for Agriculture grins.

Comment on this

And why would I not? It is a political motion.

Comment on this

If he would do less grinning and more thinking we would not have a strike at this moment. We came and we asked you to stop abusing powers you got to deal with armed conspiracy, to give these men a chance to talk around a table. We refused to take sides. The Minister came in with his sneers and his jeers. We put ourselves in the position of being jeered at from that side because we gave you those powers on the eve of war. We gave them under the assurance that you would never use them on this kind of occasion or that you would never use them, at least, until you had tried the ordinary courts.

We have never stood for lawnessness and we are not standing for it now. If property is being destroyed, if people are interfered with in their ordinary trade, then, we say, bring the offenders before the court, imprison them, fine them. Give them the ordinary law that you and I have got to stand by. They will not squeal. They will take their medicine. If another fills the breach, do the same with him. The Minister says, we have too many to do that. You have hundreds and hundreds of ordinary courts; you have only one Military Tribunal. Was that a fair argument—that one tribunal can do more than hundreds of courts?

This is a vindictive, political measure, true to form, true to your form all the time—to use any weapon to crush opposition, no matter how justified or how reasonable. Proceed if you like; defy that motion. I do not doubt your capacity, with all the forces behind you, to crush the opposition of the Irish farmers, but I would not be happy to be in the seat of any one of you the day after you did it.

Comment on this
Division

Question put.

Tá 43
·
Níl 62
Result Lost The question put was not agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?