We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Emergency Powers (Amendment) Bill, 1940—Second Stage.

Contributions 1–222 of 396. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Emergency Powers (Amendment) Bill, 1940
Enacted

No. 1 of 1940 ›

Gerald Boland Minister for Justice (Mr. Boland) Fianna Fáil

I move the Second Reading of this Bill. Deputies are aware of the reason for summoning the Dáil before it was due to assemble in February next. The Government believed they had the power of internment. As the House is aware, it has been decided by the court that they have not that power now. The Government is absolutely convinced that they must have that power. By accepting the amendments proposed in this Bill, we are satisfied that we will have that power for the period of the emergency.

Deputies will recollect that when the Emergency Powers Bill, 1939, was first introduced the particular clause dealing with internment, that was Clause (k) of Section 2, had not got the words which are now proposed to be deleted, that is, "other than natural-born Irish citizens." These words were introduced at the request of the Opposition, who pointed out that we had already got powers in the Offences Against the State Act enabling us to deal with natural-born citizens, and that these powers then were only necessary to deal with persons other than citizens. If the amendments are accepted we will have the Emergency Powers Act in the form in which it was first introduced. As the House is aware, that power will be effective only so long as the emergency lasts, and although the Act can run for 12 months, still if, by some chance, the war in Europe were over, which everybody would be glad to see, I do not think it would be desirable to proceed under that Emergency Act. The Government does not think so, and would prefer to have the Offences Against the State Act or some permanent measure under which to proceed. The Government, as I say, is absolutely convinced, and I think the House will agree also, that the power of internment is absolutely necessary. The event that has occurred very recently, that is the raid on the Magazine Fort, should have brought it home to everybody that there is here a body of persons who are highly organised. They are not very numerous, but they are highly organised. They have in their possession large sums of money. They have stores of arms and explosives. The Government is not in a position to bring evidence that will satisfy a court to deal with all these people. It can certainly do it in respect of some and has done it, but there are several of them about whom the Government is quite satisfied that they are engaged in activities hostile to the State and that they are a menace and a danger, but still, if it came to bringing them to court, we could not produce sufficient evidence to convict them. That is the position which we must face. Consequently, the power of internment must be given to the Government. We are satisfied that for the period of the emergency, at any rate, this particular Bill that is now before the House will give us that power.

When the Offences Against the State Act was going through the House it was said by members of the Opposition that the Minister had not made a case, that he had not given sufficient reasons for claiming the drastic powers which are included in that Bill. Several members of the Opposition said that. Although the Minister did give some instances in which rather serious events had occurred some time before the occasion on which the Bill was being debated here, such as the explosions that occurred in Donegal where three men were blown to pieces, still at the time the Bill was before the House there was undoubtedly a period of quietness here. There was nothing of an unusual character happening in this part of the country but the Government were aware that it was the intention of this body to take violent action of some kind. What exactly it was we were not in a position to say, but we had sufficient information to satisfy us that they did contemplate violent action of some kind which we could not tolerate. Consequently we decided to intern certain people who, we were satisfied, would likely be the leaders in any such events. We did intern certain people. They are now at large and we have got to get them and perhaps others into safe keeping until we are satisfied that it will be safe for the community, to release them.

For the information of the Dáil, I might give some few instances of incidents that have occurred in recent times. There was, firstly, a case reported from Kilcormac, Offaly, where, most people will remember, the police discovered a party which was being instructed in the use of explosives. Explosive materials were found there and a man was actually seen demonstrating on a blackboard methods of using these explosives. I have a list here of the stuff that was found on that occasion. Of course these people have been tried since. I just want to point out that this was one class that was actually found in operation. We are satisfied that there are several more in different parts of the country but we have not been able to come across them. Still, we know that they are going on even at the present moment. In this case, all the materials for making time bombs and incendiary bombs were found and a person was actually caught in the act of demonstrating the use of these bombs on the blackboard. That was on the 15th August. I need not read out the list of the materials found there, but they include all the materials necessary for making these bombs: flexes, toy balloons, etc., all sorts of chemicals, in small amounts and ingredients of these incendiary bombs.

On the 9th September, in the Rathmines district, in the course of a raid four people were found who had a large quantity of aluminium powder in the house together with two Smith and Weston revolvers and one Colt automatic with ammunition. On one man the police found a sum of 7,950 American dollars and on another man 315 American dollars. A large quantity of documents was also discovered. I want to draw attention to the fact that on these people was found a large sum of American dollars. We are quite certain that large sums have come from America. There was no label or note attached to this consignment to say: "This has been sent to the I.R.A." But we are well satisfied where that money came from.

Comment on this

Do you know who in America is sending it?

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

We have a shrewd idea of where it is coming from.

Comment on this

Why do you not tell us?

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

I am not in a position to prove it.

Comment on this

Perhaps the Minister for External Affairs would tell us.

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

I may be pretty certain of where it is coming from, but I am not going to make any statements that I am not able to substantiate, and I do not think I should be asked to do so. I should like to quote some extracts from these documents to show some of the activities in which these people were engaged. One document is headed: "Oglaigh na hEireann, 6th September. Drogheda Battalion to Department of Intelligence. Report on enemy forces in area." It goes on:

"(1) As far as I am aware there are about 20 ‘Free State' troops posted at Drogheda railway station ostensibly for the purpose of guarding communications. According to a report a strong force of ‘Free State' troops are about to be billeted in the Whitworth Hall for the purpose of garrisoning the town.

"Battalion Adjutant."

It will be observed that the troops in this State are referred to as "enemy forces." The next document is from the same battalion and states:

"Please supply electrical detonators, delay action, red oxide iron, aluminium powder, sulphuric acid carbon disulphide and phosphorous, gas bomb. The training officer has given me this list of materials he requires for his classes."

Some of these classes have been going on in Drogheda, but we have not been fortunate enough to get any of these people yet.

Another report deals with an absentee from the Bodenstown parade. It says:

"The absentee from Bodenstown parade is Volunteer——, late of—— Battalion. He is very unsatisfactory and seems to think army was formed to ornament him. The O. C. desires you to billet him in training class with a view to early transfer to active service. Urgent—If you can arrange it all billet Q/M Finglas B. Coy. who wish to go active service. Good and intelligent."

Then there is a document from the Longford Battalion. They have a requisition on the Quartermaster-General's Department for the following arms and ammunition:—One Thompson sub-machine gun with two butts, drum magazines, 2L, 2C type, 20 Lee-Enfield service rifles, 10 revolvers, 8 Webley, 1 Colt, 1 Smith and Weston and 4 automatics, 10,000 rounds of .303 and 4,000 rounds of .45 revolver, 50 rounds of Peter Painter, 6 grenades charged and primed, 2 grenades for lectures and throwing practice, 2 signal outfits, buzzers, lamps, telephones, flags and wire, complete instruction on signalling and first aid.

The last document is written from Dublin and is dated 8/9/39. It reads;

"Dear Seán,

"Just an urgent note before bearer leaves. The war has changed the whole position here. The lads are anxious to have you back as soon as possible. You will be needed here at once. Ask Clann to try and rush supplies. In haste.

"(Signed) Busher."

I should like to draw the attention of the House to the fact that it was after that raid that any internments were made. That letter was dated the 8/9/39. I am trying to assure the House that before we did use our powers of internment we took the greatest possible care and that we had every reason for taking the action which we subsequently took. On the 7th November the Guards succeeded in capturing, not just another dump, but a "lab." They found a certain amount of material in it. It was a well equipped laboratory for the purpose of making explosives and was in Killiney area. I have here a long list of the materials that were captured there. In bulk they do not amount to a great lot, but a number of the things found there showed quite clearly that this place had been used for the manufacture of incendiary and other bombs, and possibly, for instructing classes. Nobody was there when the Guards came on it. It was an empty house, and everything had been very well concealed. It was a perfectly made dump. The police were very lucky to discover this dump. They found there a clock worked by switch action, a handbook on oxy-acetylene, four alarm clocks fitted with contacts for time bombs, two rat traps, also fitted with contacts. That may appear very funny to some Deputies. It would not be so funny for the unfortunate individual who put his hand to a rat trap, set with contacts, because the moment he tipped it the bomb would go off. Other things found there were 6 lbs. and 10 lbs. of gelignite, test tubes and capsules and all sorts of chemicals, igniters, one revolver, a rifle with 100 rounds of ammunition, a Thompson gun and a sack containing a lot of those rubber balloons that Deputies have heard so much about recently. All over the floors of the rooms were traces of aluminium powder and iron oxide showing that they had been extensively used for the making of these bombs.

On the 3rd of December a party of men were arrested out near Brittas. Those people have been convicted, but we are quite satisfied that they had been doing very much more than we were able to prove. It would be alarming indeed if we had to release them at the end of the internment period. What was got there was in a car. There were some instructions about a Lewis gun. The police had information as to where they had been, and knew that a van had accompanied them, but unfortunately the van had escaped. They got away with the van and whatever was in it. On the site where they had been working, there were found:—381 discharged 303 revolver cartridge cases, 8 undischarged 303 bullets, 12 discharged 45 cartridge cases, an ammunition box and other materials. Traces of aluminium powder were also found in this district.

We then had the raid on the Phoenix Park. That matter is sub-judice. People have been tried——

Comment on this

What is that?

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

First of all, the military who allowed those people in are being tried now. At any rate, the matter is under investigation by the military. As well, there are six or seven men before the courts, and I do not want to say too much about it except to give an account of what was taken from there. The full details of the raid were given before the courts yesterday, and anyone who wants the full information will get it from the statement made by counsel appearing for the State. He gave a full account of what happened.

Comment on this

I think the Minister should give the House the information. We should not have to go to the newspapers for our information.

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

I am a bit reluctant to do that, because if we start on this then somebody, appearing on behalf of those people in the courts, may get up and say that this matter has been tried already. I put that to the Deputy. I have no hesitation in the wide world in giving the information, but I am pointing out that danger, that they may make that defence: that they may say: "The Dáil has tried us already and our case has been prejudiced."

Comment on this

And Ministers may escape their responsibilities.

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

I am not afraid of that.

Comment on this

I presume the Minister is not putting forward the view that one of the things we are not to discuss in this House is the state of Governmental control that made such a thing possible.

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

Not for a moment.

Comment on this

We want to know precisely what happened. We want to know what the actual facts are.

Comment on this

Would the Minister indicate what set of circumstances permitted such valuable State property to be taken with such apparent case, and who is responsible for that?

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

I cannot say who is responsible, if the Deputy means individuals. The Government are admittedly responsible. They cannot escape responsibility for anything under their control. If the Deputy is asking me what individual is responsible, I cannot say who was directly responsible and who failed in his duty.

Comment on this

The Minister for Defence.

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

Yes, if you like the Government. But then there is someone lower down.

Comment on this
James Fitzgerald-Kenney Mr. Fitzgerald-Kenney Fine Gael

Has the Minister for Defence tendered his resignation?

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

Is this going to become a cross-examination?

Comment on this

We only want to get the facts of what occurred.

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

I think if you get the number of rounds taken——

Comment on this

No, we want the facts.

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

I think a lot of Deputies know how much was taken. I do not know what position I am going to be in if at the trial——

Comment on this

It is very hard on the Minister to have, when the House asks him for information, the Taoiseach putting his hand on his mouth.

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

I have asked him for advice. I do not deny it.

Comment on this

May I intervene for a moment. There are two sets of judicial inquiries taking place: one in the public courts. Certain people who were caught are going to be charged with certain offences and will have to be tried. In the other case, there is a military investigation taking place. At this investigation information of various kinds has to be got. The trouble with me, and with the Minister obviously is this: what are we to go into here? As regards the things for which the Government are responsible, there is no shirking of responsibility. For anything that happened the Government are ultimately responsible, and we are not shirking the responsibility at all. What we do not want to do here to-day is to go partially, as we can only do, into the question as to how certain things happened and as to who was responsible, as Deputy Norton wants us to do. What can be given here is the amount of material that was taken, the circumstances under which it was taken, and things of that sort, but we cannot go into the question as to who are the individuals responsible, what exactly happened, and so on.

Comment on this

What precautions did you take to prevent its happening?

Comment on this

All that can be said about precautions is this, that they were the precautions that had been in existence all the time.

Comment on this

Tell us what they were.

Comment on this

We have got to be clear about what we are going to discuss. In the first instance, we are saying here that this is a Bill in which certain powers are asked for. The introduction of the question of the Magazine was only in general to point out that there is such a body active and able to take action of a certain kind and that it is necessary for the Government to have certain powers. If there is going to be an inquisition on the whole question of the Magazine incident, that will have to be postponed until certain other inquiries have taken place. We cannot go into it now if we are to be impartial here. If the Opposition care to have an opportunity—and they are at liberty to do so if they wish it—for the taking of a vote of want of confidence in the Government, they can do so and the opportunity will be given to them then to make any charges they wish.

Comment on this

A date?

Comment on this

Any date the Deputy wishes.

Comment on this

It cannot be taken to-morrow. Can the Taoiseach give us a date?

Comment on this

Next week.

Comment on this

What date?

Comment on this

Next week, when we have got this Bill through. It is essential for the safety of the State.

Comment on this

Give us a date.

Comment on this

I cannot give the Deputy a date unless I know in advance that it is required. I am not prescient.

Comment on this

Will the Taoiseach take a motion from me now, and give us a date—the earliest possible date?

Comment on this

The motion can be put down in the ordinary way. The Opposition will get all the rope they want.

Comment on this

We will give you the rope.

Comment on this

We will see, when it is finished. At the moment, what is required is to have the House appreciate the need that there is for getting these powers. It was to show such a need that this question of the Magazine Fort was brought in. If we are to go into all the details and have an examination or an inquisition, that can only take place after certain inquiries have been completed.

Comment on this

May I point out that we have a Minister for Defence, and also an auxiliary Minister?

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

We are discussing the Second Reading of a Bill and it seems to me that we are being side-tracked. This is a very important Bill, yet we are not discussing it. As the Taoiseach has indicated, if the House is anxious to have the whole question of the Magazine Fort discussed by putting down a motion, we are prepared to facilitate them; but what we are doing now is asking the House to give us power to see that the like of that will not recur, that we will have power of internment. I submit that that is what is before the Dáil at the moment.

Comment on this

May I submit that it is very unusual to have two Ministers introducing one Bill, which is what we were treated to a few moments ago.

Comment on this

I intervened on account of a remark made from the opposite benches as a result of the Minister communicating with me. I wanted to explain the position.

Comment on this

The Taoiseach did not at all explain it. May I put this point of view: we have a Minister for Defence and a Minister for the Co-ordination of Defensive Measures. According to the newspaper reports 1,000,000 rounds of State ammunition have been taken from the Magazine. Some Minister is responsible for that; some Minister is paid by this House for looking after that property; it has been taken away from the Magazine at leisure and with ease. Surely we ought to have some indication from the Government as to who was responsible for the set of circumstances which permitted such valuable State property to be taken. That is the point on which the House wants information. The Taoiseach says that some inquiries are proceeding, but this property was taken 11 days ago. Surely it ought to be possible to give some definite information now. Otherwise, the Dáil should be adjourned until it has been found out who is responsible for this negligence.

Comment on this

The Taoiseach indicated certain things in which he saw no objection to the House having information, namely, the facts of the case, as to what actually occurred, the amount of ammunition that was taken, the measures that were in force in the Magazine to see that it was properly protected. The Taoiseach, in the opening portion of this statement we have listened to, said that that information could be given now. I suggest that at least that much information should be given now.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Bill before the House is an amending Bill effectively of one clause—to delete some six words. The matter for discussion is the Bill and the reasoned amendment. Order is Heaven's first law and it is the first law of the Dáil. Extraneous matters leading to wider discussion cannot be introduced without the unanimous consent of the Dáil, and the assent of the Chair. The discussion may not range over the administration of Departments.

Comment on this

I am not anxious to enter into a debate on the conduct of the Department of Defence or of the Department for the Co-ordination of Defensive Measures or of the two Departments; but, in order to enable the House to make up its mind as to whether it would entrust the Government with the powers that are asked for, I suggest with all due respect that the limited information I have asked for might be put at the disposal of the House, purely for the purpose of helping the House to come to a decision on the two measures before it. I do not seek a roving inquiry into this particular matter at the moment, but I think this request is reasonable. We have had information about other things—cases that are dealt with; cases that cannot be dealt with because there is no evidence sufficient, in the minds of the Government, to deal with them; cases partly sub judice—and why should we not have a limited amount of information on this most spectacular of all the cases?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I suggest that the man in the street understands that this Bill arose from a decision of the courts given prior to happenings in the Phænix Park. The Chair does not suggest that certain information should not be asked for or given, but the debate must be relevant to the measure. If such matters as the raid on the Magazine Fort were to be discussed, then, on a motion of no confidence, there would be a duplication of this debate. In any case such matters are irrelevant now.

Comment on this

Speaking as an ordinary man in the street, my view is that if this legislation were urgent and necessary it would have been introduced before Christmas. The view of the ordinary man in the street, as I understand it, is that this is due to what occurred in the Phænix Park.

Comment on this

Arising out of your ruling, Sir, is it to be understood that members of the House will be precluded by your ruling from commenting on the Minister's remarks?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Chair does not rule in advance, nor give hypothetical rulings.

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

On the point that has been raised I am not prepared to give any more details, other than the quantity of ammunition which was taken, until the military inquiry and the court proceedings are finished. I do not think that the Government will agree to give such information, even if the whole thing is discussed by a motion, until those proceedings are finished. The total amount of ammunition taken in that raid was 1,084,000 rounds. Up to date 850,990 rounds have been recovered and there is still in the hands of those people 234,309 rounds of ammunition—between Thompson gun and .303.

Comment on this
Mr. Morrissey

Is all the ammunition which has been recovered ammunition taken from the Magazine?

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

Other ammunition has been recovered, too, but I am referring only to stuff which was taken from the Magazine and which was recaptured. Other dumps have been captured during the searches.

Comment on this

Is there still 234,309 rounds missing?

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

Yes.

Comment on this

From that particular raid?

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

Yes.

Comment on this

Can the Minister say how much unofficial ammunition was captured in the meantime?

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

I am not in a position to say now.

Comment on this

You mentioned that 850,990 rounds were recovered.

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

Yes.

Comment on this

On adding up the two figures, they do not tally, but there is not much difference.

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

There may be a small difference. I have not much more to say on this Bill, but I am satisfied that had it not been for the decision of the courts—I do not want to comment on the decision of the judge—that raid would not have occurred. That is not going far, but it is my opinion. Deputy O'Sullivan said that we were lax in not coming back at Christmas. Perhaps that is so. If you like we took a chance. We thought perhaps that these people having beaten us in the courts, and having lauded our Constitution, that that would be all, but we were foolish. I quite admit that we should not have waited, but should have brought Deputies back before Christmas. Unfortunately we did not, and perhaps to that extent we are blameworthy. We hoped that things would have lasted over Christmas, but unfortunately we were caught out. We are doing the best we can to see that it will not happen again. As long as a body of men, organised as they are, with plenty of money at their disposal, and thinking only of getting arms, are allowed to be at large there will always be that danger. I hope, whatever members of the Dáil may think or say about the Government in this whole matter, that they will not unduly delay the passing of this Bill, because it is very urgent.

Comment on this

Can the Minister tell us what they want the arms and ammunition for?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That matter does not arise.

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

I do not know. They must want them for something. If we thought they only wanted them as the Fenians wanted them, or to let them rot, it might not matter. But what is the case here? For ten years there have been spasmodic murders and outbursts. I do not know what these people are after. Sometimes I hear that they intend to invade the North and, at other times, that they intend to bring off coups here. What we want to do is to get these arms and to get the people that are trying to use them, and not to let them go until we are satisfied that it is safe for them to be at large.

Comment on this
James Fitzgerald-Kenney Mr. Fitzgerald-Kenney Fine Gael

Can the Minister say what is the estimated strength of the I.R.A. in the country at the present time?

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

An estimate is no good. I am not prepared to give an estimate. I do not think it is very strong numerically, but in certain counties, from the information we have, it is very highly organised and I should say is pretty efficient. It is very dangerous where it is in a position that it could be mobilised. I am perfectly satisfied that not less than 100 men took part in the raid. Maybe they were not actually on the job, but with outposts at least 100 were engaged in the Phoenix Park raid. That is speaking as a person with some little experience in these matters.

Comment on this

Is there evidence of efficiency or inefficiency?

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

I would say that it took at least another 50 men. They had lorries at their call. There are suspicions that I will not mention. They had an organisation, not very big, but of some people prepared to act. Anyone who knows the type of campaign that is carried on by an organisation of that kind will realise that it does not require very large numbers, provided they are fairly well organised, well instructed and have plenty of money. I may tell the House that I am more worried about the money they have than anything else, because once they have that they can be far more difficult to deal with. This is not a laughing matter. It is a very serious matter. If it were not for that, there would not be so many people who have nothing else to do, to take part in these things.

Comment on this

Is the Minister suggesting that the money captured of ammunition?

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

I did not say that. I say that the money enables people to act whole-time in work of that kind. I am not making any suggestion, as to how the ammunition was captured. Except people have plenty of means they must be maintained by someone. It takes money to do that. There is no other way. One of the biggest dangers that I see is the flow of money. If it were not for that I would have greater hope of dealing with this matter more quickly.

Comment on this

What percentage of the ammunition in the Magazine was taken?

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

I could not answer that. It was a small fraction.

Comment on this

Will the Minister say whether some ammunition discovered at Crossmaglen, according to a radio message, is included in that?

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

It is. I have a report about it, that two and a half tons were discovered at Crossmaglen, 15 yards over the Border.

Comment on this

And you have that.

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

We will have to get it from the other Government. We will have to make representations to them. It is included in the figures given.

Comment on this

I move the following ammendent:—

To delete all words after the word "That" and insert the words "Dáil Eireann being of opinion that the objects aimed at in this Bill can only be effectively secured by an ammendent of Article 28 of the Constitution adjourns the consideration of the Bill until the Government have introduced a Bill to amend the Constitution by extending the scope of Article 28, Section 3 to meet the existence of a domestic emergency."

This matter has been very carefully considered by us. We do not see any great prospect of a different decision being given by the courts from that already given in the case that was brought before them. In our view, it is necessary to get from the fountain head, that is, from the Constitution powers to take extraordinary statutory authority to deal with the situation which confronts the Ministry and the country. Having that power, it is then for the Dáil to make up its mind upon the policy that the Minister has just put before us, but only when it is certain that we have the authority from the Constitution, which in this case, I believe, has hampered the Ministry, but which in the opinion of a great many people it was the right of citizens to employ in order to ensure that they could not be sent to jail or be interned or that anything of that sort could happen, without something more than mere suspicion. We have had experience of something like 17 years of internment as such in this State. It is not a method of dealing with a situation of this kind which appeals to me. In the first place it seems unreasonable that citizens on mere suspicion should be deprived of their liberty. Something more than suspicion should justify loss of liberty.

We were led in the early years of the formation of this State to consider what were the best methods of getting the general support of all citizens for the legislative Assembly which passes Acts pf Parliament. By reasons of our special care in ensuring that legislation will deal justly with all citizens, we have certain rights as well as responsibilities when taking steps to deal with those who will, on the one hand, take every possiblelegal loophole they can and,on the other hand take unlawful methods to carry out their objects. The Ministry in this particular case has not particularly clean hands, either from its past record or from its immediate past record. We gave powers to the Ministry in two measures and they abused them. They dealt with certain small disturbances in the State as if they were major disturbances. They used 15-pounder guns to deal with what should have beeen dealt with by a popgun ora policeman's baton. The same people, having that record, come to us asking for extraordinary powers. Even the powers they are asking for, and the method in which they propose to get them, do not appear to us to be sufficient. If they are not sufficient, and if, by reason of any defect in the legislation now going to be passed, the Minister has to come here in a month's time or less and say:"The powers I have are still unsufficient for me and I want still more," does not the administration of government in this country become a mockery and a laughing stock? It is possible that those who were so physically efficient a short time since will commence to pat thmselves on the back and say that they are also a much bigger intellectual proposition or commonsense proposition.

We put down this motion then, in the first instance, to clear the decks. This Government does not appear to me to be likely to last very long. In fact, if they had any decency, if they had any sense of responsibility, if they had a spark of patriotism, they would not alone retire from office but retire from public life. They are not fitted for the one and they ought not to continue in the other. The peopleof the country from the incidents of the last few weeks, have had one more example of Ministerial incompetency. They had handed over to them seven or eight years ago an efficient, disciplined, well-equipped Army. They had handed over to them a disciplined and competent police force. They had handed over to them an economical Civil Service. So far as one can judge from the incidents of the last few days, they must have sabotaged the Army and paralysed the police force, and they have made the other institutions of the State more and more expensive and extravagant. Never had we more Ministers than we have at present. Never had we a larger Army in peace time. Never had we more men in police force. As to the Civil Service, we could not accommodate any more, and we have had to erect more buildings in order to house them. Notwithstanding all that, we are presented with a loss of 1,250,000 rounds of ammunition. There is one thing which seems to be common between the Government and those who are opposing them at the present time, and that is, an inability to hold what they have got. The Government could not hold the ammunition; those who have taken it from them cannot hold it either. We have, therefore, a nice example of incompetency in this country.

The Minister's statement lacked lucidity and that sort of persuasiveness, that sort of exhortation to those with whom he was until a few years ago in collaboration. Why could not this statement have been made by the Minister; why should he not have got up and told them: "For many years I did the same as you are doing, or tried to do it, and it was wrong. It was neither patriotic nor national. There was no moral justification for it. You are now going along the same road I went, and you ought to leave it"? These young men who are engaged in this work, we were told here some years ago by the Prime Minister, are practically in the same position as the Government party were a few years ago. It was wrong. The activities going on in Great Britain, the explosions there are wrong. In my opinion, they are morally and nationally doing damage to the country, and all that we got from the Ministry is that they do not approve of them.

What right has any body of men to organise themselves here and endeavour to exercise authority either here or elsewhere unless they get the authority from the people? All power comes from God to the people. Whatever authority the people exercise, they exercise it only as coming from God. Whoever is responsible for the exercise of that power, whoever is in Ministerial control at any time, is responsible to God and the people for it. If the men, by reason of their activities, have been on the wrong track, they ought to be told it. This country will never progress either spiritually, morally, economically, culturally, or in any other way unless we lay down ourselves proper orders and proper regulations, for the conduct of public policy, for correct appreciation of the citizen's rights and duties, his responsibility and his obligations as well as his rights.

The Ministry had information on the 7th or 8th December regarding the imperfections of the laws they had passed to deal with the situation. They have, as I said, a large Army. They have an augmented police force. They have had the benefit and the experience of ten years of a previous Government. They have had their own seven years of office. Yet they could not get no information about this major onslaught on the people's property which was entrusted to them, and of which they were the custodians in trust for the people, and they have lost it. This State has been upset on a festive occasion, at a time when the world is in the throes of various wars in one place or another, and when we have messages sent out from Ministers to the effect that here at least we have peace. Have we peace, taking into consideration these measures which are being brought in here? Have we inculcated into the people of the cuntry—and that is a responsibility of the Ministry—a respect for law and for ordered conditions in the State? It is true that there were two different methods employed by the two Administrations in dealing with this menance. When there was another Government in office they were told that they were not dealing with this matter properly, that there was a better method and a proper method which, if they were in power they would exercise and would put into force, and they were quite confident that they would succeed. What have we got here but a confession of the most abject failure, of the complete collapse of the policy in operation for the last seven years, of futility failure and incompetence to deal with the situation when the country might have hoped that, whatever experience the Government might have had when they came into office, at least seven years of office would have taught them something? It is not alone that the State has been robbed of its ammunition; it has also been robbed of its money, and the ordinary citizen has been robbed of his money. Robberies, in fact, are the order of the day and night.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I am loath to interrupt the Leader of the Opposition, but must draw his attention to the terms of his reasoned amendment. It seems to be indicated that there will be tabled in near future a motion of "no confidence", discussion of which should not be anticipated in this debate.

Comment on this
Mr. Morrissey

On a point of order, may I ask if the amendment proposed by the Leader of the Opposition is being debated in conjunction with the Second Reading of the Bill?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Yes, in accordance with precedent.

Comment on this
Mr. Morrissey

Then I submit, with all possible respect, that the Leader of the Opposition is not confined to the wording of the amendment, but is also at liberty to deal with the Second Reading of the BIll.

Comment on this

May I ask if, from the attitude of the Government, we are to understand they are opposing the amendment?

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

Yes.

Comment on this

Then I submit that the insistence of the Government on pursuing the line of pressing their own Bill as a means of dealing with this situation is simply a part of their general incompetence, and, therefore, their general incompetence is liable to be discussed.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The aim of this Bill is to delete some words from an Act. The whole Act is not open to discussion. Neither is the conduct of the Government nor the administration of Departments, during the past seven years. This is in scope a small Bill. It is obvious that a debate ranging over the conduct of the I.R.A., the administration of this Government in relation to the Department of Defence and other Departments, and the strength of the Civil service or police force is not relevant.

Comment on this

Might I suggest that, although this Bill only contains a proposal to delete six words, its weight and importance cannot be decided by the number of words proposed to be deleted, because it strikes at what in ordinary circumstances would be the liberty of every citizen in the State—the most vital thing we could discuss. I agree that this is an amending Bill, but it is an amending Bill of tremendous scope. We have to decide whether this Government should be entrusted with such tremendous powers as this Bill, even though it is an amending Bill, proposes to give them. I suggest that the operations of the I.R.A. are relevant to this debate. They were made relevant, if they were not relevant before, by the speech of the Minister in introducing this Bill. This Bill is necessary because the Government was incapable of dealing with the operations of the I.R.A., as it has proved itself incapable of doing. I do not see how we could have a useful discussion on the Bill if we are not to discuss that. We might as well walk out of the House if we cannot discuss whether the present Government is a fit Government to be given these powers.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

When the Deputy maintains that a relevant subject of debate is the fitness of the Government for these powers, is he not anticipating a forthcoming motion? There is an alternative in the reasoned amendment to the Government's proposal. These conjointly are open for discussion, the administration generally is not.

Comment on this

May I submit that this Bill is the result of Government policy. It arises out of and lays down Government policy. Surely it is open to us to discuss that?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The answer is obvious. Practically every Bill Introduced by a Government arises out of Government policy, but general Government policy may not be reviewed on every Bill.

Comment on this

May I make the point that, because of a motion which has not been tabled, we are being debarred from giving our reasons for having a certain hesitation as regards our attitude to this Bill. I suggest that that is unduly limiting the rights of the House.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy suggests that the Chair is endeavouring to prevent the House from giving reasons why this Bill should not be read a Second Time. The Chair has merely stated, in reply to the suggestion that this Bill exemplifies or arises out of Government policy, that the same might be said of almost all Bills. The House is not, however, entitled to discuss every aspect of Government policy on a measure dealing with one definite aspect.

Comment on this
Mr. Morrissey

May I submit a final point of order. As you, a Chinn Comhairle, say, this an amending Bill. The necessity for this amending Bill arises out of certain circumstances. In discussing the amending Bill and whether there is a necessity for it, surely the members of the House are entitled to discuss the circumstances that brought about the Bill. May I also submit that while, as a matter of procedure, this Bill is described as an amending Bill, in effect, it would have far greater force than many Bills brought in as original Bills. On Second Reading, I submit that it is open to Deputies to argue that the Bill is unnecessary, that it goes too far, that it does not go far enough, that there are certains things in the Bill which should not be in it or that certain things are not in the Bill which should be in it. I submit, with all respect, that Deputies cannot be precluded from putting before the House for its judgement the circumstances which, in the opinion of the Government, made the introduction of this Bill necessary.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Again, and finally; the Emergency Powers Act was passed by the Oireachtas. Only part of a sub-section of that Act is affected by this amending Bill. I quite agree with Deputy Morrissey when he says that Deputies are entitled to argue that the Bill is too wide or too narrow, that it is to drastic or not sufficiently so.

Comment on this

Let us face the fact that we are discussing this Bill because of English interference in this country. If the British took their hands off this country, there would be no more peaceful country in the world.

Comment on this

In so far as the preservation of order in the country is concerned, it is fairly apparent that the vast majority of the people are of one view——

Comment on this

There is a buzz of conversation goin on.

Comment on this

Not from Deputy Cosgrave.

Comment on this

No, but from some of the ignorant "yahoos" on the other side.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

If the Deputy refers to fellow-membersas "yahoos," he is quite out of order.

Comment on this

I did not intend that the Chair should hear that observation. If it was heard by the Chair, I withdraw it.

Comment on this

We could not expect anything better from over there.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That interjection also is disorderly.

Comment on this

In making that statement, I am fully satisfied that the country is willing to entrust to the constituted authority in this State power to deal with any situation that may arise. On more than one occasion the powers which have been asked for have been generously given. It is quite evident that those who asked for powers in this case did not get all they wanted, or abused some of those they did get. So far as my recollection goes, it was not asked, when the Emergency Powers Bill was introduced, that power should be given to intern our citizens.

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

That would have been possible as the Bill was introduced. It was after representations from the Opposition that an amendment was brought in.

Comment on this

The Minister said, when asked about that, that it was not his intention to take power to intern Irish-born citizens.

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

That is true. Still it could have been done.

Comment on this

According to page 142 of the Official Report of 2nd September, 1939, Deputy McGilligan asked: "Is paragraph (1) confined to persons other than natural born Irish citizens?" The reply by the then Minister for Justice, Deputy Ruttledge, was: "That is my interpretation of it." It is quite true that this arose out of the amendment which I put down, providing that a court of inquiry be made available for persons to be interned. To avoid that court of inquiry, apparently, the Minister took the view that Irish-born citizens would not be interned. Consequently, the necessity for the court did not arise. If we are going to intern people now, we are entitled to ask before what court these persons will be entitled to make a case for release. Will the Minister give us any information on that?

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

I can. As the Deputy is aware, the procedure under this Act is by way of an order, and provision has been made for a commission, before which internees can go. That provision is made in the order, and the order cannot be issued until the Bill is passed.

Comment on this

Well, am I at liberty to use the instrument that has been published?

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

As far as I am concerned, the Deputy is at liberty to use it.

Comment on this

It is mentioned there that the court to be set up shall consist of three persons, who shall be appointed and be removable by the Government, of whom one shall be a barrister or solicitor of not less than seven years' standing, or be or have been a judge of the Supereme Court, the High Court, or the Circuit Court, or a justice of the District Court. Now, one of the three persons, according to this, must belong to one of these classifications, but the other two members of the commission can be anybody at all-a member of the Fianna Fáil organisation, an officer of the Army, or an officer of the police force. I suggest that that is not a court. It may be a commission, but it is not a court. After all, in the normal course, a citizen has a right of appeal to a court in connection with imprisonment, but this is internment. Now, let there be no misunderstanding about this. I have no faith in internment—none at all—having regard to my experience of it. There is a procedure in connection with these matter—and it is embodied in legislation already passed—which will enable the Minister to deal with any citizens whom he desires to have arrested, and under that procedure he can bring them before a court and deal with them. Surely, it is not necessary to develop that point? If these people are thought to be members of an illegal organisation, they can be questioned about it, brought before a court and dealt with as such; but, above all things, do not give them any cause of complaint. If they are dealing with military matters, you can deal with them in a military style; if they are dealing with law matters, then deal with them in the law style; and if you are dealing with them as as ordinary citizens, then deal with them as citizens; but do not mix all these things up and give these people a cause of complaint. Set up a court against wich they can have no cause of complaint, and do not let them have it to say that you loaded a court in order to get a decision against them.

Now, the use and abuse of internment powers are very closely allied, one to the other; and whether they are or not, we have entered now on a stage or phase in the life of the world when propaganda and excuse and propaganda explanation are almost synonymous terms, and nobody has a better knowledge of that than the gentlemen of the present Ministry.

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

I suppose the Deputy never did the same kind of thing?

Comment on this

Mind you, I can claim one thing, and I am sure the Minister himself will give me the credit for it, and that is that, whether or not it was popular to say a thing, it never bothered me about saying it, so long as it was the right thing to say. That is the reason and the cause of this Bill. The fact is that you were trying to straddle or to ride two horses at the one time, and the mistake, unfortunately, is this: that young people in this country are being deluded. Some of them have been deluded by the Ministry, some of them have been deluded by their successors, amd some of them by the successors of the successors of the Ministry. Why do you not tell them that all this nonsense of the last 17 years, so far as your participation in it was concerned, has been a failure and a futility and that you are seeing now the fruits of what you sowed yourself? Powers we are prepared to give, but in these powers we have no faith whatever. In order to put the matter right we have advised you to amend the Constitution. You will not take that advice. You seldom do take advice until you realise that you have put your feet into it. You have gambled in the matter that happened over the Christmas, and have been gambling on it, for the succeeding days, and the result is that this country is a laughing-stock all over the world. Were the Americans told, in the message that went out over the radio, that you could not hold 1,000,000 rounds of ammunition, although, at the same time, I presume that we were ordering more? It is not right to say that the same precautions were taken as had been taken in the last ten years. Does not the Minister know that there was the same amount of ammunition there? The common argument was that even a fly could not get into the Magazine Fort, that the Minister himself could not get in, or the Commander-in-Chief, without going through the proper forms. Notwithstanding that, we have now lost 1,000,000 rounds of ammunition and have spent a week in collecting about four-fifths of that. I suppose, Sir, that by your ruling I am prohibited from giving an opinion if this Government and all its works and pomps, but I think they know it very well.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy, in his introductory remarks, expressed some opinion on that matter.

Comment on this

In my opinion, there is not a Government in this world that would have survived the loss of this 1,250,000 rounds of ammunition.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Which, of course, is not an expression of opinion on the Government.

Comment on this

At any rate, Sir, it is my opinion, and I think it is a better opinion than that of the Government. If they were to do the decent thing and the Irish thing, they would retire from the Government and from public life.

Comment on this

I want, formally, to second this reasoned amendment that has been moved by the Leader of the Opposition, and I hope, as far as possible, however great the temptation may be, to keep within the rulings you have given, and to confine my remarks to supporting the reasons underlying the reasoned amendment which we are moving. This Bill which we are discussing has been described by the Chair, I think, as a small Bill, small in its scope, and a Bill merely to delete six words of a previous Act. Although the Bill may be small in one sense, however, it is big in its principle and the scope of its principle. The principle involved in the Bill now before us is whether or not to give power to intern natural-born Irish citizens. I take the liberty describing that as a very big principle, and one to which we are opposed. I am personally opposed to it, and opposed to the putting of it into a Bill of this kind, because, however much we may desire to give whatever powers the Government may need —even in spite of their incapacity and inefficency to deal with the present situation—we think that they have adopted the wrong method, and a very insecure and unsafe method of achieving the purpose which, apparently, they have in mind. We think that the method they have adopted may lead to further insecurity in this State, and bring derision and scorn, not merely on the present Government, but on future Governments and govermental institutions in this country.

We were told by the Minister for Justice, in one of his closing remarks, that he did not wish to say anything against the judge who gave the decision which necessitated the release of the people who were kept in custody before Christmas. Now, at the outset of my remarks, I should like to say one or two words in praise of that judge and of the judiciary as a whole, and I think it is, and must be, a matter of great congratulation to the people of the country that we can have the secure knowledge that, where illegalities have occurred, they will be set right, in the first place, and that the Government will act on the appointed decrees of the court, in the second place.

Comment on this

Hear, hear!

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

If the Deputy speaks in praise of the judiciary, he might do so in general terms, since commendation of any member thereof would entitle Deputies who might hold opposite views to give expression to them.

Comment on this

My remarks were addressed not merely to the members of the present judiciary, but of the judiciary since 1922 as an institution, and not to any particular individual. I tied up my remarks with the remark of the Minister, that he did not wish to say anything about a particular judge. I do not repeat that it must be a matter of congratulation to the people that we can confidence that the rule of law will be enforced by the judges, and that it will be respected by the Government, as it was respected in this case.

The party stood, has always stood, and still stands for two things, above all things, in matters of political principle. They stand, in the first place, for the maintenance of ordered conditions in this country and for the reign of the rule of law; they stand, in the second place, for the guranteeing to citizens of the country of their constitutional rights and, in particular, of the right of the liberty of the citizen. When we were asked to give the Government powers of this kind, which are a grave infringement of the constitutional rights and liberties of the citizen, we demand that the Government shall make a case, a strong case, and an unanswerable case, for the granting of these powers. If such a case be made, and if we are satisfied that it is the Government's intention to use these powers properly and prudently, from this Party they will get these powers whatever our opinions may be as to their inefficency, their past conduct or their past history. They will get them in the interests, not merely of the maintenance of the rule of law, but in the interests of the guarantee of the liberty of the citizen, because some of the conduct of which the Minister for Justice complained here to-day is a graver infringement of the liberty of the citizen than even the powers which might be granted under this Bill.

We are asked in this Bill to give the Government power to intern Irish citizens. The Minister for Justice rather suggested that the Government found themselves in the present difficulties by reason of the fact that certain members of the Opposition had persuaded the then Minister for Justice to limit the scope of the Emergency Powers Act of 1939 by excluding from the operations of the section dealing with internment natural-born Irish citizens. Deputy Mcgilligan, Deputy Mulcahy, Deputy O'sullivan and myself all argued against the inclusion in the Emergency Powers Act of 1939 of the power to intern natural-born Irish citizens. I argued against it on the Second Reading and Committe Stage of the Bill, and I argue against it here to-day as a matter of principle. It is bad in principle, in my opinion, and we take our stand here on the reasoned amendment we put forward and say that not merely is it bad in principle, but that the wrong method has been adopted. We make no apology for the fact that we moved, and successfully persuaded the then Minister for Justice, to limit the scope of the Emergency Powers Act of 1939, so as to provide that the Government would not have the of interning natural-born Irish citizens.

In my view, and it is still my view, a Bill which was passed to deal not with the state of war existing in this country, but with a public emergency created by a war situation outside this country, is not the place where a domestic problem should be dealt with and an effort made to solve it, because the problem which we are dealing with and which the Minister asks us to solve by the Bill we are discussing, is, purely and simply, a domestic problem, a problem that existed long before war was declared between Germany, France and Great Britain, and a problem that still exists in precisely the same form as it existed months before the state of emergency was created which the Emergency Powers Act of 1939, was passed to deal with. Therefore, the view we took when that Bill was passing through Dáil was that it was not the place in which powers should be sought to intern Irish-born citizens.

We still take that view, and we have no apology to offer for it; but whether we are right or wrong, the then Minister for Justice took the same view, because, in the passage quoted by the Leader of the Opposition, at coloumns 141 and 142 of the Official Debates of 2nd September, 1939, we asked was it intended under paragraph (1) of the particular section to include natural born citizens, or, rather, was paragraph (1) confined to persons who were not natural born citizens, and the Minister for Justice said that that was his interpretation of the section. In order to make his interpretation of the section absolutely clear, he there and then moved the amendment which now appears as part of the substantive law in the Emergency Powers Act of 1939. But whether that was the Minister's view or not, I am not making any apologies for taking that view. I would do the same again. I say that this Bill is not the place in which to provide powers for the Government to intern natural-born Irish citizens, because the Emergency Powers Act of 1939 was passed to deal with a war situation, or an emergency created by an outside war situation. The problem we have to deal with is, purely and simply, a domestic problem and let us deal with it in a domestic way, and not under cover of an Act passed, and powers obtained, to deal with a situation caused by external forces at war with each other.

That is one of the reasons—from the point of view of sheer principle—for my objection to the particular method being adopted by the Government, but there is possiblly even a greater objection, and it is the objection embodied in the motion moved by the Leader of the Opposition. The Government was faced before Christmas with the decision of a judge interpreting Part VI, if not the entire of the Offences Against the State Act, 1939, and it is to deal with the situation created by that decision that this Bill and the Bill, the First Reading of which was moved to-day, have been introduced. Have the Government considered whether or not this proposal is contrary to the Consitution? Have they considered the grave effects that will follow if a decision is given that this particular Bill is contrary to the Constitution? It is not for me in this House to give what is, or is not, my legal opinion on the effect of this Bill from the point of view of the Consitution, but I am entitled to say, and I confine my observations to this, that, taking the Bill we are now discussing and considering it in relation to the judgement of the learned judge who gave a decision in the habeas corpus application before Christmas, there is not merely a reasonable possibility, but a fairly certain proability, that this Bill will be declared to be contrary to the spirit, if not the letter, of the Consitution, and the Government will then be faced with the fact that they have again failed in their efforts to deal with the present situation, and that they have brought in, or have tried to get the Dáil to forge a weapon which will break in their hands again as Part VI of the Offences Against the State Act broke in their hands.

That is not a situation the country ought to be confronted with. It is a situation which may bring into derision the institutions of this State and the Government of this State, and render it immpossible not merely for this Government but for any Government to deal with the threat and the menance with which the present Government is faced by the people who are to be interned under this Bill. I ask the House to consider very carefully whether they ought to take the risk of passing this Bill and next week having a court decision that this is unconstitutional, with the inevitable result that anybody who is interned under the provisions of this Bill, when it becomes law, is again realeased and we have for the second or third time the spectacle of the gaol gates being opened during the régime of this Government.

I do not want to anticipate—in fact I had very great doubt as to whether or not it was my duty to draw attention to this aspect of the case at all, but I ultimately felt it was—the arguments on which that may be based, but it is essential for me to explain to the Dáil at least in outline the kind of case on which that may be built up. The Emergency Powers Act, 1939, was passed for the express purpose of dealing with an emergency. In order that that Act should be passed it was essential that the Constitution should be amended; at least it was a wise course to have taken to amend the Constitution. Article 28 of the Constitution, even as amended now, merely deals with a situation which arises from war, an emergency created by an outside war, or armed revolution. Paragraph 3 of Article 28 of the Constitution prevents the Constitution being invoked to invalidate a law which is expressed to be for the purpose of securing the public safety and the preservation of the State in time of war or armed rebellion. Under a recent Constitution amendment that would include the present emergency. Now, we have there: war, an emergency created by an outside war, or armed rebellion. The situation we are facing here, in the argument which I conceive would be advanced, is neither war in this country nor is it an emergency created by the war in France, Great Britain and Germany, nor it is rebellion. Therefore, Article 28, paragraph (3), cannot be put forward as a sheild against the Bill that we are now considering, if it is passed into an Act, being declared unconstitutional along the lines of the judgement of the learned judge before Christmas.

I think I have said sufficient to show at least that i have justified the statement I made at the beginning of my remarks that not merely is there a reasonable possibility but there is almost a certain probability that the Act which we are passing now will be declared to be unconstitutional. I say again, and I emphasise it with all sincerity and earnestness, that we cannot afford to have the Government make another mess such as they have made in the last four or five years in the administration of law and justice. The country cannot afford to have the Government again made a laughing stock, because it will not merely reflect upon the existing Government but will reflect upon the existing institutions of the State, render and Government impossible in future, and give a fillip to those enemies of the State whom we are all trying to curb and whose acti vities we all wish to see at at an end. Therefore, we put down this amendment to draw the attention of the Government to the fact that they are pursuing the wrong method and adopting the wrong course. We ask them to pause and consider that the introduction of a few words, even the six words that they have here, the six little words in this Bill, those little words put into paragraph 3, Article 28 of the Constitution, will guarantee and secure that the instrument which the Government wants to forge for the protection of the State against the people referred to by the Minister for Justice will be an effective instrument, a powerful instrument and a strong instrument.

We say, if you want those powers you must make a case for them, and adopt the proper method of getting those powers. I very gravely doubt whether the country will be convinced, by the statement made by the Minister for Justice here to-day, of the necessity for those powers. We are convinced of it, but we do not want to be manoeuvred into the position that we are the people who want to deprive the citizens of this State of their constitutional rights and liberties. We are in favour of giving those powers, because we think that the people who are exercising the illegal methods referred to by the Minister for Justice are the real menace, or one of the real menances, to the liberty of the citizens of this country, but we do not want to adopt the wrong method. I do say that here we are proposing to pass this Bill into an Act, and there is at least a grave danger that it will be declared to be unconstitutional.

I do suggest to the House, therefore, that this reasonal amendment which is put down by us is worthy of support. I assume that the Government simply read our motion and said: "This is a Fine Goel motion; therefore we will oppose it", and never gave it proper or adequate consideration. I do not care whether the Government regard my observations as of any weigth or not. I do think that I have made a case here for very grave consideration by the Government before they turn down this amendment which we have put forward. There is a simple method of resolving this difficulty. Six little words were dealt with here to-day. Six little words will do it, copied from another Article of the Constitution here, which appear in our amendment—the existence of a domestic emergency. That will do it. That will safeguard the Government in the conduct of their operations under this Bill.

I do not know whether it is the intention of the Government to adopt, in reference to this Bill that we are now passing, the provisions of the Constitution enabling the President to refer this Bill to the Supreme Court for decision on its constitutionality or not. I take it there will not be time to do that, if we are to agree with the statement of the Minister for Justice that the powers in this Bill, or similar powers, are urgently required. I take it, therefore, that it is not intended to refer this Bill to the Supreme Court under the provisions of Article 26. We have introduced here to-day a Bill which really proposes to re-enact Part VI of the Offences Against the State Act. If we are to accept what is the common belief at the moment, that it is the intention of the Government to refer that Bill, if and when it is passed by this House, through the medium of the constitutional provisions of Article 26 for decision to the Supreme Court, what is the position going to be if Part VI is declared to be unconstitutional? What guarantee is there that the rest of the Offences Against the State Act of 1939 will not be declared to be unconstitutional by some judicial personage?

What will the position then be? This Bill we are now passing will be unconstitutional. The one we may or may not pass to-morrow re-enacting Part VI of the Offences Against the State Act, 1939, may or may not be unconstitutional, but at all events the net result will be that in three or four weeks this Government will find itself not merely without any powers but in a position never again to be capable of getting or exercising the powers which they say they require to deal with the situation with which they are at present confronted. I do not know how they can get a decision of the Supreme Court on this Bill. Presumably they can do it under the machinery of Article 26. I do not want to comment on the machinery of Article 26. I do not know how it could be argued when there is no legitimus contradictor, when there is no one to go before the Supreme Court and argue the contrary. I do not know what weight or authority such a decision would have. Under the machinery provided by Article 26 it is difficult to see how any effective decision can be obtained. Whether that can or cannot be, it appears to me that the plan of the Government to deal with the present situation is to bring this six words Bill, this Bill with its six little words, and pass it into law straight away, and pass the next Bill into law and immediately get the President to refer it to the Supreme Court.

What is going to happen, in the meantime, to the people who are looking to be interned, as the Minister for Justice would say, under this Bill? What is going to happen if and when a habeas corpus application is brought and again a judge declares that the Bill we are now passing is contrary to the provisions of the Constitution and is not safeguarded by the provisions of paragraph 3 of Article 28? What is going to happen then? There is no appeal to the Supreme Court. That decision is final and conclusive, and where are the powers then? What is the use of going on with this futile farce of referring the Bill we are next going to deal with to the Supreme Court?

I repeat that it is incumbent upon this House not to adopt the particular method or plan that has been put forward by the Government. It is typical of their inefficiency, typical of the fact that they cannot walk straight, that they must walk in a crooked way. If they want to walk from point A to point B, instead of walking in a straight line, they walk in a curve.

The Government have here an opportunity of walking in a straight line, of placing themselves in an impregnable position, ready to meet any emergency. Instead of doing that, they must go through the futile farce of bringing in this Bill with the six little words in it to enable them to intern Irish-born citizens under the cover of an Act passed to deal with an emergency created by a state of war existing outside this country, and they must pass a Bill repealing Part VI of the Offences Against the State Act, solemnly re-enacting it with some small amendments and then referring it to the Supreme Court, where there is no legitimus contradictor. This House ought not to take part in that futile farce; they ought not to expose the country to the spectacle of the Government and the machinery of justice being a laughing stock, as it has been. I submit that this reasoned and very reasonable amendment that we have put down should get the unanimous support of Deputies.

Comment on this

Perhaps, now that so much steam has been let off, we can get down to practical business. The present legislation was introduced because of a decision in the High Court which was based on the view that an Act passed here last June, under which certain Irish citizens were interned, was not constitutional. The decision was on a habeas corpus case, and the judge, in giving his decision, gave what is termed, I understand, a speaking order. I cannot decide why the speaking order was given unless it was to enable an appeal to be taken to the Supreme Court. That appeal seemed to us, at any rate, to lie, because of the explicit words in an Article of the Constitution. When the Constitution was being passed here, nobody suggested that there should be finality in a decision on constitutional matters, as to the repugnancy of any law to the Constitution, unless the decision is given by the Supreme Court. Running right through the whole Constitution, it is clear—it seemed to us to be clear—that the final decision as to whether an Act was or was not constitutional lay with the Supreme Court. The High Court, no doubt, could deal with the question, as a court of original jurisdiction, but right through the intention undoubtedly of the Oireachtas at the time—certainly it was my intention and that of my advisers—was that that should be so. In the campaign in the country, when the matter was put before the people, it seemed to be so, but the judge, in examining the matter, came to the conclusion that that was not so—or at least the Supreme Court, when the matter of the appeal came to them, decided that an appeal did not lie.

I want the House to remember that that is the only thing that has been decided. The Supreme Court has not decided on the question as to whether the judge who gave the writ of habeas corpus was right in his view in the speaking order which he gave in connection with it. There has been no decision by the Supreme Court yet as to whether or not Part VI of the Offences Against the State Act is or is not constitutional. The view of the Government, until the contrary is proved at any rate, is that it is constitutional and, like any other case in which there is a decision in one court from which there is an appeal, when we believe that we are right, notwithstanding the decision which the judge gave, we want to see this question decided finally as to whether, in fact, internment is forbidden, because that is really what it amounts to—whether internment is forbidden by the Constitution. We hold that it is not and we will continue to hold that view until the contrary is decided, and we want, if possible, to have that matter submitted to the Supreme Court to decide.

I do not see why we should rush in at every moment to try to amend the Constitution. We talk about bringing institutions into contempt. Well, if we bring the basis of the institutions as a whole into contempt, it will be very much worse. The fewer amendments that are necessary to the Constitution, the better. There is always a danger, when you have a written Constitution and when it has to be interpreted by a court—and although the Legislature may have given all due care to have its laws within the Constitution—that the views of the Legislature and the views of the court may not agree. In the case of a written Constitution, to try to prevent any such thing happening there have been well-known maxims to follow. In the case of the United States, for instance, the view that has been taken is that the Legislature is to be presumed to be acting bona fide and the presumption is to be in favour of the Legislature having taken due cognisance of the constitutional limitations and desiring to act within the Constitution. When these Bills were being passed in this House, we had competent lawyers on the other side, and I do not think anyone suggested that the procedure adopted was not constitutional. However, this difficulty has arisen and we are not anxious to change the Constitution or to attempt to change it until it is proved to be necessary.

Deputy Costello in speaking seemed to suggest that the changing of the Constitution was quite a tiny affair. The President has to be considered and his view may have to be taken in all this matter. I would like to remind the House that if it were proposed to change the Constitution, if the President were of opinion that the change was of a fundamental character or of such a kind that it ought not pass without the opinion of the people being taken upon it, a change within three years might involve a plebiscite on the question. First of all, I do not think it desirable that changes in the Constitution should be lightly embarked upon, and secondly, I do not think it would be right for any member of the House to think they could easily be effected. I cannot anticipate what view the President might take on matters of that kind, but I think that any Deputy in the House, if he were the President, would ask himself in the case of any amendment of the Constitution within the period of three years whether or not the matter was of a fundamental character or whether it was simply a change that was necessary, in order to make clear the commonsense intent of the Article as it stood. Amendments of that sort, I have no doubt, would pass through, and no President would be likely to question them, but when you come down to the very difficult question of the safety of individual freedom you have quite another matter. There you have that very difficult question of the proper balance between securing the right of the individual citizen and the safety of the community as a whole and, as I think one of the speakers on the opposite side suggested, the freedom of members of the community other than the particular group that may be affected or the particular individual that is affected, because in securing the safety of the State as a whole and in securing the maintenance of its system of law you are thereby securing the freedom of the other individuals. But, there is a difficult point as to how you are going to provide the greatest amount of safeguards for individual freedom, so that an individual may not be wrongfully deprived of his liberty and, at the same time, give to the organised community, the State, an opportunity of preserving its institutions, preserving its organised life, and thereby preserving the individual rights of the other citizens who would be affected by abuses of the liberty of the people.

This Constitution was intended to be a balanced document in which the safeguarding of the rights of the community as a whole was clearly envisaged, and in which, at the same time, in so far as it was feasible, it was endeavoured to ensure that the right of the individual citizen to his freedom should not be jeopardised. We, at any rate, had no doubt that in the Constitution full power was given to the State to defend itself, to defend the institutions which were set up by the people, to defend other citizens from abuses of liberty by certain groups or certain individuals. The measures we took were passed through this House, but, as I have said, it was found that the Article giving the right of habeas corpus, the right to appeal to a judge where an individual is deprived of his liberty, was one from which there was no appeal. At a later stage, at another time, we may have to consider the wisdom of leaving the Constitution finally in that form, but for the moment we are not concerned with that. We are not questioning or trying to deal here with the question of whether or not there is an appeal in the case of habeas corpus. The Supreme Court has decided that there is not an appeal and, undoubtedly, until the Constitution is changed, there is no way of remedying that particular state of affairs if it is considered by the Oireachtas desirable to remedy it. There can be arguments on both sides of that question, but I again want to point out to the House that that is not precisely the question we are dealing with here or proposing to deal with here. What we are proposing to deal with here, what will be dealt with here in these two Bills, is the question as to whether or not the State can, for its own protection, intern an Irish citizen. That is being dealt with under two heads. One is concerned with the particular circumstances of the present emergency when there is a war taking place which affects us, affects us in a variety of ways, and which creates difficulties here which do not occur in a normal time.

I would like to reply to some remark made on the opposite benches a short time ago that this is purely a domestic question and that the war situation has nothing to do with it. I say that the war situation has greatly to do with it. There is in times like these a ferment which is creating a very different position from the position we have to deal with in normal times. I am not saying for one moment that there is not also a position that has to be dealt with in normal times peculiar to ourselves here. There is, and it was on that account that, before the war situation came at all, we brought in the other Bill, the Bill under which internment of citizens took place. A domestic question obtains for which provision must be made in times other than the time of the particular emergency we are dealing with, but it would be completely wrong to say that this present emergency situation has not affected that question and perhaps changed its character, perhaps completely changed its character.

We are at the moment dealing with the domestic question in the particular atmosphere and the particular conditions of the war emergency, and we think that we are fully justified in using the war emergency legislation to deal with it. The view of the legal advisers of the Government is that in view of all the circumstances and the situation as a whole the proper line to take is, if possible, to re-enact Part VI of the Offences Against the State Act, giving an opportunity of having it referred to the Supreme Court for a decision as to whether internment is within the Constitution.

In this matter, any more than any other matter, I cannot presume to know what attitude the President may take, but again, asking ourselves what anyone here was likely to do in the circumstances, we would say to ourselves that the President is likely, having seen a decision of the judge of the High Court to the effect that this Act as it stood originally was unconstitutional, and being possessed of the power, before signature, to refer a Bill to the Supreme Court, we would say that he is likely to refer it. As I say, he will have to form his own opinion upon that after consultation, in accordance with the Constitution, with the Council of the State. But we believe, on the grounds that I have stated, that it is likely that the President will do this and we are not going to take the view that was expressed by Deputy Costello. I am talking now, in case there is any confusion, of the No. 2 Bill, that is, the second Bill, the one for ordinary times, the Offences Against the State Bill. That is the one on which we hope that the matter will be decided.

We think that in this present emergency, which creates a particularly difficult situation, unless the language of the ordinary man is to have no meaning, the legislation here is covered by Article 28, Section 3, sub-section (3) of the Constitution, namely, that "nothing in this Constitution shall be invoked to invalidate any law enacted by the Oireachtas which is expressed to be for the purpose of securing the public safety and the preservation of the State in time of war or armed rebellion, or to nullify any act done or purporting to be done in pursuance of any such law". I think that Deputy Costello suggested that as this had only reference to a time of war, it might be held that the present was not a time of war. But there was an amendment passed a short time ago which assimilated a situation such as this to a time of war and which defined the expression "time of war" as meaning a time such as the present. It seems to me, therefore, that unless words in the common ordinary way in which a man expresses himself are to have no meaning—in which case, of course, there is an end to everything—unless words in their plain meaning are to have no sense, it should mean that legislation in the present circumstances and under the present conditions cannot be nullified by an appeal to the Constitution.

Comment on this

Unless the judges agree with the Prime Minister, there is an end to all.

Comment on this

Not at all. I say if the Constitution which was brought in here, which used common-sense language and which had to be submitted to the people for enactment is not to have the meaning which the Legislature and which the people think it has, and if we cannot get some common ground on which there is an understanding of words, then we certainly cannot get on. If the Legislature and the judiciary are going to be at loggerheads in that way we shall have to change that situation.

Comment on this

Oh, oh!

Comment on this

Yes, because it means bringing everything here into confusion.

Comment on this

It is like Alice in Wonderland.

Comment on this

If the various organs of the State here, which are intended to fulfil certain purposes affected in a certain way, serve quite a contrary purpose then they cannot carry on. The Judiciary, the Executive and the Legislature have all their proper functions. To a certain extent they are a check on abuses, one on the other, but if they cannot carry on in harmony, which is the premise upon which I am talking, if words like these have not the meaning which ordinary people attach to them, I say there is an end to working in that particular way. It cannot be done. I am assuming, therefore, that words will be taken in their ordinary commonsense intention. Taking them in that intention, I have no doubt that the legislation we are passing through is constitutional and the contrary will have to be proved to me, at any rate, before I act as if the contrary were true. Deputy Costello wants us to act as if the contrary were proved true and that is what the amendment implies.

Comment on this

They will have to steal the whole Curragh Camp before they bring that home to you.

Comment on this

They want us to act as if we believed that the Judiciary was going to take what I might call a perverse view of things because that is what the suggestion is.

Comment on this

Not at all.

Comment on this

That was the suggestion. The suggestion is that we have got to go and change the Constitution before the judges have given a decision on the grounds that the Judges are going to give what I would call, in view of this Article, a perverse decision. It is the opposite benches that are making that suggestion.

Comment on this

You do not believe that. It was not stated and it is not true.

Comment on this

What is that?

Comment on this

That we say that the judges are going to take a perverse view.

Comment on this

How can we change it and get words that are more clear than these? If these words cannot carry, how can we hope to get any words that will carry? These words appear to us and to our advisers to be straightforward, and their intention to be without doubt. Until the court says the contrary, we believe they have the meaning that we intended them to have there. We intend, then, to go on with this Bill, which will give us immediate powers in order to safeguard the State in the present circumstances. We are not, therefore, taking the line suggested by the Opposition. We are bringing in this Bill which, we believe, will be good, sound law the moment it is signed by the President. We shall believe that until the contrary is proved.

With regard to the other Bill, we are anxious to have the decision of the Supreme Court obtained on that, if it can be obtained. There is no way at present under which we can directly and immediately refer this question as it stood to the Supreme Court, but under the Constitution, if the President so desires, it can be referred to that court. In view of the decision that was taken, and the opinion expressed by the High Court judge in his judgment, we believe that the President will feel constrained more or less to submit this question for decision. He will, probably, say: "Very well, this Bill does not seem very different from the other Bill, and consequently it is my duty to have the Supreme Court express its opinion upon it." I hope I have made clear, at any rate, the distinction that exists. First of all, we are not trying to deal with the question of appeal in cases of habeas corpus at the moment. Secondly, no decision has been come to as to whether or not in the Constitution there is power given for the internment of Irish citizens. Thirdly, we believe that that can be denied only by the Constitution, and it was held by the judge to be denied by the Constitution. Even in his judgment he seemed to indicate that if it had been under this Bill—that is, the Emergency Powers Bill—that the internment had taken place, the views which he held would not apply. We feel quite certain that they would not apply. We feel that once this particular Bill becomes law, we shall have the powers which are necessary. That being so, we propose to go on with the other Bill which will probably be referred to the Supreme Court. I may be asked one question which I think was mentioned—what happens if the President refers this particular Bill to the Supreme Court. Well, we do not know.

Comment on this

It would be a perverse view.

Comment on this

We take it that this particular Article, this commonsense statement, will carry through. Again, we shall not believe the contrary until we find it out to be so. With regard to the situation in the country which demands these powers, we dealt with that in June last. What the Minister for Justice has said to-day was said in other words at that time. There is nobody who doubts for a moment that there are arms in the country in the hands of private individuals and groups.

There is nobody who is ignorant of the fact that a certain group have issued proclamations taking it upon themselves to declare war in the name of our people, and, generally, they do not recognise the institutions which have been clearly set up here by the majority of the people of this community. They are prepared, apparently, to use these arms, whenever it suits them, without any question of getting power from the Irish people to do so, and they are prepared to use them, apparently, against the organised forces here in this State. They are prepared to embroil this State, if they think it accords with their purposes, with neighbouring States. Now there can be only one Government in this part of Ireland—in this community, and there can be only one Army, and only one Legislature. There is no doubt that any reasonable man can have that the Irish people here in this community have adopted a Constitution, have adopted the organs of Government, and have adopted a Legislature and all the rest of it. They have given to that Legislature certain powers to protect the community. They have given to their elected representatives the sole power of determining how national policy is to be prosecuted, if that means a prosecution with arms. At any rate, they have made it clear that, if there are to be any domestic differences of opinion about policy, these must be settled by the people in a peaceful way, and in no other way.

Comment on this

By constitutional means?

Comment on this

Yes, by constitutional means, and in no other way.

Comment on this

It is a good phrase. You did not always accept it.

Comment on this

I always did. It was the gentlemen on the opposite side who put the Constitution aside. If we want to go back on that, my view of it, and it is not likely to be changed——

Comment on this

Hear, hear!

Comment on this

——because it was well founded—is that it was the people who were putting on us the responsibility of departing from constitutional means who did it. However, we are not likely to settle that now. We are likely to go to our graves, on both sides, keeping our views on that. But, leaving that, there is no doubt, and there can be no doubt now, that the people who are assuming to act in the name of our people have not ever been elected by the Irish people in any election which they were free to go up for, if they chose to go up. They are usurping authority here, and they cannot be permitted to do so. The State must be in a position to defend itself against them——

Comment on this
Deputies

Hear, hear!

Comment on this

——and the individuals concerned must be brought to book, in so far as it is possible to do it.

Comment on this

And quickly.

Comment on this

As quickly as possible.

Comment on this

And legally.

Comment on this

We are looking for legal proofs. I am as interested in the freedom of the individual as anyone in this House, but we are dealing with a situation in which we know perfectly well that what would be full, legal, demonstrable proof cannot be given in many of these cases. That was stated from these benches by the previous Government. It is well known that if a group of people meet in a private house, and if they have organisations which will obey them and decide that there is to be an attack here, there or anywhere else, if A, B and C are appointed as the people to arrange with others to meet on a certain occasion, then every one of the orders given can be a verbal order, and there will be nothing left unless they are caught in the actual act. Their responsibility will be well known, but you cannot prove it in the sense of giving proof which would be demonstrable proof to carry conviction to anyone who did not want to believe or tried not to believe. Now, we know that that exists, and are we to go on here talking about legal niceties when, in fact, there is happening something which can end this Institution and end the liberties of the individuals that we are trying to protect. It certainly cannot be permitted. Any commonsense community would not allow it to continue.

Comment on this

Hear, hear!

Comment on this

Very well. In order to end it as quickly as possible, and in the way in which it can be done in the best manner, we want the powers that we believed we had in the Act which was declared to be unconstitutional. We believe they are the powers that are best fitted to deal with the situation. We want to restrain people who are capable of causing a great deal of mischief from doing things which would bring this country into a position from which it could not get out. We want to see that that thing does not happen. They have no authority to do it. There is no wisdom in their methods as far as the national point of view is concerned.

It was suggested by some member, I think on the Labour benches, that it is because Britain's hand is interfering that this thing is caused. Fundamentally, there is no doubt it is the partition of our country that is the urging motive which is keeping this organisation in existence and keeping it together. But the fact that this evil, and we all recognise it to be an evil, exists, is not going to be an excuse for putting this community here into a position in which it might lose everything that it has got. That fact, therefore, is not an excuse. This community here is prepared to take every measure that it can effectively take to try and bring partition to an end.

Comment on this

May I ask the Taoiseach why we do not use the wireless?

Comment on this

If we could do it by means of the wireless, and if that could be effective, it would be an easy thing to do, but I take it that the Deputy is not suggesting that the use of the wireless would bring partition to an end.

Comment on this

I suggest that it could hurry it on.

Comment on this

Very well, we will try and get the Deputy to give us some hints as to how it might be done. Undoubtedly, the Deputy would go down to history as one of the saviours of this country if he could tell us how the wireless could be used to bring partition to an end, because it certainly would be a very inexpensive and easy way of getting our common desires secured.

Comment on this

If given an opportunity I will do so this evening.

Comment on this

If the Deputy tells us, either publicly or privately, how it can be done I will be quite prepared to give his views the fullest consideration.

Comment on this

Would not a note broadcast to America help?

Comment on this

Sometimes it does.

Comment on this

Put the Minister for Industry and Commerce on the wireless next, from Belfast.

Comment on this

We all recognise that the existence of partition is going to be a disturbing factor in this community. We know that and we want to remove it as a disturbing factor, as one which is always coming between us and our neighbours. Those people who say that they have a method for doing that successfully ought to be able to convince the people that they have that method, and when they have convinced the people there is no need for them to get arms and to call the forces of the State "the enemy". They can get possession of those forces as well as any others that they are able to get, if they are able to convince the people that they have a plan. I am perfectly certain that the Irish people would put into office immediately any Government which could show that they had an effective plan for bringing partition to an end.

Comment on this

The Irish people have not got a tradition of lawlessness, as we have been told to-day by a certain journal in this country.

Comment on this

The Irish people have been maligned in the past because of their resistance to laws imposed from outside, and it has been said on that account that they were lawless. On another occasion I spoke of the tribute paid to the Irish people for obedience to law and willingness to submit to the rule of law in the past. The position here is that a group within the country take upon themselves the right to say that they represent the nation and that what they want to do is the right thing to be done. That is not possible; if that were to continue, every group in the country could say the same. We would have different sections, with different theories on economics and other matters, and each one would say that its particular thing was essential for the well-being of the country and that they had the right to use arms in order to make it effective. I do not think that it is necessary to convince this House that there is a position which needs the active intervention of the Executive, and of the powers which it can command, to control. A gap has been made in those powers by a decision of the courts, but we believe we can fill that gap by means of the legislation which is proposed here. I take it that the objection on the other side is that we will not get those powers back, as I have not heard anybody suggest we should not have those powers to deal with the situation.

Comment on this

The Government should have full powers to deal with the situation. The difficulty is that the method being adopted is not the best way.

Comment on this

That is a matter of opinion. We, on this side, are giving our views and giving the reasons why we are proceeding in this way. We believe that legal advice which we have got is as good as any legal advice being got on the Opposition side. Finally, which is right and which is wrong will only be proved when the matter is tested by the courts. It will be unfortunate if we are wrong. It will be unfortunate that we will have to come and amend the Constitution. We are not willing to believe, in view of the explicit statement in the Constitution, that an unfavourable decision will be given. It is on that belief that we are proceeding as we are proceeding. I take it, therefore, that our reasons are understood. From suggestions made on the opposite side of the House, I take it that on no side of the House is there any denial that we do need powers to deal with the situation which has been revealed by activities of recent date. No doubt everybody agrees with that. The remaining question is as to whether we are right in the method we suggest or whether the method suggested by the Opposition should be adopted. We are convinced that we are right, and our advisers have no reason for giving us advice which would be contrary to what they believe the law to be; we are convinced that our advisers in this particular matter are as good as any advisers elsewhere.

Comment on this

I want to call the attention of the House to just exactly what it has been invited to do by the Government this evening. Some months ago the House passed the Emergency Powers Bill. The reason then given for the introduction and enactment of that Bill was that a State of war existed in Europe, that an emergency situation had arisen there, and in consequence, that it was necessary that the Government should have emergency powers set out in the Bill, the object being to make provision for securing public safety and the preservation of the State in time of war, and in order to make provision for the maintenance of public order and for the provision and control of supplies and services essential to the life of the community, et cetera. When this Bill was introduced, therefore, its object was to deal with repercussions in this country of an international situation, and to enable the State to have powers to deal with that situation in so far as it had those repercussions on this country. Having given the Government powers to safeguard the interests of the nation vis-a-vis the international position that confronted it, we now find that this Emergency Powers Act is being used for the purpose, not of dealing with an international emergency situation, not of dealing with a war situation, not of dealing with any of the matters which flow from those two events, but for enshrining in the Bill a code of punishment in respect of natural-born Irish citizens. I say that a provision of the kind set out in the amending Bill circulated this evening is not a provision which ought to be in an Emergency Powers Act of this kind.

The Government, having been defeated in the courts—the Judiciary having stood up to safeguard the Constitution—now comes to the House and does not care where it gets power to violate the rights of the citizens, so long as it gets that power through some Bill, and exercises it in any manner it likes. The House is being asked to use an Emergency Powers Act, which was intended to deal with an international situation, for the purpose of shoe-horning on Irish citizens a piece of restrictive legislation of this kind. This Emergency Powers Act might as well be a British Act—it is virtually a copy of the British measure. Probably there is not a dozen words in the British measure which are not in this Act. If one compares the two Acts, it will be found that they are almost identical. That, then, is what we are using: a piece of British-patterned legislation for the purpose of giving to the Government the right to intern Irish citizens.

Comment on this

What does the Deputy mean by British-passed? It was legislation passed in this country.

Comment on this

I said British-patterned. The British passed their Bill and we——

Comment on this

Surely the Deputy will understand that we have a situation here which we have got to deal with, and that similar circumstances naturally give rise to similar difficulties and similar remedies.

Comment on this

Surely the Taoiseach will hardly deny that this piece of legislation, which is described as the Emergency Powers Act, is virtually a copy of British emergency legislation?

Comment on this

I can only say that I have never seen a copy of the British legislation.

Comment on this

I thought somebody was getting uncomfortable.

Comment on this

The right of habeas corpus lies with the British still.

Comment on this

Even at the risk of making it uncomfortable, I will tell the House something more.

Comment on this

Has the Deputy's Party the same objection to British trade unions?

Comment on this

Of course the Minister for Industry and Commerce must distinguish himself in every debate by the same disorderly, unmannerly and unintelligible interruption.

Comment on this

Who is getting cross first?

Comment on this

The Minister for Posts and Telegraphs is allowed to speak this evening. The main Act is a copy of the British Act, and we are now using it for the purpose of giving to this Government power to intern natural-born Irish citizens. We are doing that in face of the fact that citizens have the constitutional right of being charged and tried according to law, if guilty of any offences under the statute law of this country. When discussing the Bill which is now an Act, we were assured by the Minister for Justice that it was not the intention to take power in the emergency legislation of that period to intern natural-born Irish citizens, and the Minister introduced an amendment, the effect of which was to ensure that while an alien might be treated in time of war as a person who ought to be interned for its duration, because of his mischief-making capacity, it was not desirable to put into the Emergency Powers Bill a provision which enabled natural-born citizens to be detained without charge or trial. We are expected to believe, from the speech of the Minister for Justice this evening, that a situation has arisen since then which justifies the Government in seeking power to intern natural-born Irish citizens without charge or trial.

The Minister said that the Government wanted to get at people who create mischief and to keep them in until it is safe to let them out. That is what we are going to have after all the mouthing that went on for months and months about the democratic character of our Constitution and the safeguards that the individual citizen has under it. What was the case made this evening for an amending Bill of this kind? The Minister quoted a number of cases, the bulk of which were relatively minor incidents, when one considers the type of case of that kind which we have had to face in this country for the past 20 years. There was only one outstanding case, and that was where inefficient methods were allowed to operate whereby over 1,000,000 rounds of State ammunition were taken away from the custody of the State; that occurring a short time after we had a panic mobilisation of troops and a calling to the colours of soldiers that we could not then utilise, and at a time when the Army was bigger than it was for ten years. It was under circumstances of that kind that a certain organisation could manage to get from the custody of the State 1,000,000 rounds of ammunition which they could not get when the Army was only a fraction of the size it is to-day. An incident of that kind, and inefficiency of that kind, showing complete incompetence to safeguard State property, is not a reason why we should do violence to the Constitution and violence to the fundamental rights of the citizens.

Is the situation to-day any worse than it was in 1931? It is true that the organisation could not then get away with such ease and with such leisure with 1,000,000 rounds of ammunition from what was probably thought to be the most strongly defended fort in the country. Generally speaking, is the situation to-day, so far as the peaceful character of the country is concerned, worse than it was in 1931? In 1931, the case made by the Cosgrave Government when they introduced legislation equivalent in scope to the Offences Against the State Bill, was that there existed within the State 11 organisations with subversive tendencies, each of which was catalogued. We were told then that there was widespread undetected murder of State servants and State witnesses, for instance, Superintendent Curtin, Seán Ryan and Patrick Carroll. It was then stated that there was proof of the existence of a widespread conspiracy of forces to overthrow the Constitution of the State. Nobody can deny that such a situation as existed then was more serious than the situation which exists now. What did the present Government Party do then?

The Taoiseach at that time said there were incidents which everyone in the House regretted but "incidents which do not justify in my estimation anyhow the bringing in of a Bill of this sort". This Bill gives the right to intern people without charge or trial. The Taoiseach went on to say then:—

"The ordinary law is quite sufficient to deal with anything that has been referred to by the President in the long list which he has given."

We got a short and unconvincing list from the Minister this evening. There was only one incident, and that a grave one, and it was due to the incompetence of people responsible for guarding State property. The present Minister for Supplies when dealing with the Bill introduced by the previous Government said:—

"There is ample power under the ordinary law to deal with any conspiracy of violence."

The present Minister for Local Government and Public Health, who also opposed the Bill at that time, said:—

"The Government has been a hopeless failure in dealing with the economic position and they look to the one thing in which they have been a success, that is, in waging war upon their fellow-countrymen."

The Minister for Supplies at another stage was quoted as having stated at an Aeridheacht that "the object of the Bill was to stamp out the last vestige of militant republicanism." Deputy Hugo Flinn thought he could plumb the debate lower than anyone when he said:—

"This law is not respectable. It is a law for worms, it is a law for crawling creatures."

That is the kind of viewpoint which was held about a Bill of that type. The present Minister for Industry and Commerce, with all that profundity of democratic thought which he occasionally arrogates to himself, said:—

"No democratic assembly and no national legislature can afford to give uncontrolled power to the Executive."

Yet, that is precisely what the present Bill does. It gives power to suppress the courts, it gives power of arrest and internment and violates many principles of the existing common law. In or about the same time we had the Taoiseach telling the people how unnecessary it was that they should be governed and conditioned by legislation of that kind. That kind of coercion, he said, was something that did not appeal to him. It was something that was quite unnecessary. Speaking at New Ross on the 23rd January, 1932, he said:—

"He did not believe that in this country they were so vicious-minded that there was a large class of the people who had to be governed by coercion Acts. That was the British attitude towards this country. Was it to be their fate in this country that they were always to have Irish Governments like that?"

Deputy Kissane delivered himself of this when acclaiming the triumph of his Party and the abolition of coercion:

"The jails have given up political prisoners, peace has replaced war, and £1,000 of Mr. de Valera's salary and £500 of each of his Ministers' salaries have been voluntarily surrendered to the people and have helped to relieve destitution."

That was the kind of stuff we were being treated to in 1931 and 1932. Yet this evening we are given a list of relatively inconsequential incidents to justify a gross outrage on the Constitution of the country and a violent assault on the liberties of the individual. Is it any wonder that people outside continue to engage in activities such as these. At one time they used to be encouraged and aided and abetted to engage in these activities. The trouble about some of these people is that they have adhered to words and principles which other people have abandoned. The present Taoiseach told us on one famous occasion in this House that he still held that their right to be regarded as the legitimate Government of the country is faulty and that this House is faulty. There are some people outside who still believe that this House is faulty.

Comment on this

They have no justification now.

Comment on this

You had no justification in 1929.

Comment on this

That is your opinion. In any case, there is none now.

Comment on this

There was no justification then, and there is no justification now for alleging against this House that it has a faulty title. The trouble about the whole matter is that what people believed in 1929 they are being advised to forget now. They were encouraged to take roads and paths which have not been of service to this country or to its internal peace. It is by speeches and actions of that kind that you have got a difficulty such as the country has to face up to to-day. We are being asked to face up to it in a manner which blows sky-high and makes an ironic mockery of that Constitution which for two years we have been told is the badge of our nationhood and the symbol of our democratic thought.

The Minister for Justice told us in the course of his speech this evening of certain cases where people were apprehended for doing certain things. Where they have been apprehended surely there are sufficient powers to prefer charges against those people and to try them. There is no deficiency of power or inadequacy of machinery in dealing with offences of that kind where a person is actually apprehended. In addition to the extraordinary and unusual powers enshrined in the Offences Against the State Act, is the reason for seeking powers of arrest and internment without charge or trial for an indefinite period merely because some Minister thinks, or somebody with malice reports to the Minister that he thinks, a certain person is likely to do a certain thing is not immediately apprehended and interned?

I regard the power of internment as a drastic power which should be used only in a war situation in respect of a non-national, in respect of an alien who could not be expected to conform to the statute law of a country which was not his own country, and who might, out of a sense of military responsibility, be engaged in tactics calculated to have a subversive influence on the State in which he lived. It is only in a war emergency that it can be justified, and it can only be justified in respect of aliens of that kind. Where you have a peaceful country with no internal violence, except that which is encouraged by incompetence, there is no justification whatever for giving to the Government the power to arrest and detain a person without charge or trial. When a Government get power of that kind they get the most tyrannical power which it is possible for the Legislature to give them—the power to imprison a citizen and never once be called upon to prefer a charge against him.

We will be told, I suppose, that a commission will be set up to which an arrested person can submit a case for his release. That is a complete inversion of all normal law. A man is entitled to be adjudged innocent until he is proved guilty. If the Government, with their vast resources, with the expenditure of thousands of pounds on their secret service organisation, are not able to get sufficient evidence, then they are not entitled to say, "we will intern a person simply because we are either inefficient or legislatively too lazy to get evidence against a person."

I am opposed to giving these drastic powers of arrest and internment without trial. I think it is vital to the Legislature that it should insist that every citizen must be tried in accordance with law, and that it is foreign to our conception of the Constitution and democratic thought that a man can be arrested and cast into prison and that he shall have no rights as against the Government unless he is prepared to submit to a complete inversion of the normal processes of law. Nothing has been said by the Minister for Justice this evening to justify the invasion of that fundamental right. No set of conditions in the country to-day justifies the Government in seeking, either in this Bill or any other Bill, to utilise a recent set of circumstances, some within their control, others perhaps out of their control, to take the step of abrogating the fundamental right of the citizen; his right, before he can be deprived of his liberty, to be charged and tried by his own countrymen.

Comment on this

Towards the close of his speech this evening the Taoiseach said: "It is not necessary to convince the House of the necessity for this legislation." My main objection, and the difficulty that the Government have put us in on more than one occasion, thought we have asked them not to do it, is that they do not make a sufficient effort to justify to the House and to the country what they are doing. I am convinced, and have been for a considerable time, that there is a dangerous situation. But I am equally certain that the Government have always neglected to make a decent case for the legislative steps they propose taking. We have listened to two speeches from the Government Benches to-day, one from the Minister for Justice and the other from the head of the Government. Twelve months ago, when similar legislation was being introduced, we also had two Ministers in charge—the then Minister for Justice and the Taoiseach. On both of these occasions, I say without any hesitation, there was a marked difference in tone between the Minister responsible for the Department of Justice and the Taoiseach.

We have heard an academic condemnation of force and disorder from the Taoiseach—nothing more than that. I have not the slightest doubt that some of those people whom he academically condemns will be able to quote portions of the speech he made to-day in justification for what they are doing— wrongly quote; but they will do it. There was no real, definite, strong condemnation. He has time and again been asked to give such a clear condemnation; as for example when the Offences Against the State Act was being passed through this House 12 months ago. On no occasion up to to-day has he done it. The situation is serious; it was serious 12 months ago. What was the attitude then taken by the Taoiseach?

The attitude taken then was that there was no immediately serious situation but this type of legislation ought to be on the Statute Book for a Government to use should occasion arise. It is not, we were told, that he feared anything immediately—he did not! The Bill was not really directed against any existing situation, any immediate danger. It is because a Government ought to have these powers that the Bill was pushed through. I admit that a somewhat different colour was put on the whole picture by the then Minister for Justice. But that is what I complain of. The Government speak if not with two voices, certainly with two very different tones, and there is always an excusatory tone about the attitude of the Taoiseach when dealing with these people. I cannot make the same charge against the then Minister for Justice or the present Minister for Justice. But the least we could have expected from a man in the Taoiseach's position is that he should show the necessity for this legislation. We are convinced of it; we have been convinced of it. We never grudge the Government any of the powers for which they ask. I think it was unfair and ungenerous of the Minister for Justice to suggest that in any way we hampered the passing through of the Offences Against the State Bill 12 months ago. He knows well that we did nothing of the kind.

Comment on this
Mr. Boland

I did not suggest that you did. If I gave that impression, I did not mean to give it.

Comment on this

I admit that I should be surprised if the Minister deliberately did so. His words were, unfortunately, capable of that interpretation. I immediately accept the Minister's statement. Having devoted most of his speech to discussing legal technicalities, the Taoiseach tells us there is no time to discuss legal technicalities. "My opinion is," he tells us in reference to the meaning of these words. I remember, when the Constitution was going through the House, we pointed out to the Taoiseach—of course, he was not convinced; nothing we could say would ever convince him —that it did not matter what his opinion of the meaning of the words was, that what counted was the views of the judges as to what the words meant. The Taoiseach is adopting the same attitude now. We are told that if the judges disagree with him their judgment is perverse.

Comment on this

No. I said that you were suggesting in advance that their judgment was going to be perverse.

Comment on this

Because it differs from yours.

Comment on this

What I stated was the common-sense meaning.

Comment on this

The Taoiseach's meaning has been turned down by the judges, and the judges are, apparently, wrong, and he is right. The Taoiseach refers to the words as they would be interpreted by an ordinary man. When it comes to interpreting ordinary words by an ordinary man, I hold that I am more an ordinary man than the Taoiseach.

Comment on this

We shall agree to differ.

Comment on this

Is the view put forward by Deputy Costello a perverse view? It might, at least, have got into the head of the Taoiseach that there was the possibility of a division of opinion as to what the words meant. You are going to submit one of these Bills, I understand, to the court.

Comment on this

We hope to do so. That is all we can say about it.

Comment on this

You seem to be very sure of what the President will do in one case—seeking the judgment of the Supreme Court—while you cannot say what he would do in the other case—demanding a referendum. If it is brought before the courts, who is to state the case against it? Are the courts to be made a mockery of by being asked to pronounce on the constitutionality of this particular Act, without the question being properly argued before them? Who is to argue before the Supreme Court that this is an unconstitutional measure? Does the Taoiseach expect his republican friends or enemies—I do not know which they are after his speech—to do it? Take the Bill we are discussing at the moment. Deputy Costello put forward the view that, to my mind, represents the ordinary meaning of the words. Interpreting English in the ordinary sense, I cannot see how the present Bill can be brought within the provisions of the Constitution. I know the Taoiseach thinks it can, and that, therefore, if the judges differ from him, they are perverse. But it will be sufficient for one judge to be perverse. If you intern a man under this Bill, he can immediately apply for habeas corpus. If he gets any judge to grant his application, the powers of the Government become worthless. There is no appeal. The Taoiseach will not take the ordinary method of securing the necessary power because it is proposed by the Opposition. He says that the President would probably feel himself coerced to submit the measure to a Referendum.

Comment on this

I did not say that. I was more careful than that.

Comment on this

The Taoiseach said the President might do that. We have, as an example, a case in which he did not do it. The Constitution was amended last September. Was that amendment merely verbal? Was that not an important amendment? Remember what the purpose was. The purpose of the amendment was to make this emergency legislation possible. Surely that was an important amendment. It might be quite as important as the measure we are now discussing. The Taoiseach had no hesitation as regards what the President would do in that case. We shall be in a nice situation if the Government proceed against people on certain lines, as provided by these two Bills, and are then told that they have acted unconstitutionally. The Taoiseach says he is prepared to risk that. He is always prepared to risk the good name, the prestige and the safety of this State. That is what I object to. He has now laid down that, unless the judges decide along the lines he wants, unless they take not the ordinary meaning of the words but what the Taoiseach thinks is the ordinary meaning, they are perverse.

Comment on this

I said no such thing.

Comment on this

You used words which amounted to the same thing.

Comment on this

I should like to say, again, if I may——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Is Deputy O'Sullivan giving way?

Comment on this

Certainly.

Comment on this

What I said was quite the opposite. I said that we would be suggesting that the judges were going to act perversely if we adopted the views of the Opposition.

Comment on this

We have had a view put forward by an eminent lawyer as to what certain words mean. If the judges act on that, they will be acting in a perverse way.

Comment on this

There are more eminent lawyers than those sitting on the Opposition Benches.

Comment on this

If the judges happen to agree with that particular lawyer, they are perverse. That is a nice view as to their power to interpret the Constitution. If the judges do not follow the Taoiseach, then they are perverse and will have to go. That is the main contribution made by the head of the Government in justification of this Bill. If the judges give perverse judgments, then, according to him, they will have to go.

Comment on this

I did not say anything of the kind.

Comment on this

The public can read what the Taoiseach said.

Comment on this

You can turn and twist words.

Comment on this

That phrase was used.

Comment on this

There is no better man for twisting words than the Taoiseach. He is a past master in that. The Constitution was meant to be a balanced instrument, he tells us. It is about as balanced as the Budget. Further, the Taoiseach tells us: "We had no doubt we had these powers." It is because you were so sure these words meant what you thought and would listen to nobody that you are in the predicament in which you now are. The court decided there were doubts and you refuse to take the obvious means of remedying the matter because you do not want, above all things, a Referendum on this Bill. Would it not be a terrible thing if the people were allowed to vote on this Bill?

Comment on this

The objection was because of the cost.

Comment on this

We pointed that out when the Constitution was going through. We stressed the question of cost, but in vain. When fundamental liberties are in question, the objection of cost turns up! Cost is being weighed against the liberty of the people of this State! That is the view taken by the head of the Government.

Comment on this

Balderdash.

Comment on this