Committee on Finance. - Trade Union Bill, 1941—Fifth Stage.
Contributions 131–290 of 290. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 9 of 1941 ›
On a point of order. The Minister made a certain statement. He said that certain statements were made in this House and he mentioned the name of Deputy Corish. When asked to produce evidence——
Comment on this
The Minister mentioned the name of Deputy Corish in connection with an allegation he made in this House. When asked to produce proof, he produced some speech that was made at Drogheda, thereby running away from the charge impliedly made against Deputy Corish.
Comment on this
Will the Minister produce that statement or produce proof? It is a serious allegation to make against a Deputy and it should be proved or withdrawn. Is the Minister going to withdraw that lying statement?
Comment on this
My name has been mentioned in connection with this matter. I want to say very definitely that when anybody came to me and said that they should withdraw from the Defence Forces in consequence of this Bill, I told them to do nothing of the kind. I opposed action of that kind every place I went in the country. I do not agree with it, if it is suggested by a responsible Minister that I did so.
Comment on this
Is that lying statement withdrawn? A serious allegation was made. I assert it is a lying allegation.
Comment on this
I demand a withdrawal from the Minister. I did not make the statement at all. On the contrary I have been doing the opposite. The Minister says he will not withdraw so I will stand until he does.
Comment on this
You made a damnably lying statement and you are going to withdraw it. I am as good an Irishman as you are, and I am as long in the Irish movement.
Comment on this
The statement, as heard by the Chair, was to the effect that certain statements had been made in the House by persons who alleged that, if this Bill were put into effect, efforts might be made to get certain persons to withdraw their allegiance from the national movement. I did not hear Deputy Corish's name mentioned in connection with that statement.
Comment on this
The Minister said that the statement was made in the House—that was the vital point—and that reference to it had been made in the House by members of the Labour Party.
Comment on this
You said that I made the statement that men should withdraw from the Defence Forces. I think as much about them as you do and I did as much to form them as you did.
Comment on this
The Chair must rule the proceedings here and the Chair did not hear that imputation made.
Comment on this
The Chair can only rule on what it heard, and the Chair did not hear that statement made.
Comment on this
I have to defend myself, and I am not going to allow the Minister to proceed. I can leave the House, but he is going to withdraw that statement.
Comment on this
The Minister will withdraw the very definite statement that we advocated the withdrawal of people from the Defence Forces, in connection with which he mentioned my name.
Comment on this
Both will sit down. The Chair has already said that it did not hear the imputation made against Deputy Corish. The Minister says definitely that he made no such imputation. In face of that, the Chair does not see any necessity for such heat.
Comment on this
You did not say anything of the kind, and you are going to withdraw the statement you made. I will be put out of this House, or you will withdraw that statement.
Comment on this
I will not let the Minister proceed until he withdraws that statement. I have a reputation as well as the Minister, and I am not going to have it said that I tried to divide the Forces of the State when the State was in danger.
Comment on this
The Minister has explained that he made no such imputation, and, in the face of that——
Comment on this
If the Minister has not got in his mind what he has alleged against me, he will withdraw.
Comment on this
I did not allege that Deputy Corish had been endeavouring to induce persons to withdraw from the Defence Forces. I did not make that allegation and I am not going to withdraw it.
Comment on this
You are getting it from the Chair. The Chair has already ruled that it did not hear such an imputation being made, and the Minister has explained that he made no such imputation. I think that explanation of the Minister ought to be accepted.
Comment on this
On a point of order. The Minister did mention that Deputy Corish made that statement, and, before he mentioned his name, he was asked who had made it. He mentioned Deputy Corish's name and immediately was not so sure that he did make the statement.
Comment on this
On a further point of order. He took up a document to read an extract from it which he thought would justify his statement.
Comment on this
The Deputy is behaving in a thoroughly disorderly manner. The Chair has already ruled that the Deputy's name has not been mentioned in connection with this matter at all. The Minister has explained that he did not mention him in connection with it.
Comment on this
I said that I did not allege that Deputy Corish had been inducing people to withdraw from the Defence Forces. I have said that. I was going on to mention the other fact which Deputy Corish himself had given evidence of in this House, that people were trying to organise a withdrawal.
Comment on this
Did the Minister not say that that course was advocated in this House? Does he understand resentment against such a statement?
Comment on this
Do I understand the Chair to say that the Minister did not state he heard ill-considered statements made here suggesting the withdrawal of members of the Defence Forces from those forces? Is it possible that the Chair did not hear that statement, because certainly everybody else did?
Comment on this
The Chair did hear the statement mentioned by Deputy Murphy, but the Chair emphasises that the Minister did not use Deputy Corish's name in connection with it.
Comment on this
Having reached that point, is it not an indisputable fact that the Minister was asked the name of the Deputy who made the statement? May I put that question with all respect?
Comment on this
Leaving Deputy Corish out of it altogether, the Minister ought to say now what Deputy made a statement of that kind. If he does not know of any such Deputy, he should be graceful enough to withdraw the statement.
Comment on this
That is another aspect of the matter. Deputy Murphy has come to the real kernel of the question. The statement was made by the Minister that certain insinuations were made from the Labour Benches that persons would be asked to withdraw from the Defence Forces, if the Bill went through. I did not hear the name of Deputy Corish mentioned and the Minister says he did not use his name in such connection.
Comment on this
The Minister, having made the allegation that such statements as I have referred to were made in the House, proceeded to quote from a paper which had nothing to do with what took place in the House.
Comment on this
He said: "Here we are", taking up a paper, when asked who made the statement. The Minister did mention Deputy Corish as having made such a statement.
Comment on this
Deputy Corish has had explained to him already that the Chair did not hear such an expression and the Minister denies having made it.
Comment on this
The Minister has explained that he did not use it, and that explanation must be accepted.
Comment on this
He has not got the common decency to withdraw or to prove it. Common decency demands that he do one or the other.
Comment on this
May I suggest that the Minister did say that some members of the House made statements of the kind? The Minister has refrained from mentioning who they are. I think he ought to withdraw an imputation of that kind, if he is not in a position to prove it.
Comment on this
If I am to be asked to adduce evidence as to the making of ill-considered statements——
Comment on this
——I can only point to the fact that statements were made in the House which the censor felt called upon not to permit the newspapers to publish.
Comment on this
The Minister is now endeavouring to quote, in respect of the statement he made, a statement made in the House by Deputy Corish and by me, to the effect that if this Bill were passed we would do our best to advise trade unions not to look for negotiation licences under the Bill. That was one thing; but no suggestion whatever was made by this Party, or by any other member of the House, that persons would be advised to withdraw from the Defence Forces. The Minister knows that he has made a lying statement, and he has not the manliness to withdraw it.
Comment on this
What I said as to ill-considered statements having been made in the House? Not at all. I still think that some of the statements made in the House were rash and ill-considered.
Comment on this
Sir, I suggest that the country is expecting more from us than this. I would suggest to the Minister to withdraw the statement he has made. He has made that statement and he cannot deny it and surely he is big enough to withdraw the statement he has made. I was one of the first to ask who made the statement and the Minister said, "Here we are," looking for information from a document, and quoting Deputy Corish's name.
Comment on this
Deputy Corish must keep order. The Chair never heard any imputation on Deputy Corish's name with that matter.
Comment on this
The Chair is not in a position to give any ruling on the objective truth or the objective untruth of any statement made. If the Chair hears anything which is out of order the Chair will rule accordingly, but I heard nothing except what I have explained to the House. In these circumstances the Deputies ought to resume their seats and allow the Minister to conclude.
Comment on this
It is not a question of order. It is a question of the Minister making a lying allegation which I resent. Is he going to withdraw?
Comment on this
We are perfectly conscious. We want it withdrawn. It is a serious matter and we want the Minister to withdraw.
Comment on this
Deputy Corish must keep order. The Minister explained he has made no such allegation.
Comment on this
Does that mean that although a reflection of that kind is made on Deputy Corish, who is a well-known national figure, he can get no redress in this House simply because you did not hear the remark?
Comment on this
Do I understand from the Minister that he did not make the statement that members of this House suggested the withdrawal of members from the Defence Forces?
Comment on this
Did you make that statement? Do you deny making the statement that members of this House were suggesting withdrawing members from the Defence Forces?
Comment on this
I do not know what Deputy Hickey thinks he is, but that is not a point of order nor is he a cross-examining lawyer. I am going to say this, if I will be permitted——
Comment on this
I heard the name mentioned. It is a charge that could not be made outside this House and it ought not to be allowed at the present moment. I heard it. I was sitting here and I heard it.
Comment on this
It is a disgrace to the House if they allow the Minister to get away with it. It is a shame to have such an allegation made against any honourable member of this House.
Comment on this
The Chair did not hear that particular allegation. At all events, the matter must be allowed to drop.
Comment on this
I cannot ask the Minister to withdraw anything he denies saying and which I did not hear.
Comment on this
Let the Minister go to the Rathmines Town Hall and make that statement. We will deal with him.
Comment on this
Question put.
Do you agree with this result?