We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Committee on Finance. - Vote 69—Office of the Minister for Supplies.

Contributions 1–194 of 371. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Fionán Lynch An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

This Supplementary Estimate, which contains five sub-heads, will be moved by the Minister for Supplies. Sub-heads A. D. E. will be disposed of without a vote. When sub-head F is reached a motion will be moved by Deputy Dillon to reduce the Vote by £10 in respect of that sub-head. When that motion is decided, sub-head G will be taken without a vote. Finally, the Estimate, as a whole, will be dealt with.

Comment on this
Seán F. Lemass Minister for Supplies (Mr. Lemass) Fianna Fáil

I move:—

Go ndeontar suim breise ná raghaidh thar £683,908, chun íoctha an mhuirir a thiocfaidh chun bheith iníoctha i rith na bliana dar críoch an 31adh Márta, 1942, chun Tuarastail agus Costaisí Oifig an Aire Soláthairtí, maraon le conganta áirithe airgid d'íoc.

That a supplementary sum, not exceeding £683,908, be granted to defray the charge which will come in course of payment during the year ending 31st March, 1942, for the Salaries and Expenses of the Office of the Minister for Supplies, including payment of certain subsidies.

Deputies will see from the Estimate that the additional sum is required for two purposes. A sum of £42,168 is required to defray the cost of additional staff recruited by the Department of Supplies and other sums in respect of telegrams, telephones, advertising and publicity are needed in excess of the amount voted for the year in consequence of the expansion of the Department's activities. The main sum asked for is £550,000, for the purpose of subsidising the prices of flour and wheaten meal and an additional sum of £80,000 for the purpose of subsidising the price of bread. To deal first with the amount required, over and above the Estimate, in respect of salaries, wages and allowances, it is, I think, unnecessary to inform the Dáil that there has been a considerable expansion in the activities of the Department since the original Estimate was framed. Because of that expansion in its activities, substantial increases in staff were necessary. At this time last year, only one commodity was rationed —petrol. Since then, rationing, or control of distribution in one form or another, has been found necessary in respect of a number of other commodities—kerosene, mineral oils, coal, tea and sugar as well as a number of industrial materials, such as timber, cotton and woollen goods. At this time last year, the staff serving in the Department numbered 157. It has now reached 425. The provision made under sub-head A of the Estimate for the Department of Supplies in the past did not, at any time, reflect the whole cost of the staff serving in that Department because, in accordance with the practice of the Civil Service, the salaries of officers who were on loan from other Departments were paid by the Departments from which they came. It was only where officers were promoted that any provision had to be made in the Estimate for the Department of Supplies for any part of their remuneration. While the staff serving on loan has increased, the main increase in staff has resulted from the recruitment of officers from the usual Civil Service examinations for direct appointment to the Department of Supplies. These direct appointments are responsible for a substantial part of the increased provision which has had to be made under sub-head A. It has been found necessary for the staff of the Department to work overtime considerably in excess of the amount originally estimated, and provision has been made under sub-head A for the additional cost involved. It is clear that the staff of the Department will have to be considerably augmented to deal with the further measures of control of the distribution of commodities in short supply and provision has been made for the substantial increase in the amount of clerical assistance which will be required before the end of the financial year.

Because of the increased activity of the Department, the expenditure under sub-head D has also expanded. As Deputies will note, there has been a very considerable expansion, relatively speaking, in the estimated amount required for advertising and publicity. To a much greater extent than was originally considered necessary, we have resorted to the use of display advertisements in the newspapers in order to bring to the attention of the public the regulations in force concerning the distribution of commodities, the fixation of prices and other matters of that nature. These display advertisements, which are, I think, necessary to secure the requisite publicity for the matters concerned, cost much more than the usual formal type of advertisement previously used for the purpose of making Government announcements in the Press.

As I have said, the main sum asked for is that in respect of the proposed subsidy to the prices of flour and bread. As has been obvious for some considerable time past, owing to the great increase in the cost of importing wheat from abroad and the decision to increase the guaranteed minimum price for native wheat from 35/- to 40/- per barrel, a substantial increase in the price of flour and, consequently, of bread, could not be avoided during the present cereal year. For some time past—since the extraction of flour from wheat was increased to 95 per cent.—imported wheat has been allocated to flour millers by Grain Importers, Limited, at a price of 65/6 per quarter. That price, it is true, contained an element which enabled Grain Importers, Limited, to accumulate some surplus funds. A large part of the wheat allocated this year by Grain Importers was purchased before the war at pre-war prices. From the point of view of the miller, the cost was 65/6 and it was, of course, that cost which had to be taken into account in determining the price at which the miller could sell flour. It is now clear that a considerable part of the 80,000 tons of wheat, which it is considered it will be necessary to import this year, will not be brought in at a price much less, if less, than 120/- per quarter.

Comment on this

What weight is in the quarter?

Comment on this

Four hundred and eighty pounds.

Comment on this

A barrel is seven-twelfths of a quarter.

Comment on this

The important point I want Deputies to note is that the allocation price of imported wheat this year may be practically double what it was last year. Similarly, the price of native wheat has increased, and the increase in the price of native wheat will operate to increase the price of millers' grist and, consequently, the price of flour to a substantial extent. These increases in the price of wheat mean that the subsidy which will be required to enable the price of flour to be maintained unchanged during the whole of the cereal year will be about £1,900,000. As I informed the Dáil some time ago, we estimate that we shall get for milling purposes 290,000 tons of Irish wheat. If circumstances should arise which would prevent our getting that quantity of Irish wheat, then the various calculations we have made as to the cost of the subsidy will be upset. These calculations are based on the assumption that we shall have 290,000 tons of native wheat, to be supplemented by about 80,000 tons of imported wheat. The average cost of native wheat, dried and fit for milling, during the last cereal year, was 40/9 per barrel. The price on the farm was 35/-. Various additional charges had to be allowed for in respect of sacks, drying costs, agents' commission, and 10 per cent. loss on drying, which charges increased the cost of the wheat to the miller from the 35/- paid to the farmer to 40/9. The corresponding figure this year will be 46/9—an increase of 6/-. The average price paid to the farmer will be 40/6. Allowances in respect of sacks, agents' commission and drying costs will remain unchanged, but the 10 per cent. loss on drying will involve a higher figure because of the higher price. Consequently, although the guaranteed price to farmers was increased by 5/-, the actual cost of dried wheat to the millers will be increased by 6/-.

Comment on this

Is that a comparable figure with the 120/- for imported wheat?

Comment on this

Will the 120/- per quarter be the actual cost to the miller in his store?

Comment on this

Not necessarily. That will be the cost of the wheat landed here.

Comment on this

Could you give us the comparable figure?

Comment on this

That will be the lowest possible price at which the miller can get it. There will be some charges to be added, but they will not materially affect the cost.

Comment on this

At what point will the cost be 120/-?

Comment on this

Landed at an Irish port.

Comment on this

The figure, 46/9, is the cost in the miller's store?

Comment on this

In the miller's store, what will be the addition to the 120/- per quarter?

Comment on this

That would involve a calculation into which I do not want to enter now. Irish wheat, as the Deputy knows, has a moisture content higher than that required by the miller, and, consequently, the cost of drying it must be added to the price of the wheat, but imported wheat contains an insufficiency of moisture. Consequently, there is a gain to the miller because he adds moisture to the wheat.

Comment on this

The figure of 46/9 represents the cost in the miller's store. The figure of 120/- represents the cost at an Irish port. That wheat has to be transported to the miller's store. There it has to be treated for additional moisture before it comes to the comparable point with the 46/9 for homegrown wheat?

Comment on this

That is right.

Comment on this

Could you give us the comparable figure?

Comment on this

The figure I have given will do for comparison purposes. It is not necessary to go into pence. The increased cost resulting from the increased price of native wheat will be roughly £700,000. The increased cost of the 80,000 tons of imported wheat will be about £1,200,000.

Comment on this

Are you going on last year's figures?

Comment on this

The increased cost of native wheat will be £700,000. We estimate that 80 per cent. of the total wheat used will be native wheat as against something below 50 per cent. previously. The increased cost of imported wheat will be £1,200,000. We estimate that the allocation price will be £30 per ton, as against £15 per ton last year, and that only 20 per cent. of the wheat used will be imported wheat. That sum of £1,900,000, which represents the total increased price we will have to pay for wheat on the assumption that the quantity of flour to be consumed will be 2,700,000 sacks, means that, without any subsidy from any source, the price per sack of flour would be increased by about 14/-. The port price of flour at present is 52/6 per sack and that would become 66/6. In accordance with the formula on which bread prices are fixed, that would make a 4-lb. loaf 1/2 as against the present price of 1/-, even assuming there were no additional costs in the production of the loaf which would have to be offset by a higher price. I want to stress that the increase in the price of flour—the 14/- to which I have referred—is attributable solely to the increased cost of wheat, both native and imported. The other items going to make up the price of a sack of flour will remain unaltered. In other words, I am allowing nothing for any possible increase in the cost of production or for any change in the remuneration of the milling industry, which is 6 per cent. on the capital employed in the industry as a whole.

Comment on this

Six per cent. on the capital?

Comment on this

Yes. There is, however, as Deputies know, available to offset the increased cost of flour a certain sum which represents the accumulated reserves of the Wheat Reserve Committee, that is to say, the body that bought wheat before the war and held it until required—it was not required until this year—and Grain Importers Limited, who have been in the position of accumulating reserves since the increase in the extraction of flour from wheat. At the time that increased extraction was decided upon, it would have been possible for a short period to have reduced the price of flour, as more flour was being obtained from the wheat, but we decided not to reduce the price of flour but to hold the surplus funds accruing to Grain Importers Limited against this period when we knew that the cost of flour would have to be increased substantially. If we were to rely solely upon these reserve funds, which amount to £650,000——

Comment on this

£650,000?

Comment on this

Yes. I should explain that it has been decided that £650,000 be used during the cereal year but in the period of the cereal year covered by this Estimate only £330,000 will be used. That £330,000, if that were all that was available to reduce the price of flour now, would reduce the 14/- increase which would otherwise have to be faced, by 5/3 per sack. The net increase, therefore, would be 8/9 and the price of the 4-lb loaf would be 1/1½. If, on the other hand, we decided to use the whole of this reserve in this financial year, then the increase would be reduced by 10/6. These figures will help Deputies to understand the magnitude of the decision which the Government took to maintain the price of flour and bread unchanged by the provision of a subsidy. The price of flour at present is 52/6, as I have said, at four ports—Dublin, Cork, Limerick and Waterford—and elsewhere it is 52/6 plus the cost of transport by the cheapest method of transportation.

These prices have been maintained unchanged for over 15 months, from September of last year, by various devices which it is not now necessary to enumerate. They will continue unchanged in consequence of this decision of the Government to provide a subsidy. It is intended to make an order fixing maximum retail prices for flour. That order will come into operation in a day or two. It is being made because arrangements have been completed which will permit of it, and I will refer to it again in another connection.

Comment on this

I take it that the Minister does not wish to mislead us. The price is not being maintained at what it was, because heretofore the price of 52/6 was in bags: now that price is naked, representing an increase of 1/3 per sack.

Comment on this

There is no change in the price of flour since last year.

Comment on this

There has been a change, inasmuch as flour now is consigned naked.

Comment on this

When fixed by me in September of last year, that price was subject to the conditions which still obtain.

Comment on this

The Minister now knows that the effect of the Minister's decision is to increase the price by 1/3 per sack.

Comment on this

But that was done when the price was fixed.

Comment on this

No, it was done only when the Minister made the sacks 5/- and made them returnable.

Comment on this

The Deputy is referring to the Sacks Order, which was designed to ensure the return of sacks.

Comment on this

It put £150,000 per year into the pockets of the millers.

Comment on this

That is a matter which I do not intend to argue now, but I am prepared to dispute it at any time that may be arranged.

Comment on this

It is true. It represents an increase of 1/3 per sack of flour. I assure the Minister that.

Comment on this

We have a motion by Deputy Dillon to reduce this sub-head F, that is, the sub-head which deals with flour and wheaten meal. I do not know for what reason the Deputy has submitted that motion. Perhaps he intends to argue against the subsidisation of flour—I do not know—but whether he does it or I do it, somebody must give to the House the arguments that can be advanced against the subsidisation of flour. Those arguments are not inconsiderable. In fact, they are of such a nature that the Government spent a long time considering whether it would be wiser to proceed by way of subsidy or otherwise. Finally, we decided, for reasons which I can give, in favour of the subsidy, but I would like the House to understand that the decision was taken only after we had given full weight to the arguments in favour of another course. It is obvious that subsidising the price of flour does not reduce the cost of it. The cost of producing the flour required by the people of this country will increase in this cereal year by £1,900,000 over the cost of last year. That increase in the cost of providing the community's flour is due, as I have stated, to the higher price we are now paying for native wheat, which represents 80 per cent. of our supply, and to the very much higher price we have to pay for the balance, which we import in the form of hard wheats across the Atlantic.

Comment on this

Not for the wheat, but the cost of transport.

Comment on this

For the cost here. The big item in the cost is transport charges, but the effective price to us is that at which the wheat is delivered in this country.

Comment on this

But we control the freight rates through Irish shipping.

Comment on this

The payment of a subsidy to maintain flour prices tends to conceal that increase in the cost of our flour. The community will pay it as taxpayers and not as consumers. It is essential that the members of this House and the public generally should understand that we do not avoid an increase by a subsidy arrangement—we merely transfer the main burden of the charge from one section of the community to another. The community as a whole will have to pay the higher cost of the flour. The payment of a subsidy may tend to conceal the fact that our flour will cost a great deal more, and it may lead also to extravagant demands for further increases in the costs now operating to raise the price of flour—increased demands in respect of wheat by the producers of wheat and demands from other people interested in the production of flour. These might be deterred or the demands postponed if the persons concerned realised fully that the granting of their demands would have an immediate adverse effect on the consumers of the country.

If somebody proposed that the price of wheat should go up by 5/- a barrel to farmers, then everybody could relate that demand to the effect of an increase of a halfpenny in the price of the loaf; but when the element of subsidy is introduced, that fact does not become so obvious. Consequently, the decision to pay a subsidy may result in demands by producers of wheat or other persons concerned in the production of flour, of an extravagant nature, which could not be resisted so easily, as the effect upon the consumers will not be obvious. Furthermore, the introduction of an element of subsidy in the price of a commodity such as flour tends to disorganise the relationship between the price of flour and the price of other commodities. We could conceivably reduce the price of flour to a point at which we would be giving very definite encouragement to people to engage in the illegal practice of feeding flour to animals. If, by subsidy, we cause a disrelationship to appear between the price of flour and other materials that could be used as animal feeding stuffs, we are clearly taking a risk which would be completely unjustifiable in circumstances like those now existing, when it is not yet clear that we will have a sufficiency of flour to maintain the minimum requirements of our people.

I realised also, more particularly, perhaps, than other members of the Government, that a decision to pay a subsidy on the price of flour would lead to assertions that in some way flour millers were going to benefit by that subsidy and, in fact, that it was a subsidy to flour millers and not a subsidy to the consumers of flour. There is no gain of any kind to the Irish flour millers by reason of the decision to pay a subsidy. The position that the flour miller will be in is that he will continue to receive his wheat this year at the same price as he paid last year. He will have the same allowance in respect to cost of production and overhead charges, and he will be required to sell the flour at the same price.

Comment on this

Plus 1/3 a sack.

Comment on this

That is an irrelevancy.

Comment on this

It is an irrelevancy amounting to £150,000.

Comment on this

The flour millers are at present controlled at every stage of their activity. The price at which they buy the wheat is fixed; the wages of the workers are fixed; the allowances in respect to overhead charges are fixed and their profit is fixed by my Department. Thus, at every stage in the production of flour, from the growing of the wheat to its ultimate sale to the consumer, there is complete control and, so far as the miller is concerned, his position has not been affected by the payment of the subsidy.

Comment on this

How is the miller's profit controlled?

Comment on this

The price of the flour is fixed by me, or by an officer of my Department, on the known costs of producing flour, plus an allowance of 6 per cent. in respect to the capital employed. Furthermore, we had in mind, when considering this question of the paying of the flour subsidy, the fact that under the food voucher system the poorest sections of the community, those dependent for assistance on public funds of one kind or another, were, in fact, having their bread supply secured to them and the effect of an increase in the cost of bread offset by the allowance of bread free of charge which they get under that scheme. The fact, therefore, that the subsidy concealed a real increase in the cost of flour, that that concealment of the increase might lead to extravagant demands which would tend further to increase the cost of flour, that there was a risk that the subsidising of flour prices might encourage its use as an animal feeding stuff, that there might be a misunderstanding as to the effect of the subsidy on the position of individual traders, and the further fact that the poorer sections of the community were already being protected by a Government scheme against a rise in price—all these were serious considerations against the payment of a subsidy, and I stress them here because I should like the Dáil to understand that this policy of subsidisation of food prices was not lightly embarked upon and cannot lightly be pursued without regard to other consequences.

There is the risk of which the Government were fully aware, that that policy, once started, might lead us into a position of considerable danger if it were pursued recklessly. I do not want to be taken as saying that no expansion of that policy would be deemed possible in the future, but any proposal to expand it will have to have the same serious consideration which was given in the first instance to this particular aspect of it. We decided on the policy of subsidisation knowing what the risks were. We appreciated that the community would be paying more for flour, even though they would be paying as taxpayers and not as consumers. We did recognise that the burden of the additional charge would be transferred by subsidy from one section of the community to the other and that the effect of it would be, in part at any rate, to transfer it to the shoulders best able to bear it.

In announcing the decision of the Government, I made it clear that the sum of approximately £2,000,000 which was being provided this year for the purpose was the utmost that would be provided and, if any additional costs arose, these additional costs would have to be reflected in the ordinary way by an increased price of flour and bread.

Comment on this

How do you make up the £2,000,000?

Comment on this

Our estimate is £1,900,000. I used the sum of £2,000,000 as a round figure.

Comment on this

There is some money in the principal Estimate for this same purpose?

Comment on this

The total additional cost on flour in the cereal year will be £1,900,000. We are providing in this Estimate the amount required to the end of the financial year. It is, I think, necessary that we should follow up the decision to subsidise flour by exercising a more rigorous control over its distribution and use, and I want to urge on Deputies the importance of lending their moral support to the enforcement of the order which prohibits the use of wheat or flour or any wheaten product as a foodstuff for animals. He have had occasionally reports of the scarcity of flour in many parts of the country. These reports have been investigated and in some cases it is quite clear that the inability of numbers of human beings to get the quantity of flour required to maintain them was due to the fact that traders in the area had sold flour which they must have known was going to be used by the purchasers as feeding stuffs for pigs.

I think we should easily be able to get in the country the public spirit which will ensure that that practice will stop. I realise, and I am sure Deputies do, too, the tremendous difficulty of enforcing completely an order of that kind. It is almost impossible to get the evidence which will enable offenders to be convicted in a court, but if we get the public spirit aroused and get the public to understand that every person who offends against the order and uses wheat or wheaten products to feed to animals is depriving some human being of the appropriate quantity of flour, then we will get the kind of enforcement which will be most effective.

No matter what we may do, we will not have more than sufficient flour for human needs in this year. We may not have sufficient. The estimated yield of 290,000 tons from the Irish wheat crop has not yet materialised; not more than 170,000 tons has yet come in. There is, of course, still time for the balance to come in—the harvest was late—but if the full estimated quantity is not secured, then we will not be able to reach the end of the year with an all-wheaten loaf.

Comment on this

You will never succeed in stopping the use of wheat for the purpose of animal consumption unless you ration flour.

Comment on this

I shall deal later with the rationing of flour. I think it is necessary that I should explain to the House the procedure that will be adopted for the payment of the subsidy. Let me say this. I would have much preferred if we could, in this year, have paid the subsidy direct to the producers of wheat. I think we would have settled a lot of argument and have made quite clear both to wheat producers and everybody else what precisely was happening. Because of the system of minimum prices in operation under the Cereals Acts, and for other reasons, it was not practicable to do it this year. We are therefore subsidising the price of flour instead. We are doing that through the flour millers. We are doing it by arranging that the flour miller will get his wheat at the same price as that at which he got it last year. We are utilising for that purpose the organisation of Grain Importers (Eire), Limited. As Deputies are aware, Grain Importers (Eire), Limited, is a company, set up by the Government and financed by the Government for the purpose of buying wheat abroad for this country. It is a non-profit making company, the directors of which give their services voluntarily.

Comment on this

Who gets the 3/4 a ton?

Comment on this

I do not know what the Deputy is referring to. What 3/4 a ton is he referring to?

Comment on this

Is there not a commission of 3/4 a ton in respect of all the wheat handled by them?

Comment on this

So far as Grain Importers (Eire), Limited, are concerned, there is a very nominal charge to offset their expenses. There has been, in the past, a certain excess over the price at which they purchased wheat and the selling price fixed, the reserve thus being accumulated.

Comment on this

Do not the members of that body receive 3/4 a ton in respect of all the wheat they handle?

Comment on this

They receive nothing. They are a voluntary body.

Comment on this

But the directors?

Comment on this

The directors receive no remuneration.

Comment on this

No, but as to the seven men who are in that company, are they not all traders in grain in one capacity or another, and do they not receive 3/4 a ton on all foreign grain handled by them?

Comment on this

They are all directors of flour mills, are they not?

Comment on this

Obviously, they had to be people concerned with the flour milling industry.

Comment on this

Who gets the 3/4?

Comment on this

I do not know what 3/4 the Deputy is talking about. Those commercial organisations which handle the wheat, finance its purchase, and distribute it to the millers, get their expenses and a reasonable profit.

Comment on this

Is it 3/4 a ton?

Comment on this

I do not know what it is.

Comment on this

There happen to be seven houses which constitute Grain Importers (Eire) Limited.

Comment on this

Not at all. The Deputy is misinformed.

Comment on this

Well, who are they?

Comment on this

They are all directors of flour mills in the country.

Comment on this

Not all of them. One of them is from Belfast.

Comment on this

I want once again to protest here against the privileges of this House being used to abuse people who are giving valuable public services to the State without remuneration. The members of Grain Importers (Eire) Limited, as well as the members of other such companies, are businessmen of Irish nationality, who came forward at the call of the Government to put their specialised knowledge, their time and their energy, at the service of the people of this State, without pay. They are doing better work than some of the Deputies who criticise them here, and they should be immune from the type of criticism which is frequently directed against them here. How does the Deputy expect that the Government will get the services of such men in the public interest if those who are willing to offer that service feel that they are going to make themselves a cockshot for the criticisms and abuse of every narrow-minded little man who wishes to indulge in it?

Comment on this

The Minister says people are narrow-minded because they will not accept all he says.

Comment on this

I am quite prepared to say it. I am quite prepared to say it anywhere, in Cork or anywhere else.

Comment on this

The Minister cannot call me narrow-minded.

Comment on this

Grain Importers (Eire) Limited is an organisation that we set up for the purpose of importing wheat. We propose to use that organisation under this subsidy scheme. The money will be made available to Grain Importers (Éire) Limited, who will make adjustments in the allocation price of wheat to the millers in such form as to ensure that the total cost of the millers' grist will remain unchanged. That is, I think, the most effective method to ensure that the funds provided for subsidy purposes will be utilised to ensure that there will be no increase in the cost of producing flour.

Comment on this

And the amount given to Grain Importers (Éire) Limited will be checked by an official of the State?

Comment on this

Certainly. I do not know what suspicions the Deputy has. If Grain Importers (Éire) Limited were to make profits of £1,000,000, where would they go to? The only place they could go to is back to the State. The only shareholder is the State. If there is money to be distributed in the way of profits, it cannot go to anybody except to the nation.

Comment on this

Why did you put the Dock Milling Company on the board of Grain Importers (Éire) Limited, by order, if it is such an unpleasant burden?

Comment on this

If the Deputy wants to question any action that I have taken at any time, I am quite prepared to answer for it. The Deputy, however, believes every cock-and-bull story that is told to him by any casual passer-by in the street.

Comment on this

I believe that the Minister made an order putting that company on Grain Importers (Éire) Ltd.

Comment on this

I do not know what the Deputy is talking about. I made no such order.

Comment on this

The Minister will find out.

Comment on this

I should be glad to do so. If I made such an order I must have done it sometime when I was not conscious of my actions. For the purpose of assisting in the administration of the scheme a special committee is being formed consisting of Grain Importers (Eire) Ltd., and the Flour Millers' Association. That committee will be known as the financial adjustment committee and will be presided over by an officer of the Department of Supplies. As well as advising Grain Importers (Eire) Ltd. the committee will also advise me as to the nature of the directions to be given to the company. It is proposed also to subsidise the price of wheaten meal produced by licensed wheaten meal millers for sale. The cost of the subsidy in respect of wheaten meal is estimated at £33,000. It is, of course, included in the figure mentioned in sub-head F.

Comment on this

Is it included in the flour subsidy?

Comment on this

Yes. The subsidy, however, will not be payable to permitted millers, that is to say, millers who are grinding on a commission basis, and not for sale. Neither is it intended to subsidise any flour of less than 95 per cent. extraction. A limited quantity of certain types of flour is at present being produced under permit for use as altar bread, semolina, paste and starch. Flour of 95 per cent. extraction used for biscuit making, will, however, be eligible for the subsidy. Now, it is necessary also to provide a separate subsidy in respect of bread, if the aim of the Government to keep bread prices unchanged is to be realised. Deputies might have assumed that the fact that flour prices will remain unchanged automatically involves that bread prices will remain unchanged. But it is clear that other costs involved in the production of bread have risen as well as the cost of flour. As the House knows, the price of bread was controlled before the war. It was controlled under a special Act passed by the Oireachtas many years ago, following on a report of the Prices Commission, which prepared a formula designed to relate the price of bread to the price of flour. The Prices Commission drew up a table of flour prices and indicated the various points in the scale at which an increase or a decrease in the price of bread would be justifiable. Ordinarily, the price of bread goes up by ½d. per 4-lb. loaf if the price of flour rises by 4/- a sack, or, at some point in the scale, if the price of flour goes up by 3/- a sack. 50/- and 53/- per sack of flour were two points in the scale. If the price of flour fell below 50/- a decrease of ½d. in the price of bread would be involved; if it rose above 53/- an increase of ½d. would be involved. It is clear that, in preparing that formula, the Prices Commission had regard to the circumstances that existed at the time, normal circumstances pre-war, in which there was a continuous movement in the price of flour, the price of flour being fixed upon the world market price of wheat, which was continually fluctuating. Because the world market price of wheat was continually fluctuating, the home price of flour also fluctuated. In deciding upon that method of fixing bread prices, the Prices Commission assumed that that fluctuation in the price of flour would continue. If a change in the price of bread is admissible when the price of flour falls below 50/-, or when the price of flour rises above 53/-, it is clear that it is only when the price is 51/6, half-way between the two points, that the formula is strictly accurate and that the price of bread is exactly relating to the price of flour. The Prices Commission, however, assumed that the arrangement was fair to the bakers because they thought that, in the ordinary course of events, the price of flour would be as often below 51/6, as it was above it. Therefore, they said: "So long as it is at any point between 50/- and 53/- this price of 1/- a loaf should prevail."

Since the outbreak of the war, however, those circumstances ended. When the Department of Supplies was set up, it took control of the price of flour, and, as I have already stated, for a period of 15 months the price of flour has been pinned at the point of 52/6, that is 1/- above the price which was intermediate between the two points at which a change in the price of flour would take place. It was contended by the bakers that that arrangement was unfair to them; that, in holding the price of flour at a point just below the point at which they would be entitled to an increase in price, we were in fact making it impossible for them to continue in production at a profit. Now, I am going to say a few words which the bakers of this country will not like. The bakers contended that the arrangement was unfair to them, but they never proved it. Any other manufacturer in the country who considered that he was entitled to charge higher prices for his products came to my Department, produced his accounts, and satisfied the accountants in the service of the Department that an increase in costs had taken place sufficient to justify his claim for a higher price. The bakers never did that. They contented themselves with making vague general statements, some of which were so fantastic as to invalidate their whole contention. I took no action upon their claim because of their failure to make any attempt to substantiate it. It was not until a tribunal was set up by the Department of Industry and Commerce to investigate a claim by bakers employed in Dublin bakeries for an increase in their wages that the Dublin bakers produced their accounts. As Deputies who are familiar with the report of that tribunal will remember, those accounts showed in some cases—and showed to the satisfaction of the tribunal—that some at least of those bakers were selling bread at that time at a loss, or at any rate, not at a profit.

Now, I know that the price of salt and of yeast and of fuel and of petrol and of feeding stuffs for animals, and the cost of vehicles and repairs to vehicles and the like, have all increased and because I know those things I am assuming that the bakers are entitled to some increase in the price of bread, even though we disregard their claim in respect of our action in holding the price of flour at 52/6 for a period of 15 months, but the only positive information I have is the accounts submitted to me by those bakery firms in Dublin, and one out of 1,000 firms in the rest of Ireland. The various associations of bakers were asked to see that certified accounts were produced by their members, and they failed to do so. Outside the City of Dublin, out of 1,000 firms engaged in the bakery industry only one firm produced accounts. As a result of the information available to me, the examination of the accounts which were presented, and the knowledge, which is in fact common knowledge, as to the increase in the price of other commodities in addition to flour required in the manufacture of bread, I am satisfied that there has been an increase in the cost of baking bread equivalent to ½d. in the 4-lb. loaf. If, therefore, we wish to implement our decision to maintain the price of bread unchanged, this subsidy arrangement must include a provision to offset those higher costs of bakers. Under a recent order, all bakers of batch bread must be licensed, and I want to make it clear that this subsidy will be paid only to licensed bakers. The idea of licensing bakers has the official support of the three main associations of bakers. I want to mention, however, that, despite the publicity which was given to the matter, and despite the fact that the various associations of bakers were informed of the steps to be taken, the number of applications for licensing seems to be far below the number of bakers of batch bread. It must be clear that those who have failed to apply for their licences under the order will not qualify for and will not receive the subsidy.

Comment on this

How are you going to pay the subsidy?

Comment on this

The subsidy will be paid direct to the bakers in relation to their sales of batch bread.

Comment on this

Even to the 1,000 who did not furnish their accounts?

Comment on this

It will be paid to all licensed bakers.

Comment on this

Including the 999 who did not comply with your request?

Comment on this

Certainly.

Comment on this

Does the Minister wish to tell us at this stage how he will distinguish between the quantity of batch bread and fancy bread which a baker turns out?

Comment on this

Regulations will be made to enable us to determine the quantity of batch bread sold.

Comment on this

I wish to goodness the Minister would give us a brief sketch of the regulations he has in mind, because I am a baker, and how on earth he can satisfy himself as to how much batch bread and how much fancy bread is turned out is a mystery to me.

Comment on this

A number of regulations have already been made relating to the records which bakers must keep, as to the various returns that must be available for inspection by the departmental inspectors, and as to the manner in which their accounts must be presented. Those regulations are at present in force. I should have mentioned before that the subsidy in respect of flour and bread will be payable as from 15th October.

Comment on this

October last?

Comment on this

Yes, because the higher costs are in operation. If we did not make it retrospective to 15th October we would now have higher prices of flour and bread in operation. Arrangements were made with the bakers to ensure that those records would be kept. They will be sufficient, I think, to ensure that we will be able to exercise a proper check over the quantity of batch bread sold by each baker.

Comment on this

Why not add the bakers' subsidy to the flour subsidy?

Comment on this

It is not possible to do it that way because we are subsidising only the price of batch bread, and not the price of fancy bread or any other class of bread.

Comment on this

Would the difference be much?

Comment on this

The difference would be substantial. There are some bakers who produce no batch bread at all.

Comment on this

Would not the administration be a lot simpler?

Comment on this

No. There is a number of bakers in the country who do not produce batch bread. If we tried to deal with the situation by controlling the price of flour, then all those bakers, including manufacturers of confectionery, would get the benefit of the subsidy.

Comment on this

Would it matter if they did?

Comment on this

It would matter, to the extent of a very substantial amount of money.

Comment on this

I think it would mean a saving in administration and it would be a much simpler way of giving the subsidy.

Comment on this

The Deputy can be assured that that matter was fully considered because my natural inclination is towards simple administration arrangements in matters of this kind and if we decided to have a separate subsidy for batch bread it was due to the fact that no other method could be devised.

Comment on this

It will not make for very efficient administration.

Comment on this

From time to time we have had it urged here that we should reconsider the question of maintaining the extraction of flour at 95 per cent. It has been decided to retain it at 95 per cent. If we were to reduce the extraction of flour, say to the pre-war level which gave us white bread, not merely would the effect upon the price of the bread be very substantial—it would amount to 3d. or 4d. per loaf— but we would have to supplement the native wheat harvest to a much greater extent than we now contemplate. The attempt to give the community that white bread again would involve the importation of an additional 150,000 tons of wheat.

Comment on this

Not for an 85 per cent. extraction.

Comment on this

I agree, but 85 per cent. bread is not white bread. We could reduce it, as the British have done, to 80 per cent., and call it white bread, but over 80 per cent. the bran gets into the bread, and it does not make much difference from a dietetic point of view whether the extraction is 85 or 90 per cent. In respect of the keeping quality of the bread, the dietetic value of the bread, and so forth, the difference is not very significant. It is only when you get the extraction so low that there is no bran in the flour that there is any noticeable difference. At any rate, I am so advised by bread experts. I do not claim to be an expert myself.

Comment on this

You can tell the experts to eat their hats.

Comment on this

For the information of people, other than Deputy Dillon, who may feel that we should attempt to restore the white loaf again——

Comment on this

Eighty-five per cent. is not a white loaf.

Comment on this

——or reduce the extraction at all, I want to point out that any action of that kind involves a substantial increase in the quantity of wheat we would have to import. The total shipping space at our disposal is limited.

Comment on this

How much would you have to import to allow of an 85 per cent. loaf?

Comment on this

Roughly half 150,000 tons—75,000 tons. We have, as I say, a very limited amount of shipping at our disposal. The total amount of commodities which all those ships, worked to their fullest capacity, can bring in in a year is very limited. Every ton of wheat which we bring in, in excess of the minimum required to maintain the quantity of flour required by our people, can only be imported by stopping something else, and there are many other commodities, essential commodities, which are in such short supply that we must avail of these shipping facilities to bring them in. I mention tea as a case in point. There are many people who will urge, and rightly urge, that it is more important to increase the ration of tea, if we can, than to maintain a full supply of flour. Certainly it is much more important to increase the ration of tea than to reduce the extraction of flour from wheat. There are also industrial commodities upon which the livelihoods of many thousands of people depend, and if we cannot import these commodities, the industrial activities of which they are the raw materials must cease.

Comment on this

Self-sufficiency not with standing.

Comment on this

We can discuss that at another time. I should hate very much to contemplate the quantity of goods we would have to bring in if Deputy Dillon had his way for the past ten years. The position is that we must utilise our limited shipping space to the best advantage, and in order to enable us to import as many and as much of the commodities of which we are now short as we can get. Of course, in the circumstances of the world to-day, there are many commodities of which we are in need which cannot be got. It is not a question of shipping facilities at all; it is a matter of the unavailability of the commodities themselves, but there are many commodities still procurable in the world which must be imported through the medium of these limited shipping facilities. A decision, therefore, to reduce the extraction of flour from wheat means that we decide to utilise 75,000 or 150,000 tons, or at least the shipping space capable of carrying that tonnage of wheat, to carry wheat instead of some other commodities. I think that would be a very unwise decision.

Comment on this

The alternative is to grow it at home.

Comment on this

Yes, and if we can succeed in producing in this country 100 per cent. of our requirements in wheat within the next year, it will be possible for us, with the same shipping facilities, assuming we still have them, to bring in another 80,000 tons or so more of other commodities than we could bring in this year.

Comment on this

If you paid as big a price to the home producer as you pay to the foreign producer, you would get all the wheat you require grown at home.

Comment on this

If the Deputy would be satisfied with the price we pay to the foreign producer, I would be quite prepared to give it to him. The price we pay to the foreign producer is about 15/- per barrel. In fact, the Deputy can take it that there are countries in the world to-day where you can get wheat for nothing, merely for the taking away.

Comment on this

You told us it cost you 84/-.

Comment on this

That is the cost of bringing it in here, not the price paid to the foreign producer. As I have said, there are countries where we could get wheat almost for nothing if we could take it away. That has no relation to the cost of the wheat delivered in this country. It is a very interesting fact to bear in mind, however, that the enhanced price we now pay for home-grown wheat is very much below the price at which in present circumstances we could buy wheat of other origin. Deputy Dillon has referred on more than one occasion to his suggestion that we should ration flour.

Comment on this

And I sent you an admirable memorandum.

Comment on this

The Deputy made suggestions besides that seemed even not so intelligent. From time to time during the course of the last few months I have had complaints from different parts of the country that there was a shortage of flour. I want the House to believe me when I say that, to the best of my knowledge, every single one of these complaints was investigated and as a result of the investigation of the complaints I want to make the definite statement that nine out of ten of them were bogus. These shortages of flour were either caused, or alleged to exist, by traders who had a very definite interest in getting an increased supply of flour through their shops. There were exceptional circumstances in Monaghan, in Cavan and in Leitrim. There were districts along the border of those counties where the quantity of flour of native origin sold was much less than the quantity consumed, because people in those districts bought flour on the other side of the Border. In those districts there was a definite shortage of flour from the time that deliveries to traders in those areas were related to the purchases last year, and special measures had to be taken in order to deal with genuine shortages in those areas. In some other districts, or on some other occasions in particular districts, there were special and abnormal circumstances which caused real shortages which had to be made good by an increased supply.

Over the rest of the country as a whole most of the allegations of shortages were created by traders who had a vested interest in the matter. I want to urge on parish councils and similar bodies who communicate with me and my Department alleging the existence of flour shortages to investigate these things for themselves before making the allegations. In a very large number of cases which we investigated we found that there was in fact no shortage or should have been no shortage, if the traders concerned were not interested in creating one. Either there was no shortage at all and the trader was hoping to get an additional supply to sell on the black market or the trader had deliberately caused the shortage by selling exceptional quantities of flour to individuals. Furthermore, it is interesting to note that, even in the Border districts of County Monaghan, we have come across cases of traders who were sending flour out of these districts to other districts in the hope of getting a better price for it. We came across one trader in Monaghan who was actually sending flour to Kerry at the time when some newspapers were reporting a shortage of flour in Kerry.

Comment on this

Was not that white flour?

Comment on this

No, ordinary flour.

Comment on this

Surely you do not deny that there was a shortage of flour in Monaghan and along the Border?

Comment on this

The Deputy had just gone out when I was speaking of the question of the Border areas. I told the House before that 48,000 sacks of flour were being released every week for consumption. The fact is that, taking the flour milling industry as a whole, for some time past they have not got orders for 48,000 sacks of flour per week. That does not mean that in some districts there was no shortage, but it does indicate that the 48,000 sacks was sufficient to meet the requirements of the country, if distribution arrangements had been working perfectly. I have mentioned already that we are going to fix the maximum retail price of flour. That fixed retail price of flour will prevent any such transactions as that of the Monaghan trader to whom I have referred and will, I think, make it unprofitable for traders to do what a number of them have been doing—taking flour sent to them to supply the requirements of their area and sending it into other areas for sale at a higher price there, illegally. Furthermore, we have made arrangements which will, I am satisfied, ensure that no genuine shortage can arise in any area.

The institution of a rationing scheme for flour would be a very elaborate business and I think it would be entirely unjustifiable to impose all the inconvenience and hardship of a rationing scheme on the community as a whole because of the difficulties created by a few traders in a very limited number of districts. We can deal with these traders. There are probably too many traders engaged in the flour trade anyway, and the country would be better off without some of them. I want it to be known definitely that any trader who I find is not distributing the flour he receives equitably and fairly will in fact be put out of that business for the duration of the emergency or so long as I am in control of it.

Comment on this

You are passing the buck of your inefficiency on to the traders, and that is not just.

Comment on this

Any attempt to ration flour on a flat-rate basis would be eminently unfair to the poorer section of the community.

Comment on this
Daniel Morrissey Mr. D. Morrissey Fine Gael

What about tea?

Comment on this

In the diet of the poor, bread constitutes a much more important item than in the diet of the rich. In relation to the total quantity of food they buy, the poor buy much more bread than those better off, and to ration flour or bread—it would be very difficult to find an effective ration system anyhow—on a flat-rate basis would be unfair. I am not going to do it so long as it is possible to keep up the supply of flour, even if it becomes necessary to mix barley or oats with the wheat in order to maintain the supply. I think it is a much better policy to maintain a full supply of flour, even if it involves the use of other cereals, than to resort to rationing. I am prepared to deal with any case of alleged shortage that may be brought to my notice. The allegation will be investigated forthwith and, in any case where it is found there is a genuine shortage, additional supplies will be made available. These supplies will be there, we hope. In any event, we can, within the present total distribution, make available a surplus which is not now in demand in order to meet the requirements of particular areas.

I do not know if the Dáil expects me to deal with any other aspect of the work of the Department of Supplies other than this proposal to subsidise flour and bread. I do not know to what extent it is open to the Dáil to debate the whole of the activities of the Department on the Supplementary Estimate, but I assume it is. If it is desired that I should make a statement concerning the position of fuel, or tea, or sugar, or any other commodity, I am prepared to do it. I have gone at some length into this one item and perhaps it will satisfy the House if I leave it at that.

Comment on this

Will the Minister justify the price of turf?

Comment on this

I have done that already; at least I informed the House that the price of turf was fixed without relation to its cost. It was fixed on a basis of what it was considered people might be able to pay without interrupting or interfering with its equitable distribution. The actual cost of turf delivered in Dublin, that is turf produced by the county surveyors and transported from Donegal and the West will, I think, prove to be high. The price of the turf which has been stored in Dublin and has been subject to storage charges will be high. I doubt if the price at which Fuel Importers, Ltd. are now selling turf to merchants will prove to be adequate to avoid their incurring a loss.

Comment on this

God be with the days when it was to be the second greatest industry in this country.

Comment on this

What are the Dublin merchants getting out of the 64/- per ton?

Comment on this

I do not know. What it is going to work out at nobody can say. In relation to this question of turf, which is now being distributed in quantities in which it was never distributed before and through an organisation not designed for that purpose, there are a large number of unknown elements. We can estimate what their costs are likely to be, but even if we confine ourselves to the obvious costs, the cost of labour, which is by far the biggest item, the cost of rent, the storage, etc., we cannot arrive at a definite figure. But, over and above those elements, there is one factor which is completely unknown, and that is the extent to which turf loses weight in storage. If you put 100 tons of turf into a dump at the North Wall or elsewhere, you will not get 100 tons out. The Deputy knows that.

Comment on this

Even in wet weather.

Comment on this

Even in wet weather. There is the wastage of the turf, the loss of moisture content, and what weight will come out has yet to be seen. The same applies in relation to the merchants themselves. In the handling of the turf, its stacking, delivery and unstacking, there is again wastage. To what extent that will affect the cost of distribution it is impossible to say. Therefore, we had to fix a figure which had relation no doubt to our estimates, but which in relation to these estimates seems to indicate that a loss will be incurred. That is all the information I can give the Dáil at present. At a later stage, when the accountants will be able to determine what in fact the cost was in relation to the turf actually distributed, I can give the Dáil much more definite information. But, at the moment, the only information available to me is so vague and indefinite that we decided to disregard it in fixing the price of turf.

Comment on this

How did you get the price? Why did you strike 64/- instead of 54/-?

Comment on this

As I said, we had some regard to the estimates that were there and there is turf coming into Dublin at the present time which is costing more than 64/- in Dublin.

Comment on this

Some of it came in at 35/-.

Comment on this

Some came in at 35/-.

Comment on this

The best turf came in at that price.

Comment on this

So far as Fuel Importers, Limited, are concerned they, like Grain Importers, Limited, are a non-profit making company set up by the Government. The whole of their costs will be averaged out. We are not going to sell one sod of turf at one price and another sod of turf at another price. All the turf, no matter what its quality, or its origin or its prime cost, will be sold at the same price and at the end there will be an averaging out of costs and of prices. The fact I wanted to make clear was that that final accounting is not likely to reveal a profit to Fuel Importers, Limited. On the contrary, it appears fairly clear now that it will reveal a loss.

Comment on this

What did it cost to get the best Clonsast turf into Dublin formerly?

Comment on this

The cost was very heavy.

Comment on this

What was the cost?

Comment on this

The cost of transporting turf by road from Clonsast——

Comment on this

What was the cost of transporting it by rail to the North Wall dump?

Comment on this

It was very heavy. Most of the turf that came by rail came from Mayo and Galway and the far west.

Comment on this

I am talking about Clonsast turf.

Comment on this

My recollection of the figure is, I think, that the turf that came from Laoighis as a whole was by far the dearest.

Comment on this

Did the cost of the turf that came from Clonsast to Dublin at any time exceed £2 per ton?

Comment on this

Probably it cost that to bring it in.

Comment on this

Did it exceed that?

Comment on this

The stacking of the turf at the North Wall dump alone is costing 10/- a ton. Taking it out of the railway wagons and stacking it is costing that.

Comment on this

I will quote the figures if the Minister wants them. Would he know them?

Comment on this

I know that much and I know that that cost is inevitable.

Comment on this

Ten shillings a ton for stacking?

Comment on this

Of course, the men who are working on that are getting the rate of wages appropriate to workers of the Dublin docks. They are not getting the rate of wages appropriate to bog workers in Mayo or Laoighis.

Comment on this

Would you take these figures for Clonsast turf—production on the bog at 22/6; cartage to Portarlington at 5/- a ton; transport over rail at 7/11? Make that up.

Comment on this

I deny that, certainly.

Comment on this

You would deny it?

Comment on this

Certainly, and there is turf which cost in the bog less than 15/- which is costing over £3 a ton when it reaches Dublin because transport costs are very high and all the additional handlings which take place add to the cost of the turf. We can have this out more satisfactorily some other time, when I am able to produce more than provisional costings for the turf. The Deputy can be certain, so far as this turf is concerned, up to the point where it leaves Fuel Importers' hands there is no private profit in it at all. No private enterprise has had anything to do with it. It was produced by a public authority, transported at fixed rates and handled here by a non-profit-making organisation which is concerned only to recover its actual outgoings. There is no element of private profit in that price at all until it reaches the distributors' hands and the distributors are allowed a margin to cover distribution costs.

Comment on this

What is that margin?

Comment on this

It is yet impossible to say. The main element, of course, in the margin that has to be allowed to traders is the wages of the workers and I am sure the Deputy would not suggest that they should be reduced. I do not know if a general review of the turf situation or the fuel situation is called for at this stage.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

It is questionable whether it would be in order on this.

Comment on this

In that case I am more than satisfied.

Comment on this

At the same time have not we a right to raise a very wide list of matters in view of the fact that we are providing a very substantial increase in the Estimate in respect of salaries?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy must know the procedure in discussing a Supplementary Estimate. There have been several debates recently on turf production with replies by the Parliamentary Secretary who is in charge of that Department. The increase in salaries extends over many activities. Surely the Deputy would not suggest that all those activities might be discussed widely on this Vote. If the Deputy considers the amount of the Vote he will see things in their proper perspective. Of the total Vote of £683,000, over £600,000 is required for subsidies on bread or on flour and meal. There is obviously not much basis for a discussion on turf.

Comment on this

I do not want to debate turf but I think that if I did want to do so I might be entitled.

Comment on this

I do not want it to be thought that I am not anxious to give the Dáil all the information I have. I would welcome an opportunity of dealing with the whole question of prices.

Comment on this

When does the Minister hope to have the information as to costings?

Comment on this

If, in previous discussions, for stated reasons, the Minister was not able to give certain information is it not possible that he might now be able to give that information?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

On some other Estimate.

Comment on this

On an Estimate carrying a higher personnel with increased expenditure.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Minister states he has not got the figures and statistics at hand. That will be realised by the House.

Comment on this

The previous occasion to which the Deputy refers is three hours ago.

Comment on this

At the present time the Border county of Cavan is practically without flour. I received a letter signed by 13 traders in the town of Ballyconnell who say they have no flour.

Comment on this

I had that letter this morning.

Comment on this

The same thing applies to Belturbet and Blacklion. These people have no flour in their possession.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy will have an opportunity of dealing with that on item F.

Comment on this

I have already arranged for increased supplies of flour to Cavan. The representations from Ballyconnell only reached me this morning.

Comment on this

Will it come soon?

Comment on this