Emergency Powers (Continuance and Amendment) Bill, 1942—Second Stage.
Contributions 94–214 of 214. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 16 of 1942 ›
Let the Deputy tell that to the good agriculturists and let him hear what they say to him. However, I am not trying to score any points; I am trying to point out the difficulties. In those areas to which I have referred, the people had not to wait for a compulsory tillage Order to till and produce.
Comment on this
There are no graziers in the areas I am talking about. You cannot have intensive and extensive tillage and graziers in the same place. I suppose the nearest approach to that in any part of Ireland is to be found in my own county. The North Riding is completely different from the South Riding, so I have experience of both grazing and tillage. I have seen reports in relation to people who were expected to till land which gave the opinion of the farmer himself who was born and reared on the farm and the opinion of his neighbours who were good farmers that it would not give back to him the amount of seed it would take to sow it.
There is no use in compelling people to put seed into land which is not going to give back a fair return. If it can be shown that a farmer who has good land, capable of producing food, deliberately refuses to carry out his obligations to the State and to the community, I do not care how high you fix the penalty for that man, but. on the other hand, the one thing I should be afraid of is that, in our natural anxiety, brought about by the circumstances in which we are living to-day, we may go to the other extreme and expect our farmers to do impossibilities.
With regard to the Bill itself, as has been said by previous speakers, these powers were sought originally, nearly three years ago, because, we were told, they were necessary for the protection and preservation of the State. It is not an exaggeration to say that so far as their application in certain directions is concerned, it would appear as if they were being used for the very opposite purpose. To the extent that the powers conferred on the Government by the original Act have been abused, they have been used not towards strengthening the State, but towards weakening it. Order 83 and what followed from it, Order 166, are responsible for the L.D.F. and the L.S.F. being one-third weaker to day than they should be. The Taoiseach himself made an appeal within the last 12 months for thousands more men for our voluntary services. Those appeals are being repeated day in and day out, not only by members of the Government, but by ourselves. I, like other T.D.s, have been on L.D.F. recruiting platforms three or four times in the last six weeks, but when I get off the platform, I am approached by two or three workers and asked: "What do you expect us to fight for?"
I am told, and I know that in my own county, workers are expected to work in the bogs this year for a smaller cash wage than that for which they worked last year. I am not speaking about the lower purchasing power of the wages, but, in actual cash, they are not allowed by the Government to get as much as they got last year, and what they got last year was 35/- per week. For that men are expected to do what? To cycle—I do not say it is true in every case, but it is true in cases within my personal knowledge— ten miles from their homes to the bog; to be on the bog at 8 o'clock in the morning; to put in a hard day's work; and to cycle ten miles home. They are expected to do that six days a week. Some of these men are married and some have families of five or six children, and they have 5/10 per day, less stamps, to pay rent, to feed a wife and two, three, four, five or six children, and out of the small pool of food which can be purchased with that very small wage, to take a sustaining dinner for themselves to the bog every day.
Does the Taoiseach or any member on the opposite benches—and they know at least as much as we on this side know about this matter, if they do not know more—seriously suggest it can be done? Does anybody seriously suggest that a man who has to cycle 20 miles a day and to put in a hard day's work on the bog at 5/10 per day, can, unless he takes away from his wife and children, take anything more than a cup of water or weak tea and perhaps a slice or two of bread for his meal? Does anybody suggest that a man, limited by that miserable wage in the amount of food he can consume, is physically capable of producing the amount of turf he would be able to produce if he were in the physical condition in which he ought to be? I want to suggest to the Taoiseach that, apart altogether from the absolute injustice of the thing—and this, I am sure, will commend itself to him and the Parliamentary Secretary—it is economically unsound. If you feed them better, they will probably produce more turf for you.
We heard a lot of clap-trap from the Parliamentary Secretary last week about the men going across to England and working for worthless paper and so on. Is it not a fact that if those men could get work in this country at a wage which would enable them to keep themselves and their families, they would stay and work here, and to-day would be engaged in producing food and fuel for this country, and, instead of being in England, would be in the ranks of the L.D.F., the L.S.F. and the other voluntary forces? Will anybody suggest that the tens of thousands of men who have left this country in the last three years and have gone across to a country where they are risking their lives, and where many of them have unfortunately lost their lives, did so for a whim, because they did not want to work at home or because they preferred to work for an English rather than an Irish employer? No man would dare to suggest that.
Nothing on God's earth has driven those men to Britain but sheer economic necessity. I do not know the first thing about finance. I know nothing about the Central Bank Bill. I know nothing about currency, good, bad or indifferent and, unlike a good many Deputies, I do not even pretend that I know anything about it, but if the effect of these men going across is that they can feed themselves, and, for the first time in their lives so far as many of them are concerned, can send back sufficient money to enable their wives and families to get enough to eat and enough to wear, I see nothing disgraceful in it.
Now those are the factors that the Taoiseach and the Government have to face up to. The Minister for Supplies yesterday talked about facing realities and stating nothing but facts. We are stating the facts here—the real, stark facts—and I want to put this forward for consideration: the thing that amazes me is the wonderful and magnificent response that has been got in this country from the workers of this country. Having regard to the weaknesses of human nature, is it not a wonderful thing that a man will cycle, perhaps, 20 miles to his work on a bog, with very often not enough to eat, and whose family have not enough to eat, and that then, after a hard day's work in such circumstances, he will turn out for a march of four or five miles with the L.D.F. or the L.S.F. or in connection with exercises of the auxiliary fire brigade or other organisations of that nature?
That is the position, however, and does the Taoiseach believe that by using the powers that were given under the Principal Act, with which this Bill is concerned, in the way that they have been used in relation to the lowest paid people in this State, the Government are going the best way or even the right way about the preservation of the safety and peace of this country? Mind you, internal disorder could be a lot worse in many cases, perhaps, than disorder coming from outside the country. Now, I do not want in any way to be an alarmist, good, bad or indifferent, but I should like to hear the Taoiseach or anybody else attempting to defend a Government action which compels men in County Tipperary to produce turf to-day for 2/- a week less than they were getting last year, and, so far as many of them are concerned, for 2/- a week less than they had been earning during the last 20 years, particularly in view of the fact that the cost of living figure has gone up in the last three years from 73 to 140.
This is a matter which affects a far greater number of people than perhaps the Taoiseach has adverted to up to this. This is a matter which concerns the people far more deeply than many of the other matters to which the Government are giving far more time and attention, and I hope that this discussion may have the effect of bringing home to the mind of the head of the Government that it is a matter that cannot be ignored, and that, apart altogether from the question of bare justice to the men concerned, the safety of the State demands that the matter should be seen to immediately.
Comment on this
When the Principal Act was passed in this House there was almost unanimous agreement that the powers then sought should be given to the Government. Since then, however, there has been a growing feeling, not only among members of this House, but even to a greater extent among the public outside, that the present Administration should not be trusted with the powers with which they have been endowed. That feeling has been caused because of the many conflicting and unjust Orders which have been issued under this legislation. Now, the Orders compelling farmers to put under cultivation a certain minimum percentage of their arable land can hardly be questioned. Everyone will agree that in a time of emergency it is the duty of those who hold land to put a certain amount of it under tillage, in order to maintain the human population, but with that obligation there is at the same time an even stronger obligation on the Government to see that the people who are compelled to till their land are paid for the labour and the risk that they are forced to undertake. Under this emergency legislation, power is given to the Government to compel a farmer to till his land, but there is no statutory obligation on the Government to see that the farmer and his workers are given an adequate return for their labour, and as long as there is no statutory obligation on the Government, we are compelled to rely upon their sense of right and justice, and since they have not shown, during the past three years, that their sense of right and justice is as strong as we would expect it to be, I feel that this legislation should not be continued.
Many Deputies here, representing farming constituencies, meet farmers down the country from time to time and are frequently criticised for having given such extensive powers to the Government. We are told that those powers were used by the Government for the suppression of a farmers' strike, which was purely a demonstration, and that they were not used to suppress strikes or demonstrations here in Dublin by other people, such as the drapers and so on. We are told that these powers were used very drastically against members of the farming community and against people engaged in milk production in the Dublin area. As a matter of fact, people in the South of Ireland were got to send milk to Dublin in order to break the strike here. Now, when farmers consider how drastically and extensively these powers were used against them, they cannot help feeling that this is not a Government which should be trusted with such extensive powers.
An appeal has been made here for the establishment of a national Government, because it is felt that such far-reaching powers should not be vested in a Party Government, a Government which represents only one Party in this House and which must be influenced to a great extent by the interests of that Party. I agree—and I think I also made the suggestion when the Act was under consideration last year—that it is absolutely essential that a Government entrusted with such far-reaching and extreme emergency powers should be a Government representative of all Parties.
I think that sooner or later that point of view will be impressed upon the Government and that they will be compelled to adopt it. When the Principal Act was introduced we were told that it would be mainly directed towards keeping this country out of the war. So far this country has happily been spared, to a certain extent, from participation in the war. While the Government claim that they have succeeded in keeping the country neutral in this war there is, nevertheless, the fact that our young men and young women who have most to expect from life are leaving the country and going to one which is involved in war. Those young people have not been kept out of the war. They have been driven right into the centre of it, and that is a responsibility for which the Government must answer.
When discussing the turf estimate recently we were told that we had not sufficient men here to produce the fuel which the nation will require next winter. One may ask, why? Because through the operation of these emergency powers wages have been kept down to such a level that men have preferred to cross over to a nation which is involved in war, and take all the risks that are involved in the aerial bombardment of industrial centres in England. They decided to do that rather than remain in a neutral country that refuses to pay men a decent wage. I think that, in view of the fact that manual workers, farmers and the masses of the people generally have been oppressed under this emergency powers legislation, it would be unwise for this House to continue it in operation.
Comment on this
This debate has widened out to such an extent that I thought I was listening to a debate on the Estimate for the Department of the Taoiseach, the Department of Supplies or the Department of Industry and Commerce.
Comment on this
But surely every time I appear in the House in regard to any particular measure I ought not to be asked to go over things that might be more appropriately raised in another way. Take, for instance, Orders 83 and 166. When Order 83 was discussed on a previous occasion it seemed to me to be quite relevant to do so, because the case made was that it should have been brought before the House in the form of legislation. Nobody, I think, can say that it has not been discussed sufficiently often, and that anything that could be contributed on it from the point of view of discussion or examination by members of the House, has not already been done.
Comment on this
The case could be made for it that it was not the sort of thing that should be made by Government order. The matter was very fully discussed. On the motion for the annulment of the Order there was a very full discussion. The Order was passed by a majority of the House. The minority objected to it. In regard to all sorts of measures you will always have a certain minority that will object. In any case the Order came before the House and was very fully discussed. The case that could then be made for bringing it up in connection with this type of Bill could not be made now. That is quite apart from the merits or demerits of the Order. It is a matter, of course, in which there will be differences of opinion, but anyhow the case that could be made for bringing it up on this type of Bill originally could not be made now. If the matter were to be raised again I think that could be more appropriately done either by another motion or in connection with the Department of Supplies or the Department of Industry and Commerce. It does seem to me that another discussion on that Order is not exactly germane to this particular Bill, because once it has been discussed it might very well be regarded as an ordinary piece of legislation.
Comment on this
Except to express our apprehension that the Government might do something similar in the future.
Comment on this
I think Deputy Hickey told the truth about it, namely, that Deputies were anxious just to bring it up again as a matter for discussion, and they did that because it is a matter that is of public interest.
Comment on this
That has nothing to do with it. It is not a question of trust. If the Government had agreed on the policy of bringing in legislation instead of making the Order there would have been the same objections so that really the matter has nothing to do with the powers the Government have under this Bill. The case made on the previous occasion was that the matter ought not to have been dealt with by way of Emergency Powers Order but by way of general legislation.
Comment on this
It was open to Deputies to put down a motion to annul it. However, to come to the Bill. One would naturally expect that the points that would have been dealt with in the discussion were the additional powers that are being conferred and the continuation of the Act. The same reasons that obtained at the beginning for giving the Government power to make Emergency Orders still exist. Is there anybody in the House going to deny that proposition?
Comment on this
Therefore, from the point of view of the continuance of the measure, I take it that we have unanimity on the measure. In regard to the reasons that were originally given, it has been suggested now that the original measure was brought in for the preservation of our neutrality. That is quite a new sort of turn to give to the reason, I think. We asked it for a much wider purpose surely than that—for the well-being of the community in this time of crisis—and not merely for the purpose Deputy Murphy mentioned: that we came to the House and asked to be given those powers to preserve our neutrality.
Comment on this
Your colleague was not quite as frank as that. There is a great danger that if we start talking across the floor of the House we will offend all the Rules of Order.
Comment on this
It is true to say that a good atmosphere is created when one talks across the House like that, but I am afraid it is not good for the orderly transaction of business. Therefore, I tried to refrain from it. At any rate, we have it that there is general agreement that the Government do need the power to make Emergency Orders and that these Orders are needed in the wide sense to preserve the well-being of the community in present circumstances.
We have asked for additional powers or larger powers than we had under the existing Act. We are taking advantage of the fact that we have to bring in this measure to ask for increased powers. But before we come to the increased powers, there is a question, as I pointed out, of settling a matter about which there was some doubt: that the part of the section which referred to individual matters as to which Orders might be made should not in any way detract from the general powers in the earlier part of the section. We want to make sure of that. I think that is also a matter on which there will be general agreement. When discussing it on the first occasion I remember it was made quite clear that these powers which are given in the first part of the section were intended to be general and that the others were not to detract from them. Some doubts have arisen in certain cases where it might be argued otherwise in the courts, and it is to make certain that there will be no doubt in the matter that we are including Section 6.
I have admitted that the retrospective power and the power of providing for minimum penalties are powers that ordinarily we would be very loath to take and that even in the present circumstances we are very loath to take. But I want to assure Deputies that this Bill was not brought in without a good deal of consideration and a good deal of anxiety on our part, because we do recognise that there may be some particular instances in which, so to speak, justice would be better served if full discretion were given to the judge as to what the penalty should be. But we have quite a large list of cases in which the penalties inflicted seem to indicate that the justices had no appreciation of the seriousness of the offences committed by the people who were brought up before them. The penalties inflicted were altogether incommensurate with the crime against the community and not merely against the individual. The point is that other individuals will do the same thing. Unless it is made quite clear from the penalties inflicted that it is regarded as a serious offence we cannot hope to have the control of prices made effective.
I have got here a very long list of cases from one Department. When introducing the Bill I did not think that I should deal with it at this particular stage because, no matter what list of cases I give, I do not think it would be ultimately convincing, unless you have before you the particular defence that might be put up by the individual concerned. In order to be really satisfied you would want to try each individual case in so far as that is possible. The result is that you could not convince anybody who was not convinced in general by merely giving a list of cases. But as I have been asked for the list I will give some of these cases. I will take them as they have been given to me without making any selections. They will at least indicate the danger which made us regard it as necessary to amend the Act in the way we are amending it and to indicate minimum penalties.
Lest I should forget it, there is another matter to which I wish to refer, and that is that you have a very large number of justices. They have not all the same views with regard to the seriousness of the offence committed. Therefore you have no uniformity in the penalties that are being inflicted. In some cases you will see a very severe penalty. The Department have got examples where appeals were made against very severe penalties. In one case the justice imposed such a very severe penalty that even the Department felt it was unnecessarily severe, and when the Department thought it was unnecessarily severe that was going a long way. Side by side with that you have a case in which a person is let off under the Probation of Offenders Act. There is, therefore, a want of uniformity arising from the fact that different justices try these cases. If you try to get a solution to that and say: "Can you not have some central court trying these cases?" you will find that that would be impracticable. There would be a lot of difficulties in connection with that. Therefore you are more or less forced back, no matter how reluctantly, on this sort of procedure, distasteful as it undoubtedly is, and you have to say: "We have to think of the community as a whole."
Individuals here and there may suffer more severely than if they were tried in a central court with full power to the person trying the case to take all the mitigating circumstances into account. But we have to say: "The good of the community as a whole demands that we should fix these minimum penalties." If there is to be any mitigation of the penalty—all that can be done on appeal is to find out whether the person was guilty or not, because even on appeal they cannot reduce a minimum fine—the only way in which it can be reduced is by an appeal to the Minister for Justice. Before the Minister for Justice would mitigate any penalty he would have to satisfy himself that there were certain circumstances in the case of a type that lessened the offence, and that in justice he would have to take these into account and reduce the minimum penalty. It is the only way that we can see. I certainly would be very glad if we could get from any Deputy any suggestion as to how we can achieve the same end by a better method.
I said that I would give some of these cases. I do not know that it is desirable to give the actual names. The cases are listed in columns, giving the name of the person, the address, the commodity, the maximum price fixed by Order, the price charged, the name of the justice, the date of the hearing, and the result. I do not propose to give all these particulars unless I am driven to it by the wish of the House. I prefer to leave the names out both of the justice who tried the case and of the offender. I will take the case of tea. The maximum price was 3/4 per lb. The person was charged with selling it at the rate of 8/- per lb. on two occasions, namely, on the 11/11/'41 and the 18/11/'41. There was also a charge of refusing to mark the quantity on the receipt issued. In one case he was let off under the Probation of Offenders Act. In a second case he was fined 10/-, and in another, 10/6 and 4/- court costs. That was for selling tea at 8/- per lb. If everybody did that, and if the Order was contravened in that way, it is obvious that the attempt to deal with prices would go by the board. Then there was another case in which tea was sold at 5/4 per lb. on the 7/11/'41: at 5/- per lb. on the 14/11/'41; at 5/4 per lb. on the 14/11/'41; and at 4/- per lb. on the 14/11/'41. The result of that case was a fine of 2/6 on each summons, with 4/- court costs and 10/- witnesses' expenses. Naturally, the Department, observing fines of that character and seeing the matter being treated in that way, felt that the Order was going to be disobeyed, because the penalty was not sufficiently severe and the profits that could be made if persons were to continue in that way, would be sufficiently great very quickly to wipe out any fine.
The next case deals with tea and, as you know, the statutory price was 3/4. It was being sold at 5/- a pound and the Probation Act was applied. These cases come from different counties, so that there is no indication that they concern one particular individual. The Probation Act was applied in the tea case, as I have said, and there was a payment of 10/- expenses and 4/- court costs. We have another case from a different county where a person was charging 4/- a pound for tea instead of 3/4. That person was fined 5/- for overcharging and 10/- for failing to give a receipt. In another county tea was sold at 1/3 per quarter pound. The Probation Act was applied. Now, we get on to some other commodities. The maximum price for biscuits was 11d. per pound and in one case 9d. was charged for a half pound. The summons was marked "proved," the Probation Act was applied, and, in a second summons, there was a fine of 10/-, with £3 10/- costs. Then we have a case relating to cigarettes. The maximum price is 8½d. for ten and in this case 1/- was charged and there was a fine of £1. It happens that all these cases are taken from different counties.
Comment on this
I asked for a list and I am reading that list as I got it without making any selection. All I am anxious about is not to tire the House. I shall go on as long as any Deputy wishes me to do so. In another case relating to cigarettes there was a fine of £1 and a second summons was dismissed. There was a charge in another county of selling cigarettes at 2/- for 20 and there was a 10/- fine imposed. I now come to a case relating to flour. The price charged for the flour was 14/- for four stones and in the same case there was also a charge of 5/- for a ½ lb. of tea. The fine imposed in regard to the sale of tea was £1 2s. 0d. and, in the case of the flour, the Probation Act was applied. I have another case relating to cigarettes, where they were sold at 1d. each and a receipt was not given. There was a fine of 2/- and 2/- court costs. I have here a whole list of such cases if the House would care to hear it read out.
Comment on this
There is no need to read it. Has the Taoiseach any list from the Department of Agriculture?
Comment on this
I have asked for it, but I have not got it yet. I know in the case of the Department of Agriculture that, before they prosecute, they try to satisfy themselves whether there are circumstances to suggest that there might be mitigation of the penalty. I think they satisfy themselves before they prosecute that it is a case that ought to be brought to court and that the person was really guilty of evading the law.
Comment on this
Yes, deliberate evasion. I think that is the general attitude of the Department of Agriculture. I will admit that even the reading out of these cases cannot prove anything, because we might have a particular set of circumstances which might make a justice, hearing a case, say: "This is not a deliberate evasion and it is not a case where heavy penalties ought to be inflicted." But if that becomes widespread, as this list shows, it simply means that the Order might as well not have been made.
Comment on this
If the Minister is to do his work and try to keep down prices—this is largely a question of prices—he must have the requisite power. In the case of the cultivation of land, the Minister must be empowered to see that each farmer does his duty towards the community. If Ministers are to bear that responsibility, we must give them the power to see that those who deliberately evade Orders are going to suffer and that the penalty will be sufficiently high to make the person thinking of evasion see that it would be better to do his duty rather than try to evade it.
I have instanced cases where people were brought to court. In the last war, we know there were similar cases where people were brought to court for not obeying certain Orders and they simply smiled and said that it paid them very well to do it. They pointed out that by evading the law they were making so much money and they realised that they would not be fined very heavily. Consequently there was a direct monetary inducement to disobey the law. We want to make sure that on this occasion there will be no monetary inducement to disobey the law. That is our case for the minimum fine.
I regret we have to do this. I do not know whether Deputies will believe me, but the fact is that all this type of legislation goes against the grain so far as I am concerned. I believe in full discussion here. There are various aspects of every subject that will, no matter how conscientious the Minister and his officials may be, be presented in the House. There are various aspects of legislation, the manner in which it will affect sections of the community, which may not be seen in advance and the value of discussion here is that we can be shown how a measure will affect those sections. These aspects may not occur to those engaged in previous discussions, but they are brought out when the legislation is under discussion in the Dáil. That is one good argument against legislating by Order, but we have no way out at the present time. I think that Deputies who will consider this calmly will see that this particular way of dealing with the matter, drastic though it is, is better than to let things slide and let people simply ignore these Orders.
With regard to the retrospective aspect of these amendments, the point is really to see that things were valid. It is not so much to impose penalties or anything of that sort; it is to see that things were valid, that the obvious general intention of any provision should not be nullified and brought to nought by some little technical mistake or oversight. It is really to validate something that was imperfect in a particular Order that the retrospective power is asked for. I do not think there is any suggestion of retrospective action in making fines greater, or that sort of thing.
Comment on this
I think the Taoiseach will have to be a little more definite on that point on the Committee Stage. If a case has already been brought before the court and a decision given on it, whatever the decision may have been, surely it is not now proposed to have that case re-opened?
Comment on this
I do not think so. I will find out definitely but I would almost be prepared to say no, it is so unlikely, but I do not want to commit myself until I have ascertained.
Comment on this
I will, yes. If I am to be asked any questions I would be glad to get them in advance. It did not occur to me that such a thing would be thought of and I want to make certain. I certainly did not think of it and I want to make sure that nobody else had anything like it in mind.
Comment on this
When the first Bill was going through it did not occur to us that the Government would think of some of the things they afterwards thought of.
Comment on this
Again, we did not make this crisis and we did not make the developments of it. You do not anticipate when you take one step in order to rectify some particular thing that is wrong that you would have to take half a dozen other steps to see that that particular step was going to be effective. All these things only develop as you go along.
Comment on this
The only aim we have is the welfare of the community. Why should we have any other? What other purpose should we have?
Comment on this
We may take different views as to how the interests of the community may be best served. That is true. But why should we—as I think it was Deputy Norton said— deliberately try to injure the community? What good will it be to us in any mortal way? Why should we approach the thing from that point of view? It is quite obvious that that is exaggeration. Unfortunately, Deputy Norton spoils a lot of the points he has to make, most of which are good points, by completely and absolutely exaggerating as he did this evening. I see no purpose to be served by it. Nobody is going to believe that we would deliberately set out to injure the community as a whole or any particular class of the community.
Comment on this
It may be the view of one particular section, looking on it, that that is so. We may argue that, but let nobody think he would get away in any community whatever with the suggestion that the Government here have any purpose in trying to injure any particular section of the community. No matter what view you may take of the Government or even the individual members of it, what purpose could be served by doing that? It may happen that there would be difference of opinion with regard to the result of actions they have taken, but surely nobody is going to suggest, at least to state deliberately and to believe, that we could have any purpose in doing something deliberately to injure a section of the community. It passes my comprehension why people will make statements of that kind when they know they do not believe them themselves and that nobody else would believe them either.
Comment on this
I heard a couple of those statements coming from the Taoiseach's side of the House occasionally.
Comment on this
I do not suggest that the Taoiseach made them, but I have heard such statements from his side of the House.
Comment on this
If statements of that kind are made, they are stupid statements, whenever they come from. If I were guilty of it on any particular occasion, and if you point out any such statement I will say it is stupid. I cannot see how anybody can accuse people who are in office, where everything is to be gained by serving the community, of deliberately going out to injure any section of the community. It may happen that in trying to serve the interests of the community as a whole, a particular section may have to suffer in its particular interest, but it is not because they want it to suffer; it is because their idea of the interests of the community as a whole demands that they should do it. The House may be perfectly certain that all Governments, consisting of human beings, knowing that whenever they do something which injures any particular section of the community they are making enemies of that particular section for themselves, from the purely political point of view, will not do it if they can avoid it. I think that is common sense. You can always go on the assumption that Governments are much more likely to err through not being prepared to face making enemies of a section whose interests may have to suffer in the general interests than to err in the opposite direction—very much more.
With regard to this retrospective power—if I am asked any questions or if there are any particular examples that would illustrate better what is the intention, I will get the details for you, if demanded, on the Committee Stage. I did not, as a matter of fact, ask for a lot of details for this stage because I regard it as a Committee Stage Bill, after the general discussion, rather than a Bill for Second Reading because there are different things in each particular section.
Deputy McGilligan raised a matter which I will have to look into and that is whether it would be possible—it is certainly not the intention—strictly under the terms of Section 6A, on page 4, to stand at one time on one leg and another time on another leg, according to the way it pleased you to operate. I do not know if that is possible as the section is at present worded but there is no such intention. I can say that. I will look into it and see whether the wording should in any way be modified so as to exclude the possibility of what he suggests. There is no question of trying to pursue a particular individual and, for that purpose, arranging things under one or two of these provisions so that you could get after that individual or group of individuals and then come back to the other one again. That is obviously not intended but I will try to see whether we can exclude any such possibility.
With regard to delegation, I think Deputy McGilligan raised the point that he did not see that any additional powers were provided in this that we had not already. I think we advanced something like this: in the Principal Act it says:—
"Under this or any other Act or under an Emergency Order or an Order made under an Emergency Order."
It does not speak of an Order made under any other Act. You want to have it so that the power of delegation would apply to Orders that would be made under other Acts and that is provided for by the wider terms of Section 10.
That is as far as the Bill itself is concerned. With regard to the wider question as to whether the Government is using its powers in the best possible way, of course there will be always difference of opinion about that. Naturally, members of the Opposition Parties will never think that the Government are doing the thing in the best possible way. If that were so, there would be no purpose in Party groups. As a matter of fact I do not think any individual would believe that another individual was doing a job in the best possible way. Being a different individual, he will think that things should be done in a different way and it is very often because he has not got the knowledge which the person who has to take the decision has that he does not see all the things that prompted that decision.
One Deputy said that he could not see why somebody would not be allowed to bring turf into Cork; in other words, he could not see why there should be regulation in that particular way. We find in the course of discussions of this sort the most extraordinary contradiction on the part of the individuals who speak. At one time, they are advocating regulation and, at the next moment, objecting to regulation, and, on the whole, I think the Labour Party want more and more regulation. I do not see how they could possibly expect to move in some of the directions in which they want to move without more regulation, and if you have regulations intended to secure that, in the case of turf, you will not have exorbitant prices, that prices will be kept down and controlled, you can scarcely allow the ordinary law of supply and demand to operate. It might work out just as well as control, but we would have to take a big risk, because we might not have anything like a sufficient quantity of turf for our requirements. We could not, as a Government, simply sit down, and let the whole law of supply and demand work itself out. I am not saying that possibly it would not have worked out just as well and that we would not have got our turf just as cheaply, but we would have been taking a very big risk. On the whole, I do not think it would have worked as well, but in any case we could not take the risk, because there are areas which would have been in a very serious position in respect of fuel, and it is our business to do our utmost to see that that fuel is supplied.
That led immediately, as I pointed out on a previous occasion, to an effort to separate the country into two parts —that area which could reasonably supply its own needs in fuel and that area which could not—and to saying to the area which could supply its needs: "You have turf. Cut and use it. Make use of fuel which is available to you because you will get no fuel from outside. Any fuel available will have to go to places less favourably situated with regard to fuel than you."
For that reason, as much of the country as possible which could be self-supporting in fuel was indicated as a turf area and the greatest possible narrowing down was brought about so that the areas which had to be sup plied from outside could get in supplies of coal or any other outside fuel which we could get. Our big problem is Dublin. The difficulty with regard to Dublin is that it is situated further from the supplies of fuel than any other place and practically one-sixth of our population is concentrated here. In the places nearer to Dublin where there are bogs, the man-power is not available, and, taking man-power and bogs together, they are situated at the farthest possible distance from this city, which gives rise to the difficulty of transport. If we had not got that transport difficulty, the position would be all right.
Speaking of turf brings me to this question which the Labour Party are always raising—the question of increased wages. My own view is that those people who work hard physically are not getting to-day, and never did get, at any time, in my lifetime anyhow, anything like a fair reward for the service they render the community. That is my own belief. I believe that in the case of those of us, whether as clerks or other workers, who move a pencil, though it may require other qualities, it does not put on the individual doing it the same strain, nor is it as distasteful as the work which a person engaged in physical labour has to do. I want to say that clearly.
If I could easily reorganise society so as to give these people higher remuneration for their work, even at the cost of bringing down the remuneration of others who have less difficult work to do, I would do it, but it is easier to think or to wish than to bring any of these changes about. One thing, however, cannot be done: you cannot increase the wages of those who are producing materials and sell them cheaply in the end. The labourer is a consumer as well as a producer and he, in the end, has to get a product which is largely a product of labour and to pay for it.
Comment on this
Might I ask the Taoiseach to look at the returns submitted by certain county councils? He will there observe that, on a piece rate system, men are receiving £5 a week and turf is produced at 9/6 per ton and that, where 30/- is paid, the cost of the turf is 24/6 per ton.
Comment on this
The Labour Party, I think, will agree with me when I say that if it were proposed to have piece rates in respect of all sorts of labour, they would object.
Comment on this
I think you would. I do not want to pretend at all that I have studied the matter, but, from experience, I happen to know conditions in rural Ireland and to know the labouring conditions, too. I have not studied very closely—I have not had the opportunity to do so—the trade union movement in England, or even the trade union movement as a whole in Ireland. I know its general purposes and aims, but I should be greatly surprised if I am wrong in believing that if it were generally decided that work should be paid by piece rates, the trade unions would be against it. At first sight, from the point of view of the community, from the point of view of output, it would appear to be one of the fairest ways of paying for work, namely, on the return given. That looks at first sight to be fair, but the objection naturally from the labour point of view is that it means that the weaker goes to the wall. Those people to whom the Almighty gave particular powers, particular physical capabilities and so on, will do very much better than the others, who will be left behind.
Again, I am speaking as one who has not had the opportunity, although I wish I had, of studying the matter closely, but my first impression is that the result of having to make sure that the weakest is able to get a fair wage has been a diminution in the whole of output. I think that from the community point of view, it would be very much better if you could, on the one hand, allow the people who are capable of the greater output to get payment on the basis of output and, on the other, specially to look after the weaker section. There, again, however, more difficulties arise, if you follow that out, because the problem arises of how to distinguish the person who is incapable of doing it from the person who is capable. These are problems on which the very best minds of the world —both on the side of labour and on the side of industry—have been engaged for a very long time, and they have not been able to find a satisfactory solution of them yet. However, I did not intend to digress into that. All I wanted to say was that there is no doubt whatever that the workers are consumers as well as producers, and that if you pay them highly for what they produce, then they will have to pay dearly also for what they consume.
Now, a splendid example of that was given the other day in connection with the production of turf. In view of the discussion that took place here, I asked the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance to give me some figures, and they are very illuminating in this connection. I have heard a good deal of criticism from the Labour Benches as to the price at which turf was being sold here in Dublin. Now, there was no question there, let us say, of coal merchants or others making profits on the sale of that turf; it was a question, practically, of a public service, and profits were practically cut out. The only items that entered into the matter were those that entered the final cost of the turf. The figures I have got here are not quite complete up to a certain point, and I want to get some extra figures to complete the list. This is a question of consignments of turf from Westmeath to Dublin, and the various costs involved in bringing that turf from Westmeath to the dump in Dublin, and then the ultimate costs from that point to where it is sold in Dublin at 64/- a ton.
Now, here are the figures, as they have been given to me: cost of production on the bog, 22/6 per ton; cost of bringing the turf to the roadside, 3/-; cost of loading it into lorries, 1/6; cost of transporting to railhead, 4/-; cost of loading it into wagons, 1/-; railway charges, 8/-; cost of unloading it from the wagons into the lorries, 1/6; cost of transporting it to the dump, 4/-; and then unloading it, clamping it, and so on, 5/6. That makes a total of 51/-. Now, I think that everybody will admit that there is not a section of the people who were involved in all these operations who would not be able to make a case for an increase in wages. I am perfectly certain that everyone of them would say that, since the cost of living has gone up, their wages should also go up, but is it not clear that that figure of 51/- will have to be increased by every single penny that is added on, whether in wages or in any other way?
Now, the consumers in Dublin, I take it, are the people in whom we have the most interest. I take it that the Labour Party would have the most interest in the consumers in the cities, as being the poorest section of the community, and they will have to pay any addition in the cost of the turf.
Comment on this
But you are keeping down the purchasing power of the workers by your Standstill Order in connection with wages.
Comment on this
But will the cost not have to be made up somewhere? Deputy Hickey cannot put two and two together and make six of it.
Comment on this
And if you add all these items, as they go into the costings, unless somebody comes along and fills up the gap, the consumer will have to pay. Who is to fill up the gap? If it is the community, then you will have to subsidise production, and again it comes back to the fact that the individual in the community has to foot the bill in one way or another. There is no way out of it. The only possible way out of it would be the use of machinery, and there are certain objections there also. We all know the difficulties that have been experienced in that connection, and we know that, very often, the more you improve the machinery the less individuals are employed. Now, I am not saying that if you had some means by which the benefits of the machine would be distributed properly, it would not be a wise thing.
I think that we have gone ahead with the idea of improving machinery, making work light, and so on, so that in the long run it ought to be an advantage to the community, but the only way to reduce these costs is by improving the method of production so that the individuals involved will produce more and, in that way reduce the cost of production per unit, but if you add to the cost, these additional costs inevitably will have to be paid by the individual consumer and, again, the workers are consumers as well as producers. What I want is to try to see that the individual consumers and producers will secure the maximum benefit, and in that connection you have got to relate the two things together and see by what particular method they are going to benefit most, and that is the real wages, so to speak, in connection with what they produce.
Comment on this
Is not their complaint to-day that you are sending up the price of commodities while keeping down their wages?
Comment on this
To ignore the facts of the situation will not meet the difficulty, and one of the facts that has to be understood by everybody, in dealing with this question, is that the worker is a consumer as well as a producer and that if you add to the cost of production you are going to add to the cost of the article.
Comment on this
But the workers' wages are being kept down while the cost of commodities has gone up.
Comment on this
Now, I shall come to that position afterwards, but let me deal with the matter we are on at the moment. It cannot be denied by anybody in the House that the workers are consumers no less than producers and that, as surely as you add to the cost of production, you are going to add to the cost that will have to be borne by the workers as consumers. To my mind, that is a proposition which there is no denying. One cannot afford to ignore one aspect of such a question as this, and if we ignore one aspect of it, then we are not facing the facts but only facing half facts, or what are really falsehoods.
Comment on this
Now, I wish that we had a system here as a result of which we would be able to get from everybody the utmost that they are able to do, whether in producing goods or in other ways.
Comment on this
Would the Taoiseach consider this point? He has given us a set of figures as to the cost of the production of turf in Westmeath—5/- for this operation, 4/- for the other operation, and so on. Surely, that must strike him as being a very large figure for production costs, and it must seem to him that there is something wrong with the organisation which costs that much to get the turf from the turf bank in Westmeath to Dublin, and that some steps should be taken to reorganise the method?
Comment on this
Every shilling and every penny that could be cut out of that would be an advantage but, mind you, somebody is going to be short of work. In other words, it is going to create a certain amount of unemployment, in general, but if there were any system by which you could get it into the lorries at less cost, then that is an advantage.
Comment on this
Now, you cannot bring a lorry into the bog. We all know that the farmer, generally, has to put out the turf on the roadside.
Comment on this
Well, the Deputy, probably, knows more about it than I do, but I have seen farmers using donkeys to bring the turf out to the roadside because a heavy cart could not go into the bog. The farmers' sons, and everybody else, helped in that. You have to take the turf out to a firm place where a cart can travel. If that cost could be cut out, it would be an advantage, but it cannot be cut out. The Parliamentary Secretary has put that cost at 3/- a ton, which is practically 5 per cent. of the total cost. Then there is the cost of loading it in lorries, which is 1/6 a ton. I would not like to enter into the question of whether that is a relatively higher cost than the 3/- for taking the turf out to the roadside, because I do not know enough about that matter.
The cost of transport to the railhead is 7/-. That is the average In some cases it would be more and in others less. I am dealing now with the Galway figures. The charge for loading into the wagons from the lorries is put down at 1/-.
Comment on this
If we were to try to reduce the prices paid to the Dublin worker by 8d., we would have Deputy Norton saying that these prices were altogether unfair to the workers.
Comment on this
It may be daft, but will the Deputy say that the people who are prepared to work at the turf should, so to speak, be conscripted in the various places where it is to be had and taken to Kildare?
Comment on this
There is plenty of turf in Kildare if the Government would only pay decent wages for the winning of it.
Comment on this
That is like a lot of the talk we hear that you can keep people in Ireland by paying those wages. If you pay them obviously they will have to come out of the price to be paid in the end by the consumer.
Comment on this
It would be better to pay good wages in Kildare for the cutting of turf than to be spending money on transport charges from Galway.
Comment on this
When you bring workers to Kildare you have got to provide accommodation for them—to build a new town. It is not very easy to get people to leave their native place. They are prepared to work at home for a much smaller wage than the wage paid to them when transported to Kildare. That is the basis upon which this thing has been worked out. I have no doubt whatever that if, by raising wages in Kildare, turf could be produced more cheaply there, that could be done, but it does not seem to be practicable to do that. I find from the figures that I have here that the total cost of the turf taken from Galway to Dublin is 52/6 per ton. The following details are given: price of production per ton on the bog, 15/6; transport to the roadside, 3/-; loading into lorries, 1/6; cost of transport to railhead, 7/-; loading into the wagons, 1/-; transport on railway, 13/6; unloading into lorries, 1/6; cost of transport to the dump, 4/-; and 5/6 to discharge it and clamp it in the Phoenix Park. Out of that total of 52/6, 76 per cent. is represented by wages. If you increase these costs by paying higher wages you are bound to increase the price which the working consumer will ultimately have to pay. I make that point because it seems to me that very often the representatives of Labour will not face that particular aspect of the situation. They want to have prices at the lowest possible figure and the costs that make up these prices at the highest. It cannot be done.
Comment on this
I am glad that once more the Deputy and myself are in agreement. Therefore, in attacking this problem, let us not try to do the impossible, but rather what is possible. Deputy MacEoin asked if it would be possible, by better organisation, to eliminate some of those charges. If it were possible, by doing that, to lower costs at the end, you might be able to pay increased wages to individuals. The only danger I see there is that by improving your organisation you may not be able to give as much employment as before. I, for one, would be willing to face that, and say that, ultimately, that is a social problem which has to be faced everywhere: that we ought not attempt to put back the hands of the clock, but should use scientific methods—machinery and so on—and in that way try, in the shortest possible time, to make the benefit redound to the general good of the community. I know there is another view that would be taken. It has been suggested that we are holding down wages, and that, at the top, we are not holding down the price of various commodities. I have shown the House that if wages go up in regard to the things that are produced at home, it may very well happen, since you must include in your ultimate figure the costs that make up those prices, that at the end the purchasing power of the worker's wages will not be as great as it was before. That will apply to clothing, food, and other things, so that what really matters to the worker is how much of these things he can get for the wages he is given.
Comment on this
I am trying to get an understanding of this problem, and not to have a half-sided understanding of it. I have shown, in the case of taking turf from Galway to Dublin, that 75 per cent. of the cost is represented by wages. Is it admitted, or is it not, that you can increase wages, but that if you increase prices at the end you may send up the ultimate cost to such an extent that the purchasing power of what a worker receives may possibly not be as great as it was before? That, I think, is true. I will admit that if wages are only a small proportion of the ultimate cost, it would redound to the benefit of the wage earner to have his wages go up, even if prices went up something. The test, anyhow, is will he for the wages that he is given get more goods than he got before? It is possible to increase wages, but because these increases have been added to the cost of the various things that he requires the worker may find that he is able to purchase less than before he got the increase. In the case of things that are produced at home, an increase in wages does tend to increase prices at the end and, therefore, to diminish the amount that a person can purchase.
In the case of things that come from outside you may not be able to control prices at all. That is one of the difficulties of the Minister for Supplies. He is not in a position to control the price of things that come in from outside. In the case of raw materials that come in, if they are essential, you have to pay practically any price for them. They cannot be controlled. Last week-end, when on a ship on a trial run of the engines I asked what price it could be sold for. I was told that it could be sold for many times its ordinary peacetime price. The reason for that is that almost any rates will be paid if that ship can bring in essential goods. We know, for example, that people are ready to pay 10/- a lb. for tea. When things get scarce people will pay almost any price for them. The position is that if you want a thing you will pay almost any price that will fetch it for you. We want to get certain raw materials and we can only get them to carry on our industries at whatever price will enable us to get them. These costs go into the ultimate price of the goods which have to be sold. The worker, therefore, who has got a certain wage finds that not merely will any increase he has got add to the price of the goods, but over and above that there are those outside things which are added on and you cannot keep them down.
During this time, of course, prices are bound to go up if only for that reason. You cannot keep them down no matter what you do. Somebody has to bear the extra cost and the only difference between any members in this House ought to be what section of the community is to bear that cost. If labourers' wages are increased, it will not stop at that. You will have other classes seeking to increase their remuneration also. Each section will be trying to increase its remuneration on the basis that the cost of living has gone up, and every one of these increases will be reflected in the ultimate price at which goods are to be obtained. The result is that your last state may be much worse than your first.
The natural desire of everybody is to try to increase his remuneration in order to follow up the increase in the price of goods and the natural tendency is to try to hold everybody down except those at the bottom of the scale. It is true there may be a difference between us as to where to draw the line. There was an example given of one case where somebody who had £6 per week was let go, so to speak, and somebody on a lower scale was held down. I do not know anything about that case. But a case might be made that the lower scale will have to go up somewhat, because there is a minimum amount necessary to enable people to live.
No matter what happens in this crisis, we ought to try to secure, at any rate, that we shall produce sufficient food for ourselves. There is a difficulty about fuel owing to the question of transport. With the best will in the world, you may not be able to bridge that gap. But there is food available and we ought to try to distribute it. It should be grown wherever it is possible to grow it. It is possible to produce turf in this country, but we have difficulty in transporting it and that difficulty may beat us. But there is land to grow food and there are bogs on which turf can be got. These are things which we ought to set ourselves to secure to the utmost. If these are there, we ought to see to it that nobody even in this crisis will go hungry and, if at all possible, that nobody will go without fuel. We ought to try to do that.
We were talking yesterday about self-sufficiency and so on. If we had our bogs generating electricity we would be in a better position with regard to heating and supplying cooking facilities, for instance, here in the city. If, by means of gas plants, we had our bogs producing gas which could be transmitted here some of our problems would be much lighter than they will be. But that has not been done. I suppose Rome was not built in a day. That is certainly a thing which we ought to see will be done so that we will not be caught in such a position again. As we have the material for producing fuel we ought to see to it that it does not happen again.
With regard to the Standstill Order, the people in my opinion who would suffer most by allowing all remuneration to chase after the cost of goods would be the working section of the community. They would be worse off, if we permitted that, than they were before. It has been suggested that we ought to have a more effective control of prices. I am pointing out that there are certain prices which you cannot control. The one thing that I would look out for is to try to see whether the remuneration of those at the lower end of the scale is sufficient to enable them to get their share of the commodities which are produced and which are necessary for their existence. People talk as if there were not a war, as if we were in normal times. We cannot pass through this particular crisis without every section of the community feeling the pinch in one way or another.
Comment on this
There is no means that can be adopted to prevent that happening. All we have to do is to see that we survive at the end, and to make sure that during the crisis no particular section has to bear an undue part of the burden.
Comment on this
We are at one in trying to attempt that. If we get any help from other sections of the House in trying to get a better solution of these things than we have been attempting to get, nobody will be happier than I will be, because they are exceedingly difficult and very complex. Modern society is very complex, and if you touch it in one place, you may cause an upset which may be transmitted all down the line. The fact is that the various Ministers and Departments have only one aim, and that is to try to bring this community out of this crisis as well as it can possibly be done. But no Minister or no Department can perform miracles. I am satisfied that things would be worse for the workers if we were not to have control in regard to remuneration. That control does not apply alone to the workers but right through. It has been stated that nothing has been done about profits. The Minister for Finance takes very good care that anything in that line will contribute its share to the general pool. That is how he will deal with that. However, there will be a more appropriate occasion for dealing with the matter either in connection with the Vote for the Department of Industry and Commerce or the Vote for my own Department, when we come to it. Although it was brought up here it seems to me that this was not the proper occasion, because whether it was done by ordinary legislation or by an Emergency Powers Order, if there was a difference of policy, it would be expressed one way as well as the other.
Comment on this
The Deputy was not here when I pointed out the position in which that was introduced and the case that could be made for it and the case that is made now. This has been so much discussed here that there can be no suggestion that it was done by way of an Emergency Powers Order in the sense that it was done behind the back of the House or in any way like that. The fact is that the House has considered it time after time. If there is a difference of policy, that difference will be expressed in ordinary legislation just as it is expressed in the Emergency Powers Order. The view is held by certain Deputies that that Order ought not to be there, and that that attempt to control wages ought not to exist. In the view of some people there may be modifications desirable, but I am pointing out that, in the main, it is intended to, and it does, operate for the benefit of the worker, because if it were not there, and if things were allowed to go without control, the position of the worker might be very much worse.
Comment on this
Because they do not realise the other thing that could happen. People protest against existing evils. In other countries there have been changes because the people did not like the existing system; they objected to it and they were anxious for another.
Comment on this
I am not saying that they had or they had not; I am merely pointing out that these things happen in life. We are conscious of the evils that affect us, but we do not trouble to realise the evils into which we might run and, when you try to forestall things and keep people from running into those evils, they imagine you are trying to impose other evils upon them. When you try to save them from greater evils, they believe you are imposing certain other evils upon them. It is really a choice between one evil and another, and what is one to do? You ought not to finish with one particular system and then take up a new system with all its attendant evils. The wise thing to do is to try to eliminate a particular evil if you can.
Comment on this
I do not know? We are just as likely to make mistakes as other people. We are apt to make mistakes in this country.
Comment on this
That is a nice question to consider. I am afraid we would not be fair judges, in any case. I do not think we would be good judges. We shall have to leave it to other people to judge. At least we had the satisfaction of believing we were doing the right thing. In regard to this particular matter, it is a question of getting solutions for extremely difficult, complex problems. I think you will all agree with that. Will anybody say there are simple solution for these things?
Comment on this
If we have the will to do a thing, it can be done. I know of no country in the world better fitted to do it.
Comment on this
There is no Deputy in the Labour Party prepared to take greater risks than I would be prepared to take, if I saw anything at the end of it that I considered would be worth working for or anything like a hope that we could bring about better conditions. You have to make sure that you do not pile on greater evils to existing ones, that you do not change the evils you have into worse ones. The difficulty is to get people to agree. If you can see only one part of a problem of this sort, as the members of the Labour Party are constantly doing —looking at only one aspect—then you will never get a solution.
Comment on this
I hope not, but it seemed to me, when I listened to some arguments from the Labour Party, that they are wilfully closing their eyes to such a possibility as I have pointed out. I gave a list of the costs in relation to turf. Members of the Labour Party will talk to poor persons in Dublin who are not able to get turf and they will tell them it is ridiculous to be paying 64/- a ton.
Comment on this
The same Deputies will tell the people in the bogs that it is a scandal they should be getting such wages and their pay should be doubled. In Kildare the Deputy will say that the wages should be doubled and he will have the audacity to say to the Dublin people that they are paying too much for the turf.
Comment on this
Will Deputies over there indicate how we are to get turf produced in Kildare and sold to Dublin people at a lower price and, at the same time, pay all along the line in the manner that has been indicated? There is not a single item in the list that was read out here in respect of which we would not have the Labour Party telling the workers that they are not getting sufficient payment for their labour. They will tell the people working on the bogs that 15/6 a ton is a ridiculous price, especially when the people in Dublin have to pay 64/- a ton for the turf. Is not that the argument of the Labour Party? Their attitude is that they go to the Kildare people, or wherever the turf is produced, and they will tell the workers that 15/6 is a slave wage and they should be paid double that sum. They will go to the people taking the turf to the roadside and tell them something similar.
They will say the same thing to the people loading turf on the lorries, transporting it to the railhead or loading it into railway wagons for transport to Dublin. They will tell the railway people they are not getting enough and they will also tell the lorry drivers and the people transporting the turf to the dumps that they are not getting enough and their wages should be at least double what they are receiving. At every single step they will support the people looking for a higher wage and then they will go to the Dublin people, who have to pay for the labour involved in taking the turf from the bog to the city, and they will tell them that it is a disgrace that they have to pay such a high price for their turf. That is the sort of argument we hear from Labour Deputies. It is not good for labour, it is not good for the community, and it is not honest.
Comment on this
Will the Taoiseach indicate the cost involved in the light running of lorries all over the country?
Comment on this
Practically every item is paid in wages, and yet Labour Deputies tell the workers that they are getting slave wages and that their payments should be doubled. Then they tell the people at the other end that they should get the turf at half the price. I could understand the Labour Deputies if they would only talk sense, but when they say that the wages all along the line could be doubled and then at the consuming end the turf could be sold for half the existing price, I tell them that they are not honest. I say that no Labour Leader is honest who goes to the bogs and tells the men there that they are not getting enough, who tells those who clamp the turf, the people who take turf to the roadside, or who load it into lorries that they are not getting enough; and then finally tells the people who buy the turf that they are paying double what it is worth. I say that is not honest and nothing can make it so.
Comment on this
Is the Dublin coal merchant entitled to more than what the producer gets? Will the Taoiseach answer that?
Comment on this
I have not gone into that point. I am not trying to defend the coal merchant, but he will also have to meet the cost of labour.
Comment on this
I am not saying he is entitled to anything; I am merely pointing out that when it comes to a simple sum in addition, you cannot double each item and expect to get half the result at the end. In the case of turf, that is what the Labour Deputies are trying to do. With regard to this Bill, I commend it to the House. I think it is necessary. I regret that we have to proceed in this particular way with minimum penalties, but we have a crisis to face and we have to deal with it in the most effective way we can. I see no better way of doing it than this. If, on the Committee Stage, any Deputy can suggest a better way, I shall be only too happy to consider whatever amendments are put forward.
Comment on this
I will be only too happy to consider any suggestions that will have beneficial results from the point of view of the community.
Comment on this
Question put: "That the words proposed to be deleted, stand."
Do you agree with this result?