We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Emergency Powers (Continuance and Amendment) Bill, 1942—Committee. (Resumed).

Contributions 1–155 of 300. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Emergency Powers (Continuance and Amendment) Bill, 1942
Enacted

No. 16 of 1942 ›

I have not heard at any time what the Taoiseach's attitude is to these four amendments which we have been discussion. There has been a long discussion and it has been put very strongly from this side of the House that this type of legislation, this imposing of very severe penalties, is more likely to be ineffective than otherwise. As I said in an earlier part of the discussion on this matter, where you have emergency legislation such as this it derives a certain character from the fact that it is subscribed to fairly generously by the House. It is not legislation which has been regarded in this House as coming from a Party. But there is a departure in the type of legislation we have here and for the first time, so far as I am aware, the Government are taking power to increase by Order the penalties attaching to quite a number of offences. That is all I propose to say about it. I think a case has been made either for dropping the section altogether or, at any rate, for acceding to these recommendations that are made. I do not want the Taoiseach to be under any misunderstanding about this. I propose to divide on the amendments. I am not saying that provocatively. I also propose, even if we get the amendments, to divide on the section.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

It would, I submit, be more orderly if the amendments to reduce the fines were disposed of now. There might be further discussion on the section.

Comment on this

I pointed out last night that what is in this Bill is a setting out of certain maxima and certain minima leaving to the Order the settlement within these of fines of so much per unit or certain minimum fines if necessary. The nature of the offences is so varied and the possible offenders are of such different characters that if you want to meet a case where perhaps a wealthy individual or a wealthy corporation for the sake of making profit will commit such an offence, then you must obviously make the maximum high. If you want to make sure, you cannot leave the maximum low. You want a high maximum therefore. With regard to the minimum, there is no suggestion in this of a minimum except from the point of view that the minimum must be less than a certain figure. Therefore, what are here are maximum penalties, and so far as these are concerned we cannot reduce any of the figures. There is no need for me to repeat that in regard to every particular one of them. After consideration of the various types of offences, it was found that the original maxima would not be sufficiently high to be a deterrent, apart from the question of the right to set out in a special Order definite minima. With regard to these amendments proposing reductions, I am not accepting any of them.

Comment on this

Yesterday, during the debate on this matter, the Minister for Supplies stated that he would welcome any suggestion from this side of the House that might contribute to a solution of the difficulties with which the Government were faced. In connection with this matter, I have a suggestion to make. I have been thinking over what was said yesterday, and it seems to me that the difficulty that exists is that the Government feel that the penalties as they stand at present and in their present form are not sufficient to meet either the situation that has existed in the past or a situation that may exist in the future. I realise that these penalties apply to every form of unlawful activity or breach of the law in connection with emergency Orders. But, as illustrations have been taken from the tillage Order, I propose to suggest one or two cases which might come before a district justice and which, if they do come and are ruled on with a compulsory minimum, will create a very great injustice not only to the particular person concerned, but to the public generally.

I will take, for instance, the case of a farmer who has run his farm entirely on his own or perhaps with some of his younger children, who has been ill most of the winter and is unable for that reason to meet the tillage requirements. That is one case. I take the second case of a very extensive farmer who has always been used to tilling a very large quantity of land and who, under the Emergency Order, has to increase that tillage and would be short on the calculation by half an acre or two acres. That is the second case. Then I take the third case, that of a man who made every endeavour to comply with the tillage Order and bona fide believed that portion of his land was non-arable. The inspector goes to court with the contrary view and the justice decides that the cultivation of the arable land, so far as that particular farm is concerned, is not in accordance with the statutory regulations. He decides that the inspector's view is correct, with the result that again an offence has been committed. In the normal course of events the district justice, as the law stands, would use his discretion and impose only a nominal fine, but if the law is amended in the manner now proposed, the position will be that he will have to impose the minimum penalty.

In this discussion we have been thinking in terms of tilling a quarter of the arable land. We do not know what views the Government may have on this matter in the future. They might feel it necessary to increase the amount of tillage to such an extent that in many cases it will reach saturation point. Very many difficulties will then arise which, if brought to the proper quarter, may be appreciated as genuine difficulties. My suggestion is that this should bear some analogy to the intoxicating liquor code. We should have some sort of sliding scale. The law as it stands should be applied with regard to a first offence, but, where there is a serious case, the district justice should have full power to impose a very large penalty. I am not questioning maximum penalties at all. There are cases where the justice could use his discretion and impose a minimum penalty, or dismiss the case under the Probation of Offenders Act.

A person who has been brought to court and dealt with there as a malefactor, as a breaker of the law, would be given a definite indication of what the position is, and all his neighbours will have a general notice of what the position is, with the result that everybody will know their obligations and they will realise that the law has to be obeyed to the very letter. If it so happens that that man is again brought to court then, if necessary, the minimum penalty clause would apply. It seems to me that the results which the Government wish to obtain would be got in that way, and no great harm would be done to anybody.

Comment on this

I must say that Deputy Esmonde's suggestion appears to me to be very much better than the proposal put forward by Deputy McGilligan. I think that Deputy McGilligan's idea of reducing the minimum fine is a very poor pis aller. I think Deputy Esmonde's proposal is a pis aller in that I think the whole principle of the minimum fine is bad. Certainly Deputy Esmonde's suggestion for the mitigation of the evil of this provision is a very much better one than that put forward by Deputy McGilligan. It would, at any rate, go much further to meet the difficulties raised by Deputies who have criticised the Bill.

Yesterday, when I tried to direct the attention of the Taoiseach to cases where it was manifest that the district justice should maintain his discretion, he got impatient and said that people could think up these theoretical situations ad infinitum. I suppose we could, but, of course, one of the jobs we are sent to do here is to tell the Oireachtas what our experience in the country has taught us, so that we may try to impart that wisdom to our colleagues who are responsible for making the law. One of the difficulties is in regard to prices. We hear a lot of talk about the repercussions of this Bill on the tillage Order, but I think the price aspect is also important. When the inspector is sent out by the Department to find persons who are charging excessive prices, human nature being what it is, these inspectors go out to get their men and, on repeated occasions, cases have come under my notice where an inspector went into a shop and, instead of going to the responsible assistant or the manager, seeking to make his purchase, he has deliberately gone to the youngest junior behind the counter and has made a purchase from him and, without any remonstrance to the manager of the department or the proprietor of the shop, he has stolen softly and silently away and the proprietor of that shop discovers for the first time that an overcharge has been made when he receives a summons to court to answer for it.

I think a prudent man would forbear to summon any respectable trader unless he first had been overcharged, and had then satisfied himself that he had been deliberately overcharged by the proprietor or by any other responsible person on the premises. I say that to leave every citizen liable to the minimum penalty that is suitable for a black market racketeer, simply because the most junior employee in his house has made a mistake, is unjust and undesirable. I know a case in which the offence alleged is that an inspector went in and bought a tin of condensed cream for which he was charged one penny over the statutory fixed price, and since the purchase was made the Department of Supplies has increased the fixed price for cream to a point higher than was charged on the occasion when the offence was alleged to have been committed. In those circumstances the prosecution that issued against the shopkeeper, although the shopkeeper was not next or near that inspector when he purchased the article in the shop, would render the shopkeeper liable to the minimum penalty with which the Minister for Supplies desires to punish a deliberate malefide black market racketeer. That is manifestly unfair. Surely there is an obligation on us to legislate, in so far as we can, in accordance with the canons of justice. We have no prescriptive right, simply because we are T.D.s, to run amok. There are certain obligations in justice. Is it just to impose on a person who has no evil intent at all, who can demonstrate to the satisfaction of any impartial judge that he has no criminal purpose, the same penalty that you would reserve for a person who you are satisfied is engaged deliberately and malignantly and for his own private profit in the sabotage of the State? Surely that is not justice.

It cannot be too frequently reiterated that there is nobody in this House who objects to the maximum penalty. Let the penalties be fixed as high as anyone wants them fixed, leaving to the judge the discretion to apply the full maximum or any part of it in accordance with the degree of guilt visible in the offender. But let us not say to the judges that we are going to fix a minimum which, in our judgment, will wreak adequate vengeance on behalf of the community on a person guilty of a very serious crime, and we are going to impose that penalty on someone who they are satisfied is not guilty of any crime at all, but has committed himself or through his servant a purely technical breach of the law. How many Deputies in this House—and they are all legislators—at the present moment know the conditions under which they can buy a quarter of a pound of cocoa? If I were to go through the Legislature —and most of the members are men of family responsibilities—and ask them what conditions apply under statutory Order when you contemplate purchasing a quarter of a pound of cocoa, how many legislators could tell me? Not one amongst them, I believe, and the Taoiseach included.

Comment on this

I am not selling cocoa.

Comment on this

No, but you are buying it.

Comment on this

If I were selling it I would know the conditions.

Comment on this

But you are buying it. I will not pursue that in any greater detail but, in any case, he is liable to go in and break the law. The Taoiseach says eloquently that if he were dealing in cocoa he would be familiar with all the laws and conditions. We will never be able to call that bluff, because if he becomes guilty of some breach of the regulations, steps will be taken to cover it up at the earliest possible moment. I am thinking of the small shopkeeper on the side of the country road in Ireland who, the Taoiseach says, ought to know the terms of these regulations. How are they going to get to know? Where are they going to get the information the Taoiseach thinks they ought to have? That is the very point that we are making. If the district justice who has the defendant before him makes up his mind that the person does know or had every reasonable facility for finding out what the law was and just did not bother to find out or, knowing the law, broke it, then let him be penalised, but if he satisfies himself that the defendant did not know the law and could not in right reason be expected to know the law, then the district justice should have the discretion to mitigate the penalty to a nominal one. It is for that reason that Deputy Esmonde's proposal commends itself to me, because if a person was up the second time for the same offence he is fixed with notice of the law, he has the opportunity of conforming to the law, with full knowledge, and, if he breaks the law a second time he breaks it in the full knowledge that he is breaking it and let him pay the penalty.

I regret the decision of the Leader of the Opposition to divide on all these amendments because I think these amendments are barely worth the paper they are written on because they do not go to the root of the principle here involved. So long as minimum penalties remain in the section there is an essential defeat of justice and we should not be taken even tacitly to agree with that principle. I have no interest in Deputy McGilligan's amendments because they do not go to the root of the principle. Of course, the House will divide on the section and, on that, it will be worth walking into the Lobby. So far as Deputy McGilligan's amendments are concerned, I do not think it matters which way we walk but I would be glad to know if the Taoiseach would consider the via media suggested by Deputy Esmonde.

Comment on this

I could not accept that.

Comment on this

You will not accept that?

Comment on this

This section does not command the approval of anybody who looks at both sides of the case. The position is that the Taoiseach looks at only one side of the case. On that side of the case there is no difference of view in this House. Everybody sympathises with the object the Taoiseach has in view. Everybody wants to see the law observed. They want to see the object he has in view achieved. The question is as to the means by which that object will be achieved. The Taoiseach takes up the attitude that any means are justifiable but this House cannot agree that any means are justifiable. There is no use in adopting extraordinary means in cases where there is merely a technical offence. The district justice will have all the facts before him and will have regard to all those facts and will exercise the discretion that justices have always had in this country and in every country where the liberty of the people and justice are respected. The judges are the people best qualified to judge. Anybody who takes the power to impose a minimum penalty simply censures the justices of this country and implies that they are not fit to administer the law. There ought to be some other way out of the difficulty.

The Taoiseach, knowing that everybody in this House wishes to co-operate with him and to offer suggestions to find a solution of this difficulty, should not stand up against all the amendments and all the suggestions that have been offered. He should try to meet what is reasonable and just. It is easy to find instances in history of over-zealous people who, in order to stamp out evils, were prepared to introduce other evils. For instance, who is it that does not remember the over-zeal of the Pharisees? They found difficulty in catching people who were guilty of sin, but whoever was caught had to pay the extreme penalty—they were stoned to death. The Master, the Author of justice, did not go to such extreme measures and He has reformed more than all the extremists who wanted to use the most rigorous methods against whoever happened to be caught, although they might be very much less guilty than those who got away with it. It is the same way with the justices. As some Deputies pointed out yesterday, if a justice administers the law according to the facts and takes into consideration mitigating circumstances, the people will co-operate with him and they are more likely to comply with the law when they see that the law is administered in a Christian spirit and administered justly.

It is easy enough to point to different categories of offences that might be committed by individuals and that would be all treated in the same way and with the same extreme harshness, but would it be fair that the farmer who found it impossible to comply with the law and in whose case it was inevitable that he would commit a technical offence should be fined to the same extent as a person who had profited to the extent of £300 or £400 a week on the black market and who had persisted in that offence week after week? Would that be fair or right? Could the Taoiseach stand over that?

Comment on this

The Bill does not say anything of the kind. The Deputies are not reading the Bill. They are talking to something they imagine is in it. Of course, a difference can be made.

Comment on this

A minimum penalty is fixed for all these cases.

Comment on this

Is not there a maximum? We have been talking about a maximum and about making it high.

Comment on this

We do not object to the maximum at all. It is to the minimum the objection is raised and I think the Taoiseach should accept the amendment or, at least, some of the suggestions that have been put up. In the long run, if he does that, he will be more likely to achieve the object in view. Everybody is anxious to see the thing done but it should be done in the proper way.

I might give another instance. Suppose a person was entitled to get a certain ration of tea but could not procure it because his retailer had not it for him. The Department of Supplies is well aware that there are hundreds of cases of that kind. That man in order to get a little tea for his family may have to go to the black market and give something over the fixed price, or the retailer who cannot get supplies from the ordinary sources, may have to go to the black market and charge his customer a little extra. In that case there is a choice of two evils because it is an evil that a person cannot get the supply of tea to which he is entitled. If the trader cannot provide it from legitimate sources, and goes somewhere else to get it and pays a little extra for it, doing that for a good purpose, he becomes liable to this minimum penalty. I think if the whole matter were examined, the Taoiseach will find that the justices have been right in imposing only small penalties in some cases. The justices have been appointed to administer justice and the law as passed by this House, and that function should not be taken from them because it implies a censure on the justices of this country which I do not think they deserve.

Comment on this

I am really interested only in the abstract justice of this question.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That is the reduction of the fine?

Comment on this

Yes, the justice involved in that. First of all I should like to say that I have no fault to find with the maximum penalty. It is for the question of a minimum fine and the proposal to remove the discretion hitherto allowed to justices that we have to find justification. Presumably this £100 minimum can only be justified when there are absolutely no extenuating circumstances in any respect. If the Government have been too lax in the past, they ought to see that they are not too severe in the future. One of the greatest safeguards that the community has is the feeling that the laws are just and should be upheld. I should like to suggest that the public, and certainly the members of the Dáil, should be convinced of the justice of the Government's contention. Last night we were given some flagrant instances of small penalties imposed by district justices. As the crowning instance, I think the Minister for Supplies gave the case of a miller who was making some hundreds of pounds a week and was fined £3. I asked the question, was the trifling matter not omitted that in that case it would be within the Minister's power to order that the miller should be put out of business? If that is added to the £3 fine, I think it is a very substantial penalty and presumably the district justice took that into account. I do not think the Taoiseach even answered that question. If we are to have instances put up to prove a case for the Government, then when one puts a query that appears to arise out of that and no answer is given, one will find no difficulty in deciding in what way to vote on this matter.

Comment on this

For the past two days the case has been made that there should not be a minimum penalty in these cases. I think that people who carry out the laws of the country, especially people who carry out the prescribed amount of tillage, have a grievance in this matter. The farmers for the past couple of years have been ordered by the Government to carry out a certain minimum amount of tillage, and the big majority of them have complied with these orders. A minority have failed to do so, and I hold that the majority who have carried out the orders of the Government to the full extent have a grievance in this respect, because it has affected fairly seriously a big number of farmers in the country. Because they have had to till a certain percentage of their land, they definitely have a grievance, as their neighbours have not carried out the law in that respect also. Next year or the year after, these farmers who have been tilling beyond the minimum acreage laid down by the Government may be forced by the Government to till a higher percentage of their land, and they would not need to till that higher percentage if the small minority to which I have referred had carried out the law as laid down by the Government and tilled 25 per cent. of their land. I think the majority of farmers have a big grievance in this respect. Many farmers throughout the country are not slow to voice that grievance, as Deputies who live in rural areas are aware. They will point out that neighbours of theirs were not tilling the minimum percentage, and were getting away with it.

Comment on this

Are they prosecuted?

Comment on this

Yes, a number of them are prosecuted every day of the week.

Comment on this

A number of them are not.

Comment on this

Why?

Comment on this

They get away with it.

Comment on this

Why are they allowed get away with it? The Minister has said that he could not get evidence, but surely these aggrieved farmers will give evidence if they are so aggrieved?

Comment on this

That would mean that you would want to make every farmer a policeman to watch his neighbour. What I have described is happening every day of the week, and hundreds of farmers inside the last year have pointed it out to me. They believe that they are being penalised by the Government in being forced to till 25 per cent. of their land, while next-door neighbours of theirs are allowed to get away with five or ten acres or even no tillage at all in some cases. That is the case for the minimum penalty.

Comment on this

It is not the case that has been made here.

Comment on this

That is the case from the point of view of the man who is carrying out the law, that his next-door neighbour should be allowed to get away with it and that when a defaulter is brought to court he should be fined only 2/6 or 5/-. That is why these people feel that they have a very definite grievance and it is something that the Opposition has not very fully considered. I can see, of course, that there is another point of view, the point of view of the legal profession who have carried on the main opposition to these minimum penalties. They hold, of course, to the old tradition of the law, that a judge when appointed has a right within the law to decide as he wishes and that there are minimum penalties only in the case of revenue offences. Certainly these minimum penalties for revenue offences are a definite deterrent.

Comment on this

Now, now! There are more revenue offences at the moment than ever before.

Comment on this

Deputy McGilligan knows quite well that if he were going into a foreign country he would not attempt to take in goods that are revenue goods without paying the duty on them. You have it going on of course in some cases.

Comment on this

Despite the minimum penalty?

Comment on this

It is only in a very limited number of cases it is tried on. Everybody knows that every visitor from any other country would come in loaded down with revenue-bearing goods but for this minimum penalty of £100 or £200 or whatever it may be. The minimum penalty in those cases is a definite deterrent. I believe that the minimum penalty in regard to evasions of the tillage Order is in the interest of the big majority of our farmers. I hope that the Government will not reduce in any way their demands on the Dáil in that respect, and that the Dáil will give full authority to the district justices to impose minimum penalties. I should like to point out also that the district justices have discretion as to finding whether the facts have been proved or not. I think that will be admitted even by Deputy McGilligan. They need not impose any penalty; they can find that the facts have not been proved. That discretion is not being taken from them.

Comment on this

The Bill does not affect that?

Comment on this

It does not.

Comment on this

Before I deal with the remarks made by Deputy Allen, I want to point to the fallacy of the remarks that were made by Deputy Dillon on the question of the attitude of the Leader of the Opposition in dividing the House on those various amendments. We are discussing at the moment an amendment which proposes to reduce the minimum penalty from £100 to £25. That is not because we prefer a minimum of £25, or because we want a minimum of £25, but because we want no minimum, and a minimum of £25 is very much better than a minimum of £100. To use a phrase popular at the moment in military parlance, those amendments are put down to test the defences, to see what is the justification for the minimum penalty at all. In the Bill, £100 has been selected as the official figure for a minimum penalty; £25 was put down by Deputy McGilligan in order to test what was behind that figure of £100, in order to discover why £100 was selected rather than £25. That amendment and the other amendments of a similar character are put down for that purpose, and for the purpose of emphasising the fact that we are entirely against any minimum penalty.

As regards the point made by Deputy Allen that all this opposition to the minimum penalty has been carried by the legal profession, Deputy Cosgrave carried the entire opposition to this for hours yesterday, supported by farmers of this Party, and it was only towards the end of the discussion that the legal profession came in and gave their view. The opposition has been very largely by farmers of all Parties, and by Deputy Dockrell, representing the business community. We came in for the purpose of showing from our experience that minimum penalties, so far from achieving the purpose they have in view, really defeat the end aimed at. That has been the experience over centuries in reference to minimum penalties. Deputy Allen says that the farmers are not going to act as policemen. He said that hundreds of farmers have spoken to him about their grievances; that farmers who have carried out the law and done their duty feel a distinct grievance when other farmers who have not complied with the law are apparently getting away with it. He says that the remedy for that is not a maximum penalty, as we suggest, but a very serious minimum penalty. Our view is that a minimum penalty defeats its own purpose. As it stands at the moment, according to Deputy Allen, his friends who have this sense of grievance will not turn themselves into policemen and give evidence. I suggested last night, and I again suggest, that the effect of minimum penalties on public opinion in cases where they are working harshly —and they will be bound to work harshly in numerous cases—will be that public opinion will be behind the delinquents.

The Taoiseach last night asked for an alternative to this. I suggested last night, I think—if I did not, I suggest it now—that the alternative to imposing minimum penalties is to harness behind the efforts of the Government public opinion against black marketing and against abuses of the situation. By imposing those minimum penalties, there is a most serious danger that public opinion and public sympathy will range behind those who are breaking the law. That has been the history of the criminal code where it has worked harshly over the centuries. We are not going to change it now. There is at present very strong public opinion against black marketing and against abuses of the situation. If there are minimum penalties working harshly, you will find that public sympathy will range behind the offenders. No minimum penalty will then act as a deterrent; it will act as quite the opposite. If, when there is no minimum penalty at the moment, farmers will not come forward and give evidence—Deputy Allen says they will not act as policemen——

Comment on this

They need not.

Comment on this

Of course, not. Deputy Allen's argument is all nonsense.

Comment on this

What chance will there be that the farmers, or any other section of the community, will come forward and root out sufficient facts to enable a prosecution to be brought by or on behalf of the Government, if public opinion is outraged by the infliction of minimum penalties in cases where there should be no minimum penalties? I pointed out that our opposition to this is not as lawyers; it is not as members of the legal profession. It is because, from our experience of the working of criminal law, we know that minimum penalties have been a complete failure. They have never worked or never properly operated as a deterrent. The opposite has been the result. Members of the legal profession and the judiciary have been astute over the centuries—when criminal law worked harshly and there were penalties which shocked public opinion—to find technical ways, all sorts of ways, to get out of any sort of conviction. In so far as the legal profession are concerned, we are likely to have a harvest over the minimum penalties. We will be employed very much more often, and will be more astute to get people out on technical points. The judges, if the penalties are working harshly, will do the same thing. They have done it over the centuries in proper cases. Our opposition is an opposition in principle, as I think the Taoiseach himself admitted. We are in agreement with the Government that an evil exists which must be stamped out, but we think that the principle of minimum penalties, so far from stamping it out, will hinder the operations of anybody conducting prosecutions on this matter. That is the basis of our opposition.

The amendment we are speaking to at the moment is merely a token amendment put down to test the defences, to ask why £100 was fixed rather than any other sum. I presume the answer is that there was no reason for £100 rather than £1,000. The imposition of minimum penalties will not act as a deterrent, but will be more likely to produce the result that public sympathy will be got for black marketing by reason of the improper application of minimum penalties in cases where it should not be done. There is no use in saying that in a proper case the prerogative of mercy can be applied by the Department. This minimum penalty system is the child of the Government Departments so long as I know them. Since 1922 they have wanted it. They have been asking for it in every conceivable case, even when there was no emergency. I said last night, and I repeat, that nobody is a judge in his own case. This system is a bureaucratic system, wished for and devised and nursed since 1922 by the various Departments which wish for prosecutions and which conduct prosecutions. Whatever confidence we may have in any particular Minister, whether it be the Minister for Justice or anybody else, he must be guided by his officials, and those officials are not the proper persons to adjudicate on whether or not there are, in a particular case, mitigating circumstances. The proper person to adjudicate on whether or not there are mitigating circumstances is the judge who is selected by the Executive and put there under the Constitution to decide fairly, in accordance with his declaration of office, as between the State and the individual.

It is his duty and he is trained to decide whether or not a particular case requires, in the public interest, the imposition of the maximum penalty or lenient treatment. Ministers yesterday mentioned certain instances but were unable to give any facts connected with them. They recited a whole series of fines and from that deduced that the only way to remedy the situation was by the imposition of minimum penalties. At the close of the debate last night, I ascertained the facts regarding cases mentioned by the Minister in which a district justice had been fining to the extent of £5 an acre while another district justice had been fining only to the extent of 2/6 an acre. The fact is that the district justice who was fining 2/6 per acre got the maximum results, from the public point of view, by the method he adopted. Punishment is not the primary object of criminal legislation and it is certainly not the object of this class of legislation. The primary object of these food production Orders is not the punishment of offenders. That is hardly a secondary object. The primary object is to secure food for the people in the present emergency. Whoever achieves that in the best possible way is deserving of public thanks. In this case, the district justice, when a person was prosecuted, adjourned the case for a certain period to enable the offender to do the job. When he came before him again and when the district justice found that the work had been done, to the public benefit, the imposed the mitigated fine of 2/6. By means of that sound, commonsense and effective method, the object of the Legislature was achieved. The object of this minimum-penalty legislation is not to secure that anything will be done but rather that excessive punishment will be inflicted. If you want to achieve the primary object, the production of food for the people, you must have regard to human nature and, particularly, to Irish manifestations of human nature, so that the people will respond to the demand made upon them and so that public sympathy with the offenders will not be aroused by the imposition of these minimum penalties.

Comment on this

Deputy Costello said— I was glad to hear him say so—that the primary object of this class of legislation was to secure sufficient food for the people. Every Deputy is interested in that and, in their pronouncements from public platforms, they have expressed their anxiety on that score. If the maximum amount of food is to be obtained for the people, I believe it will be secured through the enforcement of the minimum penalties contained in this section. With all due respect, I disagree with Deputy Costello when he says that these minimum penalties should not be prescribed. Perhaps that would be true in normal times but this is a time of emergency and, if anything occasioned hardship to the officials and inspectors of the Department of Agriculture throughout the country, it was the non-existence of these minimum penalties since 1940. If anything prevented the farmers from acting the policemen on their neighbours, it was the very small fines and penalties imposed in the various courts throughout the country. Any practical farmer who would be selfish in his point of view would get it into his head that it would be better to pay a penalty of even £5 an acre than to put good land under tillage. He would be saving himself a considerable amount by doing so because, after all, a number of the farmers who have responded to the call have been put to a considerable amount of expense. They have had to hire extra labour and one labourer per year would cost between £70 and £80. If I were called upon to till six or ten acres of land, it would be cheaper for me to pay even a £50 fine than to take on a labourer. I could use that land for other purposes which would bring me in the £50. I believe that there is no sense at all in this attempt to cut out the minimum penalty. With the minimum penalty, there would be a better response on the part of the people in the way of reporting to the inspectors people who are "trying to get away with it" than there was when small fines were being imposed and when some people were actually let off under the First Offenders Act.

Comment on this

That can happen again.

Comment on this

It may happen again, but I am sure that there will be less of it. While I have sympathy with some of the defaulters, I must, like Deputy Allen, have sympathy with the people who, at great inconvenience to themselves, responded to the call because they realised the seriousness of the position. I remember when there was a Compulsory Tillage Order in the period 1914-18 and some of the people who now are failing to carry out the tillage regulations were quick to respond because it was an outside authority which then called upon them. I cannot understand how some of the men in opposition who helped—and helped very considerably—to bring about the changed state of affairs, can stand up to defend that type.

Comment on this

That is nonsense.

Comment on this

I resent the suggestion made by Deputy Allen that we are looking at this matter through the eyes of the legal profession. I resent the implication that we are being led by the nose by the legal profession. One thing we can boast of in this Party is individual freedom. Every individual is free to think for himself and to express his views here. We are not slaves in this Party and we are not mere "yes-men". I am not opposing this provision for minimum penalties because of the view which Deputy Costello and Deputy McGilligan hold. Both Deputies are an asset to this Party and to this House and, at times, they give us very wise advice. I have, however, looked on the question as an agriculturist. I am as much concerned as Deputy Allen or Deputy Beegan to see that our people do their duty in the way of food production. But I am also concerned to ensure that justice will be meted out to the farmers. I can visualise a set of circumstances in which people might be harshly treated under this proposal. Let us assume that the minimum penalty for tillage-default is £20 and that a man is liable to do 20 acres of tillage. He has done 18 or 19 acres, but has not complied with the terms of the tillage Order because he is short an acre or two. If he is brought before the court, the minimum penalty of £20 must be imposed.

Comment on this

Does the Deputy think that a man like that would be prosecuted?

Comment on this

Why should he not be prosecuted?

Comment on this

Is that the type of law the Deputy proposes to make?

Comment on this

Discrimination in prosecutions.

Comment on this

That is what has happened.

Comment on this

If that is what Deputy O Briain advocates, it is not what I advocate. I want to ensure that the individual will be protected in the administration of legislation of this type. The only way to protect him is to make sure that any individual appointed to act in a judicial capacity is capable of exercising authority as a judge. You must give him discrimination. Where there are mitigating circumstances to be taken into account, he must have power to take them into account. If a minimum fine is fixed, he is powerless to exercise his discretion. A man who has committed a technical offence will be liable in law to pay the minimum penalty, while the individual who has deliberately broken the law—as in the case of men opposed to tillage—will be treated in the same way. I would see that he was punished severely for failing to do his duty, but the Legislature must ensure that justice is meted out in all cases. If we are a party to the imposition of this kind of proposal, we will deeply regret it later on.

A number of cases was stated here by the Minister for Supplies last night. Take a man in the bacon industry, anxious to keep his industry going. There is a controlled price for bacon, and he goes out to buy pigs. While the price of pigs for bacon purposes is controlled, pork butchers are free to pay anything they like. Therefore, if that man complies with the law and offers to pay the controlled price, the pork butchers will get the pigs instead. In his effort to keep his industry going and his employees at work, that man may be at a loss. We know the prices that have been fixed.

Comment on this

Under the Emergency Powers Orders?

Comment on this

Does Deputy Allen suggest that the Emergency Powers Orders would not apply in that case, if we pass this legislation?

Comment on this

Why cite the case then?

Comment on this

Because it is a type of case that will come under this legislation. Make no mistake about that.

Comment on this

It can come under it. Why not?

Comment on this

Is the Deputy trying to fool himself?

Comment on this

Does it apply at present?

Comment on this

Were there any prosecutions recently?

Comment on this

Were they under the Emergency Powers Orders? There was no prosecution for paying a higher price for pigs, under the Emergency Powers Orders.

Comment on this

Applying that sort of legislation to a man who is trying to do his best under present difficulties is wrong. It does not protect him. If he wants to keep his industry going, he has to compete with the man who is free to pay any price, and at the same time he has to do his duty. If he pays more, in trying to keep on his employees, he has technically committed an offence. Deputy Allen suggests that that man should be made pay a minimum penalty of £200, £300 or £500.

Comment on this

I do not.

Comment on this

The Deputy is defending this proposal. I say it is a most unjust proposal, and I do not think the House should accept it. I am opposing it, on my own firm conviction that it cannot be administered in equity or in justice, and not because the legal Deputies in our Party have advocated that the House should not accept it. I am firmly convinced that it is bad legislation and should not be accepted.

Comment on this

The more it goes on the worse it gets. Two Deputies have intervened from the Government Benches—Deputy Allen thinks the farmers would not act as policemen; Deputy Beegan says there is no necessity for them to do so; and Deputy O Briain does not say anything. Of course, they need not act as policemen. Why can they not send a telephone message to the Gárdaí or ring up the inspector? There is no question of their appearing in court.

Comment on this

The Gárdaí know how to deal with that.

Comment on this

Deputy Allen's plea is that the farmers who do till will probably be asked to till more. That statement is rubbish. Yet he says they will not put an inspector on to the man who is disobeying the Order. It is the easiest thing possible to do that.

Comment on this

And the man would be fined 2/6.

Comment on this

They are not all fined 2/6. Remember that the Minister, in a bad case, has power to enter on the land. If he does not exercise that power, that is something for which he will have to answer. There were, I think, 106 cases—as given in answer to a question the other day. Deputy Allen says that people may have to till more because of those who do not obey the Order. He cannot have heard the figures quoted in this House, or he would not have made that statement. There are about 430 occupiers deemed to be committing a breach of the law, out of between 250,000 and 300,000 in total. Does Deputy Allen think that, if those 400 failed entirely to obey the Order, it would make a percentage difference to the tillage requirements? Remember that some of those cases were as low as seven and eight acres. I put that mathematical calculation to him. For two days we have heard that case put forward here. If the deficiency in the tillage were due to the people who were not complying with the Order, we would have been told that. Deputy Allen is the first man who hinted at it. The Taoiseach and the Minister for Agriculture said nothing about it.

Comment on this

About what?

Comment on this

That there was any possibility of the percentage required having to be increased because of this deficiency.

Comment on this

That surely does not need to be stated. It is so obvious.

Comment on this

Does the Taoiseach say 400 would make a difference?

Comment on this

Every 400 would make a difference.

Comment on this

There were only 400 in question.

Comment on this

And if the minimum fines were 2/6, there would be several four hundreds.

Comment on this

There were only 400 in question, of all the people fined, up to the maximum. It was not the half-crown lot alone, but included people who were given the maximum fine. I suggest that, if there had been any strength in the argument that the good farmers of the country would be penalised by having to till a greater percentage, that would not be so.

Comment on this

Is it not obvious that there would not be enough production?

Comment on this

If 400 people default to the extent of ten acres each?

Comment on this

It may be to the extent of 30 acres each.

Comment on this

We are not dealing with dreams and imaginations now. If 400 people had defaulted to the extent of 30 acres each, and the lack of tillage was considerable, we would have been told about it. We were not. We were told about two men with eight acres each. Those were the cases chosen. It is a nonsensical argument. Supposing the good farmers in the neighbourhood saw they would be required to till some extra percentage, because their colleagues in the neighbourhood did not do their duty, I think they would be most diligent about telling the inspector what had happened and seeing that cases were brought forward. In that event, there would be a bigger number of cases and a bigger number who could not plead mitigating circumstances; there would be heavier penalties and more land for the Minister for Agriculture to enter on. There is a record of 106 cases, or thereabouts, entered on in the course of a year, so it does not look as if there has been any real attempt to evade the Order. Where it is working, it is not a good thing to change the fabric of the law which has stood the test of years, unless there is an exceptional type of case or some exception to the rule.

Comment on this

Supposing we do not get enough food for the country?

Comment on this

That is not the reason. The shortage is due to the blundering of the Minister for Agriculture. For years we have had Deputies talking at frequent intervals about the deficiency of this, that and the other crop, but I have not heard yet urged in the House, in defence of the Minister, that people were not compelled to till. That argument is thrown in at the end as accounting for some small percentage.

Comment on this

It is a well-known fact.

Comment on this

For months we have argued about such things as the yield of wheat and the acreage under wheat, and we have had calculations about expectations, and they were all falsified, but never once was there said in defence of that, when the point was raised, that it was due to the fact that a certain number had failed to comply with the Order. That case has not been made here. It is only an afterthought put forward on the second day by a Back Bencher. I am not saying that in any insulting way to the Deputy. I believe that the people putting this case forward originally would have made that a big point, if it were a big point. I thought the Minister for Agriculture would have had sufficient touch with the countryside to know it, if it were a fact, but he did not state it to be a fact.

Deputy Beegan thinks that the deficiency in food production is to be set down to these people. Again, that was a bull point that could and should have been made by the Minister for Agriculture, but it was not made. I do not believe there is any truth in it. I do not believe it is accurate.

Comment on this

I say that the way they got away with it for the past two years has brought about the present position, and I stand by that.

Comment on this

The Deputy, however, weakened whatever strength was in that argument when he came forward with the old war-cry about people who obeyed a foreign authority in 1918 and who are now defaulting.

Comment on this

That is true.

Comment on this

That is true? Then not merely is that true, but you have to go further and say the district justices are favouring that type of fellow. If that type of fellow who is behaving in that way is not prosecuted, it is the fault of the Department. If he is prosecuted and fined, it is all right, but if he is prosecuted and only a small fine imposed on him, the district justices as a corps are under criticism in that they are favouring the 1914-18 enthusiast who is now a slacker. I do not believe that of the district justices, and I think Deputy Beegan destroyed any strength there was in his argument when he brought that forward. That is designed merely to get the applause. The Deputy at one time described himself as a living tombstone, and I suggest that he has some of the old scrolls written on himself which had to burst out. Again, there is no truth in it—no more truth or cogency in it than there is in what Deputy Allen said.

With regard to deficiency in food production, it would take a fair number of people defaulting in respect of the tillage Orders to make a difference. If the Department of Agriculture have schemed out their percentage, allowing for a certain lack of yield due to bad weather conditions, bad seed or bad anything else—if they have not something in reserve they are worse than I had previously thought— and if they have something in reserve it seems to me that it would take a very big proportion of default to make any difference. All the statements made here are to the effect that there is only a very small number of people defaulting. Deputy Esmonde urged in respect of what the Taoiseach said at one point that it was rather an insult to, and a criticism of, the whole community, and we had an angry outburst, with the statement that the farmers as a whole, 250,000 or 300,000 of them, were in the main doing their duty, but that 400 or so were not.

That is the whole extent of it and they are not all being let off with small fines like 1/-. Of the 400 odd prosecuted, all but two were fined, but the fines ranged from 1/- to a maximum of £100. I have asked to be told what percentage of the cases coming before the worst district justice, from the angle of fining, were decided on the basis of a minimum fine. We were given a statement by the Minister for Agriculture that there was one justice who deliberately—"of set purpose", I think he said—had gone out of his way to impose this fine of 2/6. When that case was examined, we found— Deputies may not believe that this is a fact but it is put here as a fact— that a certain district justice has this procedure, that, when a defaulter comes before him, he adjourns the case and asks that a special watch be kept on the man and a special report be made upon him and, when he meets him again in a month's time, if that man has complied with the Order, he says: "Technical offence—fine 2/6."

Is it better to get the land tilled and to fine a man 2/6, or to fine a man a minimum penalty and not get the tillage? I take it that the district justice who is moving around the countryside knows what he is doing. He is doing this in the proper season. A district justice has been defamed by being exposed to criticism as if in every case that came before him he simply imposed a fine of 2/6, and that was the end of it. When that was examined, we see that that is not the situation at all. That may not be the district justice referred to, although it seems peculiar that the particular type of fine coincides, but suppose he is the person referred to here. Is it not good procedure to attempt to get compliance with the Order and then impose a fine of 2/6? I suggest it is far better than the situation which will obtain under the Bill, in which people will be fined a minimum amount irrespective of the circumstances.

I notice that Deputy Beegan, strong as he is for the proposal, wound up by saying that there were some of these defaulters with whom he sympathised.

Comment on this

I sympathise much more with the people doing their duty.

Comment on this

The Deputy sympathised with some of the defaulters.

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

That, presumably, is because there is some hardship about their case; but when these defaulters come along they will be fined £100, or whatever the amount is going to be. We prefer to leave that sympathy to find expression before the district justice, and to let the district justice decide. If Deputy Beegan were looking at this matter from the angle of not being a supporter of the Government in power, I do not know if he would like to think that justice was always certain to be done by slapping on a minimum fine and leaving it to the Department to decide whether or not there were extenuating circumstances. The Deputy must have been in court when inspectors of the Department went in to prove a case, and he must know that sometimes these men become much more enthusiastic about a case than the facts would permit, and that when the facts are analysed, in the cold light of day, before a district justice, and other contentions put up, there are cases in which the inspector has not had the facts, and the district justice rules on that basis. The Deputy knows very well that when the inspector comes to make a report, he is writing in a grieved way, in an angry way. He puts up a report to the Minister and, hereafter, if the man who has got off with a small fine under these circumstances is fined £100, and it is a question of a mitigation of that fine by the Department, the Minister for Justice who, of course, will do the mitigating, will consult the officials of the Department concerned.

Do Deputies think that he will get a good report which will give him a clear and impartial view of the case from the inspector who, under the circumstances I have described, has been turned down after his arguments have been heard in court? I asked the Taoiseach the other night—and this matter could have been settled by an examination of a certain number of cases—to get us a few typical cases, to get cases of flagrant breaches in the sense that the breach was a big breach, something that could not have been passed over, and then not to evade the issue about mitigating circumstances by saying that Deputies can imagine all sorts of mitigating circumstances.

I want to know what were the circumstances as put up in court. Before we condemn a district justice for being too lenient in respect of these Orders, we should surely get a typical case from one or two of the areas, so that we may know what are the facts as put up and what was it that made a district justice, in the case of a man who defaulted to the extent of 7½ acres, impose a fine of 10/-. There must have been something in that case. He might have been one of the men with whom Deputy Beegan would have sympathy, even though he had defaulted. What was there that aroused the district justice's sympathy? I think it is very unfair not merely that district justices should have no chance to defend themselves but cannot even know what the charge against them is because no facts have been given to the House.

The Minister for Agriculture thought he had proved his case conclusively by saying:—

"I have a list at the head of which is the case of a man who defaulted to the extent of 7½ acres and who was fined £100, and at the bottom of which is the case of a man who defaulted to the same extent and who was fined 10/-. There must be something wrong with that list."

If the Minister for Agriculture wants to go back to the records of the criminal courts he will find at the top of the page that in a particular year a person was tried for killing, and was sentenced to death, and then at the bottom of the page there is a record of another person who was charged with killing and that person received a suspensory sentence and was allowed to go free. Are we to have the death penalty in both cases irrespective of conditions? You could definitely prejudge, and inaccurately prejudge judges of the High Court presiding in particular courts during that year by taking such records. The Minister for Agriculture gave us the only other example, the question of the difference between two district justices, one of whom imposed a fine of £50 and another a fine of 2/6. Examination does not prove the case at all, if the facts are as represented to us. The Minister spoke of a miller who was making an income of about £200 a week.

Comment on this

He was not milling; he was engaged in "sifting" which is a different thing.

Comment on this

"Sifting" was not the word used, but it does not matter. Whatever word was used, he was making £200 weekly and was acting against the law. He was fined £3. He had a mill.

Comment on this

He had no machinery.

Comment on this

He had machinery of a milling type.

Comment on this

He could have been put out of business.

Comment on this

Was he put out of business? We do not know where the case occurred. The Minister would not tell us. I do not believe the case happened.

Comment on this

I asked for a record of it. Why did the district justice fine £3 in Dublin? What was the case made to him?

Comment on this

Because he was a very soft-hearted man.

Comment on this

Is that so?

Comment on this

I do not know the first thing about it.

Comment on this

And the House has not been told of it except what I said, that a man who was making £200 a week was let off with a fine of £3. Everyone knows that there is something more than that in the case. Is there a solitary soul believes that the whole case is as stated, that a man making £200 weekly was let off with a fine of £3? As a simple statement, that is completely and entirely inaccurate and inadequate. There is something more in the case than that.

Comment on this

Does the Deputy know where it occurred?

Comment on this

I do not know where it occurred. I know that the case was presented in a wrong perspective. There must have been something said to the district justice. As far as I understand it this case has changed considerably in the effort to make it. Originally I was told with regard to the minimum fine that district justices all over the country were equally at fault.

Comment on this

I did not say equally at fault.

Comment on this

All at fault.

Comment on this

I said the cases ranged all over the area.

Comment on this

When the Minister for Agriculture came he spoke of areas and not the whole community. It was clear that under the Act the areas where district justices were lenient were in cases in which they took into account the expense of bringing witnesses from a different area. The Minister simply seemed to indicate that there were a couple of areas. No hint was given that Dublin was one of the bad areas, but the gentleman making £200 profit weekly who was fined £3 I gathered was in Dublin.

Comment on this

Was it in a backyard?

Comment on this

Where?

Comment on this

I do not know.

Comment on this

I thought the Deputy said that it was in a backyard in Dublin.

Comment on this

I read of such a case in the newspapers.

Comment on this

If that is the case to be made, that it was before a Dublin district justice, I have not heard it criticised. The thing would nearly warrant the man being brought before a disciplinary group to know what he meant. If the facts were simply this, that a man was making £200 weekly and was fined £3 I did not grip it. There is something else in it. We have sought vainly since this debate started to get some statement about the few cases, the heinousness of the offence, the case made to the district justices and the district justices' reactions. Then we would have some basis to go on.

Comment on this

And then we would be asked if it was a verbatim report.

Comment on this

Let us advance to the first stage. Let us keep to the case made in court.

Comment on this

That is the reason I did not go over that.

Comment on this

There are other reasons; that the case did not stand examination. That is the obvious answer, and one, I think, that would commend itself to the common sense of most people. We are definitely criticising one group of the judicial authority for not having done their duty. We are definitely saying that they are lenient where leniency was not urged.

Comment on this

That was true, too.

Comment on this

And we are going to say that that is so much the case that we cannot trust the operation of fines; but we are not going to put on a minimum penalty until we know that people will be harshly treated. The answer is that we will abandon the judicial system and let the Departmental officials advise the Minister. That is a very big change. A big number of cases occurred in which too great leniency was shown, but by examination of a half-dozen typically bad cases we could be told what was the offence and what was the defence made. After that we could judge. If there was some such case made we could go somewhere towards making these people do their duty. We have not had such cases; we were told that the reason is that there would be interminable arguments about it. In any event, we could be told what was the record of the cases that appeared in the newspapers. Then we would have something to go on. I must say that I have come to the same conclusion as Deputy Costello. I had experience of Government for a number of years. This thing is known all over the world. It is not a thing peculiar to officialdom here. It is known that officials like a clear run in administration and prefer always things like minimum penalties to fixed penalties, rather than have discretion given to anybody else. They always prefer that and urged it with such success in France that they have a completely new code.

On the Continent they have got pretty nearly a new code; it is called the Administrative Law in which, where an official of the Government is involved, you do not go beyond the ordinary tribunals, but we have always prided ourselves that we have not given in to that. We are giving in to it now, however. If the whole thing is bad, and if a change is necessary, surely we ought to have a case made for such a change, so that people here could say: "Yes, we did vote for a definite change, but we voted for it for very good reasons. Cases were given to us, and we approved of the deduction that was made from these cases: that there had been over-leniency, that that over-leniency was going to spread and be the cause of default growing and, therefore, there was likely to be a big deficiency in the food supply of the country." But we are not within 1,000 leagues of a case of that type being made. We have had a few cases here and there, and the presumption is that the farmers will not do their job because minimum penalties are not involved and they think they may get away with small fines. That is what we are told, but the best case that can be shown is that there were 430 cases, in some of which certain penalties were imposed, and we are not told why they were imposed. Whatever may be said with regard to cases here and there, when it comes to condemning the district justices out of hand I refuse to do it.

Comment on this

I should like to point out to the Opposition that one defaulter in Meath or Westmeath—and Meath in particular—is a greater loss to the nation than, say, a defaulter in Cavan. A large number of farmers with very large holdings all over the Midlands got away with this thing for the last couple of years, and their neighbours have not been reluctant in either reporting them to the Department or to me. Whenever I received such reports, I sent them on to the Department, and the people concerned were prosecuted, but their neighbours say: "What is the good of it? We are doing our best, but when these people go into court they are fined half-a-crown." These people are men of wealth. One of them, I know, boasts that he has had an income of £1 a day since the last war, and he gets off with a fine of half-a-crown. Then you have cases beside the towns in the Midlands—beside Trim, Navan, Kells and Mullingar. Even in these rich districts, you have small farmers with uneconomic holdings, who are willing to go out and give big prices for conacre so as to grow oats, barley and wheat to supply their own requirements and also for cash, and these people say to us: "We are willing to take on land if the Department put it up." and they have taken land whenever the Department took action, but when the Department take action in the particular way that we are dealing with now, the offenders are fined half-a-crown. It is not this year that that has occurred, but last year also, and it is being repeated this year and, as a result, the law has been made a laughing-stock amongst the farming community in the Midlands. They ask what is the use of all these compulsory Orders?

Comment on this

And then there is very poor land being tilled wherever it can be got.

Comment on this

Yes, and some of these big farmers, in order to comply with the tillage regulations, will go down to the fens, and will not touch the good land. We who live in the midst of this and see it all around us, and who see the necessity for food, want to tell the Opposition, as Deputy Beegan told them, that they are defending a class of individuals who are not worth defending. I differ from Deputy Beegan in this, that these individuals got away with it in 1914 and 1918, and they are getting away with it to-day. It is even said about them in the Midlands that if the cattle have to be slaughtered to provide food for the people, these individuals are such adepts at trickery that their cattle will not be slaughtered. It is time that something should be done with them. They are the very same people, too, who will go into the black market and purchase all they want there, because they have the money, and, mind you, public opinion is against the black marketeers and has shown itself in my constituency. Men have gone into black market shops, purchased goods there and been overcharged, and they have brought the prosecutions themselves. I am making no complaint on this head, because when these cases came before the district justices they inflicted very heavy fines on the black marketeers, but I wish they would inflict the same fines on the people who should provide food for our people.

I do not want to prolong this discussion, but when this kind of thing is happening, one year after another, of fines of 2/6, 5/- and 10/- being imposed on people who can afford to till and to employ tractors, and who refuse to do so, what is to be the outcome? I see no alternative but this Bill. As I said before, there are dozens and scores of small farmers all around these defaulters who, if they had an economic holding, would be a credit to this State or any State. These small farmers are willing to give a good price for conacre and do their stuff on these farms, if they only got the chance.

Comment on this

This debate, in its latter turn, has been a very great disappointment to me. On several occasions I have appealed to the members of the Fianna Fáil Party, sitting behind their Ministers, to come into the House and give us a hand in the thorough discussion of matters of importance for the country because I felt that, close up against the situation in the country as are the country Deputies from our Party, they would have realities staring them in the face and would bring an intelligent, honest and open mind and opinion to bear on them. They have entered this debate, and it has been a healthy thing that they have entered it, but it is what we hear from them that disappoints and, in fact, dismays me. I do not think I am misrepresenting the Deputies who have spoken when I say that they see nothing but the terms of this Bill that will help to get the necessary tillage done in the country. Deputy Beegan said that it has been a hardship to the Department of Agriculture and its inspectors for the last two years that they have not had these powers of minimum fines. He says that it has been a hardship on the Department and has prevented the Department from getting the necessary tillage done. Deputy Kennedy says that he sees no other way of dealing with the situation except this. Now, I think it is a terrible tragedy that the ordinary members of the Fianna Fáil Party, when they come to discuss in this House the question of getting food supplies for the nation, should see no other way, in the present circumstances, of getting our food supply than to introduce a system of minimum fines in the way which is suggested in this Bill. Apart altogether from what Deputy Costello said in such a masterly way last night about the history of the effect of a system of minimum fines, I think we have enough ordinary intelligence and ordinary experience——

Comment on this

The Deputy is misrepresenting what was said by Deputies who have spoken.

Comment on this

Well, I am prepared to sit down and hear any member of the Fianna Fáil Party say that they do not approve of this system of fines and agree with the suggestions of Deputy Costello.

Comment on this

I have sat through all this debate and listened to the statements that were made. These statements were not as Deputy Mulcahy has suggested: that there is no other way of getting food for the people of this country. The statements made were that there is no way other than this of compelling a particular section of people in this country, who have got land, to do their duty.

Comment on this

At any rate, I am honestly giving Deputies the impression made on me. If, in the subsequent development of the debate, that impression can be corrected, I shall be perfectly satisfied. But that was the impression made on me. Those of us who take an interest in the serious situation which developed here in the city as a result of bread queues were charged last night by Deputy Corry with this: that by opposing this system of minimum fines we are condemning the city to bread queues. I need only turn to the discussion here this afternoon to feel justified in what I say with regard to the attitude of the Fianna Fáil Party here. If we add what was said last night to what was said this evening I do not see that any other interpretation can be placed on that. I would be glad if we could satisfactorily understand that I have misrepresented the case.

In another way I am much more disappointed. This Bill presents itself to me in two lights. First of all, I look on it as a lazy way for an incompetent person, who is strong enough to bully and to kick, to adopt to try and get his work done. In the second place I look on it as a measure cast in the dictatorial spirit by that type of person who, in order to cover over his mistakes and faults, looks for a scapegoat, and goes saboteur hunting. What was said by Deputy Kennedy in his last speech and by another Deputy who spoke before him, suggested that the people who are failing to do their tillage to-day are people who are refusing to do for a national Government what they freely and willingly did for a Government that was not national.

Comment on this

Deputy Kennedy did not say that. He said the opposite.

Comment on this

I said that one Deputy said that. What Deputy Kennedy seemed to suggest, in the pointed way he made his statement, was that it is the active supporters of the British Government in their time, when they were here, who are at present not doing their duty in this particular case. The suggestion is that the type of people this Bill is after are the old pro-British crowd that are still here and still trying to do damage to this country.

Comment on this

Nobody ever said anything of the kind.

Comment on this

All this talk will not till one acre of ground.

Comment on this

I say that bears out one of the impressions that I gather about this Bill: that a scapegoat is being looked for, and that the excuse is being offered to all classes of people here, whether they are people in bread queues or farmers who feel a grievance in regard to somebody else, that there is a scapegoat, and that he is going to be sought out. But whether or not we have unnecessary and unlimited speech-making here, the hunting for the scapegoat is not going to get the work done.

Comment on this

We have had a lot of it on the opposite side in the last couple of days.

Comment on this

The Minister accepts it in the most charitable way— of the lazy incompetent person who is in a strong bullying position making amends by trying to cover up his mistakes. The Minister for Local Government yesterday pointed out how important, active and energetic local bodies can be during the emergency we are going through, how important it would be to have local bodies, closely connected with the country, energetic in dealing with the difficulties that are going to come before us. When the Government first approached this question of compulsory tillage I asked here that a system be introduced that would bring the county committees of agriculture into close co-operation with the scheme. That would mean that you would have competent bodies, with their technical experts, available in every county, that the Department could be the centralising machinery, and that by utilising it a clear impression could be obtained as to where a quota of this or a quota of that could be got. Under a system of that kind, it would be possible to say that the poor counties, like Cavan, might be treated in one way, and counties such as Meath in another. But the idea of utilising the county committees of agriculture in connection with the tillage scheme was scoffed at from the far benches. Two years passed before any importance was attached to them, and then they were assembled. For what? To be addressed by speeches and to be urged to do this, that and the other.

Comment on this

They were told in the first year about the compulsory tillage.

Comment on this

It was in the second year of the compulsory tillage that the speech-making campaign of addressing the county committees of agriculture was started by the Government. When there was a real thorough piece of work to be done—to force the situation where there was non-compliance—the county surveyors in certain counties were instructed to take possession of certain farms. That showed the Government, through the county surveyors and the machinery they had collected, how to work these farms. The county surveyors entered on a certain number of them. Can we be told in how many cases the owner asked the county surveyor to leave him alone and he would do the work? How many of these farms were actually given back to the owners before the ploughing was done, how many before the seeding was done, and how many before the harvesting took place? That piece of local machinery showed that you had there a powerful instrument for seeing that the real thing you wanted was there, namely, the means to get food. Even at the last moment, when there is a greater recognition of the importance of the local bodies in carrying out work during the emergency, the Government should realise the amount of assistance that they can get from them, both in seeing that there is a proper public spirit developed in relation to a compulsory tillage Order, and in getting an appreciation of the powers and resources that are at the disposal of our local government machinery in seeing that work is carried out. If that had been done there would, in my opinion, be very little need for this really disastrous type of weapon—the minimum penalty.

If Deputies on the far benches feel that I have misinterpreted their views in regard to the general position, I would like to hear them deal with that. Why were the county committees of agriculture not used from the beginning, and if they are being used now, how are they being used? The thing is that from a very narrow point of control in the Department of Agriculture the Government set out to do the whole of this big job and because they have not achieved the success they ought to have achieved they are looking now for somebody to blame.

Comment on this

That is not the case. Nobody has made that case.

Comment on this

I made that case in interpreting what I heard from the opposite benches. Now that we have got the ordinary members of the Fianna Fáil Party into this discussion, I would be glad to hear them on it. If my interpretation of the speeches is right, that they see no other way of getting, the tillage done than by these minimum fines, then it would be a very good thing for the House and the country to hear what they think as to the way in which we can get it.

There is just one point on the general business to which I should like to refer. Various classes of offences have been suggested here. But take one recent type of happening. Recently the Army was not able to get the amount of bacon from its contractors that it wanted. There is an emergency Order by which if any person has a particular thing he can be ordered under a particular Order to sell that thing to another named person. Apparently, there is some delegation, under some parent Order of that particular kind, to the Pigs and Bacon Commission. Last month the Pigs and Bacon Commission issued orders to certain bacon curers to supply certain quantities of bacon to the Army. Take the case of one minor curer whose quota of pigs is down to one-third of what it was before the emergency. He has a retail establishment and also sells wholesale to a big lot of retailers. Within 50 miles there is one of the biggest bacon centres in the country. He gets an order to supply to the Army a quantity of bacon which will leave him in the position that he cannot supply his retailers with even one-third of their normal requirements.

Comment on this

I find it very hard to see what relation this has to the section.

Comment on this

I will tell the Taoiseach. This provides that the Government may, whenever and so often as they think fit, by Order under Section 2 of the Act, declare that certain punishments will be inflicted for certain offences and that they will have minimum penalties. Under one of these sub-emergency Orders the Pigs and Bacon Commission instruct a minor curer to deliver a certain amount of bacon to the Army. The effect of doing that will be to leave retailers, whom he has been in the habit of supplying and whose supply is already reduced, I suppose, to about one-third, because the curer is reduced to about one-third, without a substantial part of their ration. Fifty miles away there is the biggest bacon curing centre in the country. Instead of the Pigs and Bacon Commission going to the main bacon centre and getting some large curers to supply the Army, a minor local curer is ordered to do it. Having got that order, if he says to himself: "I am not going to queer my position with the retailers whom I supply. I am not going to allow them to suspect that I am withholding bacon from them in order to retail it through my own retail machinery," and if he clears out what bacon he has so as to supply the retailers and because of that is not able to provide the Army with the amount of bacon he has been ordered by the Pigs and Bacon Commission to supply them with, he comes under this Order.

Comment on this
Fionán Lynch An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Does that come under these amendments?

Comment on this

Yes, he is one of the thousands of people who can be affected by this.

Comment on this
Fionán Lynch An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

By these amendments?

Comment on this

Here you have a minor curer who may be penalised under this Order because there comes into operation against him an incompetent Order issued by the Pigs and Bacon Commission, whose previous incompetence stretching over months and months has brought the pig and bacon position to what it is.

Comment on this
Fionán Lynch An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

He may or he may not come under the Order, but these amendments deal with the penalties to be imposed.

Comment on this

Yes, we have down here exploratory amendments in the name of Deputy McGilligan——

Comment on this
Fionán Lynch An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

They are very definite.

Comment on this

——trying to get the Taoiseach to justify this particular provision, that they may declare that the punishment which may be awarded in respect of the specified offences under this section on summary conviction thereof shall be a fine of not less than a specified amount, not less than £100, or more than £500. We are asking for justification for a fine of £100 on a person serving the country in that particular way. The emergency Order issued by a body that really ought to be subject to a whole series of emergency Orders itself——

Comment on this

There may never be a minimum fine of £100.

Comment on this

There may be. We are entitled to assume that there may be. That is what is in the Bill.

Comment on this

At any rate, we are entitled to assume that it will be more than £25 and might be imposed under a sub-section of an Order that might be issued under this section if it were operated as presented to the House. That is only one of the many types of people who may be affected by the operation of this. Deputy O'Sullivan suggested that we would keep the House here for weeks if we were to discuss the various types of cases which could be affected by this, but it would be well to have a general kind of picture. I should like to hear Deputies on the opposite side justify the issuing of an Order like this and having it hanging over the head of a minor curer such as I have mentioned when the machinery that is operating the bacon industry in the country orders a person like that to supply bacon to such an extent that it will clear him out of his supplies and not allow him to supply the people who retail the bacon, while the bigger curers in the neighbourhood are not asked to supply the Army with anything like the same quantity.

Comment on this

I have never listened to a debate more divorced from reality than the debate we have listened to during the past two days or a debate more out of step with what the ordinary people expect from this legislature. For the past two days we have been discussing objections to minimum fines. Whatever peace-time view we might have as to minimum fines for certain offences, it seems to me that some of the contributors to this debate do not, apparently, realise that we are a beleaguered nation, that we are living in a war situation, and that, with goods in short supply, and with a well-developed black market at home, it is obviously necessary for us to take steps to protect the interests of our people. We discussed yesterday evening, and to-day, the niceties of minimum fines. In normal peace times legal procedure of that kind might provide a very interesting source of discussion. But this is not peace time; this is a war situation, and we ought to try to attune our minds to the conditions under which we live to-day.

Yesterday evening the discussion ranged around giving the district justices discretion. I am prepared in normal times to give district justices reasonable discretion—at least, some of the district justices—but to say that we should be prepared to give all the district justices reasonable discretion is simply asking us to put our intelligence in cold storage. I am not prepared to give all the district justices the discretion which has been claimed for them from the Fine Gael Benches. I imagine that some of the greatest advocates, in this debate, of giving the district justices the wide discretion suggested, are the very people who, more than anybody else, know the idiosyncrasies to which the nation is sometimes treated by some of the district justices. We simply efface from our minds statements which have been made from time to time from the benches ornamented by some of our district justices. As a class I do not want to make any complaint against them, but everybody here knows that there are certain district justices who imagine they are the fount of wisdom, that pure equity starts to flow from their minds, and they proceed to lecture all and sundry, including the Legislature in legislative matters on their sins of omission and commission.

Possibly we could put up with these peculiarities in peace time; we could afford to smile at the comments which are made by district justices in ordinary inconsequential cases. But we cannot afford to smile and we cannot afford that kind of pontifical luxury from the judicial bench at a time when we know many of our people are being exploited in connection with the sale and distribution of essential commodities. We cannot afford in present circumstances to allow district justices to give their opinions on whether it is reasonable or unreasonable for a person who holds land to till or refuse to till that land. I am in favour of insisting that the person who has an obligation to till land shall be required to comply with national requirements in that matter and till the minimum quantity prescribed by the Legislature, and, in the matter of price charges for essential commodities, I think traders must be compelled to observe the price Orders issued from time to time by the Department of Supplies.

If people are not satisfied with the scope of these Orders, let them agitate constitutionally for a repeal or a modification, but, once the Order is issued, it must be rigidly observed. Nobody has yet said that the 25 per cent. tillage of arable land is unreasonable and no member of the consuming public has yet said that he wants to pay more than the maximum price fixed for commodities because he considered that maximum price too low.

If there is to be any complaint against these Orders, let us have a constitutional agitation to secure their repeal. But to suggest that farmers who will not till their land, or traders who want to charge more than the maximum price fixed by the Department, should be allowed to place themselves at the tender mercy of a district justice, who may hold angular views on these matters, is asking the people to swallow much more than I think in their present mood the people are prepared to swallow.

The most vital thing we have to do is to ensure that we exploit to the fullest the land which is capable of giving the goods which our people require. Equity demands that we should ensure that our people are protected against exploitation by any person who has control of goods in short supply. If the best way to ensure that there will be adequate tillage and that traders will charge a fair price for their commodities is by the institution of a scheme of minimum fines, then I am prepared to support that scheme, if it means adequate fines for transgressions against the nation or against citizens.

Quite obviously, with the well-developed black market and the known exploitation of consumers, this Legislature is bound to take steps to combat that exploitation, but it would seem for the past two days that there has been a much greater emphasis on the protection of potential offenders than there has been any safeguarding of the best interests of the consumers. It may be suggested that there are extenuating circumstances in respect of the non-cultivation of the area of land specified under the Compulsory Tillage Order. Over 95 per cent. of the farmers, realising the peril in which the nation stands, have gladly co-operated in cultivating the land in order to produce the food we require. The majority of the farmers have been patriotic and quite willing to develop their land to the utmost advantage. This Legislature and the judiciary ought not to give any encouragement or approbation to the type of farmer who to-day, as always, will find some excuse for not tilling his land, even though it is in the interests of the nation. In the main, the small farmers have responded very generously to the Government's appeal to produce more food for the people. The most fatal thing this Legislature could do in present circumstances is to appear to indicate that it has sympathy with the person who is always prepared to find an excuse for stepping out from the ranks.

Deputy Mulcahy appears to think that the Bill which gives the Government power to prescribe these penalties is most outrageous. I should like to draw his attention to one fact. We ought not to give the Government the powers enshrined in this Bill because of the way in which they abused the powers given them in the parent Act. We said, in respect of the parent Act, that the Government misused their powers and had utilised the Act for the purpose of depressing the standard of living of the workers. When we challenged a division on the Second Reading of this Bill, Deputy Mulcahy's Party went with the Government, thus indicating by their votes that the Government should have power to depress the standard of living of the workers. While it is quite all right to depress the standard of living of the workers and while the Deputy, judging by the votes of his Party, is not prepared to impede that movement, we now get an artificial stir on the Committee Stage of this Bill to try to protect potential offenders in and out of the blackmarket from the possibility that they may have minimum fines imposed on them.

I think I know as much about the feelings of the people of this city and of this country as anybody else in the city or in the country. Interpreting that feeling, I believe most of the people want to ensure that very substantial fines will be imposed on those who exploit the people's need in the present circumstances. If the only way of getting substantial fines and of curing that type of exploitation is the fixing of minimum fines, then so far as I am concerned, I welcome minimum fines.

Comment on this