Committee on Finance. - Vote 3—Department of the Taoiseach (Resumed).
Contributions 1–157 of 289. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
I was glad when I noticed that a motion had been tabled to refer back this Estimate for reconsideration. I felt very strongly that when Estimates for other Departments were proposed to be referred back and were opposed it was only right that the Estimate for the Department of the head of the Government, the man who is responsible for the direction of Government policy, should also be challenged. I considered putting down a motion to refer back this Estimate but, owing to my incurable humility. I considered it was the duty of the bigger Opposition Party to undertake that task. Anyhow, I think it is wrong that the head of the Government should be permitted to remain sublimely immune on his pedestal from the strong criticism which has been directed against the Department of Supplies, the Department of Agriculture, and the Department of the Parliamentary Secretary in control of turf production. All these Departments are operating as a portion of general Government policy directed by the Taoiseach, and that Government policy has had very disastrous results during the past year.
Time prohibited me last night from referring to the credit side of the Government's activities, in other words from paying some compliment to some of the operations which have been beneficial. But, being confined as I am to dealing with events of the past year or the operations of the Government for the past year, I am more or less compelled to concentrate upon the more unsatisfactory features of Government policy which have demonstrated themselves during the past 12 months. We have found that as a result of Governmental action the more important branches of the agricultural industry have been forced into a very grave condition. The dairying industry has declined to such an extent that it seems as if this agricultural country will be unable to provide itself with supplies of butter and other dairy produce. Notwithstanding the fact that in the past our big problem has always been to find considerable external markets and suitable prices, it appears now that our problem will be to provide ourselves with these essential foodstuffs.
With regard to the pig industry, the position is even more desperate. There you have a position in which the Government, notwithstanding the appeals made to them by farmers and farmers' representatives in this House, drastically cut the price of pigs at a time when the then existing price was not sufficient to cover the cost of production. This price was cut on the plea that a certain amount of human food was being fed to pigs. Such a plea could not justify a reduction in price because, since wheaten foodstuffs were cheaper than any other foodstuffs that could have been fed to pigs, it was only to be expected that a reduction in the price of pigs, so far from having the effect of preventing the use of wheat for pigs, would naturally tend to increase its consumption. For that reason it would seem to be a ridiculous course for a Government Department to adopt. If the Department acted on the plea that the price of pigs was too high and that it would place bacon out of the reach of the consumer, one would understand that there might be some justification for that policy. But that case was never made for the reduction in the price of pigs. As a matter of fact, the price was cut and the result of the reduction was not to reduce the price of bacon, but to enlarge the profits of the curers. We have the position to-day that the curers, in order to keep the bacon industry going in spite of Government regulations, have been paying a considerably higher price than that fixed by Government Order and for doing so they have been brought into court and severely fined.
It seems an intolerable state of affairs when farmers and pig producers generally—they are not all farmers, but they represent the poorer sections of the community, the agricultural workers and the smallholders who are engaged in the rearing and fattening of pigs and who are unable to secure an economic price for them—find that when the bacon curers, whether for conscientious reasons, for business reasons or otherwise, decided out of their profits to increase the price of pigs, they are being penalised in the court. The result of this is clearly shown by the fact that the pig industry is almost wiped out of existence and many of the bacon curers are getting less than a quarter of their normal supplies. That presents an alarming problem and it clearly demonstrates lack of planning on the part of the Department of Agriculture and a complete lack of competence and efficiency, for which the Head of the Government must take his own share of responsibility, since he declines to make any change in the head of the Department.
Farmers are frequently told that they are eternally agitating for higher prices for every item they produce and that there is no justification for such agitation. Recently a professor of Cork University investigated farmers' production costs over a very large area in the County Cork. He carried out investigations on 61 farms. The net result of his investigations was that he discovered that every male adult member of a farmer's family engaged on agricultural work was earning approximately 24/- per week. In face of that fact emerging from careful investigation, it is difficult to understand how anyone can claim that farmers are receiving undue profits or excessive prices for their produce. The minimum wage for the agricultural worker is 33/- a week. It was discovered by Professor Murphy that, if the average farmer on each of the farms he inspected was to pay the members of his family the fixed legal wage payable to agricultural workers, it would mean a loss of £19 10/- a year. If he were to make an allowance for the interest on the capital he invested on his farm, such as every manufacturer and business man makes, his loss would amount to £46 a year, based on a wage of 33/- per week, which nobody can claim is an excessive wage for agricultural workers at the present time. The most that the average boy who decides to settle down and work on a farm can hope to earn is 24/- a week.
We worry at the rapid reduction in the population of rural Ireland and at the tendency of the best of the young people in rural areas to get away from the land. Apologists for the Government, and the Minister for Agriculture in particular, have stated that there is no fight from the land. Indeed, one person has used the argument that there is a livelihood on the land for only one member of each farmer's family and therefore the second and third sons must find a means of livelihood elsewhere. Others have used the argument that if a city publican has two or three sons, the second and third sons must leave their father's homestead and seek a living elsewhere. Similarly, if a doctor has two sons the second son must earn his living outside. If we were to follow that line of argument we could condemn the flight from the publichouse and from the dispensary just the same as we condemn the flight from the land. But I suggest those arguments are false. While it is true that the second or third son of a business man or a doctor must find the means of livelihood elsewhere, it must be realised that the population of our towns and cities is steadily increasing, and the population of rural Ireland is steadily declining.
That proves how ridiculous and false and absurd are the arguments put forward by those who tell us there is no flight from the land. That flight from the land must continue until the standard of income in rural Ireland is brought up to the standard prevailing in all industrial and urban occupations. In the face of all that we have the Government recklessly and, without any sense of responsibility, ruthlessly cutting the prices of pigs and permitting a state of affairs to continue in which the price of butter is below the cost of production.
Professor Murphy in the course of his investigations discovered that the lowest price at which milk can be produced and supplied to creameries in this country economically is 8½d. per gallon, yet at the present time the maximum that farmers are able to obtain in the creamery areas is 7d. which leaves a net loss on every gallon produced. That is a clear indication of the complete failure on the part of the Government to face up to the fundamental problems of agriculture. The result of their failure is the steady decline in agricultural production and the creation of a situation in which this country is faced with complete economic collapse, because it is quite obvious that the entire economic structure of this country must depend upon a prosperous and healthy condition of agriculture.
The Taoiseach interrupted me last night to say that it is easy to be wise after the event but in connection with the pig industry I think the majority of farmer Deputies in this House were wise before the event. They warned the Government of what would happen if they were to persist in their policy of uneconomic prices for pigs produced in this country. I do not refer to these matters simply for the pleasure of finding fault with the Government. The matter is more serious than that. It is absolutely imperative that the Government should now take a lesson from the mistakes they have made in the past and plan intelligently for the future. If agricultural production is to be maintained and increased, as it must be increased, the time is now overdue when there must be a complete change of Governmental policy. The situation in which agricultural income compares unfavourably to a very alarming extent with the income obtainable in urban and industrial occupations must end. Agricultural income must be raised to the level of industrial income, no matter what difficulties lie in the way of effecting that change.
We have been frequently told in the past that agricultural prices must be governed by external market prices. That is an absolutely ridiculous contention. In this country we export less than one-third of our total agricultural output and there is no reason in the world why the other two-thirds of our agricultural output should be governed by export prices. After all, what are export prices but the prices at which other nations decide to dump their produce on some external market? Very often they bear no relation to the prices prevailing within the exporting nations. In addition to that, conditions under which production is carried on in many nations competing with us bear no relationship to the conditions of production here. Labour conditions, where coloured labour is employed, may be inferior to the labour conditions here.
Comment on this
Not at all. The coloured labourer is much better off than the agricultural labourer in this country.
Comment on this
There is also the consideration that climates vary, and in tropical climates commodities can be produced much cheaper than they can be produced in this country. There is also the fact that through manipulation of currency and through other protective arrangements, nations export their exportable surplus at prices very considerably below the prices prevailing within the country of production. Therefore, it is sheer madness to base our agricultural prices on the export level. We have got to fix a level of prices for agricultural produce based on the cost of production, and we have got to adhere to that level regardless of the prices that may prevail externally. That ought to be the fundamental guiding principle of Government policy. If we are to prevent further decline in the agricultural industry and in agricultural production, there is no alternative. We cannot expect farmers or farmers' sons to remain blind to their own interests. We cannot expect people to work on the land for less than half what can be carned elsewhere. There is only one course open, and that is to raise the standard of income in rural Ireland. Of course, the Taoiseach might suggest another alternative, namely, to lower the standard of living in our urban and industrial areas, but I do not think that any sane person would advocate such a revolutionary, retrograde course. Having regard to the fact that we have the other alternative, there is no fundamental difficulty in raising the prices of agricultural produce to a level which will cover the cost of production, and which will earn incomes for those engaged in agriculture comparable with the incomes earned by other sections of the community.
We have observed how the standard of income and of wages in agriculture has been raised in Great Britain. We have observed how the standard of income and of wages has been raised in Great Britain for various kinds of manual work, in war industries, in the manufacture of war munitions and armaments, and even in the production of coal. The incomes of workers engaged in all those industries have been enormously increased. We may ask how the British nation, beset with difficulties, engaged in a desperate struggle for survival, has been able to increase the standard of living and the earning power of practically the entire working population without any apparent difficulty while we, a neutral country, immune from involvement in war, have been unable to do anything for the most important section of the community, the people engaged in the production of food and the people engaged in the production of turf.
The Taoiseach may ask how is such a plan to be carried into effect. It can only be carried into effect, I say, by the adoption of the same attitude of mind as a Government involved in war adopts towards its military and national problems. We must adopt that attitude of mind towards our economic problems, and, no matter from what source the money requires to be raised to finance an increase in the prices payable for agricultural produce and the prices paid to people engaged in the production of fuel, that money must be found, and I suggest it can be found as easily as money is being found for war purposes by nations involved in war. Orthodox financiers, people in big business, people engaged in our export and import trade, may raise objections, but all those objections have been raised in Great Britain again and again, and they have all been over-ruled by the necessities and the difficulties of the situation and the needs of the people. The essential purpose of the nation of surviving and of surmounting all difficulties has over-ruled the objections of the vested interests. Without any intention of infringing on the copyright of the British Prime Minister, I might say of the financial interests which have obstructed the solution of economic problems both in Great Britain and in this country that, in the past, they held a light that flamed; that, at present, they hold a light that flickers; but, in the future, they will be looking for themselves in a complete blackout. The war has brought a complete change of outlook in regard to economic and financial questions. It has revealed the power of the community to solve such problems, and it is only right that the people in this country should appeal to the Government to face and to solve these problems on the same lines as those on which they have been solved in other countries.
We are facing another cereal year when the problem of providing this nation's food must be very carefully thought out and we have to consider the many blunders made during the present year. We have to consider the fact that the amount of wheat grown was not sufficient for home needs; we have to consider the fact that the total amount of grain grown was not sufficient to supply our needs; and we have the right to ask what plans are now being considered by the Government for facing these problems in the coming year. It is imperative that, in this year, at any rate, the plough shall be hitched to the reaper, that is to say, the land required for the growing of wheat next year must be put under cultivation as soon as possible after the reaping of this season's harvest.
Has any decision been reached as to the remuneration to be paid to farmers for the production of next year's crop? Have the facts disclosed by Professor Murphy in relation to the income of farmers engaged in production been taken into consideration in considering the prices to be fixed for next year's wheat crops? I suggest they ought to be, and the prices ought to show a considerable increase over this year's prices. In addition, farmers engaged in the production of wheat and of other cereal crops required directly for human consumption, ought to be guaranteed in respect of prices not for one year but for a period of years, so that we shall have a stabilised and settled policy extending over a number of years and so that the farmer can face the incurring of expenditure upon the provision of tillage equipment with an easy mind, in the realisation that it is the fixed Government policy that prices of tillage produce will be stabilised over a considerable period.
There is no reason why that should not be so. The people will always require bread; they will always require porridge and the other foodstuffs produced from cereal crops, including stout, beer and whiskey, and, since there is a substantial home market for these products, there is no reason why prices should not be guaranteed for a period of years. It can be done and it requires only bold planning and bold action to put such a policy into operation. We shall still be told that we cannot foresee the future, but we have to lay our plans for the future on some basis, and the only basis upon which we can devise plans for the future is that this country will remain an independent State for a considerable period, that it will still be an independent State when this emergency is over, and that any plans for feeding and providing for our people shall be based on the consideration that the people living within this State have complete control over the political and economic affairs of their country, and, therefore, can plan far into the future so far as the commodities required for the home market are concerned. Therefore, there is no earthly reason why prices for tillage produce should not be guaranteed over a considerable period.
At least 3,000,000 acres of tillage are required in order to provide the country's needs for man and beast. We are entitled to ask what plans have been adopted by the Government to get that acreage. Last year, so far as I know, the total area under tillage was 2,250,000 acres. I suppose there are no figures available yet as to the area under tillage this year, but the community requires a tillage area of at least 3,000,000 acres, and I have frequently pointed out, and it is no harm to remind the Government again, that there is a complete miscalculation in regard to the total area of arable land in the country. It has been frequently stated by Ministers, and by the Taoiseach himself, that there are 11,500,000 acres of arable land in the country. So far as I know, there is nothing of the kind. There has never been any survey of the total area of arable land, but I think the estimate of 11,500,000 acres is a complete miscalculation and could be out by as much as 2,000,000 acres.
This fact will be quite clear to anyone who looks at statistics or who knows anything about agriculture. Deputy Cooney laughs, because he does not know anything about agriculture. From the statistics supplied by the Department of Industry and Commerce, we find that the total area under tillage, meadowing and pasture is 11½ million acres. It must be clearly understood, however, that a very considerable proportion of the area under pasture is not suitable for tillage, and for that reason the calculations of the Department of Agriculture have been almost invariably erratic. In planning for the future, therefore, I hope that this fact will be taken into consideration and that adequate steps will be taken to ensure that we will have at least 3,000,000 acres under tillage in the coming season and, what is most important of all, that the farmer who is engaged in that tillage, the members of the farmer's family who are assisting him, and the workers employed on that farm will be permitted to have a sufficient remuneration to enable them to continue in production. There is no use in fixing a minimum acreage of tillage if the prices guaranteed for the tillage produced are not adequate to cover the cost of production, because, inevitably, there will be failure, there will be a break-down somewhere if the farmer is not able to make his cost of production. He may carry on for a few months or for a year, but sooner or later he is bound to come to the wall, and, in doing so, the nation will suffer.
Now, I think that since the object of this motion to refer back this Estimate has been to fix the responsibility for the Government failures over the past year fairly and squarely on the shoulders of the Taoiseach, he should now take steps to ensure that his Ministers carry out their obligations to the community and deliver the goods both in the industrial and the agricultural sphere and also in the sphere of fuel production. If the Taoiseach entered this House recently from Kildare Street, he might have noticed, outside the House, at the entry to the College of Art, the statues of two very miserable-looking men. I do not know how they got there or why they were put there, but it seems to me that they might be taken as representing the ordinary working people of this country, the common, decent electors, and the people who voted——
Comment on this
——poor, simple-minded foolish men who invariably shouted "Up Dev" and who were the people who were mainly responsible for putting this Government into power. It would appear as if these statues were put there to remind the Government of their failure to carry out their promises to the plain people. As I have said, they look miserable and downcast and are typical of the frustration, disappointment and defeat which the plain people of this country have suffered.
Comment on this
One of the most significant statements that has been made in this House since the Government came into office was that made by the Minister for Supplies recently on his own Estimate: "Our bargaining power is nil." It is a strange commentary, a remarkable statement, coming from a Minister, and one as to the causes of which the Government would be well advised to examine. During the whole period of the Great War of 1914-18, this country was in a state of generous production. There were very large stocks of agricultural produce of one kind or another for sale and available, and now, in the third year of the present conflict, or emergency, or war, we are faced with three problems in connection with agriculture, which ought to engage the attention of the Government. The first is as regards dairying. There is scarcely any Deputy of this House who comes from a dairying district but has pointed out that the present economic position of the dairying industry is at a much lower standard than it has been for some years past. The information given to this House within the last 12 months shows that our pig killings have gone down from about 21,000 per week to about 6,000—the average of the last six weeks.
Poultry production is also on the decline. One of the root causes of the present situation is that our imports of animal feeding stuffs have almost ceased since the war commenced, and those wheat offals, which were available until the shortage of flour became so noticeable, are no longer available for live stock. The Government may ask, in this situation, what is our suggestion. After all, before we answer that question, I think we must admit to one another that, so far as they are concerned, their plans, if they had any; their programme, if they had one; their scheme of operations, have not been a success, but have been a colossal failure. The first suggestion that I would make in connection with the matter is that if they require a larger quantity of wheat grown in this country, they ought to take steps to ensure that it will be grown: either to increase the acreage under tillage or to ensure that in respect of each holding a certain proportion of it would be devoted to wheat growing, and that it should be planned so that there will be available, for feeding live stock, bran and pollard, and that sufficient wheat will be grown in order to make that available.
I understand that we have in this country a deposit of phosphates. Why it is that the Government have not done everything possible to get out the maximum amount of that is beyond my comprehension. It is a matter that has been talked about from the very start, and in looking over the returns of imports for years past, during the period of the economic war, and so on, it can be seen that we were importing less and less phosphates than formerly. If we have any plan at all either for the present or the future, it is obvious that the first consideration present to the minds of any agriculturist ought to be to maintain the fertility of the land. It matters little what prospects there are for getting, either this year or next year, a good return, if we are to envisage then, for the future, a lowering of production.
The second suggestion is that we should make a generous, as well as a minute, examination of the dairying industry. In that industry we are facing competition now from the ends of the earth. After the war we will be facing competition from Northern Europe as well as from New Zealand and Australia. In either place, in the north or in the south, the milk yield of the cows there is greater than ours. Why should that be? Why a country like ours, famed as it is for its live stock and for the fertility of its soil, should have lower milk yields from its stock than other countries is something which, I think, the Department ought to answer for. In this matter the Government should endeavour to get the co-operation and assistance of the veterinary profession to eliminate any wasteful stock that we have as well as diseases which are peculiar to quite a number of our live stock; to advise as to how to get the best results from the animals that we have by, for example, a better class of winter feeding or something on that line. It is obvious that if you are going to do these things, with the price of milk at approximately 7d. per gallon, production costs must be reduced in every direction possible, because at present they are a hindrance to the profitability of the dairying industry.
In recent years there has been a remarkable increase in central taxation as well as in local taxation. He would be a super-optimist who could conceive of the possibility of production costs being reduced while you have central and local taxation increasing. If the dairying industry should happen to come upon a bad time, there will be smaller quantities of milk going to the creameries. Members of the House who come from the creamery areas say that is happening. If so, it is obvious that there will be a reduction in the number of pigs produced. That will be a loss, not only to those who are engaged in agriculture, who could employ in pig production feeding stuffs that might otherwise be wasted, but as well to the bacon factories and curing companies which provide considerable employment in Cork, Limerick, Waterford, Dublin and elsewhere. We learned from this morning's newspapers that it is expected that, within the next week or ten days, something like 300 men will be disemployed in the factories in Cork City. Already a very big number of Cork workers have emigrated to Great Britain. The Government seem to think that there is no answer, no way out, to that problem. Of course, if we allow those activities to deteriorate and go to rot it is obvious there will be no employment there for our people.
What we want in a case of this sort is intelligent planning. It does not require a super-abundance of intelligence to realise that the feeding stuffs which we had been accustomed to import must be provided locally, or else that the stocks to which they are fed will decrease in numbers. In February last, at almost a moment's notice, the price paid for pigs was reduced. Speaking from recollection, the reduction amounted to 6/- per cwt. Various reasons were given for that, one being that we had no feeding stuffs to spare. In the presence of the Minister for Agriculture at the time I said that the action taken appeared to me to amount to Government robbery— little short of it—so far as those who had pigs for sale at that time were concerned. If the Government had given notice a month or two earlier that the price was going to be reduced, at least we could not charge them with being dishonest, of trying to take from people something to which they were entitled and which the Government were not entitled to take from them. If the policy was to ensure that there would be fewer pigs in the country then there is no earthly reason why the people should not have been told that in advance. One of the reasons alleged for this departure in policy was that wheat was being fed to live stock. Some time about February I heard from a clergyman in the country, who is a friend of mine, that when a farmer in his neighbourhood tendered his wheat to the mill it was refused on the ground that it was not up to millable quality. He brought it home and sold it for feeding in his own neighbourhood at a price which was 6/- per barrel more than he would have got for it if it had been up to the quality of millable wheat. Those who have had the experience of the difficulty of getting feeding stuffs will realise that that was not a bad bargain for the man who bought it, if the quality was at all what might be expected.
The other matter to which I desire to refer is the price of turf, the wage paid to those engaged in its production, and the price charged for turf in Dublin and Cork. The price at which turf is produced in the country areas varies from 10/- to 15/- per ton. The price to the consumer in Dublin or Cork is 64/- a ton. One need not be surprised that those engaged in cutting turf, putting it on the railway or motor lorries to have it brought to the cities, are dissatisfied with their wage of 33/- per week. It was alleged in this House by, I think, the Taoiseach himself that, if we increase wages, we are going to increase the price of the turf. Of course that does not follow at all, as any man in business knows. Let us take the case of two men engaged in producing turf. One is being paid 33/- per week, and the other 40/- per week. If the man getting 40/- produces one and a half tons of turf, while the man paid 33/- produces only one ton, which is the cheaper labour, and which gives the better result? Obviously, the man who produces the most. His labour is far cheaper. It would represent about 28/- as against the 33/-. It is said that it is impossible to avoid this increase in cost. I should say that it is as long as we adopt the methods that have been adopted by the Government for the transportation of turf to Dublin or Cork. Why not hand over a matter of that sort to people who are experienced in transport affairs?
What does the Minister know about transport? The surface of it. What do civil servants know about it? They, too, have surface information. Even engineers, able as they may be, and qualified as they are in their profession, are not as well adapted to deal with questions of transport as are the men engaged in the transport industry. I have no doubt whatever that if tenders had been issued in connection with the transport of turf to Dublin it would be done at a far cheaper rate and with much less messing about.
Some men engaged at turf cutting by one of the parish councils around Dublin are paid 40/- a week. They have saved a quantity of turf, but it has been so parcelled out that there is no road to transport it from the bog. Then the Government decide to get a road made and they want men to do road-making work at 36/- a week, whereas the men cutting the turf get 40/-. Obviously no ordinary man will work at 36/- a week when he sees other men getting 40/-. That is one of the anomalies of the situation. Ministers have not to live on 36/- or 40/- a week, but those who have, have to make up their minds where the best value is to be got. Another case came to my notice recently which would stagger this standstill Order No. 83. A man wrote to me and said:—
"I am at present in receipt of unemployment assistance, home assistance and food allowance. I have nine children and my total income is worth £2 2s. per week to me. I have been told to go to work at a distance of eight miles at 36/- a week. I cannot afford to do it."
Could he? I should like to see a Minister supporting a wife and nine children on 36/- a week. It would not be such a laughing matter.
Comment on this
One of the remedies, anyhow, is to increase the 36/- a week. When we pointed out that there is one particular class in the community excluded from that standstill Order, the explanation given to us is that some men who were getting £6 or £8 per week have been replaced or were to be replaced by men at lower wages. Let the Government bring in a standstill Order to deal with that, and not make the excuse of preventing a man with 36/- or 40/- a week from getting an increase that he cannot look for any more and is not entitled according to law to get any more. It is an unjust law. It is no wonder that institutions of Government, and even Parliament itself, are brought into contempt when you have laws such as that. This turf at £3 4s. 0d. per ton is no solution of the fuel problem. It is intensifying it. The sooner it is reconsidered, and this whole business of the standstill Order is reconsidered, the better it will be for the Government and this House. I do not think any Government in the world has got the consideration, the support, and the co-operation which this Government have got, not alone from this House but from outside. It is time that we saw some results from that, and that they gave some value to the people for the money that is being paid to them.
Comment on this
Most of us have become more or less attuned to the characteristic note of pessimism struck by the Government in relation to the social and economic conditions now prevailing in the country. The statement of the Minister for Industry and Commerce that we had no bargaining power left is, I suppose, the culminating point of the policy of the Government which has been guilty of every type of the wildest extravagance. The hopeless position to which the country has been reduced during the past 12 months is largely due to the dismal failure of the Government to apply any vision or foresight to the tactics and strategy of the conduct of the affairs of the country during the whole period of the emergency. When the censure and blame for this situation come to be apportioned, a large portion must fall on the shoulders of the Taoiseach and his Department, because the words "Taoiseach" and "Government" are in the public minds almost synonymous. The Taoiseach's failures are regarded as the Government's failures and the Government's failures are regarded as the Taoiseach's failures.
At no time since the beginning of this emergency has any considered plan emanated from the Taoiseach with regard to the preservation of our industries. At no time has the Minister specially charged with the responsibilities connected with the Department of Industry and Commerce come before the House with any plan to protect or promote the interests of our native industries. I think all of us will agree that the preservation of these industries is no less a part of our defensive measures than the maintenance of a large and costly Army. The tendency all the time has been for the Government to attribute our failures to sinister external circumstances over which the Government had no control. At a time when man-power was never more sorely needed for the service of the State and for national development schemes such as fuel and food production, emigration has been allowed to proceed unchecked on a scale unprecedented except perhaps during the exodus following the famine years of the last century.
We cannot blame people for emigrating. Their lot is a hard one owing to the pangs of separation from their families and uprooting from their homes. Our people are fleeing in their thousands and in their tens of thousands from a land of starvation wages, from a land of submerged and depressed standards of living, from a land of black marketeers and racketeers and from a land wherein once more wealth accumulates and men decay. Emigration has been encouraged by the Government because it must have appeared to them that it would serve as a kind of palliative, if not a solution of our unemployment problem.
We are now witnessing a widespread dislocation of our transport services, I might almost say a partial collapse in many parts of the country. But the Government were aware from the beginning of the emergency of the precarious financial position of the Great Southern Railways Company. They were aware that the Great Southern Railways Company was not able to carry, because of lack of credit facilities, any more than two or three weeks' stock of coal at the outbreak of the war. They were aware of the mismanagement in that company for years, yet things were allowed to proceed without any guidance or assistance from the Government, any attempt to ease the situation or to do anything that might ensure an improvement of the position.
There is one matter in this connection which I think is worthy of notice. The transport services in the City of Dublin have been very much curtailed. I suggest it is the Government's business to pay some attention to the grave inconvenience that thousands of citizens have to suffer by having to wait in all kinds of weather at tram and bus stops. They are exposed to the rain and the wind and, as the winter months approach, they will have to contend with the snow and frost. The Government ought to take the initiative in the erection of shelters at various points throughout the city and suburbs.
Throughout the whole emergency situation the Government have failed to foresee the difficulties that have arisen. The competence of a Government in an emergency situation is usually gauged by their ability to foresee difficulties and provide ways and means to surmount them. I believe the failure of our Government in this matter is largely due not only to their lack of foresight and vision, but to their almost complete dependence for supplies of money on financial concerns disposed to give money only on considerations of self-interest and profit. I believe a large part of the failure in this emergency is due to the reluctance of the Government to apply and extend the principle of State ownership to public utility undertakings.
Comment on this
General Government policy falls to be reviewed to-day. I want to refer briefly to the observations of the Leader of the Opposition. I agree entirely with him in deploring the virtual destruction of the pig industry, and I share his amazement that, at a time like this, we find ourselves without bacon wherewith to feed our people. Shopkeepers and distributors throughout the West of Ireland and in Donegal and Monaghan will receive about one-fifth of their weekly requirements of bacon between now and next April. In my considered opinion there will not be in half the shops in rural Ireland next Christmas a pound of hard salt bacon for the consuming public. What that will mean west of the Shannon only those of us who live there can guess.
This House seems to have lost sight of the fundamental reason for that disaster. The reason is plain and simple for those who will think. The Government have decided to promote the growth of wheat by fixing a price of 50/- per barrel. That being their policy, they are determined that no other cereal will be allowed to compete with that crop in its attractions for the farmer. Therefore, no other cereal will be allowed to command, directly or indirectly, a price which compares with 50/- a barrel for wheat. For this reason the price of pigs is kept artifically low, the price of barley is kept artifically low, and the price of oats is kept artifically low. If the price of pigs were allowed to reach its normal level, people would grow barley and oats and feed them to pigs, thus cashing their crop indirectly, and they would have a much more substantial return from their land than if they employed it in growing wheat at 50/- per barrel.
That policy is wrong. In the situation in which we find ourselves, the correct policy is to fix the price of wheat at 50/- per barrel, to compel every farmer with more than a certain acreage of land to sow a percentage of his land under wheat and, if he complains that that obligation involves him in loss, then let him increase the acreage of the rest of his land under oats and barley and, by selling these crops as cash crops, or by feeding them to live stock, let him make up on the remaining acres for the loss on the wheat that he has been constrained to grow. People wangling and twangling around this problem, while our supplies grow less. Ultimately they must come to the view that I have enunciated, because it is the only solution of the problem.
Unless we take this course now, we will find ourselves very soon without wheat, oats, barley, bacon, fowl or eggs. That is absolutely certain. If, on the other hand, we fix 50/- for wheat and compel those with an acreage over 20 acres to sow a certain percentage under wheat and let there be a free field for oats, barley and the live stock to which these cereals are ordinarily fed, then I suggest there will be an abundance for our people and a surplus available for export, as was the case in the last war.
The other point in the speech delivered by the Leader of the Opposition to which I wish to refer has relation to the dairying industry. It is time that we stopped talking tripe about the dairying industry. Butter for export is as dead as Queen Anne. Make up your minds to that. You may not like to face the fact; you may think that you are going to get a few votes in Limerick, Cork or Tipperary by pretending that you do not believe it, but the fact is that butter for export is as dead as Queen Anne and the dairying industry as we know it must investigate the possibilities of "drink more milk" for our own people, and the development of casein as a by-product of the live-stock industry. Should these things fail, the dairying industry will have to be recast and we may have to face the consequences of seeing it destroyed. I do not think it will be destroyed. I think it can be saved and preserved as the keystone of our whole agricultural industry, as it ought to be, but if it is to be done it must be done by courageous action and by a clearheaded contemplation of the problem we have got to face and overcome.
The first certainty is that butter for export is as dead as Queen Anne. "Drink More Milk" is capable of consuming vastly increased quantities of liquid milk. The problem of its transport from the dairy counties to Dublin, Cork. Limerick and other large centres of population is a trivial problem, a problem which is met and surmounted every day as an ordinary economic enterprise in the United States. There is no such thing in Ireland as a long haul in terms of transport. To haul stuff from Cork to Dublin is a short haul in terms of modern transport. With glass-lined milk-conveyor cars, milk can be hauled from any dairy centre in this country into the large centres of population, and there pasteurised and distributed amongst the hungry people. So long as there are hungry people in this country there is no dairy problem. We have plenty of hungry people within 100 yards of Leinster House. If needs be, let that milk be brought into Dublin in glass-lined tanks and given away to our people, who require it. In the long run, the cost of that operation, less the saving on public health services, less the saving on tuberculosis, less the saving on maintaining cripples who have grown up to be cripples through malnutrition, will amply compensate us for any assistance that it is necessary to give the dairy industry in order to enable it to carry out that service.
The development of casein, I believe, will assume very great proportions post-war, with the development of the plastics industry throughout the world. I am not going to go at length into the technical problems of the plastics industry but I say to the dairy farmers of this country the redemption of their industry as at present constituted is to be found in plastics and, if it is not to be found there, there is no redemption for it. I believe that it is to be found there. I believe that the Taoiseach's Industrial Research Council and cognate bodies should be busying themselves now to investigate the services that can be rendered to the dairy industries by the plastic industries in America and Great Britain and the other countries of Europe so that immediately post-war we can proceed to exploit the dairy industry with casein as its by-product and milk and store cattle as the main products for the people of this country.
Now, Sir, while I felt moved to refer to these matters because they have been given special significance to-day by the reference by the Leader of the Opposition to them, I cannot help feeling that dwelling at length on the petty domestic problems that confront us here in a time like this is to leave ourselves in this House open to the charge that we are turning our backs upon reality and misleading our own people as to the true situation which confronts us. At this moment, while Dáil Eireann is sitting, a world revolution is being determined the issue of which will determine the fate of our country. I say that the policy of our Government vis-a-vis that world situation is wrong.
Comment on this
The Deputy must remember that the Vote for the Department of External Affairs has been disposed of.
Comment on this
I am dealing with Government policy. I understand that on the Estimate for External Affairs we can deal only with administration. I understand that to-day the policy of the Government can be discussed and I submit it has been discussed.
Comment on this
There is a specific Vote for Agriculture, for Supplies and a variety of other matters and they have been disposed of and they have all been discussed in regard to general policy here to-day. I only want to discuss the general policy of the Government of Éire in the person of the Taoiseach of the State who is here present to answer for his own Vote and I want to say that I believe that the policy of the Government of Éire, vis-á-vis the world revolution which is at present proceeding, corresponds neither with the interest nor the honour of this country.
Comment on this
The Deputy is going into the matter of neutrality, which is the definite policy of this Parliament and this country. That cannot be assailed here.
Comment on this
I am certainly not going to challenge that ruling, but I am going to proceed with my speech. This House is the last citadel where an elected representative of the Irish people can speak his mind freely. Until that right is denied the elected representatives of the Irish people I propose to exercise it freely here. I say that the policy of the Government of Éire, vis-a-vis the world revolution which is proceeding, corresponds neither to the honour nor the interests of Ireland. I take first the honour of our country, for this is that imperishable asset for which we stand trustee and by the effective stewardship of which our record before posterity will ultimately be judged. If this country has stood for anything in the world, it stood for the principle of justice, and whatever the cost in material goods or human suffering, we have defended that principle. We have refused to purchase peace or prosperity or temporal happiness by purchasing them with a consent, tacit or expressed, to that which we believed to violate justice. I believe that in the present war, amidst the multiplicity of issues involved, the only issue that really matters is the issue which is being contested all over the world, and that is, whether after this war men will be free to render unto Caesar the things that are Caesar's and unto God the things that are God's.
Comment on this
No. I am under no illusion. Sir, that the leading statesmen of Great Britain, the United States of America or any of the United Nations are angels, nor am I concerned with their persons. What I know is that if the United Nations win this war I shall be free to render unto God the things that are God's and to Caesar the things that are Caesar's and that if the Axis win this war I shall not.
Comment on this
I know I shall not and it is because I know that to be true that I am bound, so long as I am in public life, to tell my fellow-countrymen of the danger that confronts them. That is the danger. If the Axis prevail in this war, I tell my fellow-countrymen and fellow Deputies in this House that our freedom is at an end because the first concern of the German Reich will be to seize this country for its own world-dominion ends and, having established bases in our country for the control of the Atlantic approaches to Europe and having converted our country into a German Gibraltar of the Atlantic, they will be faced with this problem: that we have never submitted to the unjust aggression by any foreign power against our State and, with God's help, we never will. Faced with that knowledge, the German General Staff must tell its own Government that if these bases which they have seized on our west coast are to be rendered safe, the hinterland behind them must be made safe, lest, at some future date, a potential enemy should use that hinterland as a bridgehead from which to attack the German bases on our territory.
Comment on this
The policy of the Government of Eire has to do with it, and I am urging that, if this day should come to pass, our people will be confronted with the situation that the Government of the Reich must either exterminate the liberty-loving Irish people who survive in Ireland or proceed to Nazify them. I tell my colleagues in the House and the people in the country that, if the Germans attempt to Nazify this country, there will ensue a religious persecution more ferocious than has ever been seen in Ireland.
Comment on this
Why has it not? Surely it has a relation? May I, as a person who entirely disagrees with what Deputy Dillon is speaking of at the moment, say that it is surely in order on the Taoiseach's Estimate to discuss the position of this State in relation to the world?
Comment on this
There was a specific Vote in relation to External Affairs which has been disposed of.
Comment on this
As Deputy Dillon has pointed out, there was a specific Vote in relation to Supplies and Deputy Hannigan was allowed to refer to wind and cold.
Comment on this
It is a matter of terminology as to how far a reference is a passing reference, but I suggest that the entire activities of Government are open for discussion on the Taoiseach's Vote. I, myself, hope to discuss supplies, industry and possibly the war situation and I do not see why I, or any other Deputy, should be prevented from doing so.
Comment on this
I say that in face of that situation, our people will be confronted with a religious persecution. Our people will resist that persecution, and, in the ensuing situation, only those with the fortitude of martyrs will keep the Faith. For us to lose sight of that fundamental fact is, in my submission to the House, suicidal, because it will mean that in the futile hope of preserving our people from temporal suffering, which I know animates the great majority of those who believe in the policy of neutrality, it will bring down upon their heads a degree of temporal and spiritual disaster incomparably greater than the very formidable trials to which they would be exposed, were they to place at the disposal of Great Britain and the United States of America such facilities as these States at present require for the defence of the lifeline which connects America and Great Britain at present.
Comment on this
Surely it is the policy of the Government, and surely, by the fact that this State is free, every Deputy is entitled to speak his mind upon the policy of the Government, the Oireachtas or any other question.
Comment on this
That is another story, and every man must let his own conscience be his guide in that matter.
Comment on this
Every man must let his own conscience be his guide and do what he thinks is right. That is the sole criterion by which any person can regulate his conduct in face of the situation with which we are confronted at present. I recognise the anxiety which disturbs the minds of those Deputies who have complete confidence in the omniscience, the wisdom and the discretion of the Taoiseach, and I recognise also that the Taoiseach, with supreme political skill, has managed to identify, in the minds of our people, neutrality and Ireland's right to freedom. My submission is that this identification is a complete illusion. Our freedom and sovereign independence place upon us, the sovereign Parliament of Ireland, the duty of determining from day to day, from week to week and from year to year, what our policy shall be, and to say to us that to depart from one policy and adopt another is to sacrifice that sovereignty is a travesty of the facts. It is only because we are a sovereign people; it is only because it is we, the people of Ireland, who have the right to determine what we, the people of Ireland, should do, that we have the privilege and duty now of reviewing from week to week the policy of this nation and of determining on behalf of the Irish people what that policy shall be. Ours to decide; ours the responsibility; ours the duty; and ours the trust to determine what this country will do in this period of world crisis. We, the elected representatives of the people, are under no bond of honour or obligation to follow one policy or another. Our only duty is to follow the policy which we, the elected representatives of the people, believe to be right. That is our duty, and it is because it is my duty to argue with the elected representatives of the people for the establishment of what is right that I feel constrained to speak as I speak here to-day.
Comment on this
It may have been, but surely it is open to discussion? I am in favour of that policy, but I am not in favour of a policy of suppressing all comment on it. Is this a free House? Let us not get Nazi altogether.
Comment on this
On the merits of this issue, both as to our interests and our honour, I believe this policy to be wrong, but in that connection I ask the House very specially to consider one aspect of the situation which, I believe, should influence the mind of every one of us in the House. No one but a very foolish man believes that he can long survive without a friend in the world. What would each one of us as individual men think of a friend who protested his friendship for us and who, when the hour of crisis came, when we stood in mortal peril, turned to us and told us that he regretted he was not in a position to be of any assistance? Would we not feel that his friendship was of questionable value? Twentytwo years ago, the Taoiseach of to-day represented the Irish nation in America, and, speaking at Birmingham, Alabama, he said that if there had been no United States, there would never have been an Irish Republic.
Comment on this
By the mercy of God's Providence, Eamon de Valera is living in the current year, and I am sure that both friends and enemies will combine in wishing him many more years of survival. I am talking now about that man called Eamon de Valera, who is sitting in the position of Taoiseach of Éire.
Comment on this
I must protest again, Sir. Is it not possible to quote what a member of the House said previously and to contrast it with present conditions?
Comment on this
Leaving America in January, 1921, Mr. de Valera, as he then was, used these words:
"Land of the free and home of the brave, Farewell! May you ever remain as I have known you, land of the generous-hearted and the kindly. May you stand through time as they would have you who love you—Liberty's chosen champion; and oh, may you never know yourself the agony of a foreign master's lash. I came to you on a holy mission, a mission of Freedom; I return to my people who sent me, not indeed, as I had dreamed it, with the mission accomplished, but, withal, a message that will cheer in the dark days that have come upon them, and that will inspire the acceptance of such sacrifices as must yet be made. So farewell—young, fortunate, mighty land; no wish that I can express can measure the depth of my esteem for you and my desire for your welfare and glory. And farewell the many dear friends I have made and the tens of thousands who, for the reason that I was the representative of a noble nation and a storied, appealing cause, gave me honours they denied to princes—you will not need to be assured that Ireland will not forget and that Ireland will not be ungrateful."
Those are fine words. On July 31st, 1919, Mr. de Valera, as he then was, said:—
"It is in this fact, ...that American ideals and American traditions are ideals and traditions of liberty and fearless justice, that Ireland's hope lies; and, with Ireland's, the hope of the world."
I want to say most expressly, and in special reference to that extract of July 31, 1919, that I subscribe entirely to what he said.
Comment on this
From an article written by Mr. de Valera, or a speech made by him, on July 31, 1919. I cannot be certain whether it was a speech or not.
Comment on this
No, I do not think so. The message that you quoted was written by me on leaving America.
Comment on this
At any rate, the words are that "American ideals and American traditions are ideals and traditions of liberty and fearless justice, and that in that fact lies Ireland's hope, and, with Ireland's, the hope of the world". I imagine there is no paragraph in that which the Taoiseach would care to amend, as of to-day.
Comment on this
These words ring as true to-day as they rang 23 years ago, and my submission to this House is that in that extract of July 31, 1919, the Taoiseach displayed a very rare political perspicacity. The sovereignty and independence of this country depend on the Irish-American alliance. We have for generations maintained, in the very teeth of a powerful, military, imperial nation, a struggle for freedom, and its ultimate success and the maintenance of an independent State during the last three years of war, because we enjoyed the goodwill of the American nation.
It was the knowledge that any quarrel with our country would immediately create ill-feeling in the United States that strengthened our diplomacy during those difficult times and enabled us, in times of extraordinary difficulty and gravity, to survive the disaster that must otherwise have overtaken us. I say that if we lose that now, we will find ourselves, post-war, without a single friend in the world. I say that if Great Britain is destroyed in this war, we will find ourselves with the markets upon which we have been accustomed to depend, the employment which our people are at present enjoying and have enjoyed for generations through the absorption of our surplus university graduates, vanished overnight.
In my judgment, no material considerations, great as they are, and though I have felt it my duty to recapitulate them here, would justify me or any other elected representative of our people in advocating the shedding of one drop of Irish blood. I would not stake the life or the safety of one single mother's son in this country on any material considerations, however great or however valuable to those who held them. But a situation arises when, side by side with these material considerations, or indeed completely independent of them, we are confronted with a position in which our personal honour, as the friends beholden to the people of the United State of America, is involved.
We have leant on them in times of stress and difficulty and have turned to them individually and collectively, never to be turned down, never to be rejected, never to be disowned, but always to be welcomed, always to be championed, always to be helped. We find them now turning to us for the first time and saying: "In the extraordinary world situation which now envelops our nation of 120,000,000 backed with every material wealth and power that the mind of man can conceive, we find in your keeping—the people of Ireland—something of incalculable value to us in an hour when our very survival is at stake; something in your keeping which may mean the difference between survival for the United States of America and its dismemberment and destruction by those who are regarded as the enemies of democracy and individual liberty and who want to see them go." When they turn to us and ask for that thing, knowing that it will cost us dear to give it, knowing that it may involve us in great suffering, in fierce ordeal, and in mighty jeopardy, I was brought up to believe that ours was a people and ours was a nation who would reply: "Whatever the jeopardy, whatever the cost, whatever the suffering, we know the obligations of friendship and we discharge them." That, as I see it, would be the proper standard for our people, but it no longer seems to be so. Over and above that, however, if that standard has gone by the board, if that be a wrong standard, there is another consideration.
Comment on this
Would the Deputy get back to the Taoiseach's Vote now, and away from external affairs.
Comment on this
I am appealing to the Deputy to get back to the Taoiseach's Vote and away from external affairs, as he has spent nearly half an hour on external affairs already.
Comment on this
On a point of order. Is it not possible to discuss external affairs on the Taoiseach's Vote, as external affairs form part of the Taoiseach's duty?
Comment on this
I already said that external affairs could be discussed on this Vote by way of a passing reference.
Comment on this
I want to make the position clear, because I was hoping to discuss that matter myself.
Comment on this
I said that Deputy Dillon must get away from external affairs and discuss the Taoiseach's Vote. We had a specific Vote already with regard to external affairs.
Comment on this
Yes, but I submit that it is a matter that can be discussed on the Taoiseach's Vote.
Comment on this
Over and above the considerations to which I referred, I want to say that in the multifarious interests and issues joined between the warring parties in the world to-day——
Comment on this
I am not. I am discussing exclusively the functions of the Taoiseach, the Head of the Government of Éire, and the policy of the Government of which he stands Head, and nothing else, and I suggest that that is relevant to the Taoiseach's Vote —of that there can be no doubt.
Comment on this
The Chair has pointed out that there was a specific Vote for External Affairs, and the matter which the Deputy is now discussing could have been more properly raised on that Vote.
Comment on this
I am going to say what I conceive to be my duty to say, and I will ask no greater indulgence from the Chair than it affords to every other Deputy. That is all, but I claim that as a right and will defend it, not only for myself, but for every elected representative in this House, because it is the right of us all, and it may not be taken from the least amongst us without striking at the most eminent of our numbers. I say that over and above every other issue that obsesses my mind is the question of whether men in this country may continue freely to render to God the things that are God's, and to Caesar the things that are Caesar's.
Comment on this
I say that all over the world people are being denied that right at the present time. I say that a denial of that right was first forecast in the Encyclical Letter, "Mit Brennender Sorge," of Pope Pius XI. I say that the forecast contained in that letter has been amply vindicated by the events in Poland, Czechoslovakia, France and every other country which the Nazis have conquered, and the testimony of that is to be found in the bitter protests of bishops not only of the Catholic Church but of the Protestant Christian Churches of Europe. I beg our people to open their eyes to the fact in time, that it is that essential freedom, without which we cannot live, which is at present in jeopardy in the world, and that if it perishes this country will be the last citadel in which it will be defended and as the last citadel will suffer indescribable horrors.
My concern is to protect our own people from that suffering. I know that the vast majority of informed Deputies of this House realise that, in the event of a Nazi victory, my prognostications are true. I know that some ill-informed Deputies do not foresee these appalling contingencies, and imagine that such a victory can eventuate without any serious repercussions on our own country. I am trying to warn them, while there is still time, of the knowledge that if such a disaster as a Nazi triumph should come upon Europe and the world Ireland will be engulfed in it, and will be one of the most cruel sufferers because the keystone of Nazi ascendancy is the destruction of Christianity, and the only effective champion—I say effective champion—in my judgment that is left of true Christianity in the world is the Catholic Church to which 98 per cent. of our people belong. The persecution and attempted extirpation will involve our people in suffering compared with which that of past times would be as nothing. This country has still time to take its stand upon these issues. It has still the opportunity to take that stand with friends about us. If we do not want to let disaster come upon the world, and Nazism to prevail, then a moral obligation will drive our people into taking that stand or they will live to fight alone.
It is the deep consciousness of those facts that constrains me to raise this issue straightly and bluntly on the Taoiseach's Vote. I suppose there are some who will adopt the sneering reference of the Minister for the Co-ordination of Defensive Measures who described me as a minority of one. Maybe I am a minority of one, but there was a figure in classical history that had that distinction, too, and the events justified her. Cassandra warned the Trojan people of their dangers and of how, what they thought to be the policy of conciliation and forbearance would precipitate disaster on the Trojan people. She was rejected. She knew the torture of seeing the future with certainty and of being unable to convince her people. She saw with horror and consternation flame and ruin envelop her native city and destroy her people and its leaders. God forbid that that should ever overtake this country, but worse than the flame, worse than the destruction and worse than the extermination of our leaders would be the generation of persecution which we would certainly have to face if Nazism should prevail in the world.
I am saying deliberately that in the conflict at present proceeding there is no room for neutrals. If people agree with me, that the mighty issues to which I have referred are really joined between the parties, then those who are not with right and justice are against them. I say that in my judgment those who withhold from the United States of America and Great Britain and the united nations the help which would assist them to overcome this world peril are, in fact, helping that peril to prevail.
Comment on this
I want this nation to do all it can to help the united nations to prevail and to face any danger with which it is challenged by Germany in the course of that duty——
Comment on this
——to face any threat, any danger and any sacrifice that is called for effectively to discharge their duty. That is what I want. I do not want, and I have never attempted to minimise or reduce the magnitude of that enterprise.
Comment on this
I have never sought to represent to the members of this House, or to the people of this country, that that is a decision lightly to be taken, or a course of conduct which can be pursued without serious stress, danger, suffering and perhaps mighty loss. In that full knowledge I say that a united nation, loyally accepting the decision of the legitimate Government, is capable of acting. I deny that any external power by any threat, seduction or corruption can divide our people in civil war. The Irish people are capable of accepting a verdict freely given by their own Government. The Irish people are capable of loyally serving the constitutional legitimate Government of the Irish people.
Comment on this
There is but one Government, the Government of Oireachtas Eireann headed at this moment by Eamon de Valera. There is only one legitimate Government in this country and I say that no power on earth can start a civil war in this country or question the authority of that Government. So long as it retains the confidence of the majority of our people, there will be found Deputies on these benches, on the Fine Gael Benches and on the Labour Benches, if there are none on the Fianna Fáil Benches, to defend that authority with their lives if needs be, whether that Government pursues what we consider to be the right or the wrong course. I do not accept the Taoiseach's classical dictum that the people have no right to do wrong. I say that the people have the right to go politically wrong, though, of course, they have no right to override the moral law of God. They have the right to choose their own Government, whether it is the best or the worst Government, and their choice of that Government imposes an obligation upon me and on every other citizen of this State, under the law of God, loyally to accept its dictates and give effect to them, but it does not impose an obligation to silence our voices and to deny our consciences, to remain silent when we believe that it is our duty to speak out. It does not constrain us to give tacit assent to that which we believe not to be in the best interests of our country. On the contrary, the best testimony to the solidity and to the unshakableness of the legitimate Government is that every well-intentioned and law-abiding citizen shall have the right to speak freely, fully protected in the knowledge that in this country we have no longer need to fear the threat of civil war.
Let no external elements imagine that they can coerce our people by the threat of fomenting civil war. Let no external Government, who employs secret agents in this country for the purpose of stirring up civil war, and imagine that these agents will succeed. We have seen them come by parachute, with money to purchase civil war, and they have learned over the last two years that their best effort to that end has failed, in face of devoted service from the voluntary public servants of this State in the L.D.F., the L.S.F., and the Army, who are neither Fianna Fáil, Fine Gael, Labour, or otherwise, but Irishmen who recognise that the first obligation they have after their duty to God is to support the legitimate Government of the country and the authority of that Government.
Dismiss from your minds all questions of civil war. This country is capable of taking a firm decision and acting on it, and no threat of civil war will unseat the sovereign authority of Oireachtas Eireann, so firmly established by the sacrifices of generation after generation of our people. Deputy Cooney's threat of civil war does not frighten me. Let them come on, whoever wants civil war in this country, and they will find a Government and an Oireachtas who will put an end to civil war, and who will demonstrate for all time that there is no rule of law in this country but the law of the majority of our people freely expressed.
There is a Government headed by Eamon de Valera, elected by the free vote of the people. So long as it is there, no threat of civil war will supplant it, and I believe the life of every Deputy in this House is warrant for that undertaking. No threat of civil war, nor, as I hope, any other threat, will affect the minds of Deputies in determining what is the proper course to pursue. My submission is that there is one test and one test only and that is: what is it right for this Government to do and, having determined what it is right for us to do, to do it, using the best resources we may command to mitigate the consequences of our action, however grave and onerous they may be. The day we renege upon that resolution we become the plaything of every blackmailer who chooses to threaten us.
I have told this House, as I have told my constituents and as I have told my fellow-countrymen, what I think it is the right thing to do. I have to-day wrought with my associates in this House to persuade them that the course of conduct I have in mind is the course of conduct which should commend itself to them. If and when the march of events or the power of argument should bring them round to my view, then let all sides of the House say, now that decision, deliberately taken by the sole governing authority of this country as to what the policy of Ireland will be, will receive the same loyal united support from a sovereign Irish people as this Government have received so far in pursuit of the policy which they deemed it their duty to prescribe for Ireland up to now.
I do not want to conclude my observations without re-affirming a matter of fact which it is my duty, as an advocate of a certain course of conduct, to place on record. I still believe that the neutrality policy of the Government and of the leading Opposition Party in this House is a policy which at the present time commends itself to the vast majority of the Irish people. That is a fact which I am obliged to place on record as a public duty. I believe the vast majority of my fellow-countrymen to be wrong in that conclusion. I believe it to be my duty to argue with them against that conclusion. But it would be a dishonest thing on my part if any words of mine were to mislead my friends in this country or this country's friends outside. Much as I desire to see our country play its part in the mighty drama that is at present being enacted in the world, that desire is not shared by the majority of my fellow-countrymen. I would to God it were. I hope and pray it yet may be. But I thank God that we still have in this country the freedom and the right to argue and to strive with our fellow-countrymen so that what we believe to be truth may be made to prevail, and that they, seeking truth, may be afforded the opportunity of finding it.
Comment on this
Bhí me ag éisteacht go haireach leis an Teachta Diolún ar feadh cúig noiment déag is dachad. Do bhí sé ag caint ar an meastachán seo atá ós comhair an Tighe, agus deirim i láthair an Teachta agus i láthair na Dála uilig gur chuir sé dódh croidhe orm a bheith ag éisteacht leis agus tá é.
Comment on this
Do réir mo bhreitheamhnais, go gcuirfe sé an galar céadna ar mhuintir na hÉireann, nuair a léighfidh siad páipéar nuaidheachta an lae amáirigh, sin é, má scríobhtar ins na páipéirí, an chaint a thug sé uaidh annso indiu.
Comment on this
Casfaí leat fear, anois agus aris, agus déarfadh sé leat gur fear léigheanta é, an Teachta Diolún. Deirim-se, más seadh, go bhfuil sé imease na ndaoine léigheanta, a raibh an sean-rá as Gaedhilg ag tagairt dóibh. Níl ins an sean-rá sin. ach aon líne amháin agus ritheann sé man seo: "Ní fearr an iomarea den léigheann ná faoí n-a bhun."
Certainly the wisdom of that old Irish saying was never more fully demonstrated than it has been this evening by Deputy Dillon in the words he has addressed to this House, words calculated to cause disquiet, uneasiness and disunion in this country to a higher degree than anything the least learned Deputy could possibly contribute. Immediately following the outbreak of war in September, 1939, this House by unanimous resolution decided that the policy of the country towards the hostilities then prevailing was that of neutrality.
Comment on this
It is true. That decision then come to had the approval of more than 95 per cent. of the people of the country. Notwithstanding that fact, the Deputy, vacillating politician that he is, shifted from one side to another, changed his mind after September, 1939, and spoke in the country in defiance of that decision. In this House he denies that the people have the right to pursue a policy of neutrality. Was there ever such a display of effrontery? The Deputy comes into this House and, notwithstanding that he admits that more than 95 per cent. of the people support the policy of neutrality, he denies their right to do that. He assumes that he has more grey matter in his skull than 95 per cent. of the people added together. In my opinion it was the greatest demonstration of vanity that was ever presented in this House, vanity personified in the person of Deputy James M. Dillon. You all probably heard the story of the old lady who was standing on the side-walk waiting for the march past of a regiment of which her son was a member. As the section in which her son was marched passed, it was observed by everybody that the son was out of step, but the old lady rubbed her hands with glee and she said: "My James is the only one who has the step."
Comment on this
This is not a regiment; this is the Parliament of the nation. There is a great difference.
Comment on this
And the Deputy is the marshal. I am satisfied that every enemy of this country, both inside and outside the country, will rub his hands with glee when he reads what Deputy Dillon said in the House this evening. The Deputy has definitely asserted that neutrality will bring temporal and spiritual disaster to this country. Therefore, the judgement of 95 per cent. of our people is a judgement conducive to the bringing of spiritual and temporal disaster to this island. As I have stated, I am convinced that it will give comfort, consolation and joy to every enemy of this land, whether inside or outside our territory, to read the words that Deputy Dillon has uttered this evening. The Deputy is welcome to the approval of these people, but I would prefer to stand in with the men and women who are determined to preserve that neutrality, with the men and women who are prepared even to die in defence of that neutrality. I prefer to stand in with the ordinary men and women of this country, with the type of people who are cutting their turf on the bogs of Shrah, because I believe they have more national and political wisdom than this highly vocal Deputy.
Those vocal powers he has exercised in addressing words to this House that are of a highly disturbing character. They are words that he is free to utter because of his position as a Deputy of this House. If any ordinary man at the cross-roads in Clare spoke words similar to those spoken by Deputy Dillon this evening, or if any person addressing a meeting in Cathal Brugha Street to-night spoke words similar to those used by Deputy Dillon in this House, he would find himself inside prison walls by to-morrow morning. There are many men within prison walls in this country who have done less to disturb the peace of the country than Deputy Dillon has by his words this evening, and I am not satisfied that the Minister for Justice is doing his duty when men like Deputy Dillon are not placed in a position where it would not be possible for them to do anything further to disturb peace and good order in this country. It is quite true, it cannot be gainsaid. No doubt the Deputy, before he entered the House, took steps to ensure that the contribution he has made would find its way to publication outside this country, whether the Censor agreed or not.
Comment on this
On a point of order. The statement that has just been made by the Deputy is without a shadow of foundation, is quite untrue. Is it right or sensible for the Deputy, or is it in order openly to accuse me of something illegal, of a breach of the law? It would be quite illegal even to attempt to communicate any matter outside this country whether the Censor approved it or not. Of course, it is unthinkable I should do it, but is it right for the Deputy to allege I did it? Surely not?
Comment on this
He has alleged that no doubt I sought to secure publication of what I was about to say here, outside the country, with or without the approval of the Censor. That would be clearly against the law. It is certainly false, but is it in order for the Deputy to state it? I do not think so.
Comment on this
The Deputy did make the allegation and I do not think he will deny it, despite what the Chair has said.
Comment on this
On a point of order. The Deputy has alleged that doubtless before I came in here I took measures to ensure publication of what I would say, with or without the consent of the Censor. That charges me with a manifestly unlawful act. I deny, of course, that I did such a thing, but I question the Parliamentary propriety of the Deputy making the allegation against a fellow Deputy, or at least not expressing his regret for having made it when it is explained to him that he is in error.
Comment on this
I can recall a few days ago when the Minister for Justice came in here with a document correcting the Deputy in some mis-statement he made and I do not recollect that the Deputy made any apology for the mis-statement.
Comment on this
I understood the Deputy to say that Deputy Dillon made arrangements to have this published outside the House.
Comment on this
If Deputy O'Loghlen accused Deputy Dillon of consorting with the enemy or communicating with persons outside the country, he would not be in order, and I am sure he would withdraw such a statement.
Comment on this
But I made no such allegation as that the Deputy was consorting with people outside this country. The Deputy has, by his words here to-day——
Comment on this
On a point of order. Deputy O'Loghlen has alleged that before I came into this House no doubt I had taken precautions to secure the publication inside and outside this country of what I was about to say, whether the Censor permitted it or not. That is to allege an unlawful act against me. Deputy O'Loghlen does not go back on his own words.
Comment on this
That was definitely said, and I do not see why the Chair should complicate the issue by suggesting association with the enemy.
Comment on this
It is alleging an unlawful act against me. It should be unnecessary for me to deny it, but, nevertheless, I do deny it categorically.
Comment on this
It is not in order for Deputy O'Loghlen to make the allegation which the Deputy says he has made, and I will ask him to withdraw that portion of his speech.
Comment on this
I suggest that a wrong construction has been placed on what I said. I am not at all satisfied that what I have said is contrary to the law. The attempt to do a thing and the doing of it are two different matters altogether. An act should be performed before it would be contrary to the law.
Comment on this
I am defending liberty of speech in this House against the Deputy and the Chair or against the whole House.
Comment on this
I will answer that, Sir. I have made a statement as against the Chair in this respect that the Chair, in ruling on the point of order that Deputy Dillon asked a ruling on, had brought in a phrase which was not used by Deputy O'Loghlen or by Deputy Dillon and I suggest that was an undesirable thing to do. If it was done by inadvertence then I suppose it will have to pass muster but I suggest it did not bear that impression. It was putting an interpretation in order to give a ruling.
Comment on this
What I understood Deputy McGilligan to say was that he was standing up for liberty of speech against the Chair.
Comment on this
So I am, and I think the ruling you attempted to give here to-day would have narrowly restricted liberty of speech in this House. I propose to discuss that to-night.
Comment on this
The conduct of the Chair can be discussed in a relevant way, but, whoever is occupying the Chair here, whatever the Chair says goes, in accordance with the Standing Orders of this House and in accordance with the ordinary Rules of Procedure. To come back to the point between Deputy Dillon and Deputy O'Loghlen. The point is this: Deputy O'Loghlen has stated that Deputy Dillon made arrangements before he delivered his speech to have it delivered and reported and circulated outside. Deputy Dillon denies that he made any such arrangement.
Comment on this
Deputy Dillon denies that he made any such arrangement and, in the face of that denial, I would ask Deputy O'Loghlen to withdraw the allegation he has made.
Comment on this
I would ask Deputy O'Loghlen to withdraw that portion of his speech making the charge in respect of Deputy Dillon of having made previous arrangements for the publication outside of his speech.
Comment on this
I have sound reason to believe the accuracy of what I have said but, in deference to the Chair, I withdraw it.
Comment on this
On a point of order, when a Deputy is asked to withdraw his statement, is he entitled to preface his withdrawal by saying, notwithstanding, that he believes in the accuracy of what he has stated? Is that a withdrawal? I am asking for a ruling on a point of order. If that is in order it will be of general interest and possibly will be used in the House afterwards.