Intoxicating Liquor Bill, 1942—Committee Stage (resumed).
Contributions 191–390 of 390. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 17 of 1942 ›
I just want to make a short protest against the selling of wine by pharmaceutical chemists. In the North of Ireland they sell wine, but I think in Britain the right to do so has been taken away from them altogether. As far as I know the trade, those chemists sell ordinary wine, and, according to the best experts, it is cheap and bad wine. A lot of women who are addicted to drinking wine make an excuse of going to the chemists and getting a bottle of wine at all hours of the day and night. I take this opportunity of protesting against the selling of wine by chemists. I believe that, on the best analysis, those so-called medicated wines are only so much dope, but apart from medicated wines those chemists get all brands of every cheap kind of grocers' port and sell them at great profit to themselves. They should be prohibited, in this or any other advanced country, from selling wines at all.
Comment on this
I move amendment No.20:—
Before the word "and" in line 31 to insert the following words: "for premises which are an hotel or a restaurant".
I should like to say a few preliminary words with regard to the amendments generally which are down in my name. They are practically all amendments which I have been asked by the Irish Tourist Association to sponsor. A few have been suggested to me by the branch of the Tourist Association in Killarney. The proposals embodied in those amendments are directed towards conveniencing the visitors to tourist areas. They are not at all inspired by members of the licensed trade, as far as I know. Indeed, as far as I am concerned, no member of the licensed trade in my constituency approached me with a view to suggesting any amendments at all. I do not say that I would not do so; indeed I would, because, apart altogether from Deputy Daly's eulogy of the licensed trade here yesterday, which I think was entirely unnecessary, I could never understand why it was considered quite a respectable thing to brew or to distil or to own brewery shares or distillery shares, but it was not respectable to sell the product of the distilleries. I hope the Minister will meet those amendments with an open mind. In bringing legislation before this House, the Minister has the very good record that when he comes into the House he does not dig in his heels and say: "I and my advisers are right, and everybody else is wrong." He does not take up that attitude, and I hope he will not be inspired to take up that attitude with regard to some of those amendments that we have yet to deal with on the Order Paper. Yesterday, unfortunately I think, Deputy Linehan used some very tactless remarks when the Minister gave way to the general feeling in the House with regard to rural opening; Deputy Linehan referred to the slippery slopes, and suggested that the Minister was weakening. Immediately after that the Minister did dig in his heels very strongly on the question of the general Sunday opening. With regard to the coming amendments, I hope the Minister will not adopt the attitude that they must be wrong, and that what his advisers say must essentially be right; I hope he will keep an open mind, and deal with them on their merits. As I have said, most of those amendments, including this one, were suggested to me by the Irish Tourist Association.
The effect of this particular amendment, No. 20, would be to enable any holder of an on-licence, that is not necessarily the proprietor of an hotel or restaurant, to apply for an exemption order on any special occasion, that is, for a dance, and so on. I was told by the directors of the Tourist Association that very many of the best-conducted dance halls in some of the tourist centres are owned by the proprietors of licensed premises, and they think it would be an advantage, from the point of view of the tourist trade in some of those areas, if this facility were granted.
It does not mean anything further than this—that that person is empowered to go and make his application to the court, just as at the present time the proprietor of an hotel or restaurant can go to the court and apply for a special exemption order. In this matter, I cannot see any real reason for distinguishing between the proprietor of an hotel or restaurant and the proprietor of an ordinary business premises. I am assured by the Tourist Association—to be perfectly candid, I did not know this myself— that a considerable number of the dance halls in tourist areas are run by very respectable licensed premises owners, who conduct their business in the best manner from the point of view of observation of the licensing laws.
Comment on this
If the Minister is remaining adamant on the original Bill, and doing away with the bona fide traffic from 12 midnight on Sunday until 6 a.m. on Monday, the acceptance of this amendment moved by Deputy Lynch would place certain publicans in a very privileged position, because apart from tourist centres there are a number of publicans in the country who own the dance halls adjoining them. Ninety per cent. of the dances in rural Ireland are run on Sunday nights. The result of the acceptance of this amendment would be that the owners of those public houses in the country could apply for an exemption order, and, whilst the other publicans in the town were closed down from 12 midnight on Sunday till 6 a.m. on Monday morning, those privileged few would have the monopoly of selling refreshments in this way. I know several cases in the Midlands and the West where the publican is also the owner of the dance hall. I am not against this arrangement at all if the Minister concedes that we continue the system whereby bona fide traffic is allowed from 12 midnight on Sunday till 6 a.m. on Monday. If that is continued I am not opposed to this amendment, but, if the Minister is adamant on doing away with the bona fide traffic from midnight on Sunday to 6 a.m. on Monday, then the acceptance of this amendment would place a certain number of publicans in a privileged position.
Comment on this
I question that very much. Suppose there is a dance in a certain town. Can an hotel proprietor or restaurant proprietor—the Deputy is a lawyer and can inform me —open after 8 p.m. on a Sunday evening to supply intoxicating drinks? We shall take it in another way. Can a hotel proprietor or a restaurant proprietor open to supply intoxicating drinks to people attending a dance from 12 midnight until 6 a.m. at present, or if the Bill passes as it is? I do not think he can.
Comment on this
The provision in the Bill reads: "Section 5 of the Act of 1927 is hereby amended by the deletion in sub-section (1) of the words ‘and are situate in a county borough.'" Section 5 of the Act of 1927 provides: "If the holder of an hotel or a restaurant and are situate in a county borough applies to the justice of the district court for an order (in this Act referred to as a special exemption order) exempting him on any special occasion from the provisions of this Act relating to prohibited hours in respect of the said premises, such justice may, if he thinks fit so to do after hearing the officer in charge of the Gárda Síochána for the licensing area, grant to the applicant upon such conditions as he thinks proper an order so exempting him during the hours and on the special occasion to be specified in such order." That was before confined to the county boroughs. The Minister's proposal in the Bill is to extend that to the proprietors of hotels and restaurants throughout the country, a proposal with which I entirely agree. But if the hotels and restaurants in the country are given the right to make that application—and mind you it is only just power to make application to the district justice—I see no reason whatever why we should differentiate between the owner of an hotel or restaurant and the owner of a licensed premises who is in a position to provide amusements. In many of the tourist areas it is the proprietor of licensed premises who is in a position to provide facilities for dancing during the tourist season. I would, therefore, ask the Minister to consider that point, and to agree to my amendment.
Comment on this
So far as I know, public houses have not dance halls attached, which are actually part of the licensed premises, while hotels and restaurants often have. I do not think there is much point in this amendment. As far as I know, the owner of licensed premises who has a dance hall, not part of the licensed premises, can get an occasional licence for that dance hall.
Comment on this
Not for a licensed premises, but if he has a dance hall as a separate premises he can get an occasional licence for that.
Comment on this
Yes. Even marquees on the occasion of a fête could get an occasional licence. The same thing applies to anyone who has a dance hall. I do not think that there is any public house or licensed premises suitable for a dance.
Comment on this
I do not want Deputy Lynch to think that I have got my heels dug in, but as far as the other matter is concerned I am quite satisfied that I could not do it. This is a departure with which I am not inclined to agree. If a man has a dance hall and it is not attached to licensed premises, it is possible to get an occasional licence.
Comment on this
I am told under the Act of '62 as amended by the '27 Act, Section 6. A person can get an occasional licence, even for a marquee out in a field.
Comment on this
The point I would put to the Minister is that a hall and a licensed premises may be under the one roof. Can the owner of the hall and the licensed premises apply for permission to sell intoxicating drink from 12 o'clock midnight until 6 a.m. or 3 a.m. on Monday morning when, under this Bill, it is proposed to close every other public house to all kinds of traffic?
Comment on this
I am told that this amendment would be impracticable, anyhow.
Comment on this
The opening to which the Minister refers seems to be limited to the hours between sunrise and sunset.
Comment on this
Where there is a public ball there is an exception. It is a very intricate section.
Comment on this
I am agreeable to accept Deputy McGilligan's amendment, No. 23.
Comment on this
Mine has a wider area in view than that of the Minister, No. 21. I understood that this was a transfer that was regarded as a desirable one and, that being the case, I thought that, in the wider area, the transfer could be better effected. The Minister is going to look into the wider areas?
Comment on this
I am prepared to do that. That was put to me also by the licensed vintners. I am prepared to accept the principle, but the amendment may need redrafting.
Comment on this
I am not sure whether amendment No. 24, which is in my name, is necessary. The Minister's own amendment would seem to say that it can be done at a sitting of the district court. Does that mean a sitting of the district court anywhere?
Comment on this
On this section I want to ask a question. I think there is no doubt about it but there are people who have some doubts. Merely certifying that the premises are a restaurant only means that they are enabled to carry on a restaurant business during these hours and that they are not allowed to sell liquor? It does not mean that, so to speak, they can drift out into the sale of all sorts of intoxicants?
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 27:—
Section 13 of the Act of 1927, subsection (1), is hereby amended by the addition after the words "St. Patrick's Day" of the words "nor on any Christmas Day".
The object of this amendment is to allow a hotel or restaurant to serve liquor with a meal on Christmas Day. That is not permitted by the Act of 1927, though it is permitted on St. Patrick's Day. There seems to be no reason why it should not be allowed on Christmas Day also.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 29:—
Before Section 7 to insert a new section as follows:—
"Paragraph (e) of Section 14 of the Act of 1927 is hereby amended by the deletion of the words ‘Christmas Day' and ‘and St. Patrick's Day'."
This is an amendment to Section 14 of the Act of 1927. I think the Minister should give way on this as he has given way on the last one. Everyone knows that habits have changed enormously. People close up their houses at these holiday times, particularly at Christmas, and go to reside in hotels. I do not know what takes place now— whether on Christmas Eve they buy a bottle of whiskey or wine and bring it up to the room and put it in the locker for the Christmas Day dinner. I am opposed to people having to buy drink in bottles. I think it would be far better that they should order a glass of sherry, a glass of port or a glass of Beaune. I rather suspect that on the day these people arrive at the hotel they make provision for the following day. There is no harm in people taking a glass of wine at dinner on Christmas Day, and this is a reasonable amendment which I hope the Minister will accept.
Comment on this
I accept the amendment, which is a reasonable one.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 30:—
Before Section 7 to insert a new section as follows:—
Section 14 of the Act of 1927 is hereby amended by the addition of the following new paragraph:—
the sale by the holder of an on-licence (which is not a six-day licence) of intoxicating liquor for consumption on his licensed premises on any Sunday between the hours of 11 o'clock in the morning and 11 o'clock in the evening to persons who produce tickets showing that they have travelled by omnibus or other public vehicle for a distance of not less than ten miles from the place where they lodged during the previous night.
The object of this is to allow bus passengers to obtain refreshments on Sundays between the hours mentioned. At present railway passengers are entitled—and always have been entitled—to privileges of that kind at railway stations when travelling. I would like the Minister to consider some concession in this direction. I can assure him that the Irish Tourist Association has suggested to me that there is a strong case for it. Very frequently large excursion parties arrive in tourist areas on Sunday morning. I have seen Great Northern Railway buses arriving in Killarney at 9 or 10 o'clock in the morning. The passengers tour the lakes and start back in the late evening. Some provision should be made for tourists of that type, who spend one day in the area, to enable them to obtain reasonable refreshments.
Comment on this
That would be very difficult to work. I do not think there is any case for it, any more than for a man going by car. When it is a question of a railway passenger——
Comment on this
It would lead to all the old abuses. I ask the Deputy not to press it. I gave the Tourist Association no hope whatever on that point, I can assure the Deputy.
Comment on this
In the hope that the Minister may be induced, in amendment No. 42, to go a little further to 12 midnight instead of 11 o'clock, I will not move amendment No. 31, and will defer my remarks until we are discussing amendment No. 42.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 32:
Before Section 7 to insert a new section as follows:
Section 15 of the Act of 1927 is hereby amended by the deletion of sub-sections (1) and (2) and the substitution in lieu thereof of the following sub-sections, that is to say:
(1) Nothing in this Act shall operate to prohibit the holder of an on-licence (not being a six-day licence) in respect of premises which are not situate in a county borough from selling intoxicating liquor for consumption on such licensed premises to bona fide travellers:
(a) on any week-day, during a period of summer time, at any time except between the hours of one o'clock in the morning and six o'clock in the morning, or
(b) on any other week-day at any time except between the hours of midnight and six o'clock in the morning, or
(c) on any Sunday, during a period of summer time, between the hours of one o'clock in the afternoon and eight o'clock in the evening, or
(d) on any other Sunday, between the hours of one o'clock in the afternoon and seven in the evening.
I will not take the chance of waiting until the Minister comes to his own amendment, as there are some points I would like to make about this amendment of mine.
Comment on this
I would ask the Chair if we are to take a decision on all these amendments together, as we did on the 11 o'clock question.
Comment on this
I presume the House is agreeable to debate all these bona fide sections together, and have one decision.
Comment on this
On the Second Reading, the Minister said he would agree to bona fide traffic to 11.30 on an ordinary week-day. My amendment is to extend that to 1 a.m. summer time, or 11.30 by the sun. There are many reasons for it. One reason is that in my particular locality—Westmeath—we have the lakes where the dapping season at the end of May runs into June, and the tourists there fish until it is dark. They fish near villages like Finea and Castletown, where there are no hotels, and where they board in public houses. There is no reason why these men should not be entitled to refreshment. It is daylight at 11.30— which is 10 o'clock by the sun—and they keep out on the lakes. The Green fly fishing is followed by the Morrough fly, and there is trout fishing all the summer, and these people should be entitled to get a drink when they come in. Very often they stay five or six miles from the lake. There was a time when they came by motor, but they come now by bicycle.
In the same way, men who come into town to attend a circus should be entitled to a drink after the circus; or if the local dramatic society puts on a drama or a concert, they should be entitled to a drink when they come out. These performances cannot be billed as they are billed for a theatre in Dublin. You cannot say that the performance will commence at 8 o'clock summer time. The performance will commence when the people have done their work; they will troop in at dark and go by the sun time. There should not be a taboo against their getting drink. If there is a dance or a ceilidhe in the locality, people should be entitled to get refreshments when it is over. All this talk we have heard about bicycle brigades going from one town to another does not apply there. Of course, it happens in Deputy Davin's constituency, but that is a benighted constituency that elected Deputy Davin. I would not wonder at what happens there.
Comment on this
They catch the fish and they want a drink afterwards. It is in Dún Laoghaire harbour that they bring it out in the boat. They are keen on the art of fishing down my way, and want a drink when they are done. I move the amendment, and would ask the Minister to accept it.
Comment on this
There is an amendment very much to the same effect in the names of Deputy Linehan, Deputy Ryan, Deputy Morrissey and myself. I associated my name with that amendment in this spirit. Whatever licensing laws we have in this country, I should like to see them respected and carried out, not only by the officers of the State, but by the general public as well. If we have licensing laws that are unduly restrictive, or that in themselves interfere to too great an extent with the reasonable requirements of the people, I think, no matter how many Acts of that kind are passed, they are doomed to failure on the very day of their passing, in so far as if they carry on their face the stamp of being unreasonable, of interfering to an undue extent with the ordinary normal requirements of the people, then those Acts will not get public support, and the public servants charged with the responsibility of carrying out such Acts will carry them out in a rather lame way.
As this Bill stands, it would seem that we are to lay it down in this country, from north to south, from east to west, that under no circumstances, no matter if a man has travelled 200 miles between the hours of 10 o'clock at night and 10 o'clock the following morning, can drink be supplied to him in an ordinary licensed house. On the face of it, that is unreasonable. There is nothing evil in alcohol; there is nothing more evil in a glass of whiskey or a pint of beer than there is in a pound of beef. It is the abuse of either one or the other that brings about the evil, that is dangerous and harmful. Our object should not be to prevent people getting any type of solid or liquid refreshment that they want; our legislation should be aimed at preventing abuses in the use of any commodity, the outstanding one being alcohol. World experience should have taught us this much, that over-interference with the people and too rigid restrictions on a population produce reactions among the public so that the end is far worse than the beginning.
Experiments have been tried in many countries, and I think experience has shown—and time will tell here— that the only type of legislation that is likely to succeed in removing the abuses that are there and removing the scandals that have existed, is reasonable, common-sense legislation. It is definitely unreasonable to say that for 12 hours out of the 24 the person who treats himself or a friend, the person who secures refreshment, is going to be branded as a law-breaker. The Minister told us that the purpose of this legislation is to deal with disorderly houses, to put down all-night drinking, to deal with the houses that have a far bigger trade during the hours of the night and the early hours of the morning than would be done during the normal working hours. Having introduced his Bill on that note, the Minister proceeds by the very drastic provisions contained in the Bill to drive every legitimate trader into the position of being a law-breaker if he is to listen to the appeals, the knocks and the demands of his customers. That is entirely unreasonable.
The all-night house would be dealt with by the suggestions contained in any of these amendments. The all-night house would be dealt with by allowing a reasonable margin for bona fide trading over the normal hours, such as is suggested here—1 a.m. in summer time and 12 midnight in the winter. The gap between that and the ordinary hours of trading has been considerably lessened by amendments already outlined by the Minister. I urge on the Minister the advisability of accepting the type of amendment that is before him. He will at least deal with the type of house that, he has indicated, has brought about all this legislation. He would have more public support behind him and far more support from the trade in dealing with abuses and breaches of the law if the law in itself is reasonable, is common sense and appears to be fair, not only to the trader but to the general public.
I am not so very keen on the amendments from the point of view of the trader. I am more interested in the amendments from the point of view of the general public and the rights of ordinary, well-behaved citizens. I think it is an entirely undue and bureaucratic interference with the ordinary free people of this country to say that a law has to be introduced to make it a crime to take alcoholic beverages in a licensed house between 10 p.m. and 10 a.m. That particular suggestion is so restrictive that it will lead to widespread law-breaking of, what some may consider, a minor kind. The Minister and his colleagues are long enough in public life to know that, if you are to have the laws of the land respected, you must have those laws founded on a reasonable foundation, and that the very minute you bring about a mentality that "this is an unreasonable law and we will ignore it, brush it aside," it is only a step from that to the breaking of another law, and still another after that. What is really required more than anything else in this country is to stamp into the mind of the ordinary member of the community as deep a respect for all the laws as would be found in other democracies.
Our background historically over a very great number of years, indeed over a number of centuries, is a background of conflict between the people and the law. National aspirations, the national demands, the national agitations and one national movement after another found themselves in those days in conflict with the law, so that, with our papfeed, every one of us imbibed disrespect for the law and a kind of natural tendency to break and to oppose laws. Times are changed. We are our own law-makers now. We are making laws with the authority of the people, and we should make those laws with the approval of the people, and, above all, we should not legislate here in an Irish Parliament to make laws which unduly interfere with the normal rights, the normal recreations and the normal pleasures of normal people. If there are abnormal people in the community, deal with them, but do not deal with them by victimising the ordinary people. If there are abnormal licensed houses, badly supervised, badly managed, badly kept, there is ample machinery in existing Acts to empower the State to deal with them; but do not deal with them by hitting, and hitting hard, the ordinary people of the community and the ordinary member of the trade who has conducted his business within the law in an orderly and proper manner.
The particular suggestions contained in the Bill as it stands are unreasonable, either from the point of view of the member of the general public or from the point of view of the well-conducted business. The Minister, on an earlier stage of the Bill, said that his reasons for introducing the Bill, and his complaints against members of the licensed trade, were not based on a few houses in County Dublin or any other county, that abuses of the Acts in houses carried on in an improper manner were to be found in every county and every parish.
Presumably a Minister making a statement of that kind does not make it on the basis of his information as the man in the street. A Minister making such a statement bases it on information received by him as a Minister, through the services operating and functioning under him. It is an extraordinary thing that if there are houses badly-conducted, breaking the law, giving scandal and demoralising people in every parish in the country, there have been only 35 objections on behalf of the State to the renewal of licences, and that, of those 35 objections, only five were considered reasonable by the courts of the land.
On the very evidence of the Minister's answers, it would appear that the whole necessity for tightening up of a drastic kind is based on a very small percentage of the licensed houses, and because there is a very small percentage of the licensed houses improperly supervised, badly managed and anything but well-conducted, the well-conducted, highly organised trade throughout the country is to be hit, and hit drastically, and what is more, the ordinary normal citizen is to suffer more restrictions, more interference with his rights as an individual than, so far as I know, is the case in any other European country.
Are we such a weak-minded, spineless people in this country that we cannot conduct ourselves unless the State steps in between us and temptation, and unless there is a policeman to keep us from making fools of ourselves, and that the conduct of Irish people depends upon the amount of policing over every individual? I think that over-drastic legislation will do harm instead of good. Reasonable legislation, reasonable provision for reasonable people, will get reasonable people behind the State, behind the services of the State and behind the laws of the State.
I urge the Minister very strongly to consider at this stage the advisability of accepting amendments such as those before him, that bona fide trading should not be allowed during the late hours of the night or the early hours of the morning—there are the ordinary legal hours for open trading—that bona fide trading be allowed up to 12 midnight winter time or 1 a.m. summer time, that from 12 midnight winter time or 1 a.m. summer time until 6 a.m., no licensed house be allowed to serve anyone with alcoholic refreshment no matter how pressing his case is, and, having got an Act containing restrictions of that kind— reasonable restrictions, sensible restrictions and restrictions which will prevent the scandal of the all-night house—the Minister will not only have the full co-operation of his own State servants, but will have, what is more valuable in a democracy, the co-operation of the general public brought about by the belief that the Minister's legislation is reasonable and not unreasonable.
Comment on this
In connection with the bona fide traffic, one of the reasons why I and some of the other Deputies in this Party were induced to set out the hours we set out in the amendments in our names was the point which has been raised often enough in this discussion already, that is, the differentiation, particularly in country districts, between the observance of what is called summer time and what people actually do. I understand that the Minister is prepared to move from his original proposal to abolish the bona fide traffic altogether to a limitation of the period during which no licensed trade may operate to the period from 11 o'clock at night to 6 o'clock in the morning.
Again the difficulty arises there that 11 o'clock at night in country districts in summer time means 10 o'clock for all practical purposes, and that is a completely unreasonable hour, in my opinion, for the closing of the bona fide trade. I am convinced that, to be reasonable about it, 12 o'clock summer time, or 11 o'clock in the period when summer time is not in force, would be the most reasonable hours. I think it is the natural way of looking at it, and I do not think the Minister would be giving very much away in granting that concession of one hour.
So far as the general principles involved in the amendment and the Minister's attitude towards it are concerned, the main point that impressed me in respect of the value of the abolition of the bona fide traffic during the night was in dealing with the question of drink at dances in rural areas. As everybody knows, 90 per cent. of the dances in these places are held on Sunday nights. The position up to the present was that dances started at 9 or 10 o'clock and continued until 12 o'clock. After 12 o'clock, the ordinary bona fide hours started for Monday and the dance hall emptied and everybody went to the public house. If the Minister agreed to 12 midnight during the period of summer time and 11 o'clock during the period when summer time is not in force, he would be doing a reasonable job. I think the Minister would not be giving away too much if he gave away that hour, and that any great harm that was being done by permitting the carrying on of the bona fide trade during the night will be knocked out by leaving the hours as suggested in these amendments from this Party. I put it to the Minister that the hour of 10 o'clock old time, which his suggestion means, is entirely too early.
Comment on this
When I saw the Bill at first I got a bit of a shock. I was wondering if the Minister had turned into a Scotsman. If there is anything I dislike and anything which causes trouble in a community, it is puritanical action of any kind. Wherever this puritanical attitude was adopted it always caused trouble. Here we have the Minister proposing that in this country we should go from one extreme to the other. If there was anyone on the Ministerial side of the House whom I regarded from experience as a practical man, it was the Minister. But I got a rude shock when I saw this provision in the Bill. So far as I am concerned, the Minister may close the public houses for 24 hours of every day. But I am not the community. The people want some accommodation and they should get it. Let me admit, for the purpose of argument, that abuses took place. Surely that does not justify flying to the other extreme and interfering with the rights of ordinary people? Because half a dozen people in a district—and that would be as many as there would be, taking the country as a whole—abuse the rights given them, why should other people be penalised?
I travel very little by road, and really the only experience I had of travelling by road at night was about two years ago. I arrived about midnight at Athlone and found I wanted petrol. The gentleman who owned the garage at which I stopped apparently was too important to sell any petrol and I had to drive away. Ultimately, I arrived in some town in the Minister's constituency. By that time my petrol supply was running short and I was hungry and thirsty. In despair, I knocked at a house outside which there were petrol pumps. The people were all in bed, but the man came down and gave me petrol. He asked me where I was travelling to, and when I said Donegal, he said: "You have a long way to go. Will you come inside?" I said I would, that I was starving with hunger. I went in and had a glass or two of wine. Is that an abuse of any right by a man in the position in which I was on that occasion? For people who are travelling in that way these simple amenities are elementary rights. Perhaps they obtained on too broad a scale. But why should we because of that fly to the other extreme and become rigid puritans? I think it is ridiculous and it shocked me when I saw it. I thought it was incredible that the Minister should be responsible for it.
In my opinion, the only question before the House is to strike a happy medium in this matter. When I saw the amendments on the Paper, I liked amendment No. 33 rather than my own. I do not like varying hours. In making a law of this kind I think the hours should be uniform. But the unfortunate thing is that not only have we summer time, but double summer time. The time is completely put out of gear. Therefore, it is essential in a matter of this kind that we should have varying hours with regard to summer time and winter time. For that reason I prefer amendment No. 33 to my own. I think 1 o'clock in summer time is very reasonable, as it is really only 11.30. When I put down my amendment what I had in mind was this. I had an earlier amendment advancing the closing hour to 11 o'clock. I then wanted to restrict the time between the ordinary closing and the time for the bona fide trade, so that people could not get out very far to abuse the bona fide trade. Now the Minister has agreed to 10.30 for the closing of public houses, and I think his amendment with regard to 11 o'clock for the bona fide trade goes by the board. It is simply futile. Rather than stand by that, I think he should do what he proposed originally and put an end to the bona fide trade altogether. There would be only half an hour after the ordinary closing hour for the bona fide trade. I think it would make the Bill ridiculous; that it would make it appear that we were not serious or practical about this matter. If the Minister accepted the proposals in amendment No. 33, I think it would cut short this discussion and let us get on with the other amendments. I think they are reasonable proposals. On reflection, I think the Minister could not defend the jump from one extreme to the other. It was really ridiculous and I was surprised to see it. I think the Minister should accept the proposals in amendment No. 33 which I am willing to accept.
Comment on this
I would not agree with that hour at all. It would only lead to the trouble we had before.
Comment on this
As a matter of fact, I did not intend to push it that far. I was prepared to go half-way with the Minister.
Comment on this
We were talking about Sunday. I think the hour would prevent the abuses I have referred to. For the night time I am prepared to advance it from 11 to 11.30. Perhaps somebody will be taking a chance and breaking the speed limit.
Comment on this
I would like to make it 12 midnight for all the year round. There are various amendments down dealing with this matter. There is one in my name suggesting 12 o'clock. The Minister having agreed to 10.30 for the closing of public houses on week nights for the whole of the year, I do not think it would lead to any more abuse of the licensing laws if he agreed to 12 midnight for the bona fide trade, or 1½ hours later. If the Minister is to give any recognition at all to the principle of government of the people by the people for the people he would be wise to accept 12 midnight the whole year round for the bona fide trade. I think he will have dealt very fairly with what he has in mind, which is to cut out these abuses in connection with the licensing laws— people gallivanting around the country and drinking until 3 and 4 o'clock in the morning, and all that sort of thing. I think it would be better if the Minister were to get away from the Ministerial point of view and get down again to the point of view of the ordinary John Citizen. He must realise that in country towns, people, after their day's work, come in to attend meetings or concerts—perhaps something in connection with tourism or something like that—and sometimes these meetings or concerts do not end until after 11 o'clock. Surely it is not too much to ask the Minister to agree that a person like that, coming in to a concert or a meeting, or in connection with some other business, whether political or otherwise, should be allowed to have a drink as a bona fide traveller up to 12 midnight. I think that if the Minister would agree to alter his own amendment to that extent, he would meet the views of all sides of the House.
Comment on this
Well, as I have said about 100 times already, my object is to remedy these abuses, and I am afraid that if this is accepted, that object is defeated, and the whole Bill is in vain. However, I do not want to stand out against the House, but I am afraid that the whole purpose of the Bill will be defeated by this.
Comment on this
I wish to move amendment No. 37: standing in the name of Deputy Fionán Lynch:—
Before Section 7 to insert a new section as follows:—
(c) the holder of an on-licence in respect of premises situate in a scheduled tourist area from selling intoxicating liquor for consumption on such licensed premises to bona fide travellers who are tourists and who have travelled not less than 25 miles to the said tourist area:—
(i) at any time on any week day,
(ii) at any time on any Sunday.
Comment on this
I thought that Deputy Lynch was not serious in this amendment, as I notice he has left the House.
Comment on this
Well, as far as I understand it, the object behind this particular amendment is to deal with places that might be placed in the category of tourist resorts, and I think it was Deputy Lynch's idea that some concession should be given to those areas in connection with the bona fide trade, whether on week days or Sundays. Of course, I cannot advance Deputy Lynch's actual ideas on the matter, but I understand that that was the object he had in view.
Comment on this
I do not think I could accept this. I heard the views of the Tourist Association on that matter, but I think it would not be possible to work it. Mention is made in the amendment of people who have travelled not less than 25 miles to the tourist area concerned, but if people were living there for even a fortnight it would mean that they should be treated as bona fide travellers. I could not accept the amendment.
Comment on this
The amendment may be going too far, perhaps, but take the case of genuine tourists—people going to tourist resorts on holiday. Those of them who stay in a licensed premises, such as a hotel, can have all the drink they want at any hour of the day or night, but those who stay in a non-licensed premises, such as a cottage or a private house, and who want to have a drink, are debarred from having it. These people go to such resorts for a certain amount of relaxation, and I think there should be some variation in the ordinary laws, so far as such people are concerned. Otherwise, it places a handicap on the man who wants to spend a quiet holiday and who is not staying in a licensed premises. If he is staying in a hotel which has a licence he can get all the drink he wants, but if he is a paying guest in a private house or cottage he cannot get a drink.
Comment on this
I should like to support the suggestion made by Deputy Keyes, because I think there is a lot in it. The great majority of our seaside resorts are in their original state, and have practically no amenities except those with which nature provided them. They are beautiful places, but they are undeveloped. Generally, in such places, there is one fairly substantial hotel, and when that hotel is fully occupied, the other people have to live or take lodgings in private houses or cottages of one kind or another. As Deputy Keyes has pointed out, the people staying in the hotel can get all the drink they want at any hour, but the other people, living in private houses, or staying as paying guests, cannot get a drink at all. I think it was about three years ago that this House spent a considerable amount of time and did a good lot of work in connection with a Bill for the development of the tourist traffic in this country. I think we voted something like half a million pounds plus about £40,000 annually, as a contribution to the Tourist Board that was set up. Of course, even that amount of money is only a fleabite so far as the development of this country is concerned. There are places in this country, even in my own county, where you could spend £1,000,000 to bring them up to the requirements of modern tourist traffic. These are beautiful places—as beautiful as could be found in any part of the world. In my opinion they are matchless, but they are there in what I might call a raw state. Now, the development of such places would be a great source of wealth to this country generally, and I think it would have been a very wise policy for this country to have allocated a far bigger sum for that purpose. The sum that was allocated would not even touch the fringe of the matter. All it would do would be to provide a swimming-pool or a bathing box here and there, but it would not touch the real fringe of the problem.
Accordingly, I think that in connection with this Bill, the Minister should take power—he need not use the power until it is necessary—to make an exemption in the case of these districts. There are not so many of them, and they want all the help that can be given to them—far more than has been given. I should like to see millions of pounds being spent on these places, and, as I have said, it would be a source of great wealth to this country. I think the Minister should declare such districts as tourist districts so that the people who were there for, say, three or four days, could be declared bona fide and could have a drink. Such people, perhaps, are away all day, playing tennis or golf, or engaging in sea fishing, and so on. They stay away until about 10 o'clock in the evening, and then they come back and have to get their dinner, but by that time they cannot get a drink.
I am not so much concerned with the people of this country in this particular matter. I am looking far further afield and am hoping for the time when this country may become a world centre for tourists, which it should be, and which it is not, simply because of the lack of development. In my opinion, cities like Paris, London and so on, have nothing to compare with the attractions that we can offer. All they have to show are public buildings and, of course, the monuments to characters in history, but we can give tourists the most beautiful scenery in the world—the matchless scenery that human hands cannot produce. We have that all around the shores of this country, and I think the Minister should take power in this Bill —because I do not want to see Bills dealing with the licensing laws coming along year after year—to deal with this matter. As I said, he need not use the power until it is necessary, but I think he should have that power until such time as this House may decide to contribute a much larger sum for the development of these places. I should like to see millions spent on their development. As I said, it is one of the things staring us in the face in this country, and yet we do not deal with it. It has been alleged that we are a very radical and lawless people. In my opinion, we are one of the most conservative people in the world. At any rate, one proof of that is that we will not lash out and raise money to develop these resorts, the proper development of which would mean an enormous source of wealth to our country. The Minister should take power to declare these districts tourist districts so that the people who are there for three or four days or more would be regarded as bona fide and, thereby, have the amenities. As I said, he need not use that power until it is necessary.
Comment on this
I think this thing is impossible. There is no greater tourist centre in the whole of Ireland than Dublin City. I think more tourists come to Dublin City than anywhere else. How could I possibly schedule tourist centres throughout this country? All around the coast is beautiful. As a Dublin man, I think there is no better place than the outskirts of Dublin and even the city itself. How could I exclude Dublin and the districts all around the coast? The thing would be impossible. If that situation arises in future, let somebody else deal with it. I do not see how I could deal with it. I could not say what is a tourist area or what is not. I would not like to take on the job and nobody else would. I could not exclude Dublin City. Everyone knows that Dublin is packed out with tourists, both from this country and other countries.
Comment on this
It is a joke to suggest that Dublin should be declared a tourist centre. It is only a pivot from which the tourist traffic radiates. That is all it is. It is ridiculous to suggest that Dublin is a tourist centre.
Comment on this
It is a landing spot, perhaps, and a departure spot. That is all it is. Nobody could suggest it is a tourist centre. With regard to the towns surrounding it, they have ample accommodation, big hotels, that hold all the tourists in it. Of course, if the Minister does not see his way and is afraid to face the future, I cannot press him.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 38:—
Before Section 7 to insert a new section as follows:—
(1) For the purposes of this section the Minister may by order, if he so thinks proper, on application made to him, declare that any area which, in his opinion, is wont to be used, or is likely to be used, as a resort for the purpose of seeking health, pleasure or holiday recreation by a considerable number of persons, who for any of the said purposes become or are likely to become temporarily resident in the said area shall be a holiday resort.
(2) Save as is otherwise provided by this section it shall not be lawful for any person in any place so declared to be a holiday resort to sell or expose for sale or open or keep open any premises for the sale of intoxicating liquor or to permit any intoxicating liquor to be consumed on licensed premises:—
(a) on any ordinary week-day—
(i) during the period between 1st May and 30th September before the hour of 10 o'clock in the morning and after the hour of 12 o'clock midnight, or
(ii) during the period between 1st October and the following 30th April, before the hour of 10 o'clock in the morning and after the hour of 10 o'clock in the evening in any urban county district or town the population of which district or town according to the census which is for the time being the last census exceeds 5,000 or before the hour of 9 o'clock in the morning, or after the hour of 9 o'clock in the evening in any place not being a county borough or such urban county district;
(b) on any Saturday—
(i) during the period 1st May and 30th September before the hour of 10 o'clock in the morning and after the hour of 11 o'clock in the evening, or
(ii) during the period between 1st October and the following 30th April, before the hour of 10 o'clock in the morning and after the hour of 9.30 o'clock in the evening in an urban county district or town the population of which district or town according to the census which is for the time being the last census exceeds 5,000 or before the hour of 9 o'clock in the morning or after 9 o'clock in the evening in any place not being a county borough or such urban county district, or
(c) at any time on any Sunday or on Christmas Day, Good Friday or St. Patrick's Day.
(3) Nothing in this section or in the Act of 1927 shall operate to prohibit the holder of an on-licence (which is not a six-day licence) in respect of premises in an area so declared to be a holiday resort from selling intoxicating liquor for consumption on such licensed premises to persons who are temporarily resident in such area on any Sunday during the period between 1st May and 30th September between the hours of 1 o'clock and 6.30 o'clock in the afternoon and between the hours of 8.30 o'clock and 11 o'clock in the evening.
(4) Every person who shall sell or expose for sale any intoxicating liquor or open or keep open any premises for the sale of intoxicating liquor or permit any intoxicating liquor to be consumed on licensed premises in contravention of this section shall be guilty of an offence under this section and shall be liable on summary conviction thereof in the case of a first offence to a fine not exceeding £20 or in the case of a second or any subsequent offence to a fine not exceeding £40.
(5) For the purposes of this section, the expressions "Minister", "Ordinary week-day", "Saturday", "Sunday", and "St. Patrick's Day" shall have the same meaning as they respectively have in the Act of 1927.
This again is one of the proposals of the Irish Tourist Association to provide for the special circumstances of tourist areas. It asks, in paragraph (1), that the Minister should declare any area to be a tourist area and in paragraph (2) it sets out special licensing powers for week-days and Saturdays, and so on, during the tourist season. I do not know whether the Minister has given any consideration to it, but the Tourist Association are extremely keen on having this provision included in the Intoxicating Liquor Bill. There seems to be a fair case, I think, for it and I would like to have the Minister's views on it.
Comment on this
I think the thing would be impracticable. One of the difficulties—not the only difficulty, but the big difficulty—would be, how could anybody schedule these areas? I do not think Deputy Lynch was here when I mentioned Dublin. Tourists do come to Dublin. It is not merely a jumping-off ground at all. They stay out by Dollymount, Portmarnock, and other places. They come from Roscommon and other parts of the country and stay in Dublin for a couple of weeks. I do not see how you could possibly exclude Dublin. We would have all that trouble. I think the thing is impossible, and impracticable altogether. If I could see any way of doing it, I would agree to it, but I do not. I think I told the tourist people that, too.
Comment on this
On amendments Nos. 40 and 41 the question of mileage for bona fide travellers arises.
Comment on this
If it would shorten the debate I will accept those amendments.
Comment on this
Amendments Nos. 40 and 41 not moved, on the understanding that the Minister will table an amendment on Report Stage.
Comment on this
If this means that the House is assenting to some arrangement by which the present mileage would be increased, especially in rural areas, I certainly do not want to be taken as assenting to it, because I am going to oppose very strongly any increase in the mileage in rural areas. I do not care what is done about Dublin, but in the country areas we still use the ass and cart and the horse and cart and the mule and cart. We are not provided to any great extent with motors or anything else, and no real case can be made for increasing the present three mile limit.
Comment on this
The Deputy would have an opportunity of opposing the Ministerial amendment on Report Stage.
Comment on this
I thought there was a lot of support for this on the opposite side and I was not going to resist it.
Comment on this
I am not going to oppose it anyway. I do not know where that leaves me.
Comment on this
I feel the Minister's attitude left me time to consider it. There will be time to consider it between now and the Report Stage.
Comment on this
I will put down an amendment and have it debated.
Comment on this
I take amendments Nos. 40 and 41 as not moved. An amendment will be submitted on Report Stage.
Comment on this
I take it the Minister has met my idea of a break on this. Is not that the position?
Comment on this
Yes. We have not quite decided on what the exact break will be, but we have agreed to have a break.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 48.
Before Section 8 to insert a new section as follows:
Section 15 of the Act of 1927 is hereby amended by the addition of the following sub-section, that is to say:
Whenever the justice of a District Court is satisfied on the application of a superintendent of the Gárda Síochána that for good and sufficient reasons the hours during which bona fide travellers may be served on a particular premises should be limited, the justice may at his discretion limit the hours for the sale of intoxicating drink on such premises.
I gave reasons for this proposal previously. I think it would strengthen the hands of the courts and of the Guards in enforcing the law when dealing with bona fide traffic until 12 o'clock at night. While the wording may not be appropriate the principle is that, where a superintendent believes there would be grave abuse of the bona fide traffic in the hours between 10.30 and 12, the justice hearing an application will have power to limit the hours of the bona fide trading. The Dáil has already given extra power to district justices to decide whether there are abuses or not, and the justice instead of taking away the licence would, by the amendment, have power to limit the trading hours.
Comment on this
I do not think the amendment would serve the purpose intended. At present a justice can endorse a licence and penalise a publican. I do not think the amendment would meet the position that the Deputy has in mind.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 49.
Before Section 8, to insert a new section as follows:
Section 16 of the Act of 1927 is hereby amended by the addition in sub-section (1), after the words "(not being or forming part of a county borough)", of the words "or by any holder of an on-licence in that licensing area"; and by the deletion in sub-section (1) of the words "(not exceeding in the whole three hours)."
The object is to amend Section 16 of the Act of 1927, and to empower any holder of a seven-day on-licence, as well as an officer of the Gárda Síochána, to apply to the court for an area exemption order to extend the time limit beyond three hours on the occasion of football or hurling matches. I understand that when there is a football match or anything of that kind in a particular area the onus of applying for an extension order is on the local superintendent of the Gárda Síochána. It is only he can make such an application to the District Court.
That is all right where there is a sensible superintendent there, but it works out otherwise where you have a superintendent with a different complex. Some superintendents have complete pussy-foot mentalities and would not allow anybody to have a drink. Nobody can persuade them to apply for an area exemption order for their locality. With other superintendents, for an occasion such as is contemplated, there would be no difficulty about having the application made. The difficulty can be got over by empowering any licence holder in the area to make such application.
Comment on this
Except for the three hours, I would be prepared to accept the amendment. There should be some limit to three hours which seems reasonable. If the Deputy would fix, say, four hours, I will accept it on principle, and have it brought in on Report, so that a licensed trader can apply as well as the superintendent, and make it four hours.
Comment on this
I would like to fix a limit. It is not likely that four hours would be unacceptable. I am safeguarding the position, because the superintendent can still oppose if he thinks it unreasonable.
Comment on this
A particular justice might be found who would refuse to give anything at all because he had a particular mentality.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 52:—
Before Section 8 to insert a new section as follows:—
Section 24 of the Act of 1927 is hereby amended by the deletion of the word "drink" and the substitution therefor of the words "intoxicating liquor".
Section 24 of the Intoxicating Liquor Act, 1927, states that where a licensed person is convicted of an offence under the Food and Drugs Act a licence had to be endorsed as for the sale of "drink". That came to be interpreted as meaning the sale of drink of any kind. It could be read in that way where a licensed trader was carrying on a mixed trade and selling groceries. If he sold vinegar that on analysis was found not to be of the character described he was convicted for selling adulterated vinegar and his licence would be endorsed. It is suggested that this section should read "for the sale of intoxicating liquor" instead of "drink". It would be most unfair that a licensed trader convicted under the Food and Drugs Act in connection with the sale of vinegar should have his licence endorsed.
Comment on this
I am agreeable to accept the amendment. I do not think that any case of the kind suggested ever occurred. I am sure there is ample provision for dealing with such cases under the Food and Drugs Act. I am prepared to make it definite that it is the sale of intoxicating drink only that will involve endorsement.
Comment on this
On behalf of Deputy McGilligan I move amendment No. 54:
Before Section 8 to insert a new section as follows:—
Section 25 (1) of the Act of 1927 is hereby amended by deleting the word "shall" now contained therein and the substitution of the words "may if a Justice of the District Court so orders".
This amendment proposes to amend Section 25 of the Act of 1927 where it sets out that where the holder of a licence for the sale of intoxicating liquor is convicted of an offence, the conviction shall be recorded by the district justice on the licence, unless where the justice may find extenuating circumstances. At present where a justice convicts it is mandatory on him to endorse the conviction, unless there are extenuating circumstances to indicate that it was a trivial offence. In other words, if a trader is convicted, the justice has to look around for reasons that suggest that the offence was trivial. The object here is that when a case goes before a justice he shall have discretion as to whether he shall or shall not endorse the licence.
I put it to the Minister that the section has worked out badly since the Act was passed and that he will find, if he goes back over the statistics, that in the vast number of cases where licences were endorsed, in a high proportion the endorsements were removed by the circuit judge. The simple way to deal with the matter is to let the justice who has the facts before him decide whether or not the case was on the borderline, and leave it in his power to say whether the conviction should or should not be recorded. The only people who might be aggrieved by the Minister's acceptance of this amendment would be my own profession because, if discretion is left to the district justice as to whether or not he will endorse, we shall lose a valuable source of revenue in appeals to the circuit judge on the endorsement of licences.
Comment on this
I should like to adopt this amendment instead of my own amendment, No. 55, which had the same aim. Compulsory endorsement has worked out very badly in practice. It has put a strain on the inventive capacity of district justices to find "trivial circumstances". Since we have on the bench of the District Courts trained professional men, the discretion in cases of this kind should be left to them. It should be left to them to say whether or not a case brought against a licensed trader was of sufficient gravity to warrant an endorsement. The justice's hands should not be tied, and he should not be compelled, if he thinks there should not be an endorsement, to write out a rigmarole setting out the extenuating circumstances
Comment on this
I accept this proposal, but I should not like the impression to go out that we do not want any licences endorsed. We did intend to leave the matter to the discretion of the justices.
Comment on this
It may involve a certain amount of drafting, but would the Minister go the length of saying that the justice will have complete discretion in this matter? Will he assure us that this will not mean that, because an offence has been found to have been committed, the justice will say: "Now I must endorse unless you give me reasons against it"? I want the justice to have complete discretion.
Comment on this
There is a phase of this matter which the Minister would be well advised to consider. This clause in the Intoxicating Liquor Act, 1927, was originally intended to be in terrorem. It has not effected its purpose.
Comment on this
It is scarcely fair to those who have had their licences endorsed under circumstances which are now to be changed that these endorsements should remain. The Minister might consider that aspect of the matter. The original idea underlying endorsement was that the offence meriting it was of the major class. It would not have been possible during those 15 years to impose a smart fine unless the licence was endorsed. Endorsement is regarded as a very serious blot on the licensed premises and, possibly, on the character of the licensee. In considering the amendment of this section, the Minister should give attention to the cases I have mentioned. If it is his intention to start out afresh and to enforce the law in future, that should be done with notice and there should be a general absolution so far as past offences are concerned.
Comment on this
There is an amendment down to that effect. I am prepared to agree to that, too.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 63, as follows:—
Before Section 11 but in Part II of the Bill to insert a new section as follows:—
(1) Notwithstanding anything contained in the Act of 1927 or in any other enactment it shall not be lawful on St. Patrick's Day for any person to sell or expose for sale any intoxicating liquor or to open or keep open any premises for the sale of intoxicating liquor or to permit any intoxicating liquor to be consumed on licensed premises.
(2) Notwithstanding anything contained in Section 6 of the Act of 1927 an occasional licence in respect of St. Patrick's Day shall not be granted to any person so as to exempt such person from the provisions of the Act of 1927 as amended by this Act.
I am asking the Minister to provide that drink shall not be exposed for sale in any place so long as the public houses are closed. I think that it is unfair that drink should be on sale at race meetings while the public houses are closed. If we are consistent regarding the St. Patrick's Day closing—and I have heard no complaints regarding it—it is wrong that people should be able to go to a race meeting, a hotel or club and drink as much as they like on that day. The Minister should agree to this amendment and prevent the sale of intoxicating liquor at any place on St. Patrick's Day.
Comment on this
To show the want of unanimity on the Labour Benches on this Bill, I propose definitely to oppose Deputy Hickey's amendment. If Deputy Hickey desired to give effect to his idea, he should have moved an amendment to open the public houses on St. Patrick's Day.
Comment on this
This is like the case of the fox that lost its tail. Because the "pubs" are closed, every other place at which intoxicants are sold is to be closed, too. Some amenities should be permitted to the citizen. The man who attends a race meeting and backs five or six losers wants to console himself somewhere. He should have the right to go to the refreshment tent and bury his grievance there. Apart from the cases that come into that category, I should like to see the public houses open for limited hours on St. Patrick's Day. Since they are not open on that day, it is only right that some facilities should be allowed to citizens. Restricted facilities are provided by hotels and those other places to which Deputy Hickey referred. These should be allowed to remain, so that citizens may have some relaxation and so that, if they be patriotic, they can honour the National Apostle in true patriotic fashion by "drowning the shamrock". I hope that the Minister will not give any heed to what Deputy Hickey says.
Comment on this
I will not, but Deputies can talk away as much as they like.
Comment on this
I am surprised at the attitude that the Minister is taking up, and I am more surprised at Deputy Keyes' plea that public houses and clubs should be open on St. Patrick's Day. I remember when all the forces of a united Ireland were trying to provide that the national festival would be observed without the accompaniment of drink.
I object to preferential treatment being accorded to any class under the legislation passed here. The Minister has not the courage to give equal treatment to all classes. He is giving to wealthy people and members of clubs the unfair advantage of being able to get drink in clubs while the poor working man in the rural area will not be allowed to get a drink.
Comment on this
On another section on which the question might have had some relevance, Deputies were precluded from discussing the question of clubs. It is certainly not relevant now.
Comment on this
I ask the Minister to reconsider his statement that he is prepared to allow drinking on St. Patrick's Day.
Comment on this
As far as St. Patrick's Day is concerned, I am going to allow things to remain as they are.
Comment on this
The excuse given by the Minister for bringing in the Bill was to try to put an end to the scenes that, it was stated, were taking place in the County Dublin. There are other areas to be considered as well as the County Dublin. The position in the tourist areas ought to be considered. I come from a tourist area. Thousands of people come to the County Wicklow during the tourist season and, perhaps with the exception of one or two, no temperance man could make the slightest complaint against what takes place there. What I do complain about is that the Government, instead of carrying out the provisions of the 1927 Licensing Act, which aimed at reducing the number of public houses in the country, are increasing the number. The position now is that every idle mansion in the country can get a licence. Most of them are miles away from the Guards' barracks, and they get every facility. It is now proposed to give extra facilities to people to get drink on St. Patrick's Day.
Comment on this
I am not proposing to interfere with the present position as regards St. Patrick's Day. Some people have said that we are interfering with it, but we are not giving any extra facilities.
Comment on this
Are the Deputies prepared to go the whole way and advocate that on St. Patrick's Day it will be an offence for a person to have a drink in his own house? That really is what their proposal amounts to.
Comment on this
There should be no preferential treatment in connection with the sale of drink on St. Patrick's Day. Cut it out of the Bill altogether.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 64.
In sub-section (1), page 5, line 34, to delete the words "objection to."
This is really only a drafting amendment. Sub-section (1) of the section provides that an applicant shall give notice of his intention to apply for a licence in respect of specified premises. At the hearing before the Circuit Court if there be objection to such an application there is an obligation on the applicant to show certain things to the satisfaction of the court before the licence is granted. The remaining part of the sub-section, following paragraph (c), clearly implies that objectors can be heard under the provisions of an earlier Act. If the drafting be allowed to stand as it is at the moment it might possibly be implied that where an application is made, and nobody objects, the Circuit Court has no jurisdiction, in the absence of an objector, It is in order to make the position clear that I have put down the amendment. I am suggesting that it is necessary to put in something to make the position clear, such, for example, as "at the hearing of objections, if any," or by deleting the words "objection to," because it is clear in the next part of the sub-section that objections are permitted and can be heard.
Comment on this
I am advised that the section is all right as it is, but I will consult the Parliamentary draftsman on the matter.
Comment on this
On consideration of the matter, I think the Minister will find that there is some substance in it.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 65:—
To delete sub-section (1) (b), page 5, lines 40-42, and to substitute therefor the following new paragraph:—
(b) that in the licensing year including the 1st day of January, 1933, a licence was in fact issued in respect of or was attached to the said premises or to premises substantially the same as the said premises.
This amendment merely aims at making what I understand to be the intention of the Minister in this section completely effective. It is well known, of course, that this section has application to a particular case. At the hearing of it the learned Circuit Court judge, who heard it, gave a written judgment, and during the course of the proceedings gave expression to certain views which, if taken at their face value, might mean that the licence which was granted by the late Recorder of Dublin for additional premises in, I think, the year 1922, was given without jurisdiction. The Minister is probably aware that the particular premises concerned in this matter were licensed in piecemeal: that originally there was a certain portion of the premises, then additional portions were added and the whole was licensed. Finally, in, I think, the year 1922, an application came before the late Recorder of Dublin to license the additional premises as well as the premises that were the subject of the licence at that time. That licence was granted by the Recorder of Dublin and continued in existence from 1922 until the licence expired some considerable number of years afterwards by reason of its not being renewed. The point was made that in 1922 the Recorder of Dublin had no jurisdiction, by reason of the provisions of the licensing Act of 1902, to give the licence that he did give. That particular judicial personage had a way of his own in dealing with matters that came before his court. Possibly, if anybody was interested in suggesting at the time that the Recorder had no jurisdiction it would not have affected his decision one way or the other. The point is that he made the Order at the time giving the additional licence.
It might now be open to an objector to say that Section 12 is all very well, but that so far as the person applying for a licence under it is concerned the section says that there must be a licence in existence on a certain date. Under sub-section (1), paragraph (b), it is provided that "on the 1st day of January, 1933, a licence was attached to the said premises". The argument would be that the expression "on the 1st day of January, 1933, a licence was attached to the premises" was mentioned to indicate the view of the Legislature that a licence was validly and lawfully granted, or attached, to the premises. It would then be open to the objector to say: "Oh, here is a flaw in the chain of the title to the various licences given to the premises." If that were so, then, of course, the whole section would be completely nullified, and the Minister's intention rendered nugatory. It appeared to me that I should draw the Minister's attention to that possible argument that might be put up. Now is the time to see, when the Bill is before the House, that no ingenious member of my fraternity will take advantage of any point of that kind.
Comment on this
There, again, I am advised that the section is all right, but I will have it examined.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 66:—
In sub-section (1), page 5, line 45, to delete the word "shall" and substitute the word "may".
The purpose of this amendment is to ensure that the court will have discretionary power in the matter. The section was clearly designed to grant a favour to a particular person, and I suggest to the Minister that this amendment would at least remove that construction from the section.
Comment on this
Would the Minister indicate why "shall" was put in? It may be highly desirable to do this, but I should like to know why you will not trust the district justice to do it? Why is he being coerced into doing it? Is there any fear that he will not do it if "may" is there?
Comment on this
As far as this section is concerned, it concerns a well-known premises here. I did mention the name here—Deputy McGilligan commented on that—and I did it for one reason. I have been accused by members of the Labour Party, in my own constituency, of having no other motive or intention in bringing in this Bill beyond "the Guiney section" as they called it, and the suggestion was that I myself had been paid. That was the reason I mentioned the name. That happened in Roscommon and Boyle; it was said there, and I have plenty of people to prove it. That is why I actually mentioned the name of the firm, and the other firms, too. My attitude, when I was first approached by this firm, was that I would not do it. I will be very frank on this whole matter.
Comment on this
Does the Minister say that a member of this Party made the accusation to which he has referred?
Comment on this
Not a member of your Party, but a would-be member—one who is trying to become a member. I was asked by a firm of solicitors, when this Bill was first mooted, to bring in a clause dealing with this particular case. I happen to be a personal friend of Mr. Guiney, and I would not do it; I simply funked doing it. When the Bill was being prepared, my assistants brought me some similar requests from other firms in the city, Messrs. Find-later and Messrs Mitchell. I said: "If there is a case on the merits there, am I justified—because I can be accused of being friendly with a particular person—in not doing for him what I am advised to do for other people? Should I not take my courage in my hands, and let the Labour Party and their spokesmen accuse me of anything they like?" That restaurant had a licence in 1933. It is a very popular restaurant. I do not want to advertise it, but I am forced to do so by this campaign initiated by the Labour Party spokesmen. This old-established restaurant had a licence in 1933. I understand that the person who bought it thought that there was no reason why he would not get a licence. In taking over such a big establishment he prevented a great lot of unemployment both in the drapery trade and in the restaurant portion of his business. The Government was very pleased when somebody did come along and take it over, because it is a very big firm, as we all know, and its closing down would have caused a serious increase in unemployment. Consequently, I brought in this provision. I think that firm is entitled to get a licence, and I stand over that decision. I have no fears whatever of any criticism levelled at me personally about that. I did say at the time that if those firms who had approached me would get an amendment brought in here I would favourably consider it. Then I saw that the more courageous thing was to face the matter myself. I have done so, and I have no apology to make to anyone. If the Labour Party think they are going to damage me in Roscommon or anywhere else they are making a big mistake; they will not succeed.
Comment on this
I think the Minister deserves a considerable amount of congratulation for his courage in bringing in this provision, and it is a matter of regret, purely from the public point of view, that charges of the kind he has mentioned should be levelled against him. It would be a very strange thing indeed if a person who has a claim which can be justified on its merits could be defeated in getting what are undoubtedly his rights, on his merits, merely because of the fact that some Government Minister would be afraid to face the slanderous charges that would be uttered against him. I myself have hesitated very much before speaking on this matter in view of the fact that I was counsel for the person concerned. I speak on it only because of the fact that there is a public justification for it, not a private justification of a particular individual. The premises concerned were faced with being closed. A vast amount of unemployment was about to be created when the particular individual concerned stepped in and took over the business. He kept a very large number of people in employment. There had been a restaurant there for some years, but it was not a paying proposition any more than any other department of the particular concern had been for some years a paying proposition. When the person who had purchased this concern had successfully weathered a very prolonged and expensive law suit, he was faced with one department which was not a paying proposition merely by reason of the fact that for some reason unknown the licence which had attached to that department for very many years had been allowed to lapse. From the time it lapsed until the present moment, that department, although it was pretty well patronised by the public, was not a paying proposition by reason of the absence of a licence.
There was only one thing to be done at that stage by any businessman, and that was to close down the restaurant and turn it into something else which was or could be made a paying proposition, but, from the public point of view, the particular individual concerned preferred to retain in his employment the 60 people who would be put out on the roadside if this restaurant were closed down. That is the only reason why this department was not closed down after the circuit judge's decision—because of the fact that at least 60 people would have been thrown out of employment. Because of the fact that the particular man concerned in this case did not wish to see 60 of his employees out of employment, he has carried on that restaurant, as a very good concern but not as a paying proposition. From the public point of view, I think that is deserving of commendation and of support, and it certainly surprises me that the only attack on this section of the Bill comes from the Labour Party, when the only reason why this department has been kept on was because it retained people in employment. The owner of the concern was willing, for a certain time at all events, to keep a number of people in his employment even if he had to do it at the expense of the firm.
The amendment with which we are concerned here seeks to give the Circuit Court judge a discretion. I personally am all in favour of giving judges discretion, instead of tying their hands, but in this case I think it is an ease to the circuit judge who heard this case that this section should be mandatory. The position is that the circuit judge has given a judgment and given a certain reason for it. When this section is passed it will be an indication at all events—whether it is in the mandatory form or the discretionary form—that, in the view of the Legislature, there are good grounds for the granting of this licence. It might be embarrassing for the circuit judge who heard this case, or his colleague who would be bound by the previous decision, that, irrespective of the law, he would again have to consider pretty much the same facts as before. That is one reason why it should be mandatory. The second reason is that there are, of course, vested interests who are against this clause and against the licence being granted. It is natural enough that other restaurants should think that their business will be affected in some way. Personally, I think it will not, but they are the best judges of their own business. However, we are in control of the situation now, and if we think that the facts are such that in the public interest this firm is entitled as of right to get the licence anew, and to start out in the same position as their competitors across the road and all around them, in all the circumstances I think there can be no objection to the clause.
Comment on this
The only purpose of this amendment, as I have already indicated, is to give the court discretionary power in the matter. There is no intention whatever on my part, or on the part of my colleagues, to impugn the personal character of the Minister or that of Mr. Guiney, but it is reprehensible to have legislation specially designed, as this appears to be, to bestow a favour on any particular individual. It is on that basis that my objection to the section as it stands is made. In so far as the point made by Deputy Costello in regard to conflicting interests is concerned, undoubtedly there are other interests involved. I do not think that Deputy Costello could be serious in his contention that the granting of a licence to Clery's restaurant will not affect numerous other restaurants and business houses in the vicinity. I say that it will not only affect those premises, but that it will seriously adversely affect, and will have a very undesirable and disastrous affect, on the employment of those who are paid at the full trade union rate of wages in licensed premises in the vicinity of this particular restaurant.
The granting of a licence in this Bill will mean that young girls can be employed at 30/- a week in Clery's restaurant, or in the cocktail bar that can be attached to it, under this section. Surely no one will contend that that will not seriously interfere with the interests of people carrying on a licensed trade in the vicinity of Clery's? If the case is so strong for granting a licence to Mr. Guiney, what objection can there be to giving this discretionary power to the court? That case has not been answered either by the Minister or by Deputy Costello.
Comment on this
The Minister has introduced my name into this discussion, though not in connection, I think, with the particular case referred to here.
Comment on this
I was referred to as having said that it was a very bad thing to have legislation of this particular type to benefit an individual.
Comment on this
I do not mind about naming the person. I think it is as well that people should know the name, as it is an open secret anyway. I used this clause earlier to point the moral that previously we had been told that it was wrong to introduce legislation of a type antagonistic to an individual. I had in mind on that occasion the flour millers and the bacon curers, and I was told that it was wrong to bring in legislation that would have the effect of penalising these particular sections. It could be argued, as against that, that it is certainly not right now to introduce legislation to confer benefit on a particular person. We have had the facts of the case for and against in this instance and we can examine them on their merits. Deputy Costello has brought forward a considerable amount of evidence with regard to the merits of this clause. Deputy Hannigan, on the other hand, suggests that there may be some discrimination between the type of employment given in this restaurant and that given in surrounding licensed premises. That may be, but we have got to consider the advantages conferred by other sections of the Bill on these traders and the whole impact of the Bill on the present situation.
I want to draw the attention of Deputy Hannigan to the provisions of the Bill as a whole. The Bill, as introduced, was intended as a reform measure, but I do not think it has very much of that character now in the sense of restricting facilities for the sale of intoxicating liquor in the country. Can Deputy Hannigan not weigh up what I think are the very definite advantages which those who have licensed premises in this city and in the country generally have got from the earlier sections of the Bill with what is contained in this clause? I think that weighed in the balance, the mere fact that a restaurant which previously had a licence is to be given the licence again will not amount to very much when the balance is struck. I want to add one remark to those made by Deputy Costello. So far as I understood the trend of legislation from 1927 onwards, and so far as I understood the mind of judges approaching this question of granting licences, they were much more favourably disposed towards making liquor more readily available when there is food about than when there is not. That is one reason why I personally, if there were no other reason, would approve of this section.
Comment on this
In order to clarify our position, I should like to say to the Minister that I would be astounded if any person actively associated with the Labour Party were to make reflections on the Minister's character of the kind which he has indicated.
Comment on this
There is no doubt about it, they were made. The secretary of the organisation was present, and spoke on the same occasion in Boyle and Roscommon. There is any amount of evidence about that.
Comment on this
Whatever may have been said—I do not know what it was, as I never saw the matter reported in the Press——
Comment on this
I still very much doubt if anybody would make any personal reflections on the Minister's character —in any case, they do not speak for me—because anybody who knows the Minister knows perfectly well that he is above lending himself to that type of abuse. He would probably be one of the first persons in this House to scorn any attempt to put such a low valuation on principles which I know the Minister values very highly. Aside from whatever may be said on that particular matter, has the Minister been advised that there is any danger in leaving this matter to the discretion of the courts? The normal procedure in seeking a licence is that a person makes application to the court for a licence. That is the procedure adopted by any person who buys a new premises of substantial size. He has got to go to the court, make his case for the licence and abide by the judgment of the court. In this particular case, the court is being compelled to grant a licence. Is there any reason for thinking that the court, if left a discretion, would not in the circumstances grant a licence?
Comment on this
The Deputy can see we are dealing with a particular firm. If we say that the court may grant a licence, we are simply throwing it over on the judge to decide. I think that there is very little difference between that and the wording of the section as it now stands, but we are removing the embarrassment from the judge by having this matter decided by the Dáil. We all know the firm concerned, and if we think it should get a licence, why not say so and remove all embarrassment from the judge?
Comment on this
So far as I know, there is only one, but there may be others.
Comment on this
Is it the Minister's attitude that simply because the case was discussed openly and because everybody knows the Executive Council are in favour of granting this licence, that you must tell the judge that he has to grant the licence apart from the merits of the case? Why not allow the judge to examine the merits of the case? What is the reason for that?
Comment on this
We here are passing a section to enable this thing to be done, and it is superfluous, I suggest, to refer it to the courts. We are making a decision on the particular case here, and I do not see why the courts should have to review that decision. If the Dáil decides that a licence should not be given in these circumstances, well and good, but if it does decide that it is just to give a licence, why should a judge have to review that decision of the Dáil?
Comment on this
Let us examine how the Dáil comes to decide this. The Dáil is presented with a Bill which is the product of consideration by the Government and the Parliamentary draftsman. It comes here definitely providing that this particular person must get a licence, no matter what the court may think of the claim. The Government is standing, by the use of its Parliamentary majority, for the insertion of the word "shall" instead of the word "may". This Dáil would not have protested if the word "may" had been used there, because "may", in relation to this section and this type of licence, is the normal phraseology. In this case, "may" is gone completely and "shall" is put in. If a person were to erect a new hotel in the city or elsewhere, he would have to go to court and seek a licence, and take his chance of getting it in the ordinary way. In this case, a person is insulated against the possibility of defeat and is insured against any examination of the merits of his case. The case may be a good one and there may be excellent reasons for giving a licence; but, seeing that we normally allow the court discretion in the matter, what solid arguments exist for refusing to allow the court to exercise discretion now? The mere fact that some judge might be embarrassed—and there is no certainty at all that any judge on the bench will suffer excessive embarrassment—is no reason why the Dáil should reverse its whole procedure.
Comment on this
Deputy Norton has entirely missed the scope of this section. It is only in one particular instance that the discretion of the circuit judge is taken away. The circuit judge is given a wide discretion, even under "shall", because he has to take into account those things which are really material from the public point of view—which is what we should be most concerned with namely, the character of the applicant, his misconduct or his unfitness, the unfitness of his premises, or the inconvenience of his premises. If the circuit judge finds anything wrong in any one of these points, he is entitled to refuse the licence.
Comment on this
I do not think the Deputy knows anything about the circumstances as, if he did, he would have reason to believe that this is not such a walk-over at all, on the facts of the case. The applicant is, I assume, beyond reproach, but the question of the character, fitness and construction of the premises are by no means matters of presented proof. What is left out—and recommended by Deputy Hannigan to be inserted, by a subsequent amendment—is the question of other premises immediately adjoining.
The decision of the learned circuit judge was based on the fact that, for years past, there had been a loss on this restaurant. That is entirely irrelevant in existing circumstances. At the time the judge gave his decision, it was, of course, a relevant circumstance for him to take into account, and he did so. At present, however, it is not. Deputy Hannigan purported to quote here, on the Second Reading, the decision of the circuit judge, but he had not got the actual written document before him. The learned circuit judge wound up his decision by saying the very vital and essential words, that "in present or existing circumstances" he would not grant the application. The object of this particular amendment, in so far as this word is concerned, is to avoid embarrassment of the circuit judge, on his having to go into other matters. when he might be told that he had tried them already. It is the wish, in the public interest and not in the private interest of the individual, to give this licence; and, in the circumstances, the only method by which that desire can be achieved is through the machinery of this section as it stands.
Comment on this
The real point to be considered is this. Everybody knows that the person in question is a suitable person and that there is, on the grounds of physical fitness, no possible objection. Everybody knows that the premises are suitable, but the real qualifying clause that should be in the section is not in it, namely, that some regard should be had for the number of premises already in the vicinity of Clery's Restaurant. That qualifying clause is suggested in the next amendment. So far as I am concerned, the attitude taken up by the Minister on this matter is very unsatisfactory.
Comment on this
In the normal course, I would oppose a clause such as this in a Licensing Bill. The facts of this case are, to my mind, fairly clear. There were premises, close to the premises which are now the subject of our consideration, licensed as a hotel. I remember them since I was a boy. That hotel licence continued up to the time of the destruction of the premises in 1916. The licence was there all that time, until it lapsed. If we had a case here before us of an ordinary licensed premises forfeiting the licence by reason of some catastrophe such as that, we would have consideration for the person in possession of the licence —and for the family if there were one. There was a licence there, it was not destroyed by reason of endorsement or anything of that sort, it merely lapsed. This section is to revive it. The persons who are in competition in that district are in no worse condition than they were prior to the lapse of the licence.
It is not unreasonable to have a clause inserted, presenting the circumstances in that setting, and giving the judge authority to grant a licence —to revive, I might say, the licence that was there a certain number of years ago. As I have said, if this were a new licence I would oppose it, as there would be grounds for entertaining the objections that have been raised; but these objections fail when we consider that it is merely a question of a lapse and that the public convenience would be served by the granting of the licence now. I have no interest in the case nor do I know the man concerned—I met him only once.
Comment on this
The point that has been made is not made by way of being derogatory. It is not a question of opposition to the licence, as the merits of the case cannot be examined in detail. It may be desirable to have the licence restored, but here we are saying definitely to the court that the man must be given a licence. The amendment proposed by Deputy Hannigan is merely for the purpose of allowing the court to exercise its discretion. Having considered the matter, if the court says "yes," the licence may be issued. The objection is to the Minister compelling the court to grant the licence, without the court having the slightest chance.
Comment on this
All we are doing is getting the bank manager's signature on the back of the cheque, to say that it is good.
Comment on this
On Section 12, it was my intention to submit an amendment to this section, but unfortunately I was late. Lest it might be thought that the discussion to-night had provoked somebody else to move in this matter, I should like to mention to the Minister that I will move an amendment to the section on the Report Stage, dealing with one of the parties.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 70:—
In sub-section (1), page 6, to delete paragraph (c), lines 25 to 27.
The intention of this amendment is to extend to licensees in boroughs the privilege of leaving the area in which they have been carrying on business in order that they may occupy more convenient premises and be able, as it were, to follow their customers. As I mentioned on the Second Reading, I think this is a very desirable clause to introduce, and I am of the opinion that it would be much more advantageous if the Minister would extend the clause so that it may cover cities and towns as well as rural areas. I have in mind such places as slum clearance areas, where large numbers of people are removed by the local authorities, leaving, in many instances, a public house standing more or less isolated. The publican's customers are taken away from him.
That type of thing is not peculiar to a place like Limerick. It is quite common in Dublin and in other areas where there is congestion and where the local authorities think it necessary to constitute a clearance area. I think it is desirable that a publican who has established a good clientele in a particular locality should have an opportunity of transferring his licence from that locality from which his customers are taken away to a premises in a more suitable area where he will be, perhaps, following his customers. This clause is very desirable, but I think it would be a distinct improvement if the Minister would do as I suggest.
Comment on this
I think it might interfere too much in a town or city with the people already there. It is intended only for the country. There would be great opposition, and rightly so, if it were applied to a town or city. For instance, a man might have a good business established and then someone might plank himself right down beside that business. That is the danger in the case of towns and cities, and I do not see how we could possibly avoid that if we extended this clause to towns and cities. If it were possible, I should like to put in certain restrictions so that there would not be any interference with the businesses of other people, but I am afraid you would have that anyway. You might, for instance, have a person from some back lane establishing himself opposite someone who has been doing a very good business, and there might be all sorts of interference with interests already established in an area. I do not think, for that reason, that it would work.
Comment on this
I think the objection the Minister is raising might be regarded as a potential one. My point is that a licensee, through no fault of his own, will be left in a derelict position through the operation of, let us say, a slum clearance scheme. Must he be precluded from transferring his licence to another district because of the possibility of some syndicate establishing itself in opposition? We have been discussing the desirability or otherwise of giving a licence to a premises in an important city thoroughfare. Now the Minister is afraid that a small back lane public house may be bought out and the licence transferred to a premises in a place like O'Connell Street, for instance, or some other prominent thoroughfare. I regard that as a remote possibility. Under this clause, as it stands, you are going to prevent men who have devoted their lives to the licensed trade and who find themselves left without their customers, through the action of local authorities, from having their licences transferred to more convenient and more suitable premises. Why can they not be allowed to follow their customers? I think the Minister would be well advised to extend the benefits of this clause to the towns and cities.
Comment on this
Why should any man be permitted to transfer the licence from a public house that he may have purchased cheaply to an area beside some person who is already well-established there and is doing a good business?
Comment on this
No person should be permitted to do such a thing. A man might purchase a dilapidated public house in a back lane, and you want to give him the right to transfer his licence to a place where another man has a good licensed house and is doing a good business. I would call that sharp practice. I think the Minister is justified in not agreeing to that, and I do not believe the licensed trade would stand over anything of that kind.
Comment on this
The reason I put down amendment No. 72, which is dealing with the same subject, is to meet the very point that seems to be troubling Deputy Fogarty, and it may also meet the point raised by Deputy Keyes. I felt that it would be very desirable if Section 13 contained some provision such as I have suggested in my amendment: "or that there is already a sufficient number of licensed premises in the immediate vicinity of the new premises." I think that would get over the point to which the Minister has referred. If there were, let us say, two public houses in a particular rural area doing good business, then some gentleman could not come along and establish a public house beside them.
Comment on this
If the courts are entitled to refuse the transfer of a licence on the ground that there are sufficient licensed premises in the locality, that would get over the difficulty.
Comment on this
I shall look into this matter. I think there is a feeling that we should finish the Committee Stage this evening, and any amendments that are left over will be brought forward on the Report Stage.
Comment on this
On the Report Stage we can go into Committee to consider whatever amendments have been left over.
Comment on this
I shall look into the points that have been raised on this amendment and see if it will be possible to meet them.
Comment on this
On Section 13, I think it will be necessary for the Minister to make the section tighter. As I read it, a man can transfer to a new premises anywhere within the District Court area.
Comment on this
I think that is very wide altogether. It could be a mile away. I am sure Deputy McGilligan could construe it to his satisfaction if he had to make a case in court.
Comment on this
I would have nothing to do with the construction. The judge does that and you would be surprised how narrow his construction could be.
Comment on this
I think that section is required in order to deal with the position in rural areas.
Comment on this
It should not be possible to transfer a licence from one village to another which would be, perhaps, a mile away.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 73:—
In sub-section (1) (a), line 28, page 7, to insert after the word "registrar" the words "or have been acquired or are about to be acquired by a local or other public authority for public purposes".
The object of the amendment is to facilitate a local authority which wishes to make a street widening or some other similar improvement and which at present is very often deterred from so doing by the expense of extinguishing the licence. The actual premises themselves may be of small value, but the extinguishing of the licence is a costly performance, and very often by reason of what is regarded as the prohibitive cost, the work, desirable though it may be from the public point of view, is not proceeded with and the community, therefore, does not get the benefit it should get. If the Minister is prepared to accept this amendment, it will mean that instead of having to go to the expense of acquiring the licence, it will be possible for that licence to be transferred to some other premises, and the cost to the local authority will merely be the cost of the acquisition of the premises, apart altogether from the licence.
Comment on this
If the Deputy will withdraw his amendment I shall have it considered and see if the point can be met on Report Stage.
Comment on this
I suggest that the Minister should look into two matters on pages 7 and 8, lines 46 and 36, respectively. There the character, misconduct or unfitness of an applicant are grounds upon which objection can be taken in the matter of the transfer of a licence. If the character of a person be wrong, he should not have a licence. If the character of a person be wrong, it should not affect the suitability of the premises. The suitability of the premises, its convenience and the amenities of the district ought to be the prime consideration.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 75:—
Before Section 15, but in Part III, to insert a new section as follows:—
Notwithstanding anything contained in the Licensing (Ireland) Acts, 1833 to 1929, or any other statute, any person who is at the date of the passing of this Act the holder of a wholesale dealer's licence shall, on application to the Revenue Commissioners, be entitled to receive a retailer's off-licence in respect of the premises comprised in such wholesale dealer's licence.
This amendment is directed to, I think, a purely Cork City problem. There are a number of traders in Cork who have at present merely a wholesale dealer's licence, which under the existing law enables them to sell only a certain amount of spirits or other liquor—I think, above two gallons. They cannot sell in small quantities, and by reason of the increase in prices and the change in trading conditions, it is a matter of grave loss and inconvenience to the traders concerned. There is only a very small number in Cork City, and I am informed that the general trade representatives in Cork City have no objection to the amendment proposed. Perhaps the Minister would consider the problem and see if anything could be done in the matter.
Comment on this
Tá áiteanna eile seachas Corcaigh go mbaineann an scéal seo leo. Scríobhas don Aire cheana mar gheall ar chás amháin, agus beidh mé an-bhuidheach dó má dhéanann sé scrúdúchán ar an gceist arís chun 'fháil amach an féidir aon ní do dhéanamh.
Comment on this
It seems to me to be a matter of having more retail licences.
Comment on this
Retail off-licences. The whole point is merely to enable them to sell in small quantities. They can sell at the moment only in quantities above two gallons, and the amendment is designed to enable a particular number of people, who are not at the moment in a position to sell in these small quantities, to do so. I was shown a letter from the trade organisation agreeing to the proposal, but unfortunately I did not bring it with me this evening.
Comment on this
The position is that a brewery cannot give less than six dozen of stout to a publican, and there are many publicans who would never be able to buy six dozen of stout together. All that these people want is to be allowed to give such publicans two dozen or four dozen. A man might be able to pay for only a gallon of whiskey, but the wholesaler cannot give him that quantity because of the licence. I think this is a very reasonable request.
Comment on this
The limitation was imposed at a time when prices were very different from what they are now. Two gallons of whiskey, at the time of the fixing of this quantity, cost about 28/- or 30/-, and the price now is £9 or £10. People are apparently not in a position to buy a large amount, and there is no intermediate provider of these things. The wholesalers are limited to selling a particular quantity, and it would be a convenience, both for the wholesaler and the retailer, if the concession were granted.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 76:—
Before Section 15, but in Part III, to insert a new section as follows:—
Where by reason of the discontinuance of the business carried on in any premises, an off-licence attached to the said premises is extinguished or surrendered, the justice at any sitting of the District Court shall notwithstanding anything contained in the Licensing (Ireland) Act, 1902, have power to grant an off-licence for premises in the immediate vicinity of the premises to which the licence so extinguished or surrendered was attached unless the justice refuses to issue such licence on one or more of the following grounds, i.e., the character, misconduct or unfitness of the applicant or the unfitness or inconvenience of the premises.
This amendment provides for a Dublin problem. Having moved the last amendment dealing with a Cork City problem, I want to draw the Minister's attention to a specific Dublin problem. The facts of the particular case may possibly be known to the Minister. Recently, a very old-established business of a family nature in the city, to which there was attached an off-licence, that is, a licence which allowed sale for consumption off the premises, closed down rather suddenly, leaving all the staff completely without means of livelihood. One member of the staff procured a house immediately adjoining these premises, and bought from the retiring owners the goodwill, and so far as it was possible the then existing licence which had been in existence for a very considerable number of years. He proposed to start, and has in fact started, business next door, carrying on the business, with the goodwill attached to it, of the old premises and in which he and, I think, at least a dozen of the former workers, are now engaged in endeavouring to earn the livelihood of which they were deprived by the sudden closing down of this family concern.
While this section is directed to a particular case, nevertheless, I think it is one which could be of general applicability, because it is not a case of increasing the number of licences, but merely a case of transferring the licence attached to an old-established business which has closed down and been sold—to a drapery firm, I understand, but certainly not to a firm in the trade—the licence, so far as it can be sold and kept alive, being sold to the former employees. If the Minister could see his way to grant this request, there would not be merely employment for those who have endeavoured to carry on the business in the adjoining premises, but for perhaps a very considerable number more of the old employees. I think this is a matter which, in justice, requires, even for the individual case, to be considered, and it is a matter which raises an issue of general import—that no harm would be done to the public interest by a general section of this kind or something like it.
Comment on this
I am afraid the amendment is rather on the wide side.
Comment on this
I agree that it is rather wide, but the Minister might examine and narrow it down. The Minister will understand that I drafted it merely to bring the matter to his attention and not in order to have it inserted, as a matter of principle, in its present wide form.