We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Committee on Finance. - Creameries (Acquisition) Bill, 1943—Committee Stage.

Contributions 1–160 of 312. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Creameries (Acquisition) Bill, 1943
Enacted

No. 7 of 1943 ›

I move amendment No. 1:—

In page 2, before line 31, to inscrt the following paragraph:—

"the word ‘worker' includes any person employed under any contract of service or apprenticeship whether written or oral or whether expressed or implied in or about a creamery immediately before a sale order relating to such creamery is made under this Part of this Act."

This is the first of a number of proposals designed to make some attempt to protect the number of employees who are involved in the measure.

Comment on this
Fionán Lynch An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Deputy will understand that this amendment is consequential on amendments Nos. 16 and 17. Could the whole matter not be better discussed on those amendments which contain alternative proposals for compensating redundant employees?

Comment on this

No, Sir; I should prefer to move the amendment myself.

Comment on this
Fionán Lynch An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

But No. 17 is the Deputy's own amendment.

Comment on this

I should prefer to move this amendment, because I think that we ought to make a provision of this kind in the first part of the Bill; that is, in the definition section of the Bill. For instance, in the definition section of the Bill, as it stands at present, it is set forth that "the Minister" means the Minister for Agriculture; that the expression "the company" means the Dairy Disposals Company, Limited; that the word "creamery" includes any factory or plant for the manufacture of milk products, and so on; and the section also goes on to describe what is meant by such expressions as "creamery premises,""proprietor" or "chattels." All these things are defined in that section, and the one notable omission from it is the word "workers." Accordingly, I wish to move this amendment.

Comment on this

Can amendment No. 17 also be moved?

Comment on this
Fionán Lynch An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Yes.

Comment on this

Well, that is all right.

Comment on this

I do not see any necessity for dealing with this amendment at this stage.

Comment on this

Is it the intention to make any provision for compensation for workers removed from their positions as a result of this Bill?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this
Fionán Lynch An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The question of compensation does not arise here.

Comment on this

Surely, Sir, it would be well at this stage to set out what a worker is, and whether there is to be any provision for compensation as a result of such worker being removed from his position?

Comment on this

Where is there any such provision in the Bill, as it stands now?

Comment on this

I understood you, Sir, to say that this amendment was really consequential on amendments Nos. 16 and 17.

Comment on this

According to Deputy Murphy's proposed amendment, the word "worker" would include any person employed under any contract of service or apprenticeship, whether written or oral, or whether expressed or implied, in or about a creamery "immediately before" a sale order is made. It seems to me, according to that, that if people knew that a creamery was going to be disposed of to-morrow, they could take on, say, ten workers the day before, and that they could, therefore, claim compensation.

Comment on this

Well, of course, my amendment may not be quite properly worded, and I am prepared to have it put in a more definite shape, but I can assure the Deputy that that is not the intention.

Comment on this

I have been a member of this House since it was established, and I can say that in connection with every measure of this kind, which sought to bring about a scheme of amalgamation of industrial concerns, a section was always included making provision for the payment of compensation of some kind or another for the workers who would be thrown out of employment as a result of such an amalgamation scheme. This is the first measure of that kind where no provision for compensation of workers thrown out of employment is made, and I think that, even as a matter of courtesy, we are entitled to hear from the Minister whether he intends to amend this Bill so as to make it possible to provide compensation of the kind I have mentioned.

Comment on this
Fionán Lynch An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The question of compensation does not arise on this section or on Deputy Murphy's amendment.

Comment on this

I suggest, Sir, that if it is intended to make provision for the payment of compensation to workers who may be thrown out of employment as a result of this Bill, that should be done by the insertion of some amendment in the definition section of the Bill, such as that suggested by Deputy Murphy, or by the insertion of some suitable amendment that would be acceptable to the Minister along the same lines, if he desires to do so.

Comment on this
Fionán Lynch An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

It has been suggested that Deputy Murphy should forgo this until amendments Nos. 16 and 17 come under discussion, and that then the question of inserting something like this in the definition clause could be discussed.

Comment on this

I should like to point out, Sir, that the Bill has already passed its Second Reading, and if the Minister would indicate, generally speaking, what his intentions are in this respect, then we would know where we stand, and could proceed on some understandable basis.

Comment on this
Fionán Lynch An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

One cannot discuss a specific thing on an amendment or section which has nothing to do with that particular thing.

Comment on this

Do you not agree, Sir, that if the Minister, at a later stage, proposes to insert an amendment providing for the payment of compensation to workers who may lose their employment as a result of the operation of this measure, it will then be necessary to have something like this inserted in the definition clause?

Comment on this
Fionán Lynch An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Is the Deputy putting that question to me or to the Minister?

Comment on this

I am putting it to you, Sir, and I think we are entitled to an answer.

Comment on this

It is not possible to discuss the whole question of compensation now.

Comment on this

I quite agree, but I think we are entitled to an answer as to whether this should be included in the definition section.

Comment on this

Since it is not possible to discuss it intelligently now, why not leave that matter over until we come to amendments Nos. 16 and 17? I do not see any reason why these amendments could not be discussed at the same time.

Comment on this

What I want to know is whether it is the intention of the Minister to insert, at a later stage in the discussion of this measure, a clause making suitable provision by way of compensation for workers who may lose their employment as a result of the operation of this measure.

Comment on this
Fionán Lynch An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

That is in amendment No. 17.

Comment on this

But that amendment is not in the Minister's name.

Comment on this
Fionán Lynch An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

No.

Comment on this

Deputy Davin must be a very simple man. Does he not know very well that if I state now what I propose to do in the matter of compensation, it will lead to a very long discussion?

Comment on this

I do not mean that.

Comment on this

Well, why not agree to postpone the discussion of that matter until the question actually comes up?

Comment on this

Does the Minister mean that something such as this will not be necessary in the definition clause?

Comment on this

It may or it may not be.

Comment on this
Fionán Lynch An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Is Deputy Murphy withdrawing this amendment?

Comment on this

No, Sir. I am anxious to facilitate the House in every way, but I cannot see my way to withdrawing this amendment.

Comment on this
Fionán Lynch An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

It must be either pressed or withdrawn now. The whole question can be discussed on amendments Nos. 16 and 17, and then, if the Minister agrees, it can be brought in on the Report Stage.

Comment on this

Is the amendment in order?

Comment on this
Fionán Lynch An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

It is consequential on amendments that come later on.

Comment on this

Yes, but is it in order?

Comment on this
Fionán Lynch An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Yes, it is in order.

Comment on this

If you would allow it to be postponed, Sir, until we come to discuss amendments Nos. 16 and 17, I would agree to that, if it meant facilitating the House, but I should prefer the amendment to be dealt with now.

Comment on this
Fionán Lynch An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

It has been moved already.

Comment on this

I cannot accept it now.

Comment on this

Let us be clear about this. I take it that if the Committee negative this amendment, they cannot deal with it subsequently. Is that right?

Comment on this

Yes, that is right. It can be postponed or withdrawn.

Comment on this

The difficulty seems to me to be that there is no provision made here for compensation for workers who may lose their employment as a result of this Bill. The Minister says, in an off-hand way, that he is going to give compensation—at least I gathered that from what he said. Am I correct?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

Would it not be possible, then, to elaborate in five or six sentences what he proposes to do in that connection?

Comment on this

I am prepared to admit, and I dare say that Deputy Murphy will agree with me that the wording of the amendment now under discussion may not be the best possible wording when we come to find out what the Minister's intentions are. The Minister has highly-paid draftsmen at his right-hand side, good advisers; we cannot claim to have any such people at our disposal in the drafting of amendments of this kind. If the Minister will say quite frankly that, as a result of the insertion of the necessary compensation clause, he will then take the requisite steps to put in a suitable definition section, I would suggest to Deputy Murphy, if you agree, Sir, that he should waive his right to move the amendment at the moment and reserve the right to put it forward on the Report Stage.

Comment on this

I would agree with that suggestion.

Comment on this

I think that will be all right. I am not sure whether or not it will be necessary to have a definition section. That will remain to be seen after we discuss the main amendment.

Comment on this
Fionán Lynch An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

We are marking the amendment "not moved" so that it can be dealt with again.

Comment on this

I just want to say a word in regard to the amendments. There is a number of amendments here all dealing with the one thing, all dealing, generally speaking, with encumbrances, that is amendments Nos. 2, 3, 4, 5, 9, 11, 19 and 20. As Deputies may have observed, Bills of this kind that were passed here in the House in the past, such as, say, the Minerals Development Bill, the Electricity Supply Bill, and so on, had, as a basis for compensation and so on, the Land Acquisition Act. In drawing up this Bill, we did not follow that procedure. We adopted a basis, as it were, of our own, in valuing those creamery premises, superior interest, and so on. On examination, however, it was found that there was some, let us say, defect in those cases of encumbrances. It was possible, if you were dealing with dishonest people—I suppose, in legislation, we must always watch that point —that there could be injustices done to encumbrancers. I should like, however, to look further into the question, and I would ask the House to allow me not to move those amendments, Nos. 2, 3, 4, 5, 9, 11, 19 and 20, and to bring them up again on Report Stage. I think they might require some further amendment before I bring them forward.

Agreed.

Comment on this

Where does the ordinary creditor stand as regards the State? What is the intention? There is what is in the Bill and there is what the Minister is going to do. Perhaps he would give us some indication in that regard.

Comment on this

This is rather involved law, and I do not claim to be able to follow it exactly but, as the section stands, it is claimed that if there were a mortgage on any property which we were taking over under this Bill it is possible that the mortgagor might be done out of his money.

Comment on this

Was not that the purpose?

Comment on this

Oh, no.

Comment on this

I am sorry.

Comment on this

If those amendments go through—as I say, they may have to be slightly altered—it will then provide that the first charge on the moneys provided for the acquisition will be any encumbrances; next, any costs of the sale; and, thirdly, any debt that may be due to any State Department. Whatever is left, of course, goes to the person who is selling the property.

Comment on this

I must say that is a revelation to me after reading the Bill. When dealing with it on the Second Reading, I think everybody was under the impression that the intention was to postpone every other debt, no matter when incurred, until the State had got its part.

Comment on this

As the section stands, the Deputy is right, but that was not the intention.

Comment on this

There was no question of involved law there.

Comment on this

It is involved because of the amendments that are necessary to the present amendments before they are right. As the section stands, it would appear that the State would come in first, and then that the person selling the property would get the money irrespective of any mortgage that might be there. These provide that all mortgages and charges will be cleared first.

Comment on this

Even before the State gets the money?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

The reason I asked that is that for the moment it might look as if the Minister meant that before the man gets his money the mortgages must be cleared.

Comment on this

No.

Comment on this

I understand now that other encumbrances come in before the State if they are contracted before the State debt.

Comment on this

There are four items: No. 1, mortgagors; No. 2, costs; No. 3, the State; No. 4, the vendor—in that order.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 6:—

In sub-section (2), page 4, line 16, to delete the words "a creamery" and substitute the words "creamery premises".

This is merely a drafting amendment. In every other part of the Bill the words "creamery premises" are used but here the word "premises" was omitted in the drafting.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 7:—

In sub-section (2), page 4, before the word "all," in line 17, to insert the following words: "within thirty days of such compliance".

Sub-section (2) says:

"Where the proprietor of a creamery complies with a notice served on him under this section the company shall pay to him all costs necessarily and properly incurred by him in relation to such compliance."

The purpose of this amendment is to see that the costs are paid within a reasonable time. I said on the Second Reading of this Bill that on a former occasion when returns were required and were officially compiled, as I understand was necessary some years ago, there never has been one penny costs paid in respect of them since. The proposal now is to provide for the payment of the costs within a reasonable time, and I suggest in this amendment that that should be within 30 days of the compliance.

Comment on this

If the Deputy is dealing with costs alone that is already dealt with in this Bill, and there is a further amendment to make sure that all costs are covered. Apart from that, the Deputy's amendment here imposes a time limit. I think it would be very unwise to put in a time limit of 30 days, because it is quite possible that the costs would not be furnished to the company within 30 days, and then the company is bound, under certain circumstances anyway, to have the costs taxed and so on, which would take some further time. I cannot suggest what would be a fair time limit. I think that, in all the circumstances, we should leave the matter as it stands, on the understanding that the company will be prompt in its payment. I see no reason whatever why they should not be prompt, because the procedure—every step they are to take —is laid down, and if the vendor furnishes the costs they will either be paid or taxed as the case may be; then there is no reason why prompt payment should not be made. It would be dangerous to put in a time limit.

Comment on this

If the Minister thinks 30 days is too short a time, he ought to indicate the time he thinks would be suitable. Merely to say that the Dairy Disposals Board should be prompt in paying the costs has no meaning in law; a proposal of that kind cannot be put into an Act of Parliament. It is purely a pious platitude that they should be prompt in paying. I indicated on the Second Reading that they have not been prompt in paying and I propose now to return to that point. I assert that a return of this kind was asked for in 1931 and was made by one of the concerns with which this Bill proposes to deal and, since 1931, not a penny of the costs involved in making the necessary return has been paid. I want to guard against a situation of that kind and I say to the Minister that to express the view that the Dairy Disposals Board should be prompt in meeting the costs means nothing in law and cannot be enshrined in an Act of Parliament.

Comment on this

I do not know what case the Deputy is referring to, but I think it is fairly obvious that under this Bill, in the business of acquisition, each case will be dealt with. But, if the Deputy or any other member of the House has any anxiety as to the delays that may occur, I will undertake to bring forward an amendment relating to the time from which all the returns are made. If the vendor is slow about making returns it would not be fair to blame the company but, as from the time the company has all the returns presented to it, we could make a time limit. I should like to think over this matter and ascertain what would be a reasonable time. I do not know how long it takes to get a list of costs taxed. I think we should allow a fair margin of time to the company in the matter of making payments. I will look into the point and, if the Deputy withdraws his amendment, I will arrange to bring forward a satisfactory amendment on the Report Stage.

Comment on this

Who will tax the costs?

Comment on this

The law costs will be taxed by the Taxing Master.

Comment on this

I think the Minister's suggestion is a reasonable one. I believe that from the time the returns are made a period of three or six months would be fair, and I am sure Deputy Murphy would agree to that.

Comment on this

I shall consider the matter between this and the Report Stage.

Comment on this

Will the person to whom Deputy Murphy referred, who furnished his costs in 1931, have his claim considered now?

Comment on this

I do not know what that case is.

Comment on this

I am authorised to assert here that the Cork and Kerry creamery proprietors were asked for a return of this kind in 1931. Returns were made then and those people have not yet received one penny.

Comment on this

I do not know anything about that, but I shall look into it.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 8:—

Before sub-section (3), page 4, to insert a new sub-section as follows:—

(3) Any moneys due by the company under the preceding sub-section of this section may be recovered in a court of competent jurisdiction as a simple contract debt.

This provides the machinery whereby the costs may be recovered in a court of competent jurisdiction as a simple contract debt.

Comment on this

I am advised that this amendment is not necessary, that that is the law in any case. When this Bill goes through, and if arbitration takes place, a certain amount is awarded. The position then is that without this proposed sub-section the vendor can recover anything that is due to him in a court of competent jurisdiction.

Comment on this

These costs do not come under the jurisdiction of the arbitrator?

Comment on this

I take it the Deputy has in mind proceedings after the arbitrator has made his award?

Comment on this

The compensation is fixed and he can take the company into court?

Comment on this

Yes. This amendment is not necessary.

Comment on this

Who will fix the amount of costs referred to in this section?

Comment on this

Underlying all this, as Deputies may be aware, is the idea that the parties will try to come to an agreement. If they fail, then the arbitrator fixes the costs and everything else.

Comment on this

But this might never go to arbitration, and who fixes the costs in that case?

Comment on this

If the parties do not agree, it will go to arbitration.

Comment on this

The company may decide upon a certain thing and that may involve the owner of a creamery in certain work and costs and the company might not go any further. Who fixes the costs in that case?

Comment on this

Does the Deputy mean if they break off negotiations and there is nothing more done?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

The whole intention of the Bill is that the deal should go through.

Comment on this

They get a lot of information as a result of this; in fact, the scales are loaded altogether in their favour. They may determine to go on or not to go on. Suppose they determine not to go on, who fixes the costs of what has been done up to then?

Comment on this

The company will pay the costs, even if negotiations are broken off.

Comment on this

I admit that, but who fixes them?

Comment on this

They will try to agree, but if they cannot agree the matter goes to arbitration.

Comment on this

Who says it must go to arbitration—where is that provided?

Comment on this

Excuse me, I should have said the Taxing Master.

Comment on this

Without having to go before a court?

Comment on this

Yes. As the Deputy knows, that is often done.

Comment on this

Is it the Taxing Master who will fix the costs?

Comment on this

Yes, if the parties concerned fail to agree.

Comment on this

I formally move amendment No. 10:

In sub-section (6) page 5, to delete in lines 28 and 29 the words "and the Minister, after consultation with the Minister for Finance, confirms such agreement."

Comment on this

This amendment deals with the case where the company and a proprietor agree upon a price subject, as the Bill stands, to the sanction of the Minister for Agriculture and the Minister for Finance. I think it is necessary to have that provision there because, as I explained on the Second Reading, a certain amount of State funds will have to be provided to bridge the gap between what is paid for those premises and what will be received from the co-operative societies to which they are sold. The two Ministers named have, of course, an interest in seeing that the price paid is a reasonable one. Therefore, I could not agree to the deletion of those words.

Comment on this

In this case two people make a bargain as to the price to be paid. One of the parties, having put all his cards on the table, is then told that the bargain has to go before that very tough gentleman, the Minister for Finance. Surely, the obvious thing would be for the Minister for Finance, who has been in touch with the company all along, to come in before, and not after, the bargain was struck. It certainly looks objectionable to have a third party coming in after the bargain is struck, particularly when that third party has been in close touch with the business all the time.

Comment on this

In fact, what happens is that the negotiator on behalf of the company will have had prior consultations with the Minister for Agriculture and the Minister for Finance. He knows the price that he can go to. If these words were not there, and if, for any reason, the company were to pay outlandish prices that would place Government Departments in a desperate position. I agree that is not likely to happen, but it might.

Comment on this

Does the Minister anticipate that losses are going to fall on the State?

Comment on this

The Deputy knows that in all these transactions where proprietary creameries are taken over and handed back to co-operative societies, there is always a difference to be made good by the State. The co-operative societies never pay as much for those creamery premises to the Dairy Disposals Board as the latter has to pay to the proprietors, because very often the premises in question are closed down and not used as creameries at all. In such cases, there is bound to be a loss which must be met by the State.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 12:—

In sub-section (6) page 5, in line 36, to delete the words and brackets "(whose determination shall be final)".

The object of the amendment is to make it clear that the decision of the arbitrator in these cases shall not be final and that there will be the right of appeal from it to the Circuit Court judge. I regard this as one of the most vital matters in the whole Bill. Amendment No. 14 deals with the same matter.

Comment on this
Fionán Lynch An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Deputy can discuss amendments Nos. 12 and 14 together.

Comment on this

In amendment No. 14 I am proposing, before sub-section (7), page 5, to insert a new sub-section as follows:—

(7) Any party to arbitration proceedings under the next preceding sub-section of this section shall be entitled within thirty days after the publication of the award of the arbitrator to appeal to the judge of the Circuit Court against the terms of such award and in all such cases the decision thereon of the judge of the Circuit Court shall be final.

I do not think any arguments are necessary in support of either of these proposals. The object is to ensure the observance of a well recognised, a well defined, right that, generally speaking, has been very jealously guarded. I spoke strongly on this matter on the Second Reading. It would be highly objectionable, in my opinion, if the Minister who, under this Bill, is seeking to close down or absorb a number of creameries, should have the appointment of the arbitrator put into his hands, and that there should be no appeal from the arbitrator's decision. These amendments seek to remedy that position. Deputies are aware that valuation appeals and matters of that kind generally go before the Circuit Court judge. I see no reason why people who are dissatisfied with the amount of the arbitrator's award should not have the right to go before the Circuit Court judge.

Comment on this

I hope that the Minister will accept Deputy Murphy's amendment or else bring in an amendment himself to modify the Bill. Here is a most objectionable situation, whether there is a precedent for it or not. In the course of the last ten minutes' discussion, it has become quite clear that the Minister is a party and is interested in the price. The Dairy Disposals Board—the company in question—works with the Minister. It is quite clear, from what we have heard from the Minister, that when any question of price is being discussed, there is full consultation—and there is to be full consultation— between the company and the Minister. Yet, ad hoc—for that particular case— the Minister, who is one of the bargaining parties, will appoint the person to decide the price. Surely, that is neither just nor equitable. There should be the provision which Deputy Murphy referred to, or the arbitrator should be appointed—as suggested on the Second Reading—by the President of the High Court or by the Chief Justice.

The present arrangement seems inequitable, and I put it very seriously to the Minister that he will not lose anything, and that a few pounds one way or another will not count. It is objectionable that a party to the negotiations for fixing a price should appoint the person for that particular case. He is not a person appointed to look into a number of cases and who holds office under the will of the Minister: he is appointed ad hoc, for that particular bargain, and he is appointed by the Minister who, as we have seen in the course of this debate, is a most interested party. If the Minister gives this matter consideration, he will see that the interests of justice require that he meet the case put up by Deputy Murphy, or that he allow the arbitrator to be appointed by an independent person, such as the President of the High Court or the Chief Justice.

Comment on this

I, too, think there is good reason why the Minister should accept this amendment, as suggested by Deputy O'Sullivan. It would give more confidence to both parties to the bargain if some such suggestion were adopted. Without it, I do not see how either party could have confidence in the arbitrator appointed by the Minister, and I ask him to accept it.

Comment on this

Deputy O'Sullivan has made a very deep impression on me, and I think there is a lot in what he says. I would like to have finality, whatever arbitrator there be, and would prefer the alternative that the arbitrator be appointed by someone other than the Minister—maybe by the President of the High Court or by the Chief Justice. The Attorney-General would advise as to that.

Comment on this

I would prefer a judge to appoint him.

Comment on this

One or the other—the President of the High Court or the Chief Justice. I will undertake to bring in an amendment on those lines, if Deputy Murphy is satisfied.

Comment on this

I accept that.

Comment on this

This rules a similar section in Part III, with the very same wording.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 13:—

In sub-section (6), paragraph (b), to delete sub-paragraphs (iii) and (iv), and substitute the following sub-paragraphs:—

(iii) the arbitrator may, as respects the costs and expenses of the parties in any proceedings under this paragraph, by his award and at his direction—

(I) direct the company to pay a sum (to be measured by the arbitrator) towards the costs and expenses of the vendor, or

(II) direct the vendor to pay a sum (to be measured by the arbitrator) towards the costs and expenses of the company, or

(III) direct the company to pay the costs and expenses of the vendor as taxed by a Taxing Master of the High Court, or

(IV) direct the vendor to pay the costs and expenses of the company as taxed by a Taxing Master of the High Court, or

(V) direct the vendor and the company respectively to abide their own costs and expenses;

(iv) when the arbitrator directs the vendor to pay a sum (to be measured by the arbitrator) towards the costs and expenses of the company or directs the vendor to pay the costs and expenses of the company as taxed by a Taxing Master of the High Court, the company may deduct the amount payable to them under the direction from the said price.

This deals with costs and expenses. Although it is a long amendment, it differs very little from the original, except in so far as it says "costs and expenses". It was feared that "costs" alone might be held to refer only to legal costs. By including the word "expenses", it covers all such things as accountants' fees, valuers' fees and professional charges of that kind.

Comment on this

And journeys of officials?

Comment on this

I do not know about that

Comment on this

I would like to know.

Comment on this

I suppose it does.

Comment on this

Whether by train or motor car? And at the present time? We know that ordinary people must travel by train, but officials go by motor car.

Comment on this

Officials of the proprietors. The company does not come into this.

Comment on this

The expenses of the parties?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

I am afraid the company does come into it.

Comment on this

It is unlikely that they do come in.

Comment on this

Is this meant to cover all the travelling expenses?

Comment on this

It is, if necessary, but I am told that it is most unlikely that anything would come into this but the expenses of counsel, the audit, the valuation, and so on, on behalf of the proprietors. It is very unlikely that any of the company's expenses would come into this, although they are covered, admittedly.

Comment on this

Would it not be possible to make it clear? If the company is going to take over a creamery against the will of the proprietor, is it fair that he should be asked, even legally, to be liable, in the strict letter of the law, to pay the expenses in getting an auditor, and so on, and in having the accounts examined? Surely not?

Comment on this

I asked the same question myself, as to whether it was necessary or not, and it was put to me that the vendor might be very unreasonable and put the company to a good deal of trouble and expense. It is a matter for the arbitrator, in the end, to decide whether it is necessary for the company to pay these expenses and whether they should be allowed. I think it is most unlikely that they would be allowed by the arbitrator.

Comment on this

The expenses might be necessary and yet they should not be charged.

Comment on this

If the company should say to the arbitrator that a certain person was very unreasonable and that these expenses were unnecessary, the arbitrator would have to decide whether they were unreasonable or not.

Comment on this

But there are other expenses that might be quite reasonable and necessary and still should not be charged.

Comment on this

The Bill provides that they are entitled to the expenses. Does that not mean that they can claim expenses?

Comment on this

No.

Comment on this

You are making a provision which will entitle them to expenses.

Comment on this

The arbitrator can direct the company to pay the costs and expenses of the vendor, or he can do the opposite, or he can direct each to pay his own costs. The arbitrator, naturally, will be very reluctant to give the company its own costs, unless they can make a very good case.

Comment on this

Why put it in? It is not worth it.

Comment on this

I think it is necessary.

Comment on this

Here is a public company, working under statute. It is entitled to charge its expenses, according to this. Being entitled to charge its expenses, is it entitled to forgo them as a State institution? I doubt it. If it ever comes before the Committee of Public Accounts—and I understand it is not easy to get information out of the company before the Public Accounts Committee—it might be very hard to justify its not charging what it is legally entitled to charge.

Comment on this

I agree that there is something in what the Deputy says. If a Government Department were concerned, they would almost be bound to look for expenses, but the arbitrator here must be satisfied.

Comment on this

But he is bound by the law.

Comment on this

But you will see here that the arbitrator may, if he likes, direct the company to pay the costs of both, or may direct the vendor to pay the costs of both, or may direct each to pay his own. So he has the last say.

Comment on this

In my judgment the arbitrator's powers would be wide enough, without putting further powers into his hands with regard to expenses, apart from costs. I am very much obliged to Deputy O'Sullivan for the very clear manner in which he has explained this matter. I object to this amendment, and I think it will introduce a dangerous principle and one that tends to whittle down whatever few rights will be left to the proprietors.

Comment on this

I put it to the Minister this way. There are 21 premises altogether. It is not worth tying up all the loose ends and doing objectionable things, in order to provide for possibilities of that kind.

Comment on this

I do not see that there is anything unreasonable in doing this. The arbitrator can do one of five things outlined here: he can direct each to pay his own costs, he can direct one to pay all the costs as taxed, or he can name the sum that one or the other will pay. There are five alternatives. I think everyone will agree that the arbitrator appointed in a case like this—as he will be now, not by me but by another person—is not going to give the company costs unless they make a very good case.

Comment on this

I do not think we can anticipate the arbitrator's decision in any way.

Comment on this

I presume, when appointed, he will be a legal or semi-legal person.

Comment on this