We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Transport (No. 2) Bill, 1944— Report.

Contributions 154–311 of 311. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Transport (No. 2) Bill 1944
Enacted

No. 15 of 1944 ›

By whom?

Comment on this

There is, I understand, frequent difficulty in getting the consent of the local authorities to the erection of signs, but the only point I want to make at the moment is that the object which the Deputy has in mind has got to be secured by the use or amendment of the Road Traffic Act and not by the amendment of this Bill. The Road Traffic Act, as I have told him, is the responsibility of the Minister for Local Government.

Comment on this

Might I ask the Minister, who put up the indicators in Dublin? Who footed the bill in Dublin?

Comment on this

I cannot answer that question. Again, it is a matter for the Minister for Local Government.

Comment on this

But the Minister for Local Government refuses to foot the bill.

Comment on this

The Deputy must argue that matter with him.

Comment on this

I think it is quite appropriate to this Bill.

Comment on this

It would be inappropriate to this Bill. The regulation of traffic, as distinct from the provision of road services, comes under the Road Traffic Act, which is the responsibility of the Minister for Local Government. The provision of adequate cloak-room accommodation at seaside resorts is a matter for the local authorities catering for those resorts. If the Deputy has in mind the provision of cloak-room accommodation at the termini of transport services, then under the existing law the railway company is required to provide cloak-room and waiting-room facilities at railway termini, and under Section 125 of the Bill it is being required to afford similar facilities in connection with passenger services by road.

Comment on this

Under what section?

Comment on this

Under Section 125.

Comment on this

Would not the Minister consider amending the particular section to which I have referred? The section provides that the Minister "may attach conditions as to frequency and routes of services, facilities to be provided and other matters." Would not those be amongst the facilities to be provided?

Comment on this

So far as the company is concerned, they are required by the Railway and Canal Traffic Act, 1854, to provide cloak-room and waiting-room facilities at railway termini. We are extending the operation of that section of the Railway and Canal Traffic Act, 1854, to the road services of the company, which means that they must provide waiting-room and cloak-room facilities at the termini of their road transport services.

Comment on this

Why not add some other facilities?

Comment on this

Were the railways, under the original Act, bound to provide facilities at intermediate stations?

Comment on this

At railway stations.

Comment on this

They were provided at intermediate stations, but were they bound to provide them?

Comment on this

At railway stations, yes.

Comment on this

Are you making the same provision for bus services?

Comment on this

Not at intermediate stations, only at the termini.

Comment on this

Why not provide them at intermediate points?

Comment on this

I think that is much more an obligation of the local authority than of the transport company. If Deputies want to provide public conveniences and cloak-room accommodation at populous seaside resorts and other centres, they must take the matter up with the local authority whose duty it is to provide those facilities.

Comment on this

Why is there a differentiation between the termini and intervening points? The travelling public might have to wait at intervening points.

Comment on this

Does the 1854 Act apply only to stations that are termini?

Comment on this

Are you sure?

Comment on this

The Act requires the company to afford all reasonable facilities for the receiving and forwarding and delivery of traffic. That is what the Act requires, but the appropriate section has been interpreted in the courts as involving the provision of cloak rooms and waiting-rooms.

Comment on this

At all stations?

Comment on this

At certain stations where there are facilities for the receiving and forwarding and delivery of traffic.

Comment on this

Does not that mean all stations?

Comment on this

Not necessarily.

Comment on this

This may be a small matter, but it is an important one in Cork. First of all, there is the question of bus stops. The absence of indicators is an inconvenience even to the citizens of Cork. The point has been raised already by a Deputy of the Minister's own Party, Deputy Daly, I think. If the Minister would agree to Deputy Anthony's amendment now, I think we could do away with a lot of bickering and petty trouble over this question of bus stops. We all look forward to tourist traffic at the end of the war and the Government is prepared to spend a lot of money in that direction. I am not quite sure that I would go the whole way with Deputy Anthony in regard to those enormous and perhaps expensive rest-houses at seaside resorts like Crosshaven or Youghal, but I think the question of bus stops is one that affects everybody. When I hear Deputy McGilligan and Deputy Hughes advocating the erection of bus stops in Cork, I think of the Greeks, and I fear them bearing gifts, but I would ask the Minister to take Deputy Anthony's amendment in a friendly spirit and put it in. The absence of those stops is a great nuisance to people who come to a city like Cork. It is quite a big city; it is not as big as Dublin, we know, but we hope it will be bigger. I am asking the Minister to approach this amendment in a friendly way, and to accept it if he possibly can.

Comment on this

I have considerable sympathy with the amendment. All I have to say is that it is in the wrong place and to the wrong Bill. It is the Road Traffic Act that must be amended.

Comment on this

It is another Minister has the doing of it?

Comment on this

It is another Minister has the doing of it.

Comment on this

Would the Minister use his influence with the other Minister who has the doing of it?

Comment on this

Yes. The Government has extended the powers under the Road Traffic Act by an Emergency Order.

Comment on this

Would the Minister get the other Minister to issue the order?

Comment on this

The Minister for Local Government has the power now of designating stopping places and requiring the erection of signs.

Comment on this

Is the Minister for Industry and Commerce and Minister for Supplies willing to have a kindly word with the Minister for Local Government in order to get over this difficulty about the erection of signs, quite apart from the provision of cloak-rooms? The company is bound to erect signs. There should not be so much red-tape about it.

Comment on this

How does the Minister defend his contention that we should compel the new company to provide facilities at termini and not at intermediate places?

Comment on this

It may not apply to halts, but it would certainly apply to all ordinary stations.

Comment on this

It would not apply to ordinary halts, but they would be much more numerous in the case of road services.

Comment on this

The 1854 Act is going to be applied to road vehicles. That will surely apply to definite stopping places, apart from halts, and therefore, cloak-room facilities will have to be provided. Am I right in supposing that in some of the decided cases a distinction was made between cloak-room and lavatory accommodation?

Comment on this

Between waiting-room and cloak-room accommodation?

Comment on this

It is only those are to be provided, and not lavatories?

Comment on this

Well, I take it that cloak-room, accommodation includes lavatories.

Comment on this

I would have thought so, too, but I think there are cases against that.

Comment on this

There may be subsequently another interpretation by the courts as to what constitutes a reasonable facility in relation to a road service.

Comment on this

In view of the development of road services, does the Minister not consider it advisable to have such facilities provided, especially in the big towns?

Comment on this

Certainly. That is why the obligation is being placed on the company to provide them, but I do not want to make them do what should be done by the local authority.

Comment on this

As a representative of a local body, I am aware— and I am sure Deputy Anthony must be aware also — that the Cork Corporation, just as other corporations throughout the State, has the right under the Road Traffic Act to establish road-stopping places for buses.

Comment on this

We have done so.

Comment on this

We have done so and have established our own stopping-places.

Comment on this

That is not fair. We have not suggested that we have not established the compulsory stopping-places, but the company will not tell us where they are. I think it is unfair of the Deputy to make that suggestion.

Comment on this

Will the Minister agree to the spirit behind this?

Comment on this

As far as the Road Traffic Act is concerned, I think the Cork Deputies can combine against the Minister for Local Government and Public Health with success.

Comment on this

Will the Minister support us in the matter?

Comment on this

Certainly. I think you will be pushing an open door.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 23:—

In page 23 to delete Section 49, lines 14 to 31, and substitute the following section:—

(1) In this section, the expression "agreement to which this section relates" means an agreement or arrangement being—

(a) an agreement or arrangement for the allocation or routing of traffic or for the pooling of receipts from such traffic or for differential rates on traffic passing by sea to or from the State, or

(b) an agreement or arrangement varying or rescinding any such agreement or arrangement as is mentioned in paragraph (a) of this sub-section.

(2) Except in so far as authorised by an Order of the Minister, the company shall not enter into any agreement to which this section relates with any other transport undertaker.

(3) An Order under sub-section (2) of this section shall not be made in relation to any agreement to which this section relates save on the application of the parties proposing to enter into the agreement.

(4) If—

(a) an application is made for an order under sub-section (2) of this section, and

(b) it appears to the Minister that the interests of any transport undertaker (not being a proposed party to the agreement) would be affected if the agreement were made,

the Minister shall, before making the Order, give that transport undertaker an opportunity of making representations in relation to the agreement and consider any representations so made.

Deputies will recollect that the question of the suitability of the original section was raised in Committee by Deputy Coburn and other Deputies. The proposed amendment provides that the company cannot enter into any agreement for the allocation or routing of traffic or rescind any such agreement with any other transport undertaker except under a Ministerial Order and no Order may be made save on the application of the partners. If the interests of other transport undertakers appear to be affected, the Minister shall hear their representations before making an Order. The amendment differs from the original section in so far as only parties to the agreement can apply to the Minister for an Order. Previously, such applications could be made by any other transport undertaker affected by such agreement or by any representative body of traders. Secondly, the matter is not referable to the Advisory Committee, which was one of the points made by Deputy Coburn. Thirdly, provision is made to hear representations from any other transport undertaker whose interests appear to be affected; and, fourthly, the original section was incomplete as drafted, in that it left it open to the company to come to agreement with another transport undertaker without the necessity for a Ministerial Order, if they had not already got an agreement with any such undertaking. That matter is now being corrected. I agreed to reconsider the form of the section during the discussion in Committee and I found, on reconsideration, that amendments were necessary in the form in which I now propose them.

Comment on this

Is it now the situation that one of the parties to the agreement can apply?

Comment on this

And, with the consent of the other party, an Order can be made varying it?

Comment on this

No, no; both parties must agree.

Comment on this

I wonder where that is contained. I see in sub-section (3) that the parties must apply.

Comment on this

The application must be made by the parties.

Comment on this

If one party is in disagreement and does not apply, then there cannot be any variation?

Comment on this

There cannot be any variation.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 24:—

In page 24, Section 52 (3), line 10, before the words "the Minister" to insert the words "the Chief Justice at the request of".

This amendment gives effect to the promise I gives to Deputies Hughes and Cosgrave on the Committee Stage, to provide for the appointment of the arbitrator by the Chief Justice instead of by the Minister.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 25:—

In page 24, Section 52 (5), line 19, to delete the word "Minister" and substitute the words "Chief Justice".

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 27:—

In page 29, Section 65 (6), to delete line 9, and substitute the words "may determine".

This is only a drafting amendment.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 28:—

In page 42, before Section 106, line 6, to insert a new section as follows:—

The company shall pay to the Chairman of the Railway Tribunal on the abolition thereof a sum equal to the salary (less suspended pension) received by him as Chairman during the period of two years expiring on the day before the establishment date.

This amendment raises the position of the Chairman of the Railway Tribunal Deputy Davin has one down in the same terms and with the same effect, though his wording is different. The gist of both appears to be that the chairman will be put in a position approximating to that of the directors of the dissolved companies. The Chairman of the Railway Tribunal was appointed originally for a fixed term of five years, after which the appointment might be on a year-to-year basis. The position in regard to the present chairman of the tribunal — there has never been any other chairman — is that he was previously a judge and qualified for pension rights arising under his original judicial office. That pension was, of course, suspended while he was in receipt of pay as chairman of the tribunal. As a matter of fact, he got the difference between such pension as he might have secured if he retired and the exact salary as fixed. He has been enjoying that difference for a certain number of years. There was no reason to expect that he would not have gone on enjoying that for years to come.

It is quite true that he had no security and it can be objected that we should not give payment here, where there was no security of tenure, on the simple falling in of his particular post. But that falling in was brought about by the introduction of this measure and it is at that point that the analogy arises with the railway directors. The railway directors hold their appointments from year to year, from general meeting to general meeting, and might have been dislodged at any point. Under this measure, the directors are being carried forward; those who were directors on the establishment day are being declared to be the shareholders' directors and there is a provision that, if there is no agreement on the matter, there is to be determination by lot as to which shall hold office for one year, which for two years and which for three years.

The provision of the Bill go further and say that, if any of these people, who are carried forward by this Bill only on a year-to-year basis, likes to resign office, he is to be given two years of the emolument he would receive if he stayed on. Therefore, with regard to the directors, the situation is that they have exactly the same tenure of office as the chairman of the tribunal. In fact, in present circumstances, it might be said that their reliance on the continuance of their office was very much less than in his case, as there might have been considerable agitation over the way they behaved and managed the company for some time past, whereas no such complaint has arisen against the chairman of the tribunal. We are continuing them in order to buy them out by this offer of two years' salary.

I suggest that it would be a gracious thing to give the Chairman of the Railway Tribunal the same terms. I suggest that he is owed something. Ordinarily, a person put into an office of that type — originally with a fixed period of five years and continuing thereafter from year to year — has an expectation that, unless he is given something in the nature of notice or warning, he may rely on continuing for a certain period. I agree that he has no legal right whatever and could have been dropped at the beginning of any year after the first five and that, if that happened, he would have had no resort to the courts, but neither could the directors resort to the courts. I suggest that the position is very analogous in his case.

It can also be said that, if he had not been given the fixed term originally, he would not have taken the post. At his time of life and with his experience as a County Court judge, there were other possibilities open before him. There was the possibility —I suggest, the probability — that he could have accepted other lucrative employment and, by taking the railway tribunal position, he deprived himself of that. He was given a five-year contract at the beginning and, apparently, that was sufficient to make him turn his back on other offices which might have been open to him. It could be said after that that it was an appointment only from year to year. That applies to a number of public servants, but they have all this, in any event, that on their agreeing to take up a position, they are appointed for a term of years and if they do not behave in any unsatisfactory fashion, or to put it positively, if they behave well, they are likely to be carried forward, because it is always agreed in getting people for positions of this type that one has to accept that unless there is some sort of inducement held out to them they will not take a short term. They may take a short term on the understanding that if they carry out their duties efficiently, then they will be carried forward. I think that in all the circumstances this amendment should be given favourable consideration.

Comment on this

I desire to support the amendment. Deputy McGilligan has said practically everything that could be said in favour of it, but it might also be pointed out that the individual who is chairman of the tribunal enjoyed a very large practice prior to his appointment as County Court judge, and that alternative employment of one kind or another was certainly available to him. He declined that on the understanding that he would be appointed for a fixed term. Under the original arrangement, the appointment lasted for five years, and it was then put on a year-to-year basis. As Deputy McGilligan has mentioned, compensation is being paid to the directors on the basis of two years' fees. This amendment, if accepted, would make similar provision for the chairman of the tribunal. The fact that the tribunal is being abolished is not due to any fault of his, and it is reasonable to assume that, had the tribunal been continued, he would have continued to be chairman. I understand that he discharged the duties of the office extremely efficiently, and in view of the fact that all other people who could be compensated are being compensated, it is possible that it was only through an oversight that no provision was made for the chairman. I would urge on the Minister the desirability of accepting this amendment, or at any rate of accepting the spirit of the amendment, and of making some provision for this individual.

Comment on this

I do not agree at all that there is any analogy between the case of the chairman of the tribunal and the directors of the amalgamating companies. The amalgamating companies, whatever may have been their history, had their origin in private enterprise, and the State, when it interferes with the operation of private enterprises of that kind, has an obligation to ensure that the consequences of its action are not unduly hard on individuals. The Railway Tribunal was established by statute, and it was obviously within the power of this House to abolish it at any time. The chairman of the tribunal was appointed originally for five years, and has latterly been appointed from year to year. There was no obligation of any kind to reappoint him at the end of the year, and no ground for the expectation that he would be so reappointed. In fact, I think I could say that the Government would have found difficulty in reappointing the chairman of the tribunal as far back as 1939, on the grounds of age, were it not for the fact that I then informed the Government that the reorganisation of transport, which we had in contemplation, and the new legislation which would be required to give effect to that reorganisation, would in all probability provide for the disappearance of the Railway Tribunal.

I think I can say that in the past four or five years the reappointment of the existing chairman by the Government was determined by the knowledge that the Railway Tribunal would eventually disappear. I could not, therefore, agree that there is any moral obligation whatever to provide compensation for the chairman on the abolition of the tribunal. Having regard to the fact that on his retirement from the chairmanship of the Railway Tribunal the person concerned becomes entitled to a pension of £1,500 a year as Circuit Court judge under the financial agreement of 1938, I cannot agree that there will be any hardship caused by leaving the position as it is.

Comment on this

Is the Minister quite sure that the pension is as large as he says?

Comment on this

Yes, £1,500 a year.

Comment on this

He was only a Circuit Court judge.

Comment on this

That is the pension to which he is entitled under the financial agreement.

Comment on this

Has he a sufficient number of years' service to entitle him to that pension?

Comment on this

Yes. In fact, it was the knowledge that there was a certain saving arising out of the fact that this pension was in abeyance which influenced the Government in appointing the existing chairman in the circumstances to which I have adverted. I might also say that I would regard it as completely inequitable to have this charge placed on the company. Under the 1924 Act the company was liable only for half his salary; the Government was liable for the other half.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 30:—

In page 44, Section 110 (4), paragraph (a), sub-paragraph (ii), lines 4 and 5, to delete the words "in whose functional area the bridge is situate" and substitute the following words", charged, under Section 24 of the Local Government Act, 1925 (No. 5 of 1925), with the maintenance of the public road,".

I gave notice of the necessity for this amendment on Committee. It appears that some local authorities have a responsibility for the maintenance of bridges in the functional areas of other local authorities and consequently the wording of the original section has to be amended in order to deal with the situation.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 31:—

In page 44, Section 110 (4), paragraph (b), sub-paragraph (ii), lines 52 and 53, to delete the words "in whose functional area the bridge is situate" and substitute the words ", charged, under the said Section 24 of the said Local Government Act, 1925, with the maintenance of the public road,".

This is a similar amendment.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 32:—

In page 45, Section 110 (4), paragraph (e), to add at the end of the paragraph, line 66, the following new sub-paragraph:—

(iii) where, immediately before the operative date, a right of way was exercisable over the said bridge—

(I) in case the railway company, before the date referred to in sub-paragraph (i) of this paragraph do the following works, namely, replace the said bridge by a crossing on the level over the site of the abandoned railway and render the said crossing fit and safe for use, a right of way similar to that which was exercisable over the said bridge shall, by virtue of this sub-paragraph, be exercisable over the said crossing, and any person for the time being entitled thereto may do all such things as are reasonably necessary for keeping the said crossing fit and safe for use,

(II) in any other case, the right of way over the said bridge shall continue to be exercisable, and any person for the time being entitled thereto may do all such things as are reasonably necessary for keeping the said bridge fit and safe for use.

This amendment preserves rights of way and is being inserted on representations from the Minister for Lands who considers that where the railway company replaces a bridge by a level crossing, a right of way thereover should be conferred on those persons previously entitled to use the bridge inasmuch as the company may proceed to sell the site of a line and the purchaser may be in a position to take objection to the use of the level crossing unless the parties using the level crossing have a legal right to do so. Again there may be a case where the railway company would choose to pay compensation on ceasing to be liable to maintain a bridge instead of constructing a level crossing. If part of a holding is cut off by the line and access to the holding can be obtained only through the part of the line purchased by some person other than the landholder, it is necessary that the purchaser should be ready to maintain the bridge and repair the structure. A right of way is conferred on the landholder in addition to being paid compensation for the burden of keeping up the bridge as a means of access to the land.

Comment on this

If the man who has a right of way over the bridge is to be made responsible for the maintenance of the bridge, he is to get compensation?

Comment on this

If the person to whom the land is transferred chooses to maintain the bridge, then he is to be compensated for the burden of maintaining the bridge over which other people have a right of way.

Comment on this

A bridge over a railway is a considerable structure.

Comment on this

These are accommodation bridges which were erected by the railway company under agreement with certain landholders. They are not public bridges.

Comment on this

I understand we are dealing with the private bridge built to accommodate a farmer where his farm was divided when the railway was constructed. Supposing the responsibility for maintenance is taken over by the occupier, if the bridge gets into a dilapidated condition in future and that it has to be rebuilt, that would be a big proposition for a single individual.

Comment on this

It is proposed to pay compensation for the burden of maintaining the bridge if that burden falls on him.

Comment on this

What will be the position in the event of reconstruction being necessary?

Comment on this

Normally, the bridge will be demolished and a level-crossing substituted for it. The main purpose of this amendment is to secure that, if that happens, those who had a right of way over the bridge will have a right of way over the level crossing. If the bridge has to be maintained, the obligation of maintaining it will devolve on the landowner, subject to his being compensated for the burden.

Comment on this

The bridge may have to be maintained——

Comment on this

In which case, the adjoining landowner receives compensation. That is in the case of the abandonment of the railway.

Comment on this

Is there any provision for reconstruction? If a bridge becomes dangerous and has to be reconstructed, who will be responsible for the cost?

Comment on this

The owner is compensated for maintaining the bridge.

Comment on this

You are compensating him for maintenance but should there not be some provision for reconstruction? The bridge may have to be rebuilt.

Comment on this

If the bridge is maintained, it will not need to be rebuilt.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 33:—

In page 46, Section 110 (8), to add at the end of the sub-section, line 23, the words "either by private treaty to the owner of the land on both sides of such line or by public auction".

This amendment has also been suggested by the Minister for Lands and it is designed to prevent disputes arising in cases in which a railway line has been abandoned and the permanent-way is being sold. The amendment provides that the land will be offered, in the first instance, to the adjoining landowners and, only if they decline to buy, will it be sold by public auction. It is thought that there might be unnecessary cause for dispute if the land were put up for public auction, in the first instance, and purchased by persons other than the adjoining landowners. The intention is that the land should be sold to the adjoining landowners, if they want to buy it.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 34:—

In page 53, lines 42 to 49, to delete Section 125 and substitute the following section:—

Section 2 of the Railway and Canal Traffic Act, 1854, shall apply to the road traffic of any person under a passenger licence, within the meaning of the Road Transport Act, 1932 (No. 2 of 1932), or under a merchandise licence, within the meaning of the Road Transport Act, 1933 (No. 8 of 1933), in the same manner and to the like extent as the said section applies to the land traffic of a railway company.

This is a drafting amendment. In drafting this section, the draftsman used the limiting words "in any vehicles". That limitation is now being removed so as to bring the section in line with corresponding provisions in respect of railway and canal services.

Comment on this

A couple of important matters arise on this amendment, and I want to get information concerning them. The Railway and Canal Traffic Act, 1854, applied mainly to railways, but also applied to canals. It is now being applied to roads. That Act was supposed to give a right of action in connection with undue preferences. That was in what was called the "inequality clause". That provision was found to be extremely deficient when cases came up for decision. The law was amended, and I notice that this Act is being applied to the road business of the new company. Will that carry with it the amending legislation?

Comment on this

It carries the Act, as amended.

Comment on this

It is not so stated and, if the Minister will glance at other statutes, he will find the phrase used "and Acts amending the same". This Act never applied to road traffic. We are making it applicable to something to which it never previously applied. When that section was brought before the courts, the judges exposed its weakness. It was not applicable to any great extent and it was fortified by two other sections of the 1888 Act. So far as I remember, Section 25 and 27 are the sections which are specially applicable. Under Section 27, there was prima facie evidence of a preferential rate or unequal treatment if it was found that the rates, fares or tolls varied as between one trader and another and, from that moment, there was an onus on the railway company to prove various things. A few other provisions which followed were in ease of the railway company. Section 25 referred to the granting of continuous services — that a company might be made link up with another company, even a private company, so that through rates could be demanded over a particular route. However, the point I am mainly anxious about is whether or not merely bringing in this precise reference to the Railway and Canal Traffic Act, 1854, will necessarily carry with it later amending legislation.

Comment on this

I am advised that that form carries with it amending legislation.

Comment on this

I raised the point because, in a number of statutes, the phrase is used "and Acts amending the same".

Comment on this

The parliamentary draftsman advises that that is not necessary.

Comment on this

The second point is: if there are disputes under this provision, to whom will they go for decision? Will questions of undue preference and preferential rates go to the courts?

Comment on this

To the High Court.

Comment on this

Such amendment of this clause as was effected by Section 25 of the Act of 1888 refers, I think, to routing of traffic by through routes. Notwithstanding legislation by which certain matters of a like nature are referable to the Minister's Department, will such things as are referred to by the 1888 Act go to the courts?

Comment on this

On the application of either party?

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 35:—

In page 54, to delete Section 126 (4), lines 11 to 19.

We had some discussion on this sub-section on the Committee Stage and I intimated that I was not quite satisfied with it. I do not think that many Deputies were satisfied, either. The best course is, I think, to delete the sub-section, and that I now propose.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 36:—

In page 54, Section 129 (1), paragraph (a), lines 46 and 47, to delete the word "undertaking" and substitute the word "undertaker".

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 37:—

In page 55, to delete Section 133, lines 38 to 54, and substitute the following section:—

(1) In this section—

the expression "the bodies concerned" means the company, the Dublin Corporation and the Grand Canal Company;

the expression "the bridge" means the Victoria Bridge across the Grand Canal in the County Borough of Dublin;

the expression "the contemplated agreement" means an agreement to be made between the bodies concerned with respect to the maintenance (including reconstruction), and control of the bridge;

the expression "the appointed period" means the period of one year from the date of the passing of this Act, or such further period as the Minister may allow.

(2) The bodies concerned may, within the appointed period, execute the contemplated agreement, but the contemplated agreement, if so executed, shall not have any force unless confirmed by the Minister, who is hereby authorised, if he thinks fit, to do so.

(3) If the contemplated agreement is executed within the appointed period and confirmed by the Minister, the following provisions shall thereupon have effect—

(a) the said agreement shall have statutory effect;

(b) each of the bodies concerned shall, notwithstanding any limitation on the power of that body to enter into it, be deemed to have power to enter into the said agreement;

(c) it shall be the duty of each of the bodies concerned and each of the said bodies is hereby empowered to carry out the said agreement so far as the provisions thereof are to be carried out by that body.

(4) If the contemplated agreement is not executed within the appointed period or, being so executed, the Minister refuses to confirm it, the following provisions shall have effect—

(a) the Chief Justice, at the request (made after consultation with the Minister for Local Government and Public Health) of the Minister, shall appoint an arbitrator to determine, after hearing the bodies concerned, the terms and conditions which, having regard to the circumstances then existing, should, in his opinion, govern the future maintenance (including reconstruction) and control of the bridge,

(b) the determination of the arbitrator shall have statutory effect and it shall be the duty of each of the bodies concerned, and each of them is hereby empowered, to carry out the terms of the said determination so far as the provisions thereof are to be carried out by that body,

(c) the remuneration of the arbitrator shall be fixed by the Chief Justice and shall be paid in equal proportions by the bodies concerned,

(d) the arbitrator may, as respects the costs and expenses of the bodies concerned in the proceedings before him, make such order as in his discretion he thinks fit.

Deputy Doyle moved an amendment on the Committee Stage which was designed to provide, that in the event of the company, Dublin Corporation and the Canal Company failing to make an agreement in regard to the Victoria Bridge, the Minister for Local Government and Public Health should decide what was to be done and have power to impose his decision upon the parties. I intimated that the Minister for Local Government and Public Health could not be regarded as an impartial personage in a dispute of that kind and that, in order to secure that something would be done in the event mentioned, I would produce an amendment providing for the settlement of the matter by arbitration. That is what is now proposed in this amendment. If the parties agree as to what is to be done about Victoria Bridge, they are given power to put their agreement into effect. If they do not agree, then the Chief Justice shall, at the request of the Minister for Local Government, appoint an arbitrator to decide what is to be done. Provision is made to carry into effect the decision of the arbitrator.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 38:—

In page 56, First Schedule, to delete the entries relating to the Dublin, Wicklow and Wexford Railway Act, 1900, the Great Southern and Western Railway Act, 1903, and the Midland Great Western Railway of Ireland Act, 1903, and to insert the following:—

“63 & 64 Vic., c. clvi | Dublin Wicklow and Wexford Railway Act, 1900. | Sections 25 and 26.

3 Edw. VII, c. clx | Great Southern and Western Railway Act, 1903. | Sections 36 and 38.

3 Edwd. VII, c. clxiii | Midland Great Western Railway of Ireland Act, 1903. | Section 29; Section 31, so far as relates to trespass by persons.”

This amendment is consequential on an earlier amendment which related to hotels. We put in an omnibus section prescribing the powers of the company in relation to hotels and we are deleting, in this amendment, the various sections of the old Acts which will no longer be applicable.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 39:—

In page 62, line 39, Fifth Schedule, paragraph 1, sub-paragraph (1) to delete the word "undertaker" and substitute the word "licensee".

This is only a drafting amendment, the purpose of which is to delete the word "undertaker" and substitute the word "licensee".

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 40:—

In page 62, Fifth Schedule between lines 44 and 45, paragraph 1, sub-paragraph (1), to insert the following:—

the expression "former transport undertaker" means any person being—

(a) a former transport company, or

(b) a former road transport licensee.

A number of amendments effect nearly the same change, and this, which is a drafting amendment, is one of them.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 41:—

In page 62, Fifth Schedule, paragraph 1, sub-paragraph (1), to add at the end of the sub-paragraph, line 51, the following:— the word "remuneration" shall be construed as including any cost of living or other bonus.

Deputy Peadar Doyle raised this matter in Committee. I pointed out that the wording of the section was intended to ensure that the term "remuneration" would include any cost of living or other bonus, but as there appeared to be some doubt about it I agreed to put the matter beyond all doubt by the insertion of this amendment.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 42:—

In page 63, line 6, Fifth Schedule, paragraph 1, sub-paragraph (2), to delete the word "undertaker" and substitute the word "licensee".

This is also a drafting amendment, similar to amendment No. 40.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 43:—

In page 63, line 8, Fifth Schedule, paragraph 1, sub-paragraph (2) (b), to delete the word "company" and substitute the word "undertaker".

This is a similar drafting amendment.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 44:—

In page 63, Fifth Schedule, paragraph (2), before clause (c), line 19, to insert the following clause:—

(c) if that person was suspended from the service of a former transport undertaker on or after the 1st day of April, 1916, and before the 6th day of December, 1921, and the Minister certifies that his suspension was due to his national sympathies, the period of suspension shall be included in the period of his pensionable services.

Comment on this
Eamonn O'Neill An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

There is an amendment — No. 45 — to this amendment, in the names of Deputies M. O'Sullivan and Keyes.

Comment on this

Yes, Sir. I move amendment No. 45, which is an amendment to Amendment No. 44:—

After the word "suspended", where it occurs in the amendment, to insert the words "or dismissed"; and after the word "suspension", wherever it occurs in the amendment, to insert the words "or dismissal".

Comment on this

With regard to amendment No. 44, I think it was Deputy Keyes who raised this question of the possible interruption of a person's employment by the Great Southern Railways Company by reason of his refusal to drive a train or to carry munitions or armed British troops during the period from April, 1916, to December, 1921, and his desire was to arrange that any such period, during which service with the company was interrupted for such causes, would count as service with the company for purposes of compensation or pension under the Bill. I said, on that occasion, that I agreed with the proposition in principle, but that there would be difficulty in getting formal words to cover the difficulty. In view of that, the amendment I now propose is the best that I could do. I propose, under the amendment, that where the Minister certifies that the individual's suspension was due to his national sympathies, and where the suspension occurred between the 1st day of April, 1916, and the 6th day of December, 1921, then that period of suspension shall be included in the period of his pensionable service.

Comment on this

I agree that the Minister has tried to meet the principle, and I admit the difficulty of getting the proper wording to cover these cases, but all I am asking in my amendment is that the Minister should go a step further, in order to make it clear that his intentions will be carried out. The Minister says that where the suspension of an individual during that period was due to his national sympathies, the period of suspension shall be included in the period of his pensionable service, but I have in mind the cases of men who were, not merely suspended, but automatically dismissed.

Comment on this

Yes, I quite understand that, but I have explained that the draftsman found very considerable difficulty in getting the word "dismissal" into the section without providing for a limit in time, which might be very difficult to apply, and in those circumstances I felt that the best thing to do was to leave the amendment in the form in which it was drafted, and to give my assurance that if there should arise any difficulty in applying it, I shall take the matter up with the company, and I do not expect any difficulty in persuading the company to take the necessary steps to cover such cases if they should arise. Because of the legal difficulty in meeting the matter of dismissal, without making elaborate provisions covering the period of time in respect of which the dismissal operated, I should prefer to leave the amendment as it is, but I will give the assurance to the House that, in the event of any difficulty of that kind arising, in applying this provision of the Bill in the case of a person who was dismissed during that period of national difficulty, I shall take that matter up with the company with a view to getting an equitable arrangement with the company in respect of that individual.

Comment on this

I know quite well that the Minister's intentions in that regard are quite sincere, but the trouble is that the time may come when the Minister may not be in a position to take up that attitude with the company when these men are applying for their pensions. In that event, the company may take a certain line and stand upon the terms of the amendment as it is set down here, as to whether it affects suspension or dismissal. I do know that in some cases dismissal did take place here in the City of Dublin, and I have recently come across a case of a man in County Mayo who said he was dismissed because of his national sympathies during that period.

Comment on this

But there is the question of a time limit. For instance, a man may not have gone back to work.

Comment on this

Yes, but he was dismissed because of his national sympathies.

Comment on this

Yes, of course, but if he did not resume work the question of his suspension does not arise. I think it is implicit, both in the Deputy's amendment and in mine, that resumption of work should have taken place, and, as I have pointed out, it would be extremely difficult to cover all that would be implied in the word "dismissal".

Comment on this

All I am endeavouring to do is to point out to the Minister that there are such cases, and that they are not covered here.

Comment on this

I was anxious to meet the Deputy on that point but I found that there were considerable drafting difficulties.

Comment on this

If the Minister can cover the point of those who were suspended but who are still working away, I cannot understand why he should not be able to cover the case of men who were dismissed rather than suspended.

Comment on this

I will give the assurance that, if any such case should arise, I will take the matter up with the company with a view to making an equitable arrangement as between the company and the individual concerned.

Comment on this

Very good.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 46:—

In page 63, Fifth Schedule, paragraph 1, sub-paragraph (2), before clause (c), line 19, to insert the following clause:—

( ) if that person was, by reason of disruption of railway services due directly to civil strife in the years 1922, 1923 or 1924, temporarily absent from his employment with a former transport undertaker, such temporary absence shall be included in the period of his pensionable service;.

This is another amendment that, on Committee, I undertook to introduce. Its effect is to provide that if a person's employment was interrupted by reason of the disruption of transport services during the civil war, that period will count for pensionable purposes also.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 47:—

In page 63, Fifth Schedule, line 20, paragraph 1, sub-paragraph (2), clause (c), to delete the words "dissolved company" and substitute the words "former transport undertaker".

This is also a drafting amendment.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 48:—

In page 63, line 26, Fifth Schedule, paragraph 1, sub-paragraph (2), clause (d), to delete the word "company" and substitute the words "undertaker or the company".

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 49:—

In page 63, line 38, Fifth Schedule, paragraph 1, sub-paragraph (2), clause (e), to delete the word "company" and substitute the word "undertaker".

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 50:—

In page 63, lines 43 and 44, Fifth Schedule, paragraph 1, sub-paragraph (2), clause (f), to delete the words "in any former transport company" and substitute the words "with any former transport undertaker or the company".

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 51:—

In page 63, in the Fifth Schedule, paragraph 2, line 54, to delete the words "on the critical date" and substitute the words "on the date of the abolition of his office or situation".

Comment on this

Is this covered by the previous amendments?

Comment on this

No, this is different. This has to deal with the case of a trade apprentice with a former passenger licensee, and is concerned with the period of apprenticeship with the company after the establishment date.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 53:—

In page 63, in the Fifth Schedule, paragraph 3, lines 60 and 61, to delete the words "on the critical date" and substitute the words "on the date of the abolition of his office or situation."

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 56:—

In page 64, Sixth Schedule, (a), in first column and at the head thereof, to insert after the word "chapter" the words "or Number and Year," and (b) at the end of the Sixth Schedule to add the following:—

No. 11 of 1933 | The Road Traffic Act, 1933 | Section 120

The reason for this amendment is that if we did not delete this section of the Road Traffic Act, there would be a conflict between it and the relevant section of this Bill. The Bill provides that the tickets issued by the company shall be printed in Irish and may be printed in English also. The Road Traffic Act provided that they should be printed in Irish and English and the deletion of the relevant section of that Act is being provided for here.

Comment on this

Does that mean that the conditions of carriage will be printed in Irish?

Comment on this

No. It refers to permanent notices and tickets.

Comment on this

Tickets, yes, but what about those posters that one never sees, purporting to prevent us from claiming for compensation for accidents?

Comment on this

Not necessarily so. They must be printed in Irish.

Comment on this

It is bad enough that we never see those notices, but are we to take it that these handbills and so on are to be in Irish only?

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 57:—

In page 65, Eighth Schedule, paragraph 2, sub-paragraph (1), to delete all words from the words "but the" in line 16 to the end of the sub-paragraph and substitute the words "but, subject to the provisions of the Seventh Schedule to this Act, the Minister may, on the application of the company or any interested person, by order specify any articles of merchandise upon which the charges may be calculated by reference to cubic capacity and prescribe the method by which the cubic contents for the purpose of charge is to be calculated".

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 58:—

In page 65, Eighth Schedule, paragraph 6, sub-paragraph (1), line 56, to insert after the word "may" the words ",subject to the provisions of the Seventh Schedule to this Act,".

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 59:—

In page 68, Eighth Schedule, paragraph 19, to insert before the words "The Minister" the words "subject to the provisions of the Seventh Schedule to this Act,".

Comment on this

When is it proposed to take the Fifth Stage?

Comment on this

To-morrow.

Comment on this

Will it be drafted for us by to-morrow?

Comment on this

Yes; arrangements have been made to have the draft ready.

Comment on this

I think it should not be taken too early to-morrow, because it seems to me that, if the amendments are to be inserted, it would not be possible for us to take the Bill early to-morrow.

Comment on this

Very well. I shall consider that.

Comment on this