We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Arterial Drainage Bill, 1944—Committee Stage (Resumed).

Contributions 1–179 of 351. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Arterial Drainage Bill, 1944
Enacted

No. 16 of 1944 ›

I move amendment No. 75:—

To delete paragraph (f) of sub-section (2), lines 29-44, page 16.

This amendment could be debated with amendment No. 108, but there is a material difference at the same time, as this deals with certifying the work of a county council, while the other is worse, as it deals with the commissioners certifying their own work.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy could deal with both now, or withdraw amendment No. 75.

Comment on this

The degree of efficiency in which the drainage is to be maintained arises on this. If a drainage work is kept in a very poor condition and is taken over by the local authority, what period does the Parliamentary Secretary anticipate will elapse before it is put into proper condition? There is a certain amount of anomaly running through the Bill in that respect, and we will come to it later on. Some of the sections empower the commissioners to compel the local authority to maintain a work in an efficient condition and, if they fail, the commissioners have the right to enter and do the job themselves. There are other sections which set out that there is no responsibility on the local authority to keep a work in a better condition than that in which it was certified to be on inspection by the commissioners. I am doubtful as to how far the commissioners will insist on the local authority maintaining the work. It would appear that power is being taken only to compel them to maintain it in a condition equal to that in which it was when taken over, and if it was in a bad condition, then nothing will be done about it for some years, until the commissioners have it transferred to themselves. Would the Parliamentary Secretary clear up that point?

Comment on this
Patrick Smith Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance (Mr. Smith) Fianna Fáil

I am at some loss to know what exactly I have to clear up. We are aiming to hand over to county councils all drainage districts on the appointed day. In some of these cases the boards and trustees originally responsible for maintenance have gone out of existence and the people whose lands are affected have had no person or authority against whom they could take action if they felt that injustice was being done to them as a result of the neglect or alleged neglect of the district. Immediately on the passage of this Bill into law, and immediately on the appointed day being named and the districts being transferred to the county councils for maintenance, those people whose lands are affected will be in a much better position from the point of view of having a mark for a legal action. Some of the districts have been neglected for years and years and flooding would probably take place. We feel it is only right that, while we are making provision for the transfer to the county councils, we should insert safeguards in the Bill to ensure that those county councils cannot be made the cockshot of any person or group of persons and that they cannot be expected to maintain these districts in a better condition than they were in on the date of transfer, and will not be legally obliged to do so. Of course, if the county surveyor thinks that certain work should be done that would be beneficial, there is no hindrance to the county council in doing it, but naturally we could not ask the county councils to be responsible for these districts, some of which have been neglected for many years, without giving them the security which is provided in this section and which Deputy Hughes now seeks to eliminate.

It is for that reason that we provide here for the issue by the drainage authority of a certificate, which will be accepted by a court of law, to establish that the condition in which the drainage district is is not worse than what it was at the date of its transfer. For that reason it is necessary to make an inspection of each district before the fixation of the appointed day. Therefore, between the date of the passage of this Bill into law and the fixation of the appointed day, our office must make an inspection of every district, so that we will have a record of the exact condition of that district. Then, if any difficulty should arise between the riparian owners there and the local authority responsible for maintenance, we will be able to go into court and say: "Here is a certificate showing the condition in which this district was on the date of transfer to the county council, and here is a certificate which says that district is at least as good as it was on the date of transfer. The county council, while free to maintain it in a better state if it likes, is not legally obliged to maintain it up to any better standard than that at which it was maintained prior to its transfer." When Deputy Hughes thinks over that, he will probably agree — as any Deputy must agree — to the necessity for such a safeguard.

Comment on this

I am not questioning that at all.

Comment on this

If we had not this safeguard, people who had no mark previously to take a shot at for damages, could take these actions, and perhaps succeed, and so create a very awkward position, financially and otherwise, for the local authority concerned.

Comment on this

Is it by the county council that the certificate submitted by the engineer of the Board of Works will be accepted?

Comment on this

By the court.

Comment on this

Would it not be well to see that the local county surveyor was consulted as to whether schemes that are handed over to the local authority are in a suitable condition?

Comment on this

I am afraid the Deputy is confusing the point we are discussing. I want Deputies to think in terms of the fixation of the appointed day that will apply to all existing drainage districts that are not already in the hands of county councils for maintenance.

Comment on this

Deputy Heskin is talking about future drainage.

Comment on this

The phraseology of the section seems to me to be somewhat involved. I would like to know if the inspection on which a certificate is issued will take place after proceedings have been initiated by the riparian owners, or somebody else, against a county council.

Comment on this

As we proceed with the Committee Stage of the Bill, we will come to an amendment which seeks to compel us to fix the appointed day within 12 months.

Comment on this

That was my amendment which has been dealt with.

Comment on this

I resisted that amendment for the reason that we must have inspected all these districts before the appointed day is fixed. It is on the basis of the condition revealed by the inspection that must take place prior to the fixation of the appointed day that the certificate will be issued on which the court will act.

Comment on this

This paragraph in the section does not say so. I think that if the Parliamentary Secretary will read it over again he will find that an inspection takes place prior to the fixation of the appointed day, and that, in the case of proceedings against a county council, presumably another inspection will take place. It is, presumably, on that inspection that the sealed certificate will be issued, and will be presented to the court for the purpose of absolving the county council from any financial liability in respect of any claim made by the riparian owners or anybody else against the county council. Is that certificate to be issued following an inspection which is in addition to the inspection that takes place prior to the fixing of the appointed day?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

Is it not a fact that there will be a special certificate issued for the purposes of litigation?

Comment on this

The point is that we will be called upon to give a certificate to the court as to whether the district, since it was transferred to the local authority, has been maintained in as good a condition as it was in prior to its being handed over. For the purpose of seeing whether the condition in which it is or was prior to being handed over we must have an inspection carried out prior to the fixation of the appointed day. Supposing that in a year or two, or even in five years' time after the fixation of the appointed day, a case arises as between the riparian owners and the local authority, we will have to go down to the district again to inspect it, to see whether or not it was being maintained in as good a condition as it was in prior to being handed over. Obviously, a certificate to that effect could not be issued without a second inspection.

Comment on this

And that takes place subsequent to the initiation of proceedings?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

We are protecting the local authority from individuals in so far as that they cannot compel it to maintain the drainage in a better condition than that in which it was at the time it was transferred on the appointed day. The point that I am anxious about is this: can the Commissioners compel a local authority to keep a drainage in a better condition of maintenance than it was in prior to being handed over? I think that under Section 29 they can.

Comment on this

If that is not so, I would be glad if the Parliamentary Secretary would explain the meaning of paragraph (e), which says:—

"no council or councils jointly shall be obliged by this sub-section to maintain any existing drainage works in a condition or state of repair better than the condition and state of repair in which such works were at the time of the last inspection by the commissioners under this sub-section prior (but not more than 12 months prior) to the appointed day."

I would ask the Parliamentary Secretary to relate that paragraph to Section 29 which provides:—

"(1) Whenever, after the appointed day, the commissioners are of opinion that any existing drainage works which are for the time being maintainable by the council of a county or the councils of two or more counties are not being properly maintained and that maintenance or repair work is immediately necessary in respect of the said existing drainage works, it shall be lawful for the commissioners to serve by post on such council or each of such councils a notice (in this section referred to as a notice of disrepair) stating that in the opinion of the commissioners the maintenance or repair work specified in that behalf in such notice is immediately necessary in respect of the said existing drainage works and requiring such council or councils to execute the said maintenance or repair work within a time specified in that behalf in such notice."

I think that under that section the commissioners can compel a local authority to improve the state of maintenance that existed at the time of the appointed day. There is an anomaly there as between paragraph (e) of the section that we are discussing and Section 29.

Comment on this

The Deputy must remember that there are districts already in the hands of county councils for maintenance purposes, and that in the past, in many cases, these have not been maintained as they should have been. I think the Deputy will admit with me that they are in an altogether different category from the older districts that were in the hands of trustees or boards. I think it is only right, in the case of a district created under the 1925 Act on which large sums of money were spent and for which, let us say, the county council was responsible for maintenance over a period of years, that we should have the power to ensure that from now on the local authority will discharge its responsibility by seeing that the district is maintained in the manner in which it should have been maintained from the time of its constitution.

Comment on this

Is the Parliamentary Secretary taking power to compel a local authority to improve the condition of an existing maintenance?

Comment on this

To improve maintenance?

Comment on this

I think you are under Section 29. Will the Parliamentary Secretary explain to me the meaning of that section?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

We have not reached that section yet.

Comment on this

There is an anomaly there that, I think, needs to be explained.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Yes, there is a seeming anomaly.

Comment on this

We can argue it now or later on, whichever you like, but I think it ought to be cleared up some time. I direct the attention of the Parliamentary Secretary to this: sub-section (1), Section 29, says:

"... that in the opinion of the commissioners the maintenance or repair work specified in that behalf in such notice is immediately necessary in respect of the said existing drainage works and requiring such council or councils to execute the said maintenance or repair works within a time specified in that behalf in such notice."

Paragraph (b) of subsection (2) states:—

"... it shall be lawful for the commissioners to enter on the said existing drainage works and there execute or complete (as the case may be) the said maintenance or repair works."

That means that if the repair work or maintenance is not efficiently done you can either compel the local authority or go in and do it yourself and you are not limiting the responsibility of the local authority to the degree of maintenance that obtained on the appointed day. There is a definite anomaly.

Comment on this

The final awards in all these cases provide for maintenance. The final award in all the cases under the 1925 Act, for example, provided that in each case money would be expended on the district for maintenance by the county council or councils to which it was transferred.

Comment on this

We are not doing that here.

Comment on this

If that council or these councils fail to maintain that district then we certainly should have power to compel that local authority to do so.

Comment on this

Why have you not said that?

Comment on this

To the extent that we are transferring districts that were formally the responsibility of boards and trustees, all we are asking these county councils to do in relation to these districts is to maintain them up to a standard at least as good as the standard to which they were maintained by these authorities.

Comment on this

This will also cover embankments that are in the hands of trustees — is not that so?

Comment on this

No, it will not.

Comment on this

There is nothing about embankments in the section.

Comment on this

They are drainage works. Do not they come within the scope of the Bill?

Comment on this

This particular section does not refer to embankments.

Comment on this

I am referring to a trustee body that was set up.

Comment on this

We will get to that later, I think.

Comment on this

There are at least a few boards already in existence, to which I think Deputy Heskin is referring, who maintain certain drainage works that would not be styled embankments. In certain districts funds are provided for drainage purposes by boards, who may or may not be doing their work. I want to safeguard the position of the riparian owners who would not be provided for in that respect by trustee funds or other funds provided for maintaining drainage, and which was not carried out in the last four or five years. The funds may have been lying there and not put to the purpose for which they were intended, or the work might otherwise be neglected. It is obvious that if no work was carried out for five or six years preceding the appointed day these particular drainage schemes would be in a bad state of repair on the appointed day and all that would be required of the county council would be to maintain the drainage in the condition in which it was on the appointed day. The riparian owners might be in a difficulty in that respect. Is there any safeguard for the riparian owners in this particular section?

Comment on this

As far, as Section 23, paragraph (f) of sub-section (2)——

Comment on this

(e) and (f).

Comment on this

——(e) and (f)—are concerned, what you have to make up your mind about is, do you think that the authority to whom these districts are being transferred should be protected in this way or do you not?

Comment on this

I quite agree.

Comment on this

If you think they should be protected in this particular manner, then there is no way out of the acceptance of this section as it is. If you have a different point of view, and if you think the responsibility should be transferred to the local authorities, with complete freedom for every person who may feel he has a grievance to take a legal action against that local authority, then, naturally, you will ask for the deletion of these two paragraphs, (e) and (f). I think most Deputies will understand the necessity for their inclusion.

Comment on this

Yes. I recognise the necessity for these two particular paragraphs and I am not opposing them but I am wondering is there any way of providing for a contingency such as I have mentioned where a board of trustees or some such body has been set up. I do not think there are many of them in existence; there are not many in my county; but I assume there are some. I think there were some such bodies under the old landlord system, where funds were set up for the drainage of rivers. Drainage work may not have been done for the five or six years preceding the appointed day. I do not know that we could devise means to compel them, after the appointed day has been decided, to carry out the work. I think the question will arise in connection with the allocation of their funds. I do not want to press the point.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 76:

In sub-section (2), page 16, line 45, to insert the words ", agent or servant", before the words "of the commissioners".

This is a consequential amendment.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 77:—

At the end of sub-section (2), page 16, to add a new paragraph as follows:—

(h) Until such time as the Commissioners have put into repair drainage works and embankments transferred to county councils under this section, and have issued certificates of such repair, no county council shall be held responsible at law for damages arising from the present condition of such drainage works or embankments.

My view is that these two sections are not going far enough. I do not believe that you can devise any code of words or regulations which would prevent immense litigation as to the degree of liability in the State, once you have the appointed day coming in. The Parliamentary Secretary stated very glibly that a certificate will be issued as to the present state of the district when it is handed over, but is the Parliamentary Secretary not aware that embankments do not remain in a particular state? Erosion, water surface, and all these things, affect them. You are dealing with the taking over of drainage areas that were formerly the liability of other people. You are transferring them as a liability on the ratepayers of the county councils, in my view, without adequate protection, no matter how you frame it, against litigation by people who are affected or think they are affected. The only bold way of dealing with it is on the lines suggested in the amendment. Any other phrasing, or any effort to protect local authorities on the lines proposed in the Bill, will mean that any eminent lawyer will be able to drive a coach and four through the Act. I think the proposal in the Bill invites them to do it, with the great mark of the county rate as an inducement both to the applicant and to those encouraging him to proceed.

I have in mind two great works in the county, portion of which I represent. One is the drainage of the Awbeg which cost the State and the local authority something like £35,000, made up of a gift of £16,000 by the county council and the contribution of £15,000 by the State. The owners got a loan which they were repaying over 35 years to the county council. They had responsibility for the embankments — a responsibility which was more honoured in the breach by some, but that is neither here nor there — but they are now being entirely relieved of the obligation to repay that loan. Liability for the upkeep of that drainage work is being transferred to the local authority, the Cork County Council, which has already subscribed £11,000 and given a loan of £5,000. The most serious effect of the Bill, in my opinion, is that it leaves open the way to litigation and claims for damages by people living in the area. There is also a much bigger scheme which was one of the old relief works — the embankment, which is now in a very precarious state, protecting the sloblands in the town of Youghal. It is a liability of the landholders. If, by any chance, that embankment goes, the claims of property owners in the town of Youghal in respect of consequential damage will be enormous.

As I say, the only bold way to tackle it is in the way suggested in the amendment — that no local authority shall be held responsible until such time as the embankments are in repair and a certificate to that effect has been issued. If those embankments are subsequently allowed to go into disrepair and any damage occurs, the local authority will know that they will be liable. To try to get anyone to understand the degree of disrepair on the basis of their present condition is extremely difficult and I am fortified in the point I am making in favour of my amendment by the Parliamentary Secretary's anxiety to protect local authorities from frivolous and vexatious claims. Unless areas of this country are to become hotbeds of litigation as between property owners and local authorities, he should seriously consider the amendment.

Comment on this

The same problem arises in my area. In County Waterford, we have about 60 miles of embankments which, in many cases, under the Land Acts, were the responsibility of the Land Commission. According to the Bill, these will, on the appointed day, become the responsibility of the county council. Section 37 says that the local authority shall not put embankments or drainage works in a better condition than that in which they were on the appointed day. These embankments as they are at the moment, in a deplorable state, will be handed over to the county council as its future liability, and I believe that, taking into consideration the huge mileage of embankments involved and the very bad condition of these embankments at present, the county council's liability will be unbearable.

In one area, the Blackwater area, we have very nearly 18½ miles of embankments. Around Cappoquin there is one portion of the embankment extending for over a mile which would need to be built anew. If that responsibility is to fall on the county council, where will the ratepayers be? My argument is that it should be a national responsibility and not a liability of the county council, which can never bear such a burden. There is an embankment of 6½ miles on the Bride; two miles on the Colligan; four miles on the Brickey; two miles on the Mahon, and 36 miles on the Suir. I fail to see how the local authority can be expected to assume that burden, in view of the present condition of the embankments and in view of the fact that the Land Commission "funked" their responsibility in the matter of maintaining them.

I have here a communication from a lady in the Nore area, where the Land Commission in 1933 built an embankment on the river. I hold that it was the responsibility of the Land Commission, and if the Land Commission was responsible, I hold that, when it is transferred at the appointed date, the county council becomes responsible. This lady has ten acres of land which are useless to her, and in view of the provision in the Bill providing for compensation where loss or damage is occasioned, due to inadequate protection, where will the county council be? If it is the responsibility of the Land Commission, and, under the Bill, she can apply for compensation, where does the county council come in? If the county council has to compensate people as it works along 60 or 70 miles of embankments, there will be no County Waterford at all because the people will not be able to pay their rates.

The Parliamentary Secretary should do something in relation to this area to ensure that the local authority will be safeguarded at least to the extent that the embankments will be put into a proper state of repair before the appointed date. I suggest that, in order to protect the county council, a certificate from the county surveyor that he was satisfied that they were in a proper state of repair before being taken over should be received by the local authority. In the 60 miles there are, as I say, other areas not included in this and there are embankments which are the responsibility of the Land Commission. There are many areas which I and other Deputies from the constituency may have no knowledge of. Still we have to acceptresponsibility, according to this Bill. In order to safeguard the county councils, I ask the Parliamentary Secretary to provide that at least a certificate from the county surveyor should be forthcoming to satisfy the members of the local authority, before the embankments are taken over on the appointed day, that they are in a satisfactory state, in order to relieve the ratepayers of undue responsibility.

Comment on this

I have a feeling that Deputy Heskin has got things a bit trí na céile. We are not providing here for the taking over of all embankments on the appointed day. You have drainage districts under the 1842 and 1863 Drainage Acts and in some of these drainage districts you have embankments. Naturally these embankments are part of the drainage districts. When these districts are transferred, as they will be, on the appointed day, naturally these embankments will go with them. But there are embankments outside of that particular type to which I have referred for the maintenance of which trust funds have been established. There are embankments for the maintenance of which nobody has any responsibility. There are embankments situated on lands vested in tenants, whose lands are being protected by them, for the maintenance of which no fund is in existence and for which no one is legally responsible except the people on whose lands the embankments are situated. There are embankments on lands in the hands of the Land Commission which have not yet been vested in the tenants and for the maintenance of which no fund is in existence.

We are not dealing in this section with taking over embankments other than embankments that are included in drainage districts. It is true that we are making provision in Part IV to take over any of the other embankments as we come to them, if we think it wise to take them over. If we go into a district in County Waterford, County Cork, County Kerry, or any other county——

Comment on this

On a point of order. The wording in fact does appear in these amendments. There are five covering this.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

There are Sections 31 to 36.

Comment on this

Would you make a ruling as to how we are to proceed?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I think we had better discuss the section and dispose of the amendment.

Comment on this

The Parliamentary Secretary admits now that they are not taking over embankments under this Bill until such time as they think proper. They are not being automatically taken over.

Comment on this

The Youghal case, which the Deputy has in mind, is an exceptional case, I admit. The Youghal case is the one exception so far as I know to the general rule that I have tried to explain.

Comment on this

Are you taking it over under this Bill?

Comment on this

The Youghal district is a drainage district.

Comment on this

That compels me to insist on the amendment even if I have to divide the House.

Comment on this

I can only say in reply to Deputy Broderick that we could not accept an amendment of this kind, because it asks us to transfer districts only when we do reconstructional work. Of course that would mean that we could only deal with this problem piecemeal. That would mean that we could not have one appointed day in respect of the districts. It would mean that the riparian owners and the people who are called upon to pay rates under the 1925 Act, and so on, would not have their burden spread over the county-at-large, except in so far as we had actually reconstructed a district. The result of that would be that, if we start to take over a district in County Waterford, the riparian owners there would get the benefit of having their burden transferred to the county-at-large. The riparian owners in some other county would have to wait until the drainage authority was able to get to them for the purpose of putting a scheme into operation before they could get the relief provided for here. You would have a campaign such as took place in connection with the 1923 Land Act. A certain reduction was withheld from the tenants under that Act until the land was vested in them. As the result of pressure over a number of years on the part of the people affected, they compelled the Legislature to give them relief even prior to the vesting of the land in the tenants. The same thing would happen in connection with this. If we proceeded to give the people of one district the relief provided for here and the riparian owners of another district had to wait 10, 15, or 20 years for that relief, that condition of things would not be tolerated. In order to fix the appointed day, in order to ensure that these districts would not be allowed to deteriorate still further, we must have power to transfer these districts to some body, such as the county council, which will see to it that they do not get into a worse condition than they are in, until such time as they are reached under the reconstruction scheme contemplated.

Comment on this

The Parliamentary Secretary is aware that in one similar case the courts held the local authority liable. I think the State had to come to the assistance of the local authority. The Parliamentary Secretary knows what happened in Tipperary. Here you are handing over one of the biggest embankments in Ireland, which cost something like £50,000 when wages and the cost of materials were very low. You are handing that over in a precarious state to the local authority of the County Cork with a consequential liability with regard to the lands and the residential holdings behind it and holding the local authority liable. This amendment merely asks in that particular case, or so far as it applies, that no liability for damage or consequential damage would be on the local authority until such time as the embankment was put into repair. Now you tell me that this is one of the outstanding cases where it cannot be done. Do you think it is fair to transfer this embankment in its present precarious position? It is in a very bad condition at the present moment, and do you consider it fair to hand over the liability for damage for anything that might happen, to the local authority in County Cork? I think it is most unfair. I do not like dividing the House on this matter because the result, with the Government's vote, is obvious; but I, for one, strongly dissent from the proposal to have this included without a guarantee from the Department that there will be no liability on the local authority until such time as the embankment is put into repair.

Comment on this

I think Deputy Broderick has a very sound case. Even the section attempts to safeguard the interests of the local authority, to ensure that the local authority will not be mulcted for substantial damages. There is, however, this difficulty about Deputy Broderick's amendment, that first you would have to ask the commissioners to do the necessary repairs, and then it would be rather peculiar to hand it back to the local authority for a short time, and eventually hand it over to the commissioners again. You will be introducing a third stage into the procedure that you have adopted.

The present procedure is that the local authority takes it over and maintains it, if it is the drainage authority for the time being, and finally it is transferred to the commissioners. If you were to implement the amendment, the commissioners would first have to do the necessary repairs, then it would be handed to the local authority, and finally you would transfer it again to the commissioners. I do not think what Deputy Broderick is anxious to safeguard — the interests of the local authority — is properly covered by his amendment, but surely the Parliamentary Secretary will look into the matter and see that between this and Report Deputy Broderick's anxiety in this particular case so far as County Cork is concerned will be relieved.

Comment on this

Having discussed this matter with the Deputy concerned, I do not know that that would be altogether possible. The position is undoubtedly somewhat peculiar. I suppose it could be safely said that where you have sea embankments of the type that are here, you never know what might happen. The Deputy is afraid that if this drainage district is transferred to the county council for maintenance up to the standard, or not exceeding the standard in which it has been maintained, or is being maintained, some unforeseen or unprovided for thing may happen, that some breach may be effected in the embankment, and that that would expose the local authority concerned to the possibility of having to pay compensation. I do not see any way out of that. I do not see how you could in any way try to provide for such an occurrence. I think we will have to do with this district what we are aiming to do with every other district— transfer it, as we are transferring all the others, for maintenance by the local authority, and the people responsible for its maintenance and ourselves will have to take whatever risks or dangers that act will expose us to. I do not see any other way out of it.

Comment on this

I think the Parliamentary Secretary does not quite understand the position. I am not objecting to the maintenance. What I am objecting to, and what every person interested and who has knowledge of the circumstances objects to, is the liability to damage or consequential damage up to the time the local authority hands it over. Trouble is liable to come here at any moment, and any damage or consequential damage might be held by the courts to be a liability on the Cork County Council. The Parliamentary Secretary knows there were two decisions in major cases of that kind, and they were given against the local authority and even against the Government.

Your first statement to Deputy Hughes was that if he wanted the local authority to be protected he should not object to those two sections. What protection are those two sections giving to the ratepayers of Cork County? This is a question of such magnitude, it is such an enormous thing, that it ought not to be passed over without due consideration. I submit there should be no liability on the local authority until the embankment is put in some kind of repair. I have suggested that a certificate conveying the degree of bad repair, if you like, of this embankment, should be issued to the local authority. Is it conceivable that the embankment, will remain just in its present condition? Is it not more likely that its condition will be worse? I suggest there will be a glorious opportunity for adroit legal minds to interest themselves as to the condition the embankment was in when it was handed over, when they are determining the liability.

You are running a grave risk in this matter. It applies to other drainage schemes as well, even the Awbeg. Some safeguard will have to be thought out in order to protect the ratepayers of Cork County. I can see no safeguard beyond the one suggested in this amendment, that liability for damage and consequential damage should not be placed on the ratepayers or the local authority until such time as the embankments are put in repair. This is private property and I suggest we have no responsibility.

I do not want to go into the history of this property; it is well known to people in this House. It is now the liability of the tenants living alongside it. Why should a native Government throw the responsibility on the ratepayers of Cork County of maintaining a huge embankment that cost between £70,000 and £75,000? It is now in a bad state of repair, undermined, and the water is flowing over it. The banks are gone and you are endeavouring to put a big liability on the local rates. It would not be so bad if it merely threatened the land inside the embankment, but it threatens a good portion of the residential area of the town.

I would like Deputies to consider what it would mean if County Cork people were held liable in law for any damage that might be caused. I think this case is entitled to special treatment, and the only way you can safeguard the people there from litigation is to indicate that that particular portion of the drainage area should be put into proper repair before it is handed over — that we will not be liable until it is properly repaired.

Comment on this

Has the Parliamentary Secretary been advised on that aspect? It arises on paragraph (f) — the sealed certificate of the commissioners. Is that likely to safeguard the interests of the local authorities so far as consequential damage is concerned?

Comment on this

It is.

Comment on this

There is another aspect altogether, which I think Deputy Broderick is inclined to overlook and which this House should not overlook —the position of the individual, in the event of floods breaking through a bank and very serious damage being done. Whether it be in Youghal town, on a farm or in a rural district, surely we should be deeply concerned about the interests of those individuals living behind the bank which has been swept away? Their means of existence has been destroyed and may be inundated by the flood for two or three years. Is it not vital that we should provide compensation in the case of individuals so affected? Whether this is to be the responsibility of the local authority or the central authority, this House should decide, but we should not overlook that point. Listening to Deputy Broderick, it strikes me that, in our anxiety to safeguard the local authority, we may forget the more vital interest of the individuals swamped out completely by floods breaking over the bank. It is only right and proper that there should be some safeguard in the Bill for the interests of the families concerned, in the event of an artificial break through a river or a flood in any shape or form, so that the people living behind the artificial bank will be covered by some financial provision if the bank collapses through deterioration of the embankment works.

Comment on this

I hope Deputy Hughes will not think that I overlooked their interests.

Comment on this

No, I am merely saying we should not do so.

Comment on this

It must be remembered that these people have no protection whatsoever at present. The drainage district was in the hands of trustees and no work is being done, no repairs have been carried out and no funds exist for that purpose. Everybody has respect for the rights of the individual, to the extent that he has rights, but surely Deputy Hughes would not think it reasonable for Parliament to go out of its way to create very formidable rights where the individual had no rights at all prior to the introduction of this Bill?

Comment on this

Why should we not?

Comment on this

My reply to Deputy Broderick is that we have in this State 80 or 90 districts supposed to be under trustees and boards originally created when the districts were first set up, and we want to transfer those districts on an appointed day to local authorities. We want to ensure that there will be some authority responsible for seeing after them and trying to keep them at least from deteriorating still further.

Comment on this

I am with the Parliamentary Secretary there.

Comment on this

We know that we cannot get to those districts in a short space of time to reconstruct them in the manner in which Deputy Broderick suggested this particular district in Youghal should be reconstructed. The only body which could properly undertake the maintenance is the county council and we are providing here for the transfer of the districts to that authority on the appointed day, subject to our being in a position to give a certificate of protection — in the event of legal proceeding arising later — to the local authority, to ensure that they will not be called upon by the riparian owners to keep these works in a condition better than that at which they were kept previously. That is all we are seeking to do here, and I do not know how we could deal with that problem other than in the way set out here.

Comment on this

Will the Parliamentary Secretary say what the liability or responsibility of the local authority is for embankments of that sort under existing legislation?

Comment on this

We have no responsibility for embankments that are part of a drainage district.

Comment on this

Supposing they are part of an existing drainage district?

Comment on this

Then they will be expected to maintain them up to a standard at least as high.

Comment on this

That is not the point. I want to know what the responsibility is at the moment.

Comment on this

The responsibility is nil.

Comment on this

Of a private work?

Comment on this

Supposing an embankment breaks down under present legislation — the 1925 Act and previous Acts —and flooded waters are let loose as a result, is there any liability incurred so far as the local authority is concerned?

Comment on this

I could not say. I would like Deputies to be clear on this point: There are very many embankments which are not included in any drainage district.

Comment on this

We are speaking of the ones which are.

Comment on this

Any embankment which is part of a drainage district will be handed over to the county council, which will be called upon to maintain it in a condition at least as good and up to a standard at least as high as the standard at which it was maintained prior to being handed over. I cannot make that any clearer.

Comment on this

In the case of Youghal, if there is no fund at the present moment to maintain such embankments, with whom will the responsibility rest?

Comment on this

With those who have it up to now.

Comment on this

The tenants?

Comment on this

The whole area would be flooded.

Comment on this

Of course it would.

Comment on this

And it would be left so. Monetary provision should be made in the case of such embankments, which had no protection in the wide world before, to safeguard the interests of the local authority before handing them over.

Comment on this

We are not taking them over.

Comment on this

The Parliamentary Secretary says he is only asking county councils to be responsible for the prevention of deterioration until such time as they are taken over by the commissioners. Surely there is a bigger responsibility than that? He says that, at the moment, there is no one responsible, owing to the collapse of the drainage boards. We are aware where the Land Commission avoided responsibility and sheltered recently by saying that some of the old drainage boards were responsible for the flooding of the Land Commission tenants; so between the failure of the boards of trustees and the Land Commission, nothing is being done at all, and no one is responsible. The Parliamentary Secretary intends to make local authorities responsible now for any damage that may arise pending the district being taken over by the commissioners, and they will have to accept liability for any claim lodged against them. We are thus making an authority responsible which had no responsibility up to this. Why should we hand the baby on to the local authorities without letting the local authorities know to what extent they are likely to be involved?

Comment on this

There is no doubt at all that under sub-section (2) the local authority assumes a contigent liability for anything that may happen after taking over such an embankment or drainage area. They must assume a contigent liability and, as Deputies Broderick and Keyes have pointed out, if an embankment bursts, the certificate of the commissioners will not save the local authority then, because it could be argued, if the case got to court, that they did not maintain the work as well as they found it, and, as a result, the bank broke. Therefore, anything that may happen in the way of damage from embankments bursting or otherwise after being taken over by the county council will certainly be the responsibility of the council. No one could prove otherwise, so the safeguard here in (f) will not safeguard them in any way. If nothing happens, they will be safeguarded all right. But if anything should happen, this will not safeguard them. As a matter of information, I would like to know from the Parliamentary Secretary if the drainage area known as the Slob in Wexford will become a liability of the local authority under this section?

Comment on this

No. It is not a drainage district.

Comment on this

I want to know if it is a drainage district.

Comment on this

The Deputy can call it what he likes, but it is not covered by these proposals.

Comment on this

That is all right. I would be glad if the Parliamentary Secretary would again go into this question of the future liability of county councils before the commissioners have repaired those embankments. Very considerable damage may be done and very considerable liability may be placed on the shoulders of local authorities that they have not to bear at the moment. I suggest that could easily happen under the section.

Comment on this

In view of what has been said from all sides of the House I would be glad if the Parliamentary Secretary would do his best to devise a safeguard to protect local authorities from liabilities falling on them that, in justice, they should not be asked to bear. I agree that there is a necessity for repairing these embankments and for a national effort in regard to the drainage of the country. While I agree with the Parliamentary Secretary on that, I again appeal to him to devise phraseology that will safeguard the local authorities until such time as the embankments are put into a reasonable condition. If, following that, the local authorities neglect their duty, that will be their responsibility. I suggest that it would be most unfair and unjust to put on them an undefined liability at the moment, and I ask the Parliamentary Secretary to take steps to avoid the danger of that arising.

Comment on this

I am sure the Deputy is conscious of the fact that we are very much concerned to try to build up the necessary safeguards for local authorities to whom we propose to transfer these drainage districts. We have given this matter a good deal of thought, and we have done the best that could be done in the circumstances. In view of his request, I can tell him that we will give the matter further consideration between now and Report Stage. At the same time, I must say that I see little hope of making any better provision for safeguarding county councils than the provision which we are making here. However, we are always open to see if anything better can be done consistent with our duty of carrying out the scheme in this Bill.

Comment on this

The one point I am anxious about is that no unnecessary or unjust liability should be placed on local authorities.

Comment on this

Nobody wants to do that.

Comment on this

On the section, can the Parliamentary Secretary give us any idea of the period of time that is likely to elapse before a maintenance transfer Order is made? We have been told that the appointed day will be the appointed day for the whole country. I am anxious to know if the maintenance transfer Orders will be operated in the same way or if they will be issued individually.

Comment on this

Under this section we visualise the setting up of a maintenance organisation when we carry out a drainage scheme. Take, for example, the case of the Brosna. After the execution of the work there, we will have to maintain the Brosna with our own maintenance organisation as provided in the section. It will come into effect immediately on the completion of the works there. We may say: "In order to create more work for the maintenance organisation, here are two or three, or four or five drainage districts that were transferred on the appointed day to the county councils concerned; we will take back these districts from the county councils and group them with the district that we have created; we will make the maintenance organisation, which we have set up to maintain the Brosna, look after the maintenance of these districts also." That is the meaning of the section.

Comment on this

So that in some cases a local authority may have to maintain for years before you transfer.

Comment on this

That is so.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 78:—

In Section 25, page 17, to insert the following new sub-sections:—

(3) Every person who immediately before the appointed day was for a period of not less than three years the holder of an office as secretary or clerk to a drainage board or to a body of trustees to which this section applies shall be entitled to be paid compensation under this section.

(4) Compensation under this section shall become payable to the holder of an office to which this section applies on the appointed day.

(5) The compensation payable under this section shall be calculated on the basis of one-sixth of the annual remuneration of the person to whom such compensation is payable, multiplied by the number of completed years of service such person has had with the drainage board or body of trustees under which he held office immediately before the appointed day.

(6) Any sum payable under this section shall be included in the liabilities of a dissolved body mentioned in the Second Schedule to this Act.

The expression "dissolved body" has in this section the same meaning as in the Second Schedule to this Act.

I think I am correct in stating that it has been the policy of the present and the previous Government to provide compensation for persons who may lose their employment as a result of legislation passed by this House. In view of the fact that a small number of individuals will lose their part-time employment as a result of the passing of this Bill, I would ask the Parliamentary Secretary to give favourable consideration to the terms of this amendment. If he agrees to accept it, the amount of compensation payable under it will be very small, and will not involve any charge on State funds. The Parliamentary Secretary may recognise that the compensation proposed to be paid to those part-time employees is related to the terms of the compensation which was paid to the agents of the different national health insurance societies whose positions were abolished when the National Health Insurance Act became law. The proposed terms set out in the amendment have been taken, more or less, from the National Health Insurance Act. I hope the Parliamentary Secretary will give the amendment favourable consideration, in view of the fact that it involves only a very small number of individuals. His acceptance of it will maintain the principle that has been adhered to by the present and the previous Government in regard to matters of this kind.

Comment on this

We are inclined to support the amendment. As a matter of fact, I have an amendment down which covers the same point—that financial provision should be made to give compensation.

Comment on this

Is the Deputy anxious to confer rights on people who, at the moment, have no rights at all?

Comment on this

No rights?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

When they were appointed to a particular post it seemed that that post was likely to continue. Take the case of a man appointed as secretary to a drainage board.

Comment on this

Yearly.

Comment on this

He has been in that position for years and, before this piece of legislation was introduced, it appeared to him that the job was likely to continue for the remainder of his life.

Comment on this

Supposing he was appointed as secretary to a drainage board ten or 20 years ago and did nothing ever since, would you like to provide compensation for him?

Comment on this

I do not think that is so.

Comment on this

I have pointed out to the Parliamentary Secretary that a couple of people I know, holding positions of this kind, were not in a position to get money for doing nothing. I think the position is comparable in many respects to the position of agents of an old national health insurance society, who were given compensation, after considerable discussion in this House. They have no legal rights at present. They have no right unless you are prepared to admit it. Their security in regard to their positions was about as much as that of agents of a national health insurance society, who were provided for in the same way as is suggested in the amendment when the National Health Insurance Bill was passing through the House.

Comment on this

Any rights that any of them have against their employer will be transferred to the county councils.

Comment on this

There may not have been provision for superannuation or anything like that. The Parliamentary Secretary asked about the man who was doing nothing for ten years. What about the man who was doing something for ten years?

Comment on this

The assets of these boards are going to the county councils and whatever liabilities they have are also being transferred.

Comment on this

We are thinking of those for whom no provision is being made for gratuity or pension.

Comment on this

Is it not an acknowledged principle of legislation that where a citizen loses his employment or income, the House that is responsible for such an event puts the obligation upon somebody to compensate him in some way for the loss of income or employment?

Comment on this

I am not inclined to accept any amendment dealing with this particular matter. Deputy Davin has cited the case of the amalgamated societies. I do not think there is any real comparison. You have a number of these boards and a number of these trustees and a number of these officials of such boards and trustees. Some of them may have done something and most of them have done nothing.

Comment on this

I have been asked to move this amendment by a man whom I know very well, who has been working with a drainage board, and I would not move an amendment in this House to put an obligation upon anybody to give compensation to an individual who, as the Parliamentary Secretary seems to think, has done nothing.

Comment on this

I am in the same position. I put this to the Parliamentary Secretary: would he consider empowering the local authority to do it, saying that they may do it?

Comment on this

That is all that is proposed.

Comment on this

I want to make it clear that to the extent that the individual concerned has any rights with his present employer, these rights will be carried on to the county council and whatever was recoverable from his previous employer by way of compensation for loss of office will be recoverable from the county council.

Comment on this

Take the case of men who have been doing their work religiously and efficiently. Surely there is nothing wrong in the principle of putting something into this measure to pass on the obligation to the authority to pay compensation to a person whose services will be terminated when this Bill comes into operation? I would ask the Parliamentary Secretary to look into the matter. I do not know the number of people who would be involved.

Comment on this

I got some correspondence from people who were interested in this particular matter and I must say that I have not come across a case where it could be established that any hardship was being imposed or any injustice was being done.

Comment on this

If a man loses part-time employment and a part of his income as a result of legislation passed by the Deputies of this House——

Comment on this

What do you mean by a part of his income?

Comment on this

He may have an annual income as secretary of a drainage board.

Comment on this

What sort of man have you in mind?

Comment on this

Secretary of a drainage board.

Comment on this

What kind of employment would he have other than the secretaryship?

Comment on this

The material thing is the salary. There may be no contractual rights against the drainage board. This House steps in and takes the salary or wage away which it was never intended should be taken away. To that extent this House is imposing that hardship and this House should discharge that liability, quite apart from the man having any contractual rights to a pension. The pension does not arise; he could do this job until he was 70 years of age, so long as the board existed. To that extent you are imposing hardship and the matter should not be dealt with in an arbitrary way. We are taking that man's salary or whatever it was. So long as he was of good behaviour and did his work, he was entitled to an annual salary. Some provision should be made to compensate such people. It would be very wrong, very highhanded, unjust and immoral if this House were to impose such hardship.

Comment on this

I take it that the Parliamentary Secretary is not opposing the principle of the amendment because, if he is, he is doing something that is different from anything done by his colleagues in the Government in connection with every measure of this kind passed since the Government came into office. I assume that a secretary of a drainage board does not get the title merely for the purpose of giving him a title and letting him draw a salary for doing nothing. I assume he has certain responsibilities; I cannot speak with authority. I am not a member of any drainage board and I confess I do not know very much about the work of a drainage board. Would the Parliamentary Secretary say, for instance, that the secretary of the Nore Drainage Board got this title from some person in authority merely to give him a part-time salary for doing nothing? Surely that is not being asserted by the Parliamentary Secretary.

Comment on this

I have a certain amount of sympathy with the Parliamentary Secretary. There are drainage boards that have more or less lapsed. I think that is what the Parliamentary Secretary means. On the other hand, there are drainage boards that have tried to do their work and the officials or secretaries have done the usual work of summoning meetings, advertising for tenders, and all that sort of thing. What I suggest is that if we do not make some such provision in this Bill it means that if a case of hardship arises, the local authority cannot do anything about it and the Parliamentary Secretary, while he might be very sympathetic, would have to say that nothing could be done as there was no provision for it in the Bill. Supposing, instead of "shall be entitled," you were to say, "the local authority may provide a gratuity or superannuation"?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

You could leave it optional, subject to the sanction of the Minister, and then the merits of the case could be investigated and if a man merits a gratuity or pension, as the case may be, he will get it. I would ask the Parliamentary Secretary to consider that.

Comment on this

What about the position of an engineer? Is it seriously contended that a firm of auditors, or a solicitor should be included for compensation?

Comment on this

We are talking about a secretary.

Comment on this

They are not part of the drainage board.

Comment on this

Fán go foill. They would be liable to be appointed or not to be appointed annually. Take the case, for example, of the efficient board to which Deputy Hughes has referred. I take it they would have an annual meeting at which their secretary or clerk and perhaps their engineer would be appointed. The fact that this particular board met and appointed me or Deputy Davin or Deputy Hughes as secretary for the coming year would not necessarily mean that they would not appoint some other person in the year following.

Comment on this

That is never done.

Comment on this

There are annual appointments.

Comment on this

Not to my knowledge.

Comment on this

If an individual enters into a contract in the form which the Deputy seems to suggest, the position would appear to be that a man would be able to establish a case against his employer and therefore able to establish a case against the council.

Comment on this

His services are terminated by legislation.

Comment on this

Will the Parliamentary Secretary give me an assurance that if the body to whom the obligation is transferred decides to pay compensation to a person who has not less than three years' service in the capacity referred to in the amendment, there will be no surcharge? I ask the question because I believe that some of the bodies would be willing to pay in cases in which it can be proved that work was well done. I am, however, of the opinion — I cannot, of course, express a legal opinion — that if they decide to pay compensation, they will probably be surcharged. I would accept Deputy Hughes' suggestion as a way out of the difficulty.

Comment on this

I suggest that Deputy Davin would require to redraft paragraph (5). Where a man has given consecutive years of service, I think it would be very unjust for the House to take away his income. It might be a very serious matter for a man with a wife and children who was looking forward to continuing to receive that amount. I am not defending the man who does not do his work, but I think that in the case of a man who has been appointed and has held his appointment for a number of years, it would be very unjust for the House to take away his income.

Comment on this

He would be able to establish his rights.

Comment on this

Is an enabling section necessary?

Comment on this

No. The liabilities of the board by which such a man was employed will be transferred to the county council and the county council would be obliged to meet them.

Comment on this

I see how the Parliamentary Secretary hopes to get away. I have been discussing a case in which there is no contractual obligation with regard to salary. A man is appointed at an annual fee and there is no word about a pension, but we are stepping in long before he will arrive at the point at which he would cease to be able to work and taking his position from him. It is only a subterfuge to say that the rights and liabilities pass on to the county council. The right here is a right to draw an annual sum as salary, and if a man is carrying out his duties properly, he is entitled to that right. It is a right which I want to emphasise, the right to an annual salary. It is a right which is inherent so long as he can do his work and is of good behaviour.

Comment on this

The Parliamentary Secretary is not very convincing in his argument against the rather small amount involved in this proposal. He says that a big principle is involved, and he suggests that there is no comparison between these people and the accountant appointed by a firm. He objected to the analogy drawn by Deputy Davin and said that there was no analogy between these men and people who worked for small national health insurance societies. I think there would be a much closer analogy between them than between these people and an actuary who works for various firms.

The fact that a man has been appointed from year to year is no lessening of his claim to compensation if he has done his work, and the fact that he had to come before a board and fight for his job every year, means that he must be doing his bit. If he were appointed for a long period, he could lie down on the job, but I would be prepared to agree with the Parliamentary Secretary that many of these men were asleep. The drainage boards themselves were asleep — and that is one of the reasons for much of the trouble on this Bill — but where boards were not asleep and the secretary was doing his work, it would be unjust that the men who were doing their work should be scrapped and passed over and that we should depart from the practice of the House for many years past. If a liability is to be handed over to a county council, the council should at least be authorised to pay compensation in necessary or deserving cases.

That is all is being asked, that the local authorities should be the judges in the matter of compensation, that they should not be liable to surcharge and that they should not have to throw people on the scrap heap, having deprived them of certain earnings. It is the principle more than the amount which is really involved, and we ought not to depart in this Bill from the established practice in relation to persons who lose their employment as a result of legislation passed here. So far as persons who were not doing their jobs are concerned, the amendment provides safeguards against their getting compensation, but we want to put the local authorities in the position in which they can, with safety and without fear of being mulcted, do justice to themselves and to those employees who have given faithful service until disemployed by this measure.

Comment on this

I should like to ask, with regard to the secretaries of drainage boards, referred to by the Parliamentary Secretary, who did nothing, whether they continued to draw their yearly salary or whatever allowance was paid to them for work which they did not do.

Comment on this

I could not say; they may not have had any funds.

Comment on this

If they did not draw any income, they would not be entitled to compensation under the terms of the amendment.

Comment on this

It is fair that a man who did his work well and who was appointed from year to year should get consideration because we have given consideration to people of that type in various Acts which we have passed here.

Comment on this

Deputy Keyes tries to prove that there is no analogy between the case I cited and the position of these people. I was taking Deputy Davin's word for it that these were part-time employees, that the people in whom he was interested — I do not know who or what they are — people whom he knew or met who occupied positions on these boards, held them on a part-time basis. Deputy Keyes maintains that there is no analogy between these people and a firm of auditors.

Comment on this

It is very remote.

Comment on this

A firm of auditors could be employed by this, that or the other firm. I agree, but the people for whom Deputy Davin wants compensation are apparently people who were part-time employees of drainage boards, who held these positions as a sort of side-line. They could have held the secretaryship of half-a-dozen boards, or could have been engaged in any other type of work. If we are to talk here of compensation for secretaries and clerks of drainage boards, what about the engineer who has perhaps been employed by a board or a body of trustees? Has he a right to compensation too? Are we to establish the position that simply because an engineer was lucky enough to pick up this windfall and held it for three or four years, he is to have a right to compensation on the passage of this Bill?

Comment on this

Would he not be paid on a fees basis?

Comment on this

I am not interested in how he is paid.

Comment on this

And the same applies to the accountant.

Comment on this

What right has a man who happens to be at the moment secretary of a drainage board, who is appointed from year to year and who may or may not be reappointed at the end of the year, to the special protection which the Deputy seeks to establish for him here any more than any man in any other form of employment who may lose it and have to look for something else? It is all right to protect the man who has rights, and we have, in fact, provided for any man who can establish a case against his employer, a board or trustees. To the extent that he has a claim against them in the event of his losing his employment, that claim will be transferred to the county council under the Second Schedule. I do not see why it is sought to confer upon a host of people rights which ordinary people never enjoy. I am opposed to that idea and will have to resist it.

Comment on this

All I can say is that I hope the Parliamentary Secretary's colleagues in the Government will read that portion of his speech, which is completely in conflict with everything they have said in regard to other measures of the kind which have had the effect of depriving people of employment or remuneration. What he has said is quite contrary to what the Minister for Industry and Commerce said during the eight-day debate on the Transport Bill, to what the Minister for Local Government said on the National Health Insurance Act and what other Ministers said in every other case of the kind. I would not mind if there was a large amount involved in this proposal. The Parliamentary Secretary has reversed the previous policy of his Government in what he has said.

Comment on this

I have not.

Comment on this

Of course you have. If any man is deprived of his employment as a result of legislation passed here, it has been the practice of the House since I became a member in 1922 to make provision for compensation by the proper authority of a person in that position. I am not asking the Parliamentary Secretary to accept the amendment in its present form, but I am asking him to make sure that no local authority that desires to give compensation to the secretary or clerk of a drainage board will be surcharged.

Comment on this

I should like to tell the Parliamentary Secretary of the case of a man, probably over 60 years of age, who has acted as secretary of a small drainage board for many years. He has done all the inspectorial work. He has invited tenders and got work done on a piece basis. He has inspected the drains over the whole system for many years and has done all clerical work. When this is taken over by the local authority it will be a hardship to that man if he does not get compensation. Whether he can establish his right to compensation or not, according to the arguments of the Parliamentary Secretary, I do not know. We simply want to satisfy ourselves that justice will be done in such a case. I feel it may be necessary to put in a section enabling the local authority, where a claim on the grounds of justice is established by an individual in a case like that, to give compensation. No one wants to see a man getting superannuation or a gratuity or compensation for work that he has never done. I am merely anxious to see that the man who has performed his duty and who will be dispensed with as a result of the operation of this Bill will not suffer an injustice.

Comment on this

I would also ask the Parliamentary Secretary to reconsider this matter. I look upon it as a very important one in principle. One of the greatest grievances in the public service at present is when people are kept on from year to year, having a right in practice but perhaps not in legal form, and then are dispensed with after 10, 12 or 14 years' service. The emoluments which they get for the work are necessary to keep their homes in a proper way. At that stage of their lives they are unfit to turn to anything else. They are settled down in that part of the country. It is a very serious step to deprive such men as these of what they have been getting for years. Something should be done on the lines suggested in order to give them a chance of getting some compensation from any funds which the drainage board may have or otherwise they should be retained in some way or other in employment.

At any rate, something should be done to see that they do not suffer serious hardship. The case of an engineer or any other man who has a profession is not comparable with that of the ordinary working man, so to speak, who is receiving only a very small emolument. Such a man cannot go from place to place like an engineer and take up employment elsewhere. He has settled down in a certain place and wants to continue there with his family. Therefore, I ask the Parliamentary Secretary to see that something is done to enable the authority in charge either to give some compensation or to retain the man in employment in some way or other.

Comment on this

Will the Parliamentary Secretary look into the matter?

Comment on this

I will look into the matter.

Comment on this