We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Arterial Drainage Bill, 1944—Report.

Bill Arterial Drainage Bill, 1944
Enacted

No. 16 of 1944 ›

With your permission I desire to draw attention to the fact that the Parliamentary Secretary promised to make a certain amendment in the Bill which he has not done. I find from the report that the Parliamentary Secretary did, in fact give an undertaking that he would insert an amendment providing that the Minister for Local Government would be consulted in regard to certain matters. The Parliamentary Secretary said: "What I am prepared to consider is, in the event of a local authority raising an objection, as they are entitled to do, to mention specifically the Minister for Local Government. I am prepared to mention the fact that he would be consulted in the event of such an objection being raised." The Parliamentary Secretary has not made any provision for that. Perhaps he would look into it before the Bill goes to the other House.

Comment on this

We have considered the matter very thoroughly and we deliberately decided not to make the provision sought.

Comment on this

I withdrew the amendment in view of the undertaking. We would have fought it harder and divided the House if the Parliamentary Secretary had not given the undertaking to provide for consultation with the Minister for Local Government.

Comment on this

I am afraid we shall not be able to meet that.

Comment on this

I think the Parliamentary Secretary gave some undertaking.

Comment on this

To consider it.

Comment on this

The Parliamentary Secretary's words were: "What I am prepared to consider is... to mention specifically the Minister for Local Government". Deputy Allen backed me on this matter but I would have pressed it to a division if the Parliamentary Secretary had not given the undertaking.

Comment on this

I have considered it.

Comment on this

We interpreted your words to mean more than considering it.

Comment on this

I considered it all right.

Comment on this

You would not trust the Minister for Local Government— that is what it means.

Comment on this

It all depends.

Comment on this

I think that Deputy Bennett felt that because the Parliamentary Secretary did not agree to the safeguard recommended by the Drainage Commission, that is an appeal board, he might perhaps have considered linking up the Local Government Department in this matter and that that would be some little safeguard, though not very much.

Comment on this

Would it not be a strange thing to put the Minister for Finance in the position that his decision could be reviewed in this way by the Minister for Local Government?

Comment on this

What I wanted was some definite connection in the Bill as between the commissioners and the Local Government Department, but the Parliamentary Secretary has definitely decided to keep the Minister for Local Government out of it.

Comment on this
Eamonn O'Neill An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

When is it proposed to take the Final Stage?

Comment on this

I should like to have the Final Stage now.

Comment on this

Why not to-morrow?

Comment on this

I want to get the Bill to the Seanad on the 6th December. Deputies, after all, have been pressing for the fixing of the appointed day, asking when will the appointed day be fixed and when will this or that be done. After all, I agreed to have the Bill re-committed.

Comment on this

You got it through very expeditiously.

Comment on this

The Deputy was not here yesterday. I was slogging away the whole day, and when I think of all the trouble I took to facilitate Deputies and that they will not give me the Fifth Stage now, it tends to sour me against making any concessions in future.

Comment on this

Why not put the Final Stage down for to-morrow?

Comment on this

Will the House meet to-morrow?

Comment on this

Of course it will meet to-morrow.

Comment on this

I am not sure.

Comment on this

We have not finished the Mental Hospital Bill.

Comment on this

Give me this Bill now.

Comment on this

If the House is to meet to-morrow, you will get this Bill to-morrow.

Comment on this
Seán MacEntee Minister for Local Government and Public Health (Mr. MacEntee) Fianna Fáil

Is the Deputy going to oppose the Bill?

Comment on this

We are going to express opinions on the Bill on the Fifth Stage. There have been 64 amendments, and we have not seen the Bill as amended on Report.

Comment on this

I want it to go to the Seanad on 6th December.

Comment on this

And you can fix a meeting of the Seanad for 6th December.

Comment on this

I think the House is treating me most ungenerously.

Comment on this

There was a big volume of work on this re-committal. The Parliamentary Secretary re-committed the Bill, and we have spent nearly two days considering it. It is hardly fair to expect the House to pass the Bill now without seeing what it is like. The Parliamentary Secretary did not meet the House so very much on the various points raised. On the other hand, I want to say that if we are not meeting to-morrow I think it is only fair that the Parliamentary Secretary should get the Bill to-night. If we are meeting to-morrow, we should get an opportunity of discussing it.

Comment on this

It is not certain.

Comment on this

What is the hurry about this? We are told it will take five years to put the machinery into operation, and 28 years to complete the drainage. The Parliamentary Secretary re-committed this complicated Bill, to which there were 64 amendments, quite a number of them his own. The House dealt with the matter from 7 o'clock until 9 o'clock last night, and from about 5 o'clock until let us say 8 o'clock to-night. A total of only five hours has been spent on 64 complicated, technical amendments. I think the Parliamentary Secretary has got every possible facility. There has been no obstruction, and everybody has aimed at improving the Bill. I cannot understand why the Parliamentary Secretary wants us to pass a Bill, which has been amended in 64 separate respects, before we have seen those amendments carried into the Bill.

Comment on this

If I were sure that the House intends to sit to-morrow——

Comment on this

There is no doubt that it will sit to-morrow.

Comment on this

What purpose is to be served by holding over the Bill until to-morrow? I do not complain as to the manner in which the House has met me; although I must confess that a lot of time has been expended in the discussion on all the stages of this measure, I have no complaint to make about the manner in which the House treated me, but I want to get the Bill to the Seanad on 6th December. In reply to Deputy Norton, it is common knowledge that I have been pressed, not only here but outside, to give some indication as to the possible date on which the appointed day could be fixed, so that work which would be necessary could be carried out in advance. If the House feels that this is an urgent matter, I think it might facilitate me in this very minor respect.

Comment on this

We have got to get time for a discussion on the adjournment in accordance with customary practice.

Comment on this

Oh.

Comment on this

That has got to be provided for. Have no doubt about it at all. The Minister for Local Government may not like it, but there is no question about it. It has got to be provided. Lest there should be any doubt about it, I am strongly objecting to this Bill being taken to-night, and my objection must be sustained under Standing Orders, even though the Minister for Local Government says "Oh".

Comment on this

If I had adopted that attitude——

Comment on this

Your friends are your worst enemies.

Comment on this

Perhaps this would be the best way to fix the matter: if there is a decision not to meet to-morrow, we will pass the Bill to-night. If there is a decision to sit to-morrow, we will take it to-morrow.

Comment on this

I object to this Bill being taken to-night. Therefore, it cannot be taken.

Comment on this

Many thanks to the Deputy.

Comment on this