Committee on Finance. - Vote 29—Agriculture (Resumed).
Contributions 116–266 of 266. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
There is no money here for greyhounds, and I doubt if they are an agricultural product.
Comment on this
Will the Deputy point out to the Chair on what item in this Vote there is money for greyhound racing?
Comment on this
I thought anything relating to products of the land could be mentioned. I suggest that a big stake should be put up for greyhounds at a racing centre. Questions were asked as to the amount of money that came into this country during the emergency from the sale of greyhounds, but the request was refused. As the amount is increasing for the last four years, definitely greyhounds are an agricultural product.
Comment on this
There are two types of animals, bipeds and quadrupeds. Some five years ago inspectors went round looking for new ideas in connection with agriculture, and I made what I thought was a very wise suggestion. It was received good humouredly, and it was to supply jackasses. We wanted nine in County Tipperary but only got one. The results are good as can be noticed at every creamery. I heard that 3,400 asses were exported last year. A young animal four years old sells from £7 to £8. Asses were inbred for years and were not big. It is hard to keep a sire ass. Mules and jennets could not be bred from the small animals that were available. Jennets are now coming along and they are very useful animals.
I want to refer next to goats. The goat is the poor man's cow. A lady from Trillick, in County Tyrone showed goats at Ballsbridge show some years ago and, according to the records, some surprising results were obtained. These animals are in-bred and they are bad types, but it is rather a pity that more attention has not been paid to this matter. Kerrymen swear by the goats, and, 30 years ago, it was quite usual to see a goat full of milk coming in at the head of 20 or 30 cows. Deputy Corry, I am sure, remembers that time. They gave a couple of quarts of milk, very much better than the bad cows referred to by Deputy Dillon.
With regard to the colleges and the students attending these colleges, I do not see many of them coming back to the country. I am not against education, but I wonder are these boys in the colleges going to be instructors or performers. Many of them do not come back to the farm. If I sent one of my sons down to the farm of some of the farmer Deputies here—I would not pass Deputy Allen or Deputy Hughes—I suggest that they would come better our of it than they would out of any college. If I got a lad down with myself, he would see our traditional farming and how we carried on, but when the reapers and binders, the tractors and tractor ploughs and all this improved farming came along it was felt that no more instruction was needed. I have my doubts about it and I will back any one of the lads on the farms around me against any college-trained youth.
Comment on this
I refer to general farmwork. Reference was also made to holidays. I rarely heard of a farmer getting a holiday. I know of a farmer who told his first son to come for a week to Lisdoonvarna, telling the second son that he could go the following week and the third son the next week. They thought the old fellow was going mad. Everyone has holidays now but the farmer.
Comment on this
It is a holiday— working, as I have seen them, until 9 or 10 o'clock at night with threshing machines, and with 15 neighbours waiting for the machine. It is very reminiscent of Uncle Tom's Cabin. We have an Irish Free State with 65 per cent. of the population working 11 and 12 hours a day, when 8 hours is enough for any man to work, but when we ask for increased prices, so that we might lessen the hours of work—on a 30-acre farm one extra man could be put working and, on a 60-acre farm, two extra men could be put working—all we get is a clap on the back and the statement that we are great fellows, that we saved the country.
Comment on this
It is not an Irish Free State; it is an Irish slave-state, with 65 per cent. of the population working 12 hours a day while the rest work eight hours a day. An Irish Free State, mar eadh!
Comment on this
I note from the Minister's White Paper that tillage is to be made compulsory. I think the farmer and the agricultural worker have done their work and have done it well, and should get a rest and a chance of putting the worn-out stubbled land which they now have back into condition. Tillage should not be compulsory. Further, I think it is not necessary, because in the constituency which the Minister and I have the honour to represent, the majority of farmers till from 30 to 40 per cent. of their land and, to my mind, it is a big mistake to put the plough into the very good pasture land which we have in some districts. These men with good land are in opposition to the cattle exporters and very often help to get the farmer who is engaged in mixed farming a good price for his cattle.
Some weeks ago, I asked a question here about the numbers of poultry in the country. The raising of poultry and pigs is a great advantage to the people in tillage districts and the Minister for Finance, who was answering for the Minister for Agriculture on that occasion, told me that, in 1945, we had more poultry than we had in 1943 or 1944, but, if my information is correct, poultry raising is going down fast. When poultry raisers have their stocks of laying hens in and put their pullets on the market, they get only the price of old hens for them, that is, 10d per lb. and this is doing harm to the poultry industry.
The agricultural worker and the farmer are the worst paid people in the State and in order to put the farmer in a position in which he can give his worker a living wage, he must get a better price for his produce. I have pulled beet in bad weather—and I am sure the Minister never did—and I know the hardships involved in that work. When beet is being harvested, it is generally raining, sleeting or snowing, but when the men get orders to get out the beet, they have to get it out. There is no such excuse as saying that the day is wet and I have often seen men having to put on wet clothes in the morning again. The price of £4 for beet is a very poor price and the farmer should be in a position to give his farm labourer a bonus when the beet crop has been saved and harvested.
The majority of farmers are willing to give their labourers a living wage but they are not in a position to do so. There is scarcely a farmer in my county who has not two men where he wants three, and five men where he wants six or seven. They cannot afford to pay them. Going through the country, one can see weeds in our crops, when formerly the practical farmer would no more allow weeds to grow in his crops than he would cut off his head. If you have a wet harvest it is very hard to save the crop and you get no return, except weeds.
Our live-stock industry is well worth minding. To my mind, in a county, such as County Wexford, which goes in for mixed farming there is no cow so suitable as the beef Shorthorn cow. When we had all beef Shorthorn cows we had a good yield in milk and butter. It is a ridiculous situation to-day to find ourselves unable to produce sufficient butter to meet our own requirements considering that some years ago we had a big surplus for export.
I would strongly urge on the Minister not to interfere with the pig industry. If the recommendations set out in this White Paper are put into effect they will lead to the destruction of the pig industry. The Pigs and Bacon Board did a great deal of damage; but this would be the last straw. Every man who rears a pig likes to bring that pig to the market and bring his money home. I will give you an instance of what the bacon curers can do when there is no competition. If there is going to be no middleman, pig jobber, or whatever you like to call him, the bacon curer will make his own price and give what he likes for the pig. It is no use saying that the bacon curer must do this, that, or the other. He will not do it. There is no compulsion upon him to do it. The majority of the pig buyers never did anything else except buy pigs. They know nothing about cattle, or they know as much about them as I do about making watches. I think it would be an appalling crime to take their livelihood from these people. When there is a surplus of pigs the bacon curer is in a position to reject certain classes; the pig jobber could get in touch with bacon curers across the water and find a market for our surplus pigs there. I would advise the Minister to let well enough alone. The only thing which he should do is to try to increase pig production. At the present moment there is not sufficient pig feeding in the country. The supply of oats and barley is exhausted. The farmer has now to go to the shop and pay 24/6 for pig nuts. I do not know what is the composition of these pig nuts. If you examine it you will find spiders' nests in it. Obviously it is the sweepings of the lofts. It is certainly not proper pig feeding, particularly at a price of 24/6 per cwt. I am sure the Minister would not like to take away anyone's livelihood. But, again, I ask what is to happen to these unfortunate people who have been in the pig buying trade for generations past? What is there for them to do? Is the Government prepared to compensate them?
Now I would ask the Minister not to enforce the tillage Order. I would ask him to do all in his power to ensure a better price to the farmers for their produce and thereby enable them to pay the agricultural workers a living wage and employ more men on the land. There is any amount of work to be done on the land if the farmers could only afford to pay labour to do it for them. All over the countryside good land is running into marsh for want of labour. All the small rivers in my district are silted up with mud and that means that the lowlands are flooded. It is no use our getting up in this House and abusing each other. What we must do is to co-operate in a businesslike way. By means of cooperation a lot could be done for the farming industry. Agriculture is the staple industry of this country. If the farmer is not prosperous the townsman is not prosperous because there is no money in circulation. For all our industries, with the exception of agriculture and our tanneries, we have to import the raw materials. I would appeal to the Minister again not to enforce the tillage Order and not to take away from the pig dealers their means of earning a livelihood.
Comment on this
I shall be very brief because practically every aspect of the farming industry and agriculture has been debated, to my mind very fully and very adequately. I wish to express, on behalf of the farmers, our appreciation of the Government's attitude in accepting the principle of guaranteed prices and a proper market as essential for the stability of agriculture. The Minister announced some time ago that the price of milk would be guaranteed for the next five years so that the dairy farmers now know where they stand. That will put great heart into them. I hope the time is not far distant when that same principle will be extended to wheat and beet, eggs and poultry. We are told that the dairy industry is the corner-stone of our agricultural structure; that being so, it is most essential that that industry should be laid on a good foundation. Unfortunately, I am afraid that it is drifting rapidly from a position of stability and the time is not far distant when the amount of milk and the amount of butter in this country will be reduced to alarming proportions. Since 1938 there has been a decrease of six million gallons of milk in the supply to the creameries. That is a very serious matter in view of the fact that at one time, even when the price of butter was very low, we exported over three million pounds' worth of butter.
There are various factors militating against the dairying industry. Some of them can be easily remedied. Perhaps the most important factor militating against it is the low price paid for milk over a number of years. Time and again figures have been submitted to the Department of Agriculture and to the Government showing that the price paid for milk supplied to the creameries was far below the actual cost of production. However, these figures have not been accepted with the result that the industry is now going from bad to worse. Another factor militating against it is the incidence of disease amongst live stock. In the third interim report of the Commission of Inquiry into Post-War Agriculture it is stated that the loss to the farmers of the country each year, because of the incidence of disease, is over £5,000,000. That is a colossal figure and I think no effort should be spared by the Department and the Government to do everything in their power to reduce that figure to the very minimum. Amongst our dairy cattle we have the diseases of mastitis, tuberculosis and contagious abortion. Now, mastitis is a very serious disease but, as far as I can understand, it is a very easily remedied disease. Recently I was told by Professor Grimes of University College, Cork, that he had successfully carried out experiments by means of which this disease can be combated. Cattle infected with mammitis were cured in a very short time by inoculation with penicillin. It is only quite recently that Professor Grimes told me he had got a cow infected in that way and in a comparatively short time—definitely within a fortnight— the milk was restored to its normal condition and quite fit for human consumption. If that is the position then I suggest that the Department should take immediate steps to have cows affected with mastitis treated with that very important remedial measure.
In the case of contagious abortion I understand that in America there has been a nation-wide endeavour to reduce contagious abortion and tuberculosis to the very minimum—contagious abortion by a vaccine known as Strain 19 when the calves are from six to eight months old. So successful has this method been that recently the Minister for Agriculture in England issued an important statement to the people advising them to vaccinate their calves and young heifers because of the urgent necessity for them in that country for an increased supply of milk. To put his ideas into practice, the English minister arranged that all calves in the country should be inoculated with this vaccine at the cost of 1/- per calf. In the farm attached to University College, Cork, under the supervision of Professor Boyle, the animals are being treated in that way with, I understand, very satisfactory results. The Department and the Government should see to it that this particular vaccine is more generally used because we all know that animals affected with contagious abortion are a dead loss to farmers. The amount of milk is reduced by 15 to 25 per cent., the number of calves may be reduced to 40 per cent., there is a general lowering of the health of the cattle, and another virulent disease, sterility, is very often the result of contagious abortion.
Another factor that is militating against milk production in this country is the difficulty of providing milkers. I have been at many meetings throughout the country recently in connection with my work as Secretary to the Dairy Shorthorn Breeders' Society and the general cry through the country is that the farmers cannot provide milkers. The result is that the herds are being reduced very considerably. The man who in former years kept 30 or 35 cows is now down to 18 or 20, the man who had 18 to 20 is down to 12 and, unless they have members of their own family capable of milking, the tendency is to disperse the herds at the very first opportunity. Dispersal sales are quite common throughout the country. Herds are being reduced and, consequently, milk yields are going down, supplies to creameries are going down, and the whole position is very serious. I appeal, therefore, to the Government, to take steps to stem the downward trend before it is too late. It has gone very far. The Government know best what is to be done.
In order to arrive at a proper figure for the value of milk, the Department should set up a costings department. There are various schools run by the Department of Agriculture and it should be possible in those places or on certain farms, selected by the Government, to find what is the cost of producing one gallon of milk under various conditions and circumstances. I know that it varies from one part of the country to another; it varies even from farm to farm; but the general consensus of opinion is that the figure arrived at by the Department, and on which they base the low price for milk at present, cannot bear close actual investigation. The cumulative effect of all these factors—the low price for milk, the incidence of disease, the difficulty of getting milkers—has militated against the dairying industry and we appeal to the Minister and to the Government to effect remedial measures before this industry, which is the keystone of agriculture, disappears from this country altogether.
It is very important that the farm improvements scheme, which I admire very much and for which the country owes a deep debt of gratitude to the Government, should be extended to the provision of houses for live stock. If that is not feasible, long-term loans, at low rate of interest, should be available for the building and renovation of houses for live stock. Some of the houses in farmyards are dark, badly ventilated, with bad sanitary arrangements. If the farmers got any encouragement, by long-term loans at low rate of interest, just as they got in the case of hay barns, the effect on our live stock generally and on the health of our live stock would be very remarkable and would well compensate the Government for any expense incurred.
As regards the education of farmers, generally, the majority of farmers' sons and farm workers who leave school at the age of 14 have no further means of improving their education. A good deal of work has been done, and well done, by the agricultural instructors, through winter agricultural classes subsidised by the county committees of agriculture. These are very effective and, if they were more numerous, it would be very beneficial. However, the attendance at these classes is not always as good as might be expected. It would be well if some kind of mobile cinema apparatus could be made available in each instructor's area so that films could be shown depicting the various activities of the farming industry. Recently, at the Dairy Congress in Thurles, we showed a number of films sent to us by the Irish Film Company, Dublin, and the interest shown in them was amazing. In view of the fact that farmers have not adequate opportunity of keeping in touch with everyday activities, it would be well if mobile cinemas could be established in each agricultural instructor's area, which the instructor could take to lectures and classes. They would be very useful in imparting most valuable information.
There are other aspects of the farming industry that I should like to touch upon, but it is getting late and I know that they have been debated, in great detail, for the past two days. Every effort should be made by the Department to ensure that the dairying industry is not allowed to decline into a state from which it cannot be restored.
I want also to put the question of dairy bulls before the Minister. Views have been expressed about cattle generally. In my opinion, the greatest drawback at the moment to the breeding of good dairy cattle is the lack of good dairy bulls. We must aim, I think, at having in the country more proven sires—these sires that we know are producing heifers with good milking characteristics. Quite recently I found that a creamery committee in Mallow, where they have established an insemination centre, were anxious to get proven sires, but they could not find them in the country. That is unfortunate. For the past four years I am aware that a cup competition fell through because sires like that had either been slaughtered or exported. The Dairy Shorthorn Society had a cup competition for the best heifer which was judged by yields of milk and butter fat. They also gave a cup for the bull which sired that heifer. For the past three or four years the society have not been able to carry on that competition because the bull which sired the heifer was not available, as it had either been slaughtered or exported.
I think that our live-stock inspectors, when they go around each year to inspect bulls for continuation premiums, should mark out a certain number of these bulls which are likely to produce good milking heifers and that these should be distributed amongst other farmers or taken up by the Department and retained until it is known whether or not their heifers are good milk yielders. As I said, we have in the society 1,000 gallon heifers but, unfortunately, the bulls that sired these heifers are no longer available. These bulls, if available, would I think be a national asset and I appeal to the Minister and the Department to lay more stress on the desirability of having those proven sires reserved and distributed through the country.
With regard to the insemination centre in Mallow, the creamery society are doing a great deal of research work. I think that research work should be done by the Department of Agriculture and financed by the State. I should like to know what the Minister's views are on this A1 insemination centre in Mallow. Is it likely to develop the scheme, and is it likely to be a great success? I understand that insemination centres have been found to be very valuable assets in the dairying industry in America, New Zealand, England, and elsewhere. I should like to know what are the possibilities for them in this country, how far it would be possible to have these centres spread all over the country, and how far it would be possible for them to be subsidised by the State. I should like to emphasise to the Minister the desirability of examining again the fixed price for milk, with a view to helping farmers to induce workers to milk their cows by paying them a proper price. It is a very serious matter.
Comment on this
I should like to take the few points made by Deputy Halliden first. I think Deputy Halliden and Deputy O'Donnell gave the House the impression that there is a continuous decline in the number of cows in this country and in the milk supply. That is not true so far as we can judge from the figures, because we have very accurate figures so far as the output of creamery butter is concerned. For the last four years there has been practically no change. In the year ending 31st March last, the output was 607,000 cwts. That was better than the year before and better than the year before that again and almost the same as it was four years ago, when it was 611,000 cwts. We may say, however, that production is practically at a standstill.
Comment on this
I am always hearing these stories, but if we go over the last four years, we will find that there is no great change. There is a definite decrease, of course, compared with pre-war, but that was to be expected because, very naturally, we cannot expect farmers to get the same yield from their cows now when they cannot get cake and nitrogenous food for winter feeding. Deputy Halliden asked about artificial insemination. The Department has been alive to this matter and they are making investigation into what has been done in other countries and sending officials to study the system in other countries. We must only wait for the report of these officers to see what we may do. I could not really say how the centre in Mallow may stand. That, of course, as the Deputy pointed out, is being financed by the creamery society and not by the Department.
As well as the allegation that milk production is going down, Deputy Keating spoke of poultry. There, again, the indications are that poultry are not on the decline. There were more eggs produced last year than the year before. The price of pullets and cockerels was regulated with a view to encouraging farmers to keep their good laying hens. We have arranged for a very good price for cockerels, so that when the hatching is over and when the chickens are sorted out into pullets and cockerels the farmer's wife will get a very good price for cockerels if she sells them early and a very bad price for pullets, because she should keep the pullets to lay later on. We also give a good price for old hens later on in the year.
Comment on this
We are doing our best to get them to keep more of them by not giving too attractive a price. Deputy Dockrell spoke of fruit and vegetables. I agree with him that we should make every possible use of them, that we should use what we can of them and preserve the rest, whether in the form of jam or by bottling or canning them. I have no further comment to make with regard to Deputy O'Donnell's proposals about a water supply for the rural areas. I absolutely agree with him that it is a most important item. It would be a great amenity to the woman of the house to have running water for household purposes and, undoubtedly, it would be a great economic benefit to the farmers to have running water in the cow byres and for all the other animals. I think that one of our aims should be to see that the farmer is facilitated by some scheme or other in getting running water to his farm. It would be easier to do that when we have the rural electricity supply scheme put into operation. If there is any necessity for power pumping, the electricity will be available.
The only note I took during the speech of Deputy Giles was that he accused Fianna Fáil of trying to get on to the Fine Gael platform. I think we would be very foolish if we tried to get on a platform that has such poor footing at the present time. Apart from that, it is very hard to understand how any Deputy on the other side would make a suggestion of that kind. If we go back almost 20 years, and if we read the debates that took place here, we will find that it was proved conclusively, and, I think, with the greatest honesty, by some of the Fine Gael speakers, that wheat could not be grown in this country, that it was foolish to suggest wheat-growing and, therefore, they did not bother about it.
One matter that was spoken to by a good many Deputies was compulsory tillage. It met with a good deal of opposition, but it was the sort of opposition where Deputies merely said they were against it and they did not give very convincing reasons. Deputy Hughes said it was unnecessary. I think that is not a very great reason against it, because if every farmer does the tillage that would be expected from him under a compulsory Order, say 25 or 30 per cent., then compulsion does not enter into it.
Comment on this
The Deputy objects to regimentation. As regards Deputy Cogan and Deputy Blowick, that was their big objection, too. They said there was too much compulsion and they spoke of bureaucracy and even of Communism. I suppose I should not object to a person being over-religious, but I do not think it was necessary for Deputy Cogan and Deputy Blowick to be so sensitive about the religion of this country that they are afraid that if Fianna Fáil brings in compulsory tillage, religion will go. That is going a bit too far with the game, and I advise them to keep this religious charge up their sleeves. A well-known English writer said that religion is the last refuge of a certain individual—I will not say who he is. At any rate, it should be kept for the last argument.
Deputy Blowick said it was a poor recompense to the farmer who had stood by the country during the emergency. I do not think that there are very many who will be affected by the compulsory tillage proposal. Practically every Deputy expressed the opinion that it is hardly necessary, that we will have the tillage in any case. So if we do bring in this Compulsory Tillage Bill, it only means that we will compel a very small remnant of the farmers. That is the very remnant that did not do very much for us during the emergency. What they did was done under compulsion. The overwhelming majority of the farmers did their tillage willingly during the emergency, and they are to be thanked. They are not concerned whether or not we bring in compulsory tillage.
So far as White Papers are concerned, this is my conception of a White Paper. The Government, instead of bringing a Bill before the Dáil, issued a White Paper. In the Bill you have the whole plan laid out and it is very hard to alter a Bill in a big way. If you try to alter it you put your scheme out of order. You can make only slight alterations at the best. When a White Paper is issued it represents the Government's intention to do a certain thing. The White Paper is issued so that those concerned can read it and submit their objections to, or their suggestions for improvements of, the scheme outlined. There were, for instance, a few suggestions made that I think are worthy of consideration. If suggestions are put up that did not previously occur to the staff in my Department or to myself and other members of the Government when we were considering the matter, they are carefully considered and there is ample time to make a change before legislation is introduced.
I do not think there was any very strong objection put up to this proposal about compulsory tillage. There is an objection to regimentation and Deputies say that compulsion is a bad thing. If it can be avoided, compulsion should never be resorted to. I pointed out that in 1939 there were big areas where tillage was completely gone, where the farmers did not know how to till, where their men did not know how to till, where they had no horses, tractors or equipment, and it took two or three years at least before these areas got into their stride in the tillage programme. If we had not such a slow-starting war, we would have been in a very bad way. Deputies will remember that in the recent war there was very little fighting and very little interference with transport during the first one-and-a-half years and, therefore, we had good time in which to prepare and get our tillage programme working.
It would be a dangerous thing to allow ourselves to get into a position like that again, especially if we are not going to inflict any great hardship on the great majority and if we are going to make it unpleasant for only a very small number of farmers. If we are to pursue this argument that compulsion should never be resorted to, why do we agree to a law for the early closing of public houses?
Comment on this
It is only a very few who will do themselves or the country any harm if the public houses were open all night; the great majority would not be affected by it, but still we compel people not to go into public houses during certain hours. It is the very same with the farmers. Every speaker, except Deputy Fagan, admitted that it was a good thing for the farmer himself to do tillage and it was a good thing for the country. If it is a good thing for the country and for the farmer himself, and if there are a few obstinate, foolish farmers who cannot see the good for the country and themselves, we are only doing them a kindness by saying: "You better do your duty."
Comment on this
Will the Minister confine the regimentation to the areas that did not carry out tillage hitherto?
Comment on this
The great majority of farmers, I admit, but if you take a tillage area like the Deputy's constituency in East Donegal, or my constituency in County Wexford, where there will be only a few who will not do their duty in the matter of tillage——
Comment on this
It is easier for them to do the tillage than it is in an area like part of Roscommon or Westmeath, so I do not think we should neglect to look after the few, even in the tillage counties.
I do not know why there has been talk of regimentation. I think it was Deputy Blowick who said that a man could not walk into his farmyard without knocking up against an inspector. What inspector? I did not know that there were so many inspectors going around. I took over a certain number of inspectors in the Department—livestock inspectors, potato inspectors, and others. I suppose some of them have gone and others have taken their place. I do not know how many inspectors were appointed since I went to the Department. There are inspectors under the Tillage Act and under the farm improvements scheme.
Comment on this
The inspectors under that were there before I came. I do not find fault with criticism if it has anything to do with live stock, but one would imagine, after listening to the Clann na Talmhan Deputies, that numerous inspectors had been appointed; that they were all over the place. I do not know who they are. I should say that the total number of inspectors does not amount to hundreds. It is not thousands. If they are able to appear so often in farmyards they must be great men. If they are able to make their presence felt amongst the downtrodden followers of Clann na Talmhan, they are great men. It is a great compliment to me that members of Clann na Talmhan could talk about things that do not exist—inspectors and bureaucracy. I suppose I should be complimented that anyone said such things when criticising what I did not say. They did not criticise the policy of my Department to any great extent. Deputy Hughes and Deputy Cogan said that there was no sound policy laid down for agriculture. I did my best. All I can say is that I am going home regretting that I did not get the slightest help from Deputy Hughes or Deputy Cogan, except in one matter.
Comment on this
What about soil improvement? You took five or six years to appreciate it. I suppose you will do something about it in another five years.
Comment on this
Deputy Hughes talked for over an hour and I ask any Deputy except himself, to say if he made any impression on them. Can they remember any suggestion that he made? Were they so impressed by anything Deputy Hughes said in the way of amending my policy that they could stand up and say what it was? I was not. The Deputy did say that I had no faith in the future; that I was not preparing for exports, and that I had no faith in increased production. That is not true. As far as I can, I am trying to look to the future. I want, if I can, to see what the future will be like in four, five or six years, because I think it is fairly evident to any Deputy that we cannot expand our produce until we get an export market for the surplus. It will not take very long to satisfy the home market with butter, bacon and things that are scarce. If we are to have any considerable increase in production we must find an export market. Some Deputies are likely to say: "Go on with production, and you will find an export market." I do not think that is good enough. We should look around. If we can induce farmers by fair prices to produce more pigs, and if we find that we can only place a certain amount of bacon in the home market, and that there will be a surplus, what will we do then? Some Deputies may say "don't bother". I do not think that is good enough. I go to a certain amount of trouble to look into the future and to prepare, but Deputy Hughes says I have no faith in the future because I do not say as he does: "Produce 1,000,000 pigs and you will find a market somewhere." The Deputy's plan is to say to the farmer: "Produce twice as much and you will get a market."
Comment on this
You will not get a market if you do not look for it. The Minister is not prepared to look for it.
Comment on this
I am not going to adopt the easy and complacent policy of the Fine Gael Party when they say: "You will find a market somewhere."
Comment on this
Will you be able to get back the despised market, the market your Party thanked God was gone?
Comment on this
When I was making a desperate attempt to try to keep up production and to hold on to the little bit we had, I did not get much help from Deputy Keating or his colleagues. We looked in every country in Europe for alternative markets. Deputy McMenamin cannot help laughing at that statement. Deputy Hughes says that we did not go and look for markets, and Deputies on the opposite benches laugh at us when we look for them.
Comment on this
I am going to talk about that, and probably the Deputies will give me little sympathy.
Comment on this
I suggest that the Deputy should not interrupt the Minister by asking questions at this stage.
Comment on this
Possibly Fine Gael are right. But supposing they are not right, what then? I wanted to prepare for the alternative, when we might have a little competition to meet in the British market in five or six years' time. It is because I thought we might have a little competition to meet then that I thought it would be a great pity if we did not take pains to put ourselves in a position to meet that competition to the best of our ability. We should not be driven out by competition through not making the necessary preparations. Take the example of pigs. For fear I might accuse Deputy Dillon, if he is listening, of despising our own products, I pointed out that, probably, we would get a higher price for our bacon than the Canadians, but that there was a limit to that; that we might be driven by big supplies of Canadian and Danish bacon to accept a certain price, and that it would put us to the pin of our collar to compete. That is the position I have in mind. If we do it, well and good. Therefore, we should prepare to produce pigs and to put them on the foreign market at the lowest possible cost.
We commence in one White Paper by saying that when feeding stuffs are available, maize and so on, we will bring them in. We say that in order to get farmers to produce pigs as cheaply as possible, after giving feeding stuffs at the lowest possible cost. The next point that arises is that farmers must have a price for pigs announced well in advance. That price should be based on the cost of feeding stuffs. Every farmer should be in the same position. We want to see that feeding stuffs reach every farmer at the same price, as far as we can do so. How can that be done? If we want to achieve that, feeding stuffs must reach all farmers at the lowest possible cost, and at a level cost over a long period. The only way in which that can be done, so far as I can see, is by having some sort of importing agency. I do not mind whether it is a co-operative society or not. If Deputy Cogan prefers a co-operative society, and if it can be done in that way, I personally would prefer it, but I do not know how you can organise a co-operative society of that kind. If it can be done, however, well and good. There must be some sort of agency—whether a board, a department, a director of feeding stuffs or a co-operative society—which will bring in all the maize and have the maize delivered to all the mills, whether proprietary mills, co-operative mills or the farmers' own mills, at the same price. That means, I think, that practically all the farmers will have their maize at the same price. That agency which imports all the maize can keep it at a level price, because if the maize to it is going down, it can accumulate a little money, lower the price after three months, keeping it low for three months and so on; but if everybody is importing maize and the price differs from day to day, it is not possible to have a level price over a very long period. That is why I think we should have this importing agency.
Comment on this
Let the transport costs be included. Let this agency have the maize delivered to the miller. My idea is that they will pay transport costs.
Comment on this
My idea is that the importing authority—I do not want to call it a company or a co-operative society— will deliver the maize to the mill, whether it is inland or at a port—perhaps by railway and perhaps by boat— and that the maize will be the same price all round. The next point is that the price to the farmer for his pigs will be fixed on the price of feeding stuffs. Assume that we get the pigs, that we have satisfied the farmer. We say to him: "You will be paid for your pigs on the basis of the cost of feeding stuffs." We have a certain standard ration and suppose we get the pigs. The next thing we want to ensure is that every farmer will get the same price. At that stage, I cannot see— and I have a lot of experience as Deputies will admit, of trying to manage this pig business—that it is possible to get every farmer the same price for his pigs, unless there is one buyer. We have tried other methods over and over again in various ways, and have always failed.
It is all very well to say: "Drop the whole thing." That is the only alternative—to drop the whole thing and go back to the 1931-32 basis of letting pigs take whatever they get. There must be one buyer. What does that mean? It means that this board will have to buy all the pigs and I should say at this stage that that does not prevent the dealer in pigs from buying pigs from the farmer and selling to the board. It only means that the factories must buy from the board; in other words, the board will have a representative at the factory gate and at every fair and market who will take all the pigs offered to him—no pig will be turned back—at the fixed price, whatever it may be. That is the only way in which we can ensure that the farmer will get his price. If any other way can be suggested, it can be considered.
Comment on this
We might give them the choice of liveweight or deadweight. For instance, if we can have liveweight facilities at all the fairs and markets, the buyer could say to the farmer: "There is your liveweight price. Will you take it, or will I tag them and send them on to the factory where you can get your price?" That is why there must be, in my opinion, central buying.
Deputy Cogan talked about a co-operative society to deal with this maize and barley business, and may I say again that I see no objection to it. I do not see much hope, however, of organising a co-operative society of that kind. If, however, the people interested in the co-operative business say to me that they will organise a society, I will say: "Very good; if you can organise a co-operative society, representative of all the consumers of maize and representative of all the barley growers, go ahead. We will make it a co-operative society", but we cannot wait too long.
Other things follow in the matter of this pig business. The next step is to make the factories as efficient and as economical in their working as possible. That is the point of this amalgamation and so on. Deputy Dillon comes in here and throws out his usual sarcasm and perhaps even a little scurrility with regard to this pig business, but we have to do our best. There is no use on going back on the past, except to this extent, that this scheme was first brought in in 1933. It was brought in, as Deputies know or ought to know, because we could not export any more bacon, unless we did so. The British adopted a scheme under which they fixed a quota for the country. We had to agree to the quota, as every other country had to agree, and we had to export through a single agency to fill that quota, and therefore we had to regulate our business. That was the commencement of it. There was also a demand, as a result of the findings of a tribunal which sat—the Pig Industries Tribunal —for fixed prices of pigs, and that was all done.
Deputy Dillon was in this House at the time and was a member of the special committee which went into the Bill. He supported the Bill, not reluctantly either, but enthusiastically. He can repudiate it all now; I cannot. He can repudiate it, wash his hands of the whole thing, blame me for everything, walk out of the House and go home. I need hardly say any more to Deputies because I do not think any Deputy would take Deputy Dillon with him if he were going tiger hunting. He would be a very bad man to take.
Comment on this
For his opinions to-day but not for his opinions a few years ago. He will not stand up to what he did a few years ago. He will repudiate it and blame somebody else.
Comment on this
They did not succeed, but they could not succeed. Any Deputy who wishes may tell me, as I go along, where we could have done otherwise. Were we to stop the export of bacon to England when the British authorities said we must regulate? Were we to refuse the farmers a fixed price for pigs in 1933 when they were able to point out that, on the same day, pigs were 6/- per cwt. cheaper in Limerick than in Dublin, and so on all over the country? It was all agreed to unanimously by every Party.
The next step was a decision as between the factories as to who was to get the pigs, because they could not compete for them. A board was set up to divide the pigs on quotas, and it was the quotas which caused all the trouble, because, when a curer filled his quota and had pigs to spare, he had to send them from one place to another. Some Deputies said it was a shame that pigs had to be sent from Tralee to Claremorris. It was, of course, but it was part of the scheme. Why was the board blamed for that, when the House passed the Bill in 1933 and when every member of the Fine Gael Party voted for it, having seen what was in it, when Deputy Dillon was a member of the special committee which drew up the details of the Bill and supported the Bill enthusiastically and when the board was set up and told to operate the Bill? Because things went wrong, the board was blamed.
Comment on this
But the hypothetical price fund was for the producer and he did not get it; that was a crime.
Comment on this
He did not get it because there was a big debt due and it was overdrawn. That was why the producers never got it, because it was overdrawn. I think if the producers had got that they would not thank you very much for it, because you would be putting a debt of a few pounds apiece on them. That is what it amounted to. The Fine Gael Party have a habit of supporting things in this House, as they supported the Pigs Bill, and, having supported it, later on their eyes are opened because something occurs, and they immediately blame the Fianna Fáil Party, the Government, and everybody else except themselves. They have a splendid reputation for doing that.
Comment on this
The board was set up to administer this Act, which was passed through this House with the consent of the Fine Gael Party. It was subsequently found that there were defects in the Act and we tried to remedy those defects on two or three occasions. The board is now blamed for those defects. Everybody would have a much greater respect for the Fine Gael Party if they would say: "Blame us, but do not blame the board", but I think it is not very likely that they will do that.
Comment on this
I have come here on two occasions since to try to remedy the defects. But, fundamentally, the Act was wrong and that is why we now have to change it to a considerable extent.
Comment on this
The Fine Gael Party is like the boy who cried "wolf" too often; the Fine Gael Party has warned me so often that things will go wrong that I no longer listen to them. Perhaps there is an alternative market?
Comment on this
We have talked here at considerable length about the good of the country. It would be a splendid thing if some Deputy had given me a bit of good advice. I have asked some of the honest Deputies here to give me their impressions of Deputy Hughes's speech and the suggestions that he made here. He cannot have made a very big impression on the other members of the House.
Comment on this
I knew there would be no reply, in any case. I am sure if I asked Deputy Hughes to give me a résumé of Deputy Cogan's suggestions he would not be able to do so. But Deputy Cogan did make one constructive suggestion which I was glad to get. That was his suggestion that there should be a co-operative society to deal with barley. I do not want to criticise unduly because it was a constructive suggestion and I would myself prefer a co-operative society if I could get it. I am quite prepared to admit that. In the last analysis, when I put it definitely to Deputy Cogan, he admitted that really there was no great necessity for such a co-operative society to deal with malting barley because the maltsters are there and if we fix the price the farmer brings in his barley and gets his price, and there would be no necessity for a co-operative society to interfere between them. We have then the barley that is left for feeding, which might be quite good malting barley. Deputy Cogan does not agree that we should pay more than the economic price for that barley. I do not think that gets us very far but at the same time I am prepared to consider it to see if anything can be done in that direction.
Again and again, I have been attacked by Deputies for not mentioning such and such. I was accused by Deputy Hughes of having no interest in the Hot Springs Conference because I did not mention it specifically. I spoke in this House for two hours and 20 minutes and, quite candidly, I was unable to go on any longer. If I were to mention everything connected with agriculture I would want to speak for a very long time indeed. It is very difficult to mention everything. Deputy Hughes advocates fixed prices for all agricultural produce. I think Deputies in this House have agreed with me before that in order to have fixed prices you must have certain conditions. You must have a market, for instance, over which you can exercise control, and not necessarily the home market either. In the home market it is a relatively simple matter to control. If you have a negotiated price on an export market I think perhaps fixed prices could be managed. We have a fixed price for eggs. But the first important essential is that you must control the market and, secondly, you must have a standard article. You could not fix a price for store cattle because they vary in quality and so on.
Comment on this
You can have a fixed price for butter, or wheat, or anything that is of a uniform standard. The third essential then is that you must have control of the market at some particular point. We are able to fix the price for butter because we can fix the price as it leaves the creamery. We could have a fixed price for bacon because we could fix the price either at the point of entry into the factory or when the bacon is actually leaving it. One respect in which we failed in the matter of oats is because there are so many different ways of selling it and so many different places to sell it. You may sell it to an oatmeal miller; you may sell it for seed; you may sell it to a horse breeder; or you may sell a few stone of it in the local market.
Comment on this
I understand. That is what I am now trying to prove. It is not easy to fix a price for oats and, therefore, I am afraid it cannot be done. On the other hand, if the present system goes on for importing maize and there is a surplus of barley for feeding it may be possible to do something in regard to this trade too. I think, however, we should leave oats out of consideration until we see if we succeed with the others first.
I have been criticised also for setting up a committee to deal with a number of matters which were not dealt with by the Commission of Inquiry into Post-War Agriculture; I was criticised for appointing three civil servants, as they were described here, to do that work. Now, the commission itself said that it took them so long to deal with the question that the matter would never reach finality unless a full-time body were appointed and they suggested a small full-time body which would deal with these subjects with which they themselves were unable to deal. Where could we get a full-time body outside of the Civil Service? After all, I cannot take a good farmer and say: "I want you full-time for three years and when you are finished you can go back to your farm." There would probably be no farm there when he went back. I do not see how you can get a full-time body of that kind unless from the Civil Service. That is why the civil servants were chosen.
Comment on this
Does the Minister consider that was the intention of the signatories to the majority report?
Comment on this
They advocated a small full-time body. I do not know what the intention was. If you take a man who is in a position already it would be very difficult to expect him to give three years' full-time service on this board. If you take a man who has not got a position already, I do not think that he would be a very good type of person for the work envisaged here.
Comment on this
I have it here. It is paragraph 314 on page 91; the Deputy was not so far out. In the middle of the paragraph they say:—
"We consider that a small full-time body would be more suitable and we accordingly recommend the setting up of a body, to be known as the agricultural advisory council."
Comment on this
I agreed that these matters were urgent, such as credit, marketing, the organisation of the co-operative movement, farm buildings, and many other things. They are all urgent. I said: "Unless we get a full time body it will be very hard to get it finished." I agreed with it to that extent. I said: "Where are you going to get a full-time body?" They have to be civil servants and if I appoint three members of my own staff, they are a departmental committee. It is very hard to depart from that. I was asked about flax.
Comment on this
Will the Minister excuse me? I think the chief objection to it is that the Minister is treating it purely and simply as a departmental committee and treating the report and memoranda as a secret document to himself. That is what we object to. If the committee is to function as the majority report suggested, I submit that their memoranda and report should be a public document.
Comment on this
Yes. The Deputy probably has a point of view there but still I think that on the whole it is better——
Comment on this
I am not saying we are. We read the report and we do what we think right. It is very seldom that a Department will accept a report fully. They very often will not agree with some of the recommendations made. I was asked about flax. I do not know what the future of flax is. We know that after the last war the flax market slumped. We are all right for a few years to come and will get a fairly decent price but eventually we will have to fall back on the 1936 Act. I say this much, however, there is not much future for flax in this country as a self-sufficiency crop—I put it that way —because the equipment that would be necessary to process that flax into linen goods would cost, I am told, millions and that it would never pay us because the market is so small, and that we need about four thousand acres for our own requirements. So that, unless we get an export market of either the raw flax or some product, there is not much future for it, and we will do our best to get an export market as far as we can.
Then there is the question of agricultural wages. I am very strongly of opinion that the machinery set up under the Agricultural Wages Act should be continued, that is, the committees, and the board, and so on. They have just gone through the whole round again. The chairman goes down to all the committees. On these committees there are representatives of the farmers and labourers from each county. They give the chairman their views as to whether there should be an increase or not, and how much the increase should be, and all the other things that might arise from that. He comes back to the board. The board met yesterday. He reports all that to the board and then the board makes an award. I think that is a very good system. After all, if the board have been reasonable—as they have been, in my opinion—in interpreting the wishes of the committees in their awards, I think nothing could be fairer than that. We should try to preserve that machinery as far as we can and not criticise it unduly, as some Deputies are inclined to do.
I am sorry that the members of the Labour Party have found it necessary to be absent. I think they should have regard to other aspects of this business. Everybody agrees, I think, that we should try to get bigger output from the land and, in order to get that bigger output, we would expect, if you like, more effort from the farmers, their sons and their labourers. In spite of what Deputy O'Donnell says, that the farmer works 16 hours a day, everybody thinks that they could do a little more and work shorter hours—an eight-hour day is enough for anyone to work—and get a bigger output. But, as I pointed out recently in another place, if the farmer will have to compete on a foreign market and will have to accept the price on the foreign market, he must try to cut his costs, if it is necessary to cut his costs, in order to meet that competition. He is not allowed to reduce his rent or his rates. I do not think he should be asked to reduce his wages because the agricultural wages are low enough. The only place, therefore, that he could get any reduction is in the supplies he is getting from manufacturers, and so on. I am sorry that the Labour Party are not here because I want to say to them that if they would direct their efforts to getting the manufacturers to turn out cheaper goods—they, again, cannot reduce their rent or rates; we do not want them to reduce their wages—but let them work harder and turn out their goods a bit cheaper and give them to the farmer a bit cheaper, then the farmer would be able to compete, have a bigger output, capture the foreign market and treat his labourers well. That is the way it must work and I think the Labour Party would be much better advised to get after their friends who are working in the factories and tell them that that is the way to do it and not waste their time here talking about the miserable wage the agricultural worker is paid.
Deputy Bennett, I think it was, said that before the war we had plenty of butter and bacon and that now we have not enough. Of course, that is true, but the strange thing is that our people are consuming a whole lot more meat and butter. According to the publication called National Income and Expenditure, 1938-1944, taking meats as beef, mutton, pork and bacon, together, because I suppose it may be assumed that if a person cannot get bacon and if he has the money to spare, he will buy beef or mutton instead, in this country we consumed almost 2,000,000 cwts. of meat in 1938— 1,990,000 cwts.—but in 1944, the last year given, it was 2,334,000 cwts, so that we were consuming 344,000 cwts. more in 1944 than in 1938, and still we have not enough. As for butter, our consumption of butter, that is farmers' butter and creamery butter, in 1938 was 846,000 cwts. and in 1944 it was 1,040,000 cwts—which was an increase of about 200,000 cwts. Of course, against that, there were 65,000 cwts. of margarine in 1938 and none in 1944. But even putting margarine and butter together we were still up with consumption in 1944. I remember saying that to a friend of mine recently. He began to smile to himself. I know very well what he said to himself—"This fellow is trying to excuse himself and telling me a lot of lies." I said: "What are you laughing at?" and he said: "That could not be true. I am not getting as much butter as I got in 1938." That is true. There are certain people who are not getting as much butter but every person in this country is now consuming butter and I am told by retailers whom I know in the City of Dublin that practically every person, even those living on very low incomes, take their full ration of butter. Therefore, we have a level consumption of butter all over. The less well-off people are consuming a whole lot more butter than they did in 1938 but the very well-off people are getting less. We cannot help that.
Comment on this
Could the Minister quote the figures for the years previous to 1938?
Comment on this
Unfortunately, this publication goes back only to 1938. I am sorry it did not go back further. It shows our feeling for previous Governments. We were asked also a great deal about costings in regard to wheat-growing, and so on. I think it was Deputy Beirne who said that we had not done anything about it. Well, no, not actually the costing, if you like, but there are indicators which would go to show that we are paying a fair price for wheat. One is the price that farmers are prepared to pay for conacre for the growing of wheat in many parts of the country. They pay a very good price, in some places as high as £10 per acre, and in most places up to £4 per acre. They are satisfied to take land on this system. It must be more expensive to grow wheat on land like that than it is to grow it at home. It may be said that they are not so particular about exhausting the land.
Comment on this
Surely if it did not pay Deputy Hughes to grow wheat he would not give a present to a farmer of £4 or £5 an acre for the purpose of growing it.
Comment on this
These people who take conacre must be satisfied that there is something in it or they would not carry on.
Comment on this
A man who has 50 or 60 acres to let is not doing too badly if he gets £9 or £10 per acre for doing nothing. As well as that, the price paid by the British Government for wheat is lower than ours, and, although in England other crops are more attractive, still they get a good acreage of wheat grown. I was asked about the 1938 agreement by Deputy Cosgrave. Of course that agreement is not operative for many reasons. It is not operating at all at the moment. We are carrying on, as it were, from year to year. The big idea in regard to an agreement of that kind was that one country was trying to get another country to take its goods. At present one country is trying to get goods from the other country. That is the direction in which we are working now. We had some conversations about the 1938 agreement, whether it should be revived as soon as conditions permitted, or amended or scrapped and a new agreement drawn up. We have only reached that far yet—exploratory conversations. The British Government, of course, holds that the subsidy on fat cattle is a matter for themselves, that they are entitled to regulate their internal economy as they think best, and that we have no right to object or interfere in that. That may be so in some directions.
Comment on this
I am doubtful about that. There was a clause in that agreement against subsidies, but so far as I know it related to subsidies on exports. I was asked about the National Stud. The position now is that the board has been formed and that they are in a position to do business, although they have not formally got possession of the farm yet owing to some legal difficulties, but that will be fixed up in a month or so.
Comment on this
Bring it down to the Golden Vale or the County Meath. Do not mind about the buildings.
Comment on this
I got a memorial from some farmers and I got a map and, so far as I can see, there is no farmer suffering any hardship by the refusal, because I think other washing facilities are just as near to them.
Comment on this
We shall leave it to the board. Deputy Dillon gave us a lecture on beet growing. He said that cane sugar was landed in Dublin pre-war at 1½d. per lb. and that we were now paying 5d. per 1b. for sugar from our own factories. He went on to say that the difference between these two figures would provide an additional 5/- children's allowance for every child in Ireland. He may be right. But can you understand a Deputy who purports, at any rate, to talk seriously, comparing an article landed pre-war on the quays in Dublin with an article that is now made from beet costing twice as much as it cost then and which is put into the hands of the consumer at 5d. per lb.? In other words, he ignores the six war years, the fact that materials are twice as dear as they were then, he ignores the wholesalers' and the retailers' margins, goes on to make an hysterical appeal on behalf of the children and talks about what we can do with the difference of 3d. per lb. At that time, beet was 40/- and it is now 80/-. If you make the comparison on this basis, we could turn out sugar from the factories here and sell it at almost 2d. per lb less. It is sold at 5d. to the consumer. If the cane sugar the Deputy referred to which was landed on the quays in Dublin had to go through the wholesaler and the retailer and be sold to the consumer, it would, I suppose, be up by 2d. per lb., and if the price of sugar, with the price then paid for beet, were down by 2d., the margin would be a very small one. The Deputy was able to make his point, however, and I suppose that is all that matters.
Both Deputy Dillon and Deputy Corry seemed to have the same idea about inspectors from the Department visiting farmers. They talked about the white-collared inspectors from Merrion Street and seemed to have the same idea about appealing to the ignorant in this country and to the very few malcontents amongst the community who are dissatisfied with inspectors. Why they have this mentality of appealing to these people I do not know. I suppose they hope for some gain or other, whatever it may be. This criticism of inspectors is the cheapest form of criticism. Deputy Dillon and Deputy Corry are descending very low when that is the only thing they can think of. I think everybody will admit that the inspectors are doing their best and it is hardly fair that Deputies should indulge in that sort of cheap talk about them. If they want to criticise anybody let them criticise me or somebody in this House. If they want to attack inspectors, let them do that outside.
Deputy Dillon made a violent attack on the Government because it appears that some member of it, maybe more than one, said at one time that we could be beaten in the foreign market in any commodity by some country or other; that one country could beat us in butter, another in eggs, another in meat, and so on. He said that was the sort of mentality that was ruining this country. He told us that he came back from Bavaria after seeing the lovely clean farmhouses there to see the dirty houses in our own countryside. Surely, saying that about our own people is worse than what any member of the Government may have said about being beaten in a foreign market. As to lea farming, I am afraid Deputy Hughes, when he read some of these reports, confused Deputies by giving them the impression that lea farming was the same as reseeding.
Comment on this
Not the same thing. Lea farming is envisaged in the White Paper and explained in the majority report as tilling land for two or three or four years in rotation, laying down the grass-seed, grazing the land for a few years and tilling again, a type of farming, as was pointed out in this House, that has been practised for many centuries. But reseeding, which is a thing that has not been advocated by the Department as generally applicable and advisable, was what was tried on the Department's farms and quoted by Deputy Hughes as not being successful —that is, reseeding old pasture.
Comment on this
The Minister does not mean to misrepresent me, I know. I said clearly that I knew it was not lea, but it was the nearest thing I could get at, so far as any experiments were concerned. The Minister must remember that.
Comment on this
I do not want to misquote the Deputy and I accept the Deputy's explanation. Deputy Fagan, in condemning lea farming, quoted Deputy Hughes as bearing him out. He was wrong in that. Deputy Bennett said that many Hereford and Aberdeen Angus animals are sold at sales organised by the Irish Dairy Shorthorn Breeders' Society. I do not know whether Deputy Halliden would agree with that. There was an allegation made by Deputy Corry that he and his friends tried to get some seed wheat from Sweden from a merchant in Cork and they were prevented by the Department of Agriculture.
I do not think the Department of Agriculture has any malice against Deputy Corry, or anything like that. The Department of Agriculture knew that a certain amount of this wheat could be got in Sweden and they asked the pedigree seed growers to get it, because they thought they were in the best position to grow this for a year, say, and get a second year's supply from it, a larger supply. They, in turn, may have passed some of this seed wheat on to the co-operative societies for sowing in their districts. That is why some of this seed wheat may have reached the farmers in Tipperary, and apparently they were able to tell Deputy Corry that they got the wheat, where Deputy Corry had failed.
Deputy Fagan told us about a man who had 100 tons of potatoes and the Department could do nothing for him. Have we to regiment the farmers to sell their potatoes as well as everything else? Something I am astonished at what I am asked to do by the members of Clann na Talmhan and Fine Gael. We could not be expected to send an inspector to every farmer.
Comment on this
I am astonished at the type of regimentation they ask us to undertake. Anyway, I am in a position to know all about this matter. I will not give the name, but the individual concerned complained through the papers that he had 100 tons of potatoes to spare.
Comment on this
I am not sure what paper it was in; perhaps it was the Evening Mail. A factor in Dublin wrote to him and asked: “What do you want for the 100 tons?” He said: “I will quote you for 60.” The factor wrote: “Quote me for 60” and the reply came back: “I will sell you 20”. “All right,” said the factor, but he did not get the 20. If this man had the 100 tons—maybe he had and he got rid of them; I do not know—there were plenty of opportunities for selling them in this country during the last few months.
Comment on this
There are. I will say that a farmer cannot sell them now as well as he could six weeks ago. But if a farmer takes a chance and says: "I will hold on and perhaps I will get a better price later" and if he is caught out, is he entitled to write to the Evening Mail and say that the Department could not do anything for him? That is all there is in that point.
I cannot understand one of the points made by Deputy Morrissey that a farmer who misses the market with his barley loses 15/- a barrel. I cannot exactly get at the point there. Deputy Hughes said we had not carried out any experiments with regard to burnt lime and ground limestone.
Comment on this
Actually, we have. I am using the incorporeal "we." The Minister for Agriculture and his predecessors have had a series of experiments carried out in this connection, going as far back as 1924, 1925 and 1926, and the results were published in leaflets.
Comment on this
On different types of land. The experiments were aimed at ascertaining the value of burnt lime and ground limestone. I did not read the leaflets through, but the general result was that burnt lime is worth twice as much as the other. The Deputy also said that in the distribution of the lime subsidy, counties that did not need it, such as Dublin, got more than the others. That is not true.
Comment on this
County Dublin got £620; Cork £10,000; Kerry £6,800; Mayo £6,000; Leitrim £2,700. You will see there is not very much foundation for saying that Dublin got more than its share. Take Kerry and Mayo. They are very good examples. They got ten times the quantity given in Dublin.
Comment on this
I am disappointed the Minister had to go so far back in connection with the comparison of ground limestone and caustic lime. I suggest he ought to have some experiments carried out in relation to beet production.
Comment on this
Will the Minister make arrangements to carry out a series of experiments so far as live-weight and food unit increases on young lea are concerned? I think it would be essential.