Committee on Finance. - Vote 65—External Affairs.
Contributions 125–275 of 275. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
If the Deputy will please allow me—we are considering the administration of one year and the money required for another. That is all because nobody has moved to refer back this Vote. The Deputy wants to go back to 1100 and something.
Comment on this
It is said that, when the Taoiseach met Lloyd George, he had only got as far as Brian Boru when he left him.
Comment on this
Until 1783, we were in that position and then we renounced England. Grattan's Parliament, whatever else may be said about it, did renounce England.
Comment on this
But a Fianna Fáil Parliament, a Parliament with a Fianna Fáil majority, an alleged republican Party recognised the King of England and forced that Act through this House. We have been told that the King has been exercised out of the Constitution and that the Treaty has been exercised out of the Constitution.
Comment on this
——in the usual vague phraseology which we are accustomed to getting from the other side of the House. But whatever developments may have taken place in our international position, they flow from the promises which Michael Collins made in this House during the Treaty debates and whatever progress, internationally and constitutionally, Fianna Fáil may have made flows from the efforts of the late Kevin O'Higgins and of Deputy McGilligan as the then Minister for External Affairs——
Comment on this
We can see the seat of all the objection now. Does that not explain the whole thing?
Comment on this
It is impossible to deal with external affairs until the House makes up its mind on what we are. We are given nothing about external relations, and, for want of something to speak about, we have to define ourselves. We have got nothing from the Taoiseach, as Deputy Costello has said, about what is happening in the outside world, about what relations are being developed in the outside world and about what we are going to do in relation to other nations, and, in particular, to our neighbours. I am not advocating any particular form of government any more than Deputy Costello did. I do not care a hoot if it is a monarchy, a republic or a soviet, so long as the decent people, the common people of the country, get good government; but I cannot see good government here so long as we have this chicanery and quibbling, this evasion and confusion. I say emphatically that all this evasion and all this confusion is being deliberately caused to cloud the people's minds and take them away from the realities of conditions here.
Partition has been mentioned. In the name of all that is good and sensible, does the Taoiseach believe that by the President going to Wexford and declaring an Irish Republic, he will undo Partition? Is not an act of that kind calculated to make more firm that boundary between us? Is it calculated to induce the Orangemen to come in here when we find ourselves disputing whether we are in the Commonwealth or out of the Commonwealth? There is a fable—I think it is one of Aesop's fables—about the mountain and the mouse. The inhabitants around a mountain heard the mountain groan and grumble and rumble for days. The thunder within was terrifying and the people fled to a distance. From a distance, they saw the mountain quake, and, when it quaked, out walked a small mouse, a republican mouse. That republican mouse played the republic up and down until the cat came along, and, the moment the cat came along, in the mouse ran. That seems to be our position here—in and out. When the cat is out, the republic is in, but when the cat is in or about the place, the republic goes out. Let us get rid of all this. Let us get down to Michael Collins's slogan—let us get on with the work of building up this nation and let us not bother about the formulae or about the forms.
Comment on this
I am not bothering about them. I am not in the least concerned with them. I want the Taoiseach to face up to this position once and for all, and to say definitely whether we are going into the Commonwealth, whether we are staying in it or whether we are going out of it. That was the question put to him, not by me, but by Deputy Cogan, Deputy Dillon and others. I want that answered straightly.
General Smuts, in an interview with an Irish Press correspondent this evening, regretted the fact that we were not present at the conference of Prime Ministers which was called for the purpose of discussing a number of very important Commonwealth matters— defence, finance, trade and all that flows from Commonwealth relations. So far as I know, we were not represented at that conference. The Taoiseach was not there nor was any of his Ministers. Our absence from the conference was commented upon, but no ill-feelings were shown.
The Taoiseach has told us the number of conferences that were attended by representatives — civil servants, subordinate Ministers and others. These attended at conferences but the most important conferences of all— T.A.O. and the Dominions Conference —were not attended by any representative. We had, I believe, an observer at T.A.O. in Washington. We had nobody to meet General Smuts, or any of these people. Now, General Smuts and these other people are no more concerned than I am as to our future constitutional development. We are free to go our own road. So are General Smuts and these other people.
The association of the Commonwealth of Nations is dynamic and progressive. It is not static. You can be a republic overnight and still be a member of the Commonwealth of Nations. Let us cut out the twaddle of pretending we are not in the Commonwealth. If we are a republic within the Commonwealth let us say so and face up to that. Let us say to the people who are concerned: "This is the stand that we are taking; we will go in with you whole-hog otherwise." I think it is essential for the future of this country that we must take that stand, and we must co-operate with these people, particularly in defence matters. We are not able to manufacture our own weapons of defence and we must get them from somewhere else; we must keep in line with the other nations in the matter of progress in relation to new lethal weapons of all kinds and in relation to air progress of all kinds. Why not let us be honest with ourselves? Why not let us go in with our heads up instead of by these back-door methods?
Already there are indications that the Taoiseach, who is a very wily politician, is preparing you people on those benches for that rôle. He has already taken the necessary steps and he is preparing you for that, ably assisted by the Tánaiste. They are very wily fellows who do not take their hurdles all together; they take them in little easy strides but they always get the little horse safely over on the few occasions when they make him jump.
Comment on this
They are going there. We are very grateful to them for at last learning the lesson which we have been trying to teach them during the past 15 to 20 years. We are glad to see them taking our advice at last and we want them to go on taking our advice in the future. We are very glad of that and we welcome it. I think it is about time that the people of this country appreciated that for the past 25 years the people on these benches at this side of the House have been educating the people on the opposite benches. Despite all the thunder and the shouting and the muddling nevertheless we have eventually got them to take the bit and go the straight road. That is the road I see them going within the next two years. Mark my words. That is the road I see them going; and to-day the Taoiseach has let a few little words drop which would suggest that he is contemplating a political somersault right into the Commonwealth. Mark my words—republic or no republic, he is going there.
Comment on this
And already the Tánaiste is preparing the industrialists of this country for a mild shock. It takes a little time to get the proper atmosphere for these things but that atmosphere is being prepared and the smoke-screens are being laid. The Tánaiste is going to see Irish industrialists and British industrialists will compete on whatever terms are laid down under the new trade agreement now in contemplation.
I did not intend to speak at such length. I do want to say, however, that if we wish to see the end of Partition we must cut out this farce of republicanism and all these little pin-pricking policies which we have had in the past. Let us not be quite so joyful when we remove some little archaic formalism from an old Constitution but let us rather, on the contrary, try to see the other fellow's point of view. There are a million of these people in the country. They form the one-fourth part of our population and they have their historical roots deeply embedded in the soil of this country, just the same as we have. Whatever their racial origins may have been they are Irishmen. I appeal to all sides of the House to try to understand the fundamental loyalties and the political outlook of these people. Let us not offend them by any act of ours.
We have offended them in the past and I hold that the Fianna Fáil policy in the past has been calculated deliberately to offend the sentiments of these people rather than coax them in with us. You will not get them by offending them. You will only get them by goodwill and co-operation. Is it not better that we should try to understand their sentiments and their loyalties and, understanding, try to have some rapprochement with them? That is the road we have been trying to go for the last 25 years. Because we tried that road 25 years ago and because we were in advance of the political outlook of the people who occupy the benches opposite we were dubbed imperialists and traitors—aye, and worse. I am no traitor and I do not think there is any traitor behind me on these benches. I hold that I and the men with me on these benches are as good Irishmen as the men opposite. I hold that we are as good disciples of Thomas Davis as the men on the opposite benches of this House and I hold that our policy was and is calculated on the lines of Davis to unite Irishmen of every creed and class under the name of Irishmen. That is why I stand here now on these benches and that is why I advocate that rôle. I ask you now on this 25th anniversary of the Irish Treaty to abandon all this idea of republicanism and to get down to business and get on with the work.
Comment on this
I am afraid my colleague, Deputy Coogan, is destined to lead a rather dissatisfied life. He said he would not be satisfied until he got a straight answer from the Taoiseach. The Deputy will never be satisfied. Recently, the Italian nation was torn asunder on the question as to whether they were going to have a monarchy or a republic. Some terrible scenes took place in Italy and a good many lives were lost. There was a referendum to the people. It was a great pity that the Italian people did not know about the Taoiseach.
Comment on this
Because if they had, he would have shown them how to have both at the same time—both a monarchy and a republic. He would thereby have solved all their troubles without a referendum, without any loss of life, or without any injury to any person. I am inclined to agree with Deputy Coogan that the Taoiseach is about to take another line. He deliberately, in the course of a very short and scrappy speech, mentioned the word "Commonwealth" three times. The Taoiseach does not do things like that by accident. For the first time for a long number of years he deliberately and specifically mentioned our association with the Commonwealth of Nations. I understand that he has gone so far as to say that he never left it, or rather he challenged Deputy Coogan to point out when he did leave it. Will he say now whether he is inside it or outside it, or whether he has one leg inside it and the other leg outside? I do not propose to waste the time of the House any further on that matter. All this blatherskite has one purpose and one purpose only—whether it is by the Taoiseach here in the House or by the President down in Wexford —and that purpose is simply to throw dust in the eyes of the people of this country. There is no man, either inside or outside this country, who knows better or thinks more clearly in his mind as to what our status is than the Taoiseach himself; and there is no person in this country to-day who is clearer in his mind that we are not a republic than the Taoiseach is.
Comment on this
And the Taoiseach took very good care in the drawing up of the Constitution, amending the first Constitution, that that was one word which did not find its way into any Article in that Constitution. That is one word which will not be found in the Constitution from beginning to end of it. The Taoiseach told the Fianna Fáil Ard Fheis, after the passing of the Constitution, that he had no intention of declaring a republic for the TwentySix Counties. The Taoiseach likes to pretend that he has changed completely the status of this country, that he has given it a measure of freedom that it had not when he came into power. That is the pretence. The fact is that if the Taoiseach has made any change at all, he has merely changed the label on the bottle, the contents of which are still the same.
Deputy O'Connor spoke about the Constitution of 1937 having enabled us to keep out of the war. Deputy O'Connor knows quite well that before the Constitution of 1937 was ever enacted or thought about, there was no authority except Dáil Éireann that could have brought this country into any war. That was the position then; that is the position to-day. Deputy O'Connor knows it.
I want to ask the Taoiseach does he think that it is treating this House fairly, as the National Parliament, when he introduces his Estimate as Minister for External Affairs, an Estimate that covers the first complete year of peace, in a speech which gives absolutely no information worth talking about or of any value of what has transpired during the past 12 months, no information to the House as to what is to be our line in relation to any other country for the coming 12 months, or no indication as to what reports, if any, we have received from our representatives abroad, either from the political or economic point of view? No indication has been given as to whether the reports coming from our representatives abroad hold out any hope that in the coming 12 months we will be able to get increased supplies from the various countries in which we have representatives. No indication has been given as to whether, through or from our foreign representatives, we have got any information as to what are the probabilities regarding building supplies, fertilisers and the hundred-and-one other things which this country so urgently requires. We have got no line from the Taoiseach as to what our relations are with any other country on the face of the earth. None whatever. Surely we are entitled to be told in the National Parliament, when we are asked to vote money, what is being done. We ought to be told whether the money which we are asked to vote is well spent and whether we are getting value for it. I know quite well that there are reports sent to the Minister for External Affairs that perhaps it would not be in the national interest to make public here but I know that the Minister for External Affairs could give us considerably more information than he did give us without endangering the national interest. However, I am satisfied that when the Taoiseach is replying to this debate, we will hear nothing about the matters which Deputy O'Connor says are those which should be our principal and main consideration. The Taoiseach will be again word-spinning around the Constitution and talking about the word "organ" instead of the word "king." That, of course, is the sort of debate at which he excels. He would require to do a lot of word-spinning to explain away the actual facts of the situation. There is very little use in the Taoiseach telling this House or the country that the King is not there when he is there.
Comment on this
The King is there and he is the man through whom our representatives are accredited abroad and the credentials of our first ambassador to the Vatican are signed by His Britannic Majesty, George VI, Defender of the Faith.
Comment on this
The trouble here is to find out under which thimble is the pea or under which thimble is the king, but the Taoiseach will tell you that he is not the King in the Constitution; he is the organ. Those are the facts. Why not admit that?
Comment on this
Look—would you consider changing him so and, instead of having His Majesty King George VI, Defender of the Faith, signing our credentials, why not have the Sultan of Turkey or whoever is King of Siam?
Comment on this
Yes or the President of the United States of America, or if there was a U.N.O. organisation, we could have that.
Comment on this
That applies to all of us. The only difference between the Minister and myself is that I know that and the Minister does not. If it suited our foreign policy? I invite the Taoiseach to tell us why it does not suit our foreign policy to have anybody except King George VI.
Comment on this
I am sure there is not. I accept that absolutely and fully. The only trouble the Taoiseach will have is to put it in such a way that anybody other than himself will understand it, but will the Taoiseach try to bring himself down to the intellectual level of some of us?
Comment on this
I must confess that I have been trying to understand the Taoiseach for 20 odd years in this House. It may be due to the fact that I am more stupid than most members of this House—I frankly admit that it may be due to that—but I do not know when the Taoiseach means "yes" or when he means "no". Would he try, when he is dealing with this matter, to let us know in plain language that the ordinary person can understand? I invite him specially to tell us why it is more suited to our foreign relations to have King George VI than to have any other foreign potentate?
Comment on this
I approach this matter from a somewhat different angle from that in which it has been approached by Deputy Coogan and Deputy Morrissey. When we last discussed the question of the constitutional status of this country, I expressed the opinion that, so far as our internal institutions were concerned and so far as many of the attributes of our external relations were concerned, we had all the appearance of being a republic but I then said, and I want to say again now, that I have never been able to understand why, being a republic, we deliberately decide to elect a President of the Republic who in any normally-governed country would be the organ of our relations with foreign powers, and at the same time elect a British King to be the organ of our relations with foreign powers, and put the President of the Republic in the second place.
Comment on this
I think this whole constitutional position is getting muddier every day. The obvious thing to do is, if we are a republic, to put a declaration to that effect in the Constitution.
Comment on this
But they have not got King George VI in the United States as the organ of their external affairs.
Comment on this
You need not have him to-morrow if a majority decides here, or even if the Government does not choose to use him.
Comment on this
I want to move the Taoiseach along to that position if I can. I think our constitutional position here is getting muddier.
Comment on this
The Taoiseach, of course, can always see in the dark—I cannot—and the darker it is, the more the Taoiseach will say to you: "Why cannot you see, when I can see clearly?" I think our constitutional position is particularly muddy; it is getting muddier every day, and the oftener the President goes out to receive the freedom of boroughs or attend Feiseanna throughout the country, the muddier the constitutional position will get. We had a statement by the President the other day. He said that he is the President of the Republic of Ireland. Is that really the position? When the President said that, he might have been feeling a little exalted at that particular moment and he might have thought he was the President of the Republic. Maybe he is, but I do not want to see the President declaring himself as the President of the Republic if the Taoiseach and the Government do not think he is. If the Taoiseach believes the President is the President of the Republic, I want to stake this claim for the President, that he should be allowed to do what the President in every other normally governed country does, and that is to be the organ of our relations with other Powers. In our circumstances, we deliberately exclude the President from being the organ of our relations with foreign Powers.
The President is the President of the Republic when he is at a fair around the country, or receiving the freedom of some small borough, but when it comes to accrediting our representatives to any foreign Power, the poor President has no more functions than any funny man at a fancy fair. He is deliberately put in the background and the functions normally exercisable by a president are exercised by a gentleman known as George the Sixth, King of Britain and the other countries in the British Commonwealth. The Taoiseach says it is not necessary to declare a republic in the Constitution. The only case he can quote in favour of that—and I do not know whether this influenced his reticence on the matter—is that the United States has not declared itself a republic in its Constitution. Of course, there is a vast difference. Nobody doubts that the United States is a republic, but here almost half the people are doubting that we are a republic.
Comment on this
As a matter of fact, the Taoiseach knows that he started the country recently when he produced a few dictionaries and said that by attrition we are a republic.
Comment on this
The Taoiseach must get away from the slippery slope on which he stands constitutionally. He says that Deputy Dillon raised the question. The way to decide the matter is by a vote of the people. However, the Taoiseach says that is not the way, and he had to get a few British dictionaries.
Comment on this
This whole position is getting more interesting the further one probes. The Taoiseach says Deputy Dillon raised the question of our constitutional status; he wanted to know whether the country is a republic, or whether it is within the Commonwealth.
Comment on this
They are consistent? In these matters the Taoiseach is a most skilful gentleman. He can throw a somersault on the edge of a razor blade and, when you express amazement, he will say there are heaps of room for everybody to do it. He marvels that other people cannot see things with the same clarity of vision as he can. The Taoiseach says it is not inconsistent having a republic and being in the Commonwealth.
Comment on this
I want to get back to the evolution of the republic. Deputy Dillon raised a question as to whether it is a republic or whether we are in the Commonwealth. Instead of being able to say: "There it is in black and white in the Constitution," the Taoiseach refers to dictionaries. Instead of being able to say: "Our President has been elected by the people. He does everything that Presidents in other countries do. He accredits our Ministers and looks after our relations with other Powers," we are told that we must not judge by that standard and we shall have to see what the dictionaries say about republics. Having looked up the dictionaries, the Taoiseach comes to the conclusion that a republic is a kind of State in which certain things happen and, begob, we must be a republic because these things happen here.
That is not the way in which republics are declared. We had an opportunity and we still have it of asking the people: "Do you want to declare a republic or do you not" and the obvious thing to do is to give the people the choice of voting on that issue. If they say: "We want a republic" clap the phrase into the Constitution and say: "This is the Republic of Ireland" and let the President be the organ of our external relations with others Powers instead of having him declared a President at some country function.
Comment on this
Is it not enough to say: "It is a horse" without having written on a tag on his tail "I am a horse"?
Comment on this
Now the Taoiseach is reducing the Republic to the level of zoology. It is not necessary to write a tag on a horse "This is a horse", because you know it is a horse or it looks like a horse.
Comment on this
Now you see the position we are in. It is all perfectly clear to the Taoiseach, but no matter how we may struggle trying to see where the Republic is and where it got its origin, we cannot succeed. But there is one consolation. The Taoiseach sees it with an amazing brilliance and we are all inferior people because we cannot see it in the same sparkling light as the Taoiseach. I want the Taoiseach to remove every possible doubt about it—and he can do that. I shall try to show him how.
Comment on this
It is for the country to decide whether it wishes to be a republic, a monarchy or a hybrid State. If we want to retain republican status, or assert that we have it already, the normal way is to put into the Constitution "This is the Republic of Ireland" and then let our President exercise, in respect of that republic, the same rights as the president of every other republic exercises as regards the relations of this nation with other nations. But we are not satisfied with that. The Taoiseach has found another way of regulating our relations with other Powers. He says that we will have a republic for internal, ornamental and decorative purposes and the President will do all the flummery stuff within the State. We will let the President do all kinds of embroidery work with respect to State activities, but when we come to accrediting a representative to a foreign State, we will ask George the Sixth to do the accrediting and George the Sixth does the accrediting.
I want to tell the Taoiseach that he is in a very dangerous position with this gentleman who does the accrediting of our representatives to other countries. He did not ask the man whether he would do the job at all. We simply passed an Act and we passed over to that poor man the job of accrediting our representatives to other countries. I do not think he was ever asked by us to do it or that the Taoiseach had ever an interview with him to ascertain whether he would do this job. During the war George VI would not do the job because George VI was at war with Germany and Italy as King of Great Britain and the other countries in the Commonwealth. Of course George VI being Dr. Jekyll in relation to the war would not be Mr. Hyde for the purposes of the Republic of Ireland, and he would not, therefore, accredit our representatives to these countries.
Comment on this
The Taoiseach is a very wily politician and if the Taoiseach did not consult George VI to ask him to accredit our representatives to these countries, I suspect the reason was that he was afraid that George VI would get angry and would say that he would no longer act for us in accrediting representatives in these other countries. The Taoiseach would then probably wake up when he found that George VI would no longer consent to accredit our representatives to any foreign Power. Then we would have nobody to accredit our representatives to foreign countries. Suppose the King goes on strike and says: "Look here, I am not going to do this job any longer; it is an anachronism; it puts me in a wrong position with my subjects in other countries. I am not going to do the job any longer." The Taoiseach will complain probably then that he is being put out of the Commonwealth, that that is unfair, that he intended to remain in it as he wanted the King for the purpose of accrediting representatives in foreign countries. If that happens—and it may happen—the Taoiseach will have a pretty bad headache.
What is the reluctance to getting rid of this anachronism of having the King accrediting Irish representatives to independent States in Europe? Mind you, it is bad enough to have him accrediting representatives to Canada and Australia, but it is doubly humiliating to have to ask him to accredit our representatives to independent foreign States. Will somebody tell me why this man was picked to do that particular job? Might we not as well have found some other monarch in Europe or could we not get the President of the United States, for instance, to do the job? Could we not get the President of some South American Republic and say to him: "Look here, you will do this job just as well; we do not want to declare a republic in a whole-hearted way but we should like in order that we might be able to do things in a republican way to get somebody other than the King of England to accredit our representatives"? But the Taoiseach goes out of his way and he selects the King of Britain to do the accrediting of our representatives.
I think the Taoiseach is not fair to the President in this matter because the President is merely getting the secondhand headship of the State and he is not allowed to do the things that are done by Presidents in other countries. I want to know what is the hesitancy or unwillingness in allowing the President of the Republic to accredit our representatives to other Powers in the same way as Presidents in other countries accredit their representatives to foreign independent States? The Taoiseach has an excellent opportunity of clearing up this whole position now. The Taoiseach has taken the attitude that the position of the republic is to be clarified by reference to dictionaries or by reference to the action taken by film actresses when they want to change their nationality. I think our constitutional position should be clarified apart from what film actresses may do or what dictionaries may say. There is an excellent opportunity for getting that clarification now. The British Government has sent a delegation consisting of three important Ministers to India for the purpose of discussing the Indian problem and the measure of freedom that can be given to the Indians. The British Prime Minister has said publicly to the Indian people: "Look here, you are perfectly free to declare complete independence and to go completely outside the Commonwealth if you want to do that, but for old time's sake, please, if you can see your way, stay within the Commonwealth." He said furthermore that the Indians are not to be under any compulsion to stay in the Commonwealth, that they can do what they like and exercise the fullest measure of independence in deciding what form of political institutions and what form of external relations they will have in future. There is the offer by the British Government to the Indian people.
Do you imagine if the British are going to tell the Indians they can go out of the Commonwealth, that they can be as independent as Britain herself or as independent as any foreign country, that they are likely to worry in the slightest if we decide in future that we are going to ask the President of the Republic to be the organ of our external relations instead of thrusting the job on the King of England? The British are going to give the Indians the fullest measure of political liberty, with no coercion whatever to remain in the Commonwealth. Are they likely to bother their heads if we decide to dispense with the King as the organ of our external relations? They would stand condemned before the world if they attempted to interfere with us in that way. If they are offering new treaties to the Egyptians and the fullest measure of political liberty to the Indians, why should anybody fear that they would dream of interfering in our affairs here simply because we dispense with the anachronism of having the King of Britain as the organ of our external relations with independent countries? I do not think the British would worry in the slightest were we to get the position clarified.
If the President declares he is President of the Republic of Ireland, that whole position should be regularisued by having our status clarified in the Constitution and the people consulted by means of a referendum as to whether they want that clarification, whether we ought to crystallise the establishment of the Republic or whether, alternatively, they want a form of words in the Constitution that we are still in the Commonwealth if some folk want to remain in the Commonwealth. I say to the Taoiseach that he is perfectly free to take a decision on that matter to-morrow, freer than the Indians are. He can make the choice with an absolute guarantee that there is no likelihood of any force being used to impede the free choice of the people. If he wants to exercise our right to be free and to clarify our whole constitutional position, the obvious course is to give the people an opportunity of declaring what they want to do in an issue of this kind.
It might have been difficult in the circumstances of 1937 to have done what it is easy to do now. It might have been difficult to have broken with the Commonwealth in a direct and precipitate way. That day has long since passed, and the difficulties then extant have ceased to be difficulties. It seems, having regard to the declaration of the President, that he is President of the Republic of Ireland and the Taoiseach's rather subtle insinuation that this is a republic, the rather obvious thing to do is to give the people a choice to declare where they want to stand constitutionally vis-a-vis our neighbour or vis-a-vis the other States. It is easy to determine that. It can be determined by referendum. We should certainly get away from the nationally demeaning position, in which every year on the Estimate for External Affairs, we have to discuss what we really are. No Frenchman wants to know what France is, no American wants to know what America is, no Belgian wants to know what Belgium is, and no one in Holland wants to know what Holland is. Their constitutional position has long since been clarified and has ceased to be an object of discussion amongst the citizens.
Here, because of the labyrinthine way in which we went about it, no one knows whether we are now a republic or what we are. How long more will we have to ask that question? There was perfect freedom to decide the matter without any fear of physical opposition from anybody. The Taoiseach should ask the people where they want to be, and let us finish this whole muddy constitutional position in which nobody knows whether he is a citizen of a republic, whether he is in the Commonwealth, whether he is half in or half out, or whether there is internal and external association with it. That position should not continue any longer. There is no necessity in present circumstances to continue it. We have abundant opportunities to clarify the position.
Comment on this
I said that there are no people so blind as those who will not see—none. I am not such a fool as to think that I can convince people who deliberately want to have it the other way. There are two sections in this country who want not to see the light or to see the truth. One is a section that wants, as I said last year, to deny that we are a republic, because, if we were a republic; they would have no slogan to work on. There is the other section that does not want to see it because the fact that it has been achieved would be contrary to all the things they have said and done for a number of years. I did not raise this question as to what was the character of this State, what was its particular type or how it could be classified amongst States. I was quite content that the people should have passed a Constitution which gave us all we wanted. That was the position until last year when Deputy Dillon put the specific question: "Were we a republic or not?" I said we were a republic. Then the Deputy said: "My God, where are we? We are out of the Commonwealth. Everything has gone wrong, if we are a republic." Seeing the people I have to deal with, I tried to demonstrate that we were a republic in such a way that it would not rest on my saying so. When I did this, I was told that it was not a word in the dictionary, but what I said, was the thing that mattered. I had said that we were a republic. I demonstrated it by every test of what a republic should be and what a republican State was. It was said that the word was not in the Constitution.
Comment on this
I gave the reason. In the Constitution of the United States of America the State is not defined as a republic. Is anybody going to say that the United States of America is not a republic?
Comment on this
It had to begin some time. If somebody like Deputy Morrissey or Deputy Norton, a year or two after the American Constitution was adopted, said: "Oh, we cannot be a republic because it is not written in the Constitution." How then? Last year, I stated that:
"We are an independent republic associated, as a matter of our external policy, with the States of the British Commonwealth. To mark this association, we avail ourselves of the procedure of the External Relations Act—which I quoted at the time—by which the King recognised by the States of the British Commonwealth therein named acts for us, under advice, in certain specified matters in the field of our external relations."
Because of the fact that we have Partition and on account of the people of our race in Canada, Australia, New Zealand and so on, we have a special relationship to these countries, apart from a political relationship. The reason we kept this policy of association was that it suited our purpose.
It is not to-day or yesterday that we enunciated that as our policy. Back in 1921, when negotiations were taking place with Britain the Republican Cabinet of that day indicated its willingness to have an association of that sort, provided that the State which then existed was not destroyed or disestablished. We were willing to have co-operation, provided it was consistent with certain ideals we ourselves had. When we passed this Constitution, we enshrined in it our ideals as far as our people were concerned, and, consistently with these ideals being satisfied, as they were by this Constitution, and the freedom which that gives us being accepted, we were prepared for our part to continue association with the State of the British Commonwealth. That was clearly a matter which we ourselves alone could not determine.
I read for the House last year the declaration made by the British Government accepting the situation after that Republican Constitution, in which the King does not figure in any particular way, was passed, and after the passing of an enabling Act which, as a mark of that association, enables us to use the British King—not our King, but the King of Canada, Australia, and so on—in the accrediting of our representatives abroad. In the centre of the Constitution, you will find that the real executive authority in this country is the Government.
Comment on this
In most Constitutions where there is a head of State like a king, executive power is supposed to be vested in the head, even through, in practice, there is a ministry. You do not find that here. It is on a different basis. External policy and internal policy are exercised by and on the authority of the Government. The authority lies with the Government.
If the President carries out any functions except the particular limited functions which are given to him to be exercised at his discretion, he carries them out on the advice and in the form decided by the Government. So, too, when the King of Britain, Australia, Canada and New Zealand—whether the Kingship is regarded from the collective or singular point of view—accredits any representative of ours he does so in the form and on the advice given by the real executive authority, that is, the Government.
Comment on this
Let the Deputy take up the Constitution. I know something of the inside history of this matter.
Comment on this
We have it here in our Constitution, and we know it as a fact, that the letters of credence by which our representatives abroad are accredited are drawn up by us. They are signed in accordance with that Act which gives authority to sign them for that purpose, as and when we desire, and if we wanted not to do it, if at any time it was regarded as good policy not to do it, we do not even need to repeal that Act. We use the Act as a matter of external policy, and that is all there is to it.
Comment on this
It is not true in the sense in which we are doing it. He is King of Canada and he does it as head of the Canadian State. He does not do it as head of the State in our case.
Comment on this
Is it not a fact that when the King acts in that regard for Canada, Australia or South Africa, he acts on the instructions, the authority or the direction of those Governments?
Comment on this
No. He does not act as head of our State. He acts as King of these States and is used by us as a mark of our association with these States.
Comment on this
The point is that he is not head of our State. I was not here when Deputy Dillon read the form of the letter of credence. He read the English translation of it and, on the face of it, what does it exhibit? It demonstrates and proves every single thing I have said. It starts by saying: "The Government of Ireland, being desirous of maintaining the relation of friendship which exists between Ireland"—and whatever State is involved —"have advised me that they have judged it expedient that ——— be accredited.... The Irish Government feel sure"—again, it is the Irish Government—"that the choice of ——— will be perfectly agreeable"—to the head of the particular State to which it is addressed—"and that he will prove himself worthy" and so on. "I, therefore, request, on behalf of the Government of Ireland, that"—Your Holiness or Your Majesty— whichever it may be—"will give entire credence to all that ——— shall communicate to Your Majesty in their name"—that is, in the name of the Irish Government—"and I take this opportunity of renewing, etc."
Comment on this
If the Deputy wants to carry out his own policy, let him do so. We are carrying out our policy which is one of external association.
Comment on this
I must appeal to the House to let the Taoiseach conclude his speech without interruption. This whole debate is being carried on on the basis of interrogatories.
Comment on this
You will recollect, Sir, that I put up with a fair amount from the Taoiseach. The Taoiseach was not a lamb when I was speaking.
Comment on this
It is just the same as if the President of the United States of America said: "As President of the Republic of the United States." Would he be wrong? The Deputy knows he would not, and I say that the President stated an incontrovertible fact.
Comment on this
Basil Brooke will be describing himself as President of the Republic of the Six Counties one of these days.
Comment on this
He can, if he wishes. So far as we are concerned, we do not propose to make any change whatever. We do not want to bother now about this particular question. Deputy Morrissey referred to a statement of mine made to a meeting of Fianna Fáil shortly after the Constitution. I said that I did not put in the words—and I considered it very carefully—Poblacht na hÉireann or Republic of Ireland, simply because those words had a historical association with the country as a whole, when the Republic was declared here in 1919. When some of the people who are attacking us now for not declaring a Republic on a later occasion, had a chance of maintaining the Republic which was in existence, they did not stand up for it.
Comment on this
I do not mind what they say about me. I stood up for it and held for it, so long as it was possible to do so. That is the position, so far as our State is concerned. Nobody need have any doubt, except those— and I do not believe I have any chance of converting them to the truth—who do not want to see. There are such people and there will be such people, and I do not want to waste my breath on them.
The question was asked why it was I did not give a long disquisition on world affairs. Deputy Dillon started by giving his views and his dreams of the world he would like to have. I suppose some Deputies wanted me to do the same. Everybody who is at all interested in world affairs at present knows what the position is. They know perfectly well that the four great Powers which were allied during the war are not able to come to an agreement on the terms of peace, that the peace treaties have not yet been signed and that agreements have not yet been reached. There would be no point in my speculating as to when agreements will be reached, as to what are the chances of securing agreement, as to what will be their effect on us and so on. I can give no worth-while information on that point and I doubt if the people most interested in it, the four principal Ministers, could either.
Do not ask me then to try to give you an essay on what world affairs will be like, or what the consequences of various happenings will be on Ireland. We could speculate from now until this time 12 months on what effect these happenings will have. I do not think anybody will be the better for doing so. Everybody knows that the situation is far from satisfactory. They know that a world organisation has been set up and that it does not yet include a large number of States, that, in fact, the people who are meeting and carrying on discussions at present are, with very few exceptions, the people who were on the side which waged war against Germany, Italy and so on, and that they are now trying to get agreement amongst themselves. The suggestion was made that we should have been at the conference of Prime Ministers recently held in London. The fact was that, as I knew, they were discussing matters immediately relating to the war.
Comment on this
They were discussing commerce and finance and matters related to trade and employment.
Comment on this
I have more information about it than the Deputy. They were discussing, in the main, questions relevant to the peace treaties and questions on matters of that kind.
Comment on this
I told the Deputy in general terms. I am not at liberty to tell him everything. I am giving him the matter so far as I know it and in so far as I can do so. I know that in general they were discussing matters in which we were not concerned because we did not take part in the war; and these were discussions at which we could not properly be present or, if we were invited, in which we could not properly take part. When things settle down somewhat more and when the peace treaties have been signed and an attempt made to build up a world organisation, then there will be some point perhaps in our having representation. The fact is that the war situation has not entirely ended yet in the sense that peace has not really been restored. No peace treaties have yet been signed. There is not agreement, apparently, amongst the principal States. From that point of view we must, to some extent, still regard ourselves as being in the war situation or in the same situation in which we have been for some years past. The time has not yet come in which we can look forward to purely constructive work in which we would naturally be anxious to engage.
Here, in this House you have one set of Deputies suggesting that we have no contact with the British, that we cold shoulder them completely, and keep them at a great distance from us; on the other hand, you have other Deputies accusing us of having subterranean and other hidden methods of approach. The fact is that there has always been contact of various kinds. Britain is taking goods from us, as she always did; she is not yet in a position to give us the goods we want or expect to get in return. The Minister for Agriculture and the Department of Agriculture, the Minister for Supplies and the Department of Supplies, the Minister for Industry and Commerce and the Department of Industry and Commerce, all have been constantly in touch with British Ministers and Departments about matters of importance in relation to agriculture, trade and so on. It is quite wrong to suggest that these contacts are not in existence. You can do a great deal of work without having any conference. A great deal of the ordinary day-to-day business all over the world is done without any conference. Conferences very often denote that there is a crisis, or something of that sort. Conferences very often denote that big changes are taking place.
At the present moment there is no possibility of any big constructive changes taking place because all the nations of the world to-day are interested in only one big issue—that is, they want to get the nations at peace; they want to get the treaties signed and thereby lay the foundations of security in the future. They want them to form some kind of world organisation. Until these things are done there is no use in talking about being ready to take part in other types of constructive effort; there is nothing we can do to help at the moment and we are losing nothing by not being represented at these conferences.
Some minor matters were raised in the course of the debate. Deputy Davin asked about the number of people who went to Britain. All information available on any question of that sort can be obtained by means of an ordinary Parliamentary Question. I do not think it would be possible for us to supply the exact information sought. I do not think the details he asked for could possibly be given. First of all, people went abroad and there is the possibility that the same people returned, or others returned in their stead. The Minister for Finance in his Budget speech gave what he regarded as the net result of movements out and movements in. As far as I am concerned I must say that it looked to me a very small figure; I think it was 78,000. I myself was anxious that it should be checked and counter-checked. It did not seem to me at first sight that the balance could have been so small; but neither the checking, nor the counter-checking, revealed any error. I do not think it would be possible to give the details for which Deputy Davin asked. Neither do I think that we ought to make any point, as he did, of the fact that a number of our people, who went abroad, volunteered. What they did they did as private individuals. As far as this State is concerned, this State was neutral. It was so deliberately, and it stands by that now just as it stood then; and we are not now going to pretend that we were other than neutral. I do not think there are any other matters to which I need refer.
Comment on this
The Taoiseach intimated that he had certain information with regard to the Conference of Prime Ministers held recently. It was stated by that conference that certain principles of commercial and financial policy were decided which, to their mutual advantage, would guide the Governments of the various Commonwealth countries in the International Conference which is scheduled to take place soon in relation to trade and employment. Has the Taoiseach information as to what these principles were; has he taken any action in respect of that matter; or has he made any observations upon it?
Comment on this
But they actually did discuss these matters and did take decisions. Has the Taoiseach been made aware of any decisions?