We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Committee on Finance. - Sinn Féin Funds Bill, 1947—Committee (Resumed).

Contributions 137–284 of 284. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Sinn Feín Funds Bill, 1947
Enacted

No. 5 of 1947 ›

The Minister for Local Government speaking as ex-Minister for Finance. Half of his tale is disbelieved by the Taoiseach. Therefore, he is swept into the ash-can. Half only of Mrs. Buckley's story is disbelieved by the Taoiseach. Therefore, into the ash-can with her. Sceilg's version is not acceptable. Into the ash-can with him. Deputy Larry Walsh had better be careful. But the truth of it is that it is hard to take all this seriously because the purpose of every section in this Bill, no matter what they purport to do under it, is to make it sure and doubly sure that so far as the Taoiseach is concerned, neither at the invitation of the Attorney-General nor of Mrs. Buckley nor of Sceilg nor of anybody else will he have to go into the witness-box with a Bible in his fist, and all the talk of trust is so much eye-wash, but it is a disagreeable thing that this House should be called upon to use its power to sweep aside by statute that which in any civilised community is regarded as one of the most sacred of all things — trusts, things held in trust. It is a nasty thing to have to do and it is a bad precedent. I would remind the House again to remember the quotation provided by Deputy Coogan from Junius— precedents, bad precedents, are dangerous things, and so surely as they are accepted will be used for worse purposes at a later date. I hope that on this section where the House for the first time declares its intention of sweeping trusts away without even pretending to know the nature of those trusts, there will be a division so that some of us at least may go on permanent record as decrying this method of procedure.

Comment on this

I should like to make one suggestion to the Taoiseach which he will probably not regard as helpful. I would direct his attention to the fact that there is one trustee mentioned in this section to whom it is very properly proposed to give immunity from all actions, proceedings, costs, expenses, claims and demands arising out of the administration of this trust. If this Bill were proper it would go through. I gather from what the Taoiseach stated some little time ago that he himself was not merely a trustee but for some time and some unspecified period the sole trustee, and doubtless very magnanimously the Taoiseach is leaving himself open to actions for breaches of trust, to action for damages and he is not getting any money at all.

Comment on this

It would be a shame if Mrs. Buckley came after him again.

Comment on this

Some of the plaintiffs in the present proceedings may turn their former action as it at present stands in court full tilt against the Taoiseach in his capacity as additional trustee. He gets no immunity under this section.

Comment on this

I gave that advice to the Taoiseach as one of the very much despised lawyers.

Comment on this

I am very grateful to the Deputy.

Comment on this

Six-to-four there will be an amendment from the Government for that.

Comment on this

Deputy Dillon, of course, is running over the whole gamut again trying to make out that there is a difference of opinion. Deputy McGilligan comes along and again uses his knowledge as a lawyer to confuse the minds of people who are not lawyers. Deputy McGilligan knows perfectly well that if the Attorney-General were to put up an effective pleading against the claim of the plaintiffs and if he were not going to accept as admitted everything they said he would have to deny it and anything he did not deny would be admitted. If they were going before the court the duty of the Attorney-General would be to put them on proof and make them prove and substantiate what they claim, that is, that they are the body entitled to get these funds. In order that that would not go by default it was absolutely necessary for the Attorney-General to deny it.

Comment on this

What?

Comment on this

I have nothing whatever to do with the correctness or incorrectness of what the Attorney-General has done. I believe that he is competent, that he knows his business and that he did it in the most effective legal way to put the plaintiffs on proof so that they would be required to substantiate their claim. The Deputy wants to make it out that I would go into the court as a person with a thesis — that I would go into the court as a witness. My duty would be not to maintain a thesis, not to act as defendant, but simply to give the facts as I hope I know them. I have, however, the right to see that the views which I hold are in the public interest and that these views should be maintained. It would be for the court to decide this question but I believe that the public interest demands that it be decided here and that is the whole purpose of the Bill. Everybody knows that these funds were subscribed under a special set of circumstances here: that the organisation to which they were subscribed was split at least in two very soon after the time when, in view of the possible split, I was made trustee: that after that an effort had been made by me to reorganise the organisation and to try, if possible, to get it back to its previous position, to get the support of the Irish people for it: that at a later period there was another change of a substantial character in the organisation and that following that change the position so altered from what it was some 25 years ago that neither does the body that is claiming the funds now in my opinion represent the views of the people who subscribed nor is its position substantially the same. It is because the position has completely changed that I say that the main body of the Irish people who subscribed these moneys could, if their names were on record, do the very thing that has been suggested by Deputy Costello — come in and make claims against these funds if they were not debarred by, let us say — I do not know enough, I will have to depend upon the Deputy to put me right — a statute of limitations, barring claims after that length of time. I will answer Deputy Maguire by saying that I do not know that any debts which were due by the organisation at that time could be paid out of these moneys at the present time.

There was an attempt made, on the same lines as the Erasmus Smith case that has been quoted here, to get agreement and if there was agreement I am not going to suggest that this Bill would be quite the same coming before the Dáil as it is in its present position. Each one of us here can express his opinions and his view. I am expressing mine and I am responsible only for the views I express. I may be wrong. My views are that if I were able to get agreement amongst all the parties, and say "This is an agreed matter"— I do not know whether in that event it would be necessary to come before the Dáil, but simply go to the courts.

Comment on this

Quite definitely. We tried to tell Deputy O'Connor that.

Comment on this

I am not a lawyer but to my mind it is the common-sense view. I forget the circumstances now exactly which made the Erasmus Smith case a subject of legislation. It probably was in order to provide that certain things which were in the agreement were effected. I have not had time to look at it but I do know that one of the moving factors which brought about the agreement in the Erasmus Smith case was precisely to prevent the wasting of the funds lodged. The case had gone on for a lengthy period. All the parties concerned saw themselves faced with the prospect that they might continue their law proceedings and at the end the whole of the money would be spent in legal costs and nobody would have it at the end. I think that a sum of £30,000 or £40,000 — I forget the figure — had been spent and they were wise enough to come in and cut their losses at that stage and try to get a settlement for the future. I wish to goodness there was some prospect like that in this case; I would be very pleased with it.

It was suggested, these moneys having lain in court over that long period of 23 years with no active claimant coming forward, that it was time to dispose of these moneys, now that the second treasurer had died, the second person who was responsible. The personal representative naturally wanted to be clear of any implications in regard to that trust as far as he was concerned. Having despaired of any hope of agreement with any people who might feel they had a claim, I tried to get an agreement even on the method of disposal of these moneys by the body who were actively in control of them back in 1922 or so.

Deputy Dillon, of course, tries to twist what I said. I did not care for this particular method of using the funds. I would have preferred, on a sort of cy pres doctrine, if you like, that they should be applied to some purpose that was common to the original organisation, to the reorganised organisation in my time, and to those who may regard themselves as belonging to that association or organisation to-day. As I said, I did not see any hope whatever of getting that. But I was anxious that those who still survived of the executive at the time when the organisation was in its original form should agree upon the purpose to which the funds should be devoted. This present method of disposal was suggested to these and, so far as I know, there was a disposition to agree. In order to make the agreement as effective as possible, it was proposed or intended that there should be a meeting of that body, irrespective of the different views of various members, and that that meeting should, if possible, agree upon a scheme for the disposition of these funds, it being understood that the Dáil, by legislation, would cut the knot and make these funds available.

That is the position as I see it. I have no doubt in my own mind anyhow that, substantially, these are national funds and that to do substantial justice these funds had best be dealt with here by this Parliament. Unfortunately, political tactics, in my opinion—I may be wrong — have suggested that this should be approached in quite a different way. I cannot help that. In a democracy you have to take the good with the bad; you have got to face this.

Comment on this

It is a bit hard.

Comment on this

It is true.

Comment on this

It is hard as a democracy to bear that.

Comment on this

It is the truth. If I wanted to, I could show the first reaction of the Leader of the Opposition to this proposal and the position which has developed since. I have been taunted with—perhaps I am going outside the section——

Comment on this
Daniel Morrissey Mr. D. Morrissey Fine Gael

Not too far.

Comment on this

I am trying to do my best to keep reasonably to it. The trouble is that in talking about trust funds it is very hard to deal with the matter on a narrow basis. I do not want to trespass on the rules of order or lengthen the time which this Bill is taking.

Comment on this

Everybody else went outside the section.

Comment on this

Trusts are in the section.

Comment on this

I have been taunted because I used the phrase that this House was a sovereign court of justice. I used it in a certain context and I believe I was perfectly right and that my law and my theology, notwithstanding what Deputy Costello said, were both correct.

Comment on this

I do not know anything about theology.

Comment on this

The Deputy did presume on that occasion to know something about it when he said that I was wrong in both my theology and my law. I believe I am right in both. As I think I said to the Deputy on one or two occasions, I would love to hear him outside this House giving an opinion on law. Every opinion he gives here loses its value as given by a legal person because it is completely coloured by his political views. Time after time in this House he has told me that certain things were unconstitutional and could not be done when it was proved that they could be and that he was wrong legally. I believe that if he were advising a client outside he would not act in that particular fashion.

Comment on this

He brought you to court a few times and upset you on constitutional matters.

Comment on this

The Deputy talks about the Constitution. He knows well that we cannot here act effectively in an unconstitutional manner.

Comment on this

Nevertheless, you tried.

Comment on this

That is a different thing. We do not try deliberately but, as with other people, it may be found that our view of the law is not the Supreme Court's view. That has happened and will happen no matter how able the legal advisers are and no matter how able the Government of the day are. But the protection of the citizen is in the written Constitution which has to be interpreted, not here, but by the proper authority for interpreting it. Anybody who thinks that we are trying to pass here an unconstitutional measure, whether a Deputy or an affected party, has his remedy. I asked some Deputy this evening who was talking about law, what was law. I was rather anxious to know what his view was of law and what it means. I have not had time to look up any authorities, but it seems to me that when we make laws we determine rights in one form or another; that the making of laws is the determination of rights and that when we pass any measure here we affect the rights of one section of the community as against another; that every Act — I will not say every Act, because it may happen that some particular Act does not, though I find it difficult to think of an example — but, normally, we do alter rights by means of our Acts in so far as we judge between the rights of one section of the community and another section, or I would say, even in the case of an individual, that we are acting broadly as a court of justice in regard to the rights of one section of the community as against another and that we do that with the ultimate purpose of the public good. It is in that sense I said that in my belief we were a court of justice here and that we are determining rights. We have to have regard to fundamental justice and equity as between those who are affected.

Comment on this
Daniel Morrissey Mr. D. Morrissey Fine Gael

This is all strictly relevant to Section 12?

Comment on this

It is strictly relevant to the fundamental question we are being asked.

Comment on this
Daniel Morrissey Mr. D. Morrissey Fine Gael

I am only raising the point of order because the Taoiseach himself was very insistent a few moments ago that we could not talk about Sections 11 and 12, although they go together. Now he is giving us a complete Second Reading speech.

Comment on this

I am prepared to sit down.

Comment on this
Daniel Morrissey Mr. D. Morrissey Fine Gael

I would love the Taoiseach to continue, but what I really wished to remind the Chair was that those who may desire to follow the Taoiseach might be given at least part of the liberty that he has been given.

Comment on this

I understood it was accepted that the trust brought in the whole question.

Comment on this

I do not want to develop the Taoiseach's arguments on Section 12, but it struck me very forcibly that the arguments he made in support of the section were not adequate. I respectfully suggest that the Taoiseach should reconsider the whole matter. It is quite plain that while he was speaking he was labouring, and labouring very heavily. He was not quite happy, and I submit that he was making a case which he is not just in love with. That is my view.

It is true that trusts have been established in this country from time to time in the national interest and among these trusts the Sinn Féin funds trust was one of the most important. The trust the Taoiseach now proposes to establish is also a very important one, but I suggest he has taken a very peculiar line. In this section — paragraph (b) — he indemnifies one member of the trust completely and he does nothing to indemnify the legal successors of the deceased trustee. By the vagueness of this section the Taoiseach has opened up a line in which the legal representatives of the late Eamonn Duggan can be sued, and there is a precedent for that in the income-tax code, under which, down to the sixth or tenth generation, people can be sued. I do not see why the Taoiseach or his legal advisers, when they were framing this section, put only one person in. I do not see why they did not indemnify all the trustees.

Comment on this

The trust devolves on the surviving trustee.

Comment on this

I would like the Taoiseach to reconsider the matter. I am not a lawyer and therefore, I presume, my opinion is as good as the Taoiseach's in that respect, because he says he is not a lawyer either.

Comment on this

He is a lay lawyer, a Capel Street lawyer.

Comment on this

I feel these parties should be coupled. I am in a rather difficult situation. As a member of the old Sinn Féin organisation and as a person who subscribed funds to it, I feel I have as much right as any member of that organisation to say what should be done with the funds. But I was not consulted.

Comment on this

Say it now; you have a wonderful opportunity.

Comment on this

I am not going to get into any acrimonious discussion on the matter, but I will put this point to the Taoiseach. There is another fund in this country, of equal importance to the Sinn Féin funds, in which I have a right. Will it mean that when I take the legal steps I am entitled to take as a citizen to get repayment of the money in that fund belonging to me, if I take that case into court the Government or the Parliamentary majority in this House can bring in a motion or a Bill to deny me my rights? If they do, there is neither law nor equity.

I am a free citizen of this country, having all the rights and privileges and responsibilities of a citizen, and I submit nobody can take them off me. But a Parliamentary majority over there claims the right to do it. I say that they should not and that they should be very careful before they take any rights from citizens. It is true they can do things for the good order and good government of this country, but once they infringe on my rights as a citizen there will have to be very grave reasons why they do so.

I say the Taoiseach is making a very grave mistake. I am not trying to play any political trick, nor do I intend to say one word more after this in regard to this matter. I suggest the Taoiseach should very carefully reconsider this whole matter. I have given him a hint that there is another fund of equal importance, with perhaps more money in it, and, if he establishes this precedent here, then he is interfering with my rights as a citizen and I will try to resist him to the best of my ability.

Comment on this
Maurice E. Dockrell Mr. M.E. Dockrell Fine Gael

Speaking earlier to-night I mentioned that we were in this particular instance making a law deciding an issue and the Taoiseach asked me what the definition of "law" was. I looked it up in the Oxford English Dictionary, a work perhaps not unknown to the Taoiseach.

Comment on this

It is interesting to see it used by the other side now.

Comment on this
Maurice E. Dockrell Mr. M.E. Dockrell Fine Gael

It has its uses. I was only following humbly in the footsteps of the Taoiseach when I looked up the definition of that word in that dictionary. It says:

"The body of rules, whether proceeding from formal enactment or from custom, which a particular State or community recognises as binding on its members or subjects."

That is the definition of "law". I said that a law must have universality or at least widespread application; that, I think, is inherent in that definition. The definition, let me repeat, sets out that "law" is "The body of rules.... which a particular State or community recognises as binding on its members or subjects". This is not binding on all cases; it is binding on a particular case, but it is establishing a bad precedent which may afterwards be used in all cases.

Comment on this

It is a good thing, even at this late hour of the night, to get the Taoiseach's agreement as to the very clear distinction there is between what happened in the Erasmus Smith case and what happens here. I was hoping that Deputy O'Connor might have remained in the House because he had made a statement earlier on this matter. In any event, the Taoiseach has agreed that the Erasmus Smith legislation was a matter of consent. This is not. I take it that we shall hear no more about any analogy in connection with the Erasmus Smith legislation after the Taoiseach has given a hint to his Deputy.

Comment on this

Why was it brought in here?

Comment on this

I do not know.

Comment on this

If you do not know, why do you not find out?

Comment on this

May I ask the Deputy to tell me?

Comment on this

I am asking you.

Comment on this

I say I do not know but I do know this: the Erasmus Smith legislation refers to an agreement. Does this refer to an agreement? Is that not the difference?

Comment on this

It is not.

Comment on this

It is at least a difference.

Comment on this

Will you tell the House why it was necessary to have a statute passed in the Erasmus Smith case?

Comment on this

I do not know.

Comment on this

It was set out in the preamble to the Act.

Comment on this

I do know that there was an agreement in the Erasmus Smith case. Is that not so? The Taoiseach said he hoped at one time that the attempt to get an agreement on the lines of the Erasmus Smith case might have succeeded.

Comment on this

Many years ago.

Comment on this

But it did not succeed. Therefore there is that difference. That is the big difference.

Comment on this

There is always a difference.

Comment on this

It does not do to do Humpty Dumpty and to say that just because there is a point of difference, that will always distinguish cases. The big difference here is that we are thwarting people out of their rights. In the Erasmus Smith case they agreed to what was proposed.

Comment on this

Because they had more sense than the Opposition here. The Erasmus Smith governors agreed, because they knew there was legislation coming here if they did not agree.

Comment on this
Eamonn O'Neill An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Did we not have all this on a previous section?

Comment on this

The Taoiseach referred to the Erasmus Smith case on this section and I am entitled to follow him to counter what he said. I do not know that the position was as Deputy Walsh says. There probably was a dissident part of Sinn Féin to which the Deputy belonged. It might well have been that a good deal of money could have been saved, if the two branches of Sinn Féin, the dissident and those who remained at headquarters, came together and arrived at an agreement, but they did not and the courts are therefore asked to administer justice as between these two people.

Comment on this

That is what we old Sinn Féiners do not want. We want the Dáil to deal with the matter.

Comment on this

So it frankly comes to this, that the courts may be all right for other business but once Deputy Walsh makes up his mind in any matter, then we come to the sovereign court of the Dáil and we will not let the matter go to the courts of justice. What is the good of this little volume, with all the piety about the courts of justice——

Comment on this

Does the Deputy not know——

Comment on this

"Justice shall be administered in public courts established by law by judges in the manner provided by this Constitution."

Comment on this

If anything is done in this House contrary to that it is null and void.

Comment on this

"Justice shall be administered in public courts established by law by judges appointed in the manner provided by this Constitution." We are administering justice in this case. It is clearly not being done in a court of law. It is clearly not being done in the manner provided by the Constitution. What is the good of having all this record to mislead the people, if on occasions when it suits us we suddenly transform this legislative body into a sovereign court of justice and later into a sovereign court of equity? Because Deputy Walsh does not want it to go to the courts, he says it is going to be done here and that is all there is to it.

Comment on this
Eamonn O'Neill An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Deputy might now relate his remarks to the section.

Comment on this

I am relating my remarks to the Erasmus Smith case to which reference was made by the Taoiseach. The Taoiseach has rather lamented that we could not get an agreement of that type. Let him have his lament but what emerges from the necessity for that lament is that we did not get agreement.

Comment on this

Therefore the funds are to be squandered.

Comment on this

That is the distinction between his case and the Erasmus Smith case. That is clear. The Taoieach has attempted to counter another point I have twice made with regard to the trust fund, that on the file there is a pleading by the Attorney-General, that the organisation known as Sinn Féin was defunct — I am not pretending that that is the exact word used but that is the effect of it — prior to the moneys being lodged in court. The answer I have to that is that I know from the legal angle that one must deny anything made in a pleading, otherwise it is taken as admitted but they have done more than that here. What the plaintiffs have said in their statement of claim is that they were the inheritors of the old Sinn Féin Party. The traverse that is required to that is merely: "You were not" but for some reason that I do not know the Attorney-General of the day went on to say: "Sinn Féin died before 1924." That is more than a denial. That is an averment which they will have to prove. It is certainly carried beyond the ordinary denial. That is why the applicants say that they have a very strong witness in the Taoiseach.

It is hardly possible that the Taoiseach could go into court and give evidence of any value to the people who make that plea, that the organisation died before 1924, when dozens of people can come before the court carrying membership cards of Sinn Féin with a summons from the Taoiseach to a meeting in the spring of 1926 — the summons being signed by him as president of Sinn Féin. Did that not happen? The Taoiseach knows it happened. It would be an interesting situation to see the plaintiffs bringing the Taoiseach into court if it were only to meet that simple point. Whatever it may have to do with the substance of the case, here is the point on the pleadings, a point which the plaintiffs had to meet: "Sinn Féin died in 1924". Then we shall have the Taoiseach summoned to the witness box and asked: "What was the last day on which you operated as president?"

Comment on this

That would not be the question——

Comment on this

That would be a relevant point, would it not?

Comment on this

The Deputy is skipping a very important part and he knows it.

Comment on this

What is the important part?

Comment on this

The part that would have to be considered——

Comment on this

Was there continuity?

Comment on this

I tried to reorganise——

Comment on this

I was asked to give way on an interruption but not to a speech — not at this late hour of the night. I want to make a small point. If there be raised as an entry on the pleadings the point that Sinn Féin died in 1924, then at least some opportunity should be given to the plaintiffs to take the Taoiseach into court to prove that he promulgated himself as head of Sinn Féin as late as spring 1926.

Comment on this
Eamonn O'Neill An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Does this arise on the section?

Comment on this

Of course. The trusts have to do with the section and allied to the question of the trust is the question as to who are the survivors of the original representative of Sinn Féin. The plaintiffs claim to be that. The Attorney-General says that Sinn Féin ceased to be in existence in 1924 but there was one great man who paraded himself as head of the Sinn Féin organisation——

Comment on this

Paraded himself?

Comment on this

I am sure I am be-labouring the point but there are some back benchers who do not seem to undersand it and I want to make it clear that the plaintiffs would have a valuable light in the Taoiseach on that point. It would be a matter of relevance to the court——

Comment on this

Why should I be afraid?

Comment on this

Have I mentioned the word "fear"? I may be working up to it but I have not mentioned it yet. Let the Taoiseach wince when he is really wounded but not in anticipation. Would it not be an interesting thing and a relevant thing if three or four dozen people came into court and each said: "I attended a meeting of that organisation in the spring of 1926. I was summoned there. Here is my card. I know the Taoiseach's handwriting, and that is it, and he is described there as President of Sinn Féin." It may have nothing to do with the action, but it at least kills the point that the organisation was dead in 1924.

Comment on this

You are passing over the material point.

Comment on this

I am only on the one point: does that not kill the contention that Sinn Féin was dead in 1924?

Comment on this

The organisation to which these moneys were subscribed.

Comment on this

That is another side of it. All that these people are countering at the moment is the suggestion that the organisation to which they belonged, called Sinn Féin, was dead in 1924. If the Taoiseach likes, he can go in and say: "I really was hawking a bit of a corpse around the country and trying to breathe life into it, but that is the situation and let the court judge of it." I would agree that the substantial matter, the gist of the action is: did Sinn Féin survive? Are there any trusts discoverable? Has the purpose for which these moneys were subscribed for Sinn Féin survived and if these people be the successors, are they the people properly entitled to discharge the trusts? Surely that is the gist of the action. Were there trusts to which these moneys were attached? If so, who is to distribute them and to what purpose? Surely on any of these considerations the point will arise: do we know about the original trusts? Do we know who originally got the moneys? Is there a line of continuity? Are these people in the line of succession?

Comment on this

And is the organisation still there? Is that not the point?

Comment on this

According to the file, the main point is whether the organisation died in 1924, and certainly that point can be killed deader than the alleged death of Sinn Féin.

Comment on this

What difference would a date make?

Comment on this

Possibly no difference, except that it is a material point, according to the Attorney-General, because he makes the point and makes it beyond a traverse. There in any event were the issues to be decided. Why could the courts not decide them? I want to know what is the reason for saying that the trusts attached, if any such trusts were attached, to these moneys, are to be discharged or deemed to be discharged? What is there amazing about this case that makes us take this amazing attitude towards it? The courts often decide trust matters. They often have to decide whether people are the legitimate successors of old-time trustees and often have to decide whether it is possible to discharge the trusts attached to a particular fund, and they certainly could, on an application made to them in this connection, be asked to arrange a scheme, if the old purposes are no longer open. Having arranged a scheme, they could be asked to administer the trust along the lines of the scheme, and, if they were asked to do that, we still keep inside this book which is so much thought of at times, the Constitution. We are still having justice administered in courts and by judges made independent under the Constitution and asked to discharge their independent functions in accordance with the Constitution. There is nothing hard about that.

Comment on this

Except that there would be nothing to distribute by the time it comes to be done.

Comment on this

Why would there not be? We are now apparently on the money argument. We are going to throw away £8,000 in money to people who have already been held out in this House as being not worthy of any costs because they have not got a case.

Comment on this

In the Erasmus Smith case, the losses had to be cut at £40,000.

Comment on this

It was done by agreement. That is the thing you can never get over. In the Erasmus Smith case, it was done by agreement.

Comment on this

In order to save the fund.

Comment on this

By agreement.

Comment on this

To save the fund.

Comment on this

By agreement, all the time.

Comment on this

Suppose they did not?

Comment on this

If they did not, would the Dáil have stepped in?

Comment on this

It might have.

Comment on this

Would it?

Comment on this

It might have.

Comment on this

Then let us know where we are. On any case in which the Dáil is of opinion that funds are being dissipated, the Dáil will step in, the Dáil may step in. Was the Erasmus Smith case a public matter?

Comment on this

Of course it was.

Comment on this

Was it a public matter?

Comment on this

I would require to have the facts of the case in front of me. I would then be able to make up my mind, but if it were a public matter, I would not have any hesitation in preventing the money being spent, and I would think it a duty to do so.

Comment on this

Had the death of the late Chief Justice anything to do with the Erasmus Smith case being decided in the way it was decided?

Comment on this
Eamonn O'Neill An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Deputy had better let Erasmus Smith be buried.

Comment on this

I object to having discussion curtailed because of any boredom in the Chair. The Erasmus Smith case——

Comment on this
Eamonn O'Neill An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

It has no relation to this section.

Comment on this

The Erasmus Smith case is very analogous and was so introduced by every speaker, and notably by the Taoiseach, without interruption by the Chair. I demand the same rights as the Taoiseach got. I suggest that the Erasmus Smith case went to Dáil Éireann only because of the death of the late Chief Justice.

Comment on this

You said a moment ago that you did not know why.

Comment on this

I said I was not concerned with it and I say now that it went to Dáil Éireann only because of the death of the late Chief Justice. I should like a denial, if a denial can be made.

Comment on this

You are terribly worried about Erasmus Smith, whatever be the reason.

Comment on this

Only because the Deputy was befogged enough to try to bring this Dáil to the conclusion that it was the same as, or on a footing with, what is proposed here.

Comment on this

I said that and I repeat it.

Comment on this

You will repeat it?

Comment on this

Yes, and the Deputy might save the time of the House by leaving it at that. Let us agree to differ.

Comment on this

If the Deputy is so blissfully ignorant as that, it were folly to give him any wisdom, but the Erasmus Smith case is completely and entirely different from this matter. It was a matter of agreement. If you could get agreement in this case, the whole complaint disappears and nobody could say that you were cutting across a litigant's rights in court. I say you are doing so now.

Comment on this

This can be settled if it is contrary to the Constitution.

Comment on this

I do think that this is a very important matter we have reached this evening. This booklet, with our courts and the administration of justice in public courts and an independent judiciary — all that can be swept aside if this Dáil comes to the conclusion that money is being wasted in litigation and that it will step in and decide, without the agreement of the parties, in favour of one or the other.

Comment on this

The Deputy knows that that statement is not correct, that we could not sweep that "booklet" aside by anything we do here.

Comment on this

You are sweeping aside that part of the booklet which says that justice is to be administered in public court.

Comment on this

The Deputy knows we cannot.

Comment on this

You are doing it, and you are relying on the courts saying that you are entitled to do it.

Comment on this

The Deputy knows perfectly well that if anything we do is contrary to the Constitution, it is null and void to that extent.

Comment on this

I know that as well as the Taoiseach, and I say that this phrase, that justice is to be administered in courts established by law by judges appointed in accordance with the Constitution, means nothing.

Comment on this

By the courts that are there to interpret the law.

Comment on this

Let me make my point without interruption. The Constitution says that justice shall be administered in courts established by law by judges appointed in the manner provided by this Constitution. I take up this Official Report and quote the Taoiseach: "We are bringing this matter here to the sovereign court of justice."

Comment on this

For the determination of rights between citizens.

Comment on this

Earlier, the Taoiseach said: "I say that we are here the court of equity in this matter".

Comment on this

And in all matters of rights.

Comment on this

If we are the court of equity and if we are the sovereign court what is the meaning of this paragraph which says that justice is to be administered in courts——

Comment on this

Of law.

Comment on this

Oh, let me finish.

Comment on this

The Deputy is a good hand at interrupting.

Comment on this

I will not call the Taoiseach a cub, in any event.

Comment on this

I did not call anybody a cub.

Comment on this

You did. It is on record.

Comment on this

There is nobody who can say he heard me. Did the Deputy hear me?

Comment on this

And now that the Taoiseach has lost his temper, I move to report progress.

Comment on this

Will anybody stand up and say he heard me say it?

Comment on this