Committee on Finance. - Vote 29—Agriculture (Resumed).
Contributions 1–161 of 284. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
Last night I had reached a point on this Estimate where I was discussing the imposition of fines by the courts for infringement of the tillage regulations. I stated that my experience in many cases was that fines have been excessive and I now wish to state that there should be some curtailment of the powers of inspectors, or at least I would expect them to be allowed freedom of discretion in dealing with people in extenuating circumstances who were not able to comply with the regulations to the full. There may be such things as sickness in a family. There may be old age, or such a vital and important matter as lack of capital which would not permit them to comply with the tillage regulations.
I would suggest that a minute investigation should be held into the affairs of those people, and if they are suffering from sickness, infirmity, old age or lack of capital, it should receive serious consideration, and if they have to be brought to court, I would ask that the Department should not press for such penalties and that they would take into account any extenuating circumstances in the case with which the court may be concerned. I heard one Deputy in particular on the Opposition Benches suggesting that we should not export agricultural produce at all, that we should look to other aspects of our economy and to other industries for products for the export market. I cannot see for the life of me what we have got to export from this country, with the exception of agricultural produce and I would say that the biggest items of our exports have been and will continue to be cattle. In dealing with that problem, I would say that we should tackle first the question of our surplus cattle population in a businesslike manner.
For some years in this country, perhaps for a period earlier on, there has been some prejudice against trade with other countries, particularly with our nearest neighbour, Great Britain. I do not like to be raking up old history and repeating ancient statements, but I can clearly remember a time when we were led to believe that the English market was gone, and gone for ever. I never believed that. It was a fable at the time, and many Deputies, I feel, realised it was not the case and that there is a good and profitable market in Great Britain for any of our surplus products or any products we can send.
I would like if the old prejudice could be dispelled that we should try other countries in the world besides Great Britain. We have made an attempt to establish trade with many European countries. In these attempts we have not been wholly successful and I still hold that our best customer will continue to be our nearest neighbour. It is up to us to make a trade agreement with Great Britain on sound business lines. I do not mean to say that we should go hat in hand or down on bended knees and beg them to take our produce. There is no necessity for that. We have a good article to sell, and the English people realise that it is the best in the world. Therefore, there is no necessity to go craving or begging or on our knees to them. They will be glad to take it if only for the reason that it is a superior article, better than they can get elsewhere.
As I have been saying, the cattle export business is perhaps the most profitable, and will continue to be the most profitable side of our export business. We cannot hope for exports of butter and bacon for a considerable time. I think I have already dealt with the bacon position as far as administration is concerned, but I should say that a desperate and determined effort should be made to revive our cattle trade. It must be remembered that it is one of our industries that survived the war and the emergency conditions without a subsidy, even though it was not always a profitable business. But at the same time it was a business which survived without grants despite the fact that at some periods it was not by any means profitable.
Regarding the eggs arrangement with Britain, I do not consider it satisfactory at all. This arrangement means that we are more or less tied hands and feet across the water. We are asked to provide up to 700,000 cases of eggs a year, and if we do we will get a better price. I think there should be a great deal more freedom and I do not think the rod should be held over our heads that if we do not export this quantity we will not get an economic price. I think there should be some kind of open agreement without any stipulations. We could agree to stipulations as to quality but I do not think there should be any stipulation that we should export 700,000 cwts. We should have our freedom to export as much as we possibly can to Great Britain and if we are not able to do that, we should not suffer any financial loss.
Since the present Minister for Agriculture took office there are a couple of things on which I think he deserves congratulations. I am not going to say things that will cause him to leave this House or to remain in it suffering from a swelled head. I thought he was making an earnest attempt to come to the aid of the depressed farmer by voting money for the relief of rates. On the surface his proposal was good. It was a gesture, but when the gesture was boiled down, it can be assumed, and it is a reality, that that £1,000,000 voted for the relief of rates never reached the farmer's pockets. He never made a penny out of it because to coincide with it agricultural wages went up about 6/- a week per worker. I am not going to stand up and say that the agricultural labourer is overpaid. I hold, and I have always held, that he is underpaid, but I say that as far as the farmer is concerned, he derived absolutely no benefit from the £1,000,000 relief of rates because it went out again by way of increases to his agricultural workers—a very good thing—but the farmer who believes he is getting relief is living in a fool's paradise and is not sane or right.
Another matter on which I wish to congratulate the Minister is the money made available for loss of stock during the severe weather, but in that there is also a snag. Heavy losses were suffered by farmers during the winter and the spring. I say that this requirement that farmers should produce sureties is humiliating. Surely if land is worth anything at all, it should be sufficient security for advances in respect of losses of stock. I think these cases should be dealt with on their own merits. Suppose that next year we have a repetition of the great calamity where we had a bad harvest and a severe spring and suppose the losses when they are counted up prove to be greater than this year. The man who goes security for his neighbour who meets such losses will find himself in a very undesirable position when he discovers that his client is not in a position to meet his commitments so far as these loans are concerned. I suggest to the Minister that this question of sureties should be left out of it by probing fairly well into a man's financial ability and inclination to pay. In addition to that, the securities on his land and his farm should be adequate for the Government or the banks.
Comment on this
Deputy Dillon is a man who perhaps, more than any other man in this House, should understand me because he is a business man. I also am a business man but my business is not as large as that of Deputy Dillon. Does he ever take a farmer into his confidence and give him an advance and goods on his own security? I am sure he does, whereas the Department——
Comment on this
I do not know of anybody who gets that profit. When we pay a decent wage and all the other expenses we can easily count our profits. I know it because I am in the grocery trade.
I would refer to a statement which was made in this House by Deputy Moran wherein he gave a glowing and very detailed account of the sale of a side of bacon. Deputy Moran has told us here in this House that a Wiltshire side of bacon, weighing 61 lbs., when cut up into several cuts or grades shows a net profit to the shopkeeper of £1 13s. 10½d. I must say to Deputy Moran that that is highly exaggerated. Deputy Moran never stood behind the counter to cut up a side of bacon because if he did he would know exactly what the profits are. If he were in my position he would know the true position. Did he ever take into consideration the loss in bones, shrinkages and perhaps the entire loss of the side which occurs frequently at the present time of the year? With his limited experience of the bacon business as a director of the Castlebar Bacon Factory, I do not think he should try to tell the world that we, in the grocery or provision business, are extortioners or racketeers. If he divided the figure by three he would, perhaps, arrive at a nearer calculation to the net profit on a side of bacon.
I would also suggest to the Minister that the duty on imported machinery should be abolished. If we come down to brass tacks and study that duty we will find that it is an indirect and carefully hidden tax on the agricultural community and I would suggest to the Minister that that is so. I think that if there is a duty of 33? per cent. on it, as the Minister suggested——
Comment on this
I was not suggesting anything of the kind. I was talking of retailers' profits of 33? per cent.——
Comment on this
On a point of order, Sir, is it permissible for the Minister for Agriculture to start braying every five minutes——
Comment on this
I do not wish to interrupt but, whether wilfully or by accident, what I stated was misrepresented.
Comment on this
Perhaps Deputy Dillon would conduct himself. He has been in this House only two minutes, yet we have been discussing this Estimate for the past two days.
Comment on this
Is it in order, Sir, for a Deputy to accuse a Minister of braying in this House? Let us have that point cleared up.
Comment on this
Now that peace has once more been restored, I would urge the Minister to have the duty on imported machinery removed. As I have already said, it is a carefully and well-designed imposition on the agricultural industry and any man who buys agricultural implements not manufactured in this country must realise that he is paying something in indirect tax. It is an unfair and unjust tax.
In conclusion, I wish to summarise all the points I have dealt with on this Vote. In order to refresh the Minister's memory I would summarise the points under six headings. My first point is that there should be introduced under the system of primary education some kind of text-book that would give the boy in later years a flair for agriculture. My second point concerns a long-term policy for agriculture. To my mind it would be a grand and a sound idea if the Minister could give us some indication of what we will be doing next year or the year after and give us an idea of our outlook for the future, so that we can plan and hope to realise the ambitions of the Minister and of everyone connected with the agricultural industry of this country by putting it on a good, firm and solid foundation. My third point is that there should be less Government interference in agricultural industries, particularly in the pig industry. If the Government wash their hands of interference and let these industries stand on their own legs they will survive because when there is no compulsion or control the position will adjust itself. I would stress my fourth point again. I feel that trade agreements are necessary. However, they need not be only with our nearest neighbour. We could make them with anybody. I would say to the Minister that he should make the best trade agreement he can with any country in the world. It can be done. He should tell them and advertise to them that we have agricultural products in this country which are second to none and that we can give them the article if they are prepared to buy and give us a reasonable price for it. As my fifth point, I would ask the Minister to approach the Minister for Finance, who is responsible for the Drainage Act which is locked up in a pigeon-hole in this House or in some other Department, to implement that Act at once. I think agriculture and drainage are more or less interdependent. I can see myself that production in this country is greatly retarded because of the need for a proper drainage system. I would, therefore, ask the Minister to urge the Minister for Finance to implement the Drainage Act.
Finally, I would say that the Minister should go minutely into the question of prices for farm produce and, where he sees that there is a possible chance of increasing the prices of any agricultural products in this country, he should not hesitate to come to the House and ask for the money. As I have already said, the farmer should be able to get favourable remuneration and the agricultural workers should be given equitable wages. In order to do that, however, the prices must be increased. In putting these points before the Minister, I can say that if he gives effect to them I will be able to compliment him as perhaps the best Fianna Fáil Minister for Agriculture we have had up to the present.
Comment on this
I have read and read very carefully, if I have not listened to them on some occasions, nearly all the pronouncements made by the present Minister for Agriculture since he came into office. I cannot discover in any of his pronouncements any indication of any change of policy compared with that of his predecessor. The Minister will have to admit—no amount of bluff will get over it—that the policy of the Minister for Agriculture, for the past five or six years particularly, has left 20 per cent. of our citizens—because of low incomes—in the position to-day that they are unable to get bacon, butter, eggs or a sufficient quantity of milk. In addition to that, it has left us in the position that we have not a proper supply of the type of labour that will enable the agricultural industry to pay its way. Every citizen of this State must recognise, and I am sure does recognise, in some form or other, that the farmers and the agricultural labourers have rendered a great national service to the citizens during the emergency and that we can never repay them either in cash or in kind for that wonderful service. We can never repay them, either in cash or kind, for that wonderful service of feeding the people when we were absolutely isolated from other parts of the world. What is the policy of the Minister in regard to the repayment of the farmers, or, should I say, what is his policy so far as it aims at giving the primary producer a reasonable return for the use of his land and labour? Will it be suggested by the Minister that the farmer is getting a decent return for the use of his land and for his labour and that the agricultural labourer is getting a decent cash wage, sufficient to enable him, if he is a married man, to maintain his family in common decency and comfort? There must be some revolutionary change in the previous policy of the Department and the Minister for Agriculture if the agricultural industry is to survive and if farmers are to get a decent means of livelihood.
The Minister will probably say, in the same eloquent way as his predecessor, that there has been an increase in the consumption of butter. That may be true. How does that apply to the 20 per cent. of our citizens who are living on low State incomes, such as widows' and orphans' pensions, old age pensions, blind pensions, unemployment insurance benefit, unemployment assistance benefit and national health insurance benefit, apart from the large number who have to survive on the miserable maximum of 8/- per week by way of home assistance? How much butter, bacon, eggs and milk can be purchased by the people living on these incomes? I know that the Minister will say it is not his job to provide higher incomes for the classes I have mentioned. But he has a collective responsibility in that matter. He has a responsibility as Minister for Agriculture as well as a member of the Government under the Constitution to see that every citizen is provided with a decent livelihood and clothing and shelter.
Comment on this
If it is the policy of the Minister to change the policy of his predecessor and to provide a better livelihood for the farmers and agricultural labourers, will he say how he proposes to do it? Will he say, for instance, how he proposes to increase the amounts paid to the producer for his agricultural produce and live stock and, at the same time—I think both are possible if you go the right way about it—reduce the price of essential commodities to the consumer? We have too many middlemen in this country. We have more middlemen per head of the population than any other country in the world. That is why the price to-day to the producer is so low and uneconomic and, worse still, that is the reason why the charges made to the consumer are so excessive. I have personal knowledge within recent times that in the part of County Dublin where I have lived for about 25 years the average housewife would be lucky if she could get a head of cabbage for 1/2. Has the Minister taken any steps to deal with the people who make these prohibitive charges? If he has made any inquiries into the matter, will he say how much the producer was getting for the cabbage for which 1/2 per head was charged to the average housewife in the City and County of Dublin? I have been told that housewives in the city have been charged as high as 1/7 and 1/8, but I have no proof of that. My wife, however, has proof that she was charged 1/2 in the town of Dún Laoghaire for a head of cabbage. Is there any Minister or any Deputy sitting behind the Minister who will defend that policy, knowing perfectly well that the producer is only getting 3d. or 4d. per head out of it? What does the Minister propose to do to stop that kind of profiteering and racketeering? What is the Department doing to encourage the farmer, a farmer with a funny point of view like Deputy Beirne, if you like, to cut out a certain percentage of the middlemen and to get down to running this country on the basis of co-operation, co-operation as close as possible between the producer and the consumer?
If we have been cut out of the British market or other world markets—and the British market is the chief market where we have been selling agricultural produce—we have been cut out because other countries understand the meaning of co-operation; co-operation in the production, distribution and selling of produce. Anyone who knows anything about the conditions in Denmark can understand why Denmark can beat us in the British or any other market. They produce on a co-operative basis. The co-operative societies were established by the Government, are propped up by the Government, and are run under a system of Government control. They have control of their own transport or, if they have not complete control of it, they have the power to see that the farmer or the producer gets preferential low rates for the carriage of agricultural machinery or produce for export. They control their own shipping. They pay higher rates of wages and better prices to the producer in the long run than we do, because we have too many middlemen in between the producer and the consumer.
Is it possible to persuade the Minister to instruct his army of inspectors, either local inspectors or the inspectors working under his direct control, when touring the country and speaking at meetings to say a little more to the people about the value of co-operation and tell them what the Minister proposes to do to help the farmers to establish co-operative societies, or even to maintain the ones established already? The sooner we face up to that position, the sooner the Government will be in a position and the sooner this House that supports the Government will be in a position to give the producer a little bit more for his labour and the use of his land and to give the consumers those essential commodities, at a far lower price than they are forced to pay to-day.
I could go on quoting commodities essential to the life of the community for which prohibitive charges are made. Somebody may say that that has nothing to do with the Minister for Agriculture, that it is a matter for the Minister for Industry and Commerce. It is a matter for the Minister for Agriculture and for him before anybody else, because his job is to see that the primary producer is put in a position to continue in production. The present position is leading, as you can see in various aspects of the agricultural industry, to the people clearing out of production. You would nearly salute a pig now if you saw one. Of course, Deputy Cogan said he passed through a town in Wicklow where a fair was being held and saw a few pigs there. He saw more than the average Deputy will see if he goes around the country. The people are getting out of pig production. There must be some sound reason why they are getting out of production. The farmer will always hang on to the production of the commodity which pays him. He does not go out of production because he is lazy or unwilling to take advantage of whatever encouragement, financial or otherwise, may be given to him to continue in the production of essential commodities.
I cannot stress too strongly the necessity, not alone for the Minister, but for Deputies of every Party who want to see this country regain the position which it occupied in pre-war days, to produce the necessaries of life for our own people and to export whatever is genuinely exportable, so as to enable us to pay for the commodities that we must continue to import until this policy of complete self-sufficiency comes to us in the next generation or after. At the moment it certainly does not appear to be on the horizon. So long as we have to import essential commodities we must send out our exportable surplus in order to pay for such imports. There is a wrong idea in the minds of a good many people with regard to what an exportable surplus constitutes. An exportable surplus, to some people, means what you cannot sell. An exportable surplus, to my mind, means what the community are unable to consume after they themselves have been provided with the necessaries of life. We all know, and the figures are there to prove it, that a very high percentage of our people cannot purchase bacon, eggs or butter in a sufficient quantity, because they have not got the purchasing power to enable them to do so. We are told there has been an increase in the consumption of butter. Who is consuming it? It is being consumed by those people who are coming in here from the Six Counties and Great Britain and from other parts of the world from which they can get a passport. The proof of that for any Deputy who does not already know it may be found in our hotels all over the country. Our hotels are packed with foreign visitors and their pockets are packed with money. They are coming in here with unlimited funds at their disposal because of the currency system which ties us to our neighbouring nation. They can bring with them sufficient money to purchase whatever they can get in a market where there is a shortage of essential commodities for our own people. Being placed in that fortunate position, they are forcing up the cost of our essential commodities in the very country in which they are produced.
I do not blame the Minister for Agriculture altogether for that because the Cabinet has a collective responsibility as far as our monetary system and financial policy is concerned. That monetary system at present enables foreign visitors coming in here to buy up whatever they can as against our own people. Anybody who has been down at the North Wall during the past 18 months can see there the long line of furniture vans on the quays. To whom does this furniture belong? It belongs to those people who left this country in 1922 when we got a certain measure of freedom to which they took exception. It belongs to those people who left the country in 1932 who did not approve of the de Valera Government. It belongs to those people who left the country in 1939 who did not approve of our policy of neutrality. They are coming back now and they are glad to come back as quickly as they can, with their pockets bulging with money. They are glad to come back because they can buy up food and other essential commodities as against those of us who have always stayed here. All this goes to prove—if my statement is acceptable and if the Minister is in agreement with it—that a revolutionary change in our agricultural as well as in our financial policies is vitally necessary if we are to survive as a Christian democratic State.
I agree with Deputy Heskin that there is an urgent necessity for an increase in the price of milk to those farmers who supply milk to the creameries. I do not profess to have any expert knowledge of the dairying industry but I do know that the few creameries which were established in my constituency during the last 15 or 20 years are quickly going out of existence because—it is alleged at any rate—the farmers are not getting an economic price for their milk. I have always supported the policy of the Government in regard to subsidies and I have always maintained that if a subsidy is necessary for the purpose of enabling a producer to remain in production, then it should be a sufficiently large subsidy to provide an economic price for the person producing the particular article or essential commodity. There is no use in giving them a small sum in order to provide them with an uneconomic price. If you subscribe to the policy of subsidising industry you must go the whole way and give the primary producer particularly a sufficient subsidy to enable him to make a profit on his labour and on the utilisation of his land. Deputy Heskin gave figures and facts to substantiate a good case for a higher price for the dairy farmer.
I do not subscribe to the policy of the Minister—and I would like the Minister to note this in order that he may reply to it—in regard to the slaughter of calves. In the present circumstances of this country it is in my opinion inhuman and immoral that our young calves should be slaughtered. That policy should be stopped and steps must be taken by the Department of Agriculture to bring it to a stop immediately. Otherwise we shall find ourselves in a worse position from the agricultural point of view in the live-stock section of our agricultural industry not so many years hence. I would like to hear the Minister defending this policy, if he can make any defence for it. I can be converted if the Minister can advance a good and sufficient argument for his policy.
Looking over the Estimates for the Department of Agriculture and the Estimates in general, I find that we are providing here roughly a sum of £6,000,000 of the taxpayers' money for different kinds of education. I have examined the Estimates in some detail and I have had my examination checked by colleagues. Out of the £6,000,000 provided for the education of our young people in the various schools which are subsidised in this State only £160,000 is provided for agricultural education. That represents roughly 2d. or 3d. in the £ out of every £ paid by the taxpayers. I have always held the view, though I do not put my view against the view of the experts of the Department of Education or the Minister for Agriculture, that our system of education in the rural areas has always been a bit lopsided. Certainly there is something radically wrong when only 2d. or 3d. out of every £ provided by the taxpayers is provided directly for agricultural education. Compared with the days when I went to the primary school —now some 40 years ago—there has been very little change but any change that has come about has been a change for the worse from the farmers' point of view and from the point of the rural population as a whole. The boys and girls now going to our primary schools are receiving an education to fit them for "clean hands" jobs—typists, shorthand writers, counter jumpers and everything else except bricklayers or carpenters.
Comment on this
I was coming to the point where I would relate him to a definite responsibility if you will permit me to continue with another sentence. He can provide agricultural colleges in every county in this country.
Comment on this
He can provide agricultural colleges. If he cannot provide them I am prepared to listen to his reason for his inability to do so. I am speaking for my own constituency. I am not speaking for County Cavan or anywhere else. But I would like to see an agricultural college in every county in this country. If there is any difficulty in the way, I will give the Minister all the help in my power to overcome that difficulty and to remove any obstacles that may be placed in his way so far as the provision of such colleges is concerned. I would in particular like to hear him defend the provision of 2d. or 3d. in the £, out of this £6,000,000 of the taxpayers' money, for agricultural education. I am not blaming the Minister for all that is wrong in the Department of Agriculture. He has not been long enough in office to learn what has been going on during the time of his predecessor. He need not be in any way annoyed at the remarks I make here. I have said some of these things here before and I shall continue to say them so long as my constituents send me here for that specific purpose.
I think too that the farmers in this country should get all the encouragement possible from the Government, from the Minister for Industry and Commerce and from the Minister for Agriculture by the provision of cheap transport rates either by road or by rail for agricultural machinery and the raw materials of the agricultural industry. I think I can safely say that there is no other country in the world where the Government has not provided special rates of carriage for agricultural machinery and the raw materials of the agricultural industry. A glaring example of what I consider to be an unfair discrimination arose recently when the Government authorised Córas Iompair Éireann to increase their rates by 20 per cent. Anybody who knows anything about the economy of transport knows that it is the luxury articles which should be asked to bear the higher rates and the bulky traffic, whether it be machinery for the farmers or coal or anything else, should get specially low rates. I definitely advocate here that Córas Iompair Éireann should be instructed by the Department responsible for the appointment of its chairman and board of directors to provide specially low rates, such as we had in pre-war days, for those people engaged in the agricultural industry. If you must put an increase of 20 per cent. on to the rates of carriage, put it on to the motor car which is going to Parknasilla for the gentleman who is spending his holidays there. Surely it can be justified much more easily in that case than it can be justified on the raw materials of our primary industry. It is all wrong for the Government and the responsible Minister to put an all-round increase of 20 per cent. on everything carried by this semi-State controlled transport company, instead of giving preference by way of low rates to the commodities that cannot bear a heavy rate in the same way as luxury articles.
We have not heard anything from the new Minister about the reasons for the shortage of agricultural labour, or his views with regard to the rates of wages paid to agricultural labourers. The Minister may say that it is not his job, but the chairman of the Agricultural Wages Board is carrying out the policy of the Ministry in a way quite different from what is done by other Ministers in regard to rates of wages and working conditions. In this Estimate provision is made for the administration of the Agricultural Wages Acts by a chairman nominated by the Minister. The procedure adopted by the Agricultural Wages Board and the chairman should be completely altered. That is what I want to see. Why can we not have a public hearing of the claims of agricultural labourers, if they are to continue to be heard by the chairman of the Agricultural Wages Board instead of by the Labour Court? Why can there not be a public hearing instead of the secrecy that surrounds the present procedure, which is laid down by the Minister's nominee?
I understand there is no agenda issued, and there are no minutes issued after the meetings are held, and the chairman, on some occasions, has completely ignored the recommendations of the area board, as well as of the national board. The chairman is the Lord Almighty; he is like the chairman of Córas Iompair Éireann—a quorum in himself and a law unto himself. That is the Minister's policy, and compare that with the open diplomacy policy of the Minister for Industry and Commerce through the Labour Court. I know a member of an area board who wrote to the chairman some time ago asking why a recommendation made by the area board had not been adhered to. The chairman had not opposed it at the area board meeting, but when the award was made it bore no relation to the recommendation of the area board. The chairman refused to reply to that letter directly and he told the member he would have a word with him when next he was in Dublin. He was afraid to put his reasons on paper.
It is about time we got rid of that antediluvian system with regard to the wages of agricultural labourers and their working conditions. What is wrong about the chairman sitting in his office in the same way as the Labour Court, hearing both sides and letting the public be judges? The public will be the judges in the long run, but they cannot judge what happens at the Agricultural Wages Board meetings, because there are no minutes issued. There is some element of doubt in the Minister's mind, and there was also a doubt in the mind of his predecessor, as to whether there is a good case for the provision of loans for farmers at nominal rates of interest, or, as some people suggest, free of interest. That is quite common in other countries. If you are to help the farmer to cut down the cost of production and provide him with a better means of livelihood and a more profitable form of employment, one of the ways is to give loans at nominal rates of interest.
We have the Agricultural Credit Corporation and the Industrial Credit Company. The Agricultural Credit Corporation is a State-established institution. I have yet to learn that it was established for profit-making purposes, but I allege that it is paying more attention to the profits it can make upon the capital provided by the Minister for Finance than it is to the question of reducing rates of interest on loans provided to farmers. The Industrial Credit Company is a far greater sinner in that respect. I do not see why loans should not be provided for farmers on the security of their land. The bankers place no value on land as security for a loan. That is where they are upside-down in our agricultural policy. The land which produces all our wealth and the raw materials for our industries in a good many cases, is worthless to a banking institution as security for a loan to enable farmers to work the land to better advantage. If the land is worthless for that purpose, what is worth anything in this country? It is about time the Government came to the conclusion that it should be taken as a security. I would not say that the Agricultural Credit Corporation should be advised to give a loan to a farmer when a banker, some Jewman or moneylender had a charge on the farm.
Comment on this
If the banks are all right, what is the reason for the establishment of the Agricultural Credit Corporation or the Industrial Credit Company?
Comment on this
These institutions were established with capital provided by this and by the previous Government. I did compliment the Minister for Finance and the Minister for Agriculture upon making considerable progress in recent times in regard to the interest charges on loans. The Minister for Finance has had the courage, probably in spite of his advisers, to reduce the rate on local loans. I hope the Minister for Agriculture will be able to use his influence —and he has considerable influence in matters of this kind—with the Agricultural Credit Corporation to get them to reduce the rates of interest charged upon farmers' loans. By doing that he will help to reduce the cost of production, improve the position of the farmer and give him breathing space so as to buy machinery or stock that may be very badly needed.
I agree with Deputy Beirne that this idea of getting personal security from some friendly neighbour is all wrong. It is unfair even in family circles. It would be unfair for the Minister for Agriculture, although I suppose he will not require a loan as long as he is a Minister and probably never did require a loan. I expect he would feel much the same as other citizens—that if he could get a loan on decent security he would not ask even his brother to sign a bill. The personal security idea should be abolished. Once you give personal security to a brother citizen looking for a loan, your own security is interfered with if you want money for yourself. This thing called banking is all foreign and all out-of-date and would not be tolerated in any progressive country.
Comment on this
I wonder if I could touch the Deputy for a loan after this debate —I would like it on such terms.
Comment on this
I could borrow the Minister's intelligence, probably, on this matter, and I would not have to pay much for that, would I? I am sure the Minister has more intelligence on this matter than I have, because he has able advisers. I join with Deputy Beirne—although I agree to differ with him on many things he is advocating— and with other Deputies who suggested that it is the duty of the Minister here to make arrangements to meet his opposite number in the British Ministry of Agriculture at the earliest possible date.
Comment on this
He has been meeting officials for the past week. I know the Minister has a fairly good knowledge of the views of the people of the country but the longer he is in the Ministry, the less he will know about them because he will not have time to meet the ordinary people. I say to the Minister that the view of the people of the country is that it is his job to meet Mr. Tom Williams, his opposite number on the other side, so that they may put their heads together and try to work out an agreement. There is nothing wrong in that. The Minister has some very able advisers who know the advisers of the Minister on the other side but I think it would add influence to the conduct of such negotiations if the Ministers on both sides met each other and tried to understand each other. I join with Deputy Beirne or any other Deputy who says there is no time to be lost in bringing about such negotiations if beneficial results are to be achieved for the people on both sides of the channel.
Comment on this
Let us be clear on this: I compliment the Minister for Agriculture on nothing except his ability to intimidate the electors of County Cavan and to hold on to a job he is not fit to hold.
Comment on this
I do not know whether the denigration of Ministers is legitimate on the discussion of an Estimate. Deputies are elected by their constituents to the Dáil and that cannot be questioned except by legal process. They are Deputies while they are here.
Comment on this
They are, mo bhrón! I think the present Minister is incompetent and I think the Minister for Finance is incompetent.
Comment on this
The competence or the incompetence of the Minister has nothing to do with the Estimate?
Comment on this
When Deputy Davin bows from the waist to compliment these Ministers on the reduction of credit rates in this country, he seems to overlook the fact that the Government to which these Ministers belong has been in office for 15 years and they waited until Mr. Dalton the Chancellor of the Exchequer in Britain reduced the interest rates there before the brain-wave ever struck them. This Irish republic, externally associated for the purpose of foreign affairs with the Commonwealth of Nations, has fallen most dramatically into step with the base, bloody, brutal Saxon. Ever since we went through all the motions of shaking off all the shackles of our servitude——
Comment on this
Land is no security in this country for loans! And Deputy Davin and Deputy Beirne deplore that. What is security? If Deputy Davin lends money and takes land as collateral security for the loan and ultimately comes to the conclusion that his debtor is not going to pay, what does he do with his security? Will Deputy Davin tell me? Does Deputy Davin know? I am impressed by his striking silence.
Comment on this
If Deputy Davin has land as collateral security for a loan and his debtor does not pay, he must take the land. Now, for good or ill in this country, we have established the principle that we do not like people who take their neighbour's land for debt. Economists, bankers, and divers other persons take the view that Adam Smith would not have thought well of that position and the great banking authorities and the great moneylenders of history would have frowned on that decision. We were aware of that when we took the decision but, all the moneylenders domestic and international notwithstanding, we still do not like people who take their neighbour's land for debt. The knowledge that we do not like people who do that in this country, any more than we like people who grab their neighbour's land because they are covetous, has discouraged grabbers and discouraged moneylenders from taking land as collateral security for a loan. The banks would be fools to take land as collateral security for a debt.
I know that it is an attractive proposition to say that we ought to get rid of the system of getting two neighbours to guarantee a loan. However popular that thesis may be, it is false. The Agricultural Credit Corporation would be fools to give a loan to any man who could not find two of his neighbours to answer for his readiness to repay. They would not alone injure themselves but they would gravely injure a very considerable number of men who are potential borrowers. There are certain individuals down through the country and the moment they hear of an interest-free loan for anything, they are clamouring to get the form on which to apply. Some of them mean to repay but never succeed. Some of them are just cheap rogues who mean to get the loan and, having got it, join a Fianna Fáil club and become the local Fianna Fáil bosses so that when pressure is brought to bear on them to repay the loan they can go to the local Fianna Fáil T.D.s and say to them: "If the writ issues against me, I shall take over the local branch of Fianna Fáil into Clann an Poblachta and ye will not like that." Does Deputy Davin deny that that is so?
Comment on this
I am not thinking of the West. These things can happen in Leix-Offaly just as readily as they can happen anywhere else. Sometimes when I see the anxious countenance of Deputy Gorry I pity him for having such exigent supporters. From the point of view of borrowers themselves, I am strongly opposed to waiving the requirements for guarantors. If a man who is credit-worthy—that is to say a man who intends to repay his debt and who can be depended on to spend the proceeds of his loan on some rational outlay—wants to get two neighbours to guarantee him he will have no serious difficulty, but if a fellow who is either hopelessly improvident or fundamentally dishonest wants to get a loan, he will have the greatest difficulty in getting two neighbours who know him to go bail for him. I doubt very much if this system of scattering loans all over the country, interest free, has anything to commend it. You take an unfortunate small farmer who lost a couple of beasts in the middle of the winter——
Comment on this
——and you offer him an opportunity of borrowing money to replace them, and he goes to the fair, and for the first time he is in a fair in this position that he sees four or six beasts he likes and that he can buy them all without putting his hand into his pocket, and there will be no question of finding the money to pay for them for 12 months or two years, and at that it will be only an instalment "and we will get the money somewhere when the time comes" and when he brings them home he will find that he has paid a couple of pounds too much for each of them.
I remember well the heifer scheme and the disgusting farce into which that degenerated when heifers were assembled at different centres and poor damn fools were bidding against one another, and bidding two prices because the Department's inspector was there with the money to pay for them and the fools all the time hoping to God they would be able to pay some time. I solemnly warn this House on these interest-free loans that 50 per cent. of the recipients will live to curse the day they got them. There is no use pretending that we can insulate every human creature against all the misfortunes he will meet in the course of his life—it cannot be done. Every one of us from the wealthiest to the poorest will from time to time meet with reverses.
If he is a man at all and puts his shoulder to the wheel to retrieve the ground lost, be it lost through no fault of his own or not—the loss may ultimately transpire to be a blessing because it gave him an occasion of showing his fortitude and showing his courage to retrieve himself, but if the loss be so crushing as to make it impossible for the best intentioned man to get on his feet again after it, I have yet to meet the parish in Ireland where friends cannot be found to raise the price among themselves to put him back on his feet and allow him by his own effort to restore the circumstances of which misfortune deprived him. If we are going to lay down the principle that in every place misfortune falls, it becomes the duty of the State to step in and restore the status quo ante with grants, loans and benefactions, the last surviving citizen or the citizen who still takes pride in his independence will have to carry the burden of the parish.
Comment on this
I have often heard of the case of the widow who lost five cows. When I started out to find the widow who lost five cows I travelled from townland to townland. I was getting hot all the time but I never found her and I never found anyone who saw the widow who lost five cows. But there were hundreds who had met the one who had spoken to the man who had seen the widow who lost five cows, and I met crowds who had wept with the one, who was witness to the one who had wept over the widow's loss.
Come, let us face reality. We are not all angels in this country and I would like to see a Deputy of the House who would undertake to segregate the cattle or sheep which died from the effects of hard weather from the sheep that died of fluke and the cattle which died because the man who had them sold his hay and did not keep the food wherewith to feed them. That there were many who suffered parlous losses for which they could not be blamed I have no doubt, but if we try to ascertain precisely who they were and if they were in the ranks of those who qualify for help and assistance, thousands who are mere chancers looking for what good luck may send them, will come forward to meet us. Land is no security for credit in this country—God grant it never may be.
Comment on this
I have no love for moneylenders, and I never want to see the land of this country put in pawn. I have seen in other countries, in the United States of America where whole tracts of country passed into the hands of banks overnight and men who were independent farmers, holding their own land, became tenants of extremely ruthless landlords, because in that country land was security for credit.
Now, Sir, I want to deal with general questions that arise on the Agricultural Estimate. To think of the happy days when all our agricultural problems were solved by the mystic triptych, "beet, wheat, and peat". Given these three things, "all Éire's ills were o'er". Wheat? What has become of the wheat policy?
Comment on this
Beidh fáilte roimhe nuair a thiocfaidh sé isteach. Did many Deputies in this House observe the application made in the name of this country by the Minister for Industry and Commerce to the International Wheat Authority? He bespoke on behalf of Ireland, 400,000 tons per annum of Canadian or United States wheat, and he added to that request this addendum: that he would undertake on behalf of this country to accept that allocation for many years ahead. Four hundred thousand tons represent 3,200,000 barrels, which represent, in turn, the total consumption of wheat per annum by the people of this country. If we are going to buy from abroad 3,200,000 barrels of wheat, what has become of the 650,000 acres of wheat that were the keystone of the Fianna Fáil's agricultural policy? Do you remember the days when it was well-nigh high treason in this country to point out that dusty fraud of the "grow more wheat" scheme? Do you remember when it was sabotaging the national effort to expose the shameless and disgusting dishonesty of the "grow more wheat" scheme? Do Deputies remember when I warned them that that scheme was primarily designed to line the pockets of the millers of this country at the expense of those who had to eat bread that I was held up to ridicule? Do members recall, for I warned them to remember, that I said, speaking from this place, that in normal times, with markets available to us, I would not be seen dead in a field of wheat in this country——
Comment on this
There was not any kind of a proviso of that nature "in normal times". There was nothing like that.
Comment on this
——and that because I said that and because I practised that when the time of emergency came I was able to grow more wheat per acre on my land than any of the pirates who had been mining their own land with wheat during the previous ten years? And, having grown more wheat per acre on my land during the years of the war, I want to say again, with emphasis, that once wheat from abroad is available to this country again, I would not be seen dead in a field of wheat on my land in this country because I know that that whole rotten fraud in fact was invoked to permit the Rank interests and the other milling interests in this country to charge our people 30/- a cwt. for flour when they were selling it in Liverpool for 19/-. I will not have to worry because the wheat scheme is as dead as a door nail. Take off your compulsion to-morrow and see how much wheat will be grown. Did Deputy Corry tell you his estimate of the average yield of wheat from the land in this country during the last seven or eight years? How many barrels was the average yield? Ask your neighbours. Ask the Minister for Agriculture what yield he got when he went wheat-growing in Cavan. He is a very open, frank, plain-spoken man. Sometimes he would like us to believe even that he is a tough egg. Let us judge him by his personal experience and I will send him a nice wreath of rue with a big black bow which he can go out and lay on the land which so abundantly yielded wheat under his personal direction in County Cavan.
Peat! Do you remember the halcyon days when peat was to be almost the greatest industry in this country, second only to agriculture, employing 80,000 men? Do you remember the bags, great big long bags? I think we bought nearly 500,000 of them and lost them all—every one of them. I remember the last year I was Chairman of the Public Accounts Committee I inquired of the Comptroller and Auditor-General what had become of the bags and echo answered: "What"? So was fulfilled another prophesy I dared to make when that scheme was first adumbrated in this House—that the only person to make profit out of the peat scheme would be the man who made the bags.
Comment on this
I forget whether or not it is included in the statistics for agricultural production.
Comment on this
Perhaps the Minister would enlighten us as to whether peat comes within the purview of his Estimate. He is not so loquacious now as he was some time ago. I wonder why.
Comment on this
Because I was called to order and I was reminded that I should not intervene. A Chinn Comhairle, I understood that it was not in order for a Deputy to invite either a Minister or a Deputy to break the rules of the House.
Comment on this
Hear, hear! If peat is not within the purview of this Estimate, I cannot say of it the things I would like to tell.
Comment on this
It is a pretty story, Sir. There remains beet—the blessings of beet! Some day, and in the not far distant time, our people will have to ask themselves whether it is in the best interests of the community as a whole to continue the production of sugar from beet in this country at an annual cost to the community of £3,000,000 sterling. That is what it costs in normal times to keep the beet industry going in this country If, instead of growing beet and converting it into sugar, we import refined sugar into this country there will be £3,000,000 sterling more for the national exchequer and that £3,000,000 can be used to increase children's allowances in every home in Ireland from the 2/6 per child to 5/- per child, and the land vacated by that crop can be used for the production of profitable agricultural produce which will help to finance essential imports and to enrich the farmers who live upon the land.
Comment on this
What would the Deputy call profitable agricultural produce?
Comment on this
Exports. You see, I do not share the opinion first promulgated by the Deputy's Party that there is nothing which we can grow and nothing we can manufacture in this country that cannot be grown better and cheaper in some other country. That is the Fianna Fáil doctrine. Do I misquote them? Does anybody suggest I misquote them? Deputy Ryan, when Minister for Agriculture, declared that to be his view from the front benches of the Fianna Fáil Party as a justification for putting tariffs on all agricultural produce imported into this country. I reject that. I believe that in certain lines of agricultural and industrial production we can produce as cheaply, as good, if not cheaper and better than any other country in the world.
Comment on this
The Deputy very courteously invites me to be more expeditious than the circumstances of my observations will permit. But, if he will be patient, he will be very much wiser when I have finished talking than he was when I began. Some day I am convinced that beet will go up the spout after peat and wheat. God speed that day. Then the land of this country can be used for the purpose for which it was intended—the profit of those who own it and live upon it and the benefit of those who consume its products and who, without that production, might find themselves short. Deputy Moran, from Castlebar, initiated the Fianna Fáil lament for maize meal that has begun. The dulcet tones of Deputy Corry were even heard lamenting the departure of maize meal. Who stopped maize meal from coming into this country?
Comment on this
Certainly.
An Leas-Cheann Comhairle took the Chair.
Comment on this
The difference between Deputy de Valera and Deputy Ó Briain is that Deputy de Valera is receptive, but with Deputy Ó Briain it is like dropping water upon a rock. Deputy Ó Briain is perfectly honest. He really believes that up to the outbreak of the world war maize meal was flowing freely into the country for all those who wanted to purchase it.
Comment on this
Deputy Ó Briain does not realise that it was he and his colleagues who wore a track on the carpet in that Lobby to pass an Act which made it a crime punishable by imprisonment to bring in anounce of maize meal into this country.
Comment on this
Oh, yes. Not one ounce of maize meal could be brought into this country, and it was Deputy Ó Briain and his colleagues who prevented it by law. For whose benefit? For the benefit of the millers. There was no restriction on the import of maize. You could bring in maize if you were a miller, but if you were a contemptible farmer, a clodhopper on the land, you could not bring in maize. If you were a miller, one of that exalted body, imports of maize were unrestricted and untariffed, because maize was the raw material of the industrialist, and you must not tax the raw material of the industrialist. But when it was converted into meal it was then the raw material of the clodhoppers and, if it were necessary to kick them about for the protection of the industrial aristocracy, of course, Fianna Fáil was very ready to oblige. Deputy Ó Briain was marshalled to vote for the legislation which, from his own protestation now, I can have no doubt he did not understand. He gets desperately angry when I say that he was prevailed upon to vote in that Lobby for legislation the nature of which he does not understand. Yet he tells me that he never voted for the Bill to prevent the importation of maize meal. I tell him that he did. I saw him do it.
Comment on this
Maize meal is coming back. But, are we sure, or will the industrial aristocracy intervene again? I beg of Deputy Ó Briain to constitute himself a watch-dog on the future. I suggest to him that the proposal which will be made is that maize will be admitted to be ground by the industrial aristocracy and then distributed to the clodhoppers on the land, but that maize meal will not be let in, because, if it were, the price of the imported article would compete with the price charged by the industrial aristocracy and they would not be able to buy their detached houses in their own grounds with a lodge at the gate. The industrial aristocracy of this country consider it to be their God-given right to live in the fashionable suburbs of Dublin and Cork and any legislation designed to interfere with that God-given right will be deemed to be in conflict with the Constitution.
I want to see maize meal relieved from taxes, quotas and restrictions. I want our farmers to have access to their essential raw materials at the lowest price at which they can purchase them whencever they may come and I object to our farmers being called upon to pay taxes on those raw materials either to the Exchequer or to the industrial racketeers who want to bleed our people, but who should not be let. The only means of securing that they will not is to expose them to the competition of supplies of maize meal whenever they may come.
Do you remember the maize meal mixture scheme? I stood by its cradle and wept. Now that I am polishing my silk hat for its funeral, I feel as if I had accepted an invitation to a wedding. It is dead and we may speed it to its grave in the fastest vehicle we can find. It should never have been born. This was the good fairy at its cradle speaking:
"Let us grow all the feeding stuffs for which we have a market. Why should we be supporting farmers in Minnesota and the Argentine when we have our own farmers to do it? We can grow the quantity of grain which we have been importing. If we only grow the amount we have been importing, I presume we will not increase our live stock; because, if we did increase our live stock, we would have to grow more grain than we have been importing. That may be disputed. It does not matter very much to the argument, however. Suppose we did go beyond the amount of grain required to replace the imports, and we did increase the live stock, then we would be up against the question of marketing. Whatever market we get, whether the British market or the continental market or the home market, what we produce does not matter very much, as our production is a very small proportion of the world production. If we produce 20 per cent. more mutton than we have been producing, 50 per cent. more bacon, or 50 per cent. more cattle as a result of this policy, it makes very little difference in the world supplies. If we put the produce into England, France or Belgium, and if we put 5 or 10 per cent. more, we will not influence the price, if we have a home market at all."
The operative words in this prescient forecast—and the quotation is now ended—are
"Why should we be supporting farmers in Minnesota and the Argentine?"
Thus was this lovely creature born over whose premature death we rejoice to-day. My quotation is taken from Dr. Ryan, column 397, volume 48, 7th June, 1933. O, happy day!
Comment on this
Yes. That, Sir, was almost the wedding march of the parents of the maize meal mixture scheme. This is the marche funèbre of their offspring. Is it not surprising that there should have been a British food mission in this country for the past ten days and that the Minister for Agriculture has not seen fit to say a word about it? Is it not remarkable that there have been officials of the British Ministry of Food discussing with our Minister for Agriculture how best we can co-ordinate our efforts to secure more foodstuffs for the British consumer and a better market for the Irish producer and the Minister for Agriculture is absolutely silent, the reason being, I believe, because, as I warned this House when they appointed the present gentleman Minister for Agriculture, he has made a “haims” of it. Perhaps he will describe his forensic skill in dealing with these envoys from Great Britain before this discussion comes to an end. It is hard to comment on what has taken place when we have nothing but rumour to inform us. It will not be a very encouraging message if we are told that the fruits of these discussions have been nil.
Deputy Beirne spoke of his indifference as to whether we sent our surplus agricultural produce to the British market or to the markets of Europe so long as we got paid for them and made a profit.
Comment on this
Deputy Ó Briain, of Limerick, agrees with him. That will at once put Deputy Beirne on his guard. Both Deputies seem to have forgotten the iliad of the chickens. Has Deputy Ó Briain forgotten the fowl we sent to Belgium? Homer's Iliad had nothing on this. They started on their weary journey and they arrived at the Hook of Holland. It was there discovered that in order to get them in an immense import duty would have to be paid; but we paid it like a man. Then they moved to Rotterdam and at Rotterdam we discovered that there was an agricultural regulation obtaining in Holland which prohibited the sale of chickens from abroad and that these favoured fowl could not be excepted. Nothing daunted, we sped them on their way to France. They arrived—oh, safely.
Comment on this
And, on arrival there, it was discovered that in crossing the Dutch Border they had hoped to recover the duty already paid upon them; but they were informed that there was no provision in the appropriate code for any such refund. The chickens were now costing about 16/-apiece, but they still sped on their way. They passed through Belgium eventually and reached the French Republic. They wound up in Smithfield, where a meeting was held and it was decided that the best thing to do was to summon the undertaker and bury them as quickly as possible, which we did, at considerable expense.
Nothing daunted, there was the saga of the case of eggs. Of its peregrinations through Europe I have forgotten the details but they were dramatic— even sensational—and I think they were ultimately sold in Great Britain.
Comment on this
Not at all. Deputy Ó Briain is standing breast high for an alternative market. He wants to roll another cheese down the hill to see if we can find another market; and what shocks me is that my prudent friend, Deputy Beirne, seems to toy with this idea.
I remember so well going into the Department of Agriculture and meeting there a most distinguished public servant—now retired from the service, I think—who had forgotten more about eggs than most other men ever knew. He was hurrying through the corridors of the Department of Agriculture with a hunted look in his eyes. I stopped him and I said to him: "Where is the hurry; where are you going?" He said: "If you must know, Mr. Dillon, I am going to look for alternative markets for eggs, which I know do not exist but for which it is the Minister's policy to go on looking", and, faithfully and dutifully, he continued to look.
Comment on this
This much is plain to see, we sell our agricultural surplus on the British market or we do not sell it at all. Let us face that. Lest I forget, I direct the Minister's attention specifically to the fact that there is a very considerable accumulation of potatoes in South Monaghan, largely created by the provision of a guaranteed price. Those potatoes are now becoming unsaleable. There are not less than 2,000 tons which must be disposed of in the next month or they will go bad. That is in South Monaghan alone. There is no opportunity for the farmers who own them to export them and I would urge upon the Minister forthwith to remove the restrictions on the export of potatoes because there is a good market for these in Great Britain if we can export them now.
Comment on this
So far as I am concerned, if they are wanted by our best customer, he should have a preference because he will pay for them in his own good time with materials which we can use. I remember some of the eggs we spent to Spain and the oranges we got back for them.
We are subsidising butter production to the tune of £2,000,000 per annum. How long will that go on? Do we expect butter to get dearer in the markets of the world? Do we expect a time in the early future when the price of milk will become so adjusted that it will be possible to suspend this subsidy or do we intend to continue producing milk for conversion into butter in creameries at an annual cost to the taxpayer of £2,000,000 per annum? I want it to go on record most emphatically that I think such a policy is sheer insanity and is purely pursued for the purpose of maintaining the prestige of incompetents in the offices of the Minister for Agriculture since Fianna Fáil came into power. If butter cannot be produced for manufacture in creameries and sale to the public at a price which will not involve the community in a cost of 2/6 per lb. and the Exchequer in an annual grant of £2,000,000 the sooner we get out of producing butter through the medium of creameries for sale to the consumer the better it will be for the consumer and the men on whose lands the milk to make that butter is produced.
Comment on this
At the moment? That is quite another problem. The burden of my question is, is this policy of granting £2,000,000 per annum as a subsidy to the price of butter a permanent feature, because that permits the payment of only 1/2 per gallon for milk. Deputy Heskin says that anything less than 1/5 is uneconomic. Well, £2,000,000 a year permits the payment of 1/2 with a retail selling price of 2/6 per lb. for butter. If the Minister says this is merely to provide butter during the emergency when butter is not available from other sources of supply, that is another story.
Comment on this
In times of emergency one must do the best one can. I am looking forward to a period of permanency in our agricultural policy. Deputy Corry interjects: "Where did all the wheat come from during the last six years?" I say that 60 per cent. of it came from Great Britain. The Deputy need not shake his gory locks at me. These are the facts.
Comment on this
I say that 60 per cent. of the wheat consumed here in the war years came largely in British bottoms and some of it in Irish ships from Canada and the United States by leave and licence of the British Government, and when the time came in the spring of this year when our people were no longer able to get Canadian wheat for the first time since the emergency, we had the enthralling, stimulating and surprising experience of eating bread made out of Irish wheat. Before you ate it you had to hold it out in your hands, squeeze the water out of it, then tease it out and make up your mind whether it was a handful of boot polish or a handful of bread. If it was boot polish you put it on your boots or shoes and if it was bread you tried to masticate it if you were fit.
Comment on this
The astonishing thing is that that experience notwithstanding, still the ridiculous, idiotic attempt is made by the Fianna Fáil Party to maintain the fraud that we grew here all our wheat requirements. We grew 40 per cent. of our requirements and the bulk of that 40 per cent. was grown on the lands of men who had refused to grow it in peace time, because they knew it would be foolish and uneconomic to do so, but in time of emergency they had their lands in good heart and fertility and they were able to grow wheat or any other crop that the community required in the circumstances in which we found ourselves. The boys who in earlier years had robbed their land of its fertility and sold it to the Land Commission before the war were not very much worried about growing wheat during the war years. They got everything they could out of the land and then they sold the desert acres they had wrecked in the process of their plunder. The farmers who had worked their land well according to sound methods of husbandry and who wanted no doles or grants from the Government prior to the war, had it in fit condition to grow wheat or any other crop when the emergency arose. They grew up to 40 per cent. of our requirements and the remaining 60 per cent. came from abroad. Without that 60 per cent. our people would have gone hungry and there was nothing we could do about it.
What, then, should be done to make this country prosperous for its farming community, to guarantee a high standard of living for the urban population and to ensure the major amenities to which a civilised population is entitled? There are two things we should do, one, to restore to the land of this country its ability to earn profits and, two, to eject the Fianna Fáil Government from office. To-day we are primarily concerned with the first part of that enterprise. Our object should be to concentrate on the production for export of perishable agricultural products which we are in a position to deliver in a fresh condition in the British market. There is there a market capable of absorbing far more of that kind of produce than this country could ever hope in any circumstances to produce. The capacity of that market will absorb all their own farmers and all our farmers can ever produce of that class of merchandise.
If we play our hand well, we can ensure that the agricultural industry in Great Britain will be a vested interest working not only for itself but for us to ensure that nothing will be done by any other branch of the British Government to hinder the activities of the British Ministry of Agriculture in the interest of the farming community of Great Britain and, incidentally, in so far as that community will be made to depend upon us for raw materials, the agricultural community of this country.
One of the principal raw materials which we are in a position to supply to the British farmer, and which no one else in this world can supply is store cattle. If we can induce the British farmer to go in, in a big way, for the fattening of store cattle, we can ensure the creation of a huge investment by the British agricultural community in the equipment necessary for the fattening and finishing of cattle which will make it incumbent upon these farmers to safeguard our interests in their market because if we ever fail to deliver the store cattle which is the raw material of their fattening industry their huge investment will collapse because there is no alternative source of supply for them. Further, the more dependent we make them upon us, the greater the volume of store cattle we deliver to the British farmers, the more enduring becomes the guarantee we have of permanent control of that immensely valuable market, 90 per cent. of the profit of which goes into the hands of the small farmer proprietor, living in Connaught, Donegal and South-West Munster. That is the type of farmer in this country most vulnerable to disasters when they overtake the agricultural industry, because their margin is so narrow that any considerable disaster pushes them over the edge into the region of destitution.
Secondly, our primary concern should be live-stock products—pigs, fowl, eggs, cream, bacon and other live-stock products—which we are peculiarly fitted by our geographical location to deliver into the British market in a fresh condition. People may talk of refrigeration, chilling, of the quick freeze and of the hundred and one methods of preserving perishable agricultural products for the period required to ship them over a long distance to the centre of consumption. Many of these methods have great merits and great revolutions have taken place in their employment in the last 30 years, but this is certain: that no matter how good these systems are, refrigeration in any form reduces the quality of the product in some degree, great or small, below that of first quality fresh products. There is a market for first quality products delivered in a fresh condition in Britain which, by our supreme effort, we could never hope adequately to supply. If, however, we are to supply that market, then those who have charge of the task of producing supplies must have a reasonable prospect of earning a profit. However, I want to say particularly to Deputies on the Farmers' Benches: "Do not become obsessed with price; price does not matter a row of pins."
Comment on this
Is it not humiliating to have a group who profess to represent the farmers of this country——
Comment on this
——who cannot see that and who have led them from one folly to another? It is an interesting reflection that anyone who wanted to exploit our people could always suborn and defraud those who profess to represent them by that humiliating carrot of price. If you offer a farmer 80/- for wheat he is delighted and he thinks it is a great price but he is quite oblivious of the fact that he pays back that price and a little more when he is buying his bag of flour.
Comment on this
You see, he thinks it is lovely if he can get 10/- extra for a pig but he is quite indifferent to the fact that in the process of securing that 10/- extra for him, the Government have put 2/6 per cwt. on meal. Deputy Donnellan and his likes then come trotting in to me with their faces radiant and say: "Oh, did you see the great rise in the price of pigs; one cwt. of meal, if you please." Before he finishes these pigs, he will have come into me seven times and each time his face is shining at the thought of the 10/- extra for the pig but he forgets that in his seven journeys he has paid out 17/6 extra for the meal and he is 7/6 per pig worse than before they increased the price of the pig.
Comment on this
He is a simple creature if he imagines that he is making a profit at that price. I want the farmer, not the miller, to get a profit. I want to put an end to the system by which the farmer in this country is being blinded and robbed by the exploiters. While their eyes are dazzled with a fictitious price, the exploiters thrust their hands into the farmers' pockets and leave them paupers. Why are half our people walking round like paupers, the very people who are producing everything? Are the millers and the bacon curers, who are giving these wonderful prices, poor? Do their children go to the national school? Do their wives go round the house with clogs on their feet? Do the representatives of the farmers in this House ever ask themselves why is it that the man who is doing the work, the man who is producing the stuff, is always poor, no matter how high prices go? The higher they go, the poorer he gets, but the miller is never poor.
Comment on this
If the cap fits. you, wear it.
Comment on this
If the Deputy desires to discuss the fact that I am a distributor, it may be relevant to discuss the Deputy's competence as a school teacher——
Comment on this
——and Deputy Corry's occupation and the occupations of those who went before him, rather exhaustively.
Comment on this
It will be an instructive discussion if we go back three or four generations, but let us not go down to that level.
If anyone wants to initiate an inquiry on those lines it can be followed, but I am concerned only to establish this principle from the point of view of people who do the work. It is not the price but the profit that matters. If I offer a farmer in this country £10 for a pig and so rig the market for his meal, for his implements, for his machinery, for everything he has to use to produce that pig, so that the pig is going to cost him £10 10s. Od. to produce, is not that farmer losing 10/-for every pig? But suppose I say to the farmer: "Get your raw material wherever your skill enables you to get it. Get the best quality you can find for the lowest price you are asked to pay", and if the price of the pig drops down on the market to £7, to a level that an unthinking person would deplore, the farmer is at least freed from strait-jacket restrictions and he would find that it cost him only £6 5s. Od. to buy the raw materials to fatten his £7 pig. Suppose he fattens a dozen £7 pigs, he will take home with him £84 and he will have £9 profit, but if he fattens 12 of the £10 pigs, he would have £120 in his pocket and he would have lost £6.
Now, do Deputies understand what I say when I tell them that the price is rigged? The farmer is paid £120 into his hands and he thinks because he is getting a big sum of money that he is making a profit. How often have I seen my own neighbours defrauded by that loathsome confidence trick? How often have I seen the farmers' own leaders who have responsibility for keeping the farmers right and protecting them against their folly, say to the farmer: "Look at the grand price you have got", but when Paddy Hogan—the Lord have mercy upon him—was Minister, and pigs were sold at 56/-, there was not a pig sold on which a profit was not made. When pigs were. 56/-, I sold Indian meal for 4/-. Not only did I sell the meal, but I fed the pigs, and I fattened them and I sold the bacon, and does anyone tell me that I sold these pigs without a profit?
Comment on this
They were sold for as low as 30/-.
Comment on this
You could give them away if you wanted to. You have no sense anyway. I bought them, I fattened them and I sold them as pigs and I sold them as bacon, and I assert here that from the day that man took office to the day when he was put out, there was not a pig fattened that did not pay a profit, albeit a small one, but the price was only one-third of what is available to-day. Pigs were sold at 56/- then and you can get 168/- now. That is all every pig paid at the time, but the profit at 56/- then was better than the profit at 168/- at the present time.
Now, does the Deputy understand what I say, that the price does not matter? What matters is the profit, and it is because of the miller, the exploiter, those who want to live on the labour of the farmers of this country, that the profit to-day is so low. It is time that the farmers of this country learned that lesson—that the exploiter does not give a damn about the price so long as he gets the cream and the farmer is content with the skim milk. But what makes me mad is that the people who profess to lead the farmers are telling their supporters that they are far better off with the skim milk than with the cream.
Why cannot we face those realities? Cannot we realise that to make agriculture prosperous in this country we have got to get the profits for the farmers? I cannot control the price on the British market, nor can anybody else in this country. We chose to leave the Imperial House of Commons and I glory in the fact that we made that choice. We made it of our own free will. By our own determination, we divested ourselves of our right to be heard in the British House of Commons about the price to be paid in Britain for Irish produce. We did it with our eyes wide open and let us not repine and whine about that—we would do it again to-morrow if we had the choice, but we cannot control prices on the British market. We can discuss and we can negotiate. We can make the best bargain we possibly can, and try to get the best price we can and the most effective way to get the best price is to offer the best products and use the best marketing methods. But the fact that we cannot control prices in the British markets is no reason whatever why we cannot ensure that our farmers will make a profit on their work. What is the profit? The profit is the difference between the cost of production and the price we get, the gap between one hand held over the other.
Comment on this
Though the price stayed there for ever that does not mean that we cannot increase the profit. We can, by bringing down the cost of production. Why do our farmers want to do that by raising the price? We cannot do it. It is not in our power. But we can widen the profit gap. Why do not we do that, and we can do it to-morrow, there is nothing to stop us? The profit of the agricultural community at the present time is being absorbed by the taxes, quotas and restrictions which have been put on the raw materials of the industry by our own Government.
Lots of people are inclined to say: "My gracious me, most of the stuff our farmers are using does not come into the country at all; it is made here and does not pay any tariff." It does not, but study the price charged by those who make it. They raise the cost up to the highest penny which it is possible to do under the protection they get, and if the tariff is not sufficient to protect them from competition, they ask and succeed in getting from the Government a quota to prohibit imports at any price high or low, so that they will be guaranteed the opportunity of charging what they will and the farmers have to pay.
We have a Prices Commission, of course. This commission is designed to control their profits, we are told. All my eye and Betty Martin. The Prices Commission, consisting of well-intentioned civil servants, are just as competent to control millers' profits as I am to fly over the moon on a broom— stick. What is the result? Look at the millers' balance sheets.
Comment on this
I hear people continually clamouring in this House that the only hope for the whole community is an expansion of production. I quite agree. Everybody acknowledges that if we are to finance the purchase from abroad of the things we must have to maintain industry and existence and a proper standard of living for our people we have no other currency than agricultural exports wherewith to pay. How are we going to get that production? It is a perfectly simple answer. There is one way to ensure that extra production and it is none the less excellent because it is not novel. It is the method that put this suit of clothes on me. It is the method that fed every Deputy of this House. It is the method that enabled our fathers and mothers of many of us to raise families of six, ten and 12 children. It is the method of allowing the farmers of this country to farm their own land in such a way as to earn a profit for themselves. If we do that we will get ultimately from the land of this country all that the land of this country is capable of producing. If we deny it we can hold meetings, we can pass laws, we can make regulations, we can negotiate trade agreements or anything else we like, but if the man producing the stuff cannot earn a profit on his work we will not get the production and we will not be able to export. If we hope to get profit in the only foreign market where we can hope to sell our exportable surplus we have got to compete with others who are free to send their produce into that market—Danes, New Zealanders, Australians, Dutch, Belgians, every one of whom can purchase the raw materials of their industry wherever they like at the cheapest price that they can get. I am not tired of reminding this House of simple propositions which they never seem able to grasp. We will accept the rough calculation that it takes 7 cwts. of meal to feed the pig from the weanling stage to the bacon pig. 2/6 per cwt. was put on Indian meal in this country by the operation of the maize meal mixture scheme.
That means that if a farmer in this country fattened a pig and a Dane in Denmark fattened a pig, when the Dane brought his pig to London to sell it the Irishman will have had to spend seven times 2/6 more than the Dane had to spend in feeding his pig. If the Dane spent £4 for his weanling and meal cost 10/- a cwt. his fat bacon pig would cost him £4 plus £3 10s., i.e., £7 10s., and if he wanted to make 10/-profit on the pig he could sell it in London for £8. The Irishman bought his weanling pig for £4 and 7 cwt. of meal for which he had to pay £3 10s. plus 17s. 6d., i.e. £4 7s. 6d. His pig cost him £8 7s. 6d. to have ready for sale. When he went to London with his pig he had to sell the pig for the same price as the Dane. The Dane had 10/-profit on his pig and when the Irishman sold his pig both the Dane and the Irishman had got the same price but the price does not matter because the price meant a profit of 10/- for the Dane but a loss of 7/6 for the Irishman.
Comment on this
Yes we will, just as soon as we root that gang out of office, millions of them—suckers and bacon pigs—and we will send them alive and dead.
Comment on this
No. Entry would be prohibited. And, sure we would be lonesome for them. I see Deputy McCarthy looking vexed as though I made little of him. I would be deeply distressed if he or the likes of him did not exist in our midst. I like the Orangemen in Belfast, and the daftees from all sides. They are characteristic of the community in which we live. Sometimes they are a costly luxury, but so far as Deputy McCarthy or the likes of him are concerned, I consider that he gives more value than anything he ever cost this community—possibly not in the sphere of politics but in the wide range of his other everyday activities. I hope he will find it in his heart to say as much for me. We have a splendid market to which we can export an abundance of pigs and bacon if we go the right way about it and enable the pig to be produced at a profit.
I am sometimes charged with taking a poor view of industries. The greatest industry we have in this country is one that uses an immense quantity of native produce. I refer to the beer, porter and stout industry. It has no protection, no tariffs, no quotas, no monopoly. Just a group of men who wanted to earn profit legitimately went into the open market to buy barley, bought it, and sold their porter wherever they could find customers to pay the price for it. They employ a vast number of our fellow-citizens at good wages and provide a valuable export for this country-founded on the growth of barley. Such industries are a blessing not only to those who enjoy the profits earned in them but to those who grow the raw material for their processes and to those who receive the wages which they earn from them.
I want to see the output of eggs steadily increasing. Deputy Beirne sometimes feels that it is unreasonable for the British to say: "We will give you so much for your eggs, but if you increase production above a certain figure we are prepared to pay an even higher price for the whole lot." Surely that is not an unreasonable proposal. What unfairness is there in that proposal from the Deputy's point of view? Suppose the consignees said to us: "No matter what the number of the eggs we will only pay you the lower price." What would we reply—that we will send them to Antwerp—to an alternative market?