We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Clean Wool Bill, 1947—From the Seanad.

Contributions 1–132 of 258. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Clean Wool Bill, 1947
Enacted

No. 14 of 1947 ›

Patrick Smith Minister for Agriculture (Mr. Smith) Fianna Fáil

I move that the Committee agree with the Seanad in amendment No. 1:—

In Section 1, sub-section (1), page 2, line 13, the words "sheep scab" deleted and the words "or preventive of sheep scab or any other external parasitic disease of sheep" substituted.

Comment on this

What is it? Tell us all about it. What does the amendment do or not do?

Comment on this

It was felt, as a result of the discussion in the Seanad, that the definition should be extended so as to make provision for any new developments in the production of sheep dip that would have the effect of treating sheep for external parasites as well as scab.

Comment on this

Does it put any additional obligation on the farmer, or is it a permissive amendment?

Comment on this

No additional obligation.

Comment on this

I move that the Committee agree with the Seanad in amendment No. 2:—

In Section 2, sub-section (1), page 2, line 26, the words, "of the council of a county or of the corporation of a county borough" inserted before the word "appointed"; and in sub-section (2), page 2, line 29, the words "is an officer of" deleted and the words "was appointed by" substituted.

This amendment provides that the officers of local authorities as well as officers of my Department can be used for the purpose of detection of persons attempting to evade the provisions of this measure.

Comment on this

In connection with this amendment, which increases the personnel of the army of inspectors at present ranging through this country to teach people how to do their own business, I should like to inquire from the Minister for Agriculture whether, in view of the fact that he intends to swell the ranks of this bureaucratic army of busybodies, he will turn his mind to the question of whether he can, by some concessions, compensate the prospective victims of these inspectorial visitors. We could endure inspection; we could endure being harassed on our farms for the benefit of the fellmongers and the wool buyers; because, let no one in this House imagine that the farmers when selling their sheep will get any better price because they have spent their days striving to keep the fleece clean and free from contamination.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy is away from the amendment. It is a question of whether local officials should be allowed to inspect.

Comment on this

I am asking, if we submit to this additional burden, are we entitled to any consideration. I am surely entitled to remind the House——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The question of compensation does not arise. On the Second Stage, the Deputy had an opportunity of dealing with that.

Comment on this

Very well. I oppose the amendment on the ground that we have a damned sight too many inspectors careering around the country and that the inspection about to be adopted is a device to add to the expenses of the men who rear the sheep.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy is again out of order. On the Second Stage, the principle of inspection was agreed to by this House and, as regards that, the Dáil is function officio.

Comment on this

I am not opposing inspection. I am opposing an additional number of inspectors. Surely I may do that. We have provided in the Bill for a battalion of inspectors. This amendment is designed to convert that battalion into a regiment. Doubtless, some subsequent amending legislation will convert that regiment into an army corps. But, all the time, whether it is a battalion, a platoon, a regiment or an army corps the poor fools that rear the sheep will pay for them. I think that is true. If the argument were adduced that, although the farmers would be required to pay for the army corps of inspectors, the farmers would get a benefit out of the inspection, I could understand the argument. I respectfully submit that I am entitled to make the case that, when this battalion of inspectors is being turned into a regiment, the burden on the farmers who will have to pay for the regiment is increased, but the benefits that will accrue from the intensification of inspection brought about by the increase in the number of inspectors will not accrue to the farmers who are to pay for it.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy was told that that precise point is not in order and it must not be returned to in another way.

Comment on this

May I then inquire of the Minister, why are we increasing the number of inspectors? What purpose has the Minister in mind? Is this increase in the number of inspectors designed to secure that wool will be cleaner than it has been heretofore? If that is its purpose, will he commend this amendment to us on the ground that no particular category of the community will derive benefit from it? If so, what category? That is surely not out of order and I am entitled to ask that question. If we are to increase the number of inspectors, who will benefit, apart from the inspectors who get jobs?

Comment on this

Deputy O'Driscoll says the sheep will benefit.

Comment on this

And maybe he is right.

Comment on this

Even that would be some consolation, but I think it highly unlikely that the sheep will benefit in any particular way.

Comment on this

The inspectors.

Comment on this

Another Deputy on my right suggests that the inspectors will benefit. These are all interesting speculations. May I speculate? I think the fellmongers will benefit. I think the wool merchants will benefit.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy understands the amendment. The question is whether officials of local authorities should be allowed to inspect, as well as others. Who should benefit was a matter which might have been and was discussed on Second Stage and matters discussed on Second Stage, not relevant to this amendment, may not be discussed now.

Comment on this

Would the Minister say why then he wants to increase the number of inspectors? Some purpose must be served. Surely it is not for the purpose of hindering inspection? When the Minister has told us what purpose he intends to serve by increasing the number of inspectors, surely the House may discuss the likelihood of his objective being reached? I invite the Minister then to tell us what purpose is to be served by increasing the number of inspectors. Is it designed to benefit anybody and, if so, who?

Comment on this

I am as strongly opposed as Deputy Dillon to bureaucratic control, but, so far as this amendment is concerned, the House has agreed to the principle of inspection, and it is immaterial financially whether the inspection is carried out by local inspectors or by inspectors of the Department of Agriculture, because if we do not agree to inspectors of local authorities doing the inspection, the Minister can increase the inspectors in his Department. There is a much more objectionable amendment, amendment No. 6, which we will come to later.

Comment on this

I want to add my protest to the protests made by Deputy Dillon against any attempt to enlarge the huge army of inspectors who are already invading every farmer's holding. The Minister has given the House no indication of the value of these additional inspectors who are now to trespass on farmers' land. In my opinion, the vast majority of farmers are occupied in interviewing inspectors and if some effort is not made to reduce the number of inspectors parading around the farmers' places——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

It does not arise.

Comment on this

——and if the officers of local authorities are to have power to inspect a farmer's wool or sheep, we shall be reaching a stage at which the farmers will dismiss their agricultural labourers and erect offices for the purpose of interviewing these inspectors. Farmers are becoming displeased by the visits of these inspectors and it is only right that the House should join with Deputy Dillon in opposing any amendment designed to add to the number of inspectors already parading the country.

Comment on this

One point in connection with this amendment is that the number and variety of inspectors is to be increased. The farmer at present labours under a great number of difficulties, one of which is the difficulty of preventing trespass on his farm. There are people—be they tourists or tinkers —who go on the farmer's land when they require firewood and who take it without the farmer's permission. Others go after rabbits and walk over his land without his permission. The farmer may eventually lose his temper and may decide to assert his authority by bringing out his gun, but he will not know before he shoots whether he is shooting an inspector or a tourist. That is a position which should not be allowed to continue. It would be better if the number of inspectors was reduced, so that the farmer will know exactly the personal appearance of the inspector who is likely to come on his farm. No matter how carefully he studies faces—and he is not educated in such a way as to enable him to study the general personal appearance of the various people coming on his farm— he will not be able to distinguish between inspectors and people who are trespassing for the purpose of taking some of his property. That is a difficulty I see in connection with the Bill. There is another difficulty in that the Bill provides for an inspection during the shearing operation to see whether a farmer removes tar from wool during that operation.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That is another amendment.

Comment on this

The position is that the inspectors will not be aware when the farmer is carrying out shearing operations and they will be prying on the farmer, looking over his fences and possibly visiting his sheep every day to see if they can catch him in failure to remove the tar while carrying out shearing. The whole thing is making the position more confused and it would be better to narrow the number of inspectors, so that the farmer would be able to identify the particular inspector dealing with this problem.

Comment on this

The principle of this measure has been approved by the House. Its provisions, therefore, must be desirable.

Comment on this

That is a considerable assumption.

Comment on this

On that assumption, which is a perfectly legitimate assumption, it is desirable that its provisions should be made effective when it becomes law. The most effective means that can be taken within reason, then, should be taken and this amendment proposes that the existing veterinary officials now employed by local authorities should have power to assist the officials of my Department in implementing these desirable proposals.

Comment on this

The amendment does not mention the word "veterinary".

Comment on this

The Minister's point is that the principle has been agreed to, and that, therefore, the proposal is desirable. But he left out a third requisite, that the proposal in the amendment is practicable. The Minister refers to this work being undertaken by veterinary officers. I do not know if they would be veterinary officers functioning under the Department of Agriculture or the Department of Local Government. In a great number of cases the offices are combined. The Minister, if he is not already aware, merely has to consult his colleague to ascertain if there is not a case made already, arising out of the Milk and Dairies Act, that these men are overworked, that they are not able to cope with the work that has been allocated to them. There is a suggestion in this Bill to increase their duties. That may be all right if it is practicable, but if there is any substance in the case made that they are not at the moment able to reach on the work which they have, then it is unreasonable to ask the Dáil to extend their duties.

Comment on this

It is refreshing to hear the Minister for Agriculture, with the brazen-faced audacity for which he is notorious, attempt to lay down the principle that because a Bill has been passed by this House it is, therefore, a good Bill. Did he read the observations of Mr. Justice Gavan Duffy in the High Court?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That is not in order.

Comment on this

The reference is in order.

Comment on this

If he did not, I hope he will.

Comment on this

I would prefer to see the Taoiseach reading it.

Comment on this

The House has heard the eloquence used in justification of this proposal to expand the battalion of inspectors into a regiment. The House has heard that the additions to be made to the battalion of inspectors are to be the overworked veterinary officers of the local authorities. Does the House imagine, if added duties are to be imposed on the veterinary officers of local authorities, who are already overworked discharging the duties they at present have, that those local authorities will not be required to appoint more inspectors and, when they have accumulated a sufficient number of inspectors, can the House doubt that, following the well-established practice, we will be called upon to appoint inspectors of the inspectors? I was visited on my land by two inspectors and I was astonished to meet a third. I asked him: "What, in the name of God, did you come to inspect?" and he told me he came to inspect the inspectors.

When I look around the galaxy of agriculturists sitting in the Fianna Fáil Benches, I wonder does it not occur to any of them that these local authority inspectors and the inspectors who will be appointed to inspect those inspectors will have to be paid for out of the rates levied on the county and that those rates will be paid by the proprietors of the sheep? We may not inquire as to who will receive the benefits of these inspections. We do not have to inquire as to who will pay the cost. We know that. If the Minister for Agriculture is left free to choose whether he will apply to the Department of Finance for authority to expand his estimate to pay inspectors of his own department to do this work, or simply tell the local authority to do it and, if necessary, increase their staff of veterinary inspectors does anyone here doubt that the Minister will shuffle off the responsibility for increasing the cost of his estimate and leave it to the local authorities to explain to the ratepayers, in what way they can, why it has become necessary to raise the rates in order to pay for the regiment of inspectors and the inspectors to inspect the inspectors who may be required under this Bill? Deputies may not have noticed that not only are we widening the ranks of the inspectors, but simultaneously we are amplifying their powers.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Not by this amendment.

Comment on this

No, Sir, not by this amendment.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy must then deal only with the amendment.

Comment on this

Then we cannot even contemplate, when proposing extra inspectors, the probable number that will be required? Surely, I am entitled to direct attention——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy is dealing with alleged extended powers of those inspectors, which do not come into the amendment.

Comment on this

Then I will deal simply with what these inspectors are required to do, with a view to determining how many will be required. Under this Bill it can become the duty of this regiment of inspectors to manicure each individual sheep in Ireland. Do Deputies realise that?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The duties of these inspectors were fixed on the Second Stage.

Comment on this

No, Sir, they are being fixed now.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Not by this amendment.

Comment on this

They are being fixed at this stage. Surely, you will not require me to discuss this Bill on the basis of what was done in the House on an earlier stage when you know that what was then done will be undone within ten minutes? I should not be asked to argue that what was in the Bill when it left the House will continue to be there. I am not asked to discuss this amendment on that presumption, well knowing that it will be altered very shortly. Surely, that would mean reducing Parliamentary procedure to a farce? One should not say to me; "Read the Bill and there you will see what will be the duties of the inspectors," when the Chair and I both know that these will not be the duties of the inspectors. It is not what was in the Bill when it left this House that will be the law; it will be something utterly different.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

In considering amendments from the Seanad, the discussion is confined strictly to the subject-matter of each amendment. This amendment proposes that officials of local bodies may inspect just as well as Government officials. Whether that is advisable or not is the matter under discussion, not the duties of these inspectors as laid down in other sections.

Comment on this

This amendment provides that the veterinary officers of local authorities may inspect in accordance with this Clean Wool Act, as it will be. What is the meaning of the word "inspect"?

Comment on this

Get a dictionary.

Comment on this

I will tell you. You do not want a dictionary. Poor Deputy O'Driscoll is an innocent, simple kind of fellow if he thinks that a dictionary will help him; when dealing with legislation proposed by the Fianna Fáil Government, he will have to think again. Only silly billies imagine they can unravel the purpose of this Government with a dictionary. The dictionary which will unravel the problems propounded by this Government will not have to be written by a Samuel Johnson but by Eamon de Valera, who is the only man who can put the true meaning to anything.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

And he is usually referred to here as the Taoiseach.

Comment on this

Yes, Sir, in this House, but not in his capacity as a lexicographer. "Inspect" in this context does not mean what Deputy O'Driscoll expects it to mean.

Comment on this

Address the Chair and do not be looking at me.

Comment on this

"Inspect" in this context means that the officer appointed by the local authority has the power, and may have the duty, to go through the wool of every individual sheep in Ireland.

Comment on this

He would be woolgathering like the Taoiseach.

Comment on this

Like Deputy Dillon.

Comment on this

Deputy Peadar O'Loghlen here interjects incredulously that Deputy Dillon must be wool-gathering if he believes that, and yet Deputy Peadar O'Loghlen will trot into the Lobby like one of the sheep and vote for this proposition, because that is the proposition in the Bill.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The definition of "inspection" does not arise on this amendment. It arose on another stage of the Bill and the meaning of "inspection" was then laid down. The Deputy must confine himself to the question of whether it is or is not advisable that officials of local authorities should have power to inspect.

Comment on this

And Deputy O'Driscoll asks——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I am not concerned with Deputy O'Driscoll, but with Deputy Dillon and order.

Comment on this

Deputy O'Driscoll inquires about inspection. May I not, in reply, state what it means?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

No.

Comment on this

Am I to understand that I am to discuss the duties of inspectors to inspect without speculating as to what the meaning of inspection is?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I do not know what the Deputy understands but the question before the House now is, not the definition of inspection, but whether or not local officers should be allowed to inspect.

Comment on this

If I do not know what to inspect means, how I can argue as to whether local officers may be permitted to inspect or not surpasses me.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy might have learned all that when the Bill was before the House on Second Reading.

Comment on this

What I am submitting to you is that what was debated on the Second Stage of the Bill has now been rejected. What we listened to and understood on the Second Stage of the Bill has now gone.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy must keep within the rules of order.

Comment on this

What is the use of arguing that we are confronted with the same Bill if something which was in the Bill when it left the House is no longer there?

Comment on this

He is trying to educate the gallery.

Comment on this

I have an easier job than educating what is sitting in front of me.

Comment on this

They never heard you before.

Comment on this

You would not educate the gallery anyhow.

Comment on this

What gratifies me is that the less sophisticated members of Fianna Fáil are at last beginning to realise what they are required to trot into the Lobby for. It is embarrassing for them to have to do it, but they will have to do it. Of course, some of them will not find it embarrassing. They will trot anywhere for anything when told to do so.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy must return to the amendment.

Comment on this

Yes. I am speculating as to what the members of the Fianna Fáil Party will do in regard to the amendment. Deputy Dockrell maliciously suggests that they will go where the bell wether leads. I suppose in these circumstances it is not much use talking any longer about sheep to sheep.

Comment on this

I am anxious to know if it is the intention of the Minister to appoint additional inspectors and, if so, if these inspectors will be appointed by competitive examination. I am not asking that for propaganda purposes, like some other Deputies here.

Comment on this

It is not the intention.

Comment on this

For the time being.

Comment on this

Does it mean the utilisation of local inspectors and a reduction in the number of Department inspectors?

Comment on this

It means that if, in the course of the performance of a local officer's duties, he comes across a case in which the law is not being observed he has power to take action.

Comment on this

I merely want to stand up here to defend the rights of my own constituency.

Comment on this

Does it mean that the cost of these inspectors will be discharged out of central funds?

Comment on this

The inspector has duties already to perform. If, for instance, an inspector of the Dublin Corporation in the course of his duties should discover in some particular case that the law was not being observed in relation to this measure, he has power to take action.

Comment on this

If further additional duties are being imposed on an inspector surely——

Comment on this

No further additional duties are being imposed upon him but further powers are being given to him.

Comment on this
Division

Question put.

Tá 60
·
Níl 26
Result Carried The question put was agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?

I move that the Committee agree with the Seanad in amendment No. 3:—

In Section 3. sub-section (1), after the word "paint" in line 38, the words "incapable of being removed by scouring" inserted.

It was thought that the word "paint" was somewhat wide and, as a result of pressure during the discussion in the Seanad, I agreed to insert the words set out in the amendment—"incapable of being removed by scouring." There are many kinds of paint and it was held— I think rightly—that, if the word "paint" were allowed to stand, it would cover all kinds of paint, whether harmful or otherwise. The words set out in the amendment will render the position more satisfactory.

Comment on this

Who is to determine whether paint is capable of being removed by scouring or not? See the position now. A farmer brings his sheep to the fair. He has got a raddle-stick and marked the sheep in one circumstance or another, and he exposes them for sale. He is approached by a butcher who tells him he will buy his sheep, but instead of giving him five guineas each for them he will give £5, because the fleece of the sheep has been reduced in value as a result of its having been branded with paint or marked with paint. The farmer tells him that it is raddle that can be washed out of the fleece without any trouble whatsoever, but the butcher says it is not. The butcher will say to the farmer: "I cannot sell that fleece. I cannot deal in that fleece. I cannot handle it because Section 3 of the Clean Wool Act defines prohibited substances and Section 5 provides that no person shall purchase or otherwise acquire or sell, or otherwise dispose of any wool on which a prohibited substance is present" Who is going to settle, for the benefit of the parties, the question as to whether the paint appearing on the fleece of the sheep in the fair is capable of being removed by scouring or is not? Do we, in this House, believe that every fellmonger's agent coming into a fair in this country is so solicitous for the welfare of the farmers of this country that he will differentiate scrupulously between the paint which is incapable of being removed by scouring and the paint which is capable of being removed by scouring.

The Minister himself realises that to penalise every farmer would be unjust and so he seeks to put in these qualifying words. Of what use are qualifying words if there is no means of enforcing them against the person who wishes to evade the overriding proviso? Do the members of this House imagine that when a fellmonger's agent in this country buys a sheep he will go up to the farmer and say: "Your sheep will be worth only £5 if it was marked with paint which is incapable of being removed by scouring, but I am glad to notice that the quality of paint on your sheep is the quality that can be removed by scouring and, therefore, your sheep is worth £5 5s. 0d., which I am delighted to have the opportunity of paying you"? Can any Deputy envisage such a conversation taking place on a fair day in this country? Now let us picture the other scene. Can any Deputy doubt that there will be a copy of that Act in the hands of every butcher in Ireland when he goes buying a sheep hereafter? He will be as familiar with the provisions of that Act as the Supreme Court is with the Articles of the Constitution and more familiar than some members of that august body appear to be. When he sees the trace of paint on a sheep's back he will be able to recite Section 3 of this Act by heart and if the farmer challenges his recollection he will have a copy of the Act in his hip-pocket to show to him. Then the farmer will say: "Oh, but the Minister for Agriculture had foresight because when he went to the Seanad he provided that the paint used must be capable of being removed by scouring." Whereupon the butcher, with righteous indignation, will reply: "Prove that that paint can be removed by scouring." Before the farmer could prove that, he would have to skin the 60 sheep he has in the fair, scour the wool, put the fleece back on the sheep and then make his sale. I am told that this proviso is a mark of the Minister's solicitude for the farmers who will have to sell sheep to the fellmongers' agents hereafter at the fairs of this country. Is it not rather amazing that 80 per cent. of the Deputies of this House come from rural Ireland? Eighty per cent. of the Deputies of this House come here to represent the raisers of live stock, yet, every proviso in this Bill which is designed to enrich the fellmonger and increase the intolerable burden which the farmers of this country have to bear in order to be able to live is passed with acclamation.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That does not arise now. The Deputy must deal with this proviso and nothing else.

Comment on this

This proviso is the most obnoxious of all.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy must deal with this proviso only. The Deputy has referred to the other matters already.

Comment on this

This proviso professes to be a relief for farmers. If the farmer can establish that the paint is capable of being removed by scouring then the fellmonger can be reassured. Does any Deputy in this House imagine that on the fair green where the price of the sheep is being determined it will be easy to reassure the fellmonger or his agent? On the fair green the fellmonger and his agent will be as sceptical as it is humanly possible to be. True, when the fellmonger comes to sell the wool that he has taken off the skin he will point out that this prudent provision was put in by the far-seeing Minister for Agriculture in the Seanad before the Clean Wool Bill finally passed Oireachtas Éireann. He will get his profit out of it, because by the time he comes to sell the wool it will be wool detached, not only from the sheep, but from the sheep-skin, and if his certificate as to the possibility of scouring this fleece is challenged he can give a demonstration there and then without any inconvenience whatever. Not so the much despised farmer. What is the net result of that proviso? It means the farmer will get 5/- less for his sheep and the fellmonger 5/- more for his fleece. What is its only consequence?—exploitation. Victimisation of the people who have the effrontery to earn their living on the land of this country is familiar in this House. It has become a crime in this country to be independent and to earn your own living without crawling on your stomach to a Fianna Fáil T.D., but I am accustomed to watching those who scorn to prostitute themselves——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy is wide of the amendment now.

Comment on this

This amendment, Sir, in the guise of relieving the circumstances of hardworking farmers, in fact does nothing for their relief but merely provides a legal way for fellmongers more cruelly to exploit them than they have done heretofore.

Comment on this

Have the Department provided a substance suitable for the branding of sheep, in substitution for those already in use, that can be used with safety as against the tar or pitch used in days gone by, or is it the intention of the Department to introduce some such substance for branding which will last for a period?

Comment on this

I was asked for that assurance on Second Reading and I think it is on the records of this House that I gave such assurance. Approved substances are available for that purpose.

Comment on this

I mean approved substances that will remain on the wool over a period.

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

And what guarantee does the Minister give as to the price that will be charged for the substance and the circumstances under which the farmer will be able to buy it? Does the Minister propose to make it available from the Department or must it be bought from a protected manufactory in this country or will the Minister give the House a guarantee that the substance will be available to those farmers who desire to buy it from whatever source they may choose to procure it at the lowest price and the best quality available?

Comment on this

The Minister has satisfied himself that the conditions under which it will be available are reasonable.

Comment on this

That is not sufficient satisfaction for me. We have made provision for the fellmonger. We have made provision for the wool merchant. We have made provision for every human being in this country who can possibly come in contact with a sheep. The only person for whom no thought must be taken is the man who bred the sheep and reared the sheep. We are told now that the Minister for Agriculture has satisfied himself that there is available a substance which will fulfil all the requirements stipulated for by him but he cannot tell us what the substance is; he cannot tell us where it is to be got and he cannot give us any assurance as to the price that will be charged. In that vacuum how are we to arrive at a knowledge of probability except by comparison? Remember, if the farmers do not use this approved substance, it will be very hard for the average farmer to satisfy authority, to satisfy the regiment of inspectors, that his sheep are properly marked and if the farmer is compelled to purchase this approved material, which will satisfy all the inspectors and the inspectors of inspectors, from one source, from one monopolist, may he not have the same experience that we have all had when we were constrained to buy electric lamps from one monopolist?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy is outside the amendment.

Comment on this

May I speculate on the price that will be charged for this approved material?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I have just stated that the Deputy is out of order in his reference to the price of electric bulbs.

Comment on this

Very well, Sir. This commodity which the Minister has declared to be satisfactory——

Comment on this

What is the commodity?

Comment on this

He does not know. I have a pretty shrewd suspicion that it is the product of a monopolist in this country. I want to warn this House that that arrangement, if my experience goes for anything, is liable to result in the farmers being charged a price for the commodity approved by the Minister 200 to 300 per cent. greater than it would cost were the farmers permitted to purchase it wherever it could be procured cheapest. Observe, then, the endless benefits which we bestow upon the agricultural community. The bucolic fellmonger is protected.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy is repeating himself. We had that on the last amendment.

Comment on this

It is for the Gallery, Sir.

Comment on this

The categories I have mentioned are protected. We now hasten to the aid of the oppressed industrialist. He is going to be protected because the commodity he prepares for the marking of sheep is going to carry the approval of the Minister for Agriculture and the implication that any other commodity will get the farmer into trouble. But the man who had the effrontery, the indecency, the reckless improvidence to breed a sheep, the public enemy who fattened a sheep upon the land of this country——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy must deal with the amendment, not make a general speech on industry and agriculture.

Comment on this

The Gallery, Sir.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I am sure he can do it without being prompted.

Comment on this

He could if he wished. He does not want to.

Comment on this

There is a new Gallery to-day.

Comment on this

Listen to the elevating interjections of Deputy Killilea. Why would not the Deputy enter the debate?

Comment on this

To-day's Gallery have never heard the Deputy before.

Comment on this

We have never heard Deputy Killilea now, before or ever, since he first started drawing £480 a year for sitting in this House. Now, I would invite him to intervene and to give us his opinion.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I would invite the Deputy's opinion on this amendment.

Comment on this

I am giving it to the House. I am submitting to the House that this amendment is merely another instance of the burdens imposed on farmers for the benefit of industrialists who are given a monopoly. The individual who is doing something useful will be required to pay whatever the monopolist chooses to charge him. I do not believe that this amendment was introduced by the Minister for the purpose of relieving the agricultural community. I believe that this amendment has been devised for the purpose of enabling a monopoly in this country to get a fat profit on a product which the Minister's approval will make indispensable to anyone who dares to raise or fatten sheep in this country. All this makes one sometimes despair. I know that certain Deputies who have experience of business, as I have, understand that subtle purpose, while others who do not realise the devices that can be employed for the exploitation of simple people down the country are being misled into the belief that this proposal—which, on the surface, appears to be designed for the relief of farmers—is, in fact, designed for that end, when really it is merely an additional device for the consolidation of the right and power of parasites in our community to suck the blood of those who seek to earn their living without protection, subvention——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy has repeated that three times.

Comment on this

——or assistance from the Government of the day.

Comment on this

I should like to know from the Minister if this substance is available at the moment, and where is it to be had. Can it be obtained by sheep-breeders at the moment?

Comment on this

The provisions of this Bill, when it becomes an Act, will only remain in operation so long as such a substance is available.

Comment on this

But if it is not available?

Comment on this

If and when such substances are not available the provisions of this Bill, when it becomes an Act, will not apply.

Comment on this

I would like to ask the Minister for a little information on this particular matter. We all know that farmers in various districts have been in the habit of using tar and pitch as a suitable brand for sheep. Can the Minister assure us that the substance that he has in mind as a substitute for tar will be readily available to the farmer, and is he satisfied that it can be used by the farmer as easily as the old method of branding by tar? Is he satisfied that the substance which he recommends will not run? We all know that if you attempt to brand sheep with some substances that the substance will run—one letter will run into another, so that the brand will not be distinct. Further, I would like to know whether the substance that he has in mind will be accessible to the farmer. Will he be able to get it at a shop in any country place?

I should also like to know from the Minister whether the substance which he recommends can be procured at as cheap a price as the old method of branding by tar? That is an important consideration for a farmer who has a big flock of mountain sheep. If the new substance is more expensive than the old, it will be a serious matter for him, and, therefore, I suggest that the House ought not lightly pass a simple amendment like this which may mean a great deal of additional expense on the farmer. I would like to have some information from the Minister on these points. The first is, can the substance which the Minister is recommending be used as readily as the old method of branding, which was a mixture of tar and pitch; can he say whether, when it is used for lettering, it will not run, and whether it will be procurable in any shop in a country village? Can he also say whether the cost of it will be somewhat equivalent to the cost of the old method of tar and pitch?

Comment on this