Finance (No. 2) Bill, 1947—Committee (Resumed) and Final Stages.
Contributions 110–243 of 243. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 42 of 1947 ›
And the 24/- a week for the agricultural labourer.
Comment on this
In that year they paid £5,600,000 on beer and last year they paid £4,800,000. If the Deputy can explain that, he is welcome to it. The Deputy spent half an hour talking, to my mind, a good lot of nonsense.
Comment on this
The Deputy spoke the greatest tripe that was ever spoken in this House and no one interrupted him. If he had two sound ideas his brains would be heard rattling.
Comment on this
This Budget is one that the Government can stand over. It was not brought in for the purpose of catching votes; it was brought in at a critical time when there were by-elections on. The Government knew what they were doing. They did not court the favour of the voters simply because it might be popular to do so. The decent, common people of the country will never sell their country for the price of a pint of beer.
Comment on this
This Budget has been well thrashed out and I think if the Minister had only carefully considered this matter he would never have introduced such a Budget. It deserves all the praise it got from every side of the House. It is a sour Budget and it has brought nothing but gloom all over the country. I wish the Minister could have attached something novel to it, something at which the people could laugh. I heard Deputy Dillon giving a list of the things that could more suitably be taxed. I am quite satisfied that there is no reason for increased taxation. We have an Army, a Navy and a Civil Service. We should apply the slash-hook to these, cut them to the roots and thereby save millions for the taxpayers.
I will give the Dáil a list of things that I would like to see taxed. This list will bring a laugh to the people of the country, if nothing else. First of all, looking over at the smiling Minister, I would put a heavy tax on bald heads. On top of that, I would put a tax on moustaches. If we did that, there would be very few moustaches left and the ladies all over the country would be in better humour. Next I would put a tax on bachelors. I did not hear anybody talking about a tax on bachelors. Such a tax would bring in a fair amount of revenue. If it did not bring much revenue, at least it would bring some gladness to the heart of many a farmer's daughter, and many an old warrior now staying shy would be coaxed up a little. Next I would put a tax on lapdogs, the little dogs you can see being led through the streets—little Poms and other dogs of that type. I would tax them off the streets of Dublin.
Next, I would put a tax on permanent waves and I would make sure that the old fogeys all dolled up trying to look like their young daughters would pay for it. Then I would put a tax on golf, on cricket, on tennis, and on dog and horse racing. I would also put a tax on the G.A.A. and I would not be afraid to do that. If there is any Gaelic spirit at all in the G.A.A. they should be proud to pay a tax. Finally, I would put a tax on sports of other kinds. I expect that there are a few items in that list that the Minister will not be anxious to peruse.
Comment on this
I hope it will not be necessary for the Minister to appoint bald-headed inspectors or moustached inspectors.
Comment on this
The moment we put a tax on the bald heads, we will have a new factory—a factory for wigs. Fifteen or 20 years ago we had a great cry about the Cosgrave Government that took a shilling off the old age pensioners. They were nearly hounded to their graves for doing so, although it was not such a terrible thing. Fianna Fáil came along and knocked 8/- off the old age pensioner.
Comment on this
I merely wanted to bring some humour into this debate, because, for the most part, it was a dour and sour debate. The labouring man is well able to read for himself and he knows that through this Budget he has got it in the neck, so to speak, and he has to pay well for his pint and his tobacco. He knows he has been fooled for the past 15 years, but he will not be fooled much longer.
Comment on this
Question put.
Do you agree with this result?
There are three or four amendments to this section which go together. The first amendment is consequential and I can explain it in relation to the second amendment, which relates to sub-section (4). The effect of amendment No. 2 is to delete the first six lines—page 9, lines 55 to 60—and also to delete paragraph (b) of the subsection—page 10, lines 25 to 27. A new paragraph is then introduced at the beginning of the sub-section.
The reason for the change is two-fold. As sub-section (4) was originally drafted, a person claiming the benefit, that is, a reduced rate of duty, of any one of the first three sub-sections had to fulfil two conditions; he had to fall, in fact, into one of the six categories mentioned in the sub-section and, in addition, he had to include in the conveyance a certificate stating that he was within the appropriate category. Whether the deed was correctly stamped depended ultimately on proof that he fell within the category stated in the certificate.
These joint requirements gave rise to two difficulties. In the first place a purchaser in order to ensure that the conveyance was correctly stamped would normally exercise the right which exists under the Stamp Act, 1891, of submitting the deed for adjudication. This procedure means that the deed is sent to the Revenue Commissioners who, after an examination of all the circumstances, state as their opinion the amount of duty chargeable on the deed. Such an examination would inevitably include an inquiry into the circumstances justifying the claim that the person correctly came into the category specified and it would impose an intolerable burden on the staff to conduct these inquiries which would cover birth, residence, etc., of the purchaser. At the present time only a minority of deeds are sent for adjudication and if the Revenue Commissioners were to be confronted with adjudication in all cases where the lower rate of duty was claimed the existing staff would require to be substantially increased.
The second difficulty was the position facing the person who later on purchased a property the conveyance for which, having been stamped at the rate of £5 per cent., had not been submitted for adjudication. One of the requirements of a good title is that the documents forming part of the title have been correctly stamped. A new purchaser could not be satisfied that a document was correctly stamped at the lower rate of £5 per cent. unless he were supplied with such information as would clearly establish that the person from whom he was purchasing was at the time of the original purchase within one of the privileged classes set out in the sub-section. For many reasons this might involve numerous and troublesome inquiries where a property was being sold after ten or 15 years. For example, the inquiries might have to be made after the death of the first owner when perhaps nobody could positively state his circumstances at the time he purchased the property.
The proposed amendment does not extend the circumstances in which the reduced rates apply nor does it weaken the penalty position where a false certificate is given. What it does is to make the certificate in the instrument conclusive evidence that the lower rate of duty applies. If a declaration is now contained in the instrument certifying that the person is within one of the specified classes, that declaration is in itself sufficient to make the lower rate of duty applicable. It obviates the necessity for sending conveyances for adjudication on this point. Also the mere fact that the declaration is on the instrument is complete evidence for a subsequent purchaser that the deed was correctly stamped at the lower rate. He is thus relieved of the burden of questioning the grounds on which the vendor, i.e., the first purchaser, claimed to be within one of the specified classes.
If this certificate or declaration is given where the actual facts do not justify it, the person making the declaration renders himself liable for a sum equivalent to double the duty chargeable.
Comment on this
It is in sub-section (7) (b). This liability is not, however, of any concern to a subsequent purchaser as by reason of the certificate the document is, for his purposes, correctly stamped.
There are a couple of other consequential amendments I should like to advert to, with your permission, Sir.
Comment on this
It will. By amendment No. 1—sub-section (2) (a), page 9, lines 21 to 23—the words " coming" on line 21 down to "section" on line 23 are deleted. The reason for this is that the opening words of sub-section (4) as amended make it clear that sub-section (2) (a) can apply only where the condition in sub-section (4) is complied with It is, therefore, unnecessary to have this condition stated in sub-section (2) itself.
By amendment No. 3 to sub-section (4), the paragraphs previously numbered (i) to (vi) are now described as (a) to (f), and, as a consequence, the words " sub-paragraphs (i) to (v) of this paragraph" appearing on page 10, lines 22 and 23, are being amended by amendment No. 4 to " paragraphs (a) to (e) of this sub-section". It is a drafting amendment.
There is another amendment—amendment No. 8 to sub-section (7) (a), page 11, line 1. The words " sub-paragraphs (i) to (vi) of paragraph (a)" have also to be amended to "paragraphs (a) to (f)".
I move amendment No. 1.
Comment on this
Do we take it that amendment No. 1 is agreed? The essence of it is in No. 2, I think.
Comment on this
I can raise on amendment No. 2 a point that I intended to raise on the section. All this is in the framework of the conveyance of the entire beneficial interest. Why is that? The Minister must know that there are many examples in this country of conveyances, say, as between father and children or, say, between a mother, when the father has predeceased her, and children, and where the parent retains right of residence. That type of transaction will certainly be ruled out under this phrase which necessitates that the entire beneficial interest shall be conveyed. I have always thought that in this country we had agreed that it was socially a good thing to induce, say, the parents who owned a farm to get off it and to make way for the younger people and the general device adopted was that the seniors did leave the land to a son, retaining themselves—having granted to themselves—right of dwelling.
Comment on this
In any event, why insist on the "entire beneficial interest"? Why not leave it "main beneficial interest" or "beneficial interest"?
Comment on this
Because the type of transaction which the Deputy describes, that is, a father transferring a farm to his son and retaining right of residence, does not attract the higher rate of duty at all. That is our advice, that it does not attract the higher rate of duty.
Comment on this
The Minister is probably aware of the fact that in marriage writings, as they call them in the country, very frequently the girl's fortune-is handed over to the boy's parents as part of the consideration and it is in effect a sale. How would that affect it?
Comment on this
The only thing about this. whole particular section is: It is designed, as I said, to do two things, that is, to take 5 per cent. of the increased value of land from people who sell for profit, for the consideration of getting money for it, and, secondly, to. put Irish people in a favourable competitive position with people coming in from abroad. There was a particular snag in this that I have dealt with in these amendments. There may be other snags and, if there are other snags, all we can do is to meet them and if there is some grave hardship, which has not been adverted to—I do not think there will be because the thing has been very thoroughly examined—it could be dealt with by way of annulment of the whole duty. With regard to Deputy McGilligan's question, I am advised that the type of transaction that he refers to will not attract the 5 per cent. rate of duty at all.
Comment on this
Is it clear that the circumstances referred to by Deputy Costello would never be considered a sale?
Comment on this
Supposing the girl's fortune was handed over to the boy's parents in consideration that it is sold to them, reserving right of residence?
Comment on this
What we should like to be assured of is that under no circumstances, by any ingenuity on the part of the Revenue Commissioners, would that case that Deputy Costello describes be considered a sale.
Comment on this
All I will say is that if there is anything, and I had the responsibility of doing it, if it were treated as a sale we could amend it.
Comment on this
I have not looked at these as they only came to-night, but one of these drafting amendments talks about paragraphs (a) to (f) and the next one refers to (a) to (e). Is that all right?
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 6:—
At the end of paragraph (a), page 10, to add a new sub-paragraph (vii) as follows:—
or
(vii) The Revenue Commissioners are satisfied that the property comprised in the instrument is intended to be used and occupied for the purposes of any religious, cultural, educational, charitable, benevolent, sporting or athletic society or body whether incorporated or not.
When I examined this Bill I found the exemptions in favour of the lower rate of duty were given to persons and to corporations but only to incorporated bodies. There was no exemption in favour of unincorporated bodies, and it occurred to me that we have many such bodies in the country, particularly religious orders, sporting organisations, such as football, golf, and tennis clubs, and that if one of such unincorporated bodies was to purchase property they would only get the exemption to the lower rate of duty if every one of them was either an Irish citizen or resident here for three years. The only other way they could get the exemption would be to farm a company. I think that would be a result that was never intended by the Minister, and I thought the amendment first should try to make an embracing description of the kind of organisation. I abandoned that and I thought it would be more convenient to make the exemption by reference to the use to which the land or premises was to be put. For that reason I proposed this amendment.
Comment on this
If the Deputy refers to sub-section (4) it will be seen that the lower rate of duty applies where the beneficial interest in the property vests in persons or bodies who come within any of the six specified classes. The word "person" in the old paragraph (b), which is now 4 (a) (ii), is to be construed in accordance with the Interpretations Act of 1937 as importing a body corporate and an unincorporated body of persons as well as an individual. So, therefore, a body corporate or an unincorporated body or an individual will get the benefit of the lower rate of duty provided the beneficial interest vests in them and he or they come within the six specified classes.
Comment on this
Sub-section (4) (a) (ii): "a person who is for the time being ordinarily resident in the State and who was ordinarily resident in the State continuously for three years". "A person" there means, according to the Interpretation Act, either an individual, a body corporate, or an nonincorporated body of persons.
Comment on this
If the Minister is satisfied that that is the case—he will have the difficulty of dealing with these people if they find they have to pay the higher duty—I am satisfied to withdraw the amendment.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 7:
In sub-section (6) (b) after the word property in line 49, to add "is the husband or the wife or parent of the person immediately theretofore entitled," and after the word "sister" in line 56 to add "or as brother or sister of a parent".
This amendment is suggested by the Incorporated Law Society. The principle behind it is to apply the same ruling to settlements of this kind as is applied in the case of legacy duties, where a reduced rate of 5 per cent. applies upwards to an uncle and downwards to a nephew. If the same is applied here, it would cover a great many cases. There are many cases where a man might want to assign property to his parents or to his uncle, just as many as there would be as in relationship the other way; and I suggest to the Minister that, when he is giving the exemption at all, he might as well widen it a little more and let all in in the same degree of relationship.
Comment on this
It is a lineal descendant, where it is a son or a daughter, or the son or daughter of a brother or sister. Deputy O'Connor wants that he should also be able to transfer it on the lower rate to his uncle or aunt, or from a son back to his father. I am going down in lineal descent and, as far as I can see, Deputy O'Connor is going up. He wants the nephew to be able to transfer to the uncle.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 8:
In sub-section (7) (a), page 11, line 1, to delete "sub-paragraphs (i) to (vi) of paragraph (a)" and insert "paragraphs (a) to (f)".
We have dealt with this.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 9:—
In sub-section (7) (c) to delete the words "within three months" in line 17.
This amendment is designed to leave to the Revenue Commissioners the full and absolute discretion to grant a remission of a penalty at any time in a case where they think fit. They are quite a hardy, tough body of men and can be trusted not to remit penalties that they should not remit. It is most undesirable that there should be any limit placed upon the time during which they may remit a penalty. Solicitors are very much concerned with this particular matter, as if a mistake is made in the solicitor's office and there is an omission to stamp a document, is is very seldom discovered within three months. If this section passes as it stands, when the three months have gone by, the Revenue Commissioners will no longer have any discretion, as the penalty will become automatic and there will be no getting out of it.
An answer to that is that mistakes should not occur in solicitors' offices and we must agree with that; but solicitors or their assistants may become ill or die and documents may be left for a couple of months. I am satisfied that cases will arise where the Revenue Commissioners, tough and all as they are, will be anxious to remit the penalty, but will be prevented by these words "within three months" from so doing.
The same set of circumstances happened before in the Stamp Act of 1891. I find there was a stamping limit of three months but that limit was taken away by an Act passed four years later, the Finance Act of 1895. It looks as if the Minister is inclined to make a mistake that was made many years ago and corrected. I think the Revenue Commissioners will feel much more satisfied if they are left with the full and complete discretion to remit the penalty in a proper case at any time.
Comment on this
One of the difficulties about this particular amendment is that it relates to a matter which I hope is only temporary. We just cannot give the solicitors and their clients combined the option to forget and that we forgive and there will be nothing more heard about it. I think it is fair and reasonable. They are supposed to stamp a document inside a month. The Bill as it stands gives an option to the Revenue Commissioners, if it is stamped within three months, to forgo the penalty. I would say we had better leave it as it is, if it will put a spur to solicitors to stamp these documents. The penalty is pretty big and the amount involved is large, so I do not think solicitors will tend to forget the stamping of these particular documents.
Another thing is that the client is also interested in getting his affairs straightened out. A man buying a bit of property wants to get all the papers in his hands and the thing properly completed, but if he thought that, by forgetting about it for a few months, he might be able to get it stamped at a lower rate, there would be a little urge to be mindful of his interests:
Comment on this
Surely that is a very unsatisfactory objection to this amendment. Even if the "three months" phrase be cut out, the Revenue Commissioners have the entire discretion— they may if they think fit, remit the penalty recoverable under a particular sub-section. What is the use of putting in the three months? The Minister talks about forgetfulness. Deputy O'Connor has raised cases where it is not forgetfulness. There may be certain circumstances outside the solicitor's control which may mean that, four months after a particular date, he comes to the appreciation of an omission; and though there may be excuses and at that point the Revenue Commissioners say: "We would like to exercise our discretion in your favour, but cannot." It is not as if you were saying that they shall. The phrase is "may" and "may if they think fit", so that the completest discretion is given. Are we not back at the usual thing—that it makes for administrative convenience, and that so far as the Revenue Commissioners are concerned they should not have to listen to these hard cases? They can say: "We are very sorry; we would have dealt with it but there is the law." The Minister's excuse is that it is merely temporary. That is all the more reason for making this exemption.
Comment on this
With regard to amendment No. 10 in my name, I do not propose to move it, because the point is covered by amendment No. 2 which satisfies the doubt that was in my mind.
Comment on this
Perhaps at this stage I should draw attention to an obvious mistake that was overlooked in Section 11. On page 8, line 17, the figure "10" obviously should be "9".
Comment on this
There is one important matter that arises in regard to the new stamp duty. There are several ways in which the stamp duty of 25 per cent. may be avoided. I do not think that a good deal of revenue is going to be produced by that 25 per cent. tax, but, in the case of the 5 per cent. tax, that is cast iron, and there is very little chance of avoiding it. I would ask the Minister to consider, as a special case, the class of people who buy the smaller type of dwelling-house to make a home for themselves. The purchaser will have to pay the stamp duty. The Minister has already pointed out that this 5 per cent. stamp duty will have a steadying effect on the market, and will, perhaps, bring down the price of houses. I am satisfied it will have that effect, but that will not be of much advantage to the type of person that I have in mind.
In my opinion, 99 per cent. of the purchasers of the smaller type of dwelling-house are people who cannot pay the entire amount of the purchase money in cash. They will have to get two-thirds or four-fifths of it from a building society. The one point that will be uppermost in the mind of such a person is, how little cash he has to provide so that he can get possession of the house. If the reduction in price that the Minister hopes for takes place it will only mean to such a purchaser a saving of about 12/6 a month, but, as against that saving, there will be the increased stamp duty, and the difficulty in regard to it is that it must be paid in cash. Therefore, the amount of cash that a man will require in order to buy a house in which to reside will be increased. I am afraid that a great many people who had hoped to buy houses will be prevented from doing so by the imposition of this 5 per cent. stamp duty.
The only other point which I wish to make is one which, perhaps, may be of some convenience to the Revenue Commissioners. It arises on sub-paragraph (7) (b) and says "if at the expiration of 30 days after the execution thereof a transfer is not stamped..." In the other sections of the Stamp Duty Act the 30 days would run from the date on which the document entered the country if the document was executed abroad. I think there should be the same reservation in this section. There is also another rule where the document is lodged for adjudication, the time for stamping runs to 14 days.
Comment on this
I want to protest against this section. Deputy O'Connor did not make himself clear when he said that he agreed with the Minister that this section will have the effect of bringing down the price of houses. He has not told us how it is going to do that, or who is going to pay the duty—whether it is to come out of the vendor's pocket or the purchaser's pocket. I feel that, in present conditions at all events, with the scarcity of houses and the competition there is for housing properties, it is the purchaser who is going to pay.
I am concerned with the people who have small incomes. Some people in that class are not catered for very much by the provisions in our Housing Acts. They find it very difficult to get a house when they decide to get married and settle down in life. That applies in a special way to the whitecollar worker. He is compelled to save for some years before he decides to get married. He has a good deal of expenses about that time, and when he sets out to buy a house he has to go to a building society to get part of the purchase money. It is at that period of his life, when he is involved in fairly heavy expenses, that the Minister and the Government come along and pile further expenses on him in the way of stamp duty. I think it is unfortunate that the Minister and the Government should have come to that decision.
Take the case of the farmer who has a family living on a medium or rather small-sized holding. He is anxious to get his eldest son married and desires to purchase a farm for him. That is the type of young man that we should be anxious, from the national point of view to see settling down in life and rearing up a family. He should be encouraged in every way to live on the land because, from the national point of view, he is the type of young man who can make the best use of it. It is surely a wrong thing to increase the cost on his father of settling him in life.
The Minister has not given any reason to justify this imposition. He may say that he wants to prevent speculation. We all want to prevent speculation. It is a rotten situation when a man can jump in and buy property which he does not require merely for the purpose of raking off a premium for himself. Can the Minister satisfy me that this is going to eliminate that objectionable practice and can he prove that the genuine purchaser will not be mulcted? Can the Minister say that this will help the type of man whom even he himself, along with the members on all sides of the House, are anxious to ensure will not be mulcted? I refer to the young man going into a holding in the country or to the whitecollar worker who is anxious to get married, to settle down and to provide a house for himself.
It is inevitable that with the scarcity of housing at the present time, with the competition and with the difficulty of procuring a home this imposition will fall on the purchaser. The Minister certainly has not convinced me. Deputy O'Connor does not attempt to show the House why he believes that it will reduce the cost of housing. We are all concerned with the problem of emigration. This imposition is going to add to that problem. It is going to encourage people to clear out, instead of giving them facilities and encouraging them to settle down in life. We are putting on penalties instead of taking them off. The Minister obviously has not considered the matter.
Comment on this
I want Deputy Hughes to come to an auction with me. We are all at the auction. Let us assume that he is a widow-woman who has scraped all she can get and borrowed from the building society and from her friends and that she has £2,000 in her hands to bid, between loan and money. Deputy O'Connor is a young married man who is in the same boat as Deputy Hughes. He has saved and collected all the money he could. Let us say there was an auction the day before the Resolution became law. Deputy Hughes has scraped up £2,000 and Deputy O'Connor has got £2,050. On competition, Deputy O'Connor would beat Deputy Hughes and Deputy O'Connor would have to pay his 1 per cent. on his £2,050. If we could visualise the auction as being abortive, that it did not come to a conclusion, and that Deputy O'Connor still held back and did not bid the £2,050——
Comment on this
For the purpose of illustration let the Deputy assume that this auction was abortive in the first session and that meantime this Bill came into operation. Deputy Hughes has not got any more money in the meantime. He has the £2,000, part of which he saved and part of which he borrowed. Deputy O'Connor has still got his £2,050 in his bag, and he would buy the house on the second occasion at £2,050. All he can go to is £2,050— or something less than that in order to pay the stamp duty. On the first occasion he would have to go £20 less —to £2,030. On the second occasion the 5 per cent. would be £100, so that his price for the house on the second occasion would be £1,950 and all Deputy Hughes could go to would be £1,900 because he would still have to pay £100 on a £2,000 house.
In my belief that is what is going to happen. It is the vendor whose price is going to be reduced by the 5 per cent. The 5 per cent. instead of going into the vendor's pocket is going to go into the pocket of the Treasury. The competitive position of Deputy Hughes and Deputy O'Connor is not any worse. They cannot go any higher. The hypothesis was that they had scraped together all the money they could—Deputy O'Connor had £50 more than Deputy Hughes and in either case he would get the house.
Comment on this
That argument displays a typical Civil Service outlook. The picture the Minister painted completely lacks imagination. We should be realistic about the matter. The Minister pictured me as a widow-woman——
Comment on this
I will, Sir. With a little imagination the Minister ought to be able to complete the picture. I am a widow-woman. A neighbour comes to me and says: "Mrs. Murphy, go ahead. I would like your son to get the farm. I will give you a loan of £150." Will the Minister tell us what happens then? Will he allow his imagination to complete the picture? He wants to make it water-tight—if you can put an auction and competition into a water-tight compartment. The Minister knows as well as I do that that does not obtain at all in real life.
Comment on this
The Minister is trying to get us to accept what is almost impossible. It reminds me of the old story about the moon being made of green cheese. One man tried to prove to another man that the moon is made of green cheese. He says to his friend: "Either it is or it is not made of green cheese, and if it is not, therefore it is." The argument the Minister tried to put across this House is the same type of argument. He says that the prices of houses are not going to go up because of this 5 per cent. imposition. The Minister tells us first, of the case of a man who either by saving, borrowing, stealing or by any other means could only amass £2,000. He then tells us of another man who, somehow or other, by scraping got £2,050 together. By a manipulation of circumstances both these men would be compelled to stick to the price under £2,000. There may be a third man and very probably a fourth man with £2,500 who is prepared to bid over the heads of Deputy O'Connor and Deputy Hughes and who will pay under present circumstances a higher price, whether the 5 per cent. is there or not.
Everybody knows that is going to happen. Some man richer than the man who has to borrow is going to get the house. I suggested on the Second Reading that this imposition was not only a tax on the unfortunate savings of the under dog; it is a tax on his borrowing also. I am not concerned with the newly rich, the very rich or the Englishman who wants to buy a house. I am concerned with the almost very poor man—a man such as the Minister mentioned, who finds it impossible to get more than £2,000 together, whether by saving, begging or borrowing. It is going to be a tax on that man's savings and on that man's borrowing. I am glad Deputy O'Connor backed me up. He almost proved my case for me. He-said that a man would have to borrow extra on account of this 5 per cent. tax and, of course, that he would have to pay a greater amount of interest on his borrowing.
Deputy O'Connor also said in the course of his speech—and I think that it is something that we all recognised even before he adverted to it—that as far as the foreigner is concerned he is. generally able to evade the tax. He said that: "Generally speaking, a foreigner will be able to evade the tax by some means or another." Of course he will evade the tax. The Englishman, in particular, will evade it because he has always been able to evade it. He got it over in the recent deputations. The Englishman is now going to run our agricultural business for us. The foreigner will get over it, but the unfortunate Irishman will not be able to get over it. He will have to pay, and he is the man we ought to try to protect.
Comment on this
I think the Minister's argument does not hold water I think Deputy Bennett hit the nail on the head when he said that a third purchaser or a third bidder will come along. There may be a third, a fourth and fifth bidder. In any auction, where there is anything like a brisk sale and a good deal of bidding, nobody knows to whom any house or property will go except that it will eventually go to the man with the longest purse—whether that man be a "widow-woman" or anybody else.
Comment on this
Yes, or a young married person-like Deputy O'Connor. I am quoting the Minister now. We cannot say who is going to purchase or who it is going to hit; but we do know that it is going to hit the purchaser. It is going to put the cost of property up to any person who buys that property, be he deserving or undeserving. We know that many young people are searching for houses in this country. We know that if they succeed now in finding a house it is going to cost them 5 per cent. more. Many houses are put up for auction and the people who buy them will have to find something like 10 per cent. of the purchase price for solicitors' fees and so on. The Minister has exempted houses under £500 from this extra taxation. I would like to ask the Minister where on earth anyone will find a house on this day and in this age under £500.
Comment on this
I do not believe that such a house exists. No house at the present moment would be sold for less than £500 unless perhaps one occupied by a tenant receiving a very, very small weekly wage.
Comment on this
Yes, pieces of land and property. Surely, it was the prospective buyers of houses whom the Minister wished to help under this section. Surely, an exemption under £500 was meant to facilitate buyers of houses and not to facilitate transfers of small pieces of land. I want to point out to the Minister that, though on paper that £500 looks very nice, it does not mean a thing at present-day prices.
Comment on this
The point I want to make is actually not relevant to the matter under discussion at the moment but I would like to make one comment first in regard to prices. The prices of houses are controlled by the law of supply and demand. In other words, the price your house is going to fetch is the price which somebody is prepared to buy at and it is immaterial whether you section that price up into portions, part of it appropriated to stamp duty and part of it appropriated to profit to the vendor. The determining factor is going to be the all-in cost to the purchaser as far as the demand is concerned. The supply will depend on the number of people who have houses to sell. For that reason, it is my opinion that this particular imposition will have no appreciable effect subject to this qualification: I agree that the fact that the minimum deposit put down is increased does influence the position. Subject to that, I think it makes no difference as far as the price of houses from Irish citizens to Irish citizens is concerned.
I would join with the other Deputies in recommending to the Minister consideration of this point: if I were to purchase a house on the instalment system—and that is the system commonly used by those people who are the subject of this discussion—my method would be to deposit a certain sum and to borrow the remainder. In other words, the prospective purchaser has "to raise the wind" to the extent of a certain percentage of his purchase price. His main difficulty is to get that initial deposit. Usually he has less trouble in finding the instalments which fall due yearly or half-yearly. In increasing that deposit in so far as stamp duty is concerned serious objection must be taken. To that extent it will become more difficult for the young married people to purchase houses. It will become more difficult to find the initial deposit. But, as I see it, the gross price to the purchaser will not be affected.
For that reason, in regard to domestic transactions, I wonder if it would not be possible for the Minister to alleviate that burden. I do not want to restrict it merely to newly-married couples because it might be an important matter to a couple more or less advanced in years who are thinking of retiring. I cannot make specific suggestions to the Minister on that problem because it is one which would have to be examined in some detail and I have not the facilities for doing that. Subject to all that, I think there has been an unnecessary making of a case one way or the other in regard to prices generally.
As regards prices to foreign purchasers, one of the things which has undoubtedly contributed to increased prices for houses in Ireland has been the increased demand created by foreign purchasers. In other words, the increased demand so created has put up the price where, in the ordinary way, the law of supply and demand would operate as regards prospective purchasers.
We also know that there have been complaints from the country occasionally of people coming in and buying land. I for one have no hesitation in expressing my personal view that it would be well to control it. For that reason, notwithstanding the fact that it may not be suitable to certain interests, I think it is a good job that the Minister has discriminated against that by putting on the 25 per cent. in these cases. It is an effort at control. I agree with Deputy O'Connor that the method of control will possibly be evaded and I have not a great deal of faith in it. I would be inclined myself to take very drastic action in that case. However, that is a personal view.
Comment on this
You could, for instance, give a very definite preference to your own citizens straightway. At any rate, this can be said for this financial sanction: that it discourages the purchase of land by outsiders. This also can be said for it, that it is offsetting the artificial demand created and the effect on price of that demand to some extent. In agreement with a number of other Deputies, my doubt is as to the effectiveness of it in operation, owing to the ingenuity of certain people who will be inclined to get over it. I think all Deputies will agree that a considerable amount of ingenuity will be brought to bear on that.
Comment on this
I agree. I can think of a number of ways in which, if I were so minded,——
Comment on this
I should be surprised if the Deputy ever wanted to be complimentary, but I shall leave it at that. The Deputy knows as well as I do that it is going to be a perfectly easy matter in many ways to get over by such devices as trustees.
Comment on this
I am different from the Deputy. So far as I am concerned, while functioning as a Deputy, I forget that I am anything else and I do my duty as a Deputy irrespective of other interests. However, we shall leave that alone. There is another point I should like to make on this section. I regret that I was not in the House at the time, but I am informed that Deputy O'Connor's amendment was answered in regard to the religious societies by referring to the fact that the Interpretation Act, No. 38, 1837, in defining the word "person" states: "The word `person' shall, unless the contrary intention appears, be construed as importing a body corporate (whether a corporation aggregate or a corporation sole), and an unincorporated body of persons as well as an individual." The answer there was that that included an unincorporated body such as a religious body and that therefore it was not necessary to take Deputy O'Connor's amendment with regard to sub-section (4); in other words, that such an unincorporated body was captured by the word "person" in paragraph (a) of sub-section (4).
I should like to point this out to the Minister and I suggest to him that it should be examined. The method by which such unincorporated bodies as religious societies secure land or make purchases, I am informed, is by trustees. In other words, certain members of their Order, if it is a religious Order, purchase the property and take the legal estate, but in actual fact they purchase as trustees. In so purchasing as trustees they are not purchasing the beneficial interest; they are getting the legal estate. If you read this section, you will see that the exemption applies to a person who becomes entitled to the entire beneficial interest in the property. In other words, if the exemption from the 25 per cent. tax applies to a person who has the complete beneficial interest in the property, it therefore would apply to a body unincorporated who had the complete beneficial interest in the property. But in order to capture that section, every single member of that religious community would have to be made a party to the deed, which would not be a feasible proposition at all.
On the other hand, if some selected mambers take the legal estate as trustees, they have not the entire beneficial interest. Therefore, in spite of the fact that the amendment has been considered unnecessary, I should like to direct the Minister's attention to the possibility again.
I have not looked into it very carefully and I am merely going on what I was told since I came into the House and on my recollection of the definition "person". It may be necessary to reconsider that again, particularly in view of the fact that you have had to put in a specific exemption in regard to bodies corporate incorporated in the State after a certain date. Taking the exemption in paragraph (3) of sub-section (4) in conjunction with the definition of "person" in the Interpretation Act, we find that a body corporate is also a person. Therefore, the natural question would be asked in a court of law, if you were. attempting to interpret this in the way the Minister suggested: "Why did you specifically exempt a body corporate, because it is also a person?" In other words, by negative implication, there must be an intention to exclude a religious body, because "person" includes all these classes that you specifically mentioned including a body corporate. Therefore by negative implication it appears that you intended to exclude from the benefits of the exemption a body unincorporate.
There is no need to labour that point. I would ask the Minister to have that examined into again as this might have very serious repercussions apart from unfairly operating against such bodies as charitable institutions. For instance, as we know there are certain Orders who have come in here and have been of great benefit to the community by giving certain services. I am thinking of one particular Order which is the only institution in this country to cater for epileptics. They purchase property. They are doing a great national service. It would be very unfair to discriminate against Orders of that nature. That is another reason. If the difficulty should arise and if it became necessary to find a means of evading the clear legal import of this section in order to meet an equitable case of that kind, you are going to open the door completely wide to undeserving people who wish to evade this section. For these reasons, I ask the Minister, notwithstanding that Deputy O'Connor's amendment has been withdrawn and the matter is not before the House, if he would be good enough to reconsider the whole question again.
Comment on this
That is like a six-mark question. Will the Minister try to get one mark in the answer? Can he answer that question as to the legal estate business?
Comment on this
Deputy McGilligan will know how much is in the point and how much is not. I have only asked the Minister if the matter could be considered on Report.
Comment on this
There is no use in Deputy McGilligan being so clever. Deputy McGilligan is a lawyer and he understands all the legal implications but other people may not.
Comment on this
I am trying to call attention to Deputy de Valera's cleverness and I do not think that I should be pilloried for that. He has knocked the Minister out, to such an extent that he is not answering the case which the Deputy makes. I want to deal with the Minister's point, leaving out the legal aspect. I understand the situation as it presents itself is this: The Minister mentioned the case of two persons buying a house which sells at £2,000 but which is really only a £500 or a £600 house. It is going to be sold round about £2,000 and the Minister takes the case of two people who are going to bid, one provided with £2,020 on the 1 per cent. basis and the other with some higher figure. Then there is an abortive sale. I wonder would the Minister take into consideration the putting of a tax on abortive sales? He would not get much revenue from that source. There have been very few abortive sales because what Deputy de Valera calls the law of supply and demand is so operating that there is no supply and a terrific demand. The Minister makes the point that the man with the £2,000 will bid only £1,900 on the second occasion when the house is offered for sale so that it will still cost him only £2,000 even with the new tax but that would not happen in practice. I have yet to hear of an auction of property at a level of £2,000 which broke down over a matter of £80. In the main, it does not happen.
Deputy de Valera thinks there is a terrific hardship on the man who has a deposit to put down. Twenty-five per cent. is the usual deposit and so a man buying a £600-house, which is now going to cost him £2,000, will have to put down £500. Deputy de Valera thinks that a man such as that will provide the £500 but that when it comes to paying the 25 per cent. deposit on the £100, which will be the new stamp duty, he will find a difficulty in doing so. If the Deputy thinks that a man who is going to pay £2,100 for a house and is prepared to put down a deposit of £500, will shirk putting down a deposit of £525, I think he is living in the clouds. I do not think that situation arises.
I cannot yet see the force of the argument which tends in the direction of proving that the vendor is going to pay these prices, the law of supply and demand being what it is. The demand being what it is and the supply of houses being what it is at the moment, people are not going to stop short because of an extra £100. It is coming out of the purchaser's pocket and I do not think anybody believes otherwise.
Comment on this
The Minister gave an example of a man who went to a building society to get a loan. That is not out of his pocket. That is what he may in future years find it possible to pay out of his pocket. Is anybody going to fail to buy a house for the difference between £100 that he may have to pay at some future date and the £20 that he would have to pay before this tax came into operation? The man is going to pay £2,100 or £2,020, as it would have been before the additional tax was imposed, for a house that formerly was worth only £500. The fact is that money has lost all its value.
I was interested to hear that Deputy de Valera believes with me that the 25 per cent. tax on the foreigner, described in our Bill as a man who is not an Irish citizen, is going to be evaded. However, he pats himself on the back that, as a Deputy, he puts his duty as a Deputy before that of his interest as a lawyer. But he has not an amendment down to block one of the ways in which, apparently, he thinks it is possible for people to find a way to get over the 25 per cent. tax.
Comment on this
You could not draft anything comprehensive enough to do that.
Comment on this
There you are again. The Minister must recognise that argument of his own Deputies, that if you drafted a bookful of amendments you could not prevent the evasion of the 25 per cent. Is that not what it comes to? Then we are going to tax the foreigner. Before this ends I want to give the Minister a three-mark question: what is an Irish citizen? Can he tell me?
Comment on this
I was interested to hear Deputy McGilligan setting out his proofs of how it was that the purchaser will always pay this duty of 4 per cent. over and above what he had to pay a short time ago. I do not believe that Deputy McGilligan proved it even to his own satisfaction.
Comment on this
I make the simple statement given to me by my colleague. The purchaser will pay on a rising market. Is the market not still rising?
Comment on this
He did not tell us that before. Of course, Deputy Dockrell knows quite well when the purchaser pays and when the vendor pays. There are occasions when the purchaser pays and other occasions when the vendor will pay. The burden of the argument on a previous occasion in regard to this tax had reference to a certain type of person in the city or in some town in Ireland who wanted to buy a house to live in. These were the types referred to, not the farmer down the country who wanted to buy a patch of land. Say that the types who attend these auctions are limited in means in both cases.
Comment on this
Their means are limited. You cannot have it both ways. We are told about people of limited means who want to set up houses. Either their means are limited or they are not. If Deputy O'Connor and I, as men of limited means, attend in the salerooms —say that we are men with salaries of £4, £5 or £6 per week-each of us bids to the extent of his means. The vendor is selling for the best price he can get. Very definitely he pays the duty there.
Comment on this
Your argument falls to the ground if there are people attending the sales who can buy at sky-high prices. They pay then. If there are people attending these sales who have an unlimited purse and who are going to buy the property under any conditions these people will pay. They pay at that stage—the purchasers pay.
Comment on this
Question put: "That the Bill do now pass."
Do you agree with this result?