Vote 52—Office of the Minister for Lands (Resumed).
Contributions 1–159 of 295. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
A Chinn Comhairle, ar phointe mínithe, ar eagla go mbéadh mí-thuiscint san méd adúras inné, ar cheist cigireachta i gCoimisiún na Talún, ba mhaith liom cead d'fháil uait an cheist a léiriú.
In the course of my remarks last night I made a statement which seemed an aspersion on a Land Commission official. I referred to the practice of inspectors calling on local councillors, clergymen, school teachers, etc., and may I add now, Deputies of all Parties. I referred to an inspector calling on a Fine Gael councillor in a particular area and being accompanied by that councillor to a local bog, which was subsequently divided; I referred to the fact that I did not consider that the most deserving applicants got the banks. May I say now that an inspector must call on someone for local direction and that it is right and proper that he should consult with local representatives; that in his recommendations he uses his own judgment, and, in the ultimate award, that the commissioners take all the factors and circumstances into account.
I think the Minister will find, if he has the time, that when one of his predecessors was in office I submitted a tabulated statement of the estates that I considered should be acquired or resumed in County Westmeath. With that statement I submitted a list of applicants whom I considered the most deserving in the area. Side by side with the names of the applicants I set out their circumstances, the numbers in their families, etc., and whether they were uneconomic holders. Many of these estates have now been divided, but not 10 per cent. of the people whom I recommended have got holdings. Naturally, I am dissatisfied and I want to say to new Deputies on the Government Benches that if they think they will get political kudos out of the work of the Land Commission they will find themselves running on to the rocks and shoals. No commission can satisfy all the applicants for land. I was glad to hear one Deputy on the Government side of the House state that this is a national issue and that it should be approached in a national way.
As regards migration, I have been always wholeheartedly behind the policy of migration. In my area you have a people translated from an area where the system of farming was entirely different from that in County Meath and County Kildare. Heretofore, they worked with the spade and the sickle and they have now to accustom themselves to horses, ploughs and mowing machines. As a Deputy who has represented his constituency for ten and a half years, I want to say that the migrants from Connemara and Mayo have proved an unqualified success. They work their holdings according to the best system of husbandry. In many cases they have taken conacre or land on the 11 months' system. As Davis said, they are Irish of the Irish, neither Saxon nor Italian. When the Minister is contemplating further schemes in County Meath I would ask him to take into account the claims of the married sons of the migrants who, in many cases, are now living in the houses of their parents. I would make a suggestion to the Minister that in future the Land Commission, when they are dividing land, should endeavour to group the houses in village formation and avoid the making of too many roads, thus giving the people a communal life.
Comment on this
In that way they can have the benefits of rural electrification and of a common water system in addition to other amenities such as a school and a hall, or a school and hall combined, for lectures. That has been partly attempted in Rathcarn and Gibbstown, but I think that the system should be perfected. You will not have too many roads when you group the landholders together in a village. I think it has been achieved in parts of the Continent where they have grouped the landholders in villages and have avoided the boreen as much as possible.
Comment on this
Would the Deputy not think that the grouping of the houses too closely together would be undesirable?
Comment on this
I think it would be very desirable to get them as close as possible together. If you lay on a pipe water system you will want them together and if you establish a school in the new village the houses should be near the school. In addition, if the houses are too scattered the Electricity Supply Board will probably put up an objection to including them in the rural electrification scheme. We, in the Midlands, fully appreciate the benefit of land division. Cases have been put up again and again and I think the Minister for Agriculture is suspect in defending the existence of the large farm. We know to our benefit in the towns and villages of Meath and Westmeath that when an estate is divided in the vicinity of the town the trade doubles—the population is there and the butcher, the baker and the candlestick maker get their slice out of it. The small economic farmer knocks more out of an acre of land than the big farmer because, taking it all in all, he lives for his land. He has no other interests and he manures and cultivates it to the last letter. He knocks more barrels of wheat or oats or barley, as the case may be, out of the acre than his neighbour on the large farm who must use mechanism and do things in a big way. Therefore, we who represent the Midlands are very anxious to see as many economic small farms established as possible.
I heard a lot of talk from all sides of the House about demesne walls. We should not let our prejudice run away with our judgment in this matter. The great menace, as I was trying to explain last night, is the chain rancher who has farms in every parish from Athlone to Drogheda. I am speaking of the man who has a 200-acre farm here; a 250-acre farm there; a 500-acre farm in East Meath and a 400-acre farm in the west part of Meath. All he has on them is a herd, a man and a dog, living perhaps in a cottage or in a house which is unfit for human habitation. Very often, on the other hand, the landlord lives on his home estate which was probably built from the point of view of scenery and not always on the best land. The estate is surrounded by woods which were planted in marshy land and bog land and, if he is resident there, he cultivates his land and gives the maximum amount of employment. Such is not the case with the gentleman I am talking about whom nobody heeds, who is slick, and who knows how to keep every Party on his side. I consider that the landlord is an asset. I am not making a defence of landlords because I would not care if they were gone in the morning but why declare war on them whilst the chain rancher operates all over the Midlands?
Several Deputies, with whom I agree, have made the observation that in their area, whilst the Land Commission in the past has been breaking up ranches and bringing people from Gaeltacht areas into places such as Rathcarn and Gibbstown, the small economic farmer is disappearing. The 30-acre, 40-acre or 50-acre man is disappearing. He is selling out and his neighbour is buying his farm in the open market. While ranches are being smashed up on the one hand they are being created on the other. I know this is a world problem. I know that it is happening in Australia, in the United States of America and, in fact, all over the world. It is, however, a matter that the people of this nation, if they want to keep the population in rural Ireland, will have to think seriously about. I myself cannot see a solution to the problem unless the sale of farms is stopped and there again you are trading on dangerous ground. I would, however, earnestly draw the attention of the Minister and of the Land Commission and of the members of this House to this problem which needs to be solved urgently.
I opened my remarks by dealing with the matter with which I am most concerned, namely, the question of the bogs that were acquired during the emergency and that have been let year after year to cottiers, workers and small farmers. Under an emergency powers Order these bogs were taken over by the local county councils and let to these people. It is vital to these people to have their own turf. It is not a very big job and I am asking the Land Commission to act this winter and begin to take over these banks and give them to the cottiers and labourers who need them so very much and who will work them to the last letter. Sin a bhfuil agam le rá.
Comment on this
Before the Deputy sits down I should like to clear up a point. He mentioned "chain ranchers", as he described them——
Comment on this
I would be very thankful if the Deputy would bring to my notice any of these of whom he may know.
Comment on this
I have spent the last two days listening to this debate on lands which comes before this House every year and for the past three years I have listened to the same speeches. I must confess that when I think of the enthusiasm and the eagerness of every single Deputy who has spoken over these past three years and in particular during the past two days, and of their anxiety for the relief of congestion, I am forced to wonder that, with all the representations that must have been made over the last 25 or 26 years, anything is left now for the Land Commission to do. We must realise that, in spite of all the wishful thinking and all the pious hopes and resolutions in the wide world and all the help and encouragement that Deputies in this House can give and have given—because whatever else we may differ in politically we all agree that congestion, or the rural slum, must be cleared up and straightened out once and for all—something, over which this Dáil has no control, is wrong when the problem of congestion has not been solved many years ago.
No Deputy would safely stand up here and say that congestion should be left as it is. If a Deputy said such a thing in this Parliament, I expect there would be a dozen members from all Parties waiting to lynch him outside the doors. Where does the fault lie? It is not in the good intentions of Deputies here. It certainly lies in the Land Commission. We take up the Book of Estimates and we see that for the next year £1,395,575 will be made available to relieve congestion, that being, as we are told, the principal object of the Land Commission. Some of us who have sense enough to understand congestion thoroughly know that within the next year very little will be done to relieve it. Anybody who thinks that that amount of money from the Exchequer will relieve congestion and bring small farmers' holdings up to an economic size—anybody who imagines that that amount will be sufficient—is very wide of the mark.
If congestion is to be relieved, land must be got from somewhere. We are told that in order to bring farmers' holdings up to economic units we must take land from those who have it, and the amount of land available is what we have to decide. No Minister or commissioner could tell us what amount of land can be made available next year for the relief of congestion. In this country for the past 100 years— and it will happen in the years to come —there has always been chopping and changing of farms and holdings from one set of individuals to another. People residing on holdings will die and those places will become derelict or vacant. Will the Land Commission take that land? When we look at the situation that way, we cannot say definitely that there will be a certain amount of land available within the coming year for the purposes of the Land Commission.
I was surprised to hear the last Deputy saying that there are still some of what he calls the chain rancher element in this country. Some of us who travel from the West through the Midlands can observe the amount of land available and the amount that could be taken over, not this year or last year, but 25 years ago, and given to the congested holders of the West. It is still there, and there is no use in saying that the land pool shows any sign of running out. It does not. There is more waste land in the Midlands than would keep many families who are now hemmed in on congested, bad land, in perfect contentment and prosperity.
I have a unique experience. Without fear of contradiction, I can say that I am the only Deputy who, up to three years ago, was forced to make a living on an uneconomic holding, with less than a £10 valuation. If Deputies saw the number of people who are struggling on such holdings in the constituency from which I and, indeed, the Minister comes, they would understand how it is that on the Order Paper every day questions are put down by Deputies from the province of Connacht in an effort to get the Land Commission to bring justice to where injustice has so long been left.
We have had a statement from the Minister. I have every confidence that the Minister will use his best efforts, because he, as well as myself and other western Deputies, knows the problem that has to be tackled. I have every confidence in him, but I have none in the system under which the Land Commission is working. That body has been almost an absolute failure for the past 25 or 26 years. It cannot overnight get itself into active motion in order to put an end to this cancer that lies on the face of the country.
It is only wishful thinking to expect that congestion will be relieved under the system by which the Land Commission operates. We have had many changes in the methods adopted to relieve congestion. The old Congested Districts Board, which was given to us by an alien Government and over which Sir Henry Doran presided, did more good along the western seaboard in ten years than our own native Government with its Land Commission has done in 26 years. Whether it is the fault of the Government that has just gone out or the Government that went before it, the Land Commission seems to be bound hand and foot in red tape and legality. They take so long to arrive at decisions that in many cases people who set out years ago expecting to be relieved in regard to their small farms are dead and forgotten.
The Minister said that during the past year the Land Commission moved sometimes slowly and sometimes in an accelerated way. I think if he said that the Land Commission has described a complete circle, and a very small one at that, and failed to arrive anywhere, he would be saying something which some of us know to be true. He said that despite all the activity, congestion still remains. Plenty of congestion remains. The Land Commission made very little effort in the last year to solve the problem or satisfy the people on congested holdings. The former Minister for Lands, Deputy Moylan, told us last year that the whole purpose of the Land Commission was the relief of congestion. In his opening statement the present Minister said that the commission was there solely for the relief of congestion. Every Deputy who has spoken did not dwell so much on the other things the Land Commission have to do, such as vesting and one or other of their side-lines, as he did on their duty to solve the rural slum problem.
I believe we will not make much progress next year. The section of the community who have lived in hope so long, who have seen two Governments changing, are still waiting for the coveted two or three acres which would be so beneficial to them, yet which never seem to come within their grasp. Several Deputies may be inclined to think that the small uneconomic holders are a greedy and avaricious crowd who want to snap up all the land that is going. That is not the case. I have lived in the midst of those people and it is very little that would satisfy them and give them economic units. The average man who lives on less than £10 worth of land and who has to buy conacre, paying £8 to £10 an acre for it—who has had to pay that in some cases for ten, 15 or 20 years— will not mind at all if he can in time get that two or three acres which will satisfy him so easily. Then when we look at the value of an acre of land if it is purchased in the open market, it may be £50 or £60, while £150 or £200 worth of land, given once in a lifetime, will satisfy for all time the call and cry of the uneconomic holder. We should see that they are the most easily satisfied body of people or workers in this country compared with the increases which wage earners all over this island have been demanding—and rightly so —over the past two or three years. They have a court to go to and their claims are tried almost at once. Within a month or two months they know the decision of the court. They know that they have either got the increases or that they have been refused, but the poor uneconomic holder, as always, has no court to go to and he is appealing and pleading with his representatives and the Deputies here but those appeals and pleas have fallen on the deaf ears of the people who constitute the Irish Land Commission. They are, in my opinion, the real defaulters and delayers in this project which should have been settled long ago.
The commissioners who took over in 1933 to take political pull away from the Government of the day are what you would call a body of men who are neither of use nor an ornament to any country under the rising sun. I do not approve of political influence in regard to the distribution or acquisition of land, and the Minister at the time, or the Fianna Fáil Government, in all fairness to them, thought that if a certain number of commissioners were given absolute power in the three things which are most essential in this matter, the land to be acquired, those who are to get the land, and the price to be paid for it, they would have a better and cleaner type of land acquisition and land division. Instead of that, we find that not a single one of those commissioners has the slightest understanding of the work which he is supposed to do. They tour all over the country and sit in land courts for the past 15 or 16 years and in very many cases do much more harm than good in the localities they sit in.
Comment on this
I do, Sir. I do not want to go outside the debate if I possibly can, but I can also try to point out that there must be some reason for bothering about this debate in the House at all. The blame must be left on somebody's shoulders.
Comment on this
You had better tell the Minister all about it. It is not fair to attack civil servants here, as they have no come-back.
Comment on this
Very well, but the decisions and the system which have ruled the Irish Land Commission should long ago have been altered. I say this now to the Minister: unless he is prepared to introduce legislation into this House within the next 12 months he is only wasting his time telling the people all over the West of Ireland and everywhere else that congestion is going to be ended and that a settlement of the problem will be brought about in this country.
The size of the economic holding has been talked about so very often that it is very doubtful to know what really is the size of an economic holding. Everybody knows that on one side of the fence you have farmers with 15 or 20 acres of land with a valuation of £10 or £15 who will make a great success of them, while on the other side you have farms of maybe 50, 60 or 100 acres with a £100 valuation and the farmers will not be able to carry on or meet the everyday calls of life. The man who is on the land is the deciding factor as to what is the size of an economic holding. But this we do know, and some of us know it particularly, that anything less than 35 statute acres is no use to anybody to try to make a living on, absolutely none whatever. Then we are faced with the problem of whether there are 35 acres all round for uneconomic holders in the country. I doubt if there are. I am in agreement with the ex-Minister for Lands that we should not make cabbage patches of land that is to be divided. If we are to make economic holdings, let us make them economic and not create more congestion and more slums instead of relieving the slums that are already there. In Meath and Westmeath tenants and migrants who came from the West were put into holdings, and last week I travelled through one of those settlements to see for myself how well they were getting on. Like Deputy Kennedy, who spoke, I found everywhere contentment and satisfaction, except one slight complaint that the 22 or 25 statute acres which they got were not anything like sufficient, and that they should at least have got ten acres more in order to give them that sense of security that they felt they were entitled to. I would say this to the Minister, as he has the powers that are necessary to get, as he described it, "slightly accelerated" within the coming year, if he decides to bring any more migrants from the West he should take every 100 acres as a unit and divide it into three little economic holdings, each comprising 30 or maybe 35 acres, as the case may be. If one tenant happens to get better quality land, then he could do with an acre or two less. But if he divides every 100 acres into three units, he will have met with the entire approval of economic holders and migrants.
Now, to come back to County Mayo where we have a very serious problem which has caused plenty of unrest, disturbance and bad feeling in the county for a good many years. I have never denied the fact that for the past 15 years I created more disturbance, or as much disturbance as I could, in an effort to get the Land Commission to relieve the congestion and to do their duty. We have very many farms in County Mayo which should be divided and I want to point out here that I have had on the Order Paper every day for the past three years more questions in regard to land than any half a dozen Deputies in the House put together. I have never put down a question to ask the Minister or the Land Commission to acquire land from any man who is resident or making a living on the land in question, and that applies to questions I have put down asking the Minister to take over holdings from as low as five acres to as high as 750 acres which are still left in Mayo. We look over County Mayo and we find this position in it. We will start with a ranch owned by the Rt. Hon. Lord Oranmore and Browne of 1,500 acres, just outside Claremorris. We go on then and find Garret Nally of Roundfort with a farm of 650 acres which he never tilled or worked or never would work until inspectors of the Department of Agriculture were at his door night, noon and morning. We have beside him Joseph Hession who has 350 acres and who refused to till his land last year, with the result that it was taken over by the Department of Agriculture for tillage purposes and he was prosecuted. Then, within 250 yards of my own door, is a farm of 300 acres the property of John Kennedy and which was formerly the property of ex-Senator McEllin. That man purchased that land which should have been taken over for the relief of congestion and is now letting it in conacre to people in the locality and getting £8, £9 and £10 per acre for it. He has not the slightest intention of tilling it himself. Next year, when the compulsory tillage regulations are withdrawn, I can assure the House that none of these gentlemen will let a small tenant farmer inside his wall or gate, because cattle are very easy to look after and they will be much more profitable to these ranchers than letting people in on the land to till it.
Yesterday I had a question down in relation to the farm of Michael Begley, Facefield, who owns three separate farms totalling about 315 acres. Tenants in my own locality being, as they thought, as just as they could, urged the Land Commission to take the smallest of these farms, a farm of 57 acres which has a separate record number and receipt with the Land Commission. That man has fought the Land Commission for 13 years and has them now in the position that he can snap his fingers at them and say: "I defy you to take the land off me." Yesterday I got the same answer which was given to ex-Deputy Nally in this House about 13 years ago. The position is still the same or, rather, slightly more in favour of the rancher who has this land. So many Land Acts have been passed and there are so many sections which clever lawyers and able counsel can punch pot-holes in that the rancher feels that he is happy on his broad acres and can snap his fingers at the Land Commission. He can appeal so many times against resumption; he can appeal against the price offered; he can demand to be given a holding in exchange and he can keep on doing that year after year. I once thought that there was a limit of seven alternative farms which such a man could refuse before he could be migrated. I am told now that that is not the case, that he can keep on refusing holding after holding as long as he wishes. These are the snags which are holding up the Land Commission and which have left small tenant farmers on uneconomic holdings and in the same position as tenant farmers were 50 years ago.
There are some strange things happening in this country. The strangest of all is that illustrated by the film, "Captain Boycott", which was shown all over Ireland. When I tell the House that Lough Mask House with a 600-acre farm, where Captain Boycott resided and where he was boycotted, is still in the same position as it was in his time, I am sure Deputies will open their eyes in wonder and say that the children and the grandchildren of the poor people who set the headline in these times must be very disappointed that they have not got a slice of this land which their forefathers fought for so long ago.
I was very interested during the general election campaign when I came to Dublin and listened to a spokesman of a certain political Party who is now a Deputy saying that if the slum dwellers in the cities and the slum dwellers in the country formed a union they would be able to force the hands of any Government, no matter what that Government believed in. I am glad to see that there has been an awakening to the fact that something must be done in that way. On many occasions I have tried to get uneconomic holders in my constituency and county to form a union and demand their rights as a united body. But it is a very hard job, in fact it is the hardest thing in the world, because these poor unfortunate people will follow blindfold any political Party which promises them land or assistance or relief from the way in which they are at present living. Progress cannot be made by wishful thinking. It can only be made by facing up to facts.
The big trouble is in connection with the political side of this problem. I have seen it in connection with the present Government. In 1933, when the Fianna Fáil Party took over the Government of this country and were sincere and honest and determined to see that this land problem should be solved with the utmost rapidity, they had as their friends every smallholder and as their enemies every rancher in the country. Slowly and surely, however, the position changed and, in 1948, in the constituency which I represent I found that 99.9 per cent. of the ranchers of the locality were loyal and enthusiastic supporters of the Fianna Fáil Party and that 95 per cent. of the uneconomic holders were up in arms against the Fianna Fáil Party because of their failure to provide them with what they wanted. The same thing will occur again. I do not deny the fact that already I have been approached by some of these ranchers, with regard to whose lands I have put down questions in this House, who said: "Now that you are a supporter of the Government our cheque books will be available to you at the next election. Do not make any move in regard to our lands. Make as good a thing as you can out of the land question at election time and we will back you, but, when the election is over, do not say anything about our farms". This Government may find themselves in that position. Men in the Cabinet will be approached by the rancher element in an effort to stop them from taking over their land for the relief of congestion. If that happens to this Government, the present Minister, whose intentions are as good as and maybe better than my own, will find himself in the position which Deputy Flanagan spoke of yesterday. He will find himself on the same side as the ex-Minister for Lands is, with very few sympathisers and very little sympathy from this House.
We have heard it stated in debates in this House that all farms should be of equal size. That was hinted at by a Deputy yesterday. It seems to be the cry of some uneconomic holders that no man should have 50 or 60 acres while another man has only ten. We realise that that is humbug, that you will always have farms of different acreage and different valuation. The object should be to see that a farm which is not worked properly and, above all, a farm which is untenanted should be taken over as quickly as possible and made available to people who are willing to work it.
Comment on this
By introducing legislation, and, if it is not introduced, we are only wasting our breath here. Another matter which Deputy Fagan mentioned is that the price paid by the Land Commission for land at present is not satisfactory. I know that in saying that I agree with that it may be interpreted as a statement slightly favouring the larger farmers and the ranchers. Everybody knows how little respect I have for ranchers of every description, but we must be fair and agree that the prices paid by the Land Commission at present are not satisfactory. Land owners who would ultimately get this land and who have at present to pay through the nose for conacre, which they will never own, would be only too delighted to pay a little extra if the time for repayment of the purchase money were extended by 50 or 60 years. The burden of repayment would then be handed down to posterity who would equally benefit from the land. I think the Land Commission should give a bigger price, not anything like the market value, but definitely a bigger price than they have been giving recently.
Comment on this
It is not confiscation. The Land Commission are not paying the market value at the present time and it is not considered confiscation.
Comment on this
If you take property from any man and do not pay him the value of it, that is confiscation.
Comment on this
Why not charge the Land Commission with being Communistic? I am afraid nobody would allege that against them.
Comment on this
You are only making a fool of yourself, as far as I can see. I do not think there is much more to be said about this problem. We have listened too long, too patiently, and perhaps unfairly at times, to utterances in this House with regard to the land problem, but we have this big body calling itself the Irish Land Commission, a big, worthless, lazy body, tied up in red tape, wound up in Acts of Parliament with thousands of loopholes of which able lawyers can take advantage. That body will never solve the land problem of the country. I do not know whether it is the intention of the present Minister to have a shot at giving us some new legislation.
Comment on this
I am afraid then, Sir, you must have been out of the Chamber and that somebody else was in the Chair. They are all of the same opinion as myself, especially the younger Deputies—that the Land Commission has grown old and worthless and that it must be scrapped in favour of something new. We have only to pick up the daily papers and read what is happening on the Continent of Europe to realise the danger that threatens this country if something is not done. Already we have seen an election in Italy where there were two factions fighting for power. The faction we most like won, but the cry on both sides was the division of large estates and the establishment of the people on the land. While the faction who lost promised much quicker results than the faction who won, we now find that even the anti-Communist group who form the Government of Italy have achieved absolute wonders with regard to the amount of land they have made available for the people and the number of peasant proprietors created in that country. We do not need anything so drastic here. We have our own Government and our own system, but surely we can operate some system by which fairness will be meted out to everybody.
I desire to say a word about the duties of Land Commission inspectors. The duty of a Land Commission inspector when land is acquired in a certain area is to go into the locality and examine the claims of all the people who he thinks are entitled to land but I fail to see why that Land Commission official should be wasting his time, as I have seen a Land Commission official wasting his time for the past three weeks in my locality interviewing people who already own farms with valuations of from £15 to £25 and asking them do they want land, while in the next village there are other people with valuations ranging from 30/- to £4, £5 and £6 and he will not go near them. Have the Land Commission officials no regard for the valuations of claimants for land? Do they not know that their duty should be to pick out a district of, say, a mile radius around a farm which has been acquired and see who are the tenants to whom additions should be given or who are the most suitable to be migrated? These officials are bound up in red tape. They jog along at the same old trot which old dogs acquire and, mind you, it will be very hard to break them off the old routine unless they get a very rude awakening in the near future.
Political pull has been alleged against the Party in opposition in so far as the division of land is concerned and we were told that the best qualification a man could have was membership of a Fianna Fáil club but, in fairness, I will say that I would much prefer to see members or secretaries of Fianna Fáil clubs getting such land than that the ranchers should be allowed to have it. All I want is to see the land taken from the ranchers and divided amongst deserving applicants. These ranchers should not be allowed to keep their broad acres as they kept them for so many years. The Land Commission, however, should be free from political influence and there has been political influence used by the Fianna Fáil Party. I am perfectly aware of that and I can give anybody the name of a farm which was divided on political lines.
Comment on this
I will name the McEllin estate at Brize where three people living on uneconomic holdings were taken and shown three different holdings of land. A scheme was prepared but when the whole thing was taken over, landless men, who are sixth on the list to be considered, were brought into this congested area and given these holdings.
Comment on this
Whether the Minister replies or not that is so. I live within a stone's throw of them and I know what I am talking about.
Comment on this
Are not the commissioners responsible for the division of land and, therefore, is not an argument about the division of land an attack on the commissioners?
Comment on this
The Deputy has been so informed already, but he does not seem to appreciate it. The land is divided by a commissioner, who is a civil servant, and not by the Minister.
Comment on this
On a point of order, the Deputy has stated categorically that in connection with this particular farm of land political influence was brought to bear. A Deputy on this side of the House suggested that the Minister might look into this particular case, in which the name has now been given, and inform the House as to the true position.
Comment on this
The point of order is that I do not think the Deputy meant to attack officials in his reference but that he wanted to substantiate his suggestion that there was political influence.
Comment on this
The fact of the matter is that the commissioners have statutory powers independent of the Minister and the allegation is that they were influenced to go against their better judgment.
Comment on this
I cannot see any harm in a Deputy raising a matter in this House if there appears to be something strange in it when it comes to his notice. I take it that the time to do that is during the debate here, thereby giving the Minister an opportunity of clearing the air.
Comment on this
That is quite right, but the Deputy has not raised a matter like that. He has made very definite and positive allegations.
Comment on this
If the local inspectors are left to carry out their duties their first object will be to raise anybody under a £10 valuation in a particular locality and to give those people an increased holding. That is their simple duty. It is an easy one. If there is not sufficient land in the locality then those people must be given land in some other locality where land is available. I believe that the inspectors, if left alone, will carry out their duties properly and efficiently. I want the Minister to do away with all political influence. Every Deputy will be approached to make representations on behalf of certain applicants. We all do that. We shall continue to do it. No man in this House, Minister or anybody else, can say that he has never made such a recommendation on behalf of an applicant. It is the duty of Deputies to look into the merits or demerits of applicants. Applicants will always have my support and my assistance and, should the occasion arise, my criticism. I come from the same constituency as the Minister but I want him to treat my representations on behalf of applicants in the same way as he would treat the representations of any other Deputy in this House. If he does not do that the whole problem of land division will be left in the unsatisfactory position in which it has been for the last 25 years.
I would stress on the Minister the fact that it is not good policy in a congested district to allow a man to purchase a derelict holding in the hope that he will get relief from the Land Commission at some future date. More people should not be allowed into the congested areas. It would be wrong to allow this debate on lands to pass without mentioning the famous cottage farm on the Irwin estate.
Comment on this
There, there is a problem which could have been solved quite easily a year ago. It will now present considerable difficulty, because the owner is there. This farm has been purchased and the owner is living there. He will have to be provided with a holding in exchange. I would never advocate throwing him out on the side of the road. He must get a holding elsewhere. I do not blame the present Minister for that situation. I blame the stubbornness of his predecessor. The present Minister and the commissioners have inspected this famous farm at Ballyhaunis. The sooner they give a decision in this case the better. If a decision is not given the Minister's part will be no easy one while tenants are left there in congestion.
I want to refer now to the workmen and gangers employed by the Land Commission. I have had complaints from these that they have not received increases in wages to which they are entitled. Some men have got very big increases as compared with the last 20 years, but I find that the gangers have been rather badly treated in this matter. In nine cases out of ten these gangers are very competent men and carry out their work very efficiently. We all know that Land Commission gangers give a greater value in work done than do the gangers employed by the county councils and the local authorities. Sometimes these gangers have to remain away from home at considerable expense to themselves. They are not paid for the week's holiday which they get. They are not paid for church holidays. That seems to me rather unfair. I hope the Minister will do something to rectify that situation.
I have every confidence that the present Minister for Lands will do his utmost to bring about a solution to this problem. I am convinced, having listened to the debate here, that in his efforts to solve the problem he will have the support of every Deputy in this House. We are all interested in the relief of congestion. I maintain that the Minister will have to introduce legislation in order to change the system of land acquisition, land division, resettlement and everything else. Until he does that he will make no progress.
Comment on this
It is very easy for Deputies to get up and start throwing muck across the House because they always live in the hope, as they did in the past, that some of it will stick. Several Deputies sitting on the Government Benches have made statements to the effect that the Land Commission have been dividing land in the past, or during the Fianna Fáil régime at any rate, on the basis of political influence. When we ask them to give us an instance they shelve the reply straight away because the reply we want is the name of the individual of the political Party to which they refer, the name of the individual who made the recommendation, and the name of the individual responsible for the fact that a certain man who was not entitled to a holding of land got one. I challenge the Minister to get the Land Commission to go over all the records of the Land Commission and to point out to us, at any stage, a holding of land that was ever given to any individual purely on the basis of political connections with the organisation to which I have the honour to belong. I have the honour of being a Deputy for about 21 years. During every day, week, month and year of these years I have been continually advocating the acquisition or the resumption of holdings for distribution among the uneconomic landholders of this country. I must have, during all these years, recommended hundreds and hundreds of people to the Land Commission who were deserving applicants for holdings of land. I have not the slightest hesitation in saying so and if any of these applicants succeeded in getting holdings of land it cannot be held that it was because of political influence. When a man calls to me about a holding of land I do not ask him the name of the political organisation to which he belongs, but I do ask him his valuation. I do not think the Land Commission will discover on their records any recommendation by me in any case of a valuation higher than £10 or £12.
The question the Minister must answer is whether Fianna Fáil Deputies used political influence to obtain holdings of land for their followers. Nearly every Deputy in this House has recommended the applications of people for land. Every Deputy here must have in his constituency people whom he has recommended. There must be people there who got holdings of land, perhaps not on his recommendation, but that is not to say that he did not make a recommendation for it.
Comment on this
Those who are throwing muck across this House at the Fianna Fáil Party are the very people who go down the country and say: "I am the man who can get a farm of land for you. I can do this and I can do that. Do not bother to go to this fellow or to that fellow." I can quote instances of where that has happened, and on many occasions too. If the people who are sitting behind the Minister and who are helping this Cumann na nGaedheal Government to-day would sit up and realise that slinging muck is not going to help to get rid of the grievances that exist among our people, it would be better for them. It is not our duty to create the impression outside that everything anybody sitting on the Fianna Fáil Benches did was by way of political influence only and that they forgot all about the community in general. Our record can be stood over by any Government. If the present Government, when they are going out of office, have nearly as clean a record as the Fianna Fáil Government had when they left office the people of this Government will be proud.
Comment on this
Anybody who goes into the Library and takes up Volume 105 of the Official Report of the Dáil Debates and goes over the Minister's speech on this Vote last year will be amazed, to say the least of it, and terribly disappointed with the speech with which he opened this debate a few days ago. Deputy Blowick, as he was at that time, said that the Minister should not come to this House and ask for a sum of less than £1,400,000 —according to him the Minister should have asked for a sum of £6,000,000 or £7,000,000. In Deputy Blowick's opinion the then Minister for Lands and the Department of Lands were a huge joke.
Comment on this
I would advise Deputy S. Collins to read the speech while he is waiting. It will do him good and it will prevent him from interrupting.
Comment on this
Because if the Deputy keeps on with that jumbling much longer I will not know what figure I asked for.
Comment on this
It is the figure for this year. The Minister must know his own Estimate. Instead of coming to this House and asking for the sum he suggested last year, the Minister is asking for £1,399,570. There is a big difference between that sum and £6,000,000 or £7,000,000. The Minister has not made the brave attempt we thought he was going to make to settle the land problem which, he said, could be got rid of in seven or eight years. Deputy Moylan was told by him last year that this problem could be solved within ten years. I am not making these points because I know the Minister cannot do very much——
Comment on this
If Deputy Collins has established himself as the official interrupter in this House I must say that he would be better off if he were to keep his mouth closed.
Comment on this
The Chair will not tolerate persistent interruptions. New Deputies must learn that this is a deliberative Assembly which does not include deliberate interruptions.
Comment on this
I do not expect that the Minister is able to work miracles in this question of land division. I would have expected, however, that when the present Minister, as Deputy Blowick and as Leader of a Party in this House, was speaking as Leader of his Party he would have been in a position to realise as well as any of us that the Minister was merely responsible for answering for the Department of Lands rather than dictating to it how land should or should not be divided, because he was not in a position to do that.
Comment on this
Directing policy is a different thing. I know the Minister is responsible for certain things, but he is not responsible for the division of every acre of land in the country. The Minister at that time referred to what Deputy Commons mentioned as the famous farm outside Claremorris. He referred to Deputies having to take certain action that would not have to be taken if it were not for the fact that when those Deputies took up the matter with the Land Commission they got back an acknowledgment saying that the matter was receiving attention. That practice has not changed in the Land Commission offices and I do not think there is any hope of it changing, because we are still getting those letters.
Comment on this
The Minister is given as having made that statement in column 2195 of Volume 105 of the Parliamentary Debates. In making a reference to Deputies of the House having been imprisoned, the Minister said that they had taken those things up with the Land Commission and all the action the Land Commission took was to write saying that the matter was receiving attention. I am taking that from the Official Report. If that can be contradicted, let it be. I wonder how the Minister would now regard the action of people who would knock down walls and encourage others to smash up local ranches? I wonder what action he would take if a number of people were now to do something similar?
Comment on this
I did it in my day, and that is what the Minister cannot say. Reference was also made at that time by the Minister to derelict holdings, left by people who went to England or America or somewhere else. He suggested that the then Minister should encourage the Land Commission to acquire these holdings for distribution. What is the Minister's policy in that direction now? Is he prepared to direct the Land Commission to take over those holdings? If he is, we can expect him to step in very soon.
There is another burning question to which the Minister then referred and that is the subdivision of the land that still remains in the hands of the Land Commission. That is something on which we all agreed then and on which we all agree to-day. I sincerely hope the Minister will take steps to see that those lands are divided in the near future.
The Minister made strong statements at that time about bad husbandry on the part of people to whom the Land Commission had let lands. Now that the Land Commission have got back their full staffs, I hope the Minister will see that these lands are immediately subdivided. I agreed with his statement at the time and I agree with it still.
At that time the Minister suggested to the then occupant of the office that if he went about his job properly he would have more land offered voluntarily. What are the Minister's thoughts now in that direction? Has he made any provision to get these lands offered voluntarily? I have time and again—and the Parliamentary Secretary over there also advocated it —suggested the taking over of certain lands in my constituency. We have advocated the taking over of land in that constituency that would be offered voluntarily if the Land Commission would give the people concerned alternative holdings anywhere. No steps have been taken so far in that direction. I hope the Minister will give us an indication that what he said previously has some meaning and was not merely from the mouth out.
A lot of us had to sit here yesterday listening to Deputy Flanagan indulging in one of his usual mud-slinging statements. He referred to lands that were bought by non-nationals during the Fianna Fáil régime. I was interested, because some such statements were made by every member of the present Government. I was anxious to hear the reply given by the Minister for Justice to a question put by Deputy Dr. Brennan the other day. Strong as were the statements that were made here, as well as during the election campaign, there was not a Deputy to ask a supplementary question. If non-nationals are to be stopped from buying land, that will require legislation and I do not want to discuss that now—as a matter of fact, I would not be allowed to. There is a way and a manner of solving that, that the Deputy who is interested can put down a motion here and have a discussion on it.
Comment on this
It is not a lecture, Sir. It is just something to remind Deputies of the statements that were made about Maximoe and Eindiguer and all the rest during the recent election campaign. I remember statements made even since the election that if any of those people put foot on Irish soil they could be put into a plane, or a boat as the case might be, and packed back, bag and baggage, before they would have time to contaminate the soil of the country. In spite of all those statements—and some people made them very strongly— I notice that the Duke of Westminster a fortnight ago purchased a very large holding on the Annesley estate near Maynooth. No stop was put to him because the Minister, I suppose, realises that he has to act now in accordance with the law and that he sees that the wild statements which were made by him and his Party in the days gone by no longer hold good.
Comment on this
Is the Deputy quite accurate now? Is he sure that the estate was not purchased by the Duchess of Westminster, who is an Irish national.
Comment on this
I suppose she is the wife of the Duke. It does not matter if she is his tenth wife, she must be his wife. It is very easy, of course, during elections to make wild statements such as these, particularly for a Party who at that time had not the slightest indication that they would ever be called upon to make them good.
Comment on this
On a point of order, is that the manner in which a Deputy should be addressed in this House?
Comment on this
There are a number of things that the Minister should get at and get at quickly. The question of turbary has been referred to by a number of other Deputies here. We have large tracts of bog all over this country and for years we have been getting after the Land Commission to try to have them distributed amongst people who got holdings from the Land Commission without any turbary, people on holdings where no turbary has yet been made available for them although they have had those holdings for years. I had questions down recently about turbary outside Tuam, where there is a tremendous area of ten or 20 square miles from Belclare to Headford and across to Castlegar and down again into Tuam, an area where no turbary is available, and, I think, although the Minister said that representations were not made, it should not be necessary for the Land Commission to be reminded of something of which they the themselves should be aware of better than anybody else, that is, that there are vast areas in the country where no turbary is available and that the most convenient turbary should be taken over and distributed among the people who have to take the sub-letting of a bank here or there or anywhere they can get it.
There is also the question of roads made by the Land Commission. The Land Commission have the happy knack of making roads, something about eight or ten feet wide and if two carts try to get past they are stuck. Everybody understands the type of road I am referring to.
Comment on this
Surely that is not the case. I put it this way to the Deputy, has he experience of Land Commission roads?
Comment on this
I have experience of Land Commission roads which were made so narrow that two carts cannot pass by on them safely. I could not say whether they are ten feet or 12 feet wide, but I know that two carts cannot pass.
Comment on this
There is also the question of drainage. Again, the Land Commission did promise many years ago to make roads and drains when they were dividing estates and they never made those at all. I wonder is there any prospect or hope of getting some kind of relief grant in order to do that work now? It would be very useful work and would give employment to men who are unemployed at the moment.
A lot of speeches have been made on this Estimate about migrants and I agree with the Deputy who has advocated the migration of the larger landholders in the West of Ireland as being the most economic way of dealing with this problem. We have numbers of people there who would be prepared to migrate if they were facilitated any way reasonably in other places. The smaller types of economic holder that we have are not at all anxious to migrate. They will only migrate when no alternative can be found for them. They would much prefer to be left at home if the Land Commission would only make an effort to take people with a larger amount of land and make it available for distribution amongst the uneconomic landholders. I hope that something will be done now that the Land Commission have not got the excuse that they had in the days gone by, the excuse of the emergency. That was the great excuse and we all quoted it so often that we were often afraid to go into certain areas again as the people would not believe that there was an emergency. That was the excuse for the Land Commission in their do-nothing policy.
Comment on this
That is scarcely fair. You should not leave the blame of Government policy on the commissioners who were only carrying out Government policy.
Comment on this
The Land Commission cannot have the excuse now that we were making in days gone by that their staff was gone and that during the emergency they could not do so and so. I hope to see them getting to work at top speed during the coming year and that when we discuss this Estimate next year we will have relief for all the old complaints which have been haunting us for years and years.
Comment on this
At 3 o'clock yesterday and at 3 o'clock to-day the Ceann Comhairle asked that the Holy Ghost should inspire the Dáil. If some of the speeches which have been delivered are an indication of the help of the Holy Ghost, there should be less politics and less bitterness. This great national question should be faced by the unified efforts of the whole Dáil who should try for a few hours in one day to do really constructive Parliamentary work with the sense of decency and dignity which you should expect from an Irish Parliament and not have language used akin to the kind of buffoonery which caused some of the people in the gallery yesterday to think that that was what Jimmy O'Dea would be expected to do. Was there anything to cause one of the Deputies to call out "jackasses"? My friend, Deputy Killilea, a few moments ago told us that these people were consistent for their muck slinging. Instead of having speeches like that, this most important question should enlist the most serious-minded thought and a higher standard of academic discussion.
Comment on this
I do not want to exculpate him or anybody else. In 1937, I think it was, a responsible document was handed to the then Government and the authenticity of its figures cannot be questioned, because the document came from the Registrar-General. That document called for serious reflection by this Parliament. It was pointed out in that document that rural schools were closing. That was because farmers' sons and daughters had no desire to stay on the land, as it appeared to them uneconomic and farming a life of drudgery and slavery in order to make ends meet. The document also pointed out that between 1926 and the time when the document was issued 60,000 fewer children were registered in the national schools. From then until now we hear people talking about the rapid disappearance of the population from the land.
There is no doubt that for the last quarter of a century there has been an excessive migration of the rural population to our towns and cities. That is bad enough, but the excessive migration of what is left of the rural community to Great Britain and other countries is convincing evidence of a dying civilisation in this country. That is the problem which should be discussed instead of having the hurtful epithets that we have been listening to for the last day and a half. The problem is to get people to remain on the land and to indicate, if possible, to the Minister and the Land Commission ways and means as to how that can be brought about in the shortest possible time.
If I may be permitted to use a rather common expression, I was sorry to hear the "lambasting" that the Land Commission and civil servants got here during the last few days. I wonder was it just. Are we expecting too much from human nature, even in the Land Commission, when we are so venal ourselves? I have had about 20 years' contact with various Departments as a county councillor and 10 years as a Senator, and I must say that I always received courtesy, co-operation and sympathy from them. Each and every one of them did all they could to help. In fact, I found nothing but helpfulness and co-operation. There was only once incident in my career that I was sorry to witness, because it left on my mind an impress that is not yet removed. What is the Land Commission? Who are they? Who in the Land Commission is holding up this great work to maintain our race and keep them here? When I went to the inquiry office on one occasion and said: "Will you put me in touch with somebody here whose word is final and irrevocable in this matter," I was told, "I do not think you should have come here." I said: "I am after coming 140 miles with a broken knee on a matter of public business and am I to be told as a Senator that I am not entitled to have five minutes' conversation with somebody?" You usually get a communication saying: "I have been instructed by the Minister to say that your representations will be considered in due course," and about three months afterwards you ask yourself: "What about those representations?"
I should like to know what is the specific section in the Land Commission which must be charged with lethargy in dealing with this question of land division. I shall quote a case against them. A certain farmer not far away from where I live saw that there was land to be purchased near him. Having already about 150 acres of land and being a wise and prudent man, before attempting to do anything about it he wrote to the Land Commission. He said to them: "Have you any interest in this farm which is being sold? If you want it for subdivision, I shall not interfere." He got a reply from the Land Commission, telling him to proceed and buy, as they had no interest whatever in the land.
The man then acquired the farm, employed a number of men and spent about two years cultivating the land and making it more productive than it was. He spent a considerable amount on machinery and in draining and converting the farm into an economic holding. Then about 1937—I am not going to suggest any sinister influences but there are grave doubts in the matter— a Land Commission inspector came along and said: "We are going to take this place from you." He replied: "How can you do it in face of your previous decision? There is the letter from the Land Commission telling me to go ahead and buy the farm." In spite of all his protests, that man was dispossessed. He fought the issue in the first court, whatever it was, and he won the case but the Land Commission in turn brought him to a higher court and, of course, they beat him. Was that not a nasty proceeding for the Land Commission? I do not think it can be justified on any grounds. He was a progressive, hard-working farmer who made the money to acquire his farm by using modern up-to-date methods.
There are a few other matters to which I should like to refer. There is no doubt but that there must be some section of the Land Commission infected with the dangerous bacteria called "slow motion" and the Minister will have to get some virus to counteract that so as to get the Land Commission to move more quickly. I remember a number of estates which were divided during the Cosgrave régime. It was obvious that some people who got land at that time did not work it successfully and many of them parted with it since.
One gentleman in particular who parted with his land in that way decided to join the Fianna Fáil Party. When that Party developed as a political force, he joined it in the hope that he would succeed in getting portion of some further land that was being divided. But all credit to Deputy Moylan. I have great admiration for him. I think he did good work and I always found him very helpful and transparently honest on any occasion on which I had to approach him. I told Deputy Moylan that I knew of a certain gentleman who got the land under the previous Government and who, after the statutory period had passed, realised on it and put the money into his pocket. He then joined Fianna Fáil which he apparently regarded as a potent instrument for working influence. I told Deputy Moylan, who was then Minister, of the circumstances and one day he said to me: "Will you give me his name?" I said: "I will" and I gave him the name. He then said: "If I am Minister he will not get a sod of land".
Comment on this
Another point which I should like to urge is that the area given to these people, especially workers, is too small. No man, especially a man who was a cottier or labourer formerly, can hope to make a living on four or five acres and he is put into an unfortunate category by reason of the fact that he is given an allotment of that kind. Before he got the land he could get continuous work on the roads at good wages and perhaps could find employment for his pony and cart also. Immediately he became the owner of four or five acres, other workers objected to his being employed on the road as he belonged to the category of small farmers. He was then precluded from getting work which provided him with a very much better living than he could make on four or five acres of land. I think it is absurd to expect a man with a wife and small family to make a living on four or five acres. These men should be given much larger farms so as to afford them a chance of making a reasonable living.
I should like to refer for a moment —I am very glad that Deputy Moylan mentioned it yesterday—to the problem of the Maigue river. A deputation in connection with this river waited on the Minister about a month ago. The previous Minister about nine months ago visited that area and examined the whole situation. He discovered after careful review that there are 15,000 acres of land in that area rendered less productive by reason of flooding. The river is a serious menace to a couple of towns and villages along its basin when there is excessive rain. Nothing so far has been done to remedy this situation. Deputy Moylan realised—I suppose he had reasonable expectations at that time of being returned to office but his Party have passed out now and I see no earthly hope of their ever coming back—the importance of these 15,000 acres and would no doubt have done something to improve conditions there, had he remained in office. The present Minister promised some five or six weeks ago that steps would promptly be taken and that either himself or some official of his Department would visit the area with a view to getting some idea of the tragedy involved in the fact that 15,000 acres are left unproductive. I do hope that the Minister will do something about it because people living in the neighbourhood of the towns of Croom and Adare are seriously perturbed by the present position. I am glad that Deputy Moylan has borne testimony to the necessity of doing something in that area. He visited the place himself and was satisfied that it was a matter of urgent public importance.
There is another matter to which I would like to refer. I do not know whether it comes specifically under the Minister's Department but it is of vital importance to our whole agricultural economy. I raised this matter before with no effect in the Seanad. The then Minister said that he was impressed with the case I made and he asked me if I would go to the Board of Works to see if somebody there would look into the matter. I refer to the rural improvements scheme. It has been a tremendous advantage to the farmers but that scheme only operates through the board if two or more farmers are using a boreen in common.
Comment on this
That is just the point I raised. It is intimately related to the welfare of the agricultural community and it is of such importance to the weakest link in that community, namely, the single farmer, that I thought I might be allowed to refer to it.
Comment on this
I can bring it forward then. The scheme as at present worked is of no use to the man living on a serpent-like boreen. He does not get any advantage out of the scheme though he might get it under the Department of Agriculture. Some people have mentioned bog roads. A week ago in my constituency I was taken to one which is absolutely impassable. These are roads made by the local government authorities. Something should be done to repair these roads and make conditions more tolerable for the unfortunate people who have to use them.
A month ago, or so, I was in the Land Commission and I offered them 313 acres of land in a congested part of my constituency. I was told that the price they were prepared to pay was £4 per acre. The man who owns this land is physically incapable of working it because of disease. He wishes to dispose of the land for the benefit of his wife and seven children. There is no house on it and it is, therefore, not an economic proposition from the point of view of the public market. As I say, the Land Commission offered £4 per acre. That price has no relation to the market value of land. Surely, there should be some equity in the Land Commission's dealings with people such as this man. There are two other holdings where the people would be prepared to sell to the Land Commission but the price is not attractive.
The question may be asked—why would not this land be disposed of on the open market? The reason is because a somewhat peculiar situation has arisen in regard to the sale of farms. No sooner is a poster posted up advertising a farm for sale than there is a local agitation to have the farm taken over by the Land Commission and divided among the people. The seller is told that the Land Commission will be compelled to buy. That is a bad state of affairs. The Land Commission gives an uneconomic price and one that bears no relation whatsoever to the value of land.
I want to remind the Minister again about the state of the River Maigue. All sorts of debris are intercepting the flow of the river and because of that 15,000 acres of some of the best land in the county are ruined. The owners of that land are being called upon by the Land Commission for their annuities. They are being warned by the Department of Agriculture that they must till. But their land is completely useless and no longer productive. A committee has been inquiring into this for the past 12 months. They had an engineering survey made. They had an interview in the Land Commission and the present Minister promised that something would be done as quickly as possible. The previous Minister visited the area himself and was convinced of the importance and urgency of the work. So far nothing has been done.
How can we hope to stop emigration and the flight from the land if conditions are such that people are unable to obtain a livelihood from the land? That will continue until the whole land question is solved. The time will come when we shall have Mongolians and Jews walking down O'Connell Street while the Desmonds and the MacCarthys and MacDonnells fly from the land. If this inter-Party Government does its work as that work ought to be done when it comes before the people in five years' time it will have the support of all of us again.
Comment on this
Very little remains to be said on this Estimate. Practically every aspect that arises under the Vote for Lands has already been dealt with by other Deputies in this House. In introducing this Estimate the Minister said:—
"When I took office on the 18th February last, I found that, owing to a "close-down Order" on the acquisition of land in the midland and eastern areas where the Land Commission must look to form a reservoir of land out of which they can come to the relief of the classes I have mentioned, there was no land on hands. Since this restriction Order was imposed, the amount of land then on hands gradually disappeared in the form of migrants' holdings, allotments, etc., and to-day there is none on hands worth mentioning. Shortly after I took office, with the permission of the Government, I removed these restrictions and my Department is now forging ahead with the work of acquiring land for our statutory purposes. The problem of acquiring land is slow."
If you break that statement down, it means that the present Government is changing the temporary policy of the previous Government by the removal of this Order which restrained the Land Commission from acquiring fresh land. The Minister says that the Land Commission is now "forging ahead". I want to know what exactly does the Minister mean by that expression "forging ahead"? That expression can mean anything and it can mean nothing. I know what the expression meant to Paud O'Donohue when he was forging pikes, but what exactly it means in relation to the activities of the Land Commission I do not know. What progress has the Land Commission made over the last three months since the new Government took office? Now, I do not want to be answered with the formula that seems to have been adopted by the people on the Government Benches by asking me the question: "What did the previous Government do in its 16 years of office?"
Comment on this
I am dealing with this question from a national point of view. In dealing with it in that way it is a matter upon which we should and could, if we were to go about it in the proper way, get a national policy in relation to lands. The Land Commission had, prior to the imposition of that Order, served on landowners in the Midlands the resumption notices. I hope I am using the correct legal terminology in naming that Order, because I do not know what exactly the correct title is. The owners of certain lands in the Midlands were served with notices prior to the imposition of that restriction Order telling them that the Land Commission was about to resume their holdings. Does this statement that the Land Commission is forging ahead mean that in every case in which such an Order was issued the Land Commission is now investigating it to see if they can, after the removal of the Order by this Government, continue with the proceedings against each of these individuals? That is a question which the Minister should and must answer. The Minister said in his opening statement that the Land Commission will be mainly concerned with the relief of congestion. That is a point of view with which I have full sympathy, to which I have given full co-operation in the past and to which I hope to be able to give full co-operation in the future, no matter what Government may be in office in this State.
I come from an area in which land was and is available for distribution. It is not a popular thing for a public representative to stand on a public platform in such an area and declare that that is his policy and his belief. I gave service to this country in the national movement. Personally, I believe that the only right the State has to acquire lands from any individual is the right of the people to go back and reassert their right to the land of this country from which they were driven when they lost to the conquering race which dominated us for 700 years. Together with that right, of course, the State has the right to acquire lands from a private individual for the public good. Therefore, the State has acquired land and has protected the right of the individual to land irrespective of the individual. Time had passed. Irishmen had acquired land through their own hard work or through good fortune and, when this State came into existence, the land owners of this country were a very mixed lot. Many of them were good, sound Irishmen. Many of them held land which they inherited from their forefathers who had got it through the Cromwellian settlement or through some other settlement in this country. Therefore, this State was forced to recognise the right of the individuals to hold land within the Constitution and within the law of the country. When the Land Commission, in the near future, proceed to acquire land they will find that, owing to the high value it has attained, due to circumstances outside the control of the Government of this country, individuals who hold lands here will contest their right in the land courts and will, in my opinion, delay as far as they possibly can the acquisition of land for division. For that reason I want to know from the Minister what reservoir of land he hopes to acquire in the Midlands—in Meath, Westmeath, Leix-Offaly or in any other county. I shall be quite satisfied if the Minister will even be able to give a rough indication for the whole of the Midlands rather than any particular county. I know that he is facing a difficult job and I do not want him to commit himself by saying anything about which, at some future date, a Deputy may be able to say: "The Minister did not reach the target he set for himself on such and such a date when he made such and such a statement in this House." When concluding his statement the Minister said:—
"In conclusion, I ask the assistance and cordial co-operation of all Deputies, no matter to what Party they belong, and I am particularly addressing this to the Opposition, as my work can be severely hampered by Deputies who may wish to score over their colleagues in their constituencies."
From the speeches that have been delivered during this debate I think the Minister could direct that statement to some members on the Government Benches who threatened him in this House that if he did not take a certain road they would leave him sitting on this side of the House.
Comment on this
I have not the official record, because I do not believe it is printed yet, but I believe that he made that statement.
Comment on this
When you get the Official Report you will find that you have misquoted Deputy Flanagan.
Comment on this
I assumed from what the Deputy stated in this House last night that his vote had gone to leave the previous Minister for Lands on this side of the House and that unless the present Minister for Lands made the Land Commission acquire and divide land amongst the uneconomic holders and landless men in his constituency he would take steps to see that the Minister would be left sitting on this side of the House. That was the sum total of what the Deputy said.
Comment on this
The majority of the speeches which were delivered from this side of the House were reasonable and they offered co-operation in the solution of this national problem. The Land Commission is a body which has been set up by this House, and which is continued by this House, and which has been given certain statutory authority to do a certain job. They proceed to operate whatever the Government policy may be under the various Acts of Parliament which this State took over and passed through this Oireachtas to enable the Land Commission to do a particular job. People who speak of red tape, green tape or any other coloured tape must realise that the Land Commission are simply seeing that the law of this country is carried out in relation to all the aspects of Land Commission policy.
Deputies dealing with this question of policy have confined themselves mainly to the one use to which land is put by the Land Commission, and that is the taking over of certain ranches or large tracts and dividing them into what they call economic holdings and what I call standard holdings. They do not relate this land policy to general Government policy. I am not speaking now of this Government in that regard; I am speaking of the policy of all Governments prior to this Government and of the Governments that will come after this Government.
Nobody can give serious thought, or come to a serious conclusion on this question of land acquisition and division without taking into consideration our agricultural economy. That economy is not of our making. The people of this generation have not made it; it is an economy that has come down to us; it is one that may have been forced upon us by the fact that we were subject to a foreign Parliament. The fact, however, is that this country now and for years past has been, and even for years to come will mainly be, concerned with the raising of live stock. That must be taken into consideration by any Government in relation to the prosecution and following up of a land division policy.
Chain ranchers have been mentioned. They are the men who rent or buy land. Some of it they buy in the open market, while there are others who rent land on the 11 months' system for the grazing of cattle. It might be well to point out that it is not a fact that the grazing of cattle in the Midlands regulates or has anything to do with the price of live stock in the West of Ireland. There are more live stock shipped out of the West and South by three or four firms in one month than would be fed in County Meath or County Westmeath in 12. That as a factor in relation to land division should not be taken into consideration at all. The Minister apparently understands that.
The people engaged in this business, call them chain ranchers if you will, are mostly men from the South and West. They are not Indian princes; they are not people from any other country; they are not of the race from which the gentleman comes who got succour in this country, and who was so ill-manneredly referred to by Deputy Flanagan. The Deputy made insulting references in connection with a German prince, a scion of an ancient family who came into this country to find succour here such as our nationals were very glad to get in other countries in years gone by. They are mostly Irishmen reared on small farms in the South and West. They had to leave these farms because they could not get a living on them. They made good in a certain line of business and they are now engaged in a trade in which the Minister for Agriculture is vitally interested and which he is going all-out to make a greater trade. He is expounding Government policy in relation to land which is not in keeping with the Government policy in relation to land which has been expounded by the Minister for Lands.
You cannot have it both ways. You have either to leave a reservoir of land in the Midlands for that purpose or shut the trade down. That trade is mainly a fat cattle and polly trade. The division of land is bound up with the replacement of our population. You have in the City of Dublin, if you care to adopt the arguments used by Deputies who come from the congested districts, a congested district. It is dependent solely on the Midlands to secure whatever meat is required to keep up the daily ration of its inhabitants. Owing to the restrictions the war placed on us, owing to the great scarcity of pig products, the use of beef on the dinner table has increased greatly in this country, and the persons engaged in that trade in Dublin are drawing their supplies to feed the people there off the Midlands and out of the County Meath. It is true that a well-organised system of small holdings with people who would intelligently take up stall-feeding of cattle could replace on the home market for Dublin people and people in our midland towns their supplies of live-stock, but the Minister, in deciding what reservoir of land he will take for the relief of congestion, must also decide what reservoir he will leave for the purpose I have mentioned.
Comment on this
I am not interested in that. I am putting up my own opinions on those matters and speaking my mind on them. I can stand up to my opinions and I will not change my statements to-day or to-morrow—I will not make different statements. I will make my statements anywhere and if I go by the board in making them I will take that for what it is worth.
There are some other matters with which I should like to deal, and one is the question of political corruption. It is a matter which I would like to refer to because this is a thing that should never, in my opinion, have been raised in this country. In regard to this question of the division of land, Deputies have made statements in this House alleging political corruption without ever naming the estates where the political corruption is alleged to have taken place. Deputy T.F. O'Higgins, in this House on the 26th May, 1948, Volume 110, No. 16, made such a statement and I asked him to name the estate and he said you will get plenty of estates. The McEllin estate in Breize was mentioned. The Minister is in a position to tell this House what happened on this estate and he is in a position to take whatever steps are necessary to see if this estate was divided as a result of political corruption or whether any of the persons who got land on that estate got it through political corruption. He is in a position to name the persons who were guilty of this practice, if such a practice did obtain. In my opinion, it did not obtain. When Deputy T.F. O'Higgins was asked to name the estates he did not name them but went on to tell me that he was the most innocent Deputy in this House, a thing that was very hard to understand coming from Deputy T.F. O'Higgins, junior.
Comment on this
"I do not know if Deputy Hilliard thinks that because I am a new Deputy in the House that I am innocent."
Comment on this
If Deputy T.F. O'Higgins thought that I thought he was innocent then he must certainly be the most innocent Deputy that ever came into this House. I do not think anything of the sort about Deputy O'Higgins. I know that Deputy O'Higgins is a highly intelligent man. He may just have been fishing for compliments.
Comment on this
The fact of the matter is that a good deal more would be thought of Deputy T.F. O'Higgins if he left that reference to political corruption in the division of land out of his speech. I will say no more about it.
Recently the Minister received a deputation in connection with the division of a certain estate. The Minister for Lands was questioned here in this House by Deputy Con Lehane with regard to those lands, and he stated, in reply to that question, that the Land Commission had not any proceedings for their acquisition and division. Subsequently a deputation visited the Minister in the hope that they could get this estate acquired and divided. According to the Meath Chronicle of Saturday, May 22nd, 1948:—
"A deputation led by Mr. So-and-so"—
I will not mention his name, but he is an M.A. and a national teacher—
"recently waited on Mr. J. Blowick, the Minister for Lands, and was informed that the Rotheram estate of about 680 acres, situated in the townlands of Bellview and Patrickstown, between Oldcastle and Kells, would shortly be taken over by the Land Commission for division among uneconomic holders and deserving landless men in the locality. The deputation was introduced by Mr. Con Lehane, T.D."
I have no objection to the Minister receiving a deputation or to Deputy Lehane or any other Deputy leading in a deputation, but I had a question down and so had Deputy O'Reilly asking the same question as Deputy Lehane asked and we got the same answer. I do not know if the Minister did tell the deputation that this estate would be shortly taken over——
Comment on this
That is not the implication. The implication is that I gave an answer to two Parliamentary Questions that was untrue.
Comment on this
The Deputy must understand that the Minister has no control over what appears in the Press.
Comment on this
I know that he has not. But if the inference can be drawn from my statement that I am accusing the Minister of not telling the truth here in the House I want to make that quite clear.
Comment on this
The Minister answered a certain question which was put by the Deputy. Another Deputy asked the same question and the same answer was given him. In between those two questions a newspaper published a certain report of something that happened. Now the Minister has no control over what is supplied to the Press or over what the Press publishes and, therefore, he is not responsible for them.
Comment on this
This deputation was lead by a very eminent citizen and I paraphrase Shakespeare in saying that he is an honourable man. He is a man with his full senses. He has good hearing. He is an M.A. and a national teacher and he lent his name to the report.
Comment on this
That is a matter which we cannot discuss. The Minister is not responsible for a report or for whatever any citizen lends his name to. Whether he is an M.A. or a dramatist of international repute, the Minister has no responsibility for it.
Comment on this
We may take it for granted now that as far as this particular estate, the Rotheram estate, at Oldcastle, County Meath, is concerned, it will not be taken over shortly and divided in the manner described.