Committee on Finance. - Vote 68—Health (Resumed).
Contributions 117–263 of 263. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
I remember the time when we could discuss anything from Alpha to Omega and from Peru to Kamchatka.
Comment on this
I want to say that, on behalf of the present Minister for Health, it was alleged that the Department of Health had been callously administered, that the Government had callously neglected to introduce——
Comment on this
I am not now quoting from the Minister. I am merely paraphrasing criticisms for which he made himself responsible. Surely I am entitled to cite, first of all, what has been said in relation to his Department and then to ask the Minister, in his reply, to say what he has done to improve the condition of affairs which he alleged existed.
Comment on this
Am I not to be permitted to put to the Minister the allegations which he made in relation to this Department and to ask him, now that he is in office and is responsible for it, what he has done to cure them?
Comment on this
I have asked the Deputy whether he was repeating what the Minister said, and he said it was said on the Minister's behalf, which is quite a different thing.
Comment on this
I can quite easily repeat what the Minister said:
"Nearly three years ago an exuberant White Paper was published filled with grandiose promises of thousands of beds, chest hospitals——"
Comment on this
Very well, I will put myself in the position that Dr. Browne would be in if he were occupying these benches and I will say what has been alleged by people outside this House. Surely, I am entitled to have regard to what is said outside this House as well as to what is said inside it. Surely this House is the sounding board of public opinion, and surely the members of this House are entitled to repeat in this House what the public are saying outside. I say that the public have said in relation to this Department—some sections of the public at any rate—that the Government in regard to the prevention and treatment of tuberculosis had callously neglected to introduce certain simple reforms.
Comment on this
I am going to ask him whether that condition of affairs, in fact, exists. Am I not entitled to put questions to the Minister and ask him to answer them? Is this House representative of the people? Do we speak here as the people's voice? Do we repeat here what the people are saying or is debate in this House going to be stifled to this extent, that unless somebody says something in this House it cannot be repeated?
Comment on this
I am not saying that this statement was made by the Minister. I am saying that there are organs of opinion circulating in this country, voicing the views of people in regard to administration. Am I not entitled to take cognisance of what was being said in the public Press of this country about this Department? I am asking the Minister who is responsible for this Department to deal with these allegations in relation to it. I am saying that there are people who believe that the last Government was callous in its attitude towards this problem of tuberculosis. Am I not entitled to ask the Minister whether that is true or not?
Comment on this
The Deputy has four or five times, and I believe oftener before I came in, repeated that statement. He might go on now to some criticism of the administration.
Comment on this
Surely this is criticism of the administration. It has been said that the Government which was in office during the year under review did not care how many people contracted tuberculosis or how long the people who had contracted tuberculosis or had become infected in the manner described had to wait before getting into an out-of-date sanatorium or how much they and their dependents suffered mentally, physically and financially, or how many died of this preventable and curable disease. That is what is being said outside; that, in fact, is what was said by a committee of people associated either with the present Minister for Health——
Comment on this
It looks as if the Deputy is trying to assign to the Minister words that he did not utter.
Comment on this
Very well. So far as that goes, here is the White Paper dealing with an outline of proposals for the improvement of the public services. Previously another White Paper dealing with the problem of tuberculosis was issued. That has been described as "an exuberant White Paper filled with grandiose proposals or promises of thousands of beds, chest hospitals, allowances for dependents, improvement of dispensaries, etc." and this was all, it was alleged by the present Minister for Health, that had been done during the year the administration of which is now under review. I am going to say this: that though that has been alleged by the present Minister for Health in an article written and signed by him when he was attached to a sanatorium in this country, he must have known, and those who made themselves responsible for that statement must have known, that under the Health Act of 1947, an Act enacted last year by the Oireachtas and introduced by the then Minister for Health, power had been taken to give to necessitous patients, especially married men, adequate financial allowances to tide them over their illness. I say when that statement was published by the present Minister for Health in criticism of what his predecessor had done last year, the present Minister for Health must have known that that Act had been passed and that, as I have said, those powers had been taken.
I will go further. I will say to the present Minister for Health that when he wrote that article he must have known that a scheme for allowances was actually in draft. In draft form it had been submitted to the committees of the several sanatoria of the country, including, of course, the committee of Newcastle, on the staff of which Dr. Browne, as he then was, was assistant resident medical superintendent. This is what I want to know. What more has Dr. Browne done since he took office in the way of expanding or developing the counter tuberculosis campaign than was done by his predecessor? Where are the mass radiography, the new health clinics, all the things promised by Dr. Browne in his election address, large subsistence allowances for the sick, improved child welfare services, improved medical services? That is the question I am asking Dr. Browne.
Comment on this
No, I am asking him now, because these are the things which he undertook to the people to do. Of course I know that Dr. Browne will have his excuses. The country is now labouring under government by excuses.
Comment on this
Quite, but we are supposed to be discussing the Estimate. The Deputy dragged in an election address.
Comment on this
I am asking Dr. Browne, I am asking the Minister for Health, I am asking the Government, what is being done to improve the mass radiography service. Deputy Connolly, who spoke in advance of me, put the same question. He did not put it in precisely the same terms. He was trying to extenuate the Government he supports, but I am not extenuating it. I am criticising it and condemning it for not carrying out the promised programme. I want to know what has become of the new health clinics we were promised, the larger subsistence allowances for the sick, the child welfare services and the medical services. These are all questions of administration surely. What is being done to provide these services? What earnest have we that anything will be done to provide them before we vote this huge amount of £1,355,590? Of course we know that nothing will be done and that the Minister will have his excuses. That is one thing that this Government are adept at, however incompetent they may be in other matters. They are adept at——
Comment on this
——passing on the blame to others. I did not use that phrase before. If the Government sent the cost of living up, making it harder for people to maintain themselves in good health, instead of bringing it down as they undertook to do, it is the fault of the wicked bacon curers, or more remotely, I suppose, it is the fault of the wicked farmers who want higher prices for their pigs, or it is the fault of the wicked butchers, or, again, the wicked farmers who want higher prices for beef. It is the fault of the wicked industrialists——
Comment on this
I am not making a disquisition on the cost of living. But here we have a Minister who pledged himself to improve the health of the people and to reduce the cost of living, but instead of coming down the cost of living has gone up.
Comment on this
Just as the Government will plead a dozen excuses and put the blame on somebody else for the things they failed to do, so this Minister, when he falls down on the job, when he has failed to provide child welfare or improved tuberculosis services, when there is no acceleration in the rate at which hospital accommodation is being expanded, when nothing is planned or attempted except what was left cut and dried for him by his predecessor, will have glib excuses. "He has not had time to do much," his apologists will plead; "there are not the materials," he himself says; "there are not the men," we will hear from some of the devil's advocates opposite; "he has not the money"; he has admitted that himself. The Minister, however, when he was plain Dr. Browne, could write this type of article.
Comment on this
He could write an article entitled "Murder Could Not Be Bolder." He did not then accept any of these things as a valid excuse, and why should the members of this House, who are called upon to vote £1,355,590 of the people's money. accept them as valid excuses? He would not even accept as an excuse the fact that a world war was raging around this country, that we were the centre of a conflict, that this island was blockaded and that we could not get materials to build hospitals over those dreadful years. Now when materials are relatively plentiful and yet hospitals are not being built, what excuse, I ask again, has the Minister now?
The Minister has decided to curtail the Fianna Fáil hospital programme. He announced that in his opening statement and his excuse is that he has not the money. I suppose I dare not refer to what the Minister said about the question of money, that money would be no obstacle, a few months ago. But instead of carrying out the full hospital programme as drawn up by his predecessor after an exhaustive study of our hospital needs, the Minister proposes to cut that programme in half. Money has now become the dominating element in the Minister's Department. For want of money we must go short of hospitals; for want of money children must die; for want of money new health clinics cannot be built, women must die in childbirth and babies be stillborn. For want of money the mentally afflicted cannot procure institutional treatment but must drag out their long and weary pilgrimage through the limbo between sanity and madness. Yet the Government, of which the Minister is a member with collective responsibility for all it has done, has indicated that it is not in need of money, so little in need of it indeed that in recent months it has given millions away. We have been told that it surrendered no less than £6,000,000 to make champagne cheaper, to make beer cheaper——
Comment on this
I am going to relate this to the problem of health. Yet the Minister told the Dáil he does not know how he is going to keep the voluntary hospitals with their mounting deficits going and at the same time provide for the building of the new hospitals which are so urgently required. Is it not relevant in considering that problem to consider what financial arrangements the Minister's Government have made to enable him to solve that difficulty? We are asked to vote £1,355,000. If we had a larger revenue, we could vote more money; we could provide the money for the hospitals and for the deficits at the same time. Six million pounds have been handed back by this Government to the publican, to the brewer, to the tobacco manufacturer——
Comment on this
The Deputy is again irrelevant. If he persists in his irrelevancy he will have to sit down.
Comment on this
£6,000,000 a year would produce the money necessary to complete the whole hospital programme in five years. Surely when we are being told by the Minister that it is part of his policy to curtail that hospital programme, when an exhaustive study has indicated that we require to spend at least £37,000,000 on providing the country with the hospitals, the county homes, and the infirmaries which it requires, it is relevant to discuss the fact that the Minister is cutting down the necessary expenditure to £15,000,000. He has already announced that; he has put that matter in issue in this debate. Surely we are entitled to point out that if the Minister and his colleagues had pursued a different policy he would not have to restrict or curtail expenditure——
Comment on this
Under the Ministers and Secretaries Act Ministers are given responsibility for certain Departments. We are discussing one Department at present, or should be rather—not the Department of Finance.
Comment on this
I am addressing the Chair. I want to say that it is a simple computation. We require £37,000,000. Six million pounds a year for six years would produce £36,000,000. The other £1,000,000 I suppose we could scrape up in one way or another and we could then carry out the hospital programme outlined in these proposals for the improvement of the health services. But we cannot do that because the Minister for Health does not want the money. Apparently, in the view of the Minister for Health, cheap beer, cheap cigarettes, cheap pictures will do more for the health of our people than good food.
Comment on this
We shall put it this way. In the opinion of the Minister, good food, modern hospitals, improved medical services and modern but expensive drugs cannot be procured because, apparently, cheap beer, cheap cigarettes——
Comment on this
Is it because we want to get away on holidays that the debate is going to be curtailed by the Chair?
Comment on this
You do not have to name him at all, because he will leave. Surely I am as impartial as anybody, and I have listened to the discussion and satisfied myself that apparently those overworked Ministers want to get away on their holidays.
Deputy Smith withdrew from the Chamber.
Comment on this
I feel that the present Minister for Health has been fortunate in taking over this Department at the particular time in which he has taken it over. Judging by the campaign of publicity which the Minister from the time of his appointment up to the present moment has engaged in one would imagine that no provision whatever had been made for people suffering from tuberculosis, cancer and other diseases and for diseases of children, when the Minister took over office. It is quite true that in introducing the Estimate he paid a limited tribute to his predecessor. He has, however, paraded up and down this country and claimed the credit for providing extra beds for tuberculosis patients, changing the mental hospital in Castlerea into a sanatorium, and various other schemes that were already in the hands of the Department and that arrangements had been made to put into execution. One would imagine that prior to the 18th February and to the Minister coming to the Custom House no provision had been made for the sufferers from the various ailments I have enumerated.
During one of his excursions down the country the Minister thought fit to make a reference to county homes. I think that if the Minister had as much experience of local bodies as members on all sides of this House have had he would be very slow and very loath to have made the statements that he made. One can probably put down to the Minister's inexperience of local affairs the statements that he made concerning county homes. It is quite true that the structure of these buildings may not be all as we would desire. They were erected long before this State was established. They were buildings that were handed over to the local authorities throughout this country. The members of this House who, prior to the coming into operation of the County Management Act, were members of boards of health know the conditions in these county homes. They know with what unceasing care and diligent manner the Sisters of the Order of Mercy looked after the inmates in these institutions. It is a reflection not so much on the members of the public bodies as on the religious Orders in charge of the patients in these institutions that statements which were made should have been made. I wonder if the Minister for Health is himself familiar with the diet of the inmates of these institutions? He committed himself to a statement that these patients are getting nothing but soup three times a day.
Those of us who are familiar with the running of these institutions and who have had some responsibility in the past for them rubbed our eyes when we heard that statement. If the Minister had been more familiar with these institutions he certainly would not have committed himself to that statement. I trust that, having committed himself to it, he has been informed of the true state of affairs in these institutions and that when he is replying he will take the opportunity of withdrawing the reflection he has cast on all those who are associated with the internal running of these institutions and particularly the religious Orders who are in charge of the diet of the inmates.
In connection with the structural alterations of county homes, I would point out that it is not since Dr. Browne came into office that this matter has come under consideration. I am sure that the Minister for Health has read the White Paper that was issued by his predecessor in office. On page 38 of that White Paper, after dealing with the financing of hospitals, the following passage occurs:—
"Furthermore, existing institutional accommodation for the aged and infirm, and persons suffering from chronic ailments, is far from being satisfactory. Improved provision will have to be made in due course for this purpose. Replacement would, however, mean an eventual additional capital outlay in the neighbourhood of £13,000,000. The work cannot, therefore, be undertaken until the more pressing needs of the acutely ill have been met."
That is a fair statement of the position. However, without even touching on the county homes the Minister for Health is only able to make provision for £15,000,000 over the next seven years for the more necessary hospitalisation needs of the country. I am sure that the estimate contained in that White Paper in regard to county homes is a pretty accurate estimate and, if the Minister wants to make a job of it, he will have to provide—in addition to the £15,000,000—the extra £13,000,000 as well. Statements of that kind, coming from a Minister, are not very tactful and they are certainly not in the interests of public health.
Comment on this
What did Fianna Fáil do for the aged and the infirm during the 16 years they were in office?
Comment on this
Everybody in this House is just as anxious about the aged and infirm as Deputy O'Leary is and they have given as much time and labour over the years to help the aged and the infirm as Deputy O'Leary has. Fianna Fáil were every anxious to help them and they put various schemes into operation in that connection during their term of office. Deputy O'Leary's remark was most uncalled for. It is hard to imagine that there is anybody in this House who would not do everything in his power to help the aged and infirm.
Comment on this
I am sure that the Ceann Comhairle would not allow me to go into the details of the various measures that Fianna Fáil introduced into this House and put into operation throughout the country to help the aged and the infirm. I thought that the Minister for Health would have taken the opportunity that this Vote afforded to pay tribute to the various voluntary organisations throughout the country which are doing such good work in connection with tuberculosis. I refer in particular to the campaign which has been carried on for a number of years by the Irish Red Cross Society. The Irish Red Cross Society have done good work and they deserve more encouragement from the State than they are at the moment receiving for the work they are doing in endeavouring to educate public opinion in regard to the prevention and the cure of tuberculosis. When a Department of State gets the co-operation and the assistance of widespread, well-organised public opinion such as is behind the Irish Red Cross Society advantage should be taken of it. Any encouragement and assistance that can be given to the members of that society should be given in order to help them to continue the good work in which they are already engaged. I should like to say also that there are some Departments of State over and above others whose activities, if possible, should not be mixed up with politics. If that applies to one Department more than to another it applies to the Department of Health. Health is a matter which concerns every citizen of the country no matter what his political creed may be.
If the Minister for Health wants— and I am sure he does—to get the co-operation of every citizen of the State in a campaign to improve the health of the State he should avoid as far as possible being actively engaged on a political tour at the same time as he is carrying out work in connection with his Department. That has happened on at least one occasion during the present Minister's régime. I think it is a pity that that should happen in connection with the Minister for Health. If we want to get the co-operation and the assistance of every citizen of this country, irrespective of politics, I would appeal to the Minister to keep the work of his Department as far removed as possible from active politics.
Deputy Dr. Ryan referred the other night to the question of additional sanatoria. I was very interested in the provision of extra sanatoria for patients in Donegal. Some time ago—I must admit it was long before the present Minister took office—a building became vacant in Donegal which would be suitable for housing tuberculosis patients. Steps were taken by the local authority with regard to this matter and negotiations have been carried on between them and the Department for the last 12 months. The unfortunate part is that the building is still idle and accommodation for tuberculosis patients is still lacking. A month or six weeks ago I raised this matter by way of question.
I was told by the Minister then that there was no undue delay so far as his Department was concerned. Though he did not state so explicitly, he left it to be inferred that the cause of the delay was due to the local authority. I question that. I think if the Minister examines the matter he will find that he has got all the assistance, co-operation and help that the public authority could give. Out of courtesy to the local authority, I sent a copy of the Minister's reply to the county manager. I have been told that on the very day my Question was down for consideration and answer on the Order Paper, and days subsequent to that, decisions which had been held up for a considerable time were taken. I do not raise this matter in any contentious spirit. I am sure the Minister and his Department are as anxious as I am to provide extra accommodation for tuberculosis patients. I would appeal to the Minister and his Department to speed up their end of the work. There has been a good deal of correspondence in connection with architects, consulting engineers, central heating and lighting. If we were really in earnest about making this provision I think a good deal of intermediate work could be cut out. There are ways and means whereby heating and lighting could be dealt with quite expeditiously. There are ways and means in which small alterations could be carried out much more expeditiously than they have been in the past. I trust that, having raised the matter here this evening, something will now be done to bring it to a successful conclusion. This building to which I have referred is quite suitable for the purpose. It has been lying idle for the last 12 to 18 months.
I want to refer now to the hospitalisation scheme for County Donegal. It is some years since the local authority and the members of the Hospital Commission had meetings, discussions, and drew up plans for the purpose of providing a county hospital. The site has been purchased as long as 11 years. So far we have not got the hospital. In reply to a Question raised by another Donegal Deputy some time ago the Minister indicated that it would be necessary, in view of the modern trend in hospitalisation, to prepare new plans, appoint new architects and go over the whole ground again. Plans were prepared ten years ago. They were then supposed to be quite up to date. They were in accordance with hospitalisation schemes being carried out on the Continent at that time. Very little hospitalisation has been done on the Continent since and I think those plans would be sufficiently up to date for utilisation now. Had the hospital been completed at that time it would have been considered quite satisfactory. The people would have been amply satisfied with it. The present approach seems to me to be merely a delaying device. It is suggested now that, in order to take its place in the queue again, Donegal must go through the whole formula. I would appeal to the Minister to cut out as much of the trimmings as he possibly can and to provide us with the money so that we can go ahead with the county hospital in Donegal. Donegal is the third largest county in the State. It is far removed from the specialists and leading hospitals in the City of Dublin and elsewhere. We have a very strong claim for a county hospital. We have surgeons in the county operating in the existing institutions; they are severely handicapped in their work. If we had a proper hospital with up-to-date equipment the probability is that many lives would be saved.
Provision was also made in the plans for the erection of two district hospitals—one in Donegal town and the other in Carndonagh. I do not know whether plans were actually prepared for these, but sites were certainly inspected. The scheme was in process of examination and preparation when war broke out. Building ceased completely then. District hospitals are vitally essential in Donegal and the erection of them should be proceeded with as quickly as possible. These are the principal matters I wish to bring to the attention of the Minister. If he indicates that he is prepared to go ahead with the building of a county hospital in Donegal I can assure him that he will get all the assistance and co-operation the county manager and the local authority can give him.
Comment on this
When I heard the Minister for Health announce the details of his Estimate, although I had become accustomed to surprises in regard to the acts of the inter-Party Government since the election, I was more than amazed to hear the Minister speak of a reduction in the amount of finance to be allocated for hospital reconstruction while, at the same time, he made it perfectly clear that the full programme is not to be implemented, with indications as to the reasons for that decision. During the election we heard from the Party to which the Minister belongs the most wildly exaggerated accounts of the condition of destitution and disease in which the people live.
We were told that the modest sum afforded for an increase in the salaries of judges and members of the Dáil was preventing hospital construction. We were told that if the system of finance in this country was changed enough millions could be raised to provide all the hospitals required in a very short time, and that it was due to the negligence of the former Minister for Health and to our outmoded system of finance that the programme had not been carried out already. We were told also that materials were no bar to hospital construction. We were informed by speaker after speaker from the new Party platforms that vast amounts of materials had been used for the reconstruction of luxury hotels for tourist purposes, and cinemas. We, of course, informed the public that the total amount allowed for these uses was some 5 per cent. of all available building materials but, nevertheless, the talk went on that if only they could stop the building of cinemas and the construction of luxury hotels all the materials necessary would be available for this hospital programme.
The principal point made was that it was simply the act of an outworn Government and the utilisation of an outworn system of finance that was holding back a most magnificent programme of hospital development, when there would be free treatment for everyone in the hospitals. We were told that we were holding back a vast system of social welfare services, representing a total amount of £2,000,000 per annum. Now we see the present Minister for Health imbued very thoroughly with the Fine Gael mentality, which is so evident in all the Estimates that are presented to the House.
Having heard the Minister's introductory statement. I had occasion to make note of an observation by the Minister for External Affairs when speaking on the question of Marshall aid. The Minister for External Affairs, on the 1st July, column 2001 of the Parliamentary Debates, said:—
"The medical health tables indicate that the majority of the population of this country bears all the signs—I am not speaking of the upper classes or the middle classes—of under-nourishment."
I would rather we had no Marshall aid than have any attempt to "cod" the American people or the American Government by making a statement of that kind.
Comment on this
I challenge the Minister for Health to produce figures from the reports of medical officers of health which would prove a statement of that kind. Surely, it is proper for us to discuss the general views of the inter-Party Government on conditions of health in so far as they relate to under-nourishment? Surely, it is a very vital matter for the Minister to advert to under-nourishment when deciding what measures he intends to take for its prevention? I should regard that as an entirely germane matter.
Comment on this
It was the custom, unless the desire is to depart from it—which would be done very deliberately—that to discuss at length the policy of any Department it is necessary to have a motion to refer back; otherwise the debate is confined to administration solely and, under the Ministers and Secretaries Act, as the Deputy knows, each Minister is allotted a Department and, because he is in sole charge of that Department, his activities, and no one else's are relevant on his Estimate.
Comment on this
I do not wish to question your judgement, but I understand that you have given considerable latitude already in the debate to other Deputies and I trust you will allow me the same privileges. Referring generally to the question of under-nourishment——
Comment on this
I can give plenty of examples of under-nourishment in this country. I am aware there are areas in Dublin City where there is under-nourishment, and it should be the duty of the Minister to see that every measure is taken advantage of to secure that adequate quantities of the right kind of food are procured for the people concerned. I am referring to the statement of the Minister for External Affairs, implying that what must be a very large majority of the rural population are undernourished. I suggest the statement is not in any way true. I would like the Minister for Health to tell me whether, in the course of his administration, he has adverted to the figures for malnutrition given in the reports of the medical officers of health for the areas of all Ireland and whether he regards those figures as being grossly inaccurate and as indicating a state of nutrition which, in fact, is far less than it would appear to be. So far as I can recall in Longford and Westmeath—to our shame I may admit—there is some I per cent of the children who show signs of malnutrition. There are in some counties as much as 3 per cent.
The medical officers of health may have perhaps too modest a view of what is malnutrition. I would like to ask the Minister whether he wishes to contradict these reports or whether he claims that they are fairly accurate and whether, in the light of that, he wishes to uphold the statement made by the Minister for External Affairs, that the majority of the people are undernourished. I would rather see us getting no Marshall aid if we are to secure it by making statements of that kind.
I should like to repeat a question put by other Deputies as to whether the Minister intends to publish the report of the inquiry of the Committee on Dietetics. As Deputy Dockrell indicated, there are undoubtedly areas in Dublin where malnutrition exists and the public should have an opportunity of reading that report and hearing what steps the Minister is taking to overcome the undesirable conditions indicated in that report. The Minister will be well aware that the consumption of milk in Dublin has largely increased in recent years and there may be other indications that the position has improved in certain areas.
I would like to ask the Minister whether, in connection with the health campaign he intends to undertake, he has considered that it is desirable that the food voucher system be paid for out of local authority funds, or whether he will not give more encouragement to the issue of food vouchers by continuing Government grants for that purpose. That would appear to be contrary to the general spirit in which the Minister fought the election. I would also like to ask him whether he has considered that it might be desirable to alter the conditions under which school meals grants are made and arrange so as to provide for a fuller type of meal in urban areas.
I now come to the White Paper published by the former Government on the reorganisation of the health services. It will be recalled that the Public Health Act provided for mother and child welfare schemes, for the overhaul of all health inspections and the overhaul of all the administration relating to the prevention of infection. The same Act provided for the appointment of dispensary nurses. I understand it will take some time before the services of nurses adequately trained for this purpose can be availed of. These nurses have to be trained, not only as ordinary general nurses, but trained to do propaganda work among the people—trained to go into their homes and follow up cases of disease or malnutrition. They have to be people of remarkable character and personality.
Have the regulations been published yet for the appointment of such nurses? Have any efforts been made to see if nurses are not available in sufficient numbers that their training is commenced? Have the conditions being specified for their appointment? Has the Jubilee Nursing Association been contacted to ascertain if it could help in the training of these nurses, having regard to its magnificent work and its great tradition in this country? It would seem to me that the provision of these nursing services is vital to the improvement of health and, in particular, to the improvement of preventive health work of the local authorities, and that the Minister should give particular attention to this matter.
Another plan made by the previous Government provided for the establishment of health clinics. I notice that the Minister said very little in reference to that matter. At present the dispensaries, as the House knows, have an atmosphere relating more or less to the cure of sickness. It would be a tremendous advance to have health clinics where people would normally come for consultation, where they would receive advice as to the best methods of keeping fit and where they could receive treatment when they became sick. I hope the Minister will consider that question as being of equal importance to the provision of hospitals. It is quite obvious that in this country the incidence of disease is related to a very considerable degree to the late notification of disease. People constantly wait too long before consulting a physician and as a result deaths from various types of disease are more numerous here than in other countries. That is the main reason for the high mortality from certain diseases. There are, of course, social and economical reasons, but late notification and the lack of desire to acquire modern knowledge on health matters and the treatment of disease is surely a contribution to the problem.
I should next like to ask the Minister as to whether he considers that in his plan for the prevention and treatment of tuberculosis, radiography should play a greater part. I understand that some 20,000 persons were inspected in the Dublin area alone by radiographic examination for tuberculosis during the period of office of the last Government. I understand that there was some difficulty in procuring apparatus and still greater difficulty in procuring travelling vans for carrying the radiographic apparatus. I should like to ask the Minister how many vans have been ordered and at what dates, and how many are likely to be secured in order that the work of examination can proceed throughout the country and in order that people living in rural areas in very modest circumstances can be afforded an opportunity of being X-rayed, not far from their own homes.
It would seem to me that late notification of tuberculosis is again a contributory cause to the high death-rate. A great many persons could be treated in their own homes provided the housing conditions were suitable if we had more of these vans, more examinations and an earlier attack upon tuberculosis when it is found to exist. It will be recalled that during the last 15 years the mortality from tuberculosis slightly decreased and at the beginning of the war it rose again. The Minister for Health did not tell the House it rose in other countries. As I understand, it fell very slightly towards the end of the war and then it rose again in 1947. The figures quite clearly show that the plans of the previous Government to attack tuberculosis were well conceived and that much good work was done.
I should like to ask the Minister whether he can give us some account of the research work done in tuberculosis and whether the early promise of some useful discoveries has been fulfilled. It will be recalled that the previous Government gave grants for the establishment of a tuberculosis service through the local authorities. I should like to ask the Minister whether that service is in his opinion operating fairly successfully in the majority of counties.
One very great contribution to the anti-tuberculosis campaign was the decision of the previous Government to make grants to breadwinners during the period of treatment. That would make it possible for persons, who know they have tuberculosis, to undertake treatment whereas before they dreaded the loss of income to their families. I should also like to ask the Minister whether he can give us some further reports as to the utilisation of B.C.G. vaccine. I understand that special training is required to make use of the vaccine and I should like to know whether a grant will be given in order that persons can be trained abroad for that purpose. As I understand it, a very considerable prejudice has been created amongst the English medical profession which has spread over to this country owing to the misuse of a vaccine which was not, in fact, the new vaccine, causing the deaths of some children. I should like to know if that prejudice has been overcome or whether it still exists and again whether it is proposed to train persons in the use of the vaccine.
Like another Deputy, I should like to know whether sufficient grants are to be made available for the purchase of the extremely precious drug known as streptomycin and whether any limitation has been placed on the quantity of that drug that can be made available. As I understand it it costs no less than £400 to treat a patient. That no doubt is a very considerable sum but if it provides a cure for certain types of the disease we should make the money available in full measure.
The Minister, in the course of one of his speeches, referred to his dislike of the old public assistance administration in this country. He spoke rather as if the previous Government had not adverted to that matter and had not studied the problem of ending the red ticket system. Of course the House and the people of the country know that the White Paper published by the last Government indicated that they considered inaugurating new and more expensive health services over and beyond anything that has been done under the recently passed Public Health Act. When the Minister says that he disapproves of the public assistance system in general, he almost automatically commits himself to some form of medical insurance such as that advocated by Sir William Beveridge. Once he wishes to extend free treatment in hospitals or free medical treatment and all that it implies to persons other than on a means test basis, he immediately raises the question of how the money is to be provided.
It will be recalled that the previous Government made tentative plans which were to be considered by the Dáil and indeed to be considered by the Government themselves, having regard to their serious intention of improving and extending the scheme of social insurance in this country, to include medical treatment for persons receiving less than £500 per year and for farmers occupying holdings with valuations under £25. The intention was that persons above that economic standard could take part in a scheme of social insurance and have free medical and hospital treatment if they so desired. The Minister has, I think, already committed himself to a dislike of what is popularly known as the red-ticket system. I should like to know whether he has adverted to the White Paper and whether he is now considering an alternative scheme or whether there is implied in his intentions some form of medical insurance.
In connection with the publicity scheme which the Minister is now going to undertake I hope he will have regard to the present regulations governing the operations of the Film Institute. The Film Institute has a library of films dealing with health matters and has a very limited grant from the Government. Its duties are confined to providing information as to what films can be obtained, keeping a library of films and demonstrating films when asked.
If a medical officer of health desires, for example, to demonstrate health films, he will find it difficult to secure a showing of films of a kind which would interest the public in general. He will find it difficult to get a sufficient audience in an ordinary cinema hall for the showing of films on purely health matters. He will find that it is possible for him to form a committee from the local authority, the librarian, the agricultural committee jointly to raise the capital and funds to have a joint film display of what might be a semi-educational character, but which might include films of an amusing nature for the public; but he will find the administrative difficulties in doing that enormous, and any medical officer of health will be thoroughly discouraged from undertaking such a display because of the administrative difficulties involved and because of the fact that the Film Institute, although it does very fine work, has not sufficient powers to carry out the whole of the administration of a film propaganda campaign itself. I would suggest to the Minister that he should do what the previous Government might well have done, if they had come back into office, having started the Film Institute and made a grant available, that is, extend the powers of the Film Institute in order that the institute can combine propaganda compaigns for health with the showing of films interesting and amusing to the public and see that all the red tape difficulties are overcome enabling such displays to take place.
I should like to repeat what I said at the commencement of my speech—that I was very much surprised by the observations of the Minister on this Estimate. I had thought when he stood up that we would here some little account of the Clann na Poblachta health plan and I was wondering whether perhaps, for once, one particular plan of that Party was not going to be in abeyance, but, having listened ad nauseam to their speeches off the platforms, I now find that the present plans of the Minister do not conform to the official programme of that Party and that, in this matter, as in others, the Clann na Poblachta programme is in abeyance.
Comment on this
Reading the statement made by the Minister as to the amount of money available for the hospitals, I personally felt rather troubled, because one of my first duties was to go to the Minister's Department in connection with the new hospital in Cork. I should like an assurance from him—his Department looked for an assurance from us that we would speed up in every way possible the plans and specifications for the building of that hospital—that there will be no delay with regard to finance for the building of the hospital. That is one of the things that I am anxious about in connection with this Estimate.
Another matter about which I am anxious is that, in a letter I had from the Minister, he states that they had not yet decided on the site for the maternity hospital in Cork. I understood, at the interview we had with his Department, that the maternity hospital was to be built on the same site as the regional hospital. Frankly, I can see no reason for any change in that respect. I cannot see any sense in travelling around looking for other sites and paying exorbitant sums for them, when there is a site available large enough for the purpose.
The main danger to health in this country is bad housing and, in that respect, the housing programme of the previous Government contributed very largely to ending the condition of affairs which prevailed here before. I am glad to see that the housing programme is going ahead at full steam, because 90 per cent. of the disease in the country is caused by bad housing conditions, particularly in our cities and towns. Another factor which contributed very largely to ill-health is the absence of sufficient nourishing fats, and in that respect the policy of the previous Government in the matter of food vouchers undoubtedly supplied a need. I wonder if the Minister will tell us his opinion of the withdrawal of the food voucher system by the Minister for Social Services. Deputy Childers, in speaking of this matter, made a slight mistake. Local authorities cannot now give food vouchers. They can give increased cash allowances, certainly, but what mattered to the wives and children of the poor was that they received, not cash, but milk, butter and everything else, when it was impossible for them to get them otherwise. We all know what happens when there is a scarcity of money, particularly in the homes of the poor.
I heard any amount of complaints about milk, particularly in Dublin and in Cork, as well. No doubt the milk situation is unsatisfactory, but it is unsatisfactory very largely owing to the fact that neither this Government nor its predecessor was prepared to allow to the farmer or producer the cost of production. That is the whole reason that we have Deputy Dockrell complaining of the quality and condition of the milk supplied in Dublin City. When you knock out of production the ordinary producer of milk, the man who is trained in the work, and who has spent a lifetime at it—the supply of liquid milk to a city or town is a trade in itself—and bring in instead milk produced on a farm on Sunday morning, Sunday evening and Monday morning, the three milkings being put together, sent to the local creamery where it is put into a churn and sent up to Dublin for distribution the following day, you cannot expect to have other than the kind of milk Deputy Dockrell spoke about, milk which goes sour a couple of hours after being delivered. I hope the Minister will induce his colleague, the Minister for Agriculture, to do something in that respect so as to secure a sufficient supply of proper milk for the cities and towns.
There is another matter into which I would like the Minister to inquire. We know that, at the ordinary auxiliary creamery where the milk is taken in and separated and where the cream is pasteurised and sent on to the central creamery, the man in charge must have a diploma of dairy science. I wonder what diploma the employees have of the firms that are entrusted with the processing of liquid milk for Dublin City? I would like the Minister to inquire into that particular aspect of the delivery of liquid milk. If he does, he will get a rather nasty shock.
The Minister is a new Minister coming in to a special job and we will have an opportunity, I hope, of criticising his work in that job on another Estimate for Health. I believe in giving every man a chance to make good. We cannot criticise or blame a Minister for anything that happened during a period when he was not in charge of a particular Department. I have no intention of doing so. But I would like to say that I read with interest the Minister's criticism of the various county homes in the country. I have been a member of a board of assistance for about 25 years. I will not say they are perfect. I would not like to give here the conditions of affairs as we found them when we first took over. There is an enormous disparity in the condition of affairs now and the condition of affairs when we first took over. I would like the Minister, the next time he comes to Cork, to pay a visit to the county home there and have a look around. Criticism is all right if it is criticism with knowledge. Criticism without knowledge is bad. Criticism of something that has not been seen is the worst of all. I suggest to the Minister that, before he starts off criticising the administration of county homes in this country, he should at least examine them for himself, see the condition of affairs in them and, having done so, if he finds any flaw, I can assure him, as far as we in Cork are concerned, any flaw he finds in that respect will be remedied at once. I certainly object to criticism that I consider unjustified.
I do not wish to take up the time of the House. I know it has gone beyond the ordinary time for Estimates. We are not responsible for the fact that this House met only once a week or once a fortnight when the various splinters were being collected and were being bound together. We are not responsible for the lateness of the period at which the Estimates are being considered. I am sure it will be admitted that Deputies who get an opportunity of examining a particular Department one day in the year are entitled to give their views on it. That is the position in regard to this and other Estimates and, as I stated, I have no intention of delaying the House. I just wished to point out the few matters with which I am concerned.
Comment on this
I would like first of all to pay a tribute to the treatment which has been given, on the whole, to this Estimate by the majority of Deputies. As a new Deputy and a new Minister, I have been particularly impressed by the objective, critical—it is quite accepted —and to a large extent constructive and helpful suggestions which have been put forward by the majority of Deputies on both sides of the House. I welcome those criticisms as it is obvious that no Department can properly function without full consideration being given to the points which may be raised by Deputies representing constituencies in the whole of our State. I would like particularly to pay my tribute to the deliberations and helpful suggestions of my predecessor, Deputy Dr. Ryan, and of the other doctor members of the House who did contribute a number of very important suggestions and ideas, which I am certain can be of use to me in the proper running of my Department.
In dealing with these matters generally, I will attempt to reply, to the best of my ability, to the many queries which have been put forward in the debate. If, during my reply, I do not refer to questions which have been raised by some Deputies, I would like them to understand that this is so through inadvertence on my part. I would be very glad, indeed, if they would take up with me the matters in which they are particularly interested and make personal recommendations. I should be very glad to discuss any of their difficulties with any of the Deputies.
I am in complete agreement with the Deputies who have given their views that the mother and child service is an extremely important one and that a proper functioning service such as this can be of tremendous advantage to the community in the provision for us of a healthy nation. This service could be a particularly vital and important one. The seriousness which I attach to it has been responsible for my action in delaying the full implementation of a mother and child service, without first giving the whole matter of the high infantile mortality rate and the other ancillary matters in relation to it to a child health council for their consideration and their general directions. This council is composed of very eminent specialists in child health. I feel that the advice of those experts will be of paramount importance to me in introducing a scheme which is likely to be of value and assistance. I feel a very deep responsibility in the carrying out of my duties as Minister for Health and, therefore, I am not anxious to rush into the implementation of any such highly complicated and quite controversial scheme for mothers and children. However, I accept the principle of such a service and intend to introduce some such service.
There are a few misapprehensions which have filtered through a daily paper, unfortunately, down to a number of the Deputies who were unable to attend in the Dáil when I was making my opening remarks. The general trend, as delivered by the Deputies— Deputy MacEntee was one of them, and I think Deputy Childers was another— covered the question of the axing of the health services. My impression has been that, in recent days, the reliability of that paper has been successfully questioned.
Comment on this
Consequently, it is not surprising that the information which they apparently gleaned from this newspaper was incorrect. There is no question of the axing of any of these health provisions. Deputy Dr. Ryan in his otherwise extremely accurate speech in this debate, mentioned a figure of £37,000,000 which was proposed in a White Paper by the previous Administration. This was reiterated by Deputy Moran. He said that that was a proposal put up by the previous Administration. He then said that my figures were the expenditure of some £15,000,000 over a period of ten years. Both those figures are wrong. The White Paper estimate of expenditure was £30,000,000 and my expenditure is one of £15,000,000 over seven years. This is not all. They appear to have overlooked the fact that I have said that this position in regard to the provision of hospitals will be reviewed as soon as the position in regard to materials improves and, anyway, in a matter of three years. As a matter of fact, I do not remember—I may be wrong—using the words "shortage of money" anywhere in the whole of my statement in the Dáil. Certainly, it has not been a consideration in this Government in the provision of hospitals. I would like that to be clear, in the first instance. It would be easy for me to come into the Dáil and promise £37,000,000 or £30,000,000, or whatever you like but I have an old-fashioned sense of responsibility and a sense of honesty and a feeling that, if I make a statement, I should be prepared to carry out that statement and fulfil the promise made.
Deputy Dr. Ryan made some remarks about the duties of dispensary doctors, their long hours and their future in the health services. I agree completely with his criticisms of the conditions under which our dispensary medical officers are at present working and their long hours. The whole question of the future of our medical services, including that particular question, is obviously a difficult and troublesome one. Experience from other countries has shown us that the provision of a medical service, including private practitioners and public health service, is one which should not be introduced without the most mature and prolonged consideration. Other Ministers of Health have introduced such things and have tried to introduce such things. My knowledge is not complete on this subject, but as far as I know, there is not yet a perfect health medical scheme in operation. There are very severe criticisms to be heard on all sides in regard to what is considered an ideal one, the one in New Zealand. We should give serious consideration to the matter before we promise the people something which it might be impossible to introduce.
Little has been said in relation to prevention. When I went into the Department of Health, I treated the position as if I were treating a patient. I was faced with a health service which was, as a patient, seriously ill. I had to treat the condition which I found in the first instance; the question of prevention must come later, but I can assure the Deputies that it certainly will come.
Deputy Dr. Ryan talked about regional sanatoria and asked with regard to the future of these projects. Of course, every single one of them is going ahead. It is merely a question of whether we adhere to his particular idea of three major sanatoria, or consider the rather more complete decentralisation of these very large hospitals and so provide nearer home for every section of the people of the country a sub-regional sanatorium which will be completely self-contained, and which will be in a position to give a first class service to the people near their own homes. These are problems which we are considering at the moment. We shall arrive at a decision on them in a very short time. We had a number of criticisms in regard to what has been done. Deputy Dr. Ryan appears to have a simply fabulous memory. Over a number of years he remembered the number of beds provided at Peamount—120; at Newcastle 80, and at Lourdes 43; but then his memory seemed to slip him. He said that the local authority had been approached in regard to Castlerea and had agreed to hand it over, or words to that effect. In point of accuracy, that is simply not true. The authorities at Castlerea were not approached, but I am deeply indebted to the mental hospital authority there for handling it over. They had not been approached prior to my coming into the Department. Again, he produced for me one of the finest examples that I have yet seen of the triumph of mind over matter and, in fact, over fiction. He said that when he was in Galway he saw development works for the Galway regional sanatorium going ahead and he wondered what was happening now. Well, I will tell him. The development works started last Monday, and when he was down there he saw grass and trees growing, but there was little else.
Comment on this
With regard to Dublin a number of Deputies wondered what the hospital position is. Deputy McCann and Deputy Byrne and Deputy Burke and others spoke on it. In regard to the regional hospitals in Cork—Deputy Corry was worried about Cork—Galway, and Limerick they are all to go ahead. Deputy McCann was worried about the Coombe hospital. We propose to go ahead with it. He was also worried about a genito-urinary unit in the Meath hospital. We are to go ahead with a genito-urinary unit in the Meath hospital.
Comment on this
I am sorry. There is to be provided in Dublin a large general hospital of the size of perhaps St. Laurence's. A decision on that has not yet been arrived at, but it will be in the next week or so.
Comment on this
Exactly—for years. Deputy Dr. Brennan, Deputy Byrne, Deputy Burke, Deputy O'Grady, and other Deputies discussed the question of nurses, of nurses' homes, and the conditions for nurses in hospitals and sanatoria. Well, as a matter of fact, the local authorities, I think, have a particularly good reputation in regard to these nurses. I think that the nurses referred to by Deputy Dr. Brennan were the voluntary hospital nurses. We have no jurisdiction over them, and the conditions under which they work are entirely the responsibility of these hospitals, and any criticisms which are to be made can be directed towards the proper responsible authority.
In regard to local authority nurses, there is a superannuation scheme, and the working hours are not as suggested by Deputy Dr. Brennan. What we have recommended is that a 96-hour fortnight should be worked by these girls. We consider that these are the hours, and certainly no more, that these girls should be asked to work. There are a number of nurses' homes on the priority list for building in Dublin, Limerick, the Drogheda Memorial Hospital, St. Michael's, Dún Laoghaire, Mullingar, Sligo, Tralee, Tullamore, Portlaoighise, Castlebar, Roscommon, and Mallow, and also tuberculosis nurses' homes at Peamount, Newcastle, Lourdes, Woodlands, as well as a number of mental hospitals.
I am fully conscious of the conditions under which nurses have been working for a number of years. My personal opinion is that the girls are not particularly interested in the purely financial side. I think that I can pay this form of tribute to them, that if we treat them humanely, house them well and give them rather good reasonable working conditions, with good recreational facilities, we will have no shortage of nurses in Ireland. The girls are only too glad to work in their own country for their own people.
With regard to public health clinics, referred to by Deputy McCann, there is in the priority scheme £500,000 to be spent on public health clinics and dispensaries. I am fully aware of the position in regard to dispensaries. I think that, if my memory serves me, there are about 600 dispensaries and 300 depôts and that only 5 per cent. of these approximate to what are reasonable normal standards of building. That is a formidable task which we have to try to overcome.
In regard to the question of tuberculosis generally, this is a very big problem, and brings us back to what has been done. As I said in my original statement, we have been able to acquire in Castlerea the mental hospital and in Mallow the district hospital, which has been given by the people of that area—a very fine self-sacrificing act—and also Coláiste Mobhi in the Phoenix Park. Beds already provided in the four months number 373 and we hope to reach the 800 to 900 mark by the end of this year.
With regard to cancer, this I also consider to be a very important and very serious problem. Most of us are aware of it. We have set up a council of experts to advise us on what are the best lines to approach this problem. Meanwhile, as one of our priorities, we have sanctioned the provision of a large out-patients department in St. Anne's Cancer Hospital in Dublin. That is obviously a preliminary until we find out the best lines on which to approach this whole problem.
Deputy Briscoe and a number of other Deputies referred to the question of juvenile mental defectives. A total of £656,000 is to be expended on the provision of institutions for these children at Lota, County Cork; the Sisters of Charity, Clonsilla; St. Augustine's, Blackrock, and Moore Abbey. This will meet to a certain extent the demand for beds and accommodation. As Deputy Dr. Ryan pointed out, the demand at the moment is in the region of 6,000, and we are anxious to get accommodation for them.
Deputy Coburn referred to the County Louth. The hospital position in County Louth is particularly bad and we propose to sanction the building of a county hospital of 102 beds and 11 extra beds will be provided in the Drogheda Cottage Hospital. The County Hospital in Dundalk will be converted into a 36-bed maternity hospital and the fever hospital in Dundalk will be reconstructed. Similarly, in County Wicklow it is proposed to provide a county hospital containing 60 beds. It is proposed to provide for ten maternity beds, nurses' quarters and sanitary accommodation in Baltinglass District Hospital and to extend the fever hospital. In Carlow we hope to provide a regional hospital for Carlow and Kildare. I think Deputies can take it that working within the limitations, which are purely those of materials and labour, we shall spare no effort to see that every county in Ireland where there is a need shall benefit from this building grant. They can be assured, so far as I am concerned, that there is no question of any political or any other bias in arriving at my conclusions in regard to the need in any particular area for hospital facilities.
It seems to me unfortunate that this debate should have been sullied by the interference of Deputy MacEntee who has, I am glad to say, left the House. Until his intervention the debate was kept on a very high level by all sections of the House. Deputy MacEntee introduced an entirely new note. He asked a number of questions, purely mischievous ones, but I shall provide him with some answers, anyway. With regard to Cork Street Hospital, he asked why I did not publish the report of the inspector. I ask Deputy MacEntee why he did not publish the report when he was so strongly pressed to do so. He asked what I had done and said I did little else but talk and get publication in the Press. As I have said, in four months I have provided nearly 100 beds a month for sufferers from tuberculosis. If Deputy MacEntee had been sufficiently interested in this problem before he passed to that side of the House, there would be no such problem facing me at the moment.
Deputy MacEntee discussed the White Paper and referred to plans and promises. He used the word "plans" 11 times in as many minutes. He said that I criticised the White Paper. I did not criticise what was in it. My criticism was directed to the fact that the Dáil unanimously passed the Sanatoria Bill, which became law on the 6th March, 1945, which authorised the Department to provide 2,000 extra beds for sufferers from tuberculosis in three regional sanatoria, and, as I told Deputy Kennedy, the development work started last Monday on the first of these.
Comment on this
I should like to ask the Minister when were the plans and specifications prepared for this particular scheme. When was Merlin Park purchased? Is the Minister aware that the original site was held up and that it had to be changed?
Comment on this
Will the Deputy tell me what good excuses are to a man who wants a bed in a sanatorium? What good is a White Paper? I know there are difficulties.
Comment on this
The Minister gave me an opportunity of answering a question and I want an answer to it. I do not want him to shelve it.
Comment on this
You shelved the sanatoria. That is much more important to us. Deputy MacEntee talked about his plans and his proposals. He also said that I criticised at Ringsend and other places the extravagance of his administration. I most certainly did criticise at Ringsend, all round SouthEast Dublin, and all round Ireland the extravagance of Deputy MacEntee's Administration and I would do it again. I did not criticise his extravagance in regard to public health, because there was not any. I criticised the extravagance in regard to aerodromes, aeroplanes, etc. Those are the things I criticised and will continue to criticise. A White Paper or any other paper is no good; plans and promises are no good to a sick man. That is why I am at the moment working on urgent practical matters. I am not theorising; I am not now planning; I am still working in order to give practical effect to the needs of the people.
Comment on this
Deputy MacEntee also made another point, a really good one. "Did I not know what the previous Administration did." As a matter of fact I accepted it and I was not making a point of it. Allowances were made for the dependents of people with infectious diseases. I was well aware of that. I heard of it for the first time when I was going down to make an election speech on the 11th February, just prior to the general election, and I made a point of it. It seemed to me to be a startling coincidence that these allowances should be introduced a week before the general election and 16 years after Fianna Fáil came into office.
Comment on this
There is a small point with regard to salaries that I would like to refer to, a point that I hate to waste the time of the House on. The Deputy however, made a point about Minister's salaries. I said I would take whatever the salary was before. The fact of the matter is that I actually never made that promise in public, because, to me, it is a thing about which I would not like to talk, but, as it happens, I do not accept at the moment the full Ministerial salary, and we in this inter-Party Government have adhered to that particular principle.
Comment on this
I would like to deal with the question of propaganda with regard to health. It is obvious that we will use to the full the cinemas, the radio, the newspapers and talks to the people generally, and in this way I hope that we will build up a positive health campaign and that it will act as a form of preventative to bring people earlier to the authorities for treatment for their diseases.
Deputy Moran made a suggestion about compulsory examination of contacts and a number of other people. I have always considered compulsion of any kind as being a degradation of the intelligence of the average civilised member of any community, and I deprecate the use of compulsion as I did on a former occasion when a highly controversial Health Bill was introduced into this Dáil. I was not in the Dáil at the time but I opposed it as much as I could outside.
Deputy MacEntee—I have to go back to him again—said that I should spend so much more money, unlimited money. One of my remarks was that I considered that for the health of the people the provision of houses was nearly as important as the provision of hospitals. Because in this inter-Party Government there is co-ordination and sympathy between the Ministers, we are able to do our best to fit in and co-ordinate our schemes. To me it seemed unfortunate that in Deputy MacEntee's Government they could not have arrived at some such form of co-ordination and save to the taxpayers of this country the sum of £58,000 which was poured down the empty drains of Santry Court. That was one of the fiascos, that regional sanatorium which was proposed in 1945. That amount of £58,000——
Comment on this
I hope that the Deputies will accept my invitation to make personal representations with regard to any problem in connection with the provision of hospitals or dispensaries or anything relating to the health services, and I will be very glad to discuss any of these matters with Deputies of both sides of the House.
Comment on this
I just want to have one matter clarified. Galway County Council is deeply involved in this matter. I believe that a sort of reflection was cast on Galway County Council by the Minister, although it was probably done unintentionally. They prepared plans for a regional sanatorium in Galway——
Comment on this
They had purchased the site. They had contracted for development. They had advertised. They had water laid on at the site before he had the opportunity of seeing the site. I am asking for a correction from the Minister.
Comment on this
There is just one point which the Minister missed. I asked him a specific question with regard to rheumatism and whether it was his intention to go ahead with regional development, the development of regional clinics similar to that which exists in Dublin. I asked him in the course of my speech on the Estimate——
Comment on this
With regard to rheumatism clinics, we are training doctors in the first clinic and when they have gained some experience we hope to expand the service over the whole country.