We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Committee on Finance. - Vote 29—Agriculture (Resumed).

Contributions 1–134 of 252. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Last night, I was dealing with our position as regards wheat. The policy of the last Government was to endeavour to get the people of this country, so to speak, wheat-minded, so that in case of war or in case our communications with the outside world might be cut off, we would have sufficient bread to feed our people. For that purpose, during the years 1932 to 1939 we definitely paid more for wheat than the price at which it could be bought abroad. We did that for a definite purpose. The irresponsible attitude of the Minister when he came into office has brought about this year a definite reduction in the wheat acreage. There is no use in pretending that it has not. If the seed does not go into the ground, the wheat will not be produced. A very large proportion of the seed went to the millers. The Minister would have very little difficulty in finding out from his own Department the quantity of seed wheat that went back to the millers in 1947 and the quantity that went back in 1948. He will find that his foolish statements have brought about a condition of affairs that I am sure he does not wish for any more than I do. I do not want to see this country in need of wheat. I do not want to see this country in need of bread. That is, however, the Minister's job and I fear that his foolish statements will have repercussions.

I have already pointed out that the attitude of the Minister in giving us an uneconomic price for liquid milk will have definite reactions this winter in regard to the milk supply to the cities and towns. I would like to point out in that respect that recently I had a letter from the Minister's Department in connection with six months' contracts. If the Minister wants any information in connection with six months' contracts he has two means of getting it. There is the Cork Milk Board under the control of his Department. There is the Minister for Local Government, who can tell him that the contracts for the mental hospitals, county hospitals, county homes and all other institutions are six months' contracts and no more. He has a very simple way of finding out what he requires to know and it is not my duty to point out to the Minister or his Department the way in which they should get that information. They are long enough in the job to know for themselves.

We have, very definitely, an uneconomic price for milk. As far as the Minister is concerned, he has brought in a pretty steep reduction in the price of cattle. As soon as he effects non-competition in the Dublin market, the price of cattle is bound to fall. I have given the difference as stated by the Minister in this House between the price of cattle sold in Britain last year and the price of cattle sold here—£10 a head.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy is repeating.

Comment on this

I am covering the different points.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy dealt with that extensively last night.

Comment on this

All right. On the beet question, and the Minister's attitude in regard to beet, which I indicated last night, I would like to point out to the House and particularly to Deputy Cogan that up to the moment it is the only phase of the industry on which we have been met with a fair face in regard to agricultural costings. In every industry the cost of production plus profit basis is acknowledged and recognised. It is not recognised here in agriculture. Seeing the wild rush made by the Clann na Talmhan Party after my motions which I put down two years ago, I thought that the least price they would have extracted for giving us that Minister for Agriculture was that we would have some costings board here before which the agricultural community could appear and get costings on a production plus profit basis, the same as every other industry in the State. I expected it. I have dealt with the costings we have got in connection with milk.

Comment on this
James Matthew Dillon Minister for Agriculture (Mr. Dillon) Independent

Summer and winter?

Comment on this

If the Minister chooses to deny the farmer any penny for himself, or deny him his salary as manager or farm steward, if he chooses to deny what goes into every other industry, namely, interest on capital, that is his own business and the business of those who put him there—the representatives of the farmers in this House.

Comment on this

The Deputy has not produced the costings for summer milk.

Comment on this

The Minister has got the costings in as far as we got them. They are in the Department since last January.

Comment on this

There are costings for summer and winter milk and the Deputy has not given the costings for the summer milk.

Comment on this

Unfortunately, we had not got them ourselves, as we put our men and our farms on costings in October, 1946.

Comment on this

They are there, if the Deputy goes and asks for them.

Comment on this

They are there and I am sure we will get them and that there will be no objection in giving them to the Minister.

Comment on this

I will be glad to see them.

Comment on this

I am dealing with the costings the Minister has got and which are in his possession.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy dealt with costings last night.

Comment on this

I cannot help the disorderly interruption of the Minister.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy may not repeat the speech he made last night.

Comment on this

Granted.

Comment on this

He is trying to obstruct.

Comment on this

I was on beet costings, not milk costings. I made a passing reference to the fact that we had got our milk costings. We are at present engaged with the sugar company in getting out the cost of production of beet. There are something like 400 farmers engaged in that job. We are working under a guarantee from the sugar company that we will get that cost of production, plus a decent profit added on for our beet growers. All praise to the general manager of the sugar company and the company itself, they are the first people to acknowledge the right of the farmers to the cost of production plus profit.

What is the Minister's attitude towards all that? I quoted here last night his attitude towards beet, as given by him here on 6th of June, 1946. Are we, on behalf of the agricultural community, to spend a couple of thousand pounds in beet costings and put 300 or 400 of our farmers to the trouble and expense of preparing those costings, giving the time and labour to them, to hand it all over, from the so-called representatives of agriculture in this House, to a Minister who has declared that his job is to blow up the beet factories, or that they should be blown up? That is the condition of affairs which, unfortunately, has been brought about, with a very definite set purpose. I gave last night the Minister's opinion of those people who he stated "had gone from one foolish thing to another" until they crowned all their foolish things by making Deputy James Dillon Minister for Agriculture.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy may not repeat himself.

Comment on this

I want to know if it is the Minister's intention to set up a costings board, to give the farmer some hope of getting his cost of production plus profit, the same as every other industry is entitled to and has got. That is a fair question. We know where we stand at the moment in connection with milk—that every five shillings you put on to the agricultural labourer's wage represents a halfpenny a gallon on milk.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy dealt with milk extensively last night.

Comment on this

The Deputy is, I respectfully submit on a point of order, busily engaged in repeating his speech of last night, for the purpose of wasting time, in obstruction, just as Deputy Smith did for four hours.

Comment on this

You bumptious scoundrel, you.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Smith will withdraw that remark.

Comment on this

I withdraw, Sir, but I cannot help thinking.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

A withdrawal should be gracious.

Comment on this

I have dealt with the various aspects of this matter. I definitely am not repeating when I ask the Minister here if he is prepared to set up a costings board. According to my notes here, that is a thing I have not dealt with yet. I have given the results of costings committees and have stated what is desired.

In regard to bacon, I suggest to this Minister, who is so anxious that farm labourers' wages be increased, who is willing to give the farm labourer a better wage, who says that if he is there for five years and if the farm labourer is not as well paid as his comrade in the city, he will have failed in his job——

Comment on this

The Deputy did not give the agricultural labourer any assistance to get as well off.

Comment on this

I am dealing with bacon, before I finish I will deal with political pigs.

Comment on this

What does he mean?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

It would be hard to interpret the Deputy.

Comment on this

I promise that, since I am put to it, I will deal with it before I am finished. Since they want it, they can have it; and I will not be out of order, either.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That is for the Chair to judge. The Deputy is on a wide range this morning.

Comment on this

If these people draw me out, I cannot help it. The Minister says it is his policy to make the farmer better off and to increase the prices he is going to get; but, according to Deputy Fagan, he has reduced the price of bacon by 12/- per cwt., and he met the bacon curers and told them to bring down the price of that bacon from 210/- to 190/- or, in other words, by £2 each in the price of a pig. That has been the Minister's contribution towards increasing production of bacon plus the increase in the price for maize. Pigs and politics are mixed in Cork. Immediately after each general election, premiums for boars are given out on the basis of the number of election agents, and each fellow gets a premium for a boar. I am glad that Deputy McAuliffe does not deny that.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy might treat this matter seriously.

Comment on this

I am treating it seriously. I think it will be admitted that it is a very serious matter that money voted here for premiums for boars is used for paying election agents down the country.

Comment on this

I would point out that the Deputy is in a position to give more information about payments than either Deputy Halliden or myself whom he has attacked in this regard.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

He mentioned no names, and unless he wants pack drill he will not.

Comment on this

If the cap fits anyone let him wear it. I am not anxious to take up the time of the House. Deputy P. D. Lehane, a member of the Clann na Talmhan Party, speaking here in the Budget debate on freightage charges in connection with beet, said that I had made no attempt last year to go to Córas Iompair Éireann and get these freightage charges reduced. When Deputy Lehane made that statement he knew very well that it was not correct because he went with me to Córas Iompair Éireann.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That has nothing to do with this Estimate.

Comment on this

Beet, surely, has to do with agriculture.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy's alleged dispute with a fellow Deputy is not in order.

Comment on this

I am dealing with a public statement that was made in this House which was a reflection on me. Surely I am entitled to deal with a statement that was made by Deputy Lehane that I did not make any attempt——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Lehane did not speak on this Estimate.

Comment on this

Not on this Estimate.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Very good.

Comment on this

I will take some other opportunity of bringing it up in this House and of correcting it. Let there be no doubt about that. I do not intend to delay the House further. I have given the facts as I know them. My extreme sympathy goes not to the Minister but to those unfortunates who have to deal with him. I pity the Deputies opposite. I do that sincerely. Imagine the mind of the Taoiseach, how the poor man gets up in the morning in fear and trembling as to what he may find the Minister has said the night before.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Taoiseach is not in charge of this Estimate and the Deputy will now deal with it.

Comment on this

I cannot say that I have sympathy for the Clann na Talmhan Party, who are responsible for putting that Minister there.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That is repetition. You gave us all that yesterday.

Comment on this

If the Deputies opposite want me to continue for a couple of hours I am ready to oblige them. We as an agricultural community are brought up against this position— Deputy Keane alluded to it last night and Deputy McAuliffe made a few little allusions to it to-day. It is in connection with a circular which was sent out from the Minister's Department to the Cork County Committee of Agriculture in relation to a week's holidays for farm labourers and a half-day each week. During my whole lifetime I have always been anxious that the agricultural labourer would be placed in at least as good a position as his brother in the town or the city.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

We heard that at least twice last night from the Deputy.

Comment on this

Surely I am entitled to refer to this circular that was sent out.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

To repeat what was said yesterday, no.

Comment on this

The condition of affairs that we find is this, that labour is paid a wage that renders it practically impossible for us to hold any decent worker on the land. The fault for that is that the prices for agricultural products are such that they will not enable us to pay a better wage. I am as anxious as any man in the country to see the farm labourer get a week's holidays, as well as others, and his half-day on a Saturday if that can be managed by any means.

Comment on this

You voted against it last Saturday.

Comment on this

You do not know what you are talking about.

Comment on this

I know well.

Comment on this

You are too thick.

Comment on this

I would not class myself with you.

Comment on this

Deputy McAuliffe is speaking the truth.

Comment on this

He voted against it last Saturday when there were three different amendments before the County Committee of Agriculture in Cork.

Comment on this

I voted last Saturday in favour of looking for ways and means by which a week's holidays would be given, and if Deputy McAuliffe cares he can have the minutes of the meeting produced here. I voted on last Saturday to have this matter adjourned until such time as the prices for agricultural products justified it, which they do not.

Comment on this

What are we discussing? Cork County Committee of Agriculture?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

We are not, or we should not be.

Comment on this

We are but we should not be.

Comment on this

Who introduced it?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That does not bring it into order.

Comment on this

Before the Deputy leaves that matter, may I raise a point of order?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

With the Deputy's permission only.

Comment on this

The Deputy used words in reference to a Deputy of this House. "That the Deputy is too thick"——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That is the point of order. Very good. My sympathies are always with the Deputy who is interrupted, not with the interrupter. The man who interrupts looks for it and if he gets it I cannot help it.

Comment on this

I very willingly withdraw the phrase.

Comment on this

I do not want any apologies that Deputy Corry may give. Everybody knows the type Deputy Corry is and I do not want Deputy Corry to withdraw.

Comment on this

From the point of view of Parliamentary language——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I am glad that the Deputy is so concerned about it.

Comment on this

Apart from that resolution on the agenda of the Cork County Committee of Agriculture, I definitely am anxious to see a condition of affairs in which the agricultural labourer will be able to get a rest on Sunday and facilities as good at least as those enjoyed by his fellow workers in the towns and cities.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Repetition. If the Deputy persists in repetition he will sit down.

Comment on this

The Deputy had no intention of repeating himself.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The road to some place is paved with them.

Comment on this

The Deputy has no intention of occupying the time of this House unduly or unfairly.

Comment on this

God forgive you.

Comment on this

If I were to deal with all the idiotic statements of that Minister over the last five or six years I could keep the House, not for a day, but for a fortnight, and I would not be finished then.

Comment on this

I still believe in Parliamentary democracy.

Comment on this

This day is generally a field day for farmers, but unfortunately the farmers in the country will not think this a field day for them, because we have had enough Parliamentary nonsense to sicken the poorest farmer. The city mentality may think about "gombeen farmers", but farmers, who are nothing more than "gombeen" men, have spoken in this House. In the phase of agriculture over the last 25 years we have seen a good deal of compulsion. We have had compulsion from Fianna Fáil for the last 15 years, and agriculture is now in the worst position it has ever been in, but we have now a new Minister with a new outlook, a "new look" and a voluntary period will be tried out now.

I am satisfied that if our farmers are harnessed to a voluntary system of agriculture they will take off their coats and work as they ought to work. I know they will, and I know that our farmers will be the better for not having compulsion. I listened to Deputy Smith for the past two days and I am sorry to see such a despicable attitude on the part of an ex-Minister. You would think he would act as a respectable man considering the responsibility he has held on his shoulders, but the play-acting, tomboy tirade, which he tried to put across to the new Minister was the mean, low and cowardly work of a bully. Deputy Smith is not fit to wipe the boots of the man he was trying to put it across and Deputy Smith knew it. It was nothing more than a fit of jealousy, the case of a small man jealous of a big man.

Since the new Government came into power I am happy to say that the farmers have got a new trade agreement across the water, which, if it is worked in the proper spirit, will bring immense benefits to the agricultural community. The Minister has done his part and it is now up to the farmers to do their part. The farmers have the ball at their feet and I hope they play ball. I would ask the Minister in the next few years to try to bring about a better spirit among the farming community, a spirit of co-operation. Co-operation is a thing which we certainly lack in this country. The farmers have never understood co-operation. If they had we would have a far greater output than we have at the moment. Without co-operation among our farmers we will not get that output. Each farmer is an individualist who tries to pull his own way.

I heard Deputy Fagan say that we would never have co-operation from our farmers, but that is wrong. I have tried it in my own parish with six farmers, well-picked men, middle-class farmers, and it worked immensely well. We started off by co-operating to buy a reaper and binder. We worked it for a few years and got our crops cut on time. We loaned it out and got a nice income from it. We then bought an oats sower, a grass seeds sower and a sprayer. We never had a hitch over six or seven years. It changed our agriculture immensely and we have now up-to-date methods where before we had lackadaisical methods or no methods at all. What we did in a small way in the parish could be done over the whole country. With the goodwill of a few men at the top we could get an immense amount of co-operation. I know that a crank here and there can do a great deal of harm, but it is the man at the top who really matters.

What I did not like about the Fianna Fáil policy for the past 15 years was the way they broke the manly spirit of our farmers. They spent all their time trying to get our farmers and the farm labourers into the hollow of their hand. Then they knocked them down, trampled on them and wiped their boots on them. When they had them as serfs they decided to raise them up and give them little sops now and again. That is not the spirit that will raise agriculture in this country. Farmers are decent and noble men if you let them alone, but they are hardly ever let alone. What I like about the new Minister is that spirit of his that will lead the farmers to the independent position they had in the past. Let them fend for themselves. If farmers are let fend for themselves they will do their work and do it well.

Up to now farmers and farm labourers were only political suckers. They had to look to what way the wind was going to blow next. They were afraid if De Valera came into power again they would get it in the neck, but I am glad to say that De Valera is out. A new look has come in. The farmers can raise their heads and there is no doom hanging over their heads now.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

It might be more Parliamentary to say "Deputy de Valera" than "De Valera".

Comment on this

I am sorry. The Minister at the moment has his hands full as he has a good deal of rings to burst. He has the manure rings to tackle and I know he will tackle them; he has tackled the bacon ring and broken it and he has to tackle the flour ring and the cattle ring. There is a cattle ring at the moment in our fairs and markets. Not alone that, but there is a ring in connection with the buying of foreign cattle, a dirty mean ring who keep things to themselves and keep everybody else in the cattle business out in the cold. I ask the Minister to break that ring and, if possible, change many of the men who were appointed cattle buyers in the past because they were nothing more than political hacks put there for a certain purpose and they carried on in a mean way. One man would play into another man's hands and decent men were kept out and could not get to sell their cattle. I hope the Minister will tackle those rings and break them.

All the phases of agriculture have been pretty well debated. I come from a county where we have many phases of agriculture. We have the small farmer and we have the large rancher and now we have the milk business starting in a large way. All these phases of agriculture could co-operate without any harm to each other. Each man should take off his coat and mind his own business. We are told that farmers are down and out. The poor mouth is always made about farmers. I do not hold that the farmer is down and out. He will never be down and out. He has carried on for hundreds of years in bad and good times. The farmer who takes off his coat and works is always able to survive. He may go down to rock bottom, but he will come up again. It is the "fly-by-night" farmer who brought about the slump in agriculture.

The question of milk production was very fully debated. So far as my county is concerned, the small and middle-class farmers are getting into the milk business. I asked several of them how they were getting on and they told me that they were doing exceedingly well, that they were doubling their stock every year. Some of them who started with three or four cows have now 50 or 60. They all tell me that they are doing well. They would not go into the business if they thought they would not make money. Of course every man will fight for a bigger price.

Those who have to milk cows have a hard time, of course, but, at the same time, if they worked in a proper spirit for the last few months instead of going on strike, they would be better off. Last Christmas some of these people held a meeting and wanted to go on strike, but the principal leaders said: "Oh, no, we would embarrass the Government". A few months afterwards there was a change of Government and another meeting was held and they said they would go out on strike. The instigator of that strike was Deputy Smith, the former Minister. They would not embarrass Deputy Smith a few months ago. These are things which I should like to see exposed. The Minister should stick his heels in the ground, because he has the majority of the people behind him. All I want the Minister to do is to see that fair and reasonable prices and wages are paid and a proper spirit created. In that way we will have an upward trend in this country and our farmers will be in a free and independent position.

The Minister will have to focus attention on the question of industrial tariffs. With the industrial tariffs we have at present we shall never be able to put the agricultural worker in the position of the town worker. As I said last year, the small boy in the town making the leg of a chair or a piano is able to earn £6 or £8 or £10 a week, while the agricultural worker, who is producing much-needed food for the people, gets £2 10s. 0d. That matter will have to be tackled. The Minister will have to see that those who have high industrial tariffs behind them do not carry on as they are carrying on at present. I know some of these men in my own county who are enjoying these tariffs and they are able to tell me that they have so much money they do not know what to do with it.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Minister for Agriculture does not control that matter.

Comment on this

It has a lot to do with agriculture. The present tariff wall should be lowered.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Tariffs do not arise on this Vote.

Comment on this

Farmers will have to do a good deal to help the Minister in order to put agriculture where it should be. We are not getting the output from the majority of the farmers or the workers which we got in the past. They are not doing as their forefathers did. They would be far better off if they did. So far as my county is concerned, one of the things I cannot understand is that the larger the landholders the faster they are selling out. In the last four or five years nearly all those with 300 or 400 acres of land in County Meath have sold out and new people from Great Britain, India, and other countries are coming in here and taking over the land which these men left. What is wrong with these people that they cannot live on 300 or 400 acres of the best land in the County Meath? There should be an inquiry into that because there must be something wrong. I think I can put my finger on what is wrong. Most of these people are living beyond their means. They are having a royal time. They have not only one motor car, but two or three. They attend every race meeting and sports meeting in the country and the land is left to fend for itself with a herd and a dog. That is not farming. It may provide pleasure for these people, but it is not good for the country.

I ask the Minister to try to find out why these people whom we thought were wealthy are selling out. I know that if I had 100 acres I would not give two hoots about anything. I would have a royal time, but I would mind my business. On the other hand, the men with 40 or 50 acres of land are fixed units and they are doing well. The fact is that the man who minds his business will always be able to carry on.

We heard a good deal about cattle prices and we are all glad to see that good prices are being paid. It would, however, be far better if cattle prices were not quite so high. Most of the people who are doing well in the cattle line are ranchers and are going out of tillage. That is not good for the country. I should like to see a mixed tillage policy carried out in the country. The large landholders should not go completely out of tillage. They should remain in tillage so as to give employment and not go back to the herd and the dog. If they do, they are going to have endless trouble. I do not blame the small uneconomic landowners who live near one of these people for having a grievance. They see him having that grand time. He has to give no employment except to keep a herd and a dog there and the cattle are sent to the market in Britain and fetch good prices. They will say to themselves: "This fellow is well off and he has not to work hard while we are here tilling with our horses and ploughs from morning till night and we are barely able to scrape a living." Therefore, I would urge upon the Minister that we need a good mixed tillage policy for this country. I do not agree that there should be any compulsion about it because I am satisfied that there is no need for compulsion.

I would recommend the Minister to make a tour of the country and discuss matters with the people in the different districts. He should do as the Minister for Health and the Minister for Local Government have been doing in the last few months. The Minister for Local Government paid a visit to County Meath last Monday. Many of the people there did not want to see him but when he came they were highly pleased with him. He gave us an outline of what he wanted and he showed his form. He impressed all the officials of the county council of that county as a man of business. If the Minister for Agriculture were to do likewise and meet the farmers and agricultural workers it would do an immense amount of good. It would give them strength, courage and confidence, and it would bring him into closer contact with them. I would urge upon the Minister to make that tour when he can spare the time.

While he is on that tour he should break the many rings that require to be broken. Those rings have our farmers in a grip that is unnatural and unfair. I would ask him also to endeavour to bring about a better cooperative system amongst our people by getting a better market in the cities for agricultural produce. A vast amount of the produce of our farms never reaches the market because there are no marketing facilities whatever. If the Minister could bring about a proper spirit in that connection by the centralisation of marketing facilities it would be a great help. In that way a lot of farm produce which cannot be sold would be sold and there would be a good deal of extra money going into the farmers' homes.

I am not at all satisfied with our fairs. There are far too many middlemen, tanglers, tricksters and so forth knocking around at them. They can come to our fairs in large hired motor cars. They can stay in big hotels and slip off with £20, £30 or £40 in their pockets after a few hours' trickstering here and there. I am satisfied that many decent farmers in the country have it put across them before they even reach the fairs at all. These fellows are in a ring. One fellow will bid a certain price and he will pass it on to the next fellow who will bid a slightly lower price while a third will bid a few bob higher and get the animal. The result is that the unfortunate farmer does not know where he stands at all. I want to tell the Minister that those rings are the friends of the John Browns who got the cattle licences through political means. They are working all over the country to-day. For that reason the Minister should investigate salesmanship. Those farmers who are being imposed upon now should be able to sell their cattle by auction and get a fair price. The fellows who are imposing on the farmers are a dirty, mean, low crowd. Of course not all of them are bad. Some of them are making a living out of it. However, many of them have backhand methods. They are trying to make big money at the expense of the poor backward farmer who does not know very much about what is going on at the fairs or markets. The Minister is a man of strong will, strong words and firm resolution. When he sets his course he will not be diverted from it. If he sets his course in this connection he will have, not 90 per cent, but 100 per cent. of the farmers behind him. Of course, there will be a good percentage of the playboys against him but he does not worry about that.

Comment on this

A number of the agricultural farmers in County Dublin who have spent a lot of money on agricultural machinery are rather disturbed with the present Minister's policy. I represent a constituency in which there was a number of farmers before compulsory tillage began and they will still be there when compulsory tillage has gone. A number of enterprising farmers have purchased a lot of agricultural machinery and their position at the moment is that they really do not know what to do. They would like to carry on, of course, with extensive agriculture. They are good employers. I should like the Minister to make a statement as to how he is going to protect this particular type of farmer who definitely wants to carry on agriculture and even grow wheat.

Comment on this

By giving him a guaranteed price higher than your Government ever gave him for five years.

Comment on this

I do not mean this disrespectfully, but the Minister reminds me of the cow who filled the pail with milk and spilt it afterwards. The Minister, on top of that, says it is all "cod". It is very discouraging to a farmer who is anxious to grow wheat in County Dublin when he hears statements like that from the Minister.

Comment on this

Oh, musha, how bad he is. He gets paid for it.

Comment on this

Would the Minister definitely state his policy as far as the agricultural farmer of County Dublin and of Ireland as a whole is concerned? Will he tell this farmer that he is going to protect him in all the phases of his agricultural industry instead of telling him that beet is a cod and that wheat is a cod?

Comment on this

"Divil a much" beet is grown in North County Dublin.

Comment on this

I am speaking generally now. Another point in which I am very interested in regard to the agricultural farmer—and especially the farmer in County Dublin—is the question of labour. Many of these farmers employ a lot of labour. If the agricultural industry is going to go down it means that we are going to have a lot of unemployment. We have heard from time to time all the happy ejaculations that have been made from the Government benches with reference to rural Ireland. Now we are in the position where we have an opportunity of developing that agricultural industry a good deal more because manures are becoming more plentiful. The fact that manures are coming in for the farmers has been well spoken of. I do not wish to delay too long on that particular subject. A number of the farmers in County Dublin, however, have fairly fertile lands. As a result, of course, of being near the city they possibly have a better opportunity of manuring their land than other farmers down the country. The fact remains that all the artificial manure that can be obtained will be very welcome.

I also want to deal with the dairy farmers of County Dublin. Some time ago I asked the Minister for Agriculture if he would concede a certain privilege to the dairy farmers. I realised that a number of dairy farmers were going out of business. I would ask the Minister to make one concession. Where dairy farmers ask for exemption under the compulsory tillage or ask for permission to keep more land under grass their representations should be sympathetically considered. When representations were made on this matter the Minister said the law is the law. That was not very encouraging. The dairy farmers in County Dublin have considerable expenses. They have a good deal with which to contend in their particular line of business. They must keep their premises modernised; they are constantly under inspection. I would like to see the dairy farmers of County Dublin in a position to pay more to their agricultural workers. In that respect I would even like to see the industry subsidised. I do not say that milk should be dearer, but I do know these dairy farmers have certain problems.

Deputy Madden made a very good case for the farmers last night. It was pleasant to listen to him because he seemed to have a familiar knowledge of the industry. Deputy Madden represents County Limerick. In that county they are dealing with dairies; in County Dublin they are dealing direct with the consumer. Dairying is one of our principal industries and it is one of the very few in which we do not have to import some of our requirements.

Comment on this

Does the Deputy want the price of milk raised or does he want the price of milk brought down?

Comment on this

What I want to do is this——

Comment on this

You want to have it raised and brought down at the same time.

Comment on this

Just allow me to develop my point.

Comment on this

I would be very much obliged if the Deputy would.

Comment on this

When the dairying farmers make representations to the Minister I want him to go into the pros and cons of the various points put before him. As Deputy Madden said last night when the previous Minister for Agriculture raised the price of milk by 2d. per gallon that was a definite encouragement to dairy farmers all over the country to keep their herds. I am sure that practically everybody in the country would prefer to pay a little more for butter if they could get more butter, rather than to pay less, as they are doing at the present time, and get less butter. If the industry is going down the Minister should seriously consider subsidising it. That is the point I want to make.

Comment on this

The Deputy is aware that we are spending £2,250,000 at the present time on butter.

Comment on this

I am aware of that. That was done by the Fianna Fáil Government. When dairy farmers make representations to the Minister for exemption under compulsory tillage, in order that they may have more grassland or more land under hay for their cows, the Minister should sympathetically and favourably consider their representations in that respect. These dairy farmers are an important section of the community. Everybody from the child to the adult is dependent on milk. That industry must be encouraged. I do not want the Minister to quote again "the law is the law".

There is another type of industry in County Dublin to which consideration should be given. That is the market gardener and the farmer who grows vegetables on a fairly large scale. Under the Fianna Fáil régime the man who went in for the growing of vegetables was assured of success and prosperity, because he got a fair price for his vegetables. During the emergency he had difficulties to contend with in regard to seeds and fertilisers, but his representations in these matters were always sympathetically considered by the Fianna Fáil Government. I want the Minister to take steps to ensure that foreign competition will not militate against market gardening at home. In dealing with vegetables, I include in that category both soft and hard fruits.

Comment on this

I am trying to get a foreign market for them.

Comment on this

For the potato end of it only. Will the Minister allow me to make my point? I did not interrupt the Minister when he was speaking. I refer now to the importation of tomatoes. As a result of our much despised Fianna Fáil policy again, we had succeeded in encouraging our people to go in successfully for the growing of tomatoes in County Dublin and the adjoining counties. I think these growers should be protected against unfair competition. Tomatoes can be grown in other countries much more successfully than here because of warmer climates. They come to maturity much more quickly than the crop does here. I do not say that our tomatoes should be too expensive for the consumer here, but I do say there should be adequate protection.

There is one further point to which I want to refer in that connection. It does not come actually within the purview of the Minister for Agriculture but it is germane to the tomato industry. Some of the tomato growers have an insufficient water supply. Where there is no water laid on in a district I would ask the Minister to consider making a grant available for the sinking of a pump to serve six, eight or ten tomato houses. That would be a considerable benefit to these people. The industry in its initial stages is an expensive one for them because it calls for a fairly big capital outlay in the erection of glasshouses and so on. In Rush at the present time there is a grave shortage of water and the people who go in for tomato cultivation there have to carry water quite a long distance. I have already raised this matter by way of Parliamentary Question. I know the problem is a fairly difficult one.

Comment on this

It will be provided for, Deputy.

Comment on this

I am content with that. With regard to fruit, there is not enough fruit in this country and I would appeal to the Minister to encourage our fruit farmers in County Dublin and elsewhere through the medium of the county committees of agriculture. In reply, I would like the Minister to tell us what encouragement he will give to these fruit farmers. There is a future in the industry.

Another important industry is the poultry industry. Here, I want to compliment the Minister on his ability to make the hens lay twice every day when he had only been a month in office. That was on his own statement. The position is rather serious as far as the poultry industry is concerned. We have a number of stations in County Dublin which are severely handicapped through lack of land. I have discussed this matter both with the present Minister for Agriculture and with his predecessor. I would impress upon the Minister that he should use his good offices with the Minister for Lands to make more land available to these people in the poultry industry.

I was interested in one case in my own parish. A lady there was anxious to develop her poultry farm, but she had not enough land. She was a great asset to the community, but apparently it is not the policy of the Land Commission to give land in such cases. I do not say that because she is a lady the Land Commission would not give her land, but I do not think it has been the policy to do so. We have now entered into a poultry scheme in a big way and it is intended that it should be developed, following the work done by the previous Minister. The present Minister will, I hope, carry on the previous Minister's good work in that line.

I should like the Minister, where the case is definitely justified, to give priority to any enterprising poultry stations, the owners of which have not sufficient land. It is an industry that we should develop and, if the Minister intends to carry out the work he has promised to carry out, I am sure he will have no objection to making recommendations to the Minister for Lands to give people who need additional land an opportunity of properly developing their poultry industry. I would like the Minister also to state what guarantee he has of feeding stuffs for those poultry stations.

There are other aspects that I would like to discuss on this Vote, including grasslands, ranchers and cattle and sheep rearing. There are many types of farmers in my constituency. Has the Minister seriously considered how he will increase the sheep population?

Comment on this

What would the Deputy suggest?

Comment on this

I am not going to make any suggestion; I am asking the Minister, because anything I suggest would be wrong. I heard the Minister some time ago saying that the reason the sheep population had gone down was because of the increased tillage. It is agreed that some farmers might have to get rid of sheep on account of increased tillage, but in the very severe winter we had in 1947 thousands of sheep died all over the country and created a problem for the people on the hillsides. They lost stock and it will be years before they can recover. The previous Minister very kindly gave a loan, to be paid back in four years, to help those farmers. That loan was very good and it has been availed of by a number of farmers, but there are others who said, when they discovered they had to get two securities for the loan, that they were not agreeable to that course. A number then in the sheep-rearing line in a big way have no sheep at all now. I had to make representations to the local authority last year to get relief work for some of these people. Another Deputy accompanied me in order to try to get relief work in the Dublin Mountains for people who suffered serious losses. They lost their livelihood and all the stock they possessed. I am sure the Minister will give that matter serious consideration.

One of the things that is disturbing most of my area is a statement that was made by the Minister. I do not know whether he means it that way or not, but it has been interpreted that he has ostracised the horse, that the horse is an animal to be used just when you can get nothing else. In County Dublin we have a considerable number of farms of less than five acres. The Minister speaks of mechanisation. Are we to judge by the Minister's statement that the rearing of horses in the future will be largely discontinued and that the farmer who is breeding horses, if he is to take the Minister's advice, will get out of that as soon as possible? In County Dublin there are 5,241 holdings not exceeding five acres.

Comment on this

Does the Deputy imagine that I propose that hunts should hunt on tractors—that they should follow mechanical hares across the country?

Comment on this

In County Dublin we have 653 farms exceeding five but not exceeding ten acres. We have 369 farms exceeding ten acres but not exceeding 15 and we have 760 farms exceeding 15 acres but not exceeding 30. There are numbers of small farmers who definitely depend on horses.

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

How many horses could you keep on a five-acre farm?

Comment on this

Many of our small farmers definitely depend on horses and, according to the Minister, he will have no regard in the future for the horse—he just wants full mechanisation. If he can have that on these small farms, very well, but he should clarify the position. He should let us know if he needs horses for the national stud. Horses have not been a bad asset in the past and they have held up our reputation in other countries. I do not think the Minister should be uncharitable to the horse. The horse suited us during the emergency. The international horizon is not so very clear or peaceful and I think the Minister would be wise not to introduce mechanisation at the expense of the horse. On numbers of large farms they could not possibly have carried on without agricultural machinery, but that does not mean that we could dispense with the horse.

I should like to refer for a moment to the much-dreaded inspector to whom the Minister was so uncharitable. In County Dublin, of course, there were very few defaulters under the tillage scheme, but I must say that any inspectors that I knew in County Dublin during the compulsory tillage campaign were ordinary decent men. They visited the farmers, not alone for the purposes of inspection, but in an advisory capacity. They pointed out to the farmer his obligations to himself and to the community, and how essential it was that food should be produced during the time of crisis. These inspectors were, as I have said, decent men, and furthermore they were psychologists. They knew how to approach a problem and how to treat it. There has been a terrible lot of eyewash carried on in connection with the compulsory tillage campaign or, to use the Minister's own phrase, a lot of "codology". The Fianna Fáil Government did no more in enforcing the tillage campaign than the Minister for Agriculture would have done if he were in office at that time. They had to face the problem of producing food for the people. It is very easy for the Minister now, when he comes in after the time of crisis has passed, to throw stones at his predecessor and at the inspectors who went around the country during the war and did their work, very diplomatically, as I think. As a matter of fact, I think they should be complimented on the manner in which they carried out their duties. There were very few farmers in County Dublin who had to be dealt with by these inspectors, but such as there were, were treated very diplomatically, courteously and efficiently by the inspectors. It is all "codology" to say that no inspector should go on any man's land until he is asked to do so by the farmer. I was bred, born and reared, and possibly starved, on a farm and the Minister knows that there is no farmer who is going to send for an inspector.

Comment on this

Why should he be invaded by an inspector any more than anybody else in this country, if he does not want the inspector to visit him?

Comment on this

Does the Minister not know blessed well that it was in the national interest that the Government should see that the people of this country would not starve during the war? I have great admiration for the Minister in certain matters, but when he carries on this eyewash I do not think he is really wise. Nobody can gainsay that these inspectors went around the country in the national interest and not merely because they were asked to do so by the Minister. They went round to ensure that there would be sufficient food for our people. It is very easy to talk now when the battle is over and to say what fort we should have taken first. Listening to the way in which these men are spoken of, one would imagine that they were criminals like the Black-and-Tans who came in here. If any farmer had any grievance against them or if he were insulted in any way, he had the right to report them to the authorities.

Comment on this

One of them was brought before the court in Wexford recently.

Comment on this

You can get up and tell us all about Wexford in a moment.

Comment on this

An inspector was brought before the court for going into a man's land without authority.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I warned Deputy O'Leary yesterday that he should not interrupt. The effect of frequent interruptions is cumulative.

Comment on this

I shall leave the question of the inspectors for the moment. I heard a lot of stones also thrown at Deputy Dr. Ryan. No man in this country had to steer the ship of a Department through so many troubled waters as Deputy Dr. Ryan.

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

The ancient mariner.

Comment on this

It is very easy again for the Minister for Agriculture and his associates to come along, now that seeds and manures are no longer in short supply, to deal with the poultry industry, the pig industry, the cattle industry and all the other aspects of agriculture. The Minister knows that we in this country were put to the pin of our collar to feed human beings during the war. I would have much greater respect for the Minister and would be more anxious to co-operate with him, if he would desist from carrying on the misrepresentation in which he indulges from time to time.

Again I heard allegations in this House with reference to the previous Minister to the effect that there were 22,000 letters unopened in his Department. Candidly I do not believe that, because if that were so, it would be a reflection in the first place upon all the civil servants in that office. If that were the position there are plenty of capable people who are idle and who could assist at that work whom the Minister should have brought in to clear off the arrears.

We know that there has been a hold-up in the farm improvements scheme from March to July. A large number of farmers took advantage of that scheme and they would be still more anxious to avail of it had this hold-up not taken place. The previous Minister gave every encouragement to the farmers in that way. The farm buildings scheme was another very essential scheme. It is, I suggest, essential to have cattle properly housed if we are to have healthy herds. The Minister knows very well the very high percentage of tuberculosis that exists among cattle in this country. It is, therefore, essential that farmers should be encouraged to provide proper housing accommodation for their cattle. The farm buildings scheme was a very good gesture on the part of the Fianna Fáil Government. I am asking the Minister why it has been put in abeyance. Why does the Minister, when he is asked about these things, blame his predecessor? Possibly the Minister for Finance is not giving him any money to carry on this scheme. If that is so, I deplore it and I think that the Minister should take every step to have the scheme again put into operation as quickly as possible. The Minister knows that very many farm buildings are hopelessly inadequate and in very bad condition.

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

It did not all happen in one year.

Comment on this

I hope the Minister will announce in his reply when this farm buildings scheme is to come into operation. I want to deal now with pigs, a somewhat hackneyed matter at the moment. I notice that the Minister, in the discharge of his duties, has prosecuted a number of people for illegally curing bacon. I should like to know how it is that none of the shops throughout the country seem to be able to get their quota for some time back.

Comment on this

Who cannot get them?

Comment on this

I know shops in North County Dublin which have not had a rasher for quite some time.

Comment on this

The Deputy wrote to the Pigs and Bacon Commission, of course?

Comment on this

On behalf of the people concerned, yes.

Comment on this