We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Private Deputies' Business. - Road Grants—Motion.

Contributions 186–397 of 397. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

The Deputy lives in North County Dublin and that is certainly not a prairie track. If it were not such a magnificent highway there might not be so many unfortunate accidents there. The Deputy need not talk about prairie roads. I think our roads are fairly good. Of course, if the Deputy wants the type of luxury road for our tourists that Deputy MacEntee talks about that is another matter. Let me make this quite clear. As far as I am concerned and as far as this Government is concerned we are going to look after the roads and drains before we look after the luxury roads.

Comment on this

I thought you were looking for tourists in America.

Comment on this

I was. I do not believe for one moment that I am going to attract tourists——

Comment on this

What about the people on the quay in Cobh?

Comment on this

We will talk about the quay in Cobh on another occasion and about some of the Deputy's other remarks and he will hear something he might not like to hear. Let me say to the Deputy that the American tourists are not going to come over here to see if we can compete with America in building highways. There is hardly any doubt in the world that the Americans can build better, longer and wider roads than we can and we cannot show them anything better in the line of roads than they can see at home.

Comment on this

We have a long way to go in this country before our first or third-class roads will be fit even for our own people, let alone the Americans.

Comment on this

I believe that the Deputy is as anxious as I am to see people in employment. Is there any Deputy on the opposite side or on any side of the House who would question what I now say? There is work that urgently requires to be done in clearing those rivers and streams.

Comment on this

When will it start?

Comment on this

It will start immediately.

Comment on this

There will have to be legislation.

Comment on this

The legislation will be drafted. It will be a short Bill. We are not even waiting for the legislation in asking the county councils to make the preliminary arrangements.

Comment on this

The Minister says it has to be done.

Comment on this
Mr. Murphy

Authority for that has been given.

Comment on this

I am perfectly satisfied that it will not take very long to get that Bill through this House. I believe there will be no opposition. It certainly will be through in a very short while. If authority is given to every county council to proceed with the clearing of every river and stream that needs to be cleared is there any Deputy who knows rural Ireland who will assert that that scheme in itself will not provide more employment throughout rural Ireland than has been provided?

Comment on this

Where will they get the machinery for that job?

Comment on this

What machinery? I will tell you what you want. You want men with shovels and spades, a couple of horses and a chain.

Comment on this

I can tell you that you have not the faintest realisation of what you are talking about.

Comment on this

Time will tell.

Comment on this

There is no use in the Deputy talking like that. I am living in a town that has suffered from flooding since I was a child. I know that river from its source to the Shannon and I think I am entitled to say that I know the rivers and streams in my own county as well as the Deputy knows those in his county. I hope I can see an obstruction as well as anybody can. Let me also tell the Deputy that not only have I seen but I have actually yoked the horses and pulled the trees out of the river myself. I am putting the point to the Deputies opposite that if what is troubling them is the question of employment——

Comment on this

It is the question of county roads.

Comment on this
Mr. Walsh

What about county roads?

Comment on this

Deputies Walsh and Killilea tell me they are not troubled about employment.

Comment on this

We are asking what about the county roads? All the Ministers have avoided that.

Comment on this

So far as county roads are concerned there will be more money available in grants this year than last year. Is that what the Deputy wants? The Government has decided to go on with the Bord na Móna turf scheme. We are told that that is now being discouraged. Deputy MacEntee said it was, in any case.

Comment on this

Any discouragement came from that side of the House.

Comment on this

I happen to know as much, if not more, about turf as Deputies on the opposite side. I was dealing with turf when some Deputies on the opposite side were doing nothing at all. All I am going to say about that is that there will be 5,000 more men employed by Bord na Móna in this year than there were last year. I am not claiming any credit for that, good, bad or indifferent. I am just stating a fact. There will be 5,000 more men employed.

Comment on this
A Deputy

It is a pity you sacked them last year.

Comment on this

If the Deputy wants me to take him up on that I can tell him all about it. It so happens that it was on the date on which the previous Government sat down, on the famous 12th February, to take decisions on the hand-won turf that they also took the decision on the increased grants for the roads, the words of which were sent out by telegram on the Saturday morning. Take my advice and do not say anything about the turf.

Comment on this

Let us hear something about the motion.

Comment on this

Does the Deputy deny that 5,000 more men will be employed this year than last year? Do you want to start a fight on this? Is it that you are concerned only in the politics of this thing? Then go ahead. Far be it from me to stop you.

Comment on this

What about the Minister for Agriculture's famous statement about wheat or beet?

Comment on this

Deputy Brady is only satisfying me that he wants to have this sidestepped. Does the Deputy regret that the Government has decided to continue the Bord na Móna scheme?

Comment on this
A Deputy

We are discussing the Road Grant, not Bord na Móna.

Comment on this

They are not concerned about employment, drainage or in doubling the number of people employed on turf. They are concerned about trying to find something which they can use to Party advantage and in the county councils meetings throughout the country.

Comment on this

The county councils have spoken themselves.

Comment on this

I can understand that you are disappointed and upset because to your amazement after 12 months, mind you, not after 16 years, this Government have announced a scheme of national reconstruction that you never dreamed of.

Comment on this

They have announced so many things.

Comment on this

We have a few more announcements to make.

Comment on this

I am sure of that.

Comment on this

It is the one thing you will never be short of.

Comment on this

They have not yet announced a general election.

Comment on this

I would not like to give Deputy MacEntee too severe a shock. We have delivered a few shocks to the Fianna Fáil Party to-day, but if we announced a general election some of them would not be able to walk out of their places, and would certainly never walk into them again.

Comment on this

Notice the pall of gloom that has descended on them.

Comment on this

During the 26 years that I was on the opposite side of the House I did not do half the squealing that was done by Deputies there within the past 12 months.

Comment on this

You had to twist a few times: you swung from Labour to another Party and back again.

Comment on this

There was no twisting that was not endorsed by my constituents. I have been sitting in this House for a continuous period of nearly 28 years——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

I suggest the Minister should get back to the motion.

Comment on this

I was merely about to announce something which I thought would bring relief to the minds of Deputies who have been weeping on behalf of the unfortunate unemployed, the men who, according to them, would not be able, unfortunately, to get work in rural Ireland. There are farmers in the Party opposite who know at least as well as I do—some of them far better—that what I have said in relation to drainage and the clearance of rivers is quite true. There is not a Deputy over there who, if he spoke his mind in regard to the conditions in rural Ireland, would not subscribe to everything I have said, as to its value both from the point of view of benefiting the land and giving employment.

I do not subscribe to the statement made by Deputy Childers that drainage, clearing drains, in particular field drains, is the type of work that you can carry on only in summer. Anyone who knows rural Ireland and who is acquainted with farming knows quite well that it is in the winter time the average farmer looks after the drains. Deputy Corry knows that quite well. That is one of the advantages of this particular scheme and of the scheme announced by the Minister for Agriculture. They are schemes which will give continuous employment almost the whole year round, provided you do not have a period of abnormal rainfall.

My colleague, the Minister for Local Government, gave Deputies opposite a lot of information about roads and grants that they did not expect to get. He quoted from a few of the memorandums that passed from the Minister for Local Government to the local authorities and from the Minister for Finance to the Minister for Local Government and to other members of the Government. He made it clear, as well as the then Minister for Finance. Deputy Aiken, that it was only for one year, that it was to be clearly understood that it would not be repeated.

Comment on this

It was repeated.

Comment on this

I want to assert that if it had not been for the happenings in February, 1948, the wires would never have gone out to the county councils.

Comment on this

That is not true.

Comment on this

I am making that assertion. In any case, on the 12th February, the Minister sent out the telegrams.

Comment on this

You had not purchased these Parties on the 12th February.

Comment on this

No, but the Deputy apparently thought he had.

Comment on this

So they were on the market?

Comment on this

The Deputy knows a good deal about marketing.

Comment on this

On a point of order. The Deputy who was Minister for Local Government at the time those telegrams were sent out has denied in the House that they were sent out for a particular reason.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That is not a point of order.

Comment on this

I was coming to the point of order. It is this: when a statement has been denied by the person responsible at the time, must that denial not be accepted?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

It is not the personal statement of anybody; it is a question of fact relating to the reason of certain wires being sent out. It is not a point of order.

Comment on this

Some Deputies are getting very thin-skinned.

Comment on this

Not a bit in the world.

Comment on this

All I have said is that this thing came before the previous Government on the 12th February, a famous day, a day on which Fianna Fáil took a lot of famous decisions.

Comment on this

The 13th.

Comment on this

Then the wires were sent out on the morning of the 14th. I said that if it had not been for the month of February and the election of a Government coming within three or four days, those wires would not have gone out. I repeat that.

Comment on this

For a fortnight they were asking for a decision.

Comment on this

So far as the schemes to which I have referred are concerned there is no reason why, for the next seven or eight months, there will not be as many men employed on the roads, if the county councils so desire, as were employed over the same period last year. I suggest that the clearing of rivers and streams scheme will take up every available man who is ready and willing to work in rural Ireland, in conjunction with work on the roads. I am also announcing that there will be under the Bord na Móna scheme 5,000 more men employed this year than there were last year.

Comment on this

Thanks be to God.

Comment on this

My only regret is that I cannot announce that there will be 10,000 more men employed than last year. I will give the Deputy and his Party all the credit they want to derive from that. I want no credit from it; I will be quite satisfied if the men are given employment. Deputies opposite have abandoned quite openly and clearly their fears and doubts about the unemployed.

Comment on this

That is not so.

Comment on this

I have been told that by three or four Deputies. Do not worry about the roads. They are as good as ever they were. Indeed, they are a lot better than they have been for many years past. I think they are as good as we can afford at the moment when there are much more useful schemes upon which we can spend the money. I suggest that the scheme announced by the Minister for Agriculture and the scheme for river and stream clearance announced by the Minister for Local Government, plus the fact that there will be more money available for roads in this year than in any year up to the present, except last year—let us get that quite clear: this year there will be more money available to county councils for road construction and restoration than there was in any year since this State was founded, with the exception of last year; those are the facts.

Comment on this

The Minister is wrong in that.

Comment on this

Am I?

Comment on this

The Minister for Local Government has already announced that in the year 1947-48 £2,600,000 was provided out of the Road Fund and that only £2,234,000 is being provided this year.

Comment on this

There may be some difference, but I do not think the difference is very much.

Comment on this

It is about £400,000. However, that is by the way.

Comment on this

That is nothing.

Comment on this

Let it be £400,000. I suggest that we are making better provision for the workers, for the farmers, for the ratepayers and the country generally by spending the amount we propose to spend on the roads and, in addition, the amount we propose to spend on drainage. We are thereby doing much more for the ratepayers, the farmers and the workers by these combined schemes than was done under the entire road scheme last year. I do not think that that can be questioned. Deputies must make up their minds that this will happen. I have no earthly doubt but that there will be more men employed in rural Ireland in the coming year than in any year since this State was founded.

Comment on this

The subject matter of this motion is one which affects my constituency very acutely. The question of any reduction in the road grant is one of vital importance in County Dublin. Inherent in any such reduction is the possibility of resultant unemployment amongst road workers. So far as grants are concerned we feel that County Dublin is in a different position from any other county. We do not think it either just or equitable to allocate grants for road maintenance and repair in County Dublin on the same basis as in other counties. A recent traffic survey revealed that there is ten times greater density of traffic over the County Dublin roads than over any other roads in the country. When it is considered that the present grants are based upon mileage, Deputies can appreciate the disadvantage at which we find ourselves on that score alone. The Bray road is one of the busiest roads in Ireland. A recent investigation revealed that on an average 1,000 vehicles per hour pass along that road. That average cannot be equalled in any other part of the country. Traffic is so dense upon our roads that the Dublin County Council would require a larger grant per mile than any other part of the country. That is the prevailing belief in our council. That is a point of view which will be placed before the Minister within the next few days. It is hoped that the Minister will pay particular attention to it.

On the general question of the reduction of the grant, as a representative of rural workers and as secretary of a trade union representing some 10,000 county council employees up and down the country, I have been worried for some time past about the present situation. In some counties a number of workers are at present unemployed. Efforts are being made to pin responsibility for that upon the present Administration. I know that in many cases the real responsibility for that unemployment rests on the shoulders of the local authorities who last year, when given an opportunity of getting additional grants, did not avail of that opportunity and, whether by accident or design, many hundreds of workers in rural areas are now unemployed. I have said before and I repeat now that I believe it to be the duty of Government, no matter what its composition may be, to provide employment for every able-bodied man. The Opposition has nothing to crow about in that particular respect because that is one particular task upon which they fell down.

The question of the reduction of the grant is a serious one so far as the workers are concerned. To some extent the position has been alleviated by the statements made that we are to have definite schemes which will give employment to those men who may become redundant as a result of the reduction of the road rents. But I am concerned with the period which must elapse from the end of the present financial year to the commencement of these schemes. Every week that passes during which a man is unemployed imposes a greater hardship and a greater injustice upon him. Provision should be made immediately to provide the fullest possible employment in the rural areas. We should not have to wait until May or July.

Reference has been made to Bord na Móna. I know a little about Bord na Móna. Undoubtedly it will be a good thing if Bord na Móna can give employment to an extra 5,000 workers this year.

Comment on this

Do you believe that?

Comment on this

I have been assured of it by a responsible spokesman of the Government and I accept his word upon it.

Comment on this

All right—wait and see.

Comment on this

Side by side with the question of employment to be provided by Bord na Móna there is a need for consideration of the general question. This is a matter that will arise possibly at a later date.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That is so.

Comment on this

I refer to the question of the wages and working conditions that these men will enjoy. Extra employment will be provided by Bord na Móna for an additional 5,000 men. Schemes will be introduced for the cleaning and dredging of rivers and streams. But there yet remains a problem peculiar to my own constituency. Bord na Móna activities do not extend to us. We have no bogs that can be developed, and, in the matter of drainage, County Dublin is outstanding, inasmuch as it has had very little, if any, drainage at any time during its whole history, so far as the State is concerned, so that I cannot see either of these schemes filling any gap which may arise as a result of the cutting of grants in relation to my own constituency.

I understand from statements made that the ordinary accepted method of financing the roads, to use the words of the Minister for Local Government, has been the Road Fund, the fund which is accumulated by taxes upon motor vehicles and so on. I see no reason why there should not be a departure from the particular method of financing the Road Fund and I see no reason why this Government should not have considered, as an emergency matter, the imposing of special taxes in order to secure the £1,750,000 or £2,000,000 to make up the difference as between last year and this. I should be delighted if this Government had decided to reimpose the excess profits tax as a step towards getting the amount required and I feel that that step would have been welcomed by most members of the House. I do not think it is a sufficiently good case for reduced grants to say that there is no more money in the Road Fund. The money, I believe, should be found.

Comment on this

It was found last year.

Comment on this

I understand that Deputy MacEntee referred to my absence from the House and spoke of my responsibility to the workers.

Comment on this

Do not mind him.

Comment on this

I will mind him because Deputy MacEntee is——

Comment on this

Irresponsible.

Comment on this

—a Deputy who insists on being minded to some extent. There may be some people in the country, or even in the House, who may pay some slight attention to his peculiar statements and for that reason I want to make a passing reference to what he said. It ill becomes Deputy MacEntee and it ill becomes any member of the Opposition to shed crocodile tears about the road workers because my memory need not be very long to remember when Deputy MacEntee saw fit to reduce a proposal for a weekly wage increase for road workers of 10/- to 1/-. In my view, that did not display a very great love of the men about whom he now professes to be very worried. My absence from the House during the day was due to the fact that everybody must partake of some sustenance in order to keep alive and was not, I assure the House, at all due to the fact that Deputy MacEntee happened to be on his feet.

To return to the important question of the road grants, in my constituency we are faced with the position that if we are to carry out the current year's road scheme, we shall be required to place a fairly heavy levy upon the rates, and the rates in County Dublin, due to the activities of the county commissioner, are not in too healthy a condition. In County Dublin, the democratic rights accorded to other counties have been restored to us only recently—we got our county council only within the past two or three months—but if we are to carry out the current year's scheme, it will represent quite a big addition to the rates for next year.

I may say, too, that, in my view, our current year's scheme would be inadequate to meet the needs of the county for next year, so that so far as the question of road maintenance is concerned, I feel that there is a special case to be made for County Dublin— we have more traffic than any other county in Ireland and greater wear and tear. It is not just to the ratepayers of the county to base the grant to be made upon the mileage to be provided for. There should be some consideration for the density of traffic.

On the question of employment, these schemes which have been mentioned will be of little use to us. Through the activities of the late unlamented county commissioner, we in County Dublin have a smaller number of road workers than any county in Ireland, and that number is so small that we cannot but view with apprehension any further reduction in the number.

I want to say, finally, that I feel an attempt should have been made to secure the money to make up the deficiency as between last year and this year from some alternative source, if it was not in the Road Fund. If this is to bring unemployment amongst the people whom I represent, then I cannot, will not and would not support it, no matter what Government was in power. If I am satisfied that it will not mean unemployment, but that employment will be given and given immediately, then I am quite willing to accept the assurances given here, quite willing to accept that they are given in good faith and that we will see this year schemes for the development of this country such as we have never seen. I hope from the bottom of my heart that we will see in July this scheme of land drainage and so on.

Comment on this

And if you do not, what will you do?

Comment on this

Deputy MacEntee can rest assured that I will make up my own mind upon it.

Comment on this

You will make another speech.

Comment on this

If Deputy MacEntee casts his mind back a little, he will find that my activities have not been confined to speeches. Where the rights of the workers were concerned, I did not content myself with making speeches or writing letters. I wish that there could be some authoritative statement to make it plain beyond yea or nay, some definite assurance, that if any men are disemployed in any part of the country as a result of this reduction in the grants, they will get immediate re-employment in some form or other, without any worsening of their working conditions or lessening of their wages.

Comment on this

The Minister for Agriculture this evening, on the only occasion he was in any way relevant, read a letter written by the former Minister for Finance to Deputy MacEntee, then a Minister, in connection with the scheme of road grants this year. He said that that was the attitude of the Minister for Finance and that therefore nothing was going to be done. The difference between the present Government and the previous Government is that we put in a big soft-hearted, decent Minister, and put in handy boys to knock the corners off him in the shape of cash.

You read about the Minister for Agriculture being down in Charleville and telling the farmers there that he was going to increase the price of milk. You had Deputy Halliden shouting and cheering and purring like a cat with delight. Then the Minister came back and denied it himself, after telling the poor milk producers that his heart bled for them. He had the Minister for Defence saying that they had a strong case and then, lo and behold, they walked into the Minister for Finance and he said: "Do you want to raise the cost of living? Get out!" and out they got. I have to-night the utmost sympathy with the Minister for Local Government——

Comment on this
Mr. Murphy

Thanks very much.

Comment on this

You do not mean a bit of that.

Comment on this

As an old and valued comrade of some 25 years standing— I think it was back in 1924 we first met at the local authority—I have the utmost sympathy for him, for what hope had the Minister for Local Government of knocking anything out of the Minister for Finance, Deputy McGilligan? Not a hope. The poor unfortunate Labour Minister. I endeavoured last December to get the facts that were elicited last week—to get them out of the Minister for Local Government. Speaking in this House on the 10th December of last year, col. 1319, I stated :

"Last night I complained of the policy of all Governments in bringing matters as serious as this in at the tail-end of an important session and at a period when the Dáil will not have an opportunity of considering the position thoroughly. I am exceedingly anxious on one point. I wonder could we get an assurance from the Minister as to whether the money given under transition grants for the past two years in relation to roads, namely, 90 per cent. on trunk roads and 75 per cent. on county roads, will be continued this year? Can the Minister ease our minds on that matter now?

An Ceann Comhairle: What relation does that bear to this?

Mr. Corry: It has a very important relation to the amount of rates a farmer will have to pay in the next 12 months. That is why I would like the Minister to give us that information now rather than at the end of the debate."

I saw what was coming last December and I looked for the information. What happened since? The county officials in Cork County printed this sheet which I hold in my hand and sent it out to 55 or 56 of us in the Cork County Council.

Comment on this
Mr. Murphy

How many?

Comment on this

It is 45, I think, at present. At any rate, a week after it went out and after, I think, five or six or seven letters to the Minister's Department, asking the question that I asked last December, this arrived— this circular which I hold in this hand.

Comment on this
Mr. Murphy

Does Deputy Corry assert that five or six letters from the council came to the Local Government Department and were unanswered? Does he make that assertion, as I want to get that on the records of the House?

Comment on this

I make the assertion that letters were sent and requests were made for the information and it was not forthcoming.

Comment on this
Mr. Murphy

Now, Deputy Corry made a statement that five or six letters were sent from the local authority to the Local Government Department, and he asserts that the only answer he received was the circular dealing with road grants. Does he adhere to that statement?

Comment on this

I certainly say that——

Comment on this
Mr. Murphy

Now, this is a question that demands yes or no.

Comment on this

I want to be quite clear.

Comment on this
Mr. Murphy

Does the Deputy persist in that assertion or does he withdraw it?

Comment on this

I say that there were at least a number of letters sent—I do not know how many——

Comment on this

In fairness to the Minister, only one letter was sent.

Comment on this
Mr. Murphy

Does the Deputy assert that any letter that came to the Department from the county council remained unanswered—not to mind five or six?

Comment on this

That the information required was not given.

Comment on this
Mr. Murphy

That is a different story.

Comment on this

They did not give the information required.

Comment on this
Mr. Murphy

That is not what the Deputy said.

Comment on this

The information required was not given.

Comment on this
Mr. Murphy

The information was given at the earliest date at which it was available to any local authority in the country.

Comment on this

The information was given on the 7th February after the ratepayers' money had printed this sheet and sent it out.

Comment on this
Mr. Murphy

Does the Deputy remember that happening in former years? Does he or does he not?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy cannot be subjected to cross-examination.

Comment on this

I am dealing with what happened now.

Comment on this
Mr. Murphy

Very well, but deal honestly with it.

Comment on this

I will absolutely and I would be very sorry to deal with the Minister's Department or the Minister in any other way but honestly. In this famous letter the Minister tells us:

"I am directed by the Minister for Local Government to state that as the scheme of Road Fund Grants initiated in 1946-47 for the special purpose of restoring roads which had deteriorated during the war years has now been substantially implemented..."

That is the first portion of his letter. How much of it has been done in Cork County? I asked that question yesterday from the responsible official, the county surveyor. Here is the reply, as reported in the Press:

"In reply to Mr. Corry, the county surveyor, Mr. J.T. O'Donnell, said that approximately 55 per cent. of the deterioration on main roads caused during the war had so far been restored, while about 65 per cent. of the tarred county roads had been restored but only a very small percentage of county roads were tarred."

There is 55 per cent. of the job done regarding the deterioration of our main roads. The other 45 per cent. is to continue to deteriorate. That is the position. They can draw a pretty effective smoke screen, I agree, to lead a few Deputies here and there up another path about unemployment. I am concerned with the finishing of a job started three years ago, namely, putting the main roads back into proper condition. The money for that has gone in cheap pints. Further to that, the money that was guaranteed here last year, was refused on the 'phone yesterday by the Minister's Department in reply to a letter sent on the 20th January last.

Comment on this

That was last year's grant.

Comment on this

Included in that was flood damage.

Comment on this

Call it what you wish. I am reading from the county manager's statement on the matter:

"In reply to Mr. Corry, the manager explained that the estimated increase, £74,527, represented debit balances passed from time to time but that figure included the £35,000 for flood damage repairs which the council proposed to execute before the 1st April and £7,000 for increases in road workers' wages in the present quarter. ‘If we get a recoupment (continued the manager) on these two items which we asked for in our letter of January 20th last, that debit balance will be reduced by the amount of the recoupment. That £74,000, if we get the recoupment asked for, will be reduced by £30,000 and we would then be levying £44,000 which will represent about 10d. in the £.'... The county manager informed the council that they had got a reply to their telephone message to the Department and the reply was that the road grant allocation for the current financial year 1948-49 did not permit of any further grant and that if the council's request were to be given effect it would mean that the amount of the grant for next year would be correspondingly reduced."

That is the position. That is the letter sent on the 20th January that was replied to yesterday, the 22nd February, when we got into telephonic communication with the Minister's Department to extract that reply from them. I suggest to the Minister that it is unfair. I suggest to him that the Counties of Wicklow, Limerick and Galway put up supplementary estimates, as we did, and got their grants. I am not here to pillory anyone. I am here to get fair play and justice for the county I represent. Thirty thousand pounds extra will have to be levied on the ratepayers of County Cork this year owing to the Minister's refusal to honour the grant.

Comment on this
Mr. Murphy

To honour what?

Comment on this

The grants given last year.

Comment on this
Mr. Murphy

Does the Deputy say that the full estimate required by the county council was not acceded to, arising out of the abnormal situation caused by flooding?

Comment on this

Arising out of the abnormal situation.

Comment on this
Mr. Murphy

Is there any reduction?

Comment on this

Only £30,000. It has to be spent this year before the 31st March.

Comment on this
Mr. Murphy

For damage which occurred since the full demand of the county council for a supplementary estimate was met, the same as for every other county council.

Comment on this

On a point of order, I wish to protest against this hold-up of the debate by this cross-fire. It is now five past nine and I think it is unfair to other Deputies who wish to speak.

Comment on this

I am only trying to substantiate my case. My case, in reply to the Minister, is that supplementary estimates were put in by other counties and the grant given. My county has not got it. That is our position. I am not going to bother chasing the hare that other people raised here to-day. Last year they told the turf workers to go out on the roads. Now they tell them to go back to the bogs. Another Minister told us he is going to put them into the river. The Minister for Agriculture had a new scheme to-night. Goodness knows between the schemes and the schemers there is no doubt that a cute game is being played. I should like to point out that there is very little employment by Bord na Móna down around the eastern or even the northern portion of Cork County.

Comment on this

Nor will there, while the logs are in the dumps.

Comment on this

We are not going to get anything out of it. The Deputy that gave you that tip made his own share out of the logs. Do not draw me.

Comment on this

We know where the logs came from.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I presume the Cork Deputies consider this a very serious debate. If so, we might get on with it, without interruption.

Comment on this

I consider this a very serious matter. A sum of £85,000 has been stopped and deducted from the roads of Cork County. That is a very serious matter indeed on top of the £30,000 we were told by telephone that we would not get yesterday. I do not wish to occupy too much of the time of the House, but I am putting up the case so far as the ratepayers and the workers in my county are concerned. A reduction of £84,000 on the Roads Estimate is going to mean roughly 10 weeks' extra unemployment in Cork County for road workers. That is the position and no juggling, no manæuvring, or no smokescreens will get out of that situation. I said at the start that I had the utmost sympathy for the Minister. I have, honest sympathy for the Deputy Tadhg Murphy I knew and who now finds himself pressed by this posad saluc into this unfortunate position. I have lots of sympathy for any Labour representative who finds himself forced into a position where he has to dock 10 weeks' work off the road workers of his own county. I do not mind the vapourings of Deputy Dillon here this evening.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Minister for Agriculture.

Comment on this

The Minister for Agriculture—Lord have mercy on the culture. The Minister for Agriculture stood up here this evening. He gave us a lecture for about 40 minutes on everything only the reduced grants and removal of the workers from the roads. He told us of the new plan that he had for agriculture, the draining of the bogs and all the rest of it. We are all fairly old hands at this. The Minister for Local Government will agree with me that from the day the road worker gets out of the field on the road with a shovel on his shoulder he will not go back on the land. He has no intention of going there—not a notion in God's earth of ever again sticking his head in over a ditch or working for any old farmer. That is the position. When I see the road workers inside, stuck in a drain in a bog with an old hack or an old shovel, I cannot help thinking that it will be a sad case for the Minister for Agriculture at the next general election. However, that is the position and I want this House to realise it and to face the facts. Rates are going up by 5/- in the £, without taking into consideration any penny increase in the Roads Estimate for the coming year, and without taking into consideration the £74,000 for which the Department of Local Government have refused to give us the equivalent grant of £30,000 to which we are entitled. That £30,000 is going up 7d. in the £ on the ratepayers of County Cork. Remember— there is a debit sum of £74,000 to go on, in addition to this year's rates, for which the Minister has refused to give us the equivalent grant of £30,000 to which we are entitled. That is our position. The grant is reduced by £85,300. Just think of it and realise the position.

I heard the Minister for Agriculture tell this House about increased production and so forth. Anybody listening to him to-day at Question Time and to his nice observation about Deputy McQuillan's constituents and to his nice remarks to Deputy Cogan in regard to the price of milk can imagine what the increased production on the land is going to be next year. And the Minister shouts about increasing production ! I wonder how the dickens he is going to do it. I should like portion of his reclamation scheme by which he is going to drain land and reclaim it at £10 an acre. I know that the field drainage scheme in Mayo and Galway costs an average of £46 an acre—and the Minister for Agriculture is going to do it for £10 an acre. I wonder what Deputy Dunne is going to say to the standard of wages to be paid on the job, considering that men are working for the past two years on similar work which is costing £46 an acre—and the Minister for Agriculture is now going to do it for £10. I wonder what Deputy Dunne is going to say in regard to the standard of wages that is going to be paid on the job and what the road worker is going to be paid also——

Comment on this

Well, we will not stand for his being paid at the rate of £2 5s. 0d. a week, as your leader suggested last year.

Comment on this

If the Deputy who charges six guineas for ten minutes' work will stay quiet I will finish my speech. I am not concerned with politics in this connection. Various Deputies of all Parties on the Cork County Council yesterday decided that we would have to fight our corner in regard to this situation—and fight it we will.

Comment on this

What Deputy Corry has been saying is distortion pure and simple.

Comment on this

On a point of order. Are the proceedings of the Cork County Council relevant to the issue before the House?

Comment on this

Surely I am entitled, as the Deputy mentioned or implied by Deputy Corry, to contradict his statements?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Is the Deputy answering for the Chair? The reference to Cork County Council yesterday is in order, if it referred to the rates for roads in County Cork, but I think the Deputy has repeated his remarks.

Comment on this

There was a discussion on what we would do in regard to this reduction of £85,000.

Comment on this

That must be your sixth time saying that.

Comment on this

Since I am on the point, I shall read what the Minister for Local Government used to describe in the old days as "The bad old lady of Patrick Street".

Comment on this
Mr. Murphy

I never made that observation. I leave that kind of remark to Deputy Corry.

Comment on this

I shall read Deputy Keane's statement made yesterday at the meeting of the Cork County Council on this particular matter. I quote from the Cork Examiner.

Comment on this

It is a wonder it is not from the Irish Press.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Would the Deputy please make his own speech.

Comment on this

I am making my own speech, if you will keep the boys quiet for me. As reported in the Cork Examiner, Deputy Keane spoke as follows

"I second Deputy Corry, and assure him as far as my colleagues and myself are concerned, that we will fight this matter with him until we get alleviation of this hardship, and until we get an increase in our grants."

That is the statement Deputy Keane made yesterday and it cannot be said that I am quoting from any political organ or my own Party. I am quoting from the Cork Examiner.

Comment on this

On a point of order. As Deputy Corry has quoted some of the speech I made, I think I am in order in asking him to quote the rest of the speech.

Comment on this

Very well.

"Apart from our political affiliations, we sit down here as business men to do a certain piece of business, and as such we should have no hesitation in pointing out to the Minister that he should give us more consideration than he did in this estimate. I don't blame the Minister for Local Government, I know he would give what he could, I can quite understand that the Road Fund is dissipated, but there are ways and means within the province of the Ministers who govern this country."

There is the complete "Bible" from Deputy Keane. It is in the report. Was I saying anything that was wrong when I said that we decided, as Deputies of all Parties representing Cork County, to fight out this corner?

Comment on this
Michael Donnellan Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance (Mr. Donnellan) Clann na Talmhan

Has the Minister not given ways and means?

Comment on this

They have even got in and taken away your little drainage scheme.

Comment on this

No, Sir.

Comment on this

I am very glad that the Parliamentary Secretary is relieved of that particular little job he had. The rivers will now be done by the Department of Local Government.

Comment on this

The Deputy has not much intelligence when he makes a statement of that kind.

Comment on this

I have as much intelligence as the Parliamentary Secretary had when he told us he was going to do all the boreens in every county.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

As Deputy Corry has no more to say on roads, he will have to sit down.

Comment on this

I certainly have Sir, if I am not interrupted by foolish people. That is the situation that we in Cork have to face up to. We cannot ask the men who sold their oats this year at 20/- a barrel, instead of 45/-, and the men who were told to walk their spuds off the land to-day, to foot a bill for an increased 5/- in the £ on their rates. Are we to go to them now and ask them to make up the £85,000 odd that we are being deprived of in the road grant?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy is repeating himself very often.

Comment on this

That is the situation, Sir.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Quite, but we have heard it half a dozen times.

Comment on this

I should like to deal briefly with the other propositions that have been put up here to-day as the means of relieving the unemployment that would be caused by this reduction.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy realises that several Deputies would like to participate in this debate?

Comment on this

If you approach me in that tone, Sir, I will immediately sit down.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I leave it to the Deputy. The mover of the motion must get in at 20 minutes to ten.

Comment on this

I have some consideration for the Deputies who wish to speak and, therefore, I intend to be exceptionally brief. First, I would like to put a question to the Minister for Local Government: Did the Minister for Local Government recommend to the Minister for Finance that the same grant should be given this year as was given last year?

Comment on this

Surely.

Comment on this

I should like the Minister to answer that question. Did the Minister himself recommend to the Minister for Finance that the same grant should be given to the county councils as was given last year and, if he did make that recommendation, was it turned down by the Minister for Finance?

Comment on this
Mr. Murphy

The Minister for Local Government realised that it was absolutely impossible within the limits of the Road Fund to continue the grant this year at the rate at which it was given last year. There was no other source from which money could be obtained.

Comment on this

The question I asked was, did the Minister recommend to the Minister for Finance that an equivalent amount should be made available for the local authorities this year?

Comment on this
Mr. Murphy

No, not in that form.

Comment on this

Can the Minister, therefore, explain why this decision was communicated to the local authorities on the 7th of this month? I understand that it was on the 7th of this month that the decision was finally communicated to the local authorities telling them that they would not get this money. The natural assumption from that is that there were the usual Departmental discussions going on and that they were only finally determined to enable the Minister to send his circular instruction on the 7th instant.

Comment on this
Mr. Murphy

I do not want to intervene but I would say that the circular went out this year, roughly, about the same time as it was issued for several previous years, perhaps a little later.

Comment on this

I understand that the stress of a general election campaign last year made it necessary to send it by telegram about the 12th or 13th, which I can perfectly understand. However, the statutory meetings are held at the end of February. The alteration in the amounts being communicated as late as the 7th February must necessarily have caused considerable concern and considerable upset in the business of local authorities. It is clear to me that the Department of Finance has a very strict control over Government Departments. The Department of Finance has been responsible for knocking two Governments in the past. The deduction of 1/- from the old age pensioners during the period when Mr. Blythe was Minister for Finance led to the downfall of the Cumann na nGaedheal Government.

Comment on this

Are we on history now, a Chinn Chomhairle?

Comment on this

The increased tax on beer the year before last year led to the defeat of another Government, and it is quite possible that this decision taken now, in the way it has been taken, may bring about the collapse of the present Government.

Comment on this

And they richly deserve it.

Comment on this

That is not the issue. If—as I have said before in this House —this Government is brought down, it will be brought down by its own Ministers. Looking at it from the point of view of a Deputy who has generally supported the Government, this was no time to communicate a decision that will lead to substantial unemployment through the country. It was a dangerous step for the Government to take. Looking at it from a political point of view purely, I would describe it as political madness. The Minister tells us that he has been authorised by the Government to have a Bill drafted which would enable rivers and drains to be cleaned up. That Bill has to be drafted; it is apparently only a three line Bill; but it is not drafted yet. It has to go through the usual formalities. It has to come before this House and the Minister tells us that when the Act is passed into law local authorities will carry out inspections, they will prepare their plans.

Comment on this
Mr. Murphy

May I intervene? I indicated broadly that the Bill would probably be a one clause Bill; that authority to draft it had been given already; that I hope to introduce it in a very short time and that, in anticipation of the speedy passage of the Bill into law, from to-morrow out, I would ask local authorities to make their preparations to submit the schemes and to submit them immediately in anticipation of the passage of the Bill.

Comment on this

I accept that. That is perfectly correct. That is what I understood the Minister to say. The Minister thought that his local engineers will have to inspect. They will have to inspect all the places that may be improved. They have to prepare plans. They have to send those plans to the Department of Local Government. There may be inspections from the Department of Local Government before there is final approval. I hope that stage of it will be cut out. But, rushing it as quickly as the Minister and the Department possibly can, there is very little likelihood that this plan will be in operation within a period of six months.

Comment on this
Mr. Murphy

I would say positively well in swing.

Comment on this

We have some experience in this House of the progress made in housing and, if we have the same progress in this as we have in housing, I see no possibility of any substantial employment under this scheme even within the coming financial year. I was astonished when I read the other day the statement of the Minister for Agriculture about this remarkable plan he has in mind, to spend £40,000,000 or £50,000,000 to employ more people than there are available in the country for employment.

At the same time, while all these plans are in contemplation, there is a deliberate decision taken to end employment for a considerable number of people. The sensible thing would be to employ these people continuously until the schemes are available, no matter what the cost. If county councils and other local authorities have immediately to prepare a plan for the year on reduced moneys, it must be a plan to employ fewer people and there is no doubt that there will be substantial unemployment through the country.

I want to say to the Government, through the Minister, that any substantial volume of unemployment created now will not only cause political damage, but national damage. I agree with the figures given by Deputy MacEntee as to emigration. I cannot say they are perfectly right, but I do know from my own knowledge that thousands of people are leaving this country for Britain and America to get employment. Every day I have people asking me can I get them a job. I recommend them to the labour exchanges, I recommend them here and I recommend them there, but I find it absolutely impossible to get employment for a single one of these individuals. Now on top of that serious situation we have a decision taken which will lead to substantial unemployment. There is this live-horse-and-you-will-get-grass attitude; if we can only get over this we have plans to give employment in July. I hope the plans materialise. I have sufficient knowledge of the Government machine over a period of years to know how difficult it is to get these schemes into operation. It is wrong I say to create unemployment first with a promise of substantial employment later. I want to make my own position quite clear. I think this is a bad move, a bad decision, and that I can only do the thing that I ought to do, namely, to give expression to my point of view by voting for the motion.

Comment on this
Brendan Corish Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Local Government (Mr. Corish) Labour Party

In the limited time at my disposal, it might be no harm first of all to reply to some of the points raised by Deputy Cowan. The emphasis in this debate has been on the question of unemployment. I think it would be natural in the first instance to admit that if the road grants are to be curtailed this year it does mean some unemployment in consequence But, as against that, I think the statements made by the Minister for Industry and Commerce, the Minister for Local Government and the Minister for Agriculture regarding the proposed commencement of schemes of drainage, reafforestation and reclamation of land should allay the fears that Deputies may have in that respect. Deputy Cowan said that, so far as the workers are concerned, it was a question of live-horse-and-you-will-get-grass. Let us assume that these schemes which were announced will commence in July. The county councils have notified to them the annual road grant. This money is at their disposal and there is nothing to prevent county councils from engaging in the same volume of work during the months of April, May, June and, if necessary, July, so that they may keep in employment the same numbers as last year.

That will not seriously interfere with the working of any county council because, as members of local authorities realise, there is and always has been in the county councils what has always been regarded as the permanent staff. Nobody will disagree with me when I say that a very big proportion of the road workers employed since the 1946-'47 period are regarded as temporary and many of them are regarded as casuals.

As to whether places like County Dublin will benefit from these schemes which have been announced, I can assure Deputy Dunne and other Deputies who think that their particular areas will not benefit by these schemes that special consideration will be given to them both from the point of view of unemployment and from the point of view of the repairs necessary to the roads. Therefore, I do not think we need have any fears so far as unemployment is concerned for road workers from 1st April up to July when, I believe, and the Government believe, that these plans which have been announced will be put into operation. I should like to say in that respect also that, while these schemes will be commenced in July, it is anticipated that the schemes will be in full operation for the winter period. Deputies, therefore, need have no fear so far as that is concerned.

So far as the motion is concerned, it resolves itself into three problems— restoration, the burden on the ratepayers and the question of unemployment. I tried very briefly to reply to some points made by Deputy Cowan. I do not think I have the time at my disposal to deal with the other two points as to restoration and the question of the burden on the rates. So far as the extra burden on the rates and unemployment are concerned, I should merely like to emphasise that local authorities are asked this year not to provide additional money, but only to provide the same amount of money as they did last year. The Minister has also advised them that, if they think there are any further works they should do, they are empowered to do these works and raise the money by borrowing. Deputy Childers asked for details of this borrowing scheme. I think the fairest reply to him would be: let county councils or other local authorities send up their borrowing proposals and each will be considered on its merits by the Minister. I should like to say also that these schemes for which money will be borrowed would be in the nature of improvement works or works of a permanent character.

Deputy MacEntee tried to make a certain amount of airy play regarding his tussles with the Minister for Finance and Deputy Childers later on tried to tell us that the absolute and sole purpose of any Minister for Finance was to oppose any scheme which involved the spending of money. I do not think that could be considered seriously. I should like to say that the previous Minister for Local Government and the former Minister for Finance had, over a period of years, severe tussles as to how the Road Fund ought to be disposed of. It is no harm to emphasise that the reason why this special grant could be given in the last three years was because the Road Fund had accumulated despite the raids which the Fianna Fáil Administration made on it since 1940.

I think it is true to say that from 1940 up to the 31st March, 1948 the Fianna Fáil Administration had raided the Road Fund to the extent of £900,000 and I think that road restoration might have been advanced a little further if that £900,000 had been made available to the local authorities for restoration.

I would like to say also that Deputy MacEntee's speech made me think as far as his idea of road restoration is concerned. I do not know if he meant it or not, but he said that the notification of these grants yearly had a psychological effect on the local authorities. He made the point that if local authorities were under the impression that they would only get special grants for that particular year the most resourceful of the local authorities would, so to speak, jump in and avail of any money that was going. On the other hand, he contradicted himself when he said that in the earlier years, in 1946-47, certain counties could not avail of the grants because of the turf industry in those counties.

Comment on this

I said nothing of the sort.

Comment on this

It makes no difference if he said it or not, but I would like to point out in regard to the turf counties, say Offaly——

Comment on this

I was to get 20 minutes to finish.

Comment on this

If the Deputy will give me one minute more, I would like again to stress to Deputy MacEntee a matter which he raised with me last week in a question. The grants were notified each year and it was intimated to the county councils each year that these would not continue and in that particular respect the Minister for Finance opposed it strongly from year to year; so much so that in 1947-48 there was no approval by the Minister for Finance of the payment of the special grants until November when there was talk of a general election. The special grants for the second year were approved by the Minister for Finance on the 13th February when it was obvious that Fianna Fáil were going out of office and they then committed us to expenditure to the extent of £2,250,000.

Comment on this

The Parliamentary Secretary is mixing his dates.

Comment on this

In moving this motion I did not envisage such a discussion as we have had. It went circling around the unemployment there would be as a result of withholding the grants which were made available last year. In moving the motion I mentioned three things that were directly concerned, namely, the restoration of roads to their pre-war conditions—that is No. 1; the burden that might be placed on the ratepayers of this country, that is No. 2; and the unemployment that would be caused as a result of slashing the grants. The discussion circled largely around unemployment but that is only one of the three. Is it the contention of the Minister for Local Government that our roads have now been restored to their pre-war condition? If that is so, it is the duty of every council in this country to dismiss their county surveyors because they have submitted estimates asking for the same amount of money as the council put up last year, and in some cases more, on the basis that they were going to obtain the same grants as they got from the Department of Local Government last year. Now the county surveyors have misled the councils if the Minister's contention is right, but we know from going through our own constituencies that the surveyors were right and that the roads have not been restored to their pre-war condition. In the county I come from, County Kilkenny, we have bridges, as I told you in moving the motion, that have not been touched since the floods of 1947. That is the position which obtains there.

With regard to the question of unemployment, we have men working on the roads in my constituency who are from 50 to 60 years of age. Is it the suggestion of the Minister for Local Government and of Deputy Dunne, who is the organiser of the road workers and the rural workers in this country, that these men must get into the rivers next year? Is that how they are going to solve the road workers' position, to put them into rivers, drains and dykes all the year round when there is no work on the roads?

Comment on this

He wants to put them in their grave.

Comment on this
Michael Donnellan Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance (Mr. Donnellan) Clann na Talmhan

The Deputy put a few in the grave.

Comment on this

The Minister spoke of unemployment. Why has he not intimated what work is being provided for my county? We have not turf bogs in Kilkenny and if we are going to have drainage schemes, as was stated, I wonder what the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance has to say in this connection. If he remembers, I was on a deputation very recently from the General Council of County Councils and here is the reply we got when we suggested such a thing:

"To divert the board's engineers and plant to deal with smaller drainage problems at present would be a complete departure from the recommendations of the Drainage Commission and the fundamental basis of the Drainage Act of 1945. It would also mean disrupting the elaborate organisation now being built up and a deferment of the basic work on arterial drainage."

Comment on this

Is there anything wrong with that?

Comment on this

I am reading a report —supplied, I take it, from the Parliamentary Secretary's office—in the Irish Press of January 20th, 1949.

Comment on this

What is wrong with that statement?

Comment on this

That was the statement you made, was it not?

Comment on this

That is the scheme envisaged by our Minister for Local Government; it is the same scheme as was condemned by the Parliamentary Secretary.

Comment on this

Did I not tell your deputation that I was making that recommendation to the Minister for Local Government? Be honest about it.

Comment on this

That is the same scheme. I am going to ask the Minister for Local Government, if he brings into operation a scheme such as he has envisaged in his remarks here to-night, will he compensate the farmers to whom he may do damage? Who is going to compensate them? The report of the engineers says that the scheme will interfere with tributaries and that a part of the county will be flooded.

Comment on this

What is going to happen to the Nore?

Comment on this

It is going to be left in abeyance.

Comment on this

The Deputy left it for 16 years.

Comment on this

The question of solving unemployment in rural areas in this country is a very easy one if the same conditions obtain as have obtained—the emigrant ship, and instead of inviting technicans to the country, the Minister for Industry and Commerce will want to build more emigrant ships to take the people out because there is no work for them. The same thing applies as far as housing is concerned. The Minister for Local Government will have no difficulty in getting all the houses he needs because there will be nobody in rural areas to occupy them. I know what I am speaking about when I say that our rural areas are becoming depopulated. As a result of the Minister for Agriculture's policy, agricultural labourers are being thrown out of work every other day. Week after week they are going out of the country and their only hope is employment on the roads. That employment is not there for them. If the suggestion made by the Minister for Local Government is carried out there will not be work for them during three or four months of the year.

We had the Minister for Agriculture talking about his big scheme of land reclamation. Why did he not spend the £500,000 on land improvement last year that was introduced by the Fianna Fáil Government or the £250,000 on the farm buildings scheme? What is the use of the Minister talking to us now about a £40,000,000 scheme? There were schemes there that he could have easily handled but he did not put them into operation. They were left in abeyance like other things that we have heard so much about, like, for instance, the full employment that we were going to have in the country. The Minister talks about his major scheme and the £10 grant for drainage provided the farmer does it himself. If the farmer does he will have to pay £5 to the Department of Agriculture. In reply to a question, the Minister stated that the cost of the drainage is £46 per acre. Where is the land in this country, requiring drainage, that is worth even the figure of £46 an acre?

Statements were made about getting loans for works. We know what happened last year regarding these loans when the Budget was introduced. The interest rates were increased from 2½ per cent. to 3¼ per cent. That was the help that was given to the local authorities. In the case of houses and of machinery purchased for the maintenance and repair of roads, the position is to be that the rates of interest on new claims will be 15/- per £100 more than they were under the Fianna Fáil régime. That is the help that the Coalition Government are giving to the local authorities. It is there plain to be seen by everybody.

Tourism was mentioned, and the Minister for Industry and Commerce said that the roads were good enough. If we are to expect tourists to come here then we will have to provide them with good roads. The members of the Government should remember that. Our tourist traffic is worth £28,000,000 a year to us. It brings in more than our cattle, our eggs and our poultry. What provision are the Government making for it through the upkeep of the roads of the country? Are they making any provision to keep the roads in a proper state of repair? We tried to do that during the last four or five years. The help the Government are giving is to slash the grants for the roads.

In August and September next when the county councils will not have a shilling or a penny in their coffers, we will find that the water channels on the roads will not be cleaned and that the roads hedges will not be cut. The result will be that when the first floods come in October the channels will be choked and the roads will be torn up for many a mile. That will put more expense on the local authority. There will be no money there for the purpose of keeping the roads in repair. Even as it is, the county councils find it very hard to do the work that is necessary on the roads.

The question before the House is this: is the Minister going to put men out of employment for the sake of saving £2,000,000, or is he going to burden the ratepayers with the task of providing the moneys necessary to have the same amount of work done on the roads this year as that which obtained during the past three or four years? In the County Kilkenny, where I come from, we have had very little variation in the number of men employed on the roads during the past number of years. We had in or about 650 men. They worked for about ten months of the year. I am sure that the position which applies in Kilkenny applies in every other county, but even more so in those counties where turf was produced during the war. There was a great deal more work to be done on the county and main roads in the turf-producing counties than in a county like Kilkenny where we had no turf production. Our men had to do harvest work during the emergency. Nevertheless, in my constituency we were able to do more work on the roads than they were in many other areas. Notwithstanding the amount of work that we did during that period, our county surveyor has reported to us that our roads will not be back to normal for at least another two years on the condition that we will be able to spend as much money on them as we did last year. If the statement that he submitted to us is wrong, and is wrong in so far as it applies to every other county, then I submit that the Minister for Local Government should order the dismissal of every county surveyor in the country for trying to mislead the ratepayers by looking for more money than they need.

Before I conclude I want to say that the schemes envisaged by Ministers here to-night will necessarily take some time to put into operation. In view of that, I want to ask, will the Minister for Local Government not consider continuing the grants on the old scale until these new schemes come into operation? I think he indicated that these schemes would not be ready to start until next July. Why, therefore, not make the grants available for another year? If that is done we will be satisfied with the amount of work that will be done, our men will have got employment and the ratepayers will be saved the necessity of putting up this extra money. It is no longer the responsibility of the local authorities to keep the roads. They have done their duty in all cases. It is now the responsibility of the Minister for Local Government and of the Government as a whole. Let no argument be put forward in this House that the local authorities are not doing their duty. They are, and will continue to do it. The Government also have a responsibility in the matter and they must live up to that responsibility. The farmer Deputies have a responsibility to the people who sent them here. The leaders of both Labour Parties have a responsibility to the workers. This is the place in which they must shoulder their responsibilities, and the only way in which they can do so is by voting for or against this motion to-night. I challenge both of them to show their hand, and so let use see how their feelings run. They can do that by voting for or against the motion. By their vote we are going to judge their sincerity on this question.

Comment on this
Division

Question put.

Tá 66
·
Níl 72
Result _

Do you agree with this result?