Committee on Finance. - Vote 53—Forestry.
Contributions 88–194 of 194. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
I will admit straightaway that there is any amount of good land that needs drainage but I will back my knowledge against anyone else's in this matter and I will say that most of the land that needs drainage is not first, second or third class land. It is land of an inferior type. Certainly, most of the land in certain parts of Leinster that need drainage is of an inferior type.
Comment on this
The Chair is troubled to know what the drainage of land, that comes for consideration on the Estimates for the Department of Agriculture, has to do with this?
Comment on this
I am hoping to relate the fact that the Minister for Agriculture proposes to put into operation a scheme to rehabilitate certain types of land by drainage to this Estimate. Most of the land that needs drainage is third, fourth, fifth and sixth-rate land. Three-fourths of it is land of an inferior type.
Comment on this
That is the type of land that the Minister for Lands proposes to acquire for the purpose of forestry.
Comment on this
Inferior type of land. Inferior, almost valueless land is the type of land that the Minister and his Department have been acquiring for forestry over all the years. Is not that correct?
Comment on this
Maybe inferior but certainly not flooded. If the Deputy would plant trees in water, I would not.
Comment on this
The Deputy will have to come to forestry. I have listened to Deputy Allen repeating himself time and time again. I shall not continue to be lenient. The Deputy will come to the Estimate.
Comment on this
I want to point out to the Minister that he has no hope of acquiring these inferior lands in future unless he is prepared to pay ths additional value they will have when the £12 is spent on them. I want to point that out. The lands that will be improved under a scheme that will be in operation in the present year will not be available to the Minister in future. I want to point that out to him and let him chew it and think it out.
Comment on this
It is all-important that the Minister for Lands and the Government as a whole should think out that problem because it is a problem that will affect this country in the future. There is no doubt about it in the world.
An Ceann Comhairle resumed the Chair.
Comment on this
I do not propose to mention it any more, unless the Deputies opposite do.
There is not much else that I want to say on this Estimate except to ask the Minister when he is acquiring land in the course of the year to be careful not to acquire land, if possible at all, by means of the compulsory powers he has. That is all-important. That is a matter for the Minister purely and simply. He is the responsible person and he can decide it himself as I am sure he will.
Another question is that concerning shelter belts and the £10 grant. The £10 grant has been in operation for some years now and it is about time that the Minister increased it somewhat. He mentioned the reduced value of money and the Minister for Finance has told us repeatedly that money has only 50 per cent. or less of its pre-war value. That £10 grant was an encouragement and is a certain encouragement still to people who plant land that previously carried timber which was felled during the war, but by the time the work is carried out if there is a substantial amount of fencing and draining to be done £10 is of very little use, and the Minister will know that very well. I would suggest to the Minister that that grant might be increased. A big amount of the best timber that grew in this country in the past and that was felled during the war grew in the vales and the dells, and the sooner those lands that carried heavy, good, strong timber in the past are replanted the better.
I want, further, to suggest to the Minister that he should make one of his foresters available to give free advice to anyone who may require it for the planting of areas that formerly carried timber or of virgin ground. Anyone who is prepared to undertake the planting of an acre or upwards of virgin ground should have an officer of the Department available to give free advice. The grant should also be increased. If a man is prepared to plant two or three acres the grant should be increased proportionately. The more he planted the more per acre he should get. The Minister should see the wisdom of that because, as in the matter of housing, unless private individuals are prepared to come in and do their share the Minister and his Department, with the best goodwill and the best efforts in the world, will unfortunately be unable to replace in an ordinary lifetime the amount of timber lost to the country during the recent war and during the 1914-18 War.
With regard to the question of species of timber, it is of importance that the Department should plant more hardwoods than they have been planting in the past. Their efforts are directed to the extent of 90 per cent., as far as I can see, to softwoods while ash, oak, beech and elm are neglected. They are scarcely planted at all, and they are the type suitable for the heavy lands, the dells and vales that I mentioned a while ago. You want rich, strong land for hardwood timbers for they will not grow in light upper lands, and the Department should acquire that type of land, whatever they pay for it, to grow hardwoods. Hardwoods are going almost out of existence and people in the sawmilling industry will tell you that it is almost impossible at the present time to purchase either ash or elm timber. There is a great scarcity of it in different parts of the country, and the sooner the Department wakens up to that the better. Future generations will blame them for their lack of foresight. All the beech, ash and elm has been cut down during the recent emergency. That is quite true. Men engaged in making farm carts told me that they cannot buy elm or ash within a 20 miles radius of where they live at the present time and it is important that consideration and immediate consideration should be given to that by the Forestry Department. They have not planted hardwoods to any extent in the past. I do not know what the proportions are, but I do know that the proportion of spruce, Japanese larch, European larch and fir, all softwood types, has been high and they are less valuable timber and less utilised in the country than hardwoods.
Comment on this
Hardwoods are the most valuable, for they take about double or treble the number of years to grow and are therefore expensive to produce. It takes three times the number of years to produce mature hardwood than mature softwood and therefore it must be more valuable in that way.
Comment on this
Softwood is more used in building, but the type of softwood we grew was inferior. A lot of the softwood we grew and that the Department has been concentrating on, the timber that comes to maturity in 30 or 35 years, was inferior timber and scarcely suitable for use in the building of houses, if it was suitable at all. I would say that 99 out of 100 engineers and architects in the country would condemn it. If we want to produce a timber which will be of use to the country in the future, we should after careful consideration produce the species that is known to give a type of timber that can be utilised in the building of houses and in all the other activities in which timber is used in this country. Above all, hardwood should not be allowed to die out and become extinct. The Department of Forestry should see to it. They are responsible because the private planter who plants shelter belts is more inclined to plant softwoods than hardwoods because they are of faster growth and are more certain to produce a crop than the hardwoods. The hardwoods are more expensive to grow and are more liable to loss than softwood timbers, so he will concentrate on producing softwood. The private producer who is prepared to plant shelter belts or anything over half an acre should be encouraged by giving him a higher grant than he has been given by the Department over the past years.
Comment on this
For years I and other Deputies have been agitating for afforestation schemes in South Kerry, and I am glad that the Minister has taken steps to establish a forestry centre in our district. It is a step in the right direction and we regard it as a test case. What I mean by that is that, so far as afforestation in our county is concerned—and our county is mainly suitable for afforestation—that forestry centre can be developed and several centres in other areas in South Kerry established.
I followed closely some of the points made in this debate. I agree with Deputy Derrig that the proposed scheme of the Minister for Agriculture will sooner or later—at a later date, I expect—be co-related with this forestry scheme. In other words, if you have an extensive drainage scheme you are bound to have in the same area an afforestation scheme. In that way, both Departments would, in my opinion, have to co-operate. Drainage is practically summer and autumn work; afforestation schemes are usually winter work. In that way the rural workers can participate in either scheme. From that point alone, I suppose that these schemes will be co-related as time goes on.
In regard to the planting of what is called non-plantable land, that is, land on mountain slopes, I entirely disagree with Deputy Allen's statement that hardwood timber cannot be grown on uplands or in mountainous districts. Some of the best pine and larch that have been produced in this country were grown in our county on the slopes of the mountains and at a high altitude. I entirely disagree with the statement that it is only in the valleys that the best hardwood timber is found.
I would remind the House, with regard to the forestry belt in Killarney, that last year a serious fire occurred in that area and that a valuable section of forestry was destroyed. Our Forestry-Department should, as is the case in other countries, have forestry stewards or guards or caretakers. I understand that the fire was caused by a picnic party and that splendid trees of 70 years' growth and upwards were-destroyed. If we are going to the expense of establishing an extensive forestry belt we should take precautions to look after it properly by appointing suitable men to look after it.
I am not at all certain that the Minister can get all the land he has mentioned in his Estimate. Nevertheless, I refer to that one case as a casein point. I travelled that area in 1936 and 1937 with the then Forestry Director. It has taken from 1936 to the present day to get a scheme started in that area.
Comment on this
We travelled miles of that district. If it can be done after the lapse of that period of years why should we not go further and develop other schemes in the Kenmare and Iveragh districts of South Kerry? As I say, this is a test case. I appreciate everything that has been done recently in regard to this matter. I am sure the people whom I represent will appreciate the action of the Minister and of the Forestry Department in taking steps to establish this centre. However, I am anxious that you will go even further.
I disagree entirely with what Deputy Allen has said in regard to compulsory powers. Nobody is anxious for compulsory powers but, in that particular case, it was imperative on the Forestry Department to take action. The land in that district trebled in price and the Department had to seek compulsory powers to acquire the land at a reasonable price. In such a case, compulsory powers are reasonable and necessary. The Minister should not hesitate to use compulsory powers where people demand an exorbitant price. Nobody is anxious for compulsory powers but there are occasions when they must be sought, such as, for instance, in regard to housing. If you want to advance in this country, and you reach a stage when you are up against it and you meet with serious opposition, you must make use of compulsory powers and get down to business. We are fed up, as Deputy Cowan has said, with talk about what may happen or may not happen. That is not the way to do business.
Comment on this
We must get down to work. By the efforts of the Minister and the efforts of the Department, we have advanced in this case. Let me say that I hope it is only one of many as far as our county, and the country in general, are concerned.
I wish the Minister every success and I appreciate the work he has done.
Comment on this
In this debate, as in similar debates in the past, much emphasis has been laid on the value of afforestation. I do not propose to take up much of the time of the House in emphasising its importance much further. I have very little criticism to make because anybody who knows anything about afforestation will understand that it is a matter that cannot be accomplished overnight. However, what we want to see are signs that this afforestation campaign will materialise within a specified period. Obviously, to have a first-class afforestation scheme on foot, it is necessary to have nursuries for seedlings. It is in that respect that I would criticise the Minister. I understood from him that he had approximately 300 acres available for nursery purposes and that his intention is to increase that area. If that afforestation scheme is to be got going within a reasonable time it is necessary for him to acquire three times that quantity of land.
Personally, I look upon afforestation as one of the key solutions to unemployment and emigration, especially on the western seaboard. Up to this we have looked upon agriculture as our main industry. We could develop afforestation as another main industry equal in importance to agriculture. We all know that any country which is dependent on one major industry will be in a very bad state if that industry goes down. It is only natural, therefore, that we should have another major industry to depend upon if one industry is hit by world conditions or adverse markets abroad. Afforestation would provide an ideal key or main industry side by side with agriculture. It is a matter of ordinary common sense or prudence that any country which hopes to have an industrial future, or indeed a future of any kind, should ensure that the raw material for industry is available. If we are to develop industry and are to be dependent upon supplies from abroad in order to foster that industry, then we are up against world conditions straightaway. In afforestation we have one example of what we can do with our own raw material.
Much has been said about the various articles which are made or processed from timber. I do not propose to go into that. What I really got up to speak about was the West of Ireland and, in particular, the Gaeltacht areas. Certain people have stated that there are areas in Connemara and other places in the West which are not suitable for afforestation. Some of these people I believe are experts. We should not always follow the advice of experts. That is not taking away from their use or their value, but they have been found to be wrong in the past, especially in connection with afforestation. It is a well-known fact in connection with that portion of France facing the Bay of Biscay which is subject to terrible storms and where the land had been inundated with sand for years, the experts stated that the land could never be planted. I think it was Napoleon who was responsible for turning down the experts' advice. I do not know whether the Minister has any aspirations to be a Napoleon, but at any rate he could take a chance.
Comment on this
That particular portion of the coast was planted. First of all they put down the seedlings and, in order to protect them, they had to be covered with seaweed for a long period. When the outer fringe of timber started to grow it was warped and twisted, but it provided protection for the inner belts of forestry which were planted at a later stage. The inner plantation was protected from the storms and as a result that portion of France to-day is one of the richest in the country. We have also the example of Scotland.
It is acknowledged in Scotland to-day that there are three solutions for emigration and poverty in portions ot that country—afforestation, hydro-electrification and tourism. Afforestation is put first on the list. In Scotland, it is intended to plant all the bogs and hillsides and marshy land. The people concerned know that there are difficulties ahead of them, but they are prepared to face up to them. In his opening statement the Minister mentioned that the Forestry Department were now the proud possessors of a bulldozer, as if that was something to be proud of. There are thousands of bulldozers employed at afforestation work in Scotland.
Even from the employment angle, would it not be much better to have men at home working on afforestation than to see them going in droves weekly to Britain? Every man who goes abroad is a loss to this country. Then there is another way of looking at it. Many men and women who leave this country for work in Britain send their savings home. That money which they send home helps to send up the cost of living here, so that all the efforts of the Government to reduce the cost of living will go for nought unless they tackle this problem of emigration and in afforestation they have an ideal solution for it. All sections of people are interested in the Gaeltacht so that it may be preserved from extinction. There is no better way of doing that than by starting afforestation in a big way in the Gaeltacht. It would mean a large increase in the number of people employed. Apart from the employment angle, you would have an increase in agricultural produce in order to feed these workers, so that not alone would you be helping to increase the national wealth, but you would be increasing the farmers' wealth also, because their output would have to be increased in order to feed the extra population engaged on afforestation.
I think it was Deputy Mongan mentioned Ballinahinch. I happen to know that area fairly well. At present there is great talk of Ballinahinch Castle being put up for sale as a tourist hotel. I would throw out the suggestion to the Minister that he should consider taking it over as a forestry school. It is situated right in the heart of a country which is ideal for afforestation. It would be a great kicking-off ground, you might say, because the country for miles around is eminently suited for afforestation.
I think it was Deputy Allen who stated that hardwood was more important from the point of view of commercial timber than softwood. That is complete nonsense to my mind, because softwood is most important from a commercial point of view. I agree with Deputy Allen, however, that hardwood should be grown in proportion. I am not going to say what the proportion should be. It is for the experts to say what amount of planting there should be of oak, elm, beech and ash. There should be reasonable quantities planted.
Ash is valuable from the sports point of view. As one associated with the national games, I would like to advocate the planting of considerable quantities of ash. Our national game of hurling depends on ash being available. At times great difficulty is experienced in procuring the right type, and sufficient quantities, of ash.
One of the most important things about this afforestation campaign is the publicity end of it. I think that, until we make everybody in the country afforestation conscious, we will never get anywhere. I believe that in Greece the position after the last war was that most of the timber and afforestation in the country was destroyed. The stage has now been reached there that the young people are taking such an interest in planting that young trees are being made available to them by the State. They are vying with one another in the villages and in the different localities in carrying out planting. Of course, that will not be commercial planting. It will, however, add to the beauty of the countryside and will provide shelter. It is absolutely necessary that the same thing should be done here. The State can never hope to be responsible for clothing once more the entire countryside in timber. A lot will depend on planting by private individuals, but so far there has been a deplorable lack of initiative on the part of private individuals to undertake a planting campaign. The reason, to my mind, is that they know absolutely nothing about the value of afforestation or of timber.
There should be a small plantation around every farmer's house. It would be ideal for shelter and would add to the appearance of the house. There are many houses throughout the country to-day and you do not even see a bush in the vicinity of one of them. In my opinion, a publicity campaign is the only solution. America is the big country for publicity stunts. I think it would be money well spent if we got some kind of a publicity campaign on foot that would wake the people up to the advantages of afforestation. We must sell them the idea of afforestation, and until that is done we will not get anywhere.
Deputy Moylan talked about publicity. He referred to the fact that the Clann na Poblachta Party gave publicity to afforestation. I remember distinctly Deputy Moylan's publicity some years ago in the case of afforestation. I read his speeches, and the publicity that he gave to it was anything but of the hopeful sort. He referred mostly to the fact that there was no netting wire available and that we had no shovels or picks—that there was nothing available. That was during the period of the emergency. I do not want to blame Fianna Fáil for not planting 20,000 or 25,000 acres during that period, but we must remember that during the war years, in England, they continued to plant trees and to carry out afforestation work at the rate of 30,000 acres a year. That was done by Britain at a time when she felt she was going to be invaded. Here we blow a lot because we are putting 4,000 acres under afforestation.
Apart from anything else, the new drainage and reclamation scheme cannot be divorced from afforestation. As far as drainage is concerned, timber is one of the ideal solutions for the problem of flooding. We know that, in areas where you have a mountainside on which there is no timber, when heavy rain comes it washes down all the soil and strips the mountainside bare. The soil is washed into the valleys. If these mountainsides were planted they would absorb the water like a sponge. Afforestation acts like a sponge. The worst type of land for holding water is grass land. I would advocate that, in as many areas as possible, where drainage will be done and where the land may not, possibly, be of the highest value agriculturally, it should be taken over for afforestation purposes. I make that suggestion to the Minister. The ultimate value of that land will be much greater than if it were used for agriculture.
I have not the figures with me, but I know that the return from an acre of matured spruce and other timbers amounts roughly to £1,000. I am certain that was the pre-war figure. The value has gone up considerably since then. If you compare the value of an acre of land under afforestation—of land drained under this land reclamation scheme—at say over £1,000 for the timber on it when it matures, with what you would get from that acre of land now, even though the value of land has gone up considerably, I think that should make afforestation an attractive proposition to the Department of Forestry. I hope the Minister will go into that matter.
To come to my own constituency, we have quite a lot of land there that is suitable for afforestation. In the last few months various offers of land for planting have been made. These have come from Slieve Bawn in the Strokes-town area. The people there had not even to be asked. They came along and made offers of land ranging from ten acres up to 100 acres. The ideal thing about these offers is that all this land is adjoining. In other words, the Minister need not be afraid that he would have to take ten acres here and then go ten miles for another few acres. That, I suggest, eliminates all the talk there has been about taking compulsory powers. If the people realise the value of afforestation they will be anxious to co-operate in any scheme that is put forward. There is another area suitable for planting. It is in the region of Mount Mary near Ballygar. There is a lot of marshy land there that can never be made into good agricultural land. It is land that, in my opinion, would be useful for afforestation purposes. If the object of the Department be to grow only first-class commercial timber, then, of course, a lot of this type of land that is being offered to the Minister will not be accepted. I think it was Deputy Moylan who stated that it would be better to suffer a loss by draining and planting this land than to have it going to waste. I do not believe that you would suffer any financial loss at all.
Our aim is to leave something for the next generation. The idea up to the present has been somewhat short-sighted—we want an immediate return for the money we invest in any project. We cannot hope for an immediate return from the money invested in afforestation. That return will come to future generations who will thank the present generation for its energy and initiative in starting afforestation. But we will get a return in our time by keeping our young people at home by offering them permanent employment at a decent wage. There is no other means by which they can get that permanent employment. In these poor areas, especially in the West, no nibbling at the problem will solve it. Small cottage industries, glasshouses— they all help, but they do not get past the outer ridge of the problem. Until we get afforestation going in the West we will have a stream of emigration.
I have often talked to men about to go away and I have asked them why they will not stay at home when there is a certain amount of work for them to do. Very often their answer is that that work will last for six weeks on a bog drain or five weeks on a bog road and then they will be out of work for a fortnight or three weeks. If they are in the good grace of the ganger they may get another week or a fortnight. They switch over in April or May to working for farmers for a couple of months but they have no definite guarantee of employment the whole year round.
We are going to develop, I hope in a big way, our peat industry. The cutting and saving of turf take place in the summer months. That will employ numbers of our people during that period. The winter months are suitable for afforestation and these men working on the turf scheme could be switched to afforestation. If that matter is considered by the Minister, I am sure he will see there is reason attached to it.
I should like to repeat this as regards the West of Ireland. Do not accept as final any expert advice that may be given to you. If the Minister wants proof of that, I can give it to him from the most eminent writers who have dealt with the marvellous work done in France. If any other proof were needed, I can instance where people in a responsible position refused to be guided by the experts; they took it upon themselves to chance this work and they proved that they were right in spite of the experts. The conditions in France are far worse than they are in the West of Ireland. Bad and all as the storms are from the Atlantic facing Connemara and along the west coast generally, they are nothing to what happens in France along the Bay of Biscay. If France can do a job of afforestation along her exposed coastline, I do not see why Ireland cannot do it in the west.
I hope that this business of getting the nurseries going will be successful and that the Minister will come back to the House with a Supplementary Estimate. I am sure if he does he will get co-operation from all sides and will get the money that he requires for this urgent work.
Comment on this
Nuair a glactar eastát agus nuair a deintear roinnt idir na daoine sa cheantar is minic a bhíos píosa foraiseachta ar an dteorainn. Leagtar gach crann ag na feirmeoirí nua agus ní cuirtear an dlí i bhfeidhm, chun na crainn óga a chur. Sa chaoi sin deintear an-scrios agus bíonn an fhoraiseacht ag dul i laghad.
When Deputy Allen talked about planting arable land the Minister for Lands and the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance were shocked at the suggestion. And this is the Government that declares they will plant so many million acres with trees! Let us be practical on this whole question and let the Government indicate to us, through the Minister, where these millions of acres are to be found. Let each Deputy go into his constituency, as I shall go into mine, and examine the land position there and find out where are these thousands of acres. Deputies from the west and from the east, Deputies now in the House, know from practical experience that, when an estate is divided, along the boundary of that estate there are a number of acres of forest and portion of that forest is put in with a farm. It has been the practice for years that the farmer knocks down every tree and does not plant a tree in its place. There never has been an enforcement of replanting. I do not see how it is going to be done now. In Westmeath there are a number of Mayo men who got farms at Ballinagall, near Mullingar, and they have complained to me that the Forestry Department are planting good land in Ballinagall with trees. Deputy Lehane says that he does not see that there can be any conflict between the interests of agriculture and forestry. There is a conflict, and a big conflict.
Comment on this
If the Government try to put into operation the compulsory acquisition of land all over the State in order to plant hundreds of thousands of acres, they will be up against a very big problem. I have seen land divided in County Roscommon and in my own county and if you were to suggest that a considerable portion of an estate should be held for forestry, you would be lynched. There is no use in trying to plant trees where, as the saying goes, a snipe would die of cold feet. That is not the sort of land that grows good timber. We all know that, during the war, in the Midlands and in the eastern and western counties trees were bought and cut down and farmers took in hundreds of thousands of pounds for those trees. Those trees were grown on the best of land—oak, ash, beech and elm. Their circumference was immense and they could be seen in Meath, Westmeath, Mayo, on the drive to Athlone and the south. To say that one can go into Connemara and grow trees there 150 feet high and with so many feet of a circumference is altogether ridiculous.
Comment on this
Would the Deputy answer a question? Does the Deputy suggest that there is no land at present not in profitable use which is suitable for afforestation purposes? That is the case I made.
Comment on this
I am as keen on afforestation as any Deputy. I belong to a small Gaelic society and every year that society collects funds with which it subsequently buys and plants trees. When we go into a farmer's land it is not down to the snipe walks we go. The land he gives us must be developed and it must be fairly good land. In the 1946 Forestry Act there is a section which says that one must replant. There is complete evasion of that section. I am not criticising the Minister for that but I put the suggestion that that section should be rigidly enforced. I have seen thousands of pounds worth of timber cut in my constituency and those who cut it have gone down to the snipe walks and thrown a few hundred trees in there—trees which can never grow, They have turned the areas where they cut into pasture. That is a problem one is up against all over the country.
There is a conflict of interests and that conflict cannot be resolved very easily. I suggest that every Deputy should examine his own particular area to find out what the possibilities are. Let us call it "waste" land for a moment. There is a certain amount of such land. Now that land must be developed and drained. There must be a certain depth of soil in it. It would be better to make it serve some useful purpose rather than leave it growing a lot of rushes. It must be put into a state where it will be fit for planting. I agree with the suggestions put forward that we should examine the experiments carried out in France and Scotland. I have read about those experiments. They had to begin with bent grass, shrubs and so on. Eventually they succeeded in afforestation but it took them years to do it. It has been contended here that there is no fencing. There is plenty of fencing now and there is no longer any excuse for non-enforcement as regards replanting.
After Munich certain English firms came over here in 1938 and they bought up all the ash they could get. They bought a considerable quantity of ash which we commonly describe as "ditch timber". But there was no enforcement of the section as regards replanting. A considerable quantity of commercial timber has been cut down in the Midlands and around the east coast and there has been no replanting of any kind. I do not agree with Mr. Carrigan that we have too many ditches and too many hedges. I think our hedges and ditches should be increased because they are beneficial as regards climate and they help to prevent soil erosion. I think the people who compiled the statistics have not taken into consideration the timber in our ditches and hedges. It is quite considerable in amount. I would like to see shelter belts, hedges and ditches developed to a much greater extent. The Land Commission have done something in that respect by means of land division.
There are some particulars which I wish to get from the Minister. Possibly he may not be able to give them to me now. Has any progress been made in the acquisition of more land in the Castlepollard forestry area and the Clonhugh forestry area? What progress has been made in the Kinturk area as regards the land proposed to be acquired from the Sacred Heart Order? I would like to point out the fact that there there is a considerable amount of turbary involved. Is it proposed to acquire that turbary together with the land to be replanted? A number of people have banks there and I suggest they should be left those banks until the turf is completely cut away. If it is then possible to develop the subsoil to any extent subsequently it can be developed for afforestation. It would be a hardship on these people to take away their turbary. There is plenty of other land available in the area on which to carry out this forestry scheme. I would also like to know what progress has been made in the Granard and the Ballinagall forestry area?
I want to emphasise again the necessity for compelling those who cut timber to replant. That is particularly essential in the Midlands. These people made thousands out of the timber they cut and they should be compelled to put back on the land an equal number of trees to that out of which they made such tremendous profits during the war.
Comment on this
I want to congratulate the Minister on putting into operation this scheme of afforestation. I agree with Deputy McQuillan that that is one way of solving our emigration problem. In accordance with Deputy Kennedy's suggestion that we should acquaint the Minister with the situation as regards our own particular constituencies, I can tell the Minister that there are thousands of acres of suitable land in my constituency. I believe that it is land suitable for afforestation and I believe that it can be made useful and productive. Every year thousands of young men are leaving the West of Ireland because there is no employment for them at home. I believe that afforestation would keep them at home and I would suggest to the Minister that instead of taking an area of 1,000 acres he should take four areas of 250 acres each. That would help to give the local people employment near their homes. If the young men could get employment at home the possibility is that our young girls would remain here. The young girls have to leave this country simply because the boys have no employment to get at home. When there are two, three, four or five boys in a house in an area such as I have mentioned there is no alternative but for the young girls to leave also. I believe that if forestry on a big scale is started it will have the effect of keeping the young boys and girls at home simply because more money will be available for circulation which will give them an opportunity of living in their own houses in their own areas.
Coming back to the question of the suitability of the timber that will be grown, I am not prepared to discuss that because I have not sufficient knowledge. I am sure the experts of the Department engaged in forestry will be able to decide the question as to the most suitable timber for plantation— oak, ash, beech or elm. I would certainly bring before the Minister the necessity of timber especially grown for egg case material. After 25 years of native Government we find that we have to import the timber for cases for exporting eggs. Practically all the timber used to-day for exporting such things as fowl and eggs has to be imported. The value of every egg case that leaves this country, from the point of view of the timber and the employment given for the making of that case, averages about 3/6. That is a huge amount of money leaving this country. If sufficient timber had been planted 25 years ago when forestry was started all that money would have been saved to-day or would have been spent in our own country. I, therefore, make a special appeal for timber for egg case material.
I agree with Deputy McQuillan on one point of view. In my constituency, like Galway, we have a large number of lodges and mansions spread over the area which are more or less derelict. I believe those will be a help for the housing and operating of the scheme of forestry. In my area if afforestation were put into operation the possibilities are that the bog areas would be improved from the point of view that where plantation takes place I am informed that it will have the effect of draining the area for miles and miles around. I am just quoting the view of people who seem to know something about it.
I want to make a special case for my part of the country. If afforestation is going to take place I hope that the Minister will not overlook the area I represent. I may mention Ballygar, Belmullet and Achill. We have plenty of land there which is to-day derelict. Every facility is there and there will be no trouble as far as acquisition is concerned. There may be portions of it in rundale but I am satisfied that if the Minister wishes to acquire land which is even under the rundale system he will have no trouble in doing so. Not a fortnight ago a farmer told me that he had 1,000 acres of land, some of which may have been grazing land. He told me that if a forestry scheme were carried out he would be prepared to sell his 1,000 acres of land. I asked him what he would be inclined to take for this land. The price that he would be agreeable to accept was the surprising part of it. I do not say that he would get what he asked for it but from the point of view of what he would expect per acre there would be very little trouble in coming to an agreement. The Minister would have very little trouble in those areas I have mentioned and he should not overlook them when carrying out his afforestation scheme. No one knows more than he about the young people who have to emigrate because he lives along the border of those areas. He sees thousands of those boys and girls leaving the country for nine months of the year. If the scheme is put into operation he will keep at home at least 80 per cent. of those boys and girls who leave the country, doing the work in their own areas for their own country's sake.
Comment on this
I will not say very much in this debate because we have got into the habit of saying the same thing each year and there is not much to be added. The Forestry Debate in this House keeps to the same line of thought each year and even the same line of action as regards speed in planting more trees. However, the present Minister has set up a record, I believe, in that he has planted the highest number of acres of forest in the last year that ever was planted in this country. We are a long way from the target of 25,000 acres that the Government seems to have set itself out to accomplish. We will not blame them unduly, however, for their failure to reach that target in a short time because everybody knows that we need more seedlings and that it is practically impossible to get them now because all forests are depleted and nurseries where timber is used to add to the nation's wealth by exporting are, in turn, trying to restock their own depleted supplies. Therefore, they have not sufficient to sell to anybody else, However, the fact that there will be an increase of seed imported next year leads us to assume that another 1,000 or 2,000 acres may be added next year. Perhaps in four or five years the forestry situation will go ahead of its own accord, slowly we admit, but it will be coming nearer to something we should all like to see and have in this country. Now is not the time to blame anybody for what should have been done 25 or 30 years ago. In 1922 and 1923 if this country had set about the development of forestry in the proper way we should have plantations now up to 27, 28 and 30 years old which would be of immense value to this country. The unfortunate thing about our legislators at all times is that they will look to some scheme which will pay quick dividends in the following year or the year after or at least in five years.
Anybody with an ounce of sense in his head knows that nobody in this generation will ever gain any benefit from trees that are planted this year or next year, but posterity will reap the advantage of these plantations. There can be really no wealth derived from afforestation until we reach the stage of rotating forests, such as they have in the Scandinavian countries where, if a thousand acres are cut down this year, they are replanted next year, and the system is carried on in such a way that at the end of every 40 or 50 years the same ground is covered again. That is the only way in which real wealth can be derived from forestry, but a start must be made some time. There is no use in blaming anybody now for the neglect of past years. Our object should rather be to give as much encouragement and hope as we possibly can to the present Minister and to enable him to get all the things that are necessary for a proper scheme of afforestation.
I listened for some years back to the statements made on this question by the ex-Minister for Lands, Deputy Moylan. I always looked upon him as a very keen forester and I often thought that his intentions and ideas were much more concerned with afforestation than with schemes for the resettlement of land. He, however, happened to be Minister for Lands and his attitude generally was that it was impossible in the conditions which prevailed during his occupancy of that Ministry to do anything more than was being done. In fairness to him, I believe that if he had been Minister for Lands in the earlier years of the Fianna Fáil administration, he would have used much more force to promote afforestation, but still he cannot go scot-free from all blame for the poor progress made during the years he was Minister because, being a very forceful member of his Party, he should have exerted more pressure on the Department of Finance to see that the necessary funds were made available for more extensive schemes of afforestation. He always seemed to think that the scarcity of rabbit-netting was a real drawback in the operation of forestry schemes. Everybody knows that while rabbit-netting may be of great value in the protection of young trees, it will not keep rabbits out of forests; it may help but it will not succeed in entirely eliminating them. Therefore that is no excuse whatever. If he were honest enough to admit it, he should have said that the Fianna Fáil Party as a whole was not so much concerned with forestry and the Department of Finance was not willing to provide sufficient money to enable forestry schemes to be initiated on a satisfactory scale. I am glad to see that the present Minister has assured the House that if there is any possibility this year of increasing the acreage devoted to forestry, he will come to the Dáil with a Supplementary Estimate to provide the necessary fund. That is definitely encouraging, and while we may say that sufficient progress has not been made during the past year, having heard the reasons given by the Minister and having heard of the efforts made by the Minister for External Affairs to secure seeds and the necessary equipment for forestry work, we cannot lay too much blame on the Government for the slight increase in progress shown during the past year.
Coming from the western seaboard, I think the Minister should devote more attention to that area and should endeavour to provide there much needed employment by extending forestry operations. Everybody knows that there is a vast amount of unemployment in that area and that, in consequence, we have the greatest amount of emigration from it. The farms are small and congested and the people cannot make a living on them. Take for instance, the Barony of Erris and estates such as the Roy Carter Estate and the Bingham Estate where the congestion is the worst to be found in any place in Ireland. It would probably take £500,000 to resettle these people on suitable holdings. Why not, then, as an experiment, seeing that in present financial conditions £500,000 or £250,000 is a mere bagatelle devote £100,000 or £200,000 to replanting the waste mountainsides and the waste bogs there? Those of us who have travelled that countryside know that in some places you could travel along main roads for 14 to 20 miles without seeing a habitation of any kind and then suddenly you come along to find a small village at the butt of a mountain with people trying to live on holdings of 20 acres of poor land. Would it not be worth a trial to embark on a scheme of afforestation in these areas and, instead of trying to resettle these people on other lands, to provide them with an industry at their own back doors, as it were?
There are various opinions as to the type of land that is most suitable for forestry. Some people will say— Deputy Kennedy has just said it—that you want first-class land to produce first-class timber. Of course he may be right but I can guarantee, from my own personal experience, that first-class land can also produce a very poor class of timber whereas a very fine class of timber can be grown on second-class land, especially on cutaway bog. I have seen in my own village an instance of where two plantations were put down about ten years ago by one man. One plantation was planted in very good arable land but the other was planted in a piece of cutaway. The trees on the cutaway bog are now 20 feet high while the trees planted on the good arable land are not yet ten feet high. Both of them were planted by the same man and the trees planted—sitka spruce, European larch, etc. were of the same type. That goes to show that you do not necessarily require first-class land to produce first-class timber. Even so, if we could get 1,000,000 acres of land which is non-agricultural land planted, the produce of that 1,000,000 acres, while perhaps of not as much commercial value as timber, would be of immense value for wood pulp alone. We know that at the present time there is a big demand for timber for wood pulp and we know that second-rate timber is as useful for wood pulp as first-class timber.
From time to time we also hear the question asked as to what is the use of planting timber in wet land or snipe land. But it is not impossible to drain marshland. It is not impossible to see that the correct type of drains and watercourses are made even though it may be necessary to have them at a width of ten to 20 feet. It would be possible to make a start in that way and we all know, from what we have read, that plantations automatically raise the ground as they spring up and dry up the land on which they are planted. It has been proved that trees planted in very wet land leave that land quite dry in 50 or 60 years' time and often raise the level of the land as much as ten feet.
We are sometimes told that we should get expert advice on these matters but I am not at all too keen on or too much of a believer in the advice of such experts, particularly after an instance in my own county where two years ago experts of the Forestry Department condemned certain land as unfit for forestry. Last year a private firm of seed merchants and nursery-owners stepped in, took about 30 acres of that land and planted it with trees of their own. I have been told by an inspector sent there by the firm that no part of the land they have has produced more healthy or more promising plants than this particular land which was condemned before by an inspector from the Forestry Department. I wonder do the inspectors as a whole rely too much on what they learn from big volumes in their own comfortable offices or are they a bit slow to accept the advice of practical men who know from experience the capabilities of any particular district?
I have another instance of this inspectorial failure. There is a stretch of mountainside not far from my home, and when I was a small boy, about 1919, a Scottish firm came over and cut down about 60 acres of forest. That has never been replanted since. It was classified as unfit for plantation a very short time ago by inspectors of the Forestry Department; even though it produced first class timber 50 years ago, to-day it is not fit for plantation. There is something wrong somewhere. I wonder if, in this Department of which I have such suspicion, the dead hand of the Land Commission is beginning to stretch over to the Forestry Department. There has been an increase of 1,000 acres in the last year.
Comment on this
It is only 8,000. Seven thousand acres were planted in previous years and that was the highest figure. That increase saves them from being put on the same grade as their colleagues. These are instances which I can give from my own knowledge and experience and which are perfectly correct. Then there is this idea of not going into an area unless there are 300 or 500 acres. I think the minimum is 300. What is wrong with the Forestry Department taking over as low as 50 or 60 statute acres and planting it?
Comment on this
Nothing should be wrong. I do not suppose there is, but up to date there seems to be an awful fear of going in to plant a small plantation, that it is not worth the trouble, with wire fencing and so forth, and that the Department would not be justified in taking it over. I know the Minister will take a serious view of that, as he knows that places of 100 and even 50 acres of forest planted in County Mayo—his constituency and mine—would give a fair amount of employment and be of great benefit to the people of the locality. He will find —and if he does not, whoever comes after him in years to come will find— that congestion and forestry can eventually help to cancel one another out, the furtherance of one helping to relieve the other. Everyone knows you cannot just stick down 100 acres of forest and leave it there and expect it to produce good commercial timber in 30 or 40 years. The trees have to be looked after, thinned out and undergrowth kept down, until they reach a certain stage. The figures I have show that in 100 acres of forest there are 1,680 cubic feet of thinnings to be taken out, valued at £2,000 per annum.
Comment on this
That would be more like it. However, even at 1,000 acres, there would be a good market for the timber for fences, paling posts and pit props. The general outlook of forestry is so good that more encouragement and attention should be given to it by the Government than it has got. I know the present Minister is doing his very best and his colleagues in the Government do not seem to stint him in regard to money, as he has told us he can come back and get money any time he wants it to help in the work. Therefore I am hopeful that things may be better than they have been in the past.
Another thing that should be encouraged is planting by private individuals. There is nothing so beautiful as a small plantation, even at the end of a field or around a house. While we never had respect for the old landlords, if they had not done a certain amount of planting in their time we would have no trees now. It is unfortunate to have to say that, in my own constituency, the only good scheme of plantation carried out in the past 20 years was at Castlemagarrett estate, near Claremorris, by Lord Oranmore and Browne. Some 500 to 600 acres have been planted in the last 22 or 23 years. He has taken one-acre and two-acre plots and planted them with fertile, flourishing trees. He has picked out land that was no good for anything else, drained it and planted it, and the forest is beautiful to look at. Planting by private individuals should be encouraged, by an increase of the amount of the grant per acre. Ten pounds are not sufficient to encourage an individual to plant land. In the case of the small or middle-class farmer in the countryside, he cannot afford to plant, with the increased cost of forest plants at present. He cannot do very much for £10, and when he is supposed to fence the trees in a special manner the grant is not much good. If it could be doubled, it would give a certain amount of encouragement and would tempt men to plant in a better way than in the past.
The trouble in getting land seems to lie always in the fact that a piece of waste ground, 100, 200 or 1,000 acres in a locality may be available, but immediately it comes to the ear of somebody that the Government may step in to make use of it, it suddenly becomes mighty valuable. It was worthless ground before that, over which there may be commonage rights, and people begrudged paying rent and rates for it every year; but when a Government scheme is mentioned land not worth tuppence an acre becomes worth £5, £10 or even £20 an acre. The Minister has often said, and still says, he would prefer to get land without compulsion, but I welcome the statement he made to-day here, that he will use compulsory powers, if necessary, to acquire this type of land. He need not ever think he will get enough co-operation from the people who own sides of mountains and commonage rights, to allow him to carry on. We know that useless land suddenly becomes valuable when the owners think they can squeeze the Government. Everyone seems to think the Government a great paymaster, and a good development scheme can be held up for years because two or three individuals in the centre of commonage land hold out against the efforts of the Government to do something useful for the community.
I want to refer also to a particular group of workers, the forest workers, and to another section of the Forestry Department who, up to this day, seem to have got little or no consideration from any Government—the men who are called foresters. These are types of foremen over the ordinary forest workers, and there are not many of them employed by the Department at present. When a scheme of forestry in relation to, say, 200 acres of land is about to be embarked upon, these gentlemen are brought down by an inspector and told: "Here are 200 acres —go and plant them." In addition, I am informed that they are also burdened with the responsibility of paying the forestry labourers each week and of sending back reports as to the amount of work done, the amount of work to be done, the numbers of trees wanted and the amount of fencing wire, posts, spades and shovels and so on required. They have to keep an entire check of these.
These men are an unestablished body of civil servants. Following an open competitive examination, they do a course of training in the Forestry College at Avondale and are then sent out with no chance of reaping the benefits to which they are entitled. The rates of pay are by no means attractive and worst of all is the fact that these men have no pension rights, no matter how long they stay in the service. They have never been recognised as established civil servants. I believe that there is some sort of inquiry in progress at present with regard to their status, but it has been going on for the past seven years and it is time it reached a decision one way or the other, so that, if necessary, these men will have a chance of getting out of the country and going to England where they can become established civil servants and enjoy the benefits they are entitled to, benefits to which any other civil servant is entitled.
These men are very valuable and they have hard work to do because, when new recruits come in, these men have to teach them how to plant trees—the proper widths, the manner of setting them down and the depths at which they should be set. That work cannot be done by pen or pencil—it must be done by practical work; and these foresters have to teach that work to the recruits under their care. In the past few years, some of these men have fallen into bad health, and, in one or two cases, men have died as a result of hard work and exposed conditions. Their families have been left in complete destitution and only a whip-round amongst the men who know the conditions of the families has kept them from the workhouse.
I should like the Minister to take a special note of the conditions under which these men work. I am sure they have been brought to his attention already, and I know that these men have his sympathy because I know that he or any Minister would not want to see a useful body of men such as these deprived of any benefits which they should enjoy. They are a most useful body of men because on them falls the burden of carrying out the spade work in relation to the starting and rearing of the infant tree until the time comes when it can fend for itself. There are only 160 or 161 of these men in the country and they are entitled to the same status as other civil servants.
I hope the Minister's good and sincere efforts will meet with great success. In Scotland we see that, in Ross and Cromarty they are working with gigantic bulldozers and tractors, levelling waste land, bogland and swampland, land which for the past 200 years grew nothing but heather, bracken and furze, and they expect to have something like 2,500,000 acres of forest planted within the next five, six or ten years. That is a headline which we should keep our eyes on, because we, in this country, are blessed in a way in which people in other countries are not so lucky, that is, we have little or no erosion, or none involving any great harm. There may be some slight erosion in some parts but it is a fact that, on the mountainside of Croagh Patrick, there has not been a bit of erosion for the past 50 years. Even the boggy soil which is windswept by the Atlantic is still there. I do not suggest that you could grow forest trees so high up, but there are low valleys which could and should be used in a forestry scheme which should have been in operation for a long time. Such a scheme has several purposes. It provides a certain amount of employment; it does something from which the country will reap benefit in years to come; and it has the effect of beautifying the countryside and taking away the bleakness and barrenness of large stretches of infertile, useless land.
It has been said that there is a clash between forestry and agriculture, but it is a bit early in this country to think of any such clash, although that is not the case with regard to some countries in Europe. In Norway and Finland, the average farmer finds it much more profitable to plant ten, 15 or 20 acres of his finest land each year rather than to have it growing crops, and I understand that it will soon be necessary in one Scandinavian country to introduce legislation to prevent the farmers from planting land which should be used for agricultural purposes. We have 40 or 50 years yet before we need worry about that here, and, on the basis of the rate of progress so far, we would have 500 years to go, and it will be our great grandsons who will see even half the amount of forestry land available planted with trees, so that those who are worrying about the danger of a clash between the forestry and agricultural side of our economy can cease from worrying. They can sleep quite peacefully. They, and the following generation, need have no worries whatever, no matter at what speed the Department goes ahead, and even with the target of 25,000 acres, they have no reason to worry. There will be no need to worry. There is plenty of waste land and infertile land which can be used for the benefit of the country.
I do not know where the ex-Minister for Lands got this figure of 100,000 acres. He seemed to throw it over to the Clann na Talmhan Party. I do not know why he turned his attention to that Party. I have been quite a good while in the Clann na Talmhan Party and I never heard more than 15,000 acres mentioned at any meeting as the figure at which we should aim at planting each year. It may have been mentioned by way of suggestion by a Deputy in this House, but personally I would be very pleased if we could get between 15,000 to 25,000 acres of forest planted each year. The Deputy must have got his information from the Irish Press which is one of those papers on which we cannot place too much reliance. It is humbug to talk about 100,000 acres. Anyone with an ounce of sense would not mention such a figure. It may be possible to have 100,000 acres planted in 20 years and it is doubtful if it would be a wise policy to try to plant 100,000 acres a year. If we could aim at planting 20,000 to 25,000 acres each year until all the available land was planted and at the end of 40 to 60 years if we could start to fell the forests and continue in the Scandinavian system we would have brought the forestry industry to a satisfactory position and would have made it of real value. We should aim at that rather than talk of something which we know is impossible.
The most encouraging part of the Minister's statement is the indication that if necessary he will introduce a Supplementary Estimate. In that he will have the support of every Deputy. I am glad that he will have the support both of the Government and of the Opposition. We are all of opinion that forestry has been neglected and that it is time a real effort should be made. While the Minister may not have gone as far as he would like to go, the fact that he has set up a record in his second year in office will save him the hard comments and abuse on this Estimate that he was subject to on the Estimate for the Department of Lands which was before the House recently.
Comment on this
Deputy Commons has made my task very light and I will merely emphasise the point he has made and appeal to the Minister to give careful and sympathetic consideration to the demands of the foresters. I would ask the Minister, if he does not think their demands unreasonable, to remedy their grievances as soon as possible. Deputy Commons has drawn attention to the fact that these men have important work to do in directing operations. They are not allowed to go to England where they would get double the wages that they get here. Ten or 15 years ago the salaries of veterinary surgeons in the Department were so small that the men went to England where they could get double the salary. Immediately, the Government here increased the status generally of these men. Deputy Commons and other Deputies and I received a deputation of foresters and heard from them the conditions of employment. Their wages are not anything to boast about. They could be called good wages but they are not exceptionally good having regard to the importance of the work. Their service is not pensionable. If these men were established they would have pension rights and in the event of death their widow or dependents would receive a gratuity. At present they have good, constant employment but, as I have said, they are not pensionable. The Minister realises the importance of having a contented staff and I am sure that the men will give a good return for anything the Minister may do for them. I join with other Deputies and with Deputy Commons in making this appeal on behalf of these men who are doing splendid work for the nation.
Comment on this
I put down a question to-day to the Minister for Lands with regard to the workers in State Departments. I cannot understand why a State industry should limit the wages it pays to the wages paid by the ordinary farmer. The Government should depart from that low standard of wages and that must be done in this connection if we are to have forestry work undertaken. The people who plant the forests must get a living wage. Three pounds a week for forestry workers is not a living wage. If they were building houses they would have trade union rates of wages. The Minister should see to it that forestry workers are supplied with proper clothing, rubber boots and shelters. They are State employees. Other State employees are very well protected. They have trade union rates of wages. They are supplied with uniforms. In this great industry that we are discussing there is a sprinkle of men employed in County Wexford planting trees. I would like to see more men employed in the industry. It is no use sending down a man in charge with a few men. They could not plant the trees that we are talking about in a lifetime. I, as representing the working class, insist that the Government will have to do better than the Fianna Fáil Government with regard to the wages of these workers. The Minister has sympathy with the people in this industry, and I appeal to him to increase their wages to a point above the agricultural rates of wages. No Government should put the workers in their employment on the same level as farm workers who are employed by an individual farmer who has a few acres of land.
This State has money for everything except for the downtrodden, the worker. Previous Governments said 32/- a week was sufficient. The ex-Taoiseach, before the last general election, said 45/- was enough. I do not believe that to-day £3 a week is sufficient for these men. This is a very serious question. These men have to travel five and six miles. Some of them have not bicycles and have to walk. They are men with families who are faced with higher rents for agricultural cottages. There is no doubt that they will have to get an increase the same as other classes of workers. You will have no progress or contentment in rural Ireland until the State gets away from the idea of low wages, and I appeal to the Minister in all sincerity to look after that. The most important thing, as far as I am concerned, is to see that the workers get justice.
Comment on this
I must say that I have not much complaint to make as far as County Waterford is concerned. For many years past quite a number of estates have been taken over and forestry schemes have been developed on a pretty wide scale, to such an extent that I feel very keenly that the important thing is rather the interests of the workers themselves and I am very much in agreement with those who have appealed to the Minister to try to improve their condition. They are not even on the same footing as county council workers; they do not stamp unemployment insurance cards; unlike certain classes of road workers, they are not entitled to be included in any pension scheme; they have not the same facilities to get time off for holidays, and the Minister will remember that this question has been raised more than once in this House. Foresters deserve more than they are getting because a considerable amount of skill is required and because of the importance of forestry generally, and I think that something should be done for those who work in connection with the planting of trees.
Everybody in this House is impressed by the importance of the development of forestry and I was very interested to notice during some uncomplimentary remarks about the Irish Press that some people who support the Government quoted a recent article in the Irish Press.
Comment on this
I made a list of things for which forestry is useful and commercial purposes are of course the biggest, but another which is extremely important—and while I was in the House I heard no reference to it; maybe it was referred to before I came in— is defence. During the past war armies were very anxious to take advantage of any place where trees were planted along the roadside. That is of immense importance in modern warfare, because that is the only concealment that can be given to troops viewed from the air. Now that most roads are tarmacadam roads, trees do not do any harm. I do not, know whether this is a matter that should be raised on Defence or not, but ultimately the forestry people would be the people responsible for looking after the matter.
That brings me to the whole question of public opinion with reference to trees, because there is a terrible lack of publicity in this Department. They do not go out to try to fire the imagination of people all over the country for the planting of trees, whether along the roadside for defence purposes, shelter belts or for the purpose of helping drainage. The last is very important because if you can arrest water at the sources of rivers you can do a great deal to prevent the flooding of lands. There are lands in Cork along the borders of Kerry where, if trees were planted in quantity, they would hold back water and prevent a good deal of flooding and that must apply to other parts of the country as well. There is also the question of development in the West of Ireland of trees to prevent soil erosion. That problem is dealt with in France by first planting bent grass, then some other sort of bushes and the earliest trees and then the first rank of trees which later grow larger. The same system would require to be developed here but it would take a number of years. I do not think, in fact, that any of these schemes is going to solve the immediate problem of emigration because the number of people employed on such schemes at the beginning is small, but the present Estimate and the Minister's statement is not getting us on very far. Maybe the best he can do is to bring in a Supplementary Estimate, but it is obvious that the money in this Estimate is not sufficient to carry out a scheme of planting 25,000 acres.
Comment on this
It is not proposed to carry out a scheme of planting 25,000 acres because we will not have enough plants.
Comment on this
If the money is not your headache, you should indicate what price you are going to give for land. I do not say that you can give the same price for all land, but at present the average price is about £3 8s. 0d. Is that not right? If you take into consideration the changed value of money as compared to what it was; if you give a proportionate increase, say twice or three times as much; if you publish that and make it clear to the people all over the country that you are going to do that and do it quickly, you will soon find farmers coming along and making offers of land to you to help to increase the number of acres. You were able to plant 8,000 acres last year only because the ground was prepared for you by the previous Government.
Comment on this
We were all glad to give you a year's opportunity of finding your feet in the Department
Comment on this
We would probably have planted another 8,000 acres. There was an increase since the war was over and we did not promise 1,000,000 acres in five years. I hope that the Minister will not use his compulsory powers. There would be a danger when the trees were planted a little while of fires if you had not the goodwill of the people.
Comment on this
You can use compulsory powers when there is agreement of the majority of farmers or if the land is owned by absentees, but the Minister will find out, or his own sense will tell him, that he cannot use compulsory powers in other cases because he is always in a vulnerable position. The Minister has not told us how far he is increasing his acreage for nurseries. The present position is that there are about 300 acres for nurseries and it would be interesting to know if that is to be increased very largely.
Comment on this
Will this be done under the present Estimate, or are you bringing in a Supplementary Estimate for it?
Comment on this
There is an old saying to the effect that one should not bite off more than one can chew. It will come in its own good time.
Comment on this
It seems queer to bring in a main Estimate and not to deal in a complete way with the expense you anticipate. Supplementary Estimates are inevitable but they generally arise out of unexpected expenses occurring during the year.
Comment on this
No. They generally arise out of expenses that cannot be calculated when preparing the Estimate but which are quite foreseen. As an ex-Minister the Deputy should know that. I should not mind an awkward Deputy on your side of the House making that mistake but you know Cabinet procedure as well as I know it.
Comment on this
I think it would be unscrupulous on my part if I were to bring in an Estimate with the intention, at the back of my mind, of asking for more money that I expected to spend during the year——
Comment on this
I feel that the most damaging criticism is that the Minister is bringing in an Estimate with the promise of a Supplementary Estimate on which the main work of his Department is going to depend.
Comment on this
Practically every aspect of the work of the Forestry Department has been covered in this debate. I want to say that on the whole, while the speeches of some Deputies were a little critical in their nature, the Deputies were inclined to be helpful even if some did show a complete absence of knowledge of the work of the Forestry Department. Two issues were very prominent in this debate (1) that the Minister should have outlined his programme. I thought I did so, but as it would seem that I did not make myself clear to some people I shall go over that again.
The second issue was that a lot of Deputies, particularly on the opposition side of the House, seem to fear a clash between myself and the Minister for Agriculture on the question of suitable forestry ground. Forestry and agriculture need not clash, and will not clash for the reason that under the land reclamation scheme proposed by the Minister for Agriculture it is intended to reclaim land that is not arable at the present time but that, by reclamation, will become arable. Deputy Allen knows the type of land I refer to—the type of land he advised me to plant but the type of land I will refuse to plant during my time because, as it is, we have little enough arable land in this country for those who live by agriculture, despite the fact that Deputy Commons pointed out that the Governments of Norway and Sweden are thinking of introducing legislation to prevent their farmers from encroaching still further on their arable land. I believe there is enough waste land in this country to which it would not be wise for the Minister for Agriculture to apply his land reclamation scheme but which is, on the other hand, eminently suitable for the production of timber. That is the kind of land I am going after.
Comment on this
Yes, definitely. It has been said by somebody on the other side of the House that it takes good land to produce good timber.
Comment on this
Of course good land will produce good timber but that does not mean that good dry mountain land and good dry moorland will not also produce excellent timber, but perhaps of a different species. We know quite well that good upland will produce either good softwood or hardwood in most cases with the same readiness. It takes a good forestry expert to be able to determine what trees are most suitable to a particular place; he needs to have quite a good deal of experience in every type of land. I have the greatest respect for the forestry inspector. We have plenty of men who can go into a piece of very rough ground and determine, after a few experiments, what particular type of timber will flourish on that particular ground. We have men who can take a spade and tell you to a nicety what particular type of timber will flourish on that particular ground and what particular type of timber will not grow on it.
I want to take this opportunity of paying a very high tribute to our inspectorial staff who are out in the country and whose duty it is to determine whether land is suitable for forestry or not and, if it is, the type of timber that will grow on it. The best proof, even though the pace of the Forestry Department is slow, that the men are good at their work is that the percentage of failure is something as low as 3 per cent. That speaks volumes of credit for the inspectorial staff who have been very particular and who have thrown their heart and their experience into their work and who have been scrupulous and careful enough not to sink the taxpayers' money in planting land which was even doubtful. My one grouse in regard to the Forestry Department up to a short time ago was that they were too careful.
Comment on this
I have told them not to be so careful in the future—in other words, with perfect safety, seeing that they have had up to this such a very small percentage of failure, they can encroach a little bit more. Further, Deputies from every Party in this House, Opposition as well as Government, say that the Forestry Department in the past have condemned lands which later produced timber. Such is the case because more and more attention is being given to this matter, particularly in the United States and Canada, and in England, France, Poland, Germany, Norway, Sweden and Finland and experts are constantly carrying out experiments to see how exactly they can utilise more and more and more of what up to that, was described as unplantable land. We are reaping the benefit of their experience, their efforts and their experiments with the result that we also are able to encroach year after year on land that would definitely have been pronounced unplantable 25 years ago. With the knowledge available 20 years ago, they would probably have planted a species of tree or plant on a particular piece of ground which would have resulted in failure and that, perhaps, did happen and so scared them.
The land reclamation scheme, as outlined by the Minister for Agriculture, and which is going to come into operation on the 1st July next or thereabouts will not interfere with the land I need for forestry. I should not like to see any land, except the very barest minimum, planted which could be brought into cultivation and made to produce useful food crops for man and beast by the application of the land reclamation scheme under the direction of the Minister for Agriculture. The Minister for Agriculture will work up to a certain point; he will stop there and I will begin and go into the coarser land for forestry. As far as harmony between the two Departments is concerned, I would say that there have been quite a number of consultations and a number of points have been cleared up. Not alone has there not been a clash but there has been a perfect understanding between us in regard to the type of land we need for our respective schemes.
Several Deputies wanted to know what is going to happen next year and the year after. I think Deputy Allen insisted on saying that I said in my opening speech that we were going to put down 25,000 acres of forestry next year. I said no such thing. In any statement I have made in this House, either before I took office or since, I did not aim at misleading the House. If I made such a statement I should definitely be misleading the House and I did not make that statement. If Deputy Allen looks up the official report he will find that I did not do so.
Comment on this
I shall give the Deputy an outline of the difficulties, as he cannot have paid much attention to forestry up to this.
Comment on this
Hearing does not give you the necessary experience. At present we have 21,000 or 22,000 acres of plantable land on hands. I do not know the exact figure, but we have a pretty sizeable acreage of unplantable land which accumulated during the years and which could be described as barren mountain tops or sides that would not bear timber or which for other reasons is absolutely unplantable. A good deal of criticism has been levelled at me because only 3,000 acres were acquired last year. That means that there were only 3,000 acquired up to the end of the calendar year. Since the Government finally decided upon embarking on the 25,000 acres programme and since other steps were taken, the acreage coming in is very satisfying to me. It would be almost impossible to get 25,000 acres per year by ordinary methods. When we get going, unless some unforeseen snag occurs, I think we shall achieve 25,000 acres. That is a pretty big undertaking, as it works out at about 40 square miles of planting per year.
It is all very well for Deputy Moylan to cast slurs on Clann na Poblachta and other Parties who came in here with a large forestry programme. Perhaps they were wide of the mark; perhaps they were not. Whether they were or not, it is young Parties like the Party to which I belong and the Party to which Deputy Con Lehane belongs which have brought afforestation into the limelight and removed the cobwebs with which Fianna Fáil sought to cover it up. I do not know whether Clann na Poblachta mentioned 100,000 acres or whether any one spoke of 60,000 acres. It is better to say that than to have it dwindling down to a miserable 4,000 acres, which meant keeping an important Department of State smothered up and choked and not giving it the money or the assistance it should have. One thing at least has resulted from these two young Parties coming into the Dáil—there is a definite afforestation programme which both the Opposition and those on this side of the House can be proud of. I have no doubt that as it unfolds and develops the Opposition will be just as proud of it as we will be—at least the more manly spirits, because of course there will be a few carpers. Twenty-five thousand acres cannot be planted next year or the year after, as even if the Director of Forestry had 100,000 acres of land on hands next year or the year after, he can only plant as much as he has plants in the nursery to cover.
Deputy Moylan chided me for referring to the fact that the Minister for External Affairs had assisted me in getting seeds that we had failed to get through the ordinary channels. I think there is nothing wrong in paying a well-deserved tribute to a colleague. I would not have mentioned the matter again if it were not for the attitude adopted by Deputy Moylan. After we had scoured the world's markets, we were 2,000 lbs. of seeds short of the quantity necessary for the 25,000-acre programme. I mentioned the matter to the Minister for External Affairs and he said he would see what he could do. He asked me how much I was short and I told him I was 2,000 lbs. short. The result was that in a very short space of time he had secured 1,200 or 1,500 lbs., and I have no doubt that another 500 lbs. will come along. That meant the difference between 15,000 and 25,000 acres in three years. We had enough of seeds to plant about 15,000 acres in three years' time, after exhausting every known market for seeds. He has got us seeds which will plant 8,000 or 10,000 more acres. I felt very thankful to him, because he had got through diplomatic channels a certain quantity of seeds which we could not get, although we had got all we possibly could. That extra quantity was a very welcome gift to me and to the Department, which is anxious to get on with the programme as quickly as it can. In 1952, if we transplant all the plantable seedlings which are being sown, we shall be planting a year earlier than is expected, as the usual time is from three to three and a half years. We hope to plant 10,000 acres next year, provided we have got sufficient seedlings to plant. I might point out that a severe winter often-times thins out the number of plants. It kills off all but the hardiest plants and reduces the number available in the nurseries for the coming programme. Very often the acreage of a particular programme is affected by the weather in the previous winter.
Deputy Little wanted to know what nurseries we have. We have something over 300 acres of nurseries. That is adequate for the 10,000-acres programme. When the 25,000-acres programme is in full swing, about 740 acres of nurseries will be necessary. As Deputies know, it is only when the planting-out stage comes around that you want the extra land because eight or ten Irish acres will take all the seed necessary to cover a large area. One-third of the nursery ground has to be left fallow each year in order to enrich it. It is impossible to get all the farmyard manure or fertiliser necessary to keep the land in good heart, as the constant putting in and taking out of young trees robs even the richest land of its fertility. Therefore we have to allow it to recuperate by leaving it fallow. The usual thing is that one-third of the nursery is left fallow each year and you use the other two-thirds while the one-third is recuperating for the coming two or three years' period.
We cannot possibly reach the 25,000-acres programme until we have sufficient plants. That will take about three years from now. As Deputy Commons said, if we attain between 15,000 and 25,000 acres and keep at that steadily this will be a changed country in the space of 20 years. If this Government and succeeding Governments —if there is a change of Government in the next 20 years, which I do not believe there will be—can do that, we shall have a changed and improved country. We have set ourselves a target of 25,000 acres. Taking one year with another, that 25,000 acres may be reached one year and it may be down another year. You cannot just plant the exact amount each year. If you have land available, you use all the plants in the nursery. You cannot guarantee that you will carry out a definite programme to the last acre or the last ten acres. If you set yourself a target of 25,000 acres and come near it, you will be doing remarkably well.
I move to report progress.