Committee on Finance. - Vote 30—Agricultural Produce Subsidies (Resumed).
Contributions 164–323 of 323. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
——by cutting the Estimate? He cannot possibly do it. I hope that when the Minister is replying he will admit the necessity for and the wisdom of taking immediate steps to look after a market at an economic price for farmers' butter in this country.
Comment on this
I wish to raise a point of order. I made reference in this House to certain quotations from the Irish Independent of the 24th December, 1948, with regard to milk prices. The Minister said the quotation did not exist. I now have the quotation here and I can read it for the Minister.
Comment on this
The Minister tried to make a liar of me.
Comment on this
What the Deputy quoted is not in the Irish Independent of 24th December, 1948, 1848, 1748 or 1648.
Comment on this
In view of the remarks of Deputy Allen I, as a working man, wish to say that I would be very glad if the people in my constituency could get butter at 2/- a lb.
Comment on this
On this question of subsidy for farmers' butter I want to put to the Minister the unfair position the producers in my constituency are in. We have no creameries in my constituency. I am thinking, in particular, of the smaller farmers who carry on a system of mixed farming—a system of farming of which the Minister approves so much, and which he recommends. Their sales of butter are a very important part of their economy. Under the previous Government the subsidy for farmers' butter was paid for a long period. The farmers had no reason to complain at that time because the butter merchants bought the butter and they got the same price as the milk suppliers in the creamery areas. Last year when the present Minister decided to remove the subsidy on farmers' butter during the scarce period—and with the butter ration as it was then—the situation was not quite so bad because there was a market at the time for all the butter at a fairly good price. They could sell it because the supply did not exceed the demand. The position was not quite so bad up to recently, although the butter producers were very perturbed by the increase in the milk and butter in the summer months. However, when the Minister decided to increase the butter ration a few weeks ago that decision completely knocked the bottom out of the market.
Comment on this
It is the Minister's responsibility. It is not for me to suggest what the Minister should do. The increasing of the ration of butter has completely knocked the bottom out of the market for home-produced butter just at this particular time. Those producers are very perturbed about the position. They are very depressed and they cannot but remember what the conditions were in the past for people who kept cows, produced butter and carried on a system of mixed farming. The Minister should do something for these people now and they are entitled to it. They have to pay in taxation to subsidise the butter in the creamery areas. They have not creameries themselves. It is the duty of the Minister to pay attention to their case. The position of the home producers of butter is very much worse than the position of the milk producers in the creamery areas.
During the course of the debate the Minister denied that he made a promise to a deputation from the creamery areas. I went to the Library and I looked up the Irish Independent of the 24th December, 1948, in which I found the quotation. The heading is: “The Minister will reconsider milk prices”.
Comment on this
The Minister met a deputation at that time from the creamery areas. They asked for an increase in the price of their milk. First of all, the Minister told them he would not increase the price. Then, apparently, they made such a convincing case that he promised he would reconsider the matter.
Comment on this
It is as follows:—
"Though he had stated he would not increase the present price for milk, added Mr. Dillon, he would now, having regard to the case made by the deputation, reopen the whole question. He was sure that any recommendation he made would be favourably considered by the Government."
Comment on this
The subsidy affects farmers' butter. My point is that this deputation from the creamery area——
Comment on this
I am referring to farmers' butter now. What I want to bring out is that the Minister was convinced by this deputation from the creamery areas that something should be done for the butter that was already subsidised—that he was convinced to that extent—although he did not carry out his undertaking.
Comment on this
The Minister did not reopen the case. The Minister practically indicated in that interview that he was convinced that the price of milk should be increased——
Comment on this
Take a running jump at yourself.
Comment on this
He led the milk suppliers from the creamery areas to believe that they had a good case and that when he would go to the Government to put that case before them he was sure he would convince them that an increase was due. Apparently the Minister was not able to convince the Government that an increase was due to the milk suppliers in the creamery areas. When such a case can be made for the milk suppliers in the creamery areas who were already subsidised, I believe there is a convincing case there to give a subsidy to the farm butter producers in the non-creamery areas.
Comment on this
Is there anything wrong, if a group of respectable men come into a Minister of State in this country and make their case to the best of their ability, in the Minister's saying frankly to them while they are in the room: "My mind was made up that there was no case for an increase in the price of milk. I have listened carefully to all you have had to say. You have made a very strong case, and certainly the strength of the case you have made imposes on me the obligation to reopen the whole of this question and to study it afresh to see if I overlooked any relevant consideration when I was making up my mind"? Is there anything underhand or mean or deceptive in that? As certain as I am standing in this House that is precisely what happened. When that deputation left me, a conference was held in my Department with all the officers connected with milk and butter production present; the whole ground of the costings of milk and butter production was traversed. The costings which I have here in my portfolio, which were lent to me by two different parties in the country, which were prepared by Dr. Murphy of Cork University at the instance, not of the Department, but of the milk producers, were carefully examined and, as a result of that careful re-examination ab initio, I recommended to the Government that there should be no increase in the price of milk.
Comment on this
Let there be no attempt made by any Deputy on the Opposition Benches to mislead our people into believing that any influence was brought to bear on this matter except the consideration of equity and justice to the producers of milk. Let no Deputy on the Opposition Benches seek to deceive the people down the country that the Government overrode the claim of the Minister for Agriculture. The fact is that my recommendation to the Government was that there should be no increase in the price of milk and, if there is any blame due for that decision, it should all fall on me. I consider that was the right decision. I consider any other decision would have been irresponsible and wrong, and anybody in this country, who conceives that decision to have been wrong should direct his censure against me as well as against the Government to which I have the honour to belong.
Comment on this
I thought it was only when we were trying to discuss milk prices that that was the situation.
Comment on this
Not so much of the unqualified business about it. I was trying to do what the Minister is doing and I was pulled up a thousand times.
Comment on this
The Deputy will leave the House because what I am stating is a fact.
Deputy Smith withdrew.
Comment on this
Deputy Harris says Kildare has no creamery and he then says that a great many of his constituents make farmers' butter, and asks what am I going to do about it. While Deputy Harris was speaking, I asked him to give me the benefit of his advice as to whether he, with his special local knowledge of Kildare, could offer me any suggestions calculated to help in the solution of the problem he knows to exist in that county. Deputy Harris's reply to me——
Comment on this
I do not give way to Deputy Harris. I asked the Deputy for the benefit of his advice and he had none to give me. He did seem to find fault with the decision to release for consumption the creamery butter that is available. He seemed to tell the House that the special problem arising in Kildare was in no small measure due to the release for consumption by the people of Newbridge and Kildare and the other towns in that county of the creamery butter which is available.
Comment on this
Is this a point of order? If it is, then I give way. If it is not, I will not give way. Is it a point of order?
Comment on this
I have no idea. Owing to the voices I could not possibly hear what the Deputy was saying. I will not be shouted down.
Comment on this
I have no control over what interpretation the Minister applies to the Deputy's statement so long as he does not purport to quote it.
Comment on this
Am I right in saying that Deputy Harris attributed in no small measure the difficulty in Kildare to the fact that I did increase the ration of creamery butter available to the people of the towns of Kildare and Newbridge from 6 to 8 ounces? I ask Deputy Harris to help by telling me would he recommend that I should cut down their ration. Would it help in Kildare if I direct that there should be a reduced ration of butter? Deputy Allen is telling him to get up and kick up a row. Stand up like a man and do not be snivelling behind your hands.
Comment on this
You need not tell us what a man is, at all.
Comment on this
No. You have had long enough. Deputy Harris will not tell me am I to remedy the position in County Kildare by cutting down the ration of butter there. When I asked him that, he said that "the remedy is that I cannot say yes and I cannot say no".
Comment on this
I welcome the intervention of any Deputy who will join his effort to mine to resolve the problems of Deputy Harris's neighbours. But I have nothing but contempt for a Deputy who uses the difficulties of his neighbours for the base and contemptible purpose of trying to gather together votes for himself.
Comment on this
I am ready and willing to examine carefully and with goodwill any proposal from any Deputy in this House to relieve any difficulty into which his neighbours appear to have got and which he, in his special knowledge of his own district, could report to me; but I have nothing but contempt for those who trot in here waiting for whispered inspiration from mouths that fear to face the public, but whisper behind hands as to what they ought to say and ought not to say in order to make trouble and to make confusion worse confounded. Imagine the impudence of Deputy Allen——
Comment on this
——trotting in here to tell me there is a problem in County Wexford. Who made the problem? Who shut down the Shelbourne Co-operative Creamery? Was it not the Deputy's own friends on the committee of that society who had a fine creamery in South Wexford and, because they wanted to turn it into a retail shop and butchery and 101 other trades except the one trade they were set up to do, who closed down the creamery?
Comment on this
Is it in order for a Miniister of State in this country to attack people who are not represented in this House—a co-operative society who——
Comment on this
I want to ask is it in order for a Minister of State in this House deliberately to make a charge that is absolutely false?
Comment on this
Is it in order for a Minister of State to charge a trading society in this country with something that is absolutely false?
Comment on this
It is not a point of order. It is a question of fact which I cannot decide between the Minister and the Deputy.
Comment on this
Is it a fact that there is in South Wexford at this moment one of the wealthiest co-operative societies in——
Comment on this
They do not like this. I air charged with being indifferent to the interests of the milk producers in South Wexford. I am charged with that because the milk producers of South Wexford are under an obligation at present to convert their surplus milk into home-made butter. I am charged by the man who represents Wexford and who is as thick as thieves with every member of the committee. Why is it that the wealthiest co-operative in Ireland, in the middle of this area where Deputy Allen said there is a problem, closed their creamery and left the people of Wexford without a means of turning their surplus milk into creamery butter? If that co-operative wants to open its creamery to-morrow it need not wait. It has a licence now to do it and I will post it to them to-morrow morning. If that co-operative wants facilities from me to collect the milk of that county any help I can give them I will give them. But it is a bit thick that the representative of that co-operative society came into this House, stood idly by while the means of disposing of his neighbours' milk was done away with under his own nose because they could not get enough profit out of them, a society devoted to trading operations for which there was abundant accommodation elsewhere. I am then told that the people of Wexford are cruelly put upon.
Comment on this
Put to work to-morrow the creamery that the society was first set up to work. Put into the service of the people for whom that society was originally established the facilities that that society with its immense wealth could perfectly easily make available to them and every problem of every farmer to whom the Deputy has been referring will be resolved in 48 hours.
Comment on this
——to listen to Deputy Allen who is in a position to guide and direct the activities of that society, coming here and upbraiding me——
Comment on this
——for the brutal indifference with which he and his like have stood by and watched their friends and political confederates wipe out of existence a creamery in that part of Wexford which could and should meet the problem of the vast majority of the people on behalf of whom he purports to speak. Some people have faces of brass but Deputy Allen's countenance must be molybdenum— indestructible molybdenum. Deputy O'Grady speaks for Clare. He speaks for a group of farmers. He has gone away now. I think he was wise to go away. In Clare he says they have no creamery and then he mentions three of the best creameries in Ireland —one, two and three in the County Clare. But he did not seem to know that his own constituents in North Clare bought 50 new milk cans within the last month. He does not seem to know that the Clare creameries are not only prepared to collect the milk in County Clare but are going up into South Galway.
I do not deny that on occasions I grow a little impatient. The Lord was not extravagant with the gift of patience when he fashioned my unworthy frame, but the burden of work and anxieties of the Department of Agriculture are heavy enough without having to face in this House vicious, malignant, irresponsible, aimless obstruction. All this day we have been trying to find a market for home-made butter. There is a mission going abroad to-morrow to seek another market, so that I shall now be faced with this when it appears in the Dublin papers that the boys here spent the whole day in Dáil Éireann trampling the farmers' butter around the floor of Dáil Éireann as unsaleable rubbish. I have got to go in now and meet the man who wants to buy it and try to persuade him that he ought to pay me a price for it that will enable me to pay the farmers 2/- a lb. or more at a time when he is fixed with notice that everyone in this House says the stuff is unsaleable. I have got to send a mission abroad to-morrow morning to try and fight for a price for this, but the man that I am going to meet, or that my officers are going to meet, is fixed with the notice that every opposition Deputy in the House rushed in here to blurt out that "the whole country is smothered with butter and that if you do not sell it you will be eaten alive." For irresponsible folly and mischief recommend me to the Deputies of Fianna Fáil. They are like a whole lot of juvenile delinquents.
Comment on this
Upon my word, if there was a Marlboro' House in which one could put them on remand for a fortnight until the business of my Department was disposed of, it would be a blessing for the unfortunate men and women of this country whose interests they dare to treat as a plaything.
Comment on this
I think the Lord must have given me a greater measure of patience than I thought I had. The picture of Deputy Brady preaching law and order makes me weep. I said that Deputy Ó Briain took a canter. The last time he took a canter he cantered back with material for Deputy Ryan and was told to take it back whence he had brought it.
Comment on this
Now he canters out to get a bit of material for himself, and he was prepared to paraphrase it. He was prepared to give us the benefit of what his memory of a memory of it was, but the diffident creature would not read it. Poor, simple Deputy Harris darted out the other door, brought it in and read it and ruined poor Deputy Ó Briain.
Comment on this
I have answered explicitly Deputy Harris's inquiry as to what transpired at the deputation. I think Deputy Ó Briain was cantering when I dealt with his quotation which was read by Deputy Harris—poor innocent boy. Deputy Ó Briain took the precaution of bracing himself with a note written in a clerkly hand for fear he would lose his head when he got up to speak here and would not ask the right question. I congratulate him on being the only coherent member of his Party who spoke on this matter, and the reason for that was that he retired into a corner and painfully wrote down the question——
Comment on this
——so as not to ask me an irrelevant question as the rest of them have been doing in the last two hours. The question was this: "The appropriation in the Estimates for money to pay a subsidy on creamery butter appears to be related at present rates to a production of 575,000 cwts. If, as the Minister says, there is likely to be a production of 650,000 cwts., are we to infer, from the failure of the Minister for Finance to appropriate a larger sum, that if an increase of butter materialises the subsidy will dwindle with a consequent decline in the price of milk?" Now, I think Deputy Ó Briain made a most dreadful mistake, because, you see, when the Deputy put his head together with the rest of the boys, they formulated that question. They are old dogs for the hard road and they intended to ask that question sotto voce like Deputy Blaney's question on oats-all over the place—and like Deputy Davern's observations at the Fianna Fáil Cumann.
Comment on this
In that case, Charles Stewart Parnell O'Donnell blew the gaff on them; in this case, Deputy Ó Briain blew the gaff on the boys by asking the question where it could be answered, and that is madness. If you want to start a rumour never start it where it can be answered; always give it a week's start and, if possible, under the rose, and then, whether it is true or false, there will always be a few fools to be found to believe it. Fortunately, I can answer Deputy Ó Briain. I know it will comfort his soul to hear that there will be no alteration in the price of milk, good, bad or indifferent——
Comment on this
——and that whatever measures are necessary to maintain the price at precisely the same level at which it stands now, and is scheduled to stand next winter, will be taken if and when the necessity arises. Does the dullest Deputy in Fianna Fáil detect any ambiguity in that statement?
Comment on this
If so, let him stand up, or they can all stand up together if there is no difference between them. Deputy Smith had something to contribute to this discussion. He said that his subsidy scheme for farmers' butter may not have been perfect but that it was clear evidence of his desire to help. I would like to comment on that by saying that his observation, that his scheme may not have been perfect, was, I understand, described by the Greeks as meiosis. Any scheme which, at the end of 12 months, leaves your successor with 2,000 cwts. of butter surrounded by a cordon sanitaire at the port of Dublin, and which requires almost the fire brigade in gas masks to get it on board ship for export to a processing factory, is scarcely one which can aptly be described as “perhaps not perfect,” and not assumed to have reached the stage where Deputy Smith would describe it as having failed. The butter would blow the roof off the cold store.
Comment on this
I want to make this clear to the House. The fundamental fault with the whole effort to subsidise butter is this. We estimate—but it is only a very rough guess—that there are produced every year 400,000 cwts. of butter. I want the House to understand this clearly, that in our experience in the Department, of the 400,000 cwts. we have reason to believe that 350,000 cwts. are first-class butter, excellent butter. But all the good butter is either consumed in the home of the woman who makes it or her neighbours know her reputation as a first-class butter maker and before she starts making the butter she will have three or four neighbours at the house asking her to keep it for them. Alternatively, in the market town where that woman goes she deals in a shop and she will be well known in that shop as a woman who makes lovely butter and the shopkeeper will buy it for his own house.
It is true that in the city you find a great many people who do not like farmers' butter. I venture to say that most of us who live in rural Ireland, if we get good farmers' butter, find it very much more attractive than creamery butter. Whenever I was told in Ballaghaderreen that there were two or three women coming into the town who made good butter, there would be an understanding between us that whenever they would have any to spare they would leave it to me. I like home-made butter, when it is good home-made butter. On the other hand, there are two or three very decent, respectable women, but when I would see them arriving with butter-muslin hanging out of their baskets I would fly for my life, because they are not good butter makers and they would be affronted if I did not buy the butter when they were polite enough to bring it to me. But I could not live in the house with that butter, never mind eating it.
I am trying to make this case to the House, that of all the farmers' butter made in this country, more than ninetenths would be excellent butter; but there is a small minority of women who do not know how to make butter of the highest quality. The operation of price deters them from making it and when there is a creamery at hand, when they find their butter does not command a ready sale, they send the milk to the creamery. If you come along and pay a subsidy on farmers' butter, all the good butter will remain as it was, selling to the people who ordinarily buy it, but the woman who brings in her few lb. of butter—butter which may not be of first-class quality—will dump it in at the guaranteed price and she has got to get it. Once you guarantee a price for farmers' butter, what happens in effect is that all the good farmers' butter will continue to go to the people who always bought it and all the bad farmers' butter will be brought in to benefit by the subsidy and the end of it is that you get, on the completion of the season, a residue of butter which deteriorates, because nobody will take it, to the condition in which I found the 2,000 cwts. at the cold store.
It would be a thousand times better if the women who do not make that quality of butter which commands a ready sale in their own neighbourhood, would send their milk to the creamery. Where there is a large surplus of milk and no available creamery, the Irish Agricultural Organisation Society is over in Plunkett House for no other purpose than to put their services at the disposal of any responsible person in the neighbourhood to help in organising a co-operative society to make butter, cheese, dried milk or any product which would be readily saleable out of whatever milk may be available in the neighbourhood.
Clare, for instance, used to be a problem county. There was a lot of milk in Clare for which there was no outlet except home-made butter. What did we do? It amazes me that Deputy O'Grady should be under any misapprehension about this matter. Are there not three fine creameries in Clare with travelling creameries attached? Does Deputy O'Grady know of any area in County Clare where there are women anxious to sell milk but who can make no contact with the creamery? If he does, why not let me know?
Comment on this
The Dairy Disposals Company is organising creameries in County Clare, as far as I know. They have no other purpose than to serve any area where there is milk available in quantity sufficient to justify putting a travelling creamery on the road, which will go to the farmers and not ask the farmers to travel to them. Nor is the difficulty insurmountable if the quantity of milk in a given area would be an uneconomic proposition for a creamery, because we would be glad and happy to help in building up the milk supply of that area a little higher than it now is to a point that would justify the economic operation of a creamery. And we need not wait until the milk supply is there, if we think there is a sure prospect of delivery later.
Why does every Deputy on the opposite benches imagine that the Minister for Agriculture and the Dairy Disposals Company and all these charged with service to our people would wish to be in a kind of diabolical conspiracy to visit hardship and misfortune on the people we are paid to serve? Why should Deputies, unless the whole of these proceedings are fraudulent, imagine that I, working as the Minister for Agriculture, should deliberately ignore the interests of hardworking farmers, when it is just as handy for me to do that work as any other work I do? I do not spend much time sitting in the Department twiddling my thumbs and it is just as easy for me to bend my mind to covering an area where dairy farmers have not got facilities as it is for any other job that turns up. Where is the Deputy on the other side of the House who has ever approached the Dairy Disposals Company, or any officer of my Department, or myself with any legitimate representation on behalf of an area in his constituency, or outside it, who has not been courteously received? I do not think there is a Deputy in those benches, despite all the abuse that is poured out, who can say that he ever approached me personally, or any officer of my Department or any member of the Dairy Disposals Company with representations for relief or assistance required in any part of the country for which he was entitled to speak that he was not politely and civilly received and a genuine effort made to do whatever could be done to meet the problem he described. There is a problem. Why will not the Deputies on the Opposition Benches, instead of screaming imprecations at me across the floor of the House, peacefully come and, if they have any delicacy in coming to see me though I am at the disposal of everybody, see the officers of my Department and discuss with them their problems?
Comment on this
What does Deputy Allen say? Deputy Allen is not backward in coming to see me himself. He has a duty. He is under no obligation to me. I am paid to serve.
Comment on this
To see that the people have a market for their butter. Your job is to solve the problem. That is what you are there for.
Comment on this
That does not help one bit. Deputy Allen knows perfectly well when there was a problem in some of the east coast districts relating to the farmers there he was not behindhand in coming to me himself. Subsequently he came with a deputation. Let me say at once, to Deputy Allen's credit on that occasion, that when he asked me to help to solve the problem, I asked his help as chairman of the county committee to do what he could do, and I did what I could do. It ill becomes Deputies, if they share my anxiety for these problems, to make them the subject of gravely injurious discussion in this House in an atmosphere of acrimony and futility, shouting across the floor of the House that it is my problem and that it is for me to solve it. They need not worry. What I can do will be done. It may well be, however, that they can help as well.
I see no reason why, if Deputy Harris has the kind of problem of which he speaks in County Kildare, he would not consult with the Irish Agricultural Organisation Society, to organise a co-operative marketing system for this season; because for the people who have butter now and who are producing butter the problem is a problem of the present and no long-term solution will relieve them of their difficulty. I think many Deputies who are familiar with conditions in the cities and the towns will tell you that they find it very hard to get good farmers' butter. They find it difficult to get good farmers' butter in Dublin. There is a demand. In Kildare there is a supply. Surely it should be possible to get in the centre of that area of supply some kind of co-operative to sell that butter. Surely it should be possible to hire a chap with a van who would go round and collect orders from hotels, boarding houses or suburban shops two or three times a week and who on Monday would collect the butter and deliver it in Dublin and collect the cash every Saturday, or make any other arrangement suitable. Does any rational Deputy on the far side of the House doubt that that would help to solve the circumscribed problem with which Deputy Harris is faced? That kind of activity, locally and by the people themselves, with the help of those who are able to call to their aid the assistance that is available, if it is only called upon, will solve the immediate problem of the kind which farmers' butter does constitute.
Deputy Smith says that he feels it is the Government's duty to set up an independent tribunal to assess the cost of production. I think it is just to say that Professor Murphy was, in the main, such a tribunal. He was asked by the farmers producing milk for Mitchelstown creamery and by the farmers producing milk for the Cork milk supply area to go into these two areas and determine scientifically and with complete detachment the cost of production in both of them, and to report objectively to the farmers who employed him. Professor Murphy did that. I want to put it to those who requested Dr. Murphy to undertake these investigations: Will they publish his findings? I do not want their version of his findings. Will they publish verbatim the report he made to them? Unlike the Beet Growers' Association, who publish what they call accounts but which I do not call accounts——
Comment on this
They are not accounts, Deputy. I propose to explain on another occasion what accounts are and what they are not.
Comment on this
If those reports are published I think Deputy Smith will discover that just such an independent tribunal as he considers necessary has already functioned and the facts are there. I did not pay for them. I did not commission them. I have no right to use them. The farmers of those two areas paid for them and they commissioned them and they have a right to use them. I refer Deputy Smith to the farmers who did appoint such a tribunal and I invite him to ask them to publish its findings. I know that there are people who make farmers' butter who will be disappointed and very naturally upset at failing to get a good price for what they produce. Probably it would be popular if I asked the House to appropriate a large sum of public money in order to bestow largesse upon these people. It would not cost me anything. But it would be wrong and I am not going to do it. The honest advice to people is the advice I have given. In those areas where there is an unanticipated surplus of this butter what co-operative marketing can do to relieve the problem should be done. Where there is an alternative for any farmer's wife making butter for sale of sending her milk to a co-operative creamery, I advise her to send her milk to the co-operative creamery. Now, mark the words: "For sale on the public market." If she has neighbours who habitually take it from her then, of course, she has no problem. If she can use it in her own house she has, of course, no problem, but if she wants to dispose of it for cash my advice is to sell it to the creamery, if one is available in that area. If there is an area where creamery facilities are not adequate, but which adjoins an area where they are, if any Deputy will inform me of it I shall gladly consult with him as to whether we could not extend the collection area of the creamery so as to cover the area which is at present not catered for.
Every confectioner in this country who uses farmers' butter as shortening for his industrial processes can help. I am at present discussing with two potential purchasers the sale of bulk quantities of this product, but the price, to my way of thinking, is not right. If I refuse to accept 1/8 per lb. for Irish farmers' butter I hope I shall not be told afterwards that I have acted petulantly, precipitately and irresponsibly—or will I? This set look dumb now, but will they start yelling their heads off later if I cannot get a price which will enable the woman who makes butter to receive 2/- a lb? —and I do not value that price; I think 2/- a lb. is a wretched reward for home-made butter. I would far sooner see it bought and consumed by our own people. I would far sooner see the poor of Dublin, Cork and Limerick buying it and feeding it to their own children than ship it out of the country to foreign purchasers and allow them to benefit by the advantages of so low a price. I know a popular thing would be to land it up and say that nobody in the world produces better butter, but it would be wrong to do that. Remember, first, that home-made butter for sale on the bulk market is no longer an economic proposition. It may be of excellent quality. Irish frieze for overcoating is everlasting and excellent but it has gone out of fashion. You cannot get people to buy it the way they used to buy it. Home-made yarn for knitting socks, brown and white, will make better socks than any other yarn but it has gone out of fashion.
Comment on this
I am drawing the analogy that the quality of the thing does not secure for it a just reward on the commercial market.
Comment on this
Just as these things, to which I have referred, are of superlative quality but have lost their market because people have gone out of the habit of using them, so farmers' butter, even with its fine quality, never mind its secondary quality, has just gone out of fashion. People have got so accustomed to the bland, imperceptible flavour of creamery butter that they will not readily take to the comparatively strong flavour of well-made farmers' butter. There is nothing I can do, nothing any Minister for Agriculture in the world can do, to bring back into ready marketability, farmers' butter because all the world has changed and it will not change back.
Therefore, I want to say to Deputies on the far side, if, instead of making mischief, instead of coming here to complicate an already complex situation, instead of readily, and to my mind, shamefully, misleading their own neighbours—a vicious, mean thing to do—into the belief that if only people wanted to try, a good market could be found for this produce, they would collaborate with me in explaining to their neighbours that the product they had to offer, excellent in quality though it may be, was no longer readily saleable in the commercial markets of the world, and that if butter is to be made for general sale, it must be of the bland, creamery type which the bulk of urban purchasers now demand, we would very quickly solve that problem. But if everybody is to do what Deputy Allen and his friends do—jettison their responsibilities, close down the creamery, glory in their profits and repudiate any obligation to discharge a public duty to those whom they are supposed to serve as Campile appears to have done——
Comment on this
On a point of order, is the Minister in order in viciously slandering a trading concern of this country in this House?
Comment on this
The Ceann Comhairle has already told the House that these are matters of fact which the Chair cannot decide as between the Deputy and the Minister.
Comment on this
I shall not give way. This society is wealthy and powerful with abundant resources and for many years operated a creamery and two subsidiaries in the very area where Deputy Allen proclaims an emergency now.
Comment on this
Is it fair, is it just for a Deputy who is hand in glove with the management of that co-operative society to come in——
Comment on this
To run away from one's duty and come here clamouring for other people to carry the burden one has undertaken to carry oneself—I say that if no one is prepared to give better co-operation than that we will have to get on without them; it will not be the first time we have got on without them and doubtless it will not be the last. But I cannot believe that every member of Fianna Fáil has sunk so low as to use his neighbour's embarrassment for his own electoral advantage and to those Deputies of the Fianna Fáil Party who want to help I say I am at their service if they care to see me. If they have the slightest compunction, then I urge them not to hesitate to approach the officers of my Department and with our combined efforts we may be able to help some who would otherwise be disappointed. But, taking the long view, for public sale I cannot commend the production of farmers' butter as a profitable occupation and, taking the long view, I urge on those who have not a sale for it in their own locality among their own neighbours, as so many people in Wexford used to have, that they should take steps to have it converted through a co-operative agency into dried milk of one kind or another, cheese or creamery butter in which event the kind of problem that troubles us to-day is unlikely to arise again.
Comment on this
Question put.
Do you agree with this result?