Committee on Finance. - Vote 68—Health (Resumed).
Contributions 127–274 of 274. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
It does in this way, that the journal did enshrine one dictum of Dr. Noel Browne of Newcastle Sanatorium—it alleged that the Fianna Fáil Government had a purely materialistic attitude towards a number of questions. Some years ago the Government of the day, anxious to commemorate the sacrifice of those who had died here in Dublin during the War of Independence, secured from the trustees of the Rotunda Gardens the grant of a very valuable site upon which it was proposed to erect—and upon which there would be standing to-day if the war had not intervened— a memorial to commemorate those who died so heroically during that struggle.
Nobody, I think, will contest that the site was other than appropriate and fitting. In the grounds of the Rotunda on the Saturday of Easter Week some of our noblest patriots, Tom Clarke among others, were condemned to spend a night. The Rotunda itself, apart from the hospital, is associated with two historic events, the foundation of the Irish Volunteers under Grattan and the foundation of the Irish Volunteers of 1914. The place itself is surrounded by Parnell Square. It stands upon one of the main thoroughfares and this proposed site confronts Charlemont House, a name which is not unknown in Irish history. In the whole City of Dublin I doubt if there could be chosen a more appropriate site for a memorial such as that which was contemplated. It is a site in our main thoroughfare where strangers coming to this city would see that we are proud of our dead and that, if we had allowed Nelson's Pillar to remain as a reminder of the days that were gone, as a trophy, if you like, of victory, that it was not because we wished to do Nelson honour, but——
Comment on this
On a point of order. What has this to do with the Estimate, unless Nelson died of tuberculosis?
Comment on this
I am coming to it. We did not honour Nelson. We allowed him to remain there, as I have said, to remind our people of what they had suffered and what they had overcome.
Comment on this
I want to emphasise the fact that Nelson being there as a reminder of what he stood for has nothing whatever to do with this Estimate for Public Health.
Comment on this
I will speak about the diversion by this Minister of the site which was intended to honour those who died for Ireland during our war of independence, for this was the purpose for which it was acquired by the Government.
Comment on this
Quite! But I would say that any stranger listening to the debate for the last ten minutes would not have the remotest idea that this was a debate on health. He would not have the remotest idea.
Comment on this
There should be no "hear, hear" when it is a question of dishonouring our gallant dead.
Comment on this
It is too embarrassing to the Clann. What will happen to this site which was acquired for that specific purpose? The Minister for Health has collared it. I know, of course, the sentimental eye-wash that will be dished out by those who say that the health of the children is more important than the honouring of our dead. I know the sort of bleating we shall have from Deputy Lehane and some others about the plight of the poor. Will anyone tell me that in the whole of the north city there was no other site to be had for the establishment of this health clinic except the site that had been given and was intended for the erection of a memorial to the men who died during the Black and Tan war? In the whole of the north city of Dublin no other site would satisfy the present Minister for Health except this site which had been dedicated to that holy purpose.
Comment on this
I do not want to interrupt the Deputy, but if the Deputy had been attending to his business as a representative of his constituents he would know the decision is a purely temporary one.
Comment on this
I said that I was going to deal with Deputy Lehane in due course. What I had in mind was the fact that Deputy Lehane put down a question to-day which was intended to get the Minister out of his difficulty. The question was raised here on another occasion. The ventilation of this matter in this House had its public repercussions. The feelings and conscience of those who had been members of the I.R.A. were shocked. They could not believe that a Party which had described itself as an extreme Republican Party would permit one of its members to do this thing. We know that the Minister's action in this regard has been a matter of grave and serious embarrassment to the Deputies of the Clann na Poblachta Party for the City of Dublin. We know that it has been a cause of disaffection among their rank and file. Therefore some way of palliating the outrage, some way of appeasing the Old Comrades' Association, the associations of ex-I.R.A. men and members of the Clann na Poblachta organisation had to be found. So Deputy Lehane put down a question of which he apparently thought Deputy MacEntee had not taken notice. Deputy Lehane put down a question, and the sole purpose of putting down that question was to try to soothe the disturbed rank and file by pretending that this erection would only be a temporary one. It would only be a temporary erection! This site was only to be disfigured by an unsightly temporary building.
Was there no other place to erect a temporary building except in the Rotunda Gardens on the site of the proposed memorial to honour those who died during the Black and Tan war? Could we not have found some other place to erect a temporary building elsewhere than on that particular spot? When this matter was first raised and ventilated there was no question that the building to be erected would be a temporary one. There was no question at all. It was going to stand on that site as a permanent memorial to the present Minister for Health. It may be, of course, that the Minister has a congenital repugnance to any reminder of the struggle for independence. It may be that he does not like the idea of memorials being erected to those who died fighting the Black and Tans. He does not, apparently, take the same objection to memorials in relation to the civil war. He is, as a matter of fact, a member of a Government which proposes to give precedence to memorials to those who died during the civil war. I do not want to impugn their memory in any way.
Comment on this
But the men for whom this memorial was to be erected died before the civil war. Why is it that, unless it is that this idea of a memorial was so obnoxious to the Minister for Health, nothing would do him but to grab that site and erect thereon a building which, if it would not prevent for ever the erection of the intended memorial, would at least defer it for a considerable number of years —perhaps until the comrades of the men who died during the Black and Tan war had gone to their graves? There is no justification whatever for what the Minister has done in regard to this matter. The City of Dublin is not so poor in sites that some other site than this could not have been secured for the health clinic.
Comment on this
I strongly advocate the provision of such clinics. If the White Paper dealing with health services, which was circulated during the year 1947, is referred to it will be seen that this was one of the things we had in contemplation. During the war years we tried to secure the equipment for clinics of this kind. Fianna Fáil, therefore, does not object to the provision of a health clinic for children. On the contrary, it strongly supports it. But we do certainly object to the erection of that clinic being used to prevent and defer the erection, as I have said, of a memorial to those who died fighting the Black and Tans.
Comment on this
During the last year, the then Leader of the Minister's Party said that we were providing money for hotels and not for hospitals. The Minister according to his own admission has at present cut down on hospitals. The justification, of course, is that he has not the money. Can one imagine what the Minister would write in The Clann, if by a miracle it were still in existence, if Fianna Fáil pleaded that it could not proceed with the hospitalisation of the country because it had not got the money? I suppose we would be told that we had watched “with bucolic indifference the slow rot and death of approximately so and so.” We would be told that we had said that luxury hotels were not suitable for the treatment of tuberculosis. We would be told that nearly three years ago a White Paper was published full of grandiose promises, etc. We would be told all that. An additional 18 months have passed since that article was written but nobody will see, I think, in this country improved dispensaries, thousands of beds, chest hospitals and allowances for dependents, except such allowances for dependents as were provided before the Minister took office under the Public Health Act of 1947, which was so bitterly opposed by the chief Party in the present Coalition.
The Minister says he has not the money. Well there was quite a substantial sum of money in the Hospitals' Trust Fund when I was in control of it. There was quite a substantial sum of money in the Hospitals' Trust Fund when Deputy Dr. Ryan was in control of it. The yield from the sweepstakes has considerably increased since and there should be a great deal more money in the Hospitals' Trust Fund now than there was when Fianna Fáil left office. We had proposals to spend that money and those proposals were cut in half by the Minister in his first pronouncement. Now, I believe they have been further slashed and we are still without the thousands of beds for tubercular patients, still without the chest hospitals, without the children's hospital at Crumlin, without the Limerick Regional Hospital, the Galway Regional Hospital, the hospital at Ballinasloe and the new County Hospital at Manorhamilton. This Minister of "push and go" may certainly have a great deal of push about him, and, when the country gets the chance, perhaps there will be a great deal of "go" about him too.
Comment on this
But still we have not got the hospitals, though he has tons of money. When he was a mere political neophyte cutting his teeth, writing articles in The Clann, he told us that the money did not matter, that he had a simple solution for it, that all they had got to do was to break the link with sterling and to print all the money they needed.
Comment on this
Now we have it from Deputy Lehane that he is going to build hospitals by printing money— paper hospitals built with paper money.
Comment on this
There we are, plenty of money and no hospitals. If, let me repeat again, the Minister for Health controls all the money in the Hospitals' Trust Fund, it might not be any harm at this stage for Deputies to ask themselves how does this Minister control and use the money in the Hospitals' Trust Fund, which he will not spend except in a very limited and restricted way, to provide the hospitals which he held were in such urgent need 18 months ago.
Last night in this House a case was mentioned which, I think, throws a searchlight on the Minister's control of this Hospitals' Trust Fund. It is a case, I think, which warrants more attention than has, as yet, been devoted to it, in fact it warrants the fullest possible inquiry and I will tell the House why.
The present Minister for Health was formerly attached to the Newcastle Sanatorium. All of us who are familiar with the conditions there, who had, by reason of our position, an opportunity of becoming familiar with these conditions, know very well that the accommodation for the staff and patients in Newcastle Sanatorium leaves much to be desired. A great deal of attention had been devoted to the problem of supplementing the existing hospital buildings. There was a site adjacent to the hospital ground which it was thought would be very suitable indeed for a nurses' home. Some people thought that the price which was being asked for it was excessive and the site, I understand now, has not been acquired. A considerable distance from the hospital, however, there was a farm with a dwelling-house on it. I understand that negotiations for the sale of this farm to a private individual had been virtually completed. That particular sale, however, to a private individual was never completed. On the contrary, that sale was broken and this dwelling-house with land attached was bought by the Newcastle Sanatorium at an enhanced price, at something more than the vendor had been willing to sell it to a private individual for, and three-fourths of this money, which cannot be spent on hospitals by the Minister, was provided out of moneys under his control.
Who owned the farm? During the last election a certain Clann na Poblachta candidate sprang into fame as the Russian jeweller. He is a gentleman who, according to his speeches on public platforms, set up very high standards of public conduct. As often happens, as a candidate he was very censorious about the public conduct of other people. He made allegations affecting the honour and probity of Ministers in former Administrations. He alleged, for instance, that the former Minister for Industry and Commerce had gone down to open a factory in Cork and had been presented with a carpet. Perhaps the carpet or rug was something that had been made there. Everybody will know that when a Minister or any public man or any private individual opens a public institution he is generally given——
Comment on this
The Minister is not responsible for any speeches made by some candidate at the election.
Comment on this
I am not suggesting that he is. I merely want to indicate the type of gentleman who was the other party to the transaction the Minister sanctioned, and that is a gentleman who held that there was something corrupt, that there was some jobbery, or that there was some graft if a person opening a factory receives a souvenir.
Comment on this
At present we are discussing, or are supposed to be, the administration of the Minister for Health, not the character of any candidate at the election.
Comment on this
I suggest respectfully that I have not said more than is proper. I am suggesting that when £10,000 is paid for property, the owner of which would be content to take less a little while before, and when the owner of the purchased property happens to be a former neighbour of the Minister, a political colleague of his, and a nominee of the Taoiseach in the Seanad, we are entitled to have an explanation from the Minister.
Comment on this
As to the Minister's conduct. Why was not the site beside the hospital bought? Why was not the purchase of that sanctioned? Why was it felt proper to pay £10,000 for a private dwelling-house situated a mile and a half from the hospital and which was ostensibly to be used to provide accommodation for the nurses?
Comment on this
They would have a good deal of exercise walking between the hospital and their dormitory. Perhaps we are going to have provided for them transport at the expense of the hospital. I think the hospital cannot do less than that. But, when we come to consider the distance of this building from the hospital and the cost of the transport which is to be provided for the nurses, what justification was there for preferring this building one and a half miles from the hospital to a site adjacent to the hospital upon which it would have been as easily possible to erect a temporary building to provide temporary accommodation for the nurses as the Minister thinks it is possible to erect a temporary building on the site that was dedicated to those who died during the Black and Tan war? It seems to me that, if you can erect a temporary clinic in the Rotunda Gardens, you can also erect temporary accommodation for the nurses on the site adjacent to the hospital. We have heard a great deal on occasions about Maximoe——
Comment on this
As I said, in January of 1948 the slogan of the Minister for Health and the Minister for External Affairs seemed to be money for hospitals, not money for hotels. The slogan would seem to have been considerably modified since. It is no longer money for hospitals, it is money for pals. The members of that Party which issued this leaflet asking the people of this country to put an end to political corruption, jobbery and graft had better address themselves to cleaning up that mess. The Minister for Agriculture and the Taoiseach and the Tánaiste, who have been talking about corruption up and down the country——
Comment on this
I say it has not—bringing in three other Ministers. It is the administration of this Minister and no other.
Comment on this
Very well. Not only should the Dáil direct attention to the administration of this Minister but the Taoiseach and his colleagues——
Comment on this
I had no intention of intervening in this debate when I came into the House but, after hearing the contribution of Deputy MacEntee, I do not feel it possible to content myself without commenting on some of the statements which he made. I do not know whether it was in a spirit of complete irresponsibility or through a desire to work mischief but certainly Deputy MacEntee in his contribution to the debate on this Estimate——
Comment on this
You are the right man to be talking about mischief.
Comment on this
He suggested that because the Department of Health had acquired for hospital purposes a school used by one denomination in this State for the training of teachers that was tantamount to coercion by the Department of Health and by the Minister of a non-Catholic minority in this country. Deputy MacEntee knows as well as I do and as well as every Deputy in this House knows that that is nothing but poppycock, that it is something which has no basis or foundation in fact. Nobody knows that better than Deputy MacEntee but he made that statement mischievously and irresponsibly knowing at the same time that he was, as he has often done in the past, handing a weapon to the Warnocks and Basil Brookes, handing a weapon which could be used by every partitionist in order to bolster up their case for the division of this country.
Comment on this
That is the statement made by Deputy MacEntee when he attempted to criticise the acquisition by the Department of Health of the former Coláiste Móibhí. I do not propose to deal in detail with all the envenomed bitterness that Deputy MacEntee succeeded in emitting in approximately the one hour and ten minutes that he spoke. Deputy MacEntee referred to the fact that the Department of Health has taken over for a temporary period the site for the proposed memorial to those in the Dublin area who gave their lives for the cause of an Irish Republic. If Deputy MacEntee had been in this House attending to his business to-day at 3 o'clock he would have known that the Minister made it perfectly plain that that project was not abandoned, that that project was not put on any long finger——
Comment on this
——that it was postponed for a very temporary period but Deputy MacEntee was not in the House to-day. He did not come into the House until 8 o'clock and he only came into the House for the purpose of utilising his position as a Deputy in order to issue slanders against other members of the Oireachtas and against the occupant of the Ministry of Health.
Comment on this
Of course, whenever Deputy MacEntee comes into this House he brings with him the brokendown brass band of Fianna Fáil to provide an accompaniment of support and interruption for him.
Comment on this
Nor does anybody on these benches squeal. If it is Deputy Brennan from Wicklow who is talking, I will deal with Deputy Brennan and I will fling the lie back in his teeth as I flung it in Deputy Boland's teeth.
Comment on this
The brass band of Fianna Fáil, which comes in to give succour and encouragement to Deputy MacEntee when he pays one of his periodic visits to this House for the purpose of mischief-making and obstructing public business, is not going to succeed in allowing Deputy MacEntee to get away with the slanders he tried to get away with to-day.
Comment on this
We in Clann na Poblachta never had a German band, a Russian band or a British band. We had an Irish band.
Comment on this
We had a band able to play a tune effectively to send you marching home. I think it is a pity that in the debate on the Department of Health it should be necessary for any of us to speak with heat or with bitterness. Probably, of all the Estimates that come before this House it is the one which we should be able to approach in a calmer, saner manner and if I allowed myself to be led away by the attitude adopted by Deputy MacEntee, I do not want to pursue that line any further.
I would like to say to the Minister that I do not feel myself precluded from congratulating him on the work that he has done since he went into office by the fact that he is a member of the Clann na Poblachta Party. I do not see why the fact that he is a member of that Party should preclude me from offering him those congratulations. I think the work done, particularly in the domain of thoracic surgery, since the Minister took over the portfolio of the Department of Health will remain as a lasting memorial to the Minister. Throughout the country there are thousands of people, sufferers from the dread scourge of tuberculosis, who bless quite sincerely the name of Dr. Noel Browne and people will not be influenced by the envenomed bitterness and the poisonous outpourings of Deputy MacEntee.
I would like to remind the Minister of the work being done in Dundrum Mental Hospital and to commend that institution to the Minister for his sympathetic consideration in future. I think there is a good deal of leeway to be made up there. I am satisfied that a genuine effort is being made to make up that leeway but I will commend that institution to the Minister's sympathetic consideration.
I think it does come, to an extent, within the scope of the Minister, as Minister for Health, to consider the question of athletics, and I would ask him at least to consult with the leaders of various athletic bodies in the country, with a view to setting up some sort of co-ordinating council with which his Department could deal. I suggest that the Minister would serve a very useful purpose were he to call into consultation, say, representatives of the N.A.C.A. and the G.A.A. and to discuss with these bodies the setting up of some form of athletic council.
Much has been said during the course of the debate about the wonderful plans that were awaiting the Minister when he took office. The only comment I would like to make on that, in conclusion, is that there were a lot of paper plans when Dr. Noel Browne went into the Department of Health, but where there were paper plans 18 months ago there are now in many instances solid bricks and mortar.
Comment on this
In the course of this debate we have listened to a discussion on hospitalisation, the treatment of disease and so on. We have had such discussions over a number of years, but the outstanding fact is that with all the plans, energy and preparation drawn from the imagination of well-intentioned people, such as Ministers, officials, architects, county councils and others, the patients who require treatment and are recommended for it, cannot get it. We have not the necessary hospitals to receive and give them treatment. No one doubts for a moment that the present Minister for Health is in any way insincere in his efforts. In fairness, I must say that if there is one Minister in this Parliament whose name to-day would receive a general verdict of approval from the community, higher even than that of any of his predecessors, it is the present Minister. No one doubts his sincerity. Many even of his political opponents appreciate his generous efforts. Despite all these wonderful efforts, I still feel paralysed for an explanation as to why we are still without the facilities that our patients require.
Deputy MacEntee says there is ample money in the Hospitals' Trust Fund. If so, why is there this continued shortage to meet the needful demands of the sick? I am waiting to hear if the Minister has found an explanation for that. Is the failure to provide the necessary facilities for the treatment of disease due to the emergency or the shortage of supplies of material and of labour? If the money is there, then I think there should be a vast speeding up so as to justify all the nice and kindly things said about the treatment of disease and the provision of hospitals not only in this House but outside of it. Why are the facilities not being provided?
We have many counties calling for hospitals. No doubt, some splendid ones have been built. In many counties, some of which adjoin my own County of Leitrim, we still have instituations that are very primitive indeed, and that, in our present state of civilisation, could not be considered at all suitable for the accommodation or treatment of patients. Indeed, some of them would not be held to be suitable even as garages or as stables for horses. When we are faced with that situation, must we not say that there is a lot of emptiness in the fine phrases that we have heard expressed here by Ministers and others and by people interested in social welfare? One must sometimes feel that there is a lot of emptiness in these fine phrases and sentiments.
Is there money available to build hospitals and provide for the necessary needs of our suffering patients? I very often get letters from people about patients suffering from tuberculosis. They have been recommended for treatment by their doctor and yet we find that there is no place to receive them. In other cases you hear of large families living in very small homes, some of the members of which may be suffering from tuberculosis. Yet nothing can be done to remove those patients and so prevent them from spreading the disease. One would think, from all the propaganda we have to listen to, that the things that are happening daily in this age could only have occurred 50 years ago. Yet, they are happening day after day and there appears to be no prospect of an immediate remedy for them.
Instead of listening to a debate in which emphasis would be laid on doing something immediately to remedy the present state of things, we have listened to one which was two-thirds political. We have one Party flying at the other, with no desire or plan to go ahead with developments so far as the essential things are concerned. We have one Party saying that the other was, politically, misguiding or misleading the people, that it was almost misappropriating public funds to its own advantage rather than endeavouring to help the sick poor. If there is one thing that will condemn democracy and that will lead to chaos in this country it is this political bitterness, this bigotry in political Parties as against every other national interest. That is what will destroy the State and destroy democracy. I would like to see something done quickly to provide all the facilities that are required for the sick and for the poor. I am sure that I do not feel any more strongly on that than any other member of the House.
If something is not done quickly to build hospitals in every county and to deal with disease, then many of the patients who are awaiting treatment will have passed away before some of the big plans contemplated are put into operation. Could not something practical be done immediately? In the case of tuberculosis could not chalets be provided for the accommodation of patients and for their treatment pending the provision of some of the big hospitals which are contemplated? Advice and treatment might also be provided for patients by local nurses. As I say if something is not done immediately great numbers of people who are in need of treatment to-day will have passed away before some of the great plans that are contemplated are put into operation. Let us stop all this hypocrisy and start and do something. Talking politics is not going to be any remedy. There is a moral obligation on us to deal with these matters in an urgent way. We are dealing here with life and death, and I say that it is immoral for us to be talking politics and obstructing the provision of immediate facilities for the treatment of patients who are in urgent need of it.
Comment on this
I have no doubt that Deputy Maguire is sincere in his expression of condemnation of the sort of political antagonism that goes on in this House, but what he fails to comprehend is where that emanated from. If he gives a little study to the type of slanderous propaganda which brought about the change in Government, he will see there the reason for the type of discussion which takes place in this House. Naturally, members of this Party must refute the kind of suggestions that are not only being made here, but that were made during the election which brought about the change of Government. I suggest that is the only reason why there is anything that could be described as being in the nature of political suggestions in the discussion on this Estimate.
I thoroughly agree that this Estimate should be discussed, as far as it is humanly possible to discuss anything here, in a non-political atmosphere. For that reason I shall try to confine the remarks which I have to make to the Estimate proper. In his opening statement the Minister gave us some statistics which went to prove that the health situation in this country is improving. I feel sure that the Minister will not suggest that that improvement was brought about in the short period in which he has been in office. That improvement could only have been brought about as a result of careful attention to details in regard to the Department of Health on the part of his predecessors.
I am not satisfied that the figures have reached the stage at which we would like to see them. I am sure the Minister would like to see them considerably reduced. As we all know, the figures are still a long way above those of other countries in Europe and until we can bring them to the same level we will not have achieved anything in the nature of success.
I know we cannot discuss housing on this Estimate. We have discussed it pretty fully on the Estimate for the Department of Local Government. In the course of that discussion I mentioned the dire necessity for houses and the only reason I am mentioning it now is to suggest to the Minister that he will use—and I know he will—his influence with the Government to see that our housing conditions will be improved as far as it is humanly possible to have them improved, because prevention as we all know is very much better than curing.
As a layman I cannot suggest the reason for the expansion of tuberculosis in this country as compared with other countries. It can in some circumstances be ascribed to housing conditions and in other circumstances it can be ascribed to malnutrition. The extraordinary thing is that it is not confined to the families of poor people; it apparently reaches out to all sorts of families, even families in very good circumstances, and it is therefore questionable if we can say exactly how it originates. The only thing is that when it is there we must deal with it to the best of our ability.
I have had complaints from people, mainly women, who have had to attend the dispensary in Charles Street. The complaints consist in the main of the conditions which exist here. I have been told that the accommodation is very limited, especially in view of the large numbers of people who are compelled to attend. I understand there is a kind of communal room in which they have to divest themselves of their clothing and, having done so, they are then liable to catch the draughts which run through the room as a result of the doors opening and closing. Quite a large number of people are compelled to divest themselves of clothing at the same time, which means that a considerable period elapses while they are in that state. I should like the Minister to have this matter investigated. It is quite possible that it is all due to the limitations of the building.
Deputy Lehane referred to athletics. I saw recently where the Minister eulogised, at some function or other, the value of athletics from the point of view of health. I would like him to interest himself in order to see that the grant made by the last Government— I think it was a grant of something like £25,000—for the provision of cinder tracks where young men could go out in the evenings and train, will be renewed. We all know the building up of human bodies is one of the best possible preventives of disease. Therefore, it is desirable that some provision should be made available for the benefit of the youth of the country.
There is another aspect of athletics to which I would like to refer and that is the desirability of greater facilities in this city for swimming. So far as I am aware there is only the one swimming bath in the city which is available to the general public. Recently I read a blue book issued by the British Parliament on the subject of swimming facilities.
I must confess I was appalled when I read the analysis of samples of water taken from these baths at the end of the day. I cannot say at the moment whether the particular baths were equipped with a proper filtration plant. I know that the baths in the city here are not equipped with any filtration plant. Because of that, people are swimming from early morning till late at night in water which is not changed throughout the entire day. I understand these baths are treated with chlorine. Nevertheless, I am conscious of the fact that at the end of the day the water must be impregnated with exudations from the human body. I do not believe that can add anything to the health of our people who utilise these baths. Possibly a proper filtration plant could be installed. I think it is most desirable that the Minister should interest himself in this particular matter. Vast quantities of bacteria must be present in this contaminated water. We all know that water is one of the sources by which typhoid is transmitted. The number of deaths from typhoid at the present time are not very great. Possibly they could be reduced still further and I think the Minister should interest himself in this particular aspect of public health.
I was rather pleased recently to find the Minister for Local Government referring to the necessity for interesting young girls in housekeeping and cooking. A properly cooked meal is one of the most desirable attributes of married life. I think a great deal of the malnutrition which exists is not due so much to lack of food as to the manner in which the food is prepared and cooked. This food is a costly item for the poorer families and it is most essential that young girls should be trained in the proper preparation and cooking of food. I would like the Minister to do something in relation to these particular matters. So far as health generally is concerned, we shall play our part as far as possible in giving any help we can to improve the health of our people.
Comment on this
Ba mhaith liom moladh a thabhairt don Teachta Mac Uidhir as Liathdroim mar gheall ar an gcaint bhreá a rinne sé, go háirithe an chaint a rinne sé ar son na mbocht. O shléibhte Liathdroma dhó, ó áit shléibhtiúil, fearacht na háite a dtagaim féin as.
Tá caint mhór faoi ospidéil, go bhfuil an oiread seo acu ag teastáil agus go bhfuil riachtanas le deasú a dhéanamh ar ospidéil, ach tá ospidéal beag againne sa nGaeltacht, ospidéal an Chlocháin, ospidéal a theastaíos, gan aon aimhreas, a mhéadú agus áit a leath-oiread eile leapacha ar a laghad a dhéanamh ann. Go deimhin féin dá mbeadh neart air nó deis ann chuige níor mhór a dhá oiread méide a bheith ann is atá ann.
An méid atá ann ospidéal galánta é, ospidéal nua. Is é a locht a laghad. Timpeall is dhá bhliain is fiche ó rinneadh an t-ospidéal sin agus, an uair a tosaíodh ag cur dlús lena dhéanamh is mór an lán daoine a bhí in aghaidh a dhéanta. Ach an tráth sin bhí Aire Airgeadais againn nar chlis ariamh ar an nGaeltacht agus ón mbáidh bhí aige don Ghaeltacht fuaireamar uaidh go réidh an t-airgead a theastaigh lena dhéanamh. Níl aon airgead a tugadh ó shoin sa nGaeltacht, le mo linn-sa ar chuma ar bith, a raibh toradh chomh maith air is bhí ar an airgead sin ná a chruthaigh chomh maith is ab fhiú é a chaitheamh mar go bhfuil cruthaithe gur theastaigh sé go géar, agus i dteannta sin faghann an t-othar agus an t-easlán togha na haire ann agus is iomú duine a bhí tréith-lag ag dul ann dó a tháinig as amach ina dhuine láidir folláin. Sul a ndearnadh an t-ospidéal sin bhí ar dhaoine dul go Gaillimh suas le trí scóir míle go leor acu, i bhfad óna ngaolta agus óna ndaoine muintireacha. Ní ag cathú ar Ghaillimh atáim ach measaim go mbfhearrde an t-othar é dá ghaire dá mbeadh sé dá mhuintir féin.
Tá mé cinnte nach bhfuil orm ach é seo a chur i gcuimhne don Aire mar tá croí an Aire ar thaobh na ndaoine agus an méid d'iarr mise air ar son na ndaoine rinne sé a dhicheall lena dhéanamh.
Rud eile tithe le haghaidh na ndochtúirí. Faoi láthair, tá dochtúir bhreátha ghroidhiúla againn ar fonn leo fanacht againn sa nGaeltacht dá bhféadaidís. Tá gnaoi agus gean na ndaoine orthu. Ach tá cuid acu gan tithe cónaí. Tá siad dá gcur anonn is anall ar fud a gceantar. Agus nach cinnte nach bhfanfaidh duine ar bith in áit ar chúntar den tsórt sin, ar aistreán, má fhaghann sé áit chomh maith leis nó nach mbeadh chomh maith leis ar aon chor má bhíonn teach aige ann a bhféadfadh sé cónaí ann.
I dteannta an méid sin, tá díth uisce orainn in áiteacha sa nGaeltacht. Sa tsean-aimsir bhí sé ráite gurb é díth an uisce a tharraing drochthinneasacha go leor ann. Faoi láthair tá elefantacha bána againn ar thaobh na gcnoc. Iad in ainm a bheith déanta le uisce a choinneáil, na mílte míle píopa leagtha agus curtha faoi thalamh, airgeadh go leor caite ar an méid sin agus ina dhiaidh sin agus uile gan deoir uisce ag teacht trí na píopaí sin. Ní i bhpobal amháin ná i mbaile amháin atá an scéal sin le n-aithris, ach beagnach gach uile áit ar leagadh na píopaí sin. Tá muilte gaoithe go leor agus fóiséid le feiceál ach tá siad chomh tirm le cailc. An ag iarraidh dalladhmullóg a chur ar na daoine atáthar? Níor mhiste é ach a bhfuil d'airgead an phobail caite leis.
Má sheasann an aimsir bhreá seo, tá faitíos orm go mbeidh a chomhartha lena chois. Mar sin, ba cheart rud eicínt a dhéanamh agus na píopaí agus na muilte gaoithe sin a chur i ndeis agus in ordú le uisce a sholáthar.
Tá sé ráite go bhfuiltear leis na banaltraí faoi scéim Lady Dudley a thabhairt faoi urláimh an Stáit. Níl mise sásta go mba mhaith an rud é sin a dhéanamh. Gan aimhreas, is é Scéim Lady Dudley an scéim is fearr a tháinig don Ghaeltacht ariamh. Nuair a théigheas duine bocht nó duine saidhbhir ag iarraidh banaltra acu seo ní theastaíonn ticéad dubh ná ticéad dearg uaidh. Ní fiafrófar díobh a bhfuil airgead acu nó uathu ach na banaltraí amuigh de sciotán. Agus ní uair ná faoi dhó a theigheas siad chun tí ag freastal ar an othar ach go minic an fhad a bhíos a duine tinn. Má bhris dream ar bith lucht an workhouse agus cosúlacht an workhouse do na daoine is iad na banaltraí seo iad. Le haghaidh na mbocht atá siad ann agus tá cruthaithe acu a fheabhas a dhéanann siad a gcuid oibre mar tá gnaoi na ndaoine orthu. Má thograíonn duine aon phighinn a thabhairt dóibh ar son a gcumainn—ní ar a son féin—glactar leis, ach ní bítear dá iarraidh. Tugtar beagán dóibh ach is maith a bhíos an mórán tuillte acu. Déantar bailiú dhóibh ó am go ham agus tugann daoine ón Ard-Easboc anuas síntiús dóibh. Is iad an dream iad a choinníos an t-ospidéal sa teach san áit is fearr go minic a gcuirfidh an duíne dhe a chuid tinnis.
Tá súil agam go ndéanfaidh an tAire cúram de na rúdaí seo agus tá mé i ngar dá bheith cinnte go ndéanfaidh. Tá ráite ann go bhfaghann na ba bás an fhad is bhíos an féar ag fás. Tá súil agam nach mbeidh sin le samhlú leis san chomh fada is bhaineas leis na nithe seo go léir, mar is fearr an ngníomh chruthaítear ná an céad gníomh a ghealltar.
Comment on this
Much that could be said in this debate would take a very great amount of time. A good deal has been said already and I do not propose to deal with the subject generally but I should like to deal with a few points that have been mentioned already. The first matter is the question of athletics which has been mentioned by Deputy Traynor. From the health point of view, we may regard athletics as physical training, and proper organisation and a proper attitude in regard to this activity for the young, serves a twofold function. It makes for healthy bodies and for morale as well. It makes for national morale and hence the Minister for Health should pay considerable attention to those organised societies amongst us, such as the G.A.A. and others, who cater for athletics and who organise them. Particularly he should give attention to the well-being of those who take part in these games. I would say further that the Minister, in whatever relations he has with schools, the Department of Education and other places where young people are engaged in activities of this nature, should pay particular attention to the proper development of athletics, not only from the point of view of sound physical health but also from the point of view of developing a sound morale. It would be very easy to expand on that but I think I have said sufficient to indicate the point I wish to make.
It does strike one that, in regard to athletics, there are certain matters in which the Minister could actively intervene, or if not intervene, at least take an interest. The provision of swimming baths and facilities in the way of proper accommodation for games, has already been mentioned and the Minister, having some responsibility for the health of the people, should be interested in athletic activities as a means of developing the physique of our young people and of helping to safeguard their health.
There is another aspect of the athletic problem. I have already mentioned the moral aspect but there is also what one might call the mental or moral health of the nation. The question of national morale is, to some extent, bound up with the health of the people. We have seen how, before the last war, the morale of many countries in Europe was built up on athletics. Coupled with that, the physical standard of the youth of these countries was developed through concentration on athletics. Perhaps some regard to the results that arose from these activities in the past would be helpful to the Minister and I merely suggest to him that he could perhaps usefully study that aspect of the problem.
There is another matter which is not strictly relevant to the Minister's particular function but it deals again with national morale and consequently is, to that extent, relevant. The development of an athletic tradition, which could secure international recognition, as I have said will not only contribute to our morale at home but it will contribute to the prestige of the nation and to the strength of the nation in the eyes of outsiders. Only recently in international boxing Maxie McCullagh brought fame and credit to his country. It should be possible, with the potentialities of a people, largely agricultural, such as ours is, to produce more champions in many spheres of sport. Mind you, they would probably be amongst our best ambassadors to other nations. As I have said this is, perhaps, under the strict rules of debate foreign to the Minister's Department but I think it is an aspect of the problem that should not be forgotten. It is a further inducement for the Minister and the Government to consider seriously the national value of athletics and athletic activities from the point of view of the physical and moral health of the citizen, from the point of view of national morale and the prestige of the nation abroad.
Another matter which has been touched upon in this debate is the question of nurses. In tackling the Minister's problem, his troops so to speak are the personnel who have to deal with the matters of health. That is particularly true of such a problem as tuberculosis or other diseases but it is also true in regard to the routine maintenance and checking of health. I do not think the question of doctors needs any particular mention at the moment but the question of nurses does.
Heretofore, the position of the nursing profession in this country has not been altogether satisfactory. The Minister will know more about this as a professional man, but many of us who, as patients or otherwise, have seen it from another angle, cannot help feeling that the casualty rate amongst that particular section of the health groups of the country was often high, that the conditions under which these girls had to labour were often difficult, and the safeguards for their own health and efficiency that one would wish were often not there. In the case of most hospitals, everything that could be possibly done was done, but the problem was one of such proportions that it seemed to require the active intervention of the Minister.
Without going into the details of that problem, this thought strikes me. If we are to tackle health, we have to tackle it with these particular troops, so to speak. The first requisite for efficiency in dealing with the problem, after you have laid out your administration, etc., is to provide for efficiency amongst these troops. In order to get efficiency, the best possible conditions for nurses appear to be one of the first requisites. A Bill has been introduced in the other House on which this matter will probably be more properly discussed, but I think it is no harm that it should be mentioned on the Estimate.
Finally, I should like also, like Deputy MacEntee and others, to refer to the proposed clinic in Parnell Square. I wonder is the Minister wise in selecting just that location? In confining myself more or less to the narrow issue on this, I do not want to be taken as ignoring the other issue that other Deputies on this side of the House have pleaded and to whose views I very largely subscribe. But, by way of supplement to that, I should like to raise the practical question. What is the case for putting up a temporary building on the upper third of Parnell Square? Perhaps the Minister will correct me if I am proceeding on a wrong hypothesis. I am assuming the proposition is to place a temporary building as a health clinic on the upper third of Parnell Square. I understand it is to be largely a tuberculosis centre. I speak as a layman, but a layman who knows the area fairly well. It is immediately adjacent to the Rotunda Maternity Hospital. I understand that they have their clinics also and attending the maternity clinics will be expectant mothers, possibly nursing mothers who are in the post-birth period. For all I know they may have contacts actually with the hospital cases inside. It will be right up against the nurses' home for that hospital. As an ignorant layman in this matter, so to speak, I naturally ask the question: is it good business or good health organisation, even if it is only the contact of two queues for two different clinics there, to risk the contact of open tubercular cases going to one clinic with expectant mothers going to another clinic?
The Minister, with his professional knowledge, may make very small meat indeed of my question. I am not even advancing it as an argument. Quite apart from technical reasons or questions relating to the area to which the particular disease germ can be diffused or anything else, you have the physical fact that, by having a tuberculosis clinic on that square, the patients, and I presume these may include open cases, will actually be in a greater density of traffic in that vicinity. There is possible contact with the people going to the other clinic. Is that wise? I want to refrain from anything like exaggeration or anything that might tend that way. If my remarks display ignorance. I would only be too glad to be corrected. But this clinic will be right up against the back of the nurses' home. Does that improve the health environment for a group of people who, by reason of their work and by reason of their avocation, need special safeguards and special help in regard to their own health?
Apart from that, I have doubts if that particular area is the best centre. I am not aware as to exactly how much of the city this is meant to cater for. But it seems to me that, if it is meant to be one centre for the whole northern section of the city, it is hardly the best type of organisation. The north side is big and scattered. No matter where you place the clinic, if it is meant to be one clinic for the whole lot, the travel difficulty for patients attending that clinic will be a serious problem. On the other hand, if it is proposed to have a number of them, then that particular location is not well situated. Would it not be better to put one on the bombed site at the North Strand and another towards the west? There are undoubtedly other sites. Even if the Minister wanted temporary sites, I could think of a number of them. For instance, if it was a temporary site was wanted, why not take an area on the virtually waste land up near the Broadstone which is the property of the King's Inns? Incidentally, I would not otherwise recommend it as it is used as a playground by a lot of children, but at least it would not be open to the objections to which the Parnell Square site is open. For all these reasons, I think that the actual site for this clinic should be reconsidered, quite apart from the reason which has been pleaded by Deputy MacEntee in particular. I do not think that there is much sense in my repeating what has been said by other Deputies but, to summarise, I should like to commend particularly to the Minister for his sympathetic attention the question of athletics generally, the question of nurses, and the question of reconsidering this site in Parnell Square.
Comment on this
I was very much impressed by the contribution of Deputy B. Maguire and I wish to join with him in making a very honest and sincere appeal that in matters of public health speeches should be tempered with a little more Christian kindness and charity and less politics. Yesterday I was listening for a considerable time to many bouquets being passed by Fianna Fáil speakers to the present Minister for the amount of effort, industry and initiative that he has thrown into his Department and the whole technique of its administration. Other speeches made to-day which were completely at variance with those speeches and tempered with bitterness and heat were to me inexplicable. I rose to refer to one matter. Most other aspects of the case have been fully discussed. We appreciate the great effort made by the Minister in attacking the various forms of malignant and pernicious disease, such as cancer. There is another form of cancer that he must not neglect as a Minister new to the Government. We know the malignant form of cancer that attacks the human being. Science is doing everything conceivably possible to minimise and to retard the growth of that disease and the destruction that is caused by it. County Limerick appreciated the importance of dealing with cancer 14 or 15 years ago. As a member of the board of health I am in daily or weekly contact with the various institutions and hospitals.
As members of visiting committees, we had to witness the terrible suffering and agony and economic as well as physical ruin that was being wrought by that terrible disease. Appreciating our responsibility from an administrative as well as a humanitarian point of view, we decided that there was no use in rubbing 2d. worth of sulphur ointment to a cancerous growth. We appreciated that it might be a palliative but that it would never remove it. We appreciated that the only remedy was surgical treatment of the best and most modern kind. We appreciated also the economic and other difficulties entailed in bringing patients a journey of 150 or 140 miles. Viewing these facts, and recognising our responsibility, we decided to do everything possible during our term of administration to help suffering humanity. We decided that we should get a hospital built on modern lines, without regard to cost. We formed a joint committee with the Limerick Corporation and proceeded with our plans. That was about 13 years ago. It took a certain amount of courage but we faced up to it and we were encouraged by the then Government. Having prepared our plans, acquired the land, met all the legal and incidental costs, a scheme for a regional hospital on modern, scientific lines, which would cost approximately £500,000 was set out. Having done everything that administratively could be done and exercising all the statutory powers, we finally got the imprimatur of the Government.
It has been nauseating to be dealing with the Department for the last five years. Everything that we could do has been done. I said at the outset that there was another form of cancer that must be attacked by the Minister. It relates to his own particular Department. It is the cancer of red tape that is retarding public effort and increasing the suffering of the poor and the sick. I said quite recently to one of our architects: "Will you kick the damn papers away?" A proposed alteration to a door was submitted to the Department and we had to wait two months for an answer. After eight months the door will be altered. The colours of the screws did not harmonise with what it was intended the door should be when complete. All these details are sickening and irritating. This red tape is a cancer that is retarding public effort. Last May four years we thought the structure, the foundation of which were laid 12 years ago, would be finished. It took months and years of careful study and patience on the part of the old board of health. Now, four years later, we find the same sickening red tape or green tape, a new kind of social cancer, retarding the best efforts of a public body.
I wish to draw the Minister's attention to the fact that we are facing another winter and possibly another year may elapse and they may decide to change a window, which would take six to eight months more. Red tape is helping the growth of cancer. I would appeal to the Minister to show in this case the industry, initiative and determination of which, in 15 months or less, he has given unquestionable evidence.
I was glad to hear many of the Opposition Party paying a just and proper compliment to the Minister. They should bear in mind that during that 15 or 16 months he was prostrate in a hospital for six or eight weeks and was convalescent for another five weeks and that that undoubtedly weakened his effort and his attention to business, and that but for that there would be much less to tell him to-day. I again join with that fair-minded Deputy, Deputy B. Maguire, in saying that we ought to deal with this important matter with more Christian charity. It is sickening to hear epithets being hurled across the floor of the House, the result of 25 years of bitterness. We should all join in a common cause, in the knowledge that there are in the world so many conflicting ideologies, to help to build up schemes for the relief of suffering humanity.
Comment on this
This debate, which has benefited from the contributions of over 30 Deputies and has taken the major part of three days' time of the House, has been a particularly stimulating and encouraging experience for me as Minister in charge of the Department of Health because the very fact that it has taken this time shows that at least one of my efforts, that is, my effort to increase the health consciousness of our people, has permeated into the minds of our elected representatives.
Because of that reason I have been particularly glad and encouraged. I have too much appreciation of the very, on the whole, generous and objective spirit shown by all Deputies in the House, including the members of the Opposition, in the discussion of this Estimate and of the consideration which I have received from the Deputies of all Parties over the period of months that I have been in office, to follow the two ex-Ministers primarily responsible for the difficulties in which we find ourselves—Deputy MacEntee and Deputy Dr. Ryan. I have no intention of trying to play foil to the fish-wife tactics adopted by both of them and what I consider their lamentable displays in this House. I, as a new Deputy, and I suppose most of us, have the deepest respect for this House. We feel that our behaviour should go out as an example to the young men of my generation and to the older generation; that our behaviour should be an example in the national life of the country. I think that these displays, on both sides, can be said to be confined to very few Deputies. It is unfortunate that our enemies in other countries and in our own seize upon those exhibitions to denigrate the feelings of national dignity of our people, of our behaviour in attempting to legislate for ourselves.
Personally, I have no objection to politics entering into the discussion on the Vote for the Department of Health. This is a legislative Assembly in which there are political Parties of different colours. Different views are held. It is quite obvious that some of us have and must have different views as to how to run the Department of Education, the Department of Local Government, my Department or, in fact, any Department. These views are crystallised in the minds of our people under what is known as the politics of the different Parties in the country. If there is a social or an economic policy or a hospital or health policy, I do not see why it should be completely dissociated from politics. Politics is simply a form of belief. If your Party thinks that a thing can be done in a particular way, and rather better than the way in which the other Party did it, I am quite prepared to continue with my views as to the behaviour of the former Government, and they are at perfect liberty to make any comments, within reason, that they wish on my behaviour in carrying out the work of my Department. Of course, it is only the foul, vituperative tongues of the disappointed Deputy MacEntee and the former Minister, Deputy Dr. Ryan, which do detract from the ordinary give and take of political life but from which I have no fears whatever.
Now, throughout the whole debate there was plenty of criticism, constructive, destructive and every kind of criticism, and it was perfectly welcome. There were suggestions, some rather helpful than otherwise. Throughout the whole debate there was only one incident which, in any way, impinged at all upon my feelings, and of course on my standard of integrity and honesty. I feel that the House should become aware of all the facts of the particular incident to which I refer.
Comment on this
It is a pity that the Deputy who did that had not the courtesy to come in and listen.
Comment on this
That is, of course, the nurses' home at Newcastle Sanatorium, County Wicklow. I will not dwell on the grave seriousness and the implied charges made in the very meandering, tedious and tiresome speech of Deputy Dr. Ryan. They are quite obvious to all here. I will simply try and put before Deputies the facts as they are and permit them to use their good sense in judging for themselves. I ask Deputies to throw their minds back to February of last year when the change of Government took place. They may remember that one of the points in the ten-point programme was the provision of hospital accommodation for tubercular patients. That, quite obviously, in the inter-Party Government became my primary responsibility. The number of beds required was in the region of 1,000 for young men and women who were waiting institutional treatment. I suppose few people could be more aware of that than I was—due to my particular profession, the particular job which I held in that profession and my very close association with the sick people in the community. I felt particularly strongly about the whole question.
So far as I was concerned, nothing in the world could obstruct me, or stand in my way, in seeing that every man and woman whose health might be saved or whose life might be prolonged should find the necessary treatment.
I circulated to the local authorities a memorandum which pointed out to them the seriousness of the position in regard to tuberculosis and the waiting lists and I asked them to submit to me any proposals which they thought might prove helpful to us in the Department in solving this very serious bed shortage. I made my views known in public on every possible occasion. Approximately 20 proposals were submitted to us from various parts of the country, and many others by different Deputies in the House who were anxious to assist.
Of the proposals submitted to me two came from the sanatorium committee at Newcastle. One was for the acquisition of a house called Trudder Grange and the other for a house known as Mount John, owned by Senator McCartan. I might say that, from my short experience in South East Dublin during the general election and subsequent to that, I was well aware that in considering the latter proposal considerable play would be made of the fact that Senator McCartan was a member of the political organisation to which I belonged. Quite obviously, the facile ability shown by Deputy MacEntee on so many occasions to misrepresent, distort, vilify or twist any action, however good its intentions, would be directed towards me and towards the distortion of my action in this case.
Both of these houses were examined at the request of the committee. Trudder Grange proved to be quite useless for the purpose for which it was suggested—that is, a nurses' home —following the advice of architects and engineers. Mount John, however, it was agreed, could be readily converted into a temporary nurses' home to provide accommodation which would release approximately 26 beds in the hospital.
Now, the price to be paid—and these figures are important-was decided in this way. As is normally done by Government Departments, the Valuation Office was asked to value the property, which, by the by, consists of a house capable of holding 26 nurses— hardly a farm house, as Deputy MacEntee suggested—and there are also 80 acres of land attached, 60 of which are arable and 20 non-arable. The Valuation Office estimated the market value at £7,500—£4,000 for the land and £3,500 for the house. We communicated this fact to the hospital authorities and said that we, of course, could not sanction the payment of any more money for this property out of the Hospitals' Trust Fund than the valuation put upon it by the Valuation Office. The hospital authorities nevertheless proceeded to buy this house and, I understand, paid approximately £10,000 for it. But the money spent from the Hospitals' Trust Fund was £7,500.
I made a stipulation that the land should be let for grazing and it, of course, brings in an annual income. The house, costing £3,500, was to be converted into a nurses' home. Incidentally, there was a separate offer of £10,000 by an independent buyer—a firm offer in writing of £10,000 by an independent buyer. The way I looked at it was that the land was worth so much and presumbly will not lose much in value. The house, worth £3,500, provided accommodation for approximately 26 nurses and released that number of beds, occupied by nurses, in the actual hospital itself for the use of patients. Having the temporary use of this house for a period of approximately three years, required to build the nurses' home proposed by my predecessor, Deputy Dr. Ryan, but never built, will mean that I am able now to provide bed accommodation for 26 patients at approximately £1 per week over the period and the asset will still remain at the end of the period. That seemed to me to be not only the Christian and humane thing to do, but it also appeared to me to be good business.
We examined the possibility of providing alternative units on the site of the hospital for nurses. We went so far as to draw up outline sketch plans. The cost of providing that accommodation on the existing site for 24 nurses —that is, roughly, the number who now occupy the nurses' home valued at £3,500—would have been in the region of £12,000. I might add that that accommodation would have been of a temporary nature. On the one hand then, we have an expenditure from the Hospitals' Trust Fund of £7,500. The Valuation Office has valued the land at £4,000. That land is at present producing an annual income due to letting. The house was valued £3,500. Therefore, we put £7,500 against an expenditure of £12,000 required to provide the same amount of accommodation, but in a much longer time.
Another field was mentioned, at the back of the hospital. I was asked why it was not acquired. The explanation is simple. It was not acquired because that 11 acres would have cost approximately £1,600, or more than twice the cost per acre of the land comprising the Mount John estate. Having acquired that field, we would have had to build thereon a nurses' home costing £12,000.
Deputy Dr. Ryan said that this sanatorium had been turned down as a training school by the General Nursing Council. That is not true. It is a recognised training school for sanatorium nurses and has been passed as such by the General Nursing Council. The new nurses' home is some distance from the hospital, but it was not chosen for that reason. It was chosen because there was no other alternative at the time and because there were 26 people who had a right to live, a right to have their health restored and their lives saved. I well knew that, with Deputy MacEntee, Deputy Dr. Ryan and Deputy Brennan there, I was taking the risk of having everything distorted and misrepresented. I do not attach sufficient importance to success in political life to let the chance of that success stand in the way of doing what I consider to be right, of doing what I consider to be, as I said before, the Christian and the humane thing. There are to-day men and women who do not share either Deputy MacEntee's or Deputy Dr. Ryan's attitude in this matter. Too often in the past political expediency was allowed to interfere with the health of our people. So long as I am in the Department of Health the sick, religion and politics aside, will come first and my political career can come anywhere else.
I have nothing to hide. Perhaps I may be permitted to reiterate the figures for the House. The Mount John estate, composed of a house and 80 acres, 60 of which are arable and 20 non-arable, was valued by the Valuation Office at £7,500. The land was valued at £4,000 and the house £3,500. The land is at present let and is bringing in an annual income. The house is occupied by approximately 26 nurses. The beds vacated by them in the institution are occupied by patients. To provide alternative temporary accommodation for the same number would have cost £12,000. The alternative site of 11 acres would have cost £1,600, or approximately twice the cost per acre of the arable land which had to be acquired as part of the Mount John project. For the life of me, I cannot see why members of political Parties should be excluded from buying or selling their property. I have no objection in the world if Deputy Dr. Ryan himself acquired his own residence and his own estate from the Land Commission. I presume that the whole transaction was carried out in a straightforward and honest way and that he has nothing to be ashamed of. In this project, neither have I.
Deputies in this debate covered a tremendously wide field. I do not think it would be possible for me to reply in detail to all the points raised. They covered hospitals, hospitals' programme, mother and child service, cancer, clinics, dispensaries, red tickets, deficits, the problem of nurses and nursing generally. I shall do my best to cover at least the main points.
On the question of hospitals, it would be wrong to get the general impression that I am building nothing, or proposing to build nothing, but tuberculosis institutions throughout the country, and that my only concern is the problem of tuberculosis. There are problems which, in my opinion, are as serious and as grave, particularly the cancer problem. It is killing, I think unnecessarily, a large percentage of those who die each year from this disease in our country. The services available for the treatment of cancer are very limited and quite inadequate. I am well aware of that fact. The problem was discussed by Deputy Byrne, Deputy Dunne and others but it is worth remembering that this problem of cancer did not spring up overnight. So far back as 1935, the Hospitals Commission, in its second general report, pointed out the total inadequacy of cancer services in the country and made recommendations that a cancer hospital and extensions generally of services, should be provided. This was not done and so we find ourselves to-day with a still very formidable programme.
Coming to the question of what is to be done, a consultative council, composed of men associated with cancer work of all kinds and treating cancer in all the hospitals, was constituted. They were asked to study the problem and to bring in any experts who, they thought, might be of assistance to them in assessing the size of our problems, and having done so, to suggest remedies or schemes upon which I might work. They met a number of times and did a considerable amount of very hard work of which I am deeply appreciative. They had also the benefit of the advice of Dr. Pattison, a Scotsman, who is head of the Holt Radium Institute in Manchester, who came over and assisted them as best he could.
I have only to-day, as a matter of fact, received their report and their recommendations. The House can be quite certain that no time will be lost by me in considering these recommendations and, where possible, acting on them with the minimum delay. So far I have been fortunate in being able to carry out a number of things which I had given assurance to the House I would try to do. I hope that, in the next year, we shall see a considerable development of our cancer services. While obviously it is not a problem which will be solved overnight, I think I can gurantee some move towards a solution of our problems in the reasonably near future.
On the question of hospitals, Deputy MacEntee was particularly irate because he read out a list of hospital proposals which I mentioned in my opening speech on the Estimate as being likely to be commenced this year, 1949. He was particularly irate because I had not gone into the Department, taken all the proposals and the plans in the pigeon holes, made a bonfire of them, and started from the beginning, away back in 1931 and 1932.
Again, Deputy Dr. Ryan, Deputy Derring and a number of the more unthinkingly critical Deputies were wondering where the hospitals were which I had promised. A little cold thinking is useful at this point. Last year I had two separate proposals. One was a proposal to carry through a number of projects for hospital building spread over a period of years. The other was a proposal to provide a number of beds in a period of months. I have been criticised by these Deputies because of my ingénue approach to the question of hospital building, the general inference being that I believed these could be produced out of a hat by the wave of a wand. Similarly, my political organisation has been criticised because of my ingenuous belief in the speed at which you could build hospitals. Of course, that is a completely dishonest reading of the facts of the situation.
I said two things. One was that I would build a number of hospitals in seven years. I said that last year and I repeat it this year. I did not say they would appear overnight when I waved my wand. I also said that I would provide 1,000 beds for people awaiting admission to institutions within a year, approximately, of starting on that. I have realised the latter project and beaten the target by 200 beds—they have come in at the rate of at least 100 beds a month. If the Deputies who criticised had listened to my opening speech, they would have seen that if the proposals which I put to the House are fulfilled—I have every reason to think they will be fulfilled by the end of this year—we will have started on approximately £6,250,000 worth of the £17,500,000 projected for the next seven years.
If, at the end of this year, I have started on approximately one-third of my whole seven year hospital programme, I shall be pretty satisfied. There is obviously every reason to believe that, moving on that basis. I will not alone redeem by first promise —which I have done—to provide 1,000 beds, but I will redeem my second one —to increase the total bed capacity in the country by approximately 7,000 in the next seven years. That is double the existing bed accommodation in the country.
We have made great progress in the Department. Deputy Corry, Deputy McGrath, Deputy Derrig, Deputy Dr. Ryan and Deputy MacEntee are anxious to know why we have not started building here, there and everywhere. It must be obvious to Opposition Deputies that to say that is one of the most cogent criticisms that they could possibly make of their own Government and their own administration. I do not know if the Deputies understand that in the building of a hospital there are approximately 20 different moves—that one has to work from the outline schedule of accommodation right down to the getting of quantities. If the hospital projects mentioned by Deputy MacEntee in his very childish speech, the hospital projects advised by the Hospitals Commission in 1933, 1934, 1935 and 1936, all of which were ignored by Deputy MacEntee or whoever happened to be in power at the time, had made any real progress under Fianna Fáil—the emergency might have deprived them of timber, concrete, glass and steel and all the rest, but it did not deprive them of pencils and paper and some of these projects were started as far back as 1931—there was no reason why, when I went into office, I should have not been able to lay my hands on the final quantities for every single one of them. They were not available in respect of any single project which was there before the Department.
Comment on this
Each project had to be put on the move and all the preliminary steps had to be taken in order that we might bring a number of them— approximately one-third—to a commencement in one and a half years of office. I must say that I had great admiration for the extraordinary impertinence and impudence of Deputy MacEntee in his dissertation on what he was going to do next year, the year after and the year after that. Knowing the facts, as he must, we cannot help admiring his ability to come in here to blast away the fact that he did nothing but plan.
There was nothing but schemes in my Department when I went there. There were 135 of them, all of different kinds, sorts, sizes and shapes and they were all waiting. There was Longford County Hospital, first proposed in 1932; Louth, proposed in 1935; Wicklow, first proposed in 1932; Leitrim (Manorhamilton), first proposed in 1933; Cahirciveen, first proposed in 1933; Galway Regional, first proposed in 1931; Crumlin Children's Hospital, about which he spoke with great eloquence, first proposed in 1935; the Coombe Hospital, first proposed in 1931; St. Laurence and Vincent's, first proposed in 1935; Dublin Fever Hospital, first proposed in 1936; Carndonagh, Donegal, first proposed in 1932; Letterkenny, first proposed in 1932; Regional Hospital, Cork, first proposed in 1934, and the Cork Fever Hospital, first proposed in 1935. Well, now, he could talk himself out of that if he was here to do so, but he is not, and it will require all his eloquence.
As I have stated previously, the emergency did not stop them planning or getting ahead with leaving these projects in the position where I could say to a contractor "Go ahead and build." If they pursued these projects with the slightest modicum of sincerity or with any real desire or intention to provide these institutions, all I would have had to do would have been to advertise for contracts.
Comment on this
Would the Minister say what capital moneys were made available in 1932, '33, '34 and '35 from the hospitals' fund?
Comment on this
I will come to that later but I did not think that Fianna Fáil would stand in the way of providing moneys for hospitals. You had a Minister for Finance.
Comment on this
I know that but I will deal with that later. Another point to remember is that if these people had had any interest in the sick poor of this country or indeed the sick of any class in this country they would have done more than to go around the country, bleating and whining about the emergency. It is important to remember that 90 per cent. of the 1,200 beds that I provided in the last year or so were provided without the building of a single solitary hospital. The fact of the matter is that these beds were there if they were sufficiently interested or if they had bothered their heads to go and find them. The emergency did not stop them from providing these beds. I accept that explanation in regard to the building of hospitals but not in regard to supplying of these beds which were there for the taking.
Deputy Dr. Ryan asked me a number of questions but he has not had sufficient interest in the answers to remain and hear them. He made a number of statements which were in the best traditions of the Deputy Dáil Reporter. One for instance was in regard to Castlerea which he emphatically reiterated in spite of my pointing out to him that he was telling lies.
Comment on this
I pointed out to him that he was making a mistake and he had not even the good grace to withdraw it. In regard to Castlerea he said that all I had to do was to go down there, that he had completed all the preliminary negotiations, and all I had to do was to go there and tie up all the loose ends. That is—and I state it again for a second time because he made the same statement last year— at complete variance with the truth. The fact of the matter is that the only approach made to the local authority in regard to the Castlerea institution was made by me following the taking over of Deputy Ryan's position.
He asked about various places throughout the country at which projects had been dreamed about, thought about or planned about by him. One of these was in Sligo. The architect's plans for this building are nearing completion and the preparation of quantities will soon be put in hand. Tenders have only recently been received for the adaptations at Killybegs. In the case of Kilcreene, Kilkenny, this appears to have been a great worry to Deputy Derrig but it has not caused him half as much worry as it has to me. I have been to the house, acquired there during the office of Fianna Fáil, for the accommodation of tubercular patients. I cannot recall at the moment how much was paid for it but I presume it was bought in good faith. When, however, I saw it, I took one look at it and even to my completely amateur eye I could see what an unsuitable building it was. The whole roof has a pagoda-like look about it, completely U-shaped. Having seen the outside I went upstairs and saw that the explanation was that the roof was collapsing due to the fact that there is worm in it. That would not be very good buying.
In regard to Peamount, he was wondering about the beds there. At present they have been completed and are occupied. In the case of Newcastle they will be ready by September. In St. Laurence's Hospital, the beds are at present occupied, and similarly in Our Lady of Lourdes. These are all projects which have been completed in recent months. Deputy Derring and Deputy Dr. Ryan made reference to the fact that I seemed to spend more time and to be more concerned with the treatment of disease rather than with its prevention. There is an obvious enough answer to that. It is quite useless to set about the prevention of disease which already exists. Quite obviously, I must occupy a large part of my time in dealing with the hospital and sanatorium needs of the country for the people who are actually sick at the moment. No prevention in the world is going to help them much. The Deputies were not completely accurate, because, as I pointed out in my opening speech, we have set forward a scheme for prevention which was in operation—the use of B.C.G. vaccination. That is the vaccination for the prevention of tuberculosis in children, cases of contact, medical students, nurses and for all susceptible age groups. Similarly, in regard to diphtheria immunisation. By adjustments made last year in the payments to dispensary doctors, a considerable improvement has been shown in this important branch of preventive medicine. The figures are:—In 1946, 42,000 people were immunised; in 1947, 49,000 were immunised, and in 1948, 80,000 people were immunised. These figures show, I think, a very remarkable improvement, and I am sure that in future years it will pay great dividends in a falling off in the number of deaths from diphtheria.
Deputy Derring was critical of statements which I made about the continuation of pauperism in the health services of the country—of my criticism of Fianna Fáil for its continued existence. He said there was no pauperism in the health services of the country. But when I mentioned the question of getting rid of the red-ticket system, of which I have a considerable abhorrence, Deputy Burke said:—
"It is one system that I am delighted to see going. The public health dispensaries, one felt, always had the pauper feeling about them."
There is no doubt at all, of course, that the red-ticket system had rotten associations with which we can readily dispense.
There is one very important development in regard to the public assistance medical service, and that, of course, is in relation to St. Kevin's Hospital, Dublin. There are varying opinions about the services that are being provided there at the moment, but I think that as soon as the people of Dublin come to appreciate the very high standard of the medical and surgical services which have been provided there, and which will be further improved in the reasonably near future, they will understand that we will have in Dublin one of the finest municipal hospitals in Europe. This project was envisaged by the previous Government, and I think credit should go to them for that.
A group of medical consultant practitioners of the very highest grade gave considerable time and care to this whole question of the provision of a post graduate school at St. Kevin's. Having considered the problem over a long period, they submitted a report to me. I would like to take this opportunity of thanking those representatives of the medical profession for their public-spirited action in giving up so much of their valuable time to consider that, and in making these representations to me. It is always, of course, particularly satisfying to a Minister for Health to be able to have the services of these representative members of the consultant and specialist group in Dublin and in other cities to assist him in formulating his proposals for the betterment and improvement of the health services. It is proposed that a post-graduate school will be set up here, if the necessary legislation is enacted. Its purpose primarily will be to teach and give post-graduate education to the local authority medical officers only. This, of course, will not cut across any of the existing post-graduate courses at present being given by the different hospitals and medical schools in the country.
Recently we advertised for doctors, surgeons and specialists in bacteriology and pathology for this hospital. It, as Deputies are probably aware, serves practically entirely the poorer sections of the community in Dublin. The salaries which we are offering to these specialists are, I think, unprecedented in the whole local authority medical services. I am quite certain that we shall attract good, conscientious and efficient medical personnel. It will be the main duty of that personnel to serve the needs of the poorer classes in Dublin.
Deputy Derring is interested in the building programme. It may interest Deputies to know that we have divided up the programme with a view to showing the amount of money we propose to spend and the amount of building we propose to undertake in the next seven years. In 1949, that is, the present year, we propose spending £1,250,000; in 1950 we propose spending £2,750,000; in 1951 we propose spending £3,000,000; in 1952 we propose spending £3,750,000; in 1953 we propose spending £3,000,000; in 1954 we propose spending £2,250,000, and in 1955 we propose spending £1,500,000. That is a total of £17,500,000 which we propose spending over the next seven years on these projects which I have already laid before the House.
Deputy Derring was anxious to know what exactly had been done in the building line. To the uninitiated, and even to the most ignorant layman, it is quite obvious that this amount of building could not have been done at once. A number of building projects of a temporary nature have been carried out. In Castlerea a 120-bed nurses' home was erected in approximately four months. I must here pay tribute to the Irish building industry which was able to provide that accommodation in such a short time. In Castlerea, also, a 100-bed domestic staff home was provided.
Deputy Mrs. Rice and most of the other Deputies who spoke in the debate referred to the problem of Irish nurses generally. I think everybody must be aware of my views in regard to the nursing profession. I believe these women make the greatest contribution to the national life and to the health of the community. From my experience of them as doctor, patient, layman, Minister and everything else, I believe they take the highest place in the community in close association with, of course, the nursing sisters. For hundreds of years back these nursing sisters have laid the foundations and built up the traditions of the nursing profession to-day. In every country in the world these nursing sisters have nursed the sick in flood, famine, pestilence and poverty. To them we owe the magnificent standards we have to-day in this profession, standards based on Christian principles and closely associated with its very much younger offshoot, the lay nursing profession.
Deputy Byrne (Junior) suggested that the nursing profession was shortsighted because it did not form a trade union. He suggested that they would thereby lose. I am afraid I do not completely agree with him in that point of view. The most effective weapon the trade union has—and a justifiable weapon from the trade union point of view—is the strike weapon. That, of course, would be quite out of bounds in either the nursing or the medical profession. I sincerely hope that we shall never, no matter what Government is in power, attach so little importance to nurses and the nursing profession as to force them into a position where they might feel that serious action was required——
Comment on this
I think the problem of the nursing shortage is not as serious as some would lead us to believe. Certainly we have not found it so up to the present. We have made representations to local authorities asking them to pay particular regard to the living, working and recreation facilities provided for nurses.
It is well to remember that we in the Department of Health have no responsibility whatsoever for nurses in either voluntary hospitals or nursing homes. In the majority of the voluntary hospitals I think the girls are treated reasonably well. In some of them I do not think they are treated particularly well. All I can do in the Department of Health is to try to set a headline which, I hope, will be followed by these other organisations' institutions.
Comment on this
In that nurses' home in Castlerea—these may be small things, but they are important—we have given each of the girls separate bedrooms and recreation rooms, visiting rooms, lecture rooms and all these other things which make life more pleasant and comfortable for them and which will encourage them to appreciate that we are giving them here as good and better conditions than they are likely to get anywhere else.
Comment on this
Quite a number of girls are coming back these days and taking up positions in our hospitals.
Deputy Briscoe is interested in the Dublin hospitals with which he is associated in a number of ways and he is anxious to know the building programme for Dublin. It comprises a new St. Vincent's Hospital at Elm Park, a Coombe Hospital at Donore Avenue, St. Laurence's Hospital, which we propose to start in the seven-year programme, Crumlin Children's Hospital, Dublin Fever Hospital, a genito-urinary unit at the Meath Hospital and infants' units at the Rotunda and the Coombe and the National Maternity Hospital, giving a total of approximately 1,400 beds.
With regard to a number of these projects, progress is quite satisfactory. In respect of a number of these I felt that faster progress would be made if I removed Departmental control entirely from them and what I have done is to allocate a certain amount of money and thereafter we in the Department have no functions whatsoever beyond ensuring that when the hospital is built the number of beds which we have budgeted for is provided for my particular responsibility, the local authority patient. This has had useful results, particularly in regard to the Crumlin Children's Hospital.
We have done this also in regard to St. Vincent's Hospital. The amount of money is, so far as I recollect, something in the region of £1,000,000, which we have promised to the promoting body, merely asking that at the end of the time they should provide approximately 450 beds. That is the project which was first started in 1935. I hope that Deputies Briscoe and Byrne, who are interested in these hospital projects, will use their enthusiasm and interest to encourage the promoting bodies to proceed as rapidly as possible. There can be no blame attached to the Department; there can be no question of red, white or green tape. These projects are handed over lock, stock and barrel to the promoting authorities and the speed is entirely their responsibility.
In regard to the money for these projects, the present capital of the Hospitals' Trust Fund is approximately £10,000,000. Over the next seven years interest will bring in another £1,000,000 approximately, and further sweeps will give us £6,000,000, making a total of £17,000,000. Liabilities are grants amounting to £14,000,000 and the deficits approximately £3,000,000. The grants of £14,000,000 will leave approximately £3,500,000 to be found by the various promoting authorities. When the fund is exhausted, we can hope that the sweeps money will continue to flow in and in that way finance any deficits and new building.
Comment on this
Does the Minister find that these figures tally? He refers to capital £10,000,000, interest £1,000,000, anticipations from future sweeps £6,000,000, making a total of £17,000,000, On the other side we have earmarked grants £14,000,000 and deficit £3,500,000, making a total of £17,500,000. The Minister said there was a further deficit of £3,000,000. How does that arise? Maybe I misunderstood.
Comment on this
I mentioned that £3,500,000 will have to be by way of contribution. I said £14,000,000 will be available for grants and £3,500,000 will be available from the promoting authorities. For certain of these projects grants of 60 per cent., 70 per cent. and 80 per cent. will be given.
With regard to dispensaries, which seem to have worried a number of Deputies, they also have been a cause of concern to us in the Department. The position is this, that the standard of the dispensary premises is the complete responsibility of the local authority. We have no functions at all and give no grants at all to the reconditioning of dispensary premises. We have made representations on a number of occasions to different local authorities asking that they should attempt to bring up the standard of accommodation provided in these dispensaries to reasonable conditions. We can only hope that the Deputies who are members of local authorities will use their influence to encourage a little more consciousness of the importance of good appearance, cleanliness and reasonable working conditions for the doctors in the dispensaries which are their responsibility.
Deputy MacEntee had a wonderful time in the Rotunda Gardens. Deputy Vivion de Valera was also interested but I think, quite honestly, and quite sincerely, was not aware of all the facts in connection with that particular case. The history of this is, of course, that the site was given over for the project of a memorial park by the Rotunda authorities. I do think it is a very sad commentary on a Deputy of Deputy MacEntee's age and associations that he would in this House use that period and the efforts and sacrifices of the men of that period to attempt to score a small petty point in Party politics. I find it difficult as a junior member of this House to understand a mentality of that kind. Perhaps it is best to pass over Deputy MacEntee and to deal with the point of the Rotunda Gardens.
This project, of course, is not aimed at the destruction of the plans to provide a memorial park. As it happens, I have consulted the members of the Old I.R.A., who are particularly concerned, and have been concerned for a number of years, in the forwarding of this project. It was very touching indeed to see the concern of these men to assist us in the provision of this hospital. It is, of course, not a clinic or a dispensary, but a temporary hospital for the use of children in the neo-natal period, just after being born. It is one of three projects, each one of which is associated with our maternity hospitals and that might explain to Deputy Vivion de Valera, who, I think, was a little confused about the problem, why this particular site, of the sites available throughout Dublin City, was chosen. The important thing about these hospitals, one at the National Maternity Hospital, one at the Coombe and one at the Rotunda Hospital, is, of course, that we will have the advantages of these very famous maternity hospitals and the excellent service they can provide for us. I think Deputy Vivion de Valera was also confused in that he thought this was to be a tuberculosis clinic. That is not so. It is for children who might be dangerously ill in the first few months of their lives and quite obviously, if we can have for these children in the first few dangerous months of their lives the services of the staffs of these world famous maternity hospitals, it will be a tremendous contribution towards the protection of the lives of these young children. It is a purely temporary arrangement and there is no question of the indefinite postponement of the memorial park project.
Deputy Vivion de Valera also mentioned the question of athletics. Really, of course, it does not come into my Estimate at all and I have no functions in regard to the question of athletics beyond saying that, as Minister for Health, I fully appreciate the tremendous advantages which would be gained by more and more of the youth of our country taking, not a spectator's interest, but a contestant's interest in athletics generally. A number of organisations are working very hard to promote an interest in athletics in school children and young adults and such organisations are playing a very important part in this very laudable project.
A number of Deputies were concerned about the mother and child services—Deputy Maguire, Deputy Dr. Ryan, Deputy Derrig and Deputy Mrs. Rice. The mother and child service is a tremendously important and a very big project indeed. To say that it could have been introduced in a few months is, of course, arrant nonsense and nobody knows that better than Deputy Dr. Ryan. I completely agree with the project but have no intention of being panicked into bringing into operation a scheme which might not be capable of giving me the results which I require, that is, the protection of the mother in the period of maternity and of the child in its childhood and early adolescence to the age of 15 or 16. There are a number of different interests which must be consulted. Consultant councils set up by me worked extremely hard and provided a scheme, first of all, for Dublin and, secondly, for rural areas. The Dublin scheme has been examined by me and my Department and is now with, and has been examined by, the other Departments concerned. It is a very big scheme and will cost a lot of money. The Dublin scheme alone will cost anything between £250,000 and £750,000.
Comment on this
Yes. Quite obviously it would be very wrong of me to put a burden such as that upon the people if I were not quite happy in my mind that they were going to get some worthwhile results from it, and that it would be useful in reducing our too high mortality figures.
Comment on this
Is it proposed that this money should be spent by the local authority or the national Exchequer?
Comment on this
That depends. The Deputy knows the Health Services (Financial Provisions) Act. Anyway, the details have not been finally worked out and we shall have an opportunity of discussing them later.
Comment on this
That is another story. In regard to the question of tuberculosis, a number of questions were asked and I shall deal with the matter shortly. I, of course, have absolutely no apology whatsoever to offer for my preoccupation with this problem in the last year or two. I had to deal with something which was neglected for a decade and a half. This is quite obvious from the fact that, in the previous 16 years, as I mentioned in reply to a Parliamentary question, only 690 odd beds were provided by the Opposition Party when they were in office. This left us with a totally inadequate number for the needs of the country. Twelve hundred beds in different places have been provided in the last 16 months and, of course, there is no question of the abandonment of any of the regional sanatoria. Deputy Dunne referred to the Abbotstown Regional Sanatorium. The position in regard to that is that we have agreed upon a site plan and the civil engineers are at present getting out the drawings. They hope to be finished in a short time and the site works will commence before the end of the year. The same progress has been made in regard to Sarsfield Court in Cork. The site plan has been approved and the civil engineers are now working on the engineering drawings preparatory to taking out quantities and starting the civil development work. Again I hope it will be possible to start that project this year.
In regard to the question of speed, if we look at the progress made in regard to Santry Court, and start at the same stage in regard both to Sarsfield Court and Abbotstown, we have every reason to believe that we shall have reached the tendering stage for these two projects at least two months more quickly than the time taken in regard to Santry Court. That is taking the time between the commencement of the outline schedule and the taking out of quantities. We hope even to improve on that time. Deputy Corry can rest assured that we shall get on that site as quickly as possible and there will be very little delay. In addition, of course, we have the building of the sub-regional sanatorium at Ardkeen, in Waterford, which was not envisaged at all by the previous Government. In that case, tenders have been asked for and building work will commence in the next few months. Similarly, in regard to Limerick Regional Hospital the site works have been completed and quantities are being taken out. Galway Central Hospital has had a very chequered career, starting in 1931. We have also had to work particularly hard in regard to that hospital as it is badly needed. We are working to see that that building will also be commenced by the end of this year. Deputy McGrath blames the Department for the delay in the building of the regional hospital in Cork. He said that the plans were with us and asked would we make haste with them. That is not so. The plans are at present in Cork and I hope he will make haste with them. In regard to Gurranebraher Fever Hospital, I hope we shall be able to start also on that in the next couple of months. There is no reason now why it should be utilised for fever purposes. It is up to the damp course level and it is merely a question of finishing it off and using it for some purpose other than that for which it was originally intended. I understand that it is proposed to use it for the treatment of tuberculosis. There will be no need to use it for fever owing to the reduction in the incidence of fever throughout the country.
Comment on this
I referred to the cancer position when the Deputy was not here. The position is that the report has been submitted to me—it arrived to-day, as a matter of fact—and we shall act on it without delay.
Comment on this
I should like to ask the Minister whether the quarrel or disagreement between the contractors and officials of his Department in connection with the building of the huts at Mallow has reached a satisfactory conclusion or not. There are 20 beds there that could be occupied by patients for the last 14 months if these two military huts had been provided for the accommodation of the nurses.
Comment on this
Deputy Byrne was interested in the question of children suffering from pulmonary and non-pulmonary tuberculosis. The position is that development work on the Ballyowen children's hospital has already begun. That hospital will provide accommodation for approximately 250 children. Of course, there is also the Foynes children's hospital. That was an overnight hostel for visitors from all parts of the world. It is a very lovely and excellent building which was put up regardless of cost. It is very pleasant to think that the sick children of Ireland will be restored to health in that institution and will get the benefit of money spent for quite a different purpose in the last ten years.
With regard to Deputy Corry's question about the Mallow hospital, the position there is that we were very anxious that the wages variation clause should be insisted upon so that if there was a fall in building costs we would get the benefit from the contractor. That caused a certain amount of delay.
Comment on this
Will the Minister give consideration to the question of the district hospital in Mitchelstown?
Comment on this
May I ask the Minister if he intended to suggest in his opening speech that the architects and engineers whom he found in his Department when he took over had, in fact, made no substantial progress with the plans for hospitals? He said that there was not a scrap of paper with any plan in it.
Comment on this
No. A number of Deputies referred to the Civil Service generally and to the staff of my Department. The architects in my Department do not draw up plans, except in regard to sanatoria; they approve of plans. The promotion of the different projects is in the hands of the local authorities and the speed at which the Department works depends largely on the Minister. I personally have received complete co-operation and considerable help and assistance from the members of the staff in my Department. At no time have they attempted to obstruct or interfere with my work.
Comment on this
We only approved of the site plan in the last few weeks for both of these institutions.
Comment on this
I tried to cover most of the points raised by Deputies but, as I said, they were so numerous and various that I may have omitted to deal with some of them.
Comment on this
Will the Minister deal, by communicating with me, with the question I raised on the matter of diet and so forth?
Comment on this
I will. I am always at the disposal of Deputies on either side of the House if there is any suggestion they have to make which they feel may lead to the improvement or betterment of our health services. I am very glad to have the assistance of the medical members of the House and also the lay members in giving me some idea of the reactions throughout the country to our suggestions and plans for the improvement of the general health of the people.