Industrial Development Authority Bill, 1949—Second Stage (Resumed).
Contributions 1–151 of 292. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 21 of 1949 ›
The first news the country got of this so-called Industrial Development Authority was about this time last year. It was announced publicly after we had a debate here in the Dáil on the reduction in the Road Fund grants to the local authorities. It was also shortly after the news broke that the miracle workers who had got in and promised that they were to employ every person looking for employment within 24 hours that instead of employing them, they had to send them out of the country. The news that in 1948, the first year the Coalition Government was in office, nearly 13,000 people had emigrated as against the 11,000, more who came back than went out in 1947——
Comment on this
They decided that they would have to do something about it, that if they had not started industry in the first year of office they would have to pretend that they were going to start it in the future. Some of the small Parties were insistent that the Minister should do something that would give them the excuse of telling their constituents that something was going to be done; that they would press for something to be done. The Minister, I am sure, had various questions put to him from various members of the Coalition somewhat similar to the question put to-day by Deputy Flanagan and the Minister thought that the best way out of that situation was to put himself out of power to do anything particular about it, to pass the buck to this so-called Industrial Development Authority, and he proceeded to do it.
It is certainly a handy thing for a Minister who does not want to act up to the responsibilities of his office to be in a position to blame somebody else for his own lack of activity.
The sort of world which we are living in to-day demands something more from a Government than care about their own political future. We know that a Government which wanted to tackle the situation to-day, wanted to put our people in a position in which they could survive and prosper reasonably well during the times that are ahead, would have to take risks, that Ministers would have to take risks and would have to do a bit of work. If we were back in the leisurely times of 50 years ago, we could afford to set up another tariff commission. But we are not in a situation in which, if we concentrate on producing more bullocks, as the Minister for Agriculture has been doing, we can sell them in Britain and get the dollars we want to buy wheat or the industrial products that we require. At the present time, Europe is getting a large hand-out of dollars from the United States. We are borrowing dollars to import commodities, industrial and agricultural, that we should be producing within our own shores. If the Minister and the Deputies associated with him in the present Coalition Government had been active in promoting industry during the last two years, we would now be in a much better position to face 1952 when the supply of dollars will be running out.
We cannot afford the leisurely pace that the Minister is indicating for the promotion of industry. From an economic and social point of view, we cannot afford to tell people, when they make a proposition for an industry, that it is going to be examined by a new tariff commission. The people had enough of that when the Cumann na nGaedheal Government was in office. In my constituency, the result was to close down several factories. Surely the members of the Coalition, if they have any thought for the welfare of the people, will not encourage the Minister to set up this new body. We know that it is difficult to get decisions taken by Governments, that there is a long process between the making of a suggestion and reaching the stage of practical proposals. Surely we should try to short-cut all these stages instead of adding, as in this case, a further stage.
The Department of Industry and Commerce will no longer initiate proposals. That job is being put into the hands of the new tariff commission, misnamed an industrial development authority. The Department of Industry and Commerce will not have the job of thinking over the problems of the State, seeing where we are weak industrially, where there are possibilities of new industries, and then getting after the job themselves. According to this Bill, that is to be given into the hands of this new tariff commission. These people will not have any real authority. They will have authority to investigate, but they will have no authority to act, to see that steps are taken to promote industry, and that is what the country requires.
Deputy Larkin pointed out that, to the extent that this authority was to examine every suggestion for tariffs or revision of tariffs, it was going to detract from its ability to do the thinking necessary for the formation of a general all-over programme of industrial development. We all know that to be true. If Clann na Poblachta and the Labour Party had their way, I have no doubt that this is not the type of body they would propose. For a long time, both of them have been advocating the setting up of an economic council which would take under review our industrial position, and make suggestions for its improvement. But that is not to be the function of this body. It has all these other things tacked on to it; it has tacked on to it work that the Minister himself should be doing.
What does the Minister envisage as a result of the setting up of this new body? Will he relate it to the actual situation in regard to output of industrial commodities or to employment? In the year 1948, the year for which we have the latest figures, 12,793 more people went out of the country than came into it, in spite of what the Minister and Deputies now associated with him stated about emigration. We know that emigration is a grave evil. In the last year of office of the Fianna Fáil Government we had immigration into this country instead of emigration.
Comment on this
In the previous 15 years we had cut down the rate of emigration, with the exception of the war years, very much below what it was under the Cumann na nGaedheal régime.
Comment on this
In 1948, when the Minister had the chance of putting into operation his dictum that everybody who sought remunerative employment could be put into that employment within 24 hours, instead of taking that chance and putting these people into employment, he put them on the boat.
Comment on this
It was not we who turned the labour exchanges into recruiting agencies for the British.
Comment on this
The Minister indicated in outlining his policy that he was going to turn them into recruiting agencies for work in Ireland within 24 hours. Instead of that, he put the unemployed on the boat.
Comment on this
The Minister is always looking for excuses for his own failures. He said he would put all these people into employment. Instead of doing that, he shipped 24,000 of them out of the country. This Bill is yet another alibi for the Minister. If this Bill goes through, he will be able to blame, not only Fianna Fáil, but the Industrial Development Authority as well.
Deputy Larkin stated in the course of his speech that Fianna Fáil's success in developing industry had added to the difficulties of the present Minister in promoting new industries now. I do not agree with Deputy Larkin in that, but that is what he said. We all know that the inherent difficulty in promoting industry of any kind in 1932 was that there was no industrial skill or technical skill in the country. Every new industry Fianna Fáil established and it established many of them, added to the general pattern of industrial skill and industrial development. When one kills an industry, one kills not only the particular industry itself but one also destroys the possibility of having available the knowledge the technicians in that industry possess. The more industries that are established, the easier it will be to forge ahead in promoting other industries. We all know what happens in other countries. It happened here, too. When technicians have a problem, they like to discuss that with those in unlike industries as well as with those in like industries in an effort to find out a solution to their particular difficulty. Deputy Larkin was, therefore, quite wrong when he said that Fianna Fáil's success in establishing many new industries now rendered the present Minister's task more difficult. It makes the Minister's task much easier.
There is, of course, the unfortunate position that the Deputies who form the Coalition had to take into their ranks a man like the present Minister for Agriculture, a man who had denounced Irish industry and who merely wanted us to act as a counter over which to pass the goods manufactured in the four corners of the earth. It is a very severe handicap to the Coalition in the promotion of industry, should they wish to promote industry, that they are dependent for their remaining in power upon a man who denounced everybody who put a penny into Irish industry as a "tariff racketeer."
Comment on this
I would say that he is responsible to a very large extent for certain elements in the Bill. He is responsible for putting into it those clauses which turn this body into a new tariff commission to act as a delay and a brake on the establishment of industry rather than as a means of promoting industry. Not only has the present Government, by its attitude, delayed the development of industry but they have also, in their frantic efforts to be different from Fianna Fáil, destroyed industries which Fianna Fáil had established or promoted. No later than last Saturday there was an advertisement in the public Press for the disposal of machines for which Fianna Fáil had gone to the extent of making dollars available for their purchase at a time when dollars were scarce. Fianna Fáil encouraged Córas Iompair Éireann to start a chassis factory here for the purpose not only of manufacturing chassis here but also for the purpose of employing a number of people skilled in heavy engineering.
Comment on this
Surely, there was a long debate recently on Córas Iompair Éireann and that does not arise again now.
Comment on this
There was an announcement in the Press last Saturday to the effect that the machinery imported in order to establish a heavy engineering industry here was to be sold. What is happening to the premises? Instead of using those machines for the manufacture of heavy industrial equipment in those premises, the premises are being used as warehouses for foreign machinery at the present time.
Comment on this
I would rather be dumb than have a big mouth with which to say the wrong words. To what extent does the Minister expect this new organisation will advise the Government on an industry such as tourism? Will it undo some of the damage caused by the Minister for External Affairs by his opening his mouth when he should have been dumb? Will it undo the damage done to the tourist traffic when he said we should put a tax on tourists, and when he described them as nothing but "spivs" coming in here to eat our food?
Comment on this
The Minister for External Affairs proposed here that we should put a tax on tourists.
Comment on this
I do not propose to do so but I would like to refer briefly to tourism in relation to this authority. I ask the Minister will he, under subsection (8) of Section 3, request the Industrial Authority to advise him in regard to tourism? Is that an industry? Another matter is, will the Minister ask them to advise him on air transport? He cannot now take back the planes which were bought with scarce dollars and sold for pounds sterling.
Comment on this
He might at least ask this new organisation to advise him as to whether he should, even now, go ahead with air transport.
Comment on this
If the Deputy wants me to go into that I shall gladly do so on another occasion. It would give me the greatest of pleasure.
Comment on this
The Minister is always willing to go into ticklish questions on another occasion, just as he will pass Deputy Flanagan on to the Industrial Authority.
Comment on this
I am replying to the Minister's interjections and I am sorry if they take me away from the Bill. We had a long speech from Deputy Lehane and also a long speech from Deputy Larkin. They stated that it was impossible to get ahead with the development of industry under our existing capitalist system. They wanted to do away with the profit motive. As far as I know, the profit motive is in operation even in Russia, where they have the Stakanovite movement that if you do more work you get more pay—more profit. Those two gentlemen want us to start a new experiment even after it has failed in Russia, with all the power the central Government there has. I think they should take another look at that situation and see whether they are not a little bit out of step even with the people far away.
Deputy Larkin said that this measure is one more step towards planning. Perhaps that is what sold the Bill to him. What sold it to the Minister for Agriculture is that it would stop industrial development until the same procedure was gone through that used to be gone through by the Tariff Commission—that they spent years inquiring into fiddle-fals, small imports of a few thousand pounds in value. It took them years, often at great expense to the State, to see whether or not they could put a few per cent. tariff on the commodity in question. If this country is to make progress we want—instead of Bills such as this in which Ministers pass their responsibility on to some people who are not directly responsible to the Dáil—action from the particular Ministers involved. If they make mistakes, well it cannot be helped. In all the other countries of Europe you have, instead of new tariff commissions being appointed, the Department of State charged with the responsibility for the promotion of industry, in constant and daily touch with all elements in the economic life of the country. Not only do they not discourage industrialists by calling them racketeers, but they give them all sorts of encouragement—by word of mouth, by State grants, by advice, by marketing arrangements and help in marketing. While that is going on in the countries which will be our competitors for very scarce dollars, we here are calmly going to set up a new tariff commission which will take months and months, and perhaps years, to examine a thing that should be dealt with by the Minister and his staff in a few moments.
One of the great pleas of the Parties forming the Coalition in the old days was that we should have less Ministers and, of course, that the Ministers should be paid very much less.
Comment on this
We have here in this Bill four gentlemen who will be getting the salaries of Ministers but without the responsibility. They will be in addition to the couple of other Ministries which were put on foot by the Coalition which was going to cut them down——
Comment on this
The fact that four gentlemen would be getting the salaries of Ministers is certainly relevant because their names are in this particular Bill. The Minister might explain how it is that he has suddenly become more expansive at the expense of the public purse.
Comment on this
The Argentine wheat put the Minister in a position to fill the ration and without it he would have had to cut down the ration. I do not know why the Minister is talking about Argentine wheat because he has passed that particular part of his work on to the Minister for Agriculture. He is no longer responsible for wheat importation. It is another of the responsibilities which the Minister has shed—and the Minister for Agriculture, as soon as he gets the responsibility for the importation of wheat, starts to import oats from the Argentine.
Comment on this
I quite agree with you. The Minister claimed that this Bill was a new conception. It is not a new conception. It is an old conception of the wrong type and it is too late, I suppose, to hope that the members of the Coalition Parties will recognise it as such and do something to fulfil the promises they made to the people—and which, indeed, were made by the Minister himself—that all possible steps would be taken to promote industry quickly. The Minister has claimed that in the past couple of years there were additions to the number of people employed in factories. That is no thanks to him. They were employed in the factories which were promoted by Fianna Fáil from 1932 to 1948. Even if the Minister had gone away on a holiday for the two years, and stayed away, and the Department of Industry and Commerce had closed down, those factories would have gone on. It was inevitable that the impetus given to the promotion of industry during the Fianna Fáil régime would carry forward into the time when the new Government took over.
Comment on this
The footwear factories in Louth are employing thousands whereas, when Fianna Fáil came into office, the only footwear factory in the place was shut down.
Comment on this
They were closed down simply because the Minister did his utmost to close some of them down by allowing in a whole flood of imports.
Comment on this
Roughly the situation in regard to that particular industry was that when Fianna Fáil came into office the one little factory there was had closed down whereas, when we left office, about 1,600 people were in full employment in that industry. What we want to know is why, in the last couple of years, have more factories not been opened in Louth and other places like it throughout the country? We are glad to welcome some of the changes that have been indicated by some of the members of the Coalition. I understand from the Minister for Agriculture's secret organ —to which he gave a secret interview a couple of weeks ago—that he is not going to put beet up the spout. If he did, of course, that would close down remunerative employment, not only for the people engaged in the factories, but those engaged on the land.
If the Coalition groups have the power to persuade the Minister for Agriculture to swallow a good deal of what he said in the past, why can they not get him to swallow some of what he said about industries? Why cannot they get him to give expression to at least some of the praise that is due to the people who risked their money in industries here rather than export it? It was pathetic to see the Minister for Industry and Commerce going over to New York, asking Americans to come over here to invest money in Irish industry and to bring over skilled operatives for the promotion of Irish industry while at the same time others of his colleagues were denouncing those who invested a shilling or a dollar in Ireland and co-operating in sending a number of technicians who had been engaged here in air development to the ends of the earth. What we want is not so much American capital, American industrialists or American technicians, as to get our own capital invested here so that our own technicians can remain here to develop our industries and to train other people for the building up of industry in the future. It is unfortunate that we suffer at present from the handicap that a few industries started by Fianna Fáil were smashed by Fine Gael. However, the country would get over that in time if there was some clear indication from the Government that they are in earnest at this stage and that in future, no matter what they have done in the past, they are going to give every help and encouragement to the Irish people to invest their money in Ireland and to Irish technicians to remain at home in the hope and expectation that they will find reasonable employment for their talents in this country.
Comment on this
The debate on this Bill on Second Reading, so far as I have listened to it and read the reports, has been most disappointing. It appears to have become an order of the House that in order to be interesting one must be irrelevant. The Opposition have indulged in these tactics to such an extent that the whole tone of the debate has been lowered to a level which one would think it could hardly touch on a subject of this importance. This is an important question and this is an important Bill, whether one is opposed to it or whether one is in favour of it wholeheartedly or in a modified degree. The tactic of the Opposition, however, on an industrial Bill is to attack the Minister for Agriculture. Evidently on a Bill dealing with agricultural produce the proper tactic will be to cast some aspersions on the Minister for External Affairs or to try to bring into disrepute the Minister for Industry and Commerce. The whole debate, from beginning to end, has been studded with interruptions. I may say that even members on the Government Benches were rather inclined to aid the Opposition by studding the contribution of Deputy Lemass with a mass of irrelevancies. I had hoped that we would have had heard a contribution from him that might enable us to examine the whole economics and political outlook of Fianna Fáil. As this has been rendered so difficult, I am sure other Deputies as well as myself would be very much inclined to curtail their contributions to this debate.
Frankly, I am at a loss to understand what is the fundamental objection of the Opposition to this Bill. We can dismiss very lightly the contribution of Deputy Aiken and others because there does not appear to be any great substance in their arguments. Their arguments are merely intended to cause a bit of a flurry or to give us a bit of excitement in the Dáil but they did not get down to the real fundamental question that concerns the House on this Bill. Deputy Lemass, as Deputy-Leader of the Opposition, and as one who has been charged in the past with control and the expansion of Irish industry made a contribution that is naturally worthy of consideration. His chief objection to my mind seems to be that the wonderful hierarchy of bureaucracy established under his jurisdiction in the Department of Industry and Commerce, is now being split up and dispersed into several distinct units and transferred to other Ministries, so that if ever he is fortunate enough to resume the position which he vacated and become once again Minister for Industry and Commerce, he will find it very difficult to recognise that overgrown Department which was the admiration of those who believed in bureaucracy in this country.
On the one hand, we have Deputy Lemass trouncing the Minister for putting brakes on the development of Irish industry, on its expansion, setting up, as he says, another Department. What is it, he asks, but a section of the Department of Industry and Commerce transferred from Kildare Street to St. Stephen's Green? It is true they have some officers of the section of the Department of Industry and Commerce, and in so far as that is correct it may be said that this is a section of the old Department transferred to new quarters. He says that here, in a new house, they will have much the same function as they had hitherto of examining proposals to develop Irish industry, examining questions relating to tariffs, licences and such matters of that sort but, he says, that there they will act as a brake. They will act as a brake on the forward movement and impetus of the development of Irish industry. This, he says, is zero hour, and we cannot afford any brake on the efforts of Irish industrialists to make up the leeway that has to be made up in Irish industry, and to bring us somewhat nearer the balance between agriculture and industry that obtains in other countries. That would appears to be a reasonable objection but when you come to examine another part of the speech he calls for an analysis of unemployment in this country, which he says has never before been attempted. He asks:
"If it is required to have this analysis in order to know what native power we have, should we not organise another Government Department and tell them to go ahead and concentrate on that and nothing else?"
This appears to me to be a fundamental contradiction. On the one hand, he objects to the establishment of the new body as a brake on industry, and immediately after, he calls for the establishment of yet another Government Department to carry out a certain specific task. Frankly, I cannot see any logic in that, nor can I see logic in most of the other points made by the same Deputy. He tells us that we have not time, that we cannot proceed at the leisurely pace at which we might have proceeded 50 years ago, but when it comes to a question of this body which has been established and for the establishment of which sanction is asked, he finds it entirely unreasonable that the body should have been established 12 months ago and that the Minister should now ask the House to give legal effect to its establishment. Obviously you cannot have it both ways.
If we are in such a hurry, if we are in such a rush to get on with industrial development, should the Deputy-Leader of the Opposition not have praised the Minister for taking time by the forelock and establishing this body without waiting for legal sanction in order that it might put in 12 months of preparatory analytical work which any body would require to carry out before setting about its business? Why then, on the other hand, be filled with impatience because the industrialisation of the country is being held up by reason of the fact that a body has been established which will examine every plan and proposal put before it for the correct industrialisation of the country and, on the other hand, denounce the Minister for having established that body and having put it into harness without waiting for this House to give legal sanction to it through its slow methods?
I expected an entirely different type of argument in relation to this Bill. This body, as everyone knows, had its origin in a great deal of thought put into the matter by members of the Labour Party many years ago. It does not at all fulfil the conception the Labour Party had of a national economic council. It is hardly to be expected that a Coalition Government would be likely to accept the view of one of the Parties to that Government without certain modifications and certain compromises; but this body, so far as we can read the main lines of its development, is a body which is in line with that original thought and conception. It is a body which has as its function the planning of industry—assisting in that plan and advising upon that plan, initiating schemes for the carrying out of that plan and generally doing part of the work that could be done by a national economic council, bearing in mind, as Deputy Lemass said, that, in the system of society which we have, the profit motive exists.
How any section of the Opposition, or the Opposition as a whole, can object to a development of this nature is very difficult to understand, because, under any system of government in the modern world, whether it is socialistic, totalitarian or democratic in character, that Government must have some type of body, some type of authority, which will act as a conductor acts in relation to an orchestra, will try to produce harmony amongst the different parts, will try to produce the maximum good for the greatest number of the people with whom it is concerned. On that basis, the Opposition should at least have been prepared to give this Industrial Development Authority a certain amount of latitude, should have been prepared to give it a trial and let us see how it would work out over a period of 12 months or so, instead of indulging in a viciousness of attack that has rarely been witnessed.
The outline of this type of organisation came many years ago from the Labour Party, and, even as recently as the emergency period, the Labour Party were so concerned about the lack of such a body that at one stage they thought a crisis had developed to an extent which required the recalling of the Dáil to try to grapple with these economic problems, which at that time were becoming more and more serious. A joint deputation of the Trade Union Congress and the Irish Labour Party was received by the various Ministers of the Fianna Fáil Government and though they indulged in a great deal of talk and although they saw the seriousness of the problem, they took no steps whatever to organise our economics as they should have been organised, to organise the things necessary for the welfare of this State which might have put us in a far better position to face the post-war period than we are in at present.
The Minister availed of the first opportunity—the occasion of the debate upon a motion by Deputy McAuliffe and myself calling for some investigation into the industrial resources of the country—to announce the establishment of this Industrial Development Authority. We cannot expect at this stage to say very much about that authority, except that, in its experimental stage, it should receive the greatest amount of co-operation from those who are sincerely anxious to achieve a greater industrial development in this country, and, as one of those who in the past had some regard for the industrialisation programme of Fianna Fáil, I expected that they would have received this Bill and the announcement of the establishment of this authority with a great deal more enthusiasm than they exhibited; but, evidently, personal vindictiveness and viciousness of attack which has become a sort of second nature to the Opposition have superseded the good sense they might have shown and have resulted in an attack upon the Bill which has to be met by something short of contempt.
The question which would confront one, were this Bill to be seriously considered, are to some extent indicated in the Minister's speech. He indicated, though not in any great detail, certain problems which affect this country and other countries in regard to the balance of agricultural and industrial development. He takes too much for granted a certain standard which obtains in European countries. For instance, he states that in this country less than one-fifth of the working population are engaged in industry, as compared with other countries in Europe where the pattern is that of approximately one-third being engaged in industry. It is unfortunate he did not apply a philosophic mind to that and expand on it. It might have done us a great deal more good than listening to the diatribes of the Minister for Agriculture and listening to talk about boot and shoe factories and Argentine wheat and many other irrelevancies which we had to endure.
While there is necessity for industrialisation, one could pause in that conception by considering to what extent we require it, what part this country has to play in the economy of Western Europe as a whole, and whether industrialisation—misdirected industrialisation—could not go too far. One must consider not only the advantages but the disadvantages. Everyone knows that industrial countries, particularly those which are highly industrialised, suffer very severely periodically from trade slumps, mounting unemployment, financial crises and the general economic aspects which result from that industrialisation. It is very unlikely that this country of ours will ever be over industrialised within the lifetime of the present or the next generation. Even though it is a remote possibility, it should be taken into consideration. I trust and hope that the members of this body will not be completely engrossed in their every-day affairs, examining what they will do with the 51,000 applications for duty-free licences, how they will regard an attempt to set up one industry here and another over there, and examining applications for this duty and that duty. I hope these members and the board as a whole will not be bogged down completely by the every-day routine, that they will have some time to take an overall view of industrial development here. I hope they will be guided by what they consider best for the economy of the country as a whole, that they will relate one industry to another and give due regard to the importance of some types of industry here.
I would specifically mention the necessity for a heavy industry. If we are to industrialise to the extent of anything approaching one third of our working population, that should be considered. There may be good reasons, there may be an administrative question which cannot be discussed properly on this Bill, and I do not propose to do it, but I have certain sympathy—and do not conceal it in the slightest—with the idea underlying the attacks of some of the members of the Opposition on the question of what happened to the classis industry in Córas Iompair Éireann. I think their idea may be misdirected, that they seized upon this merely for propaganda, related to one particular instance, that it had no relation to this question of heavy industry as a whole. Whether it was the right or the wrong thing to use that opportunity for initiating a heavy industry, there is a paramount necessity to provide one attached to our transport industry and to certain other industries. We cannot be continuously dependent upon cross-Channel sources of supply for steel to equip, feed and repair our industries here. Those who have the experience of going through the engineering shops of the Great Northern Railway in Dundalk or the Córas Iompair Éireann one as it was in Inchicore, understand the position. For instance, despite the fact that in the Great Northern Railway they were supposed to have a high standard of efficiency, their machine shops there were probably worse equipped than most of the minor industries in some of the backward States in the Baltic.
The whole scheme of engineering here seems to have been allowed to die out, as it was given no attention in the last 20 or 30 years. Some of those who would show a visitor around some of these works would appear to boast that they had such and such a machine in operation for the last 50 years, not knowing that modern science in application to industry had produced many more efficient machines, of types which would produce the goods in better quality and entail far less strenuous labour on the part of the operatives. That is one task which would confront this Industrial Development Authority. They should see that the industries which are at present established or are being established should be fed by a properly organised heavy industry, and that such a heavy industry would have no fear whatsoever for its existence or its paying capacity. It could rely upon the very substantial work that would come in from the transport side, apart from other State-aided concerns like the Electricity Supply Board, the Beet Sugar Company, industries connected with turf development, and so on. Each of these would give its quota to enable such a heavy engineering industry to develop and make progress. In that regard we have so little tradition south of the Border that it might be necessary to examine whether this can be done on private capital alone or would require State assistance.
Whichever way it is to be done, there is no reality whatsoever in a programme of industrial development here without some basis of a heavy industry, unless we accept some new standard of industrial philosophy. That new standard may be based exclusively upon the development of light industries and those which are independent of a heavy industry in this country and are dependent necessarily, therefore, on a heavy industry located in some country outside our jurisdiction. On that point, I think that one of the most constructive contributions was made by Deputy Vivion de Valera. It may not be quite relevant to the matter, but if you have not got a heavy industry there is no basis for an industry which will supply our Defence Forces. That is so broad a question, it leads one so far away from the Bill, that I do not intend to follow it.
This Bill, setting up the Industrial Development Authority, should commend itself to this House. It should be given a trial run. The Industrial Development Authority should be allowed to develop its activities. It should be given the complete assistance that is necessary for its success by all Parties of the House. I am perfectly certain that, as it will take into consideration the welfare of the workers engaged in the various new industries, it will receive quite considerable assistance and recommendation from the workers in the country.
Comment on this
Deputy Connolly has criticised the attitude of the Opposition in regard to this Bill. I think he should extend his criticism more to the Coalition side of the House. I remember, when reference was made to the proposed establishment of this Industrial Development Authority on the occasion of the presentation of the Minister's annual Estimate to the House, I characterised the idea as so much humbug. I have no reason to change my opinion since. Certainly, now that I have read the Bill, and listened to the speeches that have been made in the House in favour of the Bill, I am even more inclined to describe this piece of legislation as so much window dressing, just in keeping with the Government's general policy of trying to persuade the people that they are going to do things that they have no notion at all of doing.
One would imagine from the speeches we have heard from those Deputies who are trying to justify the introduction of this measure that we are on the threshold of a new industrial era. I only wish that that were the case. Having had experience of the policy of some of those Ministers who seem to dominate the Government of to-day as regards the industrialisation of this country, I am inclined to be very sceptical.
It is, I think, about ten months since this so-called Industrial Development Authority was set up and, after that length of time, we are presented with a measure for the implementation of the proposal made at that time—post factum legislation. It is very strange that this Industrial Development Authority have been, as we are told, working, making plans, surveying the industrial field, etc., over the past ten months and, in addition, that their conditions as regards status and remuneration had already been determined before there was any talk of introducing a Bill in the House. That appears to me to be a departure from the usual procedure when a Bill is introduced and all the provisions thereof in relation to whatever project it is intended to carry out are explained in detail to Deputies beforehand. Not merely has this Industrial Development Authority been in existence for the past ten months, not merely did the House not get any indication of the conditions of their appointment at the time, but we are still in doubt, even with the introduction of this measure, as to what their functions will be.
Comment on this
Táim chun tagairt a dhéanamh dos na haltanna, má leigtear dom dul chun chinn agus má tugtar caoí dom chun é a dhéanamh. I was saying before I was interrupted— to which interruption I have no objection since it comes in the Irish language—that we had no clear indication from the Minister of what the functions of this body would be, but we have here, at the same time, certain sections, to which reference should be made, containing what the Minister for Agriculture would describe as certain draconian powers that are being conferred upon them.
Comment on this
Certain draconian powers. In Section 5, the members of this authority are being given power to summon witnesses and to compel them to give evidence on oath as to the affairs of their business. I regard it as a rather serious step to take to give any such powers to a quasi-departmental body. Even a Minister of State with the authority he would have behind him should not have those powers.
Comment on this
These are powers that should not be exercised by anybody outside a court of justice and if, as Deputy Hickey seems to think, certain industrialists are outstepping their duty or in any way doing an injustice to the public, there should be some other way of dealing with them. I object to giving laymen on any commission of this kind such unlimited powers, and I think it is a very dangerous precedent to establish.
Comment on this
Deputy Davin made his contribution the other night and people on this side of the House did not interrupt him—although I have no objection to an interruption from Deputy Davin now and again provided it does not go too far.
Comment on this
I object to these powers being given to a lay body as they are dangerous. We have heard a good deal from Deputies opposite about the freedom they have established here. The Minister for Agriculture has been going around the country telling the people that they will not be interfered with in their business any more, while here we have a proposal to give power and authority to four individuals acting as a commission to probe into the most private and confidential secrets of people's business. If this is freedom I do not know what the meaning of the word is.
While penalties are provided by Section 5 for people who will not answer a summons by the members of this commission or who will not give evidence on oath or who will not do what they tell them, at the same time the members of the commission can make use of whatever information they get in whatever way they like without any penalty being imposed upon them. In other words, while it is stated in sub-section (11) of Section 4 that—
"No member shall disclose any information obtained by him in the exercise of his functions under this Act as to the private affairs of any person or business except in the course of a report of the authority to the Minister."
—there is no word about any penalty for any member of the commission who violates his duty in that respect. If, however, those people who are engaged in industrial pursuits are called upon to account for their business or any items of their business they must do so under penalty of being fined up to £50.
Comment on this
If they are serving the national interests they should be pleased to give all the evidence required.
Comment on this
If that is carried to a logical conclusion there will be no security in this country for anyone. We have heard a lot about that sort of thing in other places where totalitarian régimes were in operation. In my opinion this is bordering on totalitarianism.
Comment on this
Why did the Deputy not make that objection in 1947? Did the Deputy never hear of the Industrial Efficiency Bill? Did he never hear of such powers before?
Comment on this
I have never heard of anything like this. Nothing has been attempted like this in my opinion. Here is what the Minister himself said about it:—
"No Government Department has hitherto been asked to exercise the specific and comprehensive function assigned to the Industrial Development Authority."
Comment on this
He continued:—
"Nor has any Government Department been empowered to operate with the flexibility and independency allowed to that body by the Government."
I am quoting Volume 119, column 1594.
Comment on this
Would the Deputy quote the appropriate section of the Bill of 1947 which was introduced by his colleague? That quotation was a red herring.
Comment on this
What is the underlying motive and purpose of setting up this body? Is it to co-ordinate Irish industries? Is it to encourage people to invest their capital in new industries? We do not know. Is it to specify the type of industry that certain people will engage in? We do not know, but one thing is certain: no matter what this Industrial Development Authority does no person or group of persons will be inclined to invest their capital in industries here unless they see their way clearly before them.
Comment on this
In other words, unless a well thought out and clearly defined policy is conducted by the Government of the day. What has Deputy Hickey to say to that?
Comment on this
The Deputy should reflect on what Thomas Ashe and others said about investing money in this country.
Comment on this
I am trying to point out the conditions existing here and the conditions that could be regarded as a prerequisite for the success of an industrial policy here, that is, that the Government must have a sound industrial plan so that industrialists and those who might be inclined to invest money in Irish industry should be sure that there would be a continuity of policy from one Government to another, and that a change of Government would not bring about a change in the industrial policy.
Comment on this
There is no sabotage here. I am giving the House what in my opinion should be the conditions here which would invite people to take an interest in Irish industry and invest their capital in it. The Government should be sure of its policy and the conditions under which industrialists would start industries here should be a matter for the Government because, no matter what may be said about an outside body of this kind, the final decision as to the promotion of industries here should rest with the Government of the day.
Comment on this
If the final decision rests with the Government, I do not see what useful purpose this Industrial Development Authority would serve at all. Even in connection with technical advice, we see here that the members of the Development Authority will not be depended upon to give the technical advice. Section 6 sets out:—
"The Minister, with the consent of the Minister for Finance, may appoint such officers and servants as he thinks necessary to assist the authority in the performance of their functions."
In sub-section (3) the following appears:—
"The Minister, at the request of the authority and with the consent of the Minister for Finance, may appoint technical advisers to the authority and such advisers may be paid out of moneys provided by the Oireachtas such fees or other remuneration as the Minister, with the consent of the Minister for Finance, determines."
So that, in the matter of technical advice, this Industrial Development Authority is not being regarded as competent by the Minister himself. Would it not be just as well, and indeed more sensible for the Minister —whatever Minister would be in charge of the Department—if he and his officials got that technical advice directly and made use of it in their own Department? Here we have a roundabout device of doing business. The technical advice must be given to the members of this authority and they presumably will in turn pass on that advice to the Minister and his Department. In the end, probably before any decision is arrived at, the whole thing must be discussed by the Government, which should have collective responsibility to the people for the production and the direction of industrial policy.
Comment on this
I am not concerned at the moment about the Cork train; I am concerned with this Bill and I am trying to give the House my reasons for not accepting it. Deputy Connolly mentioned the word "bureaucracy". We have often heard that expression in the past. We have been told by certain politicians that the country has been overridden by bureaucracy. If bureaucracy has been in existence in this country, I am afraid that we are adding to it now, because this appears to me to be bureaucracy in excelsis. In other words, more and more people will be given the power to interfere in other people's business.
I wish now to refer to the possibility of relating our industrial policy to the needs of the Gaeltacht. I do not know whether I am hitching my wagon to a star when I mention that, but it appears to me that the time has come when we have to turn our attention to the industrialisation of the Gaeltacht with a view to establishing employment there for the speakers of the language who are left there. I am afraid that the young people are leaving the Gaeltacht. There has been an exodus from the Gaeltacht, the equal of which has never before been seen. I am not blaming the Government or anyone for that, because it has been taking place over many years, but never to the same extent as now. What I want to find out is if, in the development of our industrial policy, we can do anything for the establishment of industries in those isolated places, where the Irish language is still spoken.
We have heard a lot about centralisation of industry. No doubt, there has been a certain amount of centralisation. That is only natural because when people have money to put into industries they will see to it that these industries will have the greatest chance of success, and their greatest chance of success, of course, will be in or adjacent to big centres of population. I am wondering if the time has not come when some inducement, financial or otherwise, should be given to people with capital to select places in the Gaeltacht for the establishment of these industries. It would be a great thing for the restoration of the Irish language. To deal with this problem of the Gaeltacht, as we have been dealing with it over a number of years, there are many factors to be taken into account—educational factors, factors affecting local government, factors affecting the Land Commission, the resettlement of holdings, fisheries and so on. I believe the Department of Industry and Commerce should be as concerned, or more concerned, about this than any other Department.
I do not know whether the Minister has given any thought or consideration to this aspect of the problem. I do not know whether any of the four people who are members of this Industrial Authority have given consideration to the problem of starting industries in the Gaeltacht or will in the future. When the Minister is replying I should like to hear his view on the possibilities that may exist for establishing industries in the Gaeltacht. It is time for us to turn our attention to that problem before it is too late, before the time will have come when nobody can do anything along economic or any other lines to preserve the spoken language in the Gaeltacht. I should also like to mention another industry—the turf industry—though I do not know if I would be in order in doing so.
Comment on this
With all respect, it certainly should have. In my opinion, the turf industry is one of our greatest industries.
Comment on this
I am not going to enlarge on it, but in our attempts, and let us be genuine in our attempts, to establish industries here, I think we should turn our attention to the possibilities of developing the bogs more than we have been doing; but, unfortunately, at the present time instead of that, as far as the County Kerry, which I represent, is concerned——
Comment on this
On a point of order. I am not asking that the Deputy should be prevented from developing his point on this. The only thing that I want to do is to stake my claim to be allowed to reply in full to him if he does develop this.
Comment on this
The Minister will be entitled to reply to anything that is said in the course of the debate. It appears to me that, so far, the Deputy is within the terms of relevancy.
Comment on this
If the Chair so rules, of course I accept that ruling; but it seems clear to me that the Deputy is trying to cloud the real issue in this Bill.
Comment on this
I am not trying to cloud any issue, but I am trying to bring one clear issue before the Dáil——
Comment on this
Or any other industry that would give employment. I consider the turf industry as being second to none in this country if proper attention were given to it. It is better than 20 individual industries that might be established here because, in its very nature and scope, it is diversified and is capable of giving employment in every place where you have bogs. The Industrial Development Authority is to be given statutory authority through the medium of this Bill. Therefore, I think they would be well advised if they are going to be helpful to the Minister, to the Government and to the State, to turn their attention to this great industry—the turf industry.
Comment on this
Bord na Móna have been doing a certain amount, but instead of going ahead, they are closing down works. I refer to my own county, where schemes of work had been carried on in bogs near Listowel and Cahirciveen and now Bord na Móna are taking their machinery away.
Comment on this
I was not going to deal with Bord na Móna until Deputy Davin interrupted me. He asked me were not Bord na Móna doing this work in the bogs, and I was proceeding to tell him that they were not doing it to the extent that they should.
Comment on this
I know that, but Deputy Davin interrupted me. I wanted to give him the information that he was looking for. Perhaps the Minister would give it to him.
Comment on this
For the Minister's information I do not look for publicity of this kind. I have never looked for publicity.
Comment on this
On a point of order. I simply drew attention to the fact that there is an authority in existence, set up by statute, for dealing with the development of the turf industry.
Comment on this
So that this Industrial Development Authority will have nothing to do with turf then?
Comment on this
I mentioned the turf industry, but I did not want to develop the subject. All that I wanted to do was to bring to the attention of the Minister that it is a very important industry, and also to make sure that, if the members of the authority are to function under this Bill, the development of the turf industry should be one of their cares and responsibilities.
Comment on this
I allowed the Deputy to refer to the development of the turf industry, but I cannot allow him to discuss administration on this Bill.
Comment on this
I do not propose to go into administration, but seeing that there is so much uneasiness in the House over the question of turf I am not going to proceed with a discussion on it except to say this, that the Government itself pretended to attach so much importance to the turf industry that they issued a statement two years ago through the Government Information Bureau to the effect that they were instructing all local authorities to make sure that turf would be used as fuel in all institutions under their care. At any rate, that was a good and a laudable thing to do, to make sure——
Comment on this
——that as much turf as possible would be used in the country so as to give employment to the people at home. When I put down a question on that——
Comment on this
I have given the Deputy a good deal of latitude and I want to tell him again that I will not allow him to discuss administration.
Comment on this
Very good. In conclusion, I would say this, that I am not in favour of setting up this authority. There is no use, as far as I can see, in my saying that now because this development authority is supposed to have been functioning for the last ten months. In spite of the fact that it has been functioning for the last ten months we are told here in the Bill that
"this is an Act to establish an Industrial Development Authority and to provide for certain matters connected therewith".
In other words, we are dealing with legislation to-day that we should have been dealing with ten months ago. Whether it is wise legislation is another matter.
Comment on this
The Minister to-day is bringing in a Bill which should have been brought in ten months ago, that is, if he believes in the efficiency of this industrial authority and in the advisability of setting it up at all, which I do not.
Comment on this
I am rather disappointed at the tone of the debate. Like Deputy Connolly, I expected far more, especially from the members of the front Opposition bench——
Comment on this
As they are ex-Ministers. Surely Deputy Lemass and Deputy Aiken have a real knowledge of the need for developing industry in this country. Deputy Lemass gave us to understand that there was no need for this Bill as the work to be accomplished by it was already being done by a certain section in the Department of Industry and Commerce. If that is so, I do not see why the House has been delayed for hours by the Opposition discussing the merits and demerits of the Bill. To my mind, the function of the Opposition should be to help a Minister or a Government by constructive criticism or helpful suggestions in order to improve any proposed legislation. So far, the attitude adopted in regard to this Bill has been the direct opposite. We had a contribution from Deputy Aiken the like of which I never listened to and I hope we shall not have it repeated in this House. In their criticism of this Bill, the Opposition have adopted the same tactics which they brought to bear on previous legislation such as the Local Authorities (Works) Bill. I do not propose to dwell on the number of amendments they put down to that Bill which had the effect of holding up very useful work. They are indulging in the same type of criticism which they indulged in on the land rehabilitation scheme all over the country in order to try and prevent farmers from taking advantage of that useful scheme.
Comment on this
They launched the same type of criticism against the new Land Bill, in which they told the people in rural Ireland that the market value which is now to be given for land will have to be paid by the allottees when they get the land.
Comment on this
I want to put the House wise to the type of obstructive criticism which comes from the Opposition Benches whenever useful legislation is introduced. We can generally measure the usefulness of any Bill by the type of criticism that we get from the Opposition Benches. The better the Bill, the more vile and scurrilous the Opposition become. What is the purpose behind a Bill of this kind? What is the purpose of developing industry? Surely we are not going to lose sight of the main idea by going down the byways that have been explored by Deputies on the opposite side. To my mind, at any rate, we should develop industries in order to put into productive employment as many of our people as we possibly can.
I think it is an accepted fact in this House that our land is not capable of absorbing all the people born on farms. If that is an accepted fact, then there must be some alternative work got for those people who have to leave the farms or who may be the sons or daughters of labourers. To a great extent, that problem in past years has been relieved by emigration. I am not criticising any Government in particular in regard to this. But in the West of Ireland the solution of the problem of overcrowding or congestion has been mainly solved by the emigrant ship. I think, therefore, that this body, which will act in a purely advisory capacity, should lay down some systematic plan by which they can tackle this problem of unemployment in the West of Ireland. Deputy Kissane mentioned the Gaeltacht areas. I would enlarge that and say all the areas west of the Shannon.
That brings me to what I consider a very important point. The Minister and his predecessor have, time and again, asked people with capital to invest their money in industries in this country. We have seen appeals to that effect made at dinners and other public functions. The appeals also stressed the fact that industrialists should get away from Dublin as much as possible and concentrate on areas down the country. That is all to the good. But, to my mind, that is not sufficient to get these industries going. That appeal has been made year in and year out but, so far as I can see, it has produced very little satisfactory results in the West of Ireland. The position is that a private industrialist finds that the best place to set up an industry is in Dublin. He has no transport problem or anything like that to face in Dublin. Naturally, he is going to go to the place that suits him best. The result is that the concentration of industries in Dublin has helped in no small way to leave the city in its present overcrowded condition. I think the attention of this new body should be directed as much as possible to getting out of Dublin some of those industries which could be set up down the country, in other words, to decentralise as much as possible.
At the moment, we depend on private enterprise to a great extent to develop industry here. My contention is that private enterprise, so far as rural Ireland is concerned, is not sufficient to tackle this big job. I have seen samples of it in my own constituency and in adjoining constituencies. On occasions, we find that a number of people are willing to start an industry in a town. The Minister and the Department say, "We will give you every encouragement." Something crops up, however, and they fail to do so. I know of several towns where such efforts have come to nothing. That is because private enterprise has failed in its job in these areas. Are we then to depend on the whim of private enterprise to stop emigration in localities in the West of Ireland? If the people with money do not feel like investing their money in industry, is the welfare of those people who dwell in rural areas to depend on the whim of such people? That is what private enterprise amounts to in rural areas. Where in such areas, particularly in the West, there is a surplus population and private enterprise is not willing to establish industries, then the Government must itself step in and establish them. The Government must set the ball rolling. Times are changing and methods are changing. This Government ought to be on the crest of the wave. It has been proved definitely that private enterprise will not solve unemployment. Neither will it stop the emigrant ship. The Government should be advised to step in and start these industries. At a later stage part of the shares might be given out on a co-operative basis amongst the workers. I see nothing wrong in that. The criticism levelled by Deputy Aiken and some of his colleagues—I will not say Deputy Lemass —was that such a step savours very much of what is happening in Soviet Russia. I do not want to develop that point, but I would like to remind the House that when anything new was mentioned during the election campaign, which was likely to help towards the prosperity of the country, Fianna Fáil immediately said: "This is Stalin's idea being implemented by the Clann na Poblachta Party here."
Deputy Kissane said it was undesirable to give the powers proposed in this measure to a group of laymen. I wonder does he remember the introduction of the managerial Act by Fianna Fáil. They were not worried about giving power into the hands of a layman. If the industrialists in this country are not working in the national interest, then some machinery must be available to control those industrialists and bring them to book. To my mind that is the main reason for the giving of this power in this measure. Fianna Fáil take exception to the fact that this body will have power to call witnesses and to take evidence. I hope they are not afraid that some of the contributions to the Fianna Fáil Party machine may have to be disclosed. I hope that is not the reason for that criticism. It is possible they are fearful of that.
I mentioned that this body should concern itself with the rural areas, particularly with the West of Ireland. I would like to mention, as did some other Deputies, that they should cooperate as much as possible with the Department concerned with reafforestation. Reafforestation will be the father and mother of numerous industries.
Comment on this
I submit it is more relevant to this Bill than was the turf mentioned by Deputy Kissane.
Comment on this
I allowed Deputy Kissane to say that the development of the turf industry might be referred to this body. Surely something controlled by a Government Department is not relevant to this measure.
Comment on this
I merely mention that from the point of view of the work I envisage this Industrial Development Authority will do. This body will plan years ahead. They will not plan on a short term, day-to-day basis. They must keep before their eyes large-scale development. If we have an assurance that reafforestation will form a major industry, particularly in the West of Ireland, I suggest it is very appropriate that this authority should play its part in the activities and planning of the Department concerned with reafforestation.
Another important point is that there must be close co-operation between this new authority and Córas Iompair Éireann. Transport is an important item in any industry. Córas Iompair Éireann should be asked to help as far as possible, particularly in the initial stages of an industry's development. I welcome this measure. I think it is very necessary. I think the problem of unemployment and emigration can be dealt with very satisfactorily under the good planning of this Industrial Development Authority.
Comment on this
Deputy McQuillan opened his remarks by referring to the alleged iniquities of the Opposition, not only in regard to this Bill but to several others. He referred, as did several other Deputies on the Government Benches, to the experience of front bench members on the Opposition in industrial matters. When the benefit of that experience is offered to the Government we are told that we are committing sabotage. Deputy McQuillan is a young man and one can, perhaps, forgive him to some extent for not knowing what happened 20 years ago and the ten years preceding it. If Deputy McQuillan had experience of the Tariff Commission, of which this body is to be a replica, I do not think he would be quite so enthusiastic about it. In my own constituency a factory that had been in existence for 120 years and which needed a tariff to help it to keep in existence actually went out of existence before the Tariff Commission could come to a decision. Successive generations had worked in that factory. I know one man whose great-grand-father before him had worked in it. He and his two sons lost their employment. When one has an experience like that one can show very little enthusiasm for the setting up of another body on the same lines. That is what this Bill proposes to do. It proposes to interpose between the Minister and his officials another body to examine into these questions for which he himself should take responsibility, take certain decisions and make certain recommendations to the Minister. To my mind that is plainly a delaying device. This Bill is an attempt to meet the divergent views existing on the Government Benches on this important question.
We all know that some of the Ministers—even since they have become Ministers—have not attempted to conceal what they feel about the industrialists of to-day in this country. This Bill is plainly an attempt to try to meet the views of those who wish to develop industry and, at the same time, it is set up as a delaying device to meet the views of those who do not wish to develop industry. That is what I see in the Bill. We definitely stand for the development of industry. The last couple of years have been the best years in the history of this country for the development of industry. They have been lost. The Minister himself told us in this House in 1947 that if he were Minister for Industry and Commerce he could solve the unemployment problem the next morning. He has been in office now for the past two years and, after that length of time, we get this Bill.
Deputy Connolly, when speaking, seemed to have some fears that some day we would become over-industrialised. None of us wishes to see that day. However, there is not the slightest fear that this country at any time—even in the two generations to which Deputy Connolly referred—will ever become over-industrialised if we set up a body such as this. For my part, I would sooner see the Minister making mistakes, and big mistakes, in trying to develop industry in a hurry, if you like, or without delay, rather than see this happen. We know that the development of industry in this country is absolutely necessary if we are to avoid the unemployment and emigration that is, unfortunately, now taking place. We know that it is necessary to cope with the surplus rural population and, with the development of agriculture on mechanised lines— as is likely to be the case—that question will become more important.
If we are going to establish a further body to consider all those questions, and a body which has no power to take any action on its decisions, we are not going to reach a stage when we can deal with that question for a very long number of years to come—it will take years to deal with even the first question which will come before it. This body, when it makes its reports, will have to go through all the delay that always existed of submitting a plan, when it is decided upon, to the Department of Finance for its further examination there. They are not, as far as I can see, at all exempted from that under this Bill. Therefore, no matter where one looks, one can only regard it as imposing a further delay on any sincere Minister who wishes to develop industry. At the moment, I think that 11 per cent. of our industrial population is unemployed. Surely that should be some incentive to us to try and hurry, up any development that could possibly be carried out.
Some remarks were made which to my mind implied that the day of private enterprise is nearly over and that it cannot cope with these matters to-day. If I am right in that interpretation of speeches which were made by some Deputies last week, may I ask if it will help to get people with capital to put it into industry and to develop it as we want it done, if that threat of nationalisation is to be held over their heads? I do not think that this country at the moment is ready for nationalisation in general and I doubt if it will ever be.