We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Committee on Finance. - Vote 50—Industry and Commerce (Resumed).

Contributions 161–330 of 330. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

The cost of low living, the cost to the ordinary person who has a modest wage and who wants to give his family a reasonable standard of living. Whatever way the cost-of-living figures are being controlled at the present time under the two-price system by the Government, the fact of the matter is that every housewife in this country knows that £1 went as far a couple of years ago as 27/6 does now. That is the universal experience of every housewife who has been accustomed to go into the grocer's shop week after week. She finds that she has to pay 27/6 now where she had formerly to pay £1 for the same quantity of goods. The Minister may congratulate himself that, owing to the two-price system, he has kept down the index figure, but if the cost of living did not go up, why is it that the Minister for Finance is taxing the people to-day with £1,000,000 to compensate civil servants, as he stated, for an increase in the cost of living? Surely there is a contradiction in that. We are putting extra taxation on the people to pay compensation to certain classes for an increase in the cost of living and we are denying at the same time that there is an increase in the cost of living.

Comment on this
A Deputy

Because they were previously underpaid by you.

Comment on this

That was not the plea. Previously, there was a clause in the agreement with civil servants that if the cost of living did not go beyond a certain point they would keep to the salary scale agreed upon. The Minister for Finance justified the additional tax on the people of this country to raise the £1,000,000 extra for compensation for civil servants on the grounds that it was to meet an increase in the cost of living. He cannot have it both ways. I wish the Government Parties would try to make up their minds as to what they want. They switch around from day to day and it is the last person who gives them a kick or exerts a bit of pressure who has his way.

I think the Minister should really do something to reduce the cost of living or to keep it within bounds. The only way I see to bring down the cost of living is to keep production up. We are not going to keep production up and provide our people with a proper standard of living unless the members of the Government take off their coats and give encouragement to those who have the money to invest it in this country. I do not think there is any necessity for the Minister to go off to America looking for money. People who have money would invest it here at home if the Minister gave them some encouragement, even if he gave as much encouragement to them as he is prepared to give to the Americans. The Government simply cannot go on in the way they have been going in the last couple of years, or the country will get into the doldrums. It is very nice to open industries that were planned or started by Fianna Fáil, but we want the Government to do a little more. We want the Government to press a button or to blow a whistle to open some industry they have promoted themselves. We hope that, as a contribution to the economic development of our country, the people here who talk about production and reducing the cost of living by 30 per cent. will be more realistic in their approach. Is that still part of the policy of the Clann na Poblachta Party for the economic development of our country?

Comment on this

Put up a few more posters with the three brass balls and you will quickly help to bring down the country.

Comment on this

Is it still Clann na Poblachta policy to reduce the cost of living by 30 per cent?

Comment on this

Economically, we have never changed.

Comment on this

Is that still the policy of the Clann na Poblachta Party?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy is repeating himself.

Comment on this

I suppose one thing that will never come to an end is the promises and still more promises made and broken by the Parties comprising the Government. But they cannot go on fooling all the people all the time.

Comment on this

You did it for 16 years.

Comment on this

You have done it for close on three years, but the end is approaching. I did not have an opportunity of taking part in the debate on the Transport Bill. May I say now that I think it was scandalous for the Minister to seize a building——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That does not come under this Estimate.

Comment on this

Part of it is in it.

Comment on this

It has nothing to do with administration.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

It has nothing to do with this Estimate.

Comment on this

The Minister seized a building for civil servants.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That is not in this Estimate.

Comment on this

I know the Minister is sensitive about it.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Chair is sensitive that it is not in this Estimate. Will the Deputy point out where it is?

Comment on this

I am talking about administration in relation to the Department of Industry and Commerce during the past year.

Comment on this

On a point of order.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

It is not in this Estimate and, therefore, there is no need for the Minister to rise. It is not in this Estimate and I will not hear anything more about it.

Comment on this

On a point of order. Are we discussing the general policy and administration of the Department of Industry and Commerce over the past year?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

You are supposed to be.

Comment on this

Was not the Bill promoted by the Minister, part of the administration of the Department of Industry and Commerce?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The matter to which the Deputy is referring was recently settled by legislation.

Comment on this

By a decision of this House.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

By a decision of this House on a Bill.

Comment on this

But it was administration.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The matter was settled by a Bill in this House and it does not arise now.

Comment on this

If the Minister wants to please the Minister for Finance and seize a building for civil servants, all right.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

It does not arise and the Deputy will not get around it in that fashion.

Comment on this

On a point of order. Would I be right in suggesting that, as a result of the administrative action of the Minister for Industry and Commerce during the past year, Córas Iompair Éireann decided to abandon Store Street as the site for a bus station?

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The matter is not in order on this Estimate.

Comment on this

If it was through the administrative action——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Is it clear to the Deputy that the matter is not in order?

Comment on this

It is clear, at least, that you have said it is not in order and we bow to your ruling.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy did not bow very low in the remark he made.

Comment on this

I just bowed as low as was necessary to suit the occasion. What does the Minister propose to do in relation to civil aviation? He has no more aeroplanes to sell this year in order to get some "dibs" for the Minister for Finance. He should at least hold out some hope to us that the country will not be left in the position of being a mere baggage carrier for foreign aeroplanes' crews. I think we would have a better chance of standing on our own feet if we had some of our own planes catering for these tourists and getting some of their money instead of merely acting as porters who carry their bags. Has the Minister in mind any change of policy in regard to transatlantic air services? I hope we shall have an answer to these questions. The Government made some changes when they came in merely because a particular policy had been adopted by Fianna Fáil. I hope they will give some indication now that they regret having parted so easily with these magnificent planes for which we had paid in dollars.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That was not this year.

Comment on this

Perhaps they will spend some money now in getting a new fleet together. This year we would have had a splendid opportunity of earning dollars and other units of currency if we had here a fleet such as we had in 1947. We have to employ foreign companies to transport our people even to the Continent of Europe. I hope some of the Minister's supporters will encourage him to make preliminary inquiries as to the possibility of obtaining new planes. I take it that it would take a few years to get these even under present conditions. It would also take time to get the crews trained. I think the Government should make some tentative approach towards restarting a transatlantic air service. The personnel would then have the assurance that every Party here was behind the venture. They would appreciate that, as we had grown up, economic questions would be decided outside the realm of political debate.

We all realise in our hearts that, if we want to develop our industry, we must expand our technical knowledge. There is nothing so conducive to the promotion of industry as enlightened discussion among technicians. The more technicians we have the better it will be for ourselves and the easier it will be to improvise should improvisation become necessary. Last week the Minister for Finance told us about a scheme under which the Americans are granting us dollars to encourage people here who want to acquire technical knowledge to go to America or to other countries. It will be too bad if, as a result of Government action, we have to send to America for advice on some transatlantic air service and meet over there people whom this Government had sacked. I hope the Minister will give some indication that this Government has changed its mind in regard to the transatlantic air service just as it changed its mind in regard to the short-wave radio station.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Why does the Deputy repeat his statements?

Comment on this

This is only the second time. It is impossible for anybody to make a speech without doing so.

Comment on this

It would be impossible for the Deputy.

Comment on this

It was only my second time. I can do it but I would take very much longer the other way.

Comment on this
General Seán MacEoin Minister for Justice (General MacEoin) Fine Gael

Do not try. Do not distress yourself.

Comment on this

Our technicians are valuable. It is essential, if they are to remain here, in view of the present opportunities in other parts of the world, that they should get an assurance from the Government and from those who support the Government that if they take employment here they will not be thrown out of that employment and that that employment will not be swept from under their feet because of pure Party politics. That is what happened to the air services across the Atlantic.

Comment on this
Mr. Browne

There are one or two matters which I wish to raise in connection with my constituency, and this is the only opportunity I have of doing so. The first issue is the question of Ballina and its future and with that I couple the future of the port. I am anxious to bring to the attention of the Minister the fact that it was proposed to establish a factory in Ballina about the year 1938. When the Minister is replying I hope he will explain how it came about that while the permit was issued in 1938 or 1939 in respect of the establishment of the factory in Ballina—immediately previous to the outbreak of the war—it was eventually transferred to another county. I want to refer to what happened, and I shall be brief. A firm of foreign factory promoters selected Ballina as a suitable site for a factory. As far as I know the permit was issued. After the issue of the permit, the next step was to find out what interest the local people would take in the working of the factory, and its prospects of progress and success. For that reason a local contribution was asked for. As far as I remember the figure was in the neighbourhood of £10,000 and, inside a week, the money was put up by the local people of Ballina. Later, what happened? The war broke out and, as a result, the scheme had to be postponed during the war years. All during that time the people of Ballina were hopeful that the matter would be settled and that, in the ordinary way, the factory would be established and put into operation Shortly after the end of the war we discovered, much to our surprise, that the permit in respect of the establishment of the factory at Ballina was transferred to another county, and that Ballina was, therefore, at a loss in that regard. That has caused great annoyance to the people in the area of Ballina, and to the younger people who depend on local employment. If this factory had been set up in Ballina it would give employment to a large percentage of the young people who are growing up in that town, whereas, at the moment, the outlook is not too hopeful. I hope the Minister, when he is replying, will let me know who was responsible for the transfer of the permit in question to another county. Is it that the promoters of the factory were responsible and, in any event, why is it that the local representatives of North Mayo, and those who represent Ballina, were not informed of the transfer of the permit from Ballina to another county? I represent North Mayo and I would point out that I heard nothing about a proposal to transer the permit. The first I heard of the matter was when I was given to understand that the permit had been transferred from North Mayo to another county, with the result that the factory would not be built at Ballina. At the present time it does not look hopeful that in the near future a factory will be established in Ballina. That is a serious state of affairs for a town like Ballina—a town with a population that has grown roughly from 5,000 to 7,000 people. When it was first suggested that a factory would be established in Ballina there were some middle-aged men who were anxious and keen on the project. They were younger men then than they are now. A period of ten or 12 years makes a big difference at a certain time in the life of a middle-aged man. Therefore, it would seem now as if younger people will have to face the problem and the responsibility of the provision of a factory or an industry in Ballina.

My second point, which I couple with the first, is the repair and maintenance of Ballina quay. During the emergency that quay was left practically derelict. After the cessation of hostilities it began to be possible again to import certain commodities and to export certain goods and boats were gradually coming back to the port. However, as a result of all the years during which the port was not used, it is in a very bad condition and it is almost impossible to import or to export from the quay. The harbour commissioners at Ballina have made an application for a grant and they are hopeful of an early decision. If the harbour commissioners do not get some assistance by way of a Government grant I can see no hope of trading vessels coming into Ballina or leaving it. I can see no hope of that benefit or assistance as far as the people of my constituency are concerned. Previous to the change of Government the bigger ports really had a monopoly and the smaller ports of this country were only an after-consideration. For instance, Sligo had special concessions and Dublin had special concessions. The small ports were, I might say, practically forgotten. That is a serious state of affairs for an area such as North Mayo, where there is practically no rail service and no delivery service except by road. With only a small corner of the constituency served by the railway, the port was a great advantage and a great benefit to the area as a whole. It had the advantage of being in competition with freight charges on the road and on the railway. The result was that the people in the area derived a double benefit from the point of view of a near acceptance of goods and competition as far as freight and delivery charges were concerned. I appeal to the Minister to make provision so that the application by the Ballina Harbour Commissioners for a grant towards the repair of the quay at Ballina will be given favourable consideration, thus giving us an opportunity of bringing the quay back to such a state that it will be used once more and give a good return again, as far as the port is concerned.

I now want to speak about the turf industry in the County Mayo. I, like other Deputies, was disappointed to find that Bord na Móna had decided to cease producing machine-won turf in Mayo. Let no one imagine that because the production of machine-won turf has stopped in Mayo the production of hand-won turf has ceased. At the start I had my doubts about the introduction of machines for the production of turf in such a huge area as North Mayo, where, I may say, there is a big consumption of hand-won turf. I felt that the introduction of the machines might do more injury than good in that area and that the people engaged on the production of hand-won turf were not going to benefit by the introduction of the machines. There were areas that did benefit from the introduction of the machines, but these were areas in which they had good roads and good bogs. These were areas, too, in which the workers had to be taken for miles by lorry for the production of the machine-won turf. What killed and stopped the sale of machine-won turf in my area was the cost of it. In my county you could get the best hand-won turf at about 18/- a ton in the bog or on the roadside. The machine-won turf cost 39/6 a ton on the roadside. Does any Deputy imagine that any common-sense person in my county is going to pay 39/6 a ton for machine-won turf when he can get an equally good article at 18/- a ton? No provision has been made for the sale of the machine-won turf which was produced over a number of years. It is still there. I am a member of the local authority, and certainly my colleagues and myself are in favour of giving first preference to the hand-won turf so far as all the public institutions in the county are concerned.

There has been an awful lot of talk about turf. The turf industry in Mayo is finished. The result is that we have not sufficient hand-won turf in my county. It is impossible to get a ton of it. Bord na Móna has the machine-won turf on the roadside, but the people are not going to pay 39/6 a ton for it. Its production was paid for out of the revenue collected from the people. If the Minister wants to dispose of it he will have to reduce the price and sell it at a loss. What has happened in regard to it is not going to result in a continuance of machine-won turf.

A lot has been said about the cost of living. A number of speakers on the other side have said that the cost of living has increased. I think the Deputies who make these statements should try and refresh their memories and compare the cost of certain articles since the change of Government took place and their cost before the change of Government took place. Deputies opposite have told us that the price of tea, sugar, flour, bread, butter, bacon and eggs has increased. I think that if Deputies will take the years 1946 and 1947 they will find that there was a big difference in the prices then charged for tea, sugar, bread and flour, compared with the prices which have been charged to the consumer for these commodities in 1948 and 1949. It would be very interesting if the Minister would give the retail price of tea which the consumer had to pay in November, 1947, also the retail price of sugar up to that year, as well as the retail price of flour and of the 2 lb. loaf, in comparison with the prices which the consumer has to pay for these commodities since the change of Government took place. If the Minister does that, I think it will be found that, while the consumer has had the same ration, he has had it at a lower price on the average during the last two years.

So far as butter is concerned, there is no doubt but that there was a black market in it. The same thing happened in the case of bacon and at a certain period in regard to eggs. I do not think anybody can deny that. As regards eggs, we had the lorries and the vans going through the country at a certain period of the year. There was no question as regards price. All that the people with the vans were concerned with was what they could get. Price did not matter. At that time the price of eggs was controlled here in the city. The price was not controlled last year, and so the vans and the black market have disappeared.

A Deputy from South Mayo, speaking on this Estimate last week, said:

"It is true that the cost of living has increased, irrespective of how the official index figure may cloak the increase. The housewife knows that the cost of all household goods has gone up in price."

I say that is wrong. They have not gone up in price, and that is why I asked the Minister earlier to give the figures that he must have in regard to the commodities that I have mentioned. If he does that, I think he will be able to show, despite the statement made by this Deputy, that prices, instead of having gone up, have over the period of the last two years come down. This Deputy from South Mayo went on to say:

"Some Deputy mentioned to-day that we no longer have a black market in this country. Since the advent of this Government and of the Minister we have had a Government black market in tea, sugar, butter, flour and bread..."

That is a statement made by a Deputy from South Mayo. On behalf of the people of North Mayo, I want to say that there was a black market there but that the new regulation of the non-subsidised tea, sugar and flour has done away with it. If it has not done away with the black market in South Mayo, it has done so in North Mayo. If it is correct that there is a black market in South Mayo, I would like, as a Mayo man, to see it stopped and it would serve a useful purpose if the people responsible were made pay the penalty. There was a black market in North Mayo, but it is finished, thank God; it was hard to root out, but the change of Government did that.

Comment on this

On a point of explanation, when I was speaking, the Minister denied that there was any power under the Control of Manufactures Act to allow Americans in here and still have control of their industry with complete American capital. If the Minister looks up the Act of 1932, Section 2 (1) (g) and also Section 6 (1), he will find that he has the power that he promised, in America, he would use to allow them in here and leave them with control of their industries.

Comment on this

I have no intention of holding the House unduly. My sole reason for intervening on this important Estimate is to bring to the attention of the Minister the economic plight of County Donegal and especially the condition of the Gaeltacht and congested areas. Without exaggerating it one bit, if it were not for the remittances we in West Donegal are receiving from the migratory workers employed in the fields, on the farms and in the factories of Scotland and England, the Gaeltacht area in County Donegal would be termed a very distressed area. I would ask the Minister to do what he can to assure that, when industries are being set up, the Gaeltacht and congested areas will be kept in mind, as they must depend on industries to keep alive. As the Minister will understand the position has worsened very much since the cessation of the turf industry and the collapse of the hand-woven tweed industry which was the backbone of various parts of Donegal for centuries. As far as we in Donegal can see, no effort is being made to help the homespun industry or to provide alternative employment for those thrown out of work when the turf industry stopped.

Without a supply of electricity, it would be difficult for us to interest industrialists and I would like to inform the Minister that County Donegal is not at all satisfied with the recent pronouncements of the Government in relation to the extension of rural electrification. The statement made recently proposes no more than the extension of lines to towns on a given circuit and outside those lines there are hundreds of townlands and rural areas which are being ignored entirely. We feel that the proper electrification of Donegal is being put on the long finger and that the areas which need it most will have to go without it for many years. I would impress on the Minister that the Gaeltacht areas cannot wait that long for development or help from the Government. Their plight is bad and is worsening year after year. We are now in the peculiar position in Donegal that we are importing coal through all the small ports around the Donegal coast, coal subsidised to the tune of 25/- a ton by this Government, while we are at the same time exporting our workers to the factories and coal mines of Glasgow and various parts of England. That is a mad policy for any Government to pursue and one that should be stopped at the earliest possible moment.

The cost of living has been well discussed and there is little I have to add. The last Deputy who spoke tried to make out that there was really no increase whatsoever. Any business man behind a counter knows very well that, leaving aside the cost of butter, bacon and some other foodstuffs, the cost of living is soaring rapidly in lines such as boots and shoes, general drapery and clothing. Surely the price of these commodities has a great bearing on the cost of living in any country. The farmer who buys a pair of nailed boots for himself is paying 7/- or 8/- more to-day than he did last year or the year before. The housewife who goes to the boot store to buy boots and shoes for her children knows she is paying at least 25 per cent. more than she did two years ago.

Comment on this

If she is, there is somebody profiteering.

Comment on this

There is no one profiteering—and that is the mistake the Minister is making when he does not face the fact that prices are going up. Everybody in business knows that before Christmas there will be a further increase in the price of boots and shoes.

Comment on this

I would be obliged if the Deputy would give particulars of the case where he says there was a 25 per cent. increase in footwear prices.

Comment on this

I can assure the Minister that salesmen who are now taking orders for winter boots and shoes, nailed boots and shoes for farm work, are pointing out that the price will be at least 7/- or 8/- more than last year.

Comment on this

I want to get particulars of the 25 per cent. increase.

Comment on this

I can show the Minister invoices for boots and shoes, and can show a greater increase than 25 per cent. With these increases, surely the cost of living is not falling appreciably? Then there is another item, the price of wool, which is rising, and the ceiling has not yet been reached. That will affect the price of clothing, hosiery and other lines needed by men, women and children. As long as these increases take place, it is rather dishonest to suggest that there has been a fall in the cost of living, or even that it is being held at the same figure. I think it would be honest on the part of the Minister and the Government if they pointed out to the people that these rises are taking place, because it is useless to tell a man in the country that he is buying more to-day with his £1 than he did two years ago.

At any rate, I would impress upon the Minister the necessity of doing something to help the people of the congested areas in the matter of industry. It is not an easy problem, I admit, but it is one that should be tackled and that will have to be tackled if we are honest about keeping the Gaeltacht alive. The people are leaving; the Gaeltacht is dwindling; the Irish-speaking sections are getting smaller year by year, because, instead of getting work at home on their bogs, at their homespuns or in other factories, the people have to seek work in Glasgow, Edinburgh and the English towns. It is a bad position and one which the Minister, who should have the interests of these people at heart, should do something to remedy at the earliest moment.

Comment on this

I will be very brief. This debate was very amusing in one way because it shows that the Government which was in power before us failed in every way according to their own members. That is really what has taken place.

Notice taken that 20 members were not present; House counted and 20 members being present—

Comment on this

I know that the Minister is in favour of the establishment of factories in the provincial towns but no group of individuals, foreigners or others, should get a permit to start a factory where they think they can carry on with slave labour conditions. The first thing some of these people who come to this country do if the men become members of a union is to close down. I got a wire yesterday about a factory which was started in my constituency. Presumably, the man who started it was from England. Because nine of the workers became members of a union they got a week's notice and I have a telegram here from the men concerned. That happened also when a factory was started previously. The proprietors were Jews and they threatened to burn down the factory if the workers became organised. No Minister should stand for that and there will be no peace among employers or employees if people are going to take such drastic steps that, because a man becomes a member of a union, the employer is running to Dublin to close down the factory or threatening to close it down. If they think that they can go to a rural area and pay the prevailing agricultural rate in sweated shops, the Minister should immediately put his foot down. He should not allow such people to start any business if they cannot pay the trade union rate of wages. No matter what factory is started, if the people who are sweating in it day after day do not get a living wage it is no good to them. That is why we had all the talk about the turf. What was wrong in the Fianna Fáil time that the workers did not stay on the bogs? They were not paid and they had not good conditions. They were brought from their homes in the South and West of Ireland and put into camps; certain people were put over them, bossing them and dogging them day after day, and that is why they left the bogs.

We had a factory in New Ross, Irish Driver Harris Company, Limited, and from the information I have in front of me another industry of the same type is about to be started in Dublin. That competition would be very serious for the people in the town of New Ross and I think that the Minister should not allow that to happen. They are all trying to get to Dublin. I am only a stranger in the city, but when I see girls and men coming out at dinner time from the back lanes I wonder where they work. I see crowds coming out from little cabooses, and surely that is not good for the health of the workers and, from a public health point of view, it should not be tolerated.

With regard to the cost of living, in June, 1947, tea was increased from 1/2 to 4/10 a lb., and anyone who wanted anything over that could buy it in the black market at from 25/- to 30/- a lb. Is it not better to have the ration, and if you want more to produce a few shillings and get it? That is better than to have it behind the counter like the cigarettes during the war, and to have to pay a fancy price for it. I think that the system is all right, and that the people are quite satisfied. If you want a little extra tea or sugar you can get it legally.

Some Deputies spoke about the white flour being produced for the rich while the poor got the other. Why was white flour put on the market? Why were the Fianna Fáil farmers in this House saying that they could not get pollard or bran? I was 25 years in a flour mill, and I know that if you did not have white flour you could not get pollard and bran. That is why the Minister advocated white flour— to get pollard and bran for the pigs of the country. Why did Fianna Fáil inspectors close down wheaten meal mills in this country? Because they found that some people were feeding their pigs on wheaten meal. Deputy Lemass knows that he had to close down those small mills because the pigs were eating the wheaten meal that humans should be getting. Only by having some white flour can you have pollard and bran for the farmers. How would you get one cwt. of pollard or bran unless you made white flour in the flour mills? Will any Deputy tell me that?

Comment on this

It must be invisible. It is not in the shops.

Comment on this

It is not in the shops. But for the stuff that was imported from Britain and America and any other places in which foreign stuff could be got, we would never have had any pig feeding. There were special trains coming into my town with this imported stuff, because there was never enough to keep the farming community in my constituency going in the matter of pig and cattle feeding. If we had white flour for everybody, we would have more pollard and bran, and less growling from the farmers about not being able to get it. During the emergency, Deputy Lemass imported white flour from America, and, when I asked in a question if he would make available some of that white flour for the use of patients in sanatoria and hospitals, he would not agree. None of it could go to the hospitals, and there was more waste in these hospitals and sanatoria through the use of inferior and bad flour than anything else.

Comment on this

The people were eating pollard and bran for flour and it killed half the country.

Comment on this

And those it did not kill have emigrated.

Comment on this

In any town to-day, you will see people asking for the white loaf. That is proof of what I say. New bakeries are starting all over the country, which are selling white flour, and nobody has any objection to paying a few pence more for it, because they are getting a good article. A new bakery has been started in my town, and the man is handing out white loaves as fast as he can turn them out, and the poor are queueing up for them. There is nothing wrong with it.

Comment on this

Except the price.

Comment on this

If you want a pint, you can get it at a particular price, but if you want a glass of whiskey, you will pay more for it. I want to ask the Minister to keep his promise with regard to the establishment of another beet factory. We have first claim.

Comment on this

New Ross. At a large meeting with the beet growers there, the ex-Minister for Agriculture, Dr. Ryan, said that experts who had come to this country had stated that New Ross was the ideal spot for such a factory. I wonder why he did not give it to us when he was in power? The farmers of Wexford are keeping Mallow, Carlow and Thurles going with their beet production. Why was the factory given to Tuam? I can tell the House. I made inquiries after that meeting in New Ross and I met a man from the West of Ireland. I asked him why did they build the factory in Tuam when they would not produce the raw material there, and he replied: " `Dev' wanted to give something to the West."

Comment on this

Exactly, and quite right, too.

Comment on this

To put a factory where there is no raw material is bad business. Deputy Beegan spoke about the rail charges. Fancy South Wexford farmers sending beet to Thurles and probably to Tuam. The farmers have to draw it to the station and send it off, and they do not know what they will get until it is made into sugar. It is washed and re-washed at the factory and it is much less in weight at that stage. The poor old farmer has to pay for all that.

With regard to hand-won turf, my constituency is not a turf-burning area but the people there will never forget the turf. They will not pass the field where it was in the dumps, lest they should see it again. I was very interested in a question put down by a Deputy on this side as to the percentage which a member of the Oireachtas had got on the coal now lying in the Park. We discovered it was 6 per cent. Why was that allowed by Deputy Lemass? Why was anybody allowed to get 6 per cent. on this coal?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

That does not arise on this Estimate.

Comment on this

The question of coal and turf has been dragged around the House all day.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Coal in certain circumstances.

Comment on this

That coal is still in the Park and cannot be sold. Slate quarries have been mentioned. At the moment, people in back lanes are making tiles for roofing which are not at all suitable, and, in five or six years, new roofs will have to be put on because the tiles being put on now will fall down. There are fellows making tiles to-day, to my own knowledge, and the sooner inspectors are sent down to examine them, the better for the tenants going into these houses. Every tile is half a stone in weight, and when the timber shrinks, the house will be gone.

We had a cement works in South Wexford in years gone by, and, during 1932, at every crossroads and in every town in the county, Fianna Fáil said that, if they were put into power, they would open these cement works at Drinagh. What happened? There was a good industry there for years, and——

Comment on this

Fianna Fáil closed it, and when the late Deputy Corish asked Fianna Fáil about their promise a Fianna Fáil Deputy said that election promises were not to be taken too seriously. That is on the records. When Fianna Fáil got into power some man named Davy Frame went down there, broke up the machinery and took it away.

Comment on this

Did the Deputy not back Fianna Fáil for a long time?

Comment on this

The workers put you in first, all right.

Comment on this

What are you blathering about, then?

Comment on this

You said: "Give us a chance." You got it, but you did not get it the next time and you will not get it again.

Comment on this

You will change again, too.

Comment on this

The change is for the better.

Comment on this

Deputy O'Leary is not the only one who made a change. So did Deputy O'Rourke.

Comment on this

And so did the Minister. He is the last man to talk about it. Did the Minister forget that?

Comment on this

No; I merely said that we are in the same boat.

Comment on this

The Minister forgot for a second.

Comment on this

Not at all. I was just reminding Deputy O'Rourke.

Comment on this

It might be hurting Deputy O'Rourke, all right.

Comment on this

Not a bit, unless I get into excessive laughter.

Comment on this

When you did not get excited the time the teachers went on strike you will never do anything. The Deputy sat there while members of his organisation were ejected from the Public Gallery one night. Do you remember that? You all quoted what people said during a general election. Deputy de Valera said he did not know what he said.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The teachers' strike has nothing whatever to do with this Estimate. Deputy O'Leary knows that.

Comment on this

I am sorry, a Leas-Chinn Comhairle.

Comment on this

Education plays a great part in it.

Comment on this

The flight from the land——

Comment on this

And the wild geese.

Comment on this

Yes. The wild geese had flown. I never forget that night. Why are people leaving the land? It is because some of the farmers have become so prosperous that they have bought tractors, ploughs and harrows and have a son to follow them and let the men go. That is happening in many cases. One class of farmer that should be considered are the small farmers, who are not as well off as some of the working men, who are struggling for existence on small holdings. The large farmers are all right, and Fianna Fáil or anyone on this side of the House need not worry about them. The question of emigration has been flogged on every side of the House.

Comment on this

The Deputy did not tell us about the flight from the land yet.

Comment on this

Do you object to any man leaving one job and getting a better one? I do not.

Comment on this

Deputy Davern would object to that.

Comment on this

I do not object to any man bettering himself. If men come to the City of Dublin to build houses, all the better. You cannot expect them to stay in the bogs all their lives. None of you talked about that. You tried to get away from it. Let the men go where they like. That is what I call freedom. Fianna Fáil, during the emergency, would not allow a turf worker or an agricultural worker to stir out of his own area.

Comment on this

Would you let them go?

Comment on this

Certainly. If they want to go to America or to Britain or anywhere else, let them go. That is freedom. That is what the people want. When Fianna Fáil were in power I heard Deputies from Mayo appealing to the Minister to let men go and not to stop the men of Mayo from going to Britain. Stop talking about emigration.

Comment on this

The Deputy has settled the problem.

Comment on this

My feet were sore from going to the United Kingdom Office to get permits for men who wanted to go away. That is a fact. They could not exist on what they were getting in their own areas as a result of the standstill Orders. Some farmers would not give you the daylight. Some of the farmers who were put on the Agricultural Wages Board by Deputy Lemass and Dr. Ryan would not give you the daylight. That is true.

I do not agree, and never did agree, during the emergency, with the building of luxury houses. Take, for instance, Cabinteely, where houses were built by speculative builders. Some of those houses are now for sale. Skilled labour was employed in building them that was needed by urban councils and local authorities to provide houses for the working classes.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Is not that a matter for Local Government rather than for the Minister for Industry and Commerce?

Comment on this

It ought to be a matter for the Minister for Industry and Commerce also. He might have something to do with supplies to those people. Let us have all the skilled men available for local authorities to build houses for the plain people. In Dublin, people are swarming on top of one another in some of the slums. It is a disgrace to have such a state of affairs in existence for so long. Go around Mountjoy Square.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy can say all that to the Minister for Local Government on his Estimate.

Comment on this

Have you not to get a licence to build a house from the Minister for Industry and Commerce? Have not you to get a licence to get timber? I want to tell the Minister here and now, if he has anything to do with the matter, that in my town a number of carpenters were laid off a housing scheme because there was no timber available. Local authorities should get priority in this matter. There is something wrong there.

I hope that the few points I have mentioned with regard to my constituency will be considered. If a beet factory is being erected, let it be erected in Ross. If a cement factory is required, open the old cement factory in Drinagh. That is what the Deputies of Wexford are here to fight for and to get, if possible.

Comment on this

The announcement made by the Minister in his introductory statement on this Estimate about the extension of the cement industry was very satisfactory, even though it was belated. Although there was protracted delay in arriving at the decision, it is very satisfactory to know that the Government have come to a decision to have the existing cement industries at Mungret, County Limerick, and in Drogheda extended. Deputy O'Leary, from Wexford, will not be satisfied with that. The pity of it is that this decision was not taken much earlier. I cannot understand why it took the Minister two years to arrive at a decision in regard to that very important question. When one considers all the money that is being lost in paying through the nose for imported cement, it is indeed regrettable that that decision was not taken long ago. Even although the decision has been announced, it will be another one and a half years, as we are told by the Minister, before the increased production in Mungret will be available and two years before the increased production can be available in Drogheda. That means that for a considerable time our people's money will be exported to purchase cement at a much higher price than the price of the native product. That is entirely to be regretted. Is fearr déanaí na go ro-dhéanach, mar a deireann sean-fhocal ins an Gaeilge.

There is another matter in which I am very interested and to which the Minister referred. It is the question of harbour development, particularly as it concerns the proposed development scheme that has been put forward by Limerick City Harbour Board and also by the port authority of Foynes. Foynes has put up to the Department a very ambitious programme. It will need an extension of jurisdiction to be provided for the harbour authorities. That has been before the Department since 1947, the question of an extension of the harbour facilities at Foynes, and I would like to know from the Minister whether there is any prospect of an immediate decision. There was a decision given in regard to the Limerick harbour proposition and, judging by the report in the local papers, the financial assistance forthcoming from the Government was not regarded as satisfactory and was not in accordance with the understanding that was given to the Limerick harbour authority when this matter was first raised before the change of Government.

I am specially interested in the ambitious programme for the development of Foynes Harbour. I would like a favourable decision in regard to that very important matter for all that side of the country and the South of Ireland, and I hope it will be expedited by the Department.

It is a good thing also to hear from the Minister that he is standing fast in regard to the question of the bypassing of Shannon Airport. As the Minister explained to us, that is a subject that is under consideration and it would not be correct to refer to it at any great length, but I will say this, that the Minister will have the support of the whole Dáil in taking a firm stand. Of course, there are members of the Government whose past comes very much against them in regard to that subject. I remember the Minister for Agriculture talking here once, when he was on this side, and he prophesied that the Shannon Airport would be a rabbit warren, and even the Minister for Finance said some time ago in the Seanad that it is only a crude junction. Nevertheless, it is vitally important that we should all stand fast for the honouring of the agreement arrived at when traffic to Shannon Airport started.

The Minister introduced during the year a "Buy Irish" scheme. I think the introduction of that scheme was futile. The Minister has power at his disposal to see that the people will buy Irish, and let him use it effectively. That is the only satisfactory way in which this problem can be solved, the only way of ensuring that articles that are manufactured here by our workers in our factories are purchased by the people. There should be full-blooded protection for the native article. This "Buy Irish" scheme was all right at one time when we had not power in our hands. I remember when I was a young lad I got interested in this question of Irish manufacture and I joined an organisation specially devoted to the purpose for which the Minister started this campaign. At that time the only support for Irish-manufactured articles came through voluntary agencies. Now we have the power to see that the people here buy Irish articles. There are slavish-minded people among us who always thought the foreign-manufactured article better than the native one. These people should not be given any choice; where there is a full supply of our requirements manufactured at home there should be no question of a foreign article being available.

The general policy with regard to industrial development has been discussed very extensively in this debate. Judging by the pronouncements the Minister made during the past year or the past year and a half, I am very glad to note that he and his Party have changed their attitude in regard to industrial development. I would like to congratulate the Minister on his conversion and the conversion of his Party to the idea of Ireland having a manufacturing arm as well as an agricultural arm. I am glad to see him in favour of having our industries developed. We in this Party have always stood for industrial development to the fullest extent possible. It is very satisfactory that this Government have now accepted that principle. Fine Gael, particularly, are to be congratulated on their conversion to the principle of full industrial development, providing here all the requirements of our people in so far as it can be done.

We have always stood for full protection for Irish industries, for worthwhile Irish industries, with suitable safeguards to provide for the consumers, the people who use our industrial products. We will not stand over inefficient production at unreasonable prices. Given fair conditions for those engaged in the industry and the putting of the article on the market at a reasonable price, there should be no question whatever of having to go outside for anything. I am glad that the value of the policy put into operation by Fianna Fáil since 1932 is now being accepted generally in this House and, where the Minister pushes ahead with the industrial programme inaugurated in 1932 and continued when Fianna Fáil was in power, this Party will be behind him in order to secure full-blooded industrial development.

I want to support the appeal of Deputy Breslin with regard to the industrial development of the congested areas in the Gaeltacht. It is very hard to get people with money to invest in industry to go to certain places and establish industries there. A very serious effort will have to be made to secure as much ruralisation of industries as possible, particularly now with the extension of rural electrification. I hope the Minister's conversion and his Party's conversion in regard to industrial development is genuine. There may be some cracks in the armour still because, while the Minister has been applauding the efforts of Irish industrialists, a colleague of his not very long ago called Irish industrialists simply licensed plunderers. It is very hard to know, in regard to Government policy, who is to be accepted as the oracle, the Minister for Industry and Commerce or the Minister for Agriculture, who spoke of industrialists as licensed plunderers. This debate has changed in tone from the debates we remember in the past in regard to industrial development. We used to hear about back-lane factories and child labour. The Minister has had two years to investigate these matters and I invite him to tell us has he discovered any of the back-lane factories or the child labour and, if he has, what has he done about them?

We have had a good deal of talk about the importance of the tourist industry. The Minister referred to it in his introductory remarks. Of course, Fine Gael and the rest of the Parties on the Government Benches—the Parties supporting the Government— have rather a past, too.

Comment on this

Forget the past.

Comment on this

I did not hear the remark of the Deputy.

Comment on this

Forget the past and think of the future.

Comment on this

The Deputy would like to see that done. He would like to forget the past because the past is pretty lurid for some of you over there and you do not like to be reminded of it.

Comment on this

He said to forget your own past.

Comment on this

We have no reason to forget our past. We can be proud of what we did since we came into this House. We can be proud of our efforts during the years we were in office. Our aim was to develop the country and to make it free. We succeeded in doing that and we have nothing to be ashamed of to-day.

Comment on this

There is nothing to be ashamed of on this side either.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy O'Brien is entitled to speak without interruption.

Comment on this

Donnchadh Ó Briain, más é do thoil é.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Tá go maith. An Teachta Ó Briain.

Comment on this

Donnchadh Ó Briain is ainm dom agus do toghadh mé mar Dhonnchadh Ó Briain.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Níl aon bhaint aige sin leis an ceist seo.

Comment on this

Tá gach baint aige leis.

Comment on this

On a point of order. Is the Chair not entitled to address the Deputy as Deputy O'Brien, seeing that the Constitution provides that English and Irish may be used on an equal basis?

Comment on this

Do toghadh mé mar Dhonnchadh Ó Briain, agus ba chóir Donnchadh Ó Briain do thabhairt orm.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Tá an ceart ag an Teachta. Ní maith liom go gcuirfeadh éinne isteach air.

Comment on this

I want to explain for the benefit of the Deputy, who does not understand Irish, that this is a question of principle with me. I was elected as Donnchadh Ó Briain. That was the name forwarded to the Clerk of the Dáil and the name which appeared on the ballot paper. Perhaps it would have been better for me, from the point of view of the public, if the name had appeared in English on the ballot paper.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy is quite right. He should be called Donnchadh Ó Briain. Having said that, I hope the Deputy will now continue his speech.

Comment on this

I think it is not a matter for a joke. It is a matter of principle, the restoration of the Irish language—and the question of the use of Irish Christian names and surnames. It is a principle for which I have always stood. I was talking about the development of the tourist industry. There is, first of all, the question of foreign visitors, and the question of the provision of facilities for our own holiday makers. I am interested in the question of tourism, particularly from the point of view of the Gaeltacht areas. I understand the Tourist Board devoted some attention to that problem in the years gone by. What has been done in regard to it in the past few years I do not know. There was the question of the development of Gaeltacht areas as holiday centres. The two things can be combined— holidays and visits to Irish-speaking districts. Many people in this country who are interested in perfecting their knowledge of Irish and in the restoration of the language would visit Gaeltacht areas during their holidays if proper facilities were provided for them. I am glad that we all seem to be of the same opinion with regard to the value of the tourist industry. We all know that we were not of the same opinion in regard to that question some time ago, when tourists were called "spivs" and it was said that they should be taxed.

The Minister has had to listen to a very long debate on this Estimate and I do not think it would be fair to detain him much longer but I should like, when he is replying, if he would tell us something in regard to the schemes for harbour development that are pending in his Department and on which the Department seems to be very slow in arriving at a decision. I should like particularly to hear something in regard to the harbour development scheme at Foynes, County Limerick.

Comment on this
Mr. Blaney

In this lengthy debate, there has been a great deal of talk about the cost of living, so much so that I think it could be agreed that enough has been said on that subject, were it not for the fact that we find Deputies on the Government side of the House who still believe, or pretend to believe, that no increase has taken place. How they can stand up and tell the people that no increase has taken place is a mystery to me. It certainly takes a brass neck or a wooden neck to try to get away with an argument of that kind. While they might get away with it and get it on the records of this House, I think the best judges of the question of the cost of living are the people outside and particularly Irish housewives. They know, as most people must know now, that when they go into the shops to buy any of the necessaries of life these things cost considerably more than they did two years ago. We had a Deputy on the other side of the House a short while ago who said that as compared with prices in 1946, an actual decrease has taken place in the price of certain commodities. While that may or may not be correct, the fact is that the price of foodstuffs, taking them all down the line of rationed foodstuffs, has increased since 1948. There are two items very much in the news, one of them in particular, in the past few weeks. They are potatoes and flake or oatmeal. Why has the price of these commodities jumped to the extent they have? It is due primarily to the interference of other Departments with the industries which produce these commodities. Nevertheless, whether it is the Department of Agriculture is responsible for the shortage of potatoes this year——

Comment on this

Or the Deputy.

Comment on this
Mr. Blaney

——or the increase in prices——

Comment on this

The Deputy was talking about a brass or a wooden neck a while ago.

Comment on this
Mr. Blaney

Has the Minister anything to say about it?

Comment on this

I have. The neck is brass but apparently the wood applies a little higher up.

Comment on this
Mr. Blaney

I can see that when I look over there. The shortage of potatoes in the market for the past four or five months is due to the fact that for the previous two years, under the present Government and under the control of the Minister for Agriculture, we had a glut in the market for potatoes and in the market for oats.

Comment on this

You told them not to grow any more.

Comment on this
Mr. Blaney

Just a second. That was in 1948. In 1948 they were told to grow potatoes and oats. The result was that there was no market nor was there a good price for these commodities. Naturally enough, as a result of that, less of these commodities was grown in the following years. That is exactly what happened. Added to that was the fact that the Minister for Agriculture——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy is now discussing agricultural policy.

Comment on this
Mr. Blaney

I am not.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The Chair says you are.

Comment on this
Mr. Blaney

I understood that you were asking me was I discussing agricultural policy.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

I am not. I know.

Comment on this
Mr. Blaney

I am not discussing agriculture, but what I am discussing is the question of the price of potatoes and oats.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy will not discuss agricultural policy and he will not shout at the Chair.

Comment on this
Mr. Blaney

I am not endeavouring to shout at the Chair.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy will have to leave agricultural policy.

Comment on this

I suggest the Chair should prevent the Deputy being shouted down by the Minister.

Comment on this

Well, well!

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

I did not allow anybody to shout down the Deputy.

Comment on this

Deputy Lemass was not listening. He has only just come into the Chamber.

Comment on this
Mr. Blaney

Getting back to the question of potatoes and oatmeal, these are two items the price of which should enter into the calculation of the cost-of-living figure. The price of these commodities has gone up and surely anybody on that side of the House should know——

Comment on this

I have nothing to do with the price of either oatmeal or potatoes.

Comment on this

On a point of order. The Deputy is entitled to argue that the Minister should have some function.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The only reason why I allowed Deputy Blaney to speak about the matter is that it may affect the cost of living.

Comment on this

Deputy Lemass should leave the baby alone. He is well able to look after himself.

Comment on this
Mr. Blaney

There is the question of the cost of flake meal. The Minister has direct control over the price of that commodity.

Comment on this

I have not.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The Minister says he has no control.

Comment on this

On a point of order. The Minister had control, but he surrendered that power by revoking the price control Order.

Comment on this
Mr. Blaney

Am I not entitled to criticise the Minister for that action?

Comment on this

The Deputy is not doing that.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The Minister has no power.

Comment on this

He has power to take control over it by legislation.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

By legislation? If the Minister says he has no control, then he has none.

Comment on this

I want to argue the point that the Minister has power to exercise control over the prices of these commodities. He revoked the Order which gave him that power. That action of the Minister is open to criticism on this occasion.

Comment on this

It is not being so criticised.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

That is not the method by which the Deputy is seeking to criticise the Minister.

Comment on this

Deputy Lemass is, of course, trying to get in a heat.

Comment on this

It is a heat in a good cause.

Comment on this
Mr. Blaney

It was the Minister himself who gave the lead. I merely wanted to mention these things in passing. Had the Minister not intervened there would not have been any of this talk. Now that he has intervened, it is as well that the matter should be discussed. I introduced these two commodities merely because of their effect on the cost of living. The Minister has revoked the Order controlling the price of flake meal. As a result of that, the price has increased considerably. Surely the Minister should now realise that he ought to give himself the power to control it again. The reason for the high prices of flake meal and oatmeal is because of scarcity; that scarcity is due, as I have already said, to maladministration in another Department.

Towards the end of last year and early this year we believed in Donegal that we would shortly have rural electrification extended to our county. In 1945, when the Electricity Supply (Amendment) Act was passed, the people in Donegal and elsewhere welcomed the proposed project. The present Minister for Industry and Commerce welcomed that measure. The then Minister for Industry and Commerce was congratulated at the time by the leader of every Party comprising the Opposition. The present Minister, when referring to that measure, had only one grievance. He thought that the £40,000,000 was not enough. Coming back to more recent times and localising this matter, what do we find? We thought in Donegal that once the Erne scheme was under way our county would be one of the first to be supplied with electricity. Towards the end of last year, or early this year, we were suddenly made aware that that would not be the case. Our county was not to have the benefit of rural electrification as soon as we expected it would. There were other areas further south to which the current had to be sent and the people in Donegal would have to wait. A deputation was arranged with the Minister for Industry and Commerce and the Taoiseach. It was made plain at that deputation that the principal reason why rural electrification was not being extended to Donegal was the high cost of doing so. A figure of £1,000,000 was mentioned as Government subsidy. Apparently, £1,000,000 was too big a figure for the Government to advance in order to give our county the benefits of rural electrification; but £40,000,000 was not enough in 1945.

If we divide that £40,000,000 by every county, surely Donegal would be entitled to something over £1,000,000 in Government expenditure on rural electrification. About a fortnight ago the Minister, in answer to a question, gave us to understand, at column 22 of Volume 121 of Official Report of 16th May, 1950:—

"... it has not been possible to supply other rural areas in County Donegal owing to the fact that the current at present available to the board for the county is limited and is sufficient only to meet the existing level of consumption."

In 1944 it was lack of money. Now it is lack of current. But, though there is not sufficient current to supply Donegal, there is sufficient to give a main line from Donegal to North Dublin. Will the Minister now tell us that it is a case of not having sufficient money to give us the scheme? It certainly cannot be a case of not having enough current since, when the scheme is in full production, the amount required for Donegal would not be missed. The reason for the change of face is, apparently, the fact that the Minister could not get away with the statement that he was precluded by law from giving more than a 50 per cent subsidy, despite the fact that, in 1944, when that subsidy was mentioned by Deputy Lemass, then Minister for Industry and Commerce, he stated that a subsidy on a figure of 50 per cent. was fixed tentatively on half the capital cost of constructing the network and the subsidy would have to be subject to review as experience might warrant.

Comment on this