We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Committee on Finance. - Vote 27—Agriculture (Resumed).

Contributions 194–407 of 407. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Well, I believe that with the trend of things and with the way they are going at the moment we would need all the agricultural produce we have for ourselves, and the Minister should be very careful about supplying this "glorious market" that we have at our door and of supplying "the old and valued customer" we heard so much about some time ago in case our own people who need these products might be left without them.

Comment on this

They were long enough without them, were they not?

Comment on this

I wonder is the Minister convinced that there is still an unlimited market across the water at remunerative prices for our products. Does the Minister still think that? Has the experience which he has had since 1948 in dealing with these people not changed him in that belief? I do not think that there is any change whatever in the attitude of these people towards the Irish producers. They have always got us or tried to get us to give them the best of our products at the lowest possible price. There was in the last century a pronouncement made by one of the British Lords Lieutenant——

Comment on this

A Chinn Chomhairle, when we get back a century, might I appeal to you to bring him to order within the scope of the debate?

Comment on this

I do not want any lesson from the Minister for Agriculture on how I should make my speech. When the Chair tells me I am out of order I will accept that.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy may proceed.

Comment on this

As I was saying, that Lord Lieutenant made a statement that the future destiny of this country was to be "the fruitful mother of flocks and herds". He was replying to a statement made by a famous Tipperary man, Charles Joseph Kickham. No matter what the Minister may say or what discussions he may have with the British, that is the attitude of the British still to our country and to the products which we have to sell to them. That has always been their attitude in the past and that still remains their attitude. If the Minister thinks that by taking up that attitude that he can sell to them cheaper because they were our "old and valued customer", he is barking up the wrong tree and is adopting the wrong attitude in not demanding of these people a better deal for the country and for the farmers of this country. He should take a strong line in regard to all these things and withdraw all his past gyrations in the matter of agriculture.

It is very hard to know what the general policy of the Minister is. His policy is, apparently, not that of the whole Government. He is evidently supreme in his own. Department and will not take any dictation from any of the splinter Parties making up the Government or even from the main Party on which the Government is based. He is a lone bird and he has no authority from the Irish people for the things he is doing. He is a bird alone and has been ever since he was thrown out of the Fine Gael Party and he has no authority for any of the somersaults and inconsistencies which masquerade as an agricultural policy. Is the Minister's policy one of bullocks and permanent pasture? Is he a believer in the old dictum of that Lord Lieuteanant who said that the future destiny of Ireland should be that of "a fruitful mother to flocks and herds"? We heard from the Taoiseach shortly after he was elected that they hoped to carry on the agricultural policy of the late Mr. Hogan, who was Minister for Agriculture for Cumann na nGaedheal—go ndeanaid Dia Trócaire ar a anam. I want to tell the Minister and Fine Gael and all the splinter Parties comprising this Coalition Government that that policy was emphatically rejected by the electorate in 1932 and was never given a mandate since. The Fine Gael Party held on to it down through the years and they kept dwindling and dwindling until the day they found that they had only 31 members in a House of 147. That policy was rejected by the people at election after election.

They talk about another cow, another sow and another acre under the plough but they will not say that there was a tail to that statement which had a sting in it. That statement was made in Hospital, County Limerick, when the late Minister, Mr. Hogan, urged the farmers to keep another sow, another cow, another acre under the plough and added that they should "tighten their belts and stick it". We do not want to see any more tightening of belts. Our policy should be the Sinn Féin policy of self-reliance, producing from the land what we need for our people here, and do not let us go, as the Minister is going, to nations outside. He is going to Iraq for barley, the Argentine for oats and to other places for maize and other things which we could produce here from our own land and for which we could find a market at home.

I think we cannot get back to the system in operation here prior to 1931 by which time the price of milk had fallen to the level of 4.47d. per gallon. It went up during the intervening period of 16 years so often referred to here and the average was 1/2¾ or 1/3 for the year round 1947. We cannot go back to the system of laissez faire as far as agriculture is concerned. The best policy here is the Sinn Féin policy of relying on the land of this country to produce our requirements.

Comment on this

You have it in butter now, and you do not like it.

Comment on this

We have not a surplus in butter yet. Recently I got figures for last year from what I regard as a reliable source that we produced 704,000 cwts, of creamery butter and consumed 714,000 cwts. on an eightounce ration. That production is still far and away behind the peak production of 836,000 cwts of creamery butter in 1936.

Comment on this

How much did we export in 1936?

Comment on this

About 35 or 40 per cent.

Comment on this

The people are better off now. They can eat it all at home.

Comment on this

That has been the case for years. We have not exported butter for years. We have not exported a pound of butter since 1940. They ate it all at home.

Comment on this

We had not got it.

Comment on this

Thanks be to God that the time came when the people were able to fare better and had not to depend on margarine as was the case when I was a young lad and as was the case during the Cumann na nGaedheal Government when they sold their butter and bought margarine because it was cheaper. We ate more last year on an 8 oz. ration than we produced—if the figures I got are correct. I believe that the source from which I got them is reliable. I am subject to correction in regard to those figures. The Minister can give us the figures in respect of production and consumption. I think the production figure is correct. It was given in reply to a Parliamentary Question in this House. If that is so, where is the necessity for the eight ounces at all: where is the necessity for the ration? Why not do away with it? It is a disgrace to continue the rationing of butter when production is at the level at which it is at the moment; when there has been an increase in the number of cows and when the cows are milking better, thus pertar mitting of an increased supply of milk to the creameries.

Comment on this

How would you make up the difference between the price for milk and the price for butter?

Comment on this

That is the Minister's responsibility and let him face it.

Comment on this

That is not an answer to the question.

Comment on this

I have an answer to it. However, let the Minister deal with the problem. If we were the Government we would have dealt with it and faced whatever the consequences might have been, popular or unpopular.

Comment on this

The Deputy is making a case; he should answer the question.

Comment on this

I am making the case that we should do away with butter rationing, and I am entitled to do so on the figures available. This matter is the responsibility of the Government. They are continuing the rationing and there is no meaning in it in present circumstances.

I was thrown off my line a small bit but it did not make any difference. I think I got on better as a result. I was asking what was the Minister's policy. I suggested that the best policy for this country would be to produce what we require from the land of Ireland and to let our own people have first preference in purchasing the produce. If there is a surplus in any line we will have to dispose of that surplus as best we can, realising the limitations which there are. There has been a good deal of talk about increasing our agricultural production. There is room for an increase and a substantial increase, in some respects. There is room for an increase in bacon until we meet all our own requirements—and when there is a surplus, well then, God help us because unless we have a better purchaser than the British we are going to be treated as we have always been treated: we are not going to get the price which will give our producers the cost of production, particularly in present conditions and even, as the Minister says, if they walked the pigs out of the houses. There is room, particularly, for an increase in tillage crops—wheat, oats, barley, potatoes, roots and so forth. There is room for an increase in the production of crops, such as vegetables, tomatoes. The Minister is very fond of tomatoes and he has shown it especially as far as the Gaeltacht glasshouse scheme is concerned. However, there is not so much room for increases production in butter, bacon and eggs because as the position is beginning to show itself now, we are going to get burned. If there has to be an export market, the farmers and their workers should not always be expected to provide at sacrifice prices the exports required in order to enable us to purchase those goods which we cannot produce here. Every section of the community should take a share in bearing that burden.

Comment on this

Hear, hear!

Comment on this

What, then, is all the talk about in connection with exports and remunerative prices and so forth?—more of the ballyhoo that we are sick of listening to. Will the Minister shut up about it and, instead, implement a rational agricultural policy, seeing that he occupies the position he does occupy and which he obtained by backstairs barganing. We want no more somersaults, ballyhoo and blather. We want a rational policy which will give security to our people on the land and, so far as it is possible, to know what kind of a future they are facing in this uncertain world. If he can get a policy of that kind on which we can all more or less agree, in principle at any rate, whatever about the details, then we shall be doing a good day's work and, in future, avoid a lot of the interchanges that takes place in these debates every year in regard to agricultural policy in this Minister's period and when other Ministers of the Fianna Fáil Government were in his place.

Comment on this

It might be well at the outset to call attention to the fact that probably we would have a better debate on agriculture if some nonfarming Deputies in their contributions would use language other than that of which I have taken down examples here. I do not think it tends to improve the tone of agricultural debates when certain people who know nothing at all about agriculture come in and accuse the Fianna Fáil Party of having done certain things—of having told inaccurate and untrue stories, and so forth. They talked about the quagmire of agriculture. There are a few Deputies in this House who are noted for stirring up quagmires. It would be much better for agriculture if these Deputies would stick to their own lasts and leave the subject of agriculture to be hammered out by the farmers Deputies. We have heard appeals to the farmers of the country, to the members of the Opposition and to others to co-operate with this Department and these appeals would be given a better hearing if certain Deputies would remain silent. However, the statement was made that there are 70 per cent. of the farmers behind the policy of the present Minister. It might be all the better if we could get away from the practice of using percentages and estimates in certain directions. I challenge that statement and I do so on the basis of having listened to this debate and other debates here and what I have heard from various sections, not alone from the Opposition but from supporters of the inter-Party Government, various criticisms and suggestions to the present Minister about the policy concerned.

We have been arguing here whether there was a surplus of barley, oats and potatoes in the past few years. I am in this position, I happen to be a farmer, and two years ago I had a surplus of potatoes. That was in 1948. I had them in sacks for the buyer; I used to deliver several tons at a time. The merchant I was to sell them to could not buy, and there they were actually growing out of the sacks, and eventually I had to sell them for pig feeding. I had a surplus for feeding my own animals. I suggest that instead of arguing and trying to put on the Opposition that we are out for propaganda, it would be much better to face up to the actual position. We are in fairly normal times but, unfortunately, we are entering on very abnormal times again and the Irish wheat that is growing to-day will have to feed our people until 1951, supposing you cannot get foreign supplies. On that basis I would suggest to all and sundry, to people who get up here and who are not farmers, who get up here only to score points, that it would be better for all of us even to encourage and back up the Minister to give a price incentive for the production of a greater quantity of wheat.

There are many people parting to-day about wheat and what the Fianna Fáil policy was. They were very glad to eat the wheat produced here when we could not get wheat elsewhere, and even then it was necessary to mix in barley and other cereals to keep up our bread supply. I think the Minister will get full co-operation there. We are told of the success of the presentday policy and figures are compared, particularly in regard to cattle and crops. I want to know whether, as regards cattle and crops, it is fair to compare the 1947 season with other seasons. Do we not know that cattle died then in the winter and spring because of the bad class of fodder and the severe weather? It was one of the severest periods in memory. Do we not all know the difficulties the farmers had with the bad quality of the grain after the harvest? They were confronted with great difficulties, due to conditions over which they had no control. We ought to thank God that last year gave us good crops. There was a period when the farmers were perturbed until the rains came, and then things turned for the better.

I do not see any use in all the talk about growing as much wheat on a smaller acreage. It is true, and why not? If the farmers in 1945, 1946 and 1947 had access to manures for their land, conditions would be very different. I heard several speakers refer to the land. I come from a mixed tillage area. Mixed tillage is no new things to us. The word was bandied about by some people who do not know what it means. I come from an old tillage area and I know well that the majority of the farmers are doing their job fairly well. If they had manure from 1946 to 1948, as they had it during the past couple of years, free access to manure, they could have as good crops as they had last year and the year before. That is only common sense.

I give every credit to the Minister and his Department for what they are doing to improve the soil. But let us not give all the credit to the Minister. There must be fair play and it must be admitted that the Fianna Fáil Party started the work at Johnstown Castle, in Wexford. There is splended work going on there and I was glad to hear the Minister giving us an invitation. As a matter of fact, I am going there on the invitation of the young farmers of the district. It will be well worth while.

I would like to nail the lie that Fianna Fáil will not co-operate for the common good. That is wrong. Some of the juvenile speakers here took up that line, but it is wrong. Fianna Fáil will co-operate where necessary for the common good. That sort of talk will not get us anywhere. We have all this talk about the farmers never being better off. I would like to know how many successive good years farmers have had—and by good years I mean years in which average prices would leave the farmers with a reasonable margin over the cost of production. The point is, will one good year make up the difference to a farmer who is hard hit? Will it put him on his feet again? Can anyone say that in recent times the farmers are so well off as some Deputies have suggested here?

My colleagues in my constituency have talked about farmers having motors cars outside churches on Sundays. Are they not as well entitled to have them as the other sections of the community, no matter who they are? As against that, perhaps there was no motor car except the priest's car there ten years ago, but if there are seven or eight cars to-day I would be glad to see them there, and I would be glad to see 40 there. I would not talk in a derogatory way about it.

Comment on this

Those who talked were boasting about it.

Comment on this

As regards the price of wheat, I would ask the Minister to be fair about it. Before we have any more crossfire in the House I would like to ask if it is not a fact that there was an announcement made by the Minister for Agriculture in October, 1947, as a guide to farmers for the 1948 crop, that the prices would be 62/6? It came from the Minister's mouth and we were glad to hear it. He announced that price early in the spring, and he added that it would hold for five years. That was a step in the right direction. I put it to the Minister now that from the time he took office many changes have occurred in farming. Have the farmers' costs not gone up? Are the farmers' costs to-day not going up? Has the cost of machinery to-day, due to the recent devaluation, not gone up? Is the farmer not paying more now for agricultural machinery than he was paying two years ago? Should there not be some set-off against, that?

People talk about average farmers. What does an acre of wheat or barley or any cereal mean in the economy, in the income, of a small farmer? How much net income will he have after all his labour in producing any of those crops? That is a point some people should examine into and they might be less vocal then. They think because the farmers had a good yield and got 62/6 a barrel that he should now be a millionaire. That is contrary to the fact. The same applies to butter. I am sorry the Minister agreed to stop giving a subsidy to the farmers in those areas where there are no creameries and where there was a surplus summer production of butter. I agree there was a certain quantity of butter put on the market that could not be considered of first quality. In the interests of Irish agriculture the less said about that the better.

Comment on this

Hear, hear!

Comment on this

It is not my business to go around parting about how my neighbour does his work. If my neighbour does something that I do not like, that is his business. If we want to sell our producer abroad. I advice the Minister that it would have been better, instead of removing the subsidy at that time, to have sent one of his inspector to stand by in the local towns or get the butter buyers from Cork or wherever they come from to refuse to buy the butter if it was not up to a certain standard. In the year when the subsidy was on, on every Tuesday morning for a number of weeks in the peak period I delivered butter for my wife in the town of Mountmellick.

The butter buyer called attention to the fact that he would like to get more butter well washed and cleanly handled. I agree that if there is an appeal made to segregate the different qualities of butter and to tell people who bring in butter that is not up to quality to go about their business and bring it home, in the same way as our Minister in our time had to tell people to bring home dirty eggs, the situation would be better. We could then leave the good farmers who produce well-made and good-quality butter to get the 2/11.

I say that the recent Government decision proves home to the hilt what I said when you can buy non-subsidised butter at 3/5. I say that the farmers who were producing during the peak period of production were entitled to a price above 3/- for their butter. We have heard some Deputies say that if the butter were brought into Mullingar a better price could have been obtained. How many people could get a fair price for their butter? Do Deputies think that a woman would have the time to go hawking her butter around the town to see what she could get from a few customers? Would it not be better that she should dispose of it in bulk and so have it handled properly?

I suggest to the Minister that if he could establish creameries in suitable areas to take up the peak supply of milk and have it manufactured into butter, it would have the result of increasing the gross production of butter all over the country. That would be a good thing at a time when farmers who cannot afford to pay £7 or £8 for suck calves are at their wits' end as to how they will dispose of their milk.

Comment on this

Will the Deputy help me to have it manufactured into cheese?

Comment on this

On the question of beetgrowing, I think the Minister would be well advised by the Dáil—I think Deputies, no matter in what part of the House they sit, should forget their prejudices and give the Minister this advice—to consider that now is the time for him to prepare a new and a bold policy for the next season. Whether the ploughs that are employed in the work of sowing next season's crop are horse-drawn or tractor-drawn is immaterial. The crops that will be harvested in 1951 will be sown next spring. We see dark clouds hovering around the world. I think the Dáil would be well justified in giving the Minister full support if he were to prepare a bold and a vigorous tillage policy for 1951.

We have heard a lot of talk about Fianna Fáil compulsion. I heard one young Deputy say that Fianna Fáil imposed compulsion in 1939. It did no such thing. I think it was Deputy Fagan who referred to certain selfish farmers who would not do their duty. If it were not for the fact that men who had good land and who could afford to do the tillage which the nation needed failed in their duty, Fianna Fáil would never have imposed compulsion. It was a case of dire necessity when compulsion was introduced.

The same thing happened in the case of the Minister for Supplies. He was criticised afterwards for the provision that he made in having supplies of fuel available. I refer to this because the handling of fuel is considered agricultural work. I am simply making a passing reference to that. But we all remember the talk there was here about the Minister's madness in piling up supplies of fuel in the Phoenix Park. I think that if the Minister for Agriculture were to start now piling up supplies of wheat, oats, barley and beet to ensure the nation's supplies in the next two or three years, every every Deputy should stand behind him, no matter what amount of subsidy he might need to give a fair deal to the farmer and the agricultural worker in producing these supplies. If the Minister were to do that he should not be criticised un fairly for it.

Comment on this

Where would I put the three years' supply? Is it in the Park-with the coal and the turf?

Comment on this

There were some references made to the Tuam beet factory. Some Deputies expressed the hope that it should be closed and taken elsewhere. I think it would be far more sensible to advice the farmers in the western parts of the country, those within a radius of 30 or 40 miles of Tuam, to grow the best which the factory requires. I think every encouragement should be given to them to do that so as to keep the factory in full production and so that the farmers in the midlands would not have to send their beet to the Tuam factory. I think that would be more practical advice to give at the present time than to have this talk of closing down the Tuam factory or of transferring it elsewhere. If that transfer were to be made it could hardly become effective for a year or two. I think the sort of talk that we heard here about the Tuam factory is not calculated to do any good.

I would ask the Minister to press home in the Department that part of the policy which he inherited from his predecessor in relation to farm buildings. Now that buildings materials are becoming more freely available, farmers should be encouraged to avail of those grants and progressively to put up storage for their own grain so that they may be able to earmark a certain quantity of it for the feeding of their own live stock. The question arises, whether the granting of a large number of such applications would interfere with the house building that is going on privately and under the Department of Local Government. I am anxious to know whether in such circumstances there would be sufficient supplies of cement to go all round. I have heard of builders down the country who are doing work for local authorities and when asked by farmers for estimates for the building of cowbyres and lofts for the storage of corn, replied that they had to let men go at a certain time because they could not get supplies of cement. If we could get an assurance that supplies of cement would be available, I think it would be good policy to encourage farmers to avail of those building grants.

Comment on this

The Deputy would not be afraid of his valuation being raised?

Comment on this

No. I am glad the Minister reminded me of that because it was stated by some Deputies who sit on the benches behind the Minister— they must have been referring to me or to some of my colleagues—that at a Fianna Fáil meeting we advised farmers against participating in the farm improvements scheme and the farm buildings scheme. Speaking for myself, I want to say that I never did any such thing. If that statement is attributed to me by any of the spokesmen at the other side of the House, I want to say that it is not true. I am not responsible for what other people may say

This evening a Deputy at the other side said I was scribbling madly and taking notes. I want to say, in reply, that I am entitled to take notes of anything that is said in this House. I have often heard the Minister upholding the privileges of members and I make no apology to anyone for making notes during any debate. If that is the sort of thing that is going to be put across, then, whether it is good for debate or bad for debate, I do not know.

On the question of providing storage for native grain credit must be given to the Fianna Fáil Government for having deliberately had silos erected in our major cities and towns to act as the nation's granaries. I suggest to the Minister that he should erect more granaries at certain strategic points. For instance, one would be very useful in Athlone to take the midland corn. That would be on the direct supply route to the West, where the farmers are not in a position to produce enough grain for their own needs. I remember a few years back when grain was selling at a very unsatisfactory price. I remember having a chat with a certain Deputy here, and telling him how unsatisfactory the price was in the Mountmellick area. We discussed the possibility of transferring the grain from the midlands, where it was in abundance, to the western counties where it was in short supply. This Deputy came from County Mayo. We wanted to transfer it at a fair price to the midland farmer. He agreed to make inquiries, and the following week he came back and said that he could place three or four wagon loads to commence with. He told me the price. I compared the price with the home price and it was better than the price we were getting at the time. But when I went to the railway station to inquire the cost of carrying the grain from the midlands to the west it knocked the bottom completely out of the whole idea. I suggest there is room for improvement in respect to the cost of transport and, if necessary, the Minister should subsidise the railway to enable it to transfer grain to those areas where it is needed.

The Minister must agreed that he did make a mistake with regard to maize prices. I do not blame him for that. Anyone can make a mistake. He certainly promised us Indian meal at £1 per cwt. Taking into consideration the cereal acreage this year, I think this is a matter which should be examined if we are to continue our poultry and pig production. The distribution of grain produced here and its removal at the right time calls for careful examination and consideration of the position. In my opinion the right time at which to take grain off the farmers' hands is when it is in sacks having come back from the mill except, of course, in the case of those farmers who are lucky enough to have adequate storage accommodation. Last year in Tullamore I know that the farmers who had oats to sell could not sell them to the local merchants because there was not sufficient storage. I was standing by when an arrangement was reached between two farmers, one a big grass farmer and the other a small tillage farmer. The man with the grass farm agreed to take the oats at £1 per barrel from his neighbour. I do not think anyone could approved of that arrangement. I think the Minister would be well advised to strike a fair price and to make arrangements through the medium of some State-sponsored scheme to buy up all the barley, oats and wheat at harvest time, and to make arrangements for its storage. That should not be impossible, and I think it would be very advisable in view of the fact that we appear to be approaching yet another emergency.

The Minister did state that extra storage accommodation will be provided. That is a step in the right direction. It is essential that that accommodation should be provided in the right places. In that respect the Minister should pay particular attention to those counties which have a reputation for mixed tillage and where, no matter from what quarter the wind blows, the soil does not become run out. These are the counties with the tillage tradition, and the farmers in them will stick to tillage.

I know a little about the Department and I have had very close association down the years with its officials and instructors. I know a bit about what goes on in Glasnevin. It is not next November or December we should consider this matter. Now is the time to do that. I can assure the Minister that I know several farmers who brought their corn in to the merchants in the normal way and the merchants could not take it off their hands. They had to store the corn in the town.

Comment on this

And they had the storage capacity there?

Comment on this

I do not blame the merchants.

Comment on this

I see.

Comment on this

The Deputy need not try to draw a red herring across the trail. I am probably more concerned about the farming community than the Deputy is since I happen to be a farmer myself. I was talking to a man in Tullamore and, at that time, the quotas were full and some of the merchants had stocks, in fact, from the preceding year.

Comment on this

Idle stores!

Comment on this

That is a matter for the Government and that is where the Government should step in and commission certain people to take up the surplus corn at a fair price.

Comment on this

I suggest a farmers' co-operative should do that for themselves.

Comment on this

Storage cannot be built in a day.

Comment on this

I know that.

Comment on this

I know the Deputy made the suggestion in good faith but there are a lot of snags. If there are areas, as Deputy Davin says there are, in which there is surplus corn the Government should instruct certain merchants to take that corn away and store it to be subsequently dealt with in whatever manner they think fit.

Comment on this

You would agree to that.

Comment on this

I do agree with it.

Comment on this

It should have been done last year.

Comment on this

I am sure Deputy Flanagan's word will be taken. He referred to two districts with which I too am acquainted where the farmers should malting barley at less than £ 1 per barrel. That should satisfy Government Deputies. I am not trying to make propaganda out of it. I am merely stating the fact.

Comment on this

I know you are, and the sooner the co-ops. start working the better it will be for the farmers.

Comment on this

It is a pity that speech was not made last year.

Comment on this

I do not want any dialogue across the floor of the Houses. I do not interrupt other Deputies. I could never understand why the Department, under the direction of the Minister, had to close down the farm improvements scheme for a whole year. I could never understand why that scheme could not have been carried on during that period and then slipped in as part of the land reclamation project. I asked the Minister on one occasion— I think it was a fair question—if he would be prepared in cases where his officials could certify that a farmer had done a certain amount of reclamation work, such as he intends doing himself or getting the farmer to do under the land rehabilitation scheme in order to clear land, to make available to those farmers certain manures and lime. I cannot see why a farmer who cleared certain fields under the guidance of the Minister's predecessor in 1947 and 1948 should be debarred from getting the same benefits from that part of the Minister's programme in relation to lime and manures as the farmers are getting who actually carry out the same work under his particular project. I would advise the Minister not to spend as much as one shilling on certain land unless he is sure that that land will be subsequently maintained. I know old farmers in my constituency who remember certain reclamation work being done. There is an example of it in the Wolfhill area. Deputy Davin knows that area very well. Drainage work was done there; the land was not subsequently maintained and after four or five years it went back to the derelict condition in which it was in the first instance. I think the Minister could improve on his programme if he went out after the second-class land first and put it into good heart. There is a tail of land on practically every farm overgrown with bushes and furze. I think that type of land should be dealt with first. I think it would bring about a better increase in production.

I have recommended and do recommend all farmers to avail of the schemes outlined. I think better improvement work can be done by the farmer and his employees than by an outside interest. There are areas, perhaps, where a Government scheme might be necessary. That is the difficulty. There are areas where there is a scarcity of agricultural workers already.

Comment on this

Hear, hear.

Comment on this

I think that a machine and a couple of men will do a lot of work, but I would prefer the other thing to come first. I am not suggesting that any farmer who wishes to avail of the other parts of the scheme should not have a free choice to do that. That is his own business.

Comment on this

I agree that labour is a problem. There is practically full employment.

Comment on this
Mr. Blaney

40,000 have emigrated.

Comment on this
Mr. Blaney

Since you came into office.

Comment on this

I do not want to carry on this debate any further. I certainly suggest to the Minister that he should not follow the bad example of some of his supporters who have spoken. I think we would have a higher tone in the debate if certain things to which I have been listening were left unsaid. In that way we would face up to a debate of such importance, in the way it should be faced up to.

Comment on this

Since this debate started, one thing that I have noticed flung across to this side of the House from Government Deputies is the allegation that we in Fianna Fáil have deliberately gone out to sabotage the land rehabilitation scheme. I heard my colleague, Deputy Madden, make that accusation against us. Speaking in this debate when introducing the Vote, the Minister as reported in Volume 121, column 1810, said when dealing with the land rehabilitation scheme:—

"Open confession is good for the soul. I ran into a bottleneck. I took a gamble. I believed that the land project would not develop faster than I could locate pipes. In a sense, I am glad and happy to say that it did, but I do not deny that I experienced a couple of weeks' embarrassment because I had drains opened and could not gets pipes to put in them. But where there is a will there is a way. We got them in Derry, Holland, Crumlin, Athlone. We got them wherever we could get them."

He asked for the co-operation of all Deputies in this House to help him out of his difficulty as regards the procuring of pipes. I am glad to inform the Minister that I took him at his word. Further on in the same column the Minister said when speaking about the unsuitability of concrete pipes:—

"Provided the land has not an acid reaction generally (he was speaking in reply to an interjection by Deputy Smith), then the Deputy will have observed that in that category of land we are using clay pipes. These are the ones that we had to get in Derry and anywhere else that we could put our hands on them."

I have welcome news for the Minister. I became interested, and I shall read here a letter I received from a farmer in West Limerick, and I am sure if the Minister was serious in the statement he made here on 15th June that he will take due notice of this letter. It reads:—

"Re yours of yesterday, which I regret I could not answer by return, as I was away from home, the greater portion of my home holding of 200 acres is of clay deposit, the same as that which the brick was made out of years ago. It is about half a mile from the surrounding bogs. This clay deposit is also in many of the adjoining farms. The brick works in Clounleharde were started by Colonel Dixon in the year 1812 and continued successfully until Mr. Sheldrake (Colonel Dixon's steward) retired through illness, when the work fell through. A sample of the clay deposit here was sent to the geological section, Hume Street, and was considered by them as the best of its kind in Eire. There were a great many houses built of the brick—even a number of houses in Limerick City. It is about 130 years since the houses were built in this area and they are in perfect condition."

Further in a postscript he says:—

"The clay (drainage) pipes made from the clay deposit here are still to be seen through the lands in this locality."

I am very glad to have this information for the Minister, as I think that it is proof that the accusation which has been made against us in Fianna Fáil, that we set out deliberately to sabotage the land rehabilitation scheme, is untrue. As a Deputy representing Western Limerick, I can say that the farmers there have availed more of the land project scheme than the farmers in any other district in Ireland. I resent the accusation made against us by Deputy Madden that we went out deliberately to sabotage this scheme.

It was also said that we told the farmers that if they availed of the schemes their land would be revalued. That is not so and the proof of our genuine desire to help in anything that is for the general good is contained in that letter. I would ask the Minister and his officials to look into this matter and if they are anxious to start this industry in Clounleharde they can get clay pipes manufactured there.

Comment on this

May I ask Bord na Móna to get in touch with the Deputy?

Comment on this

I shall be delighted to help. We on this side are at all times willing to co-operate in anything to promote the general interest, but we shall not relinquish our right to stand up here or outside to criticise anything with which we do not agree. That is our right and our privilege. Dealing with the land rehabilitation scheme, there is one factor operating in my part of the country which is not really suitable or acceptable to the small farming community. The fact that in bog land or heavy land they have to bring in heavy machinery is in itself a kind of deterrent to the farmers concerned. I think that Deputy Ben Maguire mentioned in the course of his speech that it would be much better if the farm improvements scheme had been continued so that that particular type of farmer could avail of it.

Comment on this

The farmer need not bring in machines on his holdings. He can do it himself.

Comment on this

He can do it himself but there is one matter I should like to bring to the Minister's notice as regards County Kerry and County Limerick where the inspectors are operating these schemes. I think that Deputy Smith explained the matter already. Inspectors go out, pay their visits and come back again with a map of your holding. I know of one particular instance in which they came back and told the farmer:—

"You will have to make 120 perches of drain to the acre, so many main and so many minor, as the case may be."

Many of the farmers in that district were satisfied that 80 perches to the acre would be just as effective as under the farm improvements scheme. Again there is too much delay. I have evidence that when the scheme started In County Limerick on 1st November a good many people applied for application forms, filled them up and sent them to Dublin. These people have got no directions from the inspectors or the supervisors as to when they are to start work. The Minister can state otherwise if he likes but I am telling him what the actual position is. There is no headway being made with that scheme whereas under the farm improvements scheme if it was expanded to meet the case of the people I have in mind you would have three times the amount of work done in the last six months.

Comment on this

You are quite mistaken, Deputy.

Comment on this

If the Minister says I am quite mistaken it is a matter of opinion and a matter of his opinion against mine. I am only giving him the evidence of what I know.

Comment on this

But I have the facts.

Comment on this

And I am telling the Minister what I know and trying to show him that there is some negligence or undue delay on the part of the inspectors carrying out the scheme. I received a letter this morning from a man on this matter. He said:—

"Mr. Collins will you kindly ask Mr. Dillon a few questions? I sent in a form in February to have work done and completed by April 18th. The work was completed on that date, but up to the 3rd of April I was still waiting on the manure. It has so far not arrived and has held up the whole crop."

If this Department which is charged with the responsibility of administering the land project scheme is administering it in the way that Mr. Leahy of a certain town in Limerick says it is being administered, I am sure it would be a matter that the Minister would take up.

Comment on this

You bet, and as you have read the complaint I will read the answer.

Comment on this

Leaving the question of the land rehabilitation scheme I would like to draw the attention of the Minister to what I consider to be the very unfair rate of pay that is given to the farm improvements inspectors as against the rates paid to the supervisors employed in the land rehabilitation scheme. Is the Minister aware that the majority of the farm buildings inspectors have ten farm experience and some of them have up to 15 years, experience?

Comment on this

Their scales were fixed by my predecessor and the other scales by me.

Comment on this

The Minister is now the man in occupation of that office, and is he not prepared to give equal pay to the officials working inspectors employed on the land rehabilitation scheme had no experience whatever, and in some instances they were men who were brought back from England.

Comment on this

Quite right. We brought the exiles home without talking about it.

Comment on this

But others who were employed on the farm improvements scheme for a number of years were thrown out of their work and they had to go across to England. They were men with five and six years' experience of the work, and they were dumped out.

Comment on this

Who were they?

Comment on this

They were men with five years' experience on the scheme. I would be prepared to give the Minister the names of these men.

Comment on this

If you are be sure that you have got their permission before you raise their case in public.

Comment on this

I am glad to have raised that point. I want the Minister to give the same recognition in regard to pay to the men employed on the farm buildings scheme as he has given to the supervisors on the land rehabilitation project.

On the question of manures, is the Minister aware that Limerick County Council initiated a sea-sand scheme and it was sanctioned by the Minister's Department?

Comment on this

Long, long ago.

Comment on this

This sea-sand subsidy was very beneficial to the small farmers in this particular area of 200 square miles but that scheme has been knocked on the head by a recent Order.

Comment on this

How long would the Deputy take to get to the Ballybunion Strand?

Comment on this

What has the Minister in mind about Ballybunion?

Comment on this

How long is the Deputy going to take to get there?

Comment on this

Has the Minister any objection to my discussing sea sand as a manure?

Comment on this

None whatever.

Comment on this

The value of sea sand as a manure is of very great importance to the farmers in whom I am interested. I do not know what the Minister thinks about it, but I do know that it is valuable and was being used extensively. The Minister may be surprised to hear that this particular sand from the foreshore of Ballybunion contains 65 per cent. of lime and potash and other salt deposits in surprisingly high percentages. Apart from its manurial qualities and value, it has a physical value on the land which is of great importance to tillage. We have in Limerick loamy soil, and the physical value of this sand to the soil is very important. It prizes up the land for dressing and tillage. I am sure the Minister is aware that quite recently, as a result of a regulation made by the Minister for Industry and Commerce, farmers in the area are precluded from taking this sand.

Comment on this

I beg the Deputy's pardon.

Comment on this

Is the Minister aware that the Minister for Industry and Commerce issued a regulation prohibiting the farmers from taking this sand?

Comment on this

No, but I am aware that the Deputy's colleague, Deputy Lemass, made a regulation to that effect which was substantially relaxed by the present Minister and which was designed to exclude contractors from taking this sand away for gravel for assistant county surveyors in another part of the county.

Comment on this

Can I therefore accept the Minister's assurance that farmers are free to avail of this sand?

Comment on this

As I did not make the Order I cannot speak in that regard. It was an Order made by the Minister for Industry and Commerce.

Comment on this

I want to impress on the Minister that he should endeavour to arrange with the Minister for Industry and Commerce to have the traditional rights of the farmers in the district to take this sand for their soil restored to them. The Minister should arrange with the Minister for Industry and Commerce that the right of the farmers of that area from time immemorial should be given back to them and that any recent restrictions or rearrangements of the regulations under the Foreshore Act should not preclude the farmers of that area from drawing sea sand for their own use,

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Minister is not responsible.

Comment on this

I know that the Minister is not responsible, but I am asking him to use his influence if it is his policy to go out for increased production.

Comment on this

The Fianna Fáil Foreshore Act of 1933 caused the trouble.

Comment on this

It never caused us a bit of trouble. Under that Act a certain mark was laid down in the foreshore and we had a right to take what sand we required within that mark. It is only within the past few months that a committee in Ballybunion used its influence with the Minister for Industry and Commerce to prevent us from taking what sand we required. There is no use in blaming Fianna Fáil for the Act of 1933. They brought in that Act—and rightly so—in order to protect cliff bound coasts, but they were wise enough to realise the value of the sand to the farmers of West Limerick and North Kerry and to give us the right to draw all the sand we required. Now we are cut off and we are not allowed to draw it.

I come now to the price of milk. The price of milk was last fixed in 1947 by Deputy Smith when he was Minister for Agriculture. Surely the present Minister does not contend that the price fixed in 1947 is justified to-day in view of the increase in costs of production and so forth? The Minister's offer to the creameries of a five-year plan of 1/- a gallon was, I believe, mainly influenced by the defeat of the motion in the names of Deputy Cogan and Deputy P. O'Reilly in this House on the 8th March last. When that motion was defeated I believe the Minister realised he had a backing and that he could with all confidence issue this ultimatum to the farmers. The farming Deputies who supported the rejection of that motion were, I believe, responsible for driving our farmers into a defensive position in respect of the ultimatum issued by the Minister. I am glad that Deputy Halliden is here now and listening to me. I read an account of proceedings at a meeting which was held in North Cork at which he was to some little extent brought to task for voting against that motion. The excuse he gave was that it was Fianna Fáil inspired. Can any reasonable person or body of men imagine that Deputy Cogan or Deputy P. O'Reilly would be inspired to do anything for or by the Fianna Fáil organisation or the Fianna Páil Party? The present Minister immediately issued his ultimatum to our farmers to accept 1/- a gallon on a five-year plan. That was rejected. I think the circular was sent to about 100 creameries and that only three agreed: that means that 97 threw it back. It is regrettable that those of us on all sides of the House who are interested in the dairying industry should now find ourselves in a defensive position—trying to defend and hold on to the price of 1/2 a gallon when we should be making strong representations to the Minister to increase the price of milk. The Minister told us that he would never interfere with the dairying industry without the full consent and approval of the industry itself. I am sorry that he is now leaving the House. I had a few interesting things which I should have liked him to have heard.

Comment on this

Did I not stand my ground well?

Comment on this

The Minister is tiring.

Comment on this

I shall be back.

Comment on this

I shall read an article from the Irish Times, dated the 12th May, 1950. Mind you, the Irish Times is not a Fianna Fáil paper. I am sure it never had much love or regard for or interest in the Fianna Fáil movement.

"The statement in yesterday's Irish Times that the Minister for Agriculture intends to dispose of surplus creamery butter at 3/6 per lb. off the ration was officially confirmed last night; and the butter— which may be bought in unlimited quantities—will be wrapped in a distinctive wrapper.

The Irish Times also learnt from official sources that there is no intention to alter the price of milk at the creameries.

Farmers supplying milk to creameries have been receiving a family butter ration of 12 ozs. for each person; this will be reduced to 8 ozs. for each person and will result in a saving to the Exchequer in sub—sidy of some £120,000 a year. The butter subsidy for the present year is estimated at £2,639,000."

Note this and note it well. By reducing the family butter ration of 12 ozs. per person to 8 ozs. the Minister has filched £120,000 from our dairy farmers and driven them into his black market to buy the extra amount at an increased cost of another £120,000, which two figures, added together, total £240,000—almost £250,000. The figures are there to be contradicted if the Minister is able to do so. That is really what happened. Then we hear a lot of talk about non-interference with the dairying industry and that unless the people concerned give willing authority, so to speak to the Minister, he will not interfere. I think the interference with the butter ration was an interference that should not have been made by any Minister. Imagine almost £250,000 being taken overnight from the dairying industry!

I listened on Thursday night last to my very distinguished colleague, Deputy Madden, of Limerick, defending the Minister and making a prima facie case for the Minister in connection with a circular which he sent out to 100 dairying societies to accept 1/- a gallon over a period of five years. On the 22nd June—column 2260—Deputy Madden is reported as follows:—

"The dairying industry, it is admitted, is the basis of our whole economy and it is to this point I would like to draw the attention of the Minister for Agriculture—I am glad he is here.

Perhaps there was good and sufficient reason for the Minister to leave to the farmers of the country a few months ago to decide whether to accept 1/- a gallon for a period of five years, but I would draw Deputies' attention to the international position of milk. In the United States of America £1,000,000,000 sterling of milk has been converted into food and in that same country there has been converted or manufactured into food— and this is rather staggering—nine years of the United States egg supply ready if you like to be released on the world market."

I would like to ask the Minister—I am sorry he is not here—a very simple question. I will first point out that quite recently Eggsports received from America a request for Irish eggs which would be paid for in hard currency but, owing to our egg agreement with Britain, they could not accept the American order, much as we in this country require hard currency. It is, I suppose, a repetition of the old proverb, having all our eggs in the one basket.

This statement I make publicly in this House, to be checked by the Minister if he so desires, that Eggsports received from America an order for Irish eggs and America would pay for the eggs in hard currency; but we could not supply them with an egg because we were tied up by our egg agreement with Britain. That offer from America had to be refused. The Minister told us in the Dáil that 2/- a dozen for eggs sent across the water was a sufficient price, a fairly reasonable price, and he said that during the winter months the price would go up to 3/6.

We all remember when the Minister came back from England and when he announced the terms of the trade agreement with England as regards eggs and other things that he tried to sell at the time. He said that the more eggs we supplied to the British market the better the price would be, and he could guarantee a continuity of a good price. Our people in every part of rural Ireland went full-steam ahead into the poultry industry.

We have here, as a matter of fact, according to the White Paper issued by the Minister, the amount of public money invested in the creation of poultry stations all over the country. The wives of small farmers made applications to county committees for loans or grants. What do we find at the moment? We find that that industry has gone. There is no use in refusing to face facts. The egg industry is killed for this reason, that the Minister was prepared to give all the eggs to John Bull at 2/- a dozen. I maintain that he had no right, in the first instance, without the approval of this House, to go to England to make that egg agreement with the British. He had no right to subscribe to any condition or stipulation that the price of Irish eggs would be governed by the price the Danes would supply eggs at to the English market. He committed our egg industry, by subscribing to that condition, to such an extent that now the egg industry is destroyed.

He was in a big position to fight and to say to the British: "We can supply all the eggs you require at a fixed minimum price over a fixed number of years." When he came back here he was actually applauded by Deputies on his side of the House when he announced the terms of the agreement, but he never told us that this secret clause was in that agreement, or that the price was to be governed by the price the British were prepared to pay to the Danes, the price the Danes were willing to supply at. That has put our egg industry in a bad position.

At the time the egg agreement was made with the British the Minister made a statement to the effect that we could get all the maize required for £1 a cwt. Possibly, it might not be fair to the Minister to criticise him unduly for making that wild statement. Possibly, unforseen world conditions made it possible to prove that the Minister should not have made that statement. Anyhow, the fact remains that the price of maize has soared, with the result that any sensible Deputy who comes from a rural area cannot deny that the people cannot continue putting eggs on the market because there is no reasonable margin of profit if they have to pay the present price for maize.

Comment on this

America has sold eggs to England, 15,000 tons at 2/- a lb. She has eggs in her stores to do for seven years.

Comment on this

I will repeat for the benefit of Deputy Hickey that Eggsports received an order from America for eggs to be paid for in hard currency and they could not supply the eggs. Is that not very clear? We have heard an awful lot during this debate about the Dairy Livestock Act of 1926. All my life I have felt that this Act was of British design and was imposed on this country to suit British interests. The results have proved that I am right, because to a great extent, notwithstanding all the talk about the dual-purpose cows, dual-purpose bulls, dual-purpose hens and so forth, the operation of the Dairy Livestock Act of 1926 would eventually destroy our dairying industry. In my opinion, at any rate, you cannot have beef and milk. I have seen pedigree dairy shorthorn cows mated to pedigree bulls and I saw the second and third generation leaving the milk strain and going into beef.

The late Deputy Patrick Hogan gave it as his opinion in 1932, when he was speaking here on the Opposition Benches, giving way to Deputy Dr. Ryan who was then Minister for Agriculture—Deputy Hogan was handing over the Department of Agriculture in 1932—that you could not have milk and beef. It is the opinion of the vast majority of our dairy farmers also. Just before the change of Government I understand a conference of the beef and dairy interests was held and for some time there was a discussion about the repeal of this Act.

As I have said, it was the British who imposed it and, unfortunately, it was readily accepted in 1926. It is easy to understand why it was accepted then. I am firmly convinced that the Dairy Livestock Act of 1926 should be repealed. I know that my pleadings and representations will fall on deaf ears while the present Minister for Agriculture occupies that post. I firmly believe that in agriculture he has a one-track policy. His policy in agriculture was, I think, very ably demonstrated here to-day by Deputy Fagan. His policy in agriculture is the policy of the rancher. I was amazed, and rather surprised, to hear Deputy Fagan say that the present Minister for Agriculture was the best Minister for Agriculture that we ever had in this country, and that he could not see many Fianna Fáil farmer-Deputies at the Dublin cattle market any morning. Well, a lot of them would not have the opportunity of going there and even if they were they would not be in the happy position that Deputy Fagan is in of being a salesmaster.

The policy that was initiated here and carried on for a long number of years, a policy that was imposed on us in 1926, was specially designed by the British to destroy our dairying industry and to change it over, in the course of time, to the production of beef of the best and finest quality to suit the people at the other side. It is no wonder that Deputy Fagan should throw bouquets at the Minister and tell us that he is the best Minister for Agriculture we have ever had. If the agricultural policy of this country as it relates to dairying and its allied branches is simply to be one primarily for the production and development of bullocks here, then the people who imposed that Act on us in 1926 can say: "Well, we have scored at last."

I maintain that if the dairying industry, which we recognise is the basis of our agricultural policy, does not get the protection and the help it requires, Deputy Fagan from Meath will have very little to offer for sale some fine day in the Dublin market, because if dairying is not encouraged and maintained you cannot have cattle for export. Well now, we cannot expect to keep our dairying industry on a safe level unless our dairying farmers are paid a decent price for their milk. We hear a lot from the Minister about this "Drink more milk" campaign that he has initiated all over the country, and we hear a lot of complaints and objection about the price of milk to, say, the Dublin consumer or the Dublin housewife. The people who make such complaints never pause for a moment to ask themselves the question, what quantity of milk does it take in, say, the counties of Cork, Limerick or Tipperary to make a pound of butter? It takes from 2? to 2½ gallons of milk to produce a pound of butter. That is the position in the Golden Vale. The farmers are selling their milk at 1/2 a gallon, and so the calculation of what it takes to make a pound of butter is a simple one. On the other hand, we find that the same quantity of milk which the housewife consumes costs exactly 3¼ times the price. Is there any Deputy from Dublin, be he a Labour Deputy or a Fine Gael Deputy or a Deputy of any other Party, who will contradict me when I say that butter is the best food that can be made available to any family?

The Minister for Agriculture asked while Deputy Gorry or Deputy Ó Briain was speaking for a solution or a way out of the difficulty. That is his responsibility. Deputy Ó Briain advocated the total abolition of butter rationing, and so do I. Immediately the Minister asked: "What will you do between this and between that"? That is his responsibility and his job as Minister. If he is not able to present to this House a solution, that is an admission of failure on his part —that he has not a solution. We have a solution which we will put into operation when it is our responsibility to take over agriculture in this country. The solution will be found, and was found by Deputy Dr. Ryan in 1932, when he brought in the Dairy Stabilisation Act, at a time when milk was as cheap as water.

I heard comments being made here as regards the price of milk in certain years. We were told that in 1931 the price of milk per gallon was 4.47d and that in 1932 it was 4.53d. In 1933-34, when Deputy Dr. Ryan's Dairy Stabilisation Act of 1932 would be coming into operation and giving us in the dairying industry the results we expected, our prices were pegged back to 4.12d and to 4.13d., due to the British tariffs. As Deputies will remember, we were then in the throes of the economic war when tariffs were imposed. When we go down along the line we find that the price paid for milk in 1945 and 1946 averaged between 11.32d. and 11.45d., while in 1947 the average price was 14.56d. In 1948, due to the fact that fertilisers had become more plentiful, milk supplies increased and the average price paid was—I am speaking of butter fat at the moment— 15.02d.

I think that even if I had the oratorical gifts of Philpot Curran I would be only wasting my time trying to make any impression on the present Minister. No matter what representations are made or what case is put up, I believe the Minister has definitely decided to keep the price of milk pegged down. I know that a certain amount of pressure has been brought to bear on him by the farmer Deputies supporting his Government. They are no fools and if Mr. Dillon——

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Minister.

Comment on this

And if the Minister insists on 1/- per gallon on a five year plan that will spell political suicide for the farmer Deputies supporting the present Government. The farmer Deputies supporting the Government cannot play fast and loose with the people who sent them here. They should stand up and openly tell the people through the House that the farmers who are getting 1/2 per gallon are not getting a sufficiently remunerative price. If they have not the courage to do that, then they should do what some other Deputies did recently in relation to the foreshore sand.

Deputy Finucane, in the interests of the dairy farmers of North Kerry, had to take a certain line of action when he discovered that 41 farmers from his particular area were fined a total of £700 for taking this sand for manure. The position was fraught with danger for Deputy Finucane. I understand a solution was found along a certain line of action adopted by Deputy Finucane; that line of action was to issue an ultimatum to the present Government that if the restriction were not relaxed and the regulations amended he and some of his colleagues would withdraw their support. Naturally, rather than have a split, the Government surrendered. I wonder would the farmer Deputies listening to me now have the same courage as Deputy Finucane had and another Deputy from the Midlands who inspired the move. Can they not be as courageous as Deputy Finucane was? It is hardly likely that they will be when one remembers that Deputy Cogan and Deputy O'Reilly brought in a motion to increase the price of milk and were the first to vote against it.

It can be proved beyond yea or may that production costs have gone up by at least 25 per cent. since 1947. Would the farmer Deputies not have the courage now to bring in a motion on behalf of the people they represent asking the Minister to fix a minimum price of 1/4 a gallon? If they have the courage to do that they will be assured of the wholehearted support of the Fianna Fáil Party. I know that they will not do that because, hitched together as they are, if one thread gave way the whole fabric would be destroyed. We should be honest with ourselves and with the people who sent us here. The present price of 1/2 per gallon does not pay any dairy farmer any more than it pays his wife to sell eggs across the water at 2/- per dozen. I am sorry the Minister cleared out because I had some interesting points to make.

On the 2nd May, 1950, addressing the Irish Agricultural Organisation Society at their annual meeting in Dublin, the Minister is reported in the Irish Press of Wednesday, 3rd May, 1950, as follows:—

"Unless they could produce milk during the seven months period of growing grass and convert it into butter for sale over the 12 months the dairy industry had no future.

Mr. Dillon, replying later to suggestions that the present prices should be maintained, said that he did not pay the subsidies, and nothing could be more attractive for an active politician than to pay a subsidy of £6 instead of £4.

What good did it do to him to vex every dairy farmer in Ireland, he asked, when he would not be a 1d. poorer if the subsidy was raised?

He could not, in consequence, recommend to the farmers of this country that they should pay foreigners £4 a cwt. to take our butter away. He had been criticised for making the London agreement on beef exports without getting a price for butter. Could they demand from any foreign purchaser a price in excess of that at which the Danes could supply it?"

There, the cat is out of the bag with regard to the agreement he negotiated when he went across the water to meet the British Minister of Food.

"Mr. Dillon said that, in spite of the problem in front of them, he was not in the least pessimistic. He might get trampled underfoot in the process but he would know his resurrection behind the counter from which he came, and it might pay him better than the £1,525 which he was paid as Minister for working 14 hours a day; but if he had not wanted the job, he need not have taken it. `I was 15 years wanting to be Minister for Agriculture,' he said. `I got what I wanted, and when I stop wanting I will tell you. I will continue to give my best and if you sack me before I resign there will be no ill-feeling.' "

If part of the Minister's speech could become effective, it would be the best news the farmers could have. He said he might be trampled underfoot in the process but he would know his resurrection behind the counter from which he came; as far as the dairy industry is concerned it is a pity the Minister did not stay behind the counter. One extraordinary thing in this debate is the fact that the Minister is singled out, not here in the Dáil but outside, as being responsible for the failure of the agricultural policy.

Again, the responsibility of the Minister for Agriculture should be the responsibility of the whole Government. Their attitude brings to my mind an expression used in army circles. They remind me of the round robin. None of them is prepared to take responsibility and they sign their names in a circle. They are not prepared to bear the collective responsibility they should bear for the policy of agriculture, as it relates to the country at the moment. I think that, in the absence of the Minister, I am more or less wasting my sweetness on the desert air. I have a lot of stuff here, but I do not like to inflict it on the Minister for Defence, who has the responsibility of defending the agricultural policy of the Government in the absence of the Minister. In conclusion, I would again appeal to the farmer elements who support this Government to see that the policy of the Minister for Agriculture as regards dairying is changed, and changed in the very near future.

Comment on this

I had the privilege, as this debate went on so long, of reading the speech the Minister made in introducing the Estimate very carefully. I was also able to compare his speech with the speeches he made in introducing the 1949 Estimate and the 1948 Estimate. What was interesting about a comparison of these three speeches is the change we find in the Minister for the couple of years he has occupied that position. I would describe the speech of 1948 as a most optimistic, a fighting speech, if you like. In the speech of 1949 he was on his guard, and this year his speech might be described as a defensive speech. I do not wonder at that, because the Minister was unduly optimistic about his expectations from the agreement made with Great Britain in 1948. He based his optimism for the future on the benefits that were to accrue from that agreement.

One could read several quotations from the speech the Minister made at that time and on the Estimate for 1948. As a matter of fact, the Ceann Comhairle might recollect that the Minister was ruled out of order on the Estimates for his impatience in trying to talk about the merits of this agreement with Great Britain. He actually said: "It is my impatience to deal with them and to disclose their advantage which brings them to my mind." Eventually, when the question of order was discussed and when the Ceann Comhairle had agreed that it would be practically impossible to prevent a reference to the agreement in the debate, it was thought that the agreement might be referred to. The Minister said that the articles of agreement created quite unprecedented advantages for the agricultural industry of this country. He said it was his job, or part of his job, to give the farmers an opportunity to dispose of the fruits of their labour. "That I have already done," he said in 1948. If the Minister goes back over his speeches and particularly dwells on these few words: "That I have already done" and if he then runs his mind over the last few years and just dwells on oats, potatoes, flax, bacon, butter, cream, cheese and eggs and the other items, would the Minister now ask himself: "Was I unduly optimistic?"

Comment on this

Would you?

Comment on this

I would say the Minister was foolish to make such statements. I do not know whether the Minister would agree with that. Either the Minister was mistaken as to the terms of the agreement or he was absolutely mistaken as to the general conditions of agriculture and what might be expected in the coming couple of years——

Comment on this

Was there anything during your whole administration that would compare with last year?

Comment on this

The Minister——

Comment on this
Deputies

Answer the question.

Comment on this
Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy is entitled to make his own speech.

Comment on this

I want to refer to the Minister's statement. If I ever said that my job was to provide an outlet for the fruits of the farmers' labour, that might be my job, but if I were to say then: "That I have already done," I think I would be subjected to criticism. In fact, I would say that it would be very difficult for any Minister for Agriculture that ever appeared in this country or probably will ever appear—at least unless the world changes very much—to say: "That I have already done." It is only a man with the optimism of the present Minister that could say a thing like that. I said here before and I say it again that we on these benches were inclined to believe that the Minister had made a great settlement. We did question the Minister very much because we felt to make an agreement equal to that described by the Minister was a very difficult matter and we questioned the Minister very closely. He assumed, of course, that we did not want to see a good agreement, that we were jealous, and he said that he did not wonder at our being rather disturbed about the agreement. These were the sort of answers he gave us. These are the types of answers which it is customary for him to give but he persisted that everything was right. He said that it was on success or failure of his policy in respect of agriculture in regard to these matters that his whole policy would ultimately fall to be judged.

Comment on this

Quote the text.

Comment on this

At column 2607 of Volume 3 Official Reports he says:—

"I am in a position to say to the farmers of this country that there is an unlimited market. Mind you, it is an unlimited market."

Not an unlimited market for 5,000 tons of potatoes but an unlimited market. It is not a market for 2,000 tons of farmers' inferior butter but an unlimited market at remunerative prices for cattle, sheep, pigs—and we exported one pig in January—and for butter.

Comment on this

Remember we had no pigs for the previous eight years.

Comment on this

And he continued:

"For cattle, sheep, pigs, butter, for cream."

Comment on this

He says yes although the British will not take cream at all.

Comment on this

Who will not take it?

Comment on this

The British.

Comment on this

Are you sure?

Comment on this

The Minister for Food said so a few weeks ago.

Comment on this

To your great rejoicing.

Comment on this

No, I am not rejoicing.

Comment on this

Do not rejoice 100 per cent.

Comment on this

No, the position may change. I am just asking the Minister is he prepared to state now what he stated in that particular instance, that he was in a position to assure the farmers of an unlimited market at remunerative prices?

Comment on this

Yes, for cattle, pigs, sheep and butter, I believe.

Comment on this

He believes.

Comment on this

For cream, cheese and bacon?

Comment on this

Without subsidy?

Comment on this

Yes, I hope so. You know negotiations are proceeding in London.

Comment on this

And potatoes?

Comment on this

No, I never said potatoes. You made that mistake last year and I had to correct you.

Comment on this

Did I make that mistake last year? Sorry.

Comment on this

Yes, I made you get the book——

Comment on this

Deputy Ryan is surely in possession.

Comment on this

You said potatoes according to this reference.

Comment on this

Will the Deputy read it out?

Comment on this

I will read it out. It says:—

"I am in a position to say to the farmers that there is an unlimited market at remunerative prices for cattle, pigs, sheep, cheese, butter, cream, bacon and potatoes."

Comment on this

I made a mistake last year but there is no mistake this year. It goes on:—

"Potatoes, barley, and oats and the more they can produce the better we hope prices to be..."

Comment on this

Yes, go on.

Comment on this

"There is no reservation and no qualification about that. I do not think that any Minister for Agriculture has ever been in a position to say that before, or to say to the farmers of this country that it will be irrevocably true for at least four years."

Two years of that four have already gone and do the Deputies behind him believe what the Minister says is true?

Comment on this

Without a shadow of doubt.

Comment on this

In what respect do you deny it?

Comment on this

Does the Minister deny that he said it?

Comment on this

The Minister continuing said:—

"And we hope it may be for a much longer term to come. Therefore I say to them to increase the number of their fowl, to concern themselves to sell their eggs especially in the winter."

Comment on this

Yes, 3/6 a dozen. Would you lend me the book?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

Stop the interruptions.

Comment on this

The Minister could not content himself with naming certain things.

Comment on this

Might I interrupt the Deputy?

Comment on this

Will the Minister have manners?

Comment on this

He could not content himself with naming certain things and in June 9th, 1948, at column 2607 he repeated all those things. Again at column 2252, Volume 112 of the Official Reports he said:—

"There is no achievement in the course of my ministry of which I shall be prouder than this agreement which my colleagues and I have brought back from London. It provides for the farmers of this country a sure and certain market at remunerative prices for every conceivable product that the land can produce."

Comment on this

Including pigs.

Comment on this

Including pigs and butter. For every conceivable produce that the land of Ireland can produce. There was no qualification about that.

Comment on this

There was no qualification in the Minister's speeches in 1948. I stated here, before the Minister came in, that this type of talk was wrong. I had the advantage, or should I say privilege, of reading the Minister's speech, because it appeared in the Press some days ago, and I am in the position that I was able to read it in 1948 and 1949 and to know that this particular optimism has disappeared.

Comment on this

Oh, no.

Comment on this

We do not hear now that there is a remunerative market as a result of this agreement with Great Britain for every conceivable product that the land of Ireland can produce.

Comment on this

I think there is.

Comment on this

We will take them item by item.

Comment on this

Take them seriatim.

Comment on this

Yes, we will take them seriatim, and I will start with cattle. Cattle are, I presume, the one particular product which the Minister and the Deputies sitting behind him here would say had benefited considerably by the agreement of 1948.

Comment on this

Say a word about calves now.

Comment on this

On a point of order a Leas-Chinn Chomhairle, the Minister for Agriculture is continuing to interrupt and are we not entitled to ask that if he cannot sit and listen to the speech of Deputy Ryan he should leave the House?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Interruptions are disorderly from whatever quarter they come and they should not be persisted in.

Comment on this

The Deputy was to take the items seriatim, and then he proceeds to head away and skip over some.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

All interruptions are disorderly.

Comment on this

I am taking the first one on the list and I presume it is the one which the Minister claims has conferred the greatest benefit on this country. I do not mind the Minister's interruptions because as long as he interrupts me I know I am doing very well. If he did not interrupt me then I would know I was not making a good case.

Comment on this

Do not be too hard on him.

Comment on this

I will not be too hard on him but I want to tell him the facts. First of all the agreement so far as cattle is concerned did not make any change whatsoever in the position as regards store cattle. Under the 1938 Agreement store cattle were allowed into Great Britain free of duty and free of restrictions as regards numbers so that the Minister in his agreement made no change to our advantage in that matter. He did make a slight change so far as it affected fat cattle shipments to Great Britain. In the speeches in this House to which I have referred—both on the Estimate in 1948 and on the agreement in 1948—and the many speeches made by the Minister down the country, it will be seen that he gave the people a very glowing outline of what it was going to mean to the future of the fat-cattle industry in this country. I have no doubt that the Minister felt that that agreement was going to improve the fat-cattle trade —and it did, but not very much.

Comment on this

Oh, a mere bagatelle! You could put it in a child's hands.

Comment on this

I would not call it a mere bagatelle, but at the same time it was nothing amazing. Let us take two years before and after for the sake of comparison. The number of fat cattle exported in 1946 from this country to Great Britain was 35,000—I am giving the figures to the nearest thousand. In 1947 the number was 110,000; in 1948, 66,000; in 1949, 134,000. If any Deputy wishes to examine these figures I may say that he will not find that between 1947 and 1948 something remarkable occurred to make any enormous difference, because there was not an enormous difference. To take the two years together, 1946 and 1947, and comparing the total with that for 1948 and 1949, there was an increase in 1948-49 compared with the two other years, but it was nothing very much.

Comment on this

With regard to this agreement, I would say that we must do our best to give the farmer of this country a better market in Great Britain for his produce. That was the object of the agreement. It was on that basis that the agreement got all the praise the Minister and the other members of the Government gave it. Therefore, it is well for us to take note of the total number of cattle exported during the four years. I have given the House the number of facts already. However, the total number of cattle exported in 1946 was 462,000; in 1947, 482,000; in 1948, 373,000—that is 100,000 down.

Comment on this

What did we get for them?

Comment on this

In 1949 the number was 467,000. As my colleague behind me has said, there is very little use in talking to the Minister because he does not listen. The price of store cattle was in no way related to the agreement made with the present Minister for Agriculture. Therefore, if he asks me how much we got——

Comment on this

What we got for the cattle would seem relevant.

Comment on this

What we got for the cattle is a very important matter, but I say that the Minister's achievement, as he refers to it here, in negotiating that agreement had nothing to do with the price. I would remind him that world conditions are an important factor to be taken into consideration.

Comment on this

Still, it would be very interesting to hear it.

Comment on this

I think that that is as much as I shall say in regard to cattle. I have a large number of items to go through and if I am to give a few minutes to each I must proceed. Sheep: the number of sheep is small because we are using practically the whole output of this country and what sheep are being exported are getting a good price. We can dismiss sheep at that. Pigs: Now, we will have something to say about that industry.

Comment on this

You have nothing to compare with them because there were not any pigs when you were there.

Comment on this

I am sorry if the Minister gets annoyed.

Comment on this

Not a bit.

Comment on this

I thought I was entitled to take part in this debate. When the Minister was in opposition and when I was on the Government side of the House, he never lost an opportunity of speaking on this Estimate. He used to say very hard things but I did not get annoyed because I knew he did not mean them. I ask him, therefore, to try and control himself while I am going through those few points. Strange to say, when the Minister took over control, although I made what you might describe as a fairly close search of his various statements—and the Minister speaks very often and volubly —I could not find any reference to pigs or bacon in the early months when he took over.

Comment on this

There were not any.

Comment on this

The Minister, speaking at Clones on 18th July, 1948, said that the position was obscure regarding feeding stuffs up to now but that now he is satisfied that we can secure maize and other feeding stuffs at a price which will make pig-feeding profitable. That statement is fair enough. It was the first statement he made and it was an indication to the farmers that they should go more into pig production. The next point we note is that which I have already quoted in relation to the trade agreement where he told the farmers that for whatever they might produce—pigs or anything else—there would be a certain market at a remunerative price. That was a very good hint to the farmers to go ahead. Pig production then increased fairly considerably and we had reached the point where we had enough bacon for ourselves—and then the Minister began to talk about bacon for export. In October and November of last year, the Minister, in a number of his statements, complained of the treatment of the farmer by the factories. He said that they were not paying the farmer a price commensurate with the price they were charging for the bacon. He made two threats—(1) that he would licence the export of live pigs and that, if that did not succeed, (2) he would build Government factories.

In or around that time, about August, 1949, the Minister removed the control on the price of bacon. Of course, we had an agreement with Great Britain in regard to bacon whereby we would get 225/- per cwt. for what are known as Wiltshire sides. Some of the Deputies sitting behind the Minister are not too well up on these things and I will explain for their benefit that a Wiltshire side is just a side of bacon with a shoulder and a ham on it. I do not think we exported a whole lot of bacon last year, but when it came to 1st January, 1950, the price was reduced to 217/- and the Minister felt that it was not good enough; in other words, it was not a remunerative price—we were not getting a remunerative price for all our products. We were not getting a remunerative price for bacon on 1st January, 1950.

There was another thing the Minister did. He condemned me over and over again for paying subsidies on food going over to Great Britain. I am prepared to turn up 500 quotations from the Minister where he condemned me for paying those subsidies.

Comment on this

Certainly, emphatically.

Comment on this

The fact is that the Minister found the price was not remunerative and he paid a subsidy in order to get the bacon over to England. He got the Pigs and Bacon Commission to act for him. He had not the courage, as I had, to come before the Dáil and put an Estimate before it and say: "That is for a subsidy on bacon going to England." He did it by the backdoor method. He gave a ring to the officials in the Pigs and Bacon Commission and he said to them: "Come over, boys; can you do this in a quiet way?" And they did it and the money was paid out of their funds.

The Pigs and Bacon Commission was condemned up and down by the present Minister when he was a Deputy sitting on the Opposition Bences. According to him, the members of the Pigs and Bacon Commission were amongst the greatest ruffians and racketeers. That was when the Minister was in opposition. But the members of the commission are still there, they are still in operation, and now they are useful to the Minister; now they are paying the subsidy on bacon going over to England and in that way the Minister has a remunerative price for bacon going to Britain.

Comment on this

There is no bacon going to Great Britain.

Comment on this

It is stopped now?

Comment on this

It is stopped now.

Comment on this

I must always remember that there are Deputies sitting behind the Minister who need to be informed on these matters. The Minister says there is no bacon going to Great Britain, but bacon did go and, according to an answer given in the Dáil, the Pigs and Bacon Commission paid out £18,000 on bacon going to Great Britain by way of subsidy. But the Minister apparently does not approve of subsidies on our products going to Great Britain.

Comment on this

Agreed.

Comment on this

He would not pay a subsidy on farmers' butter going to England or on anything else, but he got the Pigs and Bacon Commission to do this little job for him. The Minister repeated here several times in 1948, by way of accusation against us, that he would never allow the British Minister of Agriculture to regulate things in this country. None of us would, of course, if he could avoid it.

Comment on this

If he could avoid it?

Comment on this

The Minister could not avoid it—that is what I am coming to. The Minister made an arrangement with the British that he would agree to accept what the British gave the Danes. He was not making any bargain with the British, but he said to the British Minister of Food: "So far as I am concerned, you will tell me what price you are to give me." That is very little removed, mind you, from regulating agriculture here. He made no bargain, but he said: "Do your best with the Danes and whatever you pay the Danes, that will do me."

Comment on this

What is good enough for the Danes is good enough for us.

Comment on this

Yes, what is good enough for the Danes is good enough for us.

Comment on this

You never got the Danish price for bacon during the whole time you were Minister for Agriculture.

Comment on this

Try to keep your temper. Everybody sees through you.

Comment on this

You never got the Danish price once while you were Minister.

Comment on this

When he was introducing this Estimate here the Minister had some very interesting comments to make on bacon. He said:—

"If the whole community has got so stylish and so rich that they will eat nothing but the best rashers, I hope to God they will be made to pay 5/- a lb. for them."

He hoped they would have to pay 5/- a lb. for those rashers. Then he went on to say that so far as he was concerned, being a very humble man, he was prepared to eat pig's cheek and he recommended everybody else to eat pig's cheek. I was blue in the face when I was sitting over there where the Minister is now, trying to convince him and other Deputies that pigs do not consist entirely of back rashers and apparently now he is beginning to realise it. I will not say any more than that about it.

In the course of the debate Deputy McQuillan made an interjection and he spoke of the advisability of keeping some reasonable control on the price of bacon. The Minister said he hoped that would be done within 48 hours. That is the Minister who in the same debate said he hoped to God people would have to pay 5/- a lb. for rashers and later he said he hoped within 48 hours the price would be regulated.

Comment on this

No, reduced.

Comment on this

When he was bringing in his Estimate he hoped they would have to pay 5/-. That hope disappeared and his next hope was that the price would be reduced.

Comment on this

I was more concerned with the people who could not buy back rashers.

Comment on this

We have this extraordinary change from day to day, and nobody knows what the Minister is going to do about the pig industry; he says one thing to-day and another thing to-morrow.

Comment on this

The price of bacon has come down.

Comment on this

In a reply the other day we were told that sow services are coming down. We could not expect anything else.

Comment on this

The price of bacon is coming down and will come down.

Comment on this

At one moment it is the Minister's wish that they will have to pay 5/- a lb. for the rashers, and the next thing is that the price of bacon comes down and the Minister seems to be delighted. What about your wish of a few days ago?

Comment on this

The moon changes too, you know.

Comment on this

I move to report progress.

Comment on this