Committee on Finance. - Motion by Minister for Finance (Resumed).
Contributions 1–230 of 431. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
When speaking on this vote last week, I was endeavouring to substantiate certain main points of criticism of the handling of financial and economic policy by the Minister for Finance during the past year. Unfortunately, I was speaking in the absence of the Minister for Finance and it looks as if I will have to continue speaking in his absence to-day. I do not know whether the absence of the Minister is intended to be contemptuous of the Dáil or is due to some other cause. One would have thought that a Minister in that position would have regarded it as his duty so to arrange his affairs as to permit him to be present in the House when his administration was being subjected to examination here.
Comment on this
The Minister for Finance has been in here for a considerable period and there is a Minister on the Front Bench to take note of what the Deputy is saying.
Comment on this
I am glad to know that the Minister for Justice will take a note of what is being said and that it will be conveyed to the Minister for Finance. The Minister for Finance is asking us to vote him on account of the Supply Services this year a sum of £29,375,000 and that is no trivial matter. One would have thought that the Minister would have deemed it desirable, if not courteous, to be present when members of the Dáil are making their observations on that proposal. However, the main points which I was trying to substantiate were these. The first is that the amount which the Government are taking in the present financial year in taxation has already reached what the Minister for Finance himself described as the danger point. He regarded it as undesirable that the amount collected for the payment of the cost of the public services should exceed 25 per cent. of the aggregate of personal incomes. He admitted that in 1950 5/4 out of every £ of private income went to pay the cost of public services. It makes no matter whether that amount was secured by increasing the rates of taxation or by an expansion of revenue from existing taxes. We know that, with the recovery of trade after the war, the revenue yielded by various taxes expanded substantially; so substantially as to permit a reduction in certain tax rates even though the total revenue derived by the Exchequer from all taxes was expanding.
It is probable that in the present year, with the enormous increase in the volume of imports, the various ad valorem import duties have brought into the Exchequer a yield of revenue in excess of that budgeted for last May, and certainly in excess of that secured from customs duties in earlier years. It is equally probable that the rise in public expenditure upon beer, whiskey, tobacco and cinemas has also expanded the revenue. It may be that there has been a sufficient expansion under these heads to permit of the Minister for Finance covering the increased cost of the supply services in this year without any increase in tax rates. The fact is, however, that the amount which the public as a whole is paying in taxation is rising year after year, rising beyond the point which the Minister for Finance conceded was the danger point; and there is no evidence that the Minister for Finance proposes to concern himself about it apart from uttering a few warning phrases here. He seems willing to make whatever concessions are necessary to his partners in the Coalition whenever concessions are necessary to maintain its solidarity even though they may mean that the cost of Government services will be further inflated. I said also that the rise in the cost of public services is outpacing the rise in the national income. When the Budget of 1947 was presented here the present Minister for Finance, then Deputy McGilligan, described it as placing an intolerable burden on the national economy.
Since then that burden has increased, not merely actually but relatively, and the undesirable economic consequences foretold by the present Minister for Finance in 1947 have obviously been intensified. I pointed out also that the level of Government borrowing is out of all relation to the volume of current savings, so that the Government has been forced to finance its capital programme by dubious methods, by methods which are directly inflationary and which have not merely caused the rise in prices, which during the past two months sent the Government running around in circles, but have also caused the enormous increase in imports which the trade and shipping statistics for 1950 have revealed. These excessive imports, causing a deficit in the balance of payments for last year of no less than £30,000,000, as compared with £10,000,000 in the previous year, are dissipating the country's external assets rapidly and, unless that position is checked and remedied, will ultimately force a serious reduction in our living standards. Those were the points I made and endeavoured to substantiate by reference to known facts and published statistics.
I accused the Minister for Finance of abandoning the financial principles which he enunciated when he took office. I accused him of doing so cynically, of doing so knowing full well what the probable consequences would be of the course he was following and I accused him of following that course solely for Party political considerations. If there was any sincerity whatever in the declarations made by the present Minister for Finance here in 1948, when he first announced to the Dáil the principles he intended to apply in the administration of his Department, he owes to the Dáil now an explanation of his failure to operate those principles and of the reasons which forced him to proceed in an entirely contrary direction. But I do not think he will give us the right explanation since the right explanation is that he has been pushed from the position he intended to take up by other sections of the Government Coalition and that he allowed himself to be pushed.
Comment on this
I will deal with that. It is a case in point. Nobody objects to the Government deciding to increase old age pensions provided they believe the Government do so because they think it is the right thing to do and not because they want to bribe a few of their back benchers to go into the Division Lobby to vote for their social welfare proposals.
Comment on this
The outstanding feature of what happened on Friday is the realisation we all have now that the Government's decision was not based on the merits of the scheme put forward on behalf of pensioners and others but upon the realisation that unless they made some concession to the disgruntled back benchers they might be defeated on the Social Welfare Bill. That is my accusation against the Minister for Finance; on every occasion when he had to decide between the principles of financial policy that he himself enunciated in the past and the maintenance of cordiality between the coalition sections he sacrificed his principles for the political advantage to himself of keeping the Coalition together.
Comment on this
It has not shaken me. If it is intended to be a step preparatory to a general election, then take it from me that the people want an election on any ground and for any reason because they are aching to get an opportunity of putting an end to the mess created by the Coalition Government. They do not care what the Government are beaten on so long as they get an opportunity of putting them out of office and an opportunity of replacing them. If you do not believe me on that, try it.
Comment on this
I was led into these irrelevancies because of interjections by Deputies on the Government Benches.
Comment on this
I said here on Thursday last that I had examined the details of the various Estimates and that I was not in a position to indicate any significant economies which on their merits I could recommend; I mean economies of a real kind, such as the elimination of services which are unnecessary or undesirable or of waste in the administration of Government Departments. There are a few Coalition follies scattered around the Book of Estimates that we could get rid of, but the saving involved would not be significant in relation to the total bill of £83,000,000.
Comment on this
I agree also that many, if not all, of the genuine capital projects upon which the Government proposes to embark are desirable and that on the whole its investment programme is desirable apart from borrowing to meet budget deficits or to defray the cost of various recurring grants which create no Exchequer assets. These are devices born of political cowardice and cannot be justified on any financial ground. In so far as there is a bona fide investment programme put before the House there is not on the part of Deputies on this side of the House any desire to detract from that programme, any proposal to cut it down or eliminate any item from it. The point is, however, that we cannot go on forever inflating the cost of public services, adding new services to those already in existence and piling up the level of public debt unless we want the things the Government proposes to provide by that expenditure so badly that we are prepared to do without other things in order to get them. I think that is the issue the Government should put to the people. I think that is the issue the Government has failed to explain to the people. I think their failure to explain it is due to political motives, not because the Minister for Finance did not understand that that was the issue before the Dáil and the country but, understanding it, decided to conceal it.
In fact, the Minister for Finance, certainly other members of the Cabinet, and practically all the Deputies who sit behind them, are telling the people the opposite, not telling them that they have to choose between certain public services provided for in the Book of Estimates and certain capital services to be enunciated at the time of the Budget statement, and all the other things that they might have with the money that will otherwise be devoted to these public expenditures. The public are not being told that there is any choice. They are being told that they can have all these things at the same time, that they can have this expansion of the public services, that they can maintain a much higher level of current consumption, that they can maintain all this expanding import of luxury goods and, at the same time, have lower taxation. That is a lie. The Minister for Finance knows that it is a lie. Every Deputy who understands the elementary facts about our financial policy knows that it is a lie.
We cannot have expanding public services, an expanding level of consumption of luxury goods, expanding imports on the scale we had in 1950 and a lower taxation at the same time. We have deceived the people into believing that, by some financial trickery, they can get all these things at once. The fact is that everything we are now enjoying, every expansion of the public services, every part of the Government's investment programme, all the enormous influx of imported goods, will have to be paid for some time. We can avoid paying this year, but, eventually, they will have to be paid for, if not under the impetus of this Government, under the impetus of their successors.
We are paying now, it is true, by dissipating the external assets which were the reserves upon which we hoped to draw to expand our production capacity. We are paying now by wasting the accumulated reserves which prudent administration in the Department of Finance built up over a number of years. All these things are gone or are going. These financial reserves are being exhausted. These external assets are becoming exhausted. £225,000,000 was the estimate of the net value of our external assets at the beginning of last year. £30,000,000 of them went last year, and that means that our ability to maintain the same level of imports next year and the following year has been reduced, and that the time is in sight at which we will not be able to pay our way at all, when we will have to cut down drastically our imports and lower our standard of living. That will not take the form of a voluntary curtailment of luxury expenditure such as the Minister for Finance was pleading for. It will take the form of increased unemployment, higher taxation, leading to such depressed economic and social conditions that there will be a further exodus of population through emigration.
The public have to make a choice, when they get the opportunity, between the course which the Government are following and the course which they could follow. They will have to be given the opportunity of making that choice with all the facts put fairly before them. I can tell them that the Minister for Finance is not merely failing to put the facts before them but is deliberately misleading them as to the facts.
The level of Government spending through taxation is a matter of internal policy, a matter to be decided here in the Dáil. We will be discussing it with more point to our remarks when the Minister's taxation proposals for the year are announced to us in his Budget statement.
If we, as representatives of the public, or the Government, or the Deputies supporting the Government, can persuade people that it is better that they should have less to spend at their own discretion in order to increase the amount of Government spending, then nobody need have any complaint. Five shillings and fourpence out of every £1 of private income is now being spent by the Government, taken from the public through taxation or rates, and spent on the public services. If we want to increase expenditure on the public services, we have got to persuade people that, instead of giving 5/4 out of every £1, they should give 6/- or 6/6 or 7/-, persuade them that it is better for themselves that they should spend less at their own discretion and let the Government do their spending for them. But, that issue should be put fairly to the public. They should be told, not merely what their choice is, but the consequences of any particular choice.
The level of borrowing is a different matter. The Government has a special responsibility to safeguard the national resources entrusted to them. There is no doubt whatever that the public of this country want investment in housing, hospitals, electricity, telephones, afforestation, land improvement, in all the things which were on the list given by the Minister when announcing his capital budget last year. The public as a whole may not fully understand that investment means saving, that if there is to be a sound policy of investment in these matters, it must be made possible by expanding the volume of public savings. The aim of prudent financial policy is to keep the level of investment in line with the level of savings and that means putting aside, from the resources available to finance current consumption, some larger proportion to finance these future benefits.
Last year we had presented to us a Government investment programme totalling £34,000,000. As the statistics published only last week make abundantly clear, that investment programme was far and away beyond anything that the current level of savings would make possible and so we find that it was financed in the main, not out of current savings, but by recourse to short-term borrowing, mainly from the American Loan Counterpart Fund and also from the banks, methods of financing which the Minister for Finance himself deprecated as undesirable, which are obviously and clearly inflationary in their effect. As a result of the so-called capital investment programme of the Government, last year, £20,000,000 worth of purchasing power was distributed amongst our people over and above anything that emerged as a result of current production and the effect of that expansion of purchasing power in excess of the amount required to pay for normal supplies is to be seen, first of all, in the price rises which occurred in that period; and, secondly, in the enormous expansion in the inflow of luxury goods during the same period. Our imports in 1950 exceeded our imports in 1949 by no less than £30,000,000.
I think the public should be told more emphatically than the Minister for Finance attempted to do in his speech, introducing this Vote, that these abnormal imports of non-essential goods, while they may make life easier for some sections of our people now, are wasting our resources and making it harder for the community as a whole to pay in this year, next year and every succeeding year, for the necessary imports which we might desire to secure.
When the British Government decided last year that rearmament was necessary, British Ministers did not hesitate to come out and tell their countrymen that they could not have everything at once and that if rearmament was desirable in the interests of national security, in order to get it they had to forgo other things. They realised, being politicians like ourselves, that that was not likely to be a popular message to be carried to the voters in their constituencies. But they did not content themselves with words only; they set out to achieve the result that they thought desirable in the interests of their nation. They curtailed the production of non-essential goods and they curtailed public spending on a wide range of goods by means of a purchase tax.
Deputies who read the English papers will have learned that various public opinion polls carried out since the announcement of that policy by British Ministers showed that the popularity of the Labour Party amongst the British electorate was declining. As a result of these restrictive measures which they regarded as part and parcel of their rearmament programme, they were losing votes. I have no doubt it was the knowledge of that adverse political reaction to the tough but sound course taken by the British Government that deterred our less patriotic Ministers here from attempting to move along the same line. If our Government here had equal courage, if they were prepared to face our people in the same frank way and give them the elementary lessons in public finance and national economics which the British Ministers are doing, then we could discuss the problems confronting us now in a more realistic way.
We do not want to have to make war preparations here. We hope we will not have to do that. Nobody will regard the provision for the purchase of warlike stores in the Estimates as anything more than a gesture. Perhaps we may have to face up to the consequences of the deterioration of the international position as vigorously as the British are doing; but let us leave that aside; let us assume some magical change in the international situation will enable us to forget about all preparations for war or the emergency conditions that might follow from war elsewhere and assume we are going to have a period of international peace. Nevertheless, if we are to proceed with the programme of capital development that was outlined, even limiting that capital programme to the beneficial things which we desire, it is necessary to make it clear to our people that we cannot do it on an adequate scale unless we are prepared to do without other things at the same time.
There is, of course, a possible solution which would give us the benefit of increased public expenditure or increased investment financed by savings and at the same time avoid any serious lowering of our present standard of consumption, and that is by increasing our production. We will be able to discuss in more detail the failure of the Government adequately to stimulate increased production of industry or agriculture on the Estimates for those Departments. Up to the present the Government are riding along upon the automatic recovery in output, particularly in agriculture, which followed on the conclusion of the war, but doing little directly to stimulate it.
Some recovery in output after the war was inevitable. What expansion was possible is a matter upon which we can only speculate, but the erratic course followed by the Minister for Agriculture has clearly disheartened our agricultural producers, and the inactivity of the Department of Industry and Commerce is having the same effect on industry. If we are, however, to seek a solution of this economic difficulty of ours by expanding internal production, it obviously must mean increased spending upon productive equipment procurable abroad. It is the resources which were available to finance that spending, to finance the purchase of the productive equipment that might have made increased output possible, that are now being wasted. We may not want, as the Germans were told to want before the war, guns instead of butter, but we do want to see our limited capital resources used to buy power plants instead of motor cars, factory equipment instead of silks and satins, fertilisers instead of champagne and other foreign wines, agricultural machinery instead of cinema films.
I said in 1948 that in the circumstances of that year there was no need in this country for a policy of austerity. I was assuming then that the Minister for Finance, in outlining his policy in that year, meant what he said. I had not discovered that he was speaking then with his tongue in his cheek. I argued strongly that in the circumstances of 1948, having regard to the sound position of this country at the end of the war years and having regard to the general expectation of an improvement in economic conditions throughout the world, we did not have to embark upon a policy of restriction such as the Minister for Finance appeared then to be foreshadowing. Nor do I think yet that circumstances have arisen which would justify a policy to which the name austerity could reasonably be applied. But I think the time has come when we should consider the curtailment of foreign spending, particularly foreign spending upon non-essential goods, and maintaining that curtailment until we have ended the necessity for it either by an expansion of production or an expansion of exports.
I am not going to suggest that the Government is solely responsible for the deterioration in the general situation between 1948 and 1951. In large measure, the worsening of the relations between the great States is responsible for that situation, but in considerable degree the financial policy—the harebrained, spendthrift financial policy which the Government has followed during its three years in office—is also responsible. If these external assets of ours are to be conserved so as to be available to finance the goods we want to import and not wasted as they are now being wasted in paying for an enormous influx of non-essential goods, then we have got to consider not merely our long-term capital requirements but our immediate need to stockpile certain raw materials which are essential to the maintenance of industrial output and economic activity generally here.
It is true that one or two members of the Government have spoken about the need for stocking up essential materials. They have spoken apathetically and dispiritedly, and have given no evidence of enthusiasm for the idea much less any intention of doing anything to help it. It is true that if we were stockpiling industrial materials now it would mean more imports. It may be said that in urging more positive action towards stockpiling I am speaking in a manner contrary to what I have said already—I do not think I am. The current need for stockpiling only strengthens the case for regulating our foreign spending now so as to facilitate it. I do not think that the Government is really interested in this question of stockpiling at all. There is certainly no appreciation of industry's capital needs if it is to be achieved on any substantial scale. I do not know if any Ministers realise to what extent even the increase in the cost of raw materials last year has expanded industry's need of working capital even to maintain the previous level of stocks. The enormous increase in the prices of these materials has forced industries to exhaust capital reserves which might otherwise be available to finance expansion and has forced them to rely to an increasing extent on bank credit.
If, over and above the financing of higher prices of raw materials, there is to be an expansion of stocks of these materials, then the Government must take note of the problems, the financial problems that would be involved there. Up to the present, however, there has been no suggestion from any member of the Government that the capital needs of industry in that regard are appreciated. There has been no suggestion that the Government's investment programme might be delayed in any respect in order to facilitate stockpiling and no offer to industrialists to help them out of their difficulty in fulfilling the express wishes of the Government in that regard. Instead of getting any positive help or encouragement or evidence of appreciation of their difficulties, industrialists got instead this ridiculous Prices Freeze Order which threw all the commerce of this country into chaos for the past two months.
I do not know why the Government decided to embark upon that ill-considered course but I will tell you my theory. I think they were forced into this by the rushing tactics of the Minister for Social Welfare who knows nothing and cares less about the problems of business management and who is concerned only with the political implications to himself of the public reaction to a very foolish speech made here on the Supplies and Services Bill by the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Industry and Commerce. The adverse public reaction to that speech threw the Government into a panic. It may be that the panic was more pronounced in the mind of the Minister for Social Welfare than in that of the Minister for Industry and Commerce.
There are many who believe that when the Minister came and announced here the decision to apply a Prices Freeze Order, he was presenting his colleagues in the Government with a fait accompli: that they were put into the position that they either had to repudiate him or implement his idea.
An announcement was made in the first week of December that there was to be a Prices Freeze Order. Any Deputy who understands the variety and number of industrial transactions that take place every day will understand the problems created for the business community of this State by that announcement, when the announcement was not followed by action. Although the Minister came in here on 1st December to announce a prices freeze policy, there was no Prices Freeze Order. The Order effecting the prices freeze did not come for a month later. For the whole of the Christmas period, the busiest period of the year, the business community of this State were left in the position that a Minister had announced a prices freeze, but that nothing had been done about it. When the Order came in January of the present year, we found it was retrospective in effect, that it froze prices away back to the date of the original announcement. Any man who had even served his time in any business and who had any knowledge whatever about business management would have understood the impossibility of carrying on in any efficient way under a Prices Order retrospective in its effect. Do members of the Government not realise that the majority of the industrialists of this State are taking orders for deliveries six months, nine months and 12 months hence; that, all through the month of December, despite the Government's announcement and in the absence of any Government Order, industrialists were making contracts on the basis of the current costs of materials, and that on 2nd January all those orders were invalidated by the retrospective clause in the Prices Freeze Order. Is it any wonder that civil servants when questioned by business men told them to ignore the Order?
Comment on this
What connivance was necessary for me? Why should anyone come to me and ask what the Government meant by their Order?
Comment on this
We are entitled to criticise the Government and we will not be bullied, browbeaten or threatened by Deputy Davin into silence.
Comment on this
I say the Minister for Social Welfare rushed the Government into this course. Why should he come here and announce Government policy on a matter which was the responsibility of the Minister for Industry and Commerce?
Comment on this
Was he? I have said already that that speech was deliberately framed by the Tánaiste in order to convey the idea that all the price problems afflicting the country were due solely to the desire of Irish manufacturers and traders to secure excessive profits, that he was undermining public confidence in the private enterprise system, that he was building up this propaganda, which is designed to create in the minds of the Irish people the idea that private enterprise is necessarily anti-social. I have said that and I have challenged contradiction of it.
Comment on this
Sitting here listening, I may say that I thought it was "Russian" and a comment came at once which marked that that was the interpretation put on it.
Comment on this
There is the record: an announcement made at the beginning of December of the intention to freeze prices, with no Order drafted, no course of action decided upon and nothing following the announcement for a month; a month later, a Government Order appearing, released privately to one newspaper and then, through the Government Information Bureau, to all the others a couple of days later, that the price freeze was to be retrospective in its effect; and then some attempt to appreciate the chaos caused by these methods, leading, two months later, to an ambiguous advertisement slipped surreptitiously into the newspapers on Saturday last, saying that, as to 75 per cent. of the goods to which the price freeze applied, it has been withdrawn altogether. If there was one businessman in the Government, or if they had made any attempt before talking any steps to consult any organisation of business interests or any trade union organisation, they would have got at least enough information to have prevented the worst errors upon which they engaged. Only a Government of lawyers could have done what they have done and I will say this about lawyers, that, outside the law courts and matters concerning law, they are the most ignorant tribe of people, even though they will not admit it.
We had this announcement of a price freeze and subsequently the publication of the Order and then, following efforts to spur the Government into doing something more than wringing their hands about the price situation, we were told that a recruiting campaign was in progress for inspectors to enforce the Order and that 25 had been recruited and 25 more were to be recruited—until Saturday last when they were all sacked again, because it certainly will not need 50 inspectors to supervise the enforcement of the price freeze on the limited range of goods to which it now applies.
Comment on this
He told me he had recruited 25 and was going to recruit 25 more for outdoor work. The number who were to work indoor was not stated.
Comment on this
I do not; I have to rely upon the accuracy of the information given to me in the House. The Government have once again panicked unnecessarily. They panicked last December because of the public reaction to the speech of the Parliamentary Secretary and they are now panicking because of the representations being made to them by business interests as to the confusion they have caused in business circles. Again, I think they are panicking unnecessarily. The discontent was not with the idea of price control, but with the cumbersome nature of the machinery they set up to apply it. The administration of price control through a part-time committee of non-official persons could never have worked and never will work, but all that was necessary to remedy the blunder which created that type of machinery was to abolish that committee again and transfer responsibility for the supervision of price control back to the Department of Industry and Commerce, where it belongs.
I think the Government were driven into these foolish methods of price regulation by the collapse of the Department of Industry and Commerce. I have no doubt whatever that a proper system of price regulation is necessary in present circumstances, and is always necessary in times of impending scarcity or violent price fluctuations, and that it can be secured through the Department of Industry and Commerce working upon the responsibility of its Minister; but, in order to make it effective, there has to be behind the officials who will be dealing with members of the public, the certainty of being able to secure clear, prompt and intelligible ministerial decisions, whenever they are required. It is the knowledge in the minds of the members of the Government that in present circumstances the Department cannot function promptly, efficiently and intelligently that forced them to look around for other methods of making effective the Tánaiste's announcement of the intention to apply a price freeze and led them into the folly of this part-time advisory committee.
I think the Government were wrong in applying the price freeze last December in the way they did it. I think they are equally wrong in abolishing it now. I have argued in favour of price control. I want a system of price control that has some relation to the circumstances under which business is carried on. I want that price control to be designed to eliminate every unnecessary cause adding to price, every attempt to duplicate profits in the process of distribution, but there must be some recognition that prices are based upon costs, the costs of materials, of fuel, of wages, and that if these costs go up, prices must go up also. For two months, manufacturers in this country have been put in the position of being compelled either to manufacture only for stock, awaiting a decision upon their application for a price revision, or to work upon stocks purchased previously and to forgo the opportunity of replacing these stocks when that opportunity presented itself to them.
Comment on this
Certainly. I know it has happened. I will name a dozen factories where one or other of these things has happened and some where the manufacturers even took the other course of cutting down upon production because they could not get a decision from this absurd Prices Advisory Committee.
Comment on this
The objection which was voiced by members of the business community was not to the principle of price control in present circumstances; it was to the methods by which the Government attempted to apply it. It is no answer to that criticism to come now and take all articles of clothing, and all household utensils and decontrol them again. Were not these the precise things the rise in the price of which was causing all the public discontent? I am convinced that it is true that the Government knew enough about the working of industry, or could have got the information if they asked for it, to prevent them adopting that course if they were not driven into it by the knowledge that the Department of Industry and Commerce is not functioning.
Comment on this
I do not know why the position in the Department of Industry and Commerce has not been rectified. The public interest is being sacrificed because the Taoiseach, either for personal reasons or because of the political risks involved is reluctant to make changes, or for some other reason I do not know of. I have said before and repeat here that it is not fair to the country at this critical time when industrial opportunities which may not recur for years are slipping out of our grasp, when the problems of industry are mounting in intensity, when we should be vigorously at work trying to build up reserves to carry on our industries if a major emergency should develop, when all these price problems require day to day attention, to leave that major department of government in a position in which it cannot function effectively.
That summarises my criticism of the Government in relation to the specific matters now under discussion. They have lacked courage. They are following the course they are taking, not because they do not realise that that course is bound to lead the country ultimately to disaster but because they understand that any other course would involve political risks. They are not prepared to take political risks, they are postponing every problem they can, they are pushing back every obligation that can be pushed back, they are piling on a burden of debt for the future, they are wasting the resources that should be available in the future to meet that burden. They are doing this solely with the aim of preserving whatever they can of their dwindling political popularity between this date and whatever date they can screw up their courage to the point of facing the Irish electorate.
Comment on this
Ní fheadar cén bhrí atá le baint as an méid adúirt an Teachta deireannach. Is é an gearán atá aige leis an Rialtas ná go bhfuil an rud ceart dá dhéanamh acu, ach ná fuil dóthain sceoin agus faitís dá chur acu ar an bpobal. Ba dheacair domsa, pé scéal é, aon bhrí eile a bhaint as caint an Teachta Seán Lemass. Cuireann sé i leith an Railtais méid an Bhille atá leagtha os comhair na Dála, ach nuair a cuireadh ceist air, ní raibh sé sásta, ní raibh sé ábalta, nó ní raibh sé ndon, aon mhór-laghdú sa mBille a mholadh; ach amháin go ndearna sé, mar is gnáthach leis, iarracht ar achmhasán a chaitheamh ar an nGníomhaireacht Nuachta.
Mar a tharlaíonn uaireanta i gcás an Teachta sin, bím saghas amhrasach agus ní féidir liom m'aigne a dhéanamh suas cé acu an bhfuil sé dáríre nó an bhfuil point á dhéanamh aige a fhéachfaidh go maith ar Scéala Éireann lá arna mhárach.
Ba mhaith liom, mar sin féin, a chur in iúl dó an díobháil a dheineann sé de ghnáth nuair a labhrann sé fé mar labhair sé inniu. Ní dóigh liom gurb é sin atá uaidh, ach bíodh fhios aige gurb é mo thuairim, agus tuairim a lán Teachtaí eile, gur díobháil an toradh a bhíonn ar a chuid cainte.
At the conclusion of his speech here to-day, Deputy Lemass continued the pursuit of the bogey, or the hare, which he initially started on the occasion of the dinner of the Federation of Irish Manufacturers. I was left in some doubt, as were other Deputies on these benches, as to the exact purport of the words he used. I accept without reservation his statement that when he referred to the Tánaiste's tactics, the adjective he used was "rushing." I was in a similar doubt, as Deputy Davin, in listening to him initially. Be that as it may, his suggestion that the Tánaiste and other people on this side of the House, were attempting to discredit private enterprise in any form, was an attempt by him to encroach on the preserves of Deputy MacEntee and start raising one of Deputy MacEntee's red hares or red herrings. He should leave that to Deputy MacEntee, as it is more in his province and we have come to expect it from Deputy MacEntee. Perhaps some of us were foolish enough to expect a little bit better from Deputy Lemass. On that occasion, Deputy Lemass shook a minatory finger at the members of the Federation and delivered a homily to them in grave and sepulchral tones, that if they did not show a more open and more vigorous resentment to the policy pursued by this Government he (Deputy Lemass) would be reluctantly compelled to leave them to their own devices.
Comment on this
Yes. He told them to get out of their tents. I do not think Deputy Lemass's efforts on that occasion were attended by any considerable degree of success. I do not imagine that his effort here this afternoon will be attended by any greater degree of success. However, it apparently suits Deputy Lemass's book to pursue that line, and he is the best judge of his own interest and the interest of his Party. I would suggest to him that, whether it is in the interest of his Party or not, it is certainly not in the interest of the Irish nation.
From these benches, in the short time I am in this House, I have never been slow—and I challenge contradiction on this—to give credit to the Party opposite for many of the good things they did. I gave them credit for many advances they made, and so did other Deputies on these benches. We still give them that credit. Why cannot they adopt a similar attitude and not approach every question purely from the point of view of seeing what possible destructive criticism can be made? That is not our job. It is not for that purpose that we were sent into this House. There are points of Government policy on which, perhaps, all of us do not find ourselves on the Government side of the House in agreement but though we disagree we do not immediately start out to impute low, mean or wrong motives. There are many points I am sure upon which the present Minister for Finance and myself would find ourselves in a very serious difference of opinion. Our views would diverge widely but I am not going on these benches to impute to him wrong motives any more than I am going to impute to the Deputies opposite wrong motives when they express points of view with which I cannot find myself in complete agreement. The whole burden and tenor, however, of the speech just made by Deputy Lemass was: "We do not quarrel with what you do but we quarrel with your motives for doing it." Is not that in effect the speech which Deputy Lemass has just made in this House?
Comment on this
For not one item save one very minor one could he criticise the Book of Estimates; not one major reduction could he suggest, but the tenor of his speech was: "I cannot quarrel with the expenditure. Your expenditure is all right but the motives whereby and whereunder it is made are wrong."
Comment on this
I would ask Deputy Lemass and Deputy de Valera to reread in the Official Report what Deputy Lemass said and they will find that the construction I am putting on this speech is not an unreasonable one. If I am being unfair to him on that, I will be the first to withdraw it.
Comment on this
That was certainly the impression conveyed to me by Deputy Lemass and I am reinforced in that conviction by his failure to point to one major item in the Book of Estimates in respect of which he would suggest that a reduction should be made.
Comment on this
We did not promise a reduction in costs. It was the Minister for Finance who promised a reduction in costs.
Comment on this
The Minister for Finance can deal with that point. Speaking for the Deputies of the Clann na Poblachta Party, we never promised a reduction in taxation.
Comment on this
We had not advance information any more than the Deputy had as to what was going to happen in Korea, or perhaps you may have had some information which we had not?
Comment on this
If we are dealing with the Vote on Account the normal, rational way surely if the Vote is to be opposed, is to say that it should be opposed because there are items in that Vote with which the Party opposite do not agree, items of expenditure which they think should be cut. I do not know—I am subject to your ruling on the matter, a Leas-Chinn Comhairle—but surely that is the issue when the Vote on Account comes before the Dáil, that and no other.
Comment on this
It is open to the Deputy to make that case but the case made by him was that he did not suggest it was too small and neither did he suggest that it was too large, but that the present Minister for Finance had no right to come in and ask the Dáil for that amount of money and he imputed to the Minister for Finance wrong motives for doing so.
Comment on this
I can explain my case in a sentence. The case I made was that we cannot have this level of Government expenditure or complete the programme outlined unless we are prepared to do without other things. The Government are trying to have everything at the same time and they cannot have it, and that is going to lead to a serious deterioration in our economic circumstances in the future.
Comment on this
Yes, with all the drinking, smoking and cinema-going that is going on and that you encourage.
Comment on this
I would return to the request I made to Deputy Lemass while he was speaking; I would ask him or any other member of his Party to tell the Dáil what items in this Book of Estimates should be cut. That is the net question.
Comment on this
I did answer it. I did not want to cut expenditure except on a few fripperies and follies put in by the Coalition.
Comment on this
We now have it stated authoritatively by Deputy Lemass, on behalf of his Party, that he does not want to cut any of the items in this Book of Estimates—he puts in a minor qualification and I hope that he does not mind if I leave that aside. In other words, he thinks that the bill placed by the Minister for Finance before the Dáil is a proper bill.
Comment on this
But, of course, his whole quarrel is with the Minister for Finance in the person of Deputy McGilligan who presents that Book of Estimates before the Dáil. I am forced, a Leas-Chinn Comhairle, to repeat what I had to say on either the Budget or the Vote on Account last year or the year before. The Fianna Fáil attack is always a three-pronged attack. I thought we had got rid of that but it is being used again to-day. The first prong is: "This is a Fine Gael Government. We were warned about this awful Deputy McGilligan, this awful Minister for Finance, with his complete mania for retrenchment, his axe that was going to lop off every item of expenditure and those who had any sort of progressive ideas, any desire to expend money on social services were due, as they say in the North, of Ireland, for a hell of a gunk."
Comment on this
No; that is what you want to happen. You say: "You are all damned. You are in a Fine Gael Government which is going to economise in everything, that is going to lop 1/- off the old age pension and cut down on social services." I have not to answer for Fine Gael. I have no responsibility for them.
Comment on this
Now I will deal with the second prong of the fork. The second prong of the fork is the one most in evidence to-day because the retrenchment prong is getting a little bit rusty. It got shockingly rusty on Friday morning last, terribly rusty. The second prong is: "We will forget that you are all as meek as mice and that Fine Gael has swallowed the lot of you." The second prong: "These awful people in Labour and Clann na Poblachta are pushing the poor unfortunate Fine Gael Minister for Finance into appalling, outrageous, extravagant expenditure." Apparently that prong of the fork is getting a bit rusty too, because we find from Deputy Lemass that the expenditure is not as outrageous, as extravagant or as awful as you would think because he cannot quarrel with any of those items of expenditure, so the safest prong for Deputy Lemass to rely on is the one upon which he was forced to rely before, and it is: "There is not an awful lot to be said about these people but they are only following Fianna Fáil policy." There are the three prongs, and I would ask Deputy Lemass and the Deputies opposite which prong they are going to rely on.
Comment on this
I do not blame them for shifting after what was said about lawyers by Deputy Lemass.
Comment on this
Deputy Lemass was very fond of charging the present Minister for Finance and certain elements in the Government with a mania for retrenchment. I think it was in June or in July, 1947, that Deputy Lemass made his famous "austerity" speech. Of course, the following year he made a speech that cancelled that out—he was in opposition then—when he said that there was no necessity for austerity. In July, 1947, he was Minister for Industry and Commerce in the Fianna Fáil Government. All that he had to offer the people at that time was austerity and more austerity.
Comment on this
But the Deputy in opposition and the Minister on the Front Bench are two different characters altogether. In 1948, as plain Deputy Lemass, he told us that there was no necessity for austerity. It is a terrible pity that there cannot be a more objective approach to matters coming before the Dáil, such as this Vote on Account. Much has been said by Deputies opposite with which I find myself in agreement. I do not yield one inch to any Deputy on the far side of the House in my desire to see self-sufficiency in this country. I think that to import wheat at the moment is wrong. I agree with any strictures there may be in that respect but——
Comment on this
Without any assistance from Deputy de Valera, let me say that there were reasons and good reasons for many of the imports that had to be permitted. There was great criticism of the Minister for Agriculture in respect of the importation of butter from Denmark and New Zealand but the reason for the necessity to do so is to the Minister's credit, namely, that more butter is now available to and is consumed by the ordinary people of this country, in the ratio of seven to four as between 1951 and 1938.
Comment on this
If the Deputies opposite would make reasoned and dispassionate cases they would find a lot of agreement on this matter but when they descend into the realms of attack and criticism for the sake of attack and criticism they ruin any case they may have.
Deputy Lemass said that the amount of taxation which this Book of Estimates would contain showed that we would have passed beyond the safety limit of 25 per cent. That may be so. I welcome any redistribution of the national income which assures to the less privileged sections of the community a fairer cut out of that national income.
Comment on this
That is not in the Book of Estimates. The social welfare scheme is not in the Book of Estimates.
Comment on this
I am not referring to it but to schemes of capital investment, the mother and child scheme and many other schemes which make for a wider distribution of the national income.
Comment on this
The Deputy should read the Book of Estimates. I assumed that when the Deputy was making his long and eloquent speech he was at least familiar with the Book of Estimates.
Comment on this
I am. That is the trouble. There is nothing about the mother and child scheme or the social welfare scheme in it.
Comment on this
I do not know whether Deputy Lemass is serious when he says these schemes are not in the Book of Estimates. I suggest he should read the Book of Estimates. Deputy Lemass says that the cost of public services is outpacing the national income. I should hesitate to cross swords on that issue with a Deputy of his administrative experience and experience in this House. I return again to the only criterion that an ordinary and rather simple and rather naïve Deputy such as myself can apply, namely, where is the item that you can reduce or cut out?
There was criticism in this debate of the Minister for Agriculture because we were paying £31 per ton for imported wheat as against £25 to the Irish producer. There is a good deal of substance in that criticism, but not when it comes from Deputies who supported a Minister for Supplies who paid £50 a ton for wheat——
Comment on this
At a time when no other country in the world would get it and when the only alternative was to reduce the bread ration.
Comment on this
That was done on the 17th February, 1948—just 12 hours before another Government took over. Criticism of the price being paid for imported wheat would probably come well from any Deputy sitting on this side of the House but it does not come very well from Deputies who are now sitting on the Opposition side of the House. We may look simple but we cannot help remembering facts. We are able to read. Of necessity, a considerable amount of time in this debate has been devoted to the increased cost of living. I do not know whether Deputies on the opposite benches will come out plainly and bluntly and say that substantially the Government is responsible for the increase in prices. Of course, they realise quite well that the Government are not responsible for it. They know quite well that circumstances and events over which the Government had no control, such as the Korean incident, are responsible for the big jump. They know that this Government succeeded for more than two years in holding the cost-of-living index figure without any rise. I am not trying to make a debating point of that fact. I believe that the Deputies on the Opposition side of the House would do their case far more good if they frankly admitted that the rise in the cost of living is not the fault of the Government and that it is not anything which the Government could control. However, instead of that frank admission, there is a half-hearted——
Comment on this
No, and to that extent, let me be frank, a percentage of our criticisms—made, perhaps, immaturely—were unjustified. However, the preponderating percentage of criticisms were not alone fully justified but, had we known then as much as we know now, they would, perhaps, have been more trenchant.
Great play was made by Deputy Lemass of the possibility of our external assets being seriously reduced. I think he referred to the possibility of our external assets being completely exhausted. There would be a great deal more weight and point in that argument if Deputies had not to remember that in 24 hours, in September, 1949, our external assets were reduced in value by £100,000,000—in 24 hours.
Another line which was pursued, and pursued at considerable length, by Deputy Lemass, was that the public had to be told that this increased taxation has to be met from somewhere. They had to be told the consequences of this increased spending. I may be obtuse but I could not get the Deputy's point that of course the public will have to be told. Of course they will, of necessity, know when the bill is presented to them. The Deputy, to my mind, is overlooking completely the fact that, due to the prosperous condition in which the country finds itself at the moment, national income is greater and revenue is expanding. Deputy Briscoe was apparently of opinion that revenue was contracting when he spoke last Thursday, while Deputy Lemass made great play with the point that there was some dark secret being kept from the public, that they were not being told that the money for this additional expenditure would have to come from somewhere. That is underlining the obvious and stating a truism.
Comment on this
There is nobody in a better position to underline that to them than the Deputy. He, at least, controls a political Party newspaper, but I can see no conceivable point in making a missile out of that. Of course we know the public will have to be told. The public are aware of it already. What the public want to know is, are they going to get value for the money that is taken from them in taxation? I believe that if it is put to them, the public are prepared to pay more in taxation in order that old age pensioners, expectant mothers and little children may get increased allowances and proper health services. I believe the public are prepared to pay more in order to see that the social services generally are increased. I believe that if that question is put to the public, the public will give an unequivocal "yes", because the Irish people are generous and have never cavilled at paying the taxation necessary to finance any schemes calculated to improve the lot of the under-privileged and the weaker sections of the community. The keystone of the Government's policy is to give priority to the under-privileged, to the needy and the old people, and so long as that is the keystone of their policy this Government is on the right lines.
I agree completely with Deputy Lemass that there is a good deal of spending which could very properly be restricted. I believe money is being expended probably on betting, to a certain extent on drink, and certainly on things like imported newspapers. There is a lot of spending of that kind that could, with reason, be restricted, but to suggest that the Irish people have gone all-out on a spending spree, with no hope or thought for the future is, to my mind, a slander on our people. I do not believe that is so.
Deputy Lemass referred again to stock-piling. I know that wise stock-piling has been advocated by this Party for the last 12 or 18 months. We have advocated it both inside and outside this House.
Comment on this
By the Government and by private business interests. I would be quite prepared to give facilities, and to urge on the Government that facilities should be given, to manufactures to carry out wise stock-piling, provided always that stock-piling was not going to be operated as a means of fleecing the ordinary taxpayers.
Comment on this
I suppose, when I use that phrase, I am leaving myself open to an attack such as the attack made on the Tánaiste. Deputy Lemass seeks to exaggerate the points of difference of view between Deputies opposite and Deputies on this side of the House. In actual fact, the difference in the point of view is slight, if it is real at all, and I do not think there is any good purpose served nationally by trying to suggest that there is a wide gulf or chasm separating Deputies on that side from Deputies on this side of the House. I do not think that gloomy jeremiads about the future are of any assistance to this country. A wise appreciation of the problems that confront us, in common with other nations of the world, is a desirable thing. I do not think that an atmosphere of unadulterated gloom is good for an individual or good for a nation. A lot of Deputy Lemass's prophecies lately have come unstuck. His principal prophecy, one that received the widest currency, was that this Government was going to go out of office in the middle of March.
Comment on this
I never said that and I never believed it. I always said that they would hold on to the bitter end.
Comment on this
I beg the pardon of the House if I have strayed from the paths of order. The only connection in which I desire to mention that is that Deputy Lemass's prophecies are not always as worthy of credence as he would lead us to believe.
Comment on this
We were told that the Social Welfare Bill would never get a Second Reading in this House. It has not got it yet but I am prepared to have a side bet with Deputy Lemass that it will.
Comment on this
Again we are back to the three-pronged fork. Deputy Aiken and Deputy Lemass and many other Deputies on the opposite side told us that Labour Deputies and Clann na Poblachta Deputies have become as meek as mice and that they would do everything that the Fine Gael members wanted them to do. Now, apparently, the position is reversed.
Comment on this
I do not know who swallowed whom. The truth of the matter is that nobody swallowed anybody, that we were all working together in the Coalition Government. Instead of collapsing after three months, six months or 18 months, as we were told the Government would, the members of this Government are working loyally and courageously together and are still in the position to go on working after three years.
Comment on this
We were told that the Government lacked courage. I do not think it is the hallmark of a Government that lacked courage to embark upon a policy of capital expenditure such as that upon which this Government has embarked. We were told that the Government had no vision. I have always given Deputy Lemass credit for a considerable amount of vision, but I think he has been out-rivalled in the vision which members of the present Government have shown in many of the projects which they have undertaken. We were told that there would be a dead hand on every progressive scheme. Now because there is no dead hand, because there is progress and capital investment, because there is a desire to engage in progressive schemes of useful public works, we are criticised, and we are told that it is squandermania.
Comment on this
It was you who said that. It was you who referred to the dead hand of the Department of Finance.
Comment on this
There has been a certain amount of it, but if the Deputy would only have patience he would be surprised at the amount of good we could do on these benches.
Comment on this
I could not enlighten the Minister on that inasmuch as I am finding it hard to understand it myself.
Comment on this
I suppose it is too late for them to do it this year, but I suggest to the Party opposite that they should do it next year, and that is that when the Vote on Account comes before us they should refrain from imputing unworthy motives for everything that is done: that, instead of doing that, they should examine the Vote on Account, or any other question which comes before the Dáil, objectively, and make objective criticisms. If they do make objective criticisms that have any reality in them, they will find no one quicker to support them and to criticise with them than the Deputies on these benches, because there are not any yes-men over here. Stop, for God's sake, from imputing the worst possible motives for everything that is done on this side, and try to give a little bit of credit for patriotism and nationality to those outside the ranks of the Fianna Fáil Party.
Comment on this
Tar éis a bheith ag éisteacht leis an dTeachta atá tar éis labhartha táim in eadóchas go dtiocfaidh aon athrú ar an Rialtais so maidir le caiteachas. Táid siad imithe thar fóir agus is ag dul in olcas atá siad in aghaidh an lae. Ní hamháin go bhfuil an Bille atá os ár gcóir anois ró-mhór do mhuintir na tíre seo ach go bhfuil níos mó airgid fachta ar iasacht acu um an dtaca so ná mar a fuair an Rialtas a bhí ann rompu ar feadh 16 bliana agus tá beartaithe acu, do réir deallramh, a thuille iasachtaí d'fháil. Go bhfóiridh Dia ar na daoine sa tír seo a mbeidh orthú an t-airgead san go léir d'íoc thar n-ais le hús.
After listening to the puritanical speech that we have had from Deputy Lehane, we will have to consider our position afresh. Deputy Lehane tries to make out that the amount of money which is being spent this year does not count, that it should not count, provided the people will get value for it; but the question is, are the people getting value for this money or have they been getting value for the money that has been voted by this House since the Coalition Government came into office? I hold that they have not. We are presented this year with a colossal bill of £83,000,000. When you add to that central fund expenditure which, I dare say, will be in the region of £10,000,000, the total amount will be £93,000,000. It was hardly worth their while not making it £100,000,000. I suppose that by the time we have dealt with the Supplementary Estimates it will be over £100,000,000.
Comment on this
I would not be surprised, because no one can calculate what the amount is going to be as regards expenditure so far as this Government is concerned.
Comment on this
That is an old one. It is not the business of this side of the House to cut any item. It is the business of the Government to trim their sails in accordance with the capacity of the people to pay. I will refer the Deputy to what the Minister for Finance said when he came into this House in 1948 with the printed Book of Estimates in his hand. He said: "I am not responsible for this amount," and, in order to emphasise it the more, he caused a slip of paper to be inserted in the Book of Estimates to show that he was discarding responsibility for those Estimates. What was the bill then? It was for £65,000,000. and to-day we have a bill for £83,000,000, a difference of £18,000,000. Now, where is the economy and the retrenchment that we heard from the Minister for Finance on that occasion?
Comment on this
It was not. It was an expression that was made use of by the Minister for Finance himself, and, in order to give effect to that expression, he immediately set up an interdepartmental committee to examine in what Departments economy could be effected. What became of that committee that was set up for the purpose of effecting economies in public Departments? As Deputy Lehane has asked us to name a Department in which economies could be effected, I would like to know why there is an increase this year of £17,450 for the Department of External Affairs.
Comment on this
I was expecting that stock reply about Partition. The question is, what are those people doing about Partition, and what have they done to solve Partition? Everything that they have done up to now has been a step in the direction of placing obstacles in the way of solving Partition. There is an increase in the Vote for that Department, and they mention Partition as the justification for the increase in the Department of External Affairs. I think the less the Deputy says about Partition, the better for himself and for his Party.
Comment on this
That is all that the Deputy will be, vocal on it. The Deputy and his Party will talk about it. They will carry out stunts, here and elsewhere, in connection with the problem of Partition, but at the same time they will do nothing about it. They have done nothing about it.
Comment on this
I am pointing out a Department of State where, certainly, economy can be effected, the Department of External Affairs. I cannot see what justification there is for an increase of £17,450 for that Department. As I was saying, the expenditure here has gone out of bounds. It would not be too bad if we could see the end of it at any time, but it is mounting up from year to year. I hold that the people are getting no return for that expenditure and, worse again, that a great deal of the money that is being spent on the public services and in many ways is being borrowed. Look at the amount of money which has been borrowed since this Government came into office. I wonder is this excessive borrowing good business for the country? I hold that it is not. We have been told that this money is being utilised to install capital equipment here. Where is the capital equipment? What capital equipment has been bought outside in order to develop the resources of the country? Nothing worth while that I can see.
Comment on this
I do not want to hear anybody. I am going to make my own speech. If the Deputy does not want to listen, he can get out of the way. The Deputy will have to behave himself. Another ugly feature of the present position is our inability to make ends meet. Reference has already been made to the deficit in the balance of payments. The Taoiseach a very short time ago made a speech to the Cork Chamber of Commerce and pointed out to them that the deficit in the balance of payments in 1949 was £10,000,000, but that the deficit in the balance of payments for 1950 was £30,000,000, an increase of £20,000,000.
He proceeded to explain to his audience that that was not a bad thing for the country. If that is the case and if the deficit in the balance of payments is to continue increasing at that rate, increasing by 300 per cent. from one year to another, I wonder where we will find ourselves in a couple of years' time if the country has the misfortune of having that Government in office still. But the Minister for Finance, in putting this Vote on Account before the House, was not entirely so complacent as the Taoiseach. He gave warning to the House and to the people that it was not a happy position, that we were reaching the point when we would have to consider the position very carefully; in other words, that we were reaching the danger point. But what is the Minister for Finance going to do about it? If he realises, as he apparently does, that the danger point has been reached, will he come along and tell us that that position is going to be rectified in the future or, when he is being pushed by certain elements over there, will he again go away from that and pretend that everything is all right?
I was listening to the Minister for Agriculture last week speaking in the Dáil about many things. He spoke about moving mountains in Connemara and throwing rocks into the sea. But there is one thing he did not speak about and that is the price which the dairy farmers are getting for the milk which they deliver to the creameries. It would be much more to the point if he would make some statement about that, because I can tell him and the Government that there is any amount of dissatisfaction down the country at the attitude of the Minister and the Government towards that question. The dairy farmers tried to send a deputation to the Minister for Agriculture to discuss the price of milk and the Minister refused to meet the deputation. Why did he refuse to meet them? Are not the dairy farmers as much entitled to send a deputation to Dublin as any other section of the community? The Federation of Irish Industries sent a deputation and they were received. Every other section of the community can send a deputation to Ministers. It is strange that the deputation which the dairy farmers appointed to meet the Minister for Agriculture would not be received. I suppose there would be a certain amount of embarrassment in it for the Minister because, as Deputies will remember, he made an attempt last year, I would say a rather insidious attempt, to reduce the price of milk by holding out an offer of some nebulous five-year plan to these farmers. How is it that he gave the people no details of this plan?
Furthermore, could anybody guarantee, looking into the future, that the conditions which obtain to-day would obtain in five years' time? No. Certainly the Minister for Agriculture could not, and well he knew it. He thought that by dangling this carrot before the dairy farmers he was going to get them to accept a reduction in the price of milk. But the dairy farmers, being wiser than he thought they were, refused to negotiate on that nebulous basis.
Comment on this
The funny thing about this is that when the Minister for Agriculture took office when the Coalition Government came in he said: "We are going to be the servants of the people. I will not assume the rôle of dictator. I am going to be the servant of the people. The Irish people are paying me. I will be their servant and anybody who wants to see me or to discuss any problem with me can come along to the Department of Agriculture and there will be a cead mile fáilte before him." Here we had this deputation which tried to meet the Minister for Agriculture being refused an audience. Why? Are they not entitled to put forward a claim for an increase in the price of milk to the creameries? Remember that the price they are now getting, ½ for one part of the year and ¼ for the rest of the year, is the price fixed by the Fianna Fáil Government before leaving office. Nobody can deny that there has been an increase in the farmers' costs since then. The price of fertilisers has gone up. The price of feeding stuffs has gone up; local rates have gone up and the cost of agricultural labour has gone up.
Comment on this
That being so, are these people not entitled to an audience from the Minister for Agriculture to discuss this matter? Well and good, if the Minister for Agriculture has a case to make against them, let him make it.
Comment on this
There is no point of information. Deputy Keane will resume his seat. Unless the speaker gives way, no Deputy may interrupt Deputy Kissane on the Vote on Account.
Comment on this
I have listened to the Minister for Agriculture and to other Government supporters trying to impress upon the farmers that the prevailing prices for cattle are due to the Coalition Government. They have been touring the country sedulously trying to persuade the farmers that the prices they are getting, especially for their cattle, are due to this Government. That is not so. On the contrary, were it not for the action of the present Government, the farmers would now be enjoying a better price for their cattle. As the House knows, as a result of the 1948 agreement, our farmers are now compelled to confine the export of their cattle to the Continent to 10 per cent.
Comment on this
The rest of our cattle under that agreement must go to John Bull. If there was a free market and if no such conditions had been imposed on the sale of our cattle abroad, our farmers would be enjoying a better price for their cattle.
Comment on this
Apropos of that, there was a question to-day by Deputy C. Lehane asking the Government if they would get the British Government to release them from that condition in view of the fact that the British Government has not fulfilled its obligations with relation to the supplying of coal here. What is that but an admission that this condition militates against the farmers? Why then do Deputies on the Government benches go around the country trying to fool the people into believing that they are responsible for the prices the farmers are getting to-day? But they are not succeeding in that course because the farmers clearly understand the situation. I have referred to the price of milk. It was a good job for the dairy farmers that the price of milk was fixed before Fianna Fáil went out of office.
Comment on this
Had it not been fixed at that level then it would not have been fixed at that level since. There is no greater proof of that than the attempt made by the Minister for Agriculture to reduce the price to 1/- per gallon last year. But the farmers were not having any.
Comment on this
Irrespective of whether or not a Deputy's statement irritates another Deputy the other Deputy has no right to interrupt except on a matter relating to order. I feel constrained to warn certain Deputies that the Chair will have to take serious notice of interruptions.
Comment on this
We have been told by Deputy C. Lehane that the Government is not responsible for the high cost of living. That appears to me to be a change in position. Before Christmas last the tactics of the Government were different. They tried then to persuade the House and the people that there had been no increase in the cost of living. No doubt they thought they would get away with that. Members of the Fianna Fáil Party had been pointing out to them over long and weary months that the cost of living was increasing every day and that even the ingenious device of having two prices for certain commodities was not enough to close our eyes to the realities of the situation. The Government and its supporters took no notice of us: we were wasting our sweetness on the desert air. It was not until the public began to agitate that the Government took any notice. The housewives were feeling the pinch and they were in a much better position to feel it than Deputies were. It was not until a wave of indignation arose in the country that the Government were compelled to admit that there was a rise in the cost of living. Yet, to-day Deputy C. Lehane adopts a new position: now he says that the Government is not responsible for the high cost of living.
Let the people take note of the fact that members of the Government are now discarding all responsibility for the high cost of living; and the implication is that they will do nothing about it. It is an extraordinary thing, if that is the position, seeing that quite recently they went through the farce of setting up a so-called prices control authority. It was pointed out at the time that that was just another of the many stunts that the Coalition Government were having recourse to since they got into office. The fact of their having to release no fewer than 61 articles from the price freezing Order within the past few days is clear evidence that it was nothing but a farce
Of course, we would all like to see every genuine attempt being made to keep down the cost of living. It is our duty as representative to give encouragement to those people who genuinely seek to effect that desirable end but, when we see stunts of this kind being carried out, it is a different matter.
Deputy Lehane also mentioned that he was in agreement with us as regards growing our own produce at home—I hope I am not misquoting him when I say that—thereby obviating the necessity to import those commodities from the far ends of the earth. Deputy Lehane is in a totally different position from us as regards the matter. All that we on this side of the House can do is to appeal to the Government to realise the common sense of that policy and to try to get as much wheat, beet, barley, and so on, as is possible, produced at home. All we can do is to point out the common sense of that policy and to leave it to the judgment and direction of the Government to carry it out. Deputy Lehane, as I have said, is in a different position. He and his people can see that that policy is carried out, if he is sincere about it. I will not impute an insincere motive to him, but let him give proof of his sincerity by making the Government realise the position.
Dr. Paul Miller is the spokesman of the American Government in this country and it is his business to see that American interests in this country are well looked after. It is an extraordinary thing that the position has now come about that he must give advice to the Government here as to what they should do in regard to growing as much of our own food as possible. I remember that towards the end of last year Dr. Paul Miller spoke at Glengarriff on the advisability of the farmers of this country producing as much of their own feeding barley as possible, thus obviating the necessity to spend valuable dollars on importing maize from the ends of the earth. I put down a question asking the Minister for Agriculture whether he had read a report of the statement and, between the time the question was tabled and the answer was given in the House, the Minister went down to Kilkenny and told the farmers there that they should grow more barley and, for the first time, he mentioned a price. Quite recently, the E.C.A. administrator in this country referred to the question of wheat and advised the farmers of this country to grow as much wheat as possible.
Comment on this
No. I welcome it but it appears that the members of the Government do not welcome it.
Comment on this
That is so. The reason I am mentioning the administrator's name at all is that I want to bring home to the members of the Government their responsibility; that it is not the E.C.A. administrator from America that should have to mention those things, but the Minister for Agriculture, who is paid by the people of this country for that purpose.
Comment on this
Does the Deputy deny that the E.C.A. administrator in this country made this statement?
Comment on this
I said I did not object to anybody speaking in this country whose motives are genuine and, of course, his motives are genuine and his words of advice are welcome.
Comment on this
Ba cheart don Aire leigint don Teachta labhairt.
Comment on this
I say his motives are quite genuine and that such an able administrator and such a man, who tenders such valuable advice to the Irish people, is always welcome in this country. I am just pointing out that it is an extraordinary thing that it is left to people like him to give advice and encouragement to the Irish people when that advice and encouragement should be given by spokesmen of the Government.
Ní dóigh liom go bhfuil a thuille le rá agam anoís. Tá an-chuid ráite cheana ag na Teachtaí a labhair romham. Beidh caoi againn arís díospóireacht a bheith againn ar na cúrsaí seo agus, mar fhocal scoir, ba mhaith liom a chur in-iúl go bhfuilim-se i gcoinnibh an bhille mhóir seo i gcóir na bliana dar críoch, 1952, go bhfuil sé ro-mhór ar fad do mhuintir na tíre seo, agus nach bhfuil an t-iomlán le feiscint againn fós, mar nach bhfuil aon rud curtha síos i gcóir an Bhille mhóir sin, a bhaineann leis an Roinn Leasa Shóisialaigh, atá fá bhráid na Dála fé lathair, ná i gcoir rudaí eile mar é, agus rud eile, go bhfuilim go mór i gcoinnibh an iasacht mhor airgid seo do lorg. Ní maith an tseift é sin in aon chor maidir le gnath-chaiteachas na tíre. Aoinne a dheineas machnamh ar an scéal, chífidh sé, má leantar leis seo, go mbeidh thiar ar chúrsaí na tíre seo i gceann tamaill, má leantar de'n chaiteachas mór so gan ach an chaolchuid againn dá bharr.
Comment on this
I have listened to or have read the speeches delivered in this House on Friday and to-day by Deputies Dr. Ryan, Briscoe and Lemass. I candidly confess that never have I heard or listened to more destructive or more contradictory statements. The Deputies concerned complained about increased expenditure which increase, as they know, is due to the inauguration of schemes for national development or for increases in the social services. Deputy Dr. Ryan, in the House last Friday, complained about the cost of the scheme, which he said was not comprehensive enough. How he can reconcile the two things, I do not know. After he finished that very eloquent address and tried to reconcile these two conflicting statements, he proceeded with Deputy Little and others apparently to Lower Mount Street and reviewed the position, as he had heard it in the House during the speech of the Minister for Social Welfare, and then he announced on Saturday morning that the scheme of social security—this is what he asserted—will cost £4,000,000 —I am not sure whether that is correct —and they were standing over a scheme which would cost £4,600,000.
Comment on this
We are not discussing legislation. The Deputy was discussing legislation. He must not do so on the Vote on Account.
Comment on this
I was merely trying to point out the conflicting nature of the statements made by leading members of the Fianna Fáil Party, although they are supposed to have a united Party policy. The increased expenditure disclosed in the Book of Estimates and in the Vote on Account is due solely to expenditure on schemes of national development and to the increases provided for various social services. Deputy Lemass admitted to-day, in cross-examination by Deputy Con Lehane and others, that he could not put his finger on any item worthy of mention that should be omitted. He made the further statement, which apparently indicates that he did not read the Estimates, that there was no money provided for the mother and child welfare scheme.
Comment on this
It would seem that Deputy Little is as ignorant on these matters as Deputy Lemass. On page 403 of the Book of Estimates for the coming financial year it will be seen that a sum not less than £661,000 is provided for the mother and child welfare scheme. I suggest Deputy Little should advise Deputy Lemass that he should not come to the House again and proclaim such ignorance of the contents of the Book of Estimates.
Deputy Lemass said a terrible lot— it does not worry me—about the conflicting policies of the groups associated with the inter-Party Government. I thought that by now he and his colleagues would be tired trying to divide the groups that make up the inter-Party Government. Of course, that attitude on their part is ridiculous. The inter-Party Government have celebrated their third anniversary. Speaking for some of the persons responsible for its birth and continuance in office, I believe I could easily prove to the satisfaction of people both inside and outside this House that this is the best Government that has been in office during the 29 or 30 years that I have been in this House. From the workers' point of view it is a better Government than any single Party Government that has been in office here, and I include in that the Cumann na nGaedheal Government, and the Fianna Fáil Government that was here for a period of 16 years.
This Government, as Deputy Lemass and his colleagues know, was born and was baptised following an agreement to put into operation a ten-point programme. Five years is the legal life of any Government, provided they decide to remain in office. Inside a period of three years the present Government have put into operation nine of the ten points, and they have faced and solved many major problems that were unforeseen when they came into existence as a Government in February, 1948.
Deputy Dr. Ryan opposed the raising of further moneys for social services when he was speaking here on Friday last. I would remind Deputy Ryan that on 22nd October, 1947, when members of this group and of the Fine Gael group, who were then in opposition, brought forward a very mild motion for the modification of the means test in so far as it applied to old age and blind pensioners and to widows and orphans, he and his colleagues opposed it. He admitted at that time that the cost would be about £500,000 and could not exceed £750,000. On the eve of a general election, three months before it, he said that the country could not stand the cost and the Fianna Fáil Party would not accept that particular motion.
I want to remind Deputy Little and Deputy Ryan that since the inter-Party Government came into office it has increased old age pensions—and a further increase is now being given through the Social Welfare Bill—by not less that 5/- per week and modified the means test. In the coming financial year the aged, the blind, the infirm, and the widows and orphans will be getting £3,750,000 more than they were receiving in February, 1948.