We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Local Government (County Administration) Bill, 1950—Committee Stage (Resumed).

Contributions 111–238 of 238. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Local Government (County Administration) Bill 1950
Lapsed

No. 20 of 1950 ›

There are a few observations which I should like to make in regard to the amendment. First of all, I should like to say that I see considerable weight in much of what has been urged by Deputy Childers and some other Deputies who have spoken. Perhaps I might put it this way. If we were discussing the principle contained in this amendment de novo, without any relation to other machinery existing in this country, I could see considerable weight in what has been urged by Deputy Childers, but that is not the case. Actually to-day and each week there is in existence the type of machinery contemplated by the Bill as it stands which relates to the examination of old age pension applications and the virtual disbursement of old age pensions. Deputy Childers shakes his head but, in fact, if he will examine what I am saying, he will find that I am not very wrong. Each old age pension committee is largely staffed from the elected representatives on each county council.

Each applicant for a pension must submit his claim to these pension committees. He must there be examined as to his means and as to his merits and a decision is given by that pension committee with regard to his claim. It is true that, if he is dissatisfied with that decision, he has a statutory right of appeal to the central pension authority but that is mere machinery. The principle is the same because in the case of our old age pension committees we have had in existence for a great number of years the particular principle to which Deputy Childers objected in this Bill—the subjection of an applicant for State assistance to examination by persons who may subsequently look to him for support in elections.

Comment on this

They do not actually vote the money.

Comment on this

Voting the money in relation to the Deputy's objection on this point is quite irrelevant because as I understood Deputy Childers's objection it was that it was in some way wrong to have any person entitled to relief or assistance from the State or local funds to be beholden to anybody who might be elected by his or her vote. That I gathered to be one of the principles which Deputy Childers mentioned here. If that is so it does not much matter where the money comes from. If the objection is to the principle, it holds whether they vote the money or not. I think it is important that we should appreciate that the situation to which the Deputy objects exists to-day and has existed for a great number of years. Accordingly, I do not think that the proposal contained in the Bill is in any way unusual or revolutionary or in any way strange to anyone who has had any experience of local government or of the administration of the Old Age Pensions Acts. I cannot deny that I see considerable weight in much of the arguments used by Deputy Childers, but at the same time I cannot help feeling that the Deputy is speaking to a certain extent with his tongue in his cheek because if he really believes many of the arguments which he has addressed to the House, I think it must follow inevitably that he has a very low opinion of the elected representatives on councils of this country. I do not believe he could have that low opinion conscientiously because it is, and I think it must be, generally accepted that most county councillors and public representatives, in cases of need and distress, are more than anxious that fairness and justice should be meted out. I can say that in my constituency I have never heard of anything to the contrary, and I cannot see that the home assistance machinery will be impeded in any way, or interfered with, by the proposal in the Bill.

Comment on this

On a point of personal explanation: I do not think the Deputy is trying to misquote me, but I want to make it clear that I had no low opinion of local authorities. What I tried to say was—it may be rather ironic—that it is the most honest democracies in the world, including ourselves, who have been carrying out the principles which I have stressed. I am not reflecting on the local authorities. I said that there had been a gradual development, or a gradual evolution, of the principle of enabling assistance to be granted to individuals, but that, having to meet those who voted the moneys, we ought to go along the line I indicated, that we are as honest a democracy as others.

Comment on this

I am glad to hear the Deputy say that. I might suggest, perhaps, that he used an unhappy turn of phrase. I took the Deputy down as saying that it was important that an applicant for home assistance should not be beholden to any public representative who might later seek his vote.

Comment on this

That is a political democratic principle.

Comment on this

It is easy to talk about political principles in the abstract. I suggest that you have got to judge political principles by the ordinary facts of everyday life. I think that the particular sentence the Deputy used in relation to public representatives in this country would convey the meaning that those representatives would use home assistance for the purpose of buying votes for themselves.

Comment on this

It has happened.

Comment on this

Now, we have Deputy Allen saying that it has happened. I do not share that view of his for one moment.

Comment on this

I can prove it.

Comment on this

I think that what the Deputy has said is quite an unwarranted slur on county councillors and on the members of local authorities. It has been my experience that, with regard to assisting the needy and those in distress, there never has been in our local machinery any question of politics. The members of local bodies have always been only too anxious to ensure that the underdog and those in need would get every possible assistance.

Comment on this

Deputy Allen's Party did that.

Comment on this

It is unfortunate that such a contention should have been introduced. I feel certain that Deputy Childers does not hold that view at all, and that he is more or less endeavouring to discuss this matter in the abstract.

Comment on this

No, I am not, because the people who secured the assistance might quite easily subconsciously feel politically influenced without there being any question of it.

Comment on this

There can be no question of this, that in the post bag of every Deputy there are letters from constituents asking him to approach the Department of Social Welfare in relation, say, to a pension or some other Department about something else—letters asking the Deputy to do a hundred and one things of that kind. It is absurd to think otherwise, no matter what law you have and no matter what position you have with regard to machinery of this kind. No matter what may be done under this Bill, the ordinary constituent will still approach Deputies and elected representatives with regard to matters of this kind. If Deputy Childers is so naïve as to think that, by putting something into a section of an Act of Parliament, you are going to get people to act otherwise, all that I can say is that he has many more things coming to him.

As I said at the beginning, while academically I appreciate much of what Deputy Childers has urged here, I, nevertheless, say that, from a practical point of view and in view of what has been done with regard to Old Age Pension Acts and other matters of that kind, there is nothing strange, novel or revolutionary in the proposal in this Bill. At the same time I must say that I can agree with what, I think, Deputy T. Walsh, or maybe it was Deputy Childers, said, because frankly I do not see the necessity for this particular provision in the Bill. I did not hear the Minister's statement on it, but at the moment I do not see the necessity for it. While that is so, I, nevertheless, cannot share the view that it is something so strange and revolutionary as to be contrary to the principles which we all express and endeavour to practise. In fact, I am inclined to think that it is possible, under the proposal in the Bill, that there will be more justice meted out to home assistance applicants, in view of the fact that councillors in the different areas will know the home circumstances and know the cases more intimately. That will ensure that cases of immediate need will be brought to the notice of members of the council and that whatever hardships there are will be the more speedily relieved.

Comment on this

This is an important amendment, and I hope it will get mature consideration from every Deputy. To my mind, it is one of the most important amendments that have been put down to the Bill. I hope that the House, in its final decision on it, will not change what is in existence at the present time. It would be a retrograde step for the Dáil to revert back to what was in existence before the passing of the County Management Act. I can say that with deliberation. Home assistance is the one social service we have in which the scale of assistance given is not previously determined by the Dáil. The previous speaker referred to old age pension committees. It is true that an original application for a pension must come before a committee which is representative of people in the district. Very often, there is no public representative whatever on these committees.

Comment on this

I think that occurs very rarely.

Comment on this

What about county councillors?

Comment on this

They may not desire to serve on a committee, but that is beside the point. When an original application comes before an old age pension committee, the investigation officer, who is appointed by the Department of Social Welfare, is there, and he informs the committee of the results of his investigation into the case. He reports that applicant A.B., whoever he may be, is entitled to a certain scale of pension according to law. The committee may or may not accept his view. They do, almost always.

Comment on this

I beg your pardon.

Comment on this

If they determine otherwise, an appeal is made to the Minister for Social Welfare against the decision of the local committee. The determining officers in that Department then decide finally the scale of old age pension that a particular applicant is entitled to receive. If it is a clear case of an applicant's being entitled to the full scale of pension, no question arises afterwards. The pension is awarded as a result of the committee's decision. But if the committee act counter to the advice and opinion of the investigation officer, the investigation officer appeals in all cases. Therefore, it is quite different altogether from the administration of home assistance.

Comment on this

The principle is the same.

Comment on this

It is absolutely different. A trained investigation officer, trained by the State and in the employment of a State Department—formerly the Department of Finance and now the Department of Social Welfare—investigates the means of each applicant. That officer advises the committee according to the scale that has been laid down by the Oireachtas. Is that not so?

Comment on this

I do not think that the Deputy follows it.

Comment on this

I follow it quite well. I have worked on an old age pension committee and also on a home assistance committee.

Comment on this

Speak on local government.

Comment on this

I have some knowledge of these two types of committee.

Comment on this

You have very little knowledge of either of them.

Comment on this

With regard to the matter of home assistance as previously administered by local authorities, one of the reasons why the original County Management Act was brought before this House was because of abuses that took place in the administration of home assistance. That is a well-known fact. In one particular case in Ireland—we will not narrow it down any further——

Comment on this

That is very wise.

Comment on this

——it was publicly known that a particular personage who was a member of a home assistance committee used, at the end of each meeting, to send a note to each person who was granted home assistance on that particular day, telling him that he, the personage, had got him the home assistance. That is a well-known fact. It was because of the abuse of the administration of home assistance—in a few small individual cases, I will admit—that it was found necessary in the County Management Act to put the administration of home assistance into the hands of the county manager and his investigators.

I hope the Minister will accept this amendment by Deputy Childers. I believe it would be in the best interests of local administration that the county officer, together with his investigators, should administer home assistance. Undoubtedly, in this Bill, as in the previous County Management Act, the right to determine the remuneration and terms and conditions of employment of any individual in their employment is taken from the local authority. They have no right whatever to determine whether an officer should get shorter hours or an increase in wages or anything affecting the terms or conditions of his employment. That was done for a specific purpose. It was done in order to ensure that due, proper and non-political consideration—and when I say "non-political consideration" I mean non-public representative consideration—would determine what the remuneration of any officer in the employment of a local authority should be.

Comment on this

Who supply the moneys?

Comment on this

The council. They have no right in any single instance, not even in respect of one farthing, to determine what any officer should receive. That is in the County Management Act at the moment and it is being continued in this Bill. Almost 90 per cent. of the total rates struck and collected by any county council is spent in salaries, wages, allowances, pensions and so forth. With all this talk about democracy and the giving back of rights to local authorities, it seems to me to be very peculiar that the Minister and the Labour Party who sponsored this Bill did not give back the right——

Comment on this

It will come back.

Comment on this

——of determining how that 90 per cent. of the local taxation should be spent. Home assistance is a very small moiety of the local taxation. It has been justly and fairly administered. I say deliberately that there have been less complaints about the administration of home assistance than there were when the councils were administering it themselves.

In further support of what Deputy Childers has said, I should like to remind the House that there is nothing so degrading to a poor person as to have to go to a local representative and ask his assistance and influence in order to get what is that poor person's absolute right—and home assistance is given to the very poor sections of the community.

Comment on this

The county manager will not give it without a doctor's certificate.

Comment on this

That can be altered administratively. It does not require any change in the present law to alter that.

Comment on this

Home assistance has been granted to thousands without doctors' certificates.

Comment on this

Not now. You are not in touch with the position. When I go to the home assistance officer he tells me that the person on whose behalf I am making representations must get a doctor's certificate before the home assistance can be granted. That is in the Bill that your Party introduced. We should never have had county managers.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy Allen, on the amendment.

Comment on this

This amendment is very important. I appeal to the Minister to accept it. It will improve the Bill. We are all concerned with getting local government machinery that will work satisfactorily in the interests of all the people. Above all, we want to ensure that no possible abuse can arise under the machinery which we will provide. I hope the day will never come when members of local authorities will personally have to administer home assistance again. I hope that the Dáil will never decree in any Act that the local authorities should be the determining factor in the administration of home assistance to decide that A.B. should get so much or so little a week. It is asking the members of local authorities to do something which they should not be asked to do. The superintendent assistance officer and his assistants are trained to do it and the county manager on receiving their reports gives the final decision. If any member of a local authority has a grievance he has no difficulty in ventilating it at public or private meetings of the council or in making representations to the county manager. Representations have been made time and time again by every member of a local authority on behalf of individuals seeking home assistance and as a result investigations were made. It is degrading, however, for members of local authorities to have to determine what few shillings very poor persons should receive in the week. It can be abused. It has been abused very seriously in the past and is open to abuse in the future. I hope that the Minister will take no hard and fast line but will keep his mind open. If he will accept Deputy Childers's amendment it will be all to the good but he should promise the Dáil at least to give the matter more mature consideration before deciding that the amendment should not be inserted in the Bill.

Comment on this

Listening to Deputies Allen and Killilea I was convinced that it was their mentality which made the Management Act as it is implemented at the moment a Fianna Fáil forest. Only a warped mentality like that of Deputies Allen and Killilea could suggest for a moment that the local representatives who have the confidence of the electorate of their area would, in order to enhance their political reputation and chances, introduce corruption as we know corruption by exploiting the recipients of home assistance, the destitute people of their area. I have often heard it said that every man judges every other man by his own mentality and I was ashamed to listen to those two very responsible Deputies of the Opposition and can certainly agree with the remaining Deputies.

Deputy MacEntee mentioned 320 people—I do not know if that was a notional or factual figure—all of whom were put off and 60 of whom were kept off as a result of a more intense examination of their cases. I maintain that the proper procedure would have been to intensify the examination and to put off the 60 people who were found to be drawing home assistance to which they were not entitled, but not to victimise the other 260. I would like to know how long they were off home assistance, which was their only means of existence, and how they existed during that time. The Minister could give us a picture of that as it happened in his own area.

Deputy Smith stated that the council in Cavan divested themselves of the responsibility for awarding home assistance. They took the power from themselves and the reason was lack of moral courage. They were afraid that they would be tainted, that they would lose caste or that they would be pilloried if they accepted responsibility for administering home assistance in Cavan. Still they accepted responsibility when they put themselves before the people for election to the county council. Many of them were members of county boards of health and other statutory bodies, but yet they took the responsibility of administering home assistance from themselves and placed it on officials.

I would like to get a definition from Deputy Childers of local government administration. Would I be right in saying that local government means local administration by local representatives?

Comment on this

The Deputy has not understood a word of my speech. I will have to make it all over again.

Comment on this

I listened with interest and the Deputy need not repeat it. I listened to the word "beholden" but whether, as my colleague Deputy O'Higgins said, he meant that in the abstract or not I do not know. Deputy Childers understands that when an old age pension claim comes before a local committee the secrets of that man's means are exposed on paper and the committee are quite entitled to examine them. If a local representative is approached by some unfortunate man or woman seeking home assistance he is almost always conversant with the conditions of that man or woman if he or she lives in the neighbourhood.

He will not ask whether they are getting anything from England or America. He will not ask if they have means in the bank and get permission to investigate in the bank because he knows all about the person from the grapevine of his community. He knows more than the official who comes with the form to get information which must be given or else the applicant's means are assessed at their maximum and he is deprived of any pension he is entitled to get. The committee will then examine the case. Is it not a fact that those committees are canvassed from time to time by old age pension applicants? I know very well that I have been canvassed during the past 17 years and have been asked by the poor old good Irishman "to put in a good word" for him. I do not think it was degrading in any way for those people to ask me to put in a good word for them. From time to time the humane concepts of the local representatives overcame the red tape concepts of the officials who were carrying on the work under the local authority. I never saw any abuse during my eight years as a member of a public assistance authority. I do not know whether we in the south have a different way of carrying out business from the people in other parts of Ireland, but I can say we always dealt with home assistance at the meeting. The first thing presented to the meeting was the report from the home assistance superintendent, through the chairman, and if there were any new cases to be dealt with they were discussed, not in public, and the chairman signed the various sheets; and then the meeting went into public session to discuss hospitals and everything else. The sooner we return to that system the better. We will be removing a degrading principle which at the moment is more than prevalent. First of all, the cases are examined by the local home assistance officer, then by the superintendent and last, but not least, by the manager. When all fails, the applicant can come to the local representative and ask him to go and kow-tow to the manager. It is not the applicants who will be beholden, with some of the managers, but the local representative making a plea on their behalf.

Someone said there has been a great improvement in regard to hospitals, in the payment of the charges. We always took every case on its merits, where an application was put in to have hospital charges reduced. The area I was representing could compare favourably with any other part of Ireland regarding the payment of hospital charges. I hope that never will the function be taken away from the local representative so that he cannot intervene on behalf of a borderline case, which outwardly may look affluent but which really may be on the border between middling well off and not well off. It is a very goodly and godly idea of the Minister to return to the local representatives the authority to administer home assistance in its very wide sense. I hope that the mentality expressed by both Deputy Allen and Deputy Kennedy will not prevail. Deputy Kennedy mentioned a case where a hospital patient had a car and canvassed all the county council members to see if he could get away free gratis regarding hospital charges. That amazing statement was made by a member who stated he was chairman of a public assistance committee.

I would like to ask Deputy MacEntee would it not be the lesser of two evils if those 320 had been kept on home assistance and, when further investigations had been made, the 60 who were not entitled were knocked off, instead of peremptorily knocking off the 320, then making further investigations and putting back 260. I am sure that in his humane moments at times Deputy MacEntee would not consider victimising 260 genuine cases, leaving them to bear the brunt of want, leaving it to some charitable institution to provide for them for the week, fortnight or month that the cases were being investigated, and depriving them of the little pittance they were getting from the Limerick City or County Board of Assistance. I hope this House will repudiate the statements that were made by some of the Opposition Deputies and show that repudiation by not accepting the amendment by Deputy Childers.

In fairness to the managers that I happened to be with for the past nine years, I would like to say that at no time was there an attempt to make the Managerial Act function in County Cork as far as these people were concerned. They were always prepared to meet the committee—it was only a recommendation committee—and more often than not they agreed to the proposals put before that committee. I believe also that for the eight years before that when I was a member of the statutory body, the North Cork Board of Public Health and Assistance, the administration of home assistance was done in a far more suitable and beneficial way to the people who most deserved it. I am not talking about those who got it under pretence and did not want it. The vast majority needed it very badly. I hope that when we come back here in the New Year, after a certain amount of experience under this new County Officer Act, we will be able to say that home assistance is now being properly and justly administered.

Comment on this

I would like to say a few words in contradiction of Deputy Keane. I would be very sorry to see the present method of home assistance reverting to the former method under the county council. I am a member of a local body and can safely say that whenever I recommended a deserving case to the county manager it was attended to most conscientiously. It is humiliating enough to have to go before these people and when a person has to ask a local representative to recommend him to a manager, it is hard enough to do that; but if it reverts to the county council he will have to go around all the members to ask them to do their part in obtaining the home assistance. It would be a very retrograde step for this Dáil to go back to that. Undoubtedly, there would be abuses, as each councillor would be claiming it was he who got the home assistance for that poor person. At present they feel that they can go to a member and ask him to recommend them to the manager for an increase in home assistance or for home assistance in the first instance. It would be a great mistake to change the present system because there have been abuses in the past. As long as you have a good conscientious county officer, there is no doubt that the Act will be properly administered. Therefore, I hope the Minister will accept the amendment.

Deputy O'Higgins stated that the granting of old age pensions rested entirely with the old age pension committees. That is not so. I have served on one of these bodies and I found that the matter rests almost entirely with the investigating officer. In most cases he decides what the person is entitled to and in very rare cases have the committees been able to get him to increase the old age pension. People may appeal against his decision in the hope of getting an increase, but very rarely can they get the investigating officer to change his decision. Therefore, the committees have very little to do with the granting of the old age pension, except in a very few cases where there is no question of means or anything like that.

Comment on this

I am surprised that the discussion on this matter has taken so long and I am more than surprised that the amendment is being pressed, because the whole structure of the Bill, the whole intention of the Bill, is to restore to local authorities powers that they lost under the County Management Acts. I feel that in the matter of home assistance and the other matters referred to in the two amendments before us the decision would best be taken by local representatives with a sense of responsibility and a sense of duty. Deputy Mrs. Rice says it is all right when you have a good conscientious county manager, but you may not have a good conscientious county manager. County managers are human just like anybody else and they can make mistakes. They can have a different approach. It is because they have made mistakes and because their administration has been subject to considerable criticism that we have this general desire to replace the managerial system by a more democratic system. I feel that councillors, with their responsibility to the electorate and their duty under the statute to administer these matters, will approach them from a humane point of view, that the human aspect will be uppermost in their minds. There will be before them an individual case and the circumstances of that family may be known to a number of the councillors and, in my view, they are the best people to decide this particular matter.

Deputies overlook the fact that, even though the local councillors may have the function of deciding the matter, investigation will still be in the hands of officials and there will be before the councillors reports from these officials on each individual new application. In regard to the others, there will be the usual formal report. Therefore, you have investigation by people who are experienced in investigation and recommendations made by them. Here is where the difference will come in.

If you have the local councillors, they will approach the matter from a humanitarian point of view, and it is their duty to do so. If you have the local councillors looking at it from that point of view, that will influence those investigating officers in their approach to the problem and in their recommendation in respect of a particular individual. If the local councillors dealing with the matter are to look at it from a humanitarian point of view, then the recommendations made to them will be made on humanitarian lines. Whereas, if you have the manager, who may not have a humanitarian approach, who may simply have the approach of £ s. d., who may be a person who thinks there should not be home assistance at all, his influence will permeate to his officials and these officials will submit recommendations to accord with the known views of the particular county officer. That is the danger I see in dictatorship, whether it is local or otherwise.

I should like to see these matters discussed by the local councillors with a sense of responsibility and a sense of duty. They may make mistakes, but they will make them on the right side, and that is important. It is better to make a mistake on the right side than to make it on the wrong side. Taking it all round, it is better that these matters should be administered by the local councillors, who, after all, are elected by the people as the best persons to investigate, examine and administer these particular matters. If they are reckless, they have the responsibility of answering their electorate at the next election. For that reason, I cannot understand why this amendment is being pressed because it is out of context. It is opposed to the principle of the Bill which we are passing. It is out of harmony with the principle of the Bill as accepted in this House. That is why I am surprised that it is being pressed, and I hope that Deputy Childers will not insist on pressing it.

Comment on this

I shall go on pressing it.

Comment on this

I hope not, because it may happen that Deputy Childers may get a decision in his favour. That would not be very good; it would be very bad for the people. It would be very bad for Deputy Childers, but he will take that responsibility. If his Party as a whole decide, irrespective of how they may individually approach the matter, to support this idea I do not think that decision will be welcomed generally in the country. I would ask Deputy Childers to agree that once this House has decided to make an amendment in the Management Acts he should assist them in putting into effect the new provisions and giving democracy a chance to work.

I have no use for those who talk about corruption in relation to local councillors and in relation to local authorities. I have heard that allegation made many times, but I have never come across a single instance of corruption.

Back in 1898 when we first got local authorities the suggestion was made against them that they were corrupt and concerned solely with their own pockets. From what section of the people did this suggestion come? It came from that section of the people who were deprived of certain powers under the Act of 1898. When people of means and property are deprived of certain functions they invariably make the suggestion of corruption against those people of lesser property and lesser means who replace them. I think our local administration generally all over the country is absolutely above reproach. Whatever may be suggested in regard to these particular amendments, let them not be put forward on the basis that our local councillors are corrupt. Many Deputies are councillors. Does any Deputy who is a councillor hold himself or herself up as corrupt? Not one of them. But they make the insinuation that some other representative of the people on a local body is corrupt.

Comment on this

You are all saints over there.

Comment on this

We are all saints when we are talking about ourselves and all the sinning is done by someone else. I would like to see this Bill get a fair start. I would like to see the members of local authorities getting the powers we promised to give them. I would like to see them getting those powers with the will of the House. If, when the Bill comes into operation, it is found to be defective the House can then come together and with its experience of the working of the Act it can remove these defects. The function of this Bill is to restore to local authorities powers which were taken away from them in days when there was a new approach, particularly on the continent of Europe, to local administration. People were inclined to see good in the dictatorships in Germany and Italy, and they were inclined to put some of these concepts into operation here. That period has now passed and we are back again to democracy. We realise the benefits of it.

Comment on this

Is the Deputy talking about the Blueshirts, by any chance?

Comment on this

I know nothing about the Blueshirts.

Comment on this

Only about The Vanguard.

Comment on this

The Deputy will extend the scope of this debate if he thinks there is any connection between my amendment and Hitlerite Germany. The debate will go on for weeks until the Minister moves the closure. The Deputy will get his reply pretty quickly.

Comment on this

I have no desire to prolong the debate.

Comment on this

You have already put another half-hour on it.

Comment on this

When this conception of management was put into general operation here there were these faulty examples in existence in Europe. They have gone now. The idea is gone. We are back again to democracy in operation and democracy in action. Let us put democracy into operation and into action and let us give the local authorities the responsibility for those things for which all right-thinking people believe they should have responsibility. Do not let us try to retain some of the county management dictatorship in this new measure. In the interests of the Bill and in the interests of good administration, I appeal to Deputy Childers to withdraw his amendments.

Comment on this

Probably I have more experience of local administration than Deputy Childers has, since I am a member of a local authority. I have had the experience of people who were looking not just for home assistance but for an increase in home assistance. When I approached the officer concerned I was told that a doctor's certificate would have to be produced according to the instructions of the county manager. Are we not better judges than these dictators who obviously went astray in some counties? When Deputy Childers was Parliamentary Secretary during the Fianna Fáil régime we were deprived of our right to go to the Custom House and there make a case for an old age pensioner.

Comment on this
Gerard Sweetman Acting-Chairman (Mr. Sweetman) Fine Gael

Not on this amendment.

Comment on this

If this matter is raised, it will take another half-hour.

Comment on this
Acting-Chairman

The Chair can deal with irrelevancy without any assistance.

Comment on this

Old age pensioners were referred to. Are old age pensions committees corrupt, with their chairman a clergyman?

Comment on this
Acting-Chairman

Old age pensions do not arise under this.

Comment on this

The committee decide that a particular applicant is worthy of an old age pension. An officer is sent out to investigate that application. The officer goes to extremes. He counts the hens and the chickens. He goes back and reports. But that is not done in all cases.

Comment on this
Acting-Chairman

The matter does not arise on this amendment.

Comment on this

But that will apply if this amendment is passed. The local representatives are the best judges. If there was corruption in the past, then that corruption must have existed under Fianna Fáil since they appear to be so extraordinarily worried about it. Deputy Allen said to-day that he knew of one instance where an applicant for home assistance was sent a postcard by a particular individual notifying him that he had procured the home assistance for the applicant. Deputy Allen did not mention where that happened. He did not mention whether the individual was a member of any particular Party. Deputy Childers lives in the city. He does not come into contact with our ordinary man-in-the-street in the way in which a member of a local authority does. Why should there be any fear because the elected representatives of the people have a say in the administration of home assistance? It is we who strike the rate. Is it not a sad commentary that one should be told that an applicant for home assistance must procure a doctor's certificate? Is it not wrong that his claim should be held up? I know of one instance where a county manager had to take money from the unemployment assistance and give it out in home assistance. Did Deputy Childers know anything about that? Was that right? Was that Christian? Home assistance is given in order to tide a person over a period of distress. An unemployed man can go to the court of referees and bring any member of this House, who is in his area, to defend him at that court. Why should we not have authority to speak on behalf of whoever wants home assistance? What do the county managers, some of whom are imported into counties, know? By whom are they going to be guided if not by the local authority? Deputy Childers is greatly afraid something terrible will happen.

Comment on this

I never suggested county councillors could not recommend home assistance.

Comment on this

That is what we are setting up committees for.

Comment on this

Apparently the Deputy did not understand my speech.

Comment on this

The Deputy spoke a lot of boloney, because he knows nothing about local authorities; if he did, he would not put down that amendment. I would like the Minister to go further; I would like him to bring in a Bill to abolish all the little dictators set up by Deputy MacEntee, and give us full power. It was under their administration that some of their pets were made county managers and now they are afraid a little power will be given back to the elected representatives of the people. The people want that. Every day I meet unfortunate people from the country who cannot make a case for themselves. How will they get home assistance if they have not some local man on the committee to speak on their behalf? Have the unfortunate people to wait until the home assistance officer comes out, whenever he likes, to see if they want home assistance? Is that the Deputy's intention—that we have to wait until the home assistance officer or the county manager comes out to ascertain the circumstances in which an unfortunate man or woman is living?

Comment on this

No suggestion of that kind was ever made.

Comment on this

Committees should be set up. Why have we a committee of agriculture and other committees outside the county council? Why have we vocational committees or general purposes committees?

Comment on this

We did not even oppose the idea of a committee.

Comment on this

You are opposing the Bill with all these principles in it and you cannot get away from that. There is no use blowing hot and cold. I would like to see the county managers finished. That would save the ratepayers the £1,000 salary and expenses and we could give more towards home assistance. Is it not a shame that the Government have to fight so hard to get a Bill through that will benefit the poor? The Opposition were 16 years in office and the sooner they realise they are gone for ever, the better. Their day has passed. The day of dictators has passed. Democracy is prevailing; peace and harmony are prevailing in all parts of the country. That was not so when Fianna Fáil were in charge of the country for 16 years. They were chasing the I.R.A. and others through the country, and the jails were full.

Comment on this

I have listened to several speeches on this amendment. We have heard a lot about restoring the powers of councils, particularly from Deputy Cowan. I have been thinking over this matter and, as regards the system of administration of home assistance, so far as I know there is no dissatisfaction on the part of the people in receipt of it. I believe they are all satisfied with the present arrangement. The administration of home assistance is a very difficult matter. I would not like to see the present system changed.

A number of Deputies on the Government side to whom I listened to-night are members of local authorities. I believe they have mistaken ideas about restoring powers to county councils. They have not a proper idea of what the powers of a county council are. I have had experience of local bodies over a number of years in my own county, and I am aware that there are many individuals who have an idea that in themselves they are the county council. In my county there were individuals who thought they had a perfect right to do certain things. They would write a note to the home assistance officer asking him to give assistance to a person whom they considered was a deserving case. The home assistance officer might be weak enough to give way to that councillor. The councillor might say: "That man is entitled to home assistance; give it to him." I have known it to happen in years gone by that a note would go from a member of the board of health and the home assistance officer would need to be a fairly strong man to refuse the request in that note.

A county council composed of people with that type of outlook does not deserve to be called a council. Such persons have no idea of working together as a council. Deputy Cowan mentioned that the local councillors knew the circumstances of the people in their own areas best. A councillor in one area may have a different outlook on the position and on this question of home assistance from that of a councillor in another area. One councillor may be inclined to be overgenerous. He may have set up a standard in his area, and demand greater scales and bigger payments than would be possible throughout the whole county. In another area, against that, you may have a councillor who may err in the other direction. He may be parsimonious about the spending of public money. When this committee composed of all those councillors with different outlooks meet and weigh up the position and act fairly and impartially towards all the applicants, the result of the whole position may be—it has happened under the old system—that the applicants in one area may be neglected and not get justice, and the position may be abused in other areas.

I think the present system is as near as we possibly can get to perfection. This whole question of the powers of the county council being taken from them and of restoring the powers of the county council under this Bill, to my mind, is all nonsense. The effect of giving back to the committees the power to grant home assistance is not restoring any power. It is only making it possible for us to revert to abuses that were possible when that system was carried on before. County councils, under the Managerial Act, where they work as a council had full powers to compel the manager. The manager is the only man. He is paid for the job. He has time for it, and he has a home assistance officer. If the council meet as a council—not as individuals pulling as much as they can for their own areas and doing what they can for their own areas— and take a view of the county as a whole and try to act for the county as a whole and not for the people with whom they come into contact, they can lay down a policy for the manager that will be fair and just to all the people. If the manager is extravagant in the expenditure of money the council can deal with him. If he is inclined to restrict payments and not give to the poor—the people who are in need of home assistance—the amounts they need and to which they are entitled, the council can deal with him in that direction. The manager will very soon get to know what is best to do.

From my knowledge of officials, I know that they are always careful. That is particularly so in the case of home assistance officers. They are inclined to be on the safe side and the safe side for them is to give the benefit of the doubt to the applicant. I do not think any council should object to that. They do not want cases arising where people may die of starvation. They always have that at the back of their minds. They have a difficult job to carry out. Under the present arrangement with the county manager under the control of the council acting as a council for the whole county and with the interests of all the county in view, our present system is as near as we can possibly get to perfection. Nobody in the country, so far as I know—the poor people, the ratepayers or anybody else—is worried about the position. I think that the poor, under the county manager, are getting more attention than ever they got and that his administration is more impartial than administration under a number of individuals called a council will be. He is in a position to weigh up the situation for the whole county.

Comment on this

He knows everything.

Comment on this

Deputy O'Leary represents probably one area in a county. I represent another. I will be inclined to judge the whole county on the conditions obtaining in my own area. I often heard county councillors remark that everybody should fight for his own area. It is a good thing to see a councillor pushing forward but there must be somebody over all, somebody who will keep the interests of the county as a whole in view. That is not done either very often or always by county councillors.

Comment on this

I do not intend to say more than a few words. I feel very strongly on this question of the change of policy which it is proposed to make in this Bill. I have been a very long time on local bodies and quite a long time on boards of health. The one argument that I could see in favour of the managerial system was that there was too much work to be done by the old boards of health. This matter of public assistance was one of the things that made our work almost impossible. But we have to consider what is the present procedure in this matter of home assistance.

A county councillor, or, in fact, anybody may write to the county manager or a person who wants home assistance may make application to the county manager or secretary of the county council. The manager then proceeds to have his application investigated. He does that through his assistance officers. If necessary, in special cases, if he is not satisfied with the report of the local assistance officer, he gets the county superintendent to check up, investigate and report. Then the manager, having all these facts placed before him, decides whether the applicant is entitled to home assistance or not and awards a certain amount if he thinks fit. I would like to know how this assistance committee are going to depart from that procedure. Surely, nobody will allege that ten members of the county council can have sufficient knowledge of their own to make a decision in at least three-quarters of the applications for assistance. They could not have that knowledge. They will all the time have to rely on the reports furnished by the assistance officers. What then is the advantage? I cannot see any advantage really. They will have to decide, if they want to decide fairly, on the reports that come from the assistance officers. Deputy O'Leary will agree with that.

Comment on this

What will they do while they are waiting?

Comment on this

There is no waiting.

Comment on this

Die with the hunger?

Comment on this

If the Deputy knows the job as I know it, there is no waiting. Temporary assistance is given in every case where it is required.

Comment on this

Not in all cases.

Comment on this

In all cases, and there is no county manager who will attempt to refuse temporary assistance where it is required.

Comment on this

If he is up in the mountains, how will he get down to the manager?

Comment on this
Gerard Sweetman Acting-Chairman (Mr. Sweetman) Fine Gael

Deputy O'Rourke must be allowed to make his statement without interruption.

Comment on this

Deputy O'Leary would be surprised by the way they get down. I wonder how many of them manage to see him now and again.

Comment on this

They write to me.

Comment on this

Assuming that this committee is set up, they will not have sufficient knowledge, except in regard to odd individual cases, to decide on the necessity for home assistance and the amount to be allocated, and they will, therefore, have to rely on the reports of the assistance officer. There is no other way out of it, and, therefore, so far as information goes, there is no advantage in this committee. What are the disadvantages? In the first place, if such a committee is to deal with every individual case, it will have to be in session a long time. The county manager and those in the county council's offices are there all the time. They are doing this work day after day and are a long time in session. I wonder how long will the assistance committee be in session if they are to study each individual case. It will cost a great deal of money and is, therefore, a disadvantage to the ratepayers from the financial point of view and no advantage that I can see to the recipients of public assistance.

It has happened—I suppose it happened before the last local elections, but it certainly happened after the last local elections—that committees were appointed on a political basis. In some cases, there is scarcely a single representative of the Opposition on committees of agriculture, on vocational education committees and other committees. What, then, will be the position if we are to have public assistance committees elected on purely political lines? Will that not lead to a nice state of affairs? There is a grave danger of that happening. It has happened and such committees are in operation at present, and nobody can say that it is not likely to happen again. I say, therefore, that there is a very great danger of the whole thing developing into cliques which will not be in the interest of either the ratepayers or the poor who are supposed to get home assistance. The Minister has been a member of a local body—perhaps not as long as I have been—and he should very carefully consider this amendment. I am afraid that, if he does not accept it, a serious state of affairs for his Department will be brought about. I ask him to accept the amendment and I do so as one who never believed in using political influence to penalise anybody.

Comment on this

The Deputy is surely not serious when he says that? The Fianna Fáil clubs used every bit of it that could be used.

Comment on this
Gerard Sweetman Acting-Chairman (Mr. Sweetman) Fine Gael

Deputy O'Rourke, without interruption.

Comment on this

I know more about Fianna Fáil clubs than Deputy O'Leary——

Comment on this

He would not be allowed into one.

Comment on this

And I can assure him that such a thing as interference by any Fianna Fáil club has never happened that I am aware of, and there is no danger of it. There is, however, a danger, especially after local elections when tempers are up and feelings strong, of committees being appointed on a political basis. That would be disastrous for the administration of public assistance or the administration of any other service in which the interests of a large number of people are involved. I think it would be a retrograde step, and I am asking him now to accept the amendment as one who, in my own Party, opposed the managerial system. I was against having it as through as it is now, but one thing with which I always agreed was that the board of health could not possibly carry out the functions it was supposed to carry out. To do so these boards would have to be in almost continuous session, and I could see no way out of it other than leaving it to trusted officials to carry out these functions.

Comment on this

The discussion has ranged over a very wide field on this issue, which is definitely a very straight and simple issue, but the longer the discussion goes the more involved it seems to become. Taking the last speaker first, Deputy O'Rourke is in error when he sees a danger of political committees being appointed. It will be a matter of a committee of the whole council, a general committee, and hence there cannot be any question of interference.

Comment on this

I wonder.

Comment on this

The general tone of the discussion seems to have been based on a fear about entrusting this function to the elected representatives. The Bill itself is designed to restore powers to the elected representatives which they did not hold under the County Management Acts. They are given very wide and very representative powers in regard to contracts, roads, houses, and so on, and why we should swallow the camel and strain at the gnat, I do not know. What are we afraid of in the matter of entrusting them with the administration of home assistance? They will have the same officers. The home assistance and assistance officers will be there, and will carry out their functions as they carry them out to-day and report back, not to the manager but to the elected representatives. What, then, is the basis of the fear about the desperate corruption which is to take place?

I would join with some of the Deputies who have spoken in saying that I think the remarks made by some Deputies are not at all a worthy reflection on the character or type of those who make up our public representatives. The elected representatives are the best the country can put up, and, taking them by and large, we have no reason of any kind tobe ashamed of our county councils. We have had many Deputies showing the greatest fear that, in entrusting them with the administration of home assistance, we will be submerged in corruption instanter. I did not know until now how influential politically destitute people who are dependent on home assistance can be. They are, to my mind, numerically negligible and I hope will become more negligible; but I do not believe that, even if councillors were inclined to use them politically, it would be any great advantage to them and I certainly do not believe that they are of the type suggested by some Deputies that they cannot be entrusted with the giving of home assistance to people who are momentarily down and out.

There is a vast gulf between home assistance and old age pensions and other State pensions. In the State-aided schemes, there are well defined rules which must be obeyed. There is a certain age, a means test and so on. We have had a comparison made between the pensions officer and pensions committee and the home assistance officer, but the pensions officer is working on the basis of a well-defined code. Home assistance, which is primarily and essentially the function of the local representatives, is and must be more elastic. You are dealing there with people who are quite all right one week and who, next week, because misfortune strikes them, are momentarily down and out and require assistance. It may only be of a temporary character, but I suggest that the local representatives would be more conversant with that type of case than other persons you could name. These elected representatives will still have the cooperation and assistance of the people, the home assistance officer and assistance officer, who are trained in the work and who will report back. Why we should have the idea that all the virtues must be vested in the individual, the county officer or manager, I cannot understand. Deputy Allen mentioned that it was mainly because of home assistance that the Management Act was brought into operation.

Comment on this

One of the reasons.

Comment on this

The fact that there was abuse in the administration of home assistance was one of the principal reasons, the Deputy said, for that Act.

Comment on this

One of the reasons.

Comment on this

Since then, everything in the garden has been lovely. Deputy Childers seemed to hold the same viewpoint because he said that the county managers ought to be national leaders to whom the people would look, showing a certain association of thought. I have perfect respect for the managers, but I do not get down on my knees to adore them. They are not people to be defied. Public representatives can be trusted to carry out the functions which they are elected to carry out and the last people to cast a reflection upon them should be Deputies. I want to see this Bill working successfully. I have met the Deputies as far as I can in relation to the various amendments, in order to bring forth a machine that can function effectively in the interests of the country and democratically. I believe that the transfer of the home assistance functions from the county officer to the elected representatives is part and parcel of what we are doing in the Bill as a whole. It is one added power that we are giving to the elected representatives, and not a major one at that.

Having gone so far as we have gone with the Bill, having decided, on Second Reading, to transfer these powers to the elected representatives —they had much wider powers before that—I do not see why we should crib over this particular one. I cannot see what is the fundamental objection to allowing the people who are elected to administer home assistance. They are the people who strike the rate and who will have to make provision for home assistance, on the basis of their experience and knowledge of the circumstances in their respective areas. I have not the least fear that they will go to the moon in respect of this matter because they will be responsible for striking the rates. I believe home assistance will be administered correctly and fairly and, I hope, more generously than was the habit.

Once again I express the view that this was one of the services that were on a miserly standard throughout the country generally. I say that from what knowledge I have of public life. The standards of home assistance were very miserly and the amounts given were not competent in many cases to maintain life in the poor people who were getting it. With the introduction of this new measure, I hope it will be somewhat more generous. I have no fear whatever of local representatives over-spending or spending widely because they will be responsible for striking the rate and for making provision for the area. I hope it will be somewhat more generous than has been the customary standard of public assistance. I trust that there will be less and less people for it but such as have the misfortune to call for it ought to get a modicum to keep them going for the temporary period they are depending on it.

I would, therefore, ask the House to accept the position as it is in the Bill and to show confidence and trust in the representatives to do the right thing in respect of the home assistance service.

Comment on this

Up to date there has been a great deal of misunderstanding with regard to our attitude on the amendment. Everybody is trying to make political capital out of it. We are proposing something of a really serious character. We have not made any suggestions that county councillors are corrupt. We have not made a suggestion that county councillors cannot act as representatives and bring cases where home assistance is needed to the attention of the manager or the home assistance officer. We have not suggested that there should be any delay in the award of home assistance in urgent cases and we have not suggested that county councillors cannot check the administration of home assistance in the ordinary way. We have made none of these suggestions. We have not suggested, even, that home assistance is necessarily adequate. We are not arguing here as to whether home assistance is given on a miserly basis or not. There is nothing to prevent an increase being given in home assistance by various local authorities, if they chose to plan their rate scheme to award larger amounts and, if they do not do it, as in the case under many other Acts that have been passed, the Minister for Local Government can enforce some higher minimum scale of home assistance. None of these things has any relation to the general question of this amendment.

We have had people making comparisons between the award of home assistance and the award of old age pensions. It is quite obvious there is no comparison. First of all, there is a definite scale of values prescribed under an Act for old age pensions. Secondly, the investigation officer gives practically all the information required in every single case, and, thirdly, the old age pension applicant can appeal once more to a higher authority and the higher authority does not consist in the ordinary way of people who are immediately responsible for making available the money for the old age pension. As a matter of fact, as is known to the House, Deputy Dr. Ryan made proposals for the amendment of the Social Welfare (Insurance) Bill, which would eliminate a great deal of the publicity attached to the granting of old age pensions by substituting a valuation test for the old test which involved minute analysis of the person's means.

Comment on this
Acting-Chairman

Surely not on this amendment.

Comment on this

I have had to go far astray. What I am coming to is that I put seriously to the Minister certain principles in connection with the award of any form of social service. I wonder how many times I have to repeat them before the Minister understands them. I put them very seriously, and I suggest that when Deputy Cowan and the Minister think that the power of granting or withholding assistance should be retained in the hands of local representatives, they are actually going against what might be described as the left wing viewpoint in regard to the award of social services.

This amendment is not a conservative amendment. If anything, it is rather in the direction of the left. It is an amendment designed to maintain principles in regard to the award of social services which are entirely modern and entirely up to date and which are believed, I might add, by a great many supporters of Labour Parties throughout the world who have been fighting for the right of people to receive social assistance without tests being applied which, in fact, are humiliating to them.

What we have suggested is that, first of all, applicants for home assistance should have the right to privacy of hearing. There need not and should not be publicity unless the person really desires it. There should be privacy in regard to the hearing of the case and in regard to the person who examines the case. That is not a reflection on county councillors. That is not a reflection on the character of county councillors. It is simply making a suggestion for a modern type of administration, whereby a person can apply for assistance and have his case examined privately.

Secondly, as I said before, it is a modern principle, advocated by Labour Parties in various parts of the world, that a person who applies for social assistance should not need to depend for the granting of that home assistance on the person who voted the money. It is an absolutely fundamental democratic principle that the ultimate appeal in regard to whether he should have the money should go to some independent individual. It is a thoroughly good left wing principle. There is nothing conservative about it at all. In other words, the person making the appeal should have the right to a decision independent of political control or political influence.

A great many people here to-night have tried to make the suggestion that when we put down this amendment we were suggesting that county councillors were corrupt. So far as I am concerned, that has no relation to my argument. There is a very great distinction between the idea of corruption and the idea of, shall we say, general exercise of patronage without any evil intent. Does the Minister understand what I mean or am I again to be accused of suggesting that county councillors are corrupt? I have said that in all cases where people who voted the moneys also decide who is to get the money, they cannot help exercising a sort of patronage which is utterly undesirable and which should be eliminated from the modern State, and they exercise it unconsciously, whether they like it or not. They can exercise it entirely without any wish to have any political influence. Does the Minister understand what I mean and does he understand that persons of his own political point of view have worked for 100 years to establish the principle that people have the right to social assistance without there being any danger of that political patronage being exercised? It is not corruption and it is not even an abuse. It is simply something that we all of us know has gone on in democracies from the time the first Parliaments of this world started.

The effort of every decent democracy is to remove into the sphere of administration the granting of sums under the heading of social services. Deputy O'Leary and other Deputies talked about the humane aspect of the matter. We desire home assistance to be administered on a humane basis. We know perfectly well that it is possible to train officers to have a humane attitude and that, all over the world, there are people who have the vocation of knowing to award home assistance and other social benefits humanly and efficiently. There could always be a sufficient hierarchy of officials, in the awarding of social benefits, to ensure that there would be that difference of viewpoint so that one man would have a chance of knowing the grounds upon which another man arrived at a particular decision. We have no objection to councillors checking the administration of home assistance and going over cases so as to prevent abuses.

I hope I have made our attitude clear. We want the people of this country to have a vigorous independence of mind both in local and general elections. We do not want to have even 1 per cent. of the people, if it can possibly be avoided, using the phrase: "So-and-so did something for me" and making that the decisive reason why he should vote for that individual. We do not mind that element entering into it, as it is bound to sometimes, but one of the reasons why social services are awarded by independent officers is to avoid that particular atmosphere in an election. The Minister knows I am saying something that is absolutely true, that it has no connection with corruption, and every decent Labour Party in Western Europe has been trying, however Socialist they were, to keep all these awards of social services on that basis. I am surprised that the Labour Minister in charge of this Bill should wish to remain in the backwater or to get away from these modern principles. I am surprised that Deputy Cowan does so-much to suggest something which is not in the least in accord with modern principles of the award of social services.

I hope I have managed once again to explain our view in regard to this matter, because there is no use in the Minister's implying that we are proposing this amendment because we think that county councils are corrupt. My hope is, if this amendment is lost and the Bill goes through in its present form, that county councils will delegate authority to administer home assistance to the county officer because I believe it will show they have a proper sense of respect for persons who are victims of distress and who apply for home assistance. I hope that, while exercising a general check on administration, they will say that they prefer that they should not be asked to deal with applications from likely beneficiaries of a particular award, that they would prefer that some officers should do that, while they would have the right, if you like, of recommendation and of check. I hope local authorities throughout the State will take that action. I hope that the first step will be to delegate the right to give home assistance to the county officer which, as far as I can make out, they have power to do under the Bill. As everyone knows, that is not the final act. They can always revoke that delegation of power if they wish to do so. I do not think I can say any more than that. I have tried to make these matters clear to the Minister and I hope there will be no further suggestion that we consider that county councils are corrupt when we are merely advocating a modern principle which has been already well established in regard to the award of social services.

Comment on this

If I have misinterpreted any statement from the opposite side, I can only say that I clearly got the impression from the remarks of Deputy Childers, and also of Deputy Allen, that there was a fear amongst Opposition Deputies that the members of county councils would be corrupt, to put the matter plainly, in the administration of home assistance and that they would utilise their power for an illegal purpose to advance their own interests. That was what I gleaned from the remarks of Deputy Allen and Deputy Childers. There was the further point that they wanted the recipients of home assistance to be independent to the extent that they would not have to ask anybody to give them such home assistance. I do not know how that could be achieved because they would have to ask somebody, and you could not reasonably prevent them from approaching councillors if they wished to do so.

So far as the Deputy's suggestion in regard to a Labour Minister getting away from Labour principles is concerned, I make a present of that to the Deputy. I am standing on what I consider a reasonably fair principle. I ask the House to agree to it, and if Deputies are not inclined to do so, they can have it their own way. I am suggesting that the people who are elected by the votes of the people should have the right to dispense home assistance with the help of their officers. I think they are at least worthy of that responsibility, but it is a matter for decision by the House. That is the position. If Deputies do not like that proposal, I shall leave it to a free vote of the House. In that way councillors who constitute a very big part of the membership of this House can say whether my proposal or that of Deputy Childers is the better one.

Comment on this

We have just heard a rather extraordinary pronouncement from the Minister which I do not think should be allowed to pass unnoticed. Here we have one of the major sections in this Bill, a proposal to change radically the present system of administering public assistance, a proposal affecting the disposal of millions of public money, and the Minister calmly announces to the House that he is prepared to run away from the principle which he has embodied in this Bill, that his Government is not prepared to stand by it, and that he is going to leave a major matter of this sort to a free vote of the House. A free vote of the House! Where has the Constitution gone? Where is the doctrine of collective responsibility upon which proper government and proper administration of this country depend? We know that in ordinary matters up to this it has been put into abeyance, but here for the first time, upon a matter of the first public importance, we have a member of the Government getting up and saying that he is not prepared—because that is in fact what it means—to stand by his own proposals, and that the Government is not prepared to stand by them.

Comment on this

This is a Bill, the principle of which the House has accepted.

Comment on this

Is it any wonder that the country is in the state it is to-day? Is it any wonder that the newspapers are full of recurring Government crises? I think that it is certainly time public attention should be directed to it. Do we have any fixed principle in government at this moment? I heard Deputy Cowan talk about democracy. Democracy means, if it means anything, order and control; it means standing on principles.

If a Government meets and solemnly considers proposals for legislation put before it by a Minister, and if that Government comes to an agreement in regard to those proposals: if, in its collective wisdom, it decides that something should be done in the public interest and for the benefit of the community, what justification is there for a Minister coming into this House, simply because he appears to be in a parliamentary difficulty and to avoid the risk that he may have to face the country if he is defeated, and going back upon his colleagues and renouncing a decision which, presumably, the Government have come to in regard to public legislation? Of course, when one is speaking on these matters one is talking in the dark. We must proceed here on these benches on the assumption that things are done now as they were done when we were in office, that is to say that proposals are submitted to this House with the full consent and assent of the Government, and that every Minister coming into this House knows that he carries not merely his own personal responsibility for the legislation which is submitted to it, but the responsibility of every member in that Government, acting collectively as a team, and, therefore, in order that this may be put beyond yea or nay that every Minister who has a proposal to submit to the House submits it first to the Government for their approval.

As I say, that is the conception that we have of the manner in which a Government should be conducted. It is the manner in which we conducted it, and we would like to be able to assume that it is the manner in which it is conducted to-day. But this continuous renouncing of decisions which have been taken ostensibly by the Government, this continuous rejection of responsibility on the part of Ministers, these announcements that, "whatever you do in this House, we will make certain that the Government does not fall," lead us to believe that that is not how the affairs of the country are being conducted now.

I do not think that public confidence or public conduct in relation to big affairs was ever reduced to a lower level than it is to-day, whether it is in relation to a Social Security Bill or in relation to a County Administration Bill, or to the mother and child service programme. Everything is put up for auction in this House, and if the House is not prepared to buy, then the Government will withdraw the proposals and accept the verdict of the House because they are afraid to take the verdict of the country on their proposals.

I am very sorry that the Minister for Local Government, for whom I have some admiration and a great deal of respect, should have committed himself on a major proposal in this Bill to follow the bad example which has been set by some of his colleagues when they have been in a parliamentary difficulty. Either the Minister should stand or fall on this. If he thinks there is any merit in the proposal, and we think there is, then he should say that: "I will accept it and withdraw my own." But this idea of trying to evade responsibility by not making the question a matter of confidence if it goes to a division, is, I think, quite unworthy of the Minister.

Comment on this

Deputy MacEntee has been in the House for the past hour or so. During that time he must have heard Deputy O'Rourke behind him explain to the House that he was in favour of the amendment though he had been against the County Management Bill. It was an unfortunate moment that Deputy MacEntee selected to make the speech which he has just made, having regard to that statement of Deputy O'Rourke's.

Comment on this

Deputy O'Rourke is not a member of the Government.

Comment on this

The difficulty about Deputy MacEntee is that he has not realised that the big stick he used to wield is gone. The situation is quite clear. When the Minister for Local Government introduced this Bill, he made it quite clear on the Second Reading that he was doing so for the purpose of giving back to the local authorities some of the powers which had been taken from them by the County Management Acts of 1940 and 1942. He made it equally clear, on the Second Reading, that, so far as that principle was concerned, he was standing or falling by it, but that so far as the degree to which the powers should or should not be handed back, that was a matter on which he wanted the collective wisdom of this House, and that it was a matter on which he felt we might be able to approach the problem in a non-political spirit. Unfortunately, Deputy MacEntee, in his usual manner, has been unable to respond to that appeal on this particular amendment.

There is one matter that I should like to make clear. I see quite a lot of merit in the last proposal that was made by Deputy Childers. I do not like Deputy Childers' amendment, as such, because it would not give the power of review to the councils concerned. Deputy Childers made the suggestion, however, that he hoped that if the amendment was passed the councils would delegate the function to the county officer and that they could take it back again if it was not operated properly. In spite of the fact that Deputy MacEntee is not anxious to approach this in a non-political spirit, I still believe there should be a halfway house between the Minister and Deputy Childers on this amendment. I believe that you want, in regard to home assistance— in the general cases—to have the executive Act operated by the executive officer. But I want more than a check by the local councils. I want the local councils, effectively, to be able to get in, override and correct the mistakes that are made when mistakes are made by the county officer. I want that to be done—and I want to be quite clear on this—as Deputy Harris has stated by the council as a whole, and not by individual members of the council. I cannot see any way of getting that done except by vesting the powers in the local authorities.

The local authorities, in the ordinary case, can delegate the power to their county officer, knowing that they can retract it again. There is not any other method of doing it. I make a present of this to Deputy Childers if he can find me the halfway house between the two things: if he can find me a method by which the executive officer will carry out the job in the ordinary way, while at the same time the local council will have not merely a check but what I might perhaps describe as the harrying power which Deputy Childers himself mentioned— an actual firm corrective so that it can intervene in specific cases. If that could be done, then I think it would be much better. The only method, on the basis which Deputy Childers has suggested in his amendment, would be to leave the power with the county officer, and then to get the information. That is not adequate. You can get all the information required. You can provide in this Bill that all the information possible can be obtained, but there is only one way in which you can get the corrective, so far as I can see. I am open to conviction on the matter: we on this side of the House are open to conviction—which is different from Deputy MacEntee's view. There is only one way in which I can see that you can get that power of corrective, namely, to put the power in the hands of the local authorities and trust them to do their job.

I want to be quite clear that I am not utilising the word "corruption" in any unpleasant sense—I think Deputy Childers made that quite clear in his last speech—but even if the power were going to be utilised in a way that was undesirable it might in the long run be the best thing because it would rouse local people to ensure that that type of councillor would not again be returned. In the long run, it would be the best thing. I think that to take the other view is to accept defeat and to accept the view in defeat that we are not going to get the right type of person on our local authorities. Of course, I accept the view put forward by Deputy O'Rourke that a matter of time may be involved. That is why I want the provision that while the responsibility is that of the local councils that the corrective power is that of the local authorities. They will have power to delegate that to the county officer. There is no way at all in which that situation can be arrived at except by the position in this Bill. While I want the general principle on which the Second Reading of this Bill is based, that more power be given back to the local authorities, I am quite prepared to listen if any method should be evolved by virtue of which the time taken by details in the work of local authorities can be avoided.

Comment on this

Deputy Sweetman seems to want the best of both worlds all the time. He wants the power in the hands of the local authority and he wants the local authority to delegate it to the county officer. Deputy Sweetman must remember that when the council delegate their power to the local officer it is then in the hands of the local officer.

Comment on this

They can take it back.

Comment on this

In respect of specific cases, I take it, or the whole powers. Deputy Sweetman knows quite well that that kind of machine could never function. Either you give it to the county officer or you keep it yourself. At what stage do you take it back from him? Do you take it back from him if you find him abusing it or because he is too parsimonious or too liberal, or what? Either you operate the power and keep it in your hands or you delegate it to the county officer and trust him to use the power on behalf of the council as he should use it.

Comment on this

The Deputy is slightly embarrassed because of his earlier interruptions to-day. If the Deputy wants an answer I will give it to him.

Comment on this

Can Deputy Sweetman give us a formula whereby the council would hold the power and at the same time the county officer will operate it? You must have it either one way or the other. Deputy Sweetman knows quite well that without this Bill at all, under the Management Act, at the moment any member of a county council can have a discussion, in public session or otherwise, if there is any abuse in any single respect of the administration of home assistance—and that the manager cannot prevent him from doing so. They can pass resolutions recommending that the county officer should take lines other than those which he has been taking in the matter of the administration of home assistance. Is that not so? It can be put on the agenda for any meeting of the council. A special meeting of the council can be called if a number of members sign a requisition. The manner in which the county officer is administrating home assistance can come up as an ordinary item on the agenda at every council meeting. I have yet to hear of a single case of abuse under the Management Act in the administrative areas with which I am acquainted. To put the power of administering home assistance in the hands of a local authority might result in an abuse. It is well known that in the past the home assistance fund was used for political or patronage purposes. There is a strong and shrewd suspicion abroad that certain groups are interested in getting that power of administration back into the hands of the council for that purpose in the future. I know of things that have happened in the past in the matter of using the home assistance fund for patronage purposes. It can be used in that direction in the future. The Minister talks about giving back democratic powers to the local authorities. Home assistance is only a very small proportion of the funds raised in rates by the local authority in any county. Earlier to-day, Sections 24 and 25 were passed by this House. Many functions and powers under these sections were left in the hands of the future county officer—functions and powers that councils would be very interested in. Take, for instance, the matter of tenancy—the determining of the tenants of the hundreds of thousands of houses that have been and are being built by the local authorities. Many councillors might be interested in the future tenancies and might like to have these powers. I believe that the power should be in the hands of the manager and not of the council.

Between 80 and 90 per cent. of the total revenue of any council is spent on salaries, wages, allowances, pensions and so forth. In other words, between 80 and 90 per cent. of the total funds of a council is spent in paying the remuneration of the officers of that council. It might be considered very democratic to give back to the elected representatives the right to determine the salaries, wages and allowances, conditions of employment, etc., of all the officers in their employ, but in this Bill as in the Management Act it is deliberately being retained in the hands of the county manager. Ninety per cent. of the expenditure of the councils will be swept away out of the hands of the elected representatives in this Bill. If a Parliament or a local council have not full control over all the finances they have no power. I am not seeking that they should have control over the remuneration of the officers of the council, tenancy functions, the making of lettings, the making of advances or the fixing, revision and recovery of rent, and all these matters affect the finances of the council, but we are asking that in addition to those very far-reaching functions which are being given to the county officer he should also have the function of determining in respect of the very poor section of the community who seek home assistance what each applicant is entitled to. It is degrading that in order to get assistance a poor person should use political influence. That is humiliating and something this House should not countenance.

I would ask the Minister to accept Deputy Childers's amendment in good faith. It is the result of our experience and we are concerned with nothing but getting a good machine that will give good service to the people and under which the least possible number of abuses can take place. That is all we on this side of the House are concerned with, that and nothing else.

Imagine a council of 27 people—we have up to 45 on some councils—sitting down to administer home assistance and to determine in 200 or 300 cases each month whether they should give 2/-, 5/- or 10/- a week. Imagine the most intimate and personal matters affecting the lives of those poor people being trotted out at public sessions of the county council. The Minister was a member of a local authority for many years and he knows what that means. The applicants for home assistance are amongst the poorest sections in the community, and the home assistance officer will have a full detailed report of all matters affecting their lives. I think it would be unfair and unreasonable that that report should be investigated at a public session of the council. I hope that the Minister will see reason in this matter and agree with the Dáil and with those who believe that he is doing a wrong and an injustice to the machine he is seeking to create by insisting that the administration of home assistance be given back to the local representatives.

Comment on this

I suppose we should be thankful to Deputy MacEntee for his dissertation on political practice and thought. I refuse to get as excited as Deputy MacEntee, however, about this patter. This Bill was introduced and got its Second Reading without a division. The principles of the Bill have been accepted and have become the property of the House. I asked for and got the co-operation of both sides of the House in making this as effective an instrument as possible. Deputy MacEntee easily becomes excited when he wants to talk of disposing of £1,000,000. We are dealing simply with Deputy Childers' amendment, which seeks to delete certain words from sub-section (1) (a) of Section 26. We are deciding whether the administration of medical assistance should be left to the county officer or to the elected representatives. Sub-section (1) (b) indicates that the county officer's funtions shall be:—

"with respect to decisions as to the extent to which and the manner in which a person shall receive treatment under or otherwise avail of a health service (including the service provided under the Public Assistance Act, 1939, in relation to medical assistance)."

That is the present function of the county manager. All this storm is about the question of whether a local authority is entitled to say who is to get medical assistance; the extent is left to the county officer. Yet Deputy MacEntee seized the opportunity of suggesting that this Minister followed the bad headline of other Ministers in side-tracking all our magnificent principles. It seems that it is foreign to Deputy MacEntee to accept the decision of the House as to what would be a useful instrument for administration in the country.

No big stick tactics have been used by me since this Bill was brought in, and I succeeded in getting the decision of the House for its principle. Deputy MacEntee said that I was afraid, but I have left questions to free votes, I have accepted amendments and I have compromised with everybody on all sides of the House in order to make this a reasonably good instrument. Deputy MacEntee uses very extravagant language and refers to vital principles and the spending of £1,000,000. Amendment No. 70 is not before us, and even if its principle were accepted, we could not incorporate it in the Bill, so therefore we are dealing simply with amendment No. 69, the question of whether X will get medical assistance or not, the amount, method and extent to be decided by the county officer. I am not adamant now and was not adamant at the start, but I think that mine is the better proposal. The opposite view to mine is held on this side of the House as well as on the other side, and I am prepared to leave it to the wisdom of the House which is largely composed of members of county councils. If that is a departure from high-falutin Government policy according to Deputy MacEntee's lore, I am prepared to accept that rebuke. I am pursuing my own line on the Bill with the knowledge I have of public life in order to make a useful instrument of local government, and I will accept the decision of the House on this matter as I have done on other parts of the Bill up to now.

There are people who oppose my view on this side of the House but I would be slow to believe that everyone on the other side of the House would pass the vote of censure expressed by Deputy Allen. He did not pull his punches just now, but said that the funds of county councils had been used for political purposes, and would be used for political purposes again. That is a strange thing for a chairman of a county council to say. Speaking with knowledge, I am perfectly certain that that view is not shared on the Fianna Fáil benches any more than it is on these benches. That was a shocking reflection for Deputy Allen to make on the elected representatives of the country, and I am surprised that he should have done so. He can only assume that something will happen.

Comment on this

I was making it from knowledge.

Comment on this

It is a long time since they had the chance to do so. He is assuming that if they are given the power they will use this power for political purposes. I repeat that they would be very bad politicians if they could not do better than that. I believe that the amount of political influence of the poor destitute dependent people who have to look for public assistance would be negligible. Even if they were mean enough to stoop to that, it would be ill-spent time.

I am again asking Deputy Childers to accept the provision I am putting in, as I believe it is better than his, and if he cannot accept it I repeat that I am prepared to let the House decide it.

Comment on this
Division

Question put: "That the words proposed to be deleted stand."

Tá 63
·
Níl 55
Result Carried The question put was agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?

Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Amendment No. 70 is consequential and has been discussed.

Comment on this

I do not think it can be described as consequential.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

It is a cognate amendment.

Comment on this

I think we should have a separate division.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

If the Deputy wants a separate division, he can have it.

Comment on this

I think we would be entitled to ask for a separate division because it is quite a different principle.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

I take it that Deputy Childers is moving the amendment?

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 70:—

In subsection (1) to add a new paragraph as follows:—

(f) the granting or withholding of public assistance.

Comment on this
Captain Cown

I move amendment No. 71:—

To delete sub-section (1), lines 1 to 3, and substitute the following:—

(1) The employment function of the council of a county or elective body shall, if the council of the county or the elective body so decide, be performed by the council of the county or by the elective body, but until and unless so decided by the council of the county or the elective body the employment functions of the council or of the elective body shall, subject to the provisions of this Act, be performed by the county officer.

I think this amendment is quite clear and precise. It is in accordance with the principle that I mentioned earlier in the debate this evening. I am anxious that as much power as possible should be vested in the local authority and if the local authority wants to exercise the employment functions of the council or the elected body they may do so by resolution; but if they do not wish so to decide, then the employment functions as set out in the Bill, subject to the provisions of the Act, shall be performed by the county officer.

Comment on this