We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Social Welfare (Insurance) (No. 2) Bill, 1950—Second Stage (Resumed).

Contributions 148–326 of 326. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Social Welfare (Insurance)(No. 2) Bill 1950
Lapsed

No. 39 of 1950 ›

A Minister's pension, £10 per week and no means test.

Comment on this

For 29 years, I have been in public life in this country. I earned every penny of it——

Comment on this

You have done well out of it.

Comment on this

——and earned it hard and honestly. I have not been a shyster lawyer at any stage of my career.

Comment on this

That is typical of the Deputy's sense of responsibility after all these years of service.

Comment on this
Acting-Chairman

Order!

Comment on this

I have finished with pensions and Deputy Cowan. I was saying that the position of the working farmer and self-employed persons now is that, if they live long enough, they will get a pension, provided they are poor enough, and poor enough they will be if this Government continues in existence, for, whatever else this Bill will do, it will not make conditions easier for those who are not included in its scope and certainly will not make conditions easier for the farmer. It will, in fact, make conditions more difficult for them.

As Deputy Allen said and as we all know, there is no such thing as an employer's contribution in this Bill. There is a consumer's contribution and the employer is the means by which the contribution is collected from the consumer. I doubt whether, in the majority of cases, there is any such thing as a worker's contribution, because ultimately the worker will naturally seek to compensate himself in increased wages for the contribution he pays. The employer is entitled, in ordinary practice, to compensate himself for what is known as the employer's contribution and these two things are going to be reflected in increased costs, in an increased cost of every article manufactured in this country and every article that passes over the shopkeeper's counter. But the farmer who has to depend on an export market for his product, the farmer who has to sell in that one market in competition with everything that comes from other parts of the globe, cannot compensate himself in the same way. There is no person to whom he can pass on the burden which this Bill will impose upon the community.

As I have shown, the shopkeeper can do it, the manufacturer can do it, the shop assistant can do it and the worker in industrial employment can do it. The only man who cannot do it is the man engaged in our primary industry, the man who is a primary producer, the man whose efforts ultimately support us all. He is the one man who will be left to bear the whole cost of this Bill ultimately.

I know that many members of the Labour Party seem to regard the farmers as the enemies of the Irish people. We have had some expressions here to-day from members of the Labour Party which certainly were not complimentary to the farmers. We heard Deputy Dunne attack the farmers and his chairman, Mr. George Pollock, who had the honour of being the first Irish delegate to the Comintern, with Deputy Connolly, in the year 1922——

Comment on this

Was that the year Deputy Boland went over?

Comment on this

We read in the newspapers the speeches these two gentlemen made attacking the farmers of Ireland, as employers, as farmers and as producers, and we had their speeches broadcast at length over Radio Éireann, so that apparently neither members of the Labour Party nor members of the Government are very friendly towards the farmers, even through there are a substantial number of farmers in Fine Gael and the other Parties who are supporting them in relation to this measure. We have the Tánaiste attacking the industrialists, the men who are engaged in manufacturing industry, and we have Deputy Dunne and others attacking those who are engaged in the agricultural industry. It is very strange but it is precisely these tactics which have been engaged in elsewhere, where attempts have been made to undermine the very conception of individual effort and private enterprise, which have resulted in the condition of affairs which prevails in Czechoslovakia to-day. However, that is perhaps a little by the way.

It is not merely on the ground of the inequity and injustice with which almost half of our people will be treated under the Bill, though that is a consideration of the first importance, that we are opposed to this Bill. I at least am opposed to it on the ground that it has been presented dishonestly to the House. The true cost of this scheme has been concealed, and deliberately concealed, from the Dáil and from the public. The true cost of this scheme, over and above the cost which is represented by the burden of the contributions, will in a very few years be very much more than the £4,750,000 which the White Paper suggests will be borne by the Government. In a few years, the Government contribution to this scheme will be in the neighbourhood of £11,000,000 to £12,000,000. The Tánaiste knows that —he has the figures.

Comment on this

That is a complete fabrication, well worthy of the Deputy.

Comment on this

The Tánaiste has these figures, but nothing could extract these figures from him. Deputy Derrig put down a number of questions directed towards getting the Tánaiste to disclose to the House what the true cost of the scheme would be. He knows as well as I how much it is, but he would not answer. He would not tell us, any more than he would answer the questions which were put to him in regard to what he described as Social Welfare Bill No. 1. That was the Social Welfare Bill by which the insurance contributions under the widow's and orphan's pensions scheme were increased considerably whereas the benefits which the workers were to receive were increased only very slightly over and above what they had been drawing under the Fianna Fáil Government.

Reference has been made in the House, and by Deputy Maguire, to the speech which Deputy Lemass made on this Bill. I have referred to the rather significant fact that this Bill has been criticised and condemned by persons who do not normally interfere in ordinary political matters. I think that the significance of that fact should be pondered on deeply by all of us. These criticisms indicate that we may be at a crossroads in our social development. Up to this, when we have been dealing with social service schemes we have been content to take the machinery and organisation as we found it. That machinery and organisation for particular purposes derived from those which were introduced in Prussia, I think, about 80 years ago when Bismarck wished to kill the spirit of individual independence in that State. Simultaneously, one may say that he introduced conscription as a part of his policy to regiment the people.

Bismarckism, as we know, ended in Hitlerism. I do not want Nortonism to end in Leninism—but that ambition might not be shared by some of Deputy Norton's more intimate colleagues. However, the proposals were originally designed not so much to make easier and happier the lot of the people but to build up the military might of Prussia and to develop her manufacturing industry to that end. In 1911 a British Prime Minister took the schemes which the Prussians had developed and applied them to industrial Britain. They were applied to Ireland merely through the accident that the Act of Union was still in force. They would never, I believe, have been applied to this country in the form in which they have developed. They would never have been devised in their present form, I think, by any native Irish Government. Undoubtedly, we would have had social services which, I am sure, would be adequate to all and just to all. They would be just to all not only in the benefits which they would confer, but they would be just to all in the burdens which they would impose. Those social services of Irish origin, Irish conception and Irish creation would have been different from the benefits given and the burdens proposed by this Bill.

Has the time not come, as Deputy Lemass suggested, to review the whole problem anew? The protests and criticisms which this Bill have evoked are, I think, a manifestation of the public feeling that in this matter we are on the wrong lines. The fact that by developing on these lines we are victimising our farmers, as we are in this Bill, and that we are similarly victimising self-employed persons, is taken outside as a proof that we are developing on the wrong lines. It was not, perhaps, so serious when we were dealing only with National Health Insurance and the widows' and orphans' pensions, and when the contributions were comparatively modest. But the contributions are now becoming very significant. The contribution in respect of each person employed in industry, when this Bill goes through, will be of the order of £18 4s. 0d. a year. That is a very substantial sum. It represents a very substantial burden upon, let me point out again, the narrow section of the community who cannot pass their burdens on to anybody else. In view of this, it has become a very serious problem.

I think most of us are beginning to feel that these schemes, as originally devised, cannot be applied with equal justice or even with approximate justice to all the people entitled to benefit from them in this country and that, therefore, we are ill-advised to proceed on the lines that we have been thinking on—I as much as anybody else— up to the present, and that the time has come when we should really see if we cannot bring in a measure more closely in accord with the teachings of our moralists than this scheme appears to be. I know that everybody is anxious that want should not go unrelieved. I know that everybody is anxious that the problem of unemployment should be dealt with fairly and reasonably. But we are not dealing with the problem of unemployment or want or sickness fairly and reasonably in this Bill. We are perhaps dealing fairly with one section of the population but we are doing that entirely at the expense of the other section of the population—and that other section is not the capitalist, the employer, but the self-employed person and the farmers in the country. We are now brought face to face with this problem on a scale which perhaps we never contemplated. Surely the time has come to put our thinking caps on and see whether we cannot conceive another scheme which will not merely do justice to all but—something which is of great importance, that is, if we can do it—which will encourage voluntary adherence to a scheme of this sort and, if we can, enable us to relinquish altogether the use of compulsion as a weapon to ensure that people will provide this State, through what are, in fact, poll taxes, with the funds to ensure that they will not die of starvation or that they will be able to look after themselves when they are ill. Primarily, it is not a Christian conception that it is the duty of the State to do this. The primary responsibility rests upon the individual to look after himself in these matters. The State should come in only when conditions have made it quite impossible for the individual to do that.

In life as we know it to-day, it may not be possible for every individual to do that. It may not be possible for every thrifty individual or every industrious individual to do that. Certainly it is impossible for a great many thrifty and industrious individual to do it. If we could devise a scheme that will be so attractive that it will induce people to join it of their own free will, it would be very much better that we should proceed on those lines, from the point of view of our national character and of the self-reliance and the self-respect of our people, than that we should continue to do it in the way first devised by Bismarck in order that he might regiment and better organise the Prussian people as a military race.

Comment on this

Nobody can say that this Bill has not been thoroughly analysed, and indeed nobody who adverts in any way to the truth will attempt to deny that it has had a fair amount of misrepresentation as well. We can afford at all events to review the contributions to the Bill, to analyse the criticisms which have been offered, and to see how far those criticisms represent any real contribution to the solution of the problem with which this Bill deals.

To me the most remarkable aspect of the discussion was the completely different approaches to the Bill by sections of the Opposition. Deputies Ryan and Lemass clearly had nothing whatever in common with Deputy Derrig, and neither Deputy Derrig nor Deputies Ryan and Lemass had anything in common with the contribution which has just been made by Deputy MacEntee. Deputies Ryan and Lemass said that they accepted the bulk of the Bill, that they agreed with the principles enshrined in substantial sections of it; their only concern was that the Bill should be extended, and they wanted it extended in a certain direction. The decision to seek its extension in certain directions was of course obviously a belated one, because anyone listening to Deputy Dr. Ryan speaking on the Second Stage could see quite clearly that he was sorely confounded and dumb-founded when he realised that the Bill contained a provision to increase old age pensions to the all-time record of £1 per week, to modify further the means test and to exclude from the calculation of means a substantial portion of income derived from disability pensions enjoyed by members of the Defence Forces and from the special allowances paid under the Military Service Pensions Acts.

The fact that this Government is doing all these things after the substantial instalment of social justice which was made available at the cost of £2,500,000 per annum in 1948 was something which stunned Deputy Dr. Ryan, and in an effort to show that Fianna Fáil was desirous of doing something more he then proceeded to bid for electoral support by saying that Fianna Fáil wanted the Bill to go further and further. I will say for the Deputy that he said that with imperturbable courage. He suffered in no sense from introspection or from any feeling of shame that in this House in 1947 he had trooped into the division lobby with the Deputies opposite against a modification of the means test for old age pension purposes which would cost, he said, only £500,000 per year. Since he did that we have given an additional £2,500,000 a year for old age pensions and there is another £1,250,000 in this Bill. Of course, the fact that this Government gives two substantial instalments to the relief of the plight of old age pensioners and blind pensioners in so short a period obviously causes political discomfiture to Deputy Ryan and everyone else opposite. Consequently they proceed to bid for electoral support by saying: " If we only had the chance we would do something bigger and something better."

Let us come to the something bigger and something better that the brethren would have done in the light of the speeches made by Deputy Ryan in 1947. I must put these speeches on record again if only for the purpose of exposing the hypocrisy with which this debate has been well-seasoned. Deputies Ryan and Lemass, both to a lesser extent than subsequent speakers, wanted this Bill extended so as to cover everybody. Some said that the Bill was bad but they wanted even the badness spread over everybody. Let us hear Deputy Ryan talking in 1947, at the end of 15 years of Fianna Fáil administration and see what he was going to do to include everybody in this all-over all-embracing scheme which has been talked about in such glowing terms on the benches opposite. On March 28th, 1947 (column 554), Deputy Dr. Ryan said:—

"Deputy Murphy says he thinks we could bring 90 per cent. of the people into a contributory scheme. I do not think so. At least, I do not think it is easy to bring people into a contributory scheme unless they are wage-earners... But, to return to the point, it is not easy to collect contributions unless from wage-earners. I say that as a fact and if Deputy Murphy or anybody else can show me I am wrong, I will be delighted because I should like to see the small farmers and small shopkeepers— between them a very big class—included. It is calculated that there must be nearly 250,000 between these two classes—250,000 people who need provisions for their old age. It is a pity we cannot have a comprehensive scheme for them, and if Deputy Murphy or anybody else can show me how it can be done, I will be very delighted to have it considered for this contributory scheme. If we cannot include them in a contributory scheme, we will have to consider what can be done otherwise. That is all."

Comment on this
Mr. de Valera

Hear, hear!

Comment on this

Deputy de Valera says: "Hear, hear!" I could say "Hear hear!" to that too.

Comment on this
Mr. de Valera

To the last portion of it, which is the whole point.

Comment on this

I will come later to the plan the Deputy had in 1947 and if anybody can explain that plan to me I will add another prize to the one which Deputy Dr. Ryan was willing to give Deputy Murphy if he could show how these people could be brought into a contributory scheme.

Comment on this
Mr. de Valera

It was not contributory.

Comment on this

Let me go back. Deputy Ryan said:—

"It is a pity that we cannot have a comprehensive scheme for them."

Deputy Ryan admitted then that he could not have a comprehensive——

Comment on this
Mr. de Valera

Contributory scheme.

Comment on this

He was talking about a contributory scheme. He said that he could not have that for these people and that it was a pity that they could not be brought in. He recognised that in March, 1947. I will say definitely and deliberately—I will produce documentary proof later—that he never intended to bring farmers, shopkeepers and self-employed persons into a contributory scheme of the kind before the House, the very same kind of scheme which he intended to produce. I will produce documentary evidence in a minute.

On the 22nd October, 1947 (column 824), Deputy Dr. Ryan said:—

"Certain people will be left who will have to get non-contributory pensions—old age pensions, widows' pensions and non-contributory unemployment benefit in the way of unemployment assistance, or whatever it may be. I do not know at what level the pensions for non-contributory persons may be. It may be difficult to make them any better than they are at the moment, but it should be quite possible to give much better pensions to the contributory group when the scheme comes into operation."

That, again, is a recognition that the farmers, shopkeepers and self-employed persons could not be brought into a scheme and that he did not intend to bring them into a scheme.

Comment on this
Mr. de Valera

Into a contributory scheme.

Comment on this

I know the Deputy's disputative qualities. The Deputy would throw a somersault on the edge of a razor and, if you complained to him that you could not do the same, he would say: "There is heaps of room here for you." Again, on March 12th, 1947, Deputy Dr. Ryan said, at column 2,004:—

"Deputies will have to keep in mind, of course, that to give a very much better old age pension and to give it at a lower age, say 65, and also to improve these other schemes like national health and unemployment assistance will mean a very big contribution whenever the schemes come along. It will not be a one-sided matter. The contribution will have to be increased considerably."

Deputy Dr. Ryan made that statement in 1947. Now, Deputy Little says: "No, the contribution should not be increased", and even Deputy Dr. Ryan, free from the responsibility of office, says the contributions should not be increased now. He recognised when he was the Minister that they should be increased. Bidding for votes now, he thinks it is not necessary to do that. Deputy Little chirrups that he also would not like to have them increased. In column, 554 of the 28th March, 1947, Deputy Dr. Ryan said:—

"Deputy Murphy said that we need more courageous proposals. I quite agree with him on that and I am afraid that when this comprehensive scheme comes along, some Deputies may lose their courage, because there is no doubt that if we provided even for the aged, as Deputies would like to see them provided for, on a contributory basis, it is going to mean a very big contribution from the worker and, as I say, the courage that will be necessary to face that issue when the time arrives will be fairly substantial."

There was a realistic approach to the problem. A fairly substantial increase in contributions would be necessary and a substantial measure of courage would be necessary to face up to the problem. When he is asked to face it, Deputy Dr. Ryan now turns and runs because he will not face up to the very problem which he raised himself in the debate in the Dáil in March, 1948.

Is it not quite obvious why Deputy Dr. Ryan has changed his mind? The simple reason is that he has changed his seat in this House. If Deputy Dr. Ryan were sitting here his views would be the same, but now, sitting over there and feeling he is fated to sit there for many years, he has changed his mind and he now wants to give something to everybody for nothing. He does not even know the cost of some of the proposals which he suggested the last day. But I will come back to that.

Not even Deputy de Valera's passion for accuracy will save Deputy Dr. Ryan from the humiliation which ought to follow the disclosure of his attempts at costing his own scheme. We had another statement from Deputy Dr. Ryan on 28th March, 1947:—

"We are working towards what has been referred to by every speaker —a comprehensive scheme—but it will be, I am afraid, 12 months or so before it can be presented. I am also very glad, too, to see that every speaker appears to be in favour of a contributory scheme of insurance by which, so far as we can arrange it, people will build up their own insurance funds and insure themselves against sickness, unemployment and so on."

There was Deputy Dr. Ryan cheering for the idea that the people had so inculcated within them the spirit of contributing for insurance against those risks, that they would build up their insurance fund against the risks of sickness, unemployment and so on, clearly showing while he was sitting on the Government benches he believed in that approach, because it is the only sane and legitimate approach to the problem. In the meantime, the political faith of the Party opposite had altered. Deputy Ryan now sits in Opposition, hoping that by bidding for votes he can get back here. He now proceeds to abandon all the things he said then. I put this to Deputy de Valera: Was Deputy Dr. Ryan right when he was here, and is he right when he is there, talking in opposite terms? Is it not clear he cannot be right on both sides?

Comment on this
Mr. de Valera

May I answer?

Comment on this

Certainly, I would be delighted.

Comment on this
Mr. de Valera

It is quite clear Deputy Dr. Ryan was put there to investigate these things. He went along certain lines and examined them so far as he could and he came to certain tentative conclusions. Surely, if a person has time to reconsider these things he can change his mind about them?

Comment on this

Sixteen years!

Comment on this

I think it was Emerson who said that consistency is the hobgoblin of little minds. Deputy Dr. Ryan studied Emerson without doubt, because he was not to be anchored to any consistency once he changed his position over there. Let me say this now, and I do not think there is anything wrong in telling the Party opposite the cold and cruel truth of the position. They apparently do not know anything as to how far their own plans for social security got. In November, 1947, and that was not far away from the change of Government, Deputy Dr. Ryan authorised the then Secretary of the Department to tell British officials who were visiting Dublin at the time, discussing reciprocity matters, that he intended only to deal with the employed classes, who number 665,000; that he could not say then that he would be able exactly to deal with them, and that the other classes would have to wait until later on. They would have to wait until the sweet by and by and at the moment he was dealing only with the wage-earning classes. That is the corroborated statement made by the late Secretary of the Department on the instruction of the Minister, to the British officials.

Comment on this
Mr. de Valera

What about it?

Comment on this

The point I am making is that Deputy de Valera must have heard Deputies on his own benches for the last three days during which this Bill was discussed bleating for a scheme under which everybody was going to be covered.

Comment on this
Mr. de Valera

Hear, hear!

Comment on this

Is it not clear now, if anybody wants to be convinced, that even when in power the Fianna Fáil Party never intended to cover anybody except those employed under a contract for wages or salaries?

Comment on this
Mr. de Valera

That is a completely wrong inference. The point was that Deputy Dr. Ryan had been examining this, and this was the result of his preliminary investigations. He did not have an opportunity of completing his investigations and bringing them before his colleagues. There is a big difference between that stage and when a Bill finally comes to be passed in the House.

Comment on this

That is an interesting admission. I remember Deputy Lemass sitting over there shortly after the change of Government in 1948-and the records can be searched for the reference in which he said that Fianna Fáil, going out of office, had left a social security plan ready, pigeonholed. "Take it out and work it," he said. That was Deputy Lemass. Now his leader says that Deputy Dr. Ryan was only thinking, forming his ideas, and he had come to no conclusion.

Comment on this
Mr. de Valera

The point is that if Deputy Dr. Ryan had a scheme completed in the form in which it could be brought in as a Bill, it would be available.

Comment on this

Is it not perfectly clear that Deputy Dr. Ryan in fact had merely views about this matter in 1948, that these were his recorded views, that he told the British: "I will only cover the wage and salary-earning classes"? That is what he intended to do and, if you accept that, then you must accept that Fianna Fáil never intended to do anything else. If you say he had no views, that these were only tentative views, then Deputy Lemass did not speak truthfully when he said, in 1948, that a perfect plan had been left behind.

Comment on this
Mr. de Valera

It would be very interesting to get the changes of view; or possible changes of view, in detail, of the Tánaiste and members of the Government in regard to this.

Comment on this

If you get it, it is the most monumental record of consistency you have ever read.

Comment on this

Modesty again.

Comment on this

In any case, the mere point I want to establish is that when Fianna Fáil had power to bring in a variety of classes, which they now dishonestly pretend that they want to bring in, they did not bring them in and declared in this House and to the British representatives visiting Dublin for discussions that they did not intend to bring them in.

Comment on this
Mr. de Valera

The Fianna Fáil Government had not an opportunity of dealing with it.

Comment on this

I want to put it on record, even if it annoys Deputy de Valera.

Comment on this
Mr. de Valera

It is only the truth I want and the proper conclusions.

Comment on this

The trouble is that the Deputy wants his own variety of truth.

Comment on this
Mr. de Valera

As far as truth is concerned, I can stand up against the Tánaiste.

Comment on this

There is nobody questioning the Deputy's adherence to truth, but he must not, by inference, imply that other people are not telling the truth merely because they say things which displease the Deputy.

Comment on this
Mr. de Valera

No, but because there are certain inferences being drawn.

Comment on this

The trouble is that the Deputy wants to decide who is right and who is wrong.

Comment on this
Mr. de Valera

No, I do not.

Comment on this

Quite clearly, you cannot do that with other people's speeches.

Comment on this
Mr. de Valera

I want to show that there is another side to it.

Comment on this

We understand where we are. We can pass on. Deputy Derrig appeared in rather strange colours in the course of this debate. Deputy Dr. Ryan accepted the bulk of the scheme. Deputy Lemass said the same and that social security should not be a matter for political controversy and that we should try to put it over and above the heat of political agitation and political discussion. Deputy Derrig burnt himself into a white heat of indignation, expressing a fear as to what the cost of this scheme would be. He thought the red flag of ruin was up and that in no time we would be all launched into a crucible of bankruptcy if a scheme of this kind were put into operation. Nothwithstanding the fact that these were Deputy Derrig's fears, his two colleagues, Deputy Dr. Ryan and Deputy Lemass, wanted us to go on and impose more and more taxation. It never occurred to Deputy Derrig while he was speaking that his own colleagues had decided to advocate the expenditure of more money, the levying of more taxation, which Deputy Derrig himself feared would be the end of all things in Ireland.

Comment on this

Not more taxation ultimately than the taxation in your scheme. Explain the retirement pensions.

Comment on this

We will come to all that in a second. Deputy Dr. Ryan did not display any great acumen when dealing with figures and costs. If one looks up his Second Reading speech, at columns 1119 and 1120, it will be seen there that the Deputy first said that the additional schemes which he suggested would cost £1.5 million—that was in one column—and when he moved over to the next column he said they would cost £2,000,000. They went up by £500,000 while the Deputy moved from column 1119 to column 1120.

Comment on this

We will see by how much your estimates will go up.

Comment on this

If you follow my estimates you can have complete faith in them and you can be certain that you will not go far astray. Deputy Dr. Ryan said that, in his view, the additional taxation necessitated by his scheme would be £2,000,000 a year. That was the highest he put it at, and then the additional £1,250,000 which I was proposing to raise for the purpose of the additional old age and blind pensions. Deputy Dr. Ryan might as well have gone to a telephone directory for figures as to quote the figures which he quoted there because they are as far from reality as the Poles are apart. What are the facts? A calculation by people professionally qualified to calculate, with a reputation which extends beyond this country, shows that in one case where Deputy Dr. Ryan thought it would cost £1,500,000, in fact the cost would be £4,250,000.

Comment on this
Mr. de Valera

What is that for?

Comment on this

Widows' and orphans' pensions.

Comment on this

A few millions would not matter.

Comment on this

Deputy Dr. Ryan left out the cost of schemes such as maternity benefits, death grants, treatment benefits and increased administrative costs and made miscalculations in respect of other services as well, and the net position was that what Deputy Dr. Ryan said would cost £2,000,000—and I give him the other £1,250,000, which makes it £3,250,000-would cost an additional £10,000,000, and what the Party opposite have now advocated on this Bill is that we should raise in taxation another £10,000,000. Will Deputy de Valera square that with his Cavan speech? will Deputy de Valera say that there is in that suggestion the prudence which he advocated at Cavan? Will Deputy Derrig now tell us whether he is satisfied that his colleagues represented him when they asked that another £12,000,000 in taxation should be raised just to make this scheme something better by the Fianna Fáil suggestions? Can I now have it from Deputy de Valera that the Fianna Fáil Party stands for raising another £10,000,000 in taxation in respect of this Bill?

Comment on this
Mr. de Valera

I do not know the figures.

Comment on this

O.K. I might even give the Deputy the document. I want to know too are Deputy Cogan, Deputy Lehane and Deputy O'Reilly going into the Division Lobby with our friends opposite to vote for another scheme which will impose an additional £10,000,000 taxation, in the present circumstances of this country?

Comment on this

We will vote against this, anyhow.

Comment on this

The poor man's friend.

Comment on this

That is what the Fianna Fáil Party have gone on record as saying in respect of the proposals made by Deputy Dr. Ryan. It could not be otherwise, in any case. The Deputy was obviously bewildered when he was talking. That evening there was a kind of stop press issue of the newspapers prepared, into which was inserted the hurriedly prepared Fianna Fáil proposals, so hurriedly prepared that some of the proposals in the Bill with which, I take it, Fianna Fáil do not disagree, were excluded from the scheme they sent to the paper. Young and inexperienced men, in a hurry, made hurried calculations. Deputy Dr. Ryan, the financial wizard, says £2,000,000 or £3,250,000. The people qualified to judge say it will cost £10,000,000.

Comment on this

Who are the people qualified? Will the Tánaiste tell us from whom he is quoting and will he quote the whole document, not extracts?

Comment on this

A professional actuary.

Comment on this

Who is the professional actuary?

Comment on this

A civil servant employed in my Department, with plenty of skill and brains in that respect.

Comment on this

Publish the whole of his report then.

Comment on this

It is quite clear now in any case that, so far as Deputy Derrig's worries are concerned, Deputy Dr. Ryan is not much troubled about them because even though Deputy Derrig is worried about the cost of the scheme his colleague, Deputy Dr. Ryan says: "I am going to plaster the people with another £10,000,000 in addition." What I should like to know is what Deputy Derrig thinks of his colleague's proposal to raise another £10,000,000 on top of what is provided under this Bill. Part of the Fianna Fáil proposal also is that there are going to be no retirement pensions at 65 years of age. They are to be abolished. Deputy Kissane, again suffering from that introspection, said he was opposed to paying pensions to people at 65. The Deputy sees nothing wrong in paying pensions at 65 to civil servants, Guards, members of the Army, judges, employees of local authorities and people such as these but do not dare to pay them to builders' labourers, tradesmen, agricultural workers, road workers or dockers. It is all right for ex-Ministers and ex-Parliamentary Secretaries to get pensions when they are 40 or 50 years of age, but never must an agricultural worker or a docker get a pension at 65 years of age, according to Deputy Kissane. Let me say that I think the docker or the agricultural worker has a damn sight better right to a pension at 65 years of age than a Minister or a Parliamentary Secretary after three, five or seven years' service, and so far as I am concerned, he is going to get it under this Bill, and the Deputy can vote against it if he likes.

Comment on this

Is this a quotation?

Comment on this

I have enough to do without carrying the Deputy's speeches around with me.

Comment on this

That is a misquotation.

Comment on this

No, read your speech. Now we come to sum up two points. No. 1 is that so far as a scheme of social security is concerned, Fianna Fáil never included the farmer, the self-employed man or the shopkeeper.

Comment on this
Mr. de Valera

How can the Minister say that? Fianna Fáil were not in office and did not have the opportunity of bringing the matter to finality. Why cannot we have a proper argument if we are to debate these things?

Comment on this

The way you want it.

Comment on this
Mr. de Valera

I want the truth.

Comment on this
A Deputy

You promised it 30 years ago.

Comment on this

The trouble with the Deputy is that if he thinks he is getting the better of an argument, things are all right, but if he is not getting the better of the argument, he wants to alter the rules of the game.

Comment on this
Mr. de Valera

Fianna Fáil did not have an opportunity of bringing in its Bill. You cannot deny that.

Comment on this

My answer to that is that Deputy Lemass said in 1948 that whatever had been left behind by Fianna Fáil was a fully prepared and fully-worked out plan. You cannot be right from both standpoints. That is clear in any case. Now, in an effort to bid for additional political support, Fianna Fáil wants to extend the scheme, but it is costed so incompetently that to do what they want to do would involve abolishing the retirement pension at 65 years of age and put another £10,000,000 of taxation on the people. If that is their policy I do not mind. This policy involves imposing an additional £10,000,000 in taxation, and all the other classes are to stay out until some day in the sweet-by-and-by they will have another look at it.

There is another aspect of the Bill that deserves some consideration because we had some self-appointed theologians here who gave us the benefit of their reservoir of knowledge in that sphere. Listening to Deputy P. O'Reilly, one would think that this Bill was going to break up family life, and that children would not respect their parents in future if they knew that they took advantage of such benefits as children's allowances. He said that a stage would be reached when a child would put out its tongue at its parents and say: "You did not give me anything; the State gave it to me since I was born." He also said that it would lead to a breakdown of family life. That was the crazy kind of picture painted for us by Deputy O'Reilly on this Bill.

Comment on this

Deputy Dillon when in Opposition painted the same picture.

Comment on this

Listen now to Deputy O'Reilly, who took us back to Biblical history. Here we have got an up-to-the-minute, close-up view of the consequences of Adam's Fall:

"In my opinion, the command of God to Adam after the Fall—‘in the sweat of thy brow shalt thou eat bread'—holds as much force to-day as it did then. So far as the records of time are available to us, 4,000 years later, God's Divine Son came on earth to redeem us from that Fall."

He goes on to speak of Nazareth and says later:

"There was no State security there. There was no social welfare. From that we have tangible evidence that the Divine plan was that man should provide for himself by the sweat of his brow."

Now whatever the consequences of Adam's Fall were, I am sure that they did not include a complete ban on social security schemes at any time in the future. The trouble with Adam was that he had social security but he could not look after it. It was only when he fell that he lost his benefits. Deputy O'Reilly says that it was hinted to Adam that for the rest of his life he would have to live on the sweat of his brow. Whatever else you do, in the view of Deputy O'Reilly—and you can do a lot of things, because man has done a lot of things since-you must not start a social security scheme. If you do, you do not know what will happen. Is it not a perfectly daft statement for a public representative in this country, in an intelligent Parliament, to come in and tell the people that the human race must never have a Social Security Bill? The Deputy is going to vote against this Bill. Well, God help the electors in Cavan if he is going to vote against the Bill on the basis of a statement of that kind. I think it is political and theological lunacy.

Comment on this

The Minister is an expert on theology.

Comment on this

I am not, but I am not going to admit that the Deputy is either. The Deputy has shown himself to be an expert on nothing. Does anybody believe that you will wreck the human family or that you will destroy the Christian or Catholic concept of life, if you give a man sickness benefit when he is unfit to work? Does any body think that you will break down the moral fibre of the people if you pay unemployment benefit to a man if he has lost his job, through no fault of his own, or that you will ruin family life or separate the children from the mother if you give them widows' and orphans' pensions because the breadwinner has died?

Comment on this

We have already put on record our principles in that respect.

Comment on this

I know the Deputy's point of view in this matter is quite a comprehensive one. Deputy O'Reilly treated us to an exhibition of fear as to the consequences which will befall family life, and the Irish and Christian home, if we dare to provide the benefits such as are enshrined in this scheme. He is going to vote against this Bill because he thinks the ruin of the Irish family will be accomplished by keeping the widow and the orphan out of the county home.

Comment on this

I do not believe he meant that.

Comment on this

You did not read his speech but I read portion of it. Deputy Cogan had an incursion into the domain of theology as well, and he proceeded to give us his views as to how things should be done and arranged. I think there is a lot of impudence in a lot of these suggestions by lay people as to what is the correct procedure theologically. I would like to ask Deputy Cogan, does he imagine that the hierarchy in this country are not doing their duty, and that they are silent while we are passing through a Bill here which gives offence to the moral law? Does Deputy Cogan think that he knows canon law and the moral law better than the Church knows it, and, if the hierarchy have no reason to object to a scheme of social welfare, does not that satisfy Deputy Cogan's conscience and Deputy O'Reilly's conscience, or do they think that there is some slothfulness on the part of the hierarchy and that they are not doing their duty on this matter? Is it not a bit brazen and impudent to be advising people who need no advice in this matter? Their learning, their culture and their understanding of Irish conditions, and their regard for the Christian, the Catholic Faith needs no commendation from us because it stands high on its own eminence. It is quite dishonest to try and use some of the tracts and literature that have been issued against this Bill by people with no qualifications to judge and no authority to judge as a reason for conjuring up opposition to a Bill of this kind.

I have read, and I say it definitely and deliberately, arrant nonsense by people claiming to be putting the Catholic point of view in respect of this Bill. Here is one outrageous example of it. I can do nothing but describe it as such. Writing against "State welfare schemes", and with an obvious eye on this Bill, we get this intemperate description by the author of a pamphlet published recently. He says:—

"The proposals must then suffer many of the known evils of assistance; for example, tenants of the corporation are known to saw the rafters off the roof for convenient fuel."

I have never heard of any tenants sawing the rafters off the roofs for fuel.

Comment on this

What is the Minister quoting from?

Comment on this

From an article by Dr. Hegarty in an issue of Christus Rex. I think that is deliberate misrepresentation of the facts of Irish life. I have asked every corporation that I could if they had come across cases where the tenants sawed the rafters off their roofs for fuel, and I have not been able to trace one. I have asked publicly at a meeting to be furnished with the name of one tenant who had sawn the rafters off the roof in his house for fuel. But supposing they do, and supposing a dozen tenants saw the rafters off the roofs of corporation houses for fuel, is that any reason why we should build houses without roofs so as to prevent them doing it? Is that any reason why the corporation should stop building houses, even though there may be isolated blemishes as regards one particular aspect of a social welfare scheme? It is no reason why the decent honest person should not get the protection which a Christian and a progressive State rightly gives to all those who toil in the service of the State.

We had another example of the intemperate language that was used by people whom Deputy MacEntee befriends here. Referring to State schemes of assistance, the author says:—

"There is much sober truth in the paradox that we have as much right to free love as to free spectacles."

I think that is an unworthy reference to unfortunate people whose economic position compels them to seek free spectacles by putting the receipt of these free spectacles on the same basis as the filthy sin of free love.

Comment on this

The spectacles are no longer free now.

Comment on this

The gentleman who wrote that did not know even that. Let me say this: if you want any authority in any case in respect to the Church's attitude on social welfare schemes, and the importance which the Church attaches to the State helping the weak and helping those who need supplementary assistance in their passage through life, we can get that by reading the Encyclicals, or we can get it from publications which have been issued by the Catholic Truth Society containing a summary of the Encyclicals. Here, in one which is convenient to my hand, in the Encyclical Letter on Atheistic Communism, we meet this passage under the heading of Social Justice:—

"But social justice cannot be said to have been satisfied as long as working men are denied a salary that will enable them to secure proper sustenance for themselves and for their families; as long as they are denied the opportunity of acquiring a modest fortune and forestalling the plague of universal pauperism; as long as they cannot make suitable provision through public or private insurance for old age, for periods of illness and unemployment."

The Encyclical Letters clearly defend the right of the worker to be able to make provision for those contingencies. That represents the Catholic view to the approach to the social welfare problem. If I have to choose between the views expressed in these Encyclical Letters and the lay theology of Deputy Cogan and Deputy O'Reilly, I want to say that I prefer these Encyclicals as the fount of my knowledge to whatever information the Deputies may have scrappily picked up from time to time on the same subject.

We had a discussion, mainly initiated by Deputies in the Opposition Party, on the question that we did not need a retirement pension at 65 years of age. I could not find any reasons for the opposition to that scheme offered by the Fianna Fáil Deputies who have spoken on the matter. They merely had the idea that we should not give it at 65 years of age, but we never heard an argument as to why men should not get it at 65. Anybody who has any experience of life knows perfectly well that, in these days especially, it is extremely difficult for the worker of 60 or 65 years of age to hold his job with any employer who is engaged in activities which require hard physical work on the part of the worker. I wish that Deputy Colley, who is also opposed to retirement pensions at 65 years of age, would go around to any building job in the city and ask the foreman on the job how many times he has picked a worker who is over 60 years of age, and ask him further when did he last pick a workman who was 65 years of age. Deputy Colley will not have many to take back in the taxicab if occupations are offered them.

Comment on this
Mr. de Valera

There is, surely, an alternative for dealing with these cases.

Comment on this

What one does the Deputy suggest—that he should be paid sickness benefit or unemployment benefit?

Comment on this
Mr. de Valera

Either of two things would happen.

Comment on this

That we should offer sickness benefit or unemployment benefit. He is not sick and he is quite willing to work, but he lives in a society that will not provide him with work. The employer wants young and vigorous men and an insurance company thinks twice about insuring a man if he is 65 and has to go up any height. Deputy Little would know nothing about that, but it is a fact. It is said: "Pay the man unemployment benefit." The man is not unemployed. He is unemployable because the people who should provide him with employment, those who have got the wealth and the instruments of production will not discharge their responsibility to him. He is not unemployed in any sense; he is unemployable. They will not take him. The obvious thing is to retire the man in the same way as the State pays pensions to retiring Ministers and Parliamentary Secretaries.

Comment on this

Did we not offer the alternative of providing for such men?

Comment on this

Do they not get unemployment benefit?

Comment on this

They will get better benefits when this Bill passes. This Bill recognises the stern facts of life, that it is impossible for people of 60 or 65 or even younger who lose their jobs to be able to get work again. At 65 it is almost impossible to keep a job if physical endeavour is required from a man. In that case, the man has to live on the charity of his son or daughter, if he has a son or daughter, and if they are placed in circumstances to enable them to keep him, or he can draw unemployment benefit for a while under the present system, or he can look for home assistance, or go to the charitable organisations. I prefer to recognise that we have in this country to-day large numbers of employers—every farmer in the country is one, for example, and a lot of employers in industry are the same —who do not provide retirement pensions for workers at 65 years of age. At that age, if a worker goes, it is: "Good-bye and thanks; I am sorry to lose you." But that does not pay the grocer, it does not pay the milkman and the landlord.

Recognising the fact that these people cannot pay pensions because their own position probably does not enable them to do so, that the man has nothing to live on when he loses his job at 65, this Bill proposes to give him a pension and an allowance for his wife, irrespective of her age. That is provided for in the Bill. You can vote against that if you like, but you ought to be honest and admit what you are doing to the people for whom there may be no other provision. You were 16 years in office and you did not do it.

Comment on this
Mr. de Valera

Other people were years in office and they did not do it.

Comment on this

It is being done now and Fianna Fáil can vote against it if they like, but, quite clearly, at the first effort to provide pensions for retired workers at 65 and an allowance for a dependent wife in the case of a family which has nothing to live on, Fianna Fáil are going to vote against it with the aid of Deputy Cogan and Deputy O'Reilly.

Comment on this
Mr. de Valera

With an alternative.

Comment on this

We have had enough of these alternatives in Irish history.

Comment on this

You have an alternative Minister for Health on the Front Bench.

Comment on this

You will have to walk the tightrope very carefully when explaining your attitude towards this Bill. Some other points were raised in connection with the matter. One was the administrative cost of the scheme when administered by the State. Somebody was worried on that score but, of course, never took the trouble to find out what are the administrative costs of private insurance companies. If you take the life insurance and the industrial insurance carried on by insurance companies established in Ireland and take their business for the year 1948 you will find that the cost of administration varies from 26 to 29 per cent.

Comment on this
Mr. de Valera

These are actual, not estimates?

Comment on this

These are calculations on the basis of what they pay in commission and expenses of management as a percentage of premiums. All the figures are here.

Comment on this
Mr. de Valera

Is it an estimate?

Comment on this

No, it is a calculation from the returns which they put in.

Comment on this

The 12½ per cent. is an estimate?

Comment on this

In the case of private insurance companies it varies from 26 to 29 per cent.

Comment on this

What Deputy de Valera asked was, was not the 12½ per cent. in the White Paper only an estimate?

Comment on this

I assure you he did not ask that.

Comment on this
Mr. de Valera

I wanted to point out the difference between what has actually taken place in which every penny can be calculated and what is only an estimate. We do not know what the 12½ per cent. may amount to.

Comment on this

Perhaps you will take some figures which may have a reassuring effect. The cost of administration of the Department of Social Welfare is equal to 7½ per cent. of all income—contributions, State grant and interest. That is the cost of the administration of the Department of Social Welfare.

Comment on this

At the moment?

Comment on this

Yes. The cost of the administration of the Department under the new scheme when it is in operation in its fifth year is estimated to amount to 11 per cent. We made it 12½ per cent. to round it off in case of a possibility of error. There is obviously no need for alarm in this case so far as the State is concerned. There might well be need for knowing why so much of the premium income of private insurance companies goes in management and does not go back to the policy holders.

A question was raised by Deputy Flynn, I think, in connection with the special allowance paid to Old I.R.A. men under the Army Pensions Act or the Military Service Pensions Act. Under the Bill it is proposed to exclude any income amounting to not more than £80 received by persons as a special allowance under those Acts. The effect of that will be that approximately 1,300 persons will benefit by having that allowance disregarded out of a total of 1,500 persons who are drawing the special allowance under these Acts.

Comment on this

Might I draw attention to the fact that the highest allowance paid is £98 10s.? Why differentiate between £80 and £98 10s.? I might add that the former Minister for Defence undertook to look into that matter and gave a rather satisfactory answer in respect of it.

Comment on this

I have a return which shows that there are 97 persons receiving less than £20 per annum; 200 between £20 and £40; 390 between £40 and £60; 599 between £60 and £80; 102 between £80 and £100; 68 between £100 and £120; 30 between £120 and £140; 11 between £140 and £160; and five between £160 and £180. That is an official return which has been put into my possession, so apparently there has been a change in the procedure since the Deputy was last familiar with the position.

The question of old age pensions which will now be payable to farmers on attaining 70 years of age provided they give their holdings to a son or daughter was raised by Deputy Childers. He asked what was the extent, I think, of the change in procedure and what the object sought to be achieved? The position at the moment is that if the farmer waits until he is 70 years of age and then gives his farm to his son or daughter under existing legislation, which has been extant for a considerable time, the income from the farm is taken into consideration against him for old age pension purposes. If he gives away his farm to a son or daughter and applies for an old age pension under existing legislation he may find himself in the position that he has neither a farm nor a pension. The result is that farmers up to this, being prudent men, were reluctant to give away their farms when they reached 70 years of age in the hope that they would get a pension, but with the knowledge that they are very unlikely to get it.

This Bill enables a farmer when he reaches 70 years of age, or before it if he likes, to give his holding to a son or daughter in the knowledge that having done so he will not be assessed with the income from that farm for old age pension purposes. When this Bill becomes law he will know that he will get the old age pension for himself; that if his wife reaches 70 years of age she will get an old age pension too; and the son or daughter in possession of the farm will have the wherewithal to marry. This desirable social object will be promoted by encouraging the young unmarried people in the household to set up house for themselves, something they cannot do easily so long as the farmer holds on to his land feeling it is the only income he has.

Comment on this
B. J. Maguire Mr. B. Maguire Independent

Is that without regard to the valuation of the property?

Comment on this

That will happen in the case of every holding up to £30 in valuation and that will cover 86 per cent. of the farms of the country.

Comment on this
B. J. Maguire Mr. B. Maguire Independent

Supposing the owner of the farm has a niece or a nephew residing with him and that niece or nephew runs the farm for him, can the farmer transfer in the same way to either of them as in the case of a son or daughter?

Comment on this

That is a different matter. Nieces and nephews might arrive in droves where the old man had no son or daughter just for the sake of taking over the farm from him when he reaches 70 and they might disappear again a week after he gets the pension. In the case of a son or daughter there is an actual interest in the holding and the natural desire to succeed to it so that the son or daughter can set up house for themselves.

Comment on this
B. J. Maguire Mr. B. Maguire Independent

It does not extend then beyond the immediate family.

Comment on this

That is so. The Deputy will realise there would be most affectionate nieces hovering around the old man if we opened the door too wide.

The cost of the scheme has been raised and also the cost of the contributions. I have already given the figures in that regard. I do not think they afford any ground for disquiet. I have said that under the scheme in the first year of its existence the cost of social security will amount to approximately 2.87 of the national income for 1949; this 2.87 can be broken up as follows: .92 per cent. for the employees' contribution, 1.13 per cent for the employers' contribution and .82 per cent. representing the State contribution. In view of that coverage the provision of benefits of this widespread character need give no cause for disquiet.

Comment on this

How much would that be in millions? The national income is about £400,000,000. Therefore, 3 per cent. would be about £12,000,000.

Comment on this

Substantially less than we spend on drink and racing.

Comment on this

I am asking for the figures.

Comment on this

Drink and racing and other foibles which unfortunately enmesh the human race.

Comment on this

The Minister was shocked at £12,000,000 before.

Comment on this

I am never shocked at investing millions in humanity.

Comment on this

Let us have it clear. It will cost £12,000,000.

Comment on this

The Deputy did not approve when he saw £500,000 as the cost of modifying the means test in 1947. He ran away from that. So far as the imposition on the national income is concerned, it is relatively nothing and it is a burden well within the capacity of the nation to bear.

Comment on this

Just the same, it will cost £12,000,000. Has the Minister figures for the second year?

Comment on this

No. That is the figure for the cost. The figure for the second year will be approximately the same. If the Deputy will put down a parliamentary question I will get the figures for him for each year. I do not carry time tables and calculating tables around with me on the Second Reading of a Bill.

Comment on this

They will only be estimated figures, too.

Comment on this

Wait for the end of the second year and you will then have them in fact. Then you will be satisfied.

Comment on this

I am relating the matter to the cost of running in the first five years. Many figures have not been disclosed here.

Comment on this

Wait and see.

Comment on this

That is not the way to approach the matter.

Comment on this

Is not an estimate good enough at this stage?

Comment on this

Deputy MacEntee referred to certain aspects of the Bill and spoke about the exclusion of farmers. I hope I have convinced him now that Deputy Dr. Ryan intended to exclude them as well and they would never have appeared in a Fianna Fáil scheme.

Comment on this
Mr. de Valera

Do not say that.

Comment on this

I congratulate the Deputy on his tenacity in repeating the same thing which, unfortunately, is wrong every time.

Comment on this
Mr. de Valera

It is the tenacity of accuracy.

Comment on this

Social security has many facets. This aspect is that of maintaining income—that is, the income maintenance service we are providing. One can have social security in a whole variety of ways which do not represent maintenance. The provision of employment would represent another aspect of social security. So far as the farmer is concerned, I think he has done very well under this Government and there is no use in trying to teach the farmer to be either mean or greedy. Left alone, he will be neither. He should not be made mean and greedy to satisfy or gratify a political purpose. At present the State is paying £4,000,000 a year for the relief of rates on agricultural land, and that is being levied off citizens who are not farmers for the benefit of the farmers. That £4,000,000 is being paid by people who will never own a piece of ground beyond that which is sufficient to bury them.

Comment on this
B. J. Maguire Mr. B. Maguire Independent

Providing services which the farmer rarely uses—water for the town and roads for motor cars.

Comment on this

Not at all. If it means nothing to the farmer, then drop it. But see what the reactions will be.

Comment on this
Mr. de Valera

He will have to pay all these other things and he will get no benefit.

Comment on this

Deputy Maguire says it is no good and I say that if it is no good the farmer should not take it. We are spending £40,000,000 on a vast scheme of land reclamation. That means that the farmer is getting a subsidy from the State of £40,000,000 spent over the next ten or 12 years. That represents social security for the farmer. When people talk about the farmer not getting his share of the national cake they should not overlook these two items in particular. In addition to all that, the State is providing him with guaranteed prices for wheat, beet and milk and so arranging the home market that he is insulated, as far as the nation as a whole is concerned, against risks to which he would otherwise be exposed if the State did not intervene on his behalf. I do not say it is wrong to do that. I think it is right. We must try to shelter every person, but it is unfair in a discussion of this kind to try to set one class against another. What we ought to be doing is building up allover prosperity, so as to make the farmer wealthy, the worker wealthy, and everybody engaged in useful and purposeful national activities wealthy, so that prosperity, represented by a bigger national cake, will be shared with all the people who created the materials to provide and bake the cake.

It is in that spirit that I say to those who say they represent the farmers in particular that if the farmer is not getting everything he wants in this Bill he gets it in other spheres as well. Remember this, out of the £7,000,000 which we spend in old age pensions, much more than 75 per cent. is sent to the rural areas, and the bulk of that goes to the small farmer class.

Comment on this
Mr. Maguire

On the basis of a valuation of means, because their condition of poverty is much more acute than in the big industrial centres.

Comment on this

Let me say to Deputy Maguire that in Leitrim there are 4,000 old age pensioners and blind pensioners who will benefit by this Bill. At present they get in old age pensions £183,000. That will now be further substantially increased. If Leitrim had to bear out of its rates the cost of old age pensions and blind pensions, it would cost the Leitrim rates £1 5s. 5d. That is paid by the State to-day—rightly paid by the State— because the people of Leitrim could not bear a burden of that kind.

I do not want this whole problem approached from the point of view of a smash-and-grab raid—get what you can and run away, get the other fellow's share if you can. We ought to look on this Bill, and every other thing we do, as an effort to help the Irish people. Everybody may not be put in the first place. There may be some people to-day and others to-morrow, but so long as we are equitable in our approach and our distribution, in the course of time we can make a contribution to the needs of our people.

Comment on this
Mr. Maguire

Has the Minister estimated what the contribution from the taxpayer generally in Leitrim is towards the cost of old age and blind pensions?

Comment on this

I have not, in respect of Leitrim.

Comment on this
Mr. Maguire

It would be necessary, before making a comparison. You have to estimate their contribution on the basis of population.

Comment on this

I suggest to the Deputy that that is not a profitable investigation for a Leitrim Deputy. If I were the Deputy, I would leave it alone.

Comment on this
Mr. Maguire

I say that from the figures given it would appear as if we were definitely living on the rest of the community, but having regard to our contribution in direct and indirect taxation I say we are certainly not doing that, but from our productive capacity we are largely contributing to the cities and urban areas.

Comment on this

If the Deputy probes that closely, he will find it is an optical illusion, and if I were he I would let that hare sit. There are no tricks in that for the Deputy.

Comment on this
Mr. Maguire

I am not prepared to let it sit.

Comment on this

All right. That is often the way with people who will not let well enough alone.

Comment on this
Mr. Maguire

Why not tell the whole story? That would have been better than giving only one side of the picture.

Comment on this

Deputy Davin raised the question of local authority employees and the effect of this Bill on them. That matter obviously is one which will require consultation between my Department and the Department of Local Government. That consultation will take place during the course of the passage of this Bill through the Oireachtas. As far as employees of local authorities are concerned, they would be very much better off under a Bill of this kind, which would give them comprehensive benefits under six or seven heads for a sum proportionately no greater than they are paying for one type of benefit under the present Superannuation Act.

I do not desire to keep the House any longer. I recommend the Bill to the Dáil as a substantial instalment of social justice for men and women who toil and render service to the nation. I recommend it with a claim that it represents a substantial and a genuine effort to provide the first comprehensive social security scheme for this country. I trust that, no matter what views Deputies may have on the various political issues, they may endeavour to face up broadly to the necessity for a comprehensive social security scheme on which we can all agree in principle, no matter how much we may differ in detail. If the Opposition even now will accept that——

Comment on this
Mr. de Valera

What?

Comment on this

The fact that we agree to social security in principle—and this is social security in principle—I would undertake on the Committee Stage to allow the thing to be as open as possible, so that we could discuss the matter as freely as possible, conditioned by this overriding factor, that we have a cheque for a certain amount and we have to spend within that cheque. If we take off in one case and give to another, we have to recognise that there is a loss on one side and a gain on the other. There could be a broad understanding and a broad discussion on the Committee Stage details. I regard the passage of the Second Reading as acceptance of the principle and we can have free play for different views on the Committee Stage. However, if that is not acceptable, it does not matter. I am asking the House now to pass the Second Stage.

Comment on this
Mr. de Valera

Does the Minister wish me to speak on that?

Comment on this

If the Deputy likes.

Comment on this
Mr. de Valera

We have generally indicated our readiness and willingness to consider this whole question of social security. The difference is as to the methods by which it should be done. Where we differ with the proposals is that the method, in our opinion, is not the best that can be got. There was a proposition made that there should be some effort to try and get discussion, so as to have that question settled between us. I do not think that the amount of discussion has been sufficient for that. I do not know that in the Second Reading there would be possibility for it.

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

Can we not have a Special Committee of the House on the next stage to do it?

Mr. Maguire rose.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy Maguire has spoken already on several occasions. I must now put the question.

Comment on this
Mr. Maguire

Would the Minister consider that the small farmers of this country, who are left out of the scheme, could be included? I want an answer to that. Would he be prepared, even on the Committee Stage, to include that section of the community?

Comment on this

If the Deputy means the farmers who work for three or four months of the year on the farm and who must of necessity work on the roads or drainage schemes for the rest of the year, they are covered by the Bill, as they will be with an employer for that period, and they will keep their right and entitlement to benefit. If at any stage such a farmer decides he will work in future on his farm, he need not go out of the scheme but can become a voluntary contributor and pay a special rate covering him for the rest of his life, so long as he contributes.

Comment on this
Mr. de Valera

In regard to the proposition put up to me by the Tánaiste, it was already indicated from our benches that we are anxious, naturally, that so far as possible social security schemes should be outside Party divisions. It would be a great thing for the country if it were possible to have something like an agreed scheme. It is a matter for the Taoiseach or the Tánaiste to decide. I would like to have this division postponed, if I could, to consider that, as it is not possible for me now to consult about it.

Comment on this
Mr. Flynn

I made one point to the Tánaiste in a statement last night that——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

That is not a question. It is an argument. To the motion "That the Bill be now read a Second Time" an amendment has been moved by Deputy Dr. Ryan to delete certain words and substitute others. I am putting the question: "That the words proposed to be deleted stand."

Comment on this

On a point of order, are you putting both amendments together?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The wider amendment will embrace the narrower amendment.

Comment on this

In order to vote for my amendment, I must vote against the Bill now?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy will understand that the question is, "that the words proposed to be deleted stand". The amendments propose to delete certain words.

Comment on this
Division

Question put.

Tá 71
·
Níl 66
Result Carried The question put was agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?

Division

Question put: "That the Bill be now read a Second Time."

Tá 71
·
Níl 67
Result Carried The question put was agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?