Committee on Finance. - Vote 27—Agriculture (Resumed).
Contributions 176–369 of 369. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
We would like to know when the Minister is replying whether he proposes to reintroduce that scheme or some scheme of a similar nature in order to come to the rescue of the small farmers who cannot afford to replace the cattle that have died. We have heard speeches from some Deputies here describing how well off the farmers are. Listening to them speak, one would think that the farmers are living in riches. Deputy T.F. O'Higgins spoke about the farmers in his constituency having motor cars. I can assure Deputy O'Higgins that many farmers in the constituency I represent have not got motor cars.
Comment on this
They cannot afford such a luxury. It might be argued, perhaps, that some of the big farmers, such as those Deputy Fagan and a few others have in mind, are well off. Those who produce fat cattle and have land on which to rear those cattle are well off. They are not the farmers we have in mind. They are not the hardworking farmers who could be described as the backbone of the nation. Judging by some of the speeches made on the Government benches, one would imagine that the prices the farmers are getting at the present time are due to Government policy. Such is not the case, and that the prices the farmers are getting for their produce and their cattle, especially——
Comment on this
I would like someone to point out to me what agreement or portion of an agreement the present Government came to with anybody outside that would justify that line of argument? The present prices the farmers are getting for their cattle are due to world circumstances; they are scarcity prices. I am not in a position, no more than the Minister, I think, to say how long those scarcity prices will last, but when I hear Deputies speak here and down the country and say how well off the farmers are under the present Government, I have to smile. Somebody said here quite recently that the farmers would be better off were it not for the action of the present Government, were it not for the 1948 agreement. Somebody has referred to that already and reference has been made to the prohibition that has been put on this country by that agreement, whereby we have to sell 90 per cent. of our cattle to our neighbours across the water.
Comment on this
The Minister, in reply to that, said he had not the shipping to send them elsewhere. I am sure that if the Minister and the Government made an agreement with another country or other countries, the Governments there would find shipping, if they got the cattle.
Comment on this
If there were free competition between our nearest neighbour and the people of other countries on the Continent of Europe, the price of cattle would be higher.
Comment on this
Very nicely, thank you, Deputy. You will be very much distressed. Prepare yourself for bad news.
Comment on this
I am not, I have a very good memory, thanks be to God. Reference has been made to compulsory tillage. One would imagine by the way some Deputies opposite speak that there is a clear line of cleavage between Deputies opposite and here on that matter.
Comment on this
In my opinion, the best way to encourage tillage in this or any country is by price inducement.
Comment on this
What is the present Government doing by price inducement to encourage tillage? The Minister waited until a couple of weeks ago before he announced an increase in the price of wheat—and the best brand of wheat at that. If he were serious it is not a couple of weeks ago he would have offered it, small though it is, but in September or October of last year, so as to give the farmers an opportunity of taking advantage of it. Everybody knows that the Minister is not serious about the growing of wheat here. It would mean going back on his former statements and his attitude as evidenced by his statements here and outside. That explains why he did not announce this increase until a few weeks ago. However, my chief reason for intervening in this debate is——
Comment on this
——that I am thoroughly dissatisfied, as are many people, in the country, with the way in which the Minister has handled the milk question. I come from a part of the country——
Comment on this
——where there are many dairy farmers. The way in which the Minister has treated them is nothing short of a public scandal.
Comment on this
We remember when this present Government was formed and the Minister for Agriculture took office——
Comment on this
Since I got on my feet about a quarter of an hour ago, there has been nothing but a barrage of interruptions. I am entitled to make my views known in this House——
Comment on this
——just the same as other Deputies. It is an extraordinary thing that whenever Deputies from this side speak there is a barrage of interruptions, but no such barrage from this side when anybody over there stands up.
Comment on this
They are afraid I will tell them some of the truth and it may be all of the truth. When the present Minister assumed office, he went to great pains to tell the people that he was their servant, that they were his masters.
Comment on this
He said that any time they had a grievance all they need do would be to come to Government Buildings in Merrion Street and they would be received with open arms. I wonder to what extent the Minister has fulfilled that undertaking. I regard the dairy farmers as the most important section of the farming community. Quite recently, as everybody knows, the dairy farmers, having organised themselves as they felt it was necessary to do, arranged to send a deputation to the Minister for Agriculture. The Minister refused to meet that deputation and, when he was questioned as to the reason why, he said that it was because they belonged to a certain brand of politics and because they were racketeers. Everybody knows, of course, that there was no foundation for that allegation, none whatsoever. Everybody knows now that that was only a smoke-screen which the Minister was using to prevent the representatives of the milk suppliers from putting their case. The Minister felt that he had no case to put up against it. Why not give those people an opportunity of putting their case? What has the Minister to fear from that? Are they not as much entitled to put their case to the Minister and the Government as any other section of the community? No. The Minister did not want to receive them because he had made up his mind, from the very commencement, that he was not going to increase the price of milk delivered at the creameries. Finally, when he met the representatives of the Irish Agricultural Organisation Society, he increased the price not by 1d. a gallon as some of the Deputies here have been saying——
Comment on this
I am talking about the increase in the price per gallon. There is no increase of 1d. in the gallon for milk delivered at the creameries.
Comment on this
Make no mistake about that. There is an increase of 1d. per gallon for six months of the year, but there is no increase for the other portion of the year. While everybody must admit that the period of the year in question is the most important from the point of view of milk supplies, still at the same time there is a fairly substantial supply in the months of April and November——
Comment on this
——apart entirely from the other months. My summing up is that if the increase of 1d. per gallon were stretched over the entire 12 months, it would amount to about ¾d. Let us be clear. The Minister has given the dairy farmers an increase of only ¾d.
Comment on this
Whatever the total amounts to I hold and anybody who studies the matter must hold that the increase in the price of milk is only ¾d. per gallon.
Comment on this
Side by side with that increase of ¾d. per gallon in the price of milk, the Minister did not forget to clap on an increase of 2d. a lb. on the butter consumed by the people in the country, both rich and poor alike. The Minister's former attitude was that if he acceded to demands that had been made he was going to put a crushing burden on the consumers of this country. The Minister need not have put on any such impost on the consuming public. He need not have put on an increase of 2d. per lb. on butter because a subsidy policy is already there. All he need have done was to increase the subsidy and the money could be got for that purpose.
We have heard a lot from some of the Deputies opposite and from certain members of the Government, especially the Tánaiste, about the inordinate profits that certain people in trade and commerce in this country were getting out of the people. Why not tax those? Why not tax these people who are alleged to be getting inordinate profits over the heads of the Irish people? Why not put on the excess profits tax that we have heard so much from the Labour Party about?
Comment on this
Certainly. I will vote for it any day if these people, as has been alleged, are lining their pockets with the spoils that they have got from the Irish people. That is one way in which they can be made to disgorge these profits by the reimposition of the excess profits tax. If that is done, the Government need not increase the price of butter for the consuming public in this country. It was a mistake to do that. In my opinion, it was a great mistake, because it imposes a burden on the poor people. Large families, especially, can ill afford any increase in the price of butter at the present time. As it happens, they find it very hard to get butter at all in certain parts of the country at the present time. I think that the Minister has mishandled this whole problem. I think he would be far better off if he had received the deputation from the milk suppliers' association because they would have been in a position to discuss all these matters with him.
Comment on this
The Minister made a great mistake when he mentioned that. When we got into office first in 1932, the price of milk delivered at the creameries was 3½d. per gallon. We kept on raising the price of milk down through the years up to 1946, when it was about 9d. per gallon. In 1946, we raised the price from 9d. to 1/2 and 1/4 per gallon. That is the history of the price of milk——
Comment on this
——if the Minister forgets it. I am prepared to stand over the statement that I have made. There are Deputies in this House who know just as well as I do——
Comment on this
——that we were the first Government to lift the dairy industry from the slough of despond in which it had been up to the time we came into office.
Comment on this
We started to do that when we brought in the Dairy Produce (Price Stabilisation) Act, 1932.
Comment on this
If the Minister looks up the Dairy Produce (Price Stabilisation) Act, 1932, he will find the commencement——
Comment on this
——of the policy that has been pursued by the Fianna Fáil Government throughout the years.
Comment on this
Dealing again with the milk suppliers' association, I notice the Minister does not like to hear anything about that. It is our duty to remind him of it, and to remind him of the way in which he has thwarted those people, and the way in which he has mismanaged the whole problem. The point is that there probably would never have been a milk suppliers' association as such in existence, were it not for the action and policy of the Minister himself, because it was when the Minister made an attempt, and a very subtle attempt indeed, to reduce the price of milk last year from 1/2 or 1/4 to 1/- per gallon for the next five years that the dairy farmers thought it necessary to organise themselves in order to defend themselves against the policy of the Minister. The Minister held out the carrot of a nebulous five-year plan to the dairy farmers, if they would be foolish enough to accept 1/- a gallon for their milk.
Comment on this
The dairy farmers were wide awake and they knew very well that the Minister had no five-year plan, because if he had had such a plan, he should have explained it and should have told the people exactly what it was. It was only when he proceeded to reduce the price of milk delivered to the creameries that the people heard of this five-year plan for the first time. It was, of course, a matter of expediency then to talk about a five-year plan, but the five-year plan hoax did not fool the farmers. The dairy farmers organised themselves and they have a strong organisation in the country now, and, even though the Minister may stand up and call them racketeers and their movement a Fianna Fáil ramp as he did here recently, I can assure him that the organisation is composed of people of different political opinions. If the Minister has read the correspondence that has appeared in the Press and the resolutions and pronouncements from these farmers——
Comment on this
——he must have now come to the conclusion that they are no such thing, that they represent the dairy farmers, that they represent the farmers who supply milk to the creameries and that they are not actuated by any political motives whatever.
Comment on this
The Chair desires to have order and asks Deputies on both sides to allow Deputy Kissane to make his speech.
Comment on this
He has been speaking for the past 35 minutes and has not been given a chance by the Opposition.
Comment on this
I am not referring to the length of time but to the disorder consequent on interruptions.
Comment on this
The difficulty is that some of the Deputies opposite do not want to hear the naked truth. I have been trying to give the House a résumé of what has happened to the dairy farmers and I hope that, apart from interruptions or anything else, the Minister will bear my remarks in mind. I might as well finish my discourse on the topic of the price of milk by saying that the dairy farmers consider the Minister's offer of ¾d. per gallon increase in the price of milk——
Comment on this
It is a dear insult. I wish someone would insult me with £1,000,000 a year. It would be heartily welcome.
Comment on this
Deputy Bartley mentioned the Gaeltacht. Representing a Gaeltacht constituency as I do, I think the Minister does not appear to realise what the requirements of the Gaeltacht are. There has been much discussion and much has been written about what the Minister is going to do for the people of Connemara, and everybody knows that the scheme the Minister has in mind is quite impracticable. This proposal to remove the rocks from the soil would not deceive anybody who knows the country, who knows the lie of the land in the Gaeltacht, and, as Deputy Bartley said, it would be much better if the Minister would consider reintroducing the tomato scheme. I was surprised, and, I must say, shocked, when I heard the Minister challenging that proposal on the ground of economy. There is one thing we must make up our minds on: if we are to do something practical and something worth while for the Gaeltacht, our criterion must not be whether it is going to be economic or not.
Comment on this
I am not dealing with that. I am trying to impress on the Minister that, if the Government have any scheme in mind for an improvement of the economic conditions of the Gaeltacht, they must not consider it in terms of pounds, shillings and pence, because the people of the Gaeltacht, situated as they are in the barren parts of the country, are entitled to special consideration from the other people of the country who are in better circumstances. I hold that, instead of condemning the glass-house scheme for tomato growing as an exotic scheme, as the Minister did, he should have given it every encouragement.
Comment on this
He should have seen to it that it was extended to other parts of the Gaeltacht instead of closing it down.
Comment on this
There are other ways in which the economic conditions of the Gaeltacht can be improved, because, as the Minister is aware, certain experiments have been carried out in my constituency, in some of the barren parts, and it has been discovered that it is possible to produce the best of beet from reclaimed bog.
Comment on this
No doubt the Minister knows that. It is a scheme that was introduced by one of the agricultural instructors down there. When he went to experiment on it everybody laughed at the idea. They said that beet could not be produced from the red bog, but such has been the case. I commend the scheme to the Minister. In my opinion, not merely can beet be produced from bog, when it is properly cultivated, but other things as well can be produced from it. I remember that some time last year we had a debate in this House on the Gaeltacht. I pointed out some of the possibilities—one of which was the production of early potatoes. I do not know whether the Minister and his Department have given any consideration to that possibility. In some parts of the Gaeltacht, in the constituency which I represent, these crops come in earlier than they do in inland parts of the country. It would be worth while to make the experiment. I have in mind the individual effort or efforts of one small farmer in South Kerry who actually produced potatoes as early as the people in Rush and Swords and who actually sent them to the Dublin market.
Comment on this
Because the soil is suitable for it. The sandy soil is suitable for the production of onions.
Comment on this
I did, and I know something about it. I was reared not too far at all from the land. However, I am just trying to point out that it is possible to develop the Gaeltacht in ways other than by attacking the deep-seated rocks.
Comment on this
It is a wonder your Government did not do it during the 16 years they were in office.
Comment on this
We did many things for the Gaeltacht. During our term of office we set up industries in the Gaeltacht. We expanded the activities of Seirbhisí na Gaeltacht. We established factories in Donegal and in Mayo—toy factories, and so forth.
Comment on this
Only agricultural industries, in relation to the Department of Agriculture, are relevant now.
Comment on this
It is very difficult to separate the Gaeltacht—the agricultural needs of the Gaeltacht and the economic needs of the Gaeltacht— from any discussion on the Department of Agriculture. I imagine that, if the individual efforts of an ordinary private citizen would succeed in a case like this, surely the Department of Agriculture—with all its technical advisers and all the information that it has at its disposal—would be able to make a greater success, given the will and the wherewithal to do it.
Comment on this
I come now to the land rehabilitation scheme. This is a scheme which received the benediction of all Parties in the House.
Comment on this
I am referring to the time when the legislation was being passed through this House. When the legislation providing for the carrying out of this project was passing through the House all Parties supported it. There is no doubt about that.
Comment on this
If Deputies opposite try to suggest that any of us on these benches want to condemn the scheme they are making a mistake. For my own part, any scheme that is likely to improve the fertility and the productivity of the land will have my support. But it is one thing to support a scheme and another thing——
Comment on this
——to examine the way in which the scheme is being administered. Deputies on all sides of the House have complained of the delay that had been evident in the administration of the scheme. In fact, the other night I happened to be at a meeting and one of the members present asked me if such a scheme was in operation at all.
Comment on this
I do not travel as far as that. I just want to say that at the present rate of progress it will take a long time before the £40,000,000, which the Minister envisaged, will be expended on the scheme. I notice that no less a sum than £600,000 has been taken from it in the Estimates this year. If Deputies will look at the Book of Estimates they will see that there is a reduction of £600,000 in the amount of money being made available for the administration of the land rehabilitation scheme. I do not know the reason for that reduction.
Comment on this
Because when you have bought machinery you do not go on buying it and buying it and buying it. You buy it once and you use it.
Comment on this
The Minister might want to purchase more machinery. It may be that some of the machinery which was purchased is not suitable at all.
Comment on this
At the present slow rate of progress at which the land rehabilitation scheme is being carried out——
Comment on this
I was just pointing out that at the present rate of progress the £40,000,000 which the Minister is getting from Marshall Aid funds will not be expended until the Minister is a very old man.
Comment on this
I said: "until the Minister..." I notice that the amount in the Estimates—I have not the book with me here—is £2,700,000.
Comment on this
He is always sent out for them. Send out Deputy Davern and he will get them for you.
Comment on this
The Minister for Agriculture is much more like a runner than I am. I was never sent to get the secrets of the British Budget either. Put that in your pipe and smoke it. Do not draw me out—for your own sake and for the sake of posterity.
Comment on this
No, you are the cause of it over there. You are not prepared to listen to us.
I should like to refer to one item that came up for discussion some time before Easter. A Supplementary Estimate was before the Dáil and reference was made, I think by Deputy Major de Valera, to the 10/- per ton allowance which was taken from the wholesale flour merchants.
Comment on this
I mean wholesalers dealing in bran and pollard. Even though the Minister went to great pains to explain the reason for the reduction I cannot say that his explanation satisfied me fully. If he could point out to my satisfaction that the 10/- per ton allowance which used to be given to those wholesale merchants and which was taken from them by the present Minister was going back to the consumers everything would be all right, but the Minister did not point out any such thing. I read the debate afterwards and I could not find any evidence in the Minister's statement that the consumers were getting any concession or relief as a result of the withdrawal of that allowance. I think he endeavoured to explain that it was being utilised to keep prices at a certain level. If it is being utilised for that purpose the point is whether it will succeed; will the Minister succeed and will the withdrawal of that 10/- per ton ensure that the prices will not go up?
Comment on this
If it means that the price comes down will the Deputy agree with me that it is wise?
Comment on this
If I get an assurance from the Minister that the withdrawal of the 10/- allowance on bran and pollard will benefit the consumers then everything will be all right.
Comment on this
I did not address my question to Deputy Davin because Deputy Davin knows nothing at all about it. I addressed my question to the Minister.
Comment on this
The Minister should not be misled by Deputy Davin's reply. I should like to get a definite reply from the Minister when I ask when the effect of the withdrawal of the allowance will be seen and felt by the consumer. Could the Minister tell me that?
Comment on this
Even if I knew it it would be well that the other members of the House should know it——
Comment on this
I am not the Minister for Agriculture and it is not my duty to tell them any such thing. It is the Minister's duty to tell Deputies and the public how soon this reduction will come into operation.
Comment on this
Deputy Dockrell speaking on this Estimate rebuked us on this side of the House for being very severe on the Minister in our criticisms. Our business in this House is to criticise and to encourage also if we can, and I am inclined to think that this debate on agriculture has been conducted on very moderate lines.
Comment on this
If we sometimes use harsh expressions it is because we feel rather strongly on certain things.