We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Committee on Finance. - Vote 27—Agriculture (Resumed).

Contributions 126–259 of 259. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Frank Fahy An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy will understand that he can only get the table on record by reading it.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

I appreciate that. The Minister gave a table which I will read in a moment. I would like to say that having checked it—it is only a question of simple division by two—the table is consistent both with the answer that was given by the Parliamentary Secretary on the 7th March, and with the reply to Deputy Lemass, and that it is not inconsistent with the answer which was given to Deputy Cogan on the 14th March to which reference has been made. It is a question of which yield you take. You can compile a table showing the year, then the acreage, then the tonnage delivered to the mills, and then the yields.

Now, we have two types of yield to deal with. One is the estimated yield per acre which is what, I think, every one in the House would mean by yield. But the Minister has chosen to divide the tonnage delivered to the mills by the acreage under wheat, and to call that the yield. I suppose in a sense it is the yield to the mills per acre. But here are the figures in tabular form.

WHEAT ACREAGES, DELIVERIES AND. ESTIMATED YIELDS.

Year | Acreage | Tonnage deliver- ed to mills | Cwts. per acre delivered | Cwts. estimated yield per acre

1932/33 | 21,388 | — | — | —

1933/34 | 50,491 | 16,425 | 6.50 | 21.0

1934/35 | 93,817 | 51,950 | 11.07 | 21.7

1935/36 | 163,473 | 121,550 | 14.87 | 21.9

1936/37 | 254,521 | 154,750 | 12.15 | 16.5

1937/38 | 220,263 | 129,870 | 11.79 | 17.0

1938/39 | 230,426 | 157,750 | 13.69 | 17.2

1939/40 | 255,280 | 189,370 | 14.83 | 20.0

1940/41 | 305,243 | 192,500 | 12.61 | 20.5

1941/42 | 463,206 | 221,250 | 9.55 | 18.8

1942/43 | 574,739 | 277,120 | 9.64 | 17.8

1943/44 | 509,245 | 257,500 | 10.11 | 17.1

1944/45 | 642,487 | 306,700 | 9.54 | 17.0

1945/46 | 662,498 | 354,620 | 10.70 | 17.3

1946/47 | 642,595 | 315,560 | 9.82 | 14.4

1947/48 | 579,646 | 182,900 | 6.31 | 10.8

1948/49 | 518,383 | 319,010 | 12.30 | 15.8

1949/50 | 362,805 | 303,750 | 16.74 | 19.9

1950/51 | 366,012 | 251,200 | 13.72 | 17.8

As the Minister is here, I should like to go into this matter with him. He says that our annual requirement is 520,000 tons, of which he would require 40,000 tons for seed wheat. That is the answer he gave to a question, and I am taking that as a basis for calculation.

Comment on this

400,000 tons for consumption, plus the seed wheat.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

The actual answer which the Minister gave on the occasion to which I refer was given to Deputy Walsh and is as follows:—

"The storage capacity required to store 12 months' requirements of millable and seed wheat amounts to approximately 520,000 tons, of which 480,000 tons is applicable to millable wheat and 40,000 tons is applicable to seed wheat."

I am taking that as our annual requirement for the purpose of examining the figures. We can take it for granted also that the Minister's figures in the answer he gave on the 22nd February, generally speaking, tally with the figures he gave in this debate. It all boils down to the fact then that the wheat at his hand, whether here or from outside, will just take him to the next harvest.

Comment on this

Will the Deputy appreciate that the wheat requirement depends on the extraction?

Comment on this
Major de Valera

I appreciate that.

Comment on this

And the traditional calculation has been one sack of flour per head of the population.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

I will bear that in mind. Meantime, I want to continue this sequence. I shall be glad if the Minister will assist me should I appear to ignore any factor. On the present basis of calculation, if I understand him correctly, he will go to next September. That means that, should there be any cutting off of supplies within the next six months, saving the elasticity that the Minister himself has mentioned, we would be dependent on the next harvest for all our requirements during the ensuing year. If the acreage is not increased above the acreage last year, as Deputy Walsh has pointed out, we will run out of wheat somewhere about May or June, perhaps a little later, of 1952, again subject to the elasticity available by restricting consumption and increasing extraction. I grant the Minister all that.

I think I have made a fair statement of the position. If that is a fair statement of the position we would want now to aim at an immediate production of somewhere in the region of 550,000 acres on that calculation but on examination that will be found not to be safe for two reasons. First of all, the calculation is based on an assumption of an average yield of one ton per acre; I mean now yield on the ground, not yield to the mill. On the figures supplied in the last column of this table that I have already read out that is too high an average yield to expect. I know that it was reached and exceeded in a few years, notably before the war. The last year in which it was exceeded or reached was 1940-41, but it seems to be too high an expectation altogether. Secondly, there must be an allowance for seed for the following harvest. That must be taken into the calculations. I can only talk about statistics and I must leave it to the farmers to calculate what will be required there. I suppose 10 per cent. might be a fair calculation in as far as such a calculation can be useful at all. It can only be a rough indication. But allowances must be made for seed.

In perusing these statistics there is another factor that must be taken into account; that factor is the tillage available during the war. As the Minister very well appreciates, on that calculation and assuming that our requirements have not changed very much over the years, as I do not think they have, we should have had ample wheat for all our requirements on the acreage under cultivation during the emergency and we should not have had to import anything. We know very well that we had in fact to import wheat. We know that our requirements were not met at home. The discrepancy will be found between the two last columns, what the Minister calls his working yield per acre and what the farmer might call his yield per acre, that is the estimated yield; in other words, all the wheat grown does not find its way into the millers granaries. It is significant to note that in the column on yield as given by the Minister, with the solitary exception of the year 1949-50, nowhere have the deliveries in the whole period from 1932 to the present time exceeded 15 cwt. per acre.

Comment on this

And rarely come near that.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

And, as the Minister has said, rarely come near that. In fact in 1949 where it does exceed it there was a corresponding collapse in oats prices. Possibly that has something to do with it. These figures mean, then, that our wheat requirement for practical purposes is apparently substantially in excess of the mill requirement; consequently, the acreage under wheat last year was wholly deficient from the security point of view. In the net, what I want to urge upon the Minister on foot of that argument is: supposing I concede to the Minister—and I must concede this since it is a cogent point— that there is elasticity and leeway to make up the deficiency by (a) possibly restricting consumption within certain limits, and (b) increasing extraction, then the Minister has that to make up on that side: but on the other side there is still a big void to fill and there is this discrepancy between yield per acre and yield to the mill, which I interpret as representative of wheat consumed by the farmer himself. If that is not what it means, what does it mean?

Comment on this

An excessively optimistic estimate by the farmers of the yield which they believe themselves to be getting.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

Who estimates these yields? I am dealing with official figures.

Comment on this

The county agricultural instructors, the Civic Guards and the farmers themselves in answering queries put to them at the time of census.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

Are we then to disregard the answer given by the Parliamentary Secretary to Deputy Cogan?

Comment on this

I think we are bound to discount substantially the estimated yield per acre of any cereal crop owing to the well-known tendency of farmers who are cross-questioned for the purpose of census returns not to admit that the yield of their crop has been lower than or inferior to that of a neighbour; and every neighbour is anxious to name a level yield which will not make him appear inferior to the next man who grows the same crop in his parish. The only reliable test we have are the deliveries to the mills; but, of course, to that you must add one percentage for retained grain either for human consumption or animal feeding.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

I am not competent, as the Minister will appreciate, to comment on that. I just do not know enough. I am merely working on the statistics. I must leave it to the people with first-hand knowledge to join issue with the Minister on that matter, if necessary. For my part, I accept his explanation. The point is, there must be a certain amount used up by the farmers for their own purposes. I understand the flour regulations were tightened up, and I take it all these things have a bearing on the matter.

Comment on this

Will the Deputy allow me to make one point? The figures of delivery to the mills per year are not altogether comparable as the proportion that may be retained each year may vary. When there is a shortage of bread and flour, a greater percentage is likely to be retained than when there is a plentiful supply.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

The Minister seems to corroborate Deputy Cogan to some extent. It is somewhat significant that in the years when oats were cheap there were bigger deliveries of wheat to the mill. That seems to suggest itself from the sequence of figures here. However, I am dealing with a set of statistics, and I will not pretend that I can deal with the matter from first-hand knowledge. Supposing, for the sake of argument, I take the Minister's yields, that only strengthens the argument I am advancing to him. I think he will appreciate that, because, if the yields are of the low order he talks about, and even conceding his point about extraction, it does seem to point then to a real urgency in increasing our wheat acreage to a self-sustaining figure.

Comment on this

What would that figure be?

Comment on this
Major de Valera

That is a fair question, but if the Minister's figures are right, as given to me, first, in taking the war yield, I was prepared to base myself on a minimum of round about what we had during the war. Now it is quite clear that it must be greater. This is something to which the Minister must give his attention. I am not concerned with what the Minister's view has been in the past. We have a specific situation to face in a specific set of circumstances. In regard to this most important item of human food, I urge that we should get as quickly as possible to the stage where we can say that, at a pinch, we are able to get by on such wheat as we can produce here. I think that from these figures it is not impossible. Even 660,000 acres under wheat during the war was not sufficient at the then rate of consumption on the then standards. On the other hand, we were never rationed for bread or flour during the war.

Comment on this

We ate 100 per cent. extraction.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

Quite true, and we could have afforded to tighten our belts a bit. These figures warrant us in saying that the target which I have asked the Minister to put before himself is feasible and attainable and within the practical regions of policy.

Comment on this

It would require between 800,000 and 900,000 acres of wheat.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

At the present rate of consumption? Is that the Minister's estimate?

Comment on this

Taking the figures during the war.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

I doubt if it would be as high as that. We used to estimate at that time about two-thirds and the average for the war was not as high as 600,000. These are niceties of arithmetic, very intriguing at times, but when one goes into such details one can overemphasise their importance. I want to point out that we are not in that position, that on all the evidence available, if supplies were cut off during the period before next harvest we would be in a very serious position for a year. Thereafter, having regard to the likely acreages for next year, unless some very energetic action is taken by the Minister, that precarious position will not only last for the year ensuing but will go into the next year as well.

Having regard to the over all situation, I think that is dangerous and I commend to the Minister to pay as urgent and energetic attention to that problem as he possibly can. If the worst were to come—and I do not want to be a Jeremiah about it—we could face a very serious and unmanageable situation indeed.

Comment on this

Not wishing to give the Deputy a short answer, what would he suggest should be done, except to pack the storage with wheat and plough as much land as we are able to plough?

Comment on this
Major de Valera

This year there has been the question of weather.

Comment on this

We could not sow it.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

This year has been difficult, but I think a lot of the difficulty has been due to a lack of foresight in the past two years—as I said before the Minister came in.

Comment on this

The farmers were not asked to grow wheat until the 1st of April—that is the whole secret.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

Next year the same thing might happen. These very same points were made by myself more generally last year and the Minister would not see what was before him. I know that the Taoiseach and the leaders of the Government formerly took one view and I suppose the Minister took line with them; but they have thrown over that one and with all their talk about difficult situations and difficult times ahead, coupled with the existing situation which the Minister has to face, it is time to cut out the talk and do something.

Comment on this

Does the Deputy realise that 50 per cent. more wheat was grown in this country this year than there was in 1939?

Comment on this
Major de Valera

Let us look at the figures. In 1939 there were 255,000 acres under wheat and in 1950-51 366,000 acres.

Comment on this

Look at the yield. The yield was 189,000 tons in 1939 and 251,000 tons now.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

That is to the mills?

Comment on this
Major de Valera

Even so, that does not answer my point. I am always ready, and so is everyone on this side, to concede that we were fortunate in many respects the last time and were not put to the pinch that a real emergency would require. We are all willing to admit that, but the fact that a kind Providence gave us the possibility of learning a lesson so painlessly is all the more reason why we should buckle down and see that such a weak position does not recur. The position was weak enough, in spite of the fact that the tillage under wheat in 1939 was something over ten times the tillage for 1932, when the Fianna Fáil Government took over. However, that is the past and what I am concerned about is the future.

Turning from the question of wheat, which is a staple food for the human, we had better look at potatoes. In the acreage there, there has not been any very spectacular change. Nevertheless, the acreage last year at 336,000 is down over the emergency years and is only very slightly greater than that of 1939. I am not going into the yields and acres there, but there is one thing I would mention, as a result of a question yesterday. I asked his colleague for some information in regard to chemicals likely to be essential and likely to be in short supply; and amongst those chemicals was copper sulphate, bluestone. When I turned up the statistics, I found that we imported in 1949, 2,730 tons and in 1950, 2,369 tons. I imagine that the bulk of that was used for agricultural purposes. I may be wrong and am open to correction, or even to be laughed at, if the point is a silly one. If it is not a silly one, it is high time we considered the question of adequate supplies of bluestone in case of a cut-off. The famine of '48 was, I understand, the result of blight. Will the Minister for Agriculture depend on such supplies? I wonder if the Minister is giving any attention to that problem. It is one that should receive attention under the present situation. The Minister appreciates why I raise the matter now. I was told that there was no other chemical beyond two already mentioned under active consideration. That and the other matters which I mentioned earlier really merit attention now.

It gets me back to what I was saying earlier—perhaps I should not repeat myself—when I was pressing upon the Minister, in his absence, the need for a basic fertiliser industry here. I was criticising him on the ground that it would have been better to aim at fertilising and maintaining the fertilisation of the land which we already had available, in priority to reclaiming other land. If there were funds available and while the chance was there, we should have been building up this basic industry for the provision of fertilisers. The raw materials can all be provided for, not only in current times but also for a considerable period of absolute isolation. That industry would be not only important to our agricultural economy, but it could be the nucleus about which a chemical industry would expand.

Comment on this

Is the Deputy referring to phosphates?

Comment on this
Major de Valera

I am referring to the whole lot.

Comment on this

We have to import potash.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

Let us deal with all that. What do we need? Phosphates in some form or another. In regard to phosphates, with a proper drive surely we could have been able to stockpile. I agree that that by itself is weak, but in this case it is justified: there is an emergency reserve in Clare. With regard to potash, you can get a certain amount of potash locally if you go about it. You could organise to get it. There are certain sources from which it could be got— kelp, say.

Comment on this

Seaweed. There is no need to reduce it to kelp.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

For the nitrogeneous fertilisers, you need fresh air and electric power.

Comment on this

Which means fresh air and coal.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

Power.

Comment on this

Which is coal.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

It is a question of co-ordination. You need sulphuric acid or, alternatively, you can, if you have power, use your phosphate rock and get phosphoric acid. In any event, there are pyrites there. It should not be beyond the power of man to get over these problems. If the Minister can put all his energy and drive into getting that industry established, I feel it will be a permanent benefit.

Comment on this

The matter of pyrites is being dealt with, but not the further matters, the manufacture of nitrogenous manures.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

I understand that sulphate of ammonia is being examined.

Comment on this

It is not. I will leave the matter that way.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

There is a very strong case, to my mind, for getting after this problem. We know from the last emergency and from what our common sense tells us, that that lacuna in our economy is a very serious one for us. The tragedy of the lost opportunity is that you would have been able to base a chemical industry with relation to your primary industry, which is agriculture, and service your other industrial needs as well.

Comment on this

If you can import the coal.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

There are other forms of power. Electric power could have been available. I am surprised to find the Minister turning to excuses. The Minister must realise that excuses are the easiest things to make. It is difficult to get anything done, but it is surprising how you can get it done if the job is tackled.

Comment on this

It is a question of whether we should or should not, and that is a matter for argument.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

I would be very glad to have all the considerations put before us, as we have had no statement from any Minister and no indication over the past year. I have personally asked a number of questions and all I can elicit from the Minister for Industry and Commerce is that the matter is under consideration. If the Minister will be good enough to furnish us with information upon which we can join issue more specifically, I will be grateful.

We talked about storage. I confess I am not quite clear as to what the position is. It was a big problem the last time and it will be interesting to find out where we stand in regard to that problem now. Again, there is the problem of mechanisation.

Comment on this

I am afraid the Deputy has not read my White Paper.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

Yes, I have.

Comment on this

I think it is mentioned there.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

There are a number of things mentioned. Perhaps the deficiency may be in me. Nevertheless, it is a very important matter. The next thing is the question of the mechanisation of agriculture. I think we were agreed last year that a certain tendency in that direction is inevitable under modern conditions. It is very hard to go against the tide, but it does in itself pose a problem, a problem in regard to parts, in regard to equipment, in regard to fuel for tractors and so forth. The Minister was sympathetic when the matter was mentioned last year. If he has anything further to add to that, it would be of interest.

I have talked on this Estimate exclusively from two points of view, as I said in the beginning. I talked from the point of view of the consumer in the city on certain problems and thereafter dealt with the general situation. I was concerned with the possibility of facing an emergency in the future. That was my approach. I think it is a justifiable approach now and I think the Minister is not now going to say I am an alarmist.

If that is to be our approach, it finally gets me back on general policy to the Minister's statement which I quoted. The Minister will recollect that in opening the debate he said that he did not want to limit our live stock to the capacity of our own lands to produce and he visualised the taking in of raw materials for processing and then exporting the live stock. I indicated that I joined issue with him in that respect, even on the basis of normal economics, and said I thought it was dangerous to take that point of view at present, if the result is going to be excessive dependence on outside and if it is to be achieved at the expense of that self-reliance about which I am pressing him now. In making this case, I am trying to do so as objectively as I can. It is not a matter of saying: "We told you so"; or of scoring a point for the moment. There is a big national problem there, a problem which in the interest of the country, must be solved as rapidly as possible.

I want to suggest in connection with this question of the balance of food supplies that, when the increase in butter prices and the rumoured increase in bread prices takes place, that the Minister bear in mind the increases in jam and margarine which have already taken place. In saying that, I wish to put before him for consideration in a nut shell the problem of the consumer in the town in relation to that over-all and admittedly difficult problem which he has. I can appreciate his problem in regard to milk and the danger to the consumer of failing supplies, and the argument even from the consumer's point of view for increasing the price of milk so as to ensure the consumer's supplies. Nevertheless, there is this specific problem for the town consumer, and if bread is likely to go up as jam and margarine have gone up, and if butter is to go up, I should like the Minister to take it into account and do what he can.

While talking about butter, he made some reference to me and to my representations in that matter. He may not recollect it now.

Comment on this

Perfectly.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

I was not aware that it was on my representations that he tried to meet the city situation by making more available. I should like to be courteous and to say that that is appreciated. I am sorry that it cannot be continued, but in relation to that problem also where the whole country is involved, again I should like him to take the town aspect into consideration as well as the other.

Comment on this

It is hoped next year that, if the necessity to import butter arises, the imported butter will be distributed exclusively off the ration and the Irish butter entirely on the ration.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

That even is something. In any event, I can leave it at this, if the Minister will look on me as still urging my point of view as strongly as I can but, I hope, as reasonably as I can.

There is another conclusion which might be one for the Minister to reply to. His colleague, the Minister for Industry, mentioned mutton when I spoke about beef, but it is rather interesting to find a rather big decline in the quantity of cattle consumed at home.

Comment on this

Bear in mind the consumption of bacon.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

Yes, but I do not think that will answer it completely.

Comment on this

That is my information.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

The first reaction on seeing it was that it was an offshoot of the problem of the butchers and so forth, about which we have been hearing so much.

Comment on this

That occurred to me, but my advice is that it has to do with the consumption of bacon.

Comment on this
Major de Valera

On the fat and protein end of diet, there is certainly a problem. We have margarine, butter and meat problems but again I can leave it by asking that the townsman's point of view will not be overlooked, particularly because in this debate all the problems which confront the Minister in his very difficult task naturally tend to be looked at from the point of view of the farmer.

I can leave the rest of the debate to people more competent to deal with its details than I am. I purposely tried to deal with it in the over-all sense. There is no use in our talking about preparing for the future; there is no use in talking about defence; and there is no use in trying to build up our people or to provide for them in the difficult time that is coming—it may be that there may be no calamity and let us hope there will not be; I should like to believe that there will not, but whatever is in front of us there is going to be difficulty and the Minister will agree that there is a period of difficulty ahead of us-without the self-reliant approach which I urge. I think it is best for our people in any event, and, in spite of the Minister's former views we can point to the facts in regard to one emergency as justifying those who took that view in the past. No matter what our predilections might be, the hard facts of the present situation dictate one approach, and I think we should be all agreed upon that now.

Comment on this

I want to pay certain tributes to the Minister and to make certain criticisms and appeals to him. During the past few days we have heard people—shopkeepers, solicitors, barristers and publicans— telling us how prosperous the agricultural community are, and I think we were told that some of them even have motor-cars. There are certain aspects of this matter which we should consider carefully and seriously on this Estimate. Some of these people probably spoke sincerely and honestly and others may have spoken with ulterior motives. I will go into the details in the near future, but there is one person who gave expression to certain views yesterday, a person who is qualified in many ways to give such an expression of views so far as the agricultural community is concerned whom I should like to quote. I refer to the co-adjutor Bishop of Cork, Dr. Lucey, who is a very brilliant man. He is a bishop and has special knowledge of rural conditions by reason of the fact that he is a member of the Emigration Commission and has heard all the evidence placed before that commission. He said yesterday as reported in the Cork Examiner of to-day:—

"How often do we not hear expressions like: ‘Oh, he is only an "ould" farmer': ‘the farmer does nothing but grumble': ‘what is the world coming to with farmers buying motor-cars, if you please.' Until we get over the notion that farming is less respectable than trading, working in a Government office, being a civil servant, etc., we are not valuing the farmer at his true worth to God and the community."

Later on he says:—

"I don't want any levelling down of the townsman's wage to the country rate—God forbid. The townsman's wages are low enough God knows. But I do want a levelling up of the country labourer's wages to the urban standard. And that can come only by way of a just price for milk, eggs, pigs, poultry—the produce of mixed or genuine farming. At the moment the prices for these commodities are too low to give the farmer himself or his man the standard of living others in the community have."

I think that that is an answer to the gentlemen who prate here about the tremendous prosperity which the farmers are enjoying.

We heard a great deal about subsidies. We were told that the farmers are being subsidised to the extent of something like £10,000,000 a year. Let us analyse that statement. Where do the subsidies come from? They come from the general community—from the taxpayers and from the consumers. It will be seen, therefore, that the farmers themselves are contributing a large portion towards those subsidies. In addition, the agricultural community are paying a heavy land tax. That tax is called "annuities" but at the moment it is a land tax.

According to the Minister for Agriculture, the farming industry is subsidising the leather industry or the bootmakers industry, I do not know which, to the extent of approximately £2,000,000 a year. I believe that that is correct because the price of hides is artifically depressed in this country.

There is a subsidy on butter. The Minister himself and every reasonable man must admit that that subsidy is a consumer's subsidy because there is a general price for butter in this country which is higher than the subsidised price for butter.

There are many other respects in which the agricultural community are paying—and they are paying colossally more for subsidies to somebody else than the subsidies which are being paid to them.

Under the present Party Government we have a lovely idea—it was very successfully worked by the previous Government and now it is being successfully worked by the present Government—and that is to bribe the people with their own money, after deducting a considerable percentage for administrative expenses, something on the scale of the sweepstakes. Once upon a time it was illegal to bribe a voter with the candidate's money. However, a much better system has been found and that is to bribe the voter with his own money and to pocket the rest of it for the Exchequer. I am afraid that in the case of the present Government, as in the case of the previous Government, we have had an indication on several occasions of this urban or Dublin mentality which has affected any piece of legislation affecting agriculture in this country. Recently the Minister for Industry and Commerce put himself on record as saying that if we were to adopt the collective farming scheme, advocated by Deputy Cowan, the farmers would be a much lesser draw on the Exchequer—in spite of the fact that this is an agricultural country and that the only real wealth we have in this country is the wealth produced by the agricultural community. The Minister for Industry and Commerce tells us that if we adopt Deputy Cowan's system of collective farming the farmers will then be a lesser draw on the community as a whole.

I think that the Minister, as a Minister of a democratic Government, was wrong in refusing to meet a group of people who claim to represent the dairying industry. The Minister— rather bad-manneredly, I think—told the people that he would not meet the Creamery Milk Suppliers' Association but that he would treat with the I.A.O.S. Last year the Minister said that unless his lovely scheme of 2d. a gallon less for milk over a period of five years was accepted, some very terrible results would fall upon the dairy farmers of the country. When the Minister wanted the I.A.O.S. to impose that proposal and that scheme on the country, what did the I.A.O.S. do? They held a meeting in Plunkett House and they said: "We are an organisation to set up co-operative societies. It is none of our function to deal with the matter of price. Our function is to give advise in respect of the formation of co-operative societies and to give what technical advice we can give afterwards—but we have nothing to do with the matter of price." Nevertheless, the Minister refused to meet the Creamery Milk Suppliers' Association, and said that he would deal with the I.A.O.S., who made that decision less than 12 months ago.

The Minister has also said that the costs of milk production have not increased since 1947. It is possible that the Minister may seriously believe that statement but if the Minister believes it I may say that nobody else does. The Minister has claimed in this House that he has increased agricultural wages by 33 per cent., that he has given an annual holiday to the farm workers and also that a weekly half-holiday is being given to them. The Minister must realise that these three steps in themselves must of necessity increase the costs of production. In reply to two questions which I put to the Minister he said: "There will be no increase in the price of milk this year." Yet, a couple of days after giving me that reply the Minister announced that the price of milk was going to be increased.

Comment on this

Does the Deputy purport to quote my reply?

Comment on this

I propose to paraphrase the Minister's reply.

Comment on this

The Deputy must not do that.

Comment on this

I certainly may.

Comment on this

If you say that you are paraphrasing my reply—but not otherwise.

Comment on this

I can say that on two occasions in this House the Minister told me that he would not agree to any increase this year in the price of milk.

Comment on this

Now the sails are being trimmed.

Comment on this

That is a fact. However, the Minister then came and offered an increase. After meeting the people who told us last year that they had nothing to do with the matter of price, the Minister came and increased the price by 1d. a gallon.

Since this debate stasted the Minister has, on a number of occasions, said: "£1,000,000 a year is a great deal for the farmers." Everybody knows that the farmers are not getting £1,000,000 a year. The Minister knows that since 1947 the costs of manufacturing milk in creameries have increased. The Minister knows that they are increasing again this year.

The Ministier must be aware that the managers have applications to the Labour Court in respect of increased wages for creamery employees. The Minister must be aware that the price of packing and the price of packets and of everything else in the creamery is going up. Surely, in these circumstances, the Minister must realise that the increase of ¾d. or 1d. a gallon will be swamped in the extra charges that have occurred already, and that will continue to occur, before the end of the year, and that the extra money will not go into the pockets of the farmers at all. It is part of the propaganda however of the urban-minded people in this House to increase the price of butter by 2d. a lb. and say: "That is more of the stuff the farmers are sucking out of us" while at the same time the increase is only enough to pay some of the increased costs of manufacture, some of which were imposed by the Government and some by circumstances completely outside the control of the committees running the creameries.

A very famous quotation was mentioned to-day and I would like to add to it: there are lies, damn lies, statistics and the Minister quoting Professor Murphy's costings. The Minister has on several occasions misquoted in a most dishonest way a scientific document prepared by a professor in University College, Cork. The Minister is a man of ability and must know that he was misinterpreting him and every officer of his Department must know that too.

Deputy Desmond speaking on this Estimate said that he had found a solution for the farmers' difficulties. His solution was not 1d., 2d. or 3d. per gallon but that everybody should get cows like those Mr. Quill had in Blarney. I am afraid that Deputy Desmond will find it difficult to get the Minister to agree to that because the cows Mr. Quill had in Blarney happened to be Friesians and the Minister said that it was only cranks and old maids that keep these Pekinese breeds.

I asked the Minister a very simple question to-day. It was:—

"To ask the Minister for Agriculture whether he has made an Order to prevent milk, other than pasteurised milk, from being offered for sale in any specified area in the State."

Any sane man would think that the answer to that was yes or no. The second part of the question was:—

"If he has not made an Order in such case, whether he will give an assurance that he will not do so?"

Any sane man would think that the answer to that was yes or no, too, but instead of that the Minister gave me a big rigmarole and started by making this statement:

"It has been suggested that there was some delay on my part in replying to this question. There is no foundation for this allegation."

Comment on this

You put down the question wrong and they could not find you for ten days to correct it.

Comment on this

The Minister made that statement; I asked the Minister who made the allegation and the Minister said that I had. I told the Minister that I had not, that I had made no such allegations at all. I put down the question more than ten days ago in a different form and the Ceann Comhairle disallowed it. The clerk in the Ceann Comhairle's office came to me yesterday and told me that the Ceann Comhairle had disallowed the question. I should like the Minister to explain why he said that I made the allegation that there was a delay on his part in replying; I never made any such allegation. However, yes or no is what I am looking for and this is the rigmarole:—

"I might add to the reply just given to the same question by the Minister for Health that there is, of course, no question of genuine opposition by the public...."

I do not think I should bore the House with that, but the final paragraph states—because the Minister must have a crack at somebody:—

"I cannot believe that the Deputy is prepared to characterise himself as an advocate of the sale of tubercular milk."

That is the answer to my question asking whether he had made an Order —that I am an advocate for the sale of tubercular milk. However, we will leave it at that.

On the question of pigs there is one matter for which I should like to pay a tribute to the Minister, that is for the courageous action he took in opening the Border for the export of pigs at the time when the bacon curers were trying to hold the producers up to ransom. They wanted cheap pigs and dear bacon. I know that it was a difficult and courageous thing for the Minister to do and I want to say that we thank him and that we appreciate the courageous action he took.

The price of pigs was controlled on the 2nd December by the Prices Advisory Body but shortly afterwards the control on the price of pig feeding-stuffs was removed.

Comment on this

I do not think that the price of pigs was controlled.

Comment on this

I think it was. The price of bacon was controlled and that pegs down at a certain level the price of pigs. It depressed the price of pigs while at the same time the Advisory Body took the control off the raw material for the feeding of pigs and there is something wrong about that.

Comment on this

The Deputy will agree that the price of pigs was not controlled?

Comment on this

It affects the price of pigs. The price of bacon was controlled on the 2nd December and that pegs the price of pigs down to their 2nd December price but the price of the raw materials which were being put into the pigs was decontrolled. The price of the raw materials can soar as high as it likes but the price of pigs is kept down.

Comment on this

What is the price of pigs to-day?

Comment on this

It is down to the 2nd December price in Cork but I agree that it may be higher in Dublin.

Comment on this

It is 235/-.

Comment on this

With regard to eggs, I hope that the Minister will be successful in making a satisfactory agreement in England. I can tell him that there is very grave dissatisfaction throughout the country at the existing price of eggs and I think that the Minister is quite well aware of that himself. I hope that he will succeed in making a decent agreement which will give some sort of reasonable remuneration to the people who are trying to produce eggs.

The only thing I have against the Minister in that regard is the fact that he publicly said that 2d. was a good price for an egg. I thought he was terribly indiscreet on that occasion. It was also very unfortunate that the price of eggs should fall and that the price of meal should increase at the same time, particularly when the Minister had given an assurance that devaluation would not affect the price of meal and that the price of meal would not increase in the foreseeable future.

Comment on this

What will the Deputy say if the price of eggs goes up and the price of meal comes down?

Comment on this

I will have great pleasure in coming in and congratulating the Minister.

Comment on this

You will not have a chance.

Comment on this

Would you join in, if you got one?

Comment on this

I will not have a chance.

Comment on this

Would Deputy Corry join him if he got the chance?

Comment on this

I always thanked the Minister for any good he did——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

No further interruptions. Please allow Deputy Lehane to continue.

Comment on this

——but I got very few opportunities, for he did no good.

Comment on this

We have heard a great deal from Deputy de Valera on the question of wheat. I do not want to delay too long about it, but the Minister has admitted that it is difficult to grow satisfactory wheat, due to the climatic conditions.

Comment on this

Adequate quantities of satisfactory wheat.

Comment on this

What the Minister said—Volume 125, column 835— was:—

"The second lesson that we may learn, with advantage, from our trying experience is the folly of pretending that, in a climate such as ours, we can with any degree of certainty depend on our domestic production of wheat..."

The Minister, having admitted that because of our climatic conditions it was very difficult to grow any sort of decent wheat in this country, has made a definite statement. A number of people, both on this side and on the other side of the House, have made a very great error in talking about an increase in the price of wheat. There is no increase in the price of wheat bushelling a standard weight.

Comment on this

I take it that it was unintentionally the Deputy broke off his quotation in the middle of a sentence.

Comment on this

I gave the column from which I quoted.

Comment on this

But not the full sentence.

Comment on this

I merely wanted to quote that portion about the climate.

Comment on this

The Deputy broke off the quotation in the middle of the sentence.

Comment on this

I did, when I got to the part I wanted.

Comment on this

It is scarcely customary to do that.

Comment on this

However, there is no increase in the price of wheat.

Comment on this

May I trouble the Deputy to finish the quotation, at least to the next full stop?

Comment on this

Read the full page.

Comment on this

Will the Minister tell me when to stop? Here is the quotation:—

"The second lesson that we may learn, with advantage, from our trying experience is the folly of pretending that, in a climate such as ours, we can with any degree of certainty depend on our domestic production of wheat for our essential bread supplies."

Comment on this

The point I am coming to is that the price of wheat bushelling 57 lb. is still the same this year as it was last year. The Minister has admitted that our climate is not conducive to good wheat growing, or the growing of good quality wheat, so actually there is no increase in the price of wheat of standard weight, but we may anticipate there will be a reduction in the price of wheat below 57 lb., because the regulations will probably be enforced more stringently than in the past. But, apart from that, wheat bushelling 57 lb. this year as last year can be purchased, or will be purchased, for £25 a ton——

Comment on this

Agreed.

Comment on this

——and at the same time producers of live-stock products and poultry products are expected to pay £32 or £33 a ton for maize. I am afraid it is very difficult to get people to market wheat at £25 a ton or even, if it bushels 62 lb., at £27 a ton, and buy a mixture of one part maize and three parts sorghums for £32. I do not think the Minister is doing what he says he is doing, that is, getting wheat grown by price inducement, because there is no price inducement in growing wheat to produce flour and bran at £30 a ton when it is out of proportion with the price of the animal feeding stuffs on the market.

The Minister has referred to certain problems in the West, particularly problems where cattle got certain diseases that it took the veterinary officers a long time to discover. They found that by shifting them from the island to the mainland, and vice versa, they were able to get over some of the difficulties. The Minister said he had great regard for some of the views of the old people in the area, because they had learned in the old and tried school of experience. Since the Minister is in that frame of mind, I may tell him that the people in West Cork have a similar idea about sea sand and, so far the Cork County Committee of Agriculture cannot learn much from the Department. At least, what they have learned is that the scheme had to be dropped this year.

Comment on this

The Deputy will be consoled to know that I agree with the old people of West Cork in respect of sea sand.

Comment on this

May I take it that the scheme in Cork has been approved?

Comment on this

At this stage I do not propose to elaborate my observation.

Comment on this

Then you agree with the old people to whom I have referred? Thanks. There is one matter I should like to mention, and it has reference to ground limestone. I am afraid the Minister has not found the solution for this. The Minister has passed over transport of the ground limestone completely to Córas Iompair Éireann. Córas Iompair Éireann come along and dump the ground limestone on the side of the road. I suppose it is the Minister's idea that some local lad should buy a lime spreader and shovel six tons of lime into the spreader and take it out to the field, perhaps one or two miles away. I think the Minister is not handling that situation in the way it should be handled. The Minister should give the benefit of the subsidy to anybody with a lime spreader who is prepared to take the lime from the depot. It rather looks as if the present system is wasteful and as if the Minister is subsidising Córas Iompair Éireann rather than the farmer, because in many cases the Córas Iompair Éireann lorries may not go within a mile or two miles of the farmer's field, as they will not leave the public road; they will not go on any small byroad.

Comment on this

I think they go on any hard road.

Comment on this

I have my doubts. I know they do not do it in other cases where manures and beet are concerned; it is taken on to the main road.

Comment on this

Has the Deputy any complaint to make? Have any complaints reached the Deputy's ear on that score?

Comment on this

There were a number.

Comment on this

I would be glad to have particulars, so that I can deal with them.

Comment on this

I will be glad to give them. The Minister referred to water supplies on the farmers' holdings. I wonder is there any use in appealing to the Minister about cases of farmers who carried out work after the Minister announced he was introducing this scheme? The farmers got the work done and because they did not wait for sanction from the Department they were cut out of the grant. Will their cases be considered? It can be proved conclusively that the work was done within certain dates and there was a period of only a few months between the Minister's announcement that the scheme was going ahead and the time when they put it into operation. Will the Minister give sympathetic consideration to the cases of those people so that they can be brought within the scheme?

Comment on this

In general principle, no, but every individual case where an element of doubt exists is always considered sympathetically.

Comment on this

There is one other point and that is in connection with some of the creameries or milk producing areas in West Cork. The Minister was down there for the by-election and he promised them creamery facilities. There are certain districts in that area where facilities should be provided. There are numbers of people who had not creamery facilities and who were making farmers' butter at the particular time when the subsidy was removed. There is a grave need for a separating station, at least, on Whiddy Island. That is one thing that might be done. There will be plenty of milk on the Island if they get facilities.

Comment on this

Is that not in the Drinagh Co-operative Society's area?

Comment on this

It is in Bantry Bay. I do not know how far out in the Bay the Drinagh Co-operative Society extends, but the island is in Bantry Bay, and it is quite close to the Dairy Disposals Board. I appeal to the Minister to give due consideration to these people. They are in a bad way and they desire a creamery.

Comment on this

Proposals have been made.

Comment on this

I am aware of it, but they are quite unsatisfactory proposals.

Comment on this

I thought they were pretty good.

Comment on this

They are quite unsatisfactory. I move to report progress.

Comment on this