Vote 6—Office of the Minister for Finance.
Contributions 1–204 of 394. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
I move:—
That a sum not exceeding £99,700 be granted to complete the sum necessary to defray the Charge which will come in course of payment during the year ending the 31st day of March, 1952, for the Salaries and Expenses of the Office of the Minister for Finance, including the Paymaster-General's Office.
Comment on this
On a point of order. I want to direct the attention of the Chair to the fact that the Minister is commencing at 20 minutes to five o'clock.
Comment on this
Sir, the introduction of the Estimate for the Department of Finance is the first formal opportunity I have had of giving to the Dáil and the public the preliminary results of the review of the financial situation which I have been making since I came into office. My review will not be exhaustive because I shall have to limit my statement this evening to an exposition of facts, trends and desiderata. It will be granted, I think, in that connection that careful consideration of the various aspects of the situation and a close study of developments, must precede any attempt to formulate remedial measures.
My immediate purpose, therefore, is merely to draw attention at this stage to the seriousness of the situation and to foreshadow the difficulties which it will create for all of us. Some of what I shall say has already been said by my predecessor in his Budget statement, but it may be advantageous to put it in sharper relief and supplement it with more up-to-date information.
In my view, four features of our present situation clamour for discussion. They are, first, the character and adequacy of the current year's Budget; secondly, the problem presented by an unwieldy programme of capital expenditure; thirdly, our trading position with the rest of the world as reflected in the balance of payments between ourselves as a community and our debtors and our creditors; and, fourthly, the rapid dissipation of our external assets.
Before discussing these elements in a general situation it may be advisable to say a word or two about inflation, and to remind the Dáil and the country what inflation is and what the consequences of a prolonged inflation will inevitably be. The best known if somewhat hackneyed definition of a state of inflation is, "too much money chasing too few goods". That is a definition which every economic neophyte recites when he wishes to pontificate on a very complex problem.
Comment on this
Would the Deputy apply that to the late Minister for External Affairs? The definition is too simple, however, to be comprehensive or wholly accurate. In our case, since we have reserves of sterling and are able to draw on them to bring in more goods than our current earnings will buy, we can let the first impact of excessive spending fall to a considerable extent on imports and, therefore, avoid its immediate impingement on our monetary system by taking the first brunt on the balance of payments, but, nevertheless, this excessive spending exercises a powerful influence on our domestic costs and prices and provokes eventually an extremely unfavourable reaction.
The consequences of an "import" inflation are ultimately as serious as a purely "price" inflation. If it were allowed to continue, it would quickly exhaust our external assets; it would lower the external as well as the internal value of our currency, and would give rise to all those social and economic evils and maladjustments which are inevitably consequent upon an uncontrolled increase in the value, or rather I should say, the volume of money.
Comment on this
The Minister has the right to read his statement if he wants to. He has the statement there. It may be that he is short-sighted like myself, but he is misreading it.
Comment on this
I shall leave the Deputy alone. He has to play the rôle of perpetual nuisance. Unfortunately, the Deputy's talents are not equal to the Deputy's pretensions and, therefore, people no longer take him seriously.
Comment on this
On a point of order. If the Minister is reading his speech he is doing so without the permission of the House.
Comment on this
The Minister should be allowed to make his statement without interruption. The Deputy will get an opportunity to speak later.
Comment on this
The Minister should have the manners to sit down while a point of order is being made.
Comment on this
Surely, the House is entitled to have a ruling on the point of order.
Comment on this
I made a point of order that if the Minister wishes to read a statement, which was probably prepared by somebody else, he can only do so with the permission of the House.
Comment on this
I have made a point of order. I have no objection to the Minister reading a statement, but he should have the manners to ask for permission.
Comment on this
According to the rules of this House, that is a matter entirely for the Minister himself.
Comment on this
I am not reading a statement. I have prepared what I am about to say and I am quite entitled to refresh my memory from my notes. If Deputy Davin is not capable of doing that sort of thing, then he should keep silent. I was pointing out that the whole purpose of these interjections and interruptions was to prevent an ordered statement being made in the House because the one thing which the members of the last Government fear is that there should be an impartial and unbiased examination of the position in which they have landed the people of this country. The perilous position in which they placed us has left us defenceless on every front, not merely on the strategic front but on the economic front, on the diplomatic as well as the economic front. I was saying, if I may be permitted to repeat myself, that if "import" inflation were permitted to continue, it would quickly exhaust our external assets. It would lower the external as well as the internal value of our currency and would give rise to all those social and economic evils and maladjustments which are inevitably consequent upon an uncontrolled increase in the volume of money. I hope that has sunk into the minds of the Deputies opposite. This, as I was about to say, is our present peril. It is, let me emphasise, the direct result of the policy pursued over the past two years.
Before I proceed to relate public finance to the wider context of national income and expenditure and to consider the part the Budget should play as a moulding influence, there is something that must be said, first of all, about the mere arithmetic of the recent Budget. I should like again to remind the House that this Budget was not of my framing. In order that the business of the State might be carried on, it was necessary for me to take over the Department of Finance as a going concern and to endeavour to administer its affairs as best I could, within the limitations which had been imposed upon me by the commitments of the previous Government. Therefore, the Budget which I now propose to examine briefly is, as I want to emphasise, not my Budget. It is, as has been said, a poor thing, but, thank God, it is not my own.
No one with even a rudimentary acquaintance with economics should be complacent about Budget deficits in present circumstances. I think that all will concede that, in an inflationary situation such as exists in the world to-day, the least the State should do is to refrain from making things worse. Yet the country is faced to-day with the likelihood of a large deficit this year on the current Budget. I regret to say, having regard to the fine tradition which obtained up to recently in the administration and control of the Department of Finance, this position must have been patent to my predecessor last May, even though he failed to take the measures necessary to avoid it. Budget deficits are definitely inflationary in their consequences. They entail borrowing or the creation of money for completely unproductive purposes; in other words, they necessitate either the diversion of savings from productive use in order to meet current outgoings, or the injection of new purchasing power into circulation without any offsetting increase in the supply of goods.
Comment on this
No doubt the Dáil will recall that my predecessor, Deputy McGilligan, contrived to make current revenue and expenditure balance on paper at the £81,000,000 level. "Contrived" is a good word to use in that connection for he allowed an entirely inadequate sum, only £1,500,000, for uncovered items, although he had good reason to believe that the total of these would far exceed that amount. Moreover, he again adopted this year, as in last year, the highly questionable device of treating as proper to be met from borrowing as much as £12,000,000 of voted expenditure. Most of this expenditure is of a recurrent or unrealisable character and most of it contributes little or nothing to offset the cumulative charge on the Exchequer for the relevant borrowings.
The uncovered items of which my predecessor had forewarning included increases in pay for the Civil Service, Garda Síochána, Army and teachers, the subsidy to cover the losses of Córas Iompair Eireann, the improvement in old age and blind pensions and additional grants to the Tourist Board and other commitments.
Comment on this
The House dealt with Deputy Dillon last night and he ought to have learned his lesson.
Comment on this
The Minister ought to be allowed to make his statement without interruption. Deputies will get an opportunity later of speaking.
Comment on this
Deputies opposite do not want this to get into the newspapers. Even the additions I have already mentioned and which have materialised will amount to well over £5,000,000 this year. To this sum, there must be added the cost to the Exchequer of the recent increase in creamery milk prices and the provision which must be made for writing off the arrears of fuel subsidy and the loss on Deputy Dillon's imported butter. A moderate estimate indeed of the commitments not provided for in the published Estimates would, I think, be £6,250,000, towards which £1,500,000 has been allocated to the Budget. Apparently my predecessor had some hope of repeating the miracle of the loaves and fishes. He hoped to make £1,500,000 do the work of £6,250,000. There is, however, this gap of virtually £5,000,000 already manifesting itself in the balance of the present Budget.
Comment on this
One may say that at the date on which the Budget was introduced a gap of some millions at least was foreseen by my predecessor. But it is remarkable—or is it remarkable?—perhaps it is just what we would expect from the record of the late Coalition—that the country was not told about these amounts that were uncovered by the Budget. Instead, it was assured that the Budget, which was introduced immediately before the last general election, would show a surplus at the end of the year of £50,000. The Deputy who, as Minister for Finance, was responsible for the presentation of that false and misleading account to the people of this country is the Deputy who alleged last week that certain State documents had been mutilated.
Apart from the fact that the provision of £1,500,000 for foreseen items was grossly inadequate, no allowance whatever was made by my predecessor for Supplementary Estimates in respect of expenditure not foreseen at Budget time. I suppose that in due course he will come into the House and plead, in extenuation of that omission, that he was relying upon the buoyancy of the Budget. In view, however, of the international situation, it is very doubtful if any hopes that the revenue will greatly exceed expenditure will be realised. It is, unfortunately, very probable, on the other hand, that expenditure will exceed the revenue by many millions of pounds. So much for the character and adequacy of the current Budget.
Let us now consider the problem of our capital expenditure. The desirability of meeting capital expenditure in a way that will not stimulate inflation is self-evident. I hope that even that fact will be conceded by Deputy Dillon, but the prospect, I regret to say, of doing this is unfortunately very dim. We may leave aside for another occasion the question whether all the expenditure included in the capital Budget is genuinely productive. I have already indicated that, in my view, much of it cannot be relied upon to add in any material degree to the income of the nation or the State. I think that my predecessor shared this view also, and with good reason. In his Budget statement, he admitted—and here, Sir, I propose to read—"that a considerable proportion of the State investment programme relates to projects which are not productive in the financial sense."
Comment on this
"And that the growth of State expenditure on capital projects which are not directly remunerative carries with it the risk that the increased debt charges will entail a net addition to taxation."
Comment on this
It is from the Financial Statement and the relative columns can be determined by the Deputy himself.
Comment on this
On a point of order, if a Deputy purports to quote precise words used, there is upon him an obligation to furnish the House with the reference. So far as I know, the Minister did not profess to paraphrase but professed to quote Deputy McGilligan.
Comment on this
The Deputy who last night was posing here in the House in the role of injured innocence now assumes the role of mosquito.
Comment on this
If the House will bear with me, I will very speedily get the reference. I should say that the quotation itself was taken from the document which was circulated to the House on the occasion of the Minister's Budget speech.
Comment on this
Just like Deputy Walsh, the Minister for Agriculture, who, when he was a Deputy, was very handy for finding out these things.
Comment on this
As the Minister has given the volume or the number of the volume, is that not sufficient as a reference?
Comment on this
The Minister has done nothing of the sort. He should treat this House with courtesy.
Comment on this
Would Deputy O'Hara wait for a moment? It is Volume 125, column 1904, a notable year as the year of Deputy Dillon's birth. It is a pity he does not show his age.
Comment on this
Well, I cannot say that the two years have added anything to the Deputy's store of wisdom or experience.
Comment on this
This is a point on which the Opposition should be exposed to the House. In that connection, I might be permitted, with the Deputies' agreement, to quote from the hallowed words of my predecessor, who said:—
"The growth of State expenditure on capital projects which are not directly remunerative carries with it the risk that the increased debt charges will entail a net addition to taxation."
Having said that, may I show that the statement was well-founded— because, in fact, the service of debt in the present year will cost £7,350,000, or £3,130,000 more than in 1947-48? Perhaps, with this figure of £3,130,000 on our mind, we may digress for a moment and pause to contemplate what our position would have been if our predecessors had not imposed on us the obligation to tax the people in order to provide this considerable sum. It is tantalising to think that if that £3,000,000 odd were available for tax reduction in this year, the rate of income-tax might be reduced to 5/6 in the £.
Comment on this
The duty on beer might be lowered by 2d. per pint or perhaps the price of a packet of 20 cigarettes might be 1/6 instead of 1/8 as is normal to-day. Looked at in another way, we might remind ourselves that the £3,130,000 of taxation which our predecessors left us to find for the service of the national debt, as compared with the figure for that purpose in 1947-48, would meet the cost of the recent increases in Civil Service remuneration and the increases in pay of the Garda Síochána and the national teachers. Or, if we like to look at it in another way, if we had that £3,000,000 odd available it could have been used to cover wholly by subsidy the recent increase in the cost of milk—which I think a Fine Gael Deputy alleges is not sufficient—and would not only cover the recent increase in the cost of milk and butter, but it would leave over at least £2,000,000 to reduce considerably the price of other subsidised commodities.
Comment on this
Unfortunately, Sir, the contemplation of these happy conditions cannot in present circumstances be more than a day-dream from which we must now awake. Our predecessors, having created the present state of affairs, have left us to deal with its harsh realities. The £3,130,000 with which so much could be done to alleviate the lot of the taxpayer is not, unfortunately, available to us. Far indeed from it. It has to be raised by us to meet the charges on the public debt which was so recklessly contracted by the late Government in its three short years of office. To console us, when we are labouring under this obligation, we have the fact that in the last financial year an outlay of £8,100,000 of borrowed money for supply services produced a return to the Exchequer of one-eighth of 1 per cent. I leave it to the members of the Opposition to work that sum out in terms of pounds, shilling and pence.
Comment on this
It is not a bad criterion to apply either to a person's private affairs or national affairs. I am perfectly sure if Deputy Dillon was dealing with his own private concerns that that is the invariable rule he would apply. He would say to himself: "If I make such and such an investment what am I going to get back from it in terms of dividend, profit or interest?"
Comment on this
Without money, men, women and children cannot live and when resources have been squandered——
Comment on this
——the people whose resources have melted away as they have over the past three years will have to suffer very severely. It will not, of course, be Deputy Hickey or Deputy Dillon who will suffer. It will be the under-dog.
Comment on this
I could develop this theme very profitably, but I wish to revert to a consideration of the financial problems which will present themselves to us by reason of the expenditure to which we have been committed. In that connection I want to stress first of all that the segregation of expenditure as between current and capital has only a limited significance. Perhaps, even Deputy Dillon will agree with that. The mere identification of items as current or capital does not necessarily imply that one should be met from expenditure and the other from borrowing, entirely irrespective of the economic circumstances of the time.
In our circumstances now and in pursuance of present policy, the overriding objective is to see that the community surrenders enough purchasing power to cover all the State outlay, current and capital, on the one hand to curtail expenditure regarded as being in the national interest or, on the other hand, to adopt methods of financing its expenditure which are undoubtedly injurious to the national economy.
Normally the State can secure purchasing power from the public either compulsorily, through taxation, or, voluntarily, in the form of savings. It is true that while Marshall Aid was flowing into this country during the past two or three years, there was a third method. That is to say, the transfer from the public to the State of the cost in Irish currency of imports financed by American loans or grants. That third course, however, I suggest, should be avoided if possible. Whatever may have been the position in theory some time ago, the release of counterpart moneys now must be regarded as having a predominantly inflationary influence. The goods they represent have, for the most part, already been consumed or absorbed into our economy. Current savings, on the other hand, whether they take the form, for instance, of deposits in the savings banks or commercial banks, purchases of savings certificates, subscriptions to national loans or industrial issues or the reservation of profits to meet purchases of new plant, are an appropriate means of financing productive capital outlay. Unfortunately, however, the problem which we face and which so far has been concealed from the people is the complete inadequacy of current savings to meet the present scale of capital outlay. What that means for the State with its capital Budget of £29,000,000 this year, will, I think, be better appreciated if I refer to last year's experience.
Last year, £22,400,000 was issued from the Exchequer to meet capital expenditure. Against this, the savings obtained by the Government from the Irish public amounted to only £12,000,000 of which £3,300,000 represented small savings, that is to say, new savings bank deposits and purchases of savings certificates. It will be realised, therefore, that the increase required in our savings is of such an order of magnitude as to exclude undue optimism as to the outcome of a savings campaign. Nevertheless, we must do our utmost to secure the necessary effort. This endeavour—I shall be fortified by the belief that there will be general agreement with the view of my predecessor, the view expressed by him in his Budget statement that "increased savings are an alternative much preferable to increased taxation or increased restrictions"—again, Sir, the reference is Volume 125, Official Dáil Debates, column 1907.
Comment on this
The implication of this statement, however, I think, should be realised. It is, in fact, essential that the public should appreciate it and that the public should face up to the implication of my predecessor's statement that if savings continue to be so gravely deficient and if some order is to be maintained in our economic affairs, certain alternatives must be faced. The alternatives in question are neither of them welcome nor to be adopted without mature consideration because these alternatives are either a curtailment of capital and current expenditure or an imposition of increased taxation to help in financing them.
I do not wish these remarks of mine to create undue apprehension, but it is my duty to disclose to our people the weakness of our present financial situation because the country must face up to the implications of a continued deterioration in our public finances if that is in fact what the future holds for us. How essential it is that our public finances should be reorganised and put upon a better foundation becomes all the more apparent if we survey the broad field of national income and expenditure.
National income is the income that accrues to the community in any year to consume or invest. That is to say it is the gross revenue after provision has been made for the maintenance of the sources of this income, land, plant, machinery, buildings, etc.; in other words after provision has been made to meet the depreciation of our productive assets. If a community wants to improve its capital and increase its future income—and, I think, a wise and prudent community like a wise and prudent individual will want to do that —there should be set aside a sufficiency out of income in the form of savings to finance new investment. The remainder represents what is normally available for consumption.
On the other hand, this is what has been happening in recent years: an excess in the pool of resources over and above what the national income will allow in any year can be secured for domestic use by establishing a net inflow of goods from abroad, but this will involve a deficit in the balance of payments which, in turn, has to be financed by external disinvestment. The external disinvestment involved in such a procedure can, of course, be fully justified if the external resources are applied to raising correspondingly the level of domestic investment. Not only can it be fully justified but it has been the policy of Fianna Fáil since its foundation to encourage such a diversion of resources from external to domestic investment.
Comment on this
It is impossible to deal with these imbecilities. I was saying—and no doubt this is what Deputy Davin wished to prevent me from saying—that external disinvestment can be fully justified if its purpose is to raise the productive capacity of the nation. I was saying that not only can it be fully justified——
Comment on this
——but that it has been the policy of Fianna Fáil since its foundation to encourage such a diversion of resources from external to domestic investment. One of the first Budgets which I introduced in, I think, the year 1934, when I was Minister for Finance, provided very substantial inducement to investors to invest in Irish industry, to realise their investments abroad, bring them back and reinvest them here in productive industries at home. I remember that when I put that proposition before the Dáil in the Budget, I think, of 1934, among the people who opposed it most resolutely and opposed it quite unintelligently was Deputy Dillon, who was then on the Front Bench of Fine Gael. He was at that time, of course, a member of Fine Gael.
Comment on this
Recently, or perhaps over the past three years, it has been argued that the national income is now higher than in pre-war days. It is important, therefore, for us in this context to consider how this increase has arisen. I am sure that Deputy Dillon will listen to me while I make one very important observation because we must begin from the melancholy and depressing fact that in agriculture, our basic industry for which Deputy Dillon was responsible over the past three years, the net volume of output is still below the 1938 level. Notwithstanding that millions of dollars flowed into the country, notwithstanding that plant and fertilisers were available in greater measure than they were ever available to the farmers of the country before, the startling fact remains that, in the year 1951, the volume of agricultural output in this country is lower than it was in the year 1938.
Comment on this
It was a slip of the tongue; I meant 1950. I make a present of that to the Deputy. The fact remains that Deputy Dillon was bombasting up and down the country as the greatest Minister for Agriculture Ireland had ever produced, the greatest Minister for Agriculture in the world, we were told by some of his infatuated admirers. Notwithstanding that he had millions of pounds to spend, notwithstanding that he did spend millions of pounds on grandiose schemes, notwithstanding that he had machinery, implements and fertilisers at his command, the position was that, in the year 1950, the net volume of agricultural output in this country——
Comment on this
I know that Deputies do not want to have impressed on them these unpleasant facts, but they are facts, statistical facts that Deputy Dillon cannot deny.
Comment on this
It shows how badly you left agriculture in 1947.
Comment on this
Much of this boasted improvement in the national income is attributable to increased industrial output and this in turn has depended in great measure——
Comment on this
——on expenditure which has been heavily subsidised by the State. For example, there has been a substantial increase in building. Many houses are going up to-day reared upon foundations laid by Fianna Fáil. There has been a substantial increase in building and construction and in industries producing building materials, furniture and household equipment. As I referred to building materials perhaps I could remind the House——
Comment on this
Might I remind the Chair that the Minister proposed to speak for three-quarters of an hour and has now exceeded that?
Comment on this
I was addressing the Chair. The Minister stated in the House that he proposed to speak for three-quarters of an hour. That is not so long ago that the Minister could forget making that statement, which was made quite clearly in the House.
Comment on this
I did not say anything of the sort. I said I might speak 30 minutes, 40 minutes, 45 minutes or as long as it would take me to say what I have to say, subject, of course, to the fact——
Comment on this
——that a considerable amount of time might be wasted in dealing with these senseless and disorderly interruptions from the benches opposite.
Comment on this
This will be the last time that the Opposition will accord the Government courtesy here.
Comment on this
I suppose Deputy O'Higgins is looking forward to his holidays just like Deputy Norton and Deputy Dillon.
Comment on this
If the Deputy means that he has prevented me from attending, as a member of the Government, the honouring of the national feast day of a foreign nation which maintains a representative here, he is entitled to whatever credit he can get out of that.
Comment on this
On a point of order. There was a definite arrangement between the Whips that no speech would be longer than 45 minutes on either side. The Minister will find that that is true, if he will consult with his chief Whip.
Comment on this
There was no such arrangement and if that arrangement were made the Deputy was here in the House when this question was raised by other Deputies—and the Ceann Comhairle quite obviously knew nothing of it. I know nothing of it either. It is quite clear that the Deputies opposite do not want the country to know the position in which they have landed it. That is the whole purpose of these interruptions.
Comment on this
On a point of order. The Whips from the various Parties met about a fortnight ago when they drew up this programme. I think that Deputy Killilea was there with the Parliamentary Secretary, Deputy Ó Briain, and it was definitely understood that the speeches by the Ministers would be short and would not exceed 40 minutes.
Comment on this
It was not mentioned when the time-table was put before the House. It was not mentioned to-day.
Comment on this
On that, the arrangement was three hours, not two hours. The Minister has every facility for finding out from Deputy O Briain whether that arrangement was made or not. Let him do so. I will accept Deputy O Briain's word.
Comment on this
Deputy Sweetman should not regard himself as the arbiter of the debates in this House. At least 20 minutes of the time allotted has been wasted by senseless interruptions by the Opposition. I was saying if I may be permitted to resume now, that there had been a considerable increase in industries producing building materials.
Comment on this
Sit down and take your medicine. You are in favour of monetary reform. You are being educated now.
Comment on this
Does the Minister know that he is talking like a first year economics student at the university, though not as well?
Comment on this
On a point of order. Last night the Minister deprived a member of this side of the House of an opportunity to speak. Should we not be allowed to speak now?
Comment on this
It is quite clear that the Deputies opposite wish to prevent this information about the financial position of the country from being disclosed to the public.
Comment on this
I was saying that there had been a considerable increase in the production of industries manufacturing building materials. It is interesting, perhaps, to remark in passing, in connection with that particular aspect of the matter, that we had established in this country under the Fianna Fáil Government, a great industry for the manufacture of cement.
Comment on this
Under the Fianna Fáil Cement Act, two factories were established to manufacture native cement.
Comment on this
I am pointing out that I am going on to deal with the deficit in our balance of payments.
Comment on this
I will, if I am permitted to deal with the more important question of the deficit in our balance of payments——
Comment on this
It has, because, if the Fianna Fáil programme had been given effect to and had not been sabotaged in 1948, we would be manufacturing in this country 250,000 tons of cement which at present we are importing from abroad and at a higher price than we could manufacture it at home.
Comment on this
On a point of order. How can the desirability of manufacturing cement for the domestic market, as opposed to purchasing it from Mr. Jantzen in Denmark, be brought within the Estimate of the Department of Finance?
Mr. MacEntee rose.
Comment on this
I have raised a point of order. I consider that the Minister's remarks are manifestly irrelevant.
Comment on this
So be it. I was merely pointing out, if I may be permitted, in order that I may try to keep some sort of coherence in my speech, despite interruptions, that I want to say that, in so far as there has been any increase in the productive capacity of the Irish people, that increase in the productive capacity has not been manifested in our basic industry of agriculture but has been manifested in those industries which depend mainly upon heavy State sub-sidies—for instance, the industries which are ancillary to the building of houses.
If I may, having pointed out how this increase in our national income, of which so much has been said, has been secured, I should like to go on to deal with the other problem, the problem of consumption. The consumption, especially of non-essentials, has risen in a greater degree than the national income. In consequence, less is being saved to finance improvements in our productive capacity. This deficiency in our savings has been supported in recent years by incurring dollar debt and by realising our sterling assets. The great misfortune is that the resources supplied by these external dis-investments have been dissipated, as they have been used to a greater extent for consumption purposes than to raise the normal level of domestic investment.
Comment on this
If I might pause here in order to vindicate myself. It has been alleged by Deputy Corish and Deputy Sweetman that there was an agreement that Ministers should limit their speeches to 40 minutes.
Comment on this
The Parliamentary Secretary says there was no definite agreement to limit the Minister's time.
Comment on this
Did not the Minister give an undertaking when he started that he would only take three-quarters of an hour?
Comment on this
If I were to stigmatise that statement of Deputy S. Collins as it deserves to be stigmatised the House would probably expel me as it did Deputy Dillon recently.
Comment on this
There was an agreement that no speaker on either side would continue for more than three-quarters of an hour.
Comment on this
——by incurring dollar debt and in particular by realising our sterling assets. The great misfortune of course in this connection is that the resources supplied by this external disinvestment have been dissipated as it has been used to a greater extent for consumption purposes rather than to raise the normal level of domestic investment. This was particularly so last year. In that year current savings fell substantially below what was necessary while consumption greatly increased. To compensate for the deficit of £30,000,000 in the balance of payments there was £6,500,000 of additional home-investment as compared with 1949 and about £5,500,000 of increased stocks. For the balance, for £18,000,000 of our external resources which were realised and spent there is nothing to show.
So far this year as compared with last year the position has been much worse. The trade deficit for the first five months, that is to say, for the first five months of this year during which the Coalition Government was in office, is more than £20,000,000 higher than for the same period in 1950. The prospect is that there will be as much as £120,000,000 of a deficit for the year, or over £30,000,000 more than last year. We face, therefore, a balance of payments deficit of £60,000,000. Notwithstanding all that we have been hearing in recent years about the repatriation of our external assets for the purpose of employing them here at home, capital goods account for a very small part —almost one might say a minute fraction—of the total increase in imports compared with 1950. It is true there has been some increase in stocks, possibly enough to balance the increase in the volume of imports, but this leaves the increase in price—which is responsible for £12,500,000 of the excess over the first five months of last year—completely uncovered.
Now as against this huge and overwhelming deficit, and here are the true facts to be set against the ballyhoo that we have been listening to for the last three years, exports increased in value in the first five months of this year by only £2,700,000. Set that £2,700,000 against the £20,000,000 increase in the deficit in the balance of payments and, apart altogether from this insignificant price increase, actually there has been a decline in volume. An increase of course in agricultural output is much to be desired, and that is the justification for paying to the farmer a price that will enable him and induce him to increase his output and meet these ever-mounting costs that have been piled upon him by the defunct Coalition. An increase in agricultural output would reduce pro tanto the trade deficit. Unfortunately, however, immediate relief from this quarter can scarcely be expected with agricultural output, as I have already said, below pre-war level and domestic consumption so much above it. Nor do the conditions under which we trade——
Comment on this
——offer any better hope. The rise in import prices, which has been steep and is still in progress, has outpaced the rise in export prices, and a further and continuous deterioration in the terms of trade seems indeed to be inevitable.
Now I have dwelt on these matters because, properly interpreted, the balance of payments is the most significant single indicator of our economic position. We have reason to be content when we have something to show for the deficit in the balance of payments, whether it be by a corresponding increase in home investment, in productive industry, or in stocks, because in either case no permanent damage may result. But when we are rapidly drawing upon our external capital merely to boost for the time being our standard of living, the situation is one that must cause us all the gravest anxiety.
I would remind the House that my predecessor had some weighty observations to make on this point in his Budget statement this year.
Comment on this
He was speaking for you, I presume, or do you disagree with him? Is this another case of Cabinet disagreement now beginning to emerge?
Comment on this
Though the Minister for Finance was purporting when speaking in the House to express the collective view of the Government upon this very important matter, nevertheless he apparently was not speaking for Deputy Dillon. Perhaps he did not speak either for the then Minister for External Affairs and other members of that disunited Cabinet.
Comment on this
I wish to remind the House of something and I hope that I shall be permitted to do so without these unmannerly and foolish interruptions. I was about to remind the House of what my predecessor, Deputy McGilligan, said upon this particular question. He admitted the undesirability of realising our external assets merely to boost domestic consumption when he said at column 1882 of Volume 125 of the Official Report:
"What is abnormal and, if it persists, can be seriously damaging is to use up our external resources for consumption purposes."
He went on to say in column 1884:
"Only if the gap in the balance of payments is narrowed so that external disinvestment is balanced by additional home investment— rather than by excessive consumption —can we be satisfied that as a nation we are making ends meet and not wasting our past accumulations. One of the great benefits conferred by the possession of external assets is ability to ride out periods like the present of exceptional difficulty and stress but this external mass of manoeuvre is the mainstay of our economic independence."
It is a grave matter for reflection that our external assets have been reduced by £90,000,000 during the past three or four years, that a further reduction of £60,000,000 is in prospect this year and that only a small fraction of this total disinvestment is offset by an addition to our productive capacity.
Comment on this
Allowing for extern holdings in Ireland of non-nationals, our net external assets were estimated at £225,000,000 in 1949. If the present rate of disinvestment continues, Ireland will, by 1954, have lost her creditor status. We shall have no external resources to fall back upon in an emergency. To quote Deputy McGilligan, there will be no mainstay for our economic independence and our standard of living; our production and our population must decline. This is a position that we must do our utmost to avoid.
The way would be clearer to reaching conclusions on policy if the future course of imports could be foreseen. But, with the international situation so clouded, and the effects of rearmament still impossible to assess, it is perhaps better to wait for further light. We should, however, be considering how far it is possible to prevent our economic position from being further weakened. Various things are contributing to the general state of overspending which results in using external assets largely for consumption purposes; private and public spending are causing congestion that can be relieved only by a reduction of one or the other; credit facilities are encouraging outlay on less essential goods; money incomes of all kinds are being raised irrespective of increases in output.
Bearing what I have said in mind, there are certain propositions related to financial policy on which, I think, there should be general agreement in present circumstances: (1) that we should try to control inflation, at least to the extent of not letting our money depreciate faster than the currencies of countries with which we have close economic connections; (2) that if we incur deficits on the balance of payments, it should be to improve our domestic capital or increase our reserve stocks, mere dissipation of external resources for immediate consumption being undesirable; (3) that the Government should endeavour to obtain enough purchasing power from the public—in the form of taxation or savings—to finance Government expenditure; (4) that a substantial increase in savings at the expense of spending on the less essential consumer goods is urgently necessary in the national interest; (5) that an increase in production for export, particularly in agriculture, is urgently needed to reduce the trade deficit; (6) that income increases should be moderate since the realities of the situation preclude full and immediate compensation for rising prices which, in the main, are merely the outward evidence of the reduction in national living standards temporarily forced upon us; (7) that, in the words of my predecessor: "in present circumstances it is desirable that the banks, while continuing to finance capital projects, the laying in of essential stocks and normal import requirements, should discourage any merely speculative or excessive borrowing." A similar injunction—of course I am quoting Deputy McGilligan—applies to other lending agencies.
Comment on this
Volume 125, column 1879. I have memorised most of these quotations and I used them with good effect, from the period of May 17th to June 1st. It is because of these quotations some of you are sitting over there.
Comment on this
I was quoting from my predecessor and I was saying that the situation requires measures which he outlined in his Budget speech but to which he had not the courage to give effect. One could develop the propositions which I have put before the House at great length and, if we were discussing them in close debate, one could qualify them in various ways. However, I think that what I have said provides sufficient matter for serious consideration. It will be seen from the figures which I have put before the House and the country that the present predicament of the Irish nation, of this State and of the people of this State, is grave and serious and must be dealt with accordingly. I hope, when it does come to be dealt with, that the people who are sitting on the opposite side will realise that their responsibility in this matter is at least as heavy as ours and that they will permit whoever should have the unpleasant task of proposing these measures to this House to make a serious wellconsidered statement such as I have endeavoured to make to-day, without senseless interruption, without attempting by meaningless interjections to prevent the people of the country, whom they are supposed to represent and whose interests they are supposed to safeguard, from knowing, at long last, the truth about those discreditable three years.
Comment on this
Might I ask the Minister one question? Are we to take it that this marathon speech by him of 1 hour and 20 minutes is a long way of saying to the people: "Get ready for the Fianna Fáil hair-shirt policy in future?"
Comment on this
It would be much better for the people of this country to go around wearing a shirt and trousers than to find their creditors coming in and taking their shirt and trousers and their independence from them.
Comment on this
When I heard that the Minister was on his feet I was sorry that Deputy McGilligan was indisposed both yesterday and to-day and unable to come in to speak. When I came into the House I found myself in an atmosphere in which, it seemed to me, a very famous person named Rip Van Winkle had suddenly woken up.
The speech that was made by the Minister for Finance was a speech that could have had some meaning, in so far as it had any meaning at all in its theory, before the American crash of 1929. It was a speech that one could have quite appreciated, that one could have felt was in its proper context if it had been made, not merely before the American crash in 1929, but by the Party to which Mr. Hoover belonged even in those days.
During the last three years Deputy MacEntee, as he then was, and his cohorts in Fianna Fáil have been parading around the country, and even taking every opportunity to say in this House that we are likely to come up against sooner or later, and more sooner than later, a world conflagration, a serious international situation in which there would be international warfare and all that goes with it. The speech that the Minister has just made, if again it means anything, is an entire negation and an entire denial of all that he and the Fianna Fáil Party have been saying for those years.
If there is ever a time during which it is desirable for a Government to embark on a wise constructive policy of spending, it is a time when there is a danger in the international situation that there may be a further shortage of materials and a further international inflationary position. I think that Deputy McGilligan had to-day a written question addressed to the Minister to which the answer given showed that the value of the pound in terms of goods before the last war compared to the present time reduced by approximately half. Let us consider the position that would have emerged or will emerge if there had been or if there should be any international disturbance of the same nature. God forbid that an international disturbance should take place next year, but if it did come about, and if the work which has been done by the inter-Party Government under the wise and constructive financial policy of Deputy McGilligan had not been accomplished and had then to be undertaken, it would cost double as much as it did, in fact, cost. I heard one of the Minister's new and devoted adherents, Deputy Dr. Browne, when he was Minister for Health, talk on the same lines to his predecessor in office, Deputy Dr. Ryan. He pointed out, and pointed out correctly, that if the moneys that were in the Hospitals Trust Fund had been spent on bricks and mortar before 1939 the same number of beds would have been made available at something considerably less than one-third of the cost they would have cost after the war. Exactly the same analogy can be drawn in regard to the spending to which Deputy MacEntee has referred in such slighting terms.
The two main things which Deputy MacEntee—I beg your pardon, the Minister, though I must confess it is hard to believe that the speech we heard was a speech from a responsible Minister — proceeded to castigate, stripped of the fog which he tried to put around them, were the expenditure on housing and the expenditure on drainage, whether in respect of field drainage or arterial drainage or in respect of what I shall term for the moment minor arterial drainage.
So far as expenditure on housing is concerned, Deputy McGilligan never suggested to this House that it was an expenditure which he proposed to measure in terms of percentage returns. He took the view—and I think it was the correct view and the modern view —that it was desirable to ensure that the social return that would be obtained from the benefit of seeing that our people would be properly housed in a period when there was likely to be one of rising prices, was infinitely better than any question that could merely be measured in terms of percentage interest rates. In that respect let me remind the Minister that the position ever since 1947 was an entirely different one from what it was before. If there were a position where prices were likely to drop, then there would be a very sound reason, perhaps, for holding back as regards expenditure, except in so far as it was necessary to prime the pump, but so far as capital expenditure is concerned on goods and services that obviously would cost more subsequent to an inflation, it would be a very unwise Minister that would adopt a policy to ensure that such expenditure could not be incurred. So far as I can understand the Minister's concluding remarks, the effect of his warning to the banks must be taken to be that he does not want them to finance industry except to a very, very limited extent. It would be interesting to note whether those people who find their bank credit in industry reduced will realise when those credits are reduced, as, no doubt, they will be after the Minister's warning, that it is the Minister and his warning that have been responsible for that situation arising.
The Minister gave us a dissertation on the Budget. He told us that the Budget did not provide sufficient taxation. Quite well I can remember one instance in which the Budget did provide additional taxation.
I can remember the Minister when he was on this side of the House making the welkin ring about the additional impost that was being proposed then by Deputy McGilligan as Minister. In fact, I think, if my recollection does not serve me badly, the Minister not merely made the welkin ring but made the troops walk up into the Division Lobby against it as well. Now, apparently, he is prepared, and the Fianna Fáil Party are quite obviously prepared, to swallow most of the things they were saying on this side of the House and to utilise their position over there to carry on the viewpoint and the ideas which were put forward by the inter-Party Government.
One of the Minister's digressions into the realms of agriculture showed quite clearly that he did not appreciate that any expenditure on land reclamation or on drainage work was obviously an expenditure that could not show immediate returns. I am quite confident that when the history of the first 50 years of this State comes to be written there are two things which will stand out in that history as being the two main features from an economic point of view. One of these things will be the Shannon scheme, which the Minister described as a "white elephant", and the second will be the land reclamation scheme. It is typical of the attitude with which Fianna Fáil approach the whole concept of our economic life. They never had the courage, even though they had 16 years, of which 11 were completely free from any international disturbance, to start any big scheme which could be compared for its lasting and permanent effect with the Shannon scheme or the land reclamation scheme.