We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Supplies and Services (Temporary Provisions) Act, 1946 (Continuance) Bill, 1951—Second Stage (Resumed).

Contributions 167–366 of 366. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Supplies and Services (Temporary Provisions) Act, 1946 (Continuance) Bill 1951
Enacted

No. 24 of 1951 ›

Brendan Corish Breanndán Mac Fheórais Labour Party

What happened to it between 1945 and 1948?

Comment on this

The machinery could not be got until the war was over. There was plenty of opportunity for getting it from January, 1948, right on to 1951 —far easier than it is now. The members of the Industrial Development Authority were turning over their £2,500 per man, and they were too busy spending that and had not the time for anything else. That is only one item. Every Deputy can only judge by the activities he knows of in his own constituency. Some genius over there will read out the report received by the Parliamentary Secretary on the reason why the sheet mill could not be started until Deputy Seán Lemass came back as Minister for Industry and Commerce. Perhaps some of the Deputies will enlighten us on that.

Comment on this

Thank Peadar Cowan for that, not Seán Lemass.

Comment on this

It cannot be done.

Comment on this

Deputy Lemass waited for Peadar.

Comment on this

The last Government had no Seán Lemass. If they had it would have been a different story. If they had a Tom Walsh and a Paddy Smith they would be right.

Comment on this

God forbid!

Comment on this

They would not have gone to the Formosan. I do not pretend to be a genius on finance. I never had enough of it; I never will have enough of it, and will never have much of it either. No honest man in this country ever had much and you will not find any in the farmer's hands. However, when I hear accusations I judge each as I see it, and I judge each Government as I see it, and I see a Government that carefully refrained from spending anything and that stayed looking at that plant and machinery lying idle knowing that it could give employment, and decent employment, to 300 able-bodied men. They were not prepared to spend the money necessary to get the balance of that machinery or to put that plant in operation. Then I see a Minister who comes along and within one short month of his appointment goes down there and puts the wheels moving and gets the men on the job. At the present moment that plant is being erected in order to give employment.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I have warned the Deputy before against repetition.

Comment on this

We wonder how the people opposite can claim: "We are the people who were prepared to spend and those are the people who are too tight to spend." That is the only basis on which I can compare the situations.

I am speaking for the agricultural community in my area, for the tillage farmers of the country, for the working farmers of the country, and I say—and I do not care what Party is in power or in office—that until such time as we have a Government that is prepared to give the agricultural community a fair crack of the whip and put an end to the £3 6s. 0d. on one side of the fence and the £5 12s. 0d. on the other side you will not have the production that is absolutely essential to pull this country out of the hole she is in. There is very little use in our talking of production and mouthing sentiments unless we are prepared, as representatives of the people, to act up to what we preach and to go to the farmer and say: "Come along. We want you to produce so much wheat, so much beet, so much feeding for your animals, so many acres of each of those things and sufficient milk to give butter to the people of the country, and we are prepared to pay you at least the cost of production plus a fair profit. We are prepared to pay you sufficient to enable you to pay your labourer and your son something more than £3 10s. 0d. a week." Let us act on that basis and see how it will work.

We know the cost of production of beet. Let us give every man as much as he will get if he goes across the road into the factory to handle the other end of it. Let that be done and I am prepared to guarantee on behalf of the farmers that the farmers will pay their labourers that wage. If the cost of production of beet is made up at £4 10s., or even £5 a week; I guarantee that every farmer working in beet will pay that wage to his labourer.

Comment on this
Brendan Corish Breanndán Mac Fheórais Labour Party

If he is made.

Comment on this

There is no making. The farmers of this country treated their agricultural labourers decently before ever they heard of the manoeuvres and the regulation brought in here as a wedge between themselves and their workers during the past 10 or 20 years. There is no making. I told Deputy Corish, in speaking here six or seven weeks ago, that I was prepared to meet the Labour Party more than halfway in this thing because I cannot stand by and see labour flying from the field every day of the week until you have a condition of affairs when you cannot have increased production. Any able-bodied young man at the present day has only one thing. He says: "Very well, all I have are my four bones. I will sell them in the best labour market I can find. If the best labour market in agriculture is £3 10s. I will go somewhere else if I can get £5."

I and people like me who want to see labour decently employed and who have been accustomed to seeing contented labour on our farms will be left in the position if this condition of affairs continues that in a few short years nobody will be left on the land of this country but old-age pensioners and cripples and you can get all the production you want from them.

I am glad and very glad that we are in a position to-day to change the policy which was carried out towards agriculture for the past three and a half years. I am proud of having any part in getting rid of the old man of the sea who was tied around the unfortunate farmer's neck. His sentence is ended and I have very little respect for the Deputies of any Party who stood by while that villainy was being perpetrated on the people they pretended to represent. I cannot pretend to have respect for the men who stood by and sat in that Cabinet and refused to pay the unfortunate farmer 4/6 a ton extra on his beet——

Comment on this

I thought you had finished that an hour ago.

Comment on this

——and who were prepared to go out to Cuba and to pay an extra £1,000,000 for the same article. Is it not time that that kind of thing was ended? What respect can any decent Deputy, looking at that condition of affairs, have for the individuals who sat in that Cabinet and allowed that daft creature to get away with that kind of work for three and a half years?

Comment on this

There is a very good book which was written by Phillip Gibbs, who was at one time a member of the British House of Commons. It makes most interesting reading. The title is In the Middle of the Road. There is a character in the book whose name appears on practically every page —Moleskin Joe. Moleskin Joe frequently said: “There is a good time coming if I live to see it.” Every word that the Taoiseach uttered last night in this House reminded me of the words of Moleskin Joe. There are good times coming if we live to see them. The good times that Moleskin Joe expected did not come. He died before the good times came. If the Moleskin Joe of Dáil Éireann thinks that he is going to pull wool over the eyes of the members of this House or of the general public outside, he is making a very grave mistake.

Everybody who knows the Taoiseach knows quite well that when he says he is going to achieve a particular aim, he means the very opposite. Everybody who knows the Taoiseach knows that every promise he made in this country he broke. So, if he is to be judged by his promises, we can see that all those promises that were made in the past were never fulfilled.

Comment on this

Quite the contrary. Quite the contrary.

Comment on this

Every promise he made was broken.

Comment on this

No.

Comment on this

He said on one occasion that he would bring back the emigrants.

Comment on this

No, you brought them back.

Comment on this

They never came back. He said he would abolish the Seanad. He did, and he instituted another Seanad for his own friends.

Comment on this

Tell us what the judges said about you.

Comment on this

Will the Minister have the manners to listen and take his medicine? I have listened patiently to the Taoiseach. I did not interrupt him. I listened to the Tánaiste and did not interrupt him.

Comment on this

They did not make foul charges.

Comment on this

I am also prepared to listen to the Minister in his feeble attempts to make speeches in this House. Every promise that Fianna Fáil made was a promise made to be broken. Now let us judge them on their record. If the Minister for Defence comes into the House at this late hour of the night to endeavour to justify the broken promises of Fianna Fáil——

Comment on this

To suffer listening to you.

Comment on this

Is it in order to make a speech as to when or for what reason the Minister for Defence comes into the House?

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Chair is waiting for the Deputy to relate his remarks to the Bill before the House.

Comment on this

If the Irish people are expecting——

Comment on this

The Irish people are not fools.

Comment on this

I will let the Deputy make a speech if he wishes, but, whether he likes it or not, he is going to listen to me.

Comment on this

Provided you are in order.

Comment on this

I am in Parliament and what I have to say I will say.

Comment on this

What you have said so far is little credit to you.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Flanagan must be allowed to make his speech without interruption.

Comment on this

I was referring to the Taoiseach's speech last night. I came into the House for the purpose of interrupting the Taoiseach. I must confess that. But, when I saw such a poor spectacle presenting such a feeble case and such a bad case, my conscience revolted. It would not permit me to interrupt him.

Comment on this

When did you get it?

Comment on this

My heart, which is by no means tender or soft, would not allow me to interrupt the Taoiseach, because I was sorry for him. He was a sad, weary man, trying to hold the men he had behind him together, trying to build up and make a case that would look good out of something that was not a case at all.

We all know that he has the worries and the cares of endeavouring to keep the Government together. We know that. He has that responsibility. With men like Deputy Cogan and Deputy Cowan that is no small job to-day.

Comment on this

What has that got to do with the Bill?

Comment on this

Oh yes, it has something to do with the Government.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Will the Deputy try to deal with the Bill?

Comment on this

With respect, we are here to censure the Government severly. We are going to do that.

Comment on this

I thought we were talking about supplies and services.

Comment on this

We are going to do that. If the Minister for Defence is anxious to hear about supplies and services, he will certainly hear about supplies and services. But, before he hears about supplies and services, it is only right that his attention should be directed to the fact that for the past six months, since the present Government took office, his colleagues have been going through the country delivering speeches of despair and depression, lowering as much as they possibly can the morale of the people, telling them of bad times, telling them of the deplorable mess in which they found the country after three years of the inter-Party Government.

Comment on this

That is right.

Comment on this

It is true. They did not have to be told. They knew it.

Comment on this

Before the last general election, the present Taoiseach told the people that if he was re-elected he would reduce taxation. Every spokesman of Fianna Fáil told us that taxation would be reduced and that we were living in a time of spend-thrifts——

Comment on this

Quote.

Comment on this

——and that the inter-Party Government was squandering money and spending too much money, and that it was time to exercise economy.

Comment on this

Quote the speeches.

Comment on this

We were told, furthermore, that the very moment the inter-Party Government would be removed from office the people would be relieved of the already heavy burden of taxation that was placed on their shoulders. Of course, the poor gullible Irish believed it again. They believed it because of Government propaganda. On the Irish Press, on the Irish Independent, at every railway station, on every dead wall in the country, we saw huge posters bearing a photograph of the worried housewife and right beside it was the sad, dreary spectacle of the Taoiseach and underneath it the words: “You can trust Dev. Put him in.” Right beside it was the worried housewife, with painted fingernails, and she was expressing in her countenance Tegret at the manner in which the inter-Party Government had allowed the cost of living to go up. This paper says: “Every housewife knows that the cost of clothes, coal, soap and other household commodities has risen to a dangerous level. No amount of statistical juggling can prove otherwise.”

Comment on this

What paper is that?

Comment on this

The Irish Press.“A pound note goes nowhere in the household shopping of to-day. Every housewife knows that. Yet, the Coalition is attempting to prove by statistics and false arguments that the cost of living has not risen. What do you think? Is this honest? Does it even make sense to the housewife? Vote for a new deal, a straight deal, vote for Fianna Fáil.”

Comment on this

Is not that all true, every word of it?

Comment on this

Before the last election Fianna Fáil made so much capital out of it we had the housewife saying: "An increase in butter, in soap, in shoes, in gas, in coal and in electricty," and the Government crawled meekly into office pledged to the housewife and the fathers and mothers of families that if they were elected to office the commodities that the inter-Party Government had been responsible for increasing, as they maintained, would be reduced and that in addition the alleged increase in the cost of living at the time would be brought down. There was to be no further increases and no further taxation. Last night, however, the Taoiseach had changed. The speeches he made before the election had served their purpose. He got the votes, he captured Deputy Cogan and Deputy Cowan in the mousetraps and he secured office under false pretences. He gulled the people successfully again. But last night he did not talk about reducing the cost of living or about reducing the already heavy burden of taxation. This was what he said.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Will the Deputy give the reference?

Comment on this

The report of the Taoiseach's speech as published in the daily papers this morning.

He said:

"If the people want Government services we must make provision for them by getting the equivalent revenue. That will mean that we will have to face additional taxation."

The Minister for Finance, in a recent speech, I think it was on last Friday night, said that it was now all too clear that the people were living beyond their means. The Tánaiste, on more than one occasion, has stated that the country is living beyond its means. Recently in Cork the Taoiseach stated that we were going to face good times and that prosperity was coming, but at the same time he said: "Tighten your belts because I think there is a pinch coming and we are not very far away from it." Before the good times come we are going to have some bad times. When "Moleskin Joe" made that speech in Cork——

Comment on this

Take me as protesting against the observations of this Deputy. The personal observations he is making should not be made even on a dunghill not to speak of in this House.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Taoiseach will have to be referred to as the Taoiseach.

Comment on this

The Taoiseach made a reference in Cork—I do not know if Deputy MacCarthy was present at the meeting because from the report it appeared as if there was no one there except the Taoiseach.

Comment on this

I am not objecting to criticism of the Taoiseach, but I am objecting to the dirty personal observations of the Deputy.

Comment on this

Now that Deputy MacCarthy has satisfied himself with his protest, will he allow me to proceed?

Comment on this

Let him continue his mudlarking.

Comment on this

"A good time is coming although I may never see it" that was in practically every chapter of the book I have referred to, In the Middle of the Road. The Taoiseach carries on on identically the same road. We now find ourselves in the position that, if the Taoiseach's statement last night is correct, we are going to be faced with further taxation. I should like to know from the Taoiseach or from the Minister or from some spokesman of the Fianna Fáil set-up, what else is there to tax in this country or whom is there to tax in this country? That is something I should like to have answered.

Comment on this
A Deputy

Gasbags.

Comment on this

Are we going to tax the necessities of life?

Comment on this

Who is responsible for it?

Comment on this

Who said that?

Comment on this

I did.

Comment on this

You are a good man to be able to say anything at all. I want to know what is going to be taxed and I think the Dáil is entitled to know what is going to be taxed. If there are to be new taxes, we are entitled to know how that additional new taxation is to be levied and on whom it is to be levied. Is he going to tax the 80,000 agricultural workers in this country? Is he going to tax the 170,000 old age pensioners? Is he going to tax the 30,000 widows and orphans. Is he going to ask the agricultural workers, the small farmers, the widows and orphans and the lame and the sick to tighten their belts and to reduce their standard of living? Is he going to ask them to take off their decent clothing and get back into the rags and weep as they did for 17 years under Fianna Fáil? That was very gloomy reading this morning for the people who voted for Fianna Fáil candidates in the belief that taxation was to be reduced. They now find that Fianna Fáil have changed their policy. Instead of reducing taxation and bringing down the cost of living, they are going to permit the cost of living to rise higher and higher and taxation is going to be increased. We must take that as an established fact, and the unfortunate housewife, who was spoken of so very often on Fianna Fáil platforms during the last general election, cannot be used by Fianna Fáil any more.

The Tánaiste in this House said that when he took office there were piles of files in the Department of Industry and Commerce containing recommendations of the Prices Advisory Body for increases awaiting the Minister's sanction. He said that when Deputy Dr. O'Higgins was Minister for Industry and Commerce the Prices Advisory Body made various recommendations for increases in the prices of various commodities and that the then Minister just left the files on one side until they piled up.

Comment on this

And they were both listening and did not contradict him.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Flanagan.

Comment on this

We were told that the files were permitted to grow several feet high. I am proud of that. Neither Deputy Dr. O'Higgins nor Deputy Morrissey denied that because they were quite right in leaving those files there and that is what any shrewd, sensible Minister for Industry and Commerce would do.

Comment on this

But they had appointed the board themselves.

Comment on this

I want the House, and particularly Deputy MacCarthy, to realise that the Prices Advisory Body was established for the purpose of giving advice and making recommendations and that the Minister was not, is not and could not be bound to act on their recommendation. In their wisdom and in their foresight and because of their charity for the poor throughout the country, conscious of the fact that it was their aim and policy to keep down the cost of living, they were quite right in leaving those files there.

It would indeed have been far better if the Tánaiste had left those files alone instead of adding further to the distress and discontent of the unfortunate housewife, in whom he professed to be so interested and over whom he wept so bitterly before the general election. But he soon forgot his tears, and one of the first steps he took on coming into office was to go into the room where those files were stacked and say: "Shake the dust from them; knock the cobwebs off; I want to sign these recommendations for increases in order to inflict more hardships on the poor by making them law." He did that. Having thrown the housewife on the scrap-heap, the present Government had no further use for her. They had already captured her vote. Their first act was to put 2d. per lb. on every lb. of butter going into the workingman's home. The unfortunate widow and the orphan are compelled by order of this dishonourable Government to pay 2d. more on every lb. of butter they buy. The unfortunate old age pensioner must pay 2d. more. Every lb. of butter that goes into the home of the farm worker, into the home of the civil servant, into the home of the Garda Síochána and into the married quarters in our barracks, carries 2d. per lb. extra as a result of the Order made by the Minister. Every lb. of butter that goes into our hospitals carries an extra charge of 2d. Every ex-tuberculosis patient who has been ordered butter must pay 2d. per lb. more for it. Deputy Cogan may feel quite proud that he has achieved his aim by inflicting such a severe punishment and hardship on the unfortunate people to whom I have referred.

Comment on this

Deputy Cogan has already told you what he thinks of you.

Comment on this

The Minister for Defence knows quite well that one of the most brutal acts that can be performed is to deny the poor butter on their bread. This unwarranted and unreasonable increase was one of the first burdens imposed by the present set-up. An announcement appeared in the papers—dark, gloomy reading it made—which proclaimed to the housewife that butter would be dearer and that the hole that had been punched in the bottom of her purse would get bigger and wider with every lb. of butter she had to buy.

Deputy Dr. Ryan, in his capacity as Minister for Health, has on more than one occasion made appeals to the people to arm themselves against disease, to eat well, to clothe themselves properly and, above all, to make sure that they have butter and milk in sufficient quantities. The unfortunate school children of Dublin, their fathers and probably their older brothers and sisters taking lunch with them are to-day denied butter because of the prohibitive price Fianna Fáil has placed on butter.

Comment on this

They had not got it for three years.

Comment on this

At one time they had only two ounces.

Comment on this

The unfortunate housewife on whom Fianna Fáil gambled and won can no longer have butter. One of the slogans for the next election should be that they have now put butter beyond the reach of the housewives.

Comment on this

Why is butter being imported, then?

Comment on this

One of the first items they taxed was butter and Deputy Cowan asks now why butter is being imported. Deputy Cowan knows that for a long time the people had only two ounces of butter. I would not care if butter came from the farthest part of the globe provided the people had butter. I never want to see the people with only two ounces of butter again. I want them to get all the butter they can eat.

Comment on this

Irrespective of the price paid to the Danes or the New Zealanders?

Comment on this

I do not want to see any home denied butter. It is true that the inter-Party Government were bitterly criticised by Fianna Fáil because butter was imported. We were told that the butter that came from Denmark formed fours on the tables. We were told that it practically walked around the table. More butter has come in in the past six months than in the whole three years of the inter-Party Government. It is coming in now. Surely if it was capable of "forming fours" during the inter-Party régime it ought to be a little further advanced now; it ought to be able to slope arms and stand to attention.

Comment on this

According to Deputy Murphy it crept.

Comment on this

The Deputies who found fault with the imported butter. whose nostrils almost went back to their ears at the mention of imported butter, have now lost their sense of smell as well as their sense of decency. They find that the butter is now all right. When it was imported under Deputy James Dillon it was bad and had a smell, but when imported under the present Minister for Agriculture it is all right and does not smell. It is strange that the Deputies who made capital out of our imported butter are now very silent and have not a word to say.

Comment on this

Why is it being imported?

Comment on this

There is very little difference between the butter manufactured in our creameries and the Danish butter. The only difference is that the Danes make their butter out of what is known as ripened cream.

Comment on this

And the price?

Comment on this

When the inter-Party Government made an effort to place a pound of butter on the table of every home in the country, and to see that every child got all the butter it needed; one of the firsts acts of Fianna Fáil was to deprive these homes of their reasonable supplies of butter by putting 2d per lb. on it. So much for butter. The unfortunate housewives then realised that they had been deceived and let down, and that Fianna Fáil did not mean a word of what they had said. But if the housewives or the poor of this country knew Fianna Fáil as well as I do, they would not have been surprised. I have been looking at Fianna Fáil and listening to them for almost ten years, and I am not at all surprised at their successful attempt to deprive the unfortunate people of the country of their supplies of butter.

That was only one item in the household bill. Two days after, what did we find? More gloomy reading for the housewives. The headlines in the newspapers were: "Condensed milk dearer". Just as the people were recovering from the shock of the increase in the price of condensed milk and butter, the Minister for Industry and Commerce lost no time in finding another file of the inter-Party Government. This time he pinched out a file for tinned peas and beans, and decided to increase their price lest any worker in the city or country would consider that his lunch would be more appetising with peas or beans. With a stroke of the pen, on the recommendations of the Prices Advisory Body, and without due consideration for the consumer, no time was lost in depriving those with a taste for peas and beans of them. Fianna Fáil increased the price.

Comment on this

You must eat a lot of peas.

Comment on this

Will Deputy Cowan be able to justify this at Fairview Corner provided there is no lioness in his constituency?

Comment on this

They are all here on this Fine Gael list.

Comment on this

Not being satisfied with that, we see how Fianna Fáil proceeded to tax the commodities purchased by the working-class people. Butter was 2/10 per lb. during the term of office of the inter-Party Government. Fianna Fáil succeeded in bringing the price up to 3/- a lb. Chef sauce was increased from 1/- to 1/2, and T.D. sauce, which Deputy Cowan probably finds appetising, was next increased in price.

Comment on this

And milk of magnesia.

Comment on this

It is only on the side of the bottle the Deputy will find the "T.D." after the next election. The T.D. sauce was increased from 1/2 to 1/4. Vinegar, which was 1½d. during the period of the inter-Party Government, went up to 1/2. They next increased the price of the tin of cocoa. Every country Deputy knows that there is a tin of cocoa on the mantelpiece in every home in rural Ireland, and that the cocoa is usually taken at night. It was increased from 6d. to 8½d. a tin.

Comment on this

A packet.

Comment on this

You may call it a packet in Fairview but we call it a tin in Laoghis-Offaly. The next thing to be increased in price was something which I would recommend to the Tánaiste—Andrews' Liver Salts. It went up from 1/- to 1/2 a tin. I would recommend the Tánaiste to take an overdose of this so that he would be able to realise where he stands with the cost of living. It probably would clear his head and make him realise his responsibility towards the poor of this country and of the unfortunate people who have to purchase those commodities. Cheese was then increased in price. I suppose Deputy Corry was one of those mainly responsible for that. That was more of the gloomy reading which we had in the newspapers on the 29th August. It was gloomy reading for the housewives. The members of the Lower Prices Council wrote to the Minister asking him to have a public investigation as to why there had been an increase in the price of cheese. The inquiry has not yet been held. There is no regard for the unfortunate consumers of cheese. The Minister for Health, Deputy Dr. Ryan, tells us that cheese is a nutritious diet, but the Tánaiste lost no time in denying cheese to those who have a desire to eat it. When asked to hold an inquiry into the unreasonable, unfair and unjust increase in the price of cheese, he did not do so.

The Lower Prices Council wrote to the Minister and told him that the increase approved of for cheese had no relation whatever to the increase that the farmers got for their milk, but I do not know that the Lower Prices Council has had a reply from him. Strong and repeated representations were made by other sections of the community for an inquiry to be made into the unreasonable, unjust and unfair increase of cheese, but the Minister remained silent. Not one word of protest came from any member of the Fianna Fáil Party. Did Deputy Corry raise any objection? He did not. Did any speaker from the Fianna Fail benches protest or support the request of the Lower Prices Council in their demand — their reasonable demand—for an inquiry into the Minister's transaction in that respect? I challenge any Deputy—any Dublin Deputy—to say that he stands over the Minister's cruel and unjust act in permitting such an increase in the price of cheese.

We all know that this commodity is purchased, to a very great extent, by the working-class people. Workers whose hours of employment do not enable them to return to their homes for lunch partake of the cheese sandwiches which they have packed into their bags before setting out for work in the morning. Even the members of the Defence Forces, for whom the Minister for Defence has such sympathy, moryah, are adversely affected by the rise in the price of cheese. When they go on manæuvres, they may take cheese sandwiches with them. They now have to pay more for it than they did when the inter-Party Government were in office.

Comment on this

Who pays more?

Comment on this

Anyone who purchases cheese pays more for it.

Comment on this
Gerald Boland Minister for Justice (Mr. Boland) Fianna Fáil

Not the soldiers.

Comment on this

We are told that nobody uses cheese except the swanks, and that cheese and biscuits form portion of their luncheon menu. It is quite true that the swanks use cheese, but it is also the diet in many a humble home in this country. In fact, many a poor man once put cheese in a mousetrap, but he cannot do it to-day. If he did so he would expect to catch within the springs of the trap something more substantial than the poor, unfortunate mouse.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

All this is not relevant to the Bill under discussion.

Comment on this

I say, without any fear of contradiction, that the Minister has failed miserably with regard to this matter and that he has been responsible for this serious jump in the price of cheese and for making that Order without consultation with the proper authorities.

We next come to some very gloomy reading. Published in the daily papers, we saw: "Dublin to pay more for gas."

Comment on this

We are getting it free now.

Comment on this

"Dublin to pay more for gas." The people of Fairview have had their gas on occasions.

Comment on this

I do not think you will go there so often.

Comment on this

Deputy Cowan will remain in Fairview with the "lioness". He will not appear in Fairview so often. The people to whom promises were made that the cost of living would be reduced have found that the price of gas had been increased and that such increase was approved by the Government. The Gas Company stated that the increase was due to the increased price of coal. That same day another warning notice appeared in the newspapers. It said: "Coke will also go up £1 per ton from to-morrow."

The daily papers which published this distasteful and unwanted news to the wage-earners also announced that the Minister for Industry and Commerce had, on the recommendation of the Prices Advisory Body, increased the price of oaten meal. Even oaten meal, or, as we call it down the country, "the plate of stirabout", could not be let pass. The unfortunate poor of this country, who enjoyed the plate of stirabout, oaten meal, porridge, or whatever name one may like to call it, were penalised. The Tánaiste would know it better by the name of plain stirabout. He saw it fit to allow the price of this commodity to rise recklessly. Another increase was announced on the same date which would probably affect the Tánaiste's constituents and Deputy Cowan's constituents more than it would affect mine—the price of sherry was increased. Few of us are drinking, but any who do drink find that we pay more for it than we did when the inter-Party Government was in office.

Shortly after Fianna Fáil took office there appeared in the daily papers the news that the people of this country would have to pay more for eggs. The announcement ran: "Eggs to cost more from to-day." At the present time eggs have reached such an exorbitant price that no wage-earner can purchase them. When Deputy Dr. Browne was Minister for Health he said on one occasion, if my memory serves me right, that he wanted to see an egg on every plate in every house at least three times daily. What is he doing about it now that he is more influential with the Government than any of us, because he put them there; he had to put them there? Now, as a result of the actions of his comrades and of himself eggs have reached a prohibitive price in this city, and the Government have remained silent about it. There is many a home in this city, in the towns of Portlaoise, Tramore, Carlow, Mountmellick, Birr and Edenderry—I am saying this for the use of the Official Reports—the working class inhabitants of which cannot afford to purchase eggs.

Comment on this

Who told us to choke the hens?

Comment on this

The price of eggs has now become reckless and, according to the Fianna Fáil Government, the egg is to be purchased only by the banker, the professional man and the upper ten—the swanks. The egg is to be forgotten by the labourer, the widows and orphans and the poor unfortunate sections of our people. The Tánaiste must know that half the wage-earners of this country, if the information contained in this disgraceful document is correct, are earning approximately £3 10s. per week. We find ourselves in the position that no home of the working-class people in this city or in any of our provincial towns can find it possible to purchase eggs.

Be that as it may, the Tánaiste was not satisfied at that. Very soon afterwards we saw that when they succeeded in depriving the workers of this country of eggs, they said: "Our next step now to cripple them properly will be to deprive them of the egg's pal in the pan, the rasher." And they did so most successfully. Fianna Fáil are making wonderful strides in starving the people of this country.

Next we saw, on the 27th September in all the daily papers, this spectacle: "Bacon and pork decontrolled. Prices Order to be revoked." It was bad enough to deprive them entirely of the egg. Here we see bacon and pork decontrolled. It is quite true to say that during the term of office of the inter-Party Government every home in this country that wanted bacon and eggs could have had them twice a day at least; the bacon was available because the price was controlled, and the eggs were available.

But to-day the eggs are for the rich. The controls are off bacon and that is for the rich because they can charge what they wish for the bacon. The price of bacon, rashers, ham or pork to-day is completely outside the control of the working-class people of this country. The Tánaiste might well be satisfied. He has done a good job. The people can well tighten their belts now if they have any hips to keep the belt from slipping off entirely if Fianna Fáil is to remain in office for very long.

They have scored one point. They have achieved their aim of starving the poor. They are winning and doing well. They are succeeding in starving the people of this country and in making prices so prohibitive that the housewife or the wage-earner or the head of the family will be unable to purchase the necessaries of life to keep the bodies and souls of his family and himself together.

At the same time as bacon and pork were decontrolled, that bacon went up and pork went up, pigs went down. Can anyone understand that? Will the Tánaiste say how it was that the price of pigs fell when bacon and pork were decontrolled. I cannot understand that, and it is something that would take explanation.

On 7th July, 1951, we saw a notice appearing in all the papers which has had a very serious effect on the rise in the cost of living, and which stated: "Increased charges for electricity supply." We know that Fianna Fáil cannot possibly put a charge on the wind, on the rain or on the sunshine, but they had to do it with the light and did it fairly successfully. The very people who were bringing down the cost of living five months before, here is their record to date. Rate-payers throughout the whole country who pay for public lighting out of the rates—and I want members of local authorities to mark this—have to pay more for public lighting than they had to pay when we were in office. The man with the factory, with the mill, with the shop, with the dwelling-house, with the four-walled cabin—unless he uses the wax candle—is paying more for electric light than he was paying when the inter-Party Government was in office. The electric light bill is a bill which every housewife views with the gravest possible concern.

Comment on this

Sack the board.

Comment on this

No time was lost in seeing that the Electricity Supply Board had approval for their increase. I fail to understand, when we have additional power stations working, when we are making more electricity, when there is more of it being consumed, how this institution can get away, with the silence and consent of the Government, with robbing open-eyed the people of this country that consume electricity. I say that the Electricity Supply Board charges are mad and that no responsible Government outside the mental hospital would approve of the Electricity Supply Board charges. There are people paying for electric light in flats and in their ordinary humble homes. People in every walk of life must have light——

Comment on this

I agree with the Deputy.

Comment on this

——and here we find that Electricity Supply Board is allowed to stick their two hands into the trouser pockets of the workers who need light. That not alone affects the workers, but the business man, the professional man, the man with his office, the man with his mill, the man with his factory, the shopkeeper. Every section of the people are feeling the pinch of the unreasonable, unfair and unjust charges for electricity.

We find that nobody even sneezed on the Fianna Fáil benches about that. Did Deputy Corry mention it? Did any of the Deputies who have spoken to date refer to the way in which the Electricity Supply Board is robbing the people—and I deliberately use that expression? The people are not getting a fair return from the Electricity Supply Board. Electricity Supply Board charges are at least five times too high. It is all right for the Tánaiste, who can switch on here and switch on there. He can meet his Electricity Supply Board bills, but take the ordinary worker with a wage of £3 10s. per week who has to use electric light in his kitchen or in any of his three rooms at night time.

He is forgotten completely. Almost everyone in this country, as a ratepayer, is paying for public lighting. and in that way is affected by these increased charges. The Electricity Supply Board has got away with it so far, and they will get away with it while Fianna Fáil are in office, because Fianna Fáil will always cater for the needs of institutions such as the Electricity Supply Board. Please God, at a later stage in my speech I am going to advocate that the Electricity Supply Board be completely nationalised and I have a series of questions to put to the Minister for Industry and Commerce on this issue at a later stage.

Deputies from rural Ireland may say: "Oh, the increase in the electricity charges do not affect us very much as we have not yet got the benefits of rural electrification." Let these Deputies not think for one moment that they escaped because they did not escape. When the Tánaiste saw that the Electricity Supply Board charges were approved, he was happy because he said: "Now the people in the towns and cities will have to pay more." Then he thought: "The lads in the country are going to get away with it; how am I going to get my hands into their pockets? Paraffin oil! I will get them on that." Therefore, you see an announcement in the daily papers of the 27/7/51, and in particular in the Irish Press:“Price of paraffin oil up.” So after hitting the man in the towns and cities, the men on the hills and in the valleys, in the weary, dreary parts of rural Ireland have got to feel the pinch as well. They have to purchase paraffin oil. Their only alternative is to sit in the dark to lament that Fianna Fáil is in office and that they have to pay more to the Tánaiste for his paraffin oil.

The unfortunate farmer who lights his paraffin oil lamp at 4.30 on a winter's evening, and who keeps that lamp lighted for his game of cards or his chat or even to entertain the Seanachie, as people do in Deputy Cunningham's constituency, will have to pay an extra charge for his paraffin oil. He must either do that, sit in the dark or sit by the light of his fire, because of Fianna Fáil's attempt to raise the cost of living by increasing the price of the quarter of a gallon of oil that he buys for household purposes. They succeeded very well in their attempt. I am sorry that Deputy Corry is not here now. However, his twin brother, Deputy Cogan, is here, and he will bear with me for one moment when I say that the unfortunate farmer who has to purchase paraffin oil——

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy has said that at least half a dozen times.

Comment on this

He has to use paraffin oil for farm purposes as well as for household purposes. If a beast becomes ill during the night time, the farmer has no alternative to lighting his paraffin oil lamp to enable him to go to the aid of the sick cow, the sick calf or the sick pig, as the case may be. He finds that that is more expensive now than it was six months ago when the inter-Party Government was in office. Does he realise that he has been gulled and blinded and that the Fianna Fáil Party have done their damnedest to deprive him of his light, to make him sit in the corner of his humble homestead in the dark, blindly lamenting the fact, probably, that he voted for Fianna Fáil?

Here is what we see next. A notice appears in all the daily papers on the 14th September, 1951, and this is the way it reads: "Stonger, but dearer, ale." They did not even let that escape. The bottle of ale was the farmer's consoling drink on a fair day. It was there to quench the bog worker's thirst. The bog worker in Clonsast, Turaun and Boora, in my constituency, got the next touch. An unfortunate man, after a long, hard day's work in the fields, between the handles of a plough, following his horses from sunrise to nightfall with skill and industry, when his throat becomes parched with thirst, likes to have a bottle of ale.

Comment on this

You would want one now.

Comment on this

He got that bottle of ale at a reasonable price when the inter-Party Government was in office but he finds now that he has to pay more for it. What is the sad part of all this? The sad part of it is that some of these thirsty people, who drink ale, are to-day lubricating their throats with dearer ale and shouting "Up, Dev." at the same time. Is that not the sad part of it? Is that not the part that is hard to understand when we find a big section of our people——

Comment on this

Anybody who understands monetary reform could surely understand that.

Comment on this

When Deputy Cunningham has been as long in this House as I have been, he will have more manners. Deputy Cunningham is an apt pupil in a certain school but probably we shall be able to give him a better certificate if he comes back after the next election. We see no regret whatever amongst Deputies on the opposite side for depriving the unfortunate working man of the pleasure and delight of quenching his thirst with a bottle of ale after a hard day's work. Fianna Fáil were certainly very successful in inflicting that deprivation on him.

That takes us a little further. Two days afterwards, on 30th July, 1951, we read in the newspapers—not gloomy reading this time for the housewife but gloomy reading for all local authorities —"Cement prices up from to-day". They were not making enough out of it —and I say here that there is a hell of a racket in cement in this country. Cement was increased on 30th July, 1951, by 12/6 per ton. The fact that there was an increase in the price of cement meant that building costs increased considerably. That increase occurred under this Fianna Fáil Government which was shouting to house the people—"Provide houses. Get along with the building."—and that was asking the farmers to build proper piggeries, cowsheds, barns and various other outoffices. We find that in order to make building work prohibitive, in order to curtail building activities, in order to make it impossible for anyone to build privately and in order to make it difficult for local authorities to get on with the housing drive, cement was increased by 12/6 per ton.

Comment on this

How many tons of cement would build a four-roomed house?

Comment on this

I say that the price of cement to-day is daft and that more consideration should have been given to the cement question by this Fianna Fáil Government.

Comment on this

What is the price of cement?

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D.J. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

Deputy Cunningham should restrain himself.

Comment on this

The price of cement was increased by 12/6 per ton to 22/6 per ton as from 30th July, 1951.

Comment on this

If you can buy it at that price you are all right.

Comment on this

There was an increase of that amount per ton.

Comment on this

All imported cement, because the factories were left as they were when I left office.

Comment on this

I do not believe a word of it.

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D.J. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

The Tánaiste relaxed the restrictions on luxury building the moment he came back into office.

Comment on this

You were exporting in 1946 and 1947.

Comment on this

And will again, please God.

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D.J. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

And leave the farmers and builders without cement.

Comment on this

There was an increase from 12/6 to 22/6 per ton in the price of cement. If Deputy Cowan wants to know the price of a ton of cement I can tell him that he will get it for £8 now, and that he would have got it much cheaper six months ago when we were in office.

Comment on this

How many tons of cement will it take to build a four-roomed house?

Comment on this

Deputy Cowan knows that he is responsible for inflicting this burning hardship on the people.

Comment on this

Why will the Deputy not answer my question? I asked him how many tons of cement it will take to build a four-roomed house.

Comment on this

Why add £3? I know the £3 would be nothing to Deputy Cowan. He would be able to get £3, while he would be looking around him, for giving advice.

Comment on this

It would be good advice.

Comment on this

However, why that £3. To a very great extent, the cost of building has gone wild since the present Government took office. The price of timber has vastly increased. The price of steel windows has vastly increased. Lead cannot be had, and if it is available an impossible price is asked for it. Slates and tiles have increased in price. Paints of all kinds have vastly increased in price. Pitch and tar have increased in price. The price of all these commodities has increased, and the cost of building has gone sky high since this Cowan-Cogan Fianna Fáil set-up has taken office. These are the fruits of the present set-up.

Local authorities now find that they cannot proceed with the housing drive because of the increases sanctioned by the irresponsible Tánaiste for materials which are essential in the building of houses. Local authorities find that if they do proceed with the housing drive the houses will be set to the tenants at a rent which they cannot pay—so it is as broad as it is long. We find, therefore, that as far as building is concerned, this Government, instead of encouraging it, has done everything it can possibly do to prevent it by sanctioning unreasonable and unnecessary increases in essential building materials.

We read of the increase in the price of cement on 30th July, 1951. The next day, the 31st July, the papers announced more price increases. Milk got a touch this time in Dublin and elsewhere. The price of coke was increased and the price of oatmeal was increased. We cannot help remembering the good old days when Deputy Dr. Browne was advocating a "Drink more Milk" campaign and when the present Minister for Health, Deputy Dr. Ryan, was advocating a "Drink more Milk" campaign. Both Deputy Dr. Browne and the present Minister for Health forgot their appeals to the people to drink more milk in the interests of their health when they deprived the schoolchildren in Dublin of their bottle of milk and when they deprived the council worker and the factory worker of the milk that coloured their black tea. Every Deputy in this House knows that what I say is true.

Comment on this

Who increased the price of school meals? Did that not take place during your time in office?

Comment on this

The price of milk to-day has increased considerably in comparison with the price of milk six months ago when the inter-Party Government were in office. The people of this city—and the people of Fairview: we must not forget them—are paying more for milk to-day, thanks to Deputy Cowan, than they had to pay for it when the inter-Party Government were in office. Mothers with young children must now pay an increased price for milk for their children.

We say that has been done successfully by Fianna Fáil again and the Tánaiste must take responsibility for the sadness, despair and discontent which is in practically every household in Dublin and in our provincial towns.

Milk is a very essential part of our national diet because, without it, it is impossible to exist. The Irish have been noted tea drinkers. Having to drink tea without milk is distasteful, but it is the policy of the Fianna Fáil-Cowan-Cogan set-up to bring the people in Dundalk, Drogheda, Mullingar, Dublin City, Cork, and in every other large city or town back to the days of the black tea. Milk, and now butter and cheese have become luxuries.

Comment on this

There is more milk drunk in Dublin than ever before.

Comment on this

That is not true.

Comment on this

It is absolutely true.

Comment on this

The Deputy knows it is not true.

Comment on this

So does Deputy Flanagan. There is more milk drunk in Dublin than ever before.

Comment on this

Not at all, and the Deputy knows it quite well. He is only trying to justify himself voting for this increase.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

To say that a Deputy is saying a thing which he knows to be untrue is to charge that Deputy with telling a lie.

Comment on this

It may be a falsehood and not a lie. The price of milk has been increased to such an extent that there are families to-day which cannot purchase it. The House may say that Deputy Flanagan has told us everything about what Fianna Fáil has put up and nothing about what they brought down and that he has, so far, given a one-sided story and he has not given them credit for bringing down anything. On 3rd October, 1951, this notice appeared in the paper: "Prices Fall in the Dublin Market." That is what they brought down. To their disgrace and disgust Fianna Fáil were not satisfied until they brought down the prices that Deputy James Dillon, when Minister for Agriculture, got for our live stock. Is that to their credit? It is to their disgrace. They are the people who told the farmers they would guarantee them prices. They could not guarantee them the prices Deputy James Dillon got for them.

Deputy Corry speaks with anger and bitterness against the former Minister for Agriculture, Deputy James Dillon, but he knows within his heart that as far as ability or intelligence is concerned, Deputy Thomas Walsh, the present Minister for Agriculture, could not wipe the heels of Deputy Dillon's shoes.

Comment on this

You ought to cut out those personal references.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The personality of the Minister does not arise on this. Everything that is true does not arise on this.

Comment on this

We are not discussing everything.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The personality of the Minister does not arise at all.

Comment on this

Certainly the Minister's actions must arise on this.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I am telling the Deputy that the personality of the Minister does not arise.

Comment on this

I have accepted the ruling of the Ceann Comhairle on that, but I am still entitled to criticise the Minister's action which is bad, wrong and unsound. The least the Government might have done was to keep on the price for live stock which was guaranteed by the former Minister for Agriculture.

Comment on this

Keep the price of beef up.

Comment on this

The notice "Prices fall in the Dublin Market" appeared in the newspapers for all the farmers in the Midlands to read. So, Fianna Fáil brought down something. Did they bring down anything else? They did and I will give them credit for it. Here is what dropped under the Fianna Fáil administration: "Cheap travel for tourist planes." Put that side by side with what appeared in the papers on the 1st September: "A Jump in Córas Iompair Éireann Bus and Train Fares." Bus and train fares went up and aeroplane fares went down. A leopard never changes his spots and it is hard to beat an old dog off his track —very hard. How many of the poor people in Dublin who travel by the 2d. bus are now able to do so because the fare has been increased to 3d.? How many of them will ever see an aeroplane on the ground much less use it for transport? The Tánaiste is more concerned with the la-de-das who can fly from Shannon to Collinstown than he is with the worker who has to travel from Crumlin and Kimmage.

The Minister for Industry and Commerce in the inter-Party Government used his sound judgement as far as Córas Iompair Éireann fares were concerned. We all know the real motives behind the Minister's permitting Córas Iompair Éireann to increase the train and bus fares. I will say nothing more about that. The House has its own intelligence. This is the poor man's Government. It is the workers' Government. It is the Government which will bring down the cost of living but for what section of the community? Is it for those who travel in aeroplanes or for the unfortunate workers who have to use the train or bus? This Government are the poor man's friends. Look at them for an outfit of poor men's friends!

St. Paul once wrote that much was expected of those who know much, but we cannot expect much from those who know little. The Government were more concerned with the cigar smoker who could walk in and book a ticket to fly through the clouds leaving a trail of smoke behind him than they were with the unfortunate worker who has to board the bus in O'Connell Street. The unfortunate countryman, who had no other means of travelling to the city except by train and bus, had, at the request of the Tánaiste and with his full consent and approval, to bend his knee to Córas Iompair Éireann and allow Córas Iompair Éireann to stick their hands down into his trouser pockets and take out additional money for fares. The toff, however, who could fly in his aeroplane, had his cheaper fares.

But that is not at all the best of it. We then find that after the Córas Iompair Éireann bus and train fares had increased and after the "cheap travel for tourist planes" was announced, the next thing we saw was: "Aer Lingus cuts the excursion fares." The excursion fares were not low enough so they cut them again to make sure that they would cater properly for the well-to-do and the la-de-da who could fly, but John Citizen had to run or walk, or else pay more for his bus or train to bring him to or from his work, or from the city to his local town. The gentleman who could fly, however, got special consideration. Not alone were the excursion fares fixed at a reasonable level, but they were further cut, in order to suit the well-to-do man's taste. Now we know where the poor man's Government comes in and we know who are concerned with the poor. In the eyes of the De Valera-Cogan-Cowan coup, the man who can fly is more important than the unfortunate man who needs transport by Córas Iompair Éireann bus or train. We have been threatened that even though Córas Iompair Éireann increased its fares, that is not enough and they are still running at a loss.

Comment on this

What is the point?

Comment on this

And in the near future we are going to see a number of men allowed to go on to the unemployed list, which is big enough already. It is increasing steadily every day. I have the figures here and I shall be quoting them to-morrow because I have to deal with the White Paper and with the misleading report of the Central Bank. I have not touched these yet.

Comment on this

You will be like a clog dancer in a Russian ballet, if you deal with the Central Bank.

Comment on this

Córas Iompair Éireann were permitted to stick their hands down in the people's pockets. I am telling you this again because, as sure as we are here—we have been told that Córas Iompair Éireann is running at a loss—an attempt will be made to make Córas Iompair Éireann run on a basis which will pay by putting the fares up on the unforunate users of rail and road services or by dismissing the workers employed in Córas Iompair Éireann. That is the only alternative. Córas Iompair Éireann is a badly managed institution —it must be. Why would it not be when foreigners and aliens are dictating its policy?

Comment on this

Who is the foreigner?

Comment on this

Do you want his name?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

A fellow by the name of Stuart is one—not an Irishman. I will give Deputy Cowan any information he wants and he knows well that what I am saying is true. Córas Iompair Éireann are fleecing the people in their freight charges and how could it be otherwise when they have embarked on their wild, crazy scheme of running road transport in competition with the rail services. Is there any one of us would run our business in that fashion?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Is the Government responsible?

Comment on this

Yes. The Minister for Industry and Commerce has definite responsibility.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I do not think that is so.

Comment on this

You may not know as much about it as I know.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Chair is of opinion that the Minister for Industry and Commerce is not responsible for the running of Córas Iompair Éireann and until some evidence is produced to the contrary, I suggest that the Deputy might leave the subject.

Comment on this

The Minister for Industry and Commerce appoints the Board of Córas Iompair Éireann.

Comment on this

I have no responsibility for the board.

Comment on this

But you have responsibility for sanctioning increases in bus and train fares.

Comment on this

I have nothing to do with those, either. That is the law you passed—that I should have no function in the matter.

Comment on this

The Minister approved of them.

Comment on this

It was not asked for.

Comment on this

Did you protest against it?

Comment on this

The law you passed set up the board and gave the board full authority in the matter.

Comment on this

When the Minister was on this side of the House, he protested vigorously and determinedly but now the shoe is on the other foot and the Minister is as meek as a mouse.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

We cannot discuss every business organisation in the country on this Bill.

Comment on this

So much for Córas Iompair Éireann. All this painful and distasteful stuff that has appeared in the papers since the de Valera-Cogan-Cowan coup took office——

Comment on this

Imagine men dying to bring this about.

Comment on this

If Deputy Cowan is ashamed of being linked up with de Valera and Cogan now, why was he not ashamed at the outset?

Comment on this

The Deputy is bringing the debate to a very low level.

Comment on this

Drag yourself down if you like, but do not drag down the House.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Let us have Deputy Flanagan on the Bill and amendments.

Comment on this

Unrationed sugar is to cost more. That is the notice that appeared in the following day's paper.

Comment on this

Who said: "Blow up two factories"?

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D.J. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

Who said they were white elephants?

Comment on this

"Put beet and wheat up the spout."

Comment on this

Might I ask if this is question time?

Comment on this

Sugar is to cost more. I want to tell the House that while Deputy Cogan and Deputy Corry may make reference to the acreage under beet in connection with sugar production and with reference to my remarks about the Minister's unreasonable increase in the price of unrationed sugar, in 1939, there were 41,661 acres under beet in this country, and, in 1950, under Deputy Dillon there were 60,002 acres. There was never more beet grown than was grown during Deputy Dillon's period of office. That is the answer to Deputy Cogan.

Comment on this

We grew it in spite of you.

Comment on this

I know that a lot of the Deputy's talk would make good manure for the beet. There was never more beet grown than was grown when Deputy Dillon was Minister, and the Tánaiste knows that.

Comment on this

The smallest acreage for 20 years.

Comment on this

The Tánaiste has the figures before him, as I have.

Comment on this

You have not. If you have, you are not reading them. The acreage in 1950 was the smallest for 20 years.

Comment on this

That is not true. In 1950, 60,002 acres and, in 1939, when the Minister was Tánaiste, 41,661 acres. He cannot deny these figures, nor can anybody else deny them. These are figures published by the Department of Agriculture. The Tánaiste did not get at them to change them. Deputy Cogan knows these figures, but through rottenness of heart and jealousy, he will not admit that Deputy Dillon had a record acreage under beet in 1950. We are proud of that acreage, because it shows that there was a great attempt made by the farmers and that it followed on the encouragement given by the Minister. Under a Fianna Fáil Government in 1939, the acreage was less than the acreage grown when Deputy Dillon was Minister for Agriculture. I hope that Deputies now realise that the farmers did grow and produce beet in abundance in 1950.

Comment on this