Adjournment Debate.
Contributions 143–300 of 300. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
I do not wish to hold the House any longer. I have put the case honestly and squarely before the House. I have nailed two lies, and we will nail any more if Deputies opposite have any left in the bag.
Comment on this
Having listened to the mellifluous tones of the Deputy who has just sat down, one must be in doubt as to whether this is Christmas or Lent because we have certainly been doing our penance. As usual, Deputy Corry makes his exit.
Comment on this
The intervention by the Tánaiste in this debate to-night seemed to me to come at a rather peculiar moment. He seemed to be endeavouring to anticipate arguments which might be made by Labour representatives on this motion. He made a number of points, and one of his arguments was that, while unemployment has been developing over a period, the trend is now in the right direction and unemployment is on the down grade. That is what I gathered from his remarks, and in that connection I should like to quote the figures, the most recent figures available, to show just what the trend of unemployment is. Last year, on 1st December, the number of unemployed registered at labour exchanges was 56,790, and this year on 1st December the number was 61,070. In one week, as between 24th November and 1st December of this year, the number of unemployed rose from 59,800 odd to 61,070, so that it does not appear that the trend is in the right direction. Quite the contrary is the case.
Regardless of what excuses Deputy Corry or the Tánaiste may make, the people of the country realise one fact at present—and if you listen to them in the streets, in buses, or wherever they gather this will be borne out— that the cost of living is rising, that nothing appears to be done about it, and that unemployment is increasing.
Comment on this
Regardless of what stupid interruptions Deputy Burke may make in the matter, they hold this Government, just as they held the inter-Party Government, responsible for the economic condition of the country, and rightly so. Whatever the economic condition of the people may be, the Government must assume a responsibility for it. What do political Parties seek power for but to assume that responsibility? I think it is time that the Government faced up to its responsibility in this matter. I am not so concerned with what happened in the recent or distant past. I think there is too much time spent in talking about what happened in the past. The people of this country and the people I represent want to know what will happen in the future. They want to know what the next six months hold for them. Christmas may be a season of goodwill but for a large number of working-class families in the City and County of Dublin it will be one of the worst Christmases they will experience for many years from the point of view of money being made available to enable them to purchase goods. The Government has a responsibility in that respect. When there is any slump in trade which brings unemployment it is the duty of the Government, in my view, to take any steps that may be necessary to provide employment for disemployed workers.
In Dublin County a number of workers were disemployed as a result of a depression in the hosiery trade and in the textile industry. This happened in Balbriggan and Lucan. The help we got from the Government, which is the central authority, in putting those workers into employment for the Christmas period was negligible. County Councils were forced—as county councils throughout Ireland are forced just at the moment —to raise money by means of levying on the rates of the county to relieve a desperate condition of affairs. It is no exaggeration to say that the position is desperate. Skilled hosiers in the town of Balbriggan, who learned their trade from their fathers, who, in turn, learned it from their fathers before them, have been disemployed. The hosiery trade has existed in that town for almost 200 years, although Deputy Burke sometimes claims that he found it, but he is hardly that old. These men, with a skill which is worth something to the country and which represents wealth for the country, are now down on the foreshore picking winkles.
Comment on this
They are back at work again this week. Deputy Dunne helped the inter-Party Government to stockpile in order to disemploy these people. Now he wants to try and bluff the House.
Comment on this
I am surprised at Deputy Burke's anxiety to defend the Fianna Fáil Party because he was not too kindly dealt with by them in the last election.
Comment on this
That is wrong. There was never anything of that kind. If the Deputy wants dirt I will give it to him.
Comment on this
There is no dirt in it. It is common knowledge. Everybody knows it. Unemployment has assumed more serious proportions than it has ever assumed for a long number of years, not alone in my constituency but in rural areas throughout the country. For the past three years 1,400 men have been employed by the Meath County Council in operations under the Local Authorities (Works) Act. There are now 700 employed and 700 unemployed, as any Meath Deputy or member of the Meath County Council can verify.
The same tale is being told all over the country. Whatever chance there may be in big cities and towns such as Dublin, Cork, Galway and Waterford for a man to obtain some form of alternative employment when his ordinary employment ceases, it is better left to the imagination than described the chance he has of securing alternative employment if he works in a rural area miles away from any industry. In these areas, where he solely depends on working on drainage schemes or road works for the county council, his only alternative is to turn to agriculture. Agriculture does not seek labour at this time of the year, as everybody knows. There is real hardship in the rural areas as a result of unemployment. Many unemployed workers throughout rural areas—most of them probably voted for Fianna Fáil Deputies at the last election and may do so again, except in my constituency—have written to me to ask me to ask the Government what is going to be done for them.
Comment on this
Last year, £96,000 was provided by way of free grants to the Meath County Council by Deputy Keyes, to whom Deputy Hilliard has referred, for the employment of workers in County Meath. I doubt whether any grant ever received before by any county council for employment purposes of that nature can compare with that particular grant. I do not think that Deputy Hilliard or the Meath County Council have any complaint to make against Deputy Keyes. If they have, they are merely indulging in purely political bias. There is nothing new in that, of course. We have come to expect that from the benches opposite.
Comment on this
Deputy Martin Corry inevitably makes his exit when he has attacked somebody. He always runs away. I think there is some other form of life, which is not entirely human, that has the same kind of habit. I would like to say to members of the Fianna Fáil Party who are in the House that the farmers, as a body —the creamery farmers to some extent—have to thank Deputy Corry for having put the present Government in an embarrassing position, when they assumed office in June last, by forcing their hands to some extent to pay an extra penny a gallon for the price of milk. Deputy Corry is not satisfied with that. That increase in the price of milk meant an increase last year of 4d. per lb. in the price of butter. Those of us who represent Dublin areas, particularly suburban or small town areas around the city, know very well how great a hardship that is on the ordinary working people.
Very often it is suggested that the people who live in or about the city are living in luxury while those who live in the South of Ireland, particularly those who live in Cork, are enslaved and are holding up the rest of the country on their shoulders.
In the City and County of Dublin there is a population of over 600,000 people. Those people have to foot the bill for the increase in the price of butter. Deputy Corry states that the farmer is not getting enough for milk and obviously intends to exert all the pressure he can to get still more for milk. The only way that can be done is by an increase in the price of butter to the consumer. I wonder if all the Fianna Fáil Deputies are in agreement with that policy. I wonder if the present Minister for Agriculture proposes to bow to the will of Deputy Corry in this matter. It is of very great importance, because it will mean that the cost of living will go up further than it has gone since 13th June.
Let us refresh our memory as to the commodities that have been increased since 13th June. I am quoting from the Official Report of the Dáil Debates on Thursday, 6th December, 1951, column 537.
Comment on this
I have no circular. I will give the Deputy circulars very shortly that he will not like to hear about. I am taking the figures from a reply by the Minister for Industry and Commerce when he was asked by Deputy Declan Costello to give a list of the items that had been increased in price since 13th June and which was circulated with the Official Report. The following increases took place: Unrationed sugar, 1d. per lb.; condensed full cream milk, 1½d. and 2d. per tin; condensed skimmed milk 1½d. per tin; confectionery (sweets and chocolates), ranging from 4d. to 1/- per lb.; table jellies ½d. per tablet (two manufacturers); coal, various increases in different areas, ranging from 5/- to £1 per ton; gas, various increases, ranging from 1.25d. per therm to 5.4d. per therm in different areas; electricity 0.3d. per unit, 0.2d. per unit for night storage heating; bus fares, within eight miles of General Post Office, Dublin, ?d. per mile, outside eight miles of the General Post Office, Dublin, ¼d. per mile; tobacco, hard plug. 1½d. per oz., roll and coil, 2d. per oz., cut plug, flake, etc., 1d. to 4d. per oz.
We all know about creamery butter. On the 3rd August, cocoa was increased. Fresh milk was increased on 1st August. Then on the 29th August cheese was increased. Peas and beans were increased on the 3rd July. I do not suppose ale is regarded as an item to be calculated in the cost of living.
Comment on this
It is regarded by many people as of great importance. Dr. Ryan recommended it at some time, and even more prominent leaders than Dr. Ryan recommended it. I suppose we could accept it as an integral part of the diet. The price of ale was increased on 9th August. Soaps were increased on 22nd June; petroleum products on 27th July and on the 29th October. Imported timber was increased on 7th November. There is a long list of other items that were increased at column 540, to which I would refer Deputies. The reference is Volume 128, No. 4.
That is a sorry picture so far as the people are concerned, and even Deputies with the Demosthenic eloquence of Deputy Burke will have a job explaining at the chapel gates in a very short time just how this came about.
There is another matter to which I wish to refer. As most Deputies know, I have been associated to some degree with efforts which have been made over a period to improve the wages and working conditions of agricultural workers. When discussing unemployment and rising prices we must take into consideration and have reference to the inadequate wage rates provided for those who work on the land for employers. I submit that these men in rural areas, to whom I have already referred, suffer greater economic hardship than any other section and their number is not small. The number of male workers on the land is about 150,000. There are many others in respect of whom no statistics are available, such as sons of small farmers who may be working on the one holding, and female relatives of small farmers and of agricultural workers.
Some time ago I thought it opportune to ask the Dáil to express an opinion on the question of the very low, starvation level wages which are paid to agricultural workers. A motion was discussed. It will be recalled that the Government Party and some of its adherents voted against that motion and defeated it. The case was made in the House by the Minister for Agriculture and by others that there was only one way of dealing with the wages of agricultural workers and that was through the wages board.
It was made out to be a sacrosanct organisation whose function it was to regulate conditions and wages as between farmers and workers, and that the House would be interfering unduly if it gave a simple expression of opinion. All it was asked to do was to say that a farm labourer was entitled to £4 a week.
Comment on this
Were not we asked to say that a farm labourer in County Dublin was entitled to more than a farm labourer in Cavan, Kerry or somewhere else—something that I would not subscribe to?
Comment on this
That may be an avenue of escape for some but the simple fact is, and cannot be got away from, and Deputy Cowan knows it is correct and so does Deputy Burke—it is one of the things that he will have a job to explain away at a very early date in the constituency that he and I represent— that this House by a majority, with many absentees who apparently were not sufficiently interested in agricultural workers to cast a vote one way or the other, decided that it was better that the Agricultural Wages Board should look after the agricultural workers. It was, I suppose, pure coincidence that on the following Sunday, the Government organ, the Sunday Press, had an article carrying big black headlines about the forgotten men of Irish agriculture. The effort was then being made to retrieve what was thought might be lost political ground. “Forgotten men” were referred to.
Comment on this
The Chair has no sympathy with people who look for interruptions or with interrupters. I would advise both sides.
Comment on this
I think you are being unkind to me, a Cheann Chomhairle. I am not seeking conversation with Deputy Burke at all.
Comment on this
I am not abusing at all. I do not like to hear a man talking about something he knows nothing about.
Comment on this
That particular interjection is on a par with the statement made by the Minister for Agriculture that I did not know anything about agricultural workers. I will leave it to the agricultural workers and the farmers to decide, not the Deputy or anybody else.
Comment on this
Would Deputy Dunne not agree that a County Meath agricultural worker is entitled to as much as a County Dublin agricultural worker?
Comment on this
I was referring to this report which appeared in what has been very aptly described as the kept newspaper of the Government Party regarding the "forgotten men." It was definitely suggested there that their only hope was the Agricultural Wages Board for increased wages to help them to fight rising prices and the increased cost of living and it was suggested that they should turn their eyes in that direction. What happened? This glorified Agricultural Wages Board met on the 6th of this month and refused to give one single halfpenny to the agricultural workers by way of increase. How are these men to face rising prices and an increased cost of living? I ask anybody to tell me that. The average wage of agricultural workers throughout the country is somewhere between £3 7s. 6d. and £3 10s.
Comment on this
Why does Deputy Dunne not do something as a trade union representative about that instead of asking the Dáil to do it? Why does he not do something in the same way as every trade union representative in the country?
Comment on this
I have given Deputy Burke a good deal of latitude and he should allow Deputy Dunne to make his statement without interruption.
Comment on this
——or be unkind to him except to say that when he tried his hand as a trade union official——
Comment on this
I want to draw particular attention to one point so that Deputies in this House and agricultural workers throughout the country will be under no misapprehension regarding the attitude of the present Government vis-a-vis rising prices. It is obviously intended that the old policy of maintaining a huge mass of agricultural workers as a foundation for an economy of some kind or other is going to be pursued, and this policy means maintaining them at a very low level. The present Government's policy is to continue on those lines, on the basis we saw it operate in other years when we had large scale unemployment. I am now talking of prewar years. During the war, as everybody appreciates, there was artificial employment and wholesale emigration. Artificial employment was produced by forced conditions, but before the war, in 1937 and in 1938, which could be regarded as something approaching normality if not exactly normal years, we all remember the long queues outside the labour exchanges and agricultural workers getting 24/- or 30/- a week.
Comment on this
That was the basis of the Fianna Fáil administration. Indeed the people in the country, in Deputy Hilliard's constituency as well as in others with which I have contact, and the agricultural workers are anxious to know if that policy is to be pursued because from what we have seen in the last six months there is a bleak outlook from the point of view of unemployment and the cost of living. Whatever may be said, whatever excuses may be offered for this Government or whatever may be said in derogation of the previous administration, there is one fact in the mind of the people—and when this Government goes to the people it will find no method of getting over that fact or beating it down—and that fact is that during the previous Government's term of office there was the nearest thing to full employment. This Government will not last when it gets to the polls.
Comment on this
Unemployment rose from 58,000 to 70,000 on your taking office. Unemployment was higher in 1948-1949 than in the previous year.
Comment on this
You have only 25 minutes to go. I do not know whether a member of the Government is to reply.
Comment on this
Deputy Davin should listen to the reply, as he might be interested. I owe thanks to a colleague of mine, Deputy Colm Gallagher, for having given me a reference I was seeking for some time, an extract from a book called Down the Years, by Sir Austen Chamberlain. I am not going to read the whole reference, but I would recommend to members of the House to seek that book and read the reference. In this reference one member of the English Parliament is saying to another in reference to an Irish member of Parliament: “Have you ever seen a man caught cheating at cards have his hand pinned to the table with a knife?” I would also draw the attention of the House to Volume 126 of the Dáil Debates, July 17th, 1951, column 1787. We have a reference from Deputy Dillon, who said in this House:—
"The Minister for Finance wants to know why there was no reference in the motion in this Order Paper to the action of the Taoiseach. I shall tell him. Because the motion was put down before I pinned the Taoiseach's hand to the desk. The motion was put down before the printed copy of the unrevised report was issued. You cannot pin the cheat's hand to the card table until he stretches forth his hand to play a dishonest card."
Comment on this
I refer to that first of all, and will come back to it later. Earlier this week in a debate on a fuel Estimate, Deputy Dillon referred to me and uttered deliberate falsehoods in this House.
Comment on this
I withdraw the words "deliberate falsehood". He certainly made use of a falsehood, and I want on the eve of the Adjournment of this House for the Christmas holidays, to state now, notwithstanding what the Tánaiste has said in the matter, that these statements were false in every respect.
Comment on this
I want to put on record another thing. I was expecting to be called before you, Sir, and brought before the Committee on Procedure and Privileges.
Comment on this
The Minister for Finance and I may not agree on what is relevant to a debate. I cannot see any relevancy at all in it.
Comment on this
In this debate statements were made which were untrue. Statements are made and all kinds of interjections are hurled across the House repeating false charges, as were made this evening by Deputy Flanagan, the bed-fellow of Deputy Dillon. It is very difficult to keep the prestige of this House at the standard it should be kept.
Comment on this
I do not want to keep on intervening but really I do not see what relevance this has at all to the debate. Deputies who have spoken and Ministers have referred to the cost of living, unemployment, agricultural production and such things. The prestige of this House is worth preserving and that is why I want to preserve it on this occasion as well as on other occasions.
Comment on this
We heard references here to a Fianna Fáil policy. We were told that the Fianna Fáil leaders and the Fianna Fáil Party sought the support of the electorate on deliberate false statements and promises. Extracts were read from speeches which were made during the general election campaign and interpretations were put on these speeches which no honourable person could possibly agree to.
We heard Deputy O'Higgins to-night read a statement which was made on the eve of the general election by the Tánaiste in which the Tánaiste said that he could not hold out any promise to bring immediate or quick relief with regard to a reduction of prices. Deputy O'Higgins gave us his interpretation of that speech and put on the records of the House something which was untrue. I wonder whether the time has not come, particularly when we have an Adjournment debate, to make reference to accusations and statements which are incorrect and without foundation. I should like to point out that Deputy Dillon used the reference to the cheat having his hand pinned to the table notwithstanding the fact that that reference was used against his own father in the House of Commons.
Comment on this
On a point of order. The Deputy is now trying, a Leas-Cheann Comhairle, since you came into the Chair, to do something for which he was ruled out of order when the Ceann Comhairle was in the Chair.
Comment on this
The Chair was about to point out to Deputy Briscoe that his remarks were not relevant on an Adjournment debate.
Comment on this
I want to try to make them relevant to this extent. We in this House will get either good government or bad government if the Opposition are honest and sincere and correct.
Comment on this
Certain members of this House are deliberately attempting to bring the members and the House and the country into disrepute. The attitude of these people is that unless they themselves can be the governors or the dictators nobody else shall. It is about time some of these people were told that their behaviour is transparent and that it is obvious that they have motives other than the welfare of the people we are attempting to serve in this House.
Comment on this
If Deputy Rooney can boast in time of a record of service in this House such as that which most members of this Party have, then I will have some respect for him.
Comment on this
We shall see. What I am trying to say is that while the Government were attempting to bring about some industrial development in the undeveloped areas, this particular department of the Opposition to which I refer—and from which I again say I exclude Deputies of the character of Deputy Morrissey—said that no decent, honest businessman would go in under this scheme and that the only people who would accept an attempt to industrialise the undeveloped areas would be business racketeers.
Comment on this
On a point of order. I do not want to deprive anybody in this House of his right to reply to what he believes to be an unjust charge but Deputy Briscoe already had two opportunities to-day. He is now trying to use the Adjournment debate for that purpose. Not only that, but he is now trying to misrepresent entirely what Deputy Dillon said in that respect. I was in the House while Deputy Dillon was speaking and I heard what he said.
Comment on this
Deputy Dillon was speaking on his own amendment with regard to grants instead of loans. Deputy Dillon said that no decent man with his own business would take a grant—and Deputy Dillon was asking, on his own amendment, that it should be a loan.
Comment on this
No—not in that connection. The Deputy is talking about honesty. Let him be honest now.
Comment on this
We heard Deputy Dunne speak about unemployment and, in that connection, let us bear in mind the efforts which this Government are making to keep down unemployment and to develop the undeveloped areas. Deputy Dunne accused this Government of being the direct cause of the rapid and large increase in unemployment. As against that statement by Deputy Dunne, ridicule is made of the Government attempt to bring in legislation which seeks to give good industrial employment in parts of the country where it has been impossible up to the present to provide it.
Comment on this
On a point of order. Is it correct for Deputy Briscoe to make a statement which is untrue? He mentioned that a member of the Labour Party—and he included the Labour Party in this—attacked the present Government for being the cause of unemployment and that, at the same time, the Government were being criticised in regard to their efforts to create employment.
Comment on this
On a point of order. Is it correct and allowable that a Deputy of this House should make a false and unjustified charge in the presence of the Chair?
Comment on this
This is what we are up against. Deputy Desmond was not in the House when Deputy Dunne was speaking. For a long time during this debate Deputy Dunne was the sole occupant of the Labour benches.
Comment on this
On a point of order. Is it correct and justifiable for a member to make false charges in the House? I want a ruling on this matter. The records of the House will prove that I am correct.
Comment on this
You were not in here at all when Deputy Dunne was speaking.
Comment on this
I will not give way to Deputy Desmond. Deputy Dunne was the only occupant of the Labour benches for part of the time. He was subsequently joined by Deputy Davin. Deputy Desmond was not in the House at all while Deputy Dunne was speaking.
Comment on this
On a point of order. I appreciate your position, a Leas-Cheann Comhairle. All I am asking is whether Deputy Briscoe is entitled to make a charge relating to events here to-day which he knows is false and unjustifiable, as will be proved by the records of the House.
Comment on this
I have endeavoured to point out that I am trying to relate what I am saying to what was said by previous speakers this evening on this Adjournment debate. Deputy Dunne was speaking in this House within the past 15 minutes. One of the things which he quoted—as also Deputy Davin—was the increased number of unemployed which he alleged there were since the change of Government. Deputy Dunne accused this Government of being responsible for that increase in unemployment.
Comment on this
——when opposition and criticism and doubts and fears were referred to—I did not say it about Deputy Dunne—in regard to this Government's attempt to bring some form of industry to the undeveloped areas in the West. Might I remind Deputy Desmond that he should read Deputy Norton's speech? Deputy Norton was one of those who forced me to interrupt him, when he said he heard and he believed that this Bill would not bring employment of any kind whatsoever. I suppose that what I am stating will be put down as false?
Comment on this
There are many ways of defeating industrial development. Industrial development, which could have taken place very rapidly within the last three years, was slowed up considerably by the suggestions—again I dissociate Deputy Morrissey—of profiteering and racketeering, by statements that the people who come to open industries are "fly-by-nights". Every single bit of abuse that could be poured on the heads of people was poured on those who are now being welcomed, who are now entitled to a margin of profits, and who are now going to be supported additionally if they go to an area where there are certain disadvantages from the point of view of competition. It is a very welcome change, but the time has come when the decent members—if there are any over there, and I think there are some——
Comment on this
——at least should try to control those who were with them in the Coalition Government, and for whom they have still some responsibility, when they try to take away the characters of people in the House and outside it.
Comment on this
Yes, I will take responsibility for all my side. If I hear any of my colleagues attempt without foundation to become character assassinators I will not stand with them.
Comment on this
Deputy Morrissey knows that when I spoke within the precincts of this House, I spoke in no uncertain terms without privilege, and he at least had the decency not to interfere. I believe he at least knew I was justified in the attitude I adopted in my address to Deputy Dillon.
On the Adjournment debate we are supposed to deal more or less with criticism of the subjects which have not been dealt with, or emergency matters. However, we expect to believe each other. I want to believe a political opponent when he makes a criticism. The suggestion was made that during the elections we made some references to the 2d. a lb. on butter and criticised our predecessors. I represent in this Dáil a working-class district—Crumlin, Drimnagh, Inchicore—and at every meeting I addressed I put this to the public: "Would it not be far better for you to pay more for Irish butter produced in Irish creameries, giving employment to people at home, than be faced with this rotten, stinking Danish butter?"
Comment on this
There are only a few minutes more in this debate and I do not want to take up very much of those minutes in going back over the past, but when speaking here when the time was not so limited, I referred to the campaign by Deputy Briscoe, following in the wake of Deputy Lemass, as he then was, on the cost of living. If Deputy Briscoe wants to discover my views on that subject, he can look up the debate. I still say that it is clear and unmistakable that so far as the cost of living is concerned every member of the Fianna Fáil Party has got a most discreditable record in the way in which they started out under the leadership of Deputy Lemass a year ago to cod and fool the people. In the few minutes left, I do not intend to discuss anything about the past. The people will judge the past when they get an opportunity and the sooner they get that opportunity the better. What I do want to discuss is the future.
The Tánaiste, speaking to-night, indicated that in regard to certain aspects of industrial undertakings he believed the position was beginning to rectify itself. I do not agree with him —particularly in respect of one undertaking that was mentioned, in my constituency.
I noticed quite recently the speech made by Mr. Dwyer at the general meeting of either Seafield Fabrics or Sunbeam Wolsey in Cork, in which he made it clear that so far as that company is concerned, they were convinced as businessmen——
Comment on this
Deputy Briscoe had to give way.
Comment on this
I am going to speak; I am going to yield to a point of order, or, if the Chair tells me, and not otherwise; and I am not going to be prevented by the tactics of the Minister for Finance from exposing his shallowness in regard to the point I am about to make.
Comment on this
We had a discussion some time ago here in regard to the difficulties that were being made throughout various parts of the country and when we told about those difficulties and said that, in our opinion, the trouble was caused by a restriction of credit, we were met by the Tánaiste who said there was no such restriction.
Comment on this
On a point of order, Deputy Briscoe was not permitted to develop a theme which was very relevant to this debate, the fact that false and misleading statements and reckless charges were made that an unemployment condition existed. The Chair ruled——
Comment on this
——very narrowly on that matter. Both the Ceann Comhairle and the Leas-Cheann Comhairle refused to allow this debate to go outside the very narrow terms——
Comment on this
I am on my feet. Deputy Sweetman seems to be on his feet, too. As I am raising a point of order, I am in possession.
Comment on this
The truth is that it is the restriction of credit, for which the Minister for Finance is responsible, that is at the root of all the unemployment. That is what Mr. Dwyer said in Cork. The Minister for Finance has been trying deliberately to put me off saying that.
Comment on this
May I draw attention to the fact that this is a very old trick on the part of the Minister for Finance, which he has tried here over and over again, year in and year out?
Comment on this
I have as much right to be on my feet as the Minister for Finance has—or even the Taoiseach.