Tourist Traffic Bill, 1951—Second Stage (Resumed).
Contributions 99–243 of 243. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 34 of 1951 ›
The recommendation of the Tourist Board, which in effect meant the elimination of the Tourist Association, was that licences should be given under the Tourist Traffic Act of 1931 to local associations. One such association was formed in Sligo, as I told the House, and inevitably it succeeded in securing for itself a large part of the local contributions from the rates for tourist publicity purposes. It was obvious that a number of these associations would be formed if licences under that Act were to be given and that they would divert to themselves the revenue on which the Tourist Association had previously existed. I felt that that was an unwise decision, but more than that I understood from the developments last year that any proposal which involved the elimination of the Tourist Association was likely to be a controversial one—and I mean controversial in the political sense—and that if we were to get effective action in the development of the tourist trade it would be wise to avoid that type of controversy, if possible.
I met the Tourist Board and discussed their proposal with them. I indicated that I thought there was need for a reorganisation of the publicity services which then existed. I told them it was my intention to ask the Government to provide substantial additional funds for publicity purposes and that that seemed inevitably to involve the reorganisation to which I referred. In my first discussion with the Tourist Board I did not find them in agreement with my view. I have mentioned that they had submitted their own proposals to my predecessor, which involved proceeding on a different line.
I then met the board of directors of the Tourist Association. Their view was that we should get back to the 1939 position, in which all tourist publicity work was entrusted to them, the Tourist Board carrying on its functions under the 1939 Act.
Comment on this
I accept the correction. An objection to that course, as I saw it, was that we would be giving substantial annual sums to be administered by an organisation which was not ideally designed for the purpose and over which the Government and this House would have no control. The board of directors of the Tourist Association consists of representatives of various local authorities that strike a rate for tourist publicity purposes and representatives also of voluntary subscribers to the funds of the association. The personnel of the board of directors of the association changes fairly frequently, and in any case it is a very large board, too large to be an effective instrument of administration.
In the course of my discussions with the Tourist Association, I indicated my willingness to consider setting up this joint board, Fógra Fáilte, a board consisting of representatives of the Tourist Board and of their association, provided they were prepared to agree on handing over to the joint board the publicity functions that they had been undertaking, on the understanding that the Tourist Board would do the same thing. I got agreement on that basis. It ended a feud which was developing between the association and the board and it set up, in my opinion, an effective instrument of tourist publicity.
Comment on this
The Minister is not quite right. He says he got agreement. That was only when the joint board agreed to re-delegate back to the association the operation of the bureaux.
Comment on this
My original proposal to the association was that this Fógra Fáilte would consist of five members— three directors of the Tourist Board and two of their association. The only alteration they recommended was that there should be six members, three from each body, and I accepted that suggestion. The proposal to give to the association the administration, as agents for Fógra Fáilte, of the bureaux in this country emerged much later, and in no way arises from my discussion with the association directors. I said to them that I thought they had a very considerable part to play in the whole tourist business. The most important part I saw them fulfilling was the education of Irish public opinion in relation to the importance of tourist publicity—doing that particular job which Mr. Christenberry said had to be done by somebody and which, if not done, would negative the whole effort we were making. I asked them to submit to me their views as to what other activities they could usefully engage in, having regard to their agreement that this publicity function should be entrusted to a body representative of the two existing organisations. I got their recommendations in that regard. I did not agree with all of them; I agreed with some.
Comment on this
Some of them have not yet been decided. They are rather wider in character than the matters of administration we were dealing with at the time. It has been suggested here, first of all that this is going to mean a more costly administration and, secondly, that behind it there was the idea of creating jobs. So far as the jobs are concerned, I dispose of that suggestion straight away by pointing out that this board, Fógra Fáilte, consists, as I have told the House, of three existing members of the Tourist Board and three directors of the Tourist Association. As far as the organisation is concerned, there is nothing in that contention. This business of tourist publicity is entirely distinct and separate from the ordinary activities of the Tourist Board.
Comment on this
It requires a specialist staff. That is why it was considered quite practicable in 1939 to leave it with the Tourist Association, with the Tourist Board going ahead with and carrying out its own activities. I do not agree at all that it is necessary to have it entrusted to the one board that is also dealing with these other matters to which this Bill relates. Even if we did that, there would be under that board a completely separate organisation working up to a general management and it does not matter a rap, it seems to me, whether that organisation works under the Tourist Board or under this new joint board, Fógra Fáilte. It would be the same organisation and there will not be one additional member on it because of the existence of Fógra Fáilte.
If we decide to do what was suggested here and to get rid of Fógra Fáilte and give An Bord Fáilte, the present Tourist Board, the sole responsibility in relation to publicity, the job of supervising the work of that publicity organisation, what are we going to do with the Tourist Association? Some Deputy said to give the Tourist Association representation on the Tourist Board. I would disagree with that because it is bringing the Tourist Association into a field in which they never were before, and there is no reason to think that you will get out of the Tourist Association people with any specialised knowledge in relation to these functions. You may do it but the constitution of the Tourist Association is such that you have no certainty that you will and, in any event, it is obvious that there would be political difficulties there too.
The Tourist Association is based upon the local councils. The local councils are political bodies and even Deputy Palmer, when he was dealing with my agreement with the association and referred to the fact that I picked three directors out of six persons nominated by them, turned immediately to criticise me because I did not pick one of the six who was nominated by County Kerry and who happens to be, as everybody here knows, the lynchpin of the Fine Gael organisation in that part of Ireland, an excellent man in that job and, as I know, a real enthusiast for tourist development.
Comment on this
I would like to get this clear because this is likely to be the only part of the Bill on which there will be any major contention. It would be well if we could get the matter clarified. The Minister said a moment ago that he would not take a certain course because it would involve wiping out the Tourist Association. That is, in fact, what the Minister is doing.
Comment on this
Perhaps the Minister will allow me for a moment. The main, if not the only function of the Tourist Association since it was established was publicity. That was its sole function. A new board is being established under this Bill, the sole function of which will be publicity. Once the Tourist Association nominates these three members for that board, it has no other function.
Comment on this
I have told the Tourist Association that I expect them also to discharge the function of criticising the work of that board if it requires criticism, of furnishing it with proposals and suggestions and, in that way, working up to that board as they work to their own councils. In other words, the Tourist Association, instead of discharging its publicity activities through its own general manager and staff, will now discharge them through its representatives on Fógra Fáilte.
I will agree with any Deputy who says that if we were starting afresh, without any of the complications arising out of existing organisations, we would not think at first of doing anything except setting up one organisation. But we are not starting afresh. There is the Tourist Association there. It is a body which has been in operation in this field for 25 years, a voluntary body which commands a great deal of public goodwill and which is particularly important because of its association with the local councils. I am in favour of keeping it in the picture, of giving it specific functions in this field, and I think it is possible to do that without interfering in any way with the efficiency of our tourist organisation.
Deputy Lehane said that in the new circumstances the Tourist Association may not get contributions from local rates. I made it clear to them that, if they do not, then this arrangement will have to be reconsidered. The claim of the Tourist Association to representation upon this board dealing with publicity is based upon the fact that they are at present making a substantial contribution from their revenue to the expense of publicity.
I know Deputies have been attaching importance to this part of the Bill. I do not think it is important at all. I do not think it makes the slightest difference, from one point of view, whether we maintain An Bord Fáilte and An Fógra Fáilte or amalgamate the two, except in relation to the Tourist Association. It would be quite an easy matter to effect that amalgamation if the consequential effects upon the Tourist Association could be foreseen. Unless we are prepared to proceed on the lines we are suggesting here, the Tourist Association must go out of the picture altogether.
Comment on this
If that view is held amongst any number of directors of the Tourist Association it is because they have been so confined in their approach to tourist problems to the one issue of publicity that they have failed to realise that there is a much wider field of activity in which they could usefully engage, and in many ways more important activity.
Comment on this
There is not any director of the Tourist Association who does not feel that publicity is their whole being.
Comment on this
The Tourist Association has been spending on tourist publicity £15,000 or £16,000. There is a proposal here to spend out of State funds £250,000, and I think the House will agree that if the State is going to put up that money the State must have some say in the nomination of the persons who will control the spending of it and that that organisation must be responsible through legislation to this House for this expenditure.
Comment on this
Even though there is that position being created by this Bill, I still think it is desirable to link in with this publicity organisation the Irish Tourist Association and that is what I tried to achieve by my agreement.
Comment on this
It is true that it would be difficult to amend the Bill to eliminate Fógra Fáilte altogether now. It would involve its complete recasting. It is not a problem for me and Deputies who think I had some political motive in proceeding in this way are completely wrong. It is my view that the publicity part of tourist development is big enough and important enough to be entrusted to a separate organisation and entrusting it to a separate organisation upon which the Tourist Board has the predominant voice is a more efficient way of getting at it than of entrusting to one board the two jobs.
Comment on this
Has the Minister taken into consideration the fact that, as far as tourists are concerned, if they make a complaint to the publicity section of Fógra Fáilte in connection with some hotel the danger is that they may be fobbed off by this organisation saying: "We have nothing to do with that."
Comment on this
There will be no difficulty keeping those two bodies working harmoniously. The Irish Tourist Board, An Bord Fáilte as it will be known when this Bill becomes law, has a majority of the directors of Fógra Fáilte and the Bill provides that of the six members of Fógra Fáilte three members, including the chairman, will be directors of the Tourist Board. Therefore, they have ample means of ensuring that there will be no disharmony between them.
Comment on this
The complaint will be made normally to one of the tourist bureaux which are operated up to now by the Tourist Association, and there was no difficulty arising out of the fact that the bureaux were operated by the association while the grading and inspection of hotels was done by the Tourist Board. Under the agreement between the Tourist Association and Fógra Fáilte, these bureaux will continue to be administered by the Tourist Association. There will be no change in the position at all.
Comment on this
The case is this that if the Irish Tourist Association is to be linked with the Tourist Board in the direction of publicity then you have got to set up this committee or other board and give them equal representation with the Tourist Board to do that job. The alternative is to bring the Tourist Association into the Tourist Board itself and give them functions that they never had before and, I think, functions they should not have.
Comment on this
However, I am just trying to make it quite clear that, so far as I am concerned, my meeting with the Tourist Association was inspired by my feeling that it was undesirable that the Tourist Association position should be undermined. I met them to see if I could reach agreement with them on any arrangement which would keep them in the swim of tourist development. I reached agreement and I think it is a good agreement.
Comment on this
They will not swim with this because it is a millstone and they will go to the bottom.
Comment on this
The Minister is telling them he is giving them a lifebelt, but instead he is giving them a millstone.
Comment on this
I am giving them a continuing voice in the direction of tourist publicity, and I am giving them an opportunity to devote their undoubted energy and talent to another very important sphere. However, that can be discussed at a later stage.
I want to deal with the licensing provisions—another part of the Bill which aroused some controversy. Let me make it quite clear about these provisions. There is a great deal of misunderstanding in this connection. There is no proposal in this Bill to give any hotel the right to operate a public bar. Is that clear? The only proposal here is designed to ensure that somebody proposing to spend money on building an hotel or extending an existing hotel can find out in advance whether he can get a licence for it or not and will be entitled to get that licence without objection on the ground of the facilities for drinking already available in the locality. There may be objection when the application is made initially, on other grounds permitted under the Licensing Acts, for instance, objection on the grounds of convenience by people in the locality, that the building and operation of a licensed hotel would interfere with their amenities. The only thing we want to make clear is that the person building an hotel can find out beforehand whether he can get a licence and, secondly, we provide that his application for a licence cannot be refused on the grounds of the existence of facilities in the locality. I think that is reasonable enough. It is not merely based upon the recommendations of the experts who advised us but it seems to be a normal and desirable development. In fact, and this, I think, must be emphasised, the great majority of applications for hotel licences are granted by the courts. The number of hotel licences that have been refused because of objections on behalf of those who already had licensed premises in the locality were very few. But it is the uncertainty which will deter development. There is further objection that the practice may differ from one district to another according to the personal views upon this matter held by the courts.
Comment on this
And so it does, as Deputy Sweetman points out. I think we must recognise that if we are going to develop tourist business here we must be prepared to agree that hotels should be free to sell drink to residents. That is all that is involved. There is no other proposal in this Bill except to give assurance to an hotel proprietor that he can get a licence to sell drink for residents. He cannot get a right to a public bar. If he wants that he must apply under the Licensing Act and be subject to all the hazards that are involved under that Act. If he fails to maintain the premises as an hotel or if he so develops his business that the sale of drink becomes more important than his hotel business, then he loses his licence under this Act and if he wants to get the licence back he will have to apply under the Licensing Acts.
Comment on this
The provisions of Section 39 (2) provide that in order to get this licence renewed the premises must continue to be registered with the Tourist Board and he must qualify for the reduced licence fee under the Finance Acts, that is to say, the revenue from the sale of drink must not exceed one-third of the total revenue from the business.
Comment on this
It is because Deputies have been reading more into this part of the Bill than is intended that they are attaching significance to these things. In the ordinary course people who build an hotel can apply for a licence and be reasonably certain of getting it. I want to eliminate the word "reasonably". I want to make it certain that if I build an hotel I will get a licence. The proposal here is that if I decide to build an hotel I get my plans prepared and show them to the court. If the court approves of the plans I get an assurance that when the hotel is built a licence will be given.
Comment on this
Is the Minister serious in suggesting that an hotel proprietor is going to refuse business from the point of view of drink? I am not disagreeing on the question of the limitations imposed——
Comment on this
The licence that will be issued in consequence of this part of the Bill will be the same licence as every other hotel proprietor holds.
Comment on this
That is right, but they only get one under this Bill. A number of Deputies have made suggestions that we should take advantage of this Bill in order to remove anomalies that exist in the provisions of the Licensing Acts relating to hotels. I am going to resist any such attempt. The Licensing Acts are the responsibility of the Minister for Justice. All I am providing for here is that a new hotel can get a licence. If the conditions of hotel licensing are changed by amendment of the Licensing Acts, these changes will apply here also. I am not going, in this Bill, to remedy any defects in the Licensing Acts or to extend their scope or operations in any way. All I am providing for is that new hotels will get licences and have the rights and privileges of an hotel licence, whatever they may be.
Comment on this
The Revenue Commissioners do that. Under the Licensing Act of 1939 the holder of an hotel licence pays a reduced fee. It is the Revenue Commissioners who decide if he is entitled to obtain a licence at a reduced fee. If he does succeed in establishing his right to such fee, he will qualify under this section. Should he fail, he will cease to be entitled to a licence under this section, but that does not prevent him from going to the courts for a licence under the Licensing Acts.
Comment on this
We are not asking him to do that. We are only asking him to show to the courts that he succeeded in getting a licence at a reduced fee.
Comment on this
Under Section 39 of this Bill there is a provision that an hotel can get a licence. Under the 1902 Act there is a provision that an hotel can get a licence in a different way. Is it on the 1902 procedure that this Bill is based, or does it remain as an alternative method to the procedure under this Bill?
Comment on this
I have already decided that a certain amendment may be desirable in this section in order to make the position clear. I think it is clear enough, by a strict interpretation of the law, that an hotel which has not got a public bar already cannot be licensed under this Bill to open such public bar. There is a proposal also that instead of referring to the Borough of Dublin the reference should be to the metropolitan area which, I gather, is a different area and is the area prescribed under the Licensing Acts. It is desirable to keep it the same. An objection was raised to the fact that a person may wait for years before actually proceeding with the building of an hotel or proceeding with the alteration of his premises although he has gone to the courts with his plans and has got approval for a licence. It was suggested that we should put in a time-limit for the work. I feel that that is a reasonable enough suggestion.
So far as the provisions relating to holiday camps are concerned, let me make it quite clear that what is proposed here is that they should have the same rights to sell drink to residents as hotels have as far as Sundays and public holidays are concerned. A number of Deputies spoke about the reference to St. Patrick's Day, to Christmas Day and other days on which holiday camps are being given permission to sell drink to residents. I do not think that there is a holiday camp in Ireland open on these days. Apart from the desirability of keeping certain uniformity in the law relating to holiday camps and hotels, I do not think it is of any importance.
Comment on this
The Minister is, of course, aware that a Bill containing that provision was introduced into this House during the past six months and was kicked out.
Comment on this
I am not aware of that. There was one defect in this part of the Bill which nobody noticed. It does not provide for any penalties for a breach of any of the conditions of the Licensing Acts. We will have to rectify that.
Comment on this
Yes, it would. It is also suggested that the right of objection to the granting of a licence for a holiday camp should extend to cover inconvenience. I think that is reasonable. I feel that any persons who want to make objections to the granting of a licence to a holiday camp on the grounds that such licence would interefere with their convenience should be entitled to lodge such objections.
Comment on this
Would that include the area in which the camp is situated?
Comment on this
Can the Minister say why the Section 45 certificate provision is not put in in relation to holiday camps—the provision about one-third of the bar receipts?
Comment on this
Because that does not apply in the case of holiday camps. They are not being granted the right which is being given to hotels, that is, the right to go to the courts for a decision on the licence in advance of any expenditure of capital. The holiday camp cannot get a licence until after it has been in existence. It is being merely given in this Bill the right to get a licence which it has not got at the moment. The proprietor of a holiday camp is in a different position from an hotel proprietor. The provision in relation to hotels does not apply in the case of holiday camps, because the holiday camp is not being given the privilege which a proprietor of a new hotel is being given—the right to get a predetermination on his application.
Comment on this
I am in full agreement with what was said here by Deputies, that is, that we should be very careful to ensure that the bona fide holiday camp, properly organised and properly conducted, is actually in existence before an application for a licence is allowed to be made. It is difficult to put into words the doubt that is in my mind which, in my view, justifies us in being slightly more stringent in that regard in the case of holiday camps than in the case of hotels.
Comment on this
I do not think that that clears up the trouble about the receipts from the bar. Why should there be a different system for the licensing of holiday camps? Why are you not providing that the receipts from the bar should not exceed more than one-third of the receipts from the whole business?
Comment on this
That is the provision of the Finance Acts. It relates to the amount of licence duty paid.
Comment on this
But you provide, in relation to hotels, that, unless they get that certificate, they will lose their licence.
Comment on this
We provide, in relation to hotels, that unless they get that reduced licence fee they cannot get a renewal of their licence. In that case, of course, they could look for a licence under the Licensing Acts for an ordinary hotel licence.
Comment on this
Yes, under the special provision, but they would be put back under the ordinary provisions of the Licensing Acts.
Holiday camps come under the ordinary provisions. The only thing we are doing here is to give the courts power to give a licence to holiday camps which they have not got at the moment. I do not profess to be an authority on the licensing laws, though I have learned a great deal about them during the past few days. I do not feel that, in fact, we are altering the position in that regard very much.
The next point I want to deal with is the matter of the registration of hotels. Objection was taken to the power given to An Bord Fáilte to cancel the registration of an hotel, if it exceeds the charges which it had announced its intention of maintaining during any season. Again let me explain that there was a great deal of misunderstanding, based upon a failure to realise that the registration of an hotel with An Bord Fáilte is a voluntary act. An Bord Fáilte is given power to refuse to a premises which is not registered the right to use the name "hotel," but anybody operating a premises of that kind, and who is prepared to avoid using the name hotel, and to call his premises an inn, a club, a dump, a joint or anything else, need not register with An Bord Fáilte at all. Registration with An Bord Fáilte is a voluntary act. It is true that it secures for the proprietor of such premises the right to use the name "hotel" and it confers other advantages as well such as the insertion of particulars of the facilities which it affords in the annual publication of the board which is no doubt very important.
In my view it would be completely impracticable to have official control over hotel charges. People staying in an hotel will be found willing to pay more for the same accommodation and the same food which is given with a smile, than they would be willing to pay in another hotel where it is given with a scowl. No one can attempt to assess the value of service in an hotel for the purpose of determining what is a reasonable charge and of enforcing it with official sanctions.
All that we ask the hotel proprietor to do is to set out at the beginning of the year the charges he proposes to make and, having set these out, to see that he will maintain them. The intention is to eliminate the kind of abuse where the charges of the hotel are related to the appearance of the customer, where the proprietor tries to size up the customer, and to decide how much he will stand in the way of charges. The intention is that the charges should be known beforehand. The hotel proprietor can fix any charges he likes, but, having fixed them, he must stick to them. At least he cannot go above them. That is a very useful safeguard for visitors to the country. The great majority of people who come here to stay in hotels select from the Tourist Board list of hotels. They look down the list and know the charges fixed by the proprietor and the accommodation and other services given in return for them. They plan their holiday without knowing anything more about the hotel than is contained in that book. The most constant source of irritation amongst tourists coming from abroad was to find that they were, in fact, being charged in hotels more than they had been led to expect from these publications. It is to eliminate that type of abuse that this arrangement is designed.
Comment on this
They are enforced. If the Deputy wants to discuss with me whether the Tourist Board organisation was good or not during the past three or four years, I am quite prepared to say that I think there is considerable scope for improvement.
Comment on this
If the Minister reads the tourist guide sent out two weeks ago he will see that, in the case of some hotels, the charge is represented by just a dash after the name of the hotel. There is no charge stated.
Comment on this
I do not see why that should be so either. They should not be given the benefit of free publicity if the charges are not clearly set out.
Comment on this
The reference in the debate was to the fact that there is a withdrawal of registration where stated charges are exceeded. I think we might put in an amendment on Committee to make it clear that they must be exceeded persistently, not merely that there is an occasional overcharge.
Comment on this
Yes, a persistent overcharge. It is obvious that the board must have that power but the exercise of that power is a matter for its own discretion. I think it is to be anticipated that it will use it intelligently for the purpose of securing the development of efficient and suitable hotels.
Comment on this
Would the Minister consider an amendment providing for an appeal?
Comment on this
Would the Minister agree that the effect of cancellation of registration involves a serious capital loss to the proprietor?
Comment on this
No. I think that is where the Deputy was mistaken in his observations in regard to this Bill. There are hotel premises, if one may use that term in connection with them, operated here whose registration with the Tourist Board was terminated. The effect of that was that they could not call these premises "hotels", but they could carry on business as hotels just the same. The penalty is that they are deprived of the use of the word "hotel".
Comment on this
They lose their licences. under the special section. They would have to go to the courts for it under the ordinary law.
Comment on this
They cannot get it under the ordinary law unless they are an hotel.
Comment on this
Unless they are an hotel within the meaning of the Finance Act. But there are places which are hotels within the meaning of the Finance Act which are not entitled to call themselves hotels under the Tourist Acts.
Comment on this
Under this Bill there is a new type of penalty, that caused by the board on cancellation.
Comment on this
My objection to giving an appeal to the courts is that it is going to introduce considerable discrepancy in the administration of the Act. You will have a number of separate courts and you will have different practices established in several areas. I think it would be unwise to give an appeal to the courts. It would make for a lack of uniformity in the administration of the law, and it would tend to nullify the provisions of the section because on the first occasion, at any rate, the court will always favour the applicant for re-registration.
Comment on this
Would the Minister allow the proprietor to be heard by An Bord Fáilte before registration is cancelled?
Comment on this
The withdrawal of registration by An Bord Fáilte is subject to a number of conditions. It provides for three inspections.
Comment on this
It is desired to give the board power to deal with persistent overcharging. How can you do that except by inserting certain provisions in the Bill? You can only say that it will be left to the board. Certain difficulties have arisen this year owing to the fact that the grading system has not been in operation. It will come back next year, and the intention is that in order to secure registration maximum charges must be stated by the proprietor. Many references were made to the grading system. I agree fully we need a grading system, and that it must be on a somewhat different basis from that which existed before— that there must be segregation of hotels into types as well as a grading of standards within each type. I think these are the lines on which the Tourist Board proposes to work, but I have not yet received their ideas in any detail.
I should mention that, arising out of remarks of a number of Deputies regarding signposts, it is not intended that An Bord Fáilte will erect any signposts. They will provide them to the design approved by the Minister for Local Government and supply them to the local authorities who will be asked to erect and maintain them.
Deputy Morrissey suggested that the provisions of this Bill regarding grading and financial assistance should apply to restaurants as well as to hotels and guest-houses. There are so many restaurants that it would be impracticable to do so. It would mean a considerable increase in the administrative costs of the board. In the Six Counties they attempted the grading of restaurants but I think they have got themselves into considerable difficulty because various legal decisions have, I think, applied the description of "restaurant" even to fish and chip establishments. It would be very hard to draw the line of division between establishments of that character and restaurants which are interested in the tourist or holiday business to which we were referring.
Comment on this
Deputy Corish suggested that organisations of hoteliers or workers should be represented on An Bord Fáilte. I am completely against giving membership of these boards to anybody described as a representative of any outside interest. A director of An Bord Fáilte should be one of the team responsible for the carrying out of its functions. He should never be there as a representative of some outside organisation, responsible to that outside organisation for the line he took in discussions at board meetings.
Comment on this
I do not think so. I agree that it would be desirable to have people there with certain special qualifications and experience of a particular kind but I do not think that they should be there as representatives of any organisation.
I come now to the matters of hunting, shooting and fishing. It is open to An Bord Fáilte to assist organisations or agencies for that purpose. It would be their duty, as I see it, to interest themselves in the work of the organisations concerned with the development of these activities and, by advice and coordinating activities, to help them to achieve results. There have, in fact, been consultations and discussions between the Inland Fisheries Trust and the Tourist Board. So far as I am concerned, I should certainly encourage An Bord Fáilte, when it becomes that, to interest itself thoroughly in the possibilities of developing these sports.
Comment on this
It is along these lines that we hope to secure an extension of the season, which is our main prospect of increasing tourist revenue. In the peak holiday period, all our hotels and guest-houses are, as a rule, fully occupied. It will be understood that we cannot get increased tourist revenue by bringing in more tourists at that peak period because, unless they stay with friends or in private houses, there is not much room for them. It is by extending the duration of the tourist season that we can mainly help to increase the revenue from it.
Comment on this
A number of references were made to facilities at ports and internal transport services. I refer to this merely to remark that action has already been taken to prevent a repetition of what happened on a few occasions at Dún Laoghaire last year when a number of passengers were outshipped and had to remain overnight on the quay there or in the railway station, and to avoid the necessity for queueing which was experienced there last year. Let me be quite clear on this matter. The blame for the difficulties that arose last year is not all to be left at the door of the transport company. The shipping companies operated a reservation system. A person got his boarding ticket. That gave him the right to accommodation on the ship for which it was issued. However, with the fine weather and the attractions of holidays in Ireland, a large number of people just did not go on the ship for which they had a boarding ticket. They waited for the next ship—and always it was the last ship of the evening. It came about, therefore, that persons who had no boarding tickets—who had already given up the right they had to travel by an earlier ship—presented themselves at a later ship and caused the congestion which resulted. As the House is aware, I summoned a conference, over which I presided myself, of all the interests involved—British Railways, Córas Iompair Éireann, the Board of Works (as owners of Dún Laoghaire harbour), the local authorities and the tourist organisations. It was a very large and useful conference. There arose out of that conference the suggestion that if we could provide at Dún Laoghaire pier additional accommodation for customs examination so that passengers coming off a ship could be passed through the customs on one side and passengers joining the ship could be passed through the customs on the other side, the company could then utilise the other side of the pier for loading passengers and that that would permit of the operation of another vessel and the avoidance of the type of congestion which occurred last year. The necessary alterations to bring that situation about, on a temporary basis, are at present proceeding at Dún Laoghaire pier and, subject to all the contingencies that may arise in that connection, will be ready for the tourist season this year.
There is a long-term plan for a very substantial constructional project at Dún Laoghaire. It was prepared before the war and, while I do not think that it was ever finalised, it is still there as an idea for development. The Board of Works tell me that it would take at least six years to complete the construction work involved.
Comment on this
The Deputy asked me a question and I told him the truth. We did not go on with it during the war.
Comment on this
It is a very big project involving a great deal of money, but certainly it would not ease the problem this year or for the next six years. However, the temporary structure which is now being erected at Dún Laoghaire will ease the problem this year and, as has been announced to the Press, Córas Iompair Éireann propose to make certain changes, too.
Comment on this
I have been Minister for Industry and Commerce since last June. I attended to the matter immediately and the job will be finished by next year.
Comment on this
Córas Iompair Éireann are planning a very substantial number of bus tours for this year. I think they will be able to do a really first-class job in that respect. These are organised tours for visitors going from one hotel to another—three-day tours, seven-day tours, tours of various duration. All the plans are made for them, and I hope they will proceed. I think they will add considerably to the number of visitors who will be able to get well-organised and attractive holidays here. Deputy D.J. O'Sullivan paid a tribute to the day tours and other tours organised on the railways which, I think, are very popular and which are certainly well-patronised.
A reference was made to the necessity for organising the production of decent souvenirs. It is a matter on which I am very keen personally, and I have set up a committee representing the various interests to see what we can do in that regard.
I confess that I was somewhat shocked by the advice I got from Mr. Christenberry and others as to the type of souvenir that American visitors would like to buy. I have a prejudice—I think most Deputies have—against leprechauns, fairies, shillelaghs and blackthorn sticks. When I expressed that prejudice to Mr. Christenberry, he said: "I am sorry to hear that, because I have an order for 20 blackthorn sticks for friends which I have to bring back. There is no doubt that they are the type of souvenir that American visitors are going to buy." I think we can do something to eliminate the more objectionable type and provide a wider variety of the artistic type of souvenir which is, I think, important in connection with tourist trade development. In any event, the committee has been set up, and it is trying to see what can be done.
Comment on this
I rather draw the line at the clay pipes. Reference has been made to the dollar aspect of the tourist trade, and I was asked whether in fact the American tourist visiting this country via Great Britain does contribute in any way to our dollar resources. He does indirectly; at least an arrangement exists between the Department of Finance and the British Treasury by which we are credited with the dollar expenditure of such a tourist, but it is obviously desirable that we should get the dollars direct. It would be preferable to the alternative arrangement from many points of view, and Irish hoteliers, travel agencies and others have been asked to co-operate in securing these direct dollar payments for services given here.
The suggestion that we might have a differential rate of exchange for tourists, as other countries have, is, I fear, impracticable because of its consequences. At present we have no restrictions upon financial transactions between this country and Great Britain. The great bulk of our tourists come from Great Britain, and the operation of any differential exchange system for dollars would inevitably involve a restriction upon the movement of funds between this country and Great Britain, and we would lose far more in inconvenience to British tourists than we would gain by attracting American tourists by such a system.
Comment on this
Spain certainly operated it last year. Finally, I want to say that I agree completely with Deputy Sweetman that we must not lose sight in all this development of the importance of providing facilities for the enjoyment of holidays by our own people. I do not think Deputy Sweetman was fair to me when he suggested that I was losing sight of it. The Bill is framed to give An Bord Fáilte functions in relation to the development of holiday traffic in the State and to the State, and during my remarks, in introducing the Bill, I referred repeatedly to the desirability of improving the amenities available in Ireland for enjoyable holidays by the Irish people. It is as important that we should encourage our own people to spend on holidays at home the moneys that might otherwise be spent abroad, as it is to attract other people to come here and spend holidays in this country.
Our interest in this whole business of developing holiday resorts and amenities originated with the passing of the Holidays Act, 1936, when for the first time workers got a statutory right to paid holidays. It was recognised, by me, at any rate, that if the full benefit of that legislation was to be secured for the workers of the country we would have to do something more than merely giving them a statutory right, that we would have to go out and organise facilities which would enable them to secure holidays within their means which would be attractive to them.
Deputy Norton spoke this evening about the need for holiday camps for that type of holidaymaker. I am in complete agreement with what he said. The average worker with a wife and family can take a holiday for himself but he finds its impossible to organise a holiday for his wife and family also because accommodation in an hotel is usually beyond his means and, if he rents a house at the seaside, it is no help to his wife as she has to wash and cook just the same. It was because of that, that I conceived the idea of holiday camps with separate chalets in which a family could reside, with common dining-rooms, where they could get meals provided and with nurses in attendance to look after and organise recreation for the children. As Deputy Norton said, it was planned to organise the first camp of that kind at Courtown but that was not proceeded with. It is not intended now that An Bord Fáilte shall have functions of that kind, but I should like to encourage that idea as a development of private enterprise and I think I can say that anybody who takes up the idea and proceeds to develop it along sound lines can rely upon the support of the Government and of An Bord Fáilte.
A number of other points were raised relating to the Bill which I am afraid I will have to leave over to the Committee Stage. Many of the suggestions made by Deputies, however, did not relate to the Bill at all and they could not be implemented by amendments to the Bill. They would relate to the operations of Córas Iompair Éireann, local authorities or other organisations. Many of these suggestions have been noted and will be brought to the attention of An Bord Fáilte as an indication to them of the views of Deputies and suggestions which they might investigate.
Comment on this
Might I ask the Minister if Fógra Fáilte can provide for the production of scenic and feature films and for their development in this country?
Comment on this
I do not know how many birds the Deputy is trying to kill with that stone. They can undoubtedly finance the production of tourist development films but there are no facilities for their development in this country at the moment. That is another day's work.