We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Committee on Finance. - Resolution No. 11—General (Resumed).

Contributions 1–222 of 424. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

As I had indicated when we were adjourning last night, the sum total of the Coalition Parties' speeches before the Budget was that we could go on spending at the rate that the country had been spending hitherto, that there was no need to take stock of the financial situation here, that everything was moving smoothly, that the country was prosperous, that there was no need to introduce more taxation. This line of argument has been continued during the debate on the Budget. All that was needed, according to some Deputies on the Opposition Benches, was an injection of spending power, more borrowing and the putting of more money into circulation.

Everyone knows that whatever money is borrowed and made available in large sums would in itself tend to increase the prices of very many commodities in the State; yet when the subsidies are taken away with the resulting increases in prices we have a general outcry from the other side. Deputy Corish during a pre-Budget speech said that in spite of the statements made by Fianna Fáil in their summing up of the position as they had seen it he did not think that the Budget would contain any severe taxation. He said that for the last six months Fianna Fáil Ministers had been making scare speeches, that there was no need for them and that even the Fianna Fáil Minister themselves did not believe that a situation existed which demanded corrective measures. We have got what everyone does admit to be a severe Budget.

Comment on this

Hear, hear!

Comment on this

I do not deny it; nobody throughout the country denies it, but every thinking person will admit that that type of Budget was needed as a corrective measure for the financial and economic position which has existed and which does exist in this country. The severity of the Budget, the severity of its taxes and impositions, caused merriment on the Opposition Benches even before they were announced by the Minister for Finance. It was a godsend to them and they proceeded to make political capital. They immediately set a campaign in motion throughout the length of the country. They were justified in doing it.

Comment on this

I should think so.

Comment on this

They were justified as a Party in clutching at any straw that was available, but I think that they have found out by this time that they rushed headlong into the matter without considering what the reaction of the Budget would be on the population of the country.

Comment on this

East Limerick will tell us that.

Comment on this

East Donegal told you a story before.

Comment on this

West Donegal told us another.

Comment on this

And the general election told you the final story.

Comment on this

The Deputy need not grow pale; he is not a member for East Limerick. But his turn will come.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy Cunningham is entitled to speak without interruption.

Comment on this

But the abominable showman must show off.

Comment on this

Can we all put our feet on the seat in front of us, a Cheann Comhairle?

Comment on this
Patrick Smith Minister for Local Government (Mr. Smith) Fianna Fáil

Only the president of the Molly Maguires can do that.

Comment on this

In case Deputy Dillon has not been told so, I again tell him that it is a severe Budget. We know it is but we think it necessary. The people in the country say: "Yes, the taxes in some cases are severe and the removal of the food subsidies will mean increases, but it is an alternative to borrowing and to the repayment of large sums in interest on moneys borrowed from abroad." In a full year the interest payable on the American loan will amount to £1,200,000 which has to be paid back not in our currency but in dollars. There are two aspects to the taxes in the Budget. I have discussed the taxes on tobacco and drink not alone with our own supporters but with those who are politically opposed to Fianna Fáil and they admit that these items could bear the taxes imposed and could even bear higher taxes. There is no grumbling from the people that these taxes are over-heavy.

Deputy McGilligan said that in this year's Budget there was overestimation to the tune of £9.6 million. That may be so but overestimation even in ordinary business is a wise line to take.

Comment on this

Oh, anois tá an cat amuigh.

Comment on this

Even where there is overestimation, we find that the sum is smaller by the end of the year. In a reply to a parliamentary question the Minister for Finance said that, in 1950-51, there was underestimation to the extent of over £2,000,000 and that in 1951-52 there was still further underestimation to the tune of over £10,000,000. In the 1951-52 Budget, where that underestimation took place, there still was no provision for the Social Welfare Bill which we are told was upon the stocks. This Government could proceed to borrow from external sources. We could get the money from America.

Comment on this

Could you? How?

Comment on this

By borrowing as you did.

Comment on this

You would not be let.

Comment on this

Not by the present Government.

Comment on this

The United States Government will not lend it.

Comment on this

We have not the signs and passports of the Molly Maguires.

Comment on this

They were not too bad, the Mollies.

Comment on this

I should like to show what Nationalist opinion in the Six Counties has to say about borrowing from abroad.

Comment on this

The Derry Journal? Very dependable.

Comment on this

The Derry Journal states:

"The United States Government announced on Friday that it will give no military aid to Ireland and it stated the reason. It is the same that it gave for the stoppage of dollar advances. It offered both these on certain conditions and those conditions the Irish Government refused to accept. Until the Irish Government reconsiders its decision, reverses its attitude and agrees to Washington's terms there will be nothing more coming Ireland's way."

Comment on this

Hear, hear!

Comment on this

It goes on: —

"The agreement was one that would have placed not only the Twenty-Six Counties but their young manhood at the disposal of the United States and Britain and permitted these two Powers to establish bases wherever they deemed expedient on Twenty-Six County soil. The proposed agreement, of course, was drawn up in diplomatic language but in plain words that is what it implies. In plainer words it demands the surrender of Irish sovereignty as the price of obtaining much-needed arms and armaments. The Washington State Department is evidently hoping that the financial position will compel the Irish Government to accept its terms."

Comment on this

They never will, I hope.

Comment on this

"It was with the intention of making the Irish State independent of such needs that the Government introduced a Budget that will put it on its feet again and enable it to pay its way and at the same time continue to develop and expand...."

Comment on this

On a point of order. The Deputy has quoted a comment on documents that are alleged to have passed between the United States Government and the Irish Government and implied that certain demands have been made on the Irish Government and that these demands have a bearing on the Budget which this House is now discussing. Will the Minister for Local Government who is now here undertake to put before the House forthwith a copy of these documents before the debate concludes?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy is not quoting or purporting to quote from any official document. As I understand it, Deputy Cunningham is quoting an extract from a newspaper article. He is quite entitled to do so.

Comment on this

In view of the fact that the extract which the Deputy is quoting from the newspaper article in question implies that certain documents have been exchanged between the two Government and that these documents have a bearing on the presentation of the proposals contained in this Budget, will the Minister for Local Government or the Minister for Finance take cognisance of what has happened as a result of Deputy Cunningham's intervention in this debate? Will either of these Ministers undertake to put before the House forthwith a copy of the documents referred to or will he make a statement informing this House, in a more authoritative manner than by way of an extract from the Derry Journal, as to the situation which is alleged to have influenced the farming of this Budget?

Comment on this
Patrick Smith Minister for Local Government (Mr. Smith) Fianna Fáil

He will do neither of these things.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

As a matter of order, I can only insist if a Deputy is quoting from an official document that it be made available to the House. I understand that the Deputy is quoting from a newspaper. I can only ask that he will give the reference in respect of that newspaper. Deputy Cunningham.

Comment on this

Will the Deputy give the name of the newspaper and the date?

Comment on this

I am quoting from a leading article which appeared in the Derry Journal on the 28th April, 1952.

Comment on this

Is the article signed?

Comment on this

No, it is a leading article.

Comment on this

The most disreputable and lying newspaper in Ireland except the Irish Press.

Comment on this

It must have bitten you once or twice.

Comment on this

No—any more than a passing flea bites.

Comment on this

The article concludes as follows:—

"Without the present Budget, the Twenty-Six Counties would be face to face with the choice of two alternatives—unemployment and starvation or surrender of sovereignty. The Budget obviates both. The Budget will enable the people to save the sovereignty of their State that brave men and women so dearly won, and the people, true to themselves and their past, will take it and work it in that spirit. They have had one master against their will for over 700 years, they are not of their own will going now to sell their newlygained independence to another."

Comment on this

Will the Deputy inform me if that is the newspaper that condemned the proclamation of the Republic two years ago?

Comment on this

Lavish spending has got to cease.

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

That is what Mr. Butler says.

Comment on this

The country must get down to the task of building up its own resources in its own way without dictation from any outside country whatsoever.

It is significant that although the members of the Opposition were asked several times by speakers on the Government side of the House what they would have done if they were in government — whether they would have gone on with borrowing or gone on investing the borrowed money, to make matters worse, in foolish schemes such as the mixing of Connemara rock with the Atlantic Ocean and so forth — we have not received any definite answers.

Comment on this

Is the Deputy opposed to the Connemara schemes?

Comment on this

Yes, I am.

Comment on this

What does the Parliamentary Secretary to the Government, who has the job of looking after the gCeanntar gCúng, say?

Comment on this

I am opposed to any waste of money by any Government.

Comment on this

You ought to tell the Connemara people that you are opposed to the Connemara schemes.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Order! Deputy Cunningham.

Comment on this

The Opposition had no answer to the simple question: "Would you have gone on in the manner in which you were going or would you, on being returned to office, continue these taxes or do away with them?" No definite statement has been forthcoming in reply to that question.

I want to refer to what Deputy Corish said at the Labour Conference and, in passing, I might say that that Labour Conference has been noted for another very sound pull-up or full-stop in a certain line of action. The danger signal has been raised. It has pointed out: Thus far shalt thou go but no farther. Deputy Corish is reported as saying: —

"It had been represented that the only alternative to Mr. MacEntee's Budget was to go cap in hand to foreign moneylenders and seek loans from abroad. This was an absurd and false assertion."

The rest of the quotation, which I shall read for the House now, is typical of the rolling phrases of ex-Ministers and others — phrases which have nothing about them except the fact that they are good oratorical expressions. I have heard many very fine speeches from members of the Opposition Parties but, boiled down, they contain very little sound and solid matter. Deputy Corish went on to say: —

"The alternative was a sane and progressive economic policy based on the proper exploitation of national resources and a financial policy derived not from Throgmorton Street via Foster Place but based on the needs and requirements of our economy."

Comment on this

Is not that right? Does the Deputy disagree with it?

Comment on this

Words, words and more words. What does it all mean? Some time I will ask you to explain it.

Comment on this

Ask the Taoiseach.

Comment on this

As in the past, the Fianna Fáil Government intend to progress with the development of our country, the development of the tourist industry——

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

Do not be too optimistic. Wait until you get that chance.

Comment on this

The Fianna Fáil Government intend to develop our agriculture and our turf production and so forth.

Comment on this

Where is the money to come from for the capital development?

Comment on this

If the Deputy will study the Budget statement of the Minister for Finance, he will find the information there. It is not for me to explain that matter.

Comment on this

Fair enough.

Comment on this

Any of these developments I mentioned were frowned upon by the Fine Gael Party. Deputy MacEoin last night referred to the economic war. We can go back to that period and truthfully say that it was then the foundations of many of the existing industries were laid.

Comment on this

Free beef.

Comment on this

It was then we began in earnest to develop the different resources of the country and to foster new industries. Deputy MacEoin said that there were advantages and disadvantages in connection with the economic war and that the disadvantages outweighed the advantages. This country forgets about disadvantages when it is a question of the well-being of the State. It was not the first time in our history that we had not weighed the consequences when a certain line of action was taken, although that line might lead to severity. We never hesitated to take the necessary steps when such steps were demanded for the well-being of the State.

Comment on this

The civil war the economic war and now the dollar war.

Comment on this

Much dissatisfaction was voiced some time ago in regard to dual prices. Dual pricing was most unfair because the large family had to go outside its rations in order to meet the family needs in food — tea, sugar and butter — and had to purchase them at the higher prices. By doing away with rationing we feel that there will be freer and more competitive trading, that the element of competition will enter into the grocery business and that that eventually will tend to reduce prices. While admitting the severity of the Budget, I think it will have a very good effect in bringing home to the people that it is only by our own effort that we shall succeed, that it is only by hard work and more production that this country will eventually be put on a sound footing. I was speaking recently to an Irishman who had returned from Belgium and he said that in Belgium people did enjoy good economic conditions, that trade was brisk but that people in Belgium worked for anything they got.

Comment on this

Nous travaillons—the good old phrase.

Comment on this

That would seem to be the position in many countries all over the world but in countries where the people are not prepared to work we find that these countries are tugging with all types of financial difficulty.

Comment on this

Is Ireland included amongst those countries?

Comment on this

I would conclude by asking some of the ex-Ministers who are present what would be the position in regard to taxation if they had any say in the matter? What would they have done?

Comment on this

Listening to Deputy Cunningham one would imagine that Budget day, the 2nd day of April, had not come yet or that he had not left this House since that date. Surely to goodness, he does not expect any member of the House to believe the statement that he has gone amongst the people of Donegal and that they were quite satisfied with their new burden, that they are prepared to bear even a greater burden.

Comment on this

And that they would not work.

Comment on this

Well, that they would not work to a certain extent. We are supposed to be a lazy community; we believe in borrowing anything we can. Deputy Cunningham is a young member of this House; he has not grown up yet politically but, mind you, he has that old harangue of Fianna Fáil about saving the country and selling the country. Is it not extraordinary to realise that it was one Act of the inter-Party Government in the three and a half years during which they were in office, which gave us complete independence in this portion of the country— an Act which Fianna Fáil were afraid to face up to? You can be very sure that the people and the Parties responsible for that Act would be very far from selling this country under any circumstances. The Deputy also referred to spending. During our time £14,000,000 of Marshall Aid was spent. If it was wrong to spend that grant and loan money, was it not just as wrong to spend the £26,000,000 which we left after us and which they spent?

Comment on this

You left that in commitments.

Comment on this

If they believed this money should not be taken why did they spend the £26,000,000 we left after us?

Comment on this

What did you spend it on?

Comment on this

I shall go over the list before I am finished. The facts speak for themselves. Since last July we have had individuals going around the country mouthing on behalf of Fianna Fáil, telling the people that there would be a deficit of £20,000,000. I think one of them went so far as to say that there was going to be a deficit of £40,000,000. I have here the report of the Dáil Debates for Wednesday, 2nd April. Deputy Cunningham was in the House on that date and apparently he has not left it since. In column 1129, No. 8, Volume 130, we have the following statement by the Minister for Finance in introducing the Budget:

"Revenue, tax and non-tax, was estimated for 1951-52 at £81.1 million. It turned out to be £83.9 million or £2.8 million more than was estimated for."

That looked very well, that the Budget brought in £2.8 million more than was estimated for. In the next column, 1130 of the Official Report, he stated that the total expenditure for the year was £90.6 million and that if one takes £83.9 million from the total expenditure of £90.6 million there is a so-called deficit of £6.7 million. How then can the wordy individuals who were out through the country since last July justify all their mouthings about a deficit of £10,000,000, £20,000,000 and £40,000,000. According to the Minister himself there is a so-called deficit of £6.7 million.

Deputy Cunningham has not got the political experience that his Minister sitting on the Front Bench has. I want to point out that there is an item of £2.7 million for the stuff called turf up in the Phoenix Park. I do not blame the last Fianna Fáil Government for piling up that stuff there. It probably was necessary, but I do not think it was an item that should be paid for in one year, and I do not believe any honest Deputy will disagree with me when I say that. That expenditure should have been spread over a number of years. We were not responsible for the turf mould in the Park and therefore one can deduct that £2.7 million from the so-called deficit of £6.7 million.

One would imagine that it was yesterday Fianna Fáil took over office for the first time. I want Deputies to appreciate that they returned to power on 13th June last. There is another item here of £845,000 for losses incurred by Córas Iompair Éireann. Fianna Fáil came into power last June. Surely, therefore, we were not responsible for that £845,000 paid to Córas Iompair Éireann to recoup them for losses. That item can also be subtracted from the so-called deficit of £6.7 million. There is another item of £400,000 for replacements to Córas Iompair Éireann. That was paid by the present Government. Surely that can also be deducted from the so-called deficit.

There is another item of £400,000 in relation to the increased price given for fuel by Fianna Fáil since they came into power. I am not saying whether or not it was right or wrong to give that, but I am saying that we are not responsible for that and that can also be deducted from the so-called deficit of £6.7 million.

There is another item of £250,000 for the increased price in relation to wheat. Surely we were not responsible for that since it took place after last June. That can also be deducted from the so-called deficit of £6.7 million. I am sorry Deputy Cunningham has left the House. I thought he would be stunting with his pencil in his hand adding all these figures together. Had he done so he would have found that the so-called deficit of £6.7 million has very nearly disappeared. Why then the cheap talk up and down the country about bankruptcy, about not being able to balance the Budget and all that trash?

There is a game going on behind this Budget. A few days after the Budget a certain Fianna Fáil spokesman addressed some Fianna Fáil supporters in a certain hall in County Galway. I am sorry Deputy Captain Cowan is not here, or Deputy Dr. Browne, or Deputy Dr. ffrench O'Carroll or Deputy Cogan. I have never said a word about any of them. I do not mind how they vote. I do not mind who is in government. It does not matter who is in government. The only thing that matters is what the Government does. On the 6th April this Fianna Fáil spokesman who claims to speak for the Government when he meets some thugs down in the country, though he does not make the claim here——

Comment on this

Surely there are no thugs in County Galway.

Comment on this

There are a few. This individual made a statement at a so-called Fianna Fáil comhairle ceanntar meeting. The people who were there began to talk about the Budget. They wanted to know what the Government meant by taxing tobacco, tea, sugar, bread and butter. I will not say a word about the pint of porter or the bottle of stout because it is criminal seemingly to talk about such things here. The so-called spokesman said: "It is all right. Let me tell you. We are all right for the next 12 months because we know we are bound to get this Budget through. We have budgeted for £9,000,000 or £10,000,000 more than we require. We know we will carry it in the Dáil. We know that Deputy Captain Cowan, Deputy Dr. Browne, Deputy Cogan and Deputy Dr. ffrench-O'Carroll are bound to vote for us. Let me tell you that the Chief does not like them. He does not want to have them at all if he can do without them, and the idea is that we are budgeting for £9,000,000 or £10,000,000 more than we require and we will have a surplus next year when we will produce a good Budget and the Chief can go to the country and we can get rid of Cogan, Browne, Cowan and ffrench-O'Carroll." I can prove that statement was made. I am glad Deputy Cogan is here.

Comment on this

Can you give us the name of the statesman who made it?

Comment on this

It was made at a Fianna Fáil comhairle ceanntar meeting by a member of this House. I do not mind how Deputy Cogan votes. I have never belittled him. I have never belittled Deputy Captain Cowan or Deputy Dr. Browne or Deputy Dr. ffrench-O'Carroll. I merely want to let them know now the game that is going on. The idea is to get rid of them as soon as possible. That will be after the next Budget though I am hoping it may be before 10.30 p.m. to-night.

There is a certain amount of humour in this Budget. I am sorry the Minister is not here but I have a cartoon of him which appeared in the Sunday Independent showing him leading the dance. He has done one good thing. He has remitted the tax on dance halls to the tune of £140,000. For three years I had the honour of acting as Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance in the inter-Party Government. I am proud of that three years and will be proud of them until I die.

Comment on this

No doubt the Government was proud of you also.

Comment on this

And the people of Connaught were proud and I gave Fianna Fáil their answer when I topped the poll in my constituency.

I remember Deputy McGilligan, when he was Minister for Finance, discussing at a certain conference this dance tax which was remitted, I will admit, by Fianna Fáil in 1946. When you remit a tax you generally do it for the benefit of the general public. Fianna Fáil did remit the dance tax in 1946, and they are again remitting the sum of £140,000. But when the dance tax was remitted in 1946, did it go back to the general public? I submit that the charges remained the same: 3/9, 5/-, 10/- and in some cases £1. But not one penny of that went back to the general public. Every penny of it went into the pockets of the dance hall proprietors, and so will this £140,000 if it is remitted. That is the reason why Deputy McGilligan reimposed the tax when Minister for Finance. He was quite right in doing so. If it is remitted to-day, the benefit will not go to the general public or to the dancers. The charges to them will remain the same. Of course, the little bouncy Minister, as I say, leading a Party dances in here and says: "Enjoy yourselves, I am abolishing the tax." But I am afraid he is not giving it to the general public at all. He knew who he was giving it to because I have a letter here which was sent out a few days before the election. It is signed by the secretary of the Irish Ballroom Proprietors' Association. I will read a little paragraph from it. The secretary says that they are supporting Fianna Fáil. The letter goes on: —

"The association has decided that the support of Fianna Fáil should take the form of substantial financial help and also that all members, both city and country, should lend a hand in every possible direction to secure the return to power of the one Party who has given the association an indication that they as a Party are opposed to this undesirable entertainment tax on dances.

"It will be appreciated that, in order to have the desired effect, our financial aid must, of necessity, be generous. I may mention that one leading commercial ballroom in Dublin has headed the list of subscribers to this fund with a generous sum of £250"—

It was not a bad start at all —

"and other members of the executive have also indicated their willingness to subscribe very generously."

I must not forget this part of the letter: —

"Whilst the association does not specify any particular amount to be subscribed, they request you in your own interests to give as much as possible."

Of course, that is where the money has gone, and that is the answer. That is not bribery and that is not trickery any more than the fact that the quiet boys in the next Budget will have a surplus, and can get rid of the lads.

I am now going to refer to another class of stuff that is being given out here. I wonder does Deputy Cogan agree with it? We were members of the same Party at one time. I still happen to be in that Party, thank God. There is a kind of kink displayed in this House when you talk about collecting taxes. Some people seem to have it at the back of their heads that there is a section of people in this community who do not do their part, and that they are the farmers. As a matter of fact, I think I heard some Deputies say that this was a farmer's Budget. Of course, it is. The farmer does not eat any bread; he does not use any butter; and he does not smoke or drink. He does not take an odd half-one or a bottle of stout. He does not take any of these things, and so he is not hit at all. You hear it said that the farmer is not taxed properly, and that he does not pay income-tax.

I want to give the lie to that. The farmer is subject to the payment of income-tax the same as every other citizen of this State. The farmers are not only liable for income-tax but they pay income-tax the same as every other section in the community. We have even some of our daily newspapers writing articles saying that the farmer does not pay income-tax. But I want to ask: is the farmer not subject to the law of the country the same as all other sections of the community? I can tell the House that the Revenue Commissioners would not let him off. They are the very people who would not let him off with one sixpence. They would not let off their own mothers. Therefore, the farmer who is liable for the payment of income-tax contributes his share the same as every other citizen in this State. Having said that, I hope that we will not hear any more about the farmer not paying his share. He has always done so.

Other people will tell you that the farmer is subsidised by every other section of the community. He is not, because he carries the whole of them on his back.

Comment on this

Deputy McGilligan used to tell us that when he was Minister.

Comment on this

I am afraid the Deputy misunderstood him. You hear a lot of people criticising the farmers, but if they were wise they would shut their mouths. I do not intend to hold up the time of the House any longer beyond making an appeal to the four Independent Deputies. I do not mind how they vote. I do not mind what Government is in power ruling this country. What matters is to have an Irish Government in power, and the way they rule it and how they rule it. I will make an appeal to those four Independent Deputies who hold the reins at the moment, if they do hold them. I have warned them of the position they are in, and of how quickly they will be got rid of when the opportunity comes. I appeal to them as men to walk on this occasion into the Lobby not to cast a vote for the Fine Gael Party or the Clann na Poblachta Party or the Clann na Poblachta Party or the Labour Party, but to cast a vote for the country on this Budget and to save the people.

Again, there is a young Deputy, Deputy Dr. ffrench-O'Carroll. In his election address he said:—

"If elected I promise to focus attention constantly on the cost of living and to press for increased subsidies on food and other essential commodities."

Surely that Deputy is not going into the Lobby to-night to vote to abolish the subsidies. If he does I am afraid the people will lose faith and I am afraid that this country will turn out in the way that people will not cast a vote at all because a certain programme is put before them to-day and the next day it is quite the opposite.

Fianna Fáil, of course, said they were the people who would retain the subsidies. I have here a pamphlet which was published by Fianna Fáil during the last general election. It gives a list of commodities and starts off as follows: —

"Bread per 2 lb. loaf, 1947, when they were in power, 6d.; 1951, inter-Party Government, 6½d."

On the 1st July next it will be 9d. The pamphlet goes on: —

"Butter, 1947, when Fianna Fáil was in power, 2/8 per lb.; 1951, inter-Party Government, 2/10."

Oh, but, Sir, on the 1st July it will cost a minimum of 3/10. I believe it will cost 5/-. I will not delay the House in connection with this. In reference to this pending division I know that the people of this country are watching and waiting anxiously to see what the result will be. I know that the Fianna Fáil people are watching them there. I was watching them this evening and on other occasions and they were worried to death.

It was a great poker game. You would imagine that there were four aces in it but it was not a full hand. It had to be seen. I appeal to the four Independent Deputies to walk into the Lobby and let the country see that hand. Let the country give their decision. It is not fair to deprive the people of the country of the right to cast their vote. It is on the votes of the people that every Deputy in this House was elected. You are under an obligation to the people and your job is to vote so that the decision will be put before the people and they can decide the issue in a general election within the next 21 days.

I notice in a Sunday paper that a certain question was asked by Deputy McQuillan. The same question was asked by Deputy Dr. ffrench-O'Carroll. The question was that if there was a change of Government would the same taxes be left on or what would be done? That was an intelligent question and I congratulate both Deputy McQuillan and Deputy Dr. ffrench-O'Carroll on it. As Deputy John A. Costello, the ex-Taoiseach, and Deputy McGilligan, ex-Minister for Finance, explained the answer is that there is an overestimate here of roughly £10,000,000. With a change of Government and with the help of men like Deputy McGilligan again, taxation to the extent of that £10,000,000 could be reduced. That is the answer to the question that was asked.

Finally, I appeal to them and even to the honest Fianna Fáil man — there are a few honest ones left — to go into the Lobby this evening and give the people an opportunity to express their views. There is one reason more than anything else why I ask them to do this. This Budget has sown the seeds of Communism in this country. When next July comes and when the worker in the town with his wife and children and the poor farmer find out they cannot get enough bread or earn enough to provide the little comforts for their wives and families, then is when the seeds of discontent will be sown. It is work of that description that has bred Communism in other parts of the world. It is now being started here. If any Deputy votes for that Budget to-night to become the law of the land I have not the slightest doubt but that he will be sowing those seeds. You will have that discontent and, mind you, you may have some things in this country yet that you will regret you allowed to happen by voting for this Budget.

During 1943 and those subsequent years when I came to Dáil Éireann Deputy MacEntee, the Minister for Finance, was let loose. He was the professional mud slinger of Fianna Fáil. They let him loose in the West of Ireland. There was nothing but Communism then. Everyone was a Communist. I happened to be one according to him. Deputy Davin was one according to him and I think Deputy Cogan was one at that time too.

Comment on this

Faith he was — a budding one according to the Minister for Finance, Deputy MacEntee.

Comment on this

Deputy MacEntee, the Minister for Finance, has done more to establish Communism and sow the seeds of discontent and disorder than the worst Communist that ever lived.

Comment on this

I believe our greatest need to-day is clear-cut truth on political and industrial matters arising out of this Budget. I have been reading and listening to statements made by the members of Fianna Fáil during the last six months. We were told that if we did not accept this Budget we were likely to lose our independence. To-day we had Deputy Cunningham telling us something similar. We had another statement during the past week that if we did not accept this Budget we could not save the soul of Ireland. I think that is a terrible slander on the men who died for this country. The people who made such statements ought to read the Democratic Programme of the first Dáil in 1919 and be refreshed.

I think it is unfair to frighten the people of this country as they are being frightened by this bogey of the country being in danger of losing its independence.

Comment on this

Hear, hear!

Comment on this

I think it is no exaggeration to say that this Budget has shocked 80 per cent. of our people. I am quite satisfied that it has shocked the Fianna Fáil Party members and their followers as well as everybody else.

Comment on this

It is bound to.

Comment on this

As far as Cork is concerned the speeches that have been made have had a very serious effect on the trade of Cork City and, indeed, upon the trade of the country generally. Unemployment is increasing. Can anybody from any side of the House tell me how the 72,000 registered unemployed are going to get the purchasing power to buy their own needs and those of their families? Does anybody ever give it a thought? How are we going to have a revival of trade under the present Budget?

I want to avoid repetition in anything I have to say on this Budget because Deputy Norton, Deputy Larkin and Deputy Corish have very ably put the views of the Labour Party in regard to this Budget. I feel that we could have a much severer tax on those who are paying surtax. Looking up the statistics for some years past, I find that in 1945-46 there were 4,801 persons paying surtax with an income between them of £15,761,019; that in 1950-51 there were 5,293 persons liable to surtax whose incomes amounted to £17,601,000, or 452 more people subject to surtax. Looking back to see how we are dealing with the people who produce the goods for the sustenance of life, etc., I find that in 1935 there were 2,350 people in this State subject to surtax with a total income of £8,500,000. For the year ending March, 1951, there were 5,293, which means that there were 2,943 more people subject to surtax than there were in 1935. That means that the rich are getting richer and the poor are getting poorer.

I want to come now to the excess profits tax. Is there anything wrong in putting a tax on the excess profits which are being made in this country? In the year 1946-47, the profits taxable amounted to £15,500,000 and the tax payable was £5,000,000. In 1950-51 the profits taxable increased to £25,500,000. If a severe tax was put on these people it would not cause any great disturbance in the country nor any great hardship to those who are taking these excess profits from our people. I am opposed to indirect taxation. It is a very sinister way of making the mass of our people pay more in taxes than they should be paying. I suggest that the Minister should have a progressive tax such as they have in England, that the higher the income the higher the tax should be.

I now come to estate duties. Is there anything wrong with an increased tax on estates of £10,000 and upwards and a still higher tax on those of a larger amount? I do not see that any hardship would be created by increasing these taxes. Looking up the English estate duty tax, I find it is 83 per cent. as against 53 per cent. here. It was an unfortunate thing that we should drop even the small amount supposed to be got from the dance hall tax. After all £140,000 is not such an insignificant sum as the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs tried to convey to us. Why do we take that so lightly when the old age pensioner with £1 a week and the widows with orphans have to pay taxes on tea, bread, and sugar? We have very little scruples about these taxes, yet we can throw away £140,000 which could be got from the dance tax.

Is there anything wrong with a purchase tax on luxury goods if we are trying to equalise the burden on the people? The Minister for Justice said recently that in this Budget they were trying to ease the burden on those who are least able to bear it. I suggest that we should put the burden on those who are able to bear it and I hope that will be done before we are finished with this Budget.

Last week, when the Taoiseach was dealing with the question of money, I interjected a remark and he said that he was satisfied that I never studied the money problem at all. He went on to say that we wanted a body that will give an impartial report on money matters and that in the case of monetary control we have such a body. I intervened to say that they have no powers and he replied that they have powers and that they can exercise them in a certain way. He went on to say: —

"I was in at the framing of the Central Bank Bill, and I know the circumstances in operation then. I know my own views in regard to it and I am aware that every power necessary in order that they should do their duty properly was given to them."

That was the statement which the Taoiseach made on the 23rd of this month. I should also like to quote the statement made by the Taoiseach on the 23rd April, 1942, strange to say, when the Central Bank Bill was going through. I happened to be in the House then and, although he said that he has listened to me for many years and that he was satisfied I never studied the money problem at all, here is what he said about the Central Bank Bill on the 23rd April, 1942: —

"This Bill is not put forward as a Bill that will enable the bank or the Government effectively to control the volume of credit. It may influence it, and if there is the co-operation it can influence it tremendously, but it is not designed to effect it by coercive measures. It is based on an attempt to get co-operation between the three bodies interested, the Government as representing the community, the Central Bank as being the body that has to manage it from day to day and the commercial banks."

I ask the Taoiseach or anybody on his behalf to say which of these two statements is the truth. I submit that the Central Bank has not the power to do anything as far as our control of our money and credit is concerned. I ask the Minister for Finance or anybody who speaks on behalf of the Taoiseach to say which of these two statements is right.

That is why I say that this country is very much in need of clear-cut truth on matters of this kind. I heard the Taoiseach saying that we can do nothing except, wherever we borrow the money, we will have to be sure that we will get a return from it. If the banks refused to give the money, does it mean that we cannot do anything with our resources and with our means of production except a profit is being made out of them? I want to be very careful because I know that the Minister for Finance will say something about my associations and views as he did before. I am not concerned with that, because I have no connection with any kind of 'isms. I want to point out to the Taoiseach that the result of my study of the money question and the functions of money is that the natural use of money is to facilitate the exchange of goods. I will go further and say that its true value is, therefore, expressed in goods and not in terms of itself. Again, interest or usury is morally and economically indefeasible because it is a continual robbery of the producers of this country or any other country. All interest comes out of annual production. If anybody of my church says I am wrong in holding that view I will be the first to submit to their teaching. The Taoiseach, the Leader of the Government, tells me here that I am more concerned about phrases and then, on the other hand, he tells me that our Central Bank had the necessary powers to do all the things to safeguard the integrity of our currency and credit; yet if I went to the Central Bank to lodge a £ note they could not take it from me. They have not the power to do so. When the Central Bank Bill was going through this House we put an amendment down to give them the necessary power. But the Fianna Fáil Party refused to accept it; let it be said, however, to the credit of one member of that Party that he walked into the Lobbies with the Labour Party to support that amendment. The Deputy in question is not a member of the House at the moment.

I would like to say also to the Taoiseach that wealth or its equivalent in money divorced from labour does not increase in value but must decrease. Having that view I am convinced that interest is unnatural and therefore unjust and a robbery of producers' earnings. I know Deputy Briscoe will not agree with me in that because he was worried that the Trade Union Congress, according to a statement, were seeking to have further levies imposed upon a certain number of people who had an income between them of £17,000,000. I am suggesting to Deputy Briscoe or anybody else who has any scruples about that that those people could contribute a lot more to the finances of this country.

Comment on this

If that is as clear to the Deputy as all the rest he said, I can understand the Taoiseach referring to his knowledge of phrases and not of facts.

Comment on this

If the Taoiseach or the Deputy can tell me which of the two statements of the Taoiseach is correct, I will be satisfied.

Comment on this

They are both right. They are not in conflict.

Comment on this

He said they got all the powers that were necessary to control credit in this country.

Comment on this

He never said that.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Hickey on the motion.

Comment on this

I would be very sorry to misquote him and if I did I will be the first to correct it.

Comment on this

That last statement is a misquotation. He did not say that.

Comment on this

I am coming to the Budget speech of the Minister for Finance. Really it is depressing for the ordinary man in Ireland trying to find out where he stands, how the country is being run and who is responsible for all those false statements that are being made. I quote now from a speech of the Minister for Finance then Deputy MacEntee in the Official Debates, column 1783, Volume 121 of 14th June, 1950, when he was speaking on the Finance Bill. He said: —

"In this inflationary situation are we justified in flooding the market with more money because that in fact is what we propose to do when we propose to spend £12,000,000 upon works — whether they are meritorious or otherwise is a secondary matter—which we do not propose to procure out of the available purchasing power of the community?"

That from our Minister for Finance. He went on to say at column 1785:—

"The effect of the provisions of Section 22 of the Bill will be to weaken public confidence in the credit of the State."

I am sorry that Deputy Cunningham is not listening in view of what he said a while ago: —

"I believe that these provisions will deter investors from investing in our future loans. It is bound to do that, because they see here a proposal to saddle the State with an annual burden of £655,000."

Of course, he went on to encourage the banks to stand firm against the Government of this country elected by the people to do what needed to be done. Then we had another interesting statement from him. Some time after he wrote an article in the Sunday Press under the name of “Diddlum Dandy” and he commenced by saying:—

"We shall begin with the neediest amongst us, the old age pensioner, the destitute widow and the orphan.... The present maximum old age pension payable is 17/6 per week and the maximum rate payable to a widow without dependent children in rural areas is 10/- per week and for an orphan 6/- per week."

He said when the Fianna Fáil Government were in power the Irish £ was worth 4 dollars 2½ cents of United States money whereas to-day it is worth only 14 Fianna Fáil shillings.

"The purchasing power of the maximum old age pension has been reduced by an amount which is equivalent at the present value of 7/7½d. Coalition money, the widow's pension by an amount equivalent to 4/4½d. and the orphan's by the equivalent of 2/7¼d."

And he went on and told us in that article under the heading of "Diddlum Dandy":—

"Thus in one 12 months devaluation will have cost our people at least £120,000,000."

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Is the Minister responsible for that statement?

Comment on this

Yes. I am quoting from the Sunday Press of 13th November, 1949. The reason I am quoting from this is that I think it is strange to have a Minister responsible for our financial position who was capable of writing that article two years ago.

Comment on this

As Minister for Finance?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

He was a Deputy two years ago. The suggestion is that he made that statement as Minister for Finance.

Comment on this

No. Now the Deputy may correct me if I am wrong but that is not what I said. I said he wrote the article in 1949. It is quite obvious to the Deputy that he was then only Deputy MacEntee.

Comment on this

He was then an actor.

Comment on this

I am not worried about any individuals. There are so many personal references passed in this House that we never get a chance of discussing important matters in a cool, deliberate manner. He went on to say: —

"Mr. Dillon and his Coalition colleagues promised then to drown the British with eggs; instead they are now submerging us with sterling."

That is an interesting remark.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I am slow to interrupt the Deputy again but did Deputy MacEntee write that article over his own name.

Comment on this

Yes. I will be very much surprised if there is any question about it later. He went on: —

"They are dooming the Irish people to go down with the British ship."

Is it not strange that before we knew what this Budget was going to hold for us, our Minister for Finance was invited to London by the British Chancellor of the Exchequer for, we were told, an exchange of views? Personally I am at a loss to know why we were to be guided by the British Chancellor of the Exchequer. Our Minister for Finance said that he was going to make a statement on the financial position and that he would co-operate in every way. The British Chancellor of the Exchequer, in introducing his Budget statement said: —

"The only way to make sterling stronger is to make it scarcer, and that is what we are doing."

I am suggesting to the Minister for Finance and to everybody in this House that that is what we have done.

Comment on this

Externally, as distinct from internally.

Comment on this

I am not concerned with international affairs but with the runing of our own country.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Hickey must be allowed to proceed.

Comment on this

I am only trying to understand the Deputy.

Comment on this

On a point of order, would the Chair tell Deputy Briscoe to address the Deputy through him, and not across the House?

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I have asked Deputy Briscoe to cease interrupting. I would now ask Deputy Hickey to address his remarks to the Chair.

Comment on this

I would be sorry to have it said that I was addressing them otherwise than through the Chair. Deputy Briscoe addressed a remark to me across the House, and I turned aside for a moment to answer him.

In introducing his Budget, the British Chancellor of the Exchequer made the statement I have quoted above, and it is a remarkable thing that the implication in this Budget is that sterling can only be made stronger by making it scarcer.

The bank rate has been increased. I put down a question yesterday to the Minister for Finance asking if the Central Bank consulted him before they put up the rate of interest by 1 per cent. He replied that they had. 1 per cent. increase in the bank rate on a £1,000 house is somewhere between 2/4 and 2/6 per week in rent extra. Everybody is aware the cheapest house that can be built to-day costs £1,500 or £1,600. Because of the increase in the interest rate of 1 per cent. the rent of such houses will go up by 3/6 per week. We are also aware that the interest rate on moneys borrowed by farmers for the purpose of trying to increase production has also gone up. I am interested in finding out where we stand and to where we are being driven as far as our financial bosses are concerned. I am trying to understand the implications of our money system. I never held the view that money is superior to human beings. However, we are living under a money economy and it is what counts and not men, women and children apparently. Questions have been asked here by me during the past three or four weeks as to the amount of interest we pay for the moneys used by semi-State organisations.

I found that borrowings from the banks on Exchequer bills, public issues of stocks by the Government, land bonds and savings certificates cost £4,283,973 per year in interest alone. For the year ending March, 1951, the local authorities, excluding the harbour authorities, paid £2,013,000 in interest alone; the Electricity Supply Board paid last year £1,125,071 in interest alone for moneys borrowed for the electrification of our country; Tea Importers Limited, about which some pertinent questions were asked to-day, have a big overdraft at the expense of the State and the interest on such overdraft last year was £3,931; Grain Importers Limited, two thirds of our flour milling which is controlled from outside this country, paid in interest last year £87,740. The State had to pay this interest so that these gentlemen could produce the flour and the grain we needed. We have no say except to delegate that power. Irish Steel Holdings Limited in Haulbowline paid in interest alone last year £7,286; the Butter Marketing Committee paid in interest last year £29,207; in interest alone last year for telephone development £86,271 was paid; Fuel Importers Limited paid by way of interest last year £128,115. This makes a total, on interest alone on the moneys borrowed for these semi-State organisations, of £7,764,594. During the week the Minister for Finance was asked if he could say what was the interest paid on our national debt. He said it was £7,354,700. This makes a grand total of £15,119,294.

I am quite satisfied there has been a deliberate attempt from the vested interests and others in this country to keep the masses of our people in ignorance about our money and credit system. Money cannot be found to help the weaker sections of the community except by removing the subsidies from tea, bread, butter and sugar. Everybody knows the weaker sections of our community exist mainly on bread, tea and sugar. If anybody wants to make sure of that, he can study the nutritional survey made of this country in the past few years.

I think it is a shame that £15,000,000 in interest should be paid in a year to finance semi-State organisations including our national debt. I would ask any serious-minded person on any side of the House what contribution these individuals have made to increase production and what contribution will they make to increase production in the future. Do we realise the interest that is drawn from the community as a result of the operations of our banking system? As I said a while ago the Minister for Finance was worrying about the banks and hoping they would stand firm on the question of lending money to the previous Government— the money which was needed to do the necessary things. I have a record of their figures for the last 26 years, and I am aware that they have drawn in net profits over £36,000,000 on a paidup capital of only £9,000,000. They are the power in this country, and they are the group whom the Minister for Finance was telling in 1950 to stand firm and not to accede to the wishes of the previous Government who were anxious to develop our industrial resources and to increase production of wealth.

Deputy Donnellan was talking about Communism a short while ago. In my view, we do a lot of wishful thinking from time to time in this House about many things. I would like to put on record that it is not bombs or guns or anything of that kind which is going to fight Communism. A properly developed and just industrial system is the only system which will operate against Communism in this or in any other country.

I feel that we should not be spending £1,000,000 more on our defence forces at the present time while the agricultural industry is neglected. The reason why I talk about spending money unnecessarily on defence purposes is that I read in the Irish Press on 10th August, 1950, the following: —

"DUMPING AMMUNITION IN IRISH SEA.

Getting rid of ammunition left over from the last war is still a big problem, for although over 1,500,000 tons have been disposed of, hundreds of tons remain, a P.A. message from London says.

The Defence Ministry stated that nearly 1,000 tons are dumped in the Irish Sea every week and this might be stepped up to 60,000 tons a year. But it could not go beyond that figure without an additional port."

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

It does not seem to be relevant to the motion.

Comment on this

It does, Sir, because we are spending money on defence and increasing our Army. If we spent those millions of money on developing agriculture and producing food for our people we would be far more secure from outside sources than we are at the present time. That is why I am quoting that paragraph. We were told here by Deputies, including Deputy Cunningham, about the danger of borrowing money from outside. I think it is necessary to bring home to our people that this country has sufficient money to do anything that is required to be done to develop our resources. If war broke out to-morrow morning I am satisfied that there would be millions and millions of money made available — and the banks would not grouse about it — for military preparations. Yet, we cannot use money for peace purposes, to keep our people from being hungry. We must get our conception of things right. I believe in having an Army and an efficient Army but I think £6,000,000 a year is sufficient to spend on the Army and on defence.

Quite recently the International Review of Diplomatic and Political Science (Geneva) issued the following statement:—

"The International Review of Diplomatic and Political Science (Geneva) estimates that the money spent on World War II could have provided: £4,000 worth of furniture; a £12,000 house; £20,000 in cash to every family in the United States, Canada, Australia, New Zealand, Britain, Ireland, France, Germany and the Soviet Union.

In addition each town of over 200,000 population could have been given a cash donation of—£25,000,000 for hospitals; £25,000,000 for libraries; £25,000,000 for schools."

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

It does not arise on this motion.

Comment on this

It does, Sir, because I want to bring some reality into our Budget which proposes to spend money foolishly on defence. To spend more than £6,000,000 for that purpose does not make sense to my mind.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

We are not discussing defence. That may be raised on the Estimate.

Comment on this

We are discussing ways and means of providing money to run the affairs of this country. We are talking about policy. I say that it is necessary to bring these matters before our people. I do not say all the members of the Fianna Fáil Party, but some members of the Fianna Fáil Party, have made foolish speeches and damaging speeches all over the country, telling us that we must save the soul of the nation and of the things that will happen if we do not accept this Budget. Do we forget the past? Do we forget the sacrifices that have been made for this country? Do we forget the men who went out to face the wealthiest and most powerful empire in the world? In 1952 speeches are made threatening the innocent people of the country that if they do not accept this cruel Budget we will be bankrupt and at the mercy of people outside.

I suggest that we are the most powerful country financially in the world. We are the one creditor country at the moment except the United States of America. I am surprised that people of standing, backing and history of Fianna Fáil should make such speeches. John Bull's friends could not do better than some of the speeches that have been made by members of the Fianna Fáil Party during the past six or eight months.

Here we are talking about money. I read in the Irish Press of the 22nd of this month that a woman shrieked, fainted, recovered, laughed, shook hands with her friends, all in three minutes, at the Mansion House, when her name was drawn out of the drum, out of 2,900 odd applicants. She was told that she would have to wait a long time yet before she could get a house. I want to tell Deputies, even members of my own Party, that there are people in Cork living in houses the condition of which would shock the finer feelings of people outside this country. Here we are telling the people outside this country that we are asking for mercy. We are telling the people that if they do not accept this harsh Budget and the increase in the bank rate that there will be poverty and misery in the country. Is there any reason why, after 30 years of native government, there should be such a condition of affairs that people are looking for houses? Are we here doing our duty as Irishmen to this weaker section in the community? Whom are we defending when we talk as we do? We are defending the financial interests in trying to apply an out-dated economic system to the changing circumstances of the present day. I hope that from now on we will hear less speeches about the country being bankrupt and that we will get down to doing something in the interests of the people.

Does anybody ever think of what power we have in this House after all our years? We have listened to Deputy Cunningham asking where will we get the money and saying that we will have to stop the lavish spending. What lavish spending takes place?

I have in mind the classes of people we have in this country. I do not believe in classes but let us divide them into three categories. We have a mass of people who are in and out of industry, at small wages, sometimes living on the social services, who have a miserable existence. They do not live; they exist. The average weekly wage of an ordinary unskilled working man is about £6 5s.

Comment on this
Brendan Corish Breanndán Mac Fheórais Labour Party

That is a big average.

Comment on this

It is a big average. That is over £300 a year. Yet some of those gentlemen to whom I have referred have over £370 a week. They are the 5,293 people who have a yearly income between them of £17,601,262. I find that we have 166,000 old age pensioners; 62,000 widows and orphans; 57,000 persons drawing home assistance. Has the Minister for Finance or any member of the Fianna Fáil Party seriously considered what is the purchasing power of those thousands of people? Are they able to buy sufficient food, milk, clothing or anything else on their present incomes? They have to live on bread, tea, butter or whatever they can get and these are the things that are taxed.

Will anybody tell me how we are to have a revival of trade as long as there are 72,000 unemployed at the labour exchanges? We must face the fact that in order to bring about a revival of trade we must have more equitable distribution of the national income, so that the money will be in circulation. If the purchasing power of the mass of the people is reduced, there will be less and less buying of goods and more and more unemployment.

I regard this Budget as an ill-considered Budget. It is a deflationary Budget and deflation is more serious than inflation, about which there is all the talk. Once you indulge in a deflationary campaign, it will be many a long day before we are back in the position we were in 1950-51. We are in a vicious circle. If anybody stops buying, somebody stops selling. If somebody stops selling, somebody stops producing. If somebody stops producing, somebody stops working. If somebody stops working, somebody stops earning. If somebody stops earning somebody stops buying. There is the vicious circle that we are in. This Budget will aggravate the position.

I do not say that members of the Fianna Fáil Party are any less patriotic than I am, but, coming from a Party with the record and background of Fianna Fáil, this Budget is a surprise to me and to anybody who has the interests of the country at heart. I say here and now that this Budget is dictated mainly by the financiers and bankers of the country and nobody can convince me that is not so.

There was a statement in the Central Bank Report some time ago which encouraged the Government to adopt a policy of taking subsidies off and they said that there were compensating effects in reduction in consumption. Who is consuming too much? We heard a young Deputy like Deputy Cunningham telling us about our having to consume less and to work harder. He told us about Belgium and said that the reason for Belgium's prosperity was that they were prepared to work for anything they could get. Is that what we are to get from the young men of to-day after 30 years of native government?

We have in Cork two world-wide organisations in Fords and Dunlops, and they can tell anybody that the workers in their factories there can produce as much as, and even more than, any other workers in their organisations in the world. Then we have people telling us lightly that we must work harder and produce more or consume less. Would it not be a good thing to address that to the people who are driving around in the big cars? None of the working class people owns any of the £1,500 or £1,600 cars that one sees in the streets of Dublin and Cork, but one would imagine from all the loose talk we hear that it is the workers who are responsible for our present position.

Let us come now to agriculture. I looked up some statistics about agriculture recently and I find them simply amazing. The statistics show that, over the past 25 years, employment in industry increased from 102,000 to over 200,000 and, over the same period, agriculture output went down. In the past 16 years, the number engaged in agriculture fell from 640,000 to 500,000 — a reduction of 140,000 agricultural workers. Will anybody dispute that, in losing these 140,000 workers, we have lost 140,000 skilled agricultural workers? We find also that the average age of 200,000 male farmers is 56 years; that two-thirds were over 65 to 70 years of age; and that of 50,000 women on the land, two-thirds are widows aged 61. Is that not something that should set us thinking?

Why are we in that position after 30 years of native government, although the Taoiseach told us, in 1934, that this country could support at least 17,000,000 people, with a higher standard of living than they enjoyed at that time? Yet, after 18 years, we have not reached the 3,000,000 mark, and, instead of being able to keep the young virile elements in our country, they are going all over the world, and particularly to the country next door, to produce goods there and the send their paper money back to this country to inflate our position here and to create the bogey which has been set before us. It is an alarming state of affairs.

We have the Taoiseach, the head of the country, telling us that when we borrow money, we will have to make sure that we get sufficient to pay the charges. I remember in 1932 the Taoiseach saying that if he were asked what policy the Irish people should struggle for: "I stand side by side with James Connolly," and, in 1952, 20 years after, we are told that we cannot develop the industries except out of the savings of the Irish people. I suggest that this Government should be in control of our money and credit. Deputy Declan Costello talked about borrowing from the banks. My view — and I have stated it before — is that I am quite satisfied that we can never borrow ourselves into prosperity.

Why should the Government borrow from the banks or from the financiers on the future productivity of our people? When we talk about issuing money, let our minds be clear on this point on whose credit is the issue of money made? I say that it is clearly on the capacity of our people to produce goods and services. For 30 years a group of national and international interests have controlled our financial system and with it the power to manipulate our economic life. Why should we not now be in a position to issue money—why should we not talk about £50,000,000?—to put our 72,000 unemployed men at work producing wealth, food, fuel, shipping and land improvement? Am I talking nonsense when I say that should be done? But we cannot do it under our present financial system and until such time as the Government take control of our money and credit, we may talk about it until Tibb's Eve.

I remember reading a speech made recently by the Taoiseach on the occasion of the 25th anniversary of the Fianna Fáil Party, in the Gresham Hotel, in which he said we are a sovereign State. How can we be a sovereign State when we have to go to the banks, with cap in hand, to ask for money? What money? Paper money, which is issued against something which the people and not the banks have produced.

Comment on this

At 6 per cent.

Comment on this

Probably, from now on. I say in all seriousness to the Fianna Fáil Party that this Budget must be amended, because if not our people will revolt against it in a way very adverse to the interests of this country.

We had the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs yesterday talking to us about crackpot financiers. Of course, I am considered one of them. I wonder what he would call the financial experts to whom he entrusted the money from the Hospitals Trust Funds while the Fianna Fáil Party were in Government previously. When the Hospitals Trust Funds were invested in 1939 we lost £22,150 on the sale of the investments. In 1940 we lost £120,061 on sales of our investments; in 1941 we lost £4,988; in 1944 we lost £15,000 odd and in 1945 £10,000; making a total of £172,834. That was lost on our investments of Hospitals Trust Funds, while we had 460 schools that the medical officers and everyone else condemned as not fit for children and we had thousands of people looking for homes.

That money has been sent out of the country to Ceylon, Rhodesia, Newfoundland and all over the world and to British corporations for 2½ per cent. and 3½ per cent. while the public authorities in this country had to pay 5 per cent. Then we have the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs coming in here with an air of superiority to tell me and others: "We cannot listen to crackpot financiers saying how the country should be run." These are the people we have entrusted with our country's finances and these are some of the people who are getting £15,000,000 in interest for the running of the country. We would not trust the Pat Murphys to these things. When I said last week that I was prepared to trust the Front Bench of the Government to deal with and control our money and credit there came an answer from the Taoiseach. He asked if I wanted him to be frank and I said "certainly". He said that if I were on the Opposition Benches and saw the people that were in the last Government on the Front Benches I would not be willing to give it to them. To whom has he given it?

Comment on this

The people in College Green and Threadneedle Street.

Comment on this

Last week I went into a post office to send a subscription to New York for a publication to which I have been subscribing for years, but I could not send that 15/- without getting the permission of the Minister for Finance here. I am quite satisfied that he would give the necessary permission — even though he often seems to think I am talking nonsense when I talk about the control of our money — but I know very well that he has to get permission for it from the Bank of England. If it is the case that this is a sovereign State, it is time we should think and talk more seriously. We should not be hurling insults and sneers at each other across the House but should think more of the problems of the people who sent us here than about the next general election.

The Taoiseach wanted to know what is the limit of borrowing. If I asked that question, I know what I might expect from someone who had given it any thought. What is the limit of borrowing? I would suggest that anyone spending money must know what the circumstances are. It must be based on the lack of man power, the lack of raw materials, the lack of sufficient land. No one can say that we have had enough land improvement. Any farmer on any side of the House will tell you that we are not getting anything like what we should get from the land. The increases quoted in statistics in regard to produce from the land have not been of any great extent over the last 25 years. If we were serious we would be building up our country. We could now be on the crest of the wave, for the world is crying out for food. Here we are with not even sufficient to feed ourselves. We have to go to New Zealand for butter and pay £3,000,000 more for it, to make up the balance that we require. Then we have speeches like that we had from Deputy Cunningham a while ago telling us that this lavish spending must cease.

I listened to many of the speeches made during the last general election in Cork and I would like very much if some of the Deputies who made such speeches would go back and read what they said at that time and think of what is happening to-day. I challenge anyone in the Fianna Fáil Party to state any false statement I made during that election. While I was speaking on the platforms during that election, I was told even by my best friends: "Do not talk so seriously about these matters; talk about the things the other fellows are talking about." I did not, because I am satisfied that we all have too lively a belief in the gullibility of our people and the patience of our people. This Budget has been brought in here because of the continued patience and ignorance of most of our people. The Governments during the past 30 years, here and in other countries, have been based on the ignorance and patience of the majority of our people. That is what has been happening. We have to develop public opinion and enlighten public opinion. If that were done, we would not have had some of the speeches delivered here from Fianna Fáil Benches and by some of the leading figures of the Fianna Fáil Party down the country Sunday after Sunday.

One thing I would like to say is that, when any matter of importance to the country comes up for discussion, every opportunity is taken here to prevent people discussing it in a deliberative way. I would suggest that such matters should be discussed in future in a deliberative fashion. There are people on both sides of the House who have done signal service to the country, and no one wishes to take the credit from them, but we are living in a new world now compared to what we were in some eight or ten years ago. We must not forget that the result of the last war has been making the choice of how this country is to be run. Whoever will live to see the results, the mass of the people are thinking more than they did in the days gone by and the things that fitted previous to 1939 in this or any other country do not fit in with the circumstances of to-day. Let the young men on both sides of the House try to apply themselves to thinking of the changes that have taken place. Whether there is another war or not, we know that the last war brought about certain changes rather quickly. There are other forces at work throughout the world. We hear talk of Communism and other 'isms. Communism is just a product of injustice to people everywhere.

It is interesting to note that we had a statement recently from an ex-Minister of the British Government who was sent on a mission to Egypt and reported that of the 20,000,000 in Egypt two-thirds were living on £2 per month. Another gentleman who went on research work to several countries came back to say that two-thirds of the world population were living on an income equivalent to 10/- a week in England to-day. There was a time when we had talk of anarchists as people who attempted to revolt against injustice, but now we have people who are revolting against injustice and they are being called Communists. I repeat that we will not be able to prevent the revolt of millions of people who are living under injustice. We in this country are more in a position than the people in any other country to-day to give the people the things they want. We have the men, the land and the necessary materials to give our people a decent standard of living. We are not doing it and I say that the reason why we are not doing it is that we are not in control of the money and credit wherewith to develop the resources that our people believe should have been developed years and years ago.

Comment on this
Frank Aiken Minister for External Affairs (Mr. Aiken) Fianna Fáil

Deputy Hickey is slightly mistaken when he says that the reason we are not producing all he would like — and indeed all I would like — in order to make our people prosperous and to give them a high standard of life is that there is some conspiracy between the Government here and forces like the Bank of England.

Comment on this

I do not want to interrupt the Minister but——

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Minister might be allowed to make his speech.

Comment on this

I had nothing in mind about a conspiracy and I do not like to hear that word "conspiracy."

Comment on this

Deputy Hickey said that the reason for the present Budget was that we were driven to it by financiers, bankers and Threadneedle Street and a few other epithets that were suggested by various members of the Opposition groups. Deputy Hickey asked one question, the answer to which, if it can be answered, will give the clue to the solution of most of our problems: why are we importing butter from New Zealand? The reason is not lack of capital, not lack of spirit in our people to work, but the sheer craziness of the last Government supported by Deputy Hickey.

Comment on this

Surely.

Comment on this

The Minister should go on to something else.

Comment on this

Before we left office we spent money on land improvement and a certain amount of money on the subsidising of artificial fertilisers and lime. The first year the Coalition Government were in office they stopped the farm improvements scheme and the farm buildings scheme and curbed the subsidy on artificial fertilisers. When they got £40,000,000 of money from the Americans what did they do? Start to produce butter? No. Led by Deputy Dillon they took a ride on the bulldozer to the worst possible land they could get in the country. That is what they did instead of using their brains and money to do what Fianna Fáil had been trying to do, restore the fertility of the soil and bring it up to the point where the land of Ireland would be producing something like what it should produce at the present time. Deputy Dillon found plenty of schemes in his Department ready to go ahead in order to increase agricultural production, for instance the scheme evolved during the war by Fianna Fáil to put as soon as machinery became available all the lime the land required upon it. He threw it out of the window and started tinkering around with lime distribution and he did not even do that until he got the Marshall millions. Deputy Hickey wants to know why we are importing butter from New Zealand. It was because Deputy Dillon and Deputy Hickey went to the worst land in the country and spent millions of money and a lot of energy on it instead of trying to encourage farmers to put lime, phosphates and potash on the soil.

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D.J. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

The butter ration was increased.

Comment on this

If they had done that they would have got further with increasing production.

Comment on this

That is the one acre in Galway.

Comment on this

With all the blowing about it Deputy Dillon did when the by-election was coming in Connemara, with all the talk about shipping the rocks and mountains into the sea, all he did in his time was to clear two acres at a cost of £200 apiece, and I will swear that there is not a farmer in the country who would give 50/- for what £200 of the taxpayers' money was spent on. He did not continue with the lime scheme to give farmers with some land in bad condition a chance to increase the fertility of the soil and correct acidity. He stopped the artificial fertiliser subsidy scheme, the lime subsidy scheme and all the others. If we are ever to stop importing butter from New Zealand, wheat from America and maize from the Argentine, we will have to get down to the job of increasing agricultural production. What we must do is to encourage farmers to take as much out of the soil as the soil of Ireland can give with reasonable care.

Comment on this

Put back the heart into the land.

Comment on this

Without changing any of the other factors which should be changed, such as improving seeds and the quality of the stock, if we put fertilisers on the land to the same degree as has been done in Sweden during the past 25 years, when they increased the use of fertilisers by 150 per cent., we might expect a somewhat similar increase in agricultural production to that which occurred in Sweden during that period when, as they claim, they doubled agricultural production. We are producing from land, which is on the average as good land as there is in the world, a mere £104,000,000 worth, so if we want prosperity here and an increase in our standard of life we must get agricultural production up.

Comment on this

What hindered you?

Comment on this

Industrial production has gone up in the last 20 years by 150 per cent. and we must get agricultural production up in the same way. We must stop this chat about the Bank of England, the Central Bank of Ireland or other banks being responsible for our taking butter from New Zealand.

Comment on this

The banks are doing their job well—for themselves.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Hickey has already spoken on this motion.

Comment on this

I am sorry; I did not intend to interrupt the Minister at all.

Comment on this

High finance.

Comment on this
Brendan Corish Breanndán Mac Fheórais Labour Party

We will get it from the Minister now.

Comment on this

If we had continued after the war, as Fianna Fáil had started, the campaign to put lime and fertilisers on the soil we would not be in the sorry position of having to import butter from New Zealand.

Comment on this

The inter-Party Government, after 16 years of your policy, had terrible trouble.

Comment on this

The inter-Party Government, because the people were dissatisfied with them, gave Deputy Dillon all the money he wanted to carry out a scheme which he explained in very spectacular fashion but which was useless and worse than useless — a criminal waste of money.

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D.J. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

Is the Minister serious on that?

Comment on this

Absolutely serious. I will take any Deputy who wants to come to my constituency and show him land treated under that scheme at a cost of £50 or £60 per acre of the Irish taxpayers' money.

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D.J. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

The Minister said £200 a few minutes ago.

Comment on this

That land would not produce enough grass to feed a snipe.

Comment on this

Why are you continuing it so? Why not stop it?

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I would remind Deputies that the Minister is in possession. He is entitled to speak without interruption and the Chair will see that he is allowed to speak without interruption.

Comment on this

We did put a stop to that crazy element——

Comment on this

You did not.

Comment on this

Yes, we did.

Comment on this

Of course, you did not.

Comment on this

Deputies need not think that they can roar me down or that if they say "no" often enough to something I say it will not be believed by the people of the country. The people know who is telling the truth in these matters. The people of the country know that the Minister for Agriculture put an end to this crazy expenditure of £60 or £70 per acre on swamps, that he put a limit on the expenditure and confined the activities of the land improvement section of his Department to draining and improving land that would give some return for the money spent upon it.

Comment on this

For the ranchers.

Comment on this

Is that why you cut down the Local Authorities (Works) Act?

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Order!

Comment on this

Deputy Captain Giles has great impudence to talk about the ranchers in this respect. During the first year of the operation of Deputy Dillon's land development scheme it was confined, apart from a couple of small spots out in Mayo, largely——

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D.J. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

On a point of order, are we discussing the Estimate for the Department of Agriculture or the Budget?

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That is not a point of order.

Comment on this

If Deputies do not like to listen to me they can go out.

Comment on this

On a further point of order. Must it not be quite clear to the Chair, as it is to some of us, that the Minister is deliberately provoking the Chair to put somebody out?

Comment on this

And he will fail.

Comment on this

I should not like Deputy Davin to have that excuse.

Comment on this

The Minister will not get away with it or get me out.

Comment on this
Brendan Corish Breanndán Mac Fheórais Labour Party

He will not get away with the Budget.

Comment on this

I was saying, when I was interrupted, that we had put an end to the crazy element in the land improvements scheme and that we had changed around from spending the Irish people's money on the worst land to be found to spending it on land that would give a reasonable return within a reasonable time. We criticised Deputy Dillon when he brought in that scheme. We asked him why he had not allowed the improvements scheme that was there to go ahead and why put this over-emphasis on the draining of the worst land in the country when the real problem of increasing agricultural production was how to get the farmers to put the lime and fertilisers on the soil as quickly as possible. I was led into all that by Deputy Hickey, who asked why we were importing butter from New Zealand.

About May, 1948, Deputy Costello, the then Taoiseach, said that he was alarmed at the unfavourable balance of payments in the previous couple of years. I shall quote exactly what he said in a few moments, but I want to read now the figures he was alarmed about. From 1940 to 1946 we had a surplus balance of payments totalling £162,000,000. In 1947, the first year in which we could import goods, we had an unfavourable balance of payments or a deficit in our balance of payments of £29.8 million. The next year, 1948, we had a deficit balance of £19.7 million. That, remember, was what Deputy Costello was alarmed at. Although we had added £162,000,000 to our foreign assets in the war years, and it had decreased by less than £50,000,000, Deputy Costello was very alarmed. I shall quote now from a speech made by Deputy Costello in this House on the 5th August, 1948. The reference is column 2146. Volume 112, of the Official Report. In the course of his speech he said:

"When the 1938 agreement was being negotiated the adverse trade balance between this country and Great Britain was such as not to cause any anxiety or certainly very little anxiety. In the intervening period the adverse trade balance has gone to an extent which must cause anybody who thinks about it for one moment or who looks at the figures the utmost alarm for our economic and financial stability."

He went on to say that the adverse trade balance was one of the problems that gave his Government the greatest possible cause for dismay, and he said that he would discuss later the methods by which the Coalition Government would be enabled to deal with "that very alarming and very urgent problem." The very alarming and very urgent problem was how to correct an adverse trade balance over the previous two years of less than £50,000,000 although we had added, during the previous five or six years, £162,000,000 to our external assets.

Why did the Coalition Government change their tune about the external assets? During their first year of office they had a reasonably balanced Budget. They tried not to inflate too rapidly but, with the demands of all the various groups that comprised that Government, and the desire of Deputy McGilligan to keep going until there should be a vacancy on the bench, they decided that they would give everybody everything they asked for.

Comment on this
Deputies

Oh!

Comment on this

The result, very naturally, was a very rapid increase in the adverse trade balance. Last year it had mounted to the point where it was £61.6 million — and Deputy Costello is not alarmed at it, although he was alarmed when it was less than £50,000,000 over a period of two years. He thinks there is no cause for alarm that it should be £61.6 million in one year alone.

Comment on this

What was the position prior to 1940?

Comment on this

I think that between 1932 and 1940 we had a total deficit of a couple of million pounds—but we had got rid of the land annuities, which amounted to nearly £100,000,000.

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D.J. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

At what cost?

Comment on this

With the profit of being able to call our souls our own.

Comment on this

Part of our souls.

Comment on this

Of course, when the Coalition Government——

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D.J. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

Which one?

Comment on this

——found themselves in difficulties, and wanting to carry on, they had to get excuses for the illeffects of their policy. They developed. the euphemism for the deficit in the balance of trade and the failure to pay their way in the international trade field, that they were repatriating our external assets, that they were making a capital investment in human welfare and so on. It is all to the credit of a Government that does its best to improve the standard of living of its people and that tries to give them a higher standard of social services within the limits that the community can afford. That is all to be praised, but they should at least take the responsibility of paying their way. What happened during the last two and a half years in which they were the Government was that Deputy McGilligan, then Minister for Finance, gave to the Coalition groups a good time. He sat at the counter, ordered drinks for everybody and told the bartender to put it on the slate, that we would pay when we came back. That is what this Budget is about. We have to pay for the debts of the Fine Gael people.

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D.J. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

The fuel dumps.

Comment on this

They had a look at the supply services and they wanted to borrow for some of them instead of imposing taxation. Instead of going out to borrow for increased old age pensions or widows' and orphans' pensions, they decided that they would call some of the other sections of the supply services capital services, and that they would borrow for those. I have no doubt that Deputy McGilligan, as he said yesterday, could reduce taxation by £9,000,000 if he got the opportunity. Of course he could, not only by £9,000,000 but by £90,000,000. Any Minister for Finance who has no scruples about the future of our country could reduce the present tax bill, not alone by £9,000,000 but by £90,000,000. It is no new thing; it has been done in other parts of the world, but if that line of action were pursued here for a number of years it would have exactly the same results as it had in other parts of the world. Most people know about the inflation that took place in Germany after the first world war. Some people have heard vaguely about the inflationary situation in France but they do not know so much about it, because it is not quite so spectacular as the inflation that occurred in Germany after the first world war when the mark went through the roof and 25 per cent. of the German people lost all their savings.

Unfortunately for the French people, they had the situation where no single Party or group of large Parties has been able to form a Government. They had to take all sorts of people, all sorts of petty groups, to form these various Coalitions since the war. Whenever a Minister for Finance made a suggestion to correct the inflationary situation, to raise money by taxation rather than by borrowing from the Central Bank, one or other of the small Parties would say "no"; the Government went out and the Parties had to play musical chairs again. The result for the French people to-day is that the minimum wages guaranteed by the State will buy less than half the minimum wages guaranteed here by the State in relation to agriculture.

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D.J. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

They had a war.

Comment on this

It was not the politicians who were at fault; unfortunately, the French people were not able to give them a reasonably stable and responsible Government. If our people want, they can get a Government here that will reduce taxation over the next couple of years from the figure that we are asking them to pay. They can reduce it by £9,000,000 or £90,000,000.

Comment on this

Why do you not do it?

Comment on this

I should like to deal for a couple of moments with something Deputy Dillon stated about the Marshall Aid funds. He said that they had left no net debt due to the United States Government.

Comment on this
Brendan Corish Breanndán Mac Fheórais Labour Party

The reference, Mr. Minister?

Comment on this

It was reported in the Irish Times of the 26th April, 1952. The statement was made at Rockcorry, County Monaghan, that they had left no net debt due to the United States Government. The fact is that at the present time this country owes to the United States Government a sum in dollars amounting to $128,170,000. Deputy Costello, when he landed at Cobh, on his way back from the United States in 1948 said that he had reassured the American people, gave his word of honour and pledged the honour of the Irish people, that every dollar of that would be repaid. Deputy Dillon said there was no net debt but if we were to repay these 128,000,000 odd dollars to-morrow in a bulk sum and buy dollars with our pounds, we would have to raise £45,000,000.

Comment on this
Brendan Corish Breanndán Mac Fheórais Labour Party

How much of that did the present Government spend?

Comment on this

That is the net debt, no matter who spent it or what it was spent on. The point I am at is that there is a net debt of $128,000,000 or £45,000,000, due by this country to the United States which we were pledged by the last Government to repay. What was it spent on? We got it in the form of dollars — 128,000,000 of them. We spent millions of them in buying wheat and maize in order to drown the British in eggs.

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D.J. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

And in buying Dutch chocolates.

Comment on this

We did not succeed in drowning the British in eggs but we drowned ourselves in a dollar debt. The people who are always prating with contempt about our sterling assets, in fact, during their years of office, imposed a dollar debt on this people in order to build up our sterling assets. Where did we spend them? In the first instance they were spent on buying dollar goods. The Minister for Finance sold those dollars to people who wanted to import American goods, American wheat, American maize, American nylons and all the rest of it. The pounds received from the sale of these dollars were paid into the Loan Counterpart Fund and the Minister for Finance then proceeded to reborrow from himself and in that way they were spent by the previous Government and by this Government. Some of the pound receipts were spent on land reclamation, some in providing loans for houses, some for Electricity Supply Board development and so on and so forth. They were in fact spent for capital purposes of various kinds.

Comment on this

And provided employment.

Comment on this

If to-morrow we wanted to repay in a lump sum the £45,000,000 we owe to the United States we would either have to tax the Irish people or get them to subscribe to a loan of £45,000,000 in order to repay that sum. We cannot get it back from the houses that were built or from the lands that were drained, and the only way in which we could repay it would be either through the medium of a loan or by the imposition of taxation to the extent of £45,000,000, because that is the sum we would require to buy the dollars to be repaid.

Comment on this

May I ask one question? What sum was in the Loan Counterpart Fund at the time of the change of Government last June?

Comment on this

There was about half left.

Comment on this

Deputy McGilligan stated last night that there was £26,000,000.

Comment on this

I am not contesting that at all. Let it be £26,000,000 or £20,000,000 or £30,000,000; the point I am dealing with is — and the Deputy need not try to get away from it — that Deputy Dillon said they had left no net debt in dollars. We still owe the dollars.

Comment on this

The point I want to have clarified is: if acceptance of Marshall Aid would be opposed to the policy of the present Government, why was not the £26,000,000 which we left in the kitty paid back directly so as to lighten the total indebtedness of £45,000,000 to the United States?

Comment on this

The $128,000,000 were spent. If we had had when we came into office last June, instead of a debt due by the Minister for Finance to himself of £26,000,000, half the $128,000,000, I can assure the Deputy these dollars would have been spent in a different way. In one year we spent, I think, $30,000,000 on importing wheat and maize, most of it to drown the British in eggs in accordance with the promise made by the former Minister for Agriculture.

Comment on this

But why not have repaid the £26,000,000 that were there if it was wrong to spend them? I take it the present Government has spent most of that money, has it not? I am seeking information and I am not seeking it in a contentious way.

Comment on this

Deputy Blowick can be asked in a non-contentious way, as he is a knowledgeable man, to tell me where we could have got the dollars for the £26,000,000.

Comment on this

Surely Washington would have facilitated the Government if the Government was anxious to discharge its liability. I do not think the Minister can get out of it that easily.

Comment on this

Deputy Blowick will have to listen to me almost as patiently as I listened to other people. As a nation, we will pay back the United States of America dollars for the $128,000,000 that they lent us, dollars which were spent in importing maize, wheat and other commodities from the United States.

Comment on this
Brendan Corish Breanndán Mac Fheórais Labour Party

Would the Minister permit me to ask him a question? How much is provided in the present Estimates for the repayment of Marshall Aid.

Comment on this

The first moiety.

Comment on this
Brendan Corish Breanndán Mac Fheórais Labour Party

How much is that?

Comment on this

The Deputy can see that in the Minister's Budget speech.

Comment on this
Brendan Corish Breanndán Mac Fheórais Labour Party

Would it be £600,000?

Comment on this

The Deputy can see the figure in the Budget speech. The figure has already been given. This particular Budget was not unforeseen two or three years ago by the men in Fine Gael and in the Labour Party who knew something about finance. Deputy McGilligan, the then Minister for Finance, and I had an argument across the floor of the House on the capital expenditure and the items in the Estimates for the Supply Services, and he admitted to me that if this extraordinary capital expenditure did not result in a very high increase in production so that repayments could be taken in our stride, it would be a bit of a headache, as he put it, for some Minister for Finance; it certainly is a bit of a headache for the present Minister for Finance.

Comment on this

And for the Irish people.

Comment on this