We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Committee on Finance. - Resolution No. 11—General (Resumed).

Contributions 180–374 of 374. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

What money?

Comment on this

Deputy Rooney should learn about that when he has to pay for it by increased taxation. He should know that the repayment of one portion of the Marshall Aid borrowing alone is now going to cost us approximately £45,000,000.

Comment on this

You spent it yourself.

Comment on this

That may not be very palatable information for Deputy Rooney. He and his pals, when they were members of the Government, raised that money.

When the £ was devalued, they told the people that devaluation would make no difference. We had Deputy Dillon, when he was Minister for Agriculture, proclaiming that it would not affect the price of foodstuffs and that the price of maize would not go beyond £1 per cwt. We had Deputy McGilligan, when Minister for Finance, assuring the people in a broadcast over Radio Éireann that the devaluation of sterling meant nothing, and would have no effect on this nation. But we now find, particularly when we read the lines of the agreement which the boys signed with the American Government, that the Marshall Aid borrowing will have to be repaid in the lawful coin of the United States, in dollars, and that we will have to buy these dollars with sterling to pay back the money borrowed by the gentlemen over there.

Comment on this

On a point of order. It has been arranged, in order to facilitate business, that the Minister for Finance will be allowed in at 8 o'clock to reply. I suggest that Deputy Moran is wasting time to keep Opposition speakers from getting in before the Minister for Finance. I suggest that is contrary to the spirit in which the agreement was entered into.

Comment on this

I suggest that is not a point of order. Deputy Mulcahy comes in belatedly at this hour of the night, having been missing when Deputy Oliver Flanagan and other speakers were wasting time during the last three or four hours. If Deputy Mulcahy was not prepared to come in and listen to Deputy Oliver Flanagan, I am not going to blame him for that, but at least he should have got someone to tell him what was happening in the House. I was saying when interrupted —evidently Deputy Mulcahy did not like to hear it—that the gentlemen opposite had assured the people of this nation that the devaluation of the £ would not have any effect on sterling. We now find that we will require £45,000,000 to buy dollars to enable us to pay back the debts which those people incurred. We have got to pay those debts because the money was borrowed in the name of the nation.

Notwithstanding all the invitations which have been addressed to some of the responsible Deputies in the Fine Gael Party to say where they would find the money to meet this bill which the Government and the taxpayers have got to meet, there has not been one word or suggestion from Deputy Costello, Deputy Mulcahy or any of the leaders of the Opposition as to what they would do if they were faced with this position or as to how this money can be found. There has been a very strange quietness on the part of the Opposition to give a statement on this matter in answer to the questions which have been addressed to them by some of the Independent Deputies. Why are Deputy Costello and Deputy Mulcahy so backward in coming forward on this issue? Why have they kept so silent on whether they would, or would not, abolish the food subsidies if this House were dissolved to-night and they came back as the Government? Why have they been so slow to give a lead to Deputy McQuillan and other Deputies, and to answer these six-mark questions? Is it because they know quite well that this position has to be faced, that it is of their creation and that somebody must now pay the piper for the debts created by the Coalition Government? Is it not because they cannot make up their minds?

Comment on this

They are not anxious to get back by depending on Deputy Dr. Browne.

Comment on this

You depended on Deputy Dr. Browne for a long time.

Comment on this

On a point of order. It was agreed that the Minister for Finance would be allowed in at 8 o'clock to-night and that there would be a fair division of the time for the discussion of this matter. I want to ask again whether any Opposition speaker is going to be allowed to get into this discussion before the Minister for Finance rises at 8 o'clock. I suggest that Deputy Moran has been repetitiously irrelevant for the purpose of wasting time.

Comment on this
Seán Moylan Minister for Education (Mr. Moylan) Fianna Fáil

Deputy Mulcahy should be aware that, before Deputy Moran rose to speak, two members of Fine Gael had spoken. Let us have equal values.

Comment on this

I want to ask the Minister are we going to be put in the position that Deputy Moran is to take up all the time until 8 o'clock?

Comment on this

The Deputy has something to say and there is no reason, I think, why he should not say it.

Comment on this

Is Deputy Moran to be the first speaker in five weeks on the Government side of the House who will not be allowed to speak?

Comment on this

That seems to be the issue.

Comment on this

I did not get a chance of speaking yet.

Comment on this

The House came to an agreement and made an order that the Minister for Finance would be allowed in at 8 o'clock.

Comment on this

We can have a vote on this at 8 o'clock.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Chair has no power to curtail any Deputy when speaking in a debate. Even though agreements may be arrived at outside the House, the Chair cannot take cognisance of them and cannot direct a Deputy to cease speaking.

Comment on this

This was not an agreement that was arrived at outside the House. It was an order made by the House, and it was accepted in the spirit that there would be a fair running of the debate. I suggest that it is an unfair running of the debate for Deputy Moran and the Government Party to squeeze out Opposition speakers up to 8 o'clock when the Minister for Finance is to rise to reply.

Comment on this

Is that a point of order?

Comment on this

We can ask for extra time.

Comment on this

I want again to point out that Deputy Mulcahy was not in this House and was not aware of all the time that was taken up by Deputies on his own benches sitting behind him. They took up the time of this House for the past three hours until I started speaking. There were two or three Deputies called in succession from the opposite benches by the Chair. I can understand Deputy Mulcahy being in disagreement on this issue with the other members of his Party because it is in the air as far as his Party is concerned. It may be that they are trying to settle whether Deputy Costello or Deputy MacEoin is going to be the presidential candidate. I suggest that they should call in Deputy Burke to settle the matter.

Comment on this

I think this is totally irrelevant and is for the purpose of wasting time.

Comment on this

Deputy Mulcahy has wasted more time in this House than any other ten Deputies.

Comment on this

Since you go as far as that, how is it that the Minister for Finance was not here to hear any speech made by even the members of his own Party? Let us be fair. One cannot listen to that kind of thing.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Moran will address himself to the motion.

Comment on this

I shall address myself to the motion so long as I am allowed to do so. There seems to be a deliberate attempt being made in this House to stop me speaking, and I have no intention of succumbing to these tactics. I suggest, Sir, that if the Fine Gael Minister in the inter-Party Government had a free hand, if he were allowed to do what he thought fit the possibility is that we would not have to face this particular bill here and now. But he found—as all the Fine Gael Party found after the last election—that he was not a free agent. They found they were in the hands of vested interests and dare not go ahead with the taxation they knew to be necessary. They found they were tied —as that Party has been over a great number of years—to the strings of the licensed trade. They found that they dare not, irrespective of whether they thought it was necessary in the interests of the nation or of good finance, tax, beer and tobacco. They found that they would not be allowed to do it, even if they thought it was necessary. Being in that situation, they had to try to tide themselves over the period they were in office and they had to try to do that through the types of Budget they introduced. They tried to avail of all the borrowing they could avail of.

This bill has been left to us and the Government has got to face up to it. It is difficult for us to have to impose this taxation. We do not like doing it but we know that the only right policy is to take the people into our confidence and to point out to them that this bill is there. We must meet it and the only honest way to do that is to face up to our responsibilities. As the people have found us to be honest with them in our dealings with them before, I have no doubt the public will realise the situation that has been left to us by our predecessors. I have no doubt that nationalist Ireland will stand behind us in connection with these matters. The people know that we have to clear up these legacies left to us by the Opposition. We propose to clean them up so that we will get the country back on that solid keel it was on before the gentlemen of the Opposition got into power.

Comment on this

I realise how difficult it will be for some of us to speak in the time allotted. The Minister for Finance is supposed to come in at 8 o'clock. I say that the Leaders of the Opposition Parties should not have given the Minister that concession as he did not deserve it. We are handicapped now. There are many items of interest upon which we would like to speak, but since I want to give every man a chance. I will be as brief as possible on the subject of this very important Budget. There was much discussion about this Budget and we got many lectures from the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs, Deputy Briscoe and others. They have condemned the inter-Party Government for the policy they operated for three and a half years and have pointed out the terrible fallacy of their policy. They tell us that there is danger of inflation.

I wonder did the Chancellor of the British Exchequer tell our Minister for Finance, when they had their little secret pow-wow, that in the financial year 1938-39, before the disaster of the Second World War came upon us, the national debt in Great Britain was £8,136,000,000? Did he tell our own dearly beloved little Minister for Finance that the increase in the British national debt in that year alone amounted to £137,000,000 and that a Bill was brought before the House of Commons asking that, under the Defence Loans Act, the amount for borrowing purposes be increased from £400,000,000 to £800,000,000? Did he tell him that in 1939 £250,000 per day was spent on the provision of aircraft? If he did, did he tell Deputy MacEntee, the Minister for Finance, that almost all that was got through borrowing? We are condemned for borrowing. Great Britain borrowed to win a war. She found it in her own interests and in the interests of the people of Great Britain to borrow huge amounts during that period for defence purposes and otherwise. Yet we are condemned by a Fianna Fáil Administration who tell us they are ultra-republican in outlook. We are condemned when we say we are willing to borrow for the purpose of building houses for our people.

The present Minister for Finance stated that unless he could borrow upwards of £28,000,000 from our people housing was going to be retarded and that hospitalization was going to be retarded. No member of Fianna Fáil can contradict that. Speakers in the Opposition have said—I believe they were justified in saying it—that the policy of the Government is one of full agreement with the British policy of finance as against a policy of financial friendship with the United States of America. It is no use for them to deny it. Some of their back-benchers admitted during the course of this debate that there may be a danger in getting money from America; we may be sold out economically. If any man in this country is selling our full indepdence from an economic and financial point of view, it is the Minister for Finance.

If they object to borrowing, if they object to a system of capital budgeting, it means, as we have proof already, an increase in unemployment. This time last year, the number on the unemployed list went down. This year, unfortunately, each week the number has increased. That is not a matter that I want to gloat over. It is something that I am sincerely sorry about. What will we do to remedy that position? Do we believe in capital investment or are we satisfied to continue a policy which will allow the financiers to gloat over the quotations of stock market prices in London and New York in the morning papers? Are we satisfied that Irish money is to be invested in foreign places? Are we satisfied to allow the financial system which has dominated our economic life for years to operate? Are we satisfied with a system whereby local authorities will have to pay more in bank interest?

I have mentioned but a few points. I will curtail my speech to allow other Deputies to speak. There is an extraordinary degree of similarity between the policy as advocated by the Minister and the Government and the words of a famous statesman. I leave the House to judge. At a period when the British Government were talking about raising huge loans for defence, a famous person said, on 21st February, 1939:—

"This is no time for financial pedantry."

He went further and said:—

"This massive loan bill had added to confidence at home and was a factor on the side of stability abroad."

He concluded by saying that the Prime Minister had only to ask for whatever was necessary. That famous individual—famous, at least, from the viewpoint of the British people—Churchill —said that the Prime Minister had only to ask for whatever was necessary.

At that stage the British financial policy was based on borrowing, to finance a war. Now, because the Chancellor of the British Exchequer has told our Minister for Finance that we should not borrow, that we should adopt a policy which will bring us into a period of deflation, our Minister and our Government have accepted that policy.

Deputy Corry mentioned one particular matter. He was entitled to do so. He was sitting beside the Minister for Finance and the Minister gloated over the words of Deputy Corry. Deputy Corry drew attention to the letters which were sent to local authorities dealing with increases for staffs. Deputy Corry said that that meant robbing this country, as it were, by giving increased allowances. I would like to have it recorded in this House now that neither Deputy Corry nor any member of the Fianna Fáil Party on the Cork County Council objected to the request for increases in salaries at that time. I give them credit for supporting the increases. We believed that these staffs were entitled to an increase. But, considerual—famous ing that neither Deputy Corry nor any of his Party opposed those increases, is it not right to draw attention to the hypocrisy of condemning something now with which, 12 months ago, Deputy Corry agreed completely?

It is said that we are living beyond our means. It is said that the removal of the subsidies means an increase of only 1/6 in the cost of living. I wonder does the Minister for Finance still maintain that it means an increase of only 1/6. I am sorry that he is not here. If he does so maintain, then another prominent member of the present Government must be wrong, because the Minister for Agriculture has admitted that, on a request from the Agricultural Wages Board, he is giving the farmer an allowance of 4d. a day, which means 2/4 a week in the case of an indoor man, out of the recent increase for farm workers. If the cost of living has increased by 2/4 a week to the farmer, the producer, then the Minister for Finance knows that his 1/6 is not correct, or, if he believes it is correct, he had better consult the Minister for Agriculture and find out which of them is right or wrong.

I could expect nothing better from the Minister for Finance. There are decent men in his Party but, when a Party is controlled by a junta and when you have a Minister for Finance who had the audacity to offer 2d. a day to the honest road workers of County Cork, it is only natural to believe that he has no respect or regard for the workers. Perhaps he is more in line with the gentry, with the people who may be living beyond their means and who found pleasure in being at Punchestown for the last couple of days.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Chair understands that the Minister is to be called on at 8 o'clock to conclude the debate.

Comment on this

He can listen to two minutes' talk, anyway.

Comment on this

I have listened a long time. It is 8 o'clock.

Comment on this

Another two minutes will not do you much harm.

Comment on this

It will not do me much harm. Deputies had better toss up for it.

Comment on this

There is very little time for me to contribute to this debate. I have listened very carefully to the speeches made by members of the Government and by the leading lights in the Opposition. The speeches made by the Opposition were very convincing and I feel that the speeches made by the members of the Government Party exaggerated the position. It has always been noticeable that the Fianna Fáil Party have tried to make the Irish people believe down through the years that they and they alone are capable of running this country rightly and properly.

Comment on this

I think the hour has come. I do not want to be discourteous, but it is now 8 o'clock and we still have a great deal of business to transact before the night ends. It was an order of the House that I should rise to conclude at 8 o'clock and perhaps Deputy O'Hara will permit me on this occasion.

Comment on this

In conclusion, I want to put on the records of this House an expression of my most emphatic protest against this attempted imposition on the part of the Fianna Fáil Government.

Comment on this

The Budget on which the debate is now concluding has been criticised mainly on two grounds. The first is that it is unduly severe, and the second, that it is lacking in imagination. Let me deal with the second of these first. In an attempt to distinguish between the real and the imaginative, a philosopher has said: "Our simple apprehension of corporeal objects, if present, is sense; if absent, is imagination." Am I, in framing the Budget for the nation, to exercise my imagination and to deceive myself and the country with the idle fancy that our liquidated assets, the assets which the Coalition squandered, are still in our possession? That is an exercise to which the imaginative ex-Minister for Agriculture has devoted himself in recent days. Am I to visualise as real things the plant and capital equipment upon which the Coalition pretend they spent the £46,000,000 of Marshall Aid?

A poem or a play requires imagination in an exceptional degree, but a Budget, let me remind the gentlemen opposite, is neither of these. It is a business document which embodies proposals relating solely to an important business, the business of calculating what the State is likely to have to spend and of devising ways and means for meeting that expenditure. That is a job not for the over-imaginative person, because, as we have been told by the poet:—

"The lunatic, the lover and the poet Are of imagination all compact."

When we think of the three years of Coalition Government, we may well suppose that a triumvirate of that kind had the destinies of this country in its hands over that period.

The framing of a Budget is a job which requires, in the first place, that whoever should attempt it will have a firm grip on essentials, will have a realistic appreciation of what his proposals involve, what their effects are likely to be on trade and employment and last, but naturally with politicians by no means least, the reaction of the ordinary man in the street to them. The framing of a Budget therefore, is not a job for a visionary, nor for a man supercharged with imagination, nor for one who thinks that he can, by some monetary miracle, transform this harsh old world into an earthly paradise. It is a job primarily for a competent man of business, endowed by Providence with some commonsense and fortfited by comprehensive experience and close study of public affairs. I do not claim to meet my own specifications fully under any one of these heads. All I can claim is that I approach the difficult task which I have inherited with a full appreciation of its difficulties and its dangers, but with a determination, shared fully by my colleagues, to discharge it honestly. As a Government, we shall fulfil the duty which rests on men and Governments alike to meet all our obligations and to pay our way.

Now, as to the alleged harshness of the Budget, we in this Government and those who support us on these benches are no mere neophytes in politics. We know how unpopular the measures which we propose may be; but we also know how essential they are, if the independence, the political and economical independence of this State and the peace and wellbeing of its people, are to be assured. When we talk of people, we mean the decent, hard-working, selfrespecting men and women of Ireland, the people whose devoted loyalty and support, in good days and in bad, made this part of Ireland free. They won that freedom; it is necessary for us to take the unpalatable but the wholly necessary steps which will enable them, under Heaven, to keep it.

This Budget, we are told, is unduly burdensome. Will those who say that answer me one question? Will they tell me why I, who depend and always have depended for my seat in this Dáil mainly on the wage earners and white collars of my constituency, on the people with the smaller incomes in it, should impose unnecessary burdens upon them? They have been my friends, my supporters, for almost 30 years? Why should I be so foolish, so wrongheaded, as to tax them more heavily than the dire need of the time requires? Sooner or later, within four short years or so at the most, I shall have to go before them again and ask them to re-elect me, to judge me on what I have done. I know the Budget is not popular—no taxation ever is. I know that my intimate association with it will constitute a very heavy handicap for me personally. I accept that handicap because my duty to the people and the nation requires it but why should I increase it, why should I commit political suicide by taxing the people unnecessarily? Not even the imaginative Deputies opposite can think of an answer to that question; not even they, with all their powers of invention, can fabricate a plausible one. They know well, as every man and woman in the country knows, that it would be absurd for me to do as they are alleging, that it would be the peak and zenith of political folly.

Their allegation, therefore, that we are taxing the people unduly sounds so hollow even in their own ears that they set themselves to concoct a series of faked figures to support it. I use the word "faked" advisedly, because Deputy McGilligan himself told us why the figures were faked and how the whole plan of the Fine Gael attack upon this Budget was concocted. Speaking on Tuesday evening in this debate, my immediate predecessor as Minister for Finance gave the game away on his own Leader and his own Party, when he disclosed that Deputy J.A. Costello's figures were worked out—and these are his own words—

"not by people who thought they had discovered an overestimate here and there, but by people who considered the reasoning that was in the back of the Budget, that the scheme was to balance for a surplus and then this surplus had to be hidden and shown as a deficit."

I interrupted Deputy McGilligan at this point to say:—

"That is not very fair to Deputy Costello."

Then came back the surprising rejoinder from Deputy McGilligan:—

"It explains how he arrived at those figures, and it is an explanation that he will accept from me, because I know it to be the correct explanation."

I do not know why Deputy McGilligan should have spilled out the whole bag of beans on his colleague in this way— and in any event, the Deputy's motive is not of much importance. What is important, however, is Deputy McGilligan's disclosure that the figures, which Deputy Costello, with such an air of authority, has put before the Dáil and the people, were deliberately faked in order to support a thesis, the thesis that we are budgeting for a surplus. There is no truth in that suggestion. We are not budgeting for a surplus. Neither, however, are we budgeting for a deficit. We are budgeting for a balance.

Comment on this

Will the Minister answer the question on the figures put before him?

Comment on this

Our ambitions this year do not go beyond the lowest possible target that will make ends meet. We cannot in honesty and in prudence aim at less than that.

Comment on this

Will the Minister challenge the faked figures?

Comment on this

The Fine Gael Opposition——

Comment on this

Definite figures have been put before the Minister and he has been asked, as being responsible to this House, to answer the questions that have been put to him.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Minister is in possession and should be allowed to proceed.

Comment on this

The questions raised cannot be suppressed in that way.

Comment on this

The Deputy will have another opportunity, I hope.

Comment on this

This is the Minister's opportunity and he ought to take advantage of it.

Comment on this

Is the Minister going to be allowed to make his speech?

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Minister, without interruption.

Comment on this

I was saying, Sir, that we have been condemned, that there would seem to be something wrong about this idea of a surplus. But the Fine Gael Opposition, in the course of this debate have been loud in their praise of a Chancellor who is budgeting for a surplus and of his predecessors who budgeted for surpluses. They have been loud in laudations of Mr. Butler, because Mr. Butler did certain things. Why was he able to do them? Because Mr. Butler's predecessor in the Socialist Government had budgeted for a surplus and had left him a surplus of no less than £500,000,000.

Comment on this

And who praised him?

Comment on this

I am not in that position. I am not following in the footsteps of Mr. Gaitskell. I have told the Dáil that I am aiming at the lowest possible target, the target which will just enable us to make ends meet. The Fine Gael Opposition, while they have praised British Chancellors, present and past, for budgeting for a surplus on current revenue, think that our people would regard a surplus as in some way reprehensible and so they have been making the allegation that we are budgeting for a surplus and then set themselves to concoct the evidence to support it.

That is the first thing that Deputy McGilligan wishes us to understand; that is the first disclosure that Deputy McGilligan has made in the course of his speech on this Budget. The next thing is—and it is perhaps no less important than the first—is the fact that he disclaims any responsibility, this ex-Minister for Finance disclaims any responsibility, for the figures which Deputy J.A. Costello has produced.

Now, with this knowledge at our disposal, let us consider the case made by the Leader of the Opposition. Never was an elementary knowledge of simple arithmetic put to such poor use as it has been put by the Leader of the Opposition and those like him who have been fumbling with figures and stumbling over statistics in the course of this debate. The performance of the Fine Gael Deputies in this discussion has been so absurd that it has provoked even some of their usual allies and normal supporters to confute them. The Leader of the Opposition made the case that the Estimates on which the Budget is framed are gravely in error. He spent hours of parliamentary time in a fantastic endeavour to prove that. He has been followed on the same lines by all the Fine Gael speakers, except the ex-Minister for Finance, Deputy McGilligan. Even that eminent backwoodsman of the Party, Deputy McMenamin, has been moved to break his long years of silence and to write a letter to the papers repeating what his Leader has said.

That, however, was not the line taken by Deputy Larkin. He did not challenge the Estimates, though he is much more competent, as most people will admit, to deal with these matters than Deputy Costello has shown himself to be. Implicit throughout, Deputy Larkin's speech was the acceptance of the cold fact that additional taxation and heavy additional taxation is necessary if the Budget is to be balanced. He admitted frankly and unreservedly that "quite clearly, if we are going to have certain standards of social services, the money must be found to pay for them." That is precisely the principle on which this Budget is based. It is not because of the fact that the Budget involves increased taxation that Deputy Larkin criticises it but only that it does not provide for the sort of taxation that appeals to him. But then Deputy Larkin's concept of taxation is very much like expropriation. He thinks that the primary use of the taxing power should be to penalise the better-off, to punish people for earning too much; and the alternative forms of taxation which he suggested in his speech are all designed to that end. However, whatever be the kind of taxes Deputy Larkin would impose, he did not follow Deputy Costello in the line which the latter took, for he recognised that it is necessary to raise a great deal of additional revenue. The acceptance of this fact is implicit also in the document which was issued by the Irish Trade Union Congress last week.

When the Leader of the Opposition opened his attack on the Budget proposals he alleged that they were based on misleading estimates of expenditure and of revenue. He made specific charges in this regard and purported to substantiate each and every one of them by open calculations. Deputy McGilligan has told us how these calculations were made and what reliance is to be placed on them.

They have been shown to have been specious and misleading but it has remained for the Irish Trade Union Congress to pass final and crushing judgment upon them. In the document to which I have referred and, beyond any doubt with the allegations of Deputy Costello in mind, the Irish Trade Union Congress says:—

"Firstly, it is necessary to discover whether or not the figure of £15,000,000 constitutes the gap in the current Budget. We do not doubt for a moment, despite suggestions to the contrary, that the various Estimates both of revenue and expenditure were made as accurately as forecasting of this nature would allow."

"We do not doubt" retorts the Irish Trades Union Congress to Deputy Costello, Deputy Morrissey, Deputy Mulcahy and the lesser fry in Fine Gael. "We do not doubt for a moment... that the various Estimates both of revenue and expenditure were made as accurately as forecasting of this nature would allow."

That statement is, in itself, a sufficient and convincing rebuttal of Deputy Costello's charges and I should leave the matter at that but for the fact that I think the public interest will be served if some further consideration be given to such of the Deputy's assertions as have not yet been fully exposed to the House. I do not propose to go over in great detail the ground which has already been covered. I do not intend to embarrass the Leader of the Opposition by demonstrating again how wrong was the method of calculation by which he endeavoured to support his charge that the savings on food subsidies had been underestimated. The Taoiseach, the Tánaiste and the Minister for Health have refuted that allegation.

Comment on this

Utter nonsense.

Comment on this

10 per cent. out.

Comment on this

I must, however, refer to Deputy Costello's endeavours to mislead the public in regard to the provision which is made in the Budget to cover the estimated cost in this year of the Social Welfare Bill. In that connection it is relevant to recall that it was just about this time last year that, according to column 748, Volume 125 of the Official Report, Deputy J. A. Costello, then Taoiseach, confessed to Dáil Éireann that he had informed representatives of the medical profession that "it was obligatory as a matter of law... to have a free service for mothers and children under Part III of the Health Act", while he himself, after a study of the Act, had come-and here I quote again the Deputy's own words—"to the conclusion that there was no binding obligation on this Government or any other Government to have a free scheme or this free for all and no means test".

With that fact—I do not want to reopen the controversy—with that admission from Deputy Costello firmly fixed in our minds, let us consider his performance in this debate. If we turn to columns 1273 and 1274, Volume 130 of the current Official Debates, we shall see for ourselves how clearly the Deputy's speech paralleled his disingenuous statements to the doctors. In column 1273 the Leader of the Opposition is reported as follows:—

"I pass to the third item, which amounts to a sum of £1,000,000. Again I point out that in the ‘Table Explanatory of the Budget, 1952', item 4, the provision for proposals in the Social Welfare (Insurance) Bill, 1951, is stated to be a sum of £3,000,000."

That statement in itself is a falsification of the actual printed text of the Table Explanatory of the Budget which the Leader of the Opposition had before him when he was making his speech. In relation to item 4 of that Table the actual text reads:—

"Add:

Provision for proposals in Social Welfare (Insurance) Bill, 1951, and for other current services... £3,000,000."

"And for other current services." These are the significant words which, as the Taoiseach pointed out in his masterly speech last week, Deputy J.A. Costello carefully omitted to utter——

Comment on this

The Taoiseach will make a bow.

Comment on this

——though they were before him plain for his eyes to see and for his tongue to speak if he wished to be honest and truthful with the House and with the country. These are the words which he dropped from their context in order to bolster up his allegation that I have overstated by £1,000,000 the amount actually required for social services.

Yet Deputy J.A. Costello has the hardihood to suggest that the figures in the Budget have been falsified.

Let me consider this item 4 further and explain the basis of it to the Dáil. It is intended, as I have said, to provide for the cost in this year of the new social welfare benefits when they become effective and for other contingencies on current services which will undoubtedly arise. With regard to the new social welfare benefits, these, as the Minister for Health has stated, will cost something under £2,000,000. Let us take the cost at about £1,900,000. That will leave £1,100,000 or perhaps something more to cover other expenditure.

Comment on this

Very adequate.

Comment on this

In his Budget last year Deputy Costello's Minister for Finance, Deputy McGilligan, included £1,500,000 for the same purpose. The Deputy's £1,500,000 proved to be much too little, however, for the actual current expenditure unprovided for in the Budget came to over four times that figure at £6.8 million which is more than six times what I have allowed for in this year's Budget.

Comment on this

Blatherskite.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Dillon should cease interrupting and allow the Minister to proceed.

Comment on this

On a point of order, when the Minister states categorically that something is true which is not true, may not a modest remonstrance be uttered?

Comment on this

Nobody would ever associate the quality of modesty with the Deputy.

Comment on this

It has succeeded in directing attention to your misrepresentations.

Comment on this

I was saying that the deficit last year was £6.8 million which was more than six times——

Comment on this

Get your arithmetic right.

Comment on this

——four times——

Comment on this

That is right.

Comment on this

——what was provided for. In the previous year the provision which my predecessor made under the heading "Increases in Supply Services" was only £600,000 but the actual excess of expenditure over the original Estimate was £1.44 million which is again more than I have allowed for this year.

In his Budget for 1949-50, Deputy McGilligan, with a pretence at nice and precise calculation, allowed £676,000—it was not £675,000 nor £677,000—to cover unforeseen increases in Supply expenditure; but the total amount required to meet these increases was, in fact, almost six times as much at £3.8 million. Now the Deputy will see where the six came in instead of the four.

If we take the last three Budgets of our predecessors on the average, the amount overspent annually on current services was £4,000,000. Thus if past experience is to be a ground for criticism of the provision made for supply service contingencies and unforeseen, unavoidable expenditure, the criticism should be, not that I have budgeted for £1,000,000 too much but that I have budgeted for £3,000,000 too little. If the Leader of the Opposition has considered the matter at all, he must know that it is there the danger lies and not where he suggests.

Another criticism made by the Deputy is that I have failed to take any account of what he describes as "the traditional item known as overestimation. In column 1275 of Volume 130 of the Official Report, we may read his statement, that this item "has been taken into account by every Minister for Finance in connection with his Budget proposals. Experience has demonstrated over the years that there has never been less than a saving of £2,000,000 each year on departmental expenditure." Both these statements are demonstrably untrue, and I propose to show that. Let us take the first—the Deputy's statement that every year since the establishment of the State provision has been made for overestimation.

Comment on this

I did not say "provision has been made". You are misquoting me.

Comment on this

Has been taken into account by every Minister for Finance in connection with his Budget proposals. I have here the Tables issued with the last three Coalition Budgets, those for 1949-50, for 1950-51 and for 1951-52. In not one of them—and surely Deputy Costello must have been familiar with them—must have refreshed his memory by studying them before he made his speech—is there any reference made to possible overestimation or any allowance made for it. On the contrary, so far from allowances being made for overestimation, in all these Coalition Budgets allowances were made for underestimation. Not only that, but even the allowances made for this contingency in them from year to year was much too small for that purpose. In the three Budgets to which I have referred, the allowance to cover underestimation—not overestimation as Deputy Costello has stated—averaged £925,000 per year, whereas the overspending on the Supply Services over the same period averaged £4,000,000 per year.

The Leader of the Opposition when he was making this speech was very emphatic in the manner in which he levelled these accusations at me. He thumped his desk. He may thump his desk again in his mock forensic fury and may declare "that there has never been less than a saving of £2,000,000 each year on departmental expenditure," but the truth, and that is what we are out to get in this discussion, is, in fact, the other way round. The Leader of the Opposition in that one statement has been guilty of a statistical inexactitude to the extent of £6,000,000 a year.

Comment on this

That is new.

Comment on this

The next charge made by Deputy J.A. Costello is that the probable charge for the service of the Public Debt has been overestimated by £500,000. It is typical of the woolly outlook of the Opposition on these matters that its Leader makes no attempt whatever to back up his allegations with the relevant figures. He makes a reference in col. 1276 to the first interest payment due on the Marshall Aid loan but he slurs over the fact that in my Budget statement on the day before he spoke I had stated that, even after making provision for the ordinary public services I had still to find a further £35,000,000 to finance prospective capital expenditure. Details of the purposes for which this sum is required were given fully by me and may be found in cols. 1150 and 1151 of the current Parliamentary Report.

Comment on this

The Minister intends to borrow it.

Comment on this

They were also set out in full in the typescript copy of the Budget speech which Deputy Costello had in his possession. One might think that the Deputy did not grasp the significance of the figures, but that might be a charitable view. On the other hand, I think we all agree that it would be to rate the intelligence of the Leader of the Opposition much too low. He understood and appreciated their significance fully; but he wanted to mislead the public on this matter and so we find him, according to col. 1276, telling the people:—

"No explanation has been given of that increased figure for interest on the public debt. We have had no loan. There is only hope of a loan."

But there is going to be a loan, if the Opposition will permit it. I pass over the importance which a psycho-analyst might attach to Deputy Costello's use of the word "hope," in this context. The word "hope," as he uses it, suggests the over-optimistic and always importunate borrower, and the basis of Deputy Costello's Coalition was improvident and lavish borrowing.

That is not how I approach the question. For Deputy Costello's word "hope" I substitute the word "need". I say we need this loan in order to ensure that the programme of electrical development will not be interrupted, that the credit of the country will not be damaged by the Electricity Supply Board having to seek relief from its commitments to its suppliers. I say that we need it in order to ensure Bord na Móna against the same contingency and to enable that organisation to go ahead with its programme of turf development. I say that we need this loan in order to ensure that our housing activities will not be impeded.

I would rather that our need for it was not so great, that we were in a position to provide to a larger extent out of current revenue for the more speculative and less reproductive and remunerative, in a financial sense, elements in all these projects. That was our policy when we were previously in office. It was a policy which enabled us to leave behind to our successors a fair inheritance in a State free from external debt, in pawn to no man, and with its public credit standing the highest in Europe.

We should build the future of this country on a much solider and surer basis if it were possible to revert to that policy now. But in present circumstances it is not possible to do so. The public finances have been reduced to such a state of confusion by the maladministration of our predecessors that the utmost we can do now is to make the barest provision possible to meet current and recurring expenditure out of revenue and to borrow for the rest, to borrow for the rest to the full extent of the public's capacity to lend.

The need for a new loan, therefore, is not, as Deputy Costello thinks of it, "only a hope"; it is a certainty, an inevitable, unavoidable, undesirable certainty. And because we know it is a certainty, we have made provision to meet our obligations in regard to it. That, of course, is the honest and prudent thing to do, but apparently the Leader of the Opposition takes the view that we should not have done it.

Comment on this

You are bound to do it by the 1950 Finance Act.

Comment on this

He appears to hold that the State should propose to contract obligations, but has no need to budget to meet them, hoping, like Mr. Micawber, that something would turn up.

Comment on this

You are bound to do it by the 1950 Finance Act.

Comment on this

But Fianna Fáil was not put into office to make the Coalition mess worse, but to clean it up; and, therefore, this Budget is framed on the basis that our obligations must be honoured as they arise.

But the new loan is not the only item in respect of which we shall have obligations. Last year, as I pointed out in the Budget statement—the reference will be found in column 1131—the State had to borrow over £35,000,000—exclusive of the Budget deficit of £6.8 million. Of this sum, £9.7 million was for what Deputy Costello and his Coalition colleagues described as voted "capital services"—including Deputy Dillon's day-old chicks—those extraordinary birds for which the country will be paying on an annuity basis for the next 30 years. Let me say a word about these chicks because it throws a search-light upon the loose idea that pervaded the position in regard to what was capital expenditure. These day-old chicks cost, I am told, about 30/- per dozen, yet the finances of the Coalition had become so over-strained that Deputy McGilligan could not pay that for them on the nail but had to borrow the cash and repay his borrowing, by an annuity spread over 30 years, and the country will continue to repay his borrowing for those day-old chicks for that period.

Comment on this

Blatherskite!

Comment on this

No doubt many of Deputy Dillon's chicks were eaten by rats or vermin; many of them never laid an egg but for the next 30 years we shall be paying for them all the same.

Comment on this

Does your colleague, the Minister for Agriculture, endorse that?

Comment on this

This was done under what Deputy Costello described as his Capital Budget.

Comment on this

That is absolutely untrue.

Comment on this

In addition to this £9.75 million for voted "Capital" services the Government had to find £8.8 million for the Electricity Supply Board; £9.12 million for the Local Loans Fund; £2.6 million for Telephone Capital Development; £1.26 million for Turf Development; £0.48 million for interest on Córas Iompair Éireann Stocks.

Comment on this

And £3,000,000 for Deputy Briscoe's coal.

Comment on this

£0.88 million for Stocks; £2.13 million for redemption of National loans; and £6.68 to cover the deficit on the last Coalition Budget——

Comment on this

How many pounds a year for the day-old chicks?

Comment on this

——including £2.73 million to cover the arrears of fuel subsidy which the Coalition had permitted to accumulate ——

Comment on this

"Fuel subsidy" is a euphemism.

Comment on this

——and £1.82 million for last year's working losses on Córas Iompair Éireann. This made in all about £41.8 million, against which we were able to set certain repayments so as to leave a net borrowing of £41,000,000. Now this £41,000,000 odd was not, of course, all borrowed at once. It was raised in instalments from time to time as payments fell due and had to be met. By the end of June, that is, after the Coalition were elected, we had to borrow £6,000,000; at the end of July a further £5.56 million, and so on each month until the end of the financial year when, as I have said, the total net borrowings exceeded £41,000,000.

Comment on this

And you borrowed £24,000,000 in three months.

Comment on this

And every penny was raised to meet commitments which had been entered into before we took office. But, of course, in no case did interest on these separate borrowings run for a full year. The amount of interest chargeable last year in respect of Ways and Means advances depended not only on the amount of each advance but on the date upon which the money was obtained. In the case of the Ways and Means advances, taken in at the end of June, 1951, interest for six months was chargeable in the financial year 1951-52; in the case of money borrowed in the last quarter of the financial year nothing fell to be paid in that year. But in the year which is now running £30.1 million of that £41,000,000 will carry a full year's interest and the balance from nine to 11 months' interest. Are we to believe that the Leader of the Opposition, when planning his attack on the Budget, never thought of that? It is scarcely credible that he did not; but if he did not, what status has he as a critic at all?

It would take much too long to enumerate and deal with all the other factors which Deputy Costello ignored when he made the allegation that we have overestimated the amount required for the service of the Public Debt. Before I pass on, however, I will just mention one of them. Our predecessors, in 1950, initiated the procedure under which the expenditure on that part of the supply services which they classified as capital should be spread over 30 years on an annuity basis. I do not wish to deliver a long disquisition on the merits or demerits of that procedure; but I should point out that under it, where there was, say, an original expenditure of £20,000,000, the people will by taxation have to provide a total of £32,000,000 in respect of it. That is, at present interest rates.

On the other hand, since the difficulty of making full provision for those services which must be met out of current revenue is so great, and since the Government is anxious furthermore that the facts of the position should not be obscured by avoidable controversy as to the wisdom or propriety of the procedure initiated by our predecessors, we have decided this year to borrow for the same items in the supply services as they did.

Comment on this

Good man.

Comment on this

A very convincing alibi.

Comment on this

It is necessary, accordingly, to set up a corresponding annuity of £501,922, and this amount is, of course, included in the increased provision which we have to make in the current Budget for the service of public debt. I come now to the last ground on which the Leader of the Opposition attacks the Budget. His criticism is reported in column 1276, again of the current volume, as follows:—

"The Minister has made no provision—or if he has made any he has made inadequate provision for the buoyancy of the revenue."

I pass over the absurd conception, inherent in Deputy Costello's statement, of the revenue as something which with every year becomes more buoyant than in the year preceding, in order to deal factually with this manifest misstatement. The actual revenue collected in the financial year which closed last month was £83.9 million, which was £2,335,000 more than my predecessor had budgeted for. The taxes actually collected, however, included the accumulated arrears of taxes which ought to have been collected before the 31st March, 1951, but which due to the bank strike were not collected and paid into the Exchequer until after that date.

That is a non-recurring source of revenue. We cannot budget for another windfall like that this year, but nevertheless we are budgeting for a substantial increase and are taking the probable revenue for this year as £86.6 million. A simple subtraction, therefore, will show that in framing the Budget we have assumed that we will secure £2,700,000 more revenue than last year.

Comment on this

Why? National income has expanded.

Comment on this

Because we were anxious to take the best view we honestly could take of the position. Perhaps the ebullient Deputy would allow me to proceed?

Yet the Leader of the Opposition complains that I have made no provision for the buoyancy of the revenue, when the truth is that I have been optimistic enough to write-up the yield by £2.7 millions. They query which might indeed be raised is whether, taking world conditions as they are, such optimism is justified. It is the question which I have put to myself, the question which I am in duty bound to put to myself having regard to the sources from which our tax-revenue is obtained.

In this matter the Leader of the Opposition and his followers are in truth trying to have it every way. He and his Party tell us that a deflationary condition has set in, while at the same time they go out and tell the people we are underestimating revenue and they criticise us for not taking that highly optimistic view of the customs yield which only the admitted existence conditions would justify. Of course, in matters of this sort, we are not inspired prophets and we do not pretend—as apparently the Opposition do—that absolute accuracy in these matters is attainable by ordinary men.

The Leader of the Opposition may be in a position to foresee every event at home and abroad throughout the year which will react on the finances of the State, and may be able to assess those reactions in terms of pounds, shillings and pence. I make no such pretension. Instead, I state the simple truth that the estimate of revenue has been based on the best advice available to me, that it is the highest that on any rational grounds we should be justified in making, and that the danger is that in our anxiety to avoid imposing unnecessary taxation we have overestimated the yield. However, the Leader of the Opposition, without adducing a single authoritative calculation to prove his point, makes the assertion that we underestimated revenue and savings. And all up and down the country the Fine Gael chorus is quacking on the same note, like so many geese following a gander.

Comment on this

Pause for laughter from Fianna Fáil.

Comment on this

But on the other hand we have the emphatic statement of the Irish Trade Union Congress that they "do not doubt for a moment, despite suggestions to the contrary, that the various estimates, both of revenue and expenditure, were made as accurately as forecasting of this nature would allow". In so far as there can be any controversy as to the size of the gap between current revenue and expenditure which had to be bridged, I think that the view taken by the Trade Union Congress is the view that will be taken by all sensible men and women.

It being admitted, then, that the gap to be closed is of the order of £15.1 million, the duty of the Government and the responsibility of the Government is to close it. The question we put to ourselves and the question we had to solve was how was this to be done? Not even the Opposition, with all its predilection for borrowing, has suggested that we should borrow for it. On the contrary, the Leader of the Opposition, when referring to my assumption that it was common ground that the current Budget must be balanced, solemnly declared with his hand on his heart and his eyes turned to heaven:—

"To that principle we on this side of the House, in or out of government, have always subscribed."

So at least the Fine Gael Party and the Government are at one in their determination to balance the current Budget without recourse to borrowing. Borrowing being, therefore, by common agreement ruled out, what remains? What other course is there except to balance the Budget either by reducing expenditure or increasing taxation, or by an equitable combination of both courses?

Comment on this

Or correct the estimates.

Comment on this

Fake the estimates is what you did.

Naturally, before accepting the inevitability of increasing taxation the Government scrutinised all forms of expenditure which were chargeable against revenue. The one service which appeared by its very nature to call for examination and in which any appreciable saving might justifiably be secured was the provision for food subsidies. The attitude of the Government in regard to these subsidies has been a matter for some discussion in this debate. Perhaps I might add to what I have already said about them in my Budget statement. In that statement I examined in some detail the history and development of this service since it was first introduced during the Emergency period, when a Wages Stabilisation Order was in force. Just as the Wages Stabilisation Order was intended to be only a temporary expedient, so also was the system of food subsidies. The one was originally interlinked with the other; and both were, in the view of the Government, highly undesirable even while in the conditions then prevailing they were unavoidable.

Subsidies were introduced as a short-term expedient to deal with what was hoped would be a short-term problem. They were introduced with great hesitation as an experimental measure and with great doubt as to their over-all advantage. In the circumstances of the time the experiment had to be tried; it was worth while trying it, but it must nevertheless be conceded that it failed to achieve its original purpose. Experience of the subsidies in operation has shown up their many disadvantages. They are, as I have said, cumbersome, wasteful and expensive to administer and, so far as the majority of the taxpayers are concerned, they yield no over-all advantage.

They make rationing unavoidable and thereby tend to tie up consumers to their individual suppliers and because of the difficulty and inconvenience of retrieving ration books to leave them subject to their goodwill. They stifle competition and deprive consumers of the benefits of it; since there is no incentive to reduce costs, every increase, whether avoidable or not, can be passed on to the taxpayer. They facilitate the formation of trade rings and the development of restrictive trade practices. They foster the illusion that food is cheaper to the consumer than it really is, since the subsidy which now pays a great part of the food's true cost is provided by the consumer himself as a taxpayer. Thus, in order to continue to sell bread, tea and butter at their present prices over the whole year, to pretend—for that is what it comes to—that these things cost the consumer very much less than, in fact, they do, we should require to raise in taxation from the general body of consumers no less than £15,240,000 nett. And then, while raising it we are busily engaged in giving most of it back again.

On a rough computation, which I have made merely for the purpose of illustrating the argument, that £15,240,000 represents a combination of taxes somewhat like this:—1/- in the £ income-tax; 8d. per packet of 20 cigarettes; 4d. per pint on beer; 6d. per glass on whiskey; 4d. per gallon petrol.

By a tax scheme of this kind the £15,240,000 is collected without any highly elaborate machinery. But to give it back again to the million or so persons from whom it was originally collected requires a most elaborate organisation, heavily staffed with civil servants, millions of ration books and millions upon millions of coupons, each of which, in theory at least, must be carefully kept, then surrendered and checked, and finally given up to those who first issued it.

It costs quite an amount to collect the £15,240,000 from the taxpayer but it costs a very great deal more to give it back again in the subsidised tea, bread and butter. The consumer, as taxpayer, pays the cost in both cases.

On top of all this, there is the worry and trouble which the whole system imposes on those who are in the grocery trade. It slows up the whole business of buying and selling, records have to be kept, returns have to be made, forms have to be filled and a large part of the shopkeeper's time is spent trying to satisfy some civil servant instead of trying to satisfy his customers. All this means additional costs to the shopkeeper, and these costs, naturally, with a percentage added, are passed on to his customers.

The whole of this elaborate machinery has been devised, as I have said, in order to delude the consumer with the belief that his food is costing him less than it really does.

Comment on this

Who devised it?

Comment on this

And this applies to all the consumers, to the old age pensioner as well as to the surtax payer. Everyone who smokes, takes a drink, rides in a bus, goes to the cinema pays his share of the subsidy for everyone else—for all draw it, rich and poor alike.

Not only do the food subsidies mask the real cost of living but they distort the cost-of-living index as well. The taxation which enables the goods to be sold over the counter at less than their real cost is not taken into account when computing the cost-of-living index, but the artificially low price of the goods over the counter is used as the basis for the calculation. In a system where wages tend to be related to the cost-of-living index this is hardly to the wage-earner's advantage.

Comment on this

Listen to the honest man.

Comment on this

Would it not be better to get away from this whole system of make-believe in regard to the real cost of food? Better to cease, as I said in the Financial Statement, to foster "the illusion that food is something that can be provided cheaper for everyone at the expense of others rather than something for which everyone who can should be expected to work and pay."

Comment on this

Why did you not say that to the Taoiseach when he was drawing up the 17-point programme?

Comment on this

Why did you not say that last May?

Comment on this

I believe that it would be better. I believe it would be better for the workers, in particular, that they should know what their real wages are in terms of the true cost of commodities rather than continue the present wasteful and cumbersome and expensive system which has so developed that it now exists to conceal from them that fundamental fact. In altering the food subsidies we have acted on that principle. At the same time we have recognised in our proposals that the change should be accompanied by an extension and improvement of existing social services.

Comment on this

Where did you drop point 15?

Comment on this

Accordingly we propose to increase existing children's allowances and to extend the scheme to the second child; we propose also to increase the old age pensions and to improve unemployment assistance.

Now, these are—unlike the subsidies which will inevitably go whether this Government remains in office or not— to be permanent benefits. Any person who listened to Deputy Dr. O'Higgins's speech to-day, or who read it, noticed how evasive he was in dealing with the plain questions put to him by two Deputies. Is it not far better that we should have these permanent increased social service benefits than have these temporary subsidies? They are, as I have said, to be permanent benefits. They will be embodied in legislation and will continue thereafter to be paid as a statutory right. They will cost in a full year no less than £3,750,000. Thus, apart altogether from the additional benefits to be provided under the Social Welfare Bill, we are making this further supplementary provision.

It has been suggested that we might have done more for certain sections. We should have liked to do so. It has been the aim of this Party since it was established to ask the people, through the State, to do the utmost they can to relieve those who may be in necessity, penury or want. We should have liked, therefore, to do better than we have done but the hard fact is that we could not do anything more that would be worth while with the resources at our disposal than give compensation at the average rate which the changes in the subsidies represent.

We have been asked, in particular, why we do not propose to do more than this for the old age pensioner. In considering that question, we cannot disregard the fact that there is a wide diversity of circumstances among old age pensioners. Many, undoubtedly, particularly in the cities, are in necessitous circumstances. On the other hand, many, particularly in rural areas, cannot, in honesty, be said to be in that condition.

To give compensation to all pensioners at a greater rate than the average increase in charge which the changes in the subsidies represent would over-compensate very many whose living conditions would not justify it having regard to the rights of the other members of the community.

The Government, I may say, gave long and serious consideration to the problem in an endeavour to find a solution for it which would be administratively practicable.

At the end, we had to admit defeat and to rely on the important fact that if, in a particular instance, the cash compensation of 1/6 per week fails to obviate real hardship, the obligation still rests on the local assistance authority to deal with the case.

Comment on this

It would not buy two ounces of snuff.

Comment on this

I come now to deal with some suggestions which have been made for alternative ways of dealing with the Budget problem.

Comment on this

Will the Minister not deal with point 15?

Comment on this
Frank Aiken Minister for External Affairs (Mr. Aiken) Fianna Fáil

Drown yourself in eggs.

Comment on this

In that connection I am giving the place of honour to my predecessor in office, the former Minister for Finance, who did recognise that there was a Budget problem. He recognised that a critical position was facing this country and made a most remarkable suggestion to meet it. He started by declaring that: "It is well known that there is a vast amount of money in this country illegally acquired during the war. It has never been subject to income-tax." Note Deputy McGilligan's general statement that there is "a vast amount of money"—not a figure, "a vast amount of money," a real atomic bomb of money so far as purchasing power is concerned. Well known to whom? Deputy McGilligan did not even seem to suggest that he had any particular knowledge of it.

He went on to say that it was illegally acquired. We had there three assertions by the Deputy: that there was this vast amount of money, that it was well known, and that this vast amount of money had been illegally acquired. Like Deputy Costello, when Deputy Costello was dealing with the charge that we had falsified the Estimates of revenue and expenditure, Deputy McGilligan had not even a tittle of evidence to support any one of them. On the basis, however, of these unsubstantiated hearsay statements, statements I think of his own fabrication, Deputy McGilligan advocated that the banks should be compelled to give information as to deposit receipts and money on deposit on which tax had not been paid.

Let us hear, before the Finance Bill is concluded, if that is the official policy of Fine Gael. If it is, the public ought to be told. Deputy McGilligan, moreover, does not intend to confine his inquisition to the banks and bank accounts alone. He is prepared to go further and institute household searches. "If," he declared in justification of his proposal, "that little device applied here, it would drive out quite an amount of money that is in deposit or kept around the house".

Comment on this

If the Minister is quoting, what is the source of his quotation?

Comment on this

I am quoting from the typescript of the Official Report of the speech which Deputy McGilligan delivered on Tuesday evening last. The printed volume is not yet available, therefore I am not in a position to quote from it.

Comment on this

On a point of order. I understand that you, Sir, have ruled in this House that the typescript, to which the Minister has referred, is not a source and cannot be quoted as a source in this House and that it is disorderly when a Deputy quotes from it.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I have no recollection of having made any such ruling. The Minister says that he is quoting from the typescript, as the printed volume is not available to him.

Comment on this

Look at it here. I have it in my hand.

Comment on this

Deputy Costello had the Table Explanatory of the Budget in his hand when he was making his speech.

Comment on this

I had.

Comment on this

In any event, I stand or fall by the printed records.

Comment on this

On a point of order. The Minister purports to quote the spoken words of Deputy McGilligan. I asked him for the source and he said the typescript, because the printed report was not available. Now that we find that it is available, why does he not produce it?

Comment on this

I regret that I did not see it but I shall stand or fall by the printed report.

Comment on this

On a point of order. The Minister stood or fell by the typescript of his own speech which contained mistakes and omitted lines. I would ask him, now seeing that the Official Report is available, to use that and not the typescript which contains lines that are notoriously unreliable.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Minister must use the Official Report or cease quoting.

Comment on this

I shall say this, that I heard Deputy McGilligan declare that this little device of his would drive out quite an amount of money that is in deposit or around the house. Deputy McGilligan wants the tax collectors to go snooping around and searching out the cash which is "kept around the house". Once more I want to know, because this is important, if that is the official policy of Fine Gael. Do they wish the officers of the revenue to be given power to take steps that would bring out amounts of money that are kept around the house? Are safes to be opened, cash boxes emptied, even children's money boxes plundered to find this money which is "kept around the house"?

Comment on this

The proposal is to break all the china pigs in Ireland, to get at the children's savings in Ireland's desperate crisis.

Comment on this

The next step would logically be, if Deputy McGilligan and the Fine Gael Party were to have their way, that the collector should stop you in the street and ask you to account for the cash in your pocket. Then heaven help the man who is caught with a £20 note. He would be told that it was illegally acquired.

Comment on this

Woe betide the child with the china pig.

Comment on this

It is reputed that the ex-Minister for Finance and the ex-Minister for External Affairs were the two members of the Coalition who were closest together. What a thrill then Deputy McGilligan's word must have given to the founder of Saor Éire! With what joy his heart leaped as he learned of this new convert! A few years ago Deputy MacBride was engaged in sending fraternal greetings to Moscow. No doubt last night a cipher message went out saying: "It is all right, Uncle Joe, McGilligan is with us."

Comment on this

And Deputy Cowan.

Comment on this

The Red Nuncio.

Comment on this

I should like to know what will the farmers and shopkeepers think of this new Fine Gael policy? What will the honest people think who have their money on deposit? What will they think now that they know that, under Deputy McGilligan, their accounts and their affairs are no longer to be confidential but are to be placed at the free disposal of the Government, just because in this country as in every other there happen to be a few rogues.

Comment on this

Who are now going for the child's china pig.

Comment on this

Is this the rod which Deputy McGilligan had in pickle for the taxpayers if the Coalition had got back to power?

Comment on this

No, the china pig.

Comment on this

I know he discussed a proposal of this kind. He has now come out publicly in advocacy of it, so it must be his policy and the policy of the Fine Gael junta. I wonder is it the policy of the Fine Gael back-benchers also?

Comment on this

The rape of the china pig.

Comment on this

That was one suggestion which Deputy McGilligan put forward, as an aid to the State in the exceedingly difficult position in which it finds itself. He made one other suggestion which, likewise, was intended not to help but to confuse. Deputy McGilligan, as everybody knows, is a prolific fabricator of false charges from which, when one pins him down to proofs, he scurries away. He has explored more bolt holes than any rabbit in this country. In his speech on Tuesday he suggested that the Government was in some way making a gift to tobacco manufacturers. The manner in which that suggestion was made clearly implied that in Deputy McGilligan's view there was some impropriety involved.

Comment on this

And quite right.

Comment on this

Let us see what are the facts. The Dáil will remember how, with a flourish and loud music from the Labour Party, Deputy Norton, when Tánaiste, announced the establishment of a Prices Advisory Body. This was a body which, according to Deputy Norton, was specially chosen by the then Government to put manufacturers and others who sought increases in prices through all the processes of the Inquisition in order to discover the truth about their costs and profits. Deputy McGilligan, as Minister for Finance, played a very large part in the selection of the personnel of that body. The Prices Advisory Body has been kept in being by the present Government and functions as effectively under us as it ever did under our predecessors. Last year, the Prices Advisory Body, having duly considered an application from the tobacco manufacturers, recommended that they should be permitted to increase the price of the standard cigarette by 2d. per packet of 20.

Now the Minister for Industry and Commerce did not immediately give full effect to that recommendation. Instead he went at first only half of the way and granted permission for an increase of 1d. last October. That, however, could only be regarded in all fairness and in all justice as an instalment since it did not meet by any means the increase in the cost of the tobacco leaf and other charges which have occurred since the former standard price was fixed. It is necessary because of the continued rise in these costs to concede now the full increase recommended by the Prices Advisory Body. These are the circumstances under which Deputy McGilligan alleges we are making a gift of 1d. per packet of 20 cigarettes to the tobacco manufacturers.

Comment on this

How much would the tobacco leaf in a cigarette cost?

Comment on this

His suggestion that something improper is being done in giving effect to the recommendation of the Prices Advisory Body is, as we all know, a typical example of Deputy McGilligan's political technique. Perhaps, however, the Leader of the Opposition might address himself to this question: If it is improper for the Government to act on the recommendation of the Prices Advisory Body, is there not something improper in the recommendation itself, in the proceedings of the body which made it and in the conduct of its chairman? That, in fact, is the real charge which Deputy McGilligan, by innuendo, has made.

Deputy Corish, I think to the surprise of most people, has associated himself with this charge against the Prices Advisory Body. Deputy Corish is a follower of Deputy Norton. It occurs to me that that, perhaps, may not be the real position as recent events suggest that Deputy Corish is one of those members who, like Deputy Larkin, are dissatisfied with the role which Deputy Norton played as cloak and dagger man for Fine Gael in the late Coalition, when Fine Gael was using every opportunity to strengthen its electoral position—"Not only in the open light of day", but, as Deputy Larkin discloses, "in the dark of night."

Comment on this

That worried you.

Comment on this

Whatever be the attitude of Deputy Corish, whether it be that of a loyal follower of Deputy Norton or that of a rival on the steps of the throne, the fact is that Deputy Corish was one of those who was instrumental in setting up the Prices Advisory Body. The Prices Advisory Body, according to Deputy Norton, on 6th December, 1950, speaking at column 1818 of Volume 123 and subsequent columns, was not to be:—

"an inconsequential advisory committee ... but a price tribunal, a virile, vibrant representative body of three or five citizens, selected on the basis of their competence and on the basis that they are citizens of standing.... That tribunal will be expected to undertake the most critical and the most microscopic examination of every claim for an increase made to it and there must be no increase given by that tribunal unless the case for such an increase is proved beyond all possibility of doubt."

He went on to say:—

"The Government will assist that tribunal by making available to it ... the group of profits of the manufacturers, or the individual manufacturer, who go before the tribunal looking for an increase in price: in other words, the tribunal will not deal with these matters in vacuum."

Thus spoke Zarathrusta in the person of Deputy Norton.

The Prices Advisory Body which our predecessors established is the "price tribunal", as Deputy Norton decribed it, which heard the application of the Irish tobacco manufacturers for permission to increase their prices. It is the tribunal which, having made in Deputy Norton's phrase, "the most critical and the most microscopic examination of every claim for an increase made to it," has advised that this increase must be given if the manufacturers are to continue in business.

I do not know what evidence the Prices Advisory Body had before it in arriving at their decision but I do know that Deputy Norton told us at column 1819 of Volume 123 of the Official Report again on 6th December, 1950, that:—

"There must be no increase given by that tribunal unless the case for such an increase is proved beyond all possibility of doubt. If there is to be a doubt, it is the public and not the applicant who will get the benefit of the doubt."

Even Deputy Corish will scarcely have the nerve to suggest that the tribunal composed of his own nominees departed from that principle when considering the application of the Irish tobacco manufacturers. He will scarcely charge them, even in this place of privilege where he can speak with immunity, with being biassed in favour of the manufacturers and against the consumers. He must accept the inevitable conclusion, therefore, that there was absolutely no doubt in the minds of the members of the Prices Advisory Body that, by the most rigorous standards of justice, the application of the tobacco manufacturers must be conceded.

Deputy Corish objects to this decision. He objects to justice being done by the tribunal in this case. Now, will the Deputy tell us why? Is it because the applicants are tobacco manufacturers? Is it because they happen to be Irish tobacco manufacturers? Or is it merely because they happen to be manufacturers and employers that Deputy Corish objects to them getting justice? Even the Deputy's biassed class-hatred cannot carry him so far that, rather than see justice done, he will put the manufacturers out of business and put, in particular, the Irish-owned concerns out of business.

The Deputy, by some method of calculation, has arrived at the conclusion that this additional 1d. per packet on the price of cigarettes means £900,000 per annum to the tobacco manufacturers. I do not know how the Deputy has arrived at that figure. It is, in any event, too fantastic to be correct. The increase recommended by the Prices Advisory Body is given merely to cover increases in the cost of the tobacco leaf and other charges.

Comment on this

When was the leaf imported?

Comment on this

Yet, the Deputy's speech was designed to lead the public to believe that the Prices Advisory Body had given this huge sum as an extra profit to the manufacturers. Is there any justice in that suggestion? Is there any social justice in the suggestion? The fact is that the increase in price has been granted in order to enable the manufacturers to remain in business and this Deputy Corish well knows.

Comment on this
Brendan Corish Breanndán Mac Fheórais Labour Party

He does not.

Comment on this

Will he tell the House what the position would be if the increase were not granted? Let him take his own figure of £900,000 per year. Does he suggest that the tobacco manufacturers as a body could continue to carry losses at that rate for any appreciable time? If they could not, which of them would go first to the wall? The native-owned concerns, the smaller Irish-owned companies in Dublin, Limerick, Cork or Dundalk? The native-owned concerns would be the first to die.

Comment on this

The Imperial Tobacco Company.

Comment on this

The smaller Irish-owned companies in Dublin, Limerick, Cork and Dundalk would be broken and only the subsidiaries of the foreign combines would be left. Is that what Deputy Corish and his Party want?

Comment on this
Brendan Corish Breanndán Mac Fheórais Labour Party

He wants cheaper tobacco.

Comment on this

Is that what he desires? Does he want the ranks of the unemployed in Dublin, Limerick, Cork and Dundalk to be increased by the present employees of the Irish-owned concerns? Is that what he wants or is his criticism of the recommendation of the Prices Advisory Body, on which there sit two trade unionists, simply based on cold, malign class-hatred?

Comment on this
Brendan Corish Breanndán Mac Fheórais Labour Party

They did not advise that the leaf should be dearer.

Comment on this

Now, let the Deputy take his medicine. Suggestions have been made that the additional revenue required could have been secured more easily by taxes other than we have proposed. I cannot deal exhaustively with all these suggestions. That would require several volumes, but I can assure the Deputies who have put these suggestions forward that they were considered—every one of them— very carefully before they were rejected for the taxes upon which we are relying.

There are certain conditions which, in my view, it is desirable any particular form of tax should fulfil. In broad general terms the tax should be equitable, effective, economic and convenient. No tax that man can devise will fulfil any or all of these conditions except in a loose and approximate way; but some taxes more nearly fulfil them than others, and it is on that basis that we must proceed.

If time permitted I would show how those taxes which I have rejected fall much further short of fulfilling the conditions than those which I have adopted. So perhaps I might deal very briefly with one example. It is the one which is most commonly offered as an alternative to other taxes. It has been suggested that profits should be taxed more heavily, preferably by the introduction of an excess profits tax. Now, experience has shown that an excess profits tax is a bad tax. It is arbitrary; it is inequitable as between one taxpayer and another; it does not differentiate between profits which might correctly be described as excessive and profits which have increased because of greater enterprise, more efficient management or other desirable cause, and it lends itself easily and readily to fraud and evasion. Finally, it is a tax on marginal earnings, and marginal earnings are just the type of earnings which must be encouraged if we desire to have an efficient, expanding economy.

It was on these grounds that the Labour Government in Great Britain decided first to reduce the tax in October, 1945, and, finally in April, 1946, to abolish it altogether. In doing so, Dr. Dalton who was at that time Chancellor of the Exchequer in a Socialist Government passed this judgment on it:—

"Moreover, once the standard profit has been earned, this tax encourages extravagant and wasteful outlay, and even downright dishonesty, since if this expenditure were not incurred it would be the Treasury and not the owners of the business who would take the money. Under those conditions this tax works against incentive and against efficiency."

Now, whatever groundless allegations may be made that this Government is biassed in favour of or against any particular section, no one will suggest that Dr. Dalton, once Labour Chancellor of the Exchequer, is biassed in favour of capitalists, industrialists or profit-makers. Yet he condemns the excess profits tax unreservedly. As against this tax, so strongly condemned by a socialist chancellor, we find that the most effective tax on profits is the income-tax. There is not the fine propagandist ring about its name that there is about the excess profits tax, but it is a fairer, more effective way of collecting revenue, particularly when it is associated, as it is now, with an equitable system of earned income and reduced rate reliefs.

I should like to deal with other suggestions which have been made, but it is necessary to get on to a more general aspect of the problem. I have referred already to certain statements made by Deputy McGilligan in the course of his speech on Tuesday evening. The more closely I study that speech the more doubtful I become as to what the Deputy's real purpose in making it was. At first reading, it might appear to be the sort of slick parliamentary performance we are accustomed to from the Deputy. But there are passages in it that appear to be of deeper significance.

The "give-away", for instance, of the manner in which Deputy Costello's figures were prepared does not suggest that Deputy McGilligan is prepared to continue to serve the Party with a complete disregard of the public interest. More suggestive still were the Deputy's references to the advice which he received from his advisers when preparing his Budget for 1951-52, the Budget, that is, for the last financial year. No Deputy, no Minister or ex-Minister could speak in higher terms of the advice which he received or of the competency of his advisers than did Deputy McGilligan on Tuesday night. But how did he treat them? He told us that they had warned him of the rapidly aggravating balance of payments problem. He told us that—

"because the country is not supplying all the goods it requires we have a vast import of goods... there is this terrifying gap in the balance of payments."

"I was told last year," he said, "that the public and the Government between them are spending more than the nation can afford." He told us, "that advice came to me from people who have very good standards to give advice." He told us again on Tuesday night, "that was very good advice; taken by certain standards it was impeccable."

Let us see how did Deputy McGilligan act on that advice. Seven million pounds were the additional amount that his advisers told Deputy McGilligan he would require if the Budget of last year was to be balanced. It is an indication, a significant indication, of the soundness of the judgment and of the advice which Deputy McGilligan's advisers gave to him, but which he rejected, that, in fact, the deficit on last year's Budget, on the Coalition Budget submitted to the Dáil just 12 months ago by Deputy McGilligan as Minister for Finance, was £6.86 million. His advisers, whom Deputy McGilligan admits gave him "impeccable advice", put last year's probable deficit at £7,000,000. It turns out now to be £6.68 million. A more accurate forecast than that of the out-turn of events 12 months ahead could scarcely be expected, even from a prophet.

Let me ask again, how did Deputy McGilligan react to this figure of £7,000,000. He himself has disclosed that he did not turn down the advice out of hand. "When I began to consider", he confessed on Tuesday, "the sources from which that might be derived"—"that" being the £7,000,000 —his advisers "fell back on what is now before the Dáil"—increased taxes on "beer, tobacco, whiskey and petrol. These were certainly suggested to me." Beer, tobacco, whiskey and petrol: more ominous words than the first three could not be uttered in Deputy McGilligan's hearing.

As soon as he heard them last year, the blood in his veins turned to water and his previous resolution to do his duty by the people and bring in at least one honest Budget vanished like snow. He knew what the Fine Gael Party in Dublin owed to the five publicans who had raised a considerable sum for the 1948 election— £30,000 it has been suggested. He knew that he owed his own seat to the support of that particular vested interest in his constituency and so he turned down the advice which he himself has admitted—and I am quoting his own words—"was very good advice and which taken by a certain standard was impeccable."

What is the "certain standard" to which Deputy McGilligan referred when he declared that that was "impeccable advice"? It is the standard of objectivity set by distinguished public servants, chosen for their knowledge and experience of public finance, who are bound to advise their Minister to the best of their ability and in a purely objective way as to what financial or economic policy will best serve the interests of the people and the State. That is the standard to which the advice of Deputy McGilligan's principal advisers must be related. That is the sort of advice which they must give. They must tell their Minister, without fear or favour, what course, in their opinion, will best advance the interests of the people. Their Minister need not take it. He need not take it even though he recognises that it is "impeccable advice," as Deputy McGilligan himself has admitted it to be.

He may be afraid to take it. He may shirk his duty, as Deputy McGilligan now discloses he did last year, but that is not their responsibility. Their Minister carries full responsibility under the Constitution and that responsibility is accompanied by freedom to reject good advice—even "impeccable advice" if the political difficulties of the Minister require it. It was according to that canon of public conduct that Deputy McGilligan acted last year. He could not do otherwise, indeed, unless he wanted to weaken the Coalition still further by himself being driven from the Cabinet.

He knew that the then Minister for External Affairs dominated the then Taoiseach and that he would get no support from that quarter. He knew that Deputy Dillon treated him and his Department with almost naked contempt. And so, instead of facing up to the situation, he allowed a Cabinet Committee to cook the Estimates for the Supply Services, and to write them down arbitrarily by £4,000,000, and he himself failed, deliberately failed, in his Budget to make provision for charges which he knew would inevitably arise. That is how the £7,000,000 deficit, which Deputy McGilligan's advisers feared, was, in fact, realised. In order to salve his conscience—and he betrayed his public trust in this—he came to the Dáil, faint and bleating, uttering plaintive warnings in regard to the growing and alarming deficit in our balance of payments account, such as these:—

"The position is, however, far from satisfactory"—

I am quoting from Deputy McGilligan's Budget speech of 12 months ago—

"inasmuch as the basic £10,000,000 deficit of 1949 was repeated in 1950.... The outlook for 1951 is, I fear, that the deficit may be even greater than in 1950.... The present position on external account is by no means satisfactory, and if it continues to develop unfavourably, the application of corrective measures will be called for. At the moment these might be premature."

Might I interrupt the quotations to emphasise the importance of that last statement which was made 12 months ago, not by me, but by my predecessor? "If it"—and by "it" Deputy McGilligan meant the balance of payments deficit—"continues to develop unfavourably, the application of corrective measures will be called for. At the moment these might be premature." Quite clearly, than warning presages the grave and serious situation which has since developed.

We are now in the position in which "the application of corrective measures", which Deputy McGilligan foresaw 12 months ago, can no longer be evaded. The need for these measures was, indeed, manifest 12 months ago. Even though the duty falls on us to deal with the position, it falls on us only because he and his colleagues shirked it. They shirked it even though they knew the full consequences of doing so, even though as their Minister for Finance warned us one year ago:—

"Only if the gap in the balance of payments is narrowed so that external disinvestment is balanced by additional home investment—rather than by excessive consumption—can we be satisfied that as a nation we are making ends meet and not wasting our past accumulations. One of the great benefits conferred by the possession of external assets is ability to ride out periods like the present of exceptional difficulty and stress, but this external mass of manoeuvre is the mainstay of our economic independence."

—which we are rapidly frittering away. It is the mainstay, I would say, not only of our economic independence but of our political independence also. Later in the same speech, in that tentative way in which he always spoke on these matters, as though he feared an attack from Deputy MacBride or Deputy Norton, he ventured to say:—

"Making all allowance for the exceptional conditions now obtaining it is to be feared that we are not producing and earning enough to pay our way. The implication is obvious. We cannot have both consumption and capital development on the present scale unless we save more and produce more."

This is the position with which we have to deal to-day. Deputy McGilligan knew it existed last year. He knew it existed not only then but in the year before and in the year before that again. So did Deputy Costello. In fact, as the Minister for External Affairs reminded the House yesterday, Deputy Costello, then Taoiseach, uttered this warning in regard to it in August, 1948:—

"The adverse trade balance has grown to an extent which must cause anybody who thinks about it for one moment, or looks at the figures, the utmost alarm for our economic and financial stability."

"The utmost alarm for our economic and financial stability." It is to preserve that economic and financial stability that we have brought in this Budget. We are acting on the warning which ought to have been acted upon years ago—the warning which Deputy Costello uttered almost four years ago. If it was not necessary, if he did not believe it, why did he utter it? And since he did utter it, since it was necessary, why did he not act on it? The reason, of course, is simple. The wild men in his Cabinet, the Dillons and the MacBrides, would not let him.

Throughout those fearful years when Deputy Dillon was spending millions in an afternoon and Marshall Aid dollars were being thrown away like farthings, Deputy Costello, the ex-Taoiseach, and Deputy McGilligan, as Minister for Finance, resembled nothing so much as a demented captain and demented mate on a ship whose crew had gone out of control. The only thing they did in that situation was to career up and down the deck shouting: "We'll be on the rocks! we'll be on the rocks!" Now that situation has developed and we must ask ourselves how did it develop?

In October, 1947, the Fianna Fáil Government decided, in an effort to deal with the price situation, to increase the then existing subsidies to rates which would require the Minister for Finance to find an additional £5,765,000 for the balance of that year. In order to obtain that sum, it was necessary for them to increase existing rates of tax to bring in £4,770,000 at the same time. They allowed for a prospective surplus of £1,000,000 in the Budget. The principal increases were made on income-tax, spirits, beer, tobacco, wines, entertainments and stamp duty.

Following the General Election of 1948 and the formation of the Coalition Government, the increases in the taxes on beer, tobacco and entertainments were rescinded; but the increased rates of food subsidy were retained. The taxes were taken away but the expenditure was kept on. Thus, the total cost of the subsidies was increased from £4,436,000, at which it was estimated in May, 1947, to £14,680,000 for 1948-49; to £12,580,000 for 1949-50; to £13,070,000 for 1950-51. But there was not any additional revenue provided to cover these increases in expenditure. The reductions in the tax-rates, to which I have referred, resulted in a loss of revenue of at least £8,000,000 or £9,000,000 a year to the Exchequer. This £8,000,000 or £9,000,000, if it had been collected, would have gone a long way to help the State to balance accounts and would have prevented the present critical situation from developing.

As our experience since has shown, the remission of these taxes was quite unjustified. Our predecessors, however—everybody knows it—were coerced into making the remission. They had made themselves subservient to a certain interest——

Comment on this

Were they dance hall proprietors?

Comment on this

They had made themselves subservient to a certain interest and they were not free to serve whole-heartedly the interests of the nation. No matter how essential it might be to the well-being of the people and to secure the independence of the State, they dare not do an unpopular thing and so, instead of facing up to the responsibilities when they were confronted with them, when there was no longer any escape from them, last May, they dissolved the Dáil, went to the people, then, having been thrown out, they have left behind them a state of utter confusion in the public finances. It is our tough and unpleasant task to straighten things out and, if the people support us, we shall do that.

I have been accused here of making certain promises during the election. I made no promise and gave no undertaking that would be inconsistent with my public duty or that would fetter me in the discharge of it.

Comment on this

Have you lost your memory?

Comment on this

Here, in fact, is my election address, issued over my signature. It went to every household in my constituency. It sets out the basis on which I sought election and here is what it said:—

"It is on this basis that we offer ourselves to you in this election. In doing so, however, we wish to make it clear that Fianna Fáil makes no rash promises. We do not know the extent to which the credit and solvency of the State has been undermined by the Coalition; we suspect, however, that, bad though the position in this regard appears to be, the worst has been concealed. Therefore, if Fianna Fáil should receive a mandate to form a Government, its first task must be to reorganise the public finances and to set them in order. When this has been accomplished, Fianna Fáil pledges itself to pursue a progressive, social and economic policy, always, however, with due regard to the resources of the State and the individual rights of its citizens. It will look, too, to the nation's defences, which the Coalition has so foolishly neglected. Thus Ireland will cease to be both in grave peril herself and a source of weakness and danger to others. On this programme we submit ourselves to you, and ask for your vote and general support, so that a disastrous phase in our public life may be ended."

Comment on this

Is that what you said in Rathmines Town Hall?

Comment on this

This is what went to every voter in my constituency over my signature.

Comment on this

On a point of order. The Minister is quoting from a document. Will a copy of that document be placed in the Library?

Comment on this

God forbid!

Comment on this

It will be found in the burnt-out archives.

Comment on this

With the greatest of pleasure.

Comment on this

On a point of order. Surely the intelligence of the House and those using the Library is not to be insulted by having to read that document.

Comment on this

There are parts of that document which it would be useful to get another look at.

Comment on this

You would not learn anything from it.

Comment on this

It might not be any harm if I did place it in the Library. Think of the period when Deputy McGilligan was making one pronouncement as Minister for Finance and Deputy MacBride was making a directly contrary one. Think of the period when Deputy Norton was making one statement and Deputy Dillon another one. Here is what I said—if you want the whole of the document:—

"It is imperative that the constitutional principle that the Government as a whole is collectively responsible for all the actions and pronouncements of its members in the sphere of public affairs should be made effective again."

Comment on this

Including point 15.

Comment on this

"You have the power to do this by putting in office as Taoiseach Mr. de Valera and a Government who will accept the principle of collective responsibility without reservation and on whom responsibility can be squarely placed for the actions and utterances of each and every Minister."

Comment on this

Including point 15.

Comment on this

"After three years of collective irresponsibility of the Coalition, it is only by this means that order will be restored to the public services and to the public finances."

Comment on this

"Trust Dev."

Comment on this
Mr. O'Higgins

What about your pledge to maintain food subsidies?

Comment on this

The pledge which I gave to my constituents is the pledge which I am now endeavouring to honour.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Higgins

What about collective responsibility?

Comment on this

I am endeavouring —when I say "I" in this context, I speak for the Government—we are endeavouring to reorganise the public finances and to set them in order. We are endeavouring to do that because we wish to fulfil our pledge that, when this task has been accomplished, we shall pursue a progressive social and economic policy——

Comment on this
A Deputy

You will not be there.

Comment on this

——always with due regard to the resources of the State and the individual rights of the citizen. That is the purpose which this Budget is designed to fulfil.

Comment on this

I want to know if the Minister was quoting from the Van-guard?

Comment on this

Before the question is put, I would like to ask the Minister a question.

Comment on this

Put the question.

Comment on this

I want to get some information before this vote is taken. Will the Minister tell the House what in fact will be the price of butter from July 1st? Will it be, as announced previously by him, 3/10 per lb., or will it be more?

Comment on this

I shall not answer any further questions.

Comment on this

Say "I do not know".

Comment on this
Division

Question put.

Tá 72
·
Níl 69
Result Carried The question put was agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?

Get out!

Comment on this

Resign!

Comment on this

Resign—get out!

Comment on this

Dissolve now and go to the country.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Order!

Comment on this

It took Deputy Peadar Cowan to do it for you.

Comment on this

The "busted flush" is down to "threes".

Financial Resolutions reported and agreed to.

Comment on this