Committee on Finance. - Finance Bill, 1952—Second Stage (Resumed).
Contributions 146–305 of 305. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 12 of 1952 ›
These people are signing at the labour exchange. They were in full employment last year.
Comment on this
In Dublin Corporation we have not been given the sites to build houses on. That is our trouble.
Comment on this
I would like to know from the Minister, when he is replying, what is his aim in this Budget. Is it towards devaluation or is it to counteract deflation? Perhaps the Chancellor of the Exchequer, Mr. Butler, has warned him that at some future date it is proposed to carry out further devaluation. Whether it is deflation or devaluation, the Minister should tell the House and the country what is the aim behind this Budget. The nation is being asked to pay more than is required and more than it should.
It has been pointed out that he is budgeting for millions of pounds—actually £10,000,000 more than he will need for the management of the services set out in the Book of Estimates. In the course of his Budget speech, the Minister referred to agricultural production and he complained that the level of production had not reached the 1938 level, but the Minister knows the measure of poverty that existed amongst the farmers during the years from 1932 to 1938. The first relief they got was as a result of the financial agreement of 1938 concluded by the British Government and this country after six years of economic war.
The Minister knows that in order to make ends meet the farmers and farm workers of the country had to work night and day producing goods which would enable them to scrape together sufficient money to pay the grocer and to pay for his other liabilities. That is the explanation for the measure of agricultural production which existed in 1938 compared with the level of production which exists at the present time.
Comment on this
For instance, they were getting 6d. a gallon for creamery milk in 1938 but it took a good many gallons of milk at 6d. a gallon for the farmers to meet their ordinary liabilities to the grocer.
Comment on this
They were made to pay and they could pay. Deputy Dunne was trading on the fact that people would not buy their farms but he paid his rates in the end and so did his companions.
Comment on this
Would Deputy Dunne think that the big farmer should get away with rates while the farm labourer has to pay them?
Comment on this
Do not make Deputy Burke uncomfortable. I know what Deputy Burke's feelings are on this subject.
Comment on this
We have statements by Ministers that the remedy for the present problem is production and more production, but what are they doing about it? They have created a slump in industry by undermining confidence in commercial life. What have they done to increase production on the land? They have made no attempt to increase production in the factory or on the farm. Still they call out for more production. They should put before the country a programme aimed at increasing production.
Comment on this
If you have the bailiffs down people have to do something. We have statements that the inter-Party Government was on a spending spree. If they were on a spending spree, they were spending that money on new houses. During their three years of office, they built 30,000 houses. The money had to be found. We found a situation on coming into office that Fianna Fáil would not face a programme of housing. The excuse they offered was that they were waiting for prices to fall.
Comment on this
It has to be said but it is a sore point. We were busy building houses during our period of office.
Comment on this
We left you 1,000 sites to start with. That was when Deputy Rooney was running Dublin County Council.
Comment on this
If ever there was a honeymoon, a spending spree, in this country, it occurred since the 13th June last year, because, when the present Minister for Finance walked into his office, there was on the table £28,000,000 of American money.
Comment on this
Questions were asked in the House, and he was bound to give an answer which showed that the inter-Party Government, during three and a half years, spent £15,000,000 of the American money. That is the money which we were told was spent by the inter-Party Government. It was spent at an average rate of £4,000,000 a year. On that basis the inter-Party Government could have carried on with the American money for another seven years, and that was the programme. It was a ten-year programme designed to feed into the general capital investment programme a sum of £4,000,000 or £5,000,000 per annum.
Comment on this
That is too deep. The Deputy will have to try that on again. The American money is gone. There is no question of spending it now at the rate of £4,000,000 or £5,000,000 per annum. It was gone, I believe, on the 1st February of this year, and we must carry on without the Marshall Aid which was made available to this country.
Comment on this
The Deputy is under a misapprehension. The Marshall Aid dollars were spent long before we came into office.
Comment on this
Month after month we had to meet your commitments, including the £3.6 millions as a result of the arbitration award which you did not budget for.
Comment on this
The Minister for Finance was opposed to our system of borrowing for capital development but we now have the situation where he actually put before the House his intention of going ahead with a capital development and investment programme of £35,000,000. We did not attempt in any one year a programme so big. He is putting that programme before the House and he has not got the money to do it. He is pretending that he will do it. He can only pretend because he has not got the money to finance it and he is not prepared to borrow money. He has indicated that he proposes to go to the country for a national loan, and I hope that he will succeed. He indicated, I think, that he proposes to seek a loan of about £10,000,000, but £10,000,000 will fall very far short of the proposal to invest £35,000,000 in a capital development programme.
Coming to the domestic side of affairs we have the proposal to withdraw the subsidies on butter, tea, sugar and bread. Last year when the butter price went up from 2/8 to 2/10 per lb. there was an outcry all over the country and, of course, the leaders of that outcry were the Fianna Fáil Party. They pretended to the people at that time that if they were in office no such increase in the cost of living would take place, but they were only a fortnight in power when they put another 2d. per lb. on butter and brought it up to 3/-.
Comment on this
The Minister for Agriculture promised 6d. a gallon to the creamery milk suppliers and gave them 1d. That is why.
Comment on this
The price of milk was increased in order to get more butter and avoid the need for importing foreign butter.
Comment on this
Would the Minister read the speech of the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Agriculture and see his views as to whether he is going to get more butter or not? Read his views on the manufacture of butter.
Comment on this
Deputy Mulcahy does. When he was in the last Cabinet, he wanted to remove the subsidies.
Comment on this
If the Deputy thinks that everytime he or Deputy Dr. ffrench-O'Carroll puts a question to Deputy Costello or to Deputy Mulcahy, they will get an answer, he is barking up the wrong tree. When responsible people ask questions, they will get answers.
Comment on this
The Minister tells us that the price of butter was put up to 3/- per lb. in order to put an end to the importation of butter.
Comment on this
I did not say that. The Deputy asked why was the price of milk increased, and I said that it was done in order to get more butter.
Comment on this
In any event, it was done to get more butter. If that were the purpose, it was not achieved because there was more butter imported since the present Government came into office than, I suppose, since we became responsible for the administration of our own affairs in this country. In 1950 this country produced 750,000 cwt. of butter—more butter than our people could eat. The average consumption per head per week in 1950 was 13 oz.
Comment on this
In 1950, the last full year during which the inter-Party Government had control of the affairs of this country, our farmers produced more butter than we could eat. Actually, we had a surplus of butter. When the present Minister for Agriculture came into office, he declared that not one ounce of butter would be imported into this country after February or March, but we are still importing as much butter as ever from New Zealand at something like 3/1 per lb. The proposed price of 3/10 per lb. is obviously designed to reap a profit from imported butter. Of course, the extra charge for butter will reduce consumption. People with large families will stop consuming 13 oz. per head per week, which they were doing in 1950. They will cut down their consumption to a half pound per week or even less when the price of 3/10 per lb. comes into operation.
It was an insult to the old age pensioners to offer them 1/6 extra per week. Any old age pensioner, in his health, can sit down to 21 meals per week. It is proposed to give him 18d. —less than 1d. per meal—to enable him to meet the increased cost of essential commodities. The price of a 2lb. loaf of bread will go from 6½d. to 9d., an increase of 45 per cent.; butter will be 3/10 per lb.; there will be no such thing as being able to get tea at 2/8 per lb.; it will probably be in the region of 5/- or 5/6 per lb. The subsidised price for sugar is to be abolished and, of course, the old age pensioner is not supposed to enjoy the ordinary luxury of a pint, a nip of whiskey, or even a few cigarettes. All the relief given to him to cope with these new prices is 1/6 per week.
Comment on this
Why did the Deputy boycott the Social Welfare Bill last week when old age pensions were being discussed?
Comment on this
You wanted the Labour Party to quarrel with Fianna Fáil while you kept outside the House.
Comment on this
When the Minister for Social Welfare was giving some figures he said that the 1/6 per week extra to the old age pensioner was based on an allowance of 8 oz. of butter per head per week. In other words, he said that 13 oz. per head per week, which the old age pensioner was consuming in 1950, was far too much— that he was living beyond his means and that 8 oz. ought to be sufficient for him. However, the dance tax has been removed and the old age pensioner can dance with delight.
There is no doubt that these increased prices are going to place an extra charge of 10/- per week on the average family. One will find a few people saying that this Budget is going to mean a saving for them of 7d. or 1/7 per week. That is on the food end of things alone. They do not take into consideration the tax on tobacco, on spirits and on beer, but taking food alone they are going to save a matter of a shilling or two and pence. However, for the average family this Budget is going to mean an extra expenditure of about 10/- per week. I heard Deputy Corish giving figures in this House which could not be contradicted in relation to the increased burden that would be put on many households having two or three children. The new price of flour will be 4/9 per stone. The previous figure was 2/8 per stone. That is a colossal increase and it will prove to be a heavy burden for the housewife who normally went to the shop and brought home a copule of stone of flour and baked healthy bread.
We are told now that the loaf will be whiter and that the extra charge will be justified, even on the grounds that the bread will be whiter. However, when it suited the Fianna Fáil Government during the emergency years, they quoted medical opinion as saying that the black bread was healthy bread and good for the nation. Now they are putting forward arguments that the nation is going to get whiter bread. They cannot have it both ways. Either the bread is better blacker, or it is better whiter, but it cannot be better both ways.
Comment on this
On a point of order, the Deputy has made a statement concerning the advocacy of a certain quality of bread by Fianna Fáil. Can he adduce some evidence of that statement?
Comment on this
Has Deputy Rooney forgotten the statements made during the general election campaign?
Comment on this
If I had time to go back through the newspapers to 1943 I could go into the question, but my memory serves me quite well in this case. It is quite true. The Minister cannot deny it and neither can his colleagues.
Comment on this
Yes, but when they wanted the people to eat black bread it was healthy bread, and now when they want the people to eat dearer bread white bread is healthy bread.
Comment on this
The price of flour is certainly going to hit large families hardest. There is an increase from 2/8 to 4/9½ a stone, an increase of 2/1½ a stone.
Comment on this
Ask the Cork Deputies about the black market. The Deputies in Cork were complaining about the black market price of butter when it was 3/6 a lb. They said the inter-Party Government legalised the black marketing of butter at 3/6 a lb.
Comment on this
There is no use in talking about the black market when you read this election address which was responsible for getting Deputy MacCarthy into this House.
Comment on this
It is not necessary to deny it. It is a true statement.
Comment on this
You will have to deny it at the next election. To return to the Finance Bill, petrol has been increased by 4d. a gallon.
Comment on this
Deputy Lynch will give you a copy. It is proposed to put an extra 4d. a gallon on petrol. That is going to be a heavy burden, particularly on agriculture. We remember some years ago when the inter-Party Government increased the tax on petrol there was an uproar in this House about the increased cost of petrol for agricultural tractors. The result of that agitation was that the Minister for Finance decided that in the interests of agriculture, agricultural production and production of food, he would allow a rebate of 6d. a gallon for petrol used in agricultural tractors. This extra 4d. a gallon must be paid by the farmers who are using agricultural tractors in connection with food production. The result is that the petrol tax will amount to something like £1 a week, £52 a year, on the farmer engaged in the growing of wheat and the production of food generally.
Then we have here the allowance of £1? million to the manufacturers of tobacco. This tax has been gathered from the people's pockets and handed over to the tobacco manufacturers, for what it is hard to understand. Certainly, an excuse for it has been put up, but this tobacco was bought years ago, and it is proposed now to collect £1? million from the pockets of the taxpayers and hand it over to the manufacturers of tobacco. Sixpence on the packet of cigarettes, plus 1d., makes it 7d., and the 1d. is for the tobacco manufacturers.
Comment on this
You were going to have an efficient system of price control according to the 17 points.
Comment on this
The nation was presented with a nutritional survey, and it was indicated at that time that there was a rather low standard of living amongst our people prior to 1947, that bread appeared to be the staple diet, and that there was not very much variety in the matter of food. This Budget is certainly going to bring the bread and scrape standard of living back amongst the wage earners in this country.
Comment on this
I am sorry, bread and spread, if that will suit Deputy Cowan. But there is a lot of people in Fairview who will learn what bread and spread means when this Budget goes into force, and they will not need any explanation or description of it from Deputy Cowan. They will be able to experience it for themselves, and they will be able to tell Deputy Cowan about it.
Comment on this
We are going to get it again. We departed from the bread and spread standard of living when the inter-Party Government came into office and improved the standard of living for our people.
Comment on this
It has been said that as a nation we have not had a square meal since Essex ravaged Munster.
Comment on this
Whether there is or not, the fact remains that wage earners were able to have a decent meal of bacon and egg when the inter-Party Government was in office.
Comment on this
The bacon and egg have certainly disappeared from the breakfast table since last June.
Comment on this
Nevertheless, the average price of bacon has gone up 1/- a lb. since last year. That, of course, was the result of the decontrolling of retail prices. Similarly, the price of meat has gone up beyond the capacity of the housewife.
Comment on this
Surely the Deputy does not suggest that the hens have stopped laying since Fianna Fáil came back to office?
Comment on this
I would not be surprised if the shock of Fianna Fáil coming back to office stopped them from laying.
Comment on this
On the 1st July the cost of living is going to go up 17 per cent. It is going to be a great hardship on many people who must bear these increased prices for essential food. Unemployment continues to increase and emigration has accelerated particularly during the last 12 months. Many times in this House the question of emigration was brought up, and emigration was used as an issue. It was criticised, and it was even the subject of a Birmingham speech which proved to be a boomerang. The Army, of course, has been enlarged, and it has absorbed an extra 2,000 persons.
The question is if they had not gone into the Army would they have any employment, would they have work either in the factory or in the field? Considering that so many people are losing employment and that the unemployment figure has gone up so much, it is only right to assume that this extra 2,000 people would be unemployed if they had not joined the Army.
I hope the Minister will make a statement which will restore confidence in the country. Business is at its lowest ebb, and the only activity that is likely to improve business during the coming months is the expected increase in the number of tourists who will come to this country. Owing to the restricted allowance available to them for foreign travel, they are almost forced to come to this country. It is probable that the tourists will be the means of creating a measure of prosperity, and of providing more employment during the coming summer months, but they will be with us only a few months, and when the tourist trade declines the position will be just as it is to-day. I hope that the Minister will do something to improve the position of the country and make things easier, particularly for the weaker sections of the community, the wage earners, who are being asked to bear the heaviest burden. I will conclude——
Comment on this
He did not like to hear the Cork election address. That is what annoyed him. We had recent announcements of other increases and it is only right to ask the Minister whether this Government intend to do anything about the rising cost of living.
Comment on this
Surely the Deputy does not propose to discuss the cost of living on the Finance Bill?
Comment on this
I shall conclude by asking the Minister to explain to the public why his Party took part in deceiving the public during the last general election.
Comment on this
The question of the last general election does not arise on the Finance Bill, to which the Deputy will have to confine himself.
Comment on this
The Government are responsible for the Finance Bill and I am questioning the manner in which they came into office. They are imposing upon the people something for which the people did not vote. If the people were presented last year with a 17-point programme which did not include item 15—to maintain the subsidies, to control the prices of essential foodstuffs and to operate an efficient system of price regulation for all necessary scarce commodities—the Government would not be in office.
They secured support by undertaking to control the prices of essential commodities and to maintain subsidies. Instead of that, day after day they began decontrolling the retail prices of essential commodities, particularly foodstuffs, and on top of that they have now introduced a Budget proposing to withdraw the subsidies. The whole basis of their existence is one of dishonesty and deception and it is only fair to demand from the Minister the real explanation as to why he withdrew the subsidies and decontrolled prices when in fact the Government gave an undertaking that they would control prices and maintain the subsidies. These are the questions which are in the public mind. The public feel that they have been deceived and the Minister should give them an opportunity of expressing their disapproval of his action and the action of his Government at the earliest possible date.
Comment on this
Since the introduction of this year's Budget many Opposition Deputies have allowed themselves the luxury of identifying themselves with the suffering people. They have had a field day up and down the country worrying about the poor man's pint and the pensioner's smoke. In fact their sympathy extended to every section of the community. Having listened to their wails, I am filled with admiration of their fortitude on the day of the Budget statement. On that day, as increase after increase in taxation was announced every Opposition Deputy, with great fortitude, smiled until towards the end there was a broad smile on the face of every Opposition Deputy. It is hard, therefore, to regard seriously their various speeches about the hardships of the Budget. That is not saying that I do not agree that this is a hard and harsh Budget because it is that.
I feel sympathy, as my colleagues do, with the people of the country at having to bear such heavy taxation which could easily have been spread over the last few years. We regret having to impose such heavy taxation on the people, but the regret is something like the regret which you feel when a person has to go to work on a Monday morning. No matter how much we regret it, it has to be done because it is absolutely essential for us to put our financial affairs in order.
Listening to the speakers from the Opposition Front Bench I was disappointed, but not surprised, to find that after this continued debate, and when the smoke has cleared, we are left with no constructive suggestions for an alternative method of getting money for our Exchequer other than the suggestion of having a general election and the almost schizoid vagueness of a ten-minute speech that can produce money at the rate of £1,000,000 a minute. I am not surprised that it is now necessary for one of the leaders of the Fine Gael Party to produce money at that rate since the Party has joined Deputy Dillon, because on his own confession he was capable of spending $5,000,000 in one afternoon. I presume it is no more than the shock of this prospective spending that has caused the wild talk that money can be taken out of the air at the rate of £1,000,000 a minute. It is not indicated whether the shadow Minister would equip himself with all the impedimenta of the magician during this process, but if he believes that what he says is possible perhaps he would be a little more constructive and say how it can be done.
So short a time after a general election, nobody in the country can have much sympathy with a man who will make a statement like that, but stand shyly back and withhold the useful information, stipulating that there be a general election and that he be again returned to office. It is unreasonable to expect the people to accept his word for his ability in this respect, without any indication as to how he proposes to put it into effect. It is particularly difficult for them to accept it when they reflect on the Budget which Deputy McGilligan brought in last year and remember that there was a deficit of £6.7 million in respect of which this year we are paying a sum of £330,000 in interest. They must, of course, suspect that a ten-minute speech by the originator of last year's Budget will involve the borrowing of money.
Since the present Budget, I have moved a good deal amongst the people, and although I have heard many suggestions, I do not believe anybody believes in borrowing. In fact, I am convinced that nobody wants to borrow. I have heard many criticisms of the Budget and many alternative suggestions, but the alternatives were for alternative taxation. You had the example of the married man suggesting that the bachelor should be taxed: the publican suggesting that the bicycle should be taxed, and the teetotaller suggesting that further taxation should be put on drink. In fact, the attitude can be summed up to the effect that the people believe that taxation is essential, that somebody should be taxed, but they themselves do not want to be taxed. I think that is a very natural reaction. However, nobody with whom I spoke suggested that we should borrow.
While on the subject of alternative taxation, it might, perhaps, be well to point out to the people that the Minister had at his disposal a team of experts to advise him and to examine the revenue possibilities of any particular form of taxation. We must accept it that these people would not neglect to tax something which would yield a reasonable revenue without imposing undue hardship on the people. To explain fully their examination of all the possible sources of revenue would be too expansive. The people must accept it that each article was examined from the point of view of the amount of revenue it would yield and also of the cost of collecting the revenue. We can be assured that our officers, as well as those in every other country, seek to tax only those articles which would impose the least hardship on the people while at the same time yielding sufficient revenue.
Sufficient revenue is the important point when dealing with the illusive luxury tax. Everybody believes that there is some luxury but nobody seems to think there is any luxury in his own life. People believe that there is some nebulous group somewhere who enjoy luxuries and that we should tax that group of people. We have heard officially that what can be described as "luxuries" are enjoyed by very few people and that to attempt to get much revenue from them would probably prevent their purchase or use at all. Therefore, it is very unfair of representatives of the people to keep whipping up the idea that some group of people who are supposed to be living in luxury should be taxed. That is not so.
Deputy Rooney said that the large family will suffer because of the increase in the price of flour. My information, from where I come, is that the large family has suffered hitherto because of the rationing and because of having to buy flour and other essential commodities off the ration at enormous prices. In fact, large families will benefit very much by this Budget. The same Deputy mentioned emigration as if this problem were solely the result of the election of a Fianna Fáil Government. It depends how far back one looks, I suppose, but over the last 100 years County Clare has lost 200,000 people—and most of those were lost before Fianna Fáil ever got into office. The continued emigration of our people is a social disease which we all wish could be cured but it will never be cured by bouncing the baby from one Government to another and saying: "Emigration is your fault", and retorting: "No, it is your fault." It requires study to discover what can stem the tide of emigration of an essentially useful part of our population.
The increased price of butter is related to a number of factors, one of which is the increase in the price of milk. While the increase in the price of butter is to the detriment of a certain section of our community it is essential for another section that the price of milk be kept up. The small farmer, in particular, depends on a very limited income from the sale of milk. If the price of milk is not maintained he will have to turn to other means of earning and so may do away with milk production in this country. If the price of milk is not maintained, we shall be forced to look for butter from other sources. I move the adjournment of the debate.