We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Committee on Finance. - Financial Resolution No. 2. Excise Duties on Mechanically Propelled Vehicles.

Contributions 174–382 of 382. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy Rooney.

Comment on this

I happen to be on the Dublin County Council and I happen to watch these figures very carefully.

Comment on this

Keep your ears open in future.

Comment on this

I say very definitely that the more money that comes from the Road Fund to county councils the more money the ratepayers will have to pay in relation to it. The less money that comes from the Road Fund the less money that will be required from the ratepayers in connection with the road maintenance and road building programme. That is the test. Ratepayers need not think that if the system remains as it is at the moment the more money that comes from the Road Fund the less they will have to subscribe. That is completely wrong.

Comment on this

I want to draw the attention of the Minister to the seriousness of the situation in County Laois. Very recently the Donoughmore Co-operative Society were given instructions to reconstruct and improve the creamery at Spink, which is near the town of Abbeyleix. The company saw fit to purchase new equipment and plant, and were about to undertake the erection of a new creamery at Spink when their attention was directed to the serious effect that would flow from this Resolution. The Donoughmore Co-operative Society have a number of lorries engaged in collecting milk. It will not pay the society to keep the number of lorries that they operate on the road. The lorries are of the heavier type, in respect of which taxation will be increased to a very great extent under this Resolution. I and other Deputies who represent that constituency have been informed that the Donoughmore Co-operative Society have decided not to proceed with the erection of the creamery. This means that the milk will be left on the hands of the local farmers; that less work will be provided in the area; that drivers and helpers will be disemployed.

I would appeal to the Minister to put this matter back for serious consideration by the Government. This decision on the part of the Donoghmore Co-operative Society will have a very serious effect in the southern parts of my constituency and in North Kilkenny, where the society purchase milk from the farmers. If the Donoughmore Co-operative Society are compelled to tax their lorries at the proposed new very high rate, the services of some of their employees will have to be dispensed with.

I view this matter with grave concern. On behalf of the Donoughmore Co-operative Society, I protest in the strongest possible manner against the very serious inconvenience that will be caused by this very heavy additional burden of taxation.

I would remind the Minister of the case of the jute factory at Clara, Offaly. The firm of Goodbody's are the largest employers in the town and the only industrial concern in the area. The company employ practically every available man and woman in the district. The lorries used by this company travel between Waterford and Clara daily. The company are considering laying off the drivers and helpers on the lorries. That will have a very serious effect on the firm, both in Waterford and Clara. On behalf of that concern, I make the strongest possible protest. I protest on behalf of every worker employed by Goodbody's in Clara. Some of these workers are bound to lose their employment as a result of the proposals which the Minister has put to the House.

The firm of Goodbody's have a number of lorries, apart from the heavy type of lorries that they operate between Clara and Waterford, which will be severly taxed as a result of these proposals.

Any time Deputy Major de Valera speaks in this House he expresses his views coolly and calmly. He is one of the few Deputies of the Fianna Fáil Party who can address this House without insulting his opponents or hurting their feelings.

I want to point out that, whilst I give Deputy Vivion de Valera all the credit due to him for the manner in which he deals with political opponents, he must be dishonest with himself. Like Deputy Colm Gallagher, I can only compare him to Mohammed's coffin, neither up nor down, or to Lannah Machree's dog, to which Deputy Cowan has been compared on many occasions—that goes a bit of the road with everybody but the whole of the road with no one. Here they are, worried about the plight and the serious inconvenience of every hackney owner and taximan in Dublin —why? Because Deputy Vivion de Valera and Deputy Colm Gallagher knew that Mr. Kelly, the secretary of the Hackney Owners' Association was in the Gallery listening.

Comment on this

A Cheann Comhairle, I understood ever since I came into this House that there was to be no reference to who was or was not in the Gallery.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

It is quite undesirable to make reference to people in the Gallery.

Comment on this

I want to point out, with respect, that in order to get into the good books of the association of the hackney owners, it was necessary for the Deputy and his colleague, Deputy Gallagher, to place on record their sympathy; but I, with all respect, ask in the presence of every Deputy here, Deputy Colm Gallagher and Deputy Vivion de Valera to show their practical sympathy, their genuine sympathy, their real regret at the inconvenience being caused to the hackney owners, by voting against this. I believe that they will be found in the Division Lobby with the Minister for Local Government in order to put those people out of business, while at the same time they say: "We are sorry you are being put out of business." They will walk into the Division Lobby to make sure they are put out of business. I can safely say that that type of tactics has not been carried on on this side of the House. Any speeches that have been made on this side are speeches of sincerity, of genuineness, from the hearts of the Deputies who make them.

Comment on this
Pádraig Mac Gabhann

Maith thú.

Comment on this

I am glad the Minister is applauding that, as he certainly must know and realise that the speeches which his colleagues have made are speeches they have made for the purpose of placing their sympathy on record and that they have no intention whatever of implementing in practice the meaning of their speeches.

Comment on this
Pádraig Mac Gabhann

Cuidiú le Cumann na nGaedheal.

Comment on this

I was not in the House when Cumann na nGaedheal was in the House, but the Minister was and I am sure he has very happy memories of the days when Cumann na nGaedheal was fighting a very tough battle in the House. When the Minister was advocating disorder and discontent in this House, Cumann na nGaedheal was establishing law and order and putting a good many rowdies in their places.

Comment on this

Deputy Flanagan was a member of Fianna Fáil at that time.

Comment on this

And Deputy Cowan was in the Labour Party.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I want to hear something about the Resolution and the amendment and not a general criticism of Parties and people.

Comment on this

I have sympathy with you in carrying out your duty.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I will endeavour to carry it out without sympathy.

Comment on this

I want to cooperate with the Chair.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Thank you.

Comment on this

The Minister for Local Government has interrupted in the course of my address. I was endeavouring, before the Minister interrupted, to point out that he knows quite well that the speeches that have been made by his colleagues are speeches that carry no weight and are for the records of the House only, that any Deputy opposite who has made a speech in favour of the lorry owners or hackney owners or any other concern that is going to suffer as a result of this legislation knows quite well that the Party whip is on and he must vote for it.

I am sure that Deputy Davin will agree with me when I say that in his native district, Rathdowney in Laois, the brewery—which is the only source of employment in Rathdowney, which gives employment to a large number of workers, which has given lifelong and good service in solving any unemployment problem that would arise—will be very seriously affected as a result of the Minister's legislation; and on behalf of Messrs. Perry, Rathdowney, I desire to take this opportunity to protest against this severe and brutal tax that this firm will have to pay in order to keep lorries on the road. Everyone knows that Perry's Ale is transported by lorry to every town in the south of Ireland and to other areas as well.

Comment on this

To the west.

Comment on this

And to the west. I can assure the Minister, and I am sure Deputy Davin will agree on this, that Perrys, Rathdowney could not afford to pay the tax on all the lorries they have on the road at the present time.

Comment on this

On a point of order, the Deputy has now mentioned three private concerns, owners of businesses, one after another, taking them town by town in his own constituency and the suggestion is that those firms of repute and standing are unable to meet their obligations.

Comment on this

That is not so.

Comment on this

I put it to you, Sir, that that is the interpretation to be taken from these remarks and I suggest to you that it is improper to mention names of individual firms in the manner in which they have been mentioned by the Deputy.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I understand the Deputy is making the case that because they use heavy lorries and motor traction they will not be able to meet the impost of taxation that is proposed.

Comment on this

Yes, certainly, you understand quite rightly.

Comment on this

I am suggesting that before the names of private firms are brought into a debate like this the Deputy bringing them in should have authority from those firms.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I agree that the names of firms should not be used at all as extensively as they are here, except with the express authority of the firms concerned. It is quite undesirable that a person or business should be discussed here in that fashion.

Comment on this

I would not dream, Sir, of mentioning the name of any firm in this debate without the full sanction of that firm. I have been approached by Messrs. P. & H. Egan, of Tullamore, by Messrs. D. E. Williams of Tullamore; I have been approached by their employees—and I consider the employees of any concern more important to me than the directors.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

They may be important, but they are not responsible for the condition of the firm, the financial position, and the administration of the firm, which is a very important matter for any firm.

Comment on this

You are quite right, Sir, but on each occasion on which I have disclosed the name of any firm, they admit publicly they are anxious to avoid these additional taxes and cannot pay them, or cannot afford to pay them. On last Sunday in Tullamore I was approached by one of the directors of P. & H. Egan, and was given permission to mention that firm as one firm in this House. The same refers, and Deputy O'Higgins and Deputy Davin know, to the Donoughmore Creameries, who have written to the Deputies for the constituency asking that these matters be ventilated. We all know quite well that all those concerns, as Deputy Cowan has referred to them, give good employment, both Perrys of Rathdowney and Salts (Ireland), Limited of Tullamore. The seriousness of it for Salts (Ireland), Limited is this. As the Minister and the House will realise, they have a number of heavy type vans on the road for the purpose of bringing their employees from other towns into Tullamore to work in the mills. It is now going to mean that the employees living in towns surrounding Tullamore will not be taken into the mills, because there is the possibility that it will not pay the company to tax the heavy type vans they use for transporting the workers, and it is going to mean unemployment in those areas.

The Minister for Local Government knows—and we all know—that in the constituency of Laois-Offaly at the moment we have enough of Fianna Fáil monuments. Mountmellick Maltings, a lasting monument to Fianna Fáil, closed down. Belmont railway station closed down. Clara railway station is on the verge of closing down. Ferbane railway station is closed down as is also Banagher railway station. The toy factory in Portlaoighise closed down and the Roscrea-Birr railway is in danger.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I do not see how that is relevant to this Resolution.

Comment on this

I want to ensure that no more concerns go out of business. This type of legislation is only driving concerns out of business, factories out of business and workers out of employment. It is driving people to paying higher taxation who cannot afford to do it.

We believe that this is an unnecessary tax. It is a tax that can be avoided. It is a tax that should be avoided and it is a tax that was avoided when the inter-Party Government was in office. To us on this side of the House goes the credit for giving more employment, more work in industry, more work in agriculture and more work in business and less taxation. We did that successfully for three and a half years.

Again, I want to take this opportunity of expressing my protest, and in order to express my protest in a practical manner I am, unlike Deputy Gallagher and Deputy Vivion de Valera, prepared to back up my protest by my vote. I am prepared to vote against this legislation. I challenge Deputy Gallagher and Deputy Vivion de Valera that I will be prepared to meet them any time or any night at the meeting of the Dublin hackney owners and I guarantee that I will give them a job to explain why they expressed sympathy with them to-night and yet voted against relieving them.

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D.J. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

With the others who have spoken to-night, I wish to assure the House that I will not detain it for long. It is acknowledged by Deputies on all sides of the House that the taxi owners of Dublin and hackney owners throughout the country have been very badly hit. Appeals have come from members of the Fianna Fáil Party but they had no effect. It now remains to be seen whether they will support the case they made in the House by voting in opposition to the impost which this Resolution will mean to the taxi owners of Dublin.

I agree with Deputy Gallagher but I do not agree that Dublin hackney owners should get any more favourable assistance than the hackney drivers throughout the country, all of whom have to pay very heavy costs in the maintenance of their vehicles. The fact that they are away from home increases their financial liabilities. Since we spoke on the increased cost of drivers' licences, two particular towns in my own constituency are very much concerned at the moment in relation to transport. It is acknowledged by many members of this House and by people in the country that there is a designed effort, a distinct intention, in this legislation to drag many of the heavy vehicles off the road and divert them to the railways. Why should two of the five towns in my constituency, with a population of over 1,000, be deprived of rail facilities. Why should the traders in those towns be denied the opportunity of transporting their goods by rail? Why should all the cattle that are sold in Kanturk and the pigs and other agricultural produce put up for sale at the markets be diverted to the roads at a time when there is in this Resolution an effort to make it impossible for the people at present engaged in road transport to carry on their business? We feel that the people are certainly up against it inasmuch as the Minister has turned a deaf ear to their appeal. Before the year is out, there will be increased costs in every Government Department if this legislation is passed to-night.

Comment on this

I am just wondering what all the rush is about after so many days' discussion.

Comment on this

Where is the rush?

Comment on this

Is it not plain that orders have gone out to finish quickly?

Comment on this

I did not see any order.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Higgins

Our only interest was to hear Deputy Cowan defending the taximen.

Comment on this

And see which way the Deputy is going to vote.

Comment on this

We want to give him an opportunity of voting too.

Comment on this

I am glad that we have had this discussion because quite a number of views have been expressed by different Deputies in regard to this whole problem of road maintenance, road construction and road improvements. This evening we had a statement from Deputy Rooney which, I think, will cause considerable surprise even to those of us in the House who have heard him speak on many occasions here.

His proposition was an outstanding one, that the more money the central authority gives to a local authority for road improvement the more money the county council or local authority will themselves have to spend for that purpose and the more money the ratepayers of that local authority will have to provide.

Comment on this

That is quite right.

Comment on this

That is Deputy Rooney's proposition.

Comment on this

In proposition.

Comment on this

In other words, the more money the Dublin County Council get from the Road Fund the more money the ratepayers of County Dublin will have to provide for road improvement.

Comment on this

That is right.

Comment on this

Deputy Rooney says: "That is right," notwithstanding the fact that the Minister told him clearly that it was entirely wrong, but even if the Minister never said that, one's common sense would lead one to a completely opposite conclusion. What is Deputy Rooney's point?

Comment on this

Suppose they have to put up 10 per cent.?

Comment on this

There is no obligation on them to put up any per cent.

Comment on this

There is.

Comment on this

Of course there is, but Deputy Cowan does not know it.

Comment on this

Everyone knows that county council grants are free grants.

Comment on this

Yes, everybody knows it.

Comment on this

That is not so. I am a member of a county council.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy Cowan is entitled to speak without interruption.

Comment on this

When Deputy Rooney has spent a little time longer in the Dublin County Council——

Comment on this

I am longer on a local authority than the Deputy.

Comment on this

——and when he takes a sufficiently keen interest in the financial affairs of the county council he will find that the contention he made to-night has no foundation in fact. Of course, Deputy Rooney has to consider the people he purports to represent in this House, the farmers of North County Dublin.

Comment on this

I got the first seat and the Deputy got the last one.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Higgins

And Deputy Rooney will be in the next House.

Comment on this

The farmers of North County Dublin are the people Deputy Rooney purports to represent. It is an honourable representation.

Comment on this

I represent all sections.

Comment on this

The farmers of North County Dublin will themselves, as intelligent people, realise that under this Resolution, when it is passed into law, there will be a much larger contribution for road improvements from the Central Fund. Consequently, the farmers who are ratepayers will have to contribute less than they might have to contribute, if this Resolution was never passed.

Deputy Rooney had a further extraordinary point to make, that it was unfair that the owners of motor vehicles should have to bear this burden and that other sections of the community should be called upon to bear it. Who does Deputy Rooney want to bear this burden?

Comment on this

I said the Central Fund.

Comment on this

The Deputy says he represents all classes. Does he want the ordinary people in his constituency who have no motor-cars to contribute to it? Does he want the farmers to contribute more than they are contributing? Does he want the ordinary trader in his constituency to contribute more than he is contributing at the moment? If the roads are being used and worn mainly by motor vehicles, and particularly the owners of very heavy vehicles which do most damage, why should not the owners of these vehicles pay for the damage they do to the roads?

Comment on this

They are.

Comment on this

Does Deputy Rooney think that the people with the horses and carts or the person with the bicycle should be taxed so as to relieve the obligation which this Resolution imposes on the owners of motor vehicles? There is altogether too much loose thinking in regard to this whole problem. It has always been the contention of the farmers and farmers' representatives that the main responsibility for the upkeep and improvement of roads should be on the shoulders of those who do the damage to the roads. That has always been put forward by representatives of farmers and, when that provision is being made in this Resolution, we have a Deputy who, as I say, purports to represent farmers, saying that it is wrong that the burden should be placed on the people who wear and damage the roads and that it should be put on the shoulders of the cyclists, as Deputy Flanagan suggested the other day——

Comment on this

I did not make any such suggestion.

Comment on this

——or the owners of horse carts.

Comment on this

Deputy Cowan has accused me of suggesting that cyclists should be taxed. I now want him to produce from the records any such suggestion by me. I made no such suggestion.

Comment on this

The first suggestion we had in this House, in living memory——

Comment on this

On a point of order, Sir——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I am not unmindful of what the Deputy has said. I will deal with it in my own time.

Comment on this

The first suggestion in living memory that cyclists might be brought within special taxation was a question addressed to the Minister the other day.

Comment on this

That is not so. The first suggestion came from the Garda Review and was published in the Irish Independent of this week.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Higgins

As a result of a Fianna Fáil meeting.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy Flanagan has denied that he made any suggestion that cyclists should be taxed. Unless Deputy Cowan is prepared to substantiate his statement by quotation from a statement by Deputy Flanagan, he will withdraw the remark.

Comment on this

Deputy Flanagan was perfectly correct.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Higgins

Is the remark withdrawn?

Comment on this

Of course, I withdraw the remark. The Deputy did not make the suggestion, but he gave currency within this House by means of Parliamentary Question that cyclists might be taxed.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Higgins

He endeavoured to ensure that it would not take place.

Comment on this

I am making sure that it will not take place.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Higgins

Perhaps we could hear Deputy Cowan on the Dublin taximen now.

Comment on this

Deputy Cowan has not very much more to say but he proposes to say it in his own way.

Comment on this

About the Dublin taximen.

Comment on this

Does Deputy Rooney suggest that the cyclists of County Dublin should be made to bear more taxes for their use of the roads? Does he suggest that the owners of horse vehicles should have to bear a special tax for road improvement? What does he suggest when he says it is wrong to make the owners of motor vehicles carry the burden? I suggest that Deputy Rooney has no idea at all of what he has been talking about.

Comment on this

I am opposing this increase.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Higgins

Now we will hear Deputy Cowan on the Dublin taximen.

Comment on this

There has been quite a spate of talk about the effects on employment of the implementation of this Resolution. Obviously its implementation will mean better and more continuous employment on road maintenance and improvement and every Deputy will realise that that is something desirable. Some counties have a good record of road improvement and maintenance and others have not, but, generally speaking, all counties have now awakened to the fact that it was very bad economy to save, or to attempt to save, as they considered, money in regard to roads. The very people Deputy Rooney suggests he represents, the farmers——

Comment on this

I did not suggest I represented them.

Comment on this

——where they had control of a local authority, whenever an estimate came in for road improvements at the annual meeting, were the first to suggest that, no matter what the county engineer's recommendation was, it should be cut by £3,000, £4,000 or £5,000.

Comment on this

And more.

Comment on this

In many cases, more.

Comment on this

And they would be the first to pay.

Comment on this

We have got an understanding from the Minister that this Road Fund which is now to be increased will be available entirely for road improvement, and that there will be no raids on it in future for other purposes. That is something every Deputy will agree with.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Higgins

Do you accept that?

Comment on this

It is accepted.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Higgins

By whom?

Comment on this

I am asking is it accepted by every Deputy?

Comment on this

Are you cocksure of it?

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D.J. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

Is it accepted by the Minister for Finance?

Comment on this

I am accepting the undertaking given by the Minister.

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D.J. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

Which Minister?

Comment on this

The Minister for Local Government.

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D.J. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

It is a matter for the Minister for Finance.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy Cowan is entitled to speak without interruption. There has been a barrage of interruptions since he rose. I will have to insist that he be heard without interruption.

Comment on this

He is insisting on answers.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

He must be heard without interruption. He is not insisting on answers, and no Deputy can insist on answers.

Comment on this

He is doing the devil's advocate in any case.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I will have to take action, unless there is a change of attitude.

Comment on this

I take it that every Deputy agrees that that should be so in regard to the Road Fund, and that there should be no raids on it for the purpose of balancing Budgets or otherwise. There has been no raid on it this year, nor was there last year.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Higgins

There was.

Comment on this

Not last year.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Higgins

There was.

Comment on this

There will be no raid on it, I understand from the assurance given by the Minister, in the future.

Comment on this

There will be a raid on the taxpayers.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy Rooney takes no notice of the injunctions of the Chair. I will insist on it from now on.

Comment on this

We have reached a stage in our development when we agree that it is vitally necessary for the conduct of the business of this nation that we should have good roads, and it will put the Government to the pin of their collar to keep the roads good, even with the amounts made available by the increase in the rates of taxation envisaged in this Resolution. I am one of those who believe that the realities ought to be faced, and the reality is that the roads must be improved. The railways are out of date. Parts of the railways are being closed down now, and nobody will suggest that they should be kept open.

Comment on this

The Deputy is wrong there, anyway.

Comment on this

Nobody will suggest it.

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D.J. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

There is a silly man talking.

Comment on this

I will suggest it.

Comment on this

Nobody will suggest it. The branch lines in this country, as well as in other countries, are disappearing. Nothing can stop that, because it is in progress.

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D.J. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

Is it?

Comment on this

We have many methods of transport that we had not 40 years ago. Even the shipping service is being hard hit by the development of aeroplanes.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy seems to be travelling a bit.

Comment on this

He is up in the air.

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D.J. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

He is airborne.

Comment on this

That may have some effect in the future on road maintenance and, in fact, on the railways.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

It will not affect the Chair—that is definite—in respect to order.

Comment on this

I hope that I did not transgress.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Higgins

Not at all!

Comment on this

I believe that in the future, with the developments that we have and that we can foresee, even in this country a considerable amount of travel will be done by aeroplane within the country.

Comment on this

What about television?

Comment on this

Deputy Davin, just like the rest of us, looks into the future and can see a future in which, perhaps, the last railway engine will be a museum piece in this country.

Comment on this

Hy-Brasil.

Comment on this

Present progress and development, not only here but elsewhere, should be taken into account and, if it were I do not think we would have had the length we have had in this debate.

I have been invited by Deputy O'Higgins to make some reference to the taximen, and I have already on the first Resolution spoken with regard to them. The taximen have not made the case to anybody that they wanted the old rates of tax to remain as Deputy Alfred Byrne suggests in his amendment, nor have they suggested as Deputy MacBride suggests in his amendment that the rates should be 25 per cent. lower than the rates proposed in the Resolution. What they have asked is that the Minister should consider that they have a special case for a flat rate of duty of £20 per annum. That is what the representatives of the taxi and hackney owners have put forward to the Minister and that is what they have asked Deputies to support. I heard Deputy Dunne supporting that to-day. That was the request they made to the Minister, but Deputies, at least some Deputies, think that they can do better than the organised opinion of the representatives of the taxi and hackney owners and have put down two amendments, which they invite us to support.

One is that they should get a 25 per cent. reduction on the new rates. That was Deputy MacBride's suggestion, something not even proposed, something not even suggested, by the representatives of the taxi and hackney owners. Deputy Alfred Byrne puts down an amendment that there should be no alteration in the present rates of duty with regard to taxi and hackney owners, again something which the association has not asked anyone to advocate, recommend or vote for in this House.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Higgins

Does the Deputy think that the association is against that?

Comment on this

I have put forward already and put forward again now what Deputy Dunne put forward to-day and what I have been requested by the Taxi and Hackney Owners' Association to support: that they should have a flat rate of duty and that that flat rate should be £20 per annum. I think that is a reasonable suggestion. I thought, when I first read it, that the representatives of the taxi and hackney owners had taken a sound constructive line and I think that those Deputies who supported that and asked the Minister to consider it sympathetically and seriously are doing more for the taxi and hackney owners than will be done by amendments just drawn out of the hat and put down. Then I am asked by Deputy Rooney to go into the Lobby and vote for something which I have not been asked to support by the representatives of the Taxi and Hackney Owners' Association. Deputies cannot have it both ways. If I had been asked by the association I would have put down an amendment on the lines of their suggestion but we had Deputy MacBride jumping in the moment the Resolution appeared and writing out an amendment to give them a 25 per cent. reduction without any realisation of what they intended and we had Deputy Alfred Byrne following on the next day with an amendment that they were to remain at the old rates of duty. I have not been asked to support that and I have no intention of supporting it.

Comment on this

We knew very well that you had not.

Comment on this

I made it clear myself to the people who consulted me that that was my idea. I think it is possible within this House for Deputies who are seriously interested in a problem to influence a Minister to have a case very fully and very sympathetically considered. That can be done.

Comment on this
Brendan Corish Breanndán Mac Fheórais Labour Party

It would have to depend now on having the balance.

Comment on this

No. This House had an opportunity in regard to the old age pensions increase.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I do not see how that is relevant to the tax.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Higgins

Deputy Cowan is referring to the time he declared war on Fianna Fáil. He should be permitted to do it.

Comment on this

The only relevance is to point out that Deputies of this House can influence a Minister.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I do not want an illustration.

Comment on this

That is as far as I want to do it. Deputy O'Higgins knows that it is possible for Deputies to influence a Minister.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Higgins

It was possible. Look at the Deputies over there. Did you ever influence them?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I do not seem to be capable of influencing the interrupters.

Comment on this

I feel that Deputy Major de Valera, Deputy Gallagher and other Deputies have strongly advocated that the case put forward by the Taxi and Hackney Owners' Association is a fair case, and the Minister has some time to consider that case on its merits. I sincerely hope that that consideration—backed up by the support the case has got in this House from Deputies on all sides— will result in those taxi and hackney owners receiving the request that they have made to the Minister, his representatives and to the Deputies. I do not think it serves a useful purpose for Deputies to suggest that one makes that suggestion to the Minister but does not give two hoots whether or not the Minister agrees with it. Deputies are entitled to say that if they wish but if, every time a Deputy speaks in this House, his motives are to be open to question in that way I do not think it will lead to this House's doing the business of the country in the successful way in which it ought to be done.

Comment on this

What do you want us to do? To speak one way and to vote the other way?

Comment on this

No. The trouble with Deputy Morrissey now is that having rushed back from Clonmel——

Comment on this

I was not in Clonmel.

Comment on this

Having rushed back from somewhere down the country Deputy Morrissey just got in after I had finished making my explanation. I do not think it would be fair to go and repeat it even for such a distinguished member of the House as Deputy Morrissey.

Comment on this

The Deputy is very innocent.

Comment on this

I have made the case very strongly that two amendments which were put down — one by Deputy MacBride and the other by Deputy Byrne—neither of which has been advocated or suggested by the people concerned, the Hackney and Taxi Owners' Association——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy has said that several times.

Comment on this

They will vote for it, you will not.

Comment on this

I said it for the sake of Deputy Morrissey who is a very distinguished member of the House. I wanted to put him clear — coming in, as he does after his long journey.

Comment on this

Put the hackney owners clear. Do not mind Deputy Morrissey.

Comment on this

After all, the debate has been kept going until Deputy Morrissey has come back, so it is only fair that he should come in on the right foot.

Comment on this

I am glad the Deputy is playing his part in keeping the debate going.

Comment on this

I think the Chair will agree that as an example of absolute relevancy I have been superb.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Higgins

Superb!

Comment on this
Brendan Corish Breanndán Mac Fheórais Labour Party

Will the Deputy support an amendment framed on the lines of the request of the Hackney and Taxi Owners' Association?

Comment on this

He will support Fianna Fáil. He has to.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I am putting the amendment.

Comment on this

Surely the Minister will give an explanation?

Comment on this

The Minister was called on before.

Comment on this

I think the Minister intends to intervene.

Comment on this

Surely the Minister should be called upon?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy O. Flanagan is long enough in the House to know that the Chair has not power to force or induce any Deputy to speak who does not wish to do so.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Higgins

That is the second time in two evenings that this has happened.

Comment on this

I would ask——

Comment on this

——on behalf of the Minister.

Comment on this

Sorry.

Comment on this

This happened last night also.

Comment on this
Division

The Committee divided: Tá,

Tá 66
·
Níl 61
Result Carried The question put was agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?

Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

On the amendment on which a decision has just been taken, Deputies were allowed to travel over all the terms of the Resolution. In respect of succeeding amendments, Deputies will be required to keep to the terms of the amendments.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 2:—

Before paragraph (h) to insert a new paragraph as follows:—

(h) Motor vehicles used for questing and owned by charitable institutions supported by public subscriptions and used solely by such charitable institutions shall be exempt from the increases provided in the foregoing paragraphs.

I presume that the Minister is aware that there are a number of charitable institutions solely supported by voluntary subscriptions which care for old and infirm people. There are at least three homes in Dublin run by the Little Sisters of the Poor, one in Cork, and one in Waterford. The cars owned by these communities are used solely for questing for food and other necessaries for the maintenance of the hundreds of old people kept in these homes. Due to the rising costs of all classes of materials, etc., these and similar homes dependent on voluntary support are finding it difficult to meet their commitments for the upkeep of the homes, and if called upon to meet a further burden by the imposition of this tax, these communities will be placed in a very serious position. I, therefore, move that such charitable institutions be exempted from the tax.

Comment on this

The Deputy who has just moved this amendment would, I am sure, be the first to realise that, once you start to consider making exemptions of one kind or another, the list can become a very formidable one. Apart altogether from that consideration, there is the administrative difficulty, the difficulty of determining what particular vehicle and what particular type of charity should be relieved in this fashion. No previous representations have been made to me.

This is an amendment that might, with more effect, be considered on the Committee Stage of the Bill which will follow these Resolutions. I want to say to the House that, whatever the case might be for this or any other similar plea for any particular class, I would have to take the line that, once you give the concession to one particular class, then of course the pressure is increased in order to effect a similar concession in other directions. Although, during the course of this discussion it was charged against me and the Department and, indeed, the Government, that we did not give careful considerations to these proposals, I want the Deputies opposite to take my word that that is not the case. These proposals are the result of a very careful examination carried out by an inter-departmental committee. Indeed, the recommendations of that committee have been modified very substantially by myself and by Government decision. For that reason then, much and all as I dislike having sort of to stand firm, and maybe give the impression to the Deputy making this plea that I do not want to meet the House in any way, I ask him and the House to appreciate my difficulties. I must, therefore, resist this amendment.

Comment on this

Whatever case the Minister may have for resisting the amendment, the reasons which he has given are far from convincing. These were that one of the difficulties of meeting a claim of this kind is that if you start making exemptions you get into difficulties. The House will remember that this year it was presented with a Finance Bill. The purpose of the Finance Bill was to exempt dance-hall proprietors from paying tax on their dance halls, and this House, with its eyes wide open, put £140,000 into the pockets of the dance-hall proprietors in the same way as we are now going to impose increased taxation on motor vehicles owned by charitable organisations which are being kept out of debt, if they are being kept out of debt, by public subscriptions.

It is a bit thick to tell us in the month of October, 1952, that you cannot make exemptions from taxation for charitable organisations which have to run motor vehicles when, in the month of April or May, we handed over £140,000 to dance-hall proprietors with a special exemption for them. Where is the heart of the Minister in the matter? One hundred and forty thousand pounds for dance-hall proprietors as a special exemption, while the unfortunate people who run charitable organisations are going to get the full impact of the Minister's new motor-car taxation proposals. I do not think it is fair.

When the House is dividing on this matter, it ought to remember that we cannot lightly, with any pretext of holding ourselves respectable before the public, in the same year give a grant of £140,000 to dance-hall proprietors and inflict the impact of this taxation on charitable organisations which run motor vehicles. It is unfair to tax these charitable organisations which are doing their best to keep their heads above water. I hope that when Deputy Doyle's amendment is put, the House will show its sympathy with these charitable organisations.

Comment on this

The Minister should not forget that when the price of bread was raised recently there was surreptitiously put on a tax of £110,000, which is going into the Treasury. Under cover of increasing the price of bread there was pinched another £110,000 of additional taxation surreptitiously.

Comment on this

Might I ask Deputy Doyle how many vehicles are concerned in this?

Comment on this

How many dance-hall proprietors are there?

Comment on this

I am asking how many vehicles there are.

Comment on this
Mr. Byrne

Kilmainham Home for the destitute is one of them. If I had time I could give the names of a lot more.

Comment on this

At least two in each home. One tax will be about £16 and another £20.

Comment on this

Is Deputy Cowan objecting to the cost or the number?

Comment on this

I am asking a question.

Comment on this
Division

Amendment put.

Tá 60
·
Níl 66
Result Lost The question put was not agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?

Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Amendments Nos. 3 and 4 seek to effect the same object and they can be discussed together.

Comment on this

Deputy MacBride is not able to be present to-night and has asked me to move amendment No. 3 for him:

Before paragraph (h) to insert a new paragraph as follows:—

(h) notwithstanding anything contained in this Resolution, all the owners of mechanically propelled vehicles which are used solely or mainly as taxis or hackney cars plying for public service shall be entitled to a rebate of 25 per cent. on the rates of duty provided in the Schedule to this Resolution.

The object of the amendment is to provide that the owners of mechanically propelled vehicles which are used solely or mainly as taxis or hackney-cars plying for public service shall be entitled to a rebate of 25 per cent. on the rates of duty provided in the Schedule to the Resolution. In short, the object of the amendment is to provide that the impact of the increased rates of motor taxation will not apply to hackney owners or taxi owners. We all know the general pattern of life of taximen and hackney owners. In the main, they are people who manage to get a small sum of money together and invest that sum in taxis or hackney cars. Those of us who are familiar with their occupations know only too well that they get from the occupations a hardly-earned and precarious livelihood.

In recent years the position in respect of earning a decent livelihood by these two occupations has, if anything, seriously deteriorated; firstly, because of the influx of new persons into the business and, secondly, because, on the hackney owners' side, there is a certain amount of pirating going on. By that I mean individuals taking out a small public service vehicle licence and operating a private car on a public service vehicle licence, using that car in the main for their own private purposes or perhaps using it in order to skim off the creamy traffic that may be going.

In this Resolution the Government are seeking to impose a heavy tax on these hackney and taxi owners. I know nothing in these two callings which entitles us to feel that they are capable of bearing the tax which will be imposed under this Resolution. They are men whose resources are slender and who earn a precarious livelihood and I do not think that in the year in which we have imposed on the people the toughest Budget they have known for the past 30 years we should impose this additional taxation on persons who follow the occupation of hackney or taxi owners. It is unfair that they should be asked to bear this burden in present circumstances, especially having regard to the small return which they get from following these occupations.

Anybody who knows the Dublin taximan knows that he is on the streets morning, noon and night endeavouring to earn a livelihood. There is no livelihood for him unless he can manage to ply for hire at all hours of the day and night. Similarly, with the small hackney owner in the country whose burden in respect of running his car is so heavy that he gets a very meagre livelihood from his occupation. Although we have clear evidence and although abundant evidence can be furnished to the Minister that these two occupations are in no sense remunerative, yet the House is asked to pass this Resolution which imposes a heavy burden on those two particular avocations.

This impost is an unfair one on people with such slender resources, and if there were a free vote of this House there certainly would be such sympathy with the taxi and hackney owners that the House would express itself in favour of waiving this new burden so far as these two classes are concerned. I cannot understand how the Minister can be impervious to appeals for relief for these two classes. I believe there is widespread sympathy on all sides of the House with the claim made in this amendment. If the Minister wants to test the real feeling of the House on the matter he ought to leave the amendment to a free vote of the House.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Byrne's amendment is also being discussed with Deputy MacBride's.

Comment on this
Mr. Byrne

My amendment asks for complete exemption for taxi and hackneymen. I know of the conditions just outlined by Deputy Norton. These men are working 12 hours a day and until the early hours of the morning. This is the same as putting a tax on workmen's tools. You first tax their bread and butter and their household goods. You tax their tyres and their petrol and their oil, and then you tax the machine which they use to earn their living and to pay the other taxes. I appeal to the Minister to exempt taxis and hackneys from this extra taxation. If the Minister will not exempt them completely, I ask him to accept the recommendation of the taximen's association for a £20 flat rate. There are at least six Deputies of his own Party, whom I could name, but it would not be right, who promised faithfully that they would approach the Minister and ask him to accept the £20 flat rate. Deputy Moran yesterday, Deputy de Valera to-day and Deputy Gallagher, pleaded with the Minister for these men. Deputy de Valera said that the taximen had a splendid case, and had a claim on his generosity. Deputy Norton asked for a free vote of the House, which he is not likely to get. If the Minister does not wish to give way to the Opposition, at least he should give way to the pressure put on him by his own followers, who were approached in the country, and gave a definite guarantee to these men that they would see that their means of livelihood was not further taxed.

As I say, Deputy Moran pleaded with the Minister yesterday and Deputy de Valera to-day made an earnest plea to him, and I think Deputy Cowan also made an appeal. Yet the Minister will not listen to these Deputies who know the conditions under which these men work.

If I can challenge a division on my amendment that there should be complete exemption for them I will do so. I ask the Minister, however, if he cannot give a complete exemption at least to accept the recommendation of the taximen's association for a £20 flat rate for hackneys and taxicabs, which are at present so heavily over-burderned, and give them an opportunity to continue in their business. Most of these men were in the National Army and got a gratuity, having served the country well. They put their gratuities into taxis and hackney cars and now the Minister is driving them out of business, and they will get nothing for their cars. I support the appeal made by the other members of the House.

Comment on this

I have already, in the course of this discussion, dealt fairly fully with the pleas that I admit have been advanced to me in the House and to pleas that have been made to me within the past few weeks by all the interests, I might say, that are affected by these proposals. We have disposed of an amendment by Deputy Doyle, in which he sought to relieve charitable institutions. I was pressed by interests who were concerned about taxi owners throughout the country. Both from outside this House and in this House pleas were made to me that I should exempt certain types of lorries and exempt certain types of owners. Now there are members of this House who are members of local bodies and, as has been pointed out here by Government speakers, the question I must ask myself is—Is it reasonable to permit a situation to continue in the case of taxis, hackneys and lorries in which the charges fixed upon these vehicles were determined as far back as 1926, when costs were entirely different from what they are to-day and while the rates struck by the different local bodies in the country for the maintenance and the making of roads have increased by 100 per cent. since 1939? Is it reasonable to suggest that, with these growing costs and with the growing pressure of the increased traffic from motor-cars, lorries and all such vehicles on our roads, we should allow a system of taxation to prevail that was determined as far back as 1926?

It is all very well for Deputies of this House to make pleas to me. It is their duty to make those pleas whether they are members of the Party to which I belong or members of the Opposition. They often come to me privately and they often make the case that perhaps here is a class that should be met in such and such a way; here is a class that should be treated differently from all other classes. If I have to set myself out, as I had to in this case, to increase the Road Fund by a certain amount—and I did not manage to make the round figure of £1,000,000 per annum—I must, having considered the interests of every class and the extent to which they will be affected by the proposals, resist those pleas.

Let me say this in regard to the hackney owners and the taxi owners. The concessions which they obtained in the Supplementary Budget of 1947 were extended to them because of the special circumstances which existed at the time in regard to them. There was no protest made previously because of the fact that taxis and hackney cars were treated on the same basis as private cars from 1926 to 1947. As I admitted in the course of the discussion here every day, when any class get a concession such as was given to the taxi owners and hackney owners in 1947, it is only natural that they would strive to hold on to those concessions. But, just as in the case of other vehicles, in regard to which an amendment which we will come to later proposes to deal, I do not think a real case can be made having regard to the necessities of the Road Fund, having regard to the condition of our roads, having regard to the cost of road improvement and road maintenance, and having regard to the fact that the tax on those vehicles was fixed as far back as 1926 except for the increase that was imposed on private cars in 1947.

Looking at my responsibility and looking at the responsibility of local bodies all over the country, and listening to all the clamour that I hear day in and day out while the Dáil is sitting, asking me to contribute more substantially from the Road Fund, to contribute to Youghal Bridge, to the bridge in Wexford, to Gweebarra Bridge in Donegal, to provide funds for one purpose or another, I am sure that no reasonable person will deny the necessity for increased funds being made available. Deputy Norton's speech drew my attention to the fact that there was some unemployment among road workers in his area.

He sought to influence me to make a special grant in the case of the county he represents, although the entire sum of money in the Road Fund this year had been allotted to the different county councils. In reply to those who question me as to whether or not the funds which I am endeavouring to get to-day will be used for the purpose of repairing and maintaining roads, I can at least point to the Road Fund for this year and say I have established here for the first time in years the principle of giving, and I have persuaded the Government for the first time in years to give, the entire Road Fund for the making of our roads. I do not like to resist all those pleas that have been made to me. I do not want to be obliged to take up the position of fighting every corner and resisting every plea. That is really not my nature. If I could dissociate my responsibility from what is my nature I would not deserve the description sometimes applied to me of being rigid and unbending. I must resist those pleas because I know the money is required. In asking this House to give me the money for the purpose I have stated, I will give a guarantee to the House that while I am responsible for local government my behaviour will be in accordance with my performance this year and I will struggle to see that every penny that comes into that fund will be used for the purpose for which it was put in there. The roads of our country are crying out for more money now. It must be got in some way and as far as these proposals are concerned we have examined them very carefully indeed and we are imposing the tax without doing any real hardship to any deserving case.

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

Would not the re-imposition of the dance tax pay for all this?

Comment on this

I was discussing the Road Fund. The dance tax was discussed here. It was discussed in three by-elections down the country and you can discuss it on the hustings again as much as you will. I am here to do the nation's business and the nation's work as I see it. I do not want any irrelevancies introduced into this discussion. I am making a plea for a deserving cause and I am taking a stand for a worthy cause. That is why I am asking all the tender hearts pleading for one section or another to see the reasonableness of my approach to what our problems are.

Let us see what the additional hardships are, and, mind you, I admit that in the case of hackneymen and taximen, every shilling counts. That is the case with the ordinary working man, too. I am not denying that, but let us see if there is as much in the claim that has been made by Deputies during the course of this discussion. I will give you some figures that have been supplied to me by the Hackney and Taxi Owners' Association, showing their methods to keep their business going. These are their own figures:— Weekly outlay on taxi: garage rent, 12s. 6d.; maintenance, 5/-; workmen's compensation, 3/-; petrol, £4 19s. 2d.; oils, 10s. 6d.; depreciation, £1 5s.; insurance, £1 7s.; p.s.v. licence, 1s. 6d.; total, £9 3s. 8d. That is the burden the taximan has to carry in the ordinary way. These are his overheads. Now, add road tax and driving licence, 4/- per week. The total addition to his overheads arising from road tax and driving licence amounts to 4/- a week.

I admit that 4/- a week can be an important item to a working man, but it is extravagant to suggest that, if a man's overheads are already £12 13s. 8d., the addition of 4/- will put him out of his business. This 4/- is important, but that claim is complete and absolute exaggeration.

I ask the members of the House to stand firmly behind these proposals, because, as I have already said, most of them, during the past years, have been advocating increased expenditure on roads. Most of the Deputies who are criticising me now will be back in this House next week or the week after —and they are entitled—asking me parliamentary questions as to why bridges are not built, roads are not made and more money is not made available. They must realise that money can be provided for these purposes from only two sources, the rates on the county they represent and the Road Fund. The rates for roads have gone up 100 per cent. since 1939.

These taxes have not been moved, except in the case of private cars, since 1926. If political considerations are eliminated, and if Deputies could speak according to the dictates of their hearts on these matters, I know which way Deputies, especially those who are members of county councils and who hear the complaints of the ratepayers in regard to the rates, would vote when the division bell rings and the count is taken.

Comment on this

I think the list of expenses that the Minister gave did not include the existing road tax.

Comment on this

The list of expenses that I gave was the list supplied by the taxi owners themselves.

Comment on this
Denis O'Sullivan Mr. D.J. O'Sullivan Fine Gael

The Minister did not include the increase in the cost of living on the hackney owner and his wife and family.

Comment on this

I support the amendments moved by Deputy MacBride and Deputy Byrne. The speech to which we have just listened boils down to this: "The hackney and taximan have made a case showing the load they are carrying and have asked me to relieve them of some of the load." The Minister's reply is: "No, I will put more on you. I will weigh you down more." That is the Fianna Fáil philosophy throughout the country—to tax and tax and, if you grumble or growl, to put more taxation on you. That is an astounding situation. The Minister barefacedly admits that he has the figures that the hackneymen gave him to show that they should be relieved of some of the burden. He comes in here and says that because there was no change since 1926 he will put more on them. He says that if the people could vote according to their consciences they would vote fully with him. If he wants to test that, let the consciences operate, take off the Whips.

Comment on this

The Whips are on all around you, always.

Comment on this

Yes, because you are going to make sure that these Resolutions will pass. This is a question on which people are being challenged that they are not voting according to their consciences. I say, give them the chance of voting according to their consciences; take off the Whips and let us see how local authority representatives will vote. I support the amendment and I ask the House to accept it. I ask the people who spoke on behalf of the hackney car and taxi owners to support it.

Comment on this

I support the amendments. With Deputy Byrne and Deputy MacEoin I appeal to the Minister to allow a free vote of the House in this matter. When the Minister quoted that figure of 4/- a week, in respect of road tax and driving licences, what horse-power car was he referring to?

Comment on this

That is the point.

Comment on this

Surely he was not referring to a car of a higher horse-power than ten? The average taxi owner and hackney owner pays at least from £16 to £20 and will now have to pay at least £6 per car. The figure given by the Minister is misleading inasmuch as it applies only to ten horse-power cars, very few of which are in use as small public service vehicles.

I remind the Minister that the majority of taxi owners or hackney car owners are not wealthy. The proof that their occupation is not over-remunerative is the fact that very few of them continue operating these cars for a very long time. In many cases they are people who are not very robust and who engage in this enterprise as being a light form of work. The Minister represents a rural constituency. Has he adverted to the fact that a hackney car performs a very useful service in a locality?

I would put two points before the Minister. In many cases, ex-soldiers, ex-civic guards and other retired persons who are not fit for other work engage in this business. The second point is that these people are already paying tax on petrol. If the Minister wants money for the Road Fund, I would appeal to him not to place this burden on a section of the community that is not able to bear it.

Comment on this

The Minister put on a Casabianca act to-night. The heroism of Casabianca has nothing on the Minister this evening. The Minister was the one person who had so re-organised the Road Fund that, in future, everybody could look with pride to the Road Fund, even though it is now going to be built up by additional taxation to the tune of £800,000 some of which is to be got by asking an ordinary motor driver to pay more for his licence, by making the hackneyman and the taximan pay more for his road licence and by making a whole lot of small people in the transport industry pay additional taxation. The Minister takes pride in the fact that he is building up a Road Fund by imposing these burdens on a lot of relatively small people.

I was rather amazed at the analysis which the Minister made of the burdens which are at present imposed on taxi owners. The taxi owners apparently went to the Minister and said: "Look here, Minister, have a look at the taxes we are compelled to pay out of the total of £500 a year to keep a taxi going" and they asked would the Minister meet their viewpoint. They were told: "You come here with a grievance saying you are opposed to more taxes on your taxis; go away out of that; look at the burdens you are bearing already; do not annoy me, my main concern is to build up a Road Fund by another £800,000." That was a cheery message for every sufferer going to the Minister.

Comment on this