Adoption Bill, 1952—From Seanad. - Supplies and Services (Temporary Provisions) Act, 1946 (Continuance) Bill, 1952—Second Stage (Resumed).
Contributions 118–258 of 258. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 11 of 1952 ›
It is not true, and I am glad that one member of the Fine Gael Party will agree in asserting that it is not true.
Comment on this
The problems of this country are no greater than, and not much different from those of other countries. I think it is possible to demonstrate that we here are making more successful efforts to cope with them than many other European nations. That effort will succeed, in the course of time, if the Deputies opposite will stop peddling discontent. We have got to get our people to realise that there is a job to be done and to get them to understand that they have the strength to do it. We have got to urge them to do it instead of hawking grievances around the place so that they will be discouraged from even making an attempt.
Before going on to deal in a precise statistical way with these problems of ours, there are a few general remarks that I want to make. When this Government took office, it knew well that the measures it would have to adopt to remedy the deplorable state of the national finances, to restore the national economy and to get productive activity going in the right direction, would not be pleasant. We were fully aware that, in adopting these measures, we would be prejudicing our political future. We knew that whatever steps we took could not produce the results we expected from them, the beneficial results for the people of this country, for some time, and that the people would not realise in the immediate present how necessary or how beneficial they were until the results we anticipated from them were visible. We intend to see, so far as it is in our power to do it, that they will get the time, and that is the answer to Deputy Morrissey's question.
Comment on this
——is clear, definite and positive. We think that the circumstances of this country require a Government with a policy of that kind. We did not make our decision for the purpose of hanging on to office. We made it for the purpose of ensuring that there will not get into office a Government that would represent nothing more than a collection of diversified grievances, with no policy and no clear objectives, a Government which would be formed from a coalition of the Parties sitting opposite, and which would come in hamstrung with promises impossible of fulfilment. We are going, if we can, to save the country from that fate.
The Coalition Government which, we are told, brought all these benefits to the country, left office in 1951 voluntarily. Why did they do it? Deputy Bartley, the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Agriculture, asked that question, and it is a very pertinent question: Why did that Government in 1951, without being defeated in the Dáil, nevertheless dissolve the Dáil and go to the country?
Comment on this
Do you want to know? To get out of Deputy Dr. Browne and Deputy Peadar Cowan. That is why.
Comment on this
I repeat that the Government had not been defeated in the Dáil. There was no compulsion on it because of a Dáil situation to dissolve and go to the country at that time. What was the situation in which they did it? May I remind Deputy O'Leary and the Deputies opposite of the situation? The Minister for Finance in the Coalition Government, Deputy McGilligan, brought here the Budget statement of 1951. In accordance with the normal practice of the Dáil the debate on that Budget statement was adjourned until the next day on which the Dáil would sit. The Dáil never got a chance of sitting again. Without warning it was dissolved that night.
Comment on this
For what reason was that done? For this reason, that the Coalition Government, and their Minister for Finance, knew quite well that their Budget was a fake, and they dared not allow it to be examined in detail by the Dáil.
Comment on this
They knew that they had so presented the national accounts to the House that they were concealing their failure to make adequate provision for revenue in the financial year to meet the outgoings to which they were committed. We discovered that for ourselves within a week after becoming the Government in June of that year. We found then that the maximum revenue anticipated from the taxes that they imposed fell short of the minimum commitments in respect of expenditure which that Government had undertaken by several million pounds. We knew that the job, the unpleasant job, of proposing new taxes to the Dáil to close that gap was going to be ours.
We are told that these new taxes are harsh and impose a burden on the people. In so far as I can, I am going to ensure that the responsibility for that situation will rest where it belongs—upon that cowardly Government which, rather than face their responsibilities in that year, tricked the Dáil with a faked Budget that was followed immediately by a dissolution. They knew more than that. They knew that the very exceptional facilities which they had given for the import of manufactured goods in the previous month were bound to produce a trade slump in a number of important Irish industries. They must have realised, when they gave special licences for the import of 4,000,000 square yards of woven cloth, that, in the course of time, orders to the Irish woollen mills would dry up. When they gave their special licence for 1,000,000 nylon stockings—stockpiling against an emergency we are told— they must have realised that in due course the orders to Irish hosiery factories would be curtailed. They realised that the trade slump which they are now blaming on the present Government was bound to come following upon the measures they took, and they tried to dodge responsibility for that also.
They knew another thing. They knew that, in the last three months of their term of office, the cost of living was going up at an unprecedented rate. Deputy Norton, in the course of this debate, said that the last published index number for the cost of living while his Government was in power was 102. That was the index number for February of that year, but they did not leave office until June, and there was another index number for mid-May. They took good care, however, to go to the country before it appeared, because in that last quarter, without any withdrawal of subsidies and with the Government then in office doing nothing but sitting back and looking on, the cost of living, measured by the index number, went up by the same number of points as it went up consequent on the withdrawal of subsidies in this year—by seven points.
Comment on this
We took over a situation, as I have said, in which we knew that we had to make a choice between straightforward action to protect the national interests and our own Party advantage. We made that choice and we do not regret it. It has been suggested in the course of this debate that this Government should resign because their candidate was defeated in a recent by-election. It is ridiculous to suggest that this Government or any Government should resign if they do not win every by-election during their term of office. We know that in by-elections, particularly one caused by a vacancy on the Opposition Benches, where it is obvious that the fate of the Government is not involved, ballyhoo sometimes counts more than logical argument. You had the advantage of that situation in the recent by-election. We regret the result.
May I say that, following on the introduction of the Budget this year and the initiation of these measures to rectify the situation on which we had decided and which we knew would not pay off in benefits to our people for some time, we did not expect to win the by-elections in June last either? We were gratified to find that in two important constituencies it was possible for us so to explain the position to the voters as to secure the return of our candidates.
Comment on this
I am confident that if in any constituency, not excluding North-West Dublin, the electors have to make a choice, not between two candidates at a by-election, but between a Government of the Fianna Fáil type and a Government of the Coalition type, there will be a different result. I want the House to understand our position. We have set the ship of Government on its course and have lashed the wheel. We are concentrating on the tasks immediately to hand. If that ship gets torpedoed on its voyage, we will do the conventional thing and go down with it. We hope it will get to its ultimate destination because, when it gets there, the people will realise that the course has been well set and that the destination is one worth reaching.
Let me turn now to deal with those specific and grave economic and social problems which have been in debate here and with which this Dáil and the country are faced. The cost of living has gone up substantially, and that rise in the cost of living has imposed burdens on the people, burdens which it must be the aim of Government policy to mitigate. Can we get agreement in the Dáil that the cost of living must not be allowed to rise further, that nothing must be allowed to happen which will force it up further, that no cost will be allowed to be increased which will have the effect of making prices go higher? If Deputies are as perturbed as they declare about the rise in the cost of living, it should be possible to get agreement on that proposal. If we cannot get agreement on that proposal, a lot of their talk about the cost of living must be classed as hypocritical.
Comment on this
If this issue of the cost of living is so grave, and I do not deny its gravity, can we get agreement at least on the principle that the policy of the Government must be to prevent its going further no matter what that involves?
Comment on this
I will put more specific questions to the Deputies. They come in here tearing their hair about the rise in the cost of living. When they have gone through that process, they go out into the passage to titivate themselves and then come in to demand a higher price for milk delivered to creameries, a higher price for butter, a higher price for beet involving a higher price for sugar, a higher price for wheat involving a higher price for flour and bread.
Comment on this
There is no hypocrisy about Deputy Cogan. The hypocrisy is over there. The hypocrisy comes from people who are professing to be alarmed about the rise in the cost of living and then come in here demanding that the Government should take measures which will increase it further. Can we get agreement that these measures must not be taken? Will Deputies opposite undertake to withdraw any proposal of that kind that they have made or may intend to make?
Comment on this
Those Deputies are logical. I am trying to get similar logic from the Deputies opposite.
Comment on this
I say to any group of Deputies who come here on alternate days to deplore the rise in the cost of living and to urge measures which will cause it to go higher still that they are either incapable of putting forward a logical policy or they are allowing hypocrisy to determine the character of their speeches here.
We decided upon a reduction in subsidies. Subsidies for food prices were initiated as a temporary device in the post-war period and it was always the aim that they should disappear eventually. Does any Deputy seriously believe that we should maintain food prices subsidies in perpetuity? Do they think it would be wise to do so? Is it not better that we should get reality into our price structure? We realised that the withdrawal of the food subsidies and the rise in the price of certain foodstuffs would cause hardship. In so far as it was in our power to mitigate that hardship we took the appropriate measures. For every class of the community who are depending in any way upon Government subventions under any of the social welfare schemes the amount paid to them was increased by at least the amount that the cost of living had been raised, and in some cases by more. We said that where, over and above those measures, the rise in the price of foodstuffs required adjustment in remuneration, that adjustment should be made.
Deputy MacBride in the course of the debate endeavoured to represent me or some other Minister as saying that there should be no increases in wages. I said the contrary. I said that it was far better that we should get our price level on a basis of reality and adjust wages in relation to that price level rather than that we should maintain the policy of subsidisation.
It was also stated that the current demands for higher wages result solely from the adjustment in food subsidies made in the Budget. That is not true. Every Deputy connected with the labour movement knows it is not true. Long before the Budget was introduced, I personally became involved in discussions between the executive committees of the Congress of Irish Unions and of the Employers' Federation, discussions which ultimately led to a general agreement to regulate the increases in wages. These discussions had their origin in the rise in prices which had taken place in the previous year, and I felt I was in duty bound to tell those who participated in them that when they were engaged in their negotiations they should know that the Government contemplated changes in respect of food subsidies. I did not feel at liberty to tell them more than that but I felt that it was my duty to let them know that they might have a problem of wage adjustment to solve greater than that which was indicated by the cost-of-living index number at that time.
What is the position now and what is the position likely to be in the future? I think it is true to say that only internal factors are causing prices to go up now. The import price index number has fallen fairly consistently since the first quarter of this year. The cost of goods imported into this country and used for industrial and agricultural purposes is tending downwards but the effect of that fall in material costs on our price level is being offset by rising internal costs. There is a fair prospect that when these adjustments in internal costs are completed a position of price stability will be realised.
The Deputies opposite have, however, given to the House and to the country a completely false picture of our price situation. Even Deputy Costello who promised to be scrupulously fair and meticulously accurate on facts said that there had been a rise in the cost of every commodity. Other Deputies read out lists of commodities which had risen in price. Deputy Hickey, I think, chose a number of selected commodities and said that any given quantity of them would cost so much more now than they cost a year ago. I can select commodities which have fallen in price as numerous as those selected by Deputy Hickey and perhaps it is no harm to remind the House that within the overall situation in which the cost-of-living index number has risen, many prices, including prices of important commodities, have come down during the course of this year. The price of coal fell by a pound a ton in Dublin and by varying amounts in other counties.
Comment on this
But it is moving downward now. I am controverting a statement made that in the course of this year the price of every commodity rose.
Comment on this
The price of margarine fell by 5d. a pound, from 1/11 to 1/6; soap has fallen in price; the price of jams has fallen; the price of biscuits and oatmeal has fallen. The price of all classes of fertilisers used by farmers has fallen; motor-cars, tyres and tubes, and cycle tyres and tubes have fallen in price; paints have fallen; clothing of all kinds has fallen.
Comment on this
The clothing price index shows that. Does anybody in the House deny that the price of clothing has come down this year?
Comment on this
I cannot find the figures now for the Deputy. There are a number of other commodities but they are mostly industrial commodities that do not enter into ordinary household use.
Comment on this
I am not denying the cost of living has gone up. I am denying the statement that every commodity has gone up and any Deputy who comes here as the leader of his Party and says he is going to give a picture of the situation which is scrupulously fair and meticulously accurate and does not refer to that fact has failed to achieve the very high standard he set himself.
Comment on this
I did not say the cost of living is going down and I will not be misrepresented by Deputy MacBride's tricks. Keep them for the cross-roads. You will not get away with them here. What I have said is— and these are facts any Deputy can check—that the cost of imported materials is coming down, the import prices index shows that, but the effect of that fall in material costs is being offset by higher wages and higher costs at home; the net result is that a position of price stability may be realised when and only when the effects of the present wage adjustments are finally and fully reflected in retail prices.
We are told that all these rises in the cost of living occurred since the Fianna Fáil Government came into office. Deputy Blowick, a former Minister, actually made a statement that during the three and a half years in which the Coalition were in office only one price went up, that of butter, by 2d. a lb. I asked my Department to produce a list of the commodities that increased in price during the Coalition term of office—those that were the subject of official Government Orders sanctioning increases and those that took place with the consent of the Government without formal Orders. It would take me an hour to read over list after list of the commodities that went up in price at that time. Does Deputy Blowick seriously think that anybody will believe his assertion that during their three and a half years in office no price went up except one?
Comment on this
What I am saying is that from February, 1948, to February, 1951, there was a rise of only two points in the index.
Comment on this
And the Coalition Government were still in office in May, 1951. In the last three months of the Coalition's term of office the cost of living began to shoot up at an accelerating pace and that is one reason why they dissolved the Dáil at that time.
Deputy Costello also said that the cost of living has gone up here more than it went up in Britain. I contradict that statement. The cost-of-living index number in Britain shows that during the period between 1948 and August, 1951, the British index went up from 100 to 126. Here the index went up from 100 to 122. Whatever influences were at work here in causing the cost of living to rise were equally at work in Britain and were producing a still more definite increase in prices in Britain. Nor was that true of Britain only. In every country in Europe prices were fluctuating during the same period. It is true that in Belgium and in Germany there were no increases, whatever local circumstances operated there, but as against the increase here there was an increase in Austria of 36 per cent., in Iceland, 36 per cent., in France, 22 per cent., in Norway, 12 per cent., in Sweden, 12 per cent., in Denmark and Italy there was also an increase. In Switzerland there was a fall.
It is quite obvious, therefore, that the contention made by Deputies opposite that all these misfortunes fell on this country just because the Fianna Fáil Party came into office is not capable of statistical proof. I will put it clearer than that. It is a falsehood.
We are told that taxation is too high. I will agree that taxation is very high, that it is dangerously high having regard to the present level of national production. Could we get agreement in this House that it must not go higher? Will the Parties opposite consent to a proposition that no matter what proposal is made here for increased Government spending, no matter how desirable the objective of that spending, no matter how justifiable the claim leading to it, we will not agree to it; that, in order to keep taxation from going higher we will stop all spending from going up.
Comment on this
Of course, nobody will agree to it. Deputies who deplore the present level of taxation and then stud the Order Paper with motions demanding still higher Government spending upon particular projects in which they are interested are again, I submit, leaving themselves open to the charge of hypocrisy. Deputy Costello, it is true, admitted that, if taxation was to be reduced, Government spending would also have to be reduced, but he took very good care to give not the slightest indication of the direction in which he would achieve that reduction of spending.
We have had a number of speeches about unemployment, and the persistence of unemployment is a most serious feature of the national economy; but I again want to say that no Deputy gave a fair picture of the position, and least of all Deputy Costello, despite his aim of being scrupulously fair and meticulously accurate, when he said that the unemployment register figures gave the whole of the picture in relation to unemployment.
Comment on this
Deputy Morrissey says it is worse. I am going to give another side of the picture. The factors which influence registrations on the live register are numerous. The increase in the number on the live register, in the course of the past 18 months, took place despite the fact that there were more people in employment during that period. According to statistics from the Department of Social Welfare, the average weekly number of people employed in occupations insurable under the Unemployment Insurance Acts, calculated from the number of contributions paid in respect of them, in 1951, was 369,700 as compared with 353,600 in 1950, an increase of 14,000. I endeavoured to get from the Department later figures than those for 1951, but they told me that no later figures are available, but that sample inquiries had been made and that these inquiries suggest that, in the first six months of this year, there was a further improvement in respect of the number of people employed, as compared with the first six months last year.
Whether these statistics, when available, will show that or not, I will content myself with asserting that there was no falling off in the number of people in employment in insurable occupations during that period. That can happen, as we know, while, at the same time, the number of people seeking work in insurable occupations and registering at the employment exchanges for that kind of work can increase also. I am not going to minimise in any way the magnitude of that problem. We know that the live register is not an indication of the number of people available for the type of work that could be offered on Government works schemes. Probably not more than one-third of those on the register are capable of manual work of that kind. At any rate, that was the position as we found it when we analysed it some years ago and I am sure it has not changed fundamentally since.
The over-all situation in regard to employment, as distinct from unemployment, is not nearly as discouraging as Deputies suggested. So far as building is concerned, it is not true that there has been any curtailment of the activities of local authorities. Deputy Cosgrave, I think, agreed with that, but he did say, and probably rightly, that there has been some falling off in activity by private people. The extent to which it is possible for the Government to influence the building orders placed by private people is very problematical——
Comment on this
——but I am quite certain of this, that the rise in the cost of building has led to a falling off, and I will suggest to Deputy Cosgrave and Deputy Dockrell that the rise in the cost of building has had a far more detrimental effect upon the volume of building orders by private people than the increase in the interest rate on loans. If we could get back the cost of the materials used in the building of houses to the level at which it stood a year ago or two years ago, we would do much more than offset the effect of higher capital costs. I am going to make some shot in that direction by breaking up the builders' providers' rings under the Restrictive Trade Practices Bill, but I suggest that both Deputy Dockrell and Deputy Belton could lend their influence in getting some improvement in that direction also.
May I, as a matter of interest, mention that, in all the distributive trades in this country, in the year 1951, the average net profit on turnover taken was 4 per cent., but the builders' providers secured 6.2 per cent. and earned 14.3 per cent. on capital invested? Perhaps, if there is a falling off in the volume of private building, the builders' providers may be able to make a contribution to its restoration by being satisfied with the same net profit on turnover as other persons engaged in distributive trades.
Comment on this
The rate at which the Government can borrow is determined by a variety of circumstances. Is there a suggestion that the Government here can borrow money at lower rates of interest than other European Governments are paying? We know that there was for a time in Great Britain a cheap money policy, when Mr. Dalton was Chancellor of the Exchequer, and we were able to benefit by that policy, but just as there has been a change of policy in that regard in Britain, so also has there been a change of policy in America and all over the world. Because of changing circumstances, the cost of money, of long-term money, has risen.
Why do Deputies expect that it should rise everywhere else and not rise here? We could undoubtedly force people to lend us money at a low rate of interest, but it would mean imposing a restriction on the movement of funds between this country and Britain, and we do not think it would be worth it. We think that the cost we would pay in unemployment would be far too high for the advantages we would secure.
Comment on this
And it was the same rate of interest in 1929, 5¾ per cent., under Cumann na nGaedheal.
Comment on this
We have been concentrating upon the effort to get new industrial activities under way and to overcome the effect of the trade slump in existing industry. So far as that is concerned, we have succeeded. Deputies who have spoken here about the trade recession are talking about something which has, in the main, passed.
Comment on this
In some trades, there is still less activity than there was in 1950, but I say that in the trades that were prejudiced by the abnormal imports under licence permitted in 1951 of manufactured goods, normal working has been restored. All our woollen factories are back in full production and some are on overtime. The same is true of our leather tanneries. In most of the textile industries, normal conditions are back again. We had to take drastic measures in order to get that situation but it has been secured. During the past year we got 79 new factories into production, 12 of them being major undertakings.
Comment on this
I have said already that the special steps which were initiated by legislation to promote industrial development in the West of Ireland were slow in producing the results anticipated. I thought they might produce results more expeditiously but I am now quite satisfied that these measures will produce significant results in industrial activity in these areas. The seed has been sown, the crop will be reaped and the Deputies opposite need not be despondent about the prospects.
Comment on this
We will not get industrial activity on the scale required if Deputies opposite go around spreading this atmosphere of gloom and it is they who are at it.
Comment on this
If the people of this country got the opportunity of reading half the speeches which were delivered from the benches opposite during the course of the present week I would not blame them, no more than Deputy Dillon, for being gloomy.
Comment on this
We were told that the export of timber was an indication that building activity was falling off. Let me tell the House the story. There was set up by me during the war for the purpose of securing adequate supplies of timber during the emergency an organisation called Timber Importers, Ltd. That organisation was dissolved by Order of the Coalition Government in 1950 and its funds confiscated for the Exchequer.
Comment on this
Within a few weeks, they wanted to restore it and those concerned agreed to bring it back into existence provided they got their money back again, but that was asking too much.
Comment on this
And so the responsibility of bringing in stocks of timber in the circumstances of that year was not given to any organisation set up for that purpose but left to individual firms. Some of these individual firms brought in substantial stocks. I have no doubt they were thinking of their own interest as much as the interest of the country. After the stocks came, timber prices fell, and fell heavily and are still falling. I met the representatives of Timber Importers and they told me that they were facing such serious losses that some of them would not be able to continue in business. They endeavoured to put on me an obligation to help them out of a situation which was brought about by the request of the previous Government. I declined to agree that there was any such obligation on me. I did say that to the extent that they were carrying abnormal stocks on which they were likely to make a loss I was prepared to relieve them by giving them export licences. They have not been able to effect exports to any extent worth while.
All the experience I have had recently, in relation to timber, wool tops and other goods, convinces me of one thing, which I am going to put on the record for the benefit of any Minister who follows, that if the danger of war should arise again, it would not be fair to put the obligation of stockpiling, for safety purposes in an emergency, on private firms. We will not get it done anyway. Everybody knows that those who responded to the requests made to them in 1950 to carry abnormal stocks suffered losses in consequence and none of them will burn their fingers a second time. If we are going to have a policy of stockpiling at any time in the future then the Government in office will have to take the responsibility for setting up organisations for the purposes of financing the stocks and covering the losses in the event of a loss arising.
Comment on this
Of nylon stockings, worsted yarns and mouse traps. There was a special import licence for mouse traps.
Comment on this
Is Deputy Sweetman in the House? I do not think Deputy Sweetman should be permitted to interrupt from the passage.
Comment on this
I would like to deal with some of the more serious contributions that were made in the course of the debate than those to which I have replied so far. Deputy Costello delivered what was obviously a carefully prepared speech conveying what he described as suggestions for the improvement of the financial organisations of the State. I think it is true that the financial institutions of this State were not specifically designed to foster the economic development of a free Ireland.
Comment on this
I am convinced also that their reform must come gradually and, if possible, voluntarily. State action to press that reform if it should have the effect of creating, mistakenly or otherwise, fears that the private savings of our people were going to be seized to relieve the financial difficulties of Government, or if it aroused fears abroad that payments made in Ireland for goods sold to Ireland could not be freely transferred into sterling, would cause widespread unemployment and bring trade to a standstill. That is a risk we should not take, at least until the need has been demonstrated.
Comment on this
There has been no evidence so far that either public or private investment here has been found impracticable. We had during the years before the war and the years since the war a substantial volume of investment both in public undertakings and in private business enterprises. There has been no real evidence produced anywhere that the defects of our financial organisation have impeded seriously worth-while developments of that kind. Deputy Costello appears to be still under the delusion that the Government he led started a policy of productive capital investment.
Comment on this
And other Deputies opposite seem to share his illusion. I would ask the Deputies who share that illusion to apply this practical test. Let them read Deputy McGilligan's Budget statement of 1950 and the list of items which was then described for the first time as the Coalition's capital investment programme. They will find in that list of items only one that was not based on a Fianna Fáil Act. Every single item in that list was made possible by the legislation passed by the previous Fianna Fáil Government——
Comment on this
——with the exception of the land improvement scheme with which Deputy Dillon was associated. On referring to Deputy McGilligan's Budget statement of 1950, Deputies will find that there was appropriated for that scheme in that year £3,000,000 but if they turn up the finance accounts for the whole of the year they will find that of the £3,000,000 only half a million pounds were spent. That was a queer sort of capital development programme. What is the position this year? The position this year is that so vigorously has our Minister for Agriculture gone ahead with the land improvement programme that already the full amount voted for the year has been expended and he is coming here next week for a supplementary sum to enable the activities under that scheme to be continued and extended in the rest of the financial year. Compare that accomplishment with the large promise and poor performance of Deputy Dillon.
Comment on this
We would like to wait and see what the Supplementary Estimate is for. Do you see the Minister for Finance blushing? Look at him blushing.
Comment on this
When they have carried out these practical tests that I suggest to them, there is one further test that they should apply. I ask them to find out how much of the total amount provided for capital services in that year was actually spent. They will find that Deputy McGilligan had £10,000,000 unspent at the end of the financial year.
Comment on this
That was a queer sort of capital investment policy. It was one pushed with very little vigour or, if pushed at all, pushed the wrong way. Of course we know the policy of the Coalition in this matter changed during their term of office. They did not come in with a programme of capital investment. They came in with a programme of retrenchment and in their first year of office took pleasure in coming here and announcing that various capital schemes initiated by their predecessors had been dropped. Do not Deputies opposite remember that? Was not the whole mineral development project dropped? Did not they leave 70 workers down there in Avoca, County Wicklow, getting their pay but under orders to do no work for 15 months?
Comment on this
You are crazy. There was more prospecting done in those three years than in the previous 20.
Comment on this
Do you remember the harbour development schemes—all these proposals for the investment of money in harbour improvement works? Were not they dropped? Was not every single one of them put in the wastepaper basket and only revived in September, 1949, when political pressure made it expedient to revive them? I could enumerate here for half an hour worth-while capital investment projects which, in their first enthusiasm for retrenchment and economy, they decided to drop. But then there came a change of policy. Why there was a change of policy I do not know. Instead of retrenchment and economy and cutting down upon capital expenditure this so-called capital investment programme was initiated. I say that it was phoney from the start; it was a phrase designed to conceal the fact that they were going to borrow for ordinary Budget purposes and thus avoid the political unpleasantness of imposing necessary increases in taxation.
Comment on this
Deputy Costello said that increased taxation discourages investment. Let us take the record of this year against any of the Coalition Government's years. There was more money raised by public loan and more money expended through public organisations for investment purposes in this year than in any other previous year in the history of this country.
Comment on this
That was done in a year in which the amount of money raised by private business enterprise for development purposes was also an all-time record. There has been a larger volume of money made available for investment this year than in any previous year, despite the increased taxation, and done entirely out of our own resources, because that is the significance of the disappearance of the adverse trade balance. We can forget about that now. That problem is solved.
Comment on this
We are told that the solution of our economic difficulties is to set up an active capital market. That is Deputy Costello's proposal for ending all our difficulties. A market, as I understand it, is an institution, a place where buyers and sellers make contact, to do business. If there is a need to attract the savings of individual citizens to investment in Irish industry—and I have not seen evidence of serious difficulty on the part of Irish industry in getting new capital as required up to this—but if there is such a need, then it will be met, not by tinkering with machinery but by creating conditions in which our citizens will desire to make investments of that kind and, if that desire is to develop amongst our citizens, then there must be first of all a cessation of these attacks upon Irish industrialists as racketeers.
It was, I thought, preposterous for Deputy Costello to come here urging more voluntary investment in Irish industry, the creation of some organisation which would enable Irish citizens to invest in Irish industry—as if they had not the means already—when his first lieutenant or second lieutenant, or sergeant-major or whatever he is, spends his time in this Dáil denouncing Irish industries as criminal offences against the community and those who engage in them, those who seek the investment of Irish resources in them, as crooks and racketeers.
There must also be some effort to repair the false impression that has been created that, for political reasons, Governments may come into office here which will prevent Irish industries from earning profits commensurate with those that industries in Britain can earn. If we are to have investment in Irish industry made possible in competition with investment in English industry, then there must be the same prospect of return, the same prospect of security here as in Britain. The alternative is to impose restrictions, to have something akin to a capital levy, a conscription of capital resources, but we cannot make that effective except by imposing general restrictions upon the movement of funds between this country and Britain, and that would have such serious consequences upon our trade and employment that it is a measure we should not take until we are driven to it.
We can develop an active capital market here in the course of time provided we get rid of the mentality which regards a successful and profitable Irish industry as a public enemy. I have said that I have no evidence that industrial development by private enterprise has been unduly held up by lack of access to investment funds. If more is to be done, it is far less a matter of changing the methods by which industrialists can have access to the savings of investors than of changing the mentality which has operated in that matter heretofore.
I have been asked for a declaration of the Government's policy. It is difficult to condense a statement of policy in a few sentences but I have no hesitation in again explaining to the Dáil what the Government is trying to do, what every single Minister in the Government is trying to do. I emphasise that this is a united Government, that every member of it has the same policy and is striving to the same objectives. We argue amongst ourselves. We can afford to argue amongst ourselves because we know that, no matter how heated the argument may become——
Comment on this
——in the end, when there is a majority vote, that decision will be accepted by all members of the Government. I have always contended and I know now from examination of the records that the Coalition Government could never afford to push any question upon which there was disagreement to the point of decision and they never did. The Coalition Government whenever they came to that position adopted one of two devices: either they postponed consideration of the question indefinitely or set up a committee that never met.
With regard to the Independent Deputies who have supported this Government, I want to refute one suggestion that was made repeatedly from the benches opposite. There was no contact between the Government and any of these Deputies, much less a bargain, before the vote was taken in the Dáil that put this Government into office. There has been no understanding of any kind with them that the Government will or will not dissolve the Dáil or have an election. There is no agreement expressed or implied which binds them to support this Government one day longer than they decide in their judgment to do.
Comment on this
It is despicable that suggestions to the contrary should come from Deputies opposite, some of whom know the efforts that were made by their leaders to suborn those Deputies from their decision and to induce them, for material reasons, to vote otherwise. It is the aim of the Government by every device in its power, to utilise every instrument of legislation and administration to assist fuller and more efficient production in every branch of the national economy. I believe, unless we can get greater production of wealth from Irish farms and Irish factories, we cannot afford to sustain the present level of State services or the present standard of living of the people. We can for a time postpone the day of reckoning by living on our reserves but inevitably that day will come, unless the efforts being made to expand production and increase efficiency are successful. I think already we have made substantial progress. Whatever criticism the Opposition can make of the Government they cannot say that we have been idle. In every Departments things have already been done which they failed to undertake. Is that not so? We have come in here with legislative proposals and other measures representing the accomplishment of things which the Coalition talked of but did nothing about. The new industries established are now making an important contribution to the nation's capacity to produce more wealth. In industry also things are being done now that should have been done years ago. The extension of cement factories is a case in point and so is the extension of sugar factories and the extension of the merchant marine service. All these things could have been done much more cheaply and easily in 1948-49 but nothing was done about them.
Comment on this
Plans for the development of the natural resources of this country which were held up or delayed or scrapped by the Coalition Government are now in progress again. That applies to the mineral development proposals and to the exploitation of our peat and our water power for electricity purposes. Again, let me remind the Dáil that plans for only two electricity stations were approved by the Coalition; one was in Dublin and the other in Cork, and both were designed to use either imported coal or imported oil. Look at the picture now. From Donegal to Kerry new power stations are being planned or are being built, designed to use native resources only. The people in North Mayo have no illusions of the significance of the return of Fianna Fáil to office. The peat bogs of Bangor-Erris are being developed to feed two power stations which between them will have a greater capacity than the Shannon scheme.
Comment on this
The people of Donegal have the Clady River scheme, and the people of Kerry the Comeragh scheme. The development of turf bogs throughout all the midlands represents a solid achievement which should have been started during the Coalition's three years but was neglected.
Comment on this
Many Deputies from the West have expressed doubts about the Undeveloped Areas Act in relation to the establishment of industries in the Fíor Gaeltacht and similar areas. I do not think any inducements held out by the Government will get private enterprise to go into industry in those areas. That Act represented only one part of the Government's plan for the revival of those areas. That part was intended to encourage industrial development by private enterprise. It is going to have that effect but inevitably it will be confined to the towns and other centres of population where the ordinary amenities necessary for industrial development, such as transport facilities and water supply, are available. If more is needed to be done in these areas, in the rural hinterland of these towns, it must be and will be done by State enterprise. For that reason we set up the office of which Deputy Jack Lynch, the Parliamentary Secretary, is in charge and the proposals he has been working on during the year are now coming one by one before the Dáil.
Deputies have spoken satirically about the plan to expend £3,000,000 or £4,000,000 on the construction of roads in these areas. Do they not want it done? Which one of them will say it should not be proceeded with? The building of these roads, apart from the immediate employment they will provide, will in time tend to increase the wealth of those areas in the years ahead. The tourist trade was at one time a matter of controversy here but I understood it had long ceased to be such and that now it is recognised that the substantial net income it produces is a major prop of our national prosperity and that we were now agreed that all efforts must be made to expand it. This is one of the measures designed to that end and it will be of direct benefit to the people in all these counties.
I do not want to deal at any length with the measures which the Minister for Agriculture has taken or is planning in order to secure the expansion in production and the improvement in the technique of production in agriculture, which we require. The Government, in fact, has been devoting most of its time at recent meetings to the consideration of these measures and when they are complete in detail they will be announced to the country and to the Dáil. But I want the House to appreciate that few of these measures can be made effective without the necessary funds. If funds are to be expended, then somebody has to provide them. There may be particular projects which could be fairly described as of a capital nature to be met out of borrowed money but in most cases the necessary resources to vitalise these schemes must be secured out of normal revenue either by an expansion of the tax yield or a diversion to these purposes of money now being spent otherwise.
We do not expect Deputies opposite to agree with everything the Government does. It would be a bad thing for the House if there were a lack of debate or criticism. But we are asking for fair criticism. If there are Government plans and projects which appear in the view of Deputies capable of improvement, we will welcome their views. But the type of balderdash with which Deputies opposite have deluged the House in the past few days is doing nobody any good—not even themselves. I am quite certain that, even though there comes a time in the life of every nation when, for a very short period, ballyhoo will outweigh serious argument, inevitably serious argument will come into its own again. For the 25 years of the Fianna Fáil's Party's existence we have planned our political campaign on that assumption, and we were rarely proved wrong. I would recommend Deputies opposite to study the record of Fianna Fáil. It was able to go back again and again to the people and get a vote of confidence from them, because on each occasion it could detail the work done or proposed to be done in the most specific way.
We never relied upon vague promises. If ever we were tempted to do so, we knew that it would lead to electoral defeat, and I suggest to Deputies opposite that if they want to get the confidence of the people and create a situation in which the Irish people at an election will deliberately vote them back into office— remember, they never deliberately voted them there yet—they also must come down to specific detail on the measures and plans they propose to implement, if they have any such plans, and they must make it clear that these proposals are not merely bargaining counters in some new coalition arrangement, but matters to which all those who may support that Government are committed. No evidence of any such positive thinking, much less constructive planning, has been forthcoming in this debate, and that is why, so far as I am concerned, I do not mind when we have a general election.
Comment on this
May I ask the Minister a question? The Minister in the course of his speech made a statement, and I am just wondering whether he wants it to go or whether he wants it to remain on the record. The statement was that a sum of approximately £100,000—I am speaking now from recollection —which was in the possession of Timber Importers, Limited, was their money.
Comment on this
That is not the point I am making. The Minister, in the course of his statement—and this is important, because it involves a sum of £100,000—did say that that money was their money, referring to Timber Importers, Limited. He stated that £100,000 was "their" money.
Comment on this
In my recollection it was a fund used by the organisation to maintain timber prices stable, to offset variations in price, and the claim made by the organisation was that, when it was being wound up, this money should have been used to reduce timber prices. Instead of that, it was taken into the Exchequer.
Comment on this
I do not think the Minister understands. This is important. It will come up again in an acute form. I take it the Minister agrees with me that the money did not belong to Timber Importers, Limited.
Comment on this
The organisation was not a group of private persons. It was a non-profit-making organisation. These funds could not be used for any personal benefit, but they could have been used to reduce the price of timber.
Comment on this
If it is true that so much work has been done by the Government over the last 12 months, how does the Minister now explain the fact that there are 11,000 more unemployed?
Comment on this
Question—"That the Bread (Prices) Order, 1952 (Amendment) Order, 1952 (S.I. No. 268 of 1952) be and is hereby annulled"—put.
Do you agree with this result?