National Stud Bill, 1953—Second Stage.
Contributions 154–308 of 308. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 3 of 1953 ›
I have no intention. I shall raise the matter at a more suitable time. The proceedings of this House should not be brought into disrepute by Deputy Dunne or any other Deputy who publishes before it happens what he thinks is going to happen.
Comment on this
On a point of order. You, Sir, having ruled that the Deputy should not discuss this matter, is he in order in continuing to discuss it?
Comment on this
I submit that Deputy Flanagan has raised a very important matter. It appears to me that the action of the Daily Mailin reporting something which they knew nothing about was in contempt of the privileges of the House and that notice ought to be taken of it and of the Deputy who was responsible.
Comment on this
I have given a ruling that any discussion of the matter mentioned or of Deputy Dunne raising it on the Adjournment does not arise. The question of the Daily Maildoes not arise.
Comment on this
I submit to you, Sir, that Deputy Flanagan, having made a statement, note of it should be taken, and that it should be discussed at the Committee on Procedure and Privileges and action taken.
Comment on this
Deputy Dunne used this courageous and very proper action by the National Stud and the Government as a vote-catching measure for himself and the Labour Deputies. He has abused his position as a Deputy in order to try to convince the people who are unemployed or who are looking for something to which they think they are justly entitled that the Government in purchasing Tulyar are doing something which is contrary to their interests. It is not true that this Government in purchasing Tulyar are doing anything contrary to the interests of the people who are represented by Labour Deputies. It is not true that they are doing anything contrary to the interests of anybody in this country. It may be said that by doing this they have gone as near as possible to ensuring that the prestige of Irish bloodstock will, if possible, be higher than it is.
Comment on this
By doing that they will in time help to give employment to those who go over with the progeny of Tulyar to win the classic races in England. I only hope that Deputy Dunne and those who see with him will find time sooner or later to come in here and treat this House as a legislative Assembly and the people that they represent as an intelligent body of people. If they do that they may find themselves a good deal further on by 1954.
Comment on this
I will yield to no one here in relation to my ignorance of racing and betting and I am, therefor, unqualified to express any views as to the merits of Tulyar. I am prepared to accept the views put forward by the Minister, by Deputy Briscoe, by Deputy Dillon and Deputy S. Collins who seem to be the chief protagonistsof the purchase of Tulyar that, at best, this is a gamble of £250,000.
I welcome this Bill for a different reason from the reasons advanced by those who are in favour of it. I welcome it because it confirms me in the view I have held over the past 12 months or more. It confirms the view that the Government is in no way short of money. It is quite obvious that if the Government found itself in financial difficulties of any kind it would not for one moment consider the spending of £250,000 on the purchase of a horse, a transaction described as a complete gamble. I welcome the introduction of this Bill as conclusive proof that the Government and the State finds its coffers pretty full.
There is no shortage of money for development purposes, even for development purposes in the nature of a gamble. This Bill proves that conclusively. I think every Deputy should breathe sighs of relief at that situation because we have become so used to gloomy speeches about our state of bankruptcy, about the inability of the Government to find even the pay of its own civil servants, about the reports from the Central Bank warning us of the danger we were in, that it is refreshing now to find that apparently all these gloomy speeches and reports are completely devoid of foundation.
I welcome this Bill from that point of view. I do not know whether or not the purchase of a racehorse for £250,000 is a good investment but I am not prepared to support a proposal to spend £250,000 on a racehorse while other projects of national development are being shelved or postponed because of lack of money. I am prepared to make a gambling offer to the Minister. I am prepared to support his Bill on condition that he makes available £250,000 for the purchase of premium bulls to improve our cattle population and our dairying industry plus an equal sum for the improvement of agriculture generally. If we are in a position to give £250,000 for a racehorse we should be in a position to give £250,000 for the improvement of agriculture.
Comment on this
I am asking the Minister to make that additional sum available now. Of course Deputy Cowan has to come in and try to help the Government as usual.
Comment on this
We are buying the bulls already so there is no necessity to do that.
Comment on this
I would ask that at least £250,000 be made available now to pay the Civil Service arbitration award, particularly in the case of the lowly-paid groups.
Comment on this
I am quite certain they would be quite glad to receive £250,000 now, whatever Deputy Cowan may say.
Comment on this
They will get every halfpenny that is due under the award and the Deputy knows that.
Comment on this
Deputy Cowan may get an opportunity of honouring his words.
Comment on this
I think it is very unfair that every time Deputy MacBride speaks Deputy Cowan, whether or not he is deliberately sent in for the purpose, starts a cross-fire. I think that is not right and Deputy Cowan should not be allowed to get away with it.
Comment on this
I think Deputy MacBride is entitled to be defended here. He is the son of a famous political leader and his mother is one of our most famous women.
Comment on this
Deputy O'Leary is now interrupting. Deputy MacBride must be allowed to continue his speech.
Comment on this
A spokesman of the Government, in the course of the last week, announced here that because the Government had no money available it could not honour the award made to lowly-paid State employees.
Comment on this
The Deputy is now proceeding to discuss extraneous matters on the National Stud Bill. He is proceeding to discuss general Government policy. That cannot be permitted.
Comment on this
I accept your ruling. I merely want to relate the matter to the extent that in my view it is an act of public indecency a week after an assurance of that kind has been given for the Government to come in here and ask the House to vote £250,000 for the purchase of a racehorse.
Comment on this
I would much rather spend £250,000 on the news agency or for the ending of Partition than in the buying of a racehorse. The Minister should go back to his Government now and ask for the authority to give the assurances I have requested. Deputy Briscoe urged, and I think other Deputies argued on the same lines, that £250,000 now amounted to less than £120,000 a few years ago. Probably Deputy Briscoe is quite right in that and if that is the basis on which Government policy is being framed and public expenditure is being estimated, the same principles should apply in relation to wages and earnings generally. If money has depreciated at such a rapid rate in the course of the last few years surely the wages and earnings of State employees have depreciated just as rapidly to the same extent.
Comment on this
It is not in order to make an application for increased wages on the National Stud Bill.
Comment on this
Only to this extent, that I submit to the House it is an actof public indecency to say on the one hand we have no money at all, that the State is reduced to such a state of bankruptcy that we cannot afford to make an award without the introduction of a special Budget, and within a few days to come and ask this House to vote £250,000 for a racehorse which, at best, is only a gamble. In circumstances where the economic position of the country was favourable, in circumstances where the country was looking for an outlet for investment, then by all means there might be a case to be made for the investment in this racehorse. I am not qualified; I know nothing about it; I am prepared to accept everything the Minister and Deputy Dillon have said about the horse, but they all agree that it is just a gamble.
Comment on this
Life is just a gamble, but there are gambles and gambles. On the same basis, I wonder would the Minister for Finance—he is capable of many things—include in his Budget the provision of another £250,000 that could be used for betting.
Comment on this
No, it is not a gamble. It was formed for the purpose of breaking through the paper wall that has surrounded this country, which has been one of the causes of Partition and which has been one of the main defects from which we suffered for a long time.
Comment on this
No. If the Deputy wishes to criticise the news agency, he had better criticise my successor.
Comment on this
With the assistance of the Red Nuncio, I am sure the news agency could be improved. I suppose they have not reported any of his speeches.
Comment on this
There are times when possibly it would be desirable to make an investment of this nature even if it is an investment or gamble on a racehorse, but I do not think this is such a time, at least not having regard to the general policy which the Government has been pursuing and has been enunciating. I certainly welcome the introduction of the Bill, though I oppose it unless I get these assurances, because it seems to be conclusive proof that the State is remarkably well off and that the gloomy stories we heard are devoid of all foundation.
Comment on this
I would like to say that my Party are not averse to supplying money to improve our bloodstock industry. We realise that the National Stud has a commercial value. We also realise that it gives to this country a prestige which increases the value of racehorses born in it. In opposing this Bill, we do so not because we wish to injure the National Stud but because we wish to say that now is not the time. With over 80,000 unemployed in Ireland, we say that no Minister should offer to gamble away £250,000. It is for that reason that we in the Labour Party oppose this Bill. This country is too small. This country is too heavily taxed. To quote the Taoiseach it is "groaning under taxation"; yet the Minister calmly stands up and introduces a measure that is to pay away £250,000 for one single animal, an animal that, God forbid, could be dead in the morning.
It is a strange thing to see that this country, a country groaning under taxation, a country with over 80,000 unemployed, can still afford to outbid the richest country in the world for the purchase of a sire. Tulyar may improvethe stock of this country. It is to be presumed he will, but very little improvement will take place in the bloodstock of the very small breeder of this country. I have in my hand a paper dated 29th January, 1952, showing a group of National Stud owners at a meeting in Dublin. You would be surprised, if you would go through the names of these individuals, how very few Murphys, O'Haras, or any other Irish names you would find. You will get "Lieutenant-Colonel Silcox" and other names like that. I suggest that the use of Tulyar will be confined to those stud managers' nominees, to the ascendancy people who are still remaining in Ireland. If the Minister for Agriculture takes pleasure in purchasing something for these people while there are 88,000 people unemployed, then I wish him well with it.
The Minister has said that the horse-breeding industry is responsible for an income of over £3,000,000 per annum. That is quite correct, but it is not correct to say that horse racing of itself is responsible for it. Included in that £3,000,000 is the money paid for the old horses sent across to Belgium and to other countries to be killed to our eternal disgrace. It does not do to take the round figure of all horse prices in this country, simply put it down on one side, compare against that the price paid for Tulyar, and try to adduce from that fact that it is a fair proposition. Whether or not Tulyar has been bought too dear, whether or not the risk of racing him is one that should or should not be taken, I do not propose to express an opinion. I have very little knowledge of horse breeding, very little knowledge of horse betting. However, I do say that as a protest against the present position, as a protest in the name of the people of this country who are unemployed in my constituency, I am prepared to vote against the Bill introduced by the Minister.
Comment on this
This debate has covered many aspects of the question at issue. We are discussing whether the National Stud should be entitled to increase its capital to £500,000. Asa background to that discussion, it is of course common knowledge that the National Stud has entered into arrangements for the purchase of this sire, Tulyar. I think we can all agree that the purchase of this sire could not be carried out unless the Dáil, in fact, approved of this Bill and gave sanction to the proposed purchase. I should like to make it clear that I am not competent to question, and I do not propose to question, the judgment of the National Stud in purchasing Tulyar. They have their job to do, they are well fit to do their job, and I am prepared to assume that their decision is a good one. I am more concerned now with the question whether or not the money necessary to purchase this sire should be raised in ordinary taxation or otherwise from the people of this country. I think that is a very serious question for us here.
It has been suggested from the Government Benches that the purchase of Tulyar is a sound capital investment, that it may be a gamble but that it is a gamble worth taking and that the return in years to come will certainly justify the investment. That may be so; I am sufficiently ignorant of the industry to be impressed by what has been urged by the Minister, by Deputy Dillon and other Deputies with regard to the soundness of the investment in Tulyar but I do join with other Deputies in questioning our right to gamble in this way. It has been said that there will be a rich return in two years or four years' time. A rich return to whom? I have heard Deputies state that here as if the mere fact that yearlings in two years' time will be sold at a phenomenal figure is going to make my lot or the lot of any other Deputy better. Is that so? To speak in racing parlance, we cannot go round in blinkers and ignore the fact that the bloodstock industry is an industry run by wealthy men. There may be comparatively few of them who have the wealth or the fortune of the Aga Khan or persons of that type but they are all men of substance. It is they undoubtedly who will benefit either immediately or in the near future by the presence at stud in this countryof an outstanding sire like Tulyar. They will get a very substantial return. The progeny, the House is assured, in two or three years' time will be worth far more than the weight of the Aga Khan in gold. That is as it may be but where is the return to the ordinary people of the country?
It may be urged by the Minister that a profitable prosperous bloodstock industry will in turn benefit the country. I do not know that is so. It may be but I should like to hear this problem discussed from that point of view. I should like to know how the possible development of the bloodstock industry in the near future is going to benefit those unemployed or to create more unemployment in the industry itself. It is from that point of view we should discuss this question because we have heard—and again, we cannot close our eyes to this fact—a member of the Government proposing a capital development project, the only project of a capital nature proposed by this Government since their return to office. There is that background of failure to invest money in other lines while they propose to do it in this particular subsidiary branch of the agricultural industry. Certainly before I give my approval to this proposal I shall be anxious to know in what way the people of this country will benefit as a result of a better price being paid in future for yearlings or other progeny of Tulyar. I do not believe that there will be any return to the ordinary people. I can see that those who breed racehorses, who can afford to run them, who can afford to gamble and to do all the things that many of us would like to do if we had money, will have a new era opened for them by the advent of Tulyar to this country. For that reason I should like to suggest that if Tulyar is a worth-while investment it should be an investment made by those who stand to gain from it.
I think the purchase of Tulyar on the advice of the National Stud and by the stud should be financed and could be financed by the organisation of the bloodstock industry itself. It is not impossible to imagine small breeders here—I am speaking of comparatively small breeders who aregiven the opportunity of bringing their mares to Tulyar and who know that the return in the next two years certainly is going to be substantial— pooling their resources in a syndicate for the purchase of this sire. It has been done time and time again. Not so very long ago, a sum of £90,000 less than the price paid for Tulyar was raised by a syndicate for the purchase of a sire. I think the Minister would have been serving the country far better if he had come into this House to-day with a Bill to organise the bloodstock industry in whatever way he might think advisable to enable a pool of money to be raised for the purchase of great sires such as we are discussing now. I do not think in present circumstances and with the introduction that the proposal has been given by the Minister that we should be so complacent as to regard this as a legitimate object for the expenditure of the people's money.
I do not believe that ever before in the history of this Parliament has a Minister of State come in to ask for the voting of money on what he himself describes as a gamble. I think it is asking far too much of Deputies representing different parts of this country to sit patiently and vote the money he requires for a gamble. I do not think it is a legitimate expenditure.
Comment on this
There is no gamble in this. It is a good, sound investment.
Comment on this
The Minister may compose his differences with Deputy Briscoe and the other Deputies behind him.
Comment on this
I do not think the Minister at this late stage of the debate could be suggesting seriously that the investment of £250,000 in Tulyar is a trustee investment.
Comment on this
If the case is going to be presented in that way, then I think the Minister will find considerable difficulty in even persuading his own backbenchers to support this proposal. I do suggest that some effort should be made to organise the industry to finance this project themselves. I do not think that Deputies in this House who have pointed to existing circumstances in this country can be blamed for doing so when they are asked to vote this money to assist— it appears to assist—a particular small industry and a particular small section of the community. There are undoubtedly far more worth-while objects of this expenditure.
While I agree that the proposal to bring this sire back to this country— to buy it—is a very worthy one and while I think it is of the utmost importance that the bloodstock of this industry should be built up, I do believe that we should always put first things first. I do not believe in this connection that we are doing it to-day. I think that, apart from not going around in blinkers, it is also important that Deputies should not go round the place with their ears stuffed as I am afraid some Deputies' ears appear to be. I would like to inform the Minister that this proposal made under the existing circumstances in this country has aroused a storm of criticism.
Comment on this
I am travelling in the best company in the world, and I always do. That is why I am on this side of the House and the Minister is on the other. There is undoubtedly very serious public resentment against this proposal.
Comment on this
I know absolutely nothing about it, and I doubt if theMinister knows anything about it. In any event, I know what I am saying now—that there is very serious criticism of this proposal. If the proposal is a good one, as the Minister seems to think and as other Deputies seem to think, then surely he should make some effort to finance it through those who are going to derive the benefit. Even if Tulyar's progeny in two years' time are worth all the gold in the world there will still be unemployment in this city, there will still be unemployment in my constituency and there will still be problems to be solved for the general agricultural industry. The appreciation in the value of the Irish bloodstock will be in no way translated into a solution of the other problems facing the people themselves. Those are facts.
I think that what I am saying will find ready acceptance on all sides of this House. I think that the fallacy in the case made by the Minister is that he is asking the people generally, those who suffer now from the problems of unemployment, those in agriculture who suffer from particular problems of the agricultural industry, to foot the bill for the purchase of Tulyar when from that purchase they can derive no benefit. That does not appear to me to be good sense. I suggest to the Minister, as an individual Deputy, to take back this Bill, and if he wants the goodwill of the House in the purchase of Tulyar, let him take that back also, but let him see, negotiate and consult with those interested in the bloodstock industry itself. Let him come back to this House and do what is being done for other industries already. Get those interested in the industry to step together and finance their own problems.
That is the only way it should be done. It is the only sensible way of doing it. It is cod and nonsense, in present circumstances, to come in here and ask the ordinary taxpayer to foot the bill as the Minister now proposes to do.
Comment on this
Poor Tulyar has been so much abused that I suppose somebody will have to say a good word in his favour now. Most of the Deputies I have listened to made as an excusefor their attacks on the purchase of Tulyar by the National Stud their ignorance of Irish horse breeding. I did not think there was anybody in this country who was ignorant of Irish horse breeding, what it has meant, what it means and what it will mean when we have all passed beyond the Rubicon.
Comment on this
The prestige of Irish horse racing is something that cannot be looked upon too lightly. The Irish horse has kept Ireland on the map under very adverse circumstances. I feel very, very proud and I congratulate the Minister and the members of the National Stud on their courage in going one step further to ensure that the prestige of the Irish horse is kept before the world.
It is quite true to say that the chasing blood has been almost entirely responsible for that. We have had, unfortunately, very few long distance racehorses who have brought honour or money to this country. The Irish chaser is famous all over the world. Some day, when the progeny of Tulyar race on the Irish turf, the English turf, the American or French turf, we feel certain they will bring equal credit to this country as the Irish steeplechasers brought in the past. It is a step in the right direction.
I listened to Deputy O'Higgins and do not know whether he is for or against. He reminds me of the man looking for a job as a groom, who pretended he knew everything about the saddling of horses; but when the owner went out one day he found the saddle put on the wrong way; he reprimanded the groom saying: "You said you knew all about horses." The groom asked: "What is wrong?""The saddle is on the wrong way," said the owner; and thereupon the groom said: "How the devil did I know the direction you were travelling?" I do not know in which direction Deputy O'Higgins is travelling. Like Deputy MacBride, he has taken advantage of this sound investment toattack the Government for matters beyond their control. Deputy MacBride has been very critical and has tried to justify his News Agency Bill—an adventure and a gamble—here to-night. I wonder if he agrees with members of the Labour Party who attacked the Irish Horsebreeders' Association. I wonder if that is the way to abolish Partition, that those of that class prepared to help the Irish horse-breeding industry must be attacked in this House.
It is quite true that Tulyar cannot respond to all the criticism—he is a dumb animal—but I hope he uses his hind legs effectively on some of the people who pretend to know something about the Irish horse-breeding industry. Deputy O'Higgins talked about horses in blinkers. They are run in blinkers for a certain reason and if certain Deputies were running I am sure they would be in blinkers, too, for the very same reason. The onus was put on Deputy Dunne. The political Leader of the Labour Party has not said anything about it, but I would like to know Deputy Norton's attitude. Does he desire that the horse-breeding industry should fail? Would he go down to Kildare and tell them that? He would not, but it is all right for him to say it here.
Comment on this
There are people who make money out of industry or land or business and we are constantly criticising them. Why? Because they fail to put back some of the money; and that is bad for the land and for industry and for business. You must put back, year after year, a certain amount of money, or failure is bound to result. The National Stud Company decided in their wisdom that, having been a very successful venture up to now, they would put more money into it, to ensure that the Irish horse would get his rightful place amongst the horses of the world.
We are told investments of this kind are eating up money and giving no employment. Do the people who make those statements realise what the horse-breeding industry means in employment?There is no other industry giving so much employment and we are not going to kill it. I congratulate the Minister on his steps to ensure that the prestige of the Irish horse will live. Please God, the progeny of Tulyar will be floating past the winning-posts with their tails in the air when the tails of the critics are between their legs, and will be for evermore.
Comment on this
I believe everything that can be said about Tulyar has been said and that neither this nor any other Parliament ever spent so much time in debating the purchase of a single horse. While the debate has centred around Tulyar, the Bill does not deal exclusively with Tulyar. It is a measure to develop the bloodstock industry and I believe we are entitled to say whether or not this money could not be more gainfully employed in developing other industries. I maintain that it could be and that there is no justification whatsoever at present for the expenditure of £250,000 on a horse. Deputy Blowick made it clear that it is a gamble, and the Minister's friend, Deputy Briscoe, reminded him of that fact, too. Is this Parliament entitled to gamble with any portion of the people's money?
When we read the provincial papers or meet our constituents, we learn the country is staggering under taxation and that people cannot bear the extra burdens. The unemployed ask if any money will be made available to stimulate employment in the country.
When Deputy Dunne raised this matter here, he was told by the Government that there was no more money available. No one said it was anti-national of the Government to turn down his suggestions, but now, when the Dáil is asked to vote £250,000 to purchase Tulyar, Deputies who have opposed this measure have been termed anti-national. Why? In my opinion, this measure is to subsidise the wealthiest class, those engaged in the bloodstock industry. If the Minister wants to know who they are, let him read to-day's Independent, let him have a look at a few of the names under the photographs there. I do not want to criticise any section of thecommunity, but surely to heavens these people are not Irish in name or origin. Why should we be asked to subsidise them?
Comment on this
In view of the way the debate developed, I think I am entitled to mention it. I claim that this Parliament has been asked to vote money to develop the bloodstock industry—leaving Tulyar out of it altogether—at a time when the country can ill afford it. I was very much surprised to hear the views of my colleague from West Cork, Deputy Collins, on this subject. On all occasions, he approaches the problems which come before the House in a very intelligent fashion, and I am surprised at his viewpoint on this measure. He described it as one of the finest pieces of legislation the House was ever asked to enact. What is fine about this pieces of legislation? So far as the people whom Deputy Collins and I have the honour to represent, they do not care two hoots about this measure, and every one of them I have met has asked me to oppose it as strenuously and as vigorously as I possibly can.
Would it not be better, so far as our constituents are concerned, and, I feel, so far as the Minister's constituents down in Kilkenny are concerned, if this £250,000, instead of going to the Aga Khan, went into the poultry industry which is now dying a very rapid death, due to the sharp decline in the price of poultry during the current year? Would it not be better to help the women and girls of the country who have to get a livelihood from that industry than to subsidise Brigadier the Baron de Roebuck and his comrades down in County Kildare? I believe that Brigadier the Baron de Roebuck is very well able to look after himself and should be allowed to do so. We owe nothing to such people. Such people as Brigadier the Baron de Roebuck and his colleagues, I feel sure, have the wherewithal to purchase Tulyar, if they thought fit to purchase him. Why not let them purchase Tulyar, if he is such a bargain and ifhis progeny, as Deputy Davern prophesied, are going to pass all the posts in the country first with their tails in the air.
Comment on this
I maintain that this money could be more gainfully employed in many other directions, and, as the measure has been introduced by the Minister for Agriculture, I have mentioned one direction in which I am very much interested, the development of the poultry industry. I believe it is quite relevant to this debate. It could usefully be employed to develop agriculture under the Undeveloped Areas Act. I think it was Deputy Flanagan from Mayo who referred to that Act. We have got nothing from it in West Cork and I believe that nothing has been got in any other part of the country, with the possible exception of North Mayo, which, on the eye of the general election, got something as a vote-catching stunt.
Comment on this
I believe this is a piece of wanton expenditure and every word uttered by Deputy Dunne was quite correct, in spite of the criticism which has been levelled at him for what he has said. This is a big gamble on a horse owned by the Aga Khan. Why did the Aga Khan himself, who is regarded as the wealthiest man in the world and who has an income of several million pounds—I believe the gentleman is weighed against gold every year —not take a gamble and hold on to him if Tulyar is the wonder horse we are led to believe he is? I feel sure that he could have done so, but he is a man of some common sense, and, when he can get this Government, who have no money available for productive schemes, to give him the fine sum of £250,000 for a horse I believe he was very wise in accepting it.
We in the Labour Party are as anxious to develop the bloodstock industry as any others, but we believe that the people who are in that industry are well able to look after themselves, much better able to lookafter themselves than the many thousands of small farmers throughout the length and breadth of the country who are living on uneconomic holdings and who could not get £250,000 for the development of these holdings from the Minister, no matter what pleas they made. Some of these people and particularly those who supply milk to creameries—I made an agitation on their behalf before—had to go on strike to bring home to the Minister their economic plight and the seriousness of their position. I made it very clear to the Minister in this House before that the dairy farmers, and particularly those in the uneconomic areas —I made a special plea to the Minister for them—could not exist in present conditions.
Comment on this
Has this anything to do with the National Stud Bill?
Comment on this
I am relating it to the fact that the Bill provides for devoting £250,000 to the development of the bloodstock industry and pointing out directions, as I am entitled to do, in which the money could be more gainfully employed. The Minister knows the position of the small farmers very well himself, in view of the answer he gave to Deputy Hession with regard to the dairying industry a few days ago. Could the 90,000 unemployed in this country not do with this £250,000? Could it not be used to help a section of the unemployed by opening up some industry of one kind or another? If it were made available to county councils for the improvement of roads which are badly in need of improvement, or to the committees of agriculture for the development of agriculture to help the small farmers, would it not be more gainfully employed than in passing it on to the Aga Khan for Tulyar? Tulyar, however, is to be purchased, because, if we are to judge by the viewpoint expressed in the House, some of the Fine Gael Party are clapping the Minister on the back for his decision. I do not know what they see in it. Probably both Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael have some personal interest in this National Stud business. We havebeen criticised very much, and probably rightly so, because we do not understand all about the bloodstock industry like the people who have criticised us. We are not in a position to own racehorses, and the people we represent are not in a position to attend Punchestown, the Curragh or any of the other big racing centres. We have to confine ourselves to attending flapper events down in Drimoleague and such places. I do not know whether Deputy Collins was ever at one of these meetings or not.
Comment on this
We are not in a position to become acquainted with Brigadier the Baron de Roebeck or to have interviews, as Deputy Briscoe told us he had, with some leading racehorse owner. I agree that we are not in a position to express the views they could express and we have not got that technical knowledge of the industry that they have, but we have sufficient knowledge and intelligence to say that it is completely and entirely out of place for a Fianna Fáil Minister, backed up by a section of the Fine Gael Party, to bring before the House a measure asking the Irish taxpayers, who, on the Government's own admission, are already overburdened, to pay £250,000 for Tulyar. I say it is a gamble and I support the viewpoint expressed in this House that it is a gamble. Are we, in existing circumstances, entitled to take a gamble? We all hope that Tulyar will prove a sound investment and that Deputy Davern's prophecies will come true. As much as any other Deputy in this House, I hope that Tulyar will prove a success because I should like to see the Irish taxpayers get some return for their money. It cannot be denied that the expenditure of this large sum of money is a very definite risk. We should like to hear, when the Minister is replying, what the incidental expenses are expected to be. After the initial expenditure of £250,000 on the purchase of the animal, must insurance policies then be taken out in respect of it andis there any company which will accept such policies and, if so, at what figure?
With few exceptions, everyone throughout the length and breath of the country is stunned at the figure paid for this horse. We have heard about his racing capabilities. We were told all about the races he won in Britain and about the strong opposition which he met. All that is quite true. Definitely he is an outstanding animal. Why is it, therefore, that the English bloodstock people, with all the wealth at their command and with all the knowledge which they have, did not purchase this animal? None of them came along and offered anything like the sum of £250,000. Think of the Newmarket racing people and other big racing establishments including those of Her Majesty.
I am sure many people in Britain are interested in the racing industry. Not one of them offered £250,000 to buy the Aga Khan's horse, but the Irish taxpayers' money—which, incidentally, is used to subsidise the National Stud—was used for the purchase of this animal. In the light of these circumstances we can only assume—not being knowledgable so far as the value of racehorses is concerned—that Tulyar's price was inflated. Some Deputy said earlier in this debate that the supposed bid by an American syndicate was bogus and for the purpose of making our representatives pay an outrageous price.
No matter what way we look at this measure, I regret to say that we cannot speak very well of it. I have already said that I hope the animal will prove a success but, even if he does prove a success, who will benefit? It will not be the people whom I represent and the majority of the people in Kilkenny, whom the Minister for Agriculture represents, will not benefit very much either. It is Lord this and Sir that who will benefit—people who have the monopoly of the bloodstock business in this country. The ordinary farmer will not benefit. The unfortunate man who has to line up daily at the labour exchange in Dublin City and elsewhere will not benefit even if the horse turns out to be a wonder horse.
At a time when the people are so oppressed as a result of impositions by the present Government, I regard it as outrageous that this extra expenditure of £250,000 should now be foisted upon them. I maintain that the Labour Party's approach to this matter is the correct approach. The Government have no mandate whatever from the Irish people to pay that amount of the taxpayers' money for this horse. If the matter were put to a referendum I believe that not one person in ten would support the Government's Contention that this is a wise move. Consequently, this House should signify its disapproval in the strongest possible terms.
Comment on this
I have very little knowledge of racing and I do not attend race meetings but I must make my views known on this matter lest it be put to a division. Deputy Murphy mentioned that this money is being devoted to the improvement of blood-stock—and the purchase of Tulyar is incidental to that. The first question that strikes me is whether or not we are going to have a bloodstock industry in this country. If the answer is "Yes" then, as far as I am concerned, the bloodstock industry must be supported. One of the few things for which we are known outside this country is our bloodstock. Although we spend considerable sums of money annually on Embassies, Ambassadors and representatives abroad, for the purpose of keeping up appearances, I believe that that money is not half as well spent as the money involved in the purchase of an ambassador like Tulyar—provided, of course, the animal in question proves successful in the functions for which he has been purchased.
Like other Deputies I could paint a very gloomy picture of the situation with regard to unemployment and emigration. I could enumerate hundreds of different propositions—all good—on which this particular sum of money could be expended. If I decided, like Deputy Murphy, to suggest that this money should be diverted to, say, the improvement of the poultry industry then I am sure that that suggestion would be criticised by peoplein other areas who would say that they believe the money should be devoted to, say, the tomato industry. There is room for a difference of opinion on matters of this nature.
To my mind, we should not lose sight of the main objective, which is the improvement of the bloodstock industry, in our anxiety to get a well-deserved crack at a certain type of individual in this country: I refer to the people we see in fast and luxurious motor cars, with their rugs and field-glasses who attend every race meeting in the country. I could feel prejudiced enough to vote against this measure if I allowed my judgment to be swayed by my dislike of this particular type of parasite that has invaded this country. However, the improvement of our bloodstock is much more important than those people.
In our attitude to this measure we are more or less inclined to drive a wedge between the Irish people and to suggest that the poor man does not enjoy a flutter at the races. I discussed the purchase of this animal with several of my constituents.
The general opinion was: "Well, if we are going to purchase bloodstock, to purchase stallions, why not purchase the best?" I am in agreement with that point of view. We had, of course, Deputy Blowick, representing the Farmers' Party, speaking on this. He had a canter on Tulyar in this House. I suggest that if the Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals ever find out the manner in which this horse has been treated by Deputy Blowick he will be subjected to very severe penalties. When the Bill is passed, the Minister should, I think, ensure that there is one jockey, at any rate, that Tulyar will not have, and that is Deputy Blowick.
I should like the Minister to make this point clear. The suggestion has been made that there were various offers made for this animal. I understand that a syndicate in America or, as a matter of fact, that two syndicates offered larger sums than the sum for which the horse was sold to this country. I should like to know from the Minister if that is true. I have been told, however, that the owner ofthe horse did not accept the higher price because he felt that Ireland was entitled to first preference in regard to the purchase of this animal. I am anxious to know if that is true.
The chance of making a good purchase such as this does not present itself every day of the week. I certainly would agree with a motion of this nature if, say, animals like Tulyar were available every year. In that event I would be prepared to suggest to the Minister that "in this particular year we are not in a position to pay out this amount of money and we should defer making the purchase until next year or the year after when we will have the opportunity of purchasing an equally good animal." My opinion is that it is only once in a lifetime that an opportunity such as this presents itself. According to the descriptions we have got, this particular animal is the king of horses. It may be another generation or another 50 years before his equal comes on the market again, I therefore suggest to some of those people who have criticised the purchase that they should remember that an animal such as Tulyar is not available every year, and that consequently it is only very seldom indeed when this House is asked to pass a measure such as this.
As I have said, I am not a racing man. I do not bet and, as a matter of fact, I have no interest in racing, but I do think that if we are going to build up bloodstock here, and are to go in for the export of thoroughbreds, that we should aim at producing real thoroughbreds. Here is a criticism that I would like to offer to the Minister as regards our bloodstock. In my opinion, one of the greatest methods of publicity available to us for the sale of our bloodstock was in the ceremonial parades that, at one time, used to take place in this city on the occasion of the President making visits to particular functions. On those occasions, the President was provided to particular functions. On those occasions, the President was provided with an escort of Irish-breed horses. To my mind, these were first-class animals and their display was a means of selling that type of animal to foreigners. They presented a mostimpressive appearance, so much so that foreigners were inclined to purchase animals of that class. Now, unfortunately, we have done away with these ceremonial parades and, instead, have introduced backfiring motorcycles, which are purchased outside the country and which are a nuisance and a disgrace.
Now that I am giving my support to this measure, I should like if the Minister would have a chat with his colleagues with a view to seeing whether these ceremonial parades with horses could not be restored. They continued up to the time of the war. I think that if my suggestion were adopted by the Government it would help not only to improve our live stock, but, what is equally important, the sales of first-class horses.
I do not think there is anything further I have to say. An opportunity such as this occurs very seldom and, therefore, I think we should be slow to let it slip from us. It is an opportunity which I think we should take advantage of, and that we should agree to the purchase of this animal.
Comment on this
I oppose this measure. First of all, I propose to speak against it and, secondly, to vote against the proposal to devote £250,000 to the purchase of Tulyar. Since I became a member of the House, and even before that, I listened to Ministers and Deputies going around the country making scare-mongering speeches: telling the people that this country was doomed and facing national bankruptcy. Now we have a proposal before us to vote £250,000 for the purchase of Tulyar. In view of that, the people, I am sure, will form the opinion that what those gentlemen were saying at that time was absolutely untrue, and that there was no foundation for it.
I think it is sheer madness at the present time to vote £250,000 of the Irish taxpayers' money for a purpose of this kind, particularly when we consider that so many of our Irish boys and girls are forced to emigrate to England and America to earn sufficient to maintain the homes of their parents in Ireland. That is particularly true of my constituency inNorth Mayo. Day in and day out, year in and year out, thousands of our boys and girls are forced to emigrate to earn a livelihood abroad. I am sure that when, in their places of employment across the water, they read that this National Parliament of Dáil Éireann, assembled in Dublin, has voted £250,000 of the Irish taxpayers' money—not forgetting that some of it was, in the first instance, sent by those children to their parents at home—for the purchase of Tulyar, they certainly will be shocked.
I am opposing this Bill, because I think we should first of all consider the sons and daughters, the grandsons and the granddaughters of the children who fought with Davitt in the Land League movement. We should consider them in preference to people who were our enemies, openly declared enemies of ours and of the Irish cause, down through the years.
As I see it, it is these people we are catering for now, and that this Fianna Fáil Government has been catering for ever since its foundation. It is doing it again to-day. The people who engage in racing in this country and who own the ranches here, were never, as I say, friends of this country. Coming as I do from a poor mountainy area and representing, as I have the privilege and honour to represent as one Deputy, that historic place named Stráide where Michael Davitt with his Land Leaguers stood bravely and boldly against those people, I think it is a disgrace and a scandal that we here, assembled in the National Parliament, should put racehorse owners and racehorse breeders before our own flesh and blood, before our own brothers and sisters who have been forced to emigrate due to the fact, in many cases, that the holdings on which they were reared are uneconomic and that, for many reasons they cannot get employment at home. It is certainly strange that there are gentlemen who were elected to this House who will support such a measure. I am sure that the generations of Irishmen who gave their lives never visualised such a situation, never visualised that Dáil Éireann would assemble for this purpose. Theblood of Irishmen flowed freely that we might have a Parliament of our own and that we might consider our own people first. Here we have, as Deputy Michael Pat Murphy of Skibbereen said, a Government who are prepared to vote £250,000 of the taxpayers' money for this purpose while on the other side of the picture there is reluctance on the part of the Government to drain rivers, to reclaim land, to provide the ordinary farmer with a suitable by-road or a suitable road leading to his farm or farm buildings. It is a disgrace that such a situation should exist.
A short time ago I listened to the Taoiseach in this House saying if the British should shelter under a certain umbrella when the shower of rain comes does that mean that we should not shelter under the same umbrella? The particular umbrella that we seem to be sheltering under now is the bookie's big umbrella. I cannot say for certain whether there will be room for the Aga Khan, Mr. Winston Churchill, our Taoiseach and others under that umbrella, but I am sure that many of the Irish people will have to keep away from it.
As Deputy Murphy said, the ordinary country people cannot afford to go to Punchestown and other big race meetings throughout the length and breadth of the country. It is obvious that it is not the ordinary people that this Government are worrying about when they bring in a measure of this kind and ask Dáil Éireann to vote £250,000 of the taxpayers' money for such a purpose.
I am not narrow-minded. If I thought we had reached the stage that the country was so prosperous as to be in a position to afford such a gamble I would be quite prepared to gamble also but, as things are, while Irish people are forced through economic stress to leave the country in order to earn a livelihood, I regard this measure as ill-timed and of no benefit to the ordinary people. It is a benefit to the wealthy, to the bookies and to others.
Deputy Collins, as a member of the Fine Gael Party, said he supports this measure. I began to question why itwas that Deputy Collins should decide suddenly to vote for this measure. I am open to correction, but I have been told some time or other in this House that Deputy Collins had some connection with the Racing Board of this country or some racing interest. I am open to correction but, if that is so, if he has some personal interest in this Racing Board or these racing bodies, perhaps it is natural that he would vote with the Government on this occasion. With respect to Deputy Collins, I submit that his duty is not to racing boards. He represents the same constituency as Deputy Murphy represents, and I am sure it is the same type of people he represents. We know from song and story that the people of historic Skibbereen and other places in that constituency stood by things Irish in times gone by. It is rather surprising that a man of the name of Collins should on this occasion put racing interests before the interests of his constituents. However, I suppose that is Deputy Collins's own business, but I feel I am entitled to refer to it.
During last week I was approached by people in my constituency who are interested in procuring bulls for the improvement of the live-stock industry. They were anxious to procure a bull through the Department or through the local committee of agriculture. Having made inquiries I was told that there was a scarcity of bulls.
Comment on this
With respect, Sir. I know the question of bulls does not arise but I submit that it would be far better for the Government to invest more money in improvement of the live-stock or cattle-breeding industry than to invest it in racehorses, particularly at this juncture.
We have experts on milk yields in the Dáil and we hear them saying that milk yields should be improved. Would we not be better employed in fostering the dairying industry and improving milk yields than in fostering something which, as admitted by the Party opposite, is a complete gamble?As the leader of our Party, Deputy Blowick said, while we do not wish this industry any harm or ill-luck—far from it—we have no guarantee that this horse may not meet with an accident or that it may not die. In that event, the money spent on this undertaking will be lost. There may be certain protection in the matter of insurance of a limited kind.
I submit that the whole principle is entirely wrong at this juncture. It is in keeping with Fianna Fáil policy in the past 17 or 18 years of catering for the wealthy at the expense of the poor. It is a policy that has forced Irish boys and girls to emigrate. Racehorses, aeroplanes and extravagant schemes that are really of no benefit to the ordinary plain people have been financed. We see the result in wholesale unemployment. Unemployment figures have increased very substantially and I am sure the people who sign on at the labour exchanges in Ballina, Swinford, or any of the towns in my constituency will derive little comfort from the fact that Dáil Éireann is voting £250,000 of the people's money to buy this racehorse that may die overnight.
Having spoken against this Bill, I intend to vote against it.
Comment on this
It is my intention to support this proposal. The Minister made a reasonable case for this capital investment and I think I might go further and say that Deputy Dillon, on behalf of the Opposition or on his own behalf, made an even better case. It is unworthy of Deputies to cast any reflection on members of the Fine Gael Party who supported this proposal. A suggestion was made by a member of the Labour Party, and repeated by Deputy O'Hara, that these people had some financial interest or other in this particular investment.
Comment on this
On a point of order. In fairness to Deputy Murphy, who is not here now, surely the quotation should be produced. Tell us what he said. We listened to his speech and we could not take any such inference from it.
Comment on this
We will get the quotation when it appears in the Official Report and Deputy Dunne can read it. It is not good enough that suggestions of that kind should be made. As I said, it is only right that we should examine this matter objectively, as I think Deputy Dillon did examine it objectively. He put the case in a nutshell when he said that if we are to have a national stud we ought to set ourselves out to purchase the best bloodstock available and, if we are not prepared to do that, the best thing to do is to scrap the National Stud. I think the House will accept that that is the position.
Attempts have been made to suggest that this expenditure of £250,000 is in the nature of current expenditure out of taxation. In actual fact, it is a capital investment. We have heard a lot during the last two years about the necessity for a capital investment programme. We have heard criticism of the Government for not investing more money in projects designed to increase the wealth of the nation, to increase our export trade, and to help to make the country more prosperous. Now when there is a proposal to make an investment of this kind we hear rather stupid criticism of this as current expenditure from taxation and that the money should be spent on increasing unemployment assistance or on some matter of that kind. I do not accept that.
We have got to consider projects of this kind seriously. If we consider them seriously, we will find that every conceivable project which may be put up in the nature of a capital investment is in the nature of a gamble. Last week we had a proposal to dieselise the railway services, to invest in diesel engines. There, again, you have a project which appears on the face of it to be sound, but which may involverisks. In the same way, if it were proposed to invest £250,000 in a meat factory for the export of meat to the United States, Canada, or elsewhere, there again you would be taking a considerable risk and involving yourself in a considerable gamble. There is no conceivable industry designed to provide employment that does not involve the risk of loss.
I do not understand the type of mentality which refuses to embark upon any enterprise and which would keep this nation poor and to a great extent dependent upon outside help. The spirit of enterprise is still very much alive amongst our people and there are people who are prepared to adventure forth and to seek to improve, not only the cattle trade, but the horse-breeding industry and every other branch of national enterprise. Since we took upon ourselves the task or, if you like, the liability of establishing the National Stud to improve our bloodstock, it is only right and proper that we should carry that project to its logical conclusion and ensure that it is adequately financed to discharge the function for which it was established. It is true to say that if we breed the best type of horses that industry will grow and will provide very considerable employment. Many Deputies have talked here about the necessity for providing employment for our people, and it is only by entering upon a project of this kind and seeing how far it can be utilised for the benefit of our people and by taking risks, if necessary, that we can make any progress. The type of mentality which cries out against every conceivable enterprise, whether it is a factory or anything else, must inevitably pull our nation down and keep us poor.
There was a great depth of ignorance in regard to the ordinary life of our people displayed in Deputy O'Hara's speech when he said that the plain people of Ireland cannot afford to attend Punchestown Races. The Deputy must never have been near Punchestown, because if he were he would find a large proportion of the population of Leinster travelling by horse and cart, by bicycle, and every other type of vehicle to attend that race meeting where admission isabsolutely free and every section of the people can come together for a day's enjoyment. We ought not to allow narrow parochial or narrow class prejudice to influence our minds in the consideration of a matter of this kind. We ought to consider, as I admit Deputy Dillon did, the risks on one side and the advantages on the other side and, if we decide that the advantages to the nation as a whole outweigh the risks, we ought to support this project and support it in an honest and honourable way instead of trying to stir up class feeling and class prejudice or parochial feeling and parochial prejudice unworthy of our people.
Comment on this
In normal times I would support this Bill. At the present time I am opposed to the Bill and I will vote against it. This Bill shows that the Government is two-faced. Led by the Minister for Finance, for almost two years they have been up and down the country preaching gloom and doom, telling us the country is bankrupt, down and out and that nothing will save it. Now the Minister for Agriculture comes in here and says the Government will take a gamble.
The Government is proposing to gamble £250,000 of the taxpayers' money. That is a good gamble, and it may be successful, but I am one who will never stand for gambles. If the nation is heading towards bankruptcy we should face up to that situation and cut our cloth according to our measure. A few days ago the Minister for Finance told us that the Government could not implement the increase proposed for civil servants. He told us the Government could not afford to pay the civil servants, the teachers and the Civic Guards. Yet, the Minister for Agriculture can come in now and afford a sum of £250,000 on a gamble.
I do not think the State should interfere at all in this. This horse should have been purchased by the wealthy individuals who have money to burn. Evidently they did not think it worth their while to risk theirmoney and so the poor old Paddy must be forced to risk his. I know the horse is a good horse. There is big money in him and he can make big money. But money is not everything. The soul of the nation is more important. The country is suffering at the moment from a surfeit of gambling and speculating and it is time that some curb was put upon it. There are people in the country with money to burn. The soul of the nation is in their grip and they are weaning our people away from the ideals for which we fought and suffered in the past. It is time a halt was called.
The horse industry is a good industry, but I believe in first things first. All over the Midlands in the past there were small, thrifty, well-conducted stud farms run on sound national lines and giving a good return and good employment. Most of these to-day have been sold out. They have been bought by foreign speculators lashing money around north, south, east and west. The little man has been bought out and the foreigner is there in his place with his foreign outlook and his foreign ways. Something must be done to remedy the situation.
All round us there is national decay. We have emigration and unemployment. The language is dying. Our Irish traditions and our Irish culture have gone by the board. Everyone is looking in the direction of Punchestown and the Curragh where the big money is and the ordinary, sturdy men who had their roots deep in the soil are being squeezed out and have to fend for themselves in foreign lands.
Now is the time to take stock. There should be a review of the whole National Stud. I do not think the right people are getting service from that stud. The ordinary man breeding the ordinary type of good horse cannot get his nose inside the National Stud. I do not think the stud deserves a penny of the Irish taxpayers' or ratepayers' money. I think a review is badly needed. I could mention the names of some of the foreigners who have come in here to squeeze out our own people. Some of the names are the length ofmy arm. Their interests are contrary to Irish racing.
People talk about the horse-breeding industry and all the money it is bringing in. What good is money if the nation loses its soul? Money is not everything. The foreign monopolist is not coming in with his money bags to give more employment. He is coming in to destroy the nation. 20 or 30 years ago we would not have allowed them to do that. To-day, because of their tenacity and their grip, we are allowing them to call the tune and we are dancing like a lot of fools. The Minister should withdraw this Bill and carry out a review of the National Stud. Then we can see where we stand and we can let horse breeding and racing take their normal place in the country's life and not allow them to be monopolised by foreigners. It is time we made some effort to build up the country in a truly national way.
Comment on this
On a point of personal explanation. I understand that in my absence Deputy O'Hara alleged that I had some connection with the Racing Board. I want it put on record that I have no connection good, bad or indifferent with the Racing Board or with any other racing organisation.
Comment on this
This debate is interesting because of the expressions of opinion we have had from Deputies, In the ordinary way the time of this House should not be used for a debate of this particular kind. The National Stud has been established by statute. It operates under statute. So far it has operated successfully. The Bill before the House proposes to increase the capital of that organisation. Once the principle of the National Stud is accepted, as it has been accepted, a Bill brought in for the purpose of increasing its capital should not take very much time. The National Stud has operated successfully under successive Governments.
It has now decided to buy the finest racehorse in the world and whoever took the decision to purchase that animal should receive the congratulations of both the House and the nation. Too often we are critical of national organisations and other organisations which will not take aforward step when the opportunity arises. The National Stud in this particular instance has taken a very big decision. It was a big decision in the interests of our bloodstock industry and one that should be welcomed rather than criticised in the way it has been criticised in this House. It is a business organisation which has been operating with reasonable success. It is endeavouring to improve our bloodstock so that our reputation as a nation that produces and breeds the finest racehorses in the world should be enhanced. Why we should have this debate extending over many hours I cannot understand.
Comment on this
Is it unreasonable to suggest that if the Deputy thinks there should be no debate, that he should not continue the debate?
Comment on this
I am not talking about the debate. I am talking about the criticism. Many farmers in this country make a good living and employ quite a number of men in connection with the bloodstock industry. It ought to be the desire of every person in the country to support anything that makes for the improvement of that industry, for the maintenance of employment in it and, if possible, for the increase of employment in it.
We had the usual type of criticism that it is unwise to spend £250,000 in this way. That is the approach of some Deputies. Deputy Giles said: "On another occasion I would support a motion to spend £250,000 on the purchase of a horse like Tulyar."
Comment on this
But when will you get the opportunity again? This is an occasion when opportunity knocks at the door only once. Either you take the opportunity or you do not.
Comment on this
However, that is the approach that has been made. It was a question of either purchasing this horse or losing the opportunity of purchasing it. I think it was a wise decision to take, and it is wrong to say that we might have deferred it until things were better. DeputyMacBride suggested—I will come back to Deputy Dillon. I am not surprised that Deputy Dillon laughs, because he certainly was laughing up his sleeve while Deputy MacBride was speaking. He was smiling profoundly. Deputy MacBride made this suggestion to the Minister. "I will offer," he said, "to support this Bill if the Minister will give £250,000 to purchase a number of bulls." No wonder Deputy Dillon laughed up his sleeve, knowing the efforts that were made by Deputy Dillon, by the present Minister and, in fact, by every Minister for Agriculture we have had since the State was established, to spend all the money that was necessary in getting the finest bulls that were procurable. Deputy MacBride wants us to spend not only £250,000 on Tulyar but to spend another £250,000 on bulls, and bulls and bulls.
Comment on this
That is unfortunately the typical approach we have to a problem such as this. "It is unwise to spend it this way. You should spend it in some other way," and that coming from a Deputy who is very anxious that the Government should encourage any projects of a capital nature to repatriate the sterling that is locked up in London or elsewhere. Here is our opportunity of repatriating £250,000.
Comment on this
No, repatriating £250,000. Here is an opportunity of spending £250,000 in a capital project and Deputy MacBride says: "No, spend it on bulls." He says, of course: "Would it not be better to give the £250,000 to the civil servants." He says it would be a far better way of spending the money than spending it on the purchase of a racehorse. This money is not ordinary revenue. This is a capital project and the moneys that are being put into this project are capital moneys. There is a very big difference between capital moneys and ordinary revenue.
We had the very same thing lastweek. Deputy Lynch brought in a project here for bog development in North Mayo and to start a grass-meal industry. Again we had the same attitude of mind. Deputy MacBride says: "I think it is unwise to spend it that way. Why not grow strawberries in Mayo?" Bulls! Strawberries! That is to be our approach to every suggestion of capital development in the country. I am quite sure there will be some laughter in the Chancellories of the world when they read of Deputy MacBride's contribution to this debate which, I hope, the Irish News Agency will send abroad—this record of Deputy MacBride's fall, such a shocking fall, when he is forced to associate with Deputy O'Leary and to depend on Deputy O'Leary's defence in his opposition to a capital project such as this.
Comment on this
I do not know whether I am to claim credit or blame for it but I certainly brought Deputy O'Leary into this House.
Comment on this
You did no such thing. I was here before ever you came in and I will be here after you have gone.
Comment on this
Were it not for the fact that I appointed him an organiser down in Wexford he would never be in this House.
Comment on this
I am the very person who appointed him to that position and I am responsible for the fact that he is defending Deputy MacBride in this House to-day.
Comment on this
I was director of organisation of the Labour Party at the time and I appointed Deputy O'Leary as organiser in Wexford. I put him in that position in Wexford and God forgive me——
Comment on this
I would like to tell the House I never had any association withDeputy Cowan. I remember when he went up for Meath as a member of the Labour Party he lost his deposit. He never had anything to do with me. I would not touch him with a forty-foot pole.
Comment on this
We are discussing the National Stud Bill and Deputy Cowan should relate his remarks to the Bill.
Comment on this
Only for Deputy MacBride, Deputy Boland, the Minister for Justice, would have Deputy Cowan in an internment camp.
Comment on this
If Deputy Cowan avails of the privileges of this House to make an insolent and scurrilous attack upon Deputy O'Leary, may I submit that it is Deputy Cowan should be called to order rather than the Deputy who is the victim of the attack?
Comment on this
The Chair has called Deputy Cowan to order. If Deputy O'Leary had not made the interruptions, these remarks might not have been made.
Comment on this
There were no interruptions that I heard except the insolence and impudence from Deputy Cowan.
Comment on this
Deputy Dunne has adopted his usual tactics in regard to this matter. I think that everything we can do to improve the country should be done. On that aspect, Deputy Dillon has spoken this eveningwith restraint, knowing, of course, the particular difficulties which he was in. Deputy Collins has also spoken. Both of these Deputies certainly adopted the line that anything that could be good for the country should be done. I should imagine that when Deputy Dunne has an opportunity to consider this matter in a big way, he will realise that his opposition to this measure is unwise. It is hardly in accordance with the principles of a Party who want to create opportunities for improving the country, opportunities for capital development, for employment and national development. It is the easiest thing in the world to say: "Why not spend £250,000 on the unemployed?"
Comment on this
Is there any reason at all why we should have any unemployed? The reason we have unemployed is because we have not expended enough capital moneys in the right way. When we want to expend capital moneys on anything, we have the Deputy Dunnes and other Deputies coming along and saying: "You must not spend money in that way; give it to the unemployed." That is what I term the cross-roads approach to our problems. Anyone who reads or studies the philosophy of the Labour Party will never find that type of philosophy in it.
Comment on this
One of the means to build up this country so as to ensure that employment is maintained and increased.
Comment on this
There is a very big number of people employed in and about racing. Let anyone look around at the number of people that one sees employed here in Dublin if there is arace meeting in the Phoenix Park or in any of the other racecourses in proximity to the city. There are thousands of people who get employment in one way or another in connection with these race meetings. I maintain that there is a very large amount of employment.
Comment on this
Did the Deputy hear the Minister's answer to Deputy Dillon to-day when he said that only £12,000 was spent in wages?
Comment on this
There is an enormous number of people employed in connection with the racing industry, whether they be trainers, jockeys or people employed in bringing horses here and there. There is a very big number employed in and about racecourses, in the Tote, as bookies and bookies' clerks.
Comment on this
They all get employment in connection with it. We want to ensure that that large volume of employment will be maintained and, if possible, improved upon. If the expenditure now of a capital sum of £250,000 is a help to that, it is a small sum to expend but, of course, it looks a big sum to small minds.
Comment on this
It looks a very big sum to small minds and unfortunately, this Bill is approached by the small mind mentality. This House may be divided on the basis of the political Parties in it. There may be people like myself who do not belong to any political Party.
Comment on this
In addition to thatdivision between sides of the House, there is another very wide division. There is the division between the big minds and the small minds. If this country is to be saved, if its soul is to be saved as Deputy Giles stated, it will be saved by the people with the big minds, not by the people with the mean, narrow, petty minds, of whom we have had too many in this debate.
Comment on this
I can understand the approach of Deputy Dunne and his colleagues to this measure. It is a type of propaganda, indulged in particularly by people representing city or urban areas, which I can well understand. It is a very easy matter to suggest to city or urban dwellers that this is a very large sum to spend on the purchase of a stallion, and when it is said that the money should be put to other and better uses in which these people would be interested I can understand that type of approach.
I must say that I cannot understand the approach of the Clann na Talmhan Party to this measure. I fail for the life of me to understand why the Clann na Talmhan Party, who boast and claim to be representative of agriculture and of the farming community as a whole, should attack a measure of this kind that purports to be for the betterment of agriculture and that of live-stock breeding in this country, whether it be horses, cattle, sheep or pigs.
It is true, of course, that, in the West, we have not any racing establishments, but we have a number of industrious farmers who produce hunters from time to time. Our farming community are interested in horses and are interested to a very small extent in racing just as the people, as a whole, are interested in racing. I, therefore, fail to understand the approach of Deputy Blowick and his colleagues to this measure. When Deputy Blowick and his colleagues take this attitude towards this measure, I am sure that other Deputies representing city areas will question these Deputies the next time that they makeclaims for agriculture in this House and the next time they make claims on the Exchequer for the purpose of getting money to improve any other branch of agriculture and particularly of horse-breeding in this country.
Tulyar has got a very good canter through this House. I was amazed to hear at the end of his run Deputy O'Hara trying to wrap the green flag round him. I do not think that approach will gain any kudos anywhere, because this House, a number of years ago, decided the principle of the matter we are discussing to-night. This House, in its wisdom, decided to set up the National Stud Board for this particular purpose, to improve horse-breeding in this country.
I think the members of that board are to be congratulated and should be congratulated upon being able to secure this horse notwithstanding some of the suggestions and reflections that have been made on the former owner.
If what we are told is true I also think that this country got a special chance of purchasing this horse from the Aga Khan. I think that the thanks of the Minister and of the House should go to the Aga Khan. We all know from what we read that the Aga Khan is an extremely wealthy man. I have no doubt nor do I think that anybody believes that he was solely and entirely influenced in selling this horse to this country by a mere question of filthy lucre. We are also aware that some very close relations are more interested in the United States of America than they are in this country. We believe that the National Stud Board in this country were specially favoured in getting the opportunity of securing this horse for this country.
I believe the people who spoke here and expressed the view that this is a good investment. I believe that with some luck—and there must be some luck in connection with matters of this kind at all times— this purchase may turn out to be an excellent investment. The main point I want to emphasise is that the principle of this matter has long ago been decided in this House. It was a question that this board, when an opportunity arose, should take their courage in their hands and endeavourto secure the best horse in the world to stand in the Irish stud.
Some people say that the export of horses is not very big. It is true that our reputation as far as horses and horse breeding abroad are concerned stands second to none. It is true that this country in its wisdom sends our Army jumping team throughout the world mainly as an advertisement for the horse industry in this country and the export of horses. But if our horse-breeding industry and horse-export industry are not as large as they might be at least we should, as a matter of policy, concentrate on having them the best there are. There is an old saying in the country to the effect that if a farmer had only a goat he should be up in the middle of the fair with it. Although our horse-breeding industry may be comparatively small compared with that of America what we have is good. If we are going to maintain that tradition and reputation in world markets, I think for that reason alone the purchase of this animal, if he is lucky, is undoubtedly justified and that time will prove that the purchase of this animal is justified.
When we come to consider it, is there any reason why, having regard to the importance of this industry, this money should not be spent in this way, especially when we consider the millions of pounds that we have expended since 1925 under the Live-stock Breeding Act, 1925, on the cattle-breeding industry? You had the mentality—it is still there—of the people who told you that the scrub bull was quite all right and good enough for the people. We all know, notwithstanding the difference of opinion in connection with the cattle-breeding industry, that we have made tremendous strides since 1925 in that connection. There is just as much reason, as a capital investment and a sound one, to endeavour to hit the top as far as horse breeding is concerned, as there is in connection with the cattle industry.
Any Deputy who is concerned with the farming community and the agricultural industry as a whole realises in his heart that a good job has been done in securing the services of Tulyar for this country. He realises that theintention of the board in purchasing the animal was that in the long-term view they hoped to still further enhance the reputation of Irish horses throughout the world.
I will finish by saying that I can understand, from a propaganda point of view, the approach of the Labour Party to this question, but I certainly cannot understand the approach of the Clann na Talmhan Deputies in this connection. Horse breeding, let it be more or less what it is in my constituency, represents a vital part of the agricultural industry.
Comment on this
It seems that so far as the horse-breeding industry of this country is concerned the Minister for Agriculture, supported by many people in this House, wants to make us world-beaters. We have suddenly developed that frame of mind where we consider that the horse-breeding industry in this country should be the best in the world. I do not think that anybody on these benches would object to an ambition of that type.
Many speakers, including the last one, described the speech of Deputy Dunne and the attitude of the Labour Party as being a low form of political propaganda in view of the situation that exists in the country at the present time. One would think that Tulyar was a golden horse. Emphasis was placed on the desire of the people of this country, and especially of horse-breeders, to keep Tulyar at home. I do not think it would be a low form of debate, and I do not think there would be anything unnatural in saying that it would be far better to keep the people at home. I move the adjournment of the debate.