We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Committee on Finance. - Health Bill, 1952—Money Resolution.(Resumed).

Contributions 1–138 of 258. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Health Bill, 1952
Enacted

No. 44 of 1952 ›

When I made a statement in this House on Friday evening to the effect that Deputy McGilligan had, on a previous occasion, made a certain statement he repudiated it and denied it. I am now in a position to prove to the House that Deputy McGilligan did make the statement and I ask the permission of the Chair to read from the Official Report the exact words used by Deputy McGilligan. They are:—

"Mr. McGilligan: There are certain limited funds at our disposal. People may have to die in this country and may have to die through starvation."

Comment on this

Go on.

Comment on this

Read on.

Comment on this

I have not taken the words out of their context.

Comment on this

That is a lie.

Comment on this

It is not a lie.

Comment on this

Read on.

Comment on this

On a point of order. Is Deputy Dillon in order in saying that something is a lie?

Comment on this

What I said was that to stop there is a lie. Go on and finish the quotation. To stop there would be a lie.

Comment on this

I will read it again for you.

Comment on this

Quote the column.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy Davern should be allowed to complete the quotation.

Comment on this

Yes. Make him complete it. That is all we ask.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputies might allow Deputy Davern to proceed and read the quotation.

Comment on this

Make him complete it. I pin his hand to the desk now.

Comment on this

That is the phrase that was used about the Deputy's own father.

Comment on this

I will read it again:—

"Mr. McGilligan: There are certain limited funds at our disposal. People may have to die in this country and may have to die through starvation."

Comment on this

That is the statement which Deputy McGilligan denied.

Comment on this

Quote the column.

Comment on this

Column 562 of the 30th October, 1924.

Comment on this

Are you afraid to read on?

Comment on this

I was never afraid of anything in my life.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputies who think the quotation is not finished can read it afterwards for the House.

Comment on this

That quotation has been stigmatised in this House, six separate times in my presence, as a falsehood. The next sentence is relevant as part of that quotation.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I have no means of discovering that. If Deputy Dillon thinks that the quotation is not finished, there is nothing to prevent him from producing the quotation and reading it.

Comment on this

That is why I pinned that fellow's hand to the desk.

Comment on this

That is what was said of your own father. Is that expression of the Deputy's in order?

Comment on this

Yes, it is. Read the next sentence if you dare.

Comment on this

"Mr. Colohan: That would solve the problem."

Comment on this

That is the next sentence.

Comment on this

Read the next sentence in Deputy McGilligan's speech, if you dare.

Comment on this

That is the next sentence.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Has Deputy Davern concluded his statement?

Comment on this
Mr. O'Higgins

He is afraid to speak.

Comment on this

He is afraid to read it.

Comment on this

He is not afraid of anything.

Comment on this

I was saying when I moved to report progress that the attitude of the Fine Gael Party to this Bill was characteristic of them. The leopard does not change his spots. Neither has the Fine Gael Party changed in any way whatsoever. At every advance of the nation they have stuck their heels in the ground and taken an almost unbelievable attitude. As it was then, so is it now.

In fairness to the farmers of Tipperary that I represent I must state that I have no knowledge whatever of any farmer of £50 valuation with a Chrysler car in Tipperary. Deputy Costello stated in this House that this Bill was principally for the people of £50 valuation and under, with their Chrysler cars. If any of them have been able to rise to the old baby Ford, more power to their elbow. They need not thank Deputy Costello or the Fine Gael Party for the prosperity they now enjoy.

Comment on this

They can thank the calf slaughter.

Comment on this

Now Napoleon. Not to-night, Josephine. Deputy Mulcahy will have a very difficult job in explaining to the people of Tipperary that the Health Bill is principally for the people with Chrysler cars. If Deputy Costello had read the Bill he would not make such statements. He certainly would not have made the statement that certain bus drivers would be exempt from it. He forgets that every insured person is entitled to the benefits of this Bill.

There is, apparently, great sympathy for the people of over £50 valuation and the people under £50 valuation are begrudged any benefits this Bill confers on them because of the taxation. Deputy Dillon introduced what is known as the land project scheme. We all realise that it is the farmers over £50 valuation who get the benefits of it. There was no means test in so far as the wealthy people in this country were concerned then. This Bill will not commit the country to the same extent as regards finance. There was going to be £80,000,000 for the rehabilitation scheme. This Bill will not cost anything like that even over 20 or 25 years.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Higgins

It will not go into operation.

Comment on this

If you have patience you will be told——

Comment on this
Mr. O'Higgins

You cannot cod the people.

Comment on this

It is hard to have patience until we see the last of it.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Higgins

It began in 1945.

Comment on this

It is very hard to sit in the one House with a man of the calibre of Deputy Dillon.

Comment on this

You will not be long troubled with that ordeal. The sooner you get out the better.

Comment on this

Deputy Davern will look well in the Seanad when he gets there.

Comment on this

There is great sympathy now for the taxpayer. There was no sympathy whatsoever when we wereborrowing £40,000,000 in dollars and repaying in dollars. That scheme, which was going to cost the country over £80,000,000, was not going to develop the country but to enable the wealthy people to make their land healthy.

Comment on this

Are you against it?

Comment on this

Are you against it?

Comment on this

When we try to make the health of the people what it should be, then we have Fine Gael opposition. They oppose this Bill just the same as they opposed every national advance in the past 20 odd years.

Comment on this

There are 96,000 unemployed now. What are you doing for them?

Comment on this

Deputy McGilligan has a remedy there for everybody. Kill everybody—that is Deputy McGilligan's.

Comment on this

That remark should be withdrawn. There is no quotation for that. Even a dishonest quotation will not bring that in.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

"Kill everybody—that is Deputy McGilligan's" is a statement that should not be made and it should be withdrawn.

Comment on this

In deference to your wishes, I withdraw it.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Is the Deputy withdrawing the statement?

Comment on this

I withdrew it, Sir. Deputy McGilligan is becoming very tender-skinned now.

Comment on this

He is not a calf.

Comment on this

If Deputy Mulcahy will go down to Tipperary and tell them that the people of £50 valuation bought Chrysler cars he will get a hell of a hot reception.

Comment on this

And that you do not want the land reclamation scheme.

Comment on this

What about the 96,000 unemployed?

Comment on this

Go out with the white mice and the three-card trick.

Comment on this

Do not be hard on him; he is not a bishop.

Comment on this

Some Deputies have great fears of Communism in this country. They need not worry. I assure them that while Ireland holds the remains of its martyred dead Communism will never live. Do not worry. All the politicians on the other side who, for political reasons, will try to spread rumours of that kind will not get away with it. Do not worry. They will not get away with that at all.

This Bill, Sir, is an honest effort to do something that perhaps we should have tried to do many years ago if the time had been opportune. Naturally, if you wanted a healthy people one of the first things you had to do was to try to house the people. There was no use in hoping for a healthy nation while housing was in the horrible condition in which we found it in 1932. Not even one house had been built in a rural area. That was not conducive to the health of our people. Now that we have broken the back of the housing problem we can, I believe, with confidence, say that the time is ripe to undertake the task of restoring the health of our people in every possible way and of helping our medical practitioners to restore the health of our people. This Bill will go down in history as one of the most beneficial and one of the greatest steps forward that Fianna Fáil has been responsible for.

I must refute statement made by Deputy O'Higgins, Junior, statements that should not be made, with regard to the previous Minister for Health. Deputy Dr. Browne on every possible occasion showed that he was a man of great courage, a man who had the interests of the sick poor at heart. When he was Minister in the Coalition Government I said, just as I say now, that he was the one Minister that should be admired. He should be admired.

Comment on this

For going against the Bishops, he should be admired?

Comment on this

I did not say any such thing, but very far from it. I am quite certain that Deputy Browne has as much regard for the Bishops of Ireland as any Deputy in this House.

Comment on this

That is what you think.

Comment on this

He has proved himself a statesman and a Christian, and I can assure you that very few of the people criticising him here to-day would sacrifice ministerial position. He did rather than participate in something he felt he was not entitled to do.

Comment on this

He had to be put out for going against the Bishops of Ireland. I was on the inter-Party Government side and I know that.

Comment on this

I could not say that if we want evidence of our religion we should go to Deputy O'Leary. I do not think he is really an authority.

Comment on this

I am a Catholic, anyhow.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I have allowed Deputy O'Leary a good deal of latitude, but I cannot allow him to continue. He has been continually interrupting Deputy Davern.

Comment on this

I will obey the teaching I was brought up in.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I suggest that he cease interrupting, if he wants to obey the Chair.

Comment on this

No one takes Deputy O'Leary very seriously on religion.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Let us discuss the Money Resolution.

Comment on this

I say that Deputy Browne deserves not the censure or the mean statements that have been made here but to be taken as a man who for the sake of principle is prepared to sacrifice ministerial position and all that goes with it.

Comment on this

He had to do it.

Comment on this

I say that he has shown sincerity—sincerity that would be completely absent on the other side of the House, anyhow. I do not propose to keep the House much longer.

Comment on this

When he was in Clann na Poblachta you did not praise him.

Comment on this

That is not true. I deny that statement, and I ask you to insist that Deputy O'Leary will withdraw it. I certainly did.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

What did Deputy O'Leary say?

Comment on this

He says so much tripe no one knows or cares very much. He said that when Deputy Browne was a Clann na Poblachta Minister I did not support him.

Comment on this

I said the truth.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

These are contentious statements which are made every day, and I cannot interfere with them.

Comment on this

I believe that, contrary to the many statements we have heard, this Bill will not impede the work of any dispensary doctor, but when it has been in operation for some time nobody will be more pleased than the conscientious dispensary doctors— and, thank God, the vast majority of our doctors are conscientious, hard-working people. There might be a black sheep here or there, but the medical profession should not be censured because of that. On the whole, our Irish doctors are second to none, they are humane, and while at times they may be a little bit cross, through being brought out of bed late at night or something else, they do their work conscientiously and well. This Bill will enable them to do it in a more perfect way, it will give them more confidence, regardless of how they may interpret it now, and more appreciation of their work for the sick poor. I sincerely hope that Deputy Costello's statement that all the farmers under £50 valuation have Chrysler cars will be perfectly true long before we have seen the end of this Bill.

Comment on this

On a point of order, I made no such statement. The Deputy has attributed to me something I did not, in fact, say, and I ask you to direct him to withdraw it.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I have no means of deciding whether the Deputy is making a reflection or not.

Comment on this

With great respect, it is a reflection; and, with some respect, might I say you have a duty to ascertain what is on the records of the House and what I did say? The Deputy has stated I made a certain statement, which is a serious reflection on me politically and personally.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy misunderstands my duty. It is not my duty to get the Official Reports and go over matters contained in them.

Comment on this

It is your duty to accept my word.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

My duty to the Deputy has been to deal with a sole charge against Deputy Costello.

Comment on this

If the Ceann Comhairle thinks that a statement that I said that all farmers have Chrysler cars is not a reflection on me, then I have little respect for what the Chair says.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I cannot help what some Deputy says that the farmers have.

Comment on this

The statement was that all farmers have Chrysler cars.

Comment on this
A Deputy

Farmers of £50 valuation.

Comment on this

I made no such statement.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

It does not seem to be a personal reflection on Deputy Costello.

Comment on this

On a point of order, when Deputy Davern was speaking, he purported to quote from the Official Reports to establish the proposition that Deputy McGilligan stated that the people of this country may have to starve. I ask your leave——

Mr. Davern rose.

Comment on this

Stand your ground. You are shameless. Stand your ground. Here is the phrase that Deputy Davern refused to quote. He said that Deputy McGilligan stated that people may have to die and die of starvation. Iasked him to quote the next sentence. The next sentence is:—

" It might solve the problem, but not in the way that I desire."

Comment on this

That is not the next sentence.

Comment on this

You ought to be ashamed of yourself.

Comment on this

You ought to be ashamed of yourself to misquote.

Comment on this

You poor fish.

Comment on this

There is nothing very complimentary to Deputy McGilligan in that sentence.

Comment on this

Deputy Davern did open this in a disgusting way. This bears the mark of the scurrility used in this House about me. Anyone who tried that before has been called to order by the Chair and if Deputy Flanagan wants to employ his embryo talents like that, we may indeed get the chance of letting his nose be rubbed into it, as was done with others.

Comment on this

I would not like to insult the Chair, as Deputy Costello did and got away with it.

Comment on this

I cannot characterise Deputy Davern's conduct in the way I would like. There is a short word of three letters to describe his statement and there is a word of four letters to describe him for making the statement. The rules of order do not allow me to use those two words and I leave them to people's imagination. He was challenged as to whether he said the truth. Of course he did not. It is mild to say it was untrue, it was the furtherest end of the scale from the truth, it was simply the last thing from the truth, it was the assassination of truth. If Deputy Davern thinks he is going to carry this dishonestly conceived and badly brought forward Health Bill by this sort of tactics, even though he has the careful timidity of Deputy Flanagan to give him a little aid——

Comment on this

It is better than your attempt to create a false impression.

Comment on this

——he will get as little forward with this phrase as hewill with the Health Bill. The phrase has been used to persuade people to believe that I said that I would be prepared to allow people to die of starvation. The next phrase is there:—

"There are limited funds at our disposal. People may have to die in this country and may have to die through starvation."

Then Deputy Colohan, who was a member of the Labour Party, interrupted to say:—

"That would solve the problem."

Deputy Davern neglected to give what I said next, which was:—

"It might solve the problem but not in the way that I desire or that the Deputy desires."

If Deputy Davern thinks over the phrase, he will see that not even a pettifogging lawyer would agree with him that that establishes that I want people to die of starvation.

Comment on this

People did die, and died of starvation.

Comment on this

It is better than the disgraceful effort by Fine Gael to discredit the Bishops and make pawns out of them.

Comment on this

We are talking about that phrase.

Comment on this

Is the Deputy in order in talking about that phrase?

Comment on this

Yes, yes.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I will allow the Deputy to proceed.

Comment on this

Is it relevant to the Money Resolution?

Comment on this

Yes, yes.

Comment on this

When did Deputy Dillon become Ceann Comhairle?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

It is relevant.

Comment on this

It was brought in on the Money Resolution.

Comment on this

It is relevant to the falsehoods of Fianna Fáil.

Comment on this

Is Deputy Dillon the Ceann Comhairle now?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I am allowing Deputy McGilligan reply to what was said.

Comment on this

The Deputy was very strong to-day on theological matters. He is a bit pallid at the moment, whether from excitement or timidity.

Comment on this

Certainly not timidity.

Comment on this

He knows he is not playing the game.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy McGilligan should be allowed to make his statement without interruption. I am asking Deputy Flanagan to desist from interrupting.

Comment on this

I will, if the Deputy will bring himself to the Money Resolution.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

That is my function.

Comment on this

This is the second time to-day that Fianna Fáil members, first the Minister for Finance and now Deputy Flanagan, have sought to impose a condition on the Chair by saying: "If the Chair does so and so, we will do so and so." We can all be very rational and obey the Chair if the Chair enters into a compromise with any Deputy.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy must withdraw that statement. The Chair will not enter into any compromise with any Deputy on either side of the House.

Comment on this

I withdraw it.

Comment on this

I do not know whether the Deputy's timidity arises from the fact that he finds himself in the rather objectionable position of being associated with another Deputy at the moment. He made a mean accusation. If he read what I said and continued for a few lines further he would find that I went on:—

"To say that would solve the problem is no answer, is not facingthe fact that there are limited resources in this country."

I went on to say a lot more about husbanding resources. Deputy Flanagan's mentality is on the level of Deputy Davern's. I begin to agree with Deputy Lynch, the Parliamentary Secretary to the Government, that higher education has not had much effect, at least as far as Deputy Flanagan is concerned. I am anxious to hear from Deputy Flanagan his apology.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

We ought to discuss the Money Resolution.

Comment on this