Committee on Finance. - Resolution No. 3—General (Resumed).
Contributions 1–224 of 437. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
Last night I was drawing the attention of the Minister and the Government to the fact that the 1952 Budget had caused depression in the country and had created undue hardship amongst the most lowly-paidworkers. I pointed out that that Budget was responsible for the depression that now exists in the country and for the unemployment that has reached figures never equalled since the establishment of the State. Apart from unemployment, there has been emigration. In the whole Budget debate we received only one ray of hope, which was by way of interjection by Deputy Davern, from Tipperary, who stated that, in his constituency at least, for every one that emigrated, three returned. Unfortunately for my constituency, I cannot endorse that statement. Within the last month or two even some of the Government supporters have left and have brought their wives and families with them because they were unable to secure employment in their own country. If the Minister has any doubts, he should consult his agents who will agree that what I have stated is unfortunately too true.
There is unemployment and emigration. Men are working on half-time and others are working on a week to week basis, not knowing when they will be on the dole. Then we are told by Deputies who now support the Government that some of the Opposition Deputies felt a wave of depression when they read the Minister's speech in connection with this year's Budget. Naturally, they were depressed when they realised that no concessions had been offered to the business community, that no hope had been offered to the unemployed. Of course, the members on the Government Benches and their supporters cheered and applauded the Minister loudly when he concluded his speech. They cheered and applauded the Minister for continuing a policy that has brought distress and ruin to our country; cheered and applauded a Budget that has created such hardship amongst all sections of the community. The effects of that Budget were brutal because the people did not expect it. They had hoped that Government members who had gone around the country and had met the people would have brought some influence to bear upon the Minister so that, in 1953 at least, there would be some hope that we would not continue to have 84,000 unemployed, that there would besome hope that all our younger people would not have to emigrate. It is not that our young people have any love for another country but that they have no alternative.
If Government Deputies were to go down amongst the people they would find that in the last six months the breadwinners who were formerly in employment are now separated from their families, working in another country. Wives are left to provide for the younger members of the family. The younger members of many families in County Wicklow who were formerly employed are now separated from their families and are working in another country. These are the things for a continuance of which Government Deputies applauded the Minister. This is something that they are proud of.
The Taoiseach announced that taxation had reached the limit. Deputy Allen promised his constituents in Wicklow that no further taxation would be inflicted upon the people unless something unforeseen occurred.
There is no use in talking about stability to people whose parents or whose children have gone to another country. Members of the Labour Party have been lectured here. Personal attacks have been made on a couple of them by some of the Government Deputies. At the same time, we were appealed to to support their policy. We were told by Deputies, particularly Deputy Killilea, of the good things that the Government would do, and were doing, on behalf of the labour movement. I admit that the Government have good schemes to their credit, such as widows' and orphans' pensions and children's allowances. I admit that. All these good things were pointed to by Deputy Briscoe and Deputy Killilea, but they were very silent about the fact that during one particular period they were responsible for a standstill Order which prevented the workers from receiving any increase in wages to meet the cost of living and that there was no standstill as regards the profits of employers. Large numbers made huge profits while the wages of the workerswere kept down. To-day the position is that the increase in the wages of workers in industries giving permanent employment does not meet the increased cost of living. The Government Deputies did not inform the House that in the case of county council employees the increase sanctioned by the present Government was only 2½d. a day, to meet the cost of living. Then we are told that we should not criticise the Government because of some of the things they have accomplished on behalf of the people.
I appealed to the Minister for Industry and Commerce on his Estimate to restore the £50,000 which had been taken away from the Avoca mines. I pointed out that if further unemployment was to take place in that area in addition to the large number of men who were dismissed from the Forestry Department during the last month it would be a serious matter for the people in that area. I am certain that it was not through my influence or as a result of the appeal I made to the Minister that this £50,000 has been restored in the Budget. However, no matter in what circumstances, I am glad it has been restored in order to keep the men in employment. The secretary of the men's union had been notified by the manager that a large number of men were to be dispensed with. Then a phone message was sent to the secretary stating that the dismissals had been cancelled. Apparently something happened in the meantime and the £50,000 has been restored so that the men would be kept in employment.
Unfortunately we have a very large number of unemployed in County Wicklow notwithstanding what has been stated. There was a large number of dismissals from the Forestry Department within the last month. Again, owing to the decontrol of flour milling, some men who had been employed for years in two flour mills in the county have been dismissed and others are on three-quarter time. It is only a matter of time, I suppose, until these two mills will be closed down if decontrol is continued.
The position of the old age pensionershas been mentioned. They were given the magnificent sum of 2½d. per day to meet the increased cost of living. If a shopkeeper in Bray takes compassion on an invalid old age pensioner and supplies him a half-pound of Irish butter he is threatened with prosecution and with having his licence taken from him. It is a nice state of affairs in an agricultural country that a shopkeeper will lose his business if he is found supplying a poor person with half a pound of Irish butter. He must supply the New Zealand butter.
I believe that our representatives in this country should get together and come to a united policy on the question of restoring agriculture to its proper place. There were thousands of tons of fertiliser in stock when the inter-Party Government went out of office and the Government have now put on a 50 per cent. tariff and are charging the farmers 50 per cent. more for every ton of fertiliser which they require. The result is that less fertiliser is being purchased and, therefore, you cannot have a proper yield from the crops.
When the inter-Party Government were in power the old age pensioners could get their butter at 2/10 a lb. The price to-day is 4/2 for the New Zealand butter which they are unable to eat. Bread was 6½d. per two pound loaf; to-day it is 8¼d. and we are now threatened with a further increase. Tea was 2/8 a lb. and it is now 5/-. Sugar was 4½d. a lb. and is now 7d. Flour was 2/8 a stone and it is now 4/6. All these increases have taken place notwithstanding the promises made to Independent Deputies by the Fianna Fáil Party in their 17 point programme that they would not interfere with the food subsidies. The Fianna Fáil Party promised that if they were elected as the Government they would maintain the subsidies and keep food cheap so as to enable the people to purchase more food than formerly. The position to-day is that less food is being consumed by the poorer sections and the Government have reduced the purchasing power of a large section of the people.
Why has all this happened? We were told that it was necessary in order to balance the Budget. The inter-Party Government were charged with squandermania. Last night a Fianna Fáil Deputy—I am sure he must have embarrassed the Minister—pointed out that this was the most unpopular Budget ever introduced. At the same time he went out of his way to launch an attack upon an ex-Minister for carrying out State business in another country. He wanted to make a cheap cross-roads speech by pointing out what it cost. I am sure the Minister will agree that any Minister who has the responsibility of doing State business abroad does not take it on lightheartedly. He goes there at great inconvenience to himself, recognising that he has to do his best for the country. He comes back here a poorer man because the Department of Finance is not over-generous in the allowances which they make to Ministers or Deputies who have to travel on State business. Deputy Killilea himself must agree that when he was in Strasbourg he came back a poorer man than when he went there because the Irish delegates receive the smallest allowance given to the representatives of any European country.
Comment on this
The sooner we get away from this cheap attack upon individuals the better. I have been 30 years in this House and I have always opposed any person making an attack upon our Ministers no matter what Government they belong to. We recognise that Ministers are not wealthy men. They are not in a position to accumulate wealth and they are working for their country. I have always pointed out that, no matter what they receive, if they were working at their own private business they would be much better off. I hope we have heard the last of Deputy Killilea's attacks on the Ministers of the inter-Party Government for doing the work which the present Ministers have to do at the present time.
The Minister stated, in reply to a Deputy, that owing to the concessionhe has made by increasing the subsidy houses will be cheaper. I am proud to say that in my county we carried on the erection of houses for the working classes even during the war period. We are providing 40 or 50 houses at the present time on agreed sites. While the Government and the Minister have agreed to increase the subsidy on the £1,200 house we are informed by our officials that that increase will demand a sum of 1/8½ per week, roughly, from the agricultural labourer in increased rate. He can only secure that 1/8½ by demanding increased wages from his employer, and then we are faced again with the vicious spiral of which we have had experience during the last 12 months; one section of the community gets an increase in wages and that increase is passed on to the public. The people are chasing the increased cost of living and they are not able to overtake it.
Serious depression exists in County Wicklow. Unemployment was never so rampant. The Minister's speech held out no hope for the future. Increased taxation has been put upon the people. Deputy Briscoe chided us for voting against the Estimate for the Department of Posts and Telegraphs. Deputy Briscoe said that I would not state in Wicklow the fact that I wanted the unemployed man and the worker to pay for services used by the commercial community. My point is that there is no necessity to increase the cost of telephone calls. That increase is solely for the purpose of making good the deficiency in the telegraphic branch. Telegrams are only used now to send messages of congratulation or messages of sympathy and the telephone users are being asked to pay for the loss sustained on telegraphic communication. Deputy Briscoe thinks that is right. He thinks it is right that the old age pensioner and the unemployed man should pay for the losses sustained by Aer Lingus because passengers are not asked to pay the full fare. Because of that Aer Lingus has to be subsidised and that subsidy is got by means of indirect taxation on the poorer sections of the community.
Comment on this
No. It is Deputy Morrissey's baby and the Coalition's baby. They nationalised it, having made it bankrupt first.
Comment on this
According to Deputy Briscoe and Fianna Fáil it is wrong to ask the people generally to pay for the deficiency in the Post Office but it is quite right to ask them to pay for Aer Lingus so that the people who travel by Aer Lingus can get the benefit of cheap fares at the expense of the public.
Comment on this
That is a matter for the Government. The Minister for Industry and Commerce will deal with that problem.
Comment on this
Does Deputy Allen deny we have emigration? Does he deny we have 84,000 people unemployed? What solution is offered? What hope is held out? The Government asks us to help them in overcoming their difficulties. They created the difficulties for themselves. We were accused of being gloomy because there was no increase in taxation. We were anticipating some reductions.Those drawing the dole have to meet the increased cost of living and they were expecting some concession. All they are told is to tighten their belts, eat less and save more. How can the 84,000 unemployed save? How can the old age pensioner save? Foreign insurance companies can come in here and raise money. The Minister for Industry and Commerce is appealing for foreign capital to come into the country now because native capital has been exhausted.
No one can accuse County Wicklow of being lax in housing our people but the high rate of interest now is militating against progress. Money should be provided for housing at a reasonable rate of interest. Possibly something will be done about that matter. The ratepayers should not have to bear the full cost of providing amenities. The last Budget had the effect of increasing the cost of maintenance of inmates in county homes and patients in county hospitals. In Wicklow maintenance alone has caused an increase of 2/- in the £ on the rates. That is a serious problem particularly for the unemployed man who has to meet the increase in rates the same as everybody else. Business people may be able to pass on the increase to the consumer. But there is a limit to that too. We have reached the limit now. This Budget does not merit the applause it received from the Government Benches. I cannot understand how Government Deputies can justify themselves throughout the country.
The Minister appears to have no solution for the problem confronting the country. I will take this opportunity of registering the opposition of the constituency that I have represented for so long to this Budget. Soon the people will have an opportunity of registering their opposition. I am sure the vote recorded in Wicklow will vindicate my attitude now on this Budget. The limit has been reached. With the help of Providence, if we are given an opportunity we will remove these burdens and we will give warning to the Government of our intention by putting our man at the head of the poll in Wicklow.
Comment on this
As far as this Budget is concerned there is no increase in taxation but the Budget last year did create hardships. When you take into account that last year's Budget created hardships notwithstanding the fact that money was more plentiful and there was more money in the pockets of the people to meet their ordinary purchases, it is obvious that a Budget with the same taxation for next year will cause very serious hardships for certain sections of the people.
I come from a constituency where there is a big register of unemployed people. It is a big area of small farmers living on small holdings of land. The people depend to a great extent for maintenance on employment on relief schemes. The budgetary policy of the Government has in many ways adversely affected these people. Last year's Budget caused a rise in the cost of living due to the removal of the subsidies. As Deputy Everett has explained there was an increase in the price of flour from 3/2 to 4/2 per stone; a similar increase occurred in the price of the loaf. The price of tea is double what it was before the subsidies were removed. Tea is, of course, an essential commodity as far as the people in the poorer areas are concerned. Deputy Everett also mentioned the increase in the price of sugar. The Government were not satisfied with the increase imposed last year; they had to come along this year and add another ½d., so that the price went from 4½d. to 6½d. and a further ½d. was added on this year.
With all these increases in the cost of living and with the number of unemployed increasing week by week and month by month the country's economic position is precarious. The figure for unemployed persons is now well over the 80,000 mark and these people find it almost impossible to meet the cost of living. We may be told from the Government Benches that provision is made to give employment to people in need of it. But instead of greater provision being made for this purpose, the amount of money that was granted in previous years has been withdrawn. In my county in two of the years of the inter-Party Government's term of office—possibly three years but I think I am quite safe in saying two—the local authority got a free grant of £80,000. However, in the first year after the change of Government it is my recollection, although I speak subject to correction, that that £80,000 was reduced to £50,000. Last year it was further reduced to roughly £23,500 and if my information is correct it will be much less this year. How much less it will be I am not in a position to say but I am given to understand that there will be a considerable reduction. Such a drastic curtailment would have a very serious effect in an area where the people depend for employment on relief schemes. The difference between £80,000 and £23,000 by way of grant for that county represents a substantial reduction and is bound to create hardship for those involved, as it has done. It has done more than create hardship among that section of the community who find it absolutely necessary to secure their week's wages. It has also created hardship from the point of view of credit. Due to the fact that employment was available in the area credit accommodation was readily available but now that the amount of employment has been reduced credit is restricted.
As far as business people generally are concerned in this country, they are finding it very difficult to carry on because credit facilities are so limited. I have it on fairly good authority that the wholesale houses who, in the ordinary way, gave a reasonable amount of credit to the business people, find it impossible to do so now; the same applies to business people who previously gave a reasonable amount of credit to the public. It is now necessary for a businessman to have in his pocket money to meet the cost of goods he wishes to purchase for his customers.
There is no businessman to-day who can get credit or an overdraft on the same terms as he was able to get it before this Government took office in 1951. I am perfectly satisfied that the last loan at a rate of 5 per cent. interest has created hardship for business people from the point of view of what they have to pay if they seekcredit facilities. There was a section of the people in this country who always gave credit and it is from that section of the people that the public secured credit freely, and that is the business people. It is all right for large companies and large combines who have a method of borrowing, but the businessman has a different method and he will not use force or other methods which the banks would use. They are the people who are to-day severely handicapped and who are finding it very hard to exist. Their expenses are mounting and their sales are dropping.
I am given to understand that people generally are eating less, particularly bread. If the consumption of bread and flour is lower than it was before the subsidies were removed, obviously the people cannot afford to pay the increased prices which followed the removal of these subsidies. I should like to say a word in reference to rumours which are current in my county to the effect that the Government have decided to withdraw the turf production schemes operated there in former years. If there is any foundation for these rumours, it will mean that the people living in the poorer areas, the mountainy areas and the bog areas, will be deprived of substantial revenue which for many years past they have enjoyed from turf production. Many of these people have large families which they are trying to rear on holdings of a very low valuation. The cessation of work under the Local Authorities (Works) Act has also hit them severely. The disappearance of these sources of income means that the people will feel the effects of the taxation imposed by this Budget to a greater degree than they otherwise would.
We heard a good deal of talk last night in regard to the allegation that the inter-Party Government had abolished schemes of turf production but these very same Deputies support a Government which proposes to suspend all schemes of turf production in my county. On the 23rd April last, I asked the Minister for Industry and Commerce if it was intended to putinto operation this season the production of machine-won turf in the following areas in North Mayo— Keenagh, Dooleeg, Rathmorgan, Belderrig, Bonniconlon and Killasser. The Minister's reply was: "It is not the intention to produce machine-won turf this season in the areas mentioned." To my knowledge the people in these areas derived a big revenue from these schemes last year. Quite a considerable amount of employment was provided by such schemes and it will be a very serious matter for the people if work is not available this year having regard to the fact that schemes under the Local Authorities (Works) Act are not being operated either.
The stoppage of work under the Local Authorities (Works) Act is all the more serious in that people with small holdings hoped as a result of the land project to be able to add an acre or two of arable land to their existing acreage. If schemes under the Local Authorities (Works) Act are suspended or curtailed in any way, it will mean that much of the land which people intended to reclaim will never be reclaimed. It will be impossible to drain waterlogged land if proper head drains are not provided by schemes operated under the Local Authorities (Works) Act. Inspectors supervising the land project will not permit a land project scheme to be carried through unless proper head drains are provided. That is a serious situation for a county such as Mayo where many people were desirous of taking advantage of schemes under the land project. To-day, in many areas in the county which had the benefit of schemes under the land project, the fruits of these schemes are evident. As a matter of fact, large tracts that were previously waterlogged are now tilled.
Deputy Everett mentioned the question of local rates and I can testify to the fact that the rates have increased to such an extent that the people are unable to meet them out of their limited resources. I do not know what is going to happen in some of the small towns in the country as a result of the high rates which the people arenow called upon to pay. Things are bad enough in rural areas but at least the people there have the benefit of a certain deduction on the rates levied on agricultural land. The small shopkeeper, however, in the town has to pay the full 100 per cent. demand. From what I know of the circumstances of many of these people in the small towns I can say that they are on the point of unemployment. Their business has shrunk and they are faced with a very lean time for the coming year. Last year was bad enough when serious difficulties were facing them but these difficulties are at the doorstep this year. From what I can learn members of the licensed trade, particularly in the smaller towns, are confronted with a serious situation as a result of the increased duties on beer and spirits. I think everybody will admit that the licensed trade generally has always been well managed and was one of the greatest sources of revenue to the Government. I think it is regrettable that the Government should now try to wipe out a certain section of the people in the licensed trade by imposing upon them burdens which they are totally unable to bear. Public houses in a main street where there is always a passing trade are just existing at present but licensed premises in side streets or off the main thoroughfare and away from the passing trade are practically all on the verge of closing down. It is all very well to say that the Government must get revenue but that should not be achieved at the expense of putting a large percentage of people out of business. I believe that if these increased duties were not imposed there would be a much bigger consumption, with the probability that the Government would get the same revenue as they are now securing as a result of the increased taxes, and at the same time nobody would suffer injury.
We are told that as there is no increase in taxation under the present Budget, it will be necessary to bring about certain economies, in order that money will be available to meet the extra expenditure that the Government proposes to undertake in certaindirections. Let me say that if these economies are going to be effected at the expense of curtailing schemes under the Local Authorities (Works) Act, I think that is one direction in which economy should not take place. If economies are to be made there is plenty of room for them in the Army.
Comment on this
There is plenty of room for economies in the Army. I believe the strength of the Army is 12,500 men and were you to speak to any ordinary man with common sense in the country he would ask you what they are all there for and what was the necessity for the great cost of maintaining them. A well-equipped and well-trained Army of half that size, which would be assisted in an emergency by the L.D.F. and other voluntary forces, would relieve the people of 25 per cent. of the cost of maintenance and would give better results.
I have got the greatest respect for the boys in the Army and I had the greatest respect for those who served in the L.D.F. and the L.S.F. during the emergency. Yet once a young fellow joins the Army and subsequently resumes civilian life again, I feel that he is not the same man as he was before he joined up, not that the Army did him any harm but he got into a certain way of life and he is not a man you can put out into the fields or the bogs. There could be a saving of 50 per cent. in regard to the numbers in the Army.
I spoke about the increase that took place in the cost of living last year and also about the effects which last year's Budget had upon the people. During the year further costs were imposed on the people. The road tax was increased. There was an increase in C.I.E. freight charges both rail and road and there were increased postal services. Business was bad, and the number of registered unemployed increased from 50,000 to 80,000. Having regard to all those circumstances and to what the people have to face this year, I feel I am perfectly justified in saying that the Government will have to wake up to their responsibilities andhave more regard to the capacity of the people to pay.
People who are in need of a week's wages and who are short of money on Saturday night are the people who should be considered. Some provision should be made to provide them with alternative employment. Schemes under the Local Authorities (Works) Act were a great help to the people in the areas where they were carried out. The people in those areas are now facing a lean period. On my own responsibility and on behalf of the constituents I represent, I will vote against this Budget.
Comment on this
I was surprised and, indeed, disappointed at the casual way many of the Deputies dealt with the problem of unemployment. One Deputy told us that unemployment was more apparent than real. Another Deputy proceeded to quote from the Manchester Guardianand other English newspapers to show us what the unemployment position was over there, and the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs tried to convince us that the cause of increased unemployment was due to a world slump and to a recession in trade. It is interesting how all those phrases can be adopted by so many people. We were told there was a buyers' strike; that the buyers' strike was now over and that we had a recession in trade.
Quite candidly I consider unemployment a challenge to society. The 82,000 or 85,000 unemployed that we have in this country to-day are human question-marks. They are even more. They are living, striving human beings, unused producers of wealth and are unable to produce the wealth that thousands of our fellow-workers are crying out for. The paradox of poverty in the midst of potential plenty is an insult and a challenge to our intelligence. I think the time has really come for us to accept that challenge courageously and bring about the necessary financial adjustments to enable our people to buy the things they are capable of producing.
Taking the total number of registered unemployed and their dependents as 82,000 it is not unreasonableto say that there are at least 240,000 of our people on the verge of poverty. They are faced with poverty because they have not been allowed to produce so that they may be able to purchase the bare necessaries of life. What is wrong is that we are trying to operate a system that makes unemployment and poverty inevitable; we have thousands of unemployed and willing workers and undeveloped resources. I think it is a terrible reflection on our social system to have such a position existing. We should be able to make the system operate so as to allow all those people to live as human beings ought to live.
I listened to the Taoiseach speaking on the Vote on Account on the 18th March, 1953. I also heard him speak on the Budget statement. He made this statement on the 18th March, 1953:—
". . . we believe that taxation generally is as high as the community can afford, as high as it is wise, in the general interests of the community and even in the interests of the Exchequer, to push it."
The Taoiseach made that statement here on the 18th March, 1953. I suggest there is no message of hope in that statement for the 84,000 unemployed. Doubts are being expressed whether we can afford the miserable pittance of 24/- a week to them, which is only equal to 11/- a week in 1939. I remember reading a statement made by the Taoiseach in this House on the 19th December, 1934, as reported at column 1748 of the Official Report. The statement was as follows:—
"I said that it would be possible, with the resources of this country, for 17,000,000 people to live here in a higher standard of comfort than that in which the present people were living."
He emphasised that by saying:—
"I stand up to that. I believe it is a fact that the resources of this country, with proper organisation, are sufficient to give to 17,000,000 people a higher standard of living than the present people are getting."
Picture the position. Nineteen years after that statement was made we have not yet reached a population of 3,000,000 people. The Taoiseach told us 19 years ago that we could keep 17,000,000 people in a higher standard of comfort. Is it not worth investigating why we have the position we have to-day, with 85,000 unemployed and their dependents? We have 57,770 drawing home assistance. We have 161,000 old age and blind pensioners drawing 21/6 a week each. The purchasing power of 21/6 to-day is only 9/8 compared to what it was in 1938. Is it not time that every member of this House would set himself the question: what is wrong, 19 years after the statement which I have just quoted was made, that we have that position in the country to-day? A lot of people talk here about the economies that could be made by reducing this and by reducing that. In January last the Minister for Health addressed the annual meeting of the Cork Chamber of Commerce. In the course of his statement he said:—
"Industry, including agriculture, should be encouraged to increase production and, if possible, to provide more employment. An unemployed man could not contribute to the national income."
It would be interesting to know on what grounds the Minister for Health stated that the unemployed could not contribute to the national income. Is it not because they are not allowed to work and produce the goods that we require? What a pass we have come to—a nation of people all wanting food, clothing, houses and the ordinary comforts of life, all possessing the physical power to produce the goods that we require, and yet we are living in fear of want. The Minister went on to say:—
"Every day that the worker was out through sickness meant a loss in production. A rough estimate of the amount lost to the country by the absence of workers through sickness amounted to about £12,000,000 a year. That is a considerable sum in a country where the estimated national income is approximately £360,000,000per year. It has to be remembered that it is only part of the total cost of sickness because it took no account of the actual cost of providing curative treatment for those who became sick. A rough estimate of the cost of such curative treatment amounts to about £16,000,000 per annum or about 4.5 per cent. of the national income."
I submit that if it costs the nation £16,000,000 a year in the loss of goods and in the loss of national income for one year, that the loss to the 85,000, 87,000 or 89,000 unemployed is still greater.
I find, from looking up the statistics, that the total number weeks of illness in respect of which benefit was paid in 1951 was 1,763,700 as against 1,640,000 for 1950, or an increase of 123,700. According to the Minister for Health, this was a considerable sum representing a loss in production of £12,000,000 in a year.
Let us try and analyse what was the estimated cost to the nation of these 85,000 or 87,000 unemployed workers during the past year. I submit that these workers should be earning at least from £4 to £6 a week or £208 or £312 a year, because the average wage to-day for an unskilled worker is about £6 a week. I am allowing for women workers a wage of from £4 to £6 a week each. On these figures, I submit that from £18,000,000 to £26,000,000 worth of goods were not produced which could have been produced by having these people employed producing food, building houses, extending the electrification of the country, on afforestation, and in improving our land.
Yet, in that situation we had dead silence from responsible Ministers. As far as the Minister for Finance is concerned, he did not refer at all to the unemployment problem in his Budget speech. I suggest that taking the average cost at £6 a week, or £312 a year, there was a loss of £26,560,000 in goods and service to the nation by having those people unemployed. I want to suggest to Deputies and to the Government that this is one of the things on which they should concentratetheir thoughts if they want to improve production. There has been a good deal of talk about inflation. I submit that there is no need to discuss inflation while you have that number of unemployed people. I am satisfied that, as long as sufficient goods can be produced in the country, there is no danger of inflation.
I want to emphasise for members of the House, especially when they talk about all that they have in mind, that while I estimate that we lost £26,560,000 last year in the production of goods and services, that figure does not include the £822,832 paid in the form of unemployment benefit to the unemployed or the administrative charges which amounted to £332,771, a total of £1,555,603. Will any member of the House question my saying that it can be truthfully said that the costliest thing in the world is idleness, and that the most profitable thing in the world is well-paid labour?
I would like to see Deputies in all parts of the House take more interest in this serious problem of having our workers employed rather than in talking about what this Government did, what the last Government did, or what some Government in the past did—in other words saying: "What you can do I can do better."
I first of all listened to the Budget statement read by the Minister for Finance, and, when it was printed, I read it. Stripped of its window dressing, I want to say that it was good banker's language. He told us that the Government were going to float another loan, and that he was quite confident that the banks would respond and meet any reasonable request for assistance made to them in financing State capital projects, as well as those for C.I.E. and the Cork Corporation. I want to refer now to a very serious matter as far as my own city is concerned and those whom I represent are concerned. I am glad that my two colleagues, the Lord Mayor of Cork and Deputy MacCarthy, are present to hear what I have to say. I saw by the newspapers this morning that the Cork Corporation has now got permission to float a loan for £750,000at 5 per cent., the issue price to be 97. That to me means that it is going to cost 5? per cent. Is it any wonder that the banks would be anxious to underwrite that loan which is guaranteed by the corporation and the State, as well as to underwrite the loan for C.I.E. at 5 per cent.?
During the past year, the citizens of Cork paid £140,861 on working class dwellings for the year ending March, 1952. We have 3,500 tenants. Last year they paid in rents £112,000. I am giving round figures. They also paid £27,000 in rates and over £25,000 for the repair of houses belonging to the corporation. They paid over £13,000 in income-tax, and over £6,000 in salaries to the officials dealing with the housing problem. In addition to all these payments, they paid the enormous amount of £71,000 odd in interest on the money borrowed. In other words, the cost of interest on the money borrowed was over 52 per cent. of the entire cost of housing in Cork City last year. The cost on the rates in respect of the housing programme of Cork City last year was less than 1/2 in the £ of 31/6. The cost of the interest on the money was almost 6/- in the £. We were told this morning that Cork Corporation are floating another loan of £750,000 at 5? per cent. We should keep in mind the implications of the Minister's statement in which he congratulated the banks and said that they are coming to the rescue in all these things. In addition the Minister, in his speeches during the past week, congratulated some of the corporations across the water for subscribing to the last loan—for which we are now paying £1,000,000 interest until it is paid off.
I should like to know if the Government agree that the present system of financing projects is satisfactory. When the Cork Corporation get this loan from the banks, all the banks will do is to write in on both sides of the ledger and charge 5? per cent. to the ratepayers of Cork for doing it. I am quite satisfied that very few members of this House have taken any interest at all as to how the public are being placed by the system of paying intereston money for such socially desirable purposes as the building of houses, electrification, and so forth. Does the Minister or any member of this House assert that bank credit is superior to State credit? Does the credit of the citizens gain anything by being written into the books of a bank — which is privately owned — and lent out to the people? Should we not cease wasting the time of this House talking nonsense and, instead, get down to a serious consideration of what should be done for the people of this country?
The Minister also made a statement on how he is to get money in the future. I was interested to hear what he said about the Post Office savings. When I raised a question here about Post Office savings and where they are invested I got rather a curt reply from the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs to the effect that he has no responsibility in that matter. Needless to remark, I took that for granted. However, speaking outside this House during the past week, the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs talked about the "pseudo economic experts who talked clotted sentimental ignorant nonsense on foreign assets." I do not care if the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs accuses me of talking nonsense about foreign assets. No matter what intellectual arrogance he has displayed either inside or outside this House, he has not convinced me that we are doing the right thing with the Post Office savings of the people.
I looked up particulars of savings banks over a period of time. The amount due to depositors in the Post Office Savings Bank increased from £36,900,000 at the end of 1947 to £53,400,000 at the end of 1951. In the same period of time the amount due to the depositors in the Trustee Savings Banks increased from £5,400,000 to £8,200,000. The assets held against these totals were in British and Irish securities. I discovered, in going through these accounts, that at the end of 1947 British investments were 73 per cent. of the total assets. They were then reduced somewhat and at the end of 1951 they were 57 per cent. I submit, from the accounts, that in 1951 thesecurities held by the Post Office Savings Bank earned interest to the amount of £1,906,547 and that the amount of interest paid and credited to depositors amounted to £1,438,591. The balance, after providing for expenses, was put against depreciation in the value of securities. The cost price of these securities was £65,043,876 and were valued, apart from accrued interest, at £57,841,006 at the end of 1951. I submit that there was a loss of over £7,000,000 in the investment of Post Office savings in gilt-edged securities in London. I now ask the Minister in all seriousness, and with a full sense of his responsibility, if he will deny that during the past year there has been a further loss of £1,000,000?
Going through the last returns of the Post Office Savings Bank, I found that in 1939 there was £2,198,000 in British war bonds at 3½ per cent. In 1946 there was £5,628,050 in British war bonds at 2½ per cent. and also £200,000 in British war bonds at 3 per cent. These are very interesting figures especially when we remember that we are charging the Irish Sugar Company — a company that is doing a fine job for the people of this country — 4 per cent. in respect of £93,000 invested in producing sugar for our people and that we are charging our young men who are trying to build homes for their wives and families 5¼ per cent. for loans of £1,000 or less to be paid over a period of 20 years. The amount, if you please, set aside for provision against depreciation in value of securities was £328,562.13. I wonder if that would be so high if the money belonging to our people in the Post Office Savings Bank were invested in Irish industry. The remarkable thing is that deposits in the Post Office Savings Bank for the year ended 31st December, 1951, amounted to £13,645,273 — making a total of £70,321,809 due to depositors. Of that, we have £5,954,000 in England at 2½ per cent.; we have £12,421,010 in England at 3 per cent.; we have £13,147,420 in England at 3½ per cent.; and we have £4,450,000 in England at 4 per cent.; making a total of £35,972,430 of the savings of our people invested inBritish securities. We have Cork Corporation now saddled with a loan of £750,000 at over 5? per cent. for building houses for our people. Then we hear all this talk that has taken place here in the last fortnight and scarcely five minutes of it is worth considering as having any effect on the conditions of our people.
Comment on this
If he can smile, he can smile the last as far as I am concerned, and so can anyone who wants to smile. I suggest that the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs, with all the intellectual arrogance he likes to display, will tell me whether any of the figures I have given in the last five minutes are correct or not.
Deputy Briscoe was inclined to be very controversial in his speech on the Budget, but he did not leave me in any doubt that he stood for the present capitalist system and the private enterprise system. I have lost any hope of ever converting Deputy Briscoe to any views I hold. I am not finding fault with him.
Comment on this
Probably. I have my views and there are very few Deputies who have given any serious thought to this question as to who should control our money and our credit.
Comment on this
The Minister would be very wise if he addressed himself to the aristocrats on his side.
Comment on this
I am sufficiently conscious of the problems facing us and I am not going to make a Party speech. I know people in Cork City— and my two co-Deputies here will agree — condemned to live in so-calledhouses and in slums and flats that it is a disgrace to any country to tolerate for one 12 months.
Comment on this
Shame on the whole system. Shame on all those who are trying to maintain it and shame on all those who have that slavish mentality, trying to build it up by patching it, as we have been doing for the last 30 years. If there is any evidence as to who is guilty — I do not care what Party it is — the figures given of the way the savings of our people have been treated in the last 30 years of native government, show all these millions going into the banks, on which our people get only 1 per cent., and that money being sent across the water and then sent back here to start industries. I would like to know from the Minister — and I want to put every Deputy thinking about it — if the money in our banks is not lent in London at 2 per cent., to people who are using it here against our own native people to build factories and other things, to the detriment of our own progress. I was informed years ago that if certain groups outside this country wanted to get money to start a factory, they could get it more cheaply in London — Irish money sent across to England from the Irish banks and sent back here and lent to our people at high interest rates.
I had a question recently to the Minister for Agriculture, arising out of a statement he made in the debate last year, when he talked about the importation of manures. In the speech he stated there were landing charges, storage charges and bank charges. I started to think as to where the bank charges come in. I put down a question some months ago and asked the Minister the amount of money he had to pay to the banks for bringing in imported manure, fertilisers for the land, and he gave me the answer that he did not know at the time. He gave me the figures subsequently. I discovered later that last year we had to pay the bankers £38,000 for money lent for the time being in bringing in fertilisers to give to our farmers. I putdown a question last week, asking the Minister for Finance what amount of money the sugar company, who are the agents for the Minister for Agriculture, paid to the banks for money borrowed over a period last year and the year before and I was told it was not customary to give the information asked for. Then I was told: "Perhaps the Deputy could ask the sugar company for the figures." I did ask the sugar company and the courteous, nice, brief reply I got was that it was not customary to give the information the Deputy required. The result is that I am without the information.
Comment on this
I got two jobs to do last week when coming up here, from two of my friends in the country. One was to find out how a man could buy a tractor on the best terms and the other was from a friend who wanted a loan of £300 from the Agricultural Credit Corporation. I went into this particular place I was asked to go, and was rather surprised to find that it was an organisation which was completely outside the country but was operating here. I was told that my friend could get a tractor on 12 months' credit, 24 months' credit or 30 months', the maximum, credit. When I got all the figures, I discovered that he would be paying about 14 per cent. on the money he would pay for the tractor, for the 30 months which he had got to pay for it.
Comment on this
I will address myself for a moment to a deliberate statement of the Minister for Finance on the Sunday Pressof 13th November, 1949, that this country lost in 12 months£120,000,000 because of the devaluation of the British £. I ask him, as a Minister who has a responsibility to the people, if that is true? I believe it is. I would not expect him to put it in black and white otherwise. He had plenty of time to think about it; it is not a spontaneous outburst such as he is capable of making here. He said that in one 12 months the people lost £120,000,000 because of devaluation. If that is true, is it not time now that we should start here — apart from Party politics — and discuss whether it is not time for us to withdraw from the £ sterling and have a currency of our own and a Government of our own in charge of that currency and credit? Is that talking nonsense? I suppose that is some of the clotted nonsense that the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs is inclined to put across to us in his intellectual arrogance.
To get back to my point, I went from there to the Agricultural Credit Corporation. I just picture a poor farmer coming from the country and trying to get to the offices of the Agricultural Credit Corporation. I went in with the hope of going to the office. I was hailed by the man inside the door who said I would have to deal with him first, that I had to sign a docket. I said: "Is all this necessary?" and he asked whom I was looking for. I said I was looking for the gentleman in charge of the Agricultural Credit Corporation. He wanted me to sign documents, but, with all due respect to everybody, I think that day has gone. I told him who I was and what I was looking for, and he brought down a gentleman who interviewed me. The information I got was that the man could get the £300 for building a house at 6 per cent. over a period of 15 years. We talk about increased production on the land, but does anybody believe that that is the way it can be secured?
Comment on this
The Deputy is in order in discussing the Government's financial policy, but not the policy of the Agricultural Credit Corporation, which is a body outside this House.
Comment on this
I should be very sorry to criticise anybody unduly, but the Agricultural Credit Corporation is a State organisation.
Comment on this
Even though there is a board, it is the State which is responsible for the money in that corporation. All I am trying to indicate is the need there is for change and I ask anybody here if there is anything useful that can ever be achieved otherwise than by change. I know that the great obstacle to progress is the fear of change, yet there is nothing permanent in this world except change, and I submit to the Minister that nothing useful can be achieved except by change.
Comment on this
The Minister did his part before in trying to unseat me, with the aid of all the vile and foul propaganda it was possible for any individual to make use of.
Comment on this
He need never worry about my representing Cork City. If the Cork City people do not want me, that is their affair, but that will not prevent me trying to convey to the people the truth of what is happening to-day, and the position is that we have kept from the people who matter the truth of the story which lies behind all our doings. That is what is wrong and it is time people were told bluntly the truth about the situation here. Why should an institution from across the water be allowed to operate here,fleecing our people with high interest charges?
We were told here that the soul of the country was being sold through foreign capital coming in here, but I was surprised to see in the Press that the Minister for Industry and Commerce recently invited foreign capital into the country. I was not quite so surprised by the Minister for Finance who, when addressing another outside organisation in the Mansion House during the week, invited them to put more of their money into Irish loans. Will anybody who has read the bank returns for the past 12 months or the past few years tell me that there is not sufficient money in the country? Let him read the Irish Pressleading article after the last loan was floated in which it was stated that there was plenty money in the country. We have responsible citizens telling us that the amount of foreign money coming into the country would shock the imagination of the people but we had the Minister for Finance telling us that we should look for foreign capital to come and the Minister for Industry and Commerce saying that this was a safe place for the investment of outside capital.
What road are we travelling on? Is this what all the sacrifices were made for? There is no doubt that Terry MacSwiney was right when he said that he did not doubt that the people of Ireland would get their freedom but that he was not quite sure of the use they would make of that freedom. Nobody could be satisfied with what we have done after 30 years of native government. I am convinced — I do not care who looks on me as a crank— that we are just children in this House, without power or effectiveness in relation to doing anything we wish to do for the country, so long as we have the financial system we have. The sooner we get down to amending the Central Bank Act and giving the Government elected by the people the right to control our money and credit, the sooner we will be able to make the progress we are entitled to make.
Comment on this
Deputy Hickey's last statement with regard to what is notbeing done for the country is amusing, when on realises that during the past 20 years or so, this country had to face an economic war and an international war, and that when we tried to take the step of retaining the land annuities in this country, the people whom Deputy Hickey chooses to side with now——
Comment on this
That is not true. The Deputy will please withdraw that statement. Deputy Hickey is standing on his own, regardless of one side or the other.
Comment on this
The people whom Deputy Hickey supported for three and a half years did everything in their power to stab this country in the back——
Comment on this
——and to compel us to continue paying that sum of £5,000,000 to the British Government.
Comment on this
We did not. Do not start me telling the inside history of Deputy Norton's intrigues during that period.
Comment on this
Does Deputy Hickey think it is wrong for the Minister for Finance to ask an insurance company to invest here the money they are collecting in this country? Does he think it wrong to appeal to these people to leave a good portion of the money in the country for the benefit of the people who gave it? That appeal was made by the Minister to the Royal Liver Insurance Company: to invest here the money——
Comment on this
——which they collect in this country. Surely if an attemptis made to keep here money which is collected in this country, no attack should be made on anybody making that attempt.
Comment on this
That is another matter. That insurance company operated during the three and a half years of the inter-Party Government and no steps were taken to do away with it.
Deputy Hickey talks about what the devaluation of the £ cost the country. Deputy Briscoe, when in opposition, warned the then Minister for Finance, Deputy McGilligan, that the devaluation of the £ would involve £6,000,000 worth of dollars for this country in repaying the Marshall Loan and I did not hear Deputy Hickey making any protest on that occasion. The rates of interest on loans to local authorities were raised during that period from 2½ to 3¼ per cent. and I did not hear any protest against it. Deputy Hickey was a member of the Cork Corporation over 20 years ago — he is not now a member — and he knows that the corporation issued stock at 5 per cent. in 1930 or 1931. The people on the other side tell us that the value of the £ is much less than half what it was then. There is no doubt about that. One need not go very far to find it out. Deputy Hickey knows very well that the Cork Corporation failed on several occasions to get the money they looked for.
Comment on this
Even within recent years they failed to get it at 3¼ per cent. Does Deputy Hickey or any other Deputy think that we should leave our people without houses and put ourselves in the position of not being able to finance housing by appealing for money at a lower rate of interest, as we did a couple of years ago, when we only got £200,000 out of £500,000 and the Government had to underwrite the rest? Does not he think that it is much better for us to secure the money at 5 per cent. and make sure that therewill be no impediment to the progress of housebuilding for our people?
I agree with Deputy Hickey entirely that the people in Cork are badly in need of housing. I believe that Dublin and Cork are the two places most in need of housing. Their position would be far worse if a lot of the people on the opposite side had their way and if we had not got rid of the enemy that was in this country. Everyone will admit that our had housing position is a legacy of the British Government. At that time our people lived in conditions in which they are not prepared to live now. Now everybody wants a house. The people are not prepared to live ten and 12 in a room if we can obviate the necessity for that and we are doing our best to do so.
During the last year of the period of office of the inter-Party Government there were only a little over 100 houses built in Cork. During the past financial year we built over 300 houses.
Comment on this
I am just telling you what happened. In the present year we expect to build, and have estimated for, 400 houses. We hope to increase that in the following year. We had a deputation a couple of weeks ago, of which Deputy Hickey was a member, to the Minister for Local Government and we were told that as far as housing was concerned money need not stand in our way while he was Minister. Is not that a fact? We were told before that we would be short. We are certain now that the money will be available. With all due respect to Deputy Hickey and everybody else, it is better to get in the money. I do not know if Deputy Hickey has money to invest.
Comment on this
If he had money to invest, I am sure he would not think that 2½ per cent. now would be as good as 2½ per cent. was 20 years ago.
Comment on this
Many people who invest money are dependent on the interest. Deputies on the other side know that as well as Deputies on this side. When the value of money is so small, it is wrong to suggest that they should give their money at the same rate as obtained formerly.
I believe that we are progressing as far as housing is concerned. I appealed to the Cork citizens last night to invest their money in the Cork Corporation loan at 5 per cent. I have heard a great deal of talk about money being invested in savings banks at a lower rate of interest. Many people who have money on deposit in those places are also dependent on the income therefrom. It would be a great advantage to those people to invest the money in corporation stock at 5 per cent. for housing. I am sure that Deputy Hickey and every other Deputy from Cork believes that Cork Corporation stock is as gilt-edged as any other and that there is plenty of security for it.
I hope that the loan will be a success just as the issue of C.I.E. stock was a success. The fact that people were prepared to invest £2,500,000 in C.I.E. stock in a little over a day goes to show that the people have faith in the country and have faith in the Government and the people in charge. A couple of years ago that company was left without any provision at all to continue their employees in employment. The people who are talking about employment now made absolutely no provision for them. According to their Budget, they did not care whether the 20,000 people employed in C.I.E. were thrown out of work. They may not have meant that directly but that is what their action implied. C.I.E. were told by the Minister for Industry and Commerce at the time that they would have to work within their means.
Comment on this
When we took over there was not enough in the till topay their wages for that particular week.
Comment on this
The people have so much faith in C.I.E. now that they have invested £2,500,000 in it. They realise that things are being done in a businesslike fashion. They realise that the people in power now would not allow a chassis shop to be sold as scrap and the machinery given over at scrap prices and the men who would be still employed making chassis for the whole country thrown out of employment. These are the people now who talk about unemployment, the people who were the cause of closing up the Lockheed workshops in Shannon, when they shut down the transatlantic air service, the people who refused to allow the cement factory to expand and left us in the position of importing or trying to import foreign cement at a higher price than the price at which we were producing it here. We had to subsidise foreign cement, as everybody knows, in order to have a uniform price in the country. These are the people who are talking now about unemployment and high finance, the people who objected to appealing to an insurance company to invest the money they collected in this country in an Irish railway or Irish housing. They objected to our expanding our cement factory. I heard Deputy Hickey say they would not agree to give so much per cent. but they did not care what percentage the factory in England was getting out of the cement that they were making. They went so far as to subsidise the cement manufacturers in England and we had to charge 10/- a ton more for our cement at one period.
Comment on this
——what percentage the company in England was paying. It did not worry him. All that was worrying him was to make sure that the men working here and producing at a lower rate than the rate at which it could be brought into this country——
Comment on this
The Deputy knows very well that the price of Irish cement was lower than the price of English cement coming in here.
Comment on this
Yes, or Thomas Ashe and the rest of them. We have forgotten everything they fought and died for by allowing those fellows to dictate.
Comment on this
I will not be drawn into a discussion on those times. Deputy Hickey, during his time in charge of the dockers in Cork, often saw a little red brick building with the name on it "John Furlong and Sons" in which was manufactured all the flour that was manufactured in the South of Ireland.
Comment on this
The Deputy should relate his remarks to the Financial Resolution. The Deputy is getting away from the Financial Resolution.
Comment on this
I am referring to the question of unemployment to which Deputy Hickey referred. In Cork at present you can see fine mills and silos, as well as Dunlop's tyre factory, Sunbeam Wolsey and the others which sprang up during the period of office of the Fianna Fáil Government.
Comment on this
Those people talk about unemployment. Yet they scrapped the chassis shop because only three chassis per year would be required by C.I.E. We could not make them for the E.S.B. and the sugar company. We could only make them for C.I.E. and so we had to scrap the machinery and the people had to look at it being cleared out of the place and the chassis shop abandoned. In a debate on the Budget I would have imagined that somebody would have talked about the Budget.
Comment on this
I would have imagined that some of the Opposition would tell us what services they wanted cut down. But, from what I have heard and read, only two Deputies on the opposite side made any suggestion, Deputy Kyne, the chairman of the Labour Party, and Deputy Browne, and they said that we were spending too much on our Army. I would be sorry to hear that anybody thought that the freedom of this country which was so dearly bought for this country should be neglected and that in a time of war we should leave ourselves in the position that we would have to hand it back to the people from whom we wrested it. If we were not prepared to do our utmost to have an Army strong enough to make it uneconomic anyway for any other Power to take this country and to do everything in our power to defend that which was won for us by the blood of Terence MacSwiney and other peoplelike him, we would be doing a very wrong thing.
When all the people in the world are talking about preparation for war, it is a very wrong thing for anyone in this House to stand up and tell us that when a man goes into the Army he will be useless when he comes out. Men who went into the Army during the emergency were not useless when they came out. They were prepared to give their lives during that emergency and those of them who got employment when they came out are working as good as anyone else. I think that attempts like that to sabotage recruiting should not be allowed in this House. We want an Army that will be able to put up a decent fight if the need arises and that will not be left without the best equipment we can provide for them. We were being promised that for three years but nothing was done. We are doing it now and we are being accused of spending the people's money. That is the only service that I heard suggested should be reduced.
Everybody on the opposite side was saying that sufficient money was not being provided for the social services and the health services. Even to-day Deputy Hickey was suggesting an increase in old age pensions. I agree that it is nearly impossible for an old age pensioner living alone to live on what he gets. But, while being in agreement with that, I am not opposing the Estimate for old age pensions nor am I opposing the Budget which includes that Estimate. We had Deputy Costello saying that he would be prepared to spend even more than was provided for under the Health Bill, that the cost would not matter to him at all. Then he goes down the country and talks about our becoming a welfare State. Deputy Larkin says he does not see anything wrong with a welfare State. I wish some of these people would make up their minds as to whether they are for or against these things. Judging by the attitude of the Labour Party, they are not agreed about them because only six of them turned up to vote for the Health Bill in Committee.
Comment on this
I thought we were entitled to discuss the Estimates for the different services. These people want to get a lot more money for some of these services. I am suggesting to the people on the other side of the House that they should tell us which of the services they want reduced. Let them make their case on that and not be talking about things they know nothing about, such as high finance.
Comment on this
Apart from the financial aspect of the Budget and the Minister's statement, there is one matter I should like to refer to. Deputy McGrath has stated that we in the Opposition do not give any specific examples of what items we would like to see increased. I want to give one now. I regard the Government's attitude to the Civil Service pensioners and the local authority pensioners as a scandalous disregard of the principles of social justice. It is a scandalous thing that that unfortunate under-privileged and comparatively defenceless body of people in this State are not getting the increase in pension to which they are morally entitled. It is wrong that the Government should have refused to give to the Civil Service pensioners and the local authority pensioners an increase in pension even commensurate with the Civil Service arbitration award to which I believe they are entitled.
I put down a question some weeks ago to find out what it would cost the Exchequer to increase the pensions of Civil Service pensioners. It may be of interest to Deputies to know, as they may not have seen the reply to the question, that to increase the pensions of Civil Service pensioners on the scale of the Civil Service arbitration award would have cost annually only £62,000. We now have a Budget of over £100,000,000, and yet we cannot find £62,000 to give to the Civil Service pensioners. I believe it is morally wrong for the Government to refuse togive to Civil Service, local authority and other State pensioners an increase in their pensions in view of the increased cost of living, deliberately increased by the Government's own action last year in last year's Budget. If it is right to increase the salaries of civil servants, the Army and the Gardaí it must equally be right to increase the pensions of which State officials who have now retired are in receipt, State officials who have given such valuable service to the country in the past.
The Minister, in presenting his Budget a couple of weeks ago, went to considerable lengths to avoid stating clearly the financial manipulations he had indulged in in order to bring about a balanced Budget this year and he carefully contrived to avoid a clear statement as to how he was balancing his Budget this year. I would like briefly to give to the House what I regard as a true picture of what occurred in the Budget this year.
The Minister had to meet expenditure this year when the Central Fund service, the Supply Services and the payment to the Road Fund were added together of £116.6 million. He then found he had to add on to that figure a sum of £.75 million for proposed Supplementary Estimates and he decided — and we all agree with him in this — to give to the civil servants and other State employees the amount of the award granted under the recent arbitration proceedings and he estimated that expenditure as £2.5 million. The total expenditure above the line, therefore, which the Government had to face this year was £119.7 million approximately and the Minister decided, in accordance with our policy — a policy which he criticised very adversely and very bitterly — to deduct, I believe correctly, from that figure of £119.75 million the capital services which were included in the Supply Services last year and which amounted to a figure of £14.1 million. He then had to face expenditure of £105.5 million and that expenditure had to be met out of taxation.
We have available the figure for expenditure last year. Taking intoaccount all the expenditure above the line, taking into account the Supplementary Estimates introduced last year and deducting the capital services which were included in the expenditure under Supply Services last year, the expenditure above the line which had to be met out of taxation was £98.5 million, £7,000,000 less than this year. We have now the extraordinary situation that expenditure to be met out of taxation last year amounted to £98.5 million and this year there is £7,000,000 more to be met but there is not going to be one penny extra in taxation. We are entitled to know how that is going to be done. We are entitled to be told what magic the Minister has worked in order to ease the already over-harassed taxpayer because of the impositions placed upon him.
When we examine what the Minister has done we find that the Minister applied principles which were suggested to him by us in the debate on the Financial Resolutions last year. Last year we suggested certain items which we held would be in ease of the taxpayer, but the Minister laughed such suggestions to scorn and in order to meet his alleged Budget deficit of £15,000,000 last year he increased taxation and slashed the food subsidies. This year he has to face an increased expenditure of £7,000,000 and he resorts to the very steps that we suggested last year in order to ensure that the already overtaxed community would not have to pay still more in taxation. The revenue last year, non-tax and tax revenue, brought in £95.7 million. With expenditure this year of £105,000,000 the Minister has a deficit of £9.8 million to bridge. He does it in this way: he first of all makes a reduction of £.9 million for what is now called defensive equipment but was hitherto described as warlike stores. Every year in which it was possible, purchases of warlike stores were made. We suggested last year that it was wrong that the taxpayer should be taxed fully for the full amount of warlike stores. The Minister disregarded our arguments and taxed the taxpayers to the full amount of warlike stores brought inlast year. The original estimate for warlike stores last year was £850,000. Subsequently a Supplementary Estimate was introduced which increased the total expenditure on what is now called defensive equipment to £1.7 million and the taxpayer last year was taxed for every penny of that amount. This year the Minister has decided that is not correct financial policy and he has decided, therefore, to deduct half of the total expenditure on warlike stores or defensive equipment; defensive equipment this year will cost £1.8 million, according to the Estimates, but the taxpayer is only to be taxed to the extent of half that amount and there is, accordingly, a deduction of £.9 million in the Supply Services to be met out of taxation. But the gap was still too great and the Minister then proceeded to make further deductions and he deducted a sum of £3,500,000 for what he described as economies. Last year we called them overestimation.
Comment on this
If the Minister would state what these proposed economies are we would understand the position but the facts are that last year we suggested that in a bill of £94,000,000 for Supply Services it was normal and usual for overestimation to occur; we suggested that it was usual to have savings running into several millions of pounds on the proposed expenditure on the Supply Services. There were savings last year, savings which made it possible to bring in Supplementary Estimates without increasing taxation. Last year there were savings of over £3,000,000 on the Supply Services. We said last year that that would occur. We said it would be possible to give an ease to the taxpayer by allowing for this overestimation or, if the Minister prefers to use the phrase, economies.The Minister, however, decided to ignore that argument and he preferred instead to tax the people to the limit and slash the food subsidies.
This year he has thought better of that policy. This year he has decided to deduct £3.5 million from the Supply Services and he presents to the House a sum of £101.1 million to be met out of current taxation. Taxation last year only brought in £95.7 million. The Minister had to present what appeared to be a balanced Budget and he made reference to an item to which we drew attention in the Budget debate last year; speaking of that item this year, the Minister called it an allowance for the natural increase in revenue. He said that this year, allowing for that natural increase in revenue, he hopes to get £2,000,000 more out of current taxation. What is that but buoyancy in revenue? Why did the Minister not allow last year for buoyancy in revenue or for what he now calls the natural increase in the revenue? Why did he not give an ease to the taxpayer last year? Why did he not say that revenue would be buoyant, as it was every year before the Minister's Party came into office? Why did he not say: "I will not increase taxation by £2,000,000. I will make an allowance for buoyancy in revenue, for the natural increase in revenue, and allow the taxpayer off that £2,000,000." He chose instead to bring about the policy of higher taxes and higher-priced foodstuffs which was the charactertistic of his Budget last year.
There is also, in ease of the taxpayer this year, an estimation of £3.2 million increase in the non-tax revenue. The Minister evidently hopes that the non-tax revenue over and above the Post Office services which are under the control of his colleague, the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs, will increase this year so that the taxpayer will not be required to pay any more in taxes into the Exchequer. The Minister's colleague, the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs, was accused in the last couple of weeks of increasing taxes when he brought in his proposed increased charges in respect of the telegraph and postal services. Hedenied it hotly, but if it were not for this £.9 million which the Minister estimates he will get from non-tax revenue, it is quite apparent that the Minister would have to balance even this precariously balanced Budget by increasing the tax yield from the tax revenue side of the account in order to have his Budget properly balanced.
We are entitled to ask the Minister some questions. We are entitled to ask the Minister why he did not make an allowance last year for the natural increase in the revenue. Why did he not make allowance last year for economies amounting to £3.5 million? If the Minister, at column 1208, Volume 138, No. 10 of the Official Report of 6th May, 1953, stated:—
"There is little reason to doubt that within the framework of an expenditure of over £100,000,000 significant economies can be made without impairing efficiency or curtailing essential or useful services."
why, in a Bill of £94,000,000, would it not have been possible to make significant economies? Why did the Minister not make allowance last year for significant economies in ease of the taxpayer?
Comment on this
Has the Deputy not answered that question himself? What about the social welfare forecast in the Budget and other items that must be met?
Comment on this
I do not think the Deputy quite understands the argument I am making. When the Minister brought in his Budget last year, he added on certain Supplementary Estimates which he proposed would be brought in. This amounted in all to round about £97,000,000. The original Supply Service Estimate for last year was £94,000,000. The Budget last year was to have balanced at £97,000,000 including the social welfare services and including the proposed increase in what was called compensatory social welfare benefits. The argument I am making is that with expenditure at £97,000,000 including these things it is a very strange thing that there could not have been significant economies in that sum if there are going to besignificant economies in a sum of £100,000,000.
We are also entitled to ask the Minister why he did not, in ease of the taxpayer, make some allowance for the defensive equipment which was paid for last year. Every penny of the sum of £1.7 million which was voted in the original Supplementary Estimate for the Department of Defence was met out of taxes last year. This year the sum of £1.8 million is estimated for defensive equipment but only half of it is to be met out of current taxation. We are entitled to know what was the reason for refusing to give an ease to the taxpayer last year in these three fashions. If it was right this year to give relief to the taxpaper in these fashions, why would it have been wrong last year?
Comment on this
We have an extraordinary paradoxical position in this House. We have a Government here which says it has come in to restore order into the economy of the State bringing in a Budget which they say has a deficit of £2,000,000. According to the Minister for Finance last year the outrun of the 1951 Budget had a deficit of £6,000,000. The outrun of his Budget has a deficit of £2,000,000 and that is meant to be order in the-finances.
Comment on this
No. We are just catching up. That is all. We did not say we would do it in one year.
Comment on this
All I can say is that I hope he does not have another year in which to try it. The facts, I think, are quite clear. What happened last year was that the Government and the Minister for Finance in particular became bemused with the balance of payments problem. The thought of the deficits on our balance of payments account obsessed their minds to such an extent that they were unable to have proper regard to the real problems which confront this country. The Minister this year in his Budget speech described the balance of payments problem as "our greatest anxiety."What I object to in the policy of this Government since it has come into power is that they did regard the balance of payments problem with the greatest anxiety and that they did not regard the problems of the unemployed, the problem of increasing production both agricultural and industrial, the problem of expanding the national economy of this country as problems demanding priority over the problem of our balance of payments.
I believe that the Minister last year did not make allowance for the buoyancy of the revenue, did not make allowance for overestimation or for the stockpiling of defensive equipment when introducing his Budget because he wanted instead to tax the community, because he wanted instead to use the phrases that are spattered around his Budget speech last year such as: "reduce consumption in the State." I do not accuse the Minister of reducing employment deliberately. I think the Minister is too experienced a politician to set about such a course; nor do I accuse the Minister of deliberately setting about to reduce production. What I do accuse the Minister and his colleagues of is setting about a policy of reducing consumption in this State when there was no need to do so and when the natural consequences of such a policy were foreseeable last year, were pointed out to him, and which were rising unemployment, the reduction in industrial production, rising emigration and, let it be said, the reduction in the balance of payments.
The balance of payments account last year shows that we finished the year with a deficit of £9,000,000. I want to say categorically that that deficit is too small, that when you have a deficit of £9,000,000 brought about by reducing consumption in the State, by reducing imports, as the Minister succeeded in doing last year, the result is to increase sterling assets abroad.
It is interesting to observe the figures of sterling holdings of the commercial banks. The House may be interested to know that for the year from the 31st December, 1951, to the 31st December, 1952, the sterling assetsof the commercial banks increased by £9,000,000, the amount of the deficit in the balance of payments. We shall not have the full figures until the June Trade Journalis published but it is quite apparent that, as a result of the deficit in the balance of payments last year being only £9,000,000, we shall have substantially increased our holdings of sterling. We had the situation developing last year that we had to reduce the deficit in the balance of payments, that we had to reduce consumption in the State, that we increased the number of unemployed and that we reduced industrial production, while at the same time we increased our sterling balances. It is that financial policy that we on this side of the House are against. It was that financial policy, brought about, I believe, by the misreading of the economic situation, which we have been attacking for the last 12 months and longer — since the Government came into office. The Minister for Finance set himself the task last year of reducing consumption in the State. He did it because he believed it was necessary to reduce the amount that we import. He saw no hope of increasing exports or no hope of the price of imports coming down. He then brought about a situation, by increasing taxation, by slashing food subsidies, in which the people of the country were unable to purchase imports. In that crude fashion he brought the deficit in the balance of payments down to £9,000,000.
Our case against the Government is that that was unnecessary. Our case against the Government is that because he did that, all the evil things that have happened in the State naturally flow from it. The Minister had to reduce imports, the people were unable to purchase imports, but it was not imports of consumer goods that were reduced; it was the whole scale of imports. There was a reduction in the volume of imports of materials for agriculture and a reduction of 15.7 per cent. in volume of imports of the materials for industry. That, of course, affected employment here at home.
Deputy Hickey this afternoon referred to the unemployment situation.The number of unemployed on the 8th May last stood at 81,000. On the 8th May last year it was 64,000 and the Trade Journalfigures show that on the 8th May, 1951, it was 49,200. There has been an increase of 30,000 in the number of unemployed in the last two years. Industrial production last year declined to the extent of £3,000,000. The commercial banks' returns show that there was a reduction in loans and advances by the commercial banks to their customers of £4,000,000. As I say, during that time the sterling assets of the banking system increased by £9,000,000.
I think it is time that that financial policy stopped. I think it is time we had a Government in power who did not regard the balance of payments as the greatest anxiety. I think it is time we had a Government in power which regarded the number of people unemployed as the most important thing to be remedied, who regarded increasing production, both agricultural and industrial, as of paramount importance, a Government who regarded the expansion of our economy as the desired end to be achieved. It is time that we had a change of Government. It is time, I think, that we had a Government in power that looked to the real needs of the people. This Government is now in office but it is no longer in power. The country, I think, is drifting out of the control of the present Government. The policies of the present Government are makeshift policies and it is time there should be a change. We have challenged the Government to move the writ for Wicklow. We believe that the verdict of the people in Dublin NorthWest was a verdict symptomatic of the feeling of the whole community. We believe that the Government is now a minority Government, that the country needs a change of Government and a change of economic policy.
Comment on this
I am always intrigued by Deputy Costello's contributions to these financial discussions. It is true, as I have said on former occasions, that he has mastered a considerable amount of the technical language of finance. He can very properly make use of phrases such as"above the line" and "below the line" but whether he really understands what he advocates is another problem. I said on a previous occasion that I understood his speeches were prepared by a former official of the Department of Finance who apparently disagrees with the policy of his former comrades.
Comment on this
That explains the speech we have just heard. If I interpret this speech correctly, and I did my best to do so, in its early stages, it was a speech of satisfaction with the policy adopted by the Minister this year. The Deputy said: "The Minister was wrong last year. He is right this year. He has taken our advice. He has done the right thing this year," and then he wants an explanation as to why he did not do it last year. I wonder what is the reason for that change?
The House has listened for the last three weeks to a discussion on the Budget and I myself have listened for the past couple of days to the speeches that have been delivered here. Deputy Hickey spoke at some considerable length and he made it perfectly clear that he is not satisfied with the present system. He did not indicate how he would propose to alter that system. He says he wants change but the trouble in regard to Deputy Hickey's contribution is that he has made no suggestion as to how that change should be brought about. During the time I have been listening to the discussion I have heard nothing but repetition. A whole series of points have been mentioned covering every phase of what one might term political platform oratory. Every point has been used up here whether or not it fitted in or was relevant.
I feel that there is very little hope for the country if we are going to continue this practice of humbug. A debate such as that on the Budget ought to be a debate with an air of reality. I am perfectly certain that if any of our people were brought from any area in the country to listen to the nonsensethat was spoken in this debate they would not think very much of this House and they would probably be satisfied that there was very little to expect from this House. I take the view myself that what we really require is a completely new national policy and a programme of hard work.
If ones travels through the country one is amazed at the waste of agricultural land that one sees. Farms are derelict and not properly developed. Land is going to waste and farms are closed down. At the same time, we have very considerable numbers of our people who are very anxious to have that land and to use it properly. I think we will have to adopt a policy of more land division. We will have to adopt the policy of more tillage and we will have to consider whether or not the traditional policy of producing bullocks is the best policy for the country.
I hear a lot about the flight from the land and I hear a lot about unemployment but we cannot stop unemployment by talking about it here. We can only solve unemployment by doing something real about it and we cannot solve unemployment when we have so many acres of our land going to waste as it is at the moment—untilled and improperly used. What are we going to do about it? I suggest that we should agree—there should be no difficulty about agreement—on what we might term the maximum economic farm and that beyond that maximum economic farm no individual ought to be permitted to acquire land. If we could do that we could settle many more thousands of people on the land of the country.
Comment on this
Yes. A maximum. In other words, that there ought to be an acreage beyond which, in my view, no person ought to be permitted to acquire land. If we did that we could settle many more families in the country and we could provide them with the means of a decent livelihood. I am not too sure—in fact, I am very doubtful—whether the policy that isbeing operated for some time and which has gradually been introduced, the policy of mechanisation of our land, has been beneficial to the country. I do not think it has.
Comment on this
This would be more relevant on the Estimate for Agriculture than on the Financial Resolution.
Comment on this
With respect, Sir, if I am to be driven like everybody else to talking nonsense, very well.
Comment on this
If I am going to make certain suggestions as to how we are to end unemployment I think I am perfectly relevant.
Comment on this
The whole agricultural question certainly cannot be debated on the Financial Resolution.
Comment on this
I am only touching upon the matter. I am not going into it in detail. I believe that in a small country like this we can have more prosperous people and many more prosperous families if we used our land properly and if we used implements that, perhaps, we could manufacture and use ourselves without the introduction of petrol and those other foreign things we use now. I do not want to go into that question in any greater detail but I do think this is a matter that will have to be considered very seriously if we are to make any serious effort to end unemployment.
We want a big programme of constructive works. We will have to build not only in our cities and towns but we will also have to embark upon a programme of constructing municipal buildings which are badly needed, libraries, courthouses, municipal and rural halls. There are quite a number of things like that. Public parks might also be constructed. Only a few years ago there was a proposal to construct a new road from here to Bray. Everybody knows that was a necessary work but apparently it was killed by criticism from the very people who now say that we should have done something to ease or end unemployment.
Comment on this
If Deputy Giles thinks that is a proper observation to make he is entitled to make it. If they were removed I suppose things would not have been so bad. Unfortunately, our great difficulty is that we must be personal about everything.
Comment on this
The first sentence you started off with in reference to Deputy Costello was personal.
Comment on this
It was not. Anyhow, if we want to solve unemployment or even to ease it we have got to do something practical about it. I do not think we are going to solve it in the way suggested in this debate, particularly by members of the Fine Gael Party. I listened to Deputy Browne and his only solution was to reduce the Army. Deputy Rooney last night felt that everything that was being done at the moment should be reduced in cost and that the things that are not being increased in cost by the Budget or by Government action should be increased. In other words, the line is being taken of appealing to every element in the country for votes, rather than of making constructive suggestions as to how we are to deal with this problem.
I think, as has been mentioned, that after 30 years we must get away from this purely Party political line. The Minister brings in his Budget. It is a Budget for the year. It does not matter what Budget the Minister brings in, it will be criticised for roughly three weeks, and that much parliamentary time will be wasted. Unfortunately, the speeches will be speeches repeating what somebody else has said at some other time in the past.
Now, Deputy McGilligan may be following me. We know that he will be quoting, for perhaps an hour, statements that were made by somebody at one time or another, and that willbe the full substance of Deputy McGilligan's contribution to this debate. He will, of course, say a few nice things about me and about some other Deputies.
Comment on this
He does that. He will quote what the Minister said in 1922, 1932, 1942 or 1952. Now, what good is that? What use is that? Is not that a waste of parliamentary time and a waste of Deputy McGilligan's abilities? Could not Deputy McGilligan make some constructive suggestions as to how things could be improved? He could go back to the period of the inter-Party Government when he himself was Minister, and he could state clearly where he was at fault, where he failed to do the things that would have led to an increase in employment.
Comment on this
There was one important matter mentioned here this evening by Deputy D. Costello. I am glad he mentioned it. It is the matter of Civil Service pensioners, local authority pensioners and Government pensioners generally. I certainly support the case that is being made for the same treatment for those people as for others. There is one particular section of those Civil Service and local authority pensioners that Deputy McGilligan, as Minister for Finance, intended, if he had been longer in office as he has stated, to do something for. I heard Deputy McGilligan last year ask the Minister to treat those particular men on the same basis as the others. During Deputy McGilligan's period of office, I interviewed him on several occasions and asked him to do it. But, unfortunately, it appears he changed his mind in regard to them too late.
Comment on this
I know we must have a Budget debate every year. I would much prefer if we could deal with our financial business for a longer period than one year, and if our budgetary preparations were for aperiod of, say, three years instead of one year, I think that would be much better for the country and much better for stability. However, that cannot be done under our Constitution and so we have to get one of these annual Budget statements.
I certainly think, however, that the occasion of the Budget should be used for the purpose of making constructive suggestions as far as the Government is concerned. This business about a by-election in Wicklow and as to what the possible result of it may be, or a by-election in Cork and as to what the possible result of it may be, I think has really nothing to do with the financial business of the country, but it is being trotted out all over the debate just for the purpose of wasting public time.
Comment on this
I do not want to venture into the realm of prophecy but I do think, after what has occurred during the past year — after the stability that has been brought about —that Deputy Morrissey might be considerably disappointed if he had to go to the country to-morrow.
Comment on this
Last year, when discussing the Minister's Budget — it was a severe Budget and was so described by everybody—I said that it was necessary for us as a nation to take those steps so that we would correct the wrong tendency and the wrong inclination that was there. I am satisfied that it was necessary to take the steps the Minister took lastyear. I am satisfied that the Minister has been able to bring in this an "as you were" Budget with substantial benefits for civil servants and others as a result of last year's Budget. I feel that unless we are able to pay our way as a nation nobody else will pay for us.
I had very serious misgivings as to the way we were travelling during the latter period of the inter-Party Government. I made no bones about that. I had the feeling, and I expressed it, that this country would be run on borrowed money — that whatever money could be borrowed outside the country would be borrowed — and that the country would be run that way. I believe we have taken steps to halt that. It was only by halting it that we were able to preserve our freedom and our independence. Deputy Hickey has said something which I did not catch. I am talking about our political freedom and political independence which has been preserved and maintained by the fact that the people of this country are prepared to pay their own way. If we want to lose our freedom, if we want to lose our independence, we can easily do it. There is no trouble whatsoever about it. I think, however, that every person in this country would prefer, even at the cost of some little hardship, to maintain the political freedom of this country.
Comment on this
As I said at the beginning, Deputy Hickey stated that he is not satisfied with things as they are. In that, Deputy Hickey and I have agreed over many years. The difference between Deputy Hickey and me is that I indicate how we can bring about the change; Deputy Hickey does not.
Comment on this
I agree and I have always said that I agree with the policy of extending the powers of our Central Bank. I have always believed in that. But how is Deputy Hickey going to bring that about?
Comment on this
Let Deputy Hickey try to convince Deputy MacEoin, for instance, or Deputy Morrissey, that that should be done.
Comment on this
I have no doubt that I would have trouble. We would all have trouble trying to bring it about — that is, if it is to be brought about by an ordinary vote in this House. However, the time will come. Pending the determination of that question, Deputy Hickey has to make up his mind what change he wants and how he is going to bring about that change.
Comment on this
I think that the very first thing that Deputy Hickey must ensure is that the political freedom of this country will be maintained.
Comment on this
If the political freedom of the country is maintained, then it will be possible to bring about these changes. The only difference between Deputy Hickey and me is that I have my eye on the target.
Comment on this
I only wanted to make these observations. I do not want to follow the line that I have criticised of the very long speeches— many of them nonsensical and most ofthem irrelevant — that we have had on this Budget debate. It goes without saying that the Budget has been welcomed by the country.
Comment on this
I read prophecies in the newspapers of the removal of further subsidies, of increases here and increases there.
Comment on this
I think that the financial experts of the Fine Gael Party had convinced themselves that there must be extra taxation this year.
Comment on this
Not only had they convinced themselves of it but they gave that feeling to the country. The country, in that state, would have been prepared for extra taxation.
Comment on this
The fact that the Minister was able to introduce this Budget without any increase in taxation was very welcome news to the country, and that fact might have been accepted in much fewer words in this House than it has been.
Comment on this
That was a most weighty and constructive contribution. I was rather sorry in a way that the Deputy did not expose his hand fully as to what he would like to have done with the land of this country.
Comment on this
I do not propose to waste very much time on Deputy Cowan except to say — and I suppose it is hard to blame him — that he has tried to justify his support of the present Government. The difficulty of that task is clearly demonstrated bythe feeble effort which a very able Deputy such as Deputy Cowan was able to make. Deputy Cowan talked about unemployment.
Comment on this
Deputy Cowan cannot laugh off or whistle off or flippantly toss aside the fact that, to a greater extent than any other individual member of this House, he is responsible for the fact that there are at the moment 30,000 more unemployed persons on the register than there were two years ago. He cannot toss aside lightly the fact that he and some of his colleagues—including those whom the Irish Timesto-day said were elected to oppose the present Government — are responsible for increasing the cost of essential foodstuffs to the people of this country by anything from 50 per cent. to 100 per cent. over the price at which these essential foodstuffs were available to the community two and a half years ago.
We are exhorted to deal with facts. These are facts. Deputy Cowan tells us that the people heaved a sigh of relief at this Budget. Is that something from which he can take satisfaction? If it is anything, is it not merely an indication of what the people have come to fear from the present Administration which the Deputy is supporting? The Deputy talks about a "standstill Budget." This is not a "standstill Budget." In itself, the Budget is designed to take £7,000,000 more than last year out of the pockets of the Irish taxpayers.
Deputy Cowan did not say one word about the increase in the price of domestic sugar — an increase which has been announced in the past few days and which is made by regulation and not in the Budget. Has the Deputy any idea of what that additional halfpenny per lb. in the price of domestic sugar will yield? Has he any idea, or has he sought to have himself informed, as to where the fruits of that extra halfpenny will go? Is the Deputy aware that that proposition, which is now being given into by the present Government, was sought also from theprevious Government and the previous Government refused absolutely to increase the price of domestic sugar? Deputy Cowan is as well able to see that picture as I am. Nobody can see it more clearly and there is no man here who, if he made an honest approach to it, could not analyse and tear asunder this particular Budget and the Budget of last year and what has flowed from it.
I have here a copy of to-day's Irish Pressin which there is a three-column heading: “Dishing Up Figures To Confuse The Issue”. It is we on this side who are accused of dishing up figures to confuse the issue. I could find, in every speech that has been made from the far side of the House or by those who are supporting the Government, confirmation of that headline, from the Budget statement itself down to the Deputy who has just sat down. Let me take just a couple.
Deputy Bartley, the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Agriculture, as reported at column 1665 on the 12th May, told us that his Government had refused to accept an American loan. That statement is not true. If the Parliamentary Secretary or any member of the Party or any Minister wants to stand over that statement, I would like they would give this House and the country the date they were offered that American loan, the amount of the loan they were offered and the terms of it and the date on which they refused to accept it.
Comment on this
No, I am saying that the Parliamentary Secretary said that they did not accept it. "Dishing up figures to confuse the issue"—I will have a couple of references from the Tánaiste later on about sticking to facts and trying not to distort the position. In the same column, a little further down, Deputy Bartley said:—
"We were not vouchsafed the benefit of a grant. Our successors got both the grant and loan and they spent it."
This statement came from a Parliamentary Secretary. It is absolutely untrue.The loan was got, but less of that loan was spent by the inter-Party Government than was spent by the present Government. Approximately £18,000,000 was spent by the inter-Party Government and £24,000,000 or £24,500,000 by the present Government.
Comment on this
The Deputy can have his choice. In any case, £40,000,000 was obtained and there was £24,000,000 in the safe when we left office.
Comment on this
Unspent. As far as the grant is concerned, we never spent a penny of the grant. It is still there and still cannot be spent because of the muddling of the present Government in relation to it. That is on record.
Comment on this
The Deputy wants to make his views on that matter at home and abroad. He made them abroad, to his own notoriety but perhaps neither to the welfare nor the desire of this country.
Comment on this
If he does not give way — that is the same attitude as sending over speeches to be read out in Strasbourg.
Comment on this
The trouble about this is that it is all right, while they are making speeches themselves, to attribute most unworthy motives to any member of this House, but no one is supposed to have the right to reply to them. I am demonstrating this from the Official Report and I was not referring to Deputy Cowan. He knows that.
Comment on this
You are making a good shot at it. I was quoting from the Official Report the exact words of Parliamentary Secretary Bartley and was confirming——
Comment on this
"Dishing up figures to confuse the issue." Deputy Briscoe is nobody's fool; he is an intelligent man and he is a very intelligent person when he is dealing with finances and he knows what he is talking about. He spoke for over two hours on this Budget, I think, and he had some passages with Deputy Everett and others. In column 1614 of the 12th May, he said, as reported at thebottom of that column, in reply to Deputy Everett:—
"Is the Deputy suggesting that, during his time as Minister in the Coalition Government, there was no subsidy taken off food, or does he want me to prove that to him?"
You turn over to the next page where, a few lines from the top of the column, Deputy Briscoe says again:—
"Does the Deputy deny that food subsidies were removed during his time as Minister?"
There were a few interruptions or interjections then. Further down that same column, Deputy Briscoe went on to say this:—
"Deputy Everett has been speaking about food subsidies. I have something here which I should like to read for him. It occurred during the time when he was Minister in the Coalition Government. I propose to quote from the Dáil Debates, Volume 110, column 1041, of the 4th May, 1938. This is the quotation:—
‘Estimates for the present financial year were framed on the basis that food subsidies would cost £15,143,000, which compares with £4,426,000 estimated in the Budget of May last year. Of the additional duties imposed to meet the cost of the increased subsidies provided for in the Supplementary Budget, the Government have already abolished, at a cost to revenue of the order of £6,000,000 in the present year, those which they felt bore heavily on particular classes of the community. . .'
There you have £6,000,000 worth of subsidies taken off the backs of the taxpayer because Deputy Everett said it was unfair to have them subsidising the poor. Now who is shouting about food subsidies?"
Comment on this
I will explain it, and I think Deputy Cowan will see the point I am making. Deputy Briscoe was setting out in his own words toprove to Deputy Everett and to the House that we had taken £6,000,000 off the subsidies in May, 1948. But the £6,000,000 to which he was referring specifically was, of course, part of the additional duties imposed in the Supplementary Budget, which was Deputy Aiken's Supplementary Budget —he was then Minister for Finance— in 1947. The £6,000,000 we took off before May, 1948, was not £6,000,000 in subsidies, but the £6,000,000 additional taxation imposed on beer, spirits, tobacco and cinema tickets.
Comment on this
You can always know when you are getting home, when you are making a telling point, because Deputy Cowan always butts in. If you are not making a telling point, he will keep very quiet.
Comment on this
I give the Deputy credit for being sufficiently intelligent to know. I have unfortunately also to come to the conclusion that, no matter how good, how effective or how telling my point may be, it will not alter the Deputy in his trot in any way or the direction in which he is trotting. I am making it perfectly clear here that Deputy Briscoe, when he comes to deal with figures or finance, is an intelligent man, and I have to draw the conclusion from the use which Deputy Briscoe tried to make of that quotation of 4th May, 1948, that he was either doing it deliberately or is not the master of figures and finance that he would wish us in this House and the people outside to believe. I am quoting these figures as against the three column headline in "Truth in theNews" this morning, that we are trying to confuse the issue.
Deputy Cowan had a very cheap and, indeed, a very unworthy sneer to make about the Deputy who preceded him. It was unworthy of Deputy Cowan. I am rather glad of the fact that we have in this country and in this House — I would be still more glad if we had more of them, irrespective of what side of the House they sat on —young men who are capable of analysing and examining and criticising the Budget statement. Perhaps if some more of us — I am not suggesting for one moment that Deputy Costello did this — had our speeches checked in advance by somebody competent to do so, we might have better speeches——
Comment on this
——and fewer bad reactions. The trouble about it is that some of us are quite conscious of the fact that we do not know everything. Some of us are quite conscious of the fact that we still have a lot to learn, despite the length of time for which some of us have been in public life, and of the fact that we can learn from people not merely inside but outside this House. Deputies ought to have some sense of fair play. It is quite right, apparently, for Deputy Briscoe to make that statement, to give that twist — I do not say he did it deliberately — to that quotation from the Minister's speech of 4th May, 1948, but apparently it is quite wrong for me to expose that Deputy Briscoe was wrong and to explain what the real position is and was.
Let me refer again to that infallible and always truthful journal, the Irish Press.Another article appeared the morning after the Tánaiste had concluded the talks on the Budget over the radio —“Difficult period over”. Deputy Cowan told us that we have reached stability — stability in the present rate of unemployment, in the present rate of emigration and the present level of prices. The Tánaiste is reported in this journal as saying:—
"The difficult period is over and now we can face the future in the certainty that it will yield a continuing improvement in economic and social conditions."
I hope he is right about the future but he is wrong about the present.
Comment on this
He is not, as I will demonstrate. It does not give me any particular pleasure to have to say this. I experience it in my everyday life and it is no additional money in my pocket to have conditions as they are. "The difficult period is over"— the difficult period is not over. You cannot say that the difficult period is over when the registered number of unemployed wavers between 80,000 and 90,000. That figure, if it could be justified at all, could be justified only in a period of extreme difficulty and danger, and the existence of that figure of 80,000 or 90,000 unemployed is, in itself, sufficient to show that that is not true.
I have a few other comments, however, to make about it, and — whether Deputies like to accept it or not — I am not trying to exaggerate. I am trying to state the position as I see it and as I hear of it from those with whom I mix. The difficult period is not over and the business slump in the country is as bad to-day as at any time in the past 12 months, taking business as a whole. I ask any Deputy — I do not care on what side he sits — to go out and privately ask any businessman in this city or in the country to-day — I do not care, either, whether he is a supporter or an opponent of his — if that statement of mine is not true.
Comment on this
I will deal with the farmers in a moment, if the Deputy will allow me. I propose to come to them in another connection. There is an aspect of that I could talk about, but I will come to them in a moment. The statement I make is true and Deputy Cowan, as a professional man, knows that it is true. Any person in the House who is a trade unionist and who is in touch with the workers andwith the unemployed knows that it is true.