Health Bill, 1952—Committee (Resumed).
Contributions 246–505 of 505. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 44 of 1952 ›
If the Deputy continues to make protracted references, I must ask him to give his source or else discontinue.
Comment on this
I think you know. They did say that the sections claimeddangerous powers for the public health authority.
Comment on this
If the document is to be quoted, as this has been all the evening, am I entitled to request that that document be placed on the records of the House so that at least we will be able to read what is in it?
Comment on this
I want to submit— if Deputy McGilligan, on a point of order, would not mind sitting down— that this document has been quoted in the course of the debate now for hours and the Deputy, every time the matter is referred to, says this document was issued to the faithful. You, Sir, know, as I know, that no such document was issued to the faithful and therefore, if there is to be such an extensive quotation from a document, I ask that it be placed on the records of the House.
Comment on this
I know nothing about the document. I do not know whether the document was published. It has been the practice here when a document has been quoted from that it be placed at the disposal of Deputies. No other Deputy seems to have seen that document except Deputy McGilligan, at least no other Deputy has made use of it. If Deputy McGilligan proceeds to make protracted references to that document——
Comment on this
The source is a letter sent by the Cardinal and by the Bishop of Raphoe and the Bishop of Achonry as secretaries to the Hierarchy. That is the source of my reference. The document has not been published.
Comment on this
The date is not on the document. It is easy to get the date if you take the date upon which the Taoiseach ran across the Border and then went down to see the Editor of the Irish Times, which was within six hours afterwards.
Comment on this
It has been stated by Deputy McGilligan that the document is undated. That indicates clearly, whatever he is quoting from, that that is certainly not the document issued by the Bishops which was referred to.
Comment on this
I do not know. I am not bound to give any date. It is a document issued by the Hierarchy.
Comment on this
Then I do not know why this crossing of the Border went on. If the date is of any materiality, I can give it.
Comment on this
I would not give anything to the Deputy. If there is any feeling in the House that the date must be given, I will certainly give it, but I am not giving it in reply to casual observations in the House.
Comment on this
The main idea in asking for information with regard to a document of that kind is that the information may be available to all Deputies.
Comment on this
I cannot, unfortunately, give it to Deputies. It is not in my power because the Government have stopped it.
Comment on this
I know that the Deputyhas told a lot of untruths. I did not get up because I did not expect anything else from him.
Comment on this
Will the Minister say that it is an untruth for me to state that a document signed by the Cardinal and two Bishops, as secretaries to the Hierarchy, was issued to four newspapers on or about 4th April this year? Is that an untruth?
Comment on this
I am sick and tired of this damned thing of the good Catholics over there. Look at them—bloody frauds and hypocrites. That is what they are.
Comment on this
If the Deputy only makes a reference, I am not ruling on it, but if he does he must make it available.
Comment on this
Is it in order for the Minister, when speaking of Opposition Deputies, to call them "bloody hypocrites"?
Comment on this
The expression "bloody hypocrites" is an un-parliamentary expression and should not be used. I ask the Minister to withdraw it.
Comment on this
The Deputy will not introduce the expression in that fashion either. The expression is out of order and must not be referred to again.
Comment on this
I thoroughly agree. I hope I am not misinformed, but I understand that we were to have a considerable amount of obstruction in regard to this Bill up to a certain stage, that then there would be a demonstration in the House against it and that the Fine Gael Front Bench would then leave.
Comment on this
The Chair was under the same misapprehension as I was. I thought he had surrendered.
Comment on this
I was just waiting for a ruling of the Chair about disorderly language. I want to make a reference to this document. I have been asked whether the 1947 Act met with my approval. It did not meet with my approval at any time. Sections 21 to 28 were the ones to which we directed our Attorney-General's attention, and he ruled that two of them were distinctly unconstitutional and that regulations made under most of the others would certainly advance the matter to being a breach of the Constitution. We ordered these sections to be removed. These are the sections to which the Hierarchy mainly took exception. I understand at that stage that they spoke of the power of thepublic health authorities to treat all the illnesses and defects of children and stated that they were neglecting the pre-existing rights of the parents and of the families, particularly the parents. They spoke of the power to deal with women in respect of the gynaecological and other kinds of treatment and stated that the Catholic view with regard to sex relations was opposed by people in many countries and that these people were making provision for birth control, abortion and so on. On these grounds they were desperately afraid in regard to Sections 21 to 28 of the Act of 1947. They spoke of the claim made to direct the child according to materialistic principles.
Having stated their view of Sections 21 to 28, they went on to say that there was no safeguard provided with regard to Catholic mothers, no respect for the rights of parents, no provision that children and mothers would have to be treated in accordance with Catholic principles. They welcomed the fact that these sections had disappeared. I welcomed the fact that they had disappeared as I always objected to them, at any rate on constitutional grounds. We had discovered when in office that the Archbishop of Dublin had written a letter objecting to these things, not on constitutional grounds, but on moral grounds. These two matters were before the Cabinet to which I belonged and we presevered in that objection all the time.
The position we were in with regard to health legislation was that there never was any health legislation in the offing. There was never any scheme. There was a certain amount of what the Hierarchy called vague promises of a general type, but no detailed information as to their implementation or any principles by which the implementation could be worked out.
Comment on this
I did not. I do not know anything about it. Money was provided under the health services for making grants to the health authorities, and it was all used. The factthat it was all used makes it quite clear that there was no scheme. It could not be used under the 1947 Act because there were no regulations made under the 1947 Act in relation to mothers and children. There is the old red ticket business and all that. Money was provided for it. If the Minister wants to find out why certain moneys were provided he will find that recorded in a minute where the officials of the Department of Health came to discuss matters with the officials of the Department of Finance and put up the contention that whatever sum was carried into the Estimate could not be cut down, otherwise the doctors would be able to say that they had beaten the Minister for Health. I understood that the money would be spent for health services.
To come back to the amendment. Deputy Costello put very forcibly what I tried to put in my own limited way— that where there is power taken by Order to direct certain institutional services which the health authority must comply with, and that includes the provision of advice and treatment at an institution, it is possible under that for an Order to be given directing treatment of a type contrary to the principles which the Hierarchy have attempted to make clear to the faithful and which they have made clear to the Government. The Minister would be better advised to accept an enlargement of the first amendment and to provide not merely for patients but for the medicos who are going to comply with the directions. If I again have to meet the argument that people cannot accept, that people will do anything contrary to their conscience, then, if we accept that, we need not have either Section 4 or the first amendment brought in by the Minister because the same argument will apply. Patients in this religious community would not for one moment submit to any treatment contrary to the teachings of their religion. If that is an argument in regard to the doctor—and it is a sound argument—it is apparently not a good argument with regard to the patient. The same reasoning ought to lead the Minister to bring ina safeguard with regard to the doctor who is going to be made enforce these regulations.
Comment on this
I marvel at the arrogant suggestion of Deputy McGilligan that he did not give authority and did not take part in authorising me, as Minister for Health, to undertake to carry out the details for the implementation of a mother-and-child scheme. Section 21 of the Health Act, 1947, provided:
"A health authority shall, in accordance with regulations made under Section 28 of this Act, make arrangements for safeguarding the health of women in respect of motherhood and for their education in that respect."
Section 22 provided:—
"A health authority shall, in accordance with regulations made under Section 28 of this Act, do, in respect of children in their functional area who are not pupils of any school, the following things——"
The Act then goes on to detail, under the headings (a), (b), (c), (d) and (e), full treatment for children up to 16 years of age. All the documents in relation to the decision and the direction put by me and submitted by me, as Minister for Health, to the Cabinet were read by Deputy McGilligan presumably. In the light of those circumstances he was to make his decision. He finally did make his decision. The most important document of all—that which contained the direction to me to bring in a free no means test mother-and-child scheme up to the age of 16 years—and all the other documents are there. It is not a recollection of mine. The documents are extant and available and can be verified by this House or a Committee of this House if such a Committee wishes to go into the matter further.
As I say, I marvel at Deputy McGilligan's incredible brass-bound impudence in standing up to suggest that this very expensive and elaborate scheme, advertised fully and spoken about repeatedly by me as one of his colleagues, was considered without hisknowledge and that he was ignorant of these details and these facts.
Comment on this
Deputy McGilligan suggested that none of us are likely to carry out anything in conflict with the dictates of our conscience. From listening to Deputy McGilligan, it is quite obvious that he, as a member of the then Government, readily condoned the carrying out of something by one of his colleagues which was, as we hear to-night, in most flagrant conflict with the dictates of his conscience and his view of what was ethical, moral and socially acceptable and desirable.
Deputy McGilligan suggests that he was not aware of the scheme or of the details of the scheme. Deputy Costello, as Taoiseach, with Deputy Norton negotiated with the Irish Medical Association who were most vehemently aware of the details and objected to the details of the scheme. Deputy Costello, Deputy Norton, Deputy McGilligan and my former colleagues negotiated on the details of this scheme with the Irish Medical Association. Surely they did not negotiate in connection with a mirage or with the vague outline of a plan as suggested by Deputy McGilligan? Surely they had something to discuss and to argue with the Irish Medical Association—something which Deputies Costello and Norton were fully and clearly aware of? We all know that Deputy McGilligan must also have been clear about it. There can be no suggestion that Deputy McGilligan did not play a full and most important part in laying down the underlying principles on which the then mother and child scheme was founded based on Section 1 and 22 of the 1947 Health Act. As I said before, all the documents in that case are extant and are available. If a Committee of this House is set up to investigate the whole matter I shall be delighted.
Again, Deputy McGilligan suggested there was the vague outline of a plan for which he gave me—not very willingly, I admit—the sum of £600,000 but only a tiny part of this vast sum was given by the Minister for Financeto his colleague, the Minister for Health, to carry out, to implement a scheme, the principles of which had been considered on documents submitted by me. Having been considered— in spite of all the conscientious objections which Deputy McGilligan now throws out so profusely and so readily —it was agreed to by Deputy McGilligan and I was directed to carry on with the scheme.
The £600,000 that appears in a footnote to the Estimates for that year is there because those were Deputy McGilligan's Estimates for the year in respect of which it was decided by the inter-Party Government that the books should be faked to the tune of approximately £4,000,000——
Comment on this
——and that the sum could only be kept within limits by refusing to put forward the full sums required by each Department. I refused to connive at that conspiracy to defraud the public and I accepted the device of letting the public know —as far as I was concerned, at any rate—by means of a footnote that £600,000 would be required for a mother and child scheme. Conscientious objections. Morality. The moral law. Ethics. All these words without meaning—certainly words without any intention of practice, in my experience of the man sitting on those benches, a man who was so well described by the Minister in the two very fitting words which are, I understand, unparliamentary and which I cannot, therefore, repeat.
Comment on this
I think Deputies on all sides of the House have just got an opportunity of judging the balanced views that one must expect from Deputy Dr. Browne.
Comment on this
Listen to what Deputy Cowan says. Deputy Cowan knows nothing of what I am going to say.
Comment on this
Deputy Cowan's view of me does not matter two traneens. It does not matter in the slightest. I will give the facts very briefly inside a few minutes while we are dealing with this Bill now.
First and foremost, there was not at any time a scheme prepared by Deputy Dr. Browne. There were certain proposals. Some of the things Deputy Dr. Browne proposed and hoped to do were outlined.
Comment on this
Deputy Dr. Browne was subjected to one major limitation by his colleagues and that was that whatever health legislation he brought in would have to conform to the moral law. He refused to accept that.
Comment on this
The last occasion on which Deputy Dr. Browne discussed the matter with his colleagues in the Cabinet was after he had got what he had requested from the Church authorities. He got what he said in advance he would accept from them—and which he then refused to accept. His final words were: "Are you going to stand with me or with the Hierarchy?"
Comment on this
That was the ultimatum which the Deputy gave to his colleagues. What I say is the truth and if the Deputy had any manhood he would admit it. He knows it is the truth.
Comment on this
When the Deputy gets up and spits out that venom is he surprised at people's retort to him? When the Deputy levels every sort of unworthy motive at his colleagues, is he surprised at their reply?
Comment on this
I think I can say that during his period of office as a colleague with me he never had any reason to object in the slightest.
Comment on this
Little dictator. Just remark the tone behind that. It is typical. Similarly with Deputy Cowan. That is the mentality.
Comment on this
It is a pity, then, that the Deputy does not listen to himself. We might not hear him so frequently, if he did. I am relating the facts.
Comment on this
They were thrashed out here. Deputy Morrissey knows that he is not giving the facts.
Comment on this
Deputy Cowan knows nothing whatever about it except what he heard by way of hearsay which would not be allowed even in the District Court, much less here.
Comment on this
I am giving the facts and I am telling what is known to myself personally—not what I am depending upon to be told by anybody else. Deputy Dr. Browne was given a request, an instruction, a direction— call it what you like—by his colleagues to take the necessary steps to revoke the sections in the 1947 Act to which objection had been taken on moral grounds, and he failed to carry out those instructions of his colleaguesduring the whole period he was in office. That is the truth.
Comment on this
That is why Deputy Costello went round defending him before the Irish Medical Association.
Comment on this
Surely there is some limit to the political play-acting which Deputy Cowan is allowed to indulge in here? Surely there is some limit to the price which the Government has to pay?
Comment on this
As I said on a former occasion, what was once a big Party has certainly fallen mightily.
Comment on this
The Minister spoke to-day about obstruction. It seems to me that there is something almost approaching an organised piece of obstruction every time I get on my feet to speak. Why, I do not know.
Comment on this
The more the interruptions continue the more they grow in weight and in intelligence. Those are the facts. If Deputy Dr. Browne did not want to get all his own way in defiance of those who were competent to deal with the question of the moral law in relation to his proposals, in defiance of the entire medical profession in this country—his own professional colleagues—and in defiance of every one of his own colleagues in the Cabinet——
Comment on this
He was the only one who was right. Everybody else was wrong. However, the Deputy to-day has to swallow provisions in this legislation, which his successor was forced to introduce by way of amendment, that he refused point blank even to consider when he himself was Minister.
Comment on this
That is the picture. I do not mind the Deputy trying to get a Bill. I said on former occasions— and perhaps I have as much understanding of the needs and necessities as any ordinary lay man—that I should like to see a decent Health Bill. I would like to see a decent Health Bill.
Comment on this
The Deputy knows quite well. On one occasion, the Deputy was wavering as to which side he would come down on.
Comment on this
I am sure the Leas-Cheann Comhairle listened closely and with great attention to Deputy Dr. Browne.
Comment on this
Deputy Dr. Browne was permitted by the Chair to reply to statements made by another Deputy.
Comment on this
May I say in reply to the Minister that I did change on one occasion and on a subject of major importance that was dealt with in this House? The Minister may remember how the wheel turned and similar legislation had to be introduced by the Government of which he was a member.
Comment on this
If Deputy Dr. Browne wants to give a completely distorted view of what happened at the period and a complete misrepresentation of the facts, we have the right to reply and we are not going to be intimidated either by the Minister's threat to put us out of the House or Deputy Dr. Browne's threat about what he is going to do to us.
Comment on this
We have not run away from anything. There will be some running done, and very soon, but not from this side of the House.
Comment on this
Having got back into history, I want to be allowed to clarify certain points. Deputy Dr. Browne is trying to reinstate himself in public opinion by having it appear that he had a scheme, a scheme which had been approved. He has not to-day gone the length of saying what he said to his colleagues in March, 1951, that he believed the scheme had the goodwill of the Hierarchy. He has not said that to-night, but he did say it in March, 1951.
Comment on this
He addressed the Taoiseach on 19th March, 1951:—
"Am I correct in thinking from the terms of your letter of March 15th, that you are under the impression that the Hierarchy are opposed to the mother and child health protection scheme? May I point outthat this impression, if held by you, is certainly not borne out by the following facts?"
The Deputy was labouring under the obsession that his scheme was not objected to by the Hierarchy.
Comment on this
This was 19th March, 1951, and that is what he said to his colleagues: "Am I correct in thinking that you are under the impression that the Hierarchy are opposed to the mother and child scheme?" He got a reply from Deputy Costello on 21st March in which the then Taoiseach said:—
"If in the letter delivered to the Government, the Hierarchy continued to speak of the dangers inherent in the proposals one cannot easily understand your opinion that you had completely satisfied the Archbishop of Dublin and the Bishops of Galway and Ferns concerning the removal of these dangers. On the contrary, the Government has received no assurance whatever from the Hierarchy as to its confidence in the scheme."
On the next page of the letter addressed to the Deputy, the then Taoiseach said:—
"As I have already indicated, I am at a loss to understand how you could feel satisfied that you had at your interview on 11th October last with His Grace the Archbishop of Dublin and their Lordships of Galway and Ferns satisfactorily disposed of their objections."
The Deputy had that obsession at the time. The then Taoiseach's letter concludes by saying:—
"That you are seriously in error in thinking that you had satisfied His Grace and their Lordships at your interview is amply borne out by the letter of 8th March to you from His Grace the Archbishop of Dublin when he specifically stated, in the passages quoted in my recent letter to you, that on the occasion of your interview he stated that he could not approve of the scheme."
At the end of the letter of 19th March, addressed by Deputy Browne, then Minister, to my Leader, the Taoiseach, he said:—
"I would be interested to know whether your withholding of approval to the mother and child scheme is due either to the supposed opposition of the Hierarchy to the scheme or to the possible opposition of any individual member of the Hierarchy."
The Deputy presents the position to the House that the scheme was approved. How did he come to write to Deputy Costello on 19th March: "I would be interested to know whether your withholding of approval to the mother and child scheme..."
Comment on this
These letters were published by Deputy Dr. Browne. They were not all written by him.
Comment on this
In your good time. On 19th March, 1951, the Deputy was under the impression that the mother and child scheme had not received the approval of the Cabinet. To-night he says it had. With regard to whether there was a scheme at all or not, I know from my own information what the situation was. Here is the way it affected outsiders, the Hierarchy. In a letter of 5th April, addressed from Archbishop's House to Deputy Costello, there appears:—
"It is to be noted that the proposed scheme fails to give clear evidence of the details of implementation. The scheme, as set forth in vague, general terms, has the appearance of conferring a benefit on the mothers and children of the whole nation."
Then follows quite a lot of criticism. It was supposed to be a scheme that was fully implemented.
The Minister has two files under his control, one of which is File F. 102/67/50, on which he will get a note.
Comment on this
I took this record because I knew this would be boundto arise. I took a copy from the Government files when I was in Government. It is a copy, and, if it is not right, will you contradict me?
Comment on this
I am not allowed to take records in case this type of slanderous comment would be made afterwards?
Comment on this
I do not care what is bitter or not, but, as I understand the law, if any person takes a document belonging to the Government or to a Department, it is an offence against the Official Secrets Act. I object to any person quoting from a document which has been unlawfully obtained and which is in the possession of a Deputy by virtue of and because of an offence under the Official Secrets Act.
Comment on this
The Minister for Industry and Commerce took a file down to Avoca last Sunday and quoted from it—or misquoted from it. We will hear more about that.
Comment on this
File F. 102/67/50 in regard to health and child services contains this:—
"The actual expenditure in 1951-52 will probably be less than the figureof £661,000, but I do not think we could ask the Minister for Health to show less than last year as this might be construed as an admission of his difficulties."
Comment on this
I do not think it right that I should quote a civil servant's name, but that will be found under certain initials on 1/1/1951 on File F. 102/67/50.
Comment on this
It means Finance. There are certain civil servants' names on that file which I do not propose to quote. What is the reason for that: "The actual expenditure is likely to be less, but we could not put it down less because the Minister would have his difficulties"? These difficulties were put to us quite clearly—"cut 1/- in last year's Estimates and the Irish Medical Association will chortle and whoop that they have beaten the Minister."
Comment on this
Scandalous or not, it is a point of order. I am asking that, if a Deputy quotes from an official document, that document be placed on the records.
Comment on this
I ask that this be placed on the records. I hope that File F.102/67/50, with the minute of 1/1/51, will be placed on the records, and I join in asking that it be put on the Table. If it will not be, I will put the copy on the Table.
Comment on this
It has been the practice of the House that if a Deputy quotes from a document that document becomes available on the Table of the House.
Comment on this
I think a better record would be the official file. Theminute from that File which I wish to quote is dated 1/1/51. I suggest before it is put on the Table excisions would be made in regard to certain civil servants' names.
Comment on this
I am coming to it by the road which has been travelled by others. On File F. 72/5/49 is a minute—I am leaving out the name of the official from the Department of Health—which says: "As he was unable to say in what area the scheme would start, I regard the Estimate as largely a guess." That is the way it was, too.
Comment on this
It was not. We will be able to see now the services for which that was making provision. Can anybody explain to me how on the 19th March, 1951, the Deputy here, then Minister for Health, could write to his Government Leader and say: "Why are you withholding approval for the mother and child service?" I understood it was not approved of. I want to go back a year or two. In 1948—and the records are again in the hands of the Department; if necessary I could produce copies—the Attorney General then serving us, when he was asked to rule upon Sections 21 to 28, ruled all those sections to be unconstitutional and that, as far as others were concerned, while it might be said there was nothing immediately making them a breach of the Constitution there was no doubt that regulations under them could reasonably——
Comment on this
On a point of order. I do not like to interrupt Deputy McGilligan but I wanted to get clear whether other Deputies will be entitled to travel that ground on the amendment. I understood there was an amendment to include a section before Section 9 and that it was the section alone we were discussing.
Comment on this
This amendment has been widened by the speeches made by certain other Deputies but I will certainly support Deputy McQuillan's point.
Comment on this
We will put the word "purloined" in inverted commas. Realising how such documents could be used slanderously against me and having had the foresight to provide myself with the documents with which I can reveal the truth, I bring these documents to the notice of all and I challenge contradiction on any single point I have made to-night. I do hope Deputy McQuillan's request will be granted and that this debate will be widened and widened considerably to enable us to traverse the ground Deputy Browne decided he would go and hoped that nobody else would be permitted to travel.
Comment on this
That is a reflection on the Chair. Deputy Dr. Browne was permitted to make a statement in reply to a statement made by other Deputies but that has not widened the debate.
Comment on this
With all respect, Sir, you were not in the House and it is a complete misrepresentation as far as those who were in the House are concerned. Deputy Dr. Browne made a long statement about his woes. I am answering from documents——
Comment on this
I suggest the points made have been sufficiently answered and that the Deputy should come to the only matter before the House which is amendment No. 3.
Comment on this
I will deal with the amendment but if anyone travels this ground again I am entitled to go over it again.
Comment on this
It may have been a Via Dolorosafor some people who are not feeling very happy over the documents I have but it would be a sorry thing for me if I had not fortified myself with these documents. I am rather happy about the situation.
Comment on this
That is the situation with regard to the mother and child service and this all started over my saying that there were dangers——
Comment on this
No. The Deputy was trying to cod the inter-Party Government but we got rid of him before any bad effects could take place.
Comment on this
We got rid of the Minister for Health before irrevocable harm was done in the sense of our being tied to proposals which we accepted with the Heirarchy as being amoral. We condemned them and Deputy Morrissey has given correctly the situation that developed.
Comment on this
It is very interesting, but it is not going to help us to get a Health Bill quickly.
Comment on this
We are going to get a proper Health Bill quickly or otherwise. If my memory serves me correctly, we have been dealing with health legislation since 1943, a period of ten years.
Comment on this
My record is a record of opposition to mostly bad proposals and we know how sound the views of those were who opposed health proposals that came before this House under the 1952 scheme, the matter we are discussing now, and how eventually what I have described as the scurry and scuffle across the Border took place in orderto save a Minister's reputation by having a few amendments brought in to try to regulate and transform this whole legislation. I was asked what legislation we had in view. On 7th April, 1951, a Cabinet decision was taken.
Comment on this
Cabinet decisions are hardly confidential to me. I was there and I am fortified in this regard by this document. It is, I am sure, a Via Dolorosafor other people, but it happens to be a good resolution passed by the then Government.
Comment on this
It is relevant to the question I was asked earlier. It was addressed to various Departments:—
"I am to inform you that following consideration of a letter dated 5th April, 1951, to the Taoiseach from His Grace, the Archbishop of Dublin, Primate of Ireland, on behalf of the Catholic Hierarchy of Ireland, intimating that the particular scheme for a mother and child health service proposed by the Minister for Health is opposed to Catholic social teaching, the Government decided, at a meeting held on the 6th instant,
(1) That the scheme referred to should not be further pursued——"
Comment on this
It had already been not approved.
"(2) that, in the light of the Government's conviction that mothers and children should not be deprived of the best available health care by reason of insufficient means, a scheme or schemes for mother and child health service should, as soon as possible, be prepared and undertaken which would (a) provide the best modern facilities for those whose family wage or income does not permit them to obtain, of themselves, the health care that is necessary for mothers and children and (b) be inconformity with Catholic social teaching, and
(3) that consideration should be given to the question whether any amendments of the Health Act, 1947, additional to those proposed in the Health Bill, 1950, are necessary or desirable and, if so, that proposals for such amendments should be submitted to the Government."
I will stand over that type of legislation, legislation which, in particular, does not conflict with Part (b). I do not stand over legislation which is not in conformity with the teaching of the Church to which I belong. The last paragraph refers to the fact that in 1948 the Attorney-General who was then advising us, advised us that certain sections—nearly all of Part (3)— in the Health Act, 1947, were either unconstitutional in themselves or permitted regulations to be made which would be unconstitutional.
Comment on this
He did not advise us that it was unconstitutional. He might have said that certain proposals for adoption were unconstitutional.
Comment on this
I hope not to, but let the Captain be adopted by somebody else outside so that we shall not have his intervening with these irrelevancies.
Comment on this
I was trying to deal with it when I was interrupted. Wewere advised in 1948 that certain sections in Part III of the Bill were in themselves unconstitutional and that others were likely to lead to a breach of the Constitution. We ordered our then Minister for Health to remove these sections but that legislation was never brought in. These orders were given as we thought these sections were unconstitutional. We had also the other view with regard to morality and that was when this other matter developed. The person responsible now represents himself as having prepared this legislation and says that we withheld approval from this legislation. Was it not because the Hierarchy was against these proposals? The Deputy was apparently of the view, in his obsession, that he had got round the Hierarchy's objection. I really do believe that to the end he believed that was the situation. Quite recently these matters have been referred to again. In this latest letter of April this year, the Hierarchy again returned to their main principles. They spoke of their own objection to the original Act of 1947.
Comment on this
On a point of order. The Ceann Comhairle ruled that if Deputy McGilligan quoted again from this document, it would have to be made available to the House.
Comment on this
On a point of order. I would refer you, Sir, to Volume 63, column 793 of the Official Debates where, when a Deputy was quoting from an extract from a letter received from the Commission of Inquiry into Banking, Currency andCredit, the Chair said that he was not aware of any ruling to read the whole of any such letter if the House or any member asked for it. There is a precedent there to which, as a point of order, I would direct your attention. I would further direct attention to Volume 48, column 1303, where a decision was given and made a precedent of the House. The statement was then made by the Chair that when a Deputy makes a statement, the House has to accept the bona fidesof the Deputy in making that statement so long as it was relevant to the matter under discussion and so long as there was no personal charge on any Deputy's honour involved. As against that, with regard to documents that are not official documents, I would refer you to Volume 48, columns 1787-1788, where it is clearly declared that official documents should be quoted in full since an extract might tend to give a wrong interpretation. I submit these three rulings declare the position in connection with ordinary documents, as against official documents, and make it perfectly clear that even though the House or a member may ask for it a Deputy is not required to read the whole of a letter even if he wants to refer to the actual details.
Comment on this
The Deputy might now give us the Ceann Comhairle's ruling in regard to the letter of the Hierarchy.
Comment on this
It has been the accepted practice of the House for years that if a document is quoted and a demand made that that document should be placed on the Table of the House that the document should be so placed. If the Deputy refuses to lay the document on the Table of the House then he must cease quoting from that document.
Comment on this
Has permission been received by Deputy McGilligan from the Hierarchy to refer to this document?
Comment on this
Did Deputy Dr. Browne get the permission of the Hierarchy when he published all the correspondence in connection with the previous Bill?
Comment on this
It would be interesting to know if Deputy McGilligan has the permission of the Bishops to quote that document.
Comment on this
I had almost concluded my remarks with regard to the statements that the Hierarchy had made in the letter they had addressed to the faithful, dated the 4th April of this year. I was not quoting from that document. I am referring to it but I deliberately refrained from quoting it.
Comment on this
"There is no such document in existence," the Deputy says. So it is completely a figment of the imagination on my part!
Comment on this
I shall relate them to the amendment. I am referring to the amendment which proposes to introduce a new section that the Minister may, by Order, insist that institutional services of a specifiedclass shall be given in a health institution and that institutional services shall be given in the institution to a specified class of persons. These institutional services are defined to include diagnosis, advice and treatment in the institution. There are two matters to which I wish to refer—that the Minister, by Order, may direct a health authority to give certain treatment in a particular institution and that, if he does so, the health authority maintaining that institution must comply with that direction. I was pointing out that we had already amended that legislation in respect to the teachings of religion and that a patient who elevated this point should not be made to undergo treatment or to submit himself to a health examination contrary to the teaching of his religion. I am asking that a further safeguard be inserted in this clause by having that same exclusion made in respect to the doctor who may be ordered to give certain advice and treatment. In that connection, I was referring to the immoral parts of the Health Act of 1947. The immoral parts occurred in Part II, Sections 22 to 28. These, I suggest, had been condemned early on by the Hierarchy and I read their letters in that connection. Then I went on to say that these particular parts had been made the subject of comment by the Hierarchy in the letter of April 14th, 1953——
Comment on this
——which they had addressed to the faithful through the medium of four newspapers which I have named—the Independent, thePress, theIrish CatholicandThe Standard.
Comment on this
I am not indulging in repetition. I am emphasising, putting a different emphasis on thematters to which objection had been taken. These particular Section 21 to 28 had been objected to by the Hierarchy on moral and religious grounds as these sections claimed dangerous powers for the public health authority. The sections claimed the power, we were warned, to treat all the illnesses and the defects of children without any recognition of the existent rights of the parents. The Hierarchy spoke of Catholic doctrine in regard to sex which is nowadays violently opposed——
Comment on this
——in many countries. This is the document that does not exist according to the Deputy.
Comment on this
It does not exist because, as I say, this scurry across the Border got it taken out of the hands of the four newspaper editors.
Comment on this
They did say that health education often involved the claim to direct the child according to certain materialistic principles. They said that there was no safeguard in the Act that people would have the right to be treated or educated according to the lines of Catholic social doctrine. I am applying these phrases to institutional treatment. Where is the safeguard for the doctor? Is there any anywhere?