Committee on Finance. - Vote 27—Agriculture (Resumed).
Contributions 1–143 of 268. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
When I moved to report progress last week, I was discussing the Minister for Agriculture's Vote— when there is a little sense of responsibility restored perhaps we will get down to considering the matter.
Comment on this
To many of those legal gentleman in the Fine Gael Party, agriculture is a joke, but to the people of Ireland, the people who share in the welfare of this country, agriculture is not a joke. Agriculture is the basis of future development and expansion and even of survival. I think the fact that this debate has been carried over since last week has enabled me to have a look at the proposals put forward by Fine Gael in regard to agriculture and to examine these proposals in a fair and reasonable way.
The policy of Fine Gael as outlined by Deputy Dillon falls under two or three heads. The first step in regard to agricultural policy as outlined by Deputy Dillon was that the four sugar factories should be demolished with dynamite. It is a good thing that Deputy Dillon did not suggest an atomic explosion for the destruction of the sugar industry.
Comment on this
Suppose for a moment that the policy of abolishing the sugar beet-growing industry, and the sugar-manufacturing industry was put into operation, what would be the effect on the economy of our country? What would become of the large number of productive farmers who have acquired skill and ability in the growing of beet and are getting a fairly good return for it? The average income in a very large portion of the country particularly in the area near me, which I know well, the gross income is over £70 per statute acre. That is income that cannot be despised by any farmer and certainly not by the small farmer.
Beet growing is one of the ways in which the farmer can get the maximum income from his industry and toil and capital, and it is one of the ways in which he can get the maximum output from his land. But Deputy Dillon pursuing some obscure free-trade policy that he read about perhaps when he was a boy—a policy that was advocated by the great Liberal Party in Britain for many years—has declared that the four sugar factories should be blown up by dynamite and that the 60,000 or 70,000 acres of beet should be let down for permanent pasture. That is Fine Gael policy in regard to sugar and beet.
What is Fine Gael policy in regard to wheat? Deputy Dillon referred to it in the course of his speech last week. He said world wheat priceswere falling and, because they were falling, we should go out of wheat growing. He suggested we were paying too high a price to the Irish farmers for their wheat and that it was a serious impost on the whole community. I think—I have not the exact comparative figure—that the disparity in the price of imported wheat and the price of Irish wheat, allowing for moisture content, is slight.
I think that imported wheat has not such advantages recently over Irish wheat so far as moisture content is concerned; so that there is not a very large difference in cost between imported and home-grown wheat, and even if there was a slight margin and even if Irish wheat did cost more, is it not better to have our own people employed on the land? Or should we buy imported wheat and send our workers away to America and Australia? That is the policy advocated by Fine Gael and it requires some explanation. It certainly requires some explanation to the members of the Labour Party, who do claim they are all in favour of increased employment on the land. But wheat and beet, in the words of Deputy Dillon, must go up the spout. He considers we must have free-trade policy and I suppose it is probably logical because Deputy Dillon, being opposed to industrial development, feels that if the farmers enjoy any protection whatever they will be favourable to giving manufacturing industries a similar amount of protection. So, in order to destroy what protection there is in this country, Deputy Dillon goes out on a policy of advocating that whatever protection was enjoyed up to the present should be withdrawn. And his views in regard to wheat and beet are in full accordance with his views in the case of milk.
His policy in regard to milk when in office was to reduce the price to such a level that we would be able to compete with New Zealand and Denmark on the foreign market. He, therefore, proposed to reduce the price of milk from ½ a gallon to 1/- per gallon.
That is Fine Gael policy in regard to the dairying industry. It is a policy of refusing any help or assistance or giving any stability to the dairying industry, and the net result is not likely to be of any benefit to any section of the community because once you, with your 1/- a gallon, drive farmers out of dairying and out of milk and butter production, you create a scarcity which probably would eventually affect the consumer and make the consumers' position even more difficult than it is.
It is hard to understand how such a policy can be seriously advocated by any political Party in the State. I was glad to note the views expressed by General Costello, as reported in yesterday's papers, in which he pointed out the comparison between the number of workers employed on the land here as compared with the number in Denmark or in any of the continental countries. We here have a working population on the land of five men per 100 acres. In Denmark the figure is about three times as much, and in some of the continental countries it is five times that number. If we could so intensify agriculture as to provide a living for an increased number of people somewhat comparable to the number employed in Denmark, it would solve our entire employment problem. Because of the immense opportunities that lie in the development of the land to the utmost extent and the raising of the productive capacity of the land to the maximum, I think it is very desirable that agriculture should not be discussed in this House as a Party question.
Comment on this
Agriculture should be dealt with, not as Deputy Morrissey would deal with it, as something about which to score empty, silly debating points but in such a way that we would regard it as something upon which the life of the nation depends. That is why I suggested last week the setting up of a national council of agriculture, not as a merely hole-and-corner consultative council but as a body which would be representative of all farming associations in the country.
It is desirable that farmers should be organised vocationally and a national council, which should be taken into consultation, not only by the Minister for Agriculture but by the Government generally, should be set up because, in regard to land, there are wider problems than those which confront the Minister for Agriculture.
There is the problem of land tenure, of land settlement, and even of largescale development. Thinking of General Costello and the work which he has done in regard to the sugar and beet industry, I have often wondered if it would not be a desirable development to have some State body to buy up derelict and waste land here and there, reclaim it and develop it and let it out on lease to young farmers' sons so that they might eventually become farmers. One of the worst features of the agricultural industry at the present time is the fact that the third or fourth sons of farmers have very little opportunity of becoming farmers themselves. Their fathers and brothers must earn a very considerable amount of money if they are to be enabled to purchase land for themselves but if there was a certain amount of land held by a State company, it could be leased out to enterprising young men, sons of farmers. The same is true of agricultural labourers.
One thing which struck the members of Macra na Feirme travelling through Denmark recently and studying agricultural problems was the fact that a very large number of farm workers had the ambition and the very clear hope of eventually becoming farmers themselves. Their outlook on their business was that of potential farmers. Here it is very rarely that an agricultural labourer can ever hope to rise above the position which he now occupies. I think that is very undesirable. It would be an immense advantage if we could have a development whereby a State company could acquire land, reclaim it, improve it, put it under cultivation and perhaps divide it into holdings and lease it out to farm workers. I think we should not depend on State Departments as much as we do. Bord na Móna and the Irish Sugar Company have given positive examples of what can be doneby an enterprising State company. I put up this proposition because I think it desirable that hope should be offered to our young men to acquire land and to become the possessors of holdings and farms, even though it might only be on probation for a short time. We cannot depend on the Land Commission to solve all these problems. There is a considerable amount of derelict land which could be reclaimed and utilised in the way I suggest.
With regard to the whole land reclamation scheme, I think that it is a step in the right direction on the part of the Minister to increase the direct grants that are to be given to farmers rather than to concentrate entirely on work to be carried out by the Department. Under the Dillon scheme, a farmer who decided to carry out the work himself received a maximum grant of £20 per acre. In many cases it is very difficult to carry out the entire work for less than £35 or £40 or perhaps even more per acre. Under the Walsh plan, the farmer who spends perhaps £45 on draining a piece of land can get a clear grant of £30. That £30 would go a very considerable distance towards meeting the cost.
Comment on this
The Deputy knows that the man will not get one penny more than under the Dillon scheme.
Comment on this
I am not dealing with average costs. I am dealing with the actual costs. The carrying out of a drainage scheme in many cases would cost £40 or £45. Where it costs £45— in some cases it would be up to £50— the farmer receives £30. A lawyer who studies farms only on paper or in dusty deeds should not try to dictate to those who have a practical knowledge of the work.
Comment on this
More farmers voted for me than for the Deputy.
Comment on this
I know that the drainage of land can be a very big project. The tiles alone are very expensive and for that reason it is desirable that we should encourage more farmers toundertake the work themselves. There is another aspect of this scheme which I want to deal with now. That is that while farmers can expect to receive a grant of £30 there is the initial difficulty in many cases that a farmer may not have sufficient ready capital to undertake the work. There is also another difficulty that the contractor might raise and that is, that he would prefer to work under the Department rather than work for the farmer because there is the certainty of payment from the Department whereas if he worked for the farmer he might have to wait for the money.
Just as in regard to housing reconstruction grants it is possible for an applicant for a grant to sign a contract allowing the contractor to be paid out of that grant, a similar provision should be included in the land reclamation project. Where a farmer applies for a grant to carry out reclamation work and where the Department have approved of a grant of £30 under the scheme specified, it should be possible for the farmer to enter into a contract with the Department and the contractor by which the contractor would be allowed to draw upon the grant to the extent he required. The contractor could thus do the work in co-operation with the farmer and it would help to ensure that more work would be done under what is known as the A. scheme, because I think it is desirable that more work should be done as I feel it can be more efficiently and economically done under that section of the scheme than under the B. section. I should like the Government to consider that proposal.
With a view to bringing about closer co-operation between the farming community and the Department, it is desirable that, in addition to county committees of agriculture, there should be district committees established in every county, each district being a compact area operated by one agricultural instructor. Over the past couple of years, the number of agricultural instructors has been enormously increased with the result that there is only a comparatively small compact area allocated to each. Ishould like to see that agricultural instructor assisted by a district committee representative of the various farmers association in the district.
The local young farmers' club and associations of that kind should have the right to appoint representatives on that committee and that committee, acting in close co-operation with one agricultural officer in the compact area, would be able to ensure that the maximum advantage would be obtained from the services of that officer.
We have enormously increased expenditure on advisory services over the past few years and have increased enormously the number of agricultural instructors and it is desirable that we should get the maximum value out of every officer. These officers, on the average, are young men—young men with a very progressive and, if you like, idealistic outlook—who are anxious to do the best they can to help the farmers, and it is desirable that the best value should be secured from the services of these young men. The best way of doing that is to have each agricultural officer living in a small compact area and with a local committee to assist him. In that way, he will be keeping in close touch with farming opinion in his district and will be able to report periodically to the committee who will be able to see what he is doing and who will be able to give him advice and help.
Another point which strikes most people in regard to agriculture is the dullness of the literature circulated by the Department in relation to agricultural instruction. The leaflets issued on these subjects are in the main somewhat the same as, and in many cases identical with, those issued 50 years ago. They are written in the dullest and most unimaginative style, making no appeal whatever to the ordinary young person. What we want is a complete drafting of departmental literature on all the important subjects relating to agriculture. It is a step which is long overdue and one which should be taken immediately, so as to ensure that the message the Department are trying to impart to farmers will get across to them as speedily as possible.
In the Vote for the Department ofEducation I mentioned the desirability of closer cohesion between the Departments of Education and Agriculture in regard to agricultural education. I pointed out that vocational education, inasmuch as it includes rural science, which is only a high-falutin name for agriculture, is very closely bound up with agricultural advice and instruction. If we could get a system by which the work of the vocational schools would dovetail into that of the Department it would be very desirable, and to that end there should be provision for evening classes in every district outlying from the vocational schools. I mention this because it is essential that in regard to these evening classes the local agricultural officer should co-operate with the vocational rural science teacher. In that way the maximum value would be obtained and a real step taken to ensure that no boy leaving a national school and taking up agriculture as his vocation in life would be deprived of or denied an easy opportunity of acquiring an agricultural knowledge so far as theory is concerned.
It is true that, notwithstanding the number of vocational schools we have and the number of agritural instructors and rural science teachers available, a number of boys who go into farming, who become farmers or agricultural workers, never get even a good smattering of agricultural knowledge. If we had these evening classes in every district and made arrangements to ensure that they would be held in every parish it would be possible to give the maximum amount of theoretical knowledge in regard to agriculture to every young man in the district. There is a good deal of work to be done in this respect and I feel we are not doing half enough.
I am not too much of a believer in the value of agricultural colleges inasmuch as they cater only for a small proportion of those who become farmers or agricultural workers. The people who pass through these colleges may become pioneers in agriculture in their districts, but when a boy is taken away from his own home farm and district, there is always the danger that he may desire to travel further and avery great number of those who pass through the agricultural colleges eventually find their way into occupations other than agriculture. They may perhaps become agricultural officials of various kinds, but it is only a small proportion that goes back to the farms from which they came. While it may be desirable for a young farmer to break away from the farm for a short time, on the whole I do not think that is a solution for our problem. The real solution is to bring the schools as near as possible to the young farmers working on the land by having evening schools at which he and the agricultural labourer can attend after their day's work is done.
I think mechanisation of agriculture is something which, if encouraged in the right way, will lead to a very big improvement in the standard of agricultural work. It may also lead eventually to a greater desire on the part of young people to take up agriculture. In every industry to-day machinery is employed. Travel has increased and the motor car has brought a luxury within the reach of large numbers. The young man who decides to work on the land feels somewhat out of things if he is plodding along behind a pair of horses while others are driving tractors or lorries and buses on the roads. He feels his is a dull life. Every boy loves machinery and, from that point of view, it is desirable that mechanisation of agriculture should be encouraged.
A great deal has been done by the Department through the provision of credit schemes for the purchase of machinery and implements. These schemes have been widely availed of over the last couple of years. These schemes enable farmers to get a loan of anything up to £750, I think, to equip their farmers with tractors and up-to-date farming implements. The advantage of mechanisation is that it makes farming a more efficient process and, more important still, puts the young farmer on a par with the man working machinery in the factory, the man who drives a tractor on the land, and the man who drives a lorry or a bus on the roads.
The arguments against mechanisationdo not carry any weight. It is said that mechanisation depends on imported fuel and on imported parts. If mechanisation means the elimination of two or three horses on a farm more feeding stuffs will be available for other live stock. More farm produce will be available for export and that, in turn, will balance the imported fuel and the imported machinery. We are all hoping to increase exports. I think it is a reasonable hope.
There is in Wicklow and other counties a large amount of land which is not altogether suitable for mechanisation. At the moment only a horse will work satisfactorily on hilly land. Farming machinery is being improved every day and eventually even the problem of the hilly land will be solved. The question is often asked: How can the small farmer mechanise his farm? Armchair agriculturists suggest co-operation as the solution. I am not a lover of that particular solution. I do not believe it is really a solution. Small tractors are now being manufactured and the mechanisation of small farms no longer presents an insuperable difficulty. The economic holding can be mechanised by means of the present small tractor. The change over to mechanisation may involve a considerable capital outlay, but the difficulty is not insurmountable. As I have already pointed out, credit facilities are available to the farmers for that purpose.
I am a firm believer in short-term credit. The beet-growing industry is an example of the value of such credit. Through the Beet Growers' Association farmers can spend almost £20 per acre on manures, seeds and lime. On five acres of land that would amount to £100. The farmer would not be able to lay his hands on that money were it not for the credit provided by the Sugar Company. Under the scheme in operation the farmer can incur that expenditure with a reasonable hope of reaping a very substantial reward. The gross income from an acre of beet may run as high as £80 per acre. That £100 credit produces a very big return.
I am not suggesting, of course, that that is the entire cost of production. Labour must also be taken into consideration but, in the main, the farmer can nearly always manage to provide the labour. The small farmer can avail of the help of his own family.
If similar schemes were initiated in relation to other agricultural products we would quickly have an intensification of agricultural production. Limited credit facilities are provided by the merchants and millers in relation to wheat. If we had similar credit facilities in relation to potatoes and oats we would very quickly have increased production. Potatoes and oats can be grown on poor land. It is undesirable to leave large tracts of land to nature, so to speak. As a New Zealand expert said, nothing is more undesirable than to see large tracts of land producing the minimum it is possible to get from that land, having regard to our climate. By bringing the plough over the entire farm, by growing cash crops and crops to provide feeding stuffs for live stock it should be possible to produce more from the land and equally possible to increase the output on the subsequent pasture. In that way we would have nothing in the nature of permanent pasture. We would have young cattle following the tillage rotation.
In that way we would bring our agriculture more into conformity with what is practised in the more progressive nations. I have no use for those Deputies who spoke during this debate and suggested that the expression of any desire for increased agricultural production is a reflection on the present methods of the farmers. I do not think it is any reflection on the farmers to say we are not getting the maximum from our land. I think it may be likely to be a reflection upon our whole economic system and it may likely to be a reflection, even, on the Department of Agriculture itself. It is a problem the farmers alone cannot solve. It can be solved and broken by a close study and by active co-operation between the farmers, the Department and the Government generally.
The Young Farmers' movement has brought into the country, for the first time, a body of opinion that is in close touch with agriculture since the young farmers are men who are actually engaged in farming. It has brought forth a demand for the first time, perhaps, in the history of the country for improved methods in agriculture. If that demand came from the Department of Agriculture the farmers to a great extent would say: "Ah, well what is the use of officials telling us to do this or that? Those men are just sitting in armchairs reading about agriculture out of books." When the young farmers themselves and the younger generation of farmers come together and begin to devise ways and means of improving agriculture themselves and make demands for more advice and up-to-date knowledge in regard to the technique of agriculture, I think we are on the right lines. That movement should be encouraged to the fullest extent.
We ought not to be discouraged by those who say that there are problems in regard to agriculture which cannot be solved and which will never be solved. We have, for example, the people who say that our live-stock breeding policy is all wrong and that we cannot improve it. I do not accept that for one moment. I believe in the breeding of good dairy herds which are capable of producing not only progeny that will replace the existing cows but also produce live stock for the store cattle industry. I think that such a policy is the only one for this State.
We could, of course, follow the line in regard to dairying that has been followed in Denmark and concentrate entirely upon milk and butter production. In this country we can adopt a better policy since we have a live-stock trade. A better policy is to keep not only the best milking cows but at the same time cows which will produce suitable store cattle as well. In the main at the present time the dairy Shorthorn possesses those qualifications. The dairy Shorthorn has been very often condemned, not because of anything that is inherently wrong but because there have beengrave mistakes in regard to general policy on breeding. For example, a dairy Shorthorn will be passed for registration not on the milk record of his ancestors but upon the grading when examined by an inspector. If instead of that you had only Shorthorns passed who had a milk record and a beef record behind them you would have a foundation for improving our live stock. I think milk recording should be general in this country and with that the elimination, then, of the inferior type of cows and the extension of the A.I. system, which is one of the effective means of improving Shorthorn breeding.
If those steps are taken, we can look forward to an improvement. I think we ought to abandon as quickly as possible the system by which bulls are registered as Shorthorn simply be cause of their beef qualities. If you want a beef animal, you have the Hereford and the Aberdeen Angus but if you want to keep Shorthorn stock at all for breeding purposes, we ought to have the double purpose of producing milk and at the same time supplying the store cattle industry. I think that over the past two years the Minister has done a good job of work. He has not indulged in any wild boasting and he has not made exaggerated claims in regard to the work which he has been doing. During the two years he has been in office, I think we have seen a very considerable improvement in every sphere of agriculture. The prices of beef, beet, and wheat have increased. The price of milk has been very substantially increased as compared with what it was two years ago.
A little over two years ago the then Taoiseach dissolved the Dáil because he said that certain Independent farmer Deputies were asking for a higher price for milk. Immediately after the dissolution of the Dáil and when there was a new Government in office an increased price was given and that has been further supplemented over the last year. I was very glad to be one of those who met the milk producers of the strike committee when they were engaged in the strike to discuss this whole problem with them. I found them reasonable men,men who were prepared, if given co-operation by the Government, to go all out to improve their particular branch of the agricultural industry.
The Government ought not to yield to the demands which are being made by many sections of the community for a complete decontrol of milk. It is desirable, just as it was desirable in 1932, to have stability in the dairying industry and to have whatever amount of milk that is produced assured of a reasonable price. It is desirable that a large amount should be put into the purchase of dairy herds and the purchase of equipment for the dairying industry and that those engaged in that industry should be assured of a reasonable return. That is only fair and just in the main. It would be for the benefit not only of the producers but also of the consumer eventually. A sound and healthy dairying industry will ensure that no people in this State will be short of milk. It will ensure that no people in this State will be short of butter. It will also ensure that it will never again be necessary to import butter from outside. It will also ensure that our live-stock industry will be fed with an ever increasing number of young stock to provide for the meat exporting industry which is so valuable. Over the last couple of years there has been a big development in the canning and dead meat trade. That is all to the good. The greater the return we can get from our live-stock industry the more employment it can give in ancillary industries and the better it will be for everybody, not only for our farmers but for our industrial workers as well. There are immense possibilities still to be explored. I think that, with the active assistance of an organised agricultural industry, with the active assistance of a national council of agriculture, with the local committees co-operating with the Department and with real active collaboration between the farming community and the Department, it is possible to expand the volume of agricultural production, and so raise the standard of everybody who is engaged in or dependent upon agriculture for a living.
Comment on this
A few moments before he concluded, Deputy Cogan spoke of bulls in this country. There is no doubt but that he talked quite a lot of bull to-day and on last Thursday, with a stronger note than he talked to-day. His voice to-day was very feeble. I wonder why? I propose to start off by referring to last Thursday's debate when Deputy Cogan spoke on the Estimate for the Department of Agriculture. When he was speaking, Deputy Morrissey drew the attention of the Chair to the fact that there was not a House—that there were not 20 Deputies present. That does not surprise me because, honestly, what I find here——
Comment on this
On a point of order. I desire to draw the attention of the Chair to the fact that there is not a House present.
Notice taken that20Deputies were not present; House counted and20Deputies being present,
Comment on this
When Deputy Cogan called for a House I suppose he wanted to get an audience for me. I need not explain to Deputies the reason why there was not a House. The reason is that every time Deputy Cogan stands up they all clear out because he causes a plague in the House.
Comment on this
That is language that should not be used. The Deputy knows what a plague is, I assume.
Comment on this
The word "plague" should not be used in connection with a Deputy's contribution to debate.
Comment on this
I know what you mean, but the word "plague" should not be used in connection with a Deputy's contribution to debate.
Comment on this
It is not very helpful, on an important Estimate like this, that hours should have been spentin making references to other Deputies and other Parties. I believe that the Estimate for the Department of Agriculture is the most important Estimate which comes before the House. Speaking on Thursday last, when his voice was much louder than it was to-day, Deputy Cogan—the reference is Volume 139, column 1626—made this contribution. I am just wondering what association it has with the Estimate. Nevertheless, I am sure the Chair will allow me to deal with it. This was his contribution:—
"Even the deputy-Leader of Clann na Talmhan has been in the last few days acting as election agent—in Wicklow—for Fine Gael."
As far as Clann na Talmhan are concerned, we were sent to this House by the agricultural community of this country from our different constituencies to represent them here. As far as our attachment to Fine Gael is concerned, there are many points on which we agree with them and many on which we differ from them. The same applies to Labour and ourselves, but there is one thing we have decided on, and one that we think is necessary in this country, and that is, a change of Government from the present Cogan-Fianna Fáil contraption, and of going back to an inter-Party Government.
If I went to Wicklow, my visit there was very successful. It showed very good results. However, I always had a certain respect for Deputy Cogan, and sympathy for him, when he stood up here to speak as a farmer, as he claimed to represent farmers, until I found out what happened in Wicklow, and until I met some of the farming community in Wicklow. I will tell the House the reason why I have solidly come to the conclusion that Deputy Cogan does not now represent anybody. It is when you find that one of the candidates that Deputy Cogan was responsible for putting up there received less than 2,000 votes, and that of that number over 1,300 or 1,400 were transferred to the inter-Party candidate. That proves that Deputy Cogan no longer represents the people of Wicklow and very few of the farming community that he still speaks about.
Comment on this
I have allowed the Deputy a good deal of latitude. I understood that the Deputy was going to correct the statement that he was acting as a Fine Gael agent. That is what I understood the Deputy intended to correct, and not to go back into a discussion on the by-elections.
Comment on this
If Deputy Cogan was allowed to fill a page of the Dáil Debates in dealing with the activities of Clann na Talmhan, the Chair will certainly give me permission to reply to him.
Comment on this
Deputy Cogan, as far as I heard him, dealt with the Estimate for the Department of Agriculture. Now the Deputy is speaking about votes.
Comment on this
How votes were transferred at a by-election does not arise on this Estimate. As I say, I have allowed the Deputy a good deal of latitude. He will now have to come back to the Estimate.
Comment on this
I am not going to allow the by-elections in County Wicklow and County Cork to come into this debate. I allowed the Deputy a good deal of latitude. I thought he was going to correct a statement made by Deputy Cogan as to his activities in that election. The Deputy will now please come to the Estimate.
Comment on this
I need not apologise to Deputy Cogan or any other Deputy or Party in this House for my activities in the elections. My activities there were the wish of the 8,000 people of North Galway who elected me.
Comment on this
I allowed the Deputy to make a statement if he wanted to. Apparently he had no intention of making it.
Comment on this
Deputy Cogan was in many Parties. There were a few he tried to get into. He was in ours and he did his damnedest to disrupt it.
Comment on this
He failed to disrupt it inside and he will not succeed from the outside. I know it is a waste of time talking about ex-Deputy Cogan. It does not matter in the least whether this Estimate is passed or not by this House because I believe that within the near future this House will be dissolved. I appeal to the Taoiseach—I am sorry he is not in the House—to go to the country because there is no confidence in his Government at the moment. We are in the atmosphere of a general election. I said that when speaking on the Vote on Account, that it was a waste of time to hold by-elections. I tried to convince the Fianna Fáil Party that the people outside were clamouring against the present Government and the present legislation.
Comment on this
I said it does not matter whether the Estimate is passed or not because the present Government with ex-Deputy Cogan will not be there long enough to carry it out.
Comment on this
Having said that, the Deputy will come to the Estimate. The Chair is likely to lose patience very soon.
Comment on this
It is very seldom, Sir, I disobey your orders. The Minister for Agriculture is not in the House, I regret to say, but I hope the Parliamentary Secretary will tell him this. We as farmers and the farming community generally always believed that the Minister for Agriculture is the man who should defend the farming community. Instead of that you have other Ministers, such as the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs, Deputy Childers, running around thecountry at the present time telling the farming community what they should do and telling them about certain legislation that will be brought in. The man we should look to as our Minister—it makes no difference what Party he belongs to—appears to be dumb.
I also want to warn the Minister that in his Budget statement the Minister for Finance, Deputy MacEntee, said that taxation was lying lightly on the land. I want to warn the Minister for Agriculture that there may be a danger of some whispering or conniving similar to that in connection with the statement that was made by Senator Quirke in the Seanad when he let the cat out of the bag and said that something must be done to tax the farmer and the one way to do it would be to pay £5 a head on the export of cattle from this country. I want to warn the Minister for Agriculture that he is there as the defender of the agricultural community. It is his job to see that nothing like that is done to create a heavy burden on the people of the land. It is his job to see that such a step will be prevented. It may be all right for some Deputies, professional people and others in this House to say that the man on the land is well off now.
Comment on this
The Deputy will withdraw the remark that the Deputy was dismissed from any Government post.
Comment on this
At your wish, Sir. The Deputy should keep his mouth closed or I will close it for him.
Comment on this
Goodbye, now. He sang his swan song before he left. Iwas on the point of remarking when I was rudely interrupted by ex-Deputy Cogan——
Comment on this
"Deputy Cogan," that is right. We look to the Minister for Agriculture as being the man in the Government, as being the man in the Cabinet and in this House—as Deputy Dillon was when he was Minister for Agriculture—to protect the interests of the agricultural community. Not so long ago we found out that the Minister for Agriculture of the present Government knew from 12 to 14 days of a bounty of 6d. a lb. being paid by the British as a subsidy on the export of lambs and the dealers, jobbers and racketeers that tried to suck the lifeblood out of the farming community knew that that was so and were able to purchase these lambs at 6d. per lb. less than the agricultural community knew they were worth. Our Minister did not go before the agricultural community and say that there was such a bounty or such a subsidy, and I, as one, must lose faith in a Minister who allows a thing like that to happen.
Again, we hear the old trash that I have heard in this House for the past ten years: "Increase production". It is a matter for the farmer to increase production, to work harder and longer hours—for less pay, I suppose. The farmer is supposed to increase production for the benefit of every other section of the community. At the moment he is doing his best and I would like to know what this Government has done for the past two years to help secure that increased production. Every Deputy in this House must realise that roughly 1,000,000 acres of our land are subject to flooding. The land is our only hope of increased production. What has the present Government done in the past few years so that some of that land should be relieved from flooding? During the three and a half years ofinter-Party Government three arterial drainage schemes were started, one every year. I had the honour of being the Parliamentary Secretary who took part in that. A fourth scheme was prepared and ready to be started in the county of the present Parliamentary Secretary, who is listening to me, that would give back 53,000 acres of land to the people of that area who suffered from flooding. There was another scheme for the area in County Galway that he represented for many years and that I have the pleasure of representing now, and although they are there two years not even that scheme has been started yet.
Comment on this
But it relates to production and the drainage of land in this country. It is very important.
Comment on this
The Minister for Agriculture is not responsible for the administration of the Board of Works.
Comment on this
Would it be in order to suggest that it should be part of the policy of the Minister?
Comment on this
It is just one. If you will allow me, I am referring to the fact that there are over 1,000,000 acres of land subject to flooding and the Government, in their general policy and in connection with agriculture——
Comment on this
The Deputy will have an opportunity of discussing it on the Board of Works Estimate.
Comment on this
I am not concerned with who will be here. I am concerned with trying to direct the Deputy not to drag in the administration of other Votes.
Comment on this
I am pointing out that the Government, in their general policy, are not making an attempt to reclaim the flooded land under the land reclamation scheme or the Dillon rehabilitation scheme.
Comment on this
That matter comes under his Department. I do not think he knows whether it does or not. He does not care, anyhow.
Poor Deputy Cogan—"ex" is coming into my mind very often—referred to the fact that there would no longer be any butter imported into this country. Am I right in saying that there was more butter imported last year than during the time of the inter-Party Government? When the inter-Party Government imported butter, it was yellow, there was a smell from it, according to Fianna Fáil; it was not fit for human consumption. Butter is being imported now. It is just as yellow as ever, just as unfit for human consumption as ever. The only change is in regard to price. The price has gone from 2/10 to 4/2 per lb., thanks to Fianna Fáil. When the price was increased to 4/2 the colour and the smell and everything changed.
We hear about people who do not understand how well-off the people on the land are. We must realise that in a very short space of time 78,000 people have left the land. In my young days, the father and mother of a family selected the best son, the favouriteson, to give him the holding of land at home—"to give him a place", as they used to say. Now not a member of the family will stay. They are all gone. One would imagine there is a plague in the countryside, like some Deputies that I referred to create in this House.
The Government know very well they have lost the confidence of the people. For the past 12 months I have been trying to point that out to them. There is discontentment in every section of the community. The only way to create contentment is for the Government to go to the country. When the voice of the people is heard and when they return a Government it will be a Government of their own liking. The present Government are in office with the assistance of such Deputies as Deputy Cogan, who is going out quicker than he came in. They are in office by a few votes of that description —inter-Party Government supporters' votes. The people feel that it is not by the votes of the people the Government is in office.
I warn the Government that the people are taking note of what is happening. They are taxed on their foodstuffs, drink, cigarettes, tobacco and everything of that description. They feel that the Government that has done that is not the Government that the majority of them elected. They want that changed. I would advise the Taoiseach to give them the opportunity as soon as possible. Give it to them this week, if possible. The sooner the better. A Government will be elected which will be the best Government, the type of Government that I worked for in Wicklow, the type of Government I will work for, that is, a Government comprised of representatives of the different Parties, where the voice of representatives of every section of the community is heard. The father of this House, Deputy Davin, said some time ago in an interview that he saw different Governments in this country since 1922 but that the best Government of them all was the inter-Party Government which was in office for three and a half years.
Comment on this
The previous speaker made one correct reference when he said that this was the most important Estimate that is debated in thisHouse. That was the only sensible or relevant remark he made in his entire speech. It is the most important Estimate, because agriculture is accepted by all in this country as being the fundamental and basic industry. For that reason it is of importance to every section. As we are living in a time when the question of increased employment dominates the thoughts of every political section of the community, should we not consider whether more people could be employed in the agricultural industry than there are at present? If agriculture is the basic industry, we should concentrate on putting as many as possible into employment in that industry and ancillary industries.
Every right-thinking person in this country will appreciate that the present Minister for Agriculture has approached his task in a practical, reasonable and honest manner, without flamboyance or unnecessary flourishing of any particular scheme. He has tried by solid, practical means to put the agricultural industry on a proper footing. The success of his efforts are evident in every branch of the industry.
There is not much point in a Party one day playing up to the farmer and pointing out that he is not getting sufficient for his produce, that he should get more for the milk he produces and, the next day, appealing to another section of the community by pointing out that the price of butter is too high and that the community cannot afford to purchase it. We cannot have it both ways. If the farmer is to have an economic price for his produce then somebody has to pay for it. The people who continually point to those things and try to play up to every section should elucidate their policy and point out whether they would reduce prices at the expense of the farmer or increase prices at the expense of the purchasing community. I think the Minister is doing a good job; he is proceeding on the right lines and his efforts are already bearing fruit.
In the annual debate on this important Estimate there are many matters which Deputies would like to bring tothe attention of the Minister. There are so many aspects of the important problem that it would be impossible and unwise for any Deputy to try to cover them all. There are a few points which affect some Deputies more than others. I would like, in my sphere, to refer to a few of them. In Donegal, we are not so much concerned with the rancher or the large farmer. That is non-existent in that county. We are very much concerned with the smallholder, the mountain farmer and the uneconomic holder in the congested area. The people do not fully appreciate the significance of that type of agriculturist in the scheme of affairs.
The smallholder is indispensable to the success of agriculture in this country. He is indispensable in so far as he is a producer of store cattle. He is usually a man who takes greater interest in such things as poultry and pigs, and when we take the number of our population who are employed as smallholders we find the figure is infinitely greater than the number employed in large farms and on the ranch type of farm. For that reason we believe that it is absolutely essential that any Minister for Agriculture in this country should give special attention to the smallholder and to the mountain farmer.
Regarding the mountain farmer, I should congratulate the Minister and his representatives, as well as Córas Tráchtála, on their efforts in the clean wool campaign, but I would like in that respect to mention some of the difficulties which the people who have wool to sell experience at this time of year. During the clipping season the demand it not at its height. It is not the peak period for purchasing wool, and consequently the fleece lies over until October or November and deteriorates very much in the interim. Those mountain farmers would like if the market could be so arranged that they would get rid of their wool at the clipping season, and it would be a benefit to all concerned, because it would be in a better marketable condition then. It would not suffer so much during the period when it is stored, very often in most unsuitablebuildings. Most farmers have not suitable storage accommodation for wool and they are obliged to hold it over until the prices reach their peak, with consequent loss in the meantime and with the result that inferior wool is then marketed.
Deputy Cogan referred to the important question of bulls, and to the smallholder that is growing in importance. We believe that one of the solutions which could be found for that problem is to purchase the thoroughbred stock calves when they are young and have them brought into the areas where they will eventually be inspected and passed if found suitable as the pure bred bulls in that area. Waiting until they are purchased at shows in Dublin or elsewhere is more expensive and consequently means that some areas are not properly served with an adequate supply of bulls at all. We believe one of the ways which would solve that would be to purchase the pure bred bull calves while they are young and bring them to the areas where they would be allocated to the farmers and eventually produced for inspection. No doubt 99 per cent. Would be found suitable to continue to hold registration. That would be a cheap means of overcoming this difficulty of having adequate bulls in the congested areas where I am afraid the smallholder at the moment is not perfectly satisfied with the supply of bulls available. I should say in passing that the situation has considerably improved over the last year or so.
Comment on this
One of the other points I decided to refer to is the question touched on briefly by Deputy Cogan—the question of credit to farmers.
Comment on this
Well, that particular point he covered as I should say, ably but briefly, and I am in agreement with him in so far as he says that suitable credit facilities are available for the purchase of machinery but thefacilities provided for credit to farmers in relation to stock and other materials pertaining to their industry are by no means adequate and are not sufficiently easily obtainable. The Agricultural Credit Corporation does not function to the satisfaction of the industry in this country. There is no Deputy in this House who has not had experience time and again of applications being refused for loans for no apparent reason, and the Minister must be aware, as every Deputy in this House who is genuinely interested in agriculture is aware, that increased credit facilities to farmers mean increased production in some respect or another. When you find an honest, genuine farmer applying for some extra money in order to avail himself of the improved markets and the better prices which now exist, to enable himself to purchase in the better conditions available, and that man is refused and no reason given though he has given, say, two solvent personal securities and offered a charge on his property, then one can realise how discouraging and humiliating it is when that type of person is refused a loan to increase production on his own holding. I believe that the Minister should examine the credit facilities which are available to farmers in this country with a view to extending them. If the farmer is, as we all claim him to be, the most important member of our community, then he should be entitled to the best credit facilities that are available to the community. I would appeal to the Minister to examine the position in regard to credit for the agricultural industry with a view to having it made more readily available to genuine applicants for credit. It is bound to represent itself in increased production.
The question of the land project has already been discussed, and it is interesting to note that this reclamation of land is forging ahead and giving, in many cases, a reasonbly good return.
Comment on this
This scheme which was inaugurated by Fianna Fáil was carefully fostered by Fianna Fáil andis now being continued by them as such. There is no person who can deny that.
Comment on this
I can claim from the records that Deputy Dillon in this House said that he never took credit for the inauguration of the land reclamation scheme. I can quote that from his own statements and would be quoting correctly, but I think it was he who gave it that fancy name, rehabilitation. Whether a rose by any other name would smell as sweet, it is hard to say.
We are spending considerable sums in reclaiming farms, but I wonder if we are making sufficient progress on the main waterways into which those farms are drained. I have in mind a case where I went to every possible authority in order to get flooding relieved—the minor employment schemes, the rural improvement schemes, the Irish Land Commission and the arterial drainage scheme—without success. If people have to drain their holdings into a main artery and that artery cannot carry off the drainage at present directed into it, those people are bound to be discouraged from attempting to drain their own land. I believe that a considerable amount of the money we are spending in this rehabilitation project or drainage scheme should be used on the main drains.
Comment on this
Unfortunately, it had nothing to do with it, unless it was abused. Under that Act, the drains were made along the county roads and often, I am afraid, in places where they were not so much needed.
Comment on this
That seems to be a criticism of your county surveyor.
Comment on this
I cannot see that Act solving questions of main drainage. If there is money to be spent on roads let it be spent in whatever way the engineering staff consider most useful;if there is money to be spent on drainage, let it be spent in whatever way the agricultural inspector con siders most useful. There should not be a type of scheme where one is not sure whether it is intended for land drainage or for the roads. I personally am not in favour of a type of scheme about which there is so much doubt as to its purpose. I am in favour of examining the position, not so much in the case of the large rivers, though some of them are important and require immediate attention, but in the case of the small main drains which serve a number of families or farms in a townland.
I have taken an interest in some of the schemes in my constituency. In one instance a farmer purchased a farm for £500. It was not a very good type of soil but upwards of £2,000 has been spent on the drainage of that farm. It is very questionable if that money could not be better spent in the cleaning of the main waterways in the area. It is doubtful if it ever gave an adequate or a commensurate return to this nation for the amount of money put into it. These things require careful examination and before huge sums of money are spent we should be satisfied they are likely to give a satisfactory return, even to posterity.
On agriculture in general, it is no wonder that the farmers often think that the only time they are regarded as important is when politicians speak at public meetings or in this House. In looking back, I do not think what Deputy Donnellan was saying a while ago is correct. The choice member of the family was not selected to inherit the farm. The farmer tried to press his sons into the professions and it was only the one who failed, or was found unsuitable for the professions or a business career, who eventually found himself on the farm. The farming community feel that their social standing is not what it should be, seeing that they are an indispensable section of the community. If you meet any farmer's wife to-day, she will tell you about the success of her family, about the fellow who became a doctor, the fellow who became a teacher, the fellow who became a solicitor. Notice taken that 20 Deputies were not present; House counted, and 20 Deputies being present,
Comment on this
You will hear about all the different professions into which the family have succeeded but you will not hear about the one who is to remain at home on the farm. I believe an uplifting of the social standing of the agricultural community is necessary and imperative if it is eventually to be brought to the position in which everyone would like to see it. That can be done only by placing at the disposal of farmers' sons the facilities to enable them to learn as much as possible about this great industry. That applies to smallholders as much as to large farmers. The Young Farmers' clubs and the vocational schools are playing an important part in that work and should get every possible encouragement to continue it, in order to improve the standard of agricultural education and consequently uplift the social standing of those whose destiny it is to toil on the farms and contribute to what we all recognise as our most important industry.
Finally, I would appeal to the Minister to pay particular attention to the smallholdings. I would congratulate him on the success of the tomato scheme which has withstood the apathy of his predecessor, if not his deliberate effort to destroy that industry. I would appeal to him as one who knows how essential an adjunct that industry is to the small uneconomic holding, to have it extended to other areas in the Gaeltacht, and to take a particular interest in those things which are of so much importance to the smallholder and the uneconomic farmer.
The breeding of pigs and poultry is of great importance to the smallholder. They are essential to his well-being, if not to his existence in many cases. It is, therefore, important that the Minister should continue to take the special interest which he is taking, if not an even greater interest, in these matters. Many smallholders depend to a very great extent indeed on suchthings as the production of eggs, the sale of turkeys at Christmas time, the production of a few pigs, and so forth. and one does not require a large area of land in order to take part in that type of agriculture. While these things pay, the small farmer has some means of earning a few shillings even if he has not the acres to feed a large herd of cattle or to grow a big area of crop. For that reason, those of us who represent areas in which small farmers are in the majority are anxious that the Minister will take a special interest in that type of agriculture.
We are satisfied that the Minister is approaching this difficult problem in a sound, practical manner and that he has applied good sound reason and wisdom to his efforts and that, already, they are bearing fruit accordingly.
Comment on this
I recollect another occasion of two years ago when this Estimate was being discussed by the former House. At that time, the then Minister for Agriculture, Deputy Dillon, was able to report to the House and the country that substantial strides had been made in the building-up of agriculture and in making the utilisation of land in this country a profitable business. At that time, this Estimate was considered in the shadow of a general election and, probably for that reason, the debate then lacked, as now, some realism. Obviously, people spoke with one eye on the Estimate and the other eye on the exit from the chamber. That situation exists to-day.
I do not think that any Deputy who compares the Minister's opening statement with the speech made by Deputy Dillon, speaking for the Opposition, will find evidence of very much difference in policy. The reason for that is that, in the past five years, the entire agricultural policy of this country has been dominated by one man— Deputy Dillon. He has coloured the outlook of every Deputy in this House. He has made, for Fianna Fáil, the statement delivered last week by the present Minister for Agriculture and every Party, every Deputy and every agriculturist in this country now preaches the same views and follows the same policy that Deputy Dillonoperated when he was Minister for Agriculture. There has been a great change. If my statement is doubted, one can point to the present outlook of the Government Party and compare it with the outlook to which that same Party gave expression only five or six years ago. It would be unthinkable for the present Minister for Agriculture to say—as his predecessor in the last Fianna Fáil Government said in 1947—that, with the aid of a Guard, the bailiff and the lash he would drive the farmers into doing what he thought was the proper thing for this country. That sentiment was expressed by Deputy Smith, the present Minister for Local Government, when he was Minister for Agriculture in the last Fianna Fáil Government. That outlook has gone. To-day, the Minister for Agriculture, with sweet reasonableness, endeavours to attract our farmers to till more, to produce more and, generally, he repeats many of the statements which were made by Deputy Dillon when he was Minister for Agriculture up to two years ago. Therefore, in the discussion of this Estimate, I think that a profound difference in the policy which is being operated at present and in Deputy Dillon's policy will not be evident. The only thing that is missing is the man—and I believe that that want will shortly be filled.
In agreeing, however, with statements of policy as expressed by the Minister, there are many criticisms that we must level at the methods adopted by the present Minister in carrying out agricultural policy. For the past two years the farmers of this country have sadly missed the guiding hand of Deputy Dillon. Many of the worth-while projects and the great schemes which he initiated have been handed over to the guidance and care of a man who is, apparently, incapable of guiding them properly. Reference has been made to the land project. It was rather amusing to hear Deputy Brennan, in the nausea of impending election defeat, repeat the old Fianna Fáil canard that the land reclamation scheme had been thought of by Fianna Fáil but that they had not had time to announce it. That scheme was thefoundation-stone of the agricultural policy of the former Government. We have been extremely pleased that it has not deliberately been sabotaged by the present Government—that, within their own limitations, they are endeavouring to put it into operation though, unfortunately, perhaps not believing in it as sincerely as we believe in it. They have done some foolish things in their operation of this scheme. I think that the decision to sell the land project machinery was wrong and very unfortunate. One of the brilliant parts of the land reclamation scheme was the fact that it introduced a fair compromise between free enterprise and, if you like, State socialism with regard to the execution of necessary work. It provided an opportunity to young energetic Irishmen to operate as drainage contractors with a guarantee that the work they were doing was worth-while work and that the need for its execution would remain for a considerable length of time.
The scheme envisaged an opportunity being given to such contractors to make a living for themselves in worth-while work. At the same time care was taken deliberately to ensure that no group of contractors would have a monopoly of the service designed to be given by the land project. The previous Minister knew that once a group get control of an essential service the temptation arises unduly to value the service they give and to charge too much and, secondly, to be selective in the people for whom they work. For that reason Deputy Dillon, as Minister for Agriculture, kept available for the farmers of this country the services of the Department of Agriculture, with the trained men, the equipment and the machinery necessary to carry out land drainage work. That ensured that the drainage contractor's price for the work that he would do would be kept strictly in accord with the price charged to the scheme by the Department of Agriculture and, secondly, it ensured that the smaller farmer, who might not be as attractive a proposition to a drainage contractor, who naturally would prefer to go to the richer man and the quicker pay, would always have availablethe departmental services and the departmental machinery.
Now all that has been changed. The Minister, for reasons that he stated here and which I think could not have appeared convincing to any Deputy, has decided to sell the departmental machinery and to hand over to the drainage contractors the entire responsibility for carrying out such land reclamation work. That decision was announced in this House only a few months ago. We criticised the decision very severely at the time. In recent months I regret to have to say that my own experience in my constituency of Laois and Offaly has justified completely the fears we expressed with regard to the sale of this machinery. In West Offaly, particularly, it is impossible at the moment for farmers to obtain the services of a contractor because in many cases neither the number nor the acreage nor the purses involved are sufficiently large to attract the attention of any contractor, and in regard to these schemes progress has been considerably slowed down in recent months. That is an illustration of the bad methods employed by the present Minister in carrying out Deputy Dillon's policy. I cannot understand why, having agreed to carry out the land project, the Minister did not leave well enough alone. The scheme is a good one and if he did not interfere with it in the slightest it would have been carried on successfully.
Then there is another matter in regard to the land project. I was a bit interested some months ago when it became inevitable that sooner or later the Government Party would have to contest and fight the by-elections just concluded in Cork and Wicklow and the Minister announced that the grant for Class A schemes was being increased to a maximum of £30. The Irish Press—of course I know they have difficulty at times in printing words in theIrish Press—printed that news item without including the word “maximum”, and the readers of theIrish Press,particularly farmers in Cork and Wicklow, rejoiced to see thatthe land reclamation grant was being increased to £30 an acre. That was all very good, very nice and very suitable for the petty purpose of these two by-elections. But I do not think it is conceivable to imagine a greater hoax on the farmers of the country than was perpetrated by the Minister when he made that announcement.
The £30 maximum grant will never be paid to any farmer and the Minister knows it well. Deputies are aware that the grant payable under the scheme is three-quarters of the cost per acre of having the work done and the scheme as announced originally had a provision that it would be up to a maximum of £20. The Minister raised the ceiling to £30. That did not mean that any farmer would get an extra £10 an acre. First of all, he had to show that the cost of doing an acre of his land reached the figure of £45 before the maximum grant could be paid. In fact, we all know that the average cost of doing land under the scheme is £8 an acre. So that it does not matter a row of beans whether the maximum grant is raised to £50 or £100. It does not put one penny more in the pockets of the farmers. I think that that particular bit of little political by-play was again unfortunate because it has shaken the confidence of a lot of people in the manner in which this scheme is being administered. I know a lot of my constituents looked forward with interest to this large increase in the grants they were to obtain but when they found that in fact no increase would be payable to them, it confirmed their determination to vote against the Fianna Fáil Government next week.
Now, Sir, those are two of the criticisms I would like to apply to the operation of the land project. There are other matters that I think should engage our attention here. Reference has been made to the position with regard to butter. Surely there is obtaining in this country at the present moment a most extraordinary situation. Only a month or so ago the Minister's Department announced that the 300,000 citizens of Dublin City and the 20,000 citizens of Bray were a peculiar kind of people in this country. Theywere not to be allowed to consume Irish creamery butter and whether they liked it or not, if they wanted butter, they had to buy imported New Zealand or as they called it—yellow butter. Now what circumstances made that necessary?
Comment on this
The same circumstances that made a similar arrangement necessary in Deputy Dillon's time. Do you remember that?
Comment on this
It was a very similar situation that existed then.
Comment on this
I am glad Deputy Vivion de Valera referred to the matter because I recollect him referring to the fact with regard to butter some two or three years ago. At that time Irish creamery butter was being sold here at 2/8 a lb. Now the situation is completely different. Creamery butter is being sold now at 4/2 a lb.
Comment on this
I am not. I never side-step anything, as the Deputy should be aware.
Comment on this
What would you do about it? Will you break the farmer's market as Deputy Dillon mentioned in Wicklow?
Comment on this
Did you not try all that in Wicklow and you got your answer—we will get Fianna Fáil out?
The position that now obtains is quite different. Creamery butter is sold at 4/2 a lb. That price has been rendered necessary by reason of the milk strike and the Government's decision following it. The necessity for paying that price which, apparently, even at the moment, so far as dairy farmers are concerned, is described by them—and I am talking about the milk price—as not being economic. The circumstances which render necessary payment of that price for milk and corresponding prices for butter, certainly require examination here in this House because of theconsequences which flow from it. It means that Irish creamery butter has to be sold at 4/2 a lb. while imported New Zealand butter can be brought here at a price a few pence more than 3/- a lb.
Comment on this
We know what it is sold for. It is imported for little more than 3/- a lb., if the Deputy will bear with me. The position is that New Zealand imported butter can be, and is at the moment, brought into this country at prices substantially lower than we produce butter ourselves——
Comment on this
——and, accordingly, in order to provide a market for creamery butter the Government has to do two things. It has to zone the sale of New Zealand butter, and it has to increase the price of New Zealand butter in order to have it retailed at the same price as Irish creamery butter, at 4/2 per lb. Incidentally, in so doing the Government benefits the Exchequer and makes a profit on the deal. Now those are facts known to all of us here.
I would have liked the Minister to have dealt with the problems flowing from these known facts. All he said with regard to that was that the production of butter in this country was reaching saturation point. By that he meant, no doubt, either that our people were consuming less butter—as undoubtedly they are because of the price—or that production of butter had considerably increased. Whatever the cause may be, production of butter for the home market is now reaching saturation point. We would have expected the Minister to go on and tell us what his policy would be when that inevitable situation arises. I would like to know what then does the Government propose to do with the butter produced here at 4/2 per lb? They cannot export it. You cannot sell to Britain Irish butter at 4/2 a lb. when they can buy Danish or New Zealand butter at 1/- per lb. less. What is to happen to the butter excess to our own requirements here? It is with regard to matters of that kindthat we are entitled to a lead from the Government. I know that a frantic effort is being made again to continue the policy of Deputy Dillon and convert milk into chocolate crumb and other processes of that kind, but that will only mitigate the problem—it will not solve it. If, as the Minister says, in the near future we shall be producing more butter than is required for home consumption, what is going to happen?
Comment on this
To stop imports will not be sufficient. If we are going to produce more butter here than the home market requires what is going to happen the excess?
Comment on this
I want to know what you are going to do about it?
Comment on this
Is the Deputy advocating a lower price for the farmer? Come out with it. Deputy Hughes is very uneasy behind your back.
Comment on this
Deputy O'Higgins is in possession. Deputy Carter will have to cease his interruptions.
Comment on this
Deputy Carter is a little bit nervous. I have not said a word to anger Deputy Carter or the Minister. I am merely asking for information. I think Deputy Carter and every other Deputy knows that there is a problem to be faced.
Comment on this
I am endeavouring to state it. I do not know if Deputy Carter has been listening to me but I have been bursting my vocal chords in an endeavour to state the problem. With the price of butter at 4/2 per lb., a price which is much over the world price, if we produce more butter than we require, there is a very serious problem to be faced. I would haveexpected that in regard to this matter of butter production, which involves our entire agricultural industry as we know it, which involves in a very real way much of the accumulated wealth of this country, the Minister would have come in here with a detailed statement of policy to deal with this matter. He has not done so. Why? Because Deputy Carter and other Deputies behind the Government would be "yowling" if the Minister even attempted to state the problem. I know what the Minister is going to do. In a month, or certainly by August or September, when the peak period of milk production makes the problem very real, the Minister is going to announce, if he is there, the decontrol of the dairy industry. He is going to pull out of it. He is going to say: "Now, milk, butter and everything else, must find its own price by reason of the dictates of supply and demand." That may be a solution; I do not know whether it is or not. But it is certainly a solution that would be opposed by Deputy Carter and by other Deputies whose constituents may possibly feel the pinch.
Comment on this
During the time we were in power we produced more milk and more butter and maintained the ration.
Comment on this
But look at the price. There is a very real problem here that has not been even referred to by the Minister. If he does not decontrol the production of milk what alternative is open to him? He can decontrol the price of milk, and the price of butter will drop by 50 per cent. at least. Politically that would be disadvantageous to the Minister. He can of course, say: "Well I will not decontrol, I will subsidise."
Comment on this
I want to know what suits Deputy Carter and Deputy Cunningham?
Comment on this
I am not Minister for Agriculture. I am just endeavouring to suggest, through the Parliamentary Secretary, that the Minister should give us his policy.
Comment on this
I am trying to find out what it is. There is no good in the Minister coming in and saying: "Look, we are going to have an excess of butter. If we have an excess of butter we can use it for cart grease." Is that how the Minister thinks it should be used or is he going to suggest to the dairy farmer: "You should go out of business because I will not permit you to produce as much milk as you are producing." What is he going to do? I may tell the House that the entire dairying industry at the moment, and the people who represent the unfortunate consumer, are extremely interested in the Minister's policy with regard to this matter. At the risk of being misunderstood or misinterpreted —I do not mind—I must say that there is obviously something wrong, when the unfortunate people of this city and elsewhere are being compelled to subsidise the production of butter as apparently they are at the moment.
Comment on this
I do not stand for asking the unfortunate working man and woman in this country to pay the subsidy. When we were in power, it was the person better able to pay who paid the subsidy.
Comment on this
I cannot convince Deputy Carter. Perhaps when the Minister concludes the debate, if this is one of the debates likely to be concluded, he may deal with that matter of butter production. I know, of course, that there are many problems that we on this side of the House shallhave to face when, in a short matter of weeks, we are again charged with the responsibility of Government.
Comment on this
I do not know if Deputy Carter ever reads his paper. These benches are stronger at the moment than they were a week ago.
Comment on this
At the expense of Fianna Fáil. There are one or two other matters to which I should like to refer. I could not agree with any one more strongly than I do with Deputy Brennan when he refers to the question of credit facilities for our farmers. I have been in this House now five years representing two counties and I never knew a single man to obtain a loan from the Agricultural Credit Corporation unless he had plenty of money available behind him. I cannot understand what that corporation is there for or what it has been doing. As it was originally established, it was designed to give credit at a cheap rate of interest to the working farmer who would use that facility to increase production from his holding. As the operations of the corporation have worked out in practice, they have meant in effect that facilities, at lower than the bank rate, are made available to those who do not, in fact, require any facility at all. This is not a new problem. The matter raised by Deputy Brennan was not raised in this House for the first time. During the five debates to which I have listened, on the agricultural Estimate, the same criticism has been expressed with regard to the Agricultural Credit Corporation. It was expressed by Deputies on this side when they were on the Government side; it is expressed to-day by a Government Deputy. There has been a consistent criticism with regard to the operation of the credit corporation and that does suggest that the question of credit facilities afforded by the corporation should get immediate examination by the Minister.
We have had associated with this debate the new trade agreement. One recollects that, when the 1948 Trade Agreement was discussed in this House, it was damned with faint praise by the then Fianna Fáil Opposition. There used to be a song in those distant days: "Anything you can do I can do better", and I remember Fianna Fáil Deputies being highly critical of that trade agreement and suggesting that the provisions beneficial to this country contained therein should have been more beneficial. Indeed, the present Minister for Agriculture rather distinguished himself because he made a long speech criticising the agreement paragraph by paragraph and it was only when he was half way through his speech that it was pointed out to him that he was, in fact, criticising the Fianna Fáil agreement of a few months before. One thing, however, was clear with regard to that agreement, that a new principle was established whereby prices for our trade with Britain were linked to British domestic prices and an unlimited market was guaranteed for the things we produced.
The farmers of the country and, indeed, genuine Deputies in the Fianna Fáil Party, appreciated the significance of that trade agreement. Despite the playacting of their leaders, they knew that the inter-Party Government had made, to borrow a phrase, a damned good bargain. Now what do we find? We find that that trade agreement is freely maintained by this Government. A Schedule to it has been altered in matters of detail, but the important principle contained in it had been retained. Naturally, we are pleased with the extra benefits obtained by the revision of the Schedule in the agreement. When the 1948 Agreement was entered into, it was envisaged that the trade for which it provided would be examined from time to time and that any adjustments necessary would be made as required. The present Government have made an adjustment and we congratulate them on doing so, but do not let them parade themselves around the place as having brought back to Ireland DocumentNo. 3, because they have not. They have retained the Trade Agreement of 1948 and have adjusted it in some small respects.
Before concluding, I should like to express agreement with what has been said by Deputy Donnellan and other Deputies with regard to drainage. I do not think it is necessary to emphasise the importance of drainage and the problem it presents to the country, but, each year on this Estimate, I make a particular suggestion which I repeat now, that if the problem presented by drainage is to be tackled in a proper way, the responsibility should be taken from the Board of Works, from the Department of Local Government, from the special employment schemes office—from all these secondary offices that stud Government Buildings—and given over to the Minister for Agriculture, because it is part and parcel of agricultural policy. While we have many cooks, there is a queer old broth always brewed for our people. The great land project itself is delayed, halted and obstructed in different parts of the country because certain necessary main drainage has not been carried out. The execution of that main drainage is not the responsibility of the Department of Agriculture. They cannot do it and cannot insist upon its doing. Therefore, the neglect or omission of one Department prevents and retards the work of another. The only way in which all that red tape can be cut is to provide that the responsibility for drainage should be taken out of the hands of these various Departments and handed over to the Minister for Agriculture. Only when that is done, can real worthwhile progress be made.
As I said earlier, there has been a welcome change in the debates on agriculture in the past two years. It is not now necessary for us on this side to act as monitors for Fianna Fáil and not necessary for us to educate them as we had to do in the past. They now accept our agricultural policy and the only pity is that they are not capable of carrying it out as well perhaps as Deputy Dillon. That is a matter of detail and the responsibility for changing that detailrests outside this House. I have no doubt that this debate will not conclude until the people themselves have decided.
Comment on this
I was rather taken by the phrase which the previous speaker used in connection with Deputy Dillon. He told us that he coloured everything he did. I agree with that—he certainly put an amount of colouring stuff on most of the things he did. It is fairly hard for any Minister to make any changes in agricultural policy and I suppose that whatever changes we have made in it are due to a large extent to the war conditions which prevailed. In fact so far as I can remember—and I can remember a long while back—the only time during which the farmers were really prosperous was when there was a war on. The end of the last war brought misery and misfortune to the whole of the agricultural community.
At the moment we seem to be in a good bargaining position. We have trade agreements. We have had an excellent agreement recently concluded by the Minister. I will not say it is a new agreement. It amends the last agreement and, in amending it, improves it considerably. I was glad Deputy O'Higgins was prepared to admit that. I think that agreement will improve the farmer's credit position. It will make credit easier. If the dead meat trade continues, and I see no reason why it should not since the Government is giving it every encouragement, it will be an enormous asset from the industrial point of view as well as from the point of view of the farmer. We will be using the products of the land as our raw material and that is something many hold is the right and proper thing to do.
Everybody must admit that we have made rapid strides and that our farmers are very prosperous at the moment. They contributed a good deal last year towards building up our external assets. That in itself is an assurance for the future. It is an assurance to the workers employed in these industries that they will always be in a position to purchase fromabroad the raw materials required for particular industries.
I, too, am interested in the question of credit. The Cumann na nGaedheal Government established the Agricultural Credit Corporation with a great flourish of trumpets and much propaganda. Many of the farmers were induced, where they had any sort of credit, to borrow money to their ultimate misfortune. Many people come to me asking me if I would recommend them to the Agricultural Credit Corporation. I never do recommend them. I always tell them it is hopeless and that, if they have any assets, they should go to the banks and avail of overdrafts. At the moment the farmer's credit is not bad. This recent agreement will make his position even better. So long as the farmer has an assured market his credit is always good. It is only when there is no market that his credit deteriorates.
We have not the same problems in County Meath as they have in counties like Donegal and elsewhere. Farmers in Meath engage in all types of agriculture. One will find them in the cattle business, producing milk for sale in Dublin, rearing horses and sheep, producing fruit. Wheat has made its appearance in Meath this year. That is due entirely to the wisdom of the Minister in increasing the price for wheat. I hope now that the Minister will try to improve the conditions under which fruit is sold. Difficulty has been experienced during the last few years in that connection. Difficulty was experienced in finding a market for certain types of fruit. There is never any trouble in disposing of raspberries, but the price is not as good as it used to be.
The Minister referred to the cattle trade in his statement and to the production of cattle. Cattle present a problem. We have the position of Holland cited. We have the position of Denmark cited. The milk producers want high-class milk-producing cows. If we have nothing but dairying cows we will quickly find there is no need for any agreement such as that just concluded. Years ago when farmers had their own cow-testing methods the heifers produced by good cows werealways kept. The owners of bulls procured the right type of animal and the result was that almost all the cows in the district were Shorthorns. There was uniformity of type. Nowadays, with all the variety, if one goes into a fair at two o'clock one will find at least 30 per cent. of the animals offered unsold. The question arises: Are we producing a lot of mongrels? I am sure Deputy Giles will agree with me.
Comment on this
I will not agree with you. I will qualify it. We have the best cattle in the world in County Meath.
Comment on this
I am not speaking of County Meath alone. I am speaking of the cattle offered in the fairs throughout the country. These cattle come from the milk-producing areas in the South. We have experienced some difficulty in trying to decide what type of cattle we should breed. One section wants milk-producing cattle and the other Shorthorn cattle. I myself think that we should rely on the Shorthorn cattle and if one wants white faces they can be crossed with Shorthorns and if one wants the other type you can cross it with the black polled Angus. However, the black polled Angus from the point of view of beef producing is quite good but the right type of Shorthorn will give almost as much as any fancy breed and will give the right type of cattle.
We have a surplus of calves now and I think this new agreement will be an incentive to produce more calves and sell them. I take it that a lot of the milk now going to the creameries will go to young calves. We have practically an unlimited market for cattle in Great Britain. We are not impeded in any way. They will take all we produce.
Land fertility is an essential thing and every effort should be made to increase fertility of the land. The Minister is making every effort. He has remodelled the method of producing ground limestone and the methods of distributing it. I think that is a great advantage. Experiments are beingcarried out with manures on plots of land in County Meath and in other counties. I believe they are giving extremely good educational results. I hope they will be able to produce grasses that will fatten cattle a bit quicker and will help them to weigh better when they are killed. I think that this is a thing which could be easily done. Manures to grow the grasses will help to do that.
I want to refer in particular to the question of out-offices for farmers' houses. There are quite a number of farmers' houses which are practically without any out-offices. They are only mud-walled and are not waterproof. The result is that the farmers have no place for storage or for rearing calves or anything else. I hope that the Minister will stimulate that as far as possible and give every facility to people to erect sheds in the vicinity of their yards.
I want to request the Minister to consider the question of drying machines for wheat. We have in the County Meath now a very large acreage of wheat and quite a number of combined harvesters. We have not enough facilities to meet the demand in regard to the drying of wheat. I noticed that our committee of agriculture has offered to subsidise the purchase of about ten machines. Whether they can or cannot be got I do not know. I hope the Minister will give every facility to farmers if they find it necessary to get their wheat dried. It is hardly possible in this country to get wheat dry enough. Few seasons are so dry as to permit of the wheat being dry enough for the mills. It is essential that wheat should not be damaged in any way and that it should be dried at once.
We are told that we have magnificent driers in the City of Dublin. Wheat comes up from the country in lorries and has to remain in the lorries until the next day. In that way the wheat is damaged very much. We should go on growing wheat. I hope we will. If there was a change of Government— I know there will not be—the growing of wheat would stop. If it stops those big mills will remain where they are —in the City of Dublin. These millsare at the portside so that the wheat can be imported cheaply and with the greatest facility. If Deputy Dillon does not get control those mills will have to close down and we will begin to decentralise and put the mills where the wheat is grown. Silos will be erected and the country will go back to where it was years ago and the old ruins on the riverside will be replaced by new mills, possibly operated by electricity. That would be one of the ways of preventing the flight from the land about which we have heard so much. Local mills gave great employment ages ago. If there should be decentralisation in that connection I think we would be a lucky nation. We should try to restrict the size of this bloated city because there are too many industries in it. If Deputy Dillon got in he would probably scratch his head and stop the growing of wheat.
Comment on this
It is rather amusing to listen to Deputy O'Reilly, who comes from the County Meath, talking about the growing of wheat. There has never been much wheat grown in the County Meath except when the farmers there were compelled to grow it. If Deputy O'Reilly is so concerned about the growing of wheat he ought to try to induce the farmers of Meath to grow it.
Comment on this
We grow as much wheat in a parish of the constituency from which I come than they grow in the whole of Meath.
Comment on this
I challenge Deputy O'Reilly in regard to the amount of wheat he has grown. I will take on any Deputy on the opposite side of the House in that connection. I have grown a bigger acreage myself.
Comment on this
There were discussions on the recent trade agreement. All on this side of the House are glad tosee that that agreement has been renewed. It proves at least that the 1948 Agreement, which was made by Deputy Dillon while Minister for Agriculture, was a sound agreement. There was great opposition to it from Fianna Fáil at the time. They took grave exception to giving Britain 90 per cent. of our exports. That part of the agreement stands to-day. It is the same agreement now as it was in 1948. The agreement also proved that the Fianna Fáil Party agreed that our principal market is the British market. When the present Minister for Agriculture was a Deputy and when the agreement was negotiated in 1948, he was very concerned about this 90 per cent. to the British market. He said we had alternative markets and that it was a shame we were tied up to 90 per cent. with the British. He is the very man who now comes along and agrees with that portion of the agreement.
With regard to the recent statement in connection with the bonus on spring lambs by the British Government, it is a disgraceful thing that the Minister did not make an announcement at the time the bounty was being put in force. The Minister tried to insinuate last week that the price was reflected in the fairs. In my constituency where there is quite a number of lambs, the lambs are sold on the farm and do not have to be brought to the fair. The farmers did not know about this lamb bounty. There is no doubt that the farmers lost that valuable increase. I cannot understand why the Minister did not make a pronouncement on it when it was coming along. The farmers all over the country feel very sore about it.
Deputy O'Reilly referred to the increase in the price of wheat. The price of wheat last year was 75/- per barel on a 57 lb. bushel weight. The price this year is £4—an increase of 5/- but the bushel weight has gone up to 60 lb. Actually, the increase only amounts to 2/6. We believe that there is no increase at all on last year's price having regard to the increase in the cost of production and this 2/6 does not cover the increased cost.
Personally, I believe that it was a bad move on the part of the Minister to increase the bushel weight from 57 to 60 lb. because of the tendency there is now for mechanisation as far as harvesting is concerned. If you are going to grow wheat extensively it will be harvested by the combine harvester, and, except in a very good year such as last year was, it will be difficult to get wheat to bushel 60 lb. from the combine harvester. At the time that Deputy Dillon introduced his scheme to pay from 57/- to 60/- with an extra 2/6 per barrel for wheat bushelling anything over 60 lb., the present Minister for Agriculture very strongly opposed it. He actually pointed out at that time that there was a tendency towards harvesting by means of the combine harvester. Now he has come along himself with the present proposal. I do not know who was responsible for influencing him. I think it must be the millers who were responsible for suggesting that the basis of calculation should be 60 lb.
I think that is very unfair and that it is going to do a great deal of harm as regards wheat growing. It will be difficult in a bad year to get wheat into the condition when it will bushel 60 lb. from the combine harvester. It was difficult under the old method of cutting with a binder, and of stooking it in stacks to get it to bushel 60 lb. when it was threshed. As I say, I think this is a very bad move on the part of the Minister.
I should like to refer to the price of feeding barley. Last year, there was a good quantity of it grown. The situation arose, however, that, when it came to be harvested, the bottom had fallen out of the market. The price opened at 50/-, but in a week or two there was plenty of feeding barley in my part of the country which had to be sold at 35/- a barrel. The Minister then came along and made the price 48/-. The fault I have to find with that is that it was not made in time. A good deal of feeding barley had been marketed at the time that the Minister made his price. The result was that a number of farmers lost a considerableamount of money. I know one farmer who had sold his barley at 35/- a barrel. As a matter of fact, the stores were being packed with this barley. At the time, when there was some difficulty with malting barley, the feeding barley was being pushed on to the market. Immediately the price of it dropped. I think the Minister was wrong in not fixing the price earlier in the year. There was the added difficulty of the difference between the price fixed by the Minister for the farmer and the price that was got by the corn buyers—Grain Importers. That difference amounted to 11/- per barrel. That is to say, Grain Importers were being paid 59/- per barrel. It seems to me that this difference was far too high for drying corn last year, especially when we remember that most of it did not require any drying. It was already down to the correct moisture content. Those people were paid 11/- per barrel just for taking the corn from the farmer. I hope the Minister will look into that position this year and will fix the price in time. The price of feeding barley should be announced early in the year when the farmer is sowing it. He can then decide whether the price offered suits him or not and whether he will grow it.