Finance Bill, 1953—Fifth Stage (Resumed).
Contributions 1–133 of 258. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 15 of 1953 ›
I was inquiring, when the debate was adjourned, as to where the Minister for Finance planned to get the £300,000 to £500,000 which the Minister for Local Government had undertaken to collect from the ratepayers in relief of his Budget now that the Minister for Finance and the Government gave an undertaking to two Independent Deputies to cancel that proposal. Did the Government tell Deputy Lehane that they were going to adjust the new rate demand so as to relieve the local authorities of the extra £300,000 to £500,000 which it was suggested was going to be levied on them by the alteration of the manner of distribution of the agricultural grant? Would Deputy Lehane tell us that? This is important. Do you remember the beating of bosoms that went on on the Government Benches?They did not consider Deputies Lehane or Sheldon or Cogan. They threw the vote of confidence on the floor and told them: "Take it or leave it." But it now transpires, according to Deputy Lehane, that he told them that he would abstain from voting unless he was assured that this——
Comment on this
On a point of order. The only thing I told the Government was what I told the Government in this House.
Comment on this
I want to know, if the ratepayers are to be relieved of this sum of £300,000 to £500,000 which the Minister for Local Government has instructed the local authorities to levy on the ratepayers as a result of the adjustment of the supplementary agricultural grant, where does the Minister for Finance intend to get the money which he said he required to balance his Budget? Is it not time that the House was told?
Comment on this
Would Deputy Cowan please restrain himself? There is no need to answer rhetorical questions.
Comment on this
I can understand Deputy Cowan's position. His position was that he would make any number of requisitions on the Government before determining how to cast his vote and whatever answers they gave, whether positive or negative, we all knew what Lobby he would walk into. He salved his own conscience.
Comment on this
——is how his undertaking—now that he has cancelled the additional charge being made on the ratepayers—is going to be met if the Minister for Finance depended on the relief produced by that manoeuvre to balance his Budget. I think it is highly likely that the Minister for Finance will not answer because I think he has reached the point of irresponsibility when he does not think there is any obligation on him to answer to Dáil Éireann. He has come to consider that no matter what he says he can depend on Deputy Cowan, Deputy Dr. Browne, Deputy Dr. ffrench-O'Carroll and Deputy Cogan to vote where they are told to vote.
Comment on this
That is just the way Deputy Dillon voted as an Independent. He voted as he was told.
Comment on this
Does this quartet not see that the more often they vote that way, the more often they will be made to vote that way, and how humiliating the position of the Government becomes that depends on their suffrage for its survival? I often wonder how long can the Minister for Finance and his friends continue to survive as parasites of this quartet because that is what they are becoming. Whether the quartet are the parasites of Fianna Fáil or Fianna Fáil the parasites of the quartet the relationship is not very honourable for either party whichever way you take it, and I would submit to such members of the Fianna Fáil Party as still have some regard for the country that for an Irish Government to be in that position grows more embarrassing for everybody with every day that passes. It is bad enough to be a parasite on the body politic.
Comment on this
That the Final Stage of the Bill do now pass is the question before the House. Would the Deputy keep that in mind? As amatter of fact, Deputy Dillon may be inviting interruptions, but the Chair will not take that as an excuse for obliging him.
Comment on this
On a point of order— Deputy Dillon has made certain insinuations against me. I have made it quite clear in this House that the only thing I said to the Government, I said it in this House which, I think, is the right place to say it.
Comment on this
Deputy Dillon revealed the Minister's intention and the intention of the Government at a meeting in Blessington, and so far as I know that was the first public revelation that was made of that intention anywhere in Ireland. I think as a result of the by-elections in Wicklow and Cork it is likely that the Minister's intentions were changed in this regard. I understood that an undertaking had been given to Deputy Lehane, but if I am wrong I gladly take the opportunity of apologising. I was told that the reason he did not vote in either Lobby was that he was told by the Government that they were resolved not to put this imposition on the farmers.
Comment on this
The fact that Deputy Lehane voted or did not vote in a certain way does not arise on this Bill.
Comment on this
Deputy Dillon is increasing the Government's majority every time he opens his mouth.
Comment on this
If it is your seed, breed and generation that I am wishing upon them, I am going the surest way of burying them fathoms deep.
I now understand that no such undertaking was given to Deputy Lehane, but something has happenedbecause the Minister for Local Government refused to reveal what legislation he intends to bring in although he was very frank in communicating with the secretaries of the county councils what he intended to do. He has changed his mind for some reason. It is a matter of interest to this House that it was not anything which Deputy Sheldon or Deputy Lehane did that caused the Government to change its mind. It was the by-elections. I think we are entitled to learn from the Government and from the Minister for Finance what consequential action he proposes to take now.
Comment on this
I am quite prepared to face that accusation if the Minister can prove it. I want to refer to another matter. I read to-day a list of articles which the Taoiseach declared he intended to import from dollar sources, and to pay for them with dollars, when he put his hand upon his heart and said that he would not sign this statement or make this agreement if he did not believe that the document presented was an honest document. I asked the House when perusing the document to turn their attention to page 6 from which I proceeded to read certain figures. I should have directed the attention of the House to page 8, which is the page on which the proposed imports appear. On page 6, the figures mentioned by me really relate to the total requirements of the country. The House will remember that in reading these figures I turned to Deputy MacBride and said that there must be some mistake about them. The mistake is that I read the figures of the total requirements for the country.
Comment on this
So you did mislead the House. You are now beginning to mislead them again until you find out——
Comment on this
On page 8 the figure for the imports which the Taoiseach, the Minister for Industry and Commerce and the Minister for Agriculture informed the Marshall Aid authorities they would want or buy from dollar sources with Marshall Aid dollars are as follows——
Comment on this
It does not say so. The words that the Deputy is using "Purchases from Dollar Sources" are a figment of his own imagination. They do not appear on the page at all.
Comment on this
Let me read it for the silly little man. Wheat and flour in wheat equivalent, 336,000 tons for the year 1947-48; 327,000 tons for 1948-49; 381,000 tons for 1949-50; and 437,000 tons for 1950-51.
Comment on this
Barley, 66,000 tons in 1947-48; 86,000 tons in 1948-49; 86,000tons in 1949-50 and the same quantity in 1950-51. Maize, 392,000 tons in 1948, 441,000 tons in 1949, 490,000 tons in 1950, 580,000 tons in 1951; rice, 3,500 tons in each of these four years. Oil cakes, 40,000 tons in 1947-48; 45,000 tons in 1948-49; 50,000 tons in 1949-50 and 50,000 tons in 1950-51; raw sugar, 49,000 tons in 1947-48; 40,000 tons in 1948-49; 40,000 tons in 1949-50 and 40,000 tons in 1950-51. On page nine we find: Fish, fresh and frozen, nil; vegetables 10,000 tons in 1947-48 and the same quantity in each of the three subsequent years, to the value of 1,000,000 dollars American currency.
Comment on this
I stake my reputation that on page 9 of this document there appears this entry. It is an official White Paper of the Government of the Republic of Ireland and the entry is: Vegetables, 10,000 tons to the value of 1,000,000 dollars.
Comment on this
I challenge the Deputy to read paragraph three of the very first page of that document.
Comment on this
Dried fruit: 10,000 tons in 1947-48 to the value of $2,800,000 and the same quantity in 1948-49, 1949-50 and 1950-51. Wine: 30,000 hectolitres to the value of $1,800,000 in 1947-48; 35,000 hectolitres to the value of $2,000,000 in 1948-49; 35,000 hectolitres to the value of $2,100,000 in 1949-50 and 35,000 hectolitres to the value of $2,100,000 in 1950-51. Tea: 11,000 tons to the value of $18,000,000 in each of the four years. Cocoa: 2,500 tons to the value of $1,800,000 in each of the four years. Coffee: .8,000 tons to the value of $480,000 in each of the four years. Tobacco: 6.2,000 tons to the value of $8,000,000 in each of the four years. The reason I directed the attention of the House to these figures is that this was Deputy de Valera's own estimate of his proposed imports during the six years.
Comment on this
It was for the purpose of procuring currency facilities toensure that the State would be able to effect these imports in those years that he participated in Marshall Aid when he said, as I pointed out earlier to-day, that he would not approach good friends for help if he did not feel that the document on which he founded his justification for seeking this help was an honest document. The document I read out to this House is the document to which he then referred.
Comment on this
A document from which the Deputy has wilfully omitted all the vital conditions. Will the Deputy read the conditions?
Comment on this
I say to the Minister for Finance and to Deputy Moran who is interested to explain that this did not refer to Marshall Aid at all: would the Minister for Finance tell me why did Deputy Smith, who was then Minister for Agriculture, charter a special plane to fly to Paris, of all places in the world, with a fleet of civil servants to be followed by the Minister for Industry and Commerce, who came from Amsterdam to Paris? Why did the Taoiseach charter another special plane and go to Paris with 20 civil servants in that special plane and dine with the British Ambassador to celebrate their mutual participation——
Comment on this
I said that and these two gentlemen say that this document had no reference to Marshall Aid.
Comment on this
The Deputy is well aware that the figures given in the document he is referring to were figures given as estimates by all the democracies to O.E.E.C., some of whom had no intention or did not, in fact, borrow any American money.
Comment on this
Furthermore, our Government, if we had a right Government, would not have borrowed American money.
Comment on this
You see, their sins found them out and it is the sin of falsehood that was found out.
Comment on this
Will Deputy Dillon please come to the measure before the House? What relation has that to the measure before the House?
Comment on this
The relation is the Finance Bill. The Minister for Finance has repeatedly said that the contents of the Bill are substantially due to improvident borrowing and spending of Marshall Aid funds by his predecessor. Is that not the whole defence of his Budget?
Comment on this
Now that they have their ears nailed to the post, the Minister and his supporters are contorting in an effort to get their ears off the post, but they cannot. The truth is the truth and it cannot be avoided.
The House ought to know that the document from which I am now reading was only put in the Library as a result of parliamentary questions put down by Deputy Mulcahy. The Government of 1947 were very reluctant to put it in the Library. They said that it would be too expensive to put it in the Library and to circulate it. Look at it. They said that it would be too expensive to circulate this booklet to the Deputies of this House, that it would cost too much to duplicate. However, they put a couple of copies in the Library. Was it not lucky that we got it put in the Library?
Comment on this
Was it not lucky that we discovered what our predecessors had stipulated for when they joined the Marshall Plan?
Comment on this
"They did not"! Well, when they flew in chartered planes to Paris—we know not why or wherefore —they met somebody in Paris and they agreed to something with somebody in Paris. One of the by-products of that mysterious agreement in Paris, which was celebrated by a dinner held in the British Embassy that night, was this document here. Having negotiated that settlement, they flew back to Dublin in the chartered plane, having discharged their bill in Claridge's Hotel in Paris. Now, perhaps Deputy Moran, who was in their confidence then, will tell us who they met in Paris and what brought them to Paris.
Comment on this
I am hoping to persuade Deputy Moran to intervene in the debate in order to throw a flood of light on this whole situation. We should like to hear his version of this transaction.
Comment on this
I should most particularly enjoy hearing from him whom the Taoiseach was talking to when he put his hand upon his heart and said that he approached old friends for help only when he was in a position to do so.
Comment on this
I am asking Deputy Moran to whom the Taoiseach said that. Deputy Moran says that it was not to the Marshall Plan people—that it was not with the Marshall Plan in mind that he said it. But if the Fianna Fáil Deputies think he did say it, he said it to somebody. He did not say it to the birds in the bushes or to the blossoms on the chestnut trees of theAvenue du Bois de Boulogne. He said it to somebody. Who, and why?
Comment on this
Having, with amusement, listened to Deputy Dillon for an hour, we can now come back to the discussion of the Finance Bill. I was rather angry with my friend, Deputy Cowan, to-day for his attack on Deputy Dillon and for saying that Deputy Dillon was not in favour of public works. We had some interruptions from Deputy S. Collins—I am glad that he has just come into the House now—in connection with a new Dáil that was going to be built. Deputy Collins made some interruptions at that point and evidently wanted some information. I will give him the information if, first, he will have a little bit of patience.
Comment on this
My interruption was to the effect that some of the members of the Dáil ought to be changed.
Comment on this
I will quote now from a speech made by Deputy Dillon on the 25th May, 1945, as reported in the Official Report, Volume 97, column 1027:—
"This is a time when we should mobilise credit and use it boldly and resolve, if necessary, to repay it over the next 100 years. The extension of credit should not deter us from embarking on bold schemes at the present time, always provided that they are good schemes. As a start in that direction, one good thing would be to build a new Oireachtas, and it would prove to be an economy in the long run. We are eternally patching and tinkering with these buildings in order to make them adequate to fulfil the functions of an efficient Parliament. It is common knowledge that half the Deputies cannot find accommodation in which to write a letter. Even the Ministers' rooms are inadequate and they have no proper facilities. We are trying to get our meals in a restaurant which is built on top of the boiler-house and in which no person could sit in the months of August and September. The permanent officials are obliged to sit in cramped quarters up at thetop and their teeth are made to chatter with the noises of the machinery in the basement, because we are trying to dislodge a beetle through the medium of a vacuum cleaner in the roof. I understand that the roof is now infested with beetles and that it shall have to be rebuilt."
Comment on this
I am showing the mind and the policy that was behind the indiscriminate borrowing. That is a statement that was made by Deputy Dillon in this House on the 25th May, 1945.
Comment on this
I do not know what beetles or what roof Deputy Dillon was alluding to but, judging by what we heard from him this afternoon, he certainly has bats in his belfry. In pursuance of that policy of mobilising credit—"use it boldly and resolve, if necessary, to repay it over the next 100 years"—those people in 1948 borrowed and they borrowed again and they borrowed again on top of that and they borrowed the fourth time on top of it all. Unlike Deputy Dillon, I am not going to go back to the dark ages. I will give another little quotation now. It is from the Official Report of the 23rd April, 1952, Volume 131, column 168. The heading of the question was "State Borrowings":—
"Mr. Corry asked the Minister for Finance if he will state the total amount of State borrowing (a) in each of the years 1947-48 to 1951-52, inclusive, (b) in the years 1932-33 to 1947-48, inclusive, and (c) in the years 1923-24 to 1931-32, inclusive.
Mr. MacEntee: The net amounts borrowed for Exchequer purposes in the years mentioned by the Deputy were as follows:—
(a) 1947-48, £5,004,500."
That, of course, was to fill the Budget blank—since Deputy Dillon has been talking about the £500,000 Budget deficit there was to be—which was leftby reason of the cheap pint and the cheap cigarettes which Deputies opposite when they came into office gave back to the boys when they reduced the taxes put on beer and cigarettes. For that purpose, they borrowed £5,004,000 so that for the next 30 years the people of this country will be paying in principal and in interest for the cheap fag and the cheap pint the boys got in 1948. In 1948-49, the amount borrowed was £8,951,000; in 1949-50, £20,539,000; in 1950-51 £21,686,000; and in 1951-52, £38,938,000. That is a total in borrowing of £94,000,000 odd to run this bit of an island for three and a half years— £14,000,000 more than the total amount borrowed by the Cumann na nGaedheal Government and the Fianna Fáil Government in a period of 24 years. They borrowed £14,000,000 more to run this bit of an island for three and a half years than was borrowed by the two previous Governments to run the country up to the time they came in.
The Ceann Comhairle may ask me how that affects the present financial system. I will tell the House how it affects it. At column 167 of the Dáil Debates of that date, there is the following:—
"Mr. Corry asked the Minister for Finance if he will state
(1) the total amount payable and paid in interest and sinking fund in the financial years 1947-48, and
(2) the total amount payable in interest and sinking fund in the financial year 1952-53."
The Minister replied that the figure for interest in 1947-48 was £3,095,714, and in 1952-53, £7,354,700. For sinking funds, the figures were £1,128,620 in 1947-48, and £2,725,700 for 1952-53. The total amount that had to be paid in principal and interest for money borrowed over a period of 24 years in 1947-48 was £4,224,334, while the total amount that had to be paid in principal and interest on borrowed money when Deputy MacEntee came back as Minister for Finance was £10,080,400, with the addition this year, I understand, of the first repayment on the Marshall Loan of £1,200,000, which means that £11,200,000 a year must begot by taxation from the people to pay for the spree that Government had here for three and a half years. We hear Deputies opposite looking for a reduction in the spirit duty and a reduction in the price of the pint, but the total extra amount put on spirits and on the price of the pint would not cover the payment of the interest alone on what they borrowed during the three and a half years they were in office.
Let us get clear on these things. We had the same cry the other day in connection with the reduction of the subsidies. I heard the reduction and abolition of subsidies preached in this House before, and I know who the archpriest of that doctrine was. At column 2048 of Volume 106 of the Dáil Debates of 18th June, 1947, we find Deputy Dillon saying this:—
"We are subsidising butter production to the tune of £2,000,000 per annum. How long will that go on? Do we expect butter to get dearer in the markets of the world? Do we expect a time in the early future when the price of milk will become so adjusted that it will be possible to suspend this subsidy or do we intend to continue producing milk for conversion into butter in creameries at an annual cost to the taxpayer of £2,000,000 per annum? I want it to go on record most emphatically that I think such a policy is sheer insanity and is purely pursued for the purpose of maintaining the prestige of incompetents in the office of the Minister for Agriculture since Fianna Fáil came into power."
That is rather a strange statement, but it accounts for a lot. It accounts for the "bob" a gallon which Deputy Dillon offered the farmers for their milk, and the resultant reduction of the number of milch cows in the country by 54,000 in 12 months. As the Deputy said: "You cannot produce a calf in a month," and the effects of his activities on the live-stock trade of the country will live for a long time after. That is his first statement, and that was the result of his action. Then he comes in here and glibly demands to know why the subsidies were taken off. According to him it was sheer insanity to pay a subsidy on butter, or even toproduce butter from milk at all. That was his solemn statement. I think it was Deputy MacEoin who raised a matter in connection with the building of the new Houses of the Oireachtas on the Adjournment. Now he knows who got the brainwave—it was his own Jamesy.
Comment on this
As a matter of fact, I took part in the by-election at which Deputy MacEoin was elected a Deputy.
Comment on this
And filled your position, I am glad to say, with honour. I would not expect anything else from you. However, that is one result of the activities of Deputy James Dillon and one of the reasons for our financial position. I wish Deputies would adopt an entirely different attitude towards these matters—I think we would do better if we did. The kind of stuff that was dished out to us to-day is no benefit and no credit to this Dáil or to any House.
When we see a certain condition of affairs obtaining in regard to agricultural production, we wonder what is the reason for it.
"We had the enthralling, stimulating and surprising experience of eating bread made out of Irishwheat. Before you ate it you had to hold it out in your hands, squeeze the water out of it, then tease it out and make up your mind whether it was a handful of boot polish or a handful of bread. If it was boot polish you put it on your boots or shoes, and if it was bread you tried to masticate it if you were fit."
That was a statement made by Deputy Dillon, 1947.
Comment on this
The Deputy is making quotations which do not seem to me to be in any way relevant to the matter before the House.
Comment on this
I will make them relevant very quickly. In 1947 we produced here 579,000 acres of wheat. In 1948 we had 518,000 acres. Then we had the man that could not masticate it and the acreage fell to 362,000 acres.
Comment on this
If the Deputy gets the figures he will see that the 300,000 acres produced a bigger yield than the 518,000.
Comment on this
We will hear Deputy Collins later on that. There was a reduction from 579,000 to 281,000 acres.
Comment on this
And that reduction came about because the Minister who was in charge of agriculture then stated that he could not look at or deal with Irish wheat.
Comment on this
What was the result? There was a reduction in oats from 826,000 acres in 1947 to 619,000 acres in 1951. As between 1948 and 1951 there was a reduction in the grain acreage of 488,891. We hear a good deal aboutunemployment and so forth. Let us examine the position in regard to the root acreage.
Comment on this
The acreage under beet fell from 66,000 acres in 1948 to 59,000 acres in 1951. Potatoes fell from 385,000 acres to 321,000 acres. Turnips fell from 151,000 acres to 128,000 acres. The total reduction in the acreage of root crops was 114,162 acres and the total reduction in tillage was 603,000 acres. I am not at all surprised that we had to borrow money to buy food abroad for our people, food that should and could have been produced at home.
Comment on this
That reduction was carried out under the policy of a Minister in the inter-Party Government. I have read what he said about wheat. The Deputy might like to know what he said about wheat. On the same occasion he said:—
"There remains beet—the blessings of beet! Some day, and in the not far distant time, our people will have to ask themselves whether it is in the best interests of the community as a whole to continue the production of sugar from beet in this country at an annual cost to the community of £3,000,000 sterling."
Comment on this
I am giving the quotation as relevant to the reduction of 10,000 acres in the beet grown here during the period when Deputy Dillon was Minister for Agriculture and I am relating that to the fact that a sum of £3,000,000 had to be sent to Formosa to purchase there 74,000 tons of Formosan brown sugar to be brought in here to feed the Irish people. That is where the money went.
Comment on this
We had a solemn declaration from two Ministers in the inter-Party Government, Deputy Dillon and Deputy Morrissey, that they were prepared to pay for that 74,000 tons of foreign sugar £1,000,000 more to the Formosan than they were prepared to pay to the Irish farmer, the Irish labourer and factory workers to produce it at home.
Comment on this
There is the result: £12 a ton on 74,000 tons of sugar. I would like Deputies to consider these matters seriously. I would like them to examine the facts for themselves. I am glad to say that so far as the rural community is concerned that state of affairs has changed with the change of Government and the change of Ministers. Instead of buying 74,000 tons of sugar abroad we intend to produce that sugar at home.
Comment on this
That represents at least 200,000 tons of beet. Think of the amount of employment that will provide. Think of the 150 Mayo men who were packed, ready to go over to England, but who were brought down to Cork instead and given decent employment there. They are earning now from £10 to £15 per week and they do not have to eat horse flesh or asses. They get decent Irish meat. That is one item in the relief of unemployment. Think of the labour content and the money that will be spent in Fitting that 200,000 acres of beet, in conveying it to the factories and in processing it into sugar. Think of the £3,000,000 that we are keeping here in this country this year for the benefit of the farmer, the farm labourer, C.I.E.and the workers in the sugar factories. That is where Deputy Dillon's policy was wrong—the man who advised the blowing up of the beet factories as the wisest thing that could be done on behalf of the Irish taxpayer. And then we had the lunacy of putting this man in charge of that industry for three and a half years.
Comment on this
Other statements were made here to-day. Deputy Rooney had the neck to tell us that the grain committee of the Beet Growers' Association had reduced the price of barley.
Comment on this
Unfortunately, the evil men do lives after them. When Deputy Rooney accused in this House a responsible organisation of reducing the price of malting barley on the farmers they represented surely——
Comment on this
I told Deputy Rooney that in so far as the impact of taxation under this Bill on the distilling industry affected barley growing he was entitled to refer to it but not on any alleged reduction agreed upon by some body.
Comment on this
I will deal with the matter in that light. Deputy Dillon, when he occupied the benches over here as Minister for Agriculture, told the unfortunate farmers about the £2,000,000 Fianna Fáil had offered and when he was asked to remove the controlled price for barley so as to give us the chance of getting back some of the £2,000,000——
Comment on this
The impact of taxation in this measure on the distilling industry as it affects the production of barley is the only matter relevant.