We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Committee on Finance. - Vote 60—Office of the Minister for Social Welfare.

Contributions 210–436 of 436. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

When Deputy Davin is speaking later on he can tell us about the Social Services Act he put into operation during the three and a half years he was in power.

Comment on this

It was not half as good as ours.

Comment on this

What did you do with the death benefit that was in it? You handed them over to the insurance companies.

Comment on this

Let us come along to see what you did for the old age pensioners.

Comment on this

We woke up your Parliamentary Secretary.

Comment on this

We have to look at the acts of different Governments here. Anybody listening to Deputy Hickey, as I have listened to him, heard his tale of woe about these unfortunate people. I am prepared to admit to Deputy Hickey that anybody who has lived in this country for 70 years is deserving, not of 21/6 a week but of £5 a week, if it could be given to him.

Comment on this

"If."

Comment on this

If the bank directors agree.

Comment on this

The old age pensioners had 10/- a week in 1939. In 1947 that was increased to 15/-. In 1949, when the Labour Party was in office, the Labour Minister increased it by 2/6 to 17/6.

Comment on this

Did you not say that he did nothing?

Comment on this

Owing to the cost of living.

Comment on this

I tell Deputy Esmonde that if it were not for the £7,000,000 odd a year which has to be paid in interest for the spree that these people had and which we had to put taxation on the food of the people to pay, the cost of living would be very much reduced. The Deputy should remember that. The old age pension was 17/6 when we came into office. In 1951, it was increased to 20/- and it was afterwards increased to 21/6. During the three and a half years of the previous Government all these people did for the old age pensioners was to bring forward a proposal which Deputy McGilligan would not allow. These are the facts with regard to old age pensions and social services.

The contribution for national health insurance was increased and more money was dragged out of the unfortunate worker and Deputy Davin had nothing to say. As the "Grand Master" says: "He was as mute as a mouse." Let us examine what has been done by the Fianna Fáil Government. Old age pensions have been increased by 4/- a week since the Fianna Fáil Government came back.

Comment on this

What increase did you put on the price of butter?

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Davin should cease interrupting.

Comment on this

We had to put up the price of butter to pay for the fine spree which Deputy Davin and others had at that time.

Comment on this

You increased the rate of interest to 6 per cent.

Comment on this

I thought I would convert the Deputy when he came over near us.

Comment on this

It would take a whole lot to bring me over to your side.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Corry should address himself to the motion. These asides cannot be allowed.

Comment on this

I cannot help it when there are interruptions. I must endeavour to answer them.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

There is no necessity to answer any of them.

Comment on this

I had no intention of dealing with the question of old age pensions until I heard Deputy Hickey wailing about them. Deputy Hickey and his Party left the old age pensioners in May, 1951, in receipt of 17/6 per week. We had to consider the position of these unfortunate people and had to increase their pension and when we have a little more of the debts left to us by them cleared up we will be able to increase it more. These are the troubles which these gentlemen left after them.

The reason why I intervened in this debate was to get the couple of defects that I mentioned removed. I had to ask a question about them three weeks ago. It is a scandalous condition of affairs that a widow who is drawing a contributory pension owing to the fact that her husband contributed during his lifetime should be deprived of that pension and have her condition worsened to the extent of 2/6 a week just because she has reached the age of 70. It is a matter of "passing the buck" which I hope will be stopped now, as the ratepayers have enough on their shoulders.

Comment on this

I regret I was not present for the Minister's statement, but I should like to avail of the opportunity to speak after my Cork colleague and friend, Deputy Corry. Deputy Corry has alleged that the Labour Party did very little during the time they were in charge of theSocial Welfare Department. I feel sure that Deputy Corry's memory is just as good as mine, but, apparently, when it suits him to forget particular matters, it is very easy for him to do so. I propose to detail as briefly as possible what the Labour Party did for the old age pensioners during the three and a half years of the last Government. Let us examine how they found the old age pensioners when that Government came into office in 1948. They found them getting a pension of 10/- a week, the same as they were getting when Fianna Fáil came into office in 1932.

Comment on this

That is not true.

Comment on this

They found them getting 10/- a week old age pension, but they allowed them to get other benefits. They were very gratuitous towards those old people. Despite the fact that many representations were made by old age pensioners and their representatives to them that they could not live on the then existing allowance, Fianna Fáil refused to increase it. But they were not altogether unmindful of their interest and they told the old age pensioners: "If you can convince the local authority, you can draw a maximum of 2/6 per week from the local authority by way of home assistance allowance." Fianna Fáil told those people: "If you want to get 12/6 as an old age allowance, you can get 10/- in old age pension after a rigid means test and, if you want to make a pauper of yourself, you can go to the local authority for home assistance." That was the unfortunate position for many honest, decent people in the country. They had to go to the local home assistance officer.

If they succeeded in convincing him and the county manager, they could draw an extra 2/6 weekly. Let any Fianna Fáil Deputy who contributes subsequently to this debate confirm or deny that statement. That is the unfortunate position in which Fianna Fáil left the old age pensioners when they were put out of office in February 1948.

I would not deal with this from a political angle were it not for the allegations made against the LabourParty by Deputy Corry. Everyone knows the Labour Party was always consistently and persistently advocating the cause of the aged. When the Labour Party took office they found these people were getting only a meagre allowance of 12/6, part of which was a home assistance allowance. What was the action, immediately on taking charge of the Department of Social Welfare, of the Leader of the Labour Party, Deputy Norton? Deputy Corry knows very well and so does every other Fianna Fáil Deputy if he cares to admit it. His first action within a month or two of taking office, was to bring in legislation to increase these allowances by 5/- per week, or to make the old age pension 17/6 per week—not 17/6 made up of home assistance, and an allowance from the State but 17/6 by way of State allowance. That was a marked increase. After a few months in office we put the old age pension up to 17/6. Fianna Fáil had increased it after 16 years in office—although the cost of living increased enormously during that period—by the miserable sum of 2/6. They are the Party that claim now, through some of their agents here, that they were very mindful of the old age pensioners and of their grievances and that the Labour Party completely and entirely neglected them.

This increase made by the Labour Minister in 1948 was only a temporary measure. He had just taken office and knew very well, as all his colleagues knew, that even 17/6 was entirely inadequate. He brought in legislation which would not only improve the position of old age pensioners but that of many other unfortunate sections of the community. Deputy Corry, in conjunction with every other member of Fianna Fáil, voted against that measure. They did their best to hold it up, to obstruct it and to prevent it being enacted. They did their utmost to deny any further increase to the aged people.

It would be very hard to find fitting words to describe how they got into office. I am at a loss for words. They got into office by the support of our friend here, Deputy Dr. Browne.

Comment on this
Robert Lahiffe Mr. Lahiffe

And the old age pensioners.

Comment on this

Give me a little time. I would like to see Deputy Lahiffe contributing to the debate and saying if I am right. I would very much like to hear a little of his wisdom. Unfortunately for those pensioners, Fianna Fáil got into office by some kind of a twist or somersault made by a few former solid and solvent supporters of the inter-Party Government.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

This has no bearing whatever on the Estimate.

Comment on this

A previous speaker made certain allegations against the Labour Party and their efforts during their term of office on behalf of those people. I am trying to trace, as far as I can and as concisely and as briefly as possible, the history of the position of the old age pensioners. In doing so I am now endeavouring to relate my remarks to the period subsequent to June, 1951. I was dealing with the change of Government and I thought it was relevant to mention that the man in charge of the Department of Social Welfare changed —that there was a change in the man at the helm. I thought I was entitled to do that. Fianna Fáil got into office by this peculiar somersault—of four or five members here.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

This has nothing to do with the motion before the House.

Comment on this

We are discussing old age pensions.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy seems to be going far away from the question of old age pensions.

Comment on this

With all due respect to you, I was about to deal with the action of the Government or the reason for that action subsequent to the election. I have already said that the present Government Party were not helpful to the aged people. I was about to refer to this piece of legislation whereby they increased the pension to the present sum of21/6 per week and give my views on that change. I shall do that very briefly. They had no possible alternative, due to the attention that the Party occupying these benches focussed on those pensioners but to grant some increase. They gave them a good increase the last time they went about it, in their 1/6 per week. I need scarcely mention that in actual fact the pensions were not increased, as new taxation offset the extra allowance. It is to-day under Fianna Fáil —having regard to the present cost of living—actually much less than it was in 1908 under a foreign Government when old age pensions were first provided in this country. Is not that a well-known fact?

If they gave it in 1951, you may be sure they reached out several hands to take it away again. We have had all this extra taxation. They denied the poor men—many of them old men in Deputy Corry's constituency, fine decent men—the right of having a smoke. They did that, too, in 1947. Ask any old age pensioner what he thinks of Fianna Fáil. To many of them in the rural areas, the only comfort they have is a smoke; and Fianna Fáil have put tobacco out of their reach.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Minister for Social Welfare is not responsible for taxation.

Comment on this

No, but I thought the Government had collective responsibility?

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

We are discussing the Department of Social Welfare.

Comment on this

Very well. I will relate my remarks to the need for an increase in old age pensions. The case was ably and capably made by Deputy Hickey of Cork. I am not denying that it may be said that it is a very popular move for any Deputy to advocate here legislation that will increase old age pensions. That may be put forward by any member of the House. We in the Labour Party know just as well as anyone else that if any such pensions or benefits are to be increased,the money must come from somewhere.

Comment on this

Hear, hear!

Comment on this

The only possible place it can come from is the people's pockets.

Comment on this

Hear hear!

Comment on this

It is a pity the Parliamentary Secretary did not know that in 1951.

Comment on this

We always knew it. We did not borrow. We did not make the country bankrupt, as you did— borrow, borrow, borrow.

Comment on this

We bear in mind the fact that the money will have to come from the people's pockets. I am very thankful to the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Social Welfare for reminding me that that is something that will happen in the future—that it will come from the people's pockets not necessarily to-day or to-morrow but, according to the present policy of Fianna Fáil, in 20 years' time arising from their borrowing policy.

Comment on this

When they will all be dead.

Comment on this

The Parliamentary Secretary has mentioned borrowing. How much money did you borrow this year?

Comment on this

Forty-five million pounds.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

It does not arise on this Estimate, Deputy.

Comment on this

It would be well to borrow for the old people.

Comment on this

We borrowed at home, anyway.

Comment on this

You could not get your money.

Comment on this

That is what you would like.

Comment on this

£16,000,000.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

This conversation must cease. We are distecussing the Estimate for the Department of Social Welfare and Deputy Murphy should relate his remarks to the administration of that Department.

Comment on this

I was making the point, as has been made by several members on these benches, that we are throughly aware of the fact that if the old age pensions were increased the money would have to come from somewhere. There is no use in standing up here and agitating for an increase in this, that or the other if we do not take cognisance of the fact that the money must be found to meet it. That is how I came to mention the borrowing business in the first instance. If I may say so, the Parliamentary Secretary had already mentioned it a few minutes earlier.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Parliamentary Secretary has not spoken in this debate.

Comment on this

He is interrupting.

Comment on this

I have a right to reply to Deputy Rooney, anyway.

Comment on this

No, I am not speaking.

Comment on this

The position is that, on account of the Chair's particular view on this matter, I must not go into the subject of borrowing. I have respect for the Chair and I bow to its ruling. Might I put it this way? The Government got £21,500,000 this year through borrowing.

Comment on this

This is the Estimate for the Department of Social Welfare.

Comment on this

Is any of that money going to the old age pensioners of this country? Did any of the £20,000,000 last year go to them to improve their position?

Comment on this

Why should it?

Comment on this

What the old age pensioners are getting is 21/6 per week.

Comment on this

I thought that all the money that was borrowed was wanted for capital development purposes.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The question of borrowing does not arise on this Estimate. If Deputy Murphy cannot get away from that subject he must resume his seat.

Comment on this

The necessity for an increase in old age pensions cannot be over-emphasised. I have no intention of resuming my seat yet, as I intend to speak for some time: I have a few more observations to make. Let us examine the types of persons who compose the old age pensioners of this country. What relation do they bear to the other sections of the community who do not receive an allowance known as the old age pension but who, instead, receive something known as a superannuation allowance, which is a far nicer term? Who are these old age pensioners? I will take, for the sake of example, the people who draw the old age pension in my constituency. I am sure that they are typical of the old age pensioners in every constituency in this country. They are the several groups of workers who have to earn their living not with their coat on but with their coat off; not within the shelter of a cosy and comfortable office but out in the open, in the field with the plough, on the road with the shovel and hammer and any other such occupation. When they reach 70 years of age, there is no allowance available for these persons except the old age pension. There are thousands of farmers throughout the country and when they reach 70 years of age the only allowance available to them—if they can survive a rigid means test—is the old age pension. Thousands of business people throughout the country are working under very difficult circumstances, particularly at present, due to the keen competition of large cooperative groups and societies which are crushing out the small man from business. They are the types of persons who will be applying for this allowance of 21/6 a week when they reach 70 years of age.

At this juncture, I think I could very well refer to a question which I addressed to the Minister for Social Welfare in this House no later than a fortnight ago. I asked why the oldage pension should not be made available to people at 65 rather than at 70. I have endeavoured, in so far as I possibly could, to calculate roughly what extra amount of money would be required per year if that suggestion were put into operation. I think that, roughly, it would work out at something more than £2,000,000 a year. Undoubtedly, that is a fairly formidable figure but, mind you, it is not so formidable when we relate it to the fact that it is costing more than £100,000,000 to run this country in the present financial year or when we relate it to the extra sum of £21,500,000 that was borrowed. In the course of a supplementary question which I asked the Minister in relation to the parliamentary question, I pointed out that the contribution of these people to the State is as noteworthy—and in my opinion more so—as the contribution of many people in the sheltered professions who have no difficulty at all in getting a huge superannuation allowance on reaching 65 years and who, in addition, receive a large gratuity when they retire. I maintain, without fear of contradiction, that the people down the country whom I have mentioned, and many people in our cities and towns—be they working behind a shop counter, with a spade, a shovel or a plough—are the backbone of this country. I further maintain, without fear of contradiction, that the contribution of these people to the welfare of our State—from the national as well as from every other angle—is as noteworthy, if not more so, as that of their more fortunate brethren in sheltered occupations. I do not want it to be taken that I am casting any reflection on the professional people. I am casting no reflection whatsoever on them. I realise that they must be there and that they serve a very useful purpose. My point is that I cannot see why the ordinary working man, the small farmer or the businessman—particularly the small businessman—cannot get an allowance from the age of 65.

Let us examine the position as it applies to certain sections of our Irish people. I am not afraid to face the issue. Everybody here knows thesections of our people who, when they reach 65, will receive what I have no hesitation in describing as a fine fat cheque together with a yearly allowance not of 21/6 per week but of something far more substantial. The amount varies with the persons but in some cases it comes to a fairly substantial four figure sum. I might mention that, proportionately, I receive as much support from that section of our people as any other Deputy.

Comment on this

Are you opposed to that?

Comment on this

I am dealing now with the position of what I term sections of our people. We can, on the one hand, find this money for these sections of people at the age of 65 years, but we cannot find it for the many groups of people that I have instanced when they reach the age of 65. I contend that is most unfair and unjust and that the position is one which needs rectification. So far as my information goes, people in neighbouring countries are now getting the old age pension at the age of 65. I cannot see why that should not happen here.

Deputy Killilea has asked me if I am opposed to these people getting their allowances. I am not opposed to it, but I have mentioned their position to compare it with those in many other groups who, when they reach the age of 70 years, have no allowance other than the old age pension. I feel that I am entitled to relate the position of certain sections of people, and their contributions towards the welfare of the country, with that of other sections of our people.

I have no hesitation in maintaining, and I am sure Deputy Killilea will hardly disagree with me, that the ordinary working men down the country, the men who produce food for the nation, who repair our highways, who do the hard, physical manual work, who do what is known as the gutter work, are making as noteworthy a contribution towards the welfare of this State as those who are in the sheltered professions and are equally entitled to a retirement allowance at 65.

Comment on this

What did you do for them when you were in office?

Comment on this

The unfortunate thing was that we were not in office sufficiently long. I have already informed the House of the measures that we did put into operation when we were in office, and I think it would be unfair to the House if I were to repeat it.

At the present time, many people who would not qualify for an old age pension but are in receipt of superannuation allowances from the State or some other service, are complaining that they have reached an alarming situation and cannot live on their present superannuation allowances. If that is their position what, I ask, is the position of the ordinary working man in the country who is trying to live on 21/6 a week? In many cases these are invalid persons. How can the Minister, or any member of the Fianna Fáil Government, maintain that 21/6 a week is sufficient at the present time, particularly in view of increases which the Government have imposed on those people during their two and a half years in office? I think that if the Government had any shame in them they would compensate those people for the great wrong they did to them in other ways.

I want to repeat that the importance of this question cannot be over-emphasised. I am speaking for decent working people down the country, whether they be workers on the roads, farmers, business people or others. It is a shame to impose on them, when they reach the age of 70 years, the hardship of having to go to some local authority official, a home assistance officer, a county councillor or somebody else to intercede for them to get the home assistance allowance in order to supplement their inadequate old age pension. I think it is very unfair to ask those old people at the age of 70 years to do that. I do not think there is any need for me to dwell on that aspect of the question any further.

Every member of the House, irrespective of what side he sits on, is cognisant of the pitiable plight of those old age pensioners. I am firmly of theopinion that, if legislation is introduced to increase their allowances, it will not meet with opposition from any Party in the House, and I would strongly impress on the Minister the need there is for introducing such legislation without delay.

Having dealt with the question of the allowance, I now want to mention another aspect of the case. It is that, in order to qualify for the 21/6 a week, small and all as it is, the applicant has to undergo a very close examination as to means. That rigid examination was modified a good deal by Deputy Norton when he was in office.

Comment on this

What did he do?

Comment on this

I will tell the Deputy, although I think he was a member of the House at the time and must have been conversant with the legislation that was passed through then, particularly the important legislation dealing with the modification of the means test which was introduced by the inter-Party Government, thereby making it easier for people and particularly farmers with valuations of less than £30 to qualify for the pension. Did the Deputy not hear about that? The means test was then modified, and the position obtained that an old age pensioner who felt that he was aggrieved by a decision of the social welfare officer had the right of appeal to the central authority in Dublin. He had the opportunity, if he wished to avail of it, of interviewing any member of this House so as to have his position, in regard to his appeal, put clearly and fully before the responsible authority appointed to make a determination on the appeal.

That was another useful measure that the Labour Party provided. They gave the old age pensioner the right to submit his case verbally if he so preferred to the Department's agent who was determining that case.

Comment on this

It is easily known you are not long here.

Comment on this

He could teach you a lot.

Comment on this

You should not be so contentious over there.

Comment on this

The Deputy might be let make his speech.

Comment on this

The position was not there all the time, and is not there now, if it is any information to you. That right was made available to the aged people of this country by Deputy Norton and was taken away from them by Deputy Dr. Ryan as Minister for Social Welfare. It is not now possible, unless there is some special reservation for Government Party members, for a member of this House, so far as I know, to approach the deciding authority so far as old age pension affairs are concerned. The representations have to be submitted either in writing or in some other way, through some kind of contact man, or through some agent.

The Fianna Fáil Party began by having no faith in the local authority members in this country, believing that they were prone to corruption and such things. Then they believed the same of the elected representatives of the people who become members of this House and suggested that it is unfair and unjust to allow them to interview the determining authority in respect of an old age pensions appeal by some aged person down the country. Is that not the position? What is happening?

Take the case of the farmers and business people first of all. I am dealing with several small farmers and small business people. We have had the means test modified by the inter-Party Government but since Fianna Fáil took over it seems that behind the curtain where they cannot be seen by any representatives of this House, the determining authorities in regard to old age pension claims have not only increased the means of all these farmers and business people but have done so in some cases to an outrageous extent.

Let me give a few examples that I have come across as a member of the pensions committee of what is happening behind closed doors. I will give the Minister illustrations and let him then go to his office and find out if I am right or wrong. Let me take the case of a very industrious aged couple in my county, a man and hiswife, both of whom attained the age of 70 some 11 or 12 months ago. They live in a cottage with one acre of land, with a son and daughter. As I have already mentioned, this man is very industrious and this year the family went in for turkey-rearing. I believe they were previously engaged in that business, but in any case and to be as brief as possible, they had 300 turkeys this year when they applied for the old age pension. What happened? What would Deputies think happened in regard to their claim for a pension? What did these people behind the iron curtain— whether they are in the Custom House or elsewhere I do not know—do about this claim? They told these people living in a cottage in County Cork that they would get no pension; that they had 300 turkeys and were going to make a profit of 16/8 on each of them. I would like to see some members of the staff in Aras Mhic Dhiarmada raising 300 turkeys and making a profit of 16/8 on each of these turkeys. That is what these applicants were told and that is the pension they got.

I maintain that that position should be reviewed. I think it is a scandal and an outrage that two such industrious old people living in a cottage in this country of ours should be deprived of a pension of 21/6 a week because they were industrious enough in their cottage with one acre to produce 300 turkeys. I think it is a shame and a scandal that the officials should determine that there would be a profit of 16/8 each on turkeys in the year 1953, when prices have fallen by more than 9d. per lb.

Comment on this

I think the Deputy will agree that that is not the strongest case he could make.

Comment on this

Mind you, it is not a bad one.

Comment on this

Is there 16/8 profit?

Comment on this

No. That is the case the Deputy is making. Perhaps the pension officer could get it, but nobody else could.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Murphy.

Comment on this

My advice to the Minister is to have a talk with some of these people on the clerical staff, and although they are getting substantial salaries, in view of the profit that is being made, or is alleged to be made on turkeys, suggest that they should instead of continuing with the Department of Social Welfare, go down to County Cork and get a few acres of land and raise 3,000 turkeys next year and make a fortune.

Comment on this

Did not Deputy Lehane say that people were losing money by having turkeys?

Comment on this

That is what I maintain; that is the case I am trying to bring home.

Comment on this

Would it not be better for the old age pensioners not to raise turkeys?

Comment on this

They made money a couple of years ago.

Comment on this

This man lost 12 months of his pension because he had the misfortune of rearing 300 turkeys this year. Not only have himself and his wife lost £2 3s. a week between them, but they have lost more with the turkeys. But the gentlemen over in the Custom House, or wherever they are—perhaps in the big palace at Store Street—determined, mind you, despite clear-cut statements on my part and on the part of the applicants themselves that there was little or no profit on these turkeys, that there would be 16/8 profit on each turkey.

It may be said that no sane people would keep turkeys and rear them at a loss but that is the position this year due to a sharp decline in price. They have no redress, and it is an unfortunate position. Surely, there is no greater scandal in Ireland than that cases like that should arise. I have had several such cases and I could give other instances.

There is an old, struggling farmer whom I know well. He has beenstruggling all his life to eke out a living on a little farm that carries a valuation of £7 15s., including buildings. The people in this big building down in Store Street have decided that that man is not entitled to the full pension because of this property. They treated that man very dishonestly; because of this little bit of property they allowed him only 16/6 per week. I know this farmer very well and I know that he never had sufficient to buy himself a decent suit of clothes in all his life. Yet, these people in Store Street have decided that he does not need the full pension. I wonder what they will get when they go out on pension. What gratuity will they be given? It is disheartening to meet with these things and they are due to the changes that the present Minister has made in the administration of his Department. He has denied in clear-cut language the right of members of this House, a right enjoyed by every Deputy under the inter-Party Government, to approach the determining officer personally and set out the cases in detail before him. These determining officers are now placed on a pedestal far removed from everyone. They cannot be seen by any member of this House. Indeed, I believe they cannot be identified and, according to my information, and it is apparent from their actions, they have little or no knowledge of the position that obtains so far as the ordinary hardworking people throughout the country are concerned.

I have given the Minister two illustrations. I appeal to him now to change this unfortunate system. I appeal to him, if he is sufficiently interested, to inquire into the two cases I have cited. He will find the position exactly as I have stated it in so far as this labourer with the turkeys is concerned and in so far as the small farmer with the £7 valuation is concerned. The honest, hardworking, industrious labourer saved a few hundred pounds but it was the turkeys that were the cause of his trouble.

Comment on this

I have yet to learn that one loses money on rearing turkeys. I know what I have to pay for one when I buy it.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The turkeys have been discussed sufficiently. Let us now get on with the Estimate.

Comment on this

I appeal to the Minister to change the present system. Let him have some confidence in the members of this House and grant them the right of direct approach to the Pension Appeal Board. He is only a member himself and he ought to have some confidence in his own colleagues. This House is not composed of tricksters. Let the Minister have a little faith in Irish public life and a little confidence in the Irish people.

Comment on this

Would the Deputy not have confidence in the people who determine the appeals?

Comment on this

No, in view of these decisions.

Comment on this

They are just as Irish as the Deputy is.

Comment on this

I do not know what they are. Let the Minister have a little confidence in the people. If a Deputy can be elected here by 6,000 or 7,000 voters on an average, is he not entitled to some privileges? Is he not entitled to put these people's cases directly before the responsible authorities and not through the medium of an agent or a "contact man"? The present system is a hopeless one. It is not one that would commend itself to anyone.

During the two and a half years this Government has been in office money has been found for many schemes but very little has been found for the aged. I think the Government could find a few millions to improve the lot of these people. I think the Government could give them a pension at 65 just as easily as they found £250,000 to improve the bloodstock industry and £457,000 to throw into the transatlantic air services and all the other wanton expenditures they have incurred during the past 12 months.

Cases arise in relation to men working for local authorities and private employers earning a wage of £4 or £4 10s. a week where the wives are older than the husbands and on reaching70 years of age apply for a pension. This pension is denied to these wives because their husbands are working. Can nothing be done to rectify that position? I recognise that there may be some difficulties in the way but surely some steps could be taken to remedy the present situation. Even if the husband is earning only £2 a week the wife on reaching 70 years of age will get a pension of only 11/6. I appeal to the Minister to take some steps in this matter.

Deputy Hickey has already outlined the position sufficiently in so far as widows and orphans are concerned. They are more or less in the same category as the old age pensioners. Everybody knows that the non-contributory pension of £1 per week or the contributory pension of 24/- a week is quite inadequate having regard to the sharp rise that has taken place in the cost of living. It would not be out of place for the Government and the Minister to provide a little more money for these deserving people. It could be done by cutting some of the wanton expenditure.

The position with regard to social services generally is deplorable. Unemployment assistance is not what it should be. I regret the need for this service. I have never been able to view it with favour. I think it is shocking that a young man should start his career by drawing unemployment assistance. Yesterday, in reply to a question, the Minister told me that there are 602 people registered in the exchange in the village of Castle-townbere. No work is available for them there and they have no option but to emigrate or accept unemployment assistance. I have advised some young people in that area recently who sought my help to emigrate, as there was not alternative except the dole. I think I was right.

People in the middle age group, married people, cannot emigrate and, as employment is not available, have no option but to get benefit. The benefit is hopeless and it is difficult for many of these people to exist on it.

The Minister may not claim direct responsibility for the many unfortunatepeople who are in receipt of home assistance allowances from local authorities. The allowances vary in the different counties but the allowances in Cork are hopeless. Many invalided people get, on an average, not more than 9/- or 10/- a week. That is a scandalous position and should be rectified. These people should be entitled to some allowance directly from the Department of Social Welfare.

In conclusion, I would appeal to the Minister as strongly as I can to take cognisance of the plight of the old age pensioners and of the widows and orphans. I would ask him to take cognisance of the fact that the people in the sections that I have mentioned earlier are equally entitled to their pension at the age of 65 as the groups who now receive retirement allowances at that age.

Comment on this

A number of Deputies have pleaded eloquently for increased social benefits. Before dealing with the case they have made it is no harm to reflect on what has been done in the short course of the past two and a half years. In the past two and a half years social services have been increased by £7,500,000. That is quite a considerable amount of money and takes a considerable amount of collecting.

It is not a bad contribution on the part of any Government in any Christian country. It involves the raising of a very large amount of money by taxation. It is a very popular thing to give increased benefits, particularly to the poorer sections, but it is not such a popular thing to advocate the raising of the money which must be collected from the ordinary people.

As the Minister pointed out in introducing the Estimate, since 1932 social benefits of all kinds and the cost of social services generally have increased from £3,750,000 to £21,000,000. At present we are paying £21,000,000 in benefit to the poor and deserving sections of our community out of total revenue. That is a very substantial contribution. It places on the entire community a fairly heavy burden, aburden which the people are willing to bear.

What is dishonest on the part of politicians is to advocate increased benefits without advocating increased taxation to provide them. I would have nothing but admiration for a Deputy who would say: "I demand an increase of 2/6 per week in old age pensions and I advocate that the price of cigarettes be increased by 6d. per packet or 1/- per packet, that the price of stout be similarly increased and that all other taxed commodities of that kind be further taxed." If a Deputy says that, it can be assumed that he is genuinely anxious to help the old age pensioners. If he simply says: "I want an increase in old age pensions but I am not prepared to advocate any method of raising the money," one can hardly place too much reliance on his honesty.

Comment on this

What about paying £250,000 for Tulyar?

Comment on this

Experts consider that the National Stud will produce increased revenue that will help to pay for social services. I do not intend to speak so much in millions because the people who depend on social services are not very much concerned with millions. I doubt if they would understand what they mean. They think in terms of shillings and pence.

It is no harm to reflect on the fact that since June, 1951, old age pensions have been increased by 4/- per week, being brought from 17/6 to 21/6. That is a fairly substantial increase. It is the largest increase that was made in one year since old age pensions first came into operation. Sickness benefit in the case of a man with a wife and two dependent children has been increased from 22/6 to 52/6. Disablement benefit has been increased from 15/- in 1951 to 52/6 to-day. Unemployment assistance has been increased from 28/- to 40/6. In the case of widows' and orphans' pensions a widow with two children has had the contributory pension increased from 28/- to 40/6 and the non-contributory pension increased from 26/- to 34/6. All those increases have been effected over the past two years.

Comment on this

Tell us about the cost of living now.

Comment on this

I shall deal with the cost of living in relation to these pensions immediately. All those increases amount to a sum total of £7,500,000, which is a very considerable sum of money. Deputy O'Leary has asked me to relate those increases to the cost of living. An increase from 22/6 to 52/6 is very much above the increase in the cost of living. The cost of living in 1951, at the time of the change of Government, was 109. To-day it is 125. That is roughly an increase of 16 points. In this case the benefit is two and a half times what it was to meet that increase. In the case of unemployment benefit the increase has not been quite so much but it is almost doubled to meet the increase of 16 per cent. in the cost of living.

Deputy Norton in speaking for this motion referred particularly to the old age pensioners, and I think that in that particular case the increase in the old age pension may not have been proportionate and has not been as great as those to which I have referred —sickness benefit, unemployment benefit and others—but it has been fairly substantial. But Deputy Norton made a point which I think deserves consideration. He said that 10/- in 1939 was equal to 23 - to-day in purchasing power.

I am not sure whether the figure is exactly true or not, but I am going to accept it because I have nothing to controvert it, and being reasonable I do not dispute a figure which I am not in a position to dispute; so assuming that that is correct the old age pensioners, in order to have the same benefit as in 1939, would require 23/-, that is 1/6 more than they are getting to-day. It is no harm, however, to reflect that when Deputy Norton was in office in 1951 on his own figures 10/-in 1939 was equal to 19/9 in 1951, so that if Deputy Norton wanted to be fair to the old age pensioners, if he wanted to give them a pension equal to the 10/- that they had in 1939, he would have been obliged to give them 19/9 in 1951, but he failed to do that. He pinned the old age pension down to 17/6, thereby providing the old agepensioner not with 1/6 less than he was entitled to in order to maintain the purchasing power of the pension of 1939, but he was giving the old age pensioner 2/3 less than he was entitled to to maintain the purchasing power of 10/- in 1939; so that if the Government has failed to keep the purchasing power of the old age pension up even to the standard of 1939 it would appear that Deputy Norton failed even to a greater extent, by as much as 2/3 below the figure that was requisite to maintain the purchasing power of the old age pension, and I am speaking about the purchasing power and the difference in the cost of living in 1951 as compared with to-day.

It would be very easy to produce a graph showing how the cost of living has compared with the benefits provided under the Department of Social Welfare, and it would show that the Minister increased the real income of a large section of our people, and in connection with old age pensions it would show that Deputy Norton as Minister for Social Welfare failed to a far greater extent to maintain the income of the old age pensioners than has the present Minister. I think Deputy Norton should reflect upon these things sometimes when he comes into this House full of zeal on behalf of the poorer sections of the community. He must reflect on the fact that he had three and a half years in which to benefit the poorer sections of the community and he failed ignominiously to do anything worth while. He kept sickness benefit in the case of a family of two down to 22/6, whereas to-day it is 52/6. He may tell us that he tried to introduce legislation. Well, he did. He introduced a Bill which imposed a very high contribution upon the ordinary worker and conferred benefits in some cases not so good as under the existing legislation.

I stated that any Deputy who wished to advocate an increase in benefits, an increase in old age pensions, is entitled to do so provided that he picks out the sources from which the revenue can be provided and that he sets out what particular taxes he would wish to see imposed in order to provide the money. If he does that he is entitledto be listened to with respect, because I do not think there is any Deputy in this House, no matter what side of the House he belongs to, but has the deepest sympathy with our old age pensioners who are trying to live on 21/6, particularly those who are compelled to live upon that sum. The old age pensioner who may have some help from his family or relatives may not be quite so badly off, but the old age pensioner who has to pay rents and rates and buy fuel and provide food for himself out of 21/6 is certainly on very short rations, and that is the man or the woman for whom we should have the deepest sympathy. There are hundreds and thousands of them throughout the country and here in the City of Dublin trying to eke out an existence and to pay rent and rates on that total income.

Comment on this

The Deputy voted against 20/- a week for them.

Comment on this

No. That is one of the great lies that were used by the inter-Party in Wicklow during the election of 1951. The inter-Party Government claimed that they were supporting me and that I was elected to support them, and they went to every platform in County Wicklow and stated that I voted against a proposal to provide 20/- a week for old age pensioners.

Comment on this

That is right.

Comment on this

I never voted against such a proposal.

Comment on this

Certainly you did.

Comment on this

Now let Deputy Rooney listen. I am prepared to put a substantial sum, to put £10, to any charity if Deputy Rooney produces any official document in the records of this House to show that I voted against a proposal to increase the old age pension to 20/- a week. I never did.

Comment on this

On the 2nd March.

Comment on this

I am putting that challenge to Deputy Rooney and he can take it up and there is £10 for any organisation, even for Fine Gael, if he can prove it.

Comment on this

That will not keep him from saying it all the more.

Comment on this

No. It is very easy to make these accusations broadcast on public platforms and to come here in this House to attack and blackguard an Independent farmer Deputy, as I was at that time, and try to defeat his election, but I have denied it and challenge him to prove it, to find it in any official document. The records are in the Library. They can be produced. Produce them. What I voted against in 1951 was a rather half-baked ill-considered Social Welfare Bill which made no provision whatever for increasing the old age pension but which did make provision for collecting 3/6 per week off every agricultural worker and every other worker in this country. That was the Bill I voted against. There was no provision in that Bill for increasing the old age pensions.

Comment on this

There was.

Comment on this

There was not. There was no provision whatever.

Comment on this

Pensions at 65.

Comment on this

The Bill can be produced.

Comment on this

Deputy Cowan won an election on it.

Comment on this

Produce the Bill of 1951 and show where there is any provision in that Bill that came before the House for Second Reading which provided for an increase in the old age pension.

Comment on this

Pensions at 65 as well.

Comment on this

But Deputy Norton came into this House and said that he proposed at a later stage in the Bill to insert an amendment providing for an increase in old age pensions, and immediately he did that three Independent Deputies in this House went to the Government and said: "You are going to give an increase in the old age pensions. Give it now. Once the Government has announced that they are prepared to give an increase in the old age pensions, once they have made it clearthat their Minister for Finance is going to give the money, why keep them waiting?" That was the case we made. We put it on the records of this House that three Independent Deputies—Deputy Lehane, myself and Deputy Finucane—put up that case to the Government. What was the answer? The Government said: "No, we will not; we have the money to give this increase of 2/6 a week but we are not going to give it to them now. We are going to hold the old age pensioners up to ransom and hold this over their heads until we pass the Social Welfare Bill. In three or four months' time if we are still in office, we will give them an increase in pension."

Comment on this

Is that a quotation?

Comment on this

I can produce documents to prove that Deputy Lehane and myself raised this matter. We asked the Government to introduce a short Bill, not covering the whole sphere of social welfare but just a short Bill of one or two sections giving the old age pensioners an increase of 2/6 per week. That was all we asked but our request was not granted. The Government then went out and another Government came in and what we demanded in April and May of 1951 was granted two months later, after the new Government came in.

Comment on this

1/6 a week.

Comment on this

2/6 a week.

Comment on this

1/6.

Comment on this

The pension when the inter-Party Government was in office was 17/6. We demanded an increase of 2/6 and when the new Government came in they gave an increase of 2/6, one month after coming into office. They brought in a short Bill and got it through the House without opposition granting an increase of 2/6 a week, bringing the pension up to 20/-which was paid right away. The present Government did not wait for the enactment of their Social Welfare Bill in order to give that increase of 2/6. They gave it right away when they got into office. They did not keep the old age pensioners waitingexpectantly; they did not hold them up to ransom in order to ensure the passage of the Social Welfare Bill. In that way they honoured their pledge.

As I say, in 1951 speakers of the Opposition Party, who claim to be Christian men, did not hesitate to go on a platform and accuse me of voting against an increase of 2/6 in the old age pensions whereas, as a matter of fact, I and two other Independent Deputies brought the greatest possible pressure to bear on the inter-Party Government to force them to give that increase of 2/6 and we failed.

Comment on this

What about bringing a little pressure to bear on the present Government now?

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Cogan is in possession.

Comment on this

The record of the present Government in regard to social welfare has not been bad. As I say, they have increased the provision under all these headings by £7,500,000 over the last two and a half years. In doing that, I think they have shown that they are sympathetic to the claims of the under-privileged and those in the lower income group. I think we can depend on the present Government to follow that line in future years. I do not think that the Government would be helping the old age pensioners if they were to adopt the suggestion put forward by Deputy O'Higgins that old age pensions should be pegged to the cost of living at the present time. The cost of living at the present time is high and to peg the rate of old age pensions to the present cost of living might result, in the event of the cost of living being reduced, in a reduced rate of old age pensions later on. I do not think the Government would desire to do that.

The whole question of helping out in every possible way those who are on the lowest rate of income is the obvious policy of the Government, a policy which I trust they will continue to keep in the forefront of their programme. The fact that sickness benefit has been more than doubled, raised from 22/6 to 52/6, is a gesture in the right direction. The fact that unemployment benefit has been raised from 35/- to52/6 is also an indication that this Government is not hostile, at any rate, to the sections of our people who are unemployed or to widows and orphans. All these pensions and allowances have been increased over the last two and a half years. I think we can trust the present Government to adhere to that policy of at all times searching out for people who are in the greatest need. I have indicated that in my opinion a person like an old age pensioner who has to depend completely on his old age pension is in the class of persons in the greatest need at the present time.

Deputy Murphy suggested that Deputies have no right now to make representations on behalf of old age pensioners. I do not think there is any substance in that complaint because Deputies are still making representations on behalf of old age pensioners. Every Deputy is doing it and will continue to do it and I think they are satisfied that their representations get careful consideration. I do not think it would be right or desirable at the same time, that officers who decide claims in regard to old age pensions should come into this House and go around meeting Deputies, perhaps go into the bar, to discuss old age pensions with them. I think these officers occup a judicial position and that they are entitled to make their decisions coolly and deliberately, that they are entitled to accept Deputies' representations and weigh them carefully in making their decisions. I think that is being done. I may be quite wrong but I am satisfied from my own experience that it is being done.

We know that sometimes there is a great deal of disparity between the decisions come to but these disparities arise mainly in regard to the original investigation. One social welfare officer may be a little more strict than another in his interpretation of the Act but I think that on the whole that a reasonable effort is being made to interpret and carry out the law fairly.

That there has been no deterioration, but rather an improvement, in the provision made for old age pensioners is proved by the fact that the number ofold age pensioners is every year increasing and that the allowance provided for them out of the Exchequer is every year being stepped up. I think that in the last two years the amount has gone up by £2,000,000, possibly more. I am not sure of the exact figure but certainly it has increased. As I say, the total increase in the last two and a half years in regard to social welfare payments is over £7,500,000 and, mind you, that is a fairly substantial amount of money.

I do not wish to say anything more on this Estimate. I think I have indicated that Deputy Norton and people like him who have had the responsibility of the Government in the past, have a certain amount of audacity in coming in here to make the demands that they are making in this motion, having regard to their own conduct during their period of office. A Minister for Social Welfare who held down sickness benefit to a man with a wife and two children to the rate of 22/6 per week for three and a half years can hardly feel justified in demanding now that benefit, which has been more than doubled, should be further increased. He should have a certain amount of modesty in approaching this matter having regard to his own record as Minister for Social Welfare.

I am satisfied that everything possible will be done to improve the position of the people who have to depend on the social welfare schemes. I have never held, and I do not hold now, that unemployment benefit or unemployment assistance is any substitute for work, and I think the whole of the energies of the Minister's Department and of the Minister as a member of the Government should be devoted to providing employment rather than assistance. The giving of benefit or assistance is not to be compared with a regular week's wages and steady employment and the problem of providing for the poorer sections of our community must be faced. With regard to the old age pensions, I want to recommend strongly to the Minister the need to review the position, particularly in regard to those who have to depend absolutely without any help on the 21/6 per week.

Comment on this

There is only one particular matter which I wish to mention in connection with the old age pensioners. I listened to several Deputies patting their own favourite Government on the back for the generous treatment meted out to the old age pensioners in the years past. I have never accepted that we have been really fair in our treatment of the old age pensioners. Without going into details or drawing too many comparisons, I might refer Deputies to the conditions that obtain in other countries such as Sweden, Norway, and our next-door neighbour, Great Britain. If we compare the conditions of the aged people and the manner in which they are treated there and have a look at our own system, I think we have very little to be proud of.

The extraordinary thing is that from all sides of the House we have this praise about how generous and kind various Governments have been towards the aged. It is extraordinary, when we examine the conditions in other countries, to find that we lag behind these countries, notwithstanding all the talk about religion. Nobody can accuse our neighbours in Great Britain of being a very religious community or say that the people there are as religious or as holy as the people are in Ireland. Yet, in spite of the fact that they are less religious, they have treated their old age pensioners in a far more generous manner than the holy Irish.

If there is strong pressure brought to bear to increase substantially the allowance to the old people here, we are told that this country cannot afford to give the same type of social benefits as our more wealthy neighbours. The extraordinary thing is that we actually send out our young people to build up wealth in other countries, so that we are actually helping these other nations to provide better social services, while at home there is very little for the parents or relatives of these young men and women who have to earn a living abroad. It is good politics, I believe, when you are in opposition, to embarrass whatever Government is in power by putting down motions of this nature to increaseold age pensions. That is being done at the present time and I believe that, as far as the Labour Party are concerned, they are entitled to take advantage of the situation and take all the kudos for pressing for an increase.

The extraordinary position arises that the present Government are not prepared to accept a motion to increase old age pensions; and there is a weapon immediately put into the hands of the Opposition straightway so that they can appear on every public platform from here to Cork and up to Donegal and say that Deputy So-and-so of the Fianna Fáil Party voted against giving an increase to old age pensioners. That will happen if there is a division on this motion. Apart from the motion and the political advantage that may be gained by any Party by bringing into operation a certain increase for old age pensioners, I think that the old pensioners are entitled to an increase. Even on the basis that we have so far given a paltry 21/6 per week, I think they are entitled to a further increase in view of the increased cost of living. The increase of 1/6 per week was of very little benefit to an old man or woman living in a room as a set-off to the increase in the cost of living and the removal of the food subsidies. It was a very poor substitute indeed.

The point I am interested in in connection with old age pensions was brought to my mind very forcibly by Deputy Murphy, who made a very good case. He mentioned that there was no such thing now as a direct approach to the officials who make decisions with regard to the old age pensions. He pointed out that there is no contact man now available who will meet Deputies and listen to the case put up by them on behalf of applicants and refer the Deputies' recommendations back to the deciding officer.

The time has come for some Government to spare Deputies the trouble of meeting any contact man and to spare Deputies the trouble of writing crawling letters on behalf of these unfortunate people who seek an old age pension. Cut out the contact men and pension officers altogether. In other words, I want to see that means testremoved. I am a very strong believer in having no means test in anything. There is no concrete reason whatever why there should be a means test for the old age pension—bar the question of costs, and we cannot discuss that in this debate, as money is involved, and when it is money we will have more high-falutin' arguments like those we heard here last night on finance.

I wonder how many people realise the deception practised in connection with old age pensions. When a person comes to the age of 70 and makes application, a group of his own neighbours —respectable, decent people—sit in judgment on the application. This group is known as a pensions sub-committee, and it is composed of highly respectable and worthy citizens. Nine times out of ten that sub-committee will sanction the full pension. Is it not a joke to say that the sub-committee will sanction or grant the pension, when that sub-committee has no more power than the man in the moon to put the decision into operation? It is there only as a sop to democracy. The work of that sub-committee is counteracted straightway by the gentleman known as the pension officer. He sits there and listens to the decision and straightway proceeds to tear down the recommendation.

The next thing we have is the local Deputy, county councillor or other person alleged to have power or influence, asked by that old applicant to make representations on his behalf to the Minister. There must be a tremendous waste of money in stamps on letters, and in the time of civil servants answering letters from Deputies, parish priests, curates, local teachers and councillors on behalf of such applicants.

I want to give a certain amount of credit to Deputy Norton in connection with the means test. Most Deputies will agree with the modification that took place—that was meant to take place and that was understood to have taken place by the Deputies of this House, but which was not put into operation in the manner we hoped. I know for a fact that the pension officers are just as anxious now to count the eggs that the hen laid within the past month.

Deputy Murphy's case is one that should cause a lot of worry to Deputies. He mentioned an old couple living in a cottage with only an acre of land. By their thrift, perseverance and hard work they reared 300 turkeys. Because of that, they were deprived of the old age pension. In other words, the idea behind the giving of the pension now is that you will get it if you do no work. I take a specific case in my own constituency, of a man who is now 73—a fine hardy old gentleman —deprived of the pension because when the officer arrived he found this old man up on a ladder helping his son to repair a roof. There can be no contradiction or denial of this, because I pursued it and investigated it thoroughly. One of the reasons why that man's claim was turned down was that he was still in control and still working on the holding. If the client in question had known that the pension officer was coming, he could have put a big rug around himself and sat in on the hob, having taken the fire out, and could have shivered for a few hours. Then the report of the pension officer would have been that this was a feeble old man. There again we have a deception. There is very little honesty in the whole question. An applicant who frankly discloses full information with regard to his means, who tells even more than he is bound to tell, will be victimised straightway.

I may sound very harsh on this point now, but I feel that it is a degrading thing that old people who reach 70 and who have given the best years of their lives—as labourers, as self-employed small farmers or as people who were in business—should be asked to submit to this degrading investigation. They are asked how much money they have in the bank and what bank it is in. A banker's order is got so that the pension officer can check for himself what they have. They must disclose the number of animals on the little holding, even count the calves and sheep and pigs. They must disclose if they have any money laid aside for dowries. The whole question of a family's most private details must be exposed to a civil servant. I remember distinctly that not so long ago there was aterrible outcry because civil servants would have access to the private details of a particular family's method of living. That was in connection with the Health Bill, Here we have a means test in operation for old age pensions.

I would like the Minister to tell us when replying how much exactly it would cost if the means test were removed immediately and the pension given to every applicant over 70 years of age. I think it could not amount to more than £3,500,000 or £4,000,000. If the Minister is not prepared at this stage to remove the means test completely, I would like him to assure us that he will relax the investigation now carried out when an old person applies for a pension. I would like him to have that recommendation or suggestion of mine examined sympathetically. It is just too bad that a thrifty, hardworking man or woman who managed to save or scrape together a few pounds over all their years will, in effect, be told when they apply for the old age pension that because they were thrifty and saved a few pounds and put it in the bank or invested the money in stocks or something else they cannot be given the old age pension. I submit that that approach is a premium on idleness.

Comment on this

You have to have £1,000 there before it counts against you. Is that not true?

Comment on this

Will Deputy MacCarthy tell me what does £1,000 in the bank represent to-day?

Comment on this

Deputy McQuillan should state the case fairly.

Comment on this

I am stating it as I know it. If Deputy MacCarthy wants to tell me now what £1,000 in the bank will bring in per annum, he can do so. Will it bring in what the Department of Social Welfare suggested——

Comment on this

He will get the full pension with that amount in the bank.

Comment on this

I am asking a simple question with regard to £1,000.

Comment on this

He will get the full pension with £1,000 in the bank.

Comment on this

Then why are so many applicants refused the pension to-day?

Comment on this

Seven thousand extra persons are getting it now.

Comment on this

Applicants are being refused.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I called Deputy McQuillan.

Comment on this

That is right, too.

Comment on this

I do not care whose feelings I may be hurting in this connection. I want to make it clear that my remarks were not in any way directed as a particular criticism of the present Minister. I want that to be clearly understood. Further, I will not allow any of my remarks here to be utilised for the purpose of scoring a debating point off the present Government. Like other Deputies, I have some very painful recollections of how difficult it was to extract an increase of 2/6 per week in old age pensions from the inter-Party Government. Although we are assured now by Deputies who were Ministers in the inter-Party Government that at that time they were in Easy Street so far as money was concerned, there was no question of Easy Street when it came to increasing old age pensions—and I do not care who likes or dislikes that statement. No matter what Government might be in office, if my vote were of importance in keeping the Government in office, I would vote to put them out if I thought that the old age pensioners were not getting a fair crack of the whip from them. I might mention, in passing, that I took a similar stand on a former occasion with regard to the means test.

We should be more than anxious to ensure that the conditions of the older members of our community compare at least as favourably as those which obtain in countries such as Norway and Sweden. I am speaking on this matter purely as an Independent. The case of old age pensioners should be met sympathetically by the Minister. It may be said that there is very little money in the till to give an immediate increase in the old age pension. In my view, that difficultycan be surmounted. There are, of course, a number of conservative diehards in the country who think that when a person reaches the age of 70 he should get down on his knees and beg for something to enable him to keep body and soul together. Unfortunately, there are people of that mentality in the country. They prefer to see people in a poor state all their lives. Their attitude is that if you keep the people down and poor and dependent on charity you can always control them. That mentality exists in the country, I am sorry to say. I hope we shall never see the day when some of those diehards will sit in the saddle and have power to put their views in connection with old age pensions into operation.

The criticisms I have made in connection with the means test and the manner in which the officials carry out their instructions are not meant as a criticism of present-day conditions only. I criticised that system from the first day I entered public life in 1948 as a member of the Clann na Poblachta Party. So long as I am a member of this House, I shall strive to ensure that the policy which we stood for at that time with regard to social services generally will be put into operation fully.

Comment on this

Successive Governments in this country seem to applaud themselves in the matter of expenditure on social services. While that might be a proper thing to do when these services are viewed from a certain angle, it might also be regarded as a barometer of failure. Nobody will quarrel with the provision of money for old age pensions. Nobody will quarrel with the provision of money for blind pensions. Nobody will quarrel with the provision of money for those who are handicapped by infirmity of any kind. It is recognised that there is a responsibility on the Government of the day to make provision for the citizens who are not capable of providing a livelihood for themselves.

While the Government may boast that they are spending £21,000,000 on social services, we must consider whether or not there are other waysof spending that £21,000,000 that would bring benefits to those who are in need of them, not by increasing the demand but by reducing the demand in other directions on social services. I submit to the Minister and to the Government that this is possible. The money provided by way of unemployment benefit and unemployment assistance could be curtailed if the employment which the recipients of these two forms of assistance are demanding were provided. The Minister could, without any further demands on the Exchequer, bring much-needed relief to old age pensioners, blind pensioners, widows and orphans and even to the recipients of children's allowances. These benefits could all be increased without any further demand on the Exchequer if a solution were found to the unemployment problem. Very great economies could be made in the matter of unemployment benefit and unemployment assistance. In so far as these benefits grow, they indicate to whatever Government may be in office that it is not doing its job. There is no justification for any man or woman being unemployed in this country at the moment. A duty devolved on the Government—I am not blaming this Government any more than I blame the previous Government, because we have always had a certain degree of unemployment in this country—to ensure that work will be available for those who wish to take it. I know quite well, as I am sure the Minister knows, that there are in this country many people drawing unemployment assistance and unemployment benefit who would much prefer to do a day's work and to draw a weekly wage, because the provision made, even with this colossal expenditure, affords no real benefit to them. I submit that one of the New Year resolutions which the Government might make is to tackle that problem of unemployment and save, in respect of unemployment benefit and unemployment assistance, sufficient to increase the pensions of necessitous cases.

Deputy Esmonde referred particularly to blind pensions and, speaking as a member of a sub-committee, I can say from my own personal experiencethat it seems almost impossible for a person to be awarded a blind pension, not only at present but for a considerable time past. A man needs to be almost stone blind before he qualifies for a blind pension, and I submit that there should be some degree of visionary defect that would entitle a person to such a pension. Everybody knows that those who suffer from defective sight invariably suffer from a degree of nervousness as well, and that, when the affliction comes in middle life or later, these people are not in a position to discharge their ordinary duties with the same degree of efficiency as they were before the affliction came on them. At every meeting of our sub-committee, we find people making claims for a blind pension, and, while the sub-committee awards them, as Deputy McQuillan has said, we get the usual reply that satisfactory evidence of blindness has not been furnished. What would be satisfactory evidence of blindness, I do not know, but we can see that these applicants are definitely suffering from defective vision, and, while they might not be entitled under the Acts to the full pension, they must be entitled to some consideration by the State. I submit that there should be some alteration of the administration of that Act.

I find, too, as I am sure many Deputies find, that there is dissatisfaction with the payment of unemployment benefit, and I feel that Deputy Norton was right when he asked that some explanatory memorandum be made available so that people may understand the various regulations brought into existence in relation to the different social services, because it is a fact that no ordinary man can understand them. There is one point I should like to have clarified. I have known of a case of a man who was putting on stamps for unemployment benefit and national health insurance for about 12 years. He then stopped paying, and, after about three years, re-entered insurable employment, but, because he did not have 26 stamps since the date of his last entry into insurable employment, he was denied benefit, notwithstanding the fact thathe had been paying for 12 years before that. If that is the way our social welfare scheme operates, it needs alteration, and I should like the Minister to clarify in some way the conditions attaching to that service.

Very rarely have I agreed with Deputy McQuillan, but with his remarks on the administration of the Old Age Pensions Acts, I am in entire agreement. I dot the i's and cross the t's of everything he said in that connection. I have at all times held that, when a person comes to 70 years of age it should be open to him to make application for an old age pension and to get it. It is one sphere of social service in which I believe the means test should be abolished. I have advocated that since I came into public life and I still believe I am right, because, as Deputy McQuillan has said, it is putting a premium on idleness to suggest that if by thrift and industry, a man manages to establish himself comfortably in life, when he attains the age of 70, he thereby automatically debars himself from an old age pension. Obviously, to any intelligent man, that is an encouragement to the citizen to become an idle fellow whereas if you are a spendthrift and have squandered everything you earned all your life, you immediately, on attaining the age of 70, become entitled to an old age pension. I should like to hear what can be the justification for such a system.

I think, too, that it is utterly unfair, even under the present system, that, when computing means, pensions paid by an outside State or Government should be taken into consideration. There are in this country many people, particularly in the West of Ireland, who migrated to Britain and earned the right to a pension—a contributory pension, in most cases—and who, when they come back to this country, find that that item of income is calculated in their means. I say that it should be completely ignored and that only such assets as a person possesses in this country, or such income as he may derive from investments outside, should be taken into consideration. The pensions to which they have entitled themselves by work in othercountries should not be taken into consideration in the computation of means.

With regard to the particular means test, I think it is right to say that there is very little saving in the long run, because, when one considers all the administrative costs, all the costs which must be incurred in having investigation officers dealing with the matter, one finds that they practically offset any economies made by reason of the means test. People on all sides must realise that this is one thing that should be put right, even now, and I hope the Government will, in the near future, introduce legislation which will remove a means test of any kind in the matter of old age pensions.

Comment on this

I should like to remark that the cost of administering these various services under the Social Welfare Acts is rather high. When we examine the figures, we see that for every £100 paid out—and that does not involve many payments or many people —the cost of getting that sum into the hands of the person who receives it is £10. It costs £10 to put out every £100 in the form of old age pensions, unemployment benefit——

Comment on this

The Deputy is making a mistake there, because, as well as paying out the money from the Exchequer, you are paying out what is collected from employers and employees.

Comment on this

In other words, it is the cost of taking it in and giving it out?

Comment on this

Paying out more.

Comment on this

It is still costing £10 for every £100.

Comment on this

There is much more than £100 paid out.

Comment on this

The approximate figures are £11,400,000 being paid out at a cost of £1,300,000. That represents approximately 10 per cent.

Comment on this

The correct figure is 6.4 per cent.

Comment on this

That is a very big difference all right.

Comment on this

There is an income from employers' and employees' contributions into the fund as well as what the Exchequer pays in. It is on paying out that amount that you have the 6.4 per cent.

Comment on this

We will take it then that the cost of paying these people is almost £6 10s. for every £100 that these people receive. If it is paid out in the form of old age pensions, unemployment benefits, widows' and orphans' pensions and blind pensions, it still amounts to a fairly heavy percentage. The Minister might argue that if we compare the cost of administration with the administration costs of commercial banks we will then be able to make in some way comparisons between the administration in the commercial banks and the administration in connection with these social welfare schemes.

The trend of this debate centred around the present level of the old age pensions, which is 21/6 per week. Obviously, the reason why the emphasis was on that aspect of the debate is that when the meagre allowance to the old age pensioners is compared with the cost of living and the cost of food an immediate need is shown for a revision of the old age pension level.

I heard the Fianna Fáil Party boasting on different occasions that the amount of money now paid out in social services of various kinds is greater than it was. On the other hand, we did not hear them say that the prevailing prosperity now is greater than it was at the time the comparison was made. I mention that because we must remember that these social services are designed to meet an obvious need. They are designed to make up for a weakness in our economy or lack of prosperity created by their administration.

For instance, it is nothing to be proud of to say that we are paying £5,000,000 now to the unemployed instead of £4,000,000. If we take the years 1951 and 1953, we will find that there are 20,000 more unemployed now than there were at that time. Obviously the amount of money paid out to them will be greater. Therefore, wemust remember that, to a large extent, many of these social services are a necessary substitute for destitution and poverty. The need is there and it has to be met by these services, but it is no substitute for prosperity which ought to be created to enable those people to be in a position where they would not have to look for the benefits of such schemes as they do now.

Let us remember that the old age pension in October, 1951, was 20/-per week but the cost of living increased 15 per cent. at that time. If we take 15 per cent. of a £ the lowest figure that should be made available to them now is 23/-, but instead the pension is 21/6. Let me give some more figures just to show the difficulties which the old age pensioners are meeting at the present time.

In 1951, the loaf of bread cost 6½d. In October, 1951, the old age pension was 20/- a week. The lb. of sugar at that time was 4d. It is now 7½d. The stone of flour was 2/0½. Now it is 4/9. Tea was 2/8 per lb. Now it is 5/6. Butter was 2/10 a lb. and it is now 4/2. The figures which I have given for these essentials—and these essentials for any healthy old age pensioner or individual—are the figures for October, 1951. When you add up the figures for the cost of a unit of bread, butter, sugar, tea and flour, at the present time they come to 15/10. But when you add up the cost of those items for October, 1951, it comes to 8/5.

There is the increase that took place in regard to these units of food between October, 1951, and the present time. Obviously, the food aspect of the old age pensioners' needs is a big one. We have a situation now where those items of food amount to 15/10 at the present time compared with 8/5, when the old age pensioner was getting 20/- in October, 1951. Fianna Fáil have been traditionally unkind to the old age pensioners, no matter what they say about it.

Comment on this

We never took a shilling off them.

Comment on this

You were very slow togive them a rise. You asked where you would get the money to give them a rise in 1946.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy Rooney is making a statement.

Comment on this

There is the record of Fianna Fáil as far as the old age pensioners are concerned. I do not think anybody disputes the fact that the vast majority of them are the weakest section of the community. That is the reason why this debate centred around them, particularly in relation to the present cost of living. Other sections of the community are suffering, too, but possibly they are better able to bear it. This is the section of the community who are hardest hit by the policy of the present Government. In 1931 the old age pension was 10/-. In 1932, when the Fianna Fáil Party came into power, it was 10/-.

Comment on this

It was 9/- before that.

Comment on this

It was 10/- in 1931.

Comment on this

Yes. You took 1/- off.

Comment on this

That will not hide your failure.

Comment on this

It is all right.

Comment on this

Two wrongs never made a right.

Comment on this

The Minister continued giving them the same pension as they were getting in 1931.

Comment on this

You took 1/- off.

Comment on this

All though the 1930's and up to 1948 the pension level was 10/- for the people who were really destitute. A voucher was available to them if they could convince the pension officer they were in need of it. It was not cash. They would not be let spend the money.

Comment on this

They got the voucher automatically.

Comment on this

Of course, they did, but not cash. They got a voucher.

Comment on this

A voucher was more valuable than cash at that time.

Comment on this

Ask the old age pensioners that. Before the Governmentcame into office a motion was put down in the Dáil by Deputies Costello and Dr. O'Higgins advocating a modification of the means test——

Comment on this

What modification was that?

Comment on this

——which would mean an improvement of 2/6 a week for the old age pensioner.

Comment on this

Who said that?

Comment on this

That is a fact.

Comment on this

It is not a fact.

Comment on this

The Minister said it would cost £500,000 and that they could not afford it.

Comment on this

The present Minister was the responsible Minister at that time. He had the job of making the decision whether the means test would be modified in order to improve the pension by 2/6 a week.

Comment on this

Who said 2/6?

Comment on this

The Minister in his reply, and when it was put to a vote in this House, said the country could not afford the extra £500,000 which this modification would cost.

Comment on this

I did not say that at all. Get the book and quote from it.

Comment on this

It was in the debate.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy Rooney is entitled to speak without interruption.

Comment on this

He is not entitled to speak untruths.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

He is entitled to make his statement. That can be corrected afterwards.

Comment on this

That was in November, 1947. Three months later we had a change of Government and the first thing done by the new Minister for Social Welfare, Deputy Norton, was to increase the old age pension to 17/6 a week.

Comment on this

And the Minister said it was not enough.

Comment on this

Neither was it, that is, in 1951.

Comment on this

But he was quite satisfied that the 10/- a week and a voucher was sufficient in 1947.

Comment on this

That is not true. The pensioners had more than that in 1947.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

All this can be said later on.

Comment on this

Was it a turf voucher they had?

Comment on this

They had it in cash.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy Rooney.

Comment on this

Surely it is not in order for a Deputy to persist in saying what is untrue.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Chair has no means of enforcing things of that kind. The Chair does not know whether what Deputy Rooney is saying is correct or not. Every Deputy tells the truth as he knows it.

Comment on this

Deputy Blowick is telling him to go on repeating an untruth.

Comment on this

I was telling Deputy Rooney, in regard to the 2/6 Deputy Dr. Ryan gave the pensioners before 1947, three quarters came out of the rates and was little more than outdoor relief. Put that in your pipe and smoke it.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy Rooney is entitled to speak without interruption.

Comment on this

It is very unfair that Deputy Blowick should ask another Deputy to keep on saying what is not true.

Comment on this

Of course it is true.

Comment on this

It is a shame.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy Rooney on the Estimate.

Comment on this

Deputy Rooney knows it is not true and yet he keeps on saying it.

Comment on this

It is true.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Would Deputy Blowick please restrain himself?

Comment on this

I do not propose to remind the Minister about that again.

Comment on this

You had better not. Here is the book; quote it.

Comment on this

I will wait till the Minister gets an opportunity to reply. Apparently he is not prepared to wait until he is afforded the chance of replying, it is such a sore point. Let me remind the Minister that he was one of the whole troop of the Fianna Fáil Party who trotted into the Lobby on the 2nd March, 1951 to vote against 20/- a week for the old age pensioner.

Comment on this

We voted for it.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Everybody is speaking except Deputy Rooney and it is Deputy Rooney I called upon to speak.

Comment on this

I am glad to see Deputy Cogan back here again. When he was speaking in this regard he was talking about sickness benefit but he did not realise that in the last couple of years the National Health Society, which was paying the 22/6 a week benefit Deputy Cogan talks about, was amalgamated into the Department of Social Welfare. He did not blame the National Health Society for their system of sickness benefit payments. He did not indicate that the Government could interfere in the level of benefits being paid by the National Health Society and he did not indicate that the National Health Society had £6,000,000 funded in their funds which they could easily have given out if they wanted to in order to increase the 22/6. That settles Deputy Cogan's misunderstanding.

Comment on this

Deputy Norton says he brought that back.

Comment on this

He brought it back in order that these extra benefits could be paid and these are the benefits against which the Minister and his Party and Deputy Cogan voted in March, 1952. Deputy Cogan of course tried to offer the excuse that the costof stamps to labourers would be higher if that scheme was adopted but Deputy Cogan did not mention when he was referring to that matter that the cost of stamps included the payment of the pensions to labourers at the age of 65. He did not mention that point and if he calculated the cost of the stamps for the present scale of benefits he would probably see that the cost of stamps proposed at that time would not have been even as much as they are now.

Comment on this

No. 3/6 is less than 2/2.

Comment on this

After that inglorious effort in March, 1951, which will never be lived down by the Minister or his Party, when they voted against 20/-for the old age pensioners——

Comment on this

And came back to power.

Comment on this

——we had a change of Government in June, and in October of that year the Order which was read out here by Deputy Norton in March, 1951, was read out again in October, 1951, by the Minister for Social Welfare, Dr. Ryan, word for word.

Comment on this

Except that it was contemplated then, that is the only difference.

Comment on this

Yes, but the Minister voted against it in March, 1951; then he came in in October and read out this Order, because he knew the Deputies on this side of the House were in favour of 20/- a week and voted for 20/- a week in March, 1951. When he went over to the Government side he knew he would have no opposition from this side, because we had already tried to put it into effect in March. Although he read out word for word the Order as it was in March and put it through, he did not mention anything about having swindled the old age pensioners out of the increase from March to October, the intervening period——

Comment on this

That is a good one.

Comment on this

——when the pension was kept down at 17/6 a week.

Comment on this

By Fine Gael.

Comment on this

On a point of order. There is no provision in the Social Welfare Bill of 1951 for increasing old age pensions.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

That is not a point of order. It is a point of fact.

Comment on this

It is a point of correction.

Comment on this

I move to report progress.

Comment on this